what makes research news?
TRANSCRIPT
What Makes Research News?How to Get Journalists’ Attention
NACHRISt. Louis - March 13, 2012
Ivan Oransky, MDExecutive Editor, Reuters Health
Treasurer, Association of Health Care JournalistsAdjunct Assoc. Prof. of Journalism, New York University
Why Is It So Bad?
In a national survey of U.S. health and medical journalists: • Nearly 70% had at least a bachelor’s degree• 19% reported having a master’s degree; • 4.5% had a doctorate; about 3% were M.D.s • Almost half had a degree in journalism• 13% had a degree in communications • 8% were ‘‘life sciences’’ majors
Viswanath K et al: Occupational practices and the making of health news: A national survey of U.S. health and medical science journalists. Journal of Health Communication 2008; 13:759–777.
Who Covers Health?
Who are Today’s Media, Really?
Who are Today’s Media, Really?
What is Reuters Health?THREE WIRES COVERING 110 STUDIES EACH WEEK
Reuters Medical News Keeps physicians, researchers and other medical
professionals informed of developments in their field
Reuters Health eLineWellness and health care for the general public
Reuters Health Industry BriefingBusiness information for the healthcare community
How Reuters Health Chooses Stories
• Impact factor
• Likelihood of changing behavior/clinical practice
• Strength of evidence
• Novelty
How Reuters Health Covers Stories
How Do Others Cover Stories?
Schwitzer G. How do U.S. journalists cover treatments, tests, products, and procedures? An evaluation of 500 stories. PLoS Medicine 2008 doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.0050095
How to Get Reporters’ AttentionFrom: System AdministratorTo: Oransky, Ivan (M Edit Reu Hlth)Subject: E-mail Quota Warning - Your Mailbox is 80 percent of its allowable sizeSent: Apr 29, 2011 8:00 PM
Your mailbox exceeds 400,000 Kilobytes (KB) in size. Your mailbox size is currently 510187 KB.
When your mailbox size exceeds 500MB, you will be unable to send mail until enough messages or other items are deleted to reduce the size below 500MB.You will continue to receive incoming email until your mailbox reaches 1,024MB (1 Gigabyte), at which point all inbound email will be returned to the sender.
Improving Press ReleasesAcademic medical centers issue a average of 49 press releases/year
Among 200 randomly selected releases
– 87 (44%) promoted animal or laboratory research, of which 64 (74%) explicitly claimed relevance to human health
– Among 95 releases about clinical research, 22 (23%) left off study size and 32 (34%) failed to quantify results
– 113 releases promoted human research
• 17% promoted randomized trials or meta-analyses
• 40% reported on uncontrolled interventions, small samples (<30 participants), surrogate primary outcomes, or unpublished data—yet 58% lacked the relevant cautions
Woloshin S et al. Press releases by academic medical centers: not so academic? Ann Intern Med 2009;150:613-618
Pitch Less, Tip More
Show Context
Show Context
Show Context
It may take decades before ocean acidification’s effect on marine life shows itself. Until then, the past is a good way to foresee the future, says Richard Feely, an oceanographer at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration who was not involved in the study. “These studies give you a sense of the timing involved in past ocean acidification events—they did not happen quickly,” he said. “The decisions we make over the next few decades could have significant implications on a geologic timescale.”
What Kinds of Releases Do Well?10 Most-Visited Stories on EurekAlert! in 2011
1. Genetic research confirms that non-Africans are part Neanderthal University of Montreal
2. New math theories reveal the nature of numbers Emory University
3. Astronomers discover complex organic matter in the universe The University of Hong Kong
4. Mayo Clinic: How patients will respond to immunomodulator therapy for multiple myeloma Mayo Clinic
5. World's smallest frogs discovered in New Guinea Pensoft Publishers
6. Walking through doorways causes forgetting, new research shows University of Notre Dame
7. Taming the flame: Electrical wave 'blaster' could provide new way to extinguish fires American Chemical Society
8. Effortless sailing with fluid flow cloak Duke University
9. Mindfulness meditation training changes brain structure in 8 weeks Massachusetts General Hospital
10. Woolly mammoth's secrets for shrugging off cold points toward new artificial blood for humans American Chemical Society
What Kinds of Releases Do Well?10 Most-Visited Stories on EurekAlert! in 2011
Help Reporters Move Upstream
Use Social Media to Develop Relationships with Reporters
How Sources Develop Relationships with Reporters – and Vice Versa
Use Twitter
• Follow reporters to see what they’re interested in
• Don’t use it to send the same press release to 30 reporters
Avoid Disease of the Month
Use Embargoes Wisely
Use Embargoes Wisely
Avoid Jargon
• Talk to me like I’m your smart 14-year-old nephew
Use Anecdotes Carefully
• Is the story representative?
• Does the source of the story have any conflicts?
Watch Your Language• Lifestyle/diet – are they randomized
controlled trials, or just observational?
• If observational, make the language fit the evidence:– YES: “tied,” “linked”–NO: “reduces,” “causes”
Get to Know AHCJ
Get to Know AHCJ
• >1,200 members in every U.S. state, >25 countries
• Strict membership guidelines: Journalists only
• Annual conference with workshops, newsmakers, more
• Conference partners: NACHRI, Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, Children’s Healthcare of Atlanta, Seattle Children’s Hospital
• Website http://www.healthjournalism.org has reporting guides, blog, tipsheets, other resources
Let’s Work to Avoid This
Contact Info/Acknowledgements
@ivanoransky (better)
Thanks: Nancy Lapid, Reuters Health