whistleblower’s ethical journey...university of california april 9, 2019 boston, massachusetts...
TRANSCRIPT
3/14/2019
1
HCCA COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE 2019
Amy Block Joy, PhDFaculty/Specialist Emeritus
University of California
April 9, 2019 Boston, Massachusetts
Slides created by Amy Block Joy
WHISTLEBLOWER’S ETHICAL JOURNEY
A Real-Life Case Study on the Discovery of Fraud, Investigative Success, the $2.3 Million Payback, and the Retaliatory Consequences
of Reporting Wrongdoing
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
3/14/2019
2
Disclaimers: Some Ideas to Keep in MindInformation summarized in the presentation includes published research, documents, articles,
interviews, and recollections.
The presenter is not an auditor, accountant, or attorney. The presenter is a scientist.
The presenter would like to acknowledge the many professionals who worked on this case, including: university internal auditors, investigators, campus police, and federal agents.
Events in this presentation are factual. Some names of those involved have been changed.
Viewpoints expressed in this presentation do not necessarily represent the official position of the University of California.
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
3
Presentation Outline
1 – Discovery of fraud
2 – Reporting fraud
3 – Investigation
4 -- Retaliation
Slide created by Amy Bloc k Joy
4
3/14/2019
3
Part 1Discovery of Fraud
5
Slide created by Amy Block Joy This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-ND
Background: University Career
Faculty (33 year academic) Scientist in the field of nutrition Director (statewide program) Federal funding ($14 million annual budget)
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
6
3/14/2019
4
Discovery
7
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
Budget Error
$60K project budget Increased to $210K$150K error?Handwritten note
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
8
3/14/2019
5
ALARM!
Internal alarm leads to action
Check the office filesFiles were lockedWhere’s the key?
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
9
Red File Folder Contains Evidence
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
10
3/14/2019
6
Purchase Order in Red File
Numerous Red Flags Inappropriate approval No separation of duties Vague description (Canon Optura 600) Expensive ($1400) Vender (Fry’s Electronics) Handwritten note (“Pick Up”)
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
11
Moral DilemmaWhat is my responsibility?
As the director?As an employee?To the university?To the government?To the department chair?To the accused?
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
12
3/14/2019
7
Reporting Misconduct at the University
Policy dictates to report to supervisor
But what should one do if their supervisor doesn’t take action?
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
13
Ask Questions
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
14
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-NC
3/14/2019
8
Chair’s Response to Wrongdoing
“No big deal” “Everyone does it” “You’re out of step” “People are complaining about you” “I thought she was your friend”
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
15
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
Reporting Result
Silence: Nothing happens!And the evidence?
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
16
3/14/2019
9
What happens to the evidence?
Deposited into the Chair’s Personal Vault!
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
17
Part 2Reporting Fraud
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
18
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
3/14/2019
10
Response of Supervisor: SILENCE
Misuse not taken seriously Refusal to report upward Protecting the accused Reporter threatened: Keep quiet or else! Disposition of evidence: Hide it!Action taken? None
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
19
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
Response of Accused Employee appears contrite and works hard Employee takes responsibility Employee is monitored Employee follows the rules
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
20
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
3/14/2019
11
Is this enough?
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
21
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-NC
Monitoring Fails to Stop Accused Accused has staff member order purchaseAccused approves order Letter of warning issued Supervisory responsibility suspended
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
22
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA-NC
3/14/2019
12
A Tip from Staff Member
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
23
Travel Fraud!
Fictitious travel allegation
$800 per month
Two plus years
Loss of $20,000
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
24
3/14/2019
13
Response of Supervisor
New department chair refuses to report upward
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
25
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-NC
Moral Outrage!
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
26
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
3/14/2019
14
Blow the Whistle!
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
27
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-ND
Whistleblower Report
Misuse of government propertyEmbezzlementTravel fraud
Slide by Amy Block Joy
28
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY
3/14/2019
15
Part 3
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
29
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA-NC
Investigative Questions
Who puts employee on leave? Who secures the evidence? Who interviews the witnesses? Who begins the investigation?
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
30
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND
3/14/2019
16
Answers
Who puts employee on leave? THE WHISTLEBLOWER Who secures the evidence? THE WHISTLEBLOWER
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
31
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY
More Evidence in Red Folder!
During leave notification,the accused tried to take a file folder. She unlocked her desk drawer, took out a red folder, andput it in her box of personalbelongings.
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
32
3/14/2019
17
What was found?
FORGERY
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
33
Problems in Securing the Evidence Forgery Embezzlement Travel fraud Letters of warning Confession Repayment check Taking responsibility email
No response by high level official at dean’s office!
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
34
3/14/2019
18
Retaliation!
Hours later: Office broken into and ransacked
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
35
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY
Part 4
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
36
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
3/14/2019
19
Waiting for the Investigation
Whistleblower waits and waits and waits for the dean to take action
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
37
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA-NC
Whistleblower Under InvestigationRisk Associated with Reporting Wrongdoing
Dean serves whistleblower at home on a weekend Threatens: KEEP QUIET No safeguards for whistleblower Fraud investigation stalled
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
38
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
3/14/2019
20
Retaliation Questions Why was whistleblower falsely accused?
Why was no action taken after the whistle was blown?
Why is whistleblower under investigation without evidence?
Why did the accused’s report of misuse get more attention?
Why was the evidence not provided to the compliance professionals?
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
39
This photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
Internal Auditing Takes ActionWhistleblower meets with Internal Auditors Safe haven found Internal Auditors secure evidence Internal Auditors interview whistleblower Internal Auditors promptly investigates
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
40
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-NC
3/14/2019
21
Multiple Investigations Campus Internal Auditing Campus Investigators Campus Police Special Agents from Office of the Inspector General (OIG)
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
41
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY
Warrant Served 300 invoices 100 travel vouchers Search warrant issued Home searched “Goods” located in garage $160,000 value
Slide by Amy Block Joy
42
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
3/14/2019
22
Media Exposure Leads to More Retaliation
Petition to be removed from job False accusation of violence Car tire tampered Shoved by higher-up
Slide by Amy Block Joy
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
43
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-NDThis Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SAThis Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND
Does Retaliation Stop?
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
44
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
3/14/2019
23
Safeguards Are NeededThe Ethics Resource Center (ERC) reports that over 21% of those who reported misconduct experienced retaliation*
This calculates to 6.2 million workers
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
* Sources: Ethics Resource Center Report: “When Whistleblowers Become Victims,” 2012; “inside the Mind of a Whistleblower.” 2013.
45
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-NC
Fraud Findings: $2.3 Million Payback to Government
Embezzlement of $160,000 substantiatedTravel fraud of $25,000 substantiatedFraudster pleads guilty (2008)Fraudster serves time in prison (2009)Misappropriation by chair ($150,000)*Undocumented time claim by chair ($400,000)Undocumented time claims from others ($1.544 million)
* $150K for ‘chair’ on budget spreadsheet for unapprovedresearch signed off by fraudster
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
46
3/14/2019
24
Evidence of Collusion Chair approved employee’s fake trips (254 trips = $25K)
Employee approved costly purchases for chair ($500K)
Employee approved payroll transfer for chair’s employees ($150K)
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
47
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-NC
Rationalizations Used by Fraudsters*
“No big deal – everyone does it”
“We are helping the organization”
“No one was hurt”
“The government is cheating us”
“No one’s paying attention to the controls”
“There’s widespread corruption in our organization”
* Free, C and PR Murphy. “The Ties that Bind: The Decision to Co-Offend in Fraud.” Contemporary Accounting Research 32(1):18-54, Spring 2015.
48
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA-NC
3/14/2019
25
Why Retaliate?
If fraud was conducted by one subordinate employee working alone there would be no reason to retaliate. Retaliation may be an indicator that higher-ups are involved.
49
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-NC
Involvement of Higher-Ups Failed to put accused on investigatory leave Failed to secure evidence of misuse of federal funds Failed to lock computer so that evidence cannot be destroyed Failed to report wrongdoing to compliance professionals Failed to report break-in to campus authorities
Failure to act after fraud report = Retaliation
Slide created by Amy Block Joy
50
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND
3/14/2019
26
Steps to Take BEFORE, DURING and AFTER
BEFORE: TRAIN SUPERVISORS They need to know what action to take when receiving a report of wrongdoing
DURING: INVESTIGATE PROMPTLY The reporter needs to be protected
AFTER: COMMUNICATE FINDINGS Take correction action and update policy and protocols
Slide by Amy Block Joy
51
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY
Ethics Matter!
Improves trust Improves employee morale Increases willingness to report Reduces misconduct
Slide by Amy Block Joy
Source: Ethics Resource Center: 2009 Business Ethics Survey.
52
3/14/2019
27
Improve Institution Integrity by Preventing Retaliation
Retaliation is a predictable outcome Retaliation is a second form of misconductRetaliation is costly (resources and investigation time)Workplace ethics improves employee morale
Slide by Amy Block Joy
Source: AB Joy, “Retaliation: A predictable and costly consequence of reporting wrongdoing.” Compliance & Ethics Professional (in press), April, 2019.
53
RememberThe ethical culture of an institution is a
significant safeguard to protect employees from retaliation
Slide by Amy Block Joy
54
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND