why 90 percent of medical devices fail

89
!!" " # $ # ! ""# $% &’#(’)*)+ ,% #&’+(-’#-* % ./01. 2% 3331’01. %& ’( $ )* + , $ - & + -

Upload: rick-green

Post on 25-Jan-2016

9 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Why 90% of medical devices fail product certification testing the first time, according to ETL SEMKO

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

! !""

# $#

!""#$ %&'#(')*)+,%#&'+(-'#-*%./01.

2%3331'01.

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

Page 2: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

*.-&&-&)

!0'.0 0.4056575!(("'"00 30.84. 01

)

2 9844 00 .04 0. .. 4 0 0 $00 0 . 8 . 8.010 0$084 0 8 .008 0$0 .$83 9 00 . . 4 090 . 9. 4 0 01 :$ ; 0 440 000 0$0 4 .$.4<$48$0 04 0.81

0.0.0.0804.1

Page 3: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

-/$

0$ +1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

+'2(3 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 2

"1" 000;0 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 "1"1" 704:.$0 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 "1"1+ <.0.0.1 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 "1"1* $0.00 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 #"1"1*1" !$!1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 #"1"1*1+ 0408'.$11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111""1"1*1* 0408.$111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111""1"1- 420.0 20 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111"""1"1-1" $.$0 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111"+"1"1) .0,.=("'*'+("'*'*> 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111"+"1"1)1" .0 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111"+"1+ 8 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111"*"1+1" 0!0000 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111"*"1+1"1" ?.448011111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111"*"1+1+ .0.?0. 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111"*"1+1+1" $$04?8111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111"-

" 4$,4'(3 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 5

+1" 4901111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111")+1+ 44$.11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111"(+1+1" 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111"+1+1+ $0$8<011111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111"+1+1* ,;0 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111"+1+1- 2 64;00<4 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111"&+1+1) $5$.0.01111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111"&

6 /4'(3 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 '

*1" 8 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111+*1"1" 8$1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111+*1"1+ 801111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111+**1+ 4.. .;.?@; 80.44.0111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111+-*1+1" .. .;.? 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111+-*1+1+ ; 80.44.0111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111+)*1+1* !0!..$8?.0111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111+(*1* ?840 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111+(*1- 04<$<$;0 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111+(*1-1" ;.9 8 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111+*1-1+ 0 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111+

7 $.85(3 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111"2

-1" 000.0 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111+&-1+ 0.04706$20 <$111111111111111111111111111+&-1* 70.0,.40 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111+&-1*1" ,.!$$.111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111+&-1*1+ $4<$...3 00$.4. 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111+&-1*1* <4..4. 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111+&-1*1*1" $4+"=(1&1*1+">*>> 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111+#-1*1- .A!..000?. ;0011111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111+#-1*1) ;990$..11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111*-1*1)1" <0.0 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111*-1*1)1+ ?04. 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111*"-1*1( ,08020!90 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111*+-1*1 200 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111*+

Page 4: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

-1*1& .0.$$00.1 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111**

5 )8(3 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111167

)1" ?401111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111*-)1+ 0004. 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111*()1+1" 008;3<$ 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111*()1* $.11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111*()1*1" ?44.3$.'? 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111*()1*1+ $.040 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111*

$9&2(3 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111116'

(1" 04. 0 4...<$ 111111111111111111111111111111*#(1+ 04$0 0111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111-

2 -$ ,92(3 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111117

1" 040 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111-1"1" 0. 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111-1"1"1" 0?.. 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111-"1"1"1+ $.?0.0 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111-*1"1"1* 9 --1+ ;3$$011111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111-)1+1" 4.B0C. 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111-)1+1+ .04'.$. 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111-)1+1* 3. ;3$$0 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111-(

8 %5(31111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111172

' )$:;5(3111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111178

&7(3 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111178

"1" 04 .0111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111-&"1+ 84;.9 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111-#

<&$! 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111115

""1" $0 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111)"""1"1" !. ;011111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111)"""1"1+ ;30 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111)+""1"1* ;33. 080 00 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111)*""1"1- ,03. 0111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111)*""1"1) 3. 0 ,00;0 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111)*""1+ 43 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111)-

Page 5: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

+90:;.000$812..8.00$40 41D00 $$$$0400$ 001 03 8..00"+)'!<800$.4.0012$.$8 98$4 38..8103800$$40030.004 9.00$00 00$41

0<00.9 9#E4...9.0 009 0380 94 40000.$83 00<01

800440 ..3 83 44$.04444.01 0F.40G1

2 $.04.4 00<4..00 0. 9$4$.4.0 0.%

> ?80

> 090

.> 0040

> .$48

> 3

4$.0 8 9F0$$ G44 $.0.9.<0..0D0$000%

"1 $..18$.8498$..80*'-0 94 $481

+1 $.0.4

*1 '..$.$000469

-1 90.4.0.441

0040.94004304.1

0.000 0.4 40900$03 8 8..3 . 9$9 404 $$1

!0094$.03F00G..$ $030310 490030.044.90$.000'01 0$$. 0 43.44.0%

> 0093'3

> 004.8.1

.> 44.9004009

> $.3.$3 00

> .00400$000

H$90.0A0044.0 300'00$$. 1 0000A4.B0 4439$.001

=

=

4

4

>>

Page 6: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

0$ +

#

# #

&)&

()

)

-

"

+

*

-

)

(

&

#

"

/

4$

,4

/0/

4

<

-

$

:

,.

%

$:

;

$?

9

,8$ E,

..$8=> #E

4;. #E

8000 #E

$0 &)E

$. &E

.0 E

040@;70 E

2000. ()E

?04.@A )E

04 20 -E

?..0 -E

0 -E

,8 *E

*.-&&-&)

!0'.0 0.40

56575!(("'"00 30.84. 01

Page 7: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

+'2(3

84 00.4$04..$8=>0 ,<.8000.08 <$70=7>1040%

84<$0804.004.80..93 ...0.08 900484. 91

3$0..$8 0%

"1 000

+1 8

1 ,/

)0.00.0000$%

C8 43 . .$0 0 4 . 01 :.$0.%

3. ;3$$870I03. ;3$$870.0.57(#)1 0$.4.<044.9.0380.$0. 03400 0 .01?00. 0.;71

;340I 4<.80$..90380. <04.9.0 .$08<40.9.01 .04'.$34080 1

!"#$#$%&%' ( ) )

;0..000$,0001 8$4.00 . 94,$8000030$001 * ))(

+ ),-( . . )

.004 9''..4 90$04 .01

Page 8: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

)) ' && ) ) ( / ( + ,.

Page 9: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

704.0..F0G3 . 3308$01 00 $3 0A4 944 01,"31JB0 004 $=0$.94 0 $>1.04," 00 $3 4$4<.81

0 1 )2 ' + ( ,' ) 3 4 ! !

"*

"+

""

"

#

&

(

)

-

*

+

"

"A "A "A "A "A ":A ":A

0@ 1

0@1

0@ 1

0@

&$$*

+#

A

"-

")

":A

0

0

0

0@1

$ 9 $00 9 4 3 0 4 .0 0 400JB1 0$ 04 0 =8$.8$*' .00>1!0$$.0=0,*>00$.$ 0,8. 4$0$80 0. 0000081

Page 10: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

?0$800

$

!

,8

.$

?0$800

$0

;$

.0

2$0!

..0'

,8

C83000

Page 11: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

!"# !

30.04<81:,$.$0. 30.00 $00 0$00384$3 '0 .01 : $0 ;00 .. 8$90=4 0>03$...1

!C0

.

$

"# !$ %& !$

,A,A,A,A

.0

0

'$()* +, )-. .

04!$$.

/0)) ()* +$1-. .

Page 12: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

(2

$.4..000 4 π= 3 %

K 0 $.4 ..

π ;0 .03 ..4.4..1 4<.84 0$ ..

,$3 L+ML+4+&!2:NL)A

( ) ( ) Ω=×=×××××= −

1 00 1

9/&9 &$ %?10@1 BC

( ) ( ) Ω=×=××××= −

1 00

04.$912 $3403 0 04.4 404<80040 3 .01

9 40$04.0$38A 3$.3..448..=8$.8+13 . )A3$.4( ) ( ) ( ) Ω=××=××××= −−

%%5 1( + !"#%$$$&6&7 !"#%$$$&6&6,

$.004$ 9("'*'+("'*'*0.+3 ?.930. .$ 033001.?9.03 000469+-3 6904(("'"'+%+"0444. "##*9046(("'"'+03 31 $4..044.8 033000000 ;3$$80$.83. ;70=;7>1!.$;708. $0904 '.$$.0001 00 00034<89 .$.1

! 4 . 03 $$ 0 98 . 4. 9.0.$3. ;7$.4 00 0!$0="(!> $ $ 0 . .0 0 0$$8 . 304("'*'+1 00804 0098$ 4. 40 090 $ 44A 0=110..$ 348.0$4440>13 D040 830.<04 $.1!469+- ,?! 730 (("'"'+%+"0 00 4.$. $. 3 <0 4 ("'*'+ ..$4 1

0 ;7 4 . 8 <$ =>0 3C?.9?.91 .+ 00 3 . 4. . 9 9

Page 13: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

.$.08. $4 . 8$. 4 0 .1 39 . .0.0 044.38<09.0 0004 .9.508043 ..$04.9.01

1"

-.0044481 00430%

%7% !"2(

0.04404804 4. 04.0 94 00;4.4 7100 00$4.=40*1+"1+>08$.0 4 4..$0!00001"-#"%+6"-#"%+4 80*(1++1"D4801

4.0.$ 9.4.480+"+""1 $04.$001"1"*1

!"#

+4(("'"'+.040<0 0.%

(("'"'-%"##(O!"%"###("'*'+%("'*'*("'-'"%+("'-'+%"##)O!"%"##&O!+%+("'-'*%"##)O!"%"##&O!+%+("'-'(O!"%+("'-'&("'-'"""-#"%+

%77 ! 8

0 . 8 , 0 00.$8 .0.?0. =?>1 0 0 4 < .8 $ 9. 0$.83 3 03. $0 4 $ 0$801 0 00$.83 ?006(("'"'+%+"1 090 $90904 01.$3 .?9.0?.9 ' #*5-+54.03 90 006(("'"'+%+"1$

% & '

Page 14: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

$3 ?00.03$0.0$83. 4 3 3 04. 0 9 $$N 8$.84? 008$.844$4 0001 00084300%

> $ 9911$ 03. . 0..1 0 .. 83 00.1 00. 8 . 0 4 4 00. 0 $00 .0 0

0$90.44=8$.809Ω>1( )

*+ ,

*+ &-$ -'- ,

*+ * +,

=9>.

%

> 03 $004<..0 1 .$4.004 0%

=> 004 8$

=> 00 . N

=> 0 04 04.0.4 001

/& /.

9;0 .. $4?00$.4*(1++1+>*>03 0$.4.08=(-"')"*-00 3(1"1+"1+1>1 0.04000.%

"> $.4 ?308=(-"')"*-00 3(1"1+"1+9 >N

+> 3 $04..043 ?3080 . ..0 0 0 ..0 00?$.8$.00N

*> 0$.4.4 ?$.8$.0N

-> . 044 99.9$4 ?308?$.8$.0N

)> !0$.4.4 .04?$.8$.1

0 . 4 08 $90 $ D. ..0 .<$ 0 <.0. 4 00 $91

Page 15: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

" 4$,4'(3

, ..8 0 $$ $. 0 6 + 0 4 .$.0040#E4$.01 04<80<0 0 F2 . 4 < $.PG1 03 0 '.0(1"9>1 0 00 ' 4 0$.00 9 0$ 0 $. 0 ..8 Q0'.00(1&1*>"1" ;.& =6(&>R109.0 99040$01

0#

"1 0/$* 0

. . 0.$ 0 . 0$.4. 4 $009 .0 4 0$03 . 11 0<04.00(1&1*(1"910$.0.40&%"#&) 6 &%"### ' ;. S ;. 4 401 0.%

0

> $03 . $..0D.0$1$.08009 5 . $ . 0 $ . .08$.8$01 080 9 $$3$0= $0 3,"" $00, 00>1

0

> 8 $..0D.4$0 9.0 .0. 4 8. 4 8 0 $.91

Page 16: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

0!

.> . $00 0 =4 $$.> 4 $ 09.08.9<3 . 83$ 4 9 0$.4. =3$00>1

000$9$'44 3 4 <$.04 $.0$.3<09.$03$1 0$.0 4.B0984.0 <84 4..44. 8B0.0$. 0<$4 04.1

40.0$03 40..944.01 08840 0904 <$$09.1 40.44 $. A0. 3$04.1!0 03.0038.0030D8. $$05$00.4$.1 08F 0 $3004 .4 B$.4G0$$.I 980430 30< 0 $03 8$90001 .04$.0 9$44003'.090.$90.4 $.18$.40.%

0040.8 .44.04.03

. .9.0$94949$0

.34.0 8.40.009

. 4 $0. .00 $ . 0 $ N8$.3 . 04.4 $00A1

.. 3 4 0 ;0 0 04301

.009 .0 .0 80 3 $0. .0 43489 04.4001

.0..00. 0.0 04..0 .4.=$.056575!(("'"0*1"4 <04048>1

"1" 0/$C$4

2 .848 3 $.0$.0 $.0 8$18$90$4 04 $. $.%

.$8000$09$.0=11'3.9003$..0>

30080$0=118$9 $.00.$>

008$$..894. =118$9 044448 ..4$4.0>1

Page 17: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

77% :

02

4 $. 0 98 $1 0 $0$9 <0 00.0 4 4 $. =11 . 8. 40>1 ..8 .0 $0 4 9.0 .00$.84 03 0 0 3 0 0$$ 8 .00 12!T7;

777 ! 2 0

0

700 0 $ 4 4 4 3 =11 30$8> $.=0$.8..$$>... $84 4 4 $. $4 0 01 0$08$.0 .F ;?TG1

776

0"

,

48B48 $.04<0.4 $.3$8.900$$$491U0.08. .4.B0.0 3.9 04 3 0$. 1

F G 9.0 44 $. 0$00490 .8 904:'4.0.09 0$ 4.B0044048 404 13948 4 .8 $. $.< .4 .0 $. 30 488.$04 .3 0 8 8 0 4 8 B $.1

3

Page 18: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

77; / < 2 0

03

3 4 $. 0 $. 0 41 9 0 0 . 98 98 3 $.004040 $$1 ,$ ..0 0 .3 0 0 $0 . 0 0 0 .$98 98 0 98 $ 8$ $. $ 8 1 0 . D8 $0 $ $. $1 $0 4. 080 $. 3 9 , "$$01

%=

. 3 8 . 0 48 . 4 $$ 4 $. =08$04+)>1,"&0 303.0801

3 $.$ 0 9 +) 0 9$ .0 < 8 $9<044 $.1 0.%

> 0$. $. 3 0 4..004 .4$00

> ;904.8 0

.> 2 3 0 0 $0334448000$91

L+

775 : >(

%9

2 0$.4.8 00 8 (("'" & $ 0.0 08 .9 8 : <0 4 (("'" 0 (1"900%

F4 0$. 00 9 0$ 0 $.0 ..8G1

. $ $. 8 .008 ..800$3 '0B04.80. < 4 0 $9 3 04$4 0 $$.$9 .0 4 $.1 , $ $9. $ 0$0 04.01!08$.4903 V 5 3$. $. 4 9 F?6;62 6CG1

Page 19: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

6 /4'(3

!98$$4.9.00 9 $$0800 4 9.1 0 4< '.$.0 0 4 0 $.'.0(1"I 04<$<$$0'.0(1+ I 0 4 <$ <$ $01 '.$.0 3 4 0'$01 0 4 0.0*1"*1-1 <0'.0(1"94(("'"1,+31

,08<08 00(("'"!$$.0??4 400.$0 080 3 .00830808$ .98$. $9 00 ..9 . .0.0 4 0.080$ .00$001

0#4. "%

!8 4 6 !. 00 43 0 .8 3003 '.0(?C1"0$$.%

(?C1" 4 $4. 3 $$ .0 0 3F!76GF2!66:GF?!6:G0 .004$$3.000 .$83 43%

> ! 30 .$0 4 . 030 000 "(="5"(. > 0$$$.0

> 030 00+&=5(-. >

.> 0 0 .0 . .1 0 0 9 .0 . ...$1

Page 20: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

61 0/

6%% 20

098.44.0 $. 00 $30$$84.01,$%

045&

+ +"

%?.-C-,.,C<

<-,C)<DD)

+.+ :+"

"5>

.-<!+<<-.),<--<

?-D<++)0-

C<D,0+.<0ED)

! "> F"5>

""!"7> 5F"5>

%?-C,,0.-

A?<.))

? 56

'5! 6

> '!"7>11

,9 25%

+# 72!6C;. "7!64C;,G

.-<!$

*#$

))<,0%-C

! ''3"

6,

7(("'"

-+)-<

F""1" 1

$9 $01 8=44 >%

> 900$.40#+(-C1.12 00$.493$. $..$'"E3 3090$.4O"E9 090$.4=0&"'+#1-C>10$.03.84$ 3$$90$8... 0445..0 .12 0 9$$0"C'+-C18O5'"E33#+(-C1 <$0 $3 91

77> 01.1$$$1 .08$.80399$$?'8"Q(-"8)*+R0 01 00840 8$4 0$$81'.0(1">1

.> 4<.8008$$$1.0. $.0$ )A(A 4<.80 40)5(A1 <$38$0-(*A0 0. 4<.8344. 04$4 $.14 4.3009 0 $.303--((A.4<.03 03'$01$. 00 3 03. $30$$0 00 940 0381

> !080<0 0;V63 6$00 9. .0.="&>4;.()+#.. 4$.$98 .03 0$. 400431 V$00 4$.0 004$.10.804.00 08. $ 0=114 0300>1

Page 21: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

,G6L " ;.09.843$0

& ;.09.843$03 .0$")W

& ;.00$83

& ;.00$0 3

& ;.03D0

& ;.0$343D0

& ;.0 44.04$803

& ;.0 44.04.003

<$4;V=0$.$.>.004.0<00. 1'.0(1">

$. 040 9000$.4;V0.803 <0$80$= 9.0 0$00.040$080>1 <04;V" 3$$$14 39 $. 8F8G94$.;V0<1

> 2 330 9.0 30001 03< 94648 44.4 6480 D. 1.?9.0?.9#*5-+5!.""1

4> FT;G0840?08"0<0$4 9$03 F,G8$$$$01

> 40 0 '947)--0 90.4.03 4 1 0080$084 904(("'"1

8$4400..004 04<$0D. 40' =03 40 0>1 400$$840 48$1'.0(1">1

4040 400430%

Q$RQ=$0>RQ$.8RQCRQCR

,$+)C*$?8403 3.$.8330*!+)C+)C(1*!8403 .$.8330(1*!+)C1 31

6

Page 22: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

40

- &

- -

-- 0- )

+ +

++ >+

A4

0 09=009$40390>

=009$43 00090>

C C&=..9$43 0090>

$0 49.04 40$01

$.80 848$ .43 4010 30 434.0 0.4383 . 0 0.0.1

> <$8..0..83 F,. G081

0! ..08=4+*$$0>09!$$?08#Q(-"08)+"R14.040984..080 00'.$.1 0.80%

> 000 8

> ;.9 8

> ,. 8

9> !08908 4.

.003 00.$.$'8$ 0.98$09..15 75. * + 6 -1

0245&

+ +"

%?.-C-,.,C<

<-,C)<DD)

+.+ :+"

.-<!+<<-.),<--<

?-D<++)0-

C<D,0+.<0ED)

! "> - 0"5>

""!"7> -50"5>

%?-C,,0.-

A?<.))

? 56

'5! 6

> !"7>H

,9 25%

+# 5FC;. "7!64C;,G

.-<!$

*#$

))<,0%-C

! ''3"

6,

7(("'"

-+)-<

F""1" 1

7 6

Page 23: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

6%7 : 20 !

09 0 94$.01 0.%

> 650<8'.0(1">1 5'4 4.0$$. <$.$03 0$91

> ,<$$93 0$3$0 $04<8001!800.=0>4<$03 3$1 004C,<.8.08.0800.$4<.8. . 8=117$;3$$090>3 0404.$04 $3$1'.00(1">(1"$>1

.> 4$0..84140$9<$00004.0$1 00 4 4$0 00$$300 $.04.0$1

04044$.0$.8 03 3.$00. 0040. 001$.040441

40 04$4'.0+1"1"+1"1(+1"1"1 4.0. 0 4$..844 00430%

+1"1" ?6?6% .4<$0'A4044.8 $1

+1"1+ 6677;!6%$4$3 0$.404$.1

+1"1* 6677;!6266!?6:%$3 . <$0...08 0$$801 0$00000 '$$01 090 39044.84.3 '$$1

+1"1- 6677;!62'!?6:%$3 . <$0...08 0$$801 0$00000 '$$01 090 39044.84.3 '$$1

0+1"1) ?7TT%4 $ 04

$ 091 .04$0904980..099044.81 08$.8.8.090(-"'=09$>1

VVV

TTT

VVV0 NTTT0 4410 0$$$ 904VVVTTT11X0X40.0XX401

+1"1( 66;!6%$0040$.4..8.0. .8..$04$4$3 0$.404$.4380$3 <$03. 441

Page 24: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

+1"1" ';!6%$40$.4$04..3 0$.404$. 903. $4$044.3 <$.3..1

69004(("'" 9404$.04V'8<$=+1"1"++1"1"*>1?94. 46:...3 +#,"#". $U4 704!. 03..4 $.9030V'80801

> .<$00 44' 0 4.$00$4...08093 ...<$.900$34 .$=1147;>12 ...<$0.90$34 <$...80048099 8$4 0$.4 <$ 0$8 04 <$1 0300$$30$$000403 04 ..00$$80011

,6 !. 00$;3$$0C$.703 . <483 $.0 803 168<$3 0$$30$$8 04.$83 <04

7(("'"'.0(?C1"1"1"13 43<0%

(?C1"1"1"

!0$$3=$$30$$88. >$80$..40$$8 <$0

=> $.3 Y7;6

=> 4.8 43<9 <$%

FZZZZZZZ=<$0.$9>ZZZZZZZZZZZZZ1GF7083 =4.B0<9>ZZZZ!$=$30$$88. >GF7083 $0= > 0.1G

44.0 0 $93 <$0 .8 $0= >3 3 . <$0084.B01!0 <$0 3 8"-4?!$$?44.01

61" 0/$&4,):,&$$

67% ! ( 8

09 080 . 4 $. 4 .. 0 .1 04<800$$$4 4$.<8 8$49.991

. 9.3 $$$$00 $93 08...3 '.0(1">. 8$4$$$.. 4$.

Page 25: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

0..0 .1,8$8$,8$,$$$01!$$??080"+*1

,.443 08+08"0 $$0. 3809 $0040.3 0<1

2 <$ 0 $$$3 4404$. 90800.890=..$0>4$$$0

?4'$4$$$00 3 90801!$$??080#"""1

6%4 $.0 44.4 0. 4..40$8 $. 08"-!$$??0 91

4.093 04 9.08$4.. $=$$$$0>1 <0=;">4(("'"4<848;.=;+>1 00080 ..4$.0$91,$(("'+'+<0 4$.4$$$$008$,?4;414 430$938 4.03 9 8$,94$.1

677 !

<$$.$ 80.44.03 . 8.0 $5$0<008.. 9 A1 080$$$.0 3.8904 <$ 001

4$$.0804$. A00$8;.(-"001,'A=4$ '$3.390>8&4?4!$$?0 01

7#,$<$0800 .,00 8$$8,..84000 3 08=04>4'AQ(-"')"-R%

, A0 3 0$.4. 08 0 9 8 "- 4 ? 4!$$?0 01

(("'"'+%+" '.0 (1"1+" .0 <0 4 0 04 <$08;.<0=;+00>1 04<891

!0 (("'"'+%+* '.0 (1+"1* .9 0 4<$ 0800 0$.4 4 0 8 0 . 4<8001<$08000$.44080 .3 93 3 80 08 0$.48$40 .=0(1&1*1+".>>14 4. 000 <4(("'"'+%+"0(1+"81

Page 26: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

676 ."8

032 9 4.30 0 04 <$.0 ..$8 .0 8 "- 4 ? 4 !$$ ?Q*-&

"R 0 01 39 . 0 $4 08 0

4<80$01 0 F.G =0S-*->109.3 1

616 )/$ 4

$.3 <04'.0(1"0. .0430%

0$. $0.4<0 04<$1

0 8401

, 4 8 0 8 3 $00404")03 . 03 03 4")03 . 03 8 0$ =0 . > $ 4 ") 0 3 . 0 3 0$$8. 1

00.84 004 9$4=0!$$*(>1! 0900 930.. 01

2 9 8 44. 4 0 0 0 0 ..1 . 00 0 0D. 0 9.0 ..0000.04.1 00 $0 0$.4.8 $ 4 0A 8 .9 300A3.9 300A3 0A.$.0$+ 01 4 0.44 .8 0 0 '.$.1 '.0--11

617 4<&$# # ,

! 00<$<$$00D. 0 4 '.0 (1" 0 0 4 4 4 <$ <$ $01 003 .

! "#"$%"&'

()!

Page 27: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

6;% !

! 008 04.0$4=4"##> 0 0 4<8 ..8 3 000 ,. 081

08

..08 4 F;.9 G 00 3!$$??8(Q(-"8)"#R 00 3 , # $$01 0 .8 90 .03 0.1

;.9 0 .. ..9$0400<$4048$$001

;.9 0 .. $.9 080 8 ;.9 .1 08 0 0 4,. '$.9 $$0010.890$$$001

2 $.0$93 $$. $.9 0 $4 $$.1 ... $4 $$.0. ;.9 .0....904. 0. 0.10$$$$. $.9 08D. 4 ;.9 .1

6;7 ' (

0404$8 0<$4<8 ...3 '.0(1+4 <01

0&% .6 "+ 9 1 %: ;

03 . < 4 .$. 0 4<8000. 0 0<4'.0(1+4> >>@>1 0;.9 6 40$$8..0 3 .0 A 4..8 .. =11 90 *'$ 0 0$$8 ..>1 $.4.0800409(--)1

7 $.85(3

0.0409&)E4$.0910.040030$B0700:.1

0430 0.0470.0$4 <$093 <$ 491 2 0.0409493..0..1 00.00 00. 404<'.$.01

Page 28: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

71

6 4 0 0.0 470 8 =9 44>..$8 $.3 9401

71" $.0/%&#

!030 04 <$0$0 0.0403 $4 1

716 .+$

0 . 4 4 0.0 4 70 00 <$4.08901 00 0.0,70 4<84. 0$.4. <0 =0'.0(1&>1 4..00430%

;6%

0.0 4 0 0 4. $$. 4 <$1

;67 : )

0.0 4 0 . 4 .008 $ <$ ... 3 0 0$.4.1 0 <$ 4 4. 4 .0 0$80 00 0<. 4$ .. 0.. 4 . $0 ..000$.43 . 0.0$1

;66 2 !

0.040$9 0$3 <4$.. 4.3 <$ 9.0 3 9.9.40. 4.1=0(("'"'+%+"'0(1&1+">1

(1&1+" > .0 <0 $$. <$ 08001 0.040<. 43%

"> !0 . .. <$ 0 0$. $.0 00$09... 4$9 ..$8.0N

+> ! 0 $ , ..0 <$ . 44....<$1

#4"0.093 4 9<30 .1 0 0 9 0 $ .8.000 4. 8 3 0 80A044.4.81

4 0 30 $0 <$ 0 $ 0.0401

Page 29: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

*> . .0.$4 $.=(1&1*1+">0.8<930001;>.90 <0 $$.<$ 08001 , <$ 0800 ..$8 .0 <. 434%

! 0 4 .0 0 4 .0 =4 $$.> 0.0 ..0003 3 . 4.4 <$080.0.$.3 <04*(1+"*(1++1! 44..$.3 <04 00'.0001

!..000 0.0 .0 8 0$.4 .8 =110 0. $.>0$.4.8=1184.$>1

2!!#*"8!#+!++

84.0 9 00.4 0 9. 4 0.0084+"10(1&1*1+">*>40 4 0 01

;6; 2 * .8

0.040..0.A..000. $004 04 $00.0481$.4.8$04$0 ..$403 9.0$94 4.0 0918$.$0.%

> .0I8$4.4.B0$<N

> 0I8$C! 048$.0=0$0>N

> $;3$$8%

S !..$00%

> F7083 =4.B0<9>ZZZZ!$=$30$$88. >G

> F7083 $0= > 0.1G44.0 0 $93 <$0 .8 $0= >3 3 . <$0084.B01!0 <$0 3 8"-4?!$$?44.01

2 4.0$90..000.004 <$ 0.0400.848$.$0..000.000 '0.$. 0$.012 3930.040384<$.41,$%

6 ;6 ?0.$ Y8

+'**" ...9(V&. ;.4-

Page 30: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

;65 " .

0.0404<80. 0$044....$990$..$48 . 4<.840. .1

. 0.00$944 04$4.4.=11. 49. 0>1

!80.0400 48 $03 . $990$..0 $48 $00. $0$$.008.0 .$4.40. .1

04.A4=0$$.>0$9.0.004.0.04348<1, 8000$90430%

2!

00.04<$ 00A000 43%

F3 $. 03 30$8383 04'4. 1G

4J0B3$844$$443801 .4804I0 4A'. .04483A8. J?$B 0 $00343 .0030$831 J?$B0000 441 0080 .$.3.8084=$$>1 0$$J2BJ$8B1

T0 .0 433 9$840%

!1 8$

> A8$4. I4$3$$3.P0 8$4. 9983 830 0 $.P

> 0.84 8$4.

> 94308 . =3 08J?$B>

1$

> 8$40$4.0. ..00983 80 $.1T84$30 0$.48.$ ..4<0$1

> .40$

Page 31: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

12

> 2 $0.031!44$$3 944$03 08J2B1$.48$ 0..$4J2B1,$

*#°[)°

?1!90

> T.0.4 .0 3$90 44.04 84.00. 004404.0=8. 00. 08>1

> ,8..89.. 04.3$ 00403 .011U 0@U 083$03$01 09..86 !.20$!0U$1 80380 0$01

4 J$B3 80.0 09 .08.0 0=1120$0>1! $0.080 8 0 .0=11. 3 . 6 !.00$$8!. '#E,.0.8.!."E>1480 0$$8!. 0$.481104.0E0$$8!. 448*E03= 0$0004 0. 83 99>04.0"E!'?3 #E?0!. 0.0. 3 F2G1

.0.044 .00$.4.$.09 .40$.4.$04 <$14 ..099343 $04 <$3 . ..003 49 <$3.1?008$8404.0.0.0$804.04 <$3 9.04.0 <$3 83.98048.8.9800.1

?940$.4.0.0. 3 9.3.0 0.8 4.1

.0.03.0 .80$.$.09$0 003 0. 9.="E49.004..04 .0>1

2!

!8$. .$400=0?. $0?0.1>.. . $ 4=.90 90D849.0>304.018 $.404.0 91 0404. <$0 93

Page 32: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

9 0.00.4$ 0.$8404 $.00$.4404.3$01

24 94.0 8$0 ...3 $04.0A139.004$.0 . 9840$0 8 .04 $0 90$0$0$9.$$04.$..0.00.3..1 04.04.003. 00.8..3 $10.#$-&1

.$4000 . 903$04 <$00. 04.00.00012 0.40 '904.0A4 9.1

04.0..8 8009.0.84=114 8>10.0400 0$.48$4304.3 $0 34 ..090$1,$9<-=>>?)- ';

;6# ../

44008030090<$4<800<8$ 0.0401 040804$.(-"S:$ .0800<$5S:$ .0800<$0$4.0%

> 0800900$. 3 30$3 9

> 0 $. 04. 4.1

;6? /"

20.04<800.843 84 0.0401 04<8004.0 43G%

40.'..<$1 006 !.<4 904(("'"139. 9$4$.0484<$ 0$06 !.1;00.007-#&<90F0$:G 9. 080 0.0$01 04404$$03 4403 $401 0$.4.<0.4

77(("'"?9)1+?C1+1<$43 *'$0$00 9 3 <$04034 $3.3 <$091

)1+?C1+ ..<$$8F0$8GF0$:G. $00 $93 0.0. 8.8. 93 <$0..

Page 33: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

<9.$.F0$8GF0$:G1 .0080.00 . <$04. 0$$8.4 <$1

30.0 4<800.%

> .0470

> .0

.> 4830$ $4 <$ 044.0=11A00407C$4 4$0001>

> 204 0

2 003. $.8<8$0.0$00 9 48440 ..$8.01. 4$.408$08$0 8$$. $094 089..$9 '00 .$ 3 0.040 $. 18"-4!$$??0 0D.3 80.3 $ 1

> ;0.$70=,?!<+",&"1")>SF%,30.0 09.08 4=.0 .$.>1G

;6= ". .

!$$4$B00'.'.0(1&1*.>456575!(("'"0<$. 0.0400.0 %

3 )( . . .. ) 4

4008 4. .$.0$48 4.8 4.B00 A 000 '080.09 <04'.0(1&1*.>0$$ 0.093 $.1

,$0 0.00'.$.1

Page 34: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

5 )8(3

9&E4.9.0 39 $03 .$..0.0=@B0>5 0$93 9.3$04 9.103 .$..0.03080801$..0.0 2C=$><940100.3 39.00 0.3..04..000.0$9.0439 04.40=.$>3..0 =..>1

!$4.$..0.$00 $03 F$"G0..3 D0. 01@$08<04.01

9 [email protected] 008$0$8081

49400400430%

> 44 8$4..3008$.83 39 0..848 4. 0$ 0N

> 8$40 30300N

> .$309$0 <$N

9> 44.034. 8<$.<$030N

9> 030B93 0 <$1

51 )$

403.4(("'"+.!"!+1

0$ 4.0 040$$0 $$$81

+'?404(("'"

GGG ! /!

)$- )$

+1*1" !!!6 0$ ) ) 1

+1*1* ;!:?!6 0$ 04.4033..9$01

.$0..90 ..1 D.04'.$.4.$..0.00<0.0%

> 8$4..N

> .CN

> 8$40<

4 ..0 004$9..033$04..11

Page 35: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

GGG ! /!

)$- )$

3 $04$303. 14 $0.0 .8 $ 044.4..0 .1

+1*1+ !67!6 0$$ $90.$.0..0 .1

+1*1- ?767!6 0.$0 0.00$$801

+1*1 6,?67!6

0080$$9$03 . $904$.0..0 .<90 .00$.4 01

+1*1& 7;;6!T67!6

$0$$0.0$9$.0..0 . 94440.0

+1"1#=00+1+1+#>

66!!;27

;30.$9 ..$3.008$<$3 . 0.$ <$1

+1"1" C 4$3 . 3 ..0 $..0.. 3.=0$.4'.0"#1*>4 $..434 $ 4 $..00$4 0<$1

004 C00.4!60404.. .04 '.$.1

+1"1"+ !6;!% 84$04<$ 9..9..3 0$$801, $$04 04 $.9 ..00$4 0$1

+1"1( 67 04.4Y7;6.%

S !!;!0$0 N

S .000 40N

S 4 $$040043 0$.400$$..3 $04 04.43 3..98401

+1"1) !;;?;! !$4 <$3 . 0%

S .008.0$ 80...3 $4 <$$404.N

S . ..3 $N

S 0. 8 $1

+1"1") ;!67 !8....3 . .0$..01

;!67...9$03 . 04 $..0 .008.$83 ..0 <0=0.0+>3 . 0$4 $..0 .008.$83 .$0...<0=0)1">1

+1"1"& :6!6;7;! ;4<$$$$.9$090.04 <$4$40$8.$.001

+1"1"# :6!7;7;! ;4<$$$$9$090.0 <$4$40$8.$.001

+1-1* !,TV!'2 C3 . 0.94+)91.1

Page 36: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

GGG ! /!

)$- )$

C!:=C>% (91.1!0$$89 04.93..0 & 3 . 004 0$$808048'390489.3 <90$1

51" $

57% " . ) !

0@ 0!#

+*C .8

;

;.

00

+*C .8

;.

00

0! 0!

.88

8;3

O

'

C(C1.1LC

*

0. F?G 9 0 0 .00 0$ 9 $$ 3 0 1

908 4 $. 0 $ .004. 4 <$1

516

56% 8 ) " " &8

000 3 0.400$$100'3$1 $3. $00 01

Page 37: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

0!! 0!2

. $

$..0 .$..0.043.0 0.03B. .40 1! 04 @0.030 33930. 0=.3. ;70>10.4 $9. 00 3904 $.04#C1.1+(-C1.1 0400 0393+(-C1.1393 3.8 0439344 9 0.8004.8 $8=8$.8*)C0>1 00 .$..0.00.. 0900 +(-C1

567 " " '

! .0.4$03 .$..03 .0.40401 09$.=9044>804.0$ 044$01 000$.84044.0!0;.4..01C84.9.004!0;.4..0=117!>0$09040 49001

...83040 30.0 04.4 080..$3 300 .1 000890A0843 0.0 $44 [email protected]

2 04030 .8$3 9$...000$00 03 $40456575!(("'"'.0)1#1)1 004<89$.1 0.00 $83=0>.0$9 $4 4.000$ $840.81 30.0=.$ 03 30> 43 $830. 0.830 .$..0.0<8 001

Page 38: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

0! 0!"

;

8

.8

.8

;

8

!

?7

,766!

;

8

.8

.8

;

8

6.'

.

0!36$ 1 0!86!3

!90$49'$.041 $830 90$9 0.844.980 041 004. 4= $8$4 >$3 91?..04 4 33000 "&)C1 944.3$80.830+*O+)L+))C1

Page 39: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

0!@6?

,*#90$4 3 300 9$.$84.$0.1

8$ 4340$0009900090.001

.9 $40

08$=0>3..0..0

2 $$.48040 .00400

$..0.0<0

?..09

$9&2(38 !">!<>0>" #$#$%&% & 2!8 ) > .2!8 +

< , 00.04' $ . 0$80 =11 '0 0$80> 3 . 3 1398 4.0?$00. 1

1 $0&-&$#

43 0 00 .04 . $003. 01

' 6- )+ & , !"#$$?6

2S<

T3 S$$300<

: 84.0

!8 . 483=00.8$.0>1

Page 40: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

0 0. 4 '.$. 4 . $0 $0 0 0 0 4 . 83 =0 . !> 3 . 0 4 $$$80 . 08 0 0. 0I $3 1 . 0 $$$.4 001 4(("'"08 93.81

!$0 0$40 .8348 914 +4(("'"093%

' ;! ' !"#$#$%&%

T3 <

: 84.

!8 . 483

1" $&/

..04. 05$0 .04$0 000 0. 4 '.$.1 0 4< . 0 ..800 .?1 .0084 $0 '4 .8 0$ 4.1 0 4 . 0 0 < 0 $9 .4. 3 09 0 .0 4 .8 $9 0 4 . 0.803. 3 4.01

2 -$ ,92(3

9E4.0034 0$3 040$30$$01 004.$.0.0004301

21 -$

?%% "

!$$!'.0)1#4(("'" ,346(("'"98. ..$08.0. 0$$$4.9.01,$ 00%

9 /( 32"#"#6A /(320 (-/> % 1 ;

24<84F 04. -C=-C>3$80.8G1 08.80 00.830400434 .0. 04'.0)1#1-1 4. '00 30 0..303 008 04001! .00F 04$000 .0G12 39 000 040040.9.1

Page 41: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

0.4 .0. ..$403 4. 8<$4.9.01! 940480.$ 04 044.9.01 00 00 .00400$9 A04.1,$ 30 30.$03 <0404.0.56575!(#)$3043 .9.1

3 .

4 /"#"#6/"#@#

! '5

A

$)/

A

$)/

65! 65! 1-

380 65! 16 65! "8$00*C

80 65!"74>

65! +80$00*C

!0.0)944.0 (("'"0480<0$08(#)<01 0004 8 031

024 .55

,

$$

"7>111 /

$ &4

&

# $52

$ ! 1-

'5/17

&41

1

Page 42: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

024

! "7

"16

&46

"74>I

'5"

6

4>6 "

64>, ,

%

-

,

-

-

02!6 6A 0226 6/

(("'"'?0 (#)'?0

A

0

;8

)<

0

8$

C

.8

A

0

;8

)<

0

8$

C

.8

Page 43: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

026A .

02"6/ .

(("'"2 ;. (#)2 ;.

A

0

;8

A<

0

8$C

.8

A

A

0

;8

<,<

0

8$

C

.8

A

3

040.0....3 '.0)1#30444004.$401 04 00 04 .$..0.004.$0=00.)1*1+$*40.$..040>14 00$90 344.0. 0 3. 0 3043.0 $.41

0236 "#"#6"#@#

, ,

%

-

%-

! 8 @J

3

3%3%I%&%

@J6 I

'55 @J

%3%9&%@J"15 1

Page 44: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

3!$

"4$ BB&.6 3@+

944;.,0=!$0>

304 ,0

7$.- +1"

9-$." "1#

9"$.+) "1)

9+) "1(

0404$30$$0.0.456575!(#)8<93 0 '.. 400$4 049 01

9098$1,040.9.0 80$04 A93 9404.$4=$ >1

04 00 04000 '..04340004.8 1?00 40..$.3 98300.=8$.840$$004403 - .3 1 : - % &

4 . 0.80 '...00 0.0$.49 040.300 '..08 .01 008$.8 30'.0.40040#C!001

,565!(("'" 0403. $9VV4'.0)1#1"1,07!7(("'" 90 0.0168044.40$94 04 04$.00000!1

34BB&.6 3@

;0 $\

20.0.. 3 4 300%

400! ")

400 ")

400 "()

400, "#

400 +"

4040 4 0000A8 = -)E>10 4.B00$089489 040 <0456575!(("'"1 4.0.44. 04%

C '8004.4.3 0401.0003 04 381

Page 45: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

-$'03800$ 04C0 ;$$8$$8;,1

21" ,9

2 $004.0$ .0030.44.00.$09$30$$0049$ 31 0 030.90%

> $30$$80$80

> .0049$1

39 0003$01,04 0%

?043088.

70.0?00

0.$00$.4.0..83 48

?7% @

9. $0 .3 80 44 0 44.00. 0$.4.0..03 4 0$$01900$ 0.$D04 00.80 38431989.0.$981 00 4.0 0$.$30$$0.480 0. 400 344. 04844.9001

?77 &

00.04'.$.0430%

• ...$8=00."1"$>

• 7$$9 .'0;9.0 $810.""1

• .0090' 0.0884.$.0.. =0$.83 03. $30$$0>1

• $..?0.0=00.)1"1"1+>1

• !...04.0;404.$$.$0=003>1 00$3 ..000 .$0.1

Page 46: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

0284 (.

.0

;3$$8

$0.$$0

!$$.

?76 ))

3. $30$$0. $30$$84. .404.04$.9.01 09003 8 0$0%

"12 3. $30$$0 0FG$30$$04 0$$3

+1C

803. $30$$0.JB3 $30$$8.0$$893 9D09$. 90.1

*1,<.8 3. $30$$0.08$934<.8=8$.8-A(*A

-1A 3. $30$$0040030 4 0$$30FG0$$8

)10 2 348$0903. $30$$098$094 04$30 FG<91

39 09$8$03 03. $30$$01 0$$%

> 003. $30$$0.0.40.9.01 90D8403. $30$$0/*/+0<$$$.01 % A %/ / 0<$304.8 .04304.=8$.83*1)+!$ 0 3 <$0.. ..80$$8>1

00 8F?!T!;;C?G03. $30$$080$98 4.4 .9.12 0 3 .9.3$00..0.$...0=00""#+>10.01"1"1"1"1"1+4.$9

Page 47: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

04.=(("'">=(#)>904$..$0.01 0$ 0$.4.0 01

983 .$0.04000 0<'.0">3 00F4 .$0.5..3 $$$9$00.$83 <04'.0)1"0. .$0.5..0 0 '..G12 0 '..0...00 '.$0.=0> .001

43..$%

> ..0 39046!.

> 9.40.00 048 A0. 041

> $ 9 0 4. 9 .$.0 .8 1 0 0 . 9 0$.8 $ 4 0$$8 0901!0 .03.1

.> ..$8<04565!(("'"'+8.$3 1 008. 4300%

> 03. $30$$84. $30$$8056))++=;++>1 00 0000456))""=;"">3.1 08<0 '$.4. 00$4$0 ,0004 $30$$81

> 03. $30$$88.$83 ("'*'+("'*'*1 03. $30$$83. '$4$00 F,.G<04("'*'*1$00 F .0G<04("'*'+ 03. $30$$83 9$34...1 030033 0.4(("'"'+30$0 +"1 03. 040.$.3 00<04 .?9.0?.9#*5-+5469"+-1,?!300 0.0 .A04..$8469"+-1

.-&1

8 %5(3

3 0.9.0 .000.3=0$3>00 <04'.0)1*>=0VC>0A01,;.0=;0> 000$$8 004<890$.83 $04$3$9=!?0B>1 30.44..;..$ .0 4.. ;4<80A1 00 $04 .. ; .0.. ..3 $$0080$..48$4014

Page 48: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

9$8.0")20 0$00401$8.0..0390B 00441

-

84BC&.6 3+

$# ! "

7$.( 1)

9($." "

9"$."( "1)

9"($.+) +1)

9+)$.*+ -

9*+$.- (

9-$.(* "

' )$:;5(3

2 004'.0--1$$<$$04<$ ..000 8 $.0 4 . .. 0 00 1 00 0 0 $. .04.0A$. 0.0044.. 43 3 0<$.41, 0380'.$.0098 4.1 . 4.00%

> < . 04. 0A $.0 3 0.0470=00.-1*1)1"$*4 0.>1

> <$.0.00<8'.0"=00.)$*-4 0.>1

.> .00<80$9004<01

&7(3

1 $&

4.0 4 <$ 3 $ ..0 = ..0>4<8'.$3 '.0(1)3 . 40 .04 ..01

4.88300804%

S ;.9 ..0=00'.0"&>>N

S 8 0 ..0 0 <$ 3 . .. ..00$0 $.98 $03 $.94.

Page 49: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

$.9 0 48 .0830 4 ..01

S $<A..0=00'.0"&>>N

.0.. ;.9 ,. 0 831 2 4 0 .. .0 0 4 $$001 : 83 0.9 $ $9 ..0 4 $. 3 $01 ;.9 4. 00 4. 8440100"&1

1" $,*&A

84$.90008 4301

> ;.9.0004...0.$00...0 1 03 0 8.00003 . .0D.44 9'.$.900..0 <$4 0$$81 0099. 40..$01.$3L+0. 00...0. $31 0 00.4

$.9 ..0983[1"Ω4.'..<$[1+Ω4$8..<$1 0008$00.4+)!$0"1)0 .

4 403 . 90111+)!$01"ΩL(+1)2.000. 4 3 $3"+)21 00044. 3$3 34.0 00.3.00 $83 .000 9$09$.'44.1

> ..00D.. .0000. .80.$84 01. ..0.04 $$000. 04.0.$01.3..0 90.001 00 0440.801..040440=11000$90 $.9 ..>12 0.80$ 44 <$ ..341 039 <$3 804$.0..0 .1

$..0$40.0 8B9 .. 44.04 01$..0 390.81,-#1

02@4

$.$0.. 04

F?G9 .$..041

Page 50: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

.> 4$4 <$098 $ $.94 4 <$0 $=.$3 $0.0 0$.. 3 <$>1

> 9..9..04$ 000.10 0$.9$ 00 80$.4.804.... <04'.0(1)"&1

> 4.094.. $.9..0 0$.91

4> 4$34 00$$80$00 <$408 <$00 0$94$00 $.9.. <$$. <$1 $. $.9..$ <$0 . 0$.4'.0"&1

> ;.9 ..08 01 0 0 ''83.$ 43.00%

"> 4 0 ''83.00'0$N

+> 4$.9..0 ..0.. $.9 .. 000 0. 0 .0004$3.18.80$9 A 0 8 0 4 '4. 4 $.9..1 ..'830 08448 $.9..4 $$01

>$/ % 6 66

> <$0$.90 $93 <04'.0"&04..$.9..10340$0 1 0 4 .. 0 .$1 $ 0 9 3 830$1

#4(

Page 51: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

<&$!

1

040$30$$03 . .90.4 $ - 43 .$0 . 0.0 4 '.$.1 04. 00%

%%%%

,7! 90 6..=6,;!> 0441 04<80084.0 843 <04.<$7!1 ?9047!97(("'".)1+?C1

)1+?C1" 804<$4$4...0800.$1 <$906 !.3 $$. $=0$>4 7!1843 $ 0...3 6!2?'")'");1 08F0$:G1

,$.<$3 <$043 F0$:GF0$8G0$04 $... '0B00 0$4'$80<$3 $.9 .. 0.$83 <04 0$. $=0$> ' A0..8$0F0$8G00$.4 4!. ;0.$.07-#& <$0.$83 )1+?C1+1

)1+?C1+ 0.0470.8 $$301

..<$$8F0$8GF0$:G. $00 $93 0.0. 8.8. 93 <$0..<9.$.F0$8GF0$:G1 .0080.00 . <$04. 0$$8.4 <$1

)1+?C1* 48$$00.0V'8004<8=11;004A..0>1

,<$4$ 83 . $.00 .'0..0 . $0 ..$4.00 )$.4 .$ <$4$ .001

)1+?C1- ,0...<$4..0'$ 00.0 0$04<84 .31,$0 0$... ..0")!$014 39 9.0"-! $0"1)!="1+)>10. 3.40700.3"+!="+"1+)L")!>1

.$4V'8<$ . $0 ..$403 .00 "+)$.4 .3 09< 94 <$=.0$ $.$.4>14 <$04$403449049844

Page 52: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

..0 . $$93 <$0 ..$4 943 . <$0.4..3 0 $$4 4.81

)1+?C1) 2 $A. $00 ....0 4.0 .. $ 3 Y7;60 84 439.00 $8..0 .. 04 % ...40'0$ 0$03. ..3 44$00840 8 0'$9.$.99.1

%%%7 ) "

84.04.3 4$3.0$301 9$.FTG.3 30.04440$14 00$$$8...3 0 00$ 3943...3 01 0<0 0$0 9 $3. 1'.0)1*>*>3 00FS!6;7:0 43 ;27;;T?1G + )

04 1

>

0.>30$.$03 '.0)1*>*>104- 1

>

Page 53: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

D : % % 1 % * + % -6 % %1

%%%6 ) ) .

;3 03. 0 80 00 4 9 .$ ..0. $01 0.0 3 4. 9 74 4+)C0430%

08$I!'41!..L"1($?0.L*1VC1

%%%; )

,03. 04<8.04'.$.1...3 '.0)(1"" 403. 0404 $$01 804403. 00430%

/&9&$1$.0. .8$$. 4'$.9.0$0404.4.4"*)64"1 4.0$$94(+)

+1 0

9.0048 A1

*1,'$.9.00 . .03 98$.$01$.0. .8 9.$00$00$.00. 0$$04.1 0 89. 4.00048 A1 0$03 09$..003 403. 9=$03>438000=0$.84403. 0.$9.0>1

$#1,'$.9.000;V"..)+#14.04<8.$ 004 004 9$'$40 <1 008$.4<$3 . 8 0.0$31004030$0 403. 1 004()+#$$4$'$4<$= 0048(("'" 008 1>

$..8$$0840.3408 0.$1 00 4330 3 3.40 403. 04330 = 0>3.1 00 030000$8 403. 80$3 09$0108 0$08 403. 33.04&' 80 41 4 ..03. $044'$.9.04<$ 0;V&..)+#1$.0. .8 004()+#43 <$= 8$.00$$83 <$>1

99$0 03+-C..1

%%%5 ' ) .' '"

09.0444$.4040800$9 $.4$.$010

Page 54: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

..6 ""+39 09.04<.04'.$..0 9.0$$94 01,$4'$$9 .'0.$ .9.'.0)(1(<0 '.'4.$+014 .'40 .$001 00$8 .03 9&E4$$9 .'01

1" $9

430.840 9.0? D80.4$01908 9400 $3$ ..84 04304.3 ..0.0 44. $89894$04 <$1

2 7(("'"0(("'"'-$69004 04010..$ 94 4.B0 4$9D890$4 .9.J$B1,?!0.0 0J$B 0 84.1 408 4.B00149.00444.9 44.04 0437..1 043.<4,?!0600484 <04(("'"'-.$4D94.1

7+4(("'""##)04330F.0G30)+46(("'"'-(("'"'-0.1

0480<$(("'"'-0.$..4312 0<4 4.0 080.994.94. $ 04 0439$40$.4.4$.10.4$03 940 F90G4.0 0 9.4 04330901

? 9$4 043..03. 0$43 . 0430%

#) 0*$

80$.4. 004<8980. 8

43$.4. 0430$.4.4048

33 03 3 83 . 1?0$.4934.1

3$.4. 004<800<84

43?9$; 4$08.$1 $0 .9$ 004 ?9$48.1

43A!800; 6838000

0;=4306"-#">

6838000

08 6838000

43C4.; 90D844.03 993 9DC4.C.1 0044.93840$ 03$4.0

Page 55: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

8308 $494.91

43C; ,<8003 04394.$$0001

A!800$ 04.$0 30004. 0 0.$ 091

4394.$ 0.008$04<8 0'$04 94.=110$.$0.1>4 $1

43C$ C84<800

000 $4J04B <04(("'"'-0!$$(1 0(("'"'-=0 090> 4.00$040.$.4.$83 .03$9$.4?46 !. $.344 $71

Page 56: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

,,)G ! /$ !

:080.0

/ $ -

(-"')*+ !.

(**)'"%"##".01(

'$ 0.

(**)'"%"##".01(

'$ 0.3 ..

(-"')*" ?..

(-"')** ..

6

6

Page 57: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

:080.0

/ $ -

(-"')"# ;.9 =>

(-"')" =>

(-)) .$4 ..;!66T6!?Y7;6

(-"')+" <$8

(-"')"+ !Y7;6

,G

()+#

6L" ;.09.843$0

+ ;.09.843$03 .0$")W

* ;.00$83- ;.00$0 3) ;.03D0( ;.0$343D0 ;.0 44.04

Page 58: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

:080.0

/ $ -

'-*- !.0!;!6T6:

?76

(-"') F6G=$3>Q. 0R

(-"')& F,,G=$3>Q?0..4 0R

(-"')+(- F6G4$4 Y7;6

(-"')+)( F,,G4$4 Y7;6

(-"')(*& .80$

Page 59: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

:080.0

/ $ -

VVV

TTT

(-"' ?8.8.VVV0 NTTT0 4410 0$$$ 904VVVTTT11X0X40.0XX401

(-"')&- T;!;;?;!

6% .0(1"<0 4.443 8(-"')***8(-"')&-0

(-"')*** T;,!;;?;!

(-"')**) T;,!;;?;!

(-"')**" 8!;<$

(-"')**+ 8!;:<$

Page 60: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

:080.0

/ $ -

(-"')*( ?09

(-"')"- 6'A..

(-"')&-" ?4'$4T;!;;?;!

(-"')**- ?4'$4T;,!;;?;!

(-"')**( ?4'$4T;,!;;?;!

*&(-.0&1*

20

6..%83%.8%.

Page 61: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

, .0805(&&$9004.$4$ .0800..<$.$..1

,08<08 080 0.4 400.$0 080 3 .00830808$ .98$. $9 00..9. .0.04 0.080$ .00$001

Page 62: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

,,)G"!4) &4

4<<$# # ,

)$ 4

!$$$04.004.

!800.'=0>4

.04<04

?4'$4$$$04

?$00A$0008002

?8.8.4

.80$9..4

,. 4

,0048$4

99.04

;.004.4

0$...<$40$$8<0

4.0$$4..000.0$004.4

4.0$$40$...<$$04.4

004$40400 "*)4

0$$8$0040.4

8$4.4..000.0$004.4

8$4.40$...<$$04.4

9$024

9.0$2

; 80.44.0 8.0 $$24

;<A..4

;34 <$48$4 0$.4 <$$9 $3

;30 800.'0..040$.4.<$4

; 0$0 024

;.9 4

9$.90. .0084$.

489.4.8.4

Page 63: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

)$ 4

4.03 $$.44.00049.4

0$04$009.0

0$040$. 00

04...<$...<$$0

)$ 4

048$40 (1+>

,. 04 (1+>

,00 .'09'.0048$4

(1+>

A004.$.0 ....$0 (1+>

0$ 04 (1+>

9$04 (1+.>

024$00=7?9*1"?C1"1">

2 0.$3. $.8<8$0.0$00 9 48440 ..$8.01. 4$.408$08$0 8$$. $094 089..$9 '00 .$ 3 0.040 $. 1

*1"

60$$84 (1+ >

;.9 04 (1+4>

$$804 (1+D>@>

$40$$804$80<$ (1+>

4$

)$ 4

9.003. 0.4$0 (1*>

003. 4.4 (1*>

;303. 04FGF44G$00 (1*)(1"

7040!..$00 0080 (1*>

Page 64: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

$

)$#

!..000. $0004 (1&1+>

!9..$30..04809.0.14<4048

(1&1+>

!9..$30..0.04.8

(1&1+>

!$$$04.$49-"\ (1"<>-+1*

0.0040 (1&1+

02903.0..$0 (1&1+

00<$20$$80 (1&1+>

004.00$.40)

!.. 8$4$.0.. .

00 )1"

00 )1"

8;3 )1"

!.. 4$.0.. .4

8$ )1+

8$, )1+

8$, )1+

!.. 4$.000424=0(1">

)1*

!.. =0>40A04..8 4.

)1-

!.. 40484$$. $0.440 .3 3 80%

<$040 $0.440 .3 3 80N=60$$>

)1)

8!;<$N

)1)

8!;:<$N

)1)

.0043 (1&1+

.<80 (1&1+>

?.040!.008 (1&1+

,40.043..1 (1&1+

44008030090<$$4

(1&1+>

4..4?T;,6

Page 65: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

)$#

400.0$4

00.4

66??7566??;7;4

66!!;27$.4.4$.

4$0.4

.;03 . 0$48C;66

.;?7$48 ;6:!6K!6

00$.4(1"

004..000

003 . ;!6;!0$04 A004

9$024

; 80.$4.. .0.004

;34 <$$.4.4 <$

.$.4.204.

!,2 6:!?4;!60$$

!,T?C4.8.0.0.C;66

3;.4

:6!6;757;7;!;<$ 8.

'$;.4

'$< 40

800480004$4

. .0.$<4.3 .4

0$.024

2048.004

2.0$4

$9 /

948008

2

*&(-0'.0&1*

>=0

!$$">

2%?00$000016'09.8 D01

8'-*-

%?00$008 4016'09.8 $. 6C66

Page 66: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

=0!$$">

>480084*&(-1 $$$080$.

.8 .12 0809.$.0 8$4880 30 3 0$$809880$.408 301704.098 083<04 .8 <$4. 4. .8 <$301,6 !.0

Page 67: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

,,)G6!-/)&-/04-/

$*11

5 6 25 5 6 75 8 ' "

$*11

" 6 "5 "5 7 5 25

1- 1) 1 " "1( +1- * - -1) (!!'!6

$.03$04$$0$840$<90.0!$

1& " "1* + * - )1) & "";!:

?!6

1& " "1+ "1( +1) *1) -1) ( (1) #!!'!6

$.0$904$.'0.$$80! !/!!KA!A!

"1 + +1* * - ( & "1) "+ "(;!:

?!6

"1( + +1- *1+ ) # "+ "* "&!!'!6

$.0$9304$.?4.0!"!!4A!A!

*1- - -1( ( & "+ "( +" +- *+;!:

?!6

04-/1>

-E,A

,,0),-

-E,A+

,,0),-

-E,+

,,0),-

.-<0

<)-<

?0+.0-

<)-<

<0

<)-<

?0+.0-

<)-<

<0

<)-<

?0+.0-

<)-<

;!6! !:76;!6!7V!T76

1.1

" ) " ) " )

;!6! !:76;!6!7V!T76

1.1

" ) " ) " )

Page 68: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

;!6! !:763 ,67;;T

C!:!;;?;!

I ) )

6" ,!! !:760"#1-16+ ,75!567! !:760"#1->16* .4C4 +0X!6C!:!;;?;!X

06:,!76?63 00$.0.1

?.. .40+C4(("'"

-*$$*.>

-A-.5 5L.

5 5L."5

"5L.

L.

L.

0.0 ) " ") +7O" 7O+

$$80 ) + +) +7O+ 7O*

4.!?0

) * - +=+7O")>

+=7O+)>

4.008$0.8;.01

6"CC016+2 93 . 9000D.00'001.1 08$4000)A091 0.0 94 090 4C0

4.9=7>< 0$''$998 1

C"

O+

'+

'-

'(

" "+ "* "- ") "(

9

=>%+

K=>

K=L">

,<.8=> A

"

+K 00 +>

"L"[)E

+L"[)E

"L")M,[)E

ΩΩ

">

">

">6'.9.$0

$.]0$.K+>

?

<9 900<401

Page 69: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

,,)G7!%&&

%-/

$# <0!

"

7$.( 1)

9($." "1

9"$."( "1)

9"($.+) +1)

9+)$.*+ -1

9*+$.- (1

9-$.(* "1

&&

<$ 0 <BP ;00P

'<$ ?$=>

;0 =>

?$=>

;<$ $.=>

;0 =>

=>

<$ $.=

;0 =>

,8 $.=>

<$ ;0 =>

Page 70: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

,,)G5!9&,9&4

?83483. ;3$$87=;7>006(("'"'+%+"P

4 03 0<00 T 9 3 1488 . 0 $30$$81

?8 9D.99.4.$.0$4 . ..8 448?00.P

4 03 0<00 6 0$1 ?B 8 0 4 01 08'.$1

?83 48;7 00 6(#)P

4 03 0<00T 0$1

4. 900 .008 0 ;7 3 ..$ 40.9.1

. 0$.4.0 4 4. 0. 4 0 =08 0 $> 0800 0 F 09. 0 4 0 3 $ ..<$G1 00 .0 0$.0 = >1

?8348;700("'*'+P

4 03 0<00 T 9 3 1488 . 0 $30$$81

?8 9D.99.4.$.0$4 . ..8 448?00.P

4 03 0<00 6 0$1 ?B 8 0 4 01 08'.$1

?8348;700("'*'*P

4 03 0<00 T 9 3 1488 . 0 $30$$81

?8 9D.99.4.$.0$4 . ..8 448?00.P

4 03 0<00 6 0$1 ?B 8 0 4 01 08'.$1

Page 71: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

,,)G!$90$,&

) " 6 7 5 2 8

?C;6,'T H

;<0$.4. H

C,!6$ H

;C!?!6$ H

;. .0$.4. H

080=11;><0$.4. H

;. .0$.4. H

08000$.4. H

08000$.4. H H

C,!6 000 H H H H

;C!?!6 000 H

H .0004 $ 01

?0$

? $$. 4 ?C;6 ,'T 0 $ 3. 0.4%

+ 0911%

0439$ 0N

.$043=!>0N

$N

30439$$40N

00N

0.00N

+ ...$0N

+ 3N

+ ';4.N

+ 80.0N

+ 9.0N

+ '$8043N

+ 3$01

? $.04 .<8"-#"100 3$0.81;..84.0..0009.01 .00$.8X^X4.0 .00"-#"1

Page 72: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

4.4

3

40!K!?

^-1+

$

^*1-

;<

0$.4.

-&1(

;. .

0$.4.

-&1

?00$.4.

-&1&

C!?!6 0

00

-&1"

?7!

^(1*

04

0.CT

90

^-1*

!

6!T

$.

^-

0

-&1)1"1+

00$.4.

-&1&

080

. .

0$.4.

-&1

080

<0

0$.4.

-&1(

!0000$

-&1"+

<8.0

!6!:6

,

^*1)

Y 8.0

C,!6$

-&1#

?C;6,'

T

-&1-

C!?!6$

-&1"

54

!800

^(1-^

0

$

^&

!K!?

9

<0.

C,!6

0

. <000

9

?7!

?7!

9

^(1*

C,!6

-&1 #

6

-&1 )1+

C!76

^)

!6!T

^-

!K!?

^"

!K!?

^"

!K!?

^"

!K!?

^"

Page 73: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

! !7 &4

0.0 $.44;9$0(("'"'-1.000430.0%

1 !.. .03 . 000$ $.<0400 3 0<004303 . 0..1

1 !. .03 . 308 $4 1

) &4

. .0 4 0.00 <04("'"'-..4 .000.#4 01 $$04 . .00000 00004;...8000 0<0139 9$$.0049;_0084403 .0$.1 4.3 0.0 8.8 00008 ..03 ;0 <04 01

, 0$$0 43.. .00$93 $4 D.94. $.00$.4.9. 01 .0 8$4. 8 9$$.004;1! .0.0 3 0 .4 .0 .9 0$.0.$83 <04 01 4 0. .00000$ 0000$.00 $4 <012 .800 00000904. 0041

4?.<0

-F) </K* ! !7

$.!0

!.00 ...3 (1*4#'*1

)+1+"1"

4080

9. 0,0$$900. ...3 4.4080...3 (1+4#'*1* %%+

)+1+"1+

)+1++1*

$44.5. .$.....3 -1)1+4#"

)+1+""1"

)+1+""1+

Y4.4$0 0 <8<4$0 904 $$$001

)+1+)

Page 74: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

70

9$043P

' Y!$.0$$

' 4

' 0

' A4.

' 00

)+1+"1"

)+1+"1+

)+1++1*

)+1+-1+

)+1+-1*1"1

)+1+-1*1+1"

?.0$.

"108

' 4 A0 .00

' 040

' 4.04800

' <=0>.0

' 94 44.90040.

' 4.94. 000

;90084 A00004800 44.9003 4.94.1

)+1+"1*

)+1+-1*1"1"

)+1+-1*1+1)

)+1+-1-1)

)+1+-1-1(

)+1+#1*

+10;

' 0.$4$

' 0$00

' A4.

;99934 $$. $ 0000.3 ;1

)+1++1"

)+1++1+

)+1+-1*1"1"

*1;.?9$;

Page 75: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

?9$4'8.

' 9$4'.8.=409$4;>

' 0.$49$$ 00=3 $0$04. $ 0>

' 9.40. $ 0

' .<0

' 94.9$0

<00$.4.

' <00$.4.4;. 400'0800

' 0'4.0

' 488.048'4.0

0 9$4 ;30..$'40.$3 0 9$$.001

0 9$4 ;8400'080300<00$.4. 0'4.048049$. 0049.0 $04 ;$004.1

)+1+*1"

)+1+*1+

)+1+*1*

)+1+*1-

)+1+*1)

)+1+(1"

)+1+(1+

)+1+(1*

-10;.00

0!800

' A800N04 A04.0<.0<.490...001

' 00N 40098.A 01

0

' ?4403 D04.

' 0. 0=. 098 >

0 %

> A000.3 $4 ; 9.040..0.0

> .$$. 0$0 000.3 . A

.> .0 93 $$$. 400..$91

0 3 30.0$N 040$.90004=30>1

, 00 $9<95<904 000$.00$$.8 9$4 ;1

)+1+-1*1"1"

)+1+-1*1"1+

)+1+-1*1"1*

)+1+-1*1"1-

)+1+-1*1"1(

)+1+-1*1"1

)+1+-1*1"1&

)+1+-1*1"1#

)+1+-1*1+1"

)+1+-1*1+1+

)+1+-1*1+1*

)+1+-1*1+1-

)+1+-1-1"

)+1+-1-1+

)+1+-1-1*

)+1+-1-1-

Page 76: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

)1;.?0?.

!. .

' 0$.4.4 . .4 ;00'0800

?0$

' 000$.4.4;. 0'080

' 0$.4.<0452529$0.1=0$$$>

C4.

' 94.$4. $ 049$

' 00494.

C

' 9$

' 0049

0 . .4 ;0008000048 <00$.4.1

0 048<0 9$1

0 048<0 9$.0008$$$$40003 $4 01

)+1+1"

)+1+1+

)+1+1*

)+1+#1"

)+1+#1+

)+1+"1"

)+1+"1+

)+1+"1*

)+1+"1-

)+1+"1)

)+1+"1(

Page 77: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

? .0

041 ,0

("'"'-)+1+"

?.

)+1+"1"

#'*.-1"(

?.0$.4$$.4 000 0 4$4 <8.0N04+"1 00 ...3 (1*4#'*1

)6E F6 G

)+1+"1+

#'*.-1)

0.0 40 0,0 $$900. ...3 4.40801 00 ...3 (1+4#'*1

. )(((%

= )= A = * +

.

= =

Page 78: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

041 ,0

)+1+"1* !080 9$ ?9$4'.8.0$4 0410 .%

> 4!K!? .00> 040.> 4. 04800.

<04880. 04 A

> 9444.90040.> 4.94.

)

' * H+ 1 %.7 1

* & +

5"1"" 4 ,)+1++1" 4.0 $$0

$

$$04 0.04 $04 . ..903 . <0 9$4.8.1

)+1++1+ 0$0 . 43%

>.$4 $4 $D.$. 9$4'.8.$ 0043 . $0$$.% * .%

> 9$4'.8.$$=0)+1+*>.94.$9$= G G = .

Page 79: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

041 ,0

.>0$00...3 -1"4#"(

>0$.00I -7-=(

><0493

)+1++1* 4 $. 0 .049$.4 . 00 $

- G

)+1+* ?9$4.8.0 (/A.

)+1+*1" !9$4'.8.0 44 09$4 ;

)+1+*1+ 9$4'.8.0 9$ 00003 3S4$$.984.

/ 1 % / / D

)+1+*1* 9$4'.8.0 .$.00040. 1

)+1+*1- 9$4'.8.0 ..<0

)+1+*1) 0.900 $$8 9$4'.8.0$$$N0)+1+-

)+1+- 0;.00 1

)+1+-1")+1+-1+

!0$.000 0 0 430%' 0800' 0.

Page 80: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

041 ,0

)+1+-1+ $.000 $$ 9$4'.8.

)+1+-1* 0!800

)' = 1 = 1

)+1+-1*1" A!800

)+1+-1*1"1" A04.0 .04 0$N0)+1++

) > . A

' H

)+1+-1*1"1+ A00 440840..0.0.%' 0' ..0'

)+1+-1*1"1* A0.00 .0$$$%

' A0$0' A0$0' A009.$0' A0800' A0 9

)+1+-1*1"1- 08400<.04903 . 80 A0 .01

< H*/0A/-%0-+

' 1

-'

Page 81: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

041 ,0

& H*' +

' H

)+1+-1*1"1) .00.00 .0$$$%

4.0N % 6 %

340G * %0A/-+

4340 0G/A 9.0%&

' %: %

,& , &

. %A%

- %% %

. G A

)+1+-1*1"1( 0.00 .0$$$% $84080.$0.

3043 704...

3000 !...84040 0

4.0.040 ?$.4

.00 054. $8043

6 H

)+1+-1*1"1 A4. 0$$$ 9$4'.8.$ 00 0A G &% % & %1% 11 1

Page 82: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

041 ,0

)+1+-1*1"1& 00=1148004044.0800>0 . 041

)+1+-1*1"1# 004 $$.4 00 . 041A % % % 1 % %

)+1+-1*1"1"

. 4 A0.000 . 0081

1H

)

' '

* 1 1 + '

&F'

)+1+-1*1+ 00

)+1+-1*1+1" ,. 4 A 00 01

)+1+-1*1+1+ 04 00 004 4. A5 0984 .0<.04. A1

% ' 1 H 1 H

)+1+-1*1+1* 0989.0 0 . 041

' 1 % 1 H

)+1+-1*1+1- 0 0 <9<90 . 041

Page 83: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

041 ,0

& 1

)+1+-1*1+1) 000 .0. A 0081

)+1+-1- 0

)+1+-1-1" 00 .0 004. 4 A0..$1=..0.0>1

)+1+-1-1+ !00..$4 0000 < 0 0003008$..1

& 1% 1 % 1/& 1 : H H

1 H

< -7-=( : H

)+1+-1-1* 040.0 . 4 A. 0984 A 1

< 1 H H

)+1+-1-1- 0. 00 . .04 A0=118.0 >8.$.9003 . $3 .04 A0$0 0 43$8%

' 040' $.900.0' <04 00

' H

J % ' %

Page 84: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

041 ,0

% %

( % * +%

*1 - 1%% %

)+1+-1-1) <0. 00 . 008=.80.00'4.>1

1 .= (/A.% % % %

)+1+-1-1( !94 44.9004 0.00 . 081=11$090.. 9000.1>1

%= 1A ' 1 1 %: % 1

)+1+) Y4.4;0

1 &H- H-&%&%1 F %1 F 1

)+1+( <$.4.

)+1+(1" , ;. 4000800=114;> 0 <0$.4.1

)+1+(1+ <0$.4.0 4.0 01 0.04.03 . .0004% > .% A 00049.0 0003 ; ;004.0

Page 85: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

041 ,0

*$ 1 G #2!+

)+1+(1* ,. 4 04.0 <00$.4.0 9 940488.008. 001

. 1

)+1+ !. .

)+1+1" . .0 0048 <00$.4.1

%

)+1+1+ , ;. 4000800. .0 0$.41

6%

& * +

)+1+1* 2 $$$ 0$.4.0 .<04% !.40.0000800

.$04 ; .8 ?908 ,004.$0 ?0..9*6 6

G5+ .040 80.40 090 .G

% %

;.4 .00

%:

Page 86: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

041 ,0

)+1+& ?0$

)+1+&1" 2 $$$ 00 .$000800. 9000$.4.1

)+1+&1+ 2 $$$<00 0$.44%

439$ 0 %

.. 3 $043!0 00 !.0 ;4. 80.0 9.0/A ; $8043$.

% %

)+1+# C4.

)+1+#1" C4.4 $4048<00 .

- 1 =A(%

% %

C

)+1+#1+ !94.$3$.0 3 3 048<04. 9$4'.8.

Page 87: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

041 ,0

$ 03941

)+1+#1* !4. 0004 94..900 . 0081

)+1+" C

)+1+"1" C 048<00 .1

)+1+"1+ !9$0 $.0 3 ..048<0 9$1

*+

)+1+"1* 4 .8 90 $4 01

%

)+1+"1- !$4000 $04 04 93 00 . 0,1

)+1+"1) 6400 9 0301

#!

)+1+"1( !4. 004 90 . 0,1

: H H

)+1+"" 4.

)+1+""1" 48400044.40 4 00$$004330 .984 $900.0 00004.. $.1

/ H

0

* 6 +H

)+1+""1+ !9.0 9$4.8.0 9093$$9..0. ...3 -1)1+4#"<91

Page 88: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

041 ,0

A -

%

)+1+"+ !0000

)+1+"+1" !00000 .0 ; 09$...3 <04 00. 041 08.81

1/"#662H

F H

<K- H

< H

F& H

Page 89: Why 90 Percent of Medical Devices Fail

%&'($)*+,$-&+-

!$$$.

$ $9& )*