wide binary science using pan-starrs1 niall deacon (mpia) michael liu, eugene magnier, will best,...

22
WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN- STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER (CALTECH), ADAM KRAUS, TRENT DUPUY, ANDREW MANN (TEXAS)

Upload: stephanie-goodwin

Post on 19-Jan-2016

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER

WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1

NIALL DEACON (MPIA)

MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER (CALTECH), ADAM KRAUS, TRENT DUPUY, ANDREW MANN (TEXAS)

Page 2: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER

BREAKING THE DEGENERACY

Saumon & Marley models

Page 3: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER

PSO 318-22:THE “LONELY PLANET”

Liu+ 2013

PSO J318.5−22 is the first free-floating object with the colors, spectra, magnitudes, luminosity, and mass that overlap the young dusty planets around HR 8799 and 2MASS J1207−39.

Page 4: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER

PS1 + 2MASS SEARCH FINDS SUBSTELLAR MEMBERS OF YOUNG MOVING GROUPS

Wavelength (μm)

Flu

x +

Con

stan

t

Incr

easi

ng A

ge

40 MJup

Kimberly Aller (IfA)

Page 5: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER
Page 6: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER

BENCHMARK SYSTEMSWide companions to main sequence stars

Age, distance and metallicity determined from primary

Break degeneracy

Formation mechanism for wide binaries uncertain

2MASS J

Page 7: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER

BENCHMARKSWHAT ARE THEY GOOD FOR?

Testing atmospheric models of ultracool dwarfs.

Deacon et al. (2012) Burningham et al. (2009)

Higher order multiples can also have masses measured.

Dupuy et al. (2009,2014)

Used to define metallicity relations for M dwarfs. Mann et al. (2014), Newton et al. (2014), Royas-Ayala et al. (2012)

Huh! GoodGodY’all!

Starr et al. 1969

Page 8: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER

SELECTING CANDIDATES

Input primary listHigh m Hipparcos starsM dwarfs from LSPM, rNLTT, Lepine & Gaidos (2011)

Search PS1 proper motions for objects with comparable proper motions (rmax = 10,000 AU or 20 arcmins)

Follow up companions with IRTF/SpeXHigh priority: zp1-yp1 > 0.8Back-up: J<15Preferentially followed up close (<5 arcmins) companions

Page 9: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER

DISCOVERY SUMMARY

58 new companions

31 known

24 new Ls

23 late Ms

Deacon et al. ApJ revised

Page 10: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER

Open: total knownSolid: Our contribution

Doubled

82% more

Deacon et al. ApJ revised

Page 11: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER

NEW ATMOSPHERIC MODELS REPRODUCE TEMPERATURES WELL

Deacon et al 2012

Page 12: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER

HIGHER ORDER MULTIPLICITY

8 of our objects are tertiary components

One companion showed usual water band absorption

Spectra suggest L1 + T3

See Burgasser (2007), Dupuy & Liu (2012) for methodology

Keck NIRC2 LGS/AO0.12” binary>300 yr period

Page 13: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER

WIDE COMPANIONS AND EXOPLANETS

Kaib et al. 2013

Page 14: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER

Full proper motion survey of the Kepler field using all available data

GOALS

Probe effect of wide binarity on planet occurrence

Wide binaries as tests of gyrochronology

Testing axial alignment of binaries

Powerful legacy dataset to characterise Kepler planet hosts

PS1 KEPLER STANDARD PROJECT

Page 15: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER

ASTROMETRIC ACCURACY

Page 16: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER

PROBLEM AREAS

Reduced Proper MotionHr = r +5 + 5log10mHr = Mr + 5log10vt + const

Page 17: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER
Page 18: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER

PS1 KEPLER STATUS

Combining PS1 + 2MASS + POSS I & II+ UKIRT + WISE+SDSS

Will rerun on corrected DVO database

Include Skyprobe data for bright KICs

High resolution spectroscopic follow-up at McDonald

Probabilistic binary selection

STS field

Run on K2 fields?

TO-DO

Page 19: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER

CLOSE BINARIES IN SYNOPTIC SURVEYS

Objects have ≈50 observations in PS1

True binaries will be more elliptical in better seeing

Can be used to identify >0.4’’ binaries in PS1 data

0.4” binary

First used on PTF data by Terziev et al. (2012)

Blue histogram: objects not resolved as binaries with AO

Page 20: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER

SUMMARY

Doubled the number of wide late M companions

82% increase in wide late L companions

Most successful survey for benchmark companions to date

PS1Kepler probing wide binary – planet connection

Synoptic surveys provide a wealth of data for discovering new multiple systems

Page 21: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER

COINCIDENT?

Page 22: WIDE BINARY SCIENCE USING PAN-STARRS1 NIALL DEACON (MPIA) MICHAEL LIU, EUGENE MAGNIER, WILL BEST, KIMBERLY ALLER, MICHAEL KOTSON (HAWAII), BRENDAN BOWLER

STABILITY

Deacon et al. ApJ revised