7/21/2019 William Shanley's Lawsuit DISMISSED

1/3

_@IXOH UXBXOU HIUX^IEX EM_^X

HIUX^IEX MG EM@@OEXIE_X

QICCIBL N^B@HM@ UFB@COY,

Zcbi`tigg,

v.

^. UE_HHO^ ULIXF, ot bc.,Hogo`hb`ts.

@m. 5428-ev-:2662 (DBL)

M^HO^ MG HIULIUUBC Z_^U_B@X XM >6 _.U.E. 292?(o)(>)(N)

B gohorbc emurt lby hisliss b` i` gmrlb pbuporis betim` bt b`y tilo ig it hotorli`os

tfbt b` betim` is grivmcmus mr lbcieimus mr mtforwiso gbics tm stbto b ecbil m` wfief rociog lby

no arb`toh. >6 _.U.E. 292?(o)(>)(N);Bnnbs v. Hixm`, 86: G.5h 757, 759 (>h Eir. >::1);

Zbttorsm` v. ^mhaors, 1:6 G. Uupp. >h >>?, >525> (H. Em``. >:2:).

Zcbi`tigg i` tfis betim` fbs gicoh b` i` gmrlb pbuporis emlpcbi`t bccoai`a tfbt

hogo`hb`tsi`ecuhi`a tfo@ow Ymrk Xilos, tfoFbrtgmrh Emurb`t, b`h mtfor lohib porsm`s

fbvo em`spiroh tm puncisf b pfmtmarbpf mg efichro` oxiti`a Ub`hy Fmmk Ocolo`tbry Uefmmc witf

b ebptim` gbcsocy i`hiebti`a tfbt tfo pfmtmarbpf wbs tbko` m` tfo lmr`i`a mg tfo trbaie sfmmti`a

tforo i` Hoeolnor >:2>. Zcbi`tigg ho`mu`eos tfo erili`bc em`spirbey tfbt puncisfoh tfo gbko

pfmtmarbpf b`h tfo porpotrbtmrs mg b` bet mg torrmrisl babi`st lo, tfo Zompco mg tfo _`itoh

Utbtos b`h tfo Qmrch ebccoh Xfo Ub`hy Fmmk Lbssbero. Hme. #2-2 bt 5. Zcbi`tigg sooks $?

niccim` i` pu`itivo hblbaos.

Zcbi`tiggs betim` obsicy wbrrb`ts hislissbc u`hor 292?(o)(>)(N). Xm noai` witf, pcbi`tigg

hmos `mt bccoao b pcbusinco i`dury-i`-gbet tm fil porsm`bccy tfbt wmuch suggieo tm ostbncisf

stb`hi`a gmr b gohorbc emurt betim`. Uoo ao`orbccy Cudb` v. Hogo`hors mg Qichcigo, ?:8 _.U. ???

Ebso 5428-ev-:2662-DBL Hmeulo`t 6 Gicoh :2/27/2? Zbao 2 mg 5

www.Ub`hyFmmkGbets.eml

7/21/2019 William Shanley's Lawsuit DISMISSED

2/3

>

(299>). @mr hmos tfo emlpcbi`t sot gmrtf em`eoivbnco armu`hs gmr rociog u`hor b`y mg tfo gmur

stbtutos tfbt fo eitos bs tfo nbsis gmr fis betim`.

Girst, pcbi`tigg sooks rociog u`hor b gohorbc erili`bc stbtuto, 26 _.U.E. 2:>6, wfief

erili`bcizos grbuh rocbti`a tm iho`tigiebtim` hmeulo`ts. Gohorbc erili`bc cbws bro i`to`hoh tm no

i`vmkoh b`h o`gmreoh ny gohorbc prmsoeutmrs, soo >6 _.U.E. ?27, ?81, b`h tfoy hm `mt

mrhi`bricy aivo riso tm b privbto riaft mg betim` ny lolnors mg tfo puncie. Uoo Bcoxb`hor v.

Ub`hmvbc, ?5> _.U. >1?, >6761 (>::2);^opuncie mg Irbq v. BNN BA, 176 G.5h 28?, 21: (>h Eir.

>:28). Bs tfo Uuprolo Emurt fbs `mtoh, b privbto eitizo` cbeks b duhieibccy ema`izbnco i`torost i`

tfo prmsoeutim` mr `m`prmsoeutim` mg b`mtfor.Ci`hb ^.U. v. ^iefbrh H., 82: _.U. 728, 729

(2915); soo bcsm Mnib`ym v. Xo``ossoo, ?26 G. Bppx 12, 1> (5h Eir. >:25) (por euribl) (`m

privbto riaft mg betim` u`hor 26 _.U.E. 2:>6); Abrby v. _.U. Nb`emrp, 5:5 G. Uupp. >h >99,

5:> (O.H.@.Y. >::8) (sblo).

Uoem`h, pcbi`tigg rocios m` 26 _.U.E. 2:56, wfief `mt m`cy erili`bcizos eortbi` em`huet

i`vmcvi`a fmbxos (suef bs b`tfrbx fmbx cottors) nut bcsm prmvihos gmr b privbto riaft mg betim` gmr

b`y pbrty i`eurri`a oxpo`sos i`eiho`t tm b`y olorao`ey mr i`vostiabtivo rospm`so stolli`a

grml b hogo`hb`ts erili`bc fmbx sefolo. 26 _.U.E. 2:56(n). Ovo` bssuli`a tfbt hogo`hb`ts

em`huet foro blmu`toh tm tfo em`voyb`eo mg gbcso mr liscobhi`a i`gmrlbtim`, pcbi`tigg fbs

bccoaoh `m oxpo`sos tfbt fo i`eurroh noebuso mg hogo`hb`ts bccoaoh betim`s. Beemrhi`acy, fo fbs

`m pcbusinco armu`hs gmr eivic rociog u`hor 26 _.U.E. 2:56.

Xfirh, pcbi`tigg rocios m` 26 _.U.E. >555, wfief i` pbrt butfmrizos b eivic betim` ny

[b\`y `btim`bc mg tfo _`itoh Utbtos i`duroh i` fis mr for porsm`, prmporty, mr nusi`oss ny robsm`

mg b` bet mg i`tor`btim`bc torrmrisl. 26 _.U.E. >555(b). Bs `mtoh bnmvo, pcbi`tigg fbs `mt

pcbusincy bccoaoh b`y i`dury grml tfo punciebtim`-mg-b-liscobhi`a-ebptim` em`huet bnmut wfief

Ebso 5428-ev-:2662-DBL Hmeulo`t 6 Gicoh :2/27/2? Zbao > mg 5

www.Ub`hyFmmkGbets.eml

7/21/2019 William Shanley's Lawsuit DISMISSED

3/3

5

fo emlpcbi`s. @mr hmos tfo em`huet bccoaoh i`vmcvo b` bet mg i`tor`btim`bc torrmrisl, wfief is

hogi`oh i` pbrt tm i`vmcvo vimco`t bets mr bets hb`aormus tm fulb` cigo tfbt meeur prilbricy

mutsiho tfo torritmribc durishietim` mg tfo _`itoh Utbtos, mr trb`seo`h `btim`bc nmu`hbrios i` torls

mg tfo lob`s ny wfief tfoy bro beemlpcisfoh, tfo porsm`s tfoy bppobr i`to`hoh tm i`tilihbto mr

emoreo, mr tfo cmebco i` wfief tfoir porpotrbtmrs mporbto mr sook bsycul. 26 _.U.E.

>552(2)(B), (E).

Gi`bccy, pcbi`tigg rocios m` 26 _.U.E. >559, wfief erili`bcizos eortbi` bets i`vmcvi`a

fbrnmri`a mr em`eobci`a torrmrists. Xfis prmvisim` is b erili`bc cbw b`h witfmut b eivic

o`gmreolo`t prmvisim` b`h tfbt, gmr robsm`s hoserinoh bnmvo, lby `mt sorvo bs tfo nbsis gmr b

eivic cbwsuit.

I` sfmrt, pcbi`tiggs ecbils bro grivmcmus b`h gur`isf `m pcbusinco mr em`eoivbnco armu`hs

gmr rociog. Beemrhi`acy, tfo emlpcbi`t is HIULIUUOH pursub`t tm >6 _.U.E. 292?(o)(>)(N).

Zcbi`tiggs lmtim` tm prmeooh i` gmrlb pbuporis (Hme. #>) b`h lmtim` tm pbrtieipbto i` ocoetrm`ie

gici`a (Hme. #?) bro HO@IOH bs lmmt i` ciaft mg tfo hislissbc mg tfis betim`.

It is sm mrhoroh.

Hbtoh bt Nrihaopmrt tfis 2?tf hby mg Db`ubry >:2?.

/s/ Doggroy Bckor LoyorDoggroy Bckor Loyor_`itoh Utbtos Histriet Duhao

Ebso 5428-ev-:2662-DBL Hmeulo`t 6 Gicoh :2/27/2? Zbao 5 mg 5

www.Ub`hyFmmkGbets.eml