winning strategies - amazon s3 · winning strategies in economic development marketing ... approach...

48
WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing A Study By Development Counsellors International 2017 A View From Corporate America

Upload: others

Post on 30-May-2020

11 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

WINNING STRATEGIES

In Economic Development MarketingA Study By Development Counsellors International

2017

A View From Corporate America

Page 2: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best
Page 3: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

xx

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Index of Charts and Tables

Executive Summary

Introduction and Methodology

Influencing Executive Perceptions: Leading Sources of

Information

Leading Sources of Information: Corporate Executives

vs. Location Advisors

Best Marketing Techniques from the Customer’s

Perspective

The Web and Location Decisions

First Contact: When and How Decision Makers

Approach Economic Development Organizations

Social Media and Executive Decision Makers

Best and Worst Places for Business

Outlook for International Investment

The Consultants Speak :

Best Economic Development Groups

Looking Forward: Location Decisions During the Years

Ahead

Appendix A: Questionnaire and Invitation to Participate

Appendix B: Most-Favorable Business Climate Rankings

for All States

Appendix C: Least-Favorable Business Climate

Rankings for All States

Appendix D: Demographic Profile of Respondents

A Word About DCI

4

6

10

11

13

15

18

22

25

27

30

32

33

36 44

45

46

47

Page 4: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

4

Table A Leading Sources of Information Influencing Executive

Perceptions of an Area’s Business Climate

Table B Most-Effective Marketing Techniques

Chart H Likelihood of Visiting Economic Development

Organizations’ Websites During Next Site Search

Table C First Contact with Economic Development Groups

Table D Most-Favorable Business Climate

Table E Least-Favorable Business Climate

COMPARISONS: RESPONSES OVER TIME

Chart A Leading Sources of Information Influencing Executive

Perceptions of an Area’s Business Climate

Chart C Most-Effective Marketing Techniques

Chart E Frequency of Internet Use in Most-Recent Site-Location

Search

Chart G Likelihood of Visiting Economic Development

Organizations’ Websites During Next Site Search

Chart J Most-Useful Features of an Economic Development

Organization’s Website

Chart L First Contact with Economic Development Groups

Chart N Executives Most Likely to Lead Location Decisions

Chart P Social Media Channels Used for Business

Chart R Part of the World with the Best International Growth

Opportunity

Chart T Trump Administration’s Impact on Investment Plans

Chart V Projected Location Decision in the Next 24 Months

Chart W Plans to Outsource a Portion of Site-Selection

Process

11

15

18

19

20

22

24

26

30

33

34

34

12

16

19

23

28

29

INDEX OF CHARTS AND TABLES | 2017 SURVEY RESULTS

Page 5: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

5

Chart B Leading Sources of Information Influencing Executive

Perceptions of an Area’s Business Climate

Chart D Most-Effective Marketing Techniques

Chart F Frequency of Internet Use in Most-Recent Site-Location

Search

Chart I Likelihood of Visiting Economic Development

Organizations’ Websites During Next Site-Location

Search

Chart K Most-Useful Features of an Economic Development

Organization’s Website

Chart M First Contact with Economic Development Groups

Chart Q Social Media Channels Used for Business

Chart D Most-Effective Marketing Techniques

Chart O Executives Most Likely to Lead Location Decisions

Chart U Trump Administration’s Impact on Investment Plans

Chart S Part of the World with the Best International Growth

Opportunity

Chart X Professional Likely to Assist with Site-Location Search

13

17

18

19

21

23

26

17

24

33

31

35

COMPARISONS: RESPONSES BY RESPONDENT TYPE LOCATION ADVISORS VS. CORPORATE EXECUTIVES

EXECUTIVES FROM MIDSIZE VS. LARGE COMPANIES

MANUFACTURING VS. SERVICE INDUSTRY EXECUTIVES

UNITED STATES VS. INTERNATIONAL EXECUTIVES

Page 6: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Since 1996, Development Counsellors

International (DCI) has provided economic

development professionals with a unique

opportunity — to hear directly from their

“customers” through a comprehensive survey

of corporate executives and their advisors.

Through the Winning Strategies survey

and analysis, DCI has provided insights into

current best practices in marketing places

and how these practices have changed

over time.

The outlook for the U.S. economy is

strong. The economy is approaching

full employment, long-term inflation

expectations remain low and gross domestic

product (GDP) is projected to continue

growing at a moderate rate in 2017 and 2018.

However, uncertainty remains regarding

the new U.S. administration’s policies and

how they affect the U.S. economy and

the worldwide economy. The interest in

how executives make location decisions

has never been higher, given this current

political and economic climate. Winning

Strategies continues to deliver new insights

into the minds of key influencers and their

decision-making process by asking them

questions about the impact of the current

administration on location decisions.

The interest in how executives make location decisions has never been higher, given this current political and economic climate.

Page 7: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

7

With the election of President Trump, DCI

was interested in the new administration’s

impact on location decisions. Respondents

were presented with the following statement

and question: “President Trump was

elected into office several months ago.

Please indicate how this has affected your

investment plans,” and “What is the most

important thing President Trump/the federal

government could do to encourage U.S.

companies to expand in the United States?”

Key findings are as follows:

• The majority of respondents (57 percent)

reported that the Trump administration

hasn’t affected their investment plans.

• Only 10 percent of respondents reported

that they are more likely to explore

international locations, 33 percent are

more likely to explore growth locations in

the United States.

• About 38 percent of respondents

reported that reducing corporate tax

rates/reforming corporate tax policies

should be a priority to encourage U.S.

companies to expand in the United States.

Beyond the administration-related questions,

the survey queried executives on factors

related to best practices in attracting

corporate investment (which has been

the focus of the survey since 1996). Key 2017

findings, based on the aggregate responses, are:

• Dialogue with industry peers, as it has

been since 1996, continues to be the top

source of information about an area,

followed by business travel and articles

in newspapers and magazines.

• In order, The Wall Street Journal,

The New York Times and local daily

newspapers rank as the top news source

of executives.

indicate the election of President Trump hasn’t impacted their investment plans.

57%

Page 8: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

Location advisors said staff contact information and incentive information are the most useful features of an economic development organization’s website.

• Having an internet/website presence is

rated as the most-effective marketing

technique, followed by planned visits to

corporate executives.

• Sixty-five percent of respondents used

the internet during their last site-selection

search, and 65 percent reported a

strong likelihood that they would visit an

economic development organizations’

website during the next site search.

• As has been the case since 2008,

incentive information (57 percent),

demographic information (48 percent)

and a searchable database of available

buildings and sites (44 percent) rank as

the most-useful features of an economic

development organization’s website.

• Location advisors said staff contact

information and incentive information are

the most-useful features of an economic

development organization’s website.

• For the third time, LinkedIn (77 percent)

is the top-used social media outlet for

business.

Page 9: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

9

• The percentage of respondents who

do not use social media for business

purposes continues to decline — 11

percent of respondents in 2017 vs. 21

percent in 2014 and 38 percent in 2011.

• Top executives within a company (49

percent), such as the chairman/CEO/

president, are most likely to lead location

decisions, followed by the COO (27

percent). In addition, a notable difference

exists between midsize (less than $100

million in revenue) and large companies

(more than $100 million in revenue).

Among midsize companies, the chairman/

CEO/president is the primary decision

maker; in large companies, the chairman/

CEO/president, the COO and the CFO

location are typically included in the

location decisions.

• Texas has the most-favorable business

climate, followed by Florida, Georgia,

South Carolina and North Carolina.

• North America outside of the United

States (32 percent) and Asia/Pacific

locations (29 percent) represent the best

opportunities for international expansion.

reported a strong likelihood of visiting an economic development website during their next site location search.

65%

Page 10: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

INTRODUCTION & METHODOLOGY This survey and all preceding Winning Strategies surveys are studies of perceptions. A perception is an attitude, belief or impression and not necessarily a reflection of reality. Business executives have certain identifiable opinions and beliefs about doing business in the United States and throughout the world. Some of these perceptions might be accurate; some might be genuine misperceptions.

In 1996 and subsequently every three years,

DCI has conducted a comprehensive survey

of corporate executives with site-selection

responsibilities to determine the “customer’s

perspective” on the most-effective strategies

and techniques in economic development

marketing. Now in its eighth iteration, Winning

Strategies continues to document changes in the

perceptions of corporate decision makers in the

United States. The survey has been conducted

online since 2008, and participants are incented

for their participation via an Amazon or

Starbucks gift card.

The survey audience consists of executives at

a random selection of U.S.-based companies

with direct site-selection responsibilities and

is heavily weighted toward the following titles:

CEO, president, CFO and vice president. The

distribution list was augmented with the addition

of more than 300 location advisors/consultants,

a similarly influential group providing guidance

and counsel to corporate executives nationwide.

DCI received 331 responses. The survey — which

includes multiple-choice, close-ended and

open-ended questions — contains a series of

classification questions to categorize responses

into large-company executives (more than $100

million in revenue), midsize-company executives

(less than $100 million in revenue) and location

advisors, as well as into select demographic

categories. The report contains data presented by

the various classification categories (in Appendix

D) or as trend data over time. The responses

to open-ended questions were edited for

completeness and coded into thematic groupings.

Page 11: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

11

INFLUENCING EXECUTIVE PERCEPTIONS: LEADING SOURCES OF INFORMATION How are perceptions of a location’s business climate formed? More importantly, how can an economic development organization promote a favorable perception of its community among corporate decision makers? Although many factors influence awareness of a location for investment purposes, dialogue with industry peers, as it has been since 1996, continues to be the top influencer on perceptions of an area, followed by business travel and articles in newspapers and magazines.

Since the inaugural survey in 1996, Winning Strategies has asked corporate decision makers who possess selection responsibilities a series of questions to determine the leading sources of information influencing executive perceptions of an area’s business climate. Respondents can choose up to three of the 13 provided responses. Over time, to reflect changing trends, responses have been added or slightly altered, such as advertising (which had previously consisted of two separate categories — print advertising and TV/radio advertising), rankings/surveys (previously called national surveys), online sources (added in 1999) and social media (added in 2011).

Chart A: Leading Sources of Information – 2017

46%

42%

34%

33%

27%

22%

21%

17%

11%

9%

8%

6%

2%

Dialogue with industry peers

Business travel

Articles in newspapers and magazines

Meetings with economic development groups

Online sources

Word of mouth

Rankings / surveys

Social media

Advertising

Other

TV and radio newscasts / shows

Direct Mail

Personal travel

Page 12: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

OmnisDam corum qui con rem conem ipsunt.

Genienit eveniat iatque vel illorit rem int audae min nos simenis et veres anis aut qui officie nihitiate

As shown in Table A, the leading sources of information have remained relatively constant since the survey was first conducted. Results from 2017 saw business travel displace articles in newspapers and magazines as the second-most-influential source of information. For the first time since

the category was included as a response in 2011, social media garnered more than 10 percent of responses and has become a more influential source of information. Consistent with previous years, the fewest number of executives chose direct mail.

Sources 2017 2014 2011 2008 2005 2002 1999 1996

Dialogue with industry peers 46% 55% 50% 61% 54% 56% 71% 68%

Business travel 42% 37% 27% 42% 45% 47% 45% 52%

Articles in newspapers and magazines 34% 44% 46% 53% 45% 62% 61% 60%

Meetings with economic development organizations 33% 31% 28% 32% 33% 21% 27% 24%

Online sources 27% 22% 20% 28% 22% 9% 9% --

Word of mouth 22% 21% 19% 19% 16% 29% 21% 24%

Rankings/surveys 21% 24% 36% 22% 17% 23% 31% 34%

Personal travel 17% 13% 9% 14% 13% 14% 8% 21%

Social media 11% 2% 0% -- -- -- -- --

Advertising 9% 4% 3% 4% 3% 4% 4% 4%

Other 8% 12% 13% 10% 14% 14% 8% 15%

TV/radio newscasts/shows 6% 9% 14% 7% 5% 14% 7% 4%

Direct mail 2% 2% 0% 2% 2% 2% 3% 4%

Table A: Leading Sources of Information Influencing Executive Perceptions of Business Climate Comparisons (Responses over Time)

Page 13: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

13

Online sources

28%24%

Meetings with economic development organizations

23%55%

Dialogue with industry peers

42%55%

Subgroups within the survey audience collect

information differently. The following chart

illustrates the differences between corporate

executives and location advisors and what

each audience perceives to be its leading

sources of information.

As Chart B shows, corporate executives rely

heavily on first-hand experience — business

travel and dialogue with industry peers — as

leading sources of information. Although

location advisors also rely heavily on

dialogue with industry peers, this information

source is valued equally with information

gleaned from meetings with economic

development groups (each being selected

by 55 percent of respondents). Corporate

executives value meetings with economic

development groups significantly less than

location advisors (23 percent vs. 55 percent).

LEADING SOURCES OF INFORMATION: CORPORATE EXECUTIVES VS. LOCATION ADVISORS

Chart B: Leading Sources of Information Influencing Executive Perceptions of an Area’s Business Climate (Responses by Respondent Type)

Corporate Executives Location Advisors

Business travel

45%36%

Articles in newspapers and magazines

34%35%

Word of mouth

26%14%

Page 14: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

WHERE DO EXECUTIVES GET THEIR NEWS?

When designing a comprehensive

marketing program, economic development

organizations must know how and where

decision makers consume their news.

For respondents who selected articles

in newspapers and magazines, online

sources, rankings/surveys and/or TV/radio

newscasts/shows as influential sources of

information, DCI asked follow-up questions

to determine the specific media consumed in

these categories.

As has been the case for several years, The Wall Street Journal ranks first in the list of most-read print publications in the

newspapers and magazines category.

However, the percentage of respondents

choosing the outlet fell from 82 percent in

2011 to 62 percent in 2017

The Wall Street Journal 62%

The New York Times 42%

Local daily news 21%

Forbes 13%

The Economist 13%

Washington Post 13%

USA Today 12% Bloomberg Businessweek 11%

Financial Times 10%

Time 8%

Area Development 7%

Respondents who selected online sources

first turn to general internet searches via

Google to obtain information about an area’s

business climate. In 2014, WSJ.com was the

most-used online source, unlike this year

when it failed to place in the top four sources.

Google 17%

Bloomberg.com 7%

NYTimes.com 7%

Private data vendors

(CCH, ESRI, PCensus) 7%

Forbes continues to have the greatest

following among respondents who chose

rankings/surveys as an influential information

source, followed by Site Selection Magazine

and Area Development.

Forbes 21%

Site Selection 16%

Area Development 14%

Tax Foundation 11%

Chief Executive 7%

Page 15: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

15

51%

Hosting Special Events

51%

Media Relations / Publicity

BEST MARKETING TECHNIQUES FROM THE CUSTOMER’S PERSPECTIVE

Chart C: Most Effective Marketing Techniques (% Rating 4 or 5 on a 5-Point Scale)

74%

66%

39%

32%

23%

17%

Internet / Website

Planned Visits to Corporate Executives

Trade Shows

Advertising

Direct Mail

Telemarketing

DCI asked respondents to gauge the

effectiveness of eight conventional marketing

techniques used by economic development

groups. Since 1996, respondents have rated

each technique (advertising, direct mail,

internet/website, media relations/publicity,

hosting special events, planned visits to

corporate executives and telemarketing) on

a scale from 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent). Chart C

shows the percentage of respondents who

rated each technique as a 4 or a 5.

Having an internet/website presence rates

as the most-effective marketing technique,

followed by planned visits to corporate

executives. Media relations/publicity and

hosting special events tied for third.

Page 16: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

The perceived value of having a well-designed internet/website presence has increased steadily. Also, a consistent, perceived value

exists in face-to-face contact, evidenced by

the placement of planned visits to corporate

executives as one of the top-two-rated

techniques since the first edition of the survey.

Considering responses by company size and

type (midsize company, large company and

location advisors), midsize- and large-company

Table B: Most Effective Marketing Techniques % Rating 4 or 5 on a 5-Point Scale (Response over Time)

executives (77 percent and 64 percent,

respectively) said, in order, a location’s internet/

website presence, planned visits to corporate

executives and media relations/publicity

are the top-three most-effective marketing

techniques for economic development groups.

Location advisors’ top-three choices for best

form of marketing are, in order, planned visits

to corporate executives (79 percent), hosting

special events and internet/website.

*Trade shows was excluded inadvertently in the 2008 survey.

Technique 2017 2014 2011 2008 2005 2002 1999 1996

Internet/Website 74% 67% 55% 56% 53% 34% 37% 18%

Planned Visits to Corporate Executives 66% 64% 57% 55% 54% 53% 46% 53%

Media Relations/ Publicity 51% 48% 33% 52% 50% 21% 19% 19%

Hosting Special Events 51% 46% 35% 45% 49% 37% 42% 49%

Trade Shows* 39% 38% 35% -- 33% 32% 45% 39%

Advertising 32% 17% 16% 15% 20% 21% 19% 19%

Direct Mail 23% 14% 15% 19% 23% 33% 25% 25%

Telemarketing 17% 6% 4% 4% 6% 4% 6% 7%

Page 17: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

17

Advertising

%

%

%

34

36

20

Trade Shows

%

%

%

41

42

30

Hosting Special Events

%

%

%

32

45

74

Internet/Website

77 %

%

%

64

73

Planned Visits to Corporate Executives

%

%

%

53

60

79

Media Relations / Publicity

%

%

%

43

48

56

Direct Mail

%

%

%

24

26

16

Telemarketing

%

%

%

22

21

6

Chart D: Most Effective Marketing Techniques % Rating 4 or 5 on a 5-point scale (Responses by Respondent Type)

Midsize Large Location Advisors

Page 18: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

THE WEB AND LOCATION DECISIONS

Chart E: Frequency of Internet Use in Most Recent Site Location Search Distribution of Responses on a 1-5 scale (1 = Not at all and 5 = Often)

Not at all Often21 3 4 5

8%7% 21% 16% 48%

Chart F: Frequency of Internet Use in Most Recent Site Location Search Distribution of Responses on a 1-5 scale 1 = Not at all and 5 = Often (Responses by Respondent Type)

Not at all Often1 2 3 4 5

Corporate Executives 9% 9% 20% 18% 44%

Not at all Often1 32 4 5

Location Advisors 1% 7% 21% 13% 58%

A common theme among several of this year’s findings is the increasing value placed on the internet and other digital information during the site-selection process. When respondents were asked to rate how often they used the internet during their last location search, on a scale of 1 (not at all) to 5 (often), 65 percent of the executives reported a score of 4 or 5.

As was the case in 2011 — when this question was incorporated into the survey — and in 2014,

this year’s data show that location advisors use the internet in their site-selection search more

than corporate executives. Overall, both groups use the internet frequently, with 71 percent of

location advisors and 62 percent of corporate executives rating their usage as a 4 or 5. About

58 percent of location advisors selected a 5, whereas 44 percent of corporate executives

selected a 5.

All

Page 19: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

19

Often, an economic development organization’s website is the first introduction to a location being considered for investment. When asked the likelihood of visiting an economic development organization’s website during their next site-location search, 65 percent of respondents reported a rating of 4 or 5 on a five-point scale, in which 1 is low and 5 is high.

The percentage of corporate executives in 2017 who are likely to visit an economic

development organization’s website has held steady from 2014 (54 percent in 2017 vs. 53

percent in 2014) and is significantly lower than the percentage of location advisors (87

percent) that will turn to an economic development organization’s website.

Chart G: Likelihood of Visiting Economic Development Organizations’ Websites During Next Site Search (1 = Not at all likely and 5 = Highly likely)

Chart H: Likelihood of Visiting Economic Development Organizations’ Websites During Next Site Search % Rating 4 or 5 on a 5-Point Scale (Response over Time)

65%

2017 2014 2011 2008 2005 2002

63% 47% 64% 65% 39%

Chart I: Likelihood of Visiting Economic Development Organizations’ WebsitesDuring Next Site Search Distribution of Responses on a 1-5 Scale (Response by Type)

1 2 3 4 5

Corporate Executives 13% 10% 23% 25% 29%

1 32 4 5

Location Advisors 0% 7% 6% 21% 66%

Highly Likely

Highly Likely

Highly Likely

Not at allLikely

Not at allLikely

Not at allLikely

21 3 4 5

All 9%9% 17% 24% 41%

As seen in Chart H, this percentage of respondents reporting a rating of 4 or 5 has rebounded

after falling to a low of 47 percent in 2011 and then rising again to 63 percent in 2014.

Page 20: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

Winning Strategies asked respondents to rate those features that are most important to the usefulness of an economic development organization’s website. Respondents could select up to five of the 14 offered features most typically included in an economic development website.

As has been the case since 2008, incentive information (57 percent) is ranked as the most-useful feature of an economic development organization’s website, followed by demographic information (48 percent), a searchable database of available buildings and sites (44 percent) and workforce statistics (43 percent).

Decision makers place less weight on testimonials from local employers and video content, which were selected by 8 percent and 3 percent of the respondents, respectively.

Chart J: Most-Useful Features of an Economic Development Organization’s Website

57%

48%

44%

43%

39%

38%

32%

25%

22%

18%

18%

8%

3%

29%

Incentive information

Demographic information

Searchable database of available buildings and sites

Workforce statistics

Comparisons to competitor locations

Major employer list

Quality of life information

Staff contact information

Target industries and related information

Maps of the community / region

Current press releases / announcements

Educational institution information (K-12 & post-secondary)

Testimonials from local employers

Video content

Page 21: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

21

Educational institution information

18%16%

19%29%

Maps of the community / region

23%27%

Target industries and related information

10%69%

Staff contact information

Quality of life information

40%14%

Major employer list

28%60%

Comparisons to competitor locations

48%21%

Searchable database of available buildings and sites

42%51%

24%Demographic information

60%

Incentive information

52%69%

Significant differences exist between the habits of location advisors and corporate executives. As seen in Chart K, 60 percent of corporate executives said demographic information is the most-useful feature on an economic development organization’s

Corporate Executives

Location Advisors

Chart K: Most Useful Features of an Economic Development Organization’s Website (Responses by Respondent Type)

43%42%

Workforce statistics

10%36%

Current press releases / announcements

8%7%

Testimonials from local employers

4%

Video content0%

website, compared to 24 percent of location advisors. Location advisors chose staff contact information and incentive information (both with 69 percent) as the most-useful features of an economic development organization’s website.

Page 22: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

Respondents indicated during which of the five stages of the site-selection process they are most likely to make first contact with an economic development organization. As seen in Chart L, the most-frequent response is following the development of a short list of communities to request specific information or to arrange site visits, with 42 percent of respondents selecting this option.

FIRST CONTACT: WHEN AND HOW DECISION MAKERS APPROACH ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ORGANIZATIONS

After a location has already been selected, for assistance in identifying a suitable building/lot.

Chart L: First Contact with Economic Development Groups

First Contact with Economic

Development Groups

30%

12%

5%

11%

42%

After we have developed a shortlist of potential communities, to request specific data or arrange site visits.

During the initial screening of all possible locations, to request preliminary data.

We would not contact an economic development organization at any stage in a site location search.

After the field has been narrowed to a few finalists, to negotiate incentive offers.

Since 2005, corporate decision makers and

location advisors are most likely to contact

an economic development organization

after a short list of potential communities

has been developed, to request data

or arrange site visits. About 12 percent

of respondents report that they would

not contact an economic development

organization at any stage during a site-

location search, down from a peak of 17

percent in 2011 and 16 percent in 2014.

Page 23: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

23

12%

6%

After the field has been narrowed to a few finalists, to negotiate incentive offers.

8%

0%

After a location has already been selected, for assistance in identifying a suitable building/lot.

17%

0%

We would not contact an economic development organization at any stage in a site location search.

27%

36%

During the initial screening of all possible locations, to request preliminary data.

36%

58%

After we have developed a shortlist of potential communities, to request specific data or arrange site visits.

Table C: First Contact with Economic Development Groups (Response over Time)

Location advisors continue to be more likely than corporate executives to use the services of economic development organizations. As shown in Chart M, location advisors will

always contact an economic development

organization during the site-selection

process and often earlier in the process than

Chart M – First Contact with Economic Development Groups (Response by Respondent Type)

Corporate Executives Location Advisors

corporate executives. About 17 percent of

corporate executives would not contact an

economic development organization at any

stage during a site-location search, and 8

percent will contact an organization only after

a location has been selected, for assistance in

identifying a suitable building/lot.

Timing of First Contact 2017 2014 2011 2008 2005

After we have developed a shortlist of potential communities, to request specific data or arrange site visits. 42% 41% 40% 40% 48%

During the initial screening of all possible locations, to request preliminary data.

30% 25% 24% 29% 27%

We would not contact an economic development organization at any stage in a site location search. 12% 16% 17% 8% 8%

After the field has been narrowed to a few finalists, to negotiate incentive offers. 11% 15% 13% 18% 15%

After a location has already been selected, for assistance in identifying a suitable building/lot. 5% 3% 6% 5% 2%

Page 24: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

1%

7%

Other Vice President/Director

3%

3%

Vice President/Director of Human Resources

3%

6%

Vice President of Manufacturing

6%

7%

Vice President/Director of Strategic Planning

16%

24%

Chief Financial Officer

9%

19%

Vice President/Director of Corporate Real Estate

For the first time, Winning Strategies

provided a list of eight executive titles and

asked respondents who is most likely to lead

corporate location projects. Respondents could

choose more than one option. Respondents

report that top executives — chairman/CEO/

president (49 percent) and COO (27 percent)

— were most likely to lead a location decision.

At midsize companies, the chairman/CEO/

president is the primary decision maker

for location decisions, whereas it’s the

chairman/CEO/president, the COO and

the CFO at large companies.

Chart N: Executives Most Likely to Lead Location Decisions

49%

27%

24%

22%

10%

9%

5%

5%

Chairman/CEO/President

Chief Operating Officer

Vice President/Director of Corporate Real Estate

Chief Financial Officer

Vice President/Director of Strategic Planning

Vice President of Manufacturing

Vice President/Director of Human Resources

Other Vice President/Director

Chart O: Executives Most Likely to Lead Location Decisions (Responses by Respondent Type)

Midsize Large

73%

39%

Chairman/CEO/President

15%

35%

Chief Operating Officer

Page 25: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

xx

SOCIAL MEDIA AND EXECUTIVE DECISION MAKERS

Social media has become an increasingly

important source of information during the

site-selection process. For the third time,

Winning Strategies asked location advisors

and corporate executives which top social

media channels they use for business

purposes. Also for the third time, LinkedIn

(77 percent) is the No. 1 social media outlet

for business, beating out the other such

options as Facebook, Twitter, Blog Forums,

YouTube, Instagram, Podcasts and other

social media channels. 2017 is the first year

that podcasts (17 percent) and Instagram (18

percent) have been included in the options.

The percentage of respondents who report they do not use social media for business purposes continues to decline — 11 percent of respondents in 2017 vs. 21 percent in 2014 and 38 percent in 2011.

Chart P: Social Media Channels Used for Business

77%

43%

37%

27%

26%

18%

17%

11%

5%

LinkedIn

Facebook

Twitter

Blog forums

YouTube

Instagram

Podcasts

I do NOT use social media for business purposes

Other

25

The percentage of respondents who report they do not use social media for business purposes continues to decline — 11 percent of respondents in 2017 vs. 21 percent in 2014 and 38 percent in 2011.

Page 26: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

32%

13%

YouTube

30%

19%

Blog forums

Chart P: Social Media Channels Used for Business (Responses by Respondent Type)

74%

53%

38%

19%

9%

5%

82%

20%

34%

12%

16%

6%

LinkedIn

Facebook

Twitter

25%

Instagram

Podcasts

I do NOT use social media for business purposes

Other

Corporate Executives

Location Advisors

Corporate executives tend to use all social

media outlets — except for LinkedIn — for

business purposes more often than location

advisors, of which 16 percent reported they

do not use social media for business purposes.

2%

Page 27: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

27

BEST AND WORST PLACES FOR BUSINESS

Every edition of Winning Strategies garners

tremendous interest, from media as well as

economic development organizations, from

states that are perceived favorably for their

business climate by key decision makers.

Starting in 2014, DCI broadened the scope of

research to include international locations.

All respondents were asked to provide up to

three states that they perceive to have the

most-favorable business climates. This year,

respondents rate Texas (42 percent) as

No. 1, followed by Florida (22 percent),

Georgia (20 percent), South Carolina (16

percent) and North Carolina (15 percent).

Respondents reported several qualities

supporting their perceptions through an

open-ended question. The top business-

related assets in Texas are a favorable tax

climate (40 percent), an overall pro-business

environment (26 percent) and a quality

workforce (22 percent), which displaced

incentives as a top factor since the 2014

edition of Winning Strategies.

TEXAS

GEORGIA

FLORIDA

SOUTH CAROLINA

NORTH CAROLINA

42%

22%

16%

20%

15%

1

2

3

4

5

Page 28: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

Respondents who named Florida as having

a favorable business climate also frequently

mentioned the pro-business environment

(27 percent), the favorable tax climate

(22 percent) and its strategic location

(20 percent), including its proximity to

international markets.

Georgia was noted specifically for its

pro-business climate (21 percent) and its

responsive and coordinated economic

development program (19 percent). The

“team sport” mentality and local economic

Table D: Most Favorable Business Climate (Responses over Time)

development organizations were noted as

specific strengths of the state. Incentives

(19 percent) were also noted as a strength.

Texas has been the top-rated state for seven

consecutive editions of Winning Strategies,

and the top five states have been consistent.

Florida moved into the second-place position in

2014 and continued to hold this position in 2017.

Georgia held on to the third-place ranking, North

Carolina dropped to fifth and South Carolina

maintained the fourth-place ranking.

2017 2014 2011 2008 2005 2002 1999 1996

TX42%

TX 50%

TX 49%

TX 41%

TX 33%

TX 25%

TX30%

NC 33%

FL 22%

FL18%

NC 27%

NC 30%

NC 26%

NC 20%

CA22%

TX28%

GA20%

GA/NC 17% (tie)

SC14%

GA20%

SC20%

SC 18%

NC 20%

GA27%

SC15%

SC 12%

TN14%

FL/TN15%

GA18%

FL18%

GA17%

SC 21%

NC15%

TN 11%

FL14%

NV14%

NV16%

GA15%

FL14%

TN20%

Page 29: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

29

STATES WITH THE LEAST FAVORABLE BUSINESS CLIMATES

Winning Strategies also reveals the states

that are perceived to have the least favorable

business climates. California has held the

distinction of being the least-favorable

state for the past six editions of the survey;

however, the percentage of respondents who

selected California declined from 74 percent

in 2014 to 57 percent in 2017. New York,

Illinois and New Jersey retain the dubious

distinction, and Connecticut enters the top-

five most-unfavorable states, a position not

held since 1999.

The top five responses are:

1. California 57%

2. New York 40%

3. Illinois 29%

4. New Jersey 16%

5. Connecticut 10%

Respondents, through an open-ended

question, said an unfavorable tax climate and

the regulatory environment are the top reasons

why they perceive certain states as having the

least-favorable business climates.

Table E: Least Favorable Business Climate (Responses over Time)

California was noted for having a

challenging/burdensome regulatory

environment (49 percent), an unfavorable

tax climate (42 percent) and high overall

operating costs (28 percent).

New York reportedly has an unfavorable tax

climate (47 percent), high overall operating

costs (22 percent) and a challenging/

regulatory environment (18 percent).

Illinois, as it has been since 2011, continues

to be plagued by the perception of

dysfunctional/corrupt government (35

percent), an unfavorable tax climate (35

percent) and fiscal challenges at the state

level (22 percent).

The least-favorable states have remained

consistent over the years. Since 2002,

California has held the top spot, followed

by New York. Illinois has held steady as the

third-ranked least-favorable state since 2011,

while New Jersey has consistently been

ranked as the fourth least-favorable state

since 1999.

Massachusetts has dropped in and out of the

top five since Winning Strategies was first

conducted in 1996 and recently was replaced

by Connecticut, which was No. 5 in 1999.

Responses over time are provided in Table E.

2017 2014 2011 2008 2005 2002 1999 1996

CA

57%

CA

74%

CA

71%

CA

72%

CA

66%

CA

57%

NY

29%

NY

55%

NY

40%

NY

42%

NY

47%

NY

42%

NY

34%

NY

36%

CA

25%

CA

47%

IL

29%

IL

34%

IL

24%

MI

17%

MA

22%

MA

18%

MA

19%

NJ

20%

NJ

16%

NJ

16%

NJ

24%

NJ

14%

NJ

21%

NJ

15%

NJ

14%

MA

19%

CT

10%

MA

11%

MI

16%

MA

12%

IL

13%

FL

10%

CT

10%

CT

9%

Page 30: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

OUTLOOK FOR INTERNATIONAL INVESTMENT

Starting in 2014, DCI expanded the Winning

Strategies survey to include a select group of

questions about international business location

decisions. Because of the current global political

and economic climate, interest in U.S. companies

and their expansion plans overseas is a topic of

great interest.

Winning Strategies asked corporate executives

which part of the world offers the best

international growth opportunities, and which

specific countries will offer the strongest

opportunities for international investment

during the next three years. In 2017, the option

of selecting North America outside the United

States was included to encompass location

decisions in Canada and Mexico.

In 2017, North America outside the United States

(32 percent) represents the best opportunity for

international expansion opportunities, followed

closely by Asia/Pacific locations (29 percent)

and Western Europe (22 percent). The remaining

regions, Africa, Eastern Europe, Latin America

and the Middle East, received less than 9 percent

of the responses.

Chart R: Part of the World with the Best International Growth Opportunity

Part of the World with the Best

International Growth Opportunity

Western Europe22%

North America outside of the U.S.32%

Africa2%

Asia/Pacific29%

Eastern

Europe5%

Latin

America8%

Middle East 2%

Page 31: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

31

Depending on the industry sector of the

respondent, a difference exists in the

regions that offer the best opportunity

for international growth. Manufacturing

executives view the Asia/Pacific region as

the top region (39 percent), followed by

Western Europe (30 percent). Executives

in the service sector view North America

outside the United States and Asia/Pacific

region as the best international opportunities.

Executives indicated which specific

countries they are most likely to explore for

investment, and China (31 percent), United

Kingdom (22 percent) and Canada (21

percent) top the list. The United Kingdom

placed second in 2014, and Canada moved

up six places from the ninth-ranked spot in

2014 with triple the number of respondents

naming it as a top country of opportunity.

1. China 31%

2. United Kingdom 22%

3. Canada 21%

4. Germany 16%

5. Mexico 15%

6. India 13%

7. France 11%

8. Italy/Japan 8% (tie)

9. Australia 7%

Chart S: Part of the World with the Best International Growth Opportunity(Responses by Company Type)

Manufacturing Executive Responses

Eastern Europe3%

Latin America3%

Middle East3%

North America outside the United States 22%

Western Europe 30%

Africa 0%

Asia/Pacific 39%

Asia/Pacific23%

North America outside the

United States 38%

Africa 3%

Middle East 2%

Western Europe 18%

Latin

America 11%

Eastern

Europe 5%Services

Executive Responses

Page 32: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

THE CONSULTANTS SPEAK: BEST ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT GROUPS

Location advisors work with economic development organizations nationwide and tend to have greater interaction with these groups than corporate executives do, which allows them to compare and contrast the effectiveness of each organization and provide an unbiased assessment of which regional and statewide organizations are “best in class.” This year’s edition of Winning Strategies —in which 72 location advisors listed 80 regional organizations — had a tie for first place, with each organization receiving recognition from 21 percent of respondents.

BEST IN CLASS – REGIONAL OR COMMUNITY ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ORGANIZATION

1. Columbus 2020 21% Kansas City Area Development Council

2. Greater Phoenix Economic Council 15%

3. Nashville Area Chamber of Commerce 10%

4. Charlotte Regional Partnership Dallas Regional Chamber Orlando Economic Partnership

8%

5. Metro Denver Economic Development Corporation Tennessee Valley Authority

7%

A total of 73 location providers offered their input

on “best in class” state organizations, naming 34

different state economic development agencies. The

top responses are:

BEST IN CLASS – STATE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ORGANIZATION

1. Georgia 32%

2. South Carolina 30%

3. Ohio 21%

4. North Carolina

Texas 19%

5. Tennessee 18%

Comparatively, 38 location advisors provided input

on who they perceive to be “best in class” foreign

investment agencies. The clear leaders in this

category are:

1. Ireland (IDA) 32%

2. Costa Rica (CINDE) 27%

3. Singapore (EDB) 16%

TIE

TIE

TIE

TIE

Page 33: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

33

LOOKING FORWARD: LOCATION DECISIONS IN THE YEARS AHEAD IN LIGHT OF THE NEW ADMINISTRATION

With the election of President Trump, DCI requested input for this statement: “ President Trump was elected into office several months ago. Please indicate how this has impacted your investment plans.” A majority of respondents (57 percent) report that the Trump administration hasn’t impacted our investment plans, 33 percent are more likely to explore growth locations in the United States and 10 percent are more likely to explore international locations.

The majority of midsize (57 percent) and large

(56 percent) companies report that the election of

President Trump hasn’t impacted their investment plans.

Chart T: Trump Administration’s Impact on Investment Plans

Chart U: Trump Administration’s Impact on Investment Plans (Responses by Respondent Type)

Hasn’t impacted our investment plans 57%

I’m more likely to explore growth locations in the United States 33%

I’m more likely to explore international locations 10%

Trump Administration

Impact on Investment Plans

Midsize57%

33%

10%

Large56%

10%

34%

Page 34: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

Respondents were also asked to complete

the following sentence: “The most important

thing President Trump/the federal

government could do to encourage U.S.

companies to expand in the United States is

…” The top answers were reduce corporate

tax rates/reform corporate tax policies (38

percent), provide better/more financial

incentives (7.1 percent), resign (5.8 percent)

and to act more presidential/less erratic

(4 percent).

Every edition of Winning Strategies has

asked executives about future location

decisions. 2017 results show that corporate

executives are optimistic about investment

plans during the next two years, with 50

percent reporting that their company will

make a location decision (such as move,

expand or consolidate) during the next 24

months — 6 percentage points up from 2014

— 31 percent report that they are not sure if

their company will make a location decision

during the next 24 months (vs. 30 percent

in 2014) and 19 percent reported that their

company would make no location decision

during the next 24 months, down from 26

percent in 2014.

Corporate executives are optimistic about investment plans during the next two years, with 50 percent reporting that their company will make a location decision during the next 24 months

Chart V: Projected Location Decision During the Next 24 Months

Yes 50%

Not Sure 31%

No 19%

Chart W: Plans to Outsource a Portion of the Site-Selection Process

Yes 54%

No 46%

To understand the site-selection process further, Winning Strategies asked corporate executives if they anticipate outsourcing a portion of the site-selection process during their next site-selection search. Showing a significant increase from 2014 (40 percent), 2017 results show that 54 percent

answered “yes,” they would outsource some or all

of the site-selection process.

The same percentage of large companies and midsize companies (53 percent) report they will outsource a portion of the site-selection process, compared to 59 percent of large companies and 37 percent of midsize companies in 2014.

Page 35: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

35

Chart X shows the individual/organizations that are most likely to assist with domestic or international location site-selection searches. In domestic searches, executives are most likely to use real estate brokers (35 percent) and site-selection consultants (21 percent). In international searches, executives report they are most likely to use site-selection consultants (28 percent).

Chart X: Professional Likely to Assist with Site Location Search

Site Selection Consultant

21%

Real Estate Broker

35%

Lawyer18%

Accountant16%

Other 10%

Domestic

Site Selection Consultant

28%

Real Estate Broker

18%

Accountant13%Other

23%

InternationalLawyer

18%

Page 36: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

APPENDIX A:

QUESTIONNAIRE AND INVITATION TO PARTICIPATE

First Name,

Although the attached survey will take you less than five minutes to complete, your comments

will be of enormous help to the nation’s economic development professionals in better

understanding the site-selection needs of companies like yours.

Please share your opinions by clicking the link below and answering the survey’s questions.

LINK

The survey’s findings will be presented Monday, Sept. 18 at the International Economic

Development Council’s 2017 Annual Conference in Toronto. Your responses will remain

anonymous and confidential.

Thank you for your consideration of this request.

P.S. We will gladly send your choice of a $10 Starbucks or $10 Amazon e-gift card for

your participation. We’ll also share an executive summary of the findings when reported in

September.

Sincerely,

Andy Levine

President and Chief Creative Officer

Development Counsellors International

215 Park Avenue South, 14th Floor

New York, NY 10003

T 212.444.7107 C 908.397.4762

E [email protected]

Page 37: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

37

WINNING STRATEGIES 2017 – CORPORATE EXECUTIVE VERSION

1. Are you involved in the decision to relocate, expand, consolidate or build new facilities for

your company?

• Yes (Please continue.)

• No (Please forward to the appropriate person in your organization.)

2. During your next location search, do you anticipate outsourcing a portion of the site-

selection responsibilities?

• Yes

• No

2a. Which type of individual/organization likely will assist you with the search?

3. In general, during which stage in a site-selection search do you first contact economic

development organizations?

• During the screening phase of all possible locations, to request preliminary data

• Following the development of the short list of communities, to request specific information or to arrange a site visit

• After identifying finalists, to negotiate incentives

• After a final location has been selected and a suitable building or lot is needed

• We would not contact an economic development organization at any stage during a site-location search

4. Please indicate the three U.S. states with business climates you perceive as most favorable,

and then briefly indicate why.

State No. 1 ________________________________________________

Reason for state No. 1 ________________________________________________

State No. 2 ________________________________________________

Reason for state No. 2 ________________________________________________

Location of Search

Accountant

Lawyer

Site-selection consultant

Real estate broker

Other (please specify)

United States

O

O

O

O

O

International Location

O

O

O

O

O

Page 38: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

State No. 3 ________________________________________________

Reason for state No. 3 ________________________________________________

5. Please indicate the three U.S. states with business climates you perceive as least favorable,

and then briefly indicate why.

State No. 1 ________________________________________________

Reason for state No. 1 ________________________________________________

State No. 2 ________________________________________________

Reason for state No. 2 ________________________________________________

State No. 3 ________________________________________________

Reason for state No. 3 ________________________________________________

6. Which part of the world represents the best international growth opportunity for your

company? (Please select one answer.)

• Africa

• Asia/Pacific

• Eastern Europe

• Latin America

• Middle East

• Western Europe

• North America outside the United States

6a. If you explore international investment during the next three years, which countries do you

believe offer the strongest investment opportunities for your company?

Country No. 1 ________________________________________________

Country No. 2 ________________________________________________

Country No. 3 ________________________________________________

7. In light of your responses to the previous questions, what are the three leading sources of

information influencing your perceptions of an area’s business climate?

• Advertising

• Articles in newspapers and magazines

• Business travel

• Dialogue with industry peers

• Direct mail

• Meetings with economic development groups

• Rankings/surveys

• Online sources

Page 39: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

39

• Personal travel

• Social media

• TV/radio newscasts/shows

• Word of mouth

• Other ________________________________________________

7a. Which type of advertising do you view as the most effective?

• Online

• Print

• Radio

• Television

7b. Which newspapers and magazines do you read most frequently?

1. ________________________________________________

2. ________________________________________________

3. ________________________________________________

7c. To which specific rankings/surveys do you pay the most attention?

1. ________________________________________________

2. ________________________________________________

3. ________________________________________________

7d. Which online sources do you view most frequently?

1. ________________________________________________

2. ________________________________________________

3. ________________________________________________

7e. Which television/radio newscasts/shows do you listen to or view most frequently?

1. ________________________________________________

2. ________________________________________________

3. ________________________________________________

8. Please check all social/new media channels that you currently use for business purposes.

• Blog forums

• Facebook

• Instagram

• LinkedIn

Page 40: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

• Podcasts

• Twitter

• YouTube

• Other ________________________________________________

• I do not use social media for business purposes

9. During your most-recent site-location search, how often did you use the internet as a source

of community information?

• 1 (not at all)

• 2

• 3

• 4

• 5 (often)

10. What is the likelihood that you will visit an economic development organization’s website

during your next site-location search?

• 1 (not likely)

• 2

• 3

• 4

• 5 (extremely likely)

11. Which of the following features do you consider most important to the utility of an

economic development organization’s website? (Please select up to five responses.)

• Comparisons to competitor locations (such as cost comparisons)

• Searchable database of available buildings and sites

• Demographic information (such as population, income, age distribution and education)

• Incentive information

• Major employer list

• Educational institution information (K-12 and postsecondary)

• Maps of the community/region

• Current press releases/announcements

• Quality-of-life information (such as cost of living and cultural/recreational opportunities)

• Staff contact information

• Target industries and related information

• Testimonials from local employers

• Video content

• Workforce statistics (such as labor force and employment by industry/occupation)

Page 41: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

41

12. Within your organization, who is most likely to lead corporate location decisions?

• Chairman/CEO/president

• COO

• CFO

• Vice president/director of corporate real estate

• Vice president/director of HR

• Vice president of manufacturing

• Vice president/director of strategic planning

• Other vice president/director (please specify) ___________________________________

13. Understanding that each project is different, please select the top three factors in your

location decisions:

• Available sites/buildings

• Availability of skilled workers

• Competitive labor costs

• Availability of worker training programs

• Presence of postsecondary institutions

• Efficient transportation systems (highway, air, rail or port)

• Business-friendly government

• Competitive incentives

• Competitive corporate tax structure

• Low occupancy costs

• Strong quality of life (such as restaurants, shopping, and lifestyle and recreational opportunities)

• Availability of good K-12 education

• Low overall operating costs

• Presence of company’s business cluster

Page 42: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

14. Please rate the effectiveness of the following marketing techniques as a means of

influencing your opinion when considering a new location.

Extra Credit: President Trump was elected into office several months ago. Please indicate how this has affected your investment plans.

• I’m more likely to explore growth locations in the United States

• I’m more likely to explore international locations

• Hasn’t affected our investment plans

Finish this sentence: The most-important thing President Trump/the federal government could do to encourage U.S. companies to expand in the United States is:

Business Classification: The last few questions will help classify your business (Confidential)

C1. Which of the following best describes your primary business?

• Manufacturing

• Services

C2. What was the gross revenue last year for your company, including all plants, divisions, branches and subsidiaries?

• Less than $25 million

• $25 million to $49 million

• $50 million to $99 million

• $100 million to $249 million

• $250 million to $499 million

• $500 million and higher

1 (poor) 2 3 4 5 Don’t Know

AdvertisingO O O O O O

Direct mail O O O O O O

Internet/website O O O O O O

Media relations/publicity O O O O O O

Hosting special events O O O O O O

Planned visits to corporate

executives

O O O O O O

Telemarketing O O O O O O

Trade shows O O O O O O

Page 43: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

43

C3. Will your company make a location decision (move, expand or consolidate) during the next 24 months?

• Yes

• No

• Not sure

C4. Gender:

• Male

• Female

Thank you for completing this survey. All responses will be kept confidential, and you are not required to provide your name. If you want to receive a $10 Starbucks or a $10 Amazon e-gift card, then please provide your contact information and your choice of gift card below. If you do not provide your contact information, then simply submit your survey. In addition to your gift card, we would be happy to send you an executive summary of the results after the research has been released in September 2017. Check the box below if you want to receive the results.

Name ________________________________________________

Title ________________________________________________

Organization ________________________________________________

Email address ________________________________________________

Please send me:

• $10 Starbucks Card

• $10 Amazon Card

Please send me:

• An executive summary of the report

Page 44: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

APPENDIX B:

MOST-FAVORABLE BUSINESS CLIMATE RANKINGS FOR ALL STATES

State %

Texas 41.9%

Florida 21.7%

Georgia 19.8%

South Carolina 15.8%

North Carolina 15.4%

California 14.2%

New York 14.2%

Tennessee 13.4%

Ohio 11.1%

Nevada 9.1%

Utah 9.1%

Indiana 8.3%

Colorado 7.1%

Virginia 6.7%

Alabama 6.3%

Washington 6.3%

Pennsylvania 5.9%

Louisiana 5.1%

Arizona 4.7%

Massachusetts 4.7%

New Jersey 4.3%

Oklahoma 3.6%

Delaware 3.2%

Illinois 3.2%

Kansas 2.4%

Michigan 2.4%

Maryland 2.0%

South Dakota 2.0%

Minnesota 2.0%

Arkansas 1.6%

Idaho 1.6%

Missouri 1.6%

Montana 1.6%

Wisconsin 1.6%

Iowa 1.2%

New Mexico 1.2%

Wyoming 1.2%

State %

Mississippi 0.8%

Oregon 0.8%

West Virginia 0.8%

Alaska 0.4%

Connecticut 0.4%

Hawaii 0.4%

Kentucky 0.4%

Maine 0.4%

Nebraska 0.4%

New Hampshire 0.4%

North Dakota 0.4%

Vermont 0.4%

Page 45: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

45

APPENDIX C:

LEAST-FAVORABLE BUSINESS CLIMATE RANKINGS FOR ALL STATES

State %

California 57.0%

New York 39.8%

Illinois 29.1%

New Jersey 16.0%

Connecticut 9.8%

Florida 8.6%

Alaska 7.0%

Massachusetts 7.0%

Washington 6.1%

Hawaii 4.9%

Mississippi 4.9%

Texas 4.5%

Vermont 4.1%

Michigan 3.7%

North Dakota 3.7%

Oregon 3.7%

Pennsylvania 3.7%

Idaho 3.3%

Maine 3.3%

Ohio 3.3%

Alabama 2.9%

Oklahoma 2.9%

Arkansas 2.5%

Montana 2.5%

North Carolina 2.5%

West Virginia 2.5%

Wyoming 2.5%

Louisiana 2.5%

Kentucky 2.5%

Georgia 2.0%

Indiana 2.0%

Kansas 2.0%

Minnesota 2.0%

Missouri 2.0%

Tennessee 2.0%

Maryland 1.6%

Nebraska 1.6%

Nevada 1.6%

New Mexico 1.6%

State %

Rhode Island 1.6%

Arizona 1.2%

District of Columbia 1.2%

Iowa 1.2%

South Dakota 1.2%

Colorado 0.8%

Delaware 0.8%

New Hampshire 0.8%

South Carolina 0.8%

Wisconsin 0.8%

Utah 0.4%

Virginia 0.4%

Page 46: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

C-level corporate executives . . . . . . . 75%

Location advisors/consultants . . . . . 25% Gender:

Male . . . . . . . 76%

Female . . . . . 24% Industry: Gross Revenue: Location Advisors Only:

Size of Company

I am a single practitioner. . . . . 11%

1-25 employees. . . . . . . . . . . . . 35%

25+ employees . . . . . . . . . . . . . 53%

APPENDIX D:

Services64%

Manufacturing36%

20

$500 million and higher

10

$250 million to $499 million

13

$100 million to $249 million

12

12

$50 million to $99 million

$25 million to $49 million

33

Less than $25 million

%

%

%

%

%

%

Page 47: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

47

A WORD ABOUT

Interested in learning more? We’d love to explore how we might assist your community:

Andrew T. Levine

President/Chief Creative Officer

Development Counsellors International

215 Park Avenue South

New York, NY 10003

Phone: 212-725-0707 Ext. 107

[email protected]

aboutdci.com

Development Counsellors International (DCI)

specializes in economic development marketing

and lead generation. Our tailored approach raises

a community’s image, increases project inquiries

and generates investment opportunity. We achieve

this through a deep understanding of your target

audience—a niche segment that includes corporate

executives, their key influencers and skilled profes-

sionals—and the overall location selection process.

Our areas of expertise include:

• Editorial placement and media relations

• Website development

• Place branding

• Lead generation

• Social/digital media

• Location advisor relationship building

• Perception studies (corporate executives/location advisors and consultants)

• Media training

• Talent-attraction programs

• Special events

• Marketing blueprints

• Research

• Tourism development

• Crisis communications

DCI has worked with more economic

development groups than all other marketing

agencies combined. The firm also has formed

alliances with local advertising, public relations

and marketing agencies to provide specialized

economic development input.

Page 48: WINNING STRATEGIES - Amazon S3 · WINNING STRATEGIES In Economic Development Marketing ... Approach Economic Development Organizations Social Media and Executive Decision Makers Best

48

DEVELOPMENT COUNSELLORS INTERNATIONAL

NEW YORK

215 Park Avenue South

New York, NY 10003

(212) 725-0707

DENVER

1786 Platte Street

Denver, CO 80202

(303) 627-0272

TORONTO

130 King Street West

Toronto, ON M5X 1E3

(647) 256-1913

LOS ANGELES

5670 Wilshire Boulevard

Los Angeles, CA 90036

(323) 648-6629

www.aboutdci.com