Wireless Mesh Networks: Cross-Layer Scheduling

Jason Ernst

University of Guelph Prepared for CS6650 – Mobile and Wireless

Networks

Presentation Outline• Introduction & Background– Wireless Mesh Networks

• Motivation– Fair Scheduling– Classification of Scheduling Techniques– Cross-Layering

• Related Work• Current Problems• Future Work & Conclusions• Questions

2Jason Ernst - University of Guelph

Wireless Mesh Networks• WMN - Wireless Mesh

Network:– Ad-hoc network with a core

which has limited mobility• Mesh Router:– A wireless base station with

limited or no mobility– Infrastructure of the

network• Mesh Clients:– A wireless node which is

fully mobile, may also act as a router in some WMNs

Image: Indigo Systems – WMN for Environmental Monitoring

3Jason Ernst - University of Guelph

Motivation: Fair Scheduling

• Starvation & Unequal Quality of Service (QoS)– “Greedy” flows cause other traffic to be ignored

resulting in starving or unequal QoS– Nodes closer to the gateways cause farther nodes

starvation or unequal QoS• In commercial applications people who pay

the same amount expect the same quality of service

4Jason Ernst - University of Guelph

Motivation: Fair Scheduling

Jason Ernst - University of Guelph 5

Image: NC State University Elec. Eng. Dept.

Classifications of Scheduling

Jason Ernst - University of Guelph 6

Throughput Fairness

Classifications of Scheduling

Jason Ernst - University of Guelph 7

Throughput Fairness

Maximum Throughput Scheduling

Equal Fairness

Proportional Fairness

Min-Max

Motivation: Cross-Layering

• Still ongoing debate as to whether cross-layering is worthwhile or not– Performance improvement and more intelligent

decisions– However possibility of “spaghetti-code” or

unintended effects due to unexpected interactions with other layers

8Jason Ernst - University of Guelph

Cross-Layering

• Methods of Cross-Layering- Power Adaption

- Adjust Power in order to avoid interference and increase fairness- Routing / MAC [J. Thomas] - Transport / LL [Wang et al.]

- Rate Control- Adjust the data rates in order to achieve fairness- Network / Transpot [Neely et al.]- Transport / Network / MAC [Tang et al.]

- Route Control- Change routes in order to avoid congestion- LL / network [Kuran et al.]

9Jason Ernst - University of Guelph

Related Work: Fair Scheduling

• Operating Systems– User / process scheduling in interactive OS’s

started in the 1960s and 70’s (multics, unix)• Wired Networks & Wireless LAN (single hop)• Ad-hoc Networks• Distributed Computing – SHARCNET

• Cross-Layering: Wired Networks

Jason Ernst - University of Guelph 10

Current Problems

• Cross-Layered Fair Scheduling– Some papers make assumptions such as single

hop networks, limited mobility, fixed topology (APs cannot be added or removed)

– Assumption which treats uplink and downlink together when it may be beneficial to treat them independently

– Localized VS Centralized scheduling & load balancing

11Jason Ernst - University of Guelph

Future Work

• Future Work:– Identifying an area of current research to expand

upon– Make use of experimentation to determine

optimal parameter values, metrics for load balancing etc.

– Cross Layered Optimizations on solution– Write a thesis based on the research

12Jason Ernst - University of Guelph

References• Agrawal et Al. Achieving Load Balancing in Wireless Mesh Networks Through Mulitple Gateways. IEEE.

2006. 807-812.• Bejerano, Yigal., Han, S-J., Kumar, Amit. Efficient Load-Balancing Routing for Wireless Mesh Networks.

2007. Computer Networks. 51. 2450-2466.• Chandranmenon et. Al. On the Design and Implementation of Infrastructure Mesh Networks. IEEE

Workshop on Wireless Mesh Networks (WiMesh) 2005.• Cheng, S-M., Lin, Phone., Huang, Di-Wei., Yang, Shun-Ren. A Study on Distributed / Centralized

Scheduling for Wireless Mesh Network. 2006. IWCMC ’06. ACM. 599-604.• Gupta, Piyush., Sankarasubramaniam, Yogesh., Stolyar, Alexander. Random-Access Scheduling with

Service Differentiation in Wireless Networks. 2005. IEEE. 1815-1825.• Erwu, Liu., Shan, Jin., Gang, Shen., Luoning, Gui. Fair Scheduling in Wireless Multi-Hop Self-Backhaul

Networks. IEEE AICT/ICIW 2006. • Hubaux, J-P., Salem, Ben Naouel. A Fair Scheduling for Wireless Mesh Networks. WIMESH. 2005• Koutsonikolas, Dimitrios., M. Das., Saumitra., Hu, Charlie, Y. An Interference-aware Fair Scheduling for

Multi-cast in Wireless Mesh Networks. 2008. Journal of Parallel and Distributed Computing. 68. 372-286.

• Popa, Lucian., Rostamizadeh, Afshin., Karp, Richard, M., Papadimitriou, Christos., Stoica, Ion. Balancing Traffic Load in Wireless Networks with Curveball Routing. 2007. Mobihoc ‘07. ACM. 170 – 179.

13Jason Ernst - University of Guelph

References• J. Thomas, “Cross-Layer Scheduling and Routing For Unstructured And Quasi-Structured Wireless

Networks”• M.S. Kuran, G. Gur, T. Tugcu, F. Alagoz, “Cross-Layer Routing-Scheduling in IEEE 802.16 Mesh

Networks”, in Mobilware’08. Austria, 2008.• M. Neely, R. Urgaonkar, “Cross-layer adaptive control for wireless mesh networks,” in Ad Hoc

Networks Vol . 5, pp 719-743, 2007.• J. Tang, G. Xue, W. Zhang, “Cross-Layer Design for End-To-End Throughput and Fairness

Enhancement in Multi-Channel Wireless Mesh Networks,” in IEEE Transactions on Wireless Communications, Vol. 6. pp 3482-3486. October 2007.

• X. Wang, K. Kar, “Cross-Layer Rate Control for End-to-End Proportional Fairness in Wireless Networks with Random-Access,” in MobiHoc ’05. Illinois, USA, 2005.

• J. Tang, G. Xue, C. Chandler, W. Zheng, “Link Scheduling with Power Control for Throughput Enhancement in Multihop Wireless Network

• V. Kawadia, P.R. Kumar, “A Cautionary Perspective on Cross-Layer Design,” in IEEE Wireless Communications, pp 3-11, February 2005.

• I.F. Akyildiz, X. Wang, “Cross-Layer Design in Wireless Mesh Networks,” in IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology, Vol. 57, 2, pp 1061- 1076, March 2007.

14Jason Ernst - University of Guelph

Questions?

Jason Ernstjernst@uoguelph.ca

University of GuelphAdvisor: Dr. Mieso Denko

15Jason Ernst - University of Guelph