wiscon sin's ro le in early autom obile industry · cars. brief case studies of the tour major...
TRANSCRIPT
WISCON SINS RO LE IN EARLY AUTOM OBILE INDUSTRY
MICHAEL D ALBERT
DEPARTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY
UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN - RIVER FALLS
ABSTRACT
The disappearance of American Motors in the late 1980s brought to a close Wisconsins long history as a home of independent passenger car manufacturers Wisconsin played a prominent role in the early auto industry Four volume producers emerged in the southeastern part of the state by 1915 records indicate nearly 100 other attempts to build automobiles This paper describes the distribution of these manufacturers and analyzes the locational factors that shaped the distribution All major auto product ion centers developed in the existing manushyfacturing belt owing to access to capital labor and management skills good transportation a large market and proximity to raw materials and manufacturers of components Southeast Wisconsin at the western edge of this belt dominated the state map of efforts to build cars Brief case studies of the tour major Wisconsin auto companies demonstrate that the successful manufacturers grew out of existing large-scale builders of vehicles such as wagons bicycles or farm implements
~TRODUCllON
The disappearance of American Motors in the late 1980s brought to an end Wisconsins long history as the home of major independent automobile producers Wisconsin emerged as an auto manufacturing center in the early days of the industry and based on several experimental vehicles built between 1871 and 1890 the claim has even been advanced that Wisconsin is the birthplace of the automobile industry of the United States In any case Wisconsin can rightly claim to have been the first American state to subsidize the industrys development (Mohs 1969 p 11) In 1875 the state passed the following Act There is hereby appropriated the sum of $10000 to be used as a bounty and to be paid to a citizen of Wisconsin who shall invent and after five years continued trial and use shall produce a machine propelled by steam or other motive agent which shall be a cheap and practical
substitute for the use of horses and other animals on the highway and farm The state also required that contestants for the prize should submit to a road trial of 200 miles A number of inventors aspired to the prize but in a July 1878 race only two cumbersome steam vehicles competed with the winner completing the 201 mile course in thirty-three hours twenty-seven minutes at the thrilling speed of about six miles per hour The state then reneged on its promise of the $10000 prize on the grounds that the winning vehicle was not cheap and practical After threats of litigation however the state agreed to pay half the prize
Though ne1ther of the entrants in that worlds first auto race ever saw production Wisconsin became the site of numerous later manufacturing attempts Between 1895 and 1920 more than 100 efforts to enter the automotive business occurred (Kimes and Clark 1989) This paper will briefly examine the distribution of these attempts general location factors that affected early US auto production and take a closer look at the four Wisconsin operations that achieved greatest success
THE DISTRIBUTION OF AUTO MANUFACTURERS
The map in Figure 1 identifies those firms that actually achieved production of autos for sale even if that production was very low Therefore those cases in which a prototype was built but production never followed those that represented single autos built by inventors for their own use and not intended for production and several others that appear to have been attempts to swindle investors caught up in the excitement of early automania were eliminated The remaining seventy cases are shown (Figure 1) Note t hat truck manufacturers and branch plants operated by non-Wisconsin firms are omitted
By far the largest group is made up of companies who failed or left the auto business after building less than 100 cars Many of these companies date from the first fifteen years of the period mappedl and produced
1
WIS
CO
NS
IN
AU
TO
MO
BIL
E
MA
NU
FA
CT
UR
ER
S
1895 -
1920
omiddot
N
Tolal A
uto Production (in num
ber of Gars)
o 1
shy100
amp
10 I -1000
tI _
_
Over 1000
Num
ber of Manufacturers
----------------------2S
Source f(jm
es and Oark
Dcig n
ed b
y L
eo
Lan
glo
is laquo) 1
99
2
Fig
ure 1
vehicles that were little more than gasshypowered buggies or motorized farm wagons (Hugill 1990) The second group with eight members enjoyed marginal success and built up to around 1000 vehicles Finally four manufacturers Kissel Motor Car Company of Hartford Mitchell Motor Company and JI Case Threshing Machine Company of Racine and the Thomas B Jeffery Company of Kenosha (later to become Nash and then American Motors) achieved at least some volume of production spread over several decades or longer
LOCATION FACTORS AFFECTING THE DISTRIBUTION
What factors enabled Wisconsin to become a significant center of auto production Some of the answers are not particularly surprising and illustrate general location factors familiar to any economic geography student (Wheeler and Muller 1986) The concentration of auto producers both of early failures and longer term successes is overwhelmingly in southshyeastern Wisconsin and corresponds closely to the states population distribution In the early years of the century the demand for autos exceeded the supply and many smaller firms that soon failed hoped to cash in on this opportunity by catering to strictly local or regional markets The four largest producers however invested in national advertising almost from their inception
Although located at the western end of the traditional Manufacturing Belt Wisconsin nevertheless shared that regions oth er locational advantages There was access to capital for new industrial ventures Transshyportation by lake and rail had already tied southeastern Wisconsin into national markets for its output and its raw material supplies Access to supplies of wood for the construction of early automobiles deserves attention as a location factor equal to other raw materials Auto bodies were almost entirely framed with wood with metal exterior panels attached into the 1930s and even wood chassis frames were commonly employed in the early years Henry Fords purchase of more than 700000 acres of timber in northern Michigan to guarantee his supply attests to that resources importance (Nevins and Hill 1957 pp 218-19) Obviously Wisconsin had a favored location with respect to wood supplies Previous industrial developshyment in southeastern Wisconsin ensured t he presence of a skilled labor supply and industries prepared to manufacture composhy
nents for the emerging auto industry were already present Management skills for large production operations would also have been available
Finally it should be noted that as is the case in other states where auto production centered (Flink 1970 p 296) Wisconsins successful early auto entrepreneurs were more likely to be prosperous companies already producing products closely related to the new automobile than individual inventors embarking on an entirely new business Owing to the locational advantages cited above Wisconsin already had several large vehicle-related companies In the light of the preceding statements let us briefly examine the four most successful Wisconsin auto companies
MAJOR WISCONSIN AUTO MANUFACTURERS
The Case automobile was a product of the JI Case Threshing Machine Company founded in Racine in 1842 By the late 19th century Case was the worlds largest maker of steamshypowered farm equipment and had begun manufacturing gasoline-powered tractors In the early 1900s a number of its leading stockholders and officials invested in the automaking venture of a marine engine company in Racine Case absorbed this company in 1910 and thereafter built a moderate number of medium priced cars whose popularity was enhanced by the reputation of the companys famous tractors (Figure 2) By the 1920s the Case automobile was simply a good assembled car that is one produced from components made by outside suppliers and not designed in-house In 1927 the company elected to withdraw from the auto business having produced somewhat more than 25000 cars over the life of the automotive division (Macllvain 1974 pp 12shy15 Kimes and Clark 1989 p 2249)
Kissel autos were the product of a German family that by the turn of the century had established a mini-empire in the Hartford area ranging from a home construction company to the production of farm implements and stationary gasoline engines From the start of operations in 1906 until the end In 1931 the Kissel was a high-quality medium to uppershymedium priced car famous beyond its modest levels of production because of its distinctive styling (Figure 3) In total the company built about 35000 cars before the Depression proved to be the final blow to a company
3
Th
e Libullbull rary
Digesl Jo
r Maul
16 1918
1l7
+=shycro
wd
lnS no u
ncom
fortable posi tions E
ach occupant
may
enjoy real com
fort
Th
e cushions ore Marshall the
wheelbase is 125 inches
the rear sp
rings are 56Y2 in ch
underslun
g sem
i-elliptic
CIM
dei~n h
-ybullbull
~comfJlishltd an A
U thfi~ dv
nt~
mSl lce
tha New
u tr1lorcin
ary TTln
~(1m-n[
oJ com
lO
C~
Su
at lUi
ptrltlnt Price
bull disshy
fhtU
T(-J
wh
ich
gtOU
m
t1U
Meo
ml
acshytinctly
Itrn
criv
e b
uy
~
yo
ull
quainltl d with to ftuy
pp~-iI
A
118IYe one1l
yo
u ~o o
ver thU
C
8T
-once
Jhort gtid
il bull
NIWW
C
ase Six u surshy
you rid
e in it lL
ifTH
proo
t
oull find it A C1U
plirtlcularly timely
R ea
l -P
assenB
el C
om
fort
NO
T th
e lenst of the attractions of the New
middotCase Six is
its speciousness
With
each S~
occupied there is no
In d
dition
to u
mn
ul com
lcn tl d
-in desin
in n
ME
cost rd
in
Op
elshycJr
bn
ury
tn
n t
11 th
e JUft-day
Hbnlm
tonts found aly on
eSl t1l coshy
I lion
T~ In m
o A
e lM
DeahI w
ill be A-lad to
how
An
d ev
ery n
u(h nical
tu
N
ia of
y ou
tAla aup
ttlot car O
T y
ou
JT
l1y vn
ite th
e umllil hi~
TIIok E
I
ry one U
wltll
dirte to
u
lor In illustrated
rmd
de-shylcnow
n nd
proven tcrip
riv alllo~
Faily
Mod
l rgr 7
01 J JIIIO
Pt ~
11111= blw
11875
Sp(7Pf
-food (tn
-ofI bullbull ~
JOT ~~
jJ81
$
AflmiddotsJO
lj fod~l
StiJzufd T
YP r 1 0 s ~~l
bullbull (010 d rk bllIl JZ
J75
J I C
AS
E T
M
CO
MP
AN
Y Inc
r-~
IAll
2laquo
LilK
ny s~ U
rW W
Ia U s
U-SSE~
I~
to
Ki~1 C
US
1om B
ult F()t)r Pustnaer TOUUf~r
Motordom
s 1919 De L
uxe Edition
PR
OU
FlC
in
those
individu
alized b
ody
appo
intshy
men
ts an
d
specialized m
echanical fea
tures
the
connoisseur w
ould dem
and w
ere he the designer lop
ir~tio1 in
cuom
-mad
e C03Ch
digng
ond buildin~
Cf-e
rille am-pies
of Ihe
hond wroug~t
on
of
the lulled rtioe n
AL
L-Y
EA
R
Th
e 4-Peng
er To
urstr in
Silver Blue
nd
lhe 2middot penIl-r
(a
r SpeedsT
in Ch
rome Y
ellow afC m
ounted
0 0 th
e Kid custom
middot built ch bullbullbullimiddot-
unsu1
ou
cd
in m
echniCAI
cellence
for tw
lvr y
ears
-an
d
crow
ned
w
ith th
e n
ew
Kisel
cu~tommiddotb
LJilt m
oto
r
The new
71
)Jucccr S
cndrd T D
u ri nt to be old
at _
modcrat~
price IH
~middot e mo
un
ted Q
n t~~t n
( Kiu e cu
tom
middotbuih Cklo i bull
Kissel M
otor Car C
o) Hartfo
rd Wisbull U
S A
Kis
ul d
eClIn
in o ff pncipoi cilic~
Lilrra
tn o
n rc
qu
ut
F1 eu
re
L
Fi
gu
re
3
29
25
-Lb
s-OfmiddotB
ea
uty
Silence~ P
oweh
imiddot Com
fort and Strenfth
T his is the unique w
ay one owner o
f TH
E S
IX o
f 16 describ
e the latest M
itchell m
asterpiece T
his beautiful long luxu
rious car calls for n m
ethod of d~ption A
ll p
nd
iction
[or its wcalt hebullbull bon
tu~
bur by pustun Ihe
f~
l ory III) iu
uU
tIOft limj l-
~ty-four ho
urs de)bull n
d Y
w k
- - IIIbl to ~t
t ~d~
rwI kI tht t
m~jt
dliti poIfblbullbull
n IftltO
n [or hi uccm
I in Ifgt a r
ItHl r
ft il the -I~t car ylua Ih (Jfld h n
er Juon
Yo
u or impd w
i) its but
01 ~nt Jihl
But it
w
h 1fU
u nu
hln
ltrr
the cO
Untry rodrth
n th
IM
I f bull bum
p t~t jICOJ rJI iu fJ1JU
f
Evory car dlrln
d croott on h~m
t II llfQ
thf U
f
Word a
nn
o( dK
rlb
TH
ES
IX of 16
You
mw
t it-fH
I the
hl-
itl the thrill of it nnoolh action
Promp dol
In
booing mod by
Mitch1I db l
ht T
ht one in
ylaquo
Jr tO
Wn
Atl fo
r III dlFfT
OnU
nbor
~
The
Li~rary
D~~I for
Septemb
er 18 19
15 61 7
ltT1
THE SIXO
f16J~-$1250
Every C
ar SeIls A
nother
~hU
~PJifr R(Hldlifr $
1250
fflIr-P4ltr--T
cunmiddotn
eel s-fr~c-J ~
~o-mrsJshy
AU
PU
CU
F O D
AAO
NE
~tIur31o1btR
Icine Nh
U S
A
Fig
ure
4
1 D t E
i1
51-n
Hodel 27 $1000
Alt rarn
lbecl w
llh Jebullbuller eeralpm
enc a 1950
ON
T
HIS
C
AR
is em
bodied the
highest developm
ent o
f the
II
simple po
wer plant
Mo
tor an
d transm
ission gear are com
pletely housed as a unit w
ith three-point support E
very
part o
f the m
otor tran
smittin
g m
echan
ism an
d
appurshytenances are perfectly accessible fro
m a
bo
ve and
by reason of th
e tilting body m
ay be reach
ed w
itho
ut trouble o
r discomfort
Th
e 1907 line com
prises two
m
odels o
f this type M
odel 27
sho
wn
above and
M
odel 21 a m
edium
weig
ht
touring car with
detachable tonneau
O
ur ad
vance catalogue describing both is at y
ou
r service M
ain
O
ffi ce
an
d
Facto
r- K
en
osh
a
Wis
co
nsin
B
ran
ch
es
Ch
icago
M
ilWA
uk
ee B
Olto
n
Pb
iladelp
hia
San
Fran
cisco
NeW
Yo
rk A
renlZ-Y 3s--to W
6Zod
St
Rep
ren n
trI9U
in allle
din
g c
iliu
Th
otn
as
B
Jeffe
ry
reg
C
o tnp
an
y
Fig
ur e
5
- UntitledPDFpdf
-
WIS
CO
NS
IN
AU
TO
MO
BIL
E
MA
NU
FA
CT
UR
ER
S
1895 -
1920
omiddot
N
Tolal A
uto Production (in num
ber of Gars)
o 1
shy100
amp
10 I -1000
tI _
_
Over 1000
Num
ber of Manufacturers
----------------------2S
Source f(jm
es and Oark
Dcig n
ed b
y L
eo
Lan
glo
is laquo) 1
99
2
Fig
ure 1
vehicles that were little more than gasshypowered buggies or motorized farm wagons (Hugill 1990) The second group with eight members enjoyed marginal success and built up to around 1000 vehicles Finally four manufacturers Kissel Motor Car Company of Hartford Mitchell Motor Company and JI Case Threshing Machine Company of Racine and the Thomas B Jeffery Company of Kenosha (later to become Nash and then American Motors) achieved at least some volume of production spread over several decades or longer
LOCATION FACTORS AFFECTING THE DISTRIBUTION
What factors enabled Wisconsin to become a significant center of auto production Some of the answers are not particularly surprising and illustrate general location factors familiar to any economic geography student (Wheeler and Muller 1986) The concentration of auto producers both of early failures and longer term successes is overwhelmingly in southshyeastern Wisconsin and corresponds closely to the states population distribution In the early years of the century the demand for autos exceeded the supply and many smaller firms that soon failed hoped to cash in on this opportunity by catering to strictly local or regional markets The four largest producers however invested in national advertising almost from their inception
Although located at the western end of the traditional Manufacturing Belt Wisconsin nevertheless shared that regions oth er locational advantages There was access to capital for new industrial ventures Transshyportation by lake and rail had already tied southeastern Wisconsin into national markets for its output and its raw material supplies Access to supplies of wood for the construction of early automobiles deserves attention as a location factor equal to other raw materials Auto bodies were almost entirely framed with wood with metal exterior panels attached into the 1930s and even wood chassis frames were commonly employed in the early years Henry Fords purchase of more than 700000 acres of timber in northern Michigan to guarantee his supply attests to that resources importance (Nevins and Hill 1957 pp 218-19) Obviously Wisconsin had a favored location with respect to wood supplies Previous industrial developshyment in southeastern Wisconsin ensured t he presence of a skilled labor supply and industries prepared to manufacture composhy
nents for the emerging auto industry were already present Management skills for large production operations would also have been available
Finally it should be noted that as is the case in other states where auto production centered (Flink 1970 p 296) Wisconsins successful early auto entrepreneurs were more likely to be prosperous companies already producing products closely related to the new automobile than individual inventors embarking on an entirely new business Owing to the locational advantages cited above Wisconsin already had several large vehicle-related companies In the light of the preceding statements let us briefly examine the four most successful Wisconsin auto companies
MAJOR WISCONSIN AUTO MANUFACTURERS
The Case automobile was a product of the JI Case Threshing Machine Company founded in Racine in 1842 By the late 19th century Case was the worlds largest maker of steamshypowered farm equipment and had begun manufacturing gasoline-powered tractors In the early 1900s a number of its leading stockholders and officials invested in the automaking venture of a marine engine company in Racine Case absorbed this company in 1910 and thereafter built a moderate number of medium priced cars whose popularity was enhanced by the reputation of the companys famous tractors (Figure 2) By the 1920s the Case automobile was simply a good assembled car that is one produced from components made by outside suppliers and not designed in-house In 1927 the company elected to withdraw from the auto business having produced somewhat more than 25000 cars over the life of the automotive division (Macllvain 1974 pp 12shy15 Kimes and Clark 1989 p 2249)
Kissel autos were the product of a German family that by the turn of the century had established a mini-empire in the Hartford area ranging from a home construction company to the production of farm implements and stationary gasoline engines From the start of operations in 1906 until the end In 1931 the Kissel was a high-quality medium to uppershymedium priced car famous beyond its modest levels of production because of its distinctive styling (Figure 3) In total the company built about 35000 cars before the Depression proved to be the final blow to a company
3
Th
e Libullbull rary
Digesl Jo
r Maul
16 1918
1l7
+=shycro
wd
lnS no u
ncom
fortable posi tions E
ach occupant
may
enjoy real com
fort
Th
e cushions ore Marshall the
wheelbase is 125 inches
the rear sp
rings are 56Y2 in ch
underslun
g sem
i-elliptic
CIM
dei~n h
-ybullbull
~comfJlishltd an A
U thfi~ dv
nt~
mSl lce
tha New
u tr1lorcin
ary TTln
~(1m-n[
oJ com
lO
C~
Su
at lUi
ptrltlnt Price
bull disshy
fhtU
T(-J
wh
ich
gtOU
m
t1U
Meo
ml
acshytinctly
Itrn
criv
e b
uy
~
yo
ull
quainltl d with to ftuy
pp~-iI
A
118IYe one1l
yo
u ~o o
ver thU
C
8T
-once
Jhort gtid
il bull
NIWW
C
ase Six u surshy
you rid
e in it lL
ifTH
proo
t
oull find it A C1U
plirtlcularly timely
R ea
l -P
assenB
el C
om
fort
NO
T th
e lenst of the attractions of the New
middotCase Six is
its speciousness
With
each S~
occupied there is no
In d
dition
to u
mn
ul com
lcn tl d
-in desin
in n
ME
cost rd
in
Op
elshycJr
bn
ury
tn
n t
11 th
e JUft-day
Hbnlm
tonts found aly on
eSl t1l coshy
I lion
T~ In m
o A
e lM
DeahI w
ill be A-lad to
how
An
d ev
ery n
u(h nical
tu
N
ia of
y ou
tAla aup
ttlot car O
T y
ou
JT
l1y vn
ite th
e umllil hi~
TIIok E
I
ry one U
wltll
dirte to
u
lor In illustrated
rmd
de-shylcnow
n nd
proven tcrip
riv alllo~
Faily
Mod
l rgr 7
01 J JIIIO
Pt ~
11111= blw
11875
Sp(7Pf
-food (tn
-ofI bullbull ~
JOT ~~
jJ81
$
AflmiddotsJO
lj fod~l
StiJzufd T
YP r 1 0 s ~~l
bullbull (010 d rk bllIl JZ
J75
J I C
AS
E T
M
CO
MP
AN
Y Inc
r-~
IAll
2laquo
LilK
ny s~ U
rW W
Ia U s
U-SSE~
I~
to
Ki~1 C
US
1om B
ult F()t)r Pustnaer TOUUf~r
Motordom
s 1919 De L
uxe Edition
PR
OU
FlC
in
those
individu
alized b
ody
appo
intshy
men
ts an
d
specialized m
echanical fea
tures
the
connoisseur w
ould dem
and w
ere he the designer lop
ir~tio1 in
cuom
-mad
e C03Ch
digng
ond buildin~
Cf-e
rille am-pies
of Ihe
hond wroug~t
on
of
the lulled rtioe n
AL
L-Y
EA
R
Th
e 4-Peng
er To
urstr in
Silver Blue
nd
lhe 2middot penIl-r
(a
r SpeedsT
in Ch
rome Y
ellow afC m
ounted
0 0 th
e Kid custom
middot built ch bullbullbullimiddot-
unsu1
ou
cd
in m
echniCAI
cellence
for tw
lvr y
ears
-an
d
crow
ned
w
ith th
e n
ew
Kisel
cu~tommiddotb
LJilt m
oto
r
The new
71
)Jucccr S
cndrd T D
u ri nt to be old
at _
modcrat~
price IH
~middot e mo
un
ted Q
n t~~t n
( Kiu e cu
tom
middotbuih Cklo i bull
Kissel M
otor Car C
o) Hartfo
rd Wisbull U
S A
Kis
ul d
eClIn
in o ff pncipoi cilic~
Lilrra
tn o
n rc
qu
ut
F1 eu
re
L
Fi
gu
re
3
29
25
-Lb
s-OfmiddotB
ea
uty
Silence~ P
oweh
imiddot Com
fort and Strenfth
T his is the unique w
ay one owner o
f TH
E S
IX o
f 16 describ
e the latest M
itchell m
asterpiece T
his beautiful long luxu
rious car calls for n m
ethod of d~ption A
ll p
nd
iction
[or its wcalt hebullbull bon
tu~
bur by pustun Ihe
f~
l ory III) iu
uU
tIOft limj l-
~ty-four ho
urs de)bull n
d Y
w k
- - IIIbl to ~t
t ~d~
rwI kI tht t
m~jt
dliti poIfblbullbull
n IftltO
n [or hi uccm
I in Ifgt a r
ItHl r
ft il the -I~t car ylua Ih (Jfld h n
er Juon
Yo
u or impd w
i) its but
01 ~nt Jihl
But it
w
h 1fU
u nu
hln
ltrr
the cO
Untry rodrth
n th
IM
I f bull bum
p t~t jICOJ rJI iu fJ1JU
f
Evory car dlrln
d croott on h~m
t II llfQ
thf U
f
Word a
nn
o( dK
rlb
TH
ES
IX of 16
You
mw
t it-fH
I the
hl-
itl the thrill of it nnoolh action
Promp dol
In
booing mod by
Mitch1I db l
ht T
ht one in
ylaquo
Jr tO
Wn
Atl fo
r III dlFfT
OnU
nbor
~
The
Li~rary
D~~I for
Septemb
er 18 19
15 61 7
ltT1
THE SIXO
f16J~-$1250
Every C
ar SeIls A
nother
~hU
~PJifr R(Hldlifr $
1250
fflIr-P4ltr--T
cunmiddotn
eel s-fr~c-J ~
~o-mrsJshy
AU
PU
CU
F O D
AAO
NE
~tIur31o1btR
Icine Nh
U S
A
Fig
ure
4
1 D t E
i1
51-n
Hodel 27 $1000
Alt rarn
lbecl w
llh Jebullbuller eeralpm
enc a 1950
ON
T
HIS
C
AR
is em
bodied the
highest developm
ent o
f the
II
simple po
wer plant
Mo
tor an
d transm
ission gear are com
pletely housed as a unit w
ith three-point support E
very
part o
f the m
otor tran
smittin
g m
echan
ism an
d
appurshytenances are perfectly accessible fro
m a
bo
ve and
by reason of th
e tilting body m
ay be reach
ed w
itho
ut trouble o
r discomfort
Th
e 1907 line com
prises two
m
odels o
f this type M
odel 27
sho
wn
above and
M
odel 21 a m
edium
weig
ht
touring car with
detachable tonneau
O
ur ad
vance catalogue describing both is at y
ou
r service M
ain
O
ffi ce
an
d
Facto
r- K
en
osh
a
Wis
co
nsin
B
ran
ch
es
Ch
icago
M
ilWA
uk
ee B
Olto
n
Pb
iladelp
hia
San
Fran
cisco
NeW
Yo
rk A
renlZ-Y 3s--to W
6Zod
St
Rep
ren n
trI9U
in allle
din
g c
iliu
Th
otn
as
B
Jeffe
ry
reg
C
o tnp
an
y
Fig
ur e
5
- UntitledPDFpdf
-
vehicles that were little more than gasshypowered buggies or motorized farm wagons (Hugill 1990) The second group with eight members enjoyed marginal success and built up to around 1000 vehicles Finally four manufacturers Kissel Motor Car Company of Hartford Mitchell Motor Company and JI Case Threshing Machine Company of Racine and the Thomas B Jeffery Company of Kenosha (later to become Nash and then American Motors) achieved at least some volume of production spread over several decades or longer
LOCATION FACTORS AFFECTING THE DISTRIBUTION
What factors enabled Wisconsin to become a significant center of auto production Some of the answers are not particularly surprising and illustrate general location factors familiar to any economic geography student (Wheeler and Muller 1986) The concentration of auto producers both of early failures and longer term successes is overwhelmingly in southshyeastern Wisconsin and corresponds closely to the states population distribution In the early years of the century the demand for autos exceeded the supply and many smaller firms that soon failed hoped to cash in on this opportunity by catering to strictly local or regional markets The four largest producers however invested in national advertising almost from their inception
Although located at the western end of the traditional Manufacturing Belt Wisconsin nevertheless shared that regions oth er locational advantages There was access to capital for new industrial ventures Transshyportation by lake and rail had already tied southeastern Wisconsin into national markets for its output and its raw material supplies Access to supplies of wood for the construction of early automobiles deserves attention as a location factor equal to other raw materials Auto bodies were almost entirely framed with wood with metal exterior panels attached into the 1930s and even wood chassis frames were commonly employed in the early years Henry Fords purchase of more than 700000 acres of timber in northern Michigan to guarantee his supply attests to that resources importance (Nevins and Hill 1957 pp 218-19) Obviously Wisconsin had a favored location with respect to wood supplies Previous industrial developshyment in southeastern Wisconsin ensured t he presence of a skilled labor supply and industries prepared to manufacture composhy
nents for the emerging auto industry were already present Management skills for large production operations would also have been available
Finally it should be noted that as is the case in other states where auto production centered (Flink 1970 p 296) Wisconsins successful early auto entrepreneurs were more likely to be prosperous companies already producing products closely related to the new automobile than individual inventors embarking on an entirely new business Owing to the locational advantages cited above Wisconsin already had several large vehicle-related companies In the light of the preceding statements let us briefly examine the four most successful Wisconsin auto companies
MAJOR WISCONSIN AUTO MANUFACTURERS
The Case automobile was a product of the JI Case Threshing Machine Company founded in Racine in 1842 By the late 19th century Case was the worlds largest maker of steamshypowered farm equipment and had begun manufacturing gasoline-powered tractors In the early 1900s a number of its leading stockholders and officials invested in the automaking venture of a marine engine company in Racine Case absorbed this company in 1910 and thereafter built a moderate number of medium priced cars whose popularity was enhanced by the reputation of the companys famous tractors (Figure 2) By the 1920s the Case automobile was simply a good assembled car that is one produced from components made by outside suppliers and not designed in-house In 1927 the company elected to withdraw from the auto business having produced somewhat more than 25000 cars over the life of the automotive division (Macllvain 1974 pp 12shy15 Kimes and Clark 1989 p 2249)
Kissel autos were the product of a German family that by the turn of the century had established a mini-empire in the Hartford area ranging from a home construction company to the production of farm implements and stationary gasoline engines From the start of operations in 1906 until the end In 1931 the Kissel was a high-quality medium to uppershymedium priced car famous beyond its modest levels of production because of its distinctive styling (Figure 3) In total the company built about 35000 cars before the Depression proved to be the final blow to a company
3
Th
e Libullbull rary
Digesl Jo
r Maul
16 1918
1l7
+=shycro
wd
lnS no u
ncom
fortable posi tions E
ach occupant
may
enjoy real com
fort
Th
e cushions ore Marshall the
wheelbase is 125 inches
the rear sp
rings are 56Y2 in ch
underslun
g sem
i-elliptic
CIM
dei~n h
-ybullbull
~comfJlishltd an A
U thfi~ dv
nt~
mSl lce
tha New
u tr1lorcin
ary TTln
~(1m-n[
oJ com
lO
C~
Su
at lUi
ptrltlnt Price
bull disshy
fhtU
T(-J
wh
ich
gtOU
m
t1U
Meo
ml
acshytinctly
Itrn
criv
e b
uy
~
yo
ull
quainltl d with to ftuy
pp~-iI
A
118IYe one1l
yo
u ~o o
ver thU
C
8T
-once
Jhort gtid
il bull
NIWW
C
ase Six u surshy
you rid
e in it lL
ifTH
proo
t
oull find it A C1U
plirtlcularly timely
R ea
l -P
assenB
el C
om
fort
NO
T th
e lenst of the attractions of the New
middotCase Six is
its speciousness
With
each S~
occupied there is no
In d
dition
to u
mn
ul com
lcn tl d
-in desin
in n
ME
cost rd
in
Op
elshycJr
bn
ury
tn
n t
11 th
e JUft-day
Hbnlm
tonts found aly on
eSl t1l coshy
I lion
T~ In m
o A
e lM
DeahI w
ill be A-lad to
how
An
d ev
ery n
u(h nical
tu
N
ia of
y ou
tAla aup
ttlot car O
T y
ou
JT
l1y vn
ite th
e umllil hi~
TIIok E
I
ry one U
wltll
dirte to
u
lor In illustrated
rmd
de-shylcnow
n nd
proven tcrip
riv alllo~
Faily
Mod
l rgr 7
01 J JIIIO
Pt ~
11111= blw
11875
Sp(7Pf
-food (tn
-ofI bullbull ~
JOT ~~
jJ81
$
AflmiddotsJO
lj fod~l
StiJzufd T
YP r 1 0 s ~~l
bullbull (010 d rk bllIl JZ
J75
J I C
AS
E T
M
CO
MP
AN
Y Inc
r-~
IAll
2laquo
LilK
ny s~ U
rW W
Ia U s
U-SSE~
I~
to
Ki~1 C
US
1om B
ult F()t)r Pustnaer TOUUf~r
Motordom
s 1919 De L
uxe Edition
PR
OU
FlC
in
those
individu
alized b
ody
appo
intshy
men
ts an
d
specialized m
echanical fea
tures
the
connoisseur w
ould dem
and w
ere he the designer lop
ir~tio1 in
cuom
-mad
e C03Ch
digng
ond buildin~
Cf-e
rille am-pies
of Ihe
hond wroug~t
on
of
the lulled rtioe n
AL
L-Y
EA
R
Th
e 4-Peng
er To
urstr in
Silver Blue
nd
lhe 2middot penIl-r
(a
r SpeedsT
in Ch
rome Y
ellow afC m
ounted
0 0 th
e Kid custom
middot built ch bullbullbullimiddot-
unsu1
ou
cd
in m
echniCAI
cellence
for tw
lvr y
ears
-an
d
crow
ned
w
ith th
e n
ew
Kisel
cu~tommiddotb
LJilt m
oto
r
The new
71
)Jucccr S
cndrd T D
u ri nt to be old
at _
modcrat~
price IH
~middot e mo
un
ted Q
n t~~t n
( Kiu e cu
tom
middotbuih Cklo i bull
Kissel M
otor Car C
o) Hartfo
rd Wisbull U
S A
Kis
ul d
eClIn
in o ff pncipoi cilic~
Lilrra
tn o
n rc
qu
ut
F1 eu
re
L
Fi
gu
re
3
29
25
-Lb
s-OfmiddotB
ea
uty
Silence~ P
oweh
imiddot Com
fort and Strenfth
T his is the unique w
ay one owner o
f TH
E S
IX o
f 16 describ
e the latest M
itchell m
asterpiece T
his beautiful long luxu
rious car calls for n m
ethod of d~ption A
ll p
nd
iction
[or its wcalt hebullbull bon
tu~
bur by pustun Ihe
f~
l ory III) iu
uU
tIOft limj l-
~ty-four ho
urs de)bull n
d Y
w k
- - IIIbl to ~t
t ~d~
rwI kI tht t
m~jt
dliti poIfblbullbull
n IftltO
n [or hi uccm
I in Ifgt a r
ItHl r
ft il the -I~t car ylua Ih (Jfld h n
er Juon
Yo
u or impd w
i) its but
01 ~nt Jihl
But it
w
h 1fU
u nu
hln
ltrr
the cO
Untry rodrth
n th
IM
I f bull bum
p t~t jICOJ rJI iu fJ1JU
f
Evory car dlrln
d croott on h~m
t II llfQ
thf U
f
Word a
nn
o( dK
rlb
TH
ES
IX of 16
You
mw
t it-fH
I the
hl-
itl the thrill of it nnoolh action
Promp dol
In
booing mod by
Mitch1I db l
ht T
ht one in
ylaquo
Jr tO
Wn
Atl fo
r III dlFfT
OnU
nbor
~
The
Li~rary
D~~I for
Septemb
er 18 19
15 61 7
ltT1
THE SIXO
f16J~-$1250
Every C
ar SeIls A
nother
~hU
~PJifr R(Hldlifr $
1250
fflIr-P4ltr--T
cunmiddotn
eel s-fr~c-J ~
~o-mrsJshy
AU
PU
CU
F O D
AAO
NE
~tIur31o1btR
Icine Nh
U S
A
Fig
ure
4
1 D t E
i1
51-n
Hodel 27 $1000
Alt rarn
lbecl w
llh Jebullbuller eeralpm
enc a 1950
ON
T
HIS
C
AR
is em
bodied the
highest developm
ent o
f the
II
simple po
wer plant
Mo
tor an
d transm
ission gear are com
pletely housed as a unit w
ith three-point support E
very
part o
f the m
otor tran
smittin
g m
echan
ism an
d
appurshytenances are perfectly accessible fro
m a
bo
ve and
by reason of th
e tilting body m
ay be reach
ed w
itho
ut trouble o
r discomfort
Th
e 1907 line com
prises two
m
odels o
f this type M
odel 27
sho
wn
above and
M
odel 21 a m
edium
weig
ht
touring car with
detachable tonneau
O
ur ad
vance catalogue describing both is at y
ou
r service M
ain
O
ffi ce
an
d
Facto
r- K
en
osh
a
Wis
co
nsin
B
ran
ch
es
Ch
icago
M
ilWA
uk
ee B
Olto
n
Pb
iladelp
hia
San
Fran
cisco
NeW
Yo
rk A
renlZ-Y 3s--to W
6Zod
St
Rep
ren n
trI9U
in allle
din
g c
iliu
Th
otn
as
B
Jeffe
ry
reg
C
o tnp
an
y
Fig
ur e
5
- UntitledPDFpdf
-
Th
e Libullbull rary
Digesl Jo
r Maul
16 1918
1l7
+=shycro
wd
lnS no u
ncom
fortable posi tions E
ach occupant
may
enjoy real com
fort
Th
e cushions ore Marshall the
wheelbase is 125 inches
the rear sp
rings are 56Y2 in ch
underslun
g sem
i-elliptic
CIM
dei~n h
-ybullbull
~comfJlishltd an A
U thfi~ dv
nt~
mSl lce
tha New
u tr1lorcin
ary TTln
~(1m-n[
oJ com
lO
C~
Su
at lUi
ptrltlnt Price
bull disshy
fhtU
T(-J
wh
ich
gtOU
m
t1U
Meo
ml
acshytinctly
Itrn
criv
e b
uy
~
yo
ull
quainltl d with to ftuy
pp~-iI
A
118IYe one1l
yo
u ~o o
ver thU
C
8T
-once
Jhort gtid
il bull
NIWW
C
ase Six u surshy
you rid
e in it lL
ifTH
proo
t
oull find it A C1U
plirtlcularly timely
R ea
l -P
assenB
el C
om
fort
NO
T th
e lenst of the attractions of the New
middotCase Six is
its speciousness
With
each S~
occupied there is no
In d
dition
to u
mn
ul com
lcn tl d
-in desin
in n
ME
cost rd
in
Op
elshycJr
bn
ury
tn
n t
11 th
e JUft-day
Hbnlm
tonts found aly on
eSl t1l coshy
I lion
T~ In m
o A
e lM
DeahI w
ill be A-lad to
how
An
d ev
ery n
u(h nical
tu
N
ia of
y ou
tAla aup
ttlot car O
T y
ou
JT
l1y vn
ite th
e umllil hi~
TIIok E
I
ry one U
wltll
dirte to
u
lor In illustrated
rmd
de-shylcnow
n nd
proven tcrip
riv alllo~
Faily
Mod
l rgr 7
01 J JIIIO
Pt ~
11111= blw
11875
Sp(7Pf
-food (tn
-ofI bullbull ~
JOT ~~
jJ81
$
AflmiddotsJO
lj fod~l
StiJzufd T
YP r 1 0 s ~~l
bullbull (010 d rk bllIl JZ
J75
J I C
AS
E T
M
CO
MP
AN
Y Inc
r-~
IAll
2laquo
LilK
ny s~ U
rW W
Ia U s
U-SSE~
I~
to
Ki~1 C
US
1om B
ult F()t)r Pustnaer TOUUf~r
Motordom
s 1919 De L
uxe Edition
PR
OU
FlC
in
those
individu
alized b
ody
appo
intshy
men
ts an
d
specialized m
echanical fea
tures
the
connoisseur w
ould dem
and w
ere he the designer lop
ir~tio1 in
cuom
-mad
e C03Ch
digng
ond buildin~
Cf-e
rille am-pies
of Ihe
hond wroug~t
on
of
the lulled rtioe n
AL
L-Y
EA
R
Th
e 4-Peng
er To
urstr in
Silver Blue
nd
lhe 2middot penIl-r
(a
r SpeedsT
in Ch
rome Y
ellow afC m
ounted
0 0 th
e Kid custom
middot built ch bullbullbullimiddot-
unsu1
ou
cd
in m
echniCAI
cellence
for tw
lvr y
ears
-an
d
crow
ned
w
ith th
e n
ew
Kisel
cu~tommiddotb
LJilt m
oto
r
The new
71
)Jucccr S
cndrd T D
u ri nt to be old
at _
modcrat~
price IH
~middot e mo
un
ted Q
n t~~t n
( Kiu e cu
tom
middotbuih Cklo i bull
Kissel M
otor Car C
o) Hartfo
rd Wisbull U
S A
Kis
ul d
eClIn
in o ff pncipoi cilic~
Lilrra
tn o
n rc
qu
ut
F1 eu
re
L
Fi
gu
re
3
29
25
-Lb
s-OfmiddotB
ea
uty
Silence~ P
oweh
imiddot Com
fort and Strenfth
T his is the unique w
ay one owner o
f TH
E S
IX o
f 16 describ
e the latest M
itchell m
asterpiece T
his beautiful long luxu
rious car calls for n m
ethod of d~ption A
ll p
nd
iction
[or its wcalt hebullbull bon
tu~
bur by pustun Ihe
f~
l ory III) iu
uU
tIOft limj l-
~ty-four ho
urs de)bull n
d Y
w k
- - IIIbl to ~t
t ~d~
rwI kI tht t
m~jt
dliti poIfblbullbull
n IftltO
n [or hi uccm
I in Ifgt a r
ItHl r
ft il the -I~t car ylua Ih (Jfld h n
er Juon
Yo
u or impd w
i) its but
01 ~nt Jihl
But it
w
h 1fU
u nu
hln
ltrr
the cO
Untry rodrth
n th
IM
I f bull bum
p t~t jICOJ rJI iu fJ1JU
f
Evory car dlrln
d croott on h~m
t II llfQ
thf U
f
Word a
nn
o( dK
rlb
TH
ES
IX of 16
You
mw
t it-fH
I the
hl-
itl the thrill of it nnoolh action
Promp dol
In
booing mod by
Mitch1I db l
ht T
ht one in
ylaquo
Jr tO
Wn
Atl fo
r III dlFfT
OnU
nbor
~
The
Li~rary
D~~I for
Septemb
er 18 19
15 61 7
ltT1
THE SIXO
f16J~-$1250
Every C
ar SeIls A
nother
~hU
~PJifr R(Hldlifr $
1250
fflIr-P4ltr--T
cunmiddotn
eel s-fr~c-J ~
~o-mrsJshy
AU
PU
CU
F O D
AAO
NE
~tIur31o1btR
Icine Nh
U S
A
Fig
ure
4
1 D t E
i1
51-n
Hodel 27 $1000
Alt rarn
lbecl w
llh Jebullbuller eeralpm
enc a 1950
ON
T
HIS
C
AR
is em
bodied the
highest developm
ent o
f the
II
simple po
wer plant
Mo
tor an
d transm
ission gear are com
pletely housed as a unit w
ith three-point support E
very
part o
f the m
otor tran
smittin
g m
echan
ism an
d
appurshytenances are perfectly accessible fro
m a
bo
ve and
by reason of th
e tilting body m
ay be reach
ed w
itho
ut trouble o
r discomfort
Th
e 1907 line com
prises two
m
odels o
f this type M
odel 27
sho
wn
above and
M
odel 21 a m
edium
weig
ht
touring car with
detachable tonneau
O
ur ad
vance catalogue describing both is at y
ou
r service M
ain
O
ffi ce
an
d
Facto
r- K
en
osh
a
Wis
co
nsin
B
ran
ch
es
Ch
icago
M
ilWA
uk
ee B
Olto
n
Pb
iladelp
hia
San
Fran
cisco
NeW
Yo
rk A
renlZ-Y 3s--to W
6Zod
St
Rep
ren n
trI9U
in allle
din
g c
iliu
Th
otn
as
B
Jeffe
ry
reg
C
o tnp
an
y
Fig
ur e
5
- UntitledPDFpdf
-
29
25
-Lb
s-OfmiddotB
ea
uty
Silence~ P
oweh
imiddot Com
fort and Strenfth
T his is the unique w
ay one owner o
f TH
E S
IX o
f 16 describ
e the latest M
itchell m
asterpiece T
his beautiful long luxu
rious car calls for n m
ethod of d~ption A
ll p
nd
iction
[or its wcalt hebullbull bon
tu~
bur by pustun Ihe
f~
l ory III) iu
uU
tIOft limj l-
~ty-four ho
urs de)bull n
d Y
w k
- - IIIbl to ~t
t ~d~
rwI kI tht t
m~jt
dliti poIfblbullbull
n IftltO
n [or hi uccm
I in Ifgt a r
ItHl r
ft il the -I~t car ylua Ih (Jfld h n
er Juon
Yo
u or impd w
i) its but
01 ~nt Jihl
But it
w
h 1fU
u nu
hln
ltrr
the cO
Untry rodrth
n th
IM
I f bull bum
p t~t jICOJ rJI iu fJ1JU
f
Evory car dlrln
d croott on h~m
t II llfQ
thf U
f
Word a
nn
o( dK
rlb
TH
ES
IX of 16
You
mw
t it-fH
I the
hl-
itl the thrill of it nnoolh action
Promp dol
In
booing mod by
Mitch1I db l
ht T
ht one in
ylaquo
Jr tO
Wn
Atl fo
r III dlFfT
OnU
nbor
~
The
Li~rary
D~~I for
Septemb
er 18 19
15 61 7
ltT1
THE SIXO
f16J~-$1250
Every C
ar SeIls A
nother
~hU
~PJifr R(Hldlifr $
1250
fflIr-P4ltr--T
cunmiddotn
eel s-fr~c-J ~
~o-mrsJshy
AU
PU
CU
F O D
AAO
NE
~tIur31o1btR
Icine Nh
U S
A
Fig
ure
4
1 D t E
i1
51-n
Hodel 27 $1000
Alt rarn
lbecl w
llh Jebullbuller eeralpm
enc a 1950
ON
T
HIS
C
AR
is em
bodied the
highest developm
ent o
f the
II
simple po
wer plant
Mo
tor an
d transm
ission gear are com
pletely housed as a unit w
ith three-point support E
very
part o
f the m
otor tran
smittin
g m
echan
ism an
d
appurshytenances are perfectly accessible fro
m a
bo
ve and
by reason of th
e tilting body m
ay be reach
ed w
itho
ut trouble o
r discomfort
Th
e 1907 line com
prises two
m
odels o
f this type M
odel 27
sho
wn
above and
M
odel 21 a m
edium
weig
ht
touring car with
detachable tonneau
O
ur ad
vance catalogue describing both is at y
ou
r service M
ain
O
ffi ce
an
d
Facto
r- K
en
osh
a
Wis
co
nsin
B
ran
ch
es
Ch
icago
M
ilWA
uk
ee B
Olto
n
Pb
iladelp
hia
San
Fran
cisco
NeW
Yo
rk A
renlZ-Y 3s--to W
6Zod
St
Rep
ren n
trI9U
in allle
din
g c
iliu
Th
otn
as
B
Jeffe
ry
reg
C
o tnp
an
y
Fig
ur e
5
- UntitledPDFpdf
-