wkh&$ wk'lvwulfw&rxuwri$sshdo'lylvlrq...volume 1 of 2, exhibits 1-7a, pp. 1-174...

Appeal No. G058506

IN THE COURT OF APPEALFOR THE STATE OF CALIFORNIAFOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE___________________________________________

FRIENDS FOR FULLERTON’S FUTURE,JOSHUAFERGUSON, and DAVID CURLEE

Petitioners,

v.

SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA,COUNTY OF ORANGE

Respondents,

CITY OF FULLERTON

Real Party in Interest.

___________________________________________

APPEAL FROM THE SUPERIOR COURT FORTHE COUNTY OF ORANGE

Hon. Thomas A. Delaney, (657) 622-5224Superior Court No. 30-2019-01107063-CU-NP-CJC

___________________________________________

APPENDIX OF EXHIBITS IN SUPPORT OFPRELIMINARY OPPOSITION

VOLUME 1 OF 2, EXHIBITS 1-7a, pp. 1-174

___________________________________________

Kimberly Hall Barlow (SBN 149902)Krista MacNevin Jee (SBN 198650)JONES & MAYER3777 No. Harbor BoulevardFullerton, CA 92835(714) 446-1400/(714) 446-1448/faxAttorneys for Real Party in Interest,CITY OF FULLERTON

000001

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Exhibit Page(s) Date Title of Document

1 000004 -000013

11/01/2019 SUPPLEMENTALMEMORANDUM OF POINTSAND AUTHORITIES INSUPPORT OF PLAINTIFF’SMOTION FOR PRELIMINARYINJUNCTION

2 000014 -000109

11/01/2019 SUPPLEMENTALDECLARATION OF MATTHEWSTREBE IN SUPPORT OF CITYOF FULLERTON’S MOTIONFOR PRELIMINARYINJUNCTION

3 000110 -000156

11/01/2019 SUPPLEMENTALDECLARATION OF MEA KLEININ SUPPORT OF CITY OFFULLERTON’S MOTION FORPRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

4 000157 -000162

11/01/2019 DECLARATION OF IVY M. TSAIIN SUPPORT OF CITY OFFULLERTON’S MOTION FORPRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

5 000163 -000165

11/01/2019 DECLARATION OF MARNIRICE IN SUPPORT OFPLAINTIFF’S MOTION FORPRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

6 000166 -000168

11/01/2019 DECLARATION OF MICHAEL J.RICE IN SUPPORT OFPLAINTIFF’S MOTION FORPRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

7 000169 -000171

11/01/2019 DECLARATION OFCHRISTOPHER TENNYSON INSUPPORT OF PLAINTIFF’SMOTION FOR PRELIMINARYINJUNCTION

000002

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

7a 000172 -000177

11/01/2019 [PROPOSED] ORDERGRANTING PLAINTIFF’SMOTION FOR PRELIMINARYINJUNCTION

Dated: November 18, 2019

Respectfully submitted,

JONES & MAYER

Kimberly Hall BarlowKrista MacNevin JeeAttorneys for Real Party in Interest,CITY OF FULLERTON

000003

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EX

EM

PT

FR

OM

FIL

ING

FE

ES

PU

RS

UA

NT

TO

GO

VE

RN

ME

NT

CO

DE

SE

CT

ION

6103

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT OFPLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

JONES & MAYERKimberly Hall Barlow, Esq. SBN [email protected] A. Lindsay, Esq., SBN [email protected] Choi Arredondo, Esq., SBN [email protected] North Harbor BoulevardFullerton, CA 92835Telephone: (714) 446-1400Facsimile: (714) 446-1448

Attorneys for DefendantCITY OF FULLERTON

SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

COUNTY OF ORANGE – CENTRAL JUSTICE CENTER

CITY OF FULLERTON,

Plaintiff,

vs.

FRIENDS FOR FULLERTON’S FUTURE,JOSHUA FERGUSON, DAVID CURLEE,CHRISTOPHER TENNYSON, and DOES 1through 20, inclusive,

Defendants.

Case No. 30-2019-01107063-CU-NP-CJC

Assigned for all purposes to:Judge Thomas A. Delaney, Department C24

SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM OFPOINTS AND AUTHORITIES INSUPPORT OF PLAINTIFF’S MOTIONFOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

[Filed Concurrently with:Supp. Declaration of Matthew Strebe; Supp.Declaration of Mea Klein; Declaration of IvyTsai; Declaration of Marni Rice; Declaration ofMichael J. Rice; Declaration of ChristopherTennyson; Declaration of Kimberly HallBarlow; and [Proposed] Order]

Date: November 21, 2019Time: 8:30 a.m.Dept.: C24

Action filed: 10/24/2019

Electronically Filed by Superior Court of California, County of Orange, 11/01/2019 05:06:00 PM.DAVID H. YAMASAKI, Clerk of the Court By Dollie Campos, Deputy Clerk. 30-2019-01107063-CU-NP-CJC ROA # 31

000004

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT OFPLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES

I. INTRODUCTION

At issue in Plaintiff City of Fullerton’s (“the City”) motion for preliminary injunction are

18 Dropbox folders that contained over 122 PST files that included over 51,700 emails (not

including attachments).1 (Supplemental Declaration of Matthew Strebe (“Supp. Strebe Dec.”), ¶¶

8-26 & Exhs. 2-20). These PST files contained within these 18 Dropbox folders are of paramount

concern to the City because they are considered attorney work product collections of documents

that were only potentially responsive to Public Records Act requests and were specifically culled

by IT personnel for attorney review.

Defendants2 routinely and systematically downloaded these 18 Dropbox folders containing

over 122 PST files before the City’s attorney could complete her review for privileged and

confidential records and information to withhold and/or redact under applicable Public Records Act

exemptions. (Id.; Supplemental Declaration of Mea Klein (“Supp. Klein Dec.”; Declaration of Ivy

M. Tsai (“Tsai Dec.”)). Although Defendants also downloaded many other folders and documents

from the City’s Dropbox account, (see Strebe Dec., Exh. A), the City has narrowly tailored its

request herein to these 18 Dropbox folders containing the over 122 work product PST files, as

outlined in Exhibit A to the concurrently filed [Proposed] Order.

The City never gave Defendants express authority to download, copy or use the 18 Dropbox

folders at issue. The fact that Curlee received a link to the City’s entire Dropbox on June 6, 2019

from a City employee responding a PRA request did not give him license to download, copy and

use the 18 Dropbox folders that were never produced directly to him. Moreover, by that time,

Defendants had already downloaded all of the 18 Dropbox folders at issue. To the extent the Court

considers this an inadvertent disclosure, the California Supreme Court has held that inadvertent

disclosures under the Public Records Act do not result in a waiver of the attorney-client or work

product privileges. Ardon v. City of Los Angeles, 62 Cal. 4th 1176 (2016).

1 One of the 18 Dropbox folders at issue is the Subject File “pr1919 – Josh Ferguson.zip” was addressed at length inPlaintiff’s opening brief, and contained over 11,000 emails + attachments.2 The term “Defendants” herein shall refer to Defendants Friends for Fullerton’s Future, Joshua Ferguson, DavidCurlee, and Does 1 to 20.” Although Christopher Tennyson was included in the action, the City anticipates it willdismiss him from the action. See Declaration of Christopher Tennyson (“Tennyson Dec.”).

000005

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

- 2 -SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT OF

PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

Moreover, even if a City employee had tried to waive the privilege by posting these files in

the City’s Dropbox, such an attempted waiver of the attorney-client privilege would be ineffectual.

Commodity Futures Trading Com. v. Weintraub, 471 U.S. 343, 348 (1985) (right to waive attorney-

client privilege rests with officers of corporation). In any event, the privileged information does

not lose its privileged status because it was stolen by Defendants.

Defendants have indicated they will file an anti-SLAPP motion, which is scheduled to be

heard at the same time as Plaintiff’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction. While that issue will be

briefed separately, neither the First Amendment nor the anti-SLAPP statutes protect Defendants

from suit where the Plaintiff’s claims are based on illegal conduct of the Defendants.

II. LEGAL ANALYSIS

A. The City Did Not Waive its Claim of Attorney-Client and Work ProductPrivilege over the PST Files Contained in Dropbox Folders Created forAttorney Review

1. The City Did Not Give Defendants Express Authority to Download AllDocuments Contained within its Dropbox Account

Defendants suggest that they had license to download, copy and use all documents within

the City’s Dropbox account merely because they received a link and password to the entire account

from City employee Margot Cronce on June 6, 2019, in response to a Public Records Act request

made by Curlee. (Klein Dec., ¶ 14(e) & Exh. E). However, Ms. Cronce’s email expressly identified

the specific Dropbox folder that contained the responsive documents being provided to Curlee.

Nowhere in Ms. Cronce’s email did she give express authority for Defendants to access all other

folders within the Dropbox account, for all time. Moreover, by the time Curlee received the link

to the entire Dropbox account, Defendants had already downloaded all of the folders at issue.

(Supp. Klein Dec.; Supp. Strebe Dec., ¶¶ 7-26 & Exh. 2-20). The City did not give Defendants

direct links to the 18 Dropbox folders at issue; nor did the City otherwise give them permission to

download, copy and use these 18 Dropbox folders. (Supp. Klein Dec.; Tsai Dec., ¶9). Certainly a

single inadvertent release of the password to Curlee in June 2019 cannot retroactively absolve

Defendants of their prior repeated thefts of files from the City’s account. This is equivalent to a

burglar saying that, having stolen objects from my home for years, he is immune from prosecution

000006

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



for all the thefts that came before because the last time he went there, he found the door unlocked.

A reasonable person would not have interpreted the receipt of a link to the entire Dropbox

account, with reference to the specific folder containing responsive records, as a license to

download anything and everything within the City’s Dropbox account. In fact, another user who

received a link to the Dropbox account with direction to the specific folder that contained records

responsive to his request limited his downloads to the records contained in the specific folder

referenced in the City’s email production to him. (Supp. Strebe ¶ 10 & Exh. 4B; Supp. Klein Dec.,

¶ 7 & Exh. L).

2. Inadvertent Disclosure Does Not Waive the Attorney-Client Privilegeor Work Product Doctrine

The exemptions to the Public Records Act are numerous and generally involve documents

that should remain confidential for one reason or another. Ardon, 62 Cal. 4th at 1182. One of the

main exceptions to the Public Records Act request is Government Code section 6254(k), which

exempts from disclosure “[r]ecords, the disclosure of which is exempted or prohibited pursuant to

federal or state law, including, but not limited to, provisions of the Evidence Code related to

privilege.” The applicable privileges include both the attorney-client privilege and the work

product privilege. Ardon, 62 Cal. 4th at 1182.

Even if the Court finds that the sharing of the link to the entire Dropbox account on June 6,

2019 resulted in an inadvertent disclosure to Curlee, Defendants had already downloaded all 18

Dropbox folders before June 6, 2019. (Supp. Strebe Dec., ¶ 7 & Exh. 1; see also Strebe Exhs. 2-

20).

More importantly, the California Supreme Court has held that a City does not waive the

attorney-client or work product privilege through inadvertent disclosures made under the Public

Records Act. Ardon, 62 Cal. 4th at 1189. In doing so, the Court recognized that the attorney-client

privilege “safeguards ‘the confidential relationship between clients and their attorneys so as to

promote full and open discussion of the facts and tactics surrounding individual legal matters.” (Id.

at 1186 (quoting Mitchell v. Super. Ct., 37 Cal. 3d 591, 599 (1984)). The Court also recognized

that the attorney work product “enables ‘a lawyer [to] work with a certain degree of privacy, free

000007

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



from unnecessary intrusion by opposing parties and their counsel.’” Ardon, 62 Cal. 4th at 1186

(quoting Hickman v. Taylor, 329 U.S. 495 (1947)). The Court also specifically noted that the

waiver provision under Government Code § 6254.5 applied to intentional disclosures rather than

inadvertent disclosures. Ardon, 62 Cal. 4th at 1184.

In reaching its conclusion, the Supreme Court specifically noted that the attorney-client and

work product privileges apply to governmental entities as well as private entities.

A city council needs freedom to confer with its lawyers confidentially inorder to obtain adequate advice, just as does a private citizen who seekslegal counsel, even though the scope of confidential meetings is limited bythis state’s public meeting requirements. The public interest is served bythe privilege because it permits local government agencies to seek advicethat may prevent the agency from becoming embroiled in litigation, and itmay permit the agency to avoid unnecessary controversy with variousmembers of the public.

Id. (citing Roberts v. City of Palmdale, 5 Cal. 4th 363, 380-81 (1993)).

In Harleysville Ins. Co. v. Holding Funeral Home, Inc., 2017 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 162058

(W.D. Va. 2017), the Western District of Virginia held that the attorney-client and work product

privileges had not been waived through the inadvertent sharing of a link to the party’s cloud-based

Box, Inc. file-sharing account, because the producing party did not intend to specifically disclose

the privileged insurance claims file contained therein, and had taken reasonable precautions to keep

the file-sharing account secure. Id. at *17-21. The disclosure in Harleysville occurred because the

privileged claims file was uploaded to a file sharing account without password protection.

However, the court held that the file sharing account was not public because it was not searchable

on the Box, Inc. website. Access was limited to an invitation or “sharing” link. Id. at *18-19.

Moreover, the materials contained within the claims file were marked as privileged and

confidential. Id. at *21.

Here, the City took similarly reasonable precautions to secure its Dropbox account. Access

to the City’s Dropbox account was limited to persons who received direct links or invitations to the

City’s Dropbox account. (Strebe Dec., ¶¶ 20-21).

More importantly, the PST Files contained within the Dropbox folders at issue were

specifically created by IT for attorney review, and not intended for review by any third parties, as

000008

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



they contained privileged and confidential documents and/or documents otherwise exempted from

disclosure under the Public Records Act, including attorney-client communications, attorney work

product (including attorney comments and revisions on draft documents), draft settlement and other

agreements, insurance-related documents, etc. Some of the PST files also included highly sensitive

information such as social security numbers, law enforcement investigative records, personnel

records and related information, and employee medical information. (Tsai Dec., ¶ 10).

Each of the PST files included in the 18 Dropbox folders at issue, was essentially the

equivalent of folders of dozens to thousands of potentially responsive records culled or collected

for attorney review. It would be fundamentally unfair for Defendants to be allowed to keep and

use clearly privileged collections of documents culled for attorney review. As the Supplemental

Declaration of Mea Klein establishes, there were 16 PRA requests made that corresponded with the

18 Dropbox folders at issue. Of these 16 PRA requests, the City produced documents to Defendants

and other third parties in response to 11 of the requests, either through PDF attachments to an email

or links to separate Dropbox folder not at issue or another file-sharing site containing the responsive

documents. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶¶ 5-9, 11-14, 18-19 & Exhs. J-N, P-S, V, W). For the remaining

5 of 16 PRA requests, the City responded that either (1) no responsive records existed, (2) the

responsive records were exempted from disclosure under the PRA, or (3) the request was too broad

and burdensome and needed to be narrowed. (Id., ¶¶ 10, 15-17, 20 & Exhs. O, T, U, X; see also

Klein Dec., ¶¶ 17-21 & Exhs. F-I).

The only PST file specifically produced by the City to one of the Defendants was

“PPR_18_326_Curlee.zip,” which was a separate Dropbox folder created to house a PST file that

included emails reviewed by Deputy City Attorney Ivy Tsai, after she reviewed the collection of

emails and attachments created for her review at “PPR_Cox.zip.” (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 21).

Because this Dropbox folder was directly produced to Curlee and because it only contained

documents determined to be responsive, non-privileged and not otherwise subject to exemption

under the PRA, the City is not seeking the return of this particular Dropbox folder.

Defendants’ suggestion that they are entitled to keep the Dropbox folders because some of

them contained their names or PRA numbers assigned to their PRA requests is nonsensical, and

000009

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



tantamount to suggesting that they could roam around the City Attorney’s Office and take any file

folders referencing their names regardless of whether they were privileged or confidential, simply

because the folders referenced their names. Defendants were familiar with the concepts of the

attorney-client and work product privileges and the names of attorneys representing the City from

the multitude of PRA requests they have made over the last 3 years (80 and counting), and from

their Blog activities. (See Klein Dec., ¶ 13). Despite seeing documents labeled attorney-client

privileged as well as other documents they had reason to know were privileged or otherwise

exempted, they used and published privileged documents obtained from their downloads of the 18

Dropbox folders at issue, in contravention of Penal Code section 502(c) and 18 U.S.C. § 1030.

As such, the Court should find there was no waiver of the City’s attorney-client and work

product privileges.

3. Lower Level Employees Cannot Waive the Attorney-Client Privilege

To the extent that Defendants argue that the City somehow waived its attorney-client

privilege by the inadvertent acts of an employee who is not part of the City’s Management and

where no waiver was ever authorized by the City Council, they are wrong. A City, like any other

corporate entity, has only a limited number of officers who have the power to waive the attorney-

client privilege. [T]he power to waive the corporate attorney-client privilege rests with the

corporation’s management and is normally exercised by its officers and directors.” Commodity

Futures Trading Com. v. Weintraub, 471 U.S. 343, 348 (1985).

Moreover, providing non-management employees access to attorney-clientprivileged information in order to facilitate its gathering and provision tocounsel for review, does not change the character or privileged status ofthe information. “ . . . [A] communication does not loseits privilege merely because it was obtained, with the knowledge andconsent of the employer, by an agent of the employer acting under suchagency.”

D. I. Chadbourne, Inc. v. Super. Ct. of S.F., 60 Cal. 2d 723, 737 (1964). Surely if an inadvertent

disclosure does not waive the privilege as noted above, then the privilege cannot be deemed waived

because the Defendants successfully stole the documents.

///

///

000010

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



B. THE ANTI-SLAPP STATUTE DOES NOT PROTECT DEFENDANTSFROM SUIT OR FROM THE GRANT OF A MOTION FORPRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

Defendants’ mere assertion, in opposing injunctive relief, that Plaintiff’s suit is subject to

an anti-SLAPP motion has nothing to do with the merits of Plaintiffs’ Motion for Preliminary

Injunction. If, and when, Defendants file an anti-SLAPP motion, Plaintiff fully expects to defeat

it. First, as to the initial prong of the anti-SLAPP analysis, Defendants have the burden of

demonstrating that “the challenged cause of action arises from protected activity.” Malin v. Singer,

217 Cal. App. 4th 1283, 1303 (2013). As a matter of law, computer hacking, and theft as alleged

in the Complaint, and injuries resulting from those activities, are not protected activities under the

anti-SLAPP laws. Id. (“[T]he acts underlying … civil rights and related ... causes of action are

computer hacking and wiretapping. Those acts do not fit one of the categories of protected conduct

defined … in [Code of Civil Procedure] section 425.16, subdivision (e)….”) (emphasis in original.)

See also, Gerbosi v. Gaims, Weil, West & Epstein, LLP, 193 Cal. App. 4th 435, 445 (2011) (Anti-

SLAPP “cannot be invoked by a defendant whose assertedly protected activity is illegal as a matter

of law, and for that reason, not protected by constitutional guarantees of free speech and

petition.”)(emphasis in original). Second, even if Defendants could establish that any cause of

action in Plaintiff’s Complaint arose from protected activity, an anti-SLAPP motion cannot succeed

where, as here, the Plaintiff has proffered more than enough evidence to establish that it has a

“reasonable possibility of winning.” Gerbosi, 193 Cal. App. 4th at 447. In fact, the evidence is

overwhelming that Defendants downloaded confidential files and folders which they were not

authorized to obtain and that they have used those files in such a way as to endanger the rights of

city employees, expose the city to liability, and interfere with the Attorney-Client privilege.

C. THE COURT MAY AND SHOULD ISSUE AN ORDER FOR ANINDEPENDENT EXPERT TO SEARCH COMPUTERS FOR THE CITY’SFILES

Defendants have further argued that the California Constitution, Article I, section 2(b)

(commonly referred to as the California Shield Law) prevents this Court from issuing an order

preventing them from using or disseminating the confidential records they criminally obtained and

that it prevents the Court from appointing a third party to search for the City’s confidential records

000011

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



on Defendants’ electronic devices and computers. They are wrong on both counts. First, neither

the requested injunction nor the appointment of a third party expert seek or require that Defendants

“disclose the source of any information” or to “disclose any unpublished information” as provided

in the Shield Law.

The Defendants have neither argued nor provided a shred of evidence that they lawfully

obtained the records in question from a third party rather than by personally accessing the City’s

account and taking the files – i.e., by engaging in criminal activity themselves. The evidence

demonstrates that Defendants themselves went into the City’s Dropbox and downloaded the

privileged files, not that they obtained them from someone else. The City is not seeking to force

Defendants to disclose their interactions with third parties or to otherwise disclose the source of

lawfully obtained information. Nor does it seek to prohibit the publication of documents lawfully

obtained.

Second, what Plaintiff is seeking is not to force Defendants to “disclose” unpublished

information to the City – just the opposite. Plaintiff wants its confidential information returned to

it. It does not seek disclosure from Defendants at all. Finally, to the extent that Defendants argue

that Evidence Code section 1070 protects them from having to turn over records or to have a third

party review whether the confidential records are in their possession, that is incorrect.

The California Supreme Court has made clear that the California Shield Law is not absolute

where the “news” agency or individual is a party to the litigation, such as here. As noted in Miller

v. Superior Court of San Joaquin County, 21 Cal. 4th 883, 899 (1999):

In Mitchell v. Superior Court (1984) 37 Cal. 3d 268, we consideredwhether a newsperson who is a defendant in a libel suit can be compelledto reveal confidential information during the discovery process. As wemade clear, the shield law was not at issue; rather, because newspersonsand a news organization were parties in the case, they could be subject tosanctions other than contempt for failing to reveal the requestedinformation, including entry of judgment against them. (Id., at p. 274.)Therefore, our analysis was based on an implied First Amendment shieldagainst such sanctions rather than the explicit immunity from contemptfound in our state Constitution. (Id., at pp. 274-276.) We concluded that anewsperson who was a party to litigation was eligible for a limitedprotection from civil discovery, subject to a balancing test similar to theone later articulated in Delaney.

000012

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



Miller, 21 Cal. 4that 899 (emphasis added).

As a result, the Court may allow discovery to demonstrate that in fact Defendants are in

possession of confidential and privileged PST files never released to them. There may also be

communications between Defendants relating to their personal and unlawful downloading of the

documents. The City is entitled to obtain that evidence. Out of respect for the privacy and other

legitimate concerns of Defendants, Plaintiff has suggested an independent court appointed expert

who would report to the Court to prevent any potential for the City to seek or acquire anything

other the limited categories of information legitimately related to this lawsuit

III. CONCLUSION

For the foregoing reasons, the City respectfully requests that the Court grant Plaintiff’s

Motion for Preliminary Injunction.

Dated: November 1, 2019 JONES & MAYER

By:

Kimberly Hall BarlowBruce A. LindsayMonica Choi ArredondoAttorneys for DefendantCITY OF FULLERTON

000013

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EX

EM

PT

FR

OM

FIL

ING

FE

ES

PU

RS

UA

NT

TO

GO

VE

RN

ME

NT

CO

DE

SE

CT

ION

6103

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF MATTHEW STREBE IN SUPPORT OFCITY OF FULLERTON’S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION





CITY OF FULLERTON,

Plaintiff,

vs.


Defendants.

Case No. 30-2019-01107063-CU-NP-CJC


SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OFMATTHEW STREBE IN SUPPORT OFCITY OF FULLERTON’S MOTIONFOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

[Filed Concurrently with Supp.Memorandum of Points and Authorities;Supp. Declaration of Mea Klein; Declarationof Ivy M. Tsai; Declaration of Marni Rice;Declaration of Michael J. Rice; Declarationof Christopher Tennyson; and [Proposed]Order]




000014

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

- 1 -SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF MATTHEW STREBE IN SUPPORT OF

CITY OF FULLERTON’S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

DECLARATION OF MATTHEW STREBE

I, MATTHEW STREBE, hereby declare as follows:

1. I am an adult over the age of eighteen and I have personal knowledge of the facts

contained in this declaration. I could testify to these facts in a court of law if called upon to do so.

2. I make this supplemental declaration in support of Plaintiff City of Fullerton’s (City)

Motion for Preliminary Junction, to address additional information obtained and clarification of my

prior declaration submitted in support of the City’s Ex Parte Application for Temporary Restraining

Order.

3. Correction of Paragraph 77: Blog Post: “So What Did Lieutenant Kathryn Hamel

Do?” published on June 13, 2019 at: https://www.fullertonsfuture.org/2019/so-what-did-

lieutenant-katheryn-hamel-do/. Confidential document published: Privileged email regarding PD

internal affairs investigation. Source documents: Privileged email from City’s outside counsel, J.

Scott Tiedeman of Liebert Cassidy Whitmore to outside counsel Arthur Hartinger of Public Law

Group, Gretchen Beatty and Chief of Police, “Assistance with Internal Affairs Investigation.”

Taken from: PST file “pr1919JF_to_rd.pst” contained within the Subject File.

Christopher Tennyson and Fullerton Cameras

4. I understand that Defendant Chris Tennyson has declared he never accessed or

downloaded any folders or documents from the City’s Dropbox account, but did use the Fullerton

Cameras store computer to access his personal Dropbox account (registered to

[email protected]) to send photographs to clients. (Declaration of Christopher Tennyson).

As previously noted in Paragraph 22 of my prior declaration, Dropbox utilizes an automatic login

function whereby Dropbox will automatically register the login information from the last logged-

in session associated with a particular computer when a user accesses Dropbox through a link,

unless the user affirmatively logs out of Dropbox and/or takes steps to anonymize his or her

Dropbox session. (See Strebe Dec., ¶ 22). The City’s Dropbox activity log recorded Mr. Tennyson

as having accessed and downloaded a folder named “PRRS01152019_JF.zip” on January 16, 2019.

(See Strebe Dec., Exh. I). As such, Mr. Ferguson most likely accessed and downloaded this folder

from the City’s Dropbox account sometime after Mr. Tennyson’s logged in use of his Dropbox

000015

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



account, using the store’s computer.

5. I understand that the owners of Fullerton Cameras have declared they have never

accessed or downloaded any folders or documents from the City’s Dropbox account, but that the

owners and employees of Fullerton Cameras used the store’s Dropbox account (registered to

[email protected]) to send photographs to clients. (Declarations of Marnie Rice and

Michael J. Rice). The City’s Dropbox activity log recorded the store’s email address as having

accessed and downloaded the following folders on December 29, 2017: (1) “ACUSA_PRR.zip,”

(2) “51022 Malvern,” and (3) “Pro-Card.” (See Strebe Dec., Exh. D, pp. 1-3). I understand that

the Dropbox folder “Pro-Card” had been produced to Mr. Ferguson’s associate David Curlee on

September 16, 2017 in response to a Public Records Act request (PRR). (Declaration of Mea Klein

(“Klein Dec.”), ¶14(a) & Exh. A thereto). As such, given Mr. Ferguson’s confirmed logged-in

downloads from the City’s Dropbox account, his employment at Fullerton Cameras, the fact that

the folder “Pro-Card” had been produced to his associate, and that no other store employee or owner

accessed the City’s Dropbox account, there is no question that Mr. Ferguson was in fact the

individual who downloaded these 3 folders attributed to the store’s Dropbox login

([email protected]) on December 29, 2017. (See Strebe Dec., Exh. D). If Mr. Ferguson

accessed and downloaded the folders by utilizing links to these folders immediately after a login

session that utilized the store’s Dropbox login, his December 29, 2017 activities would have been

attributed to the store’s login due to Dropbox’s automatic login feature.

Dropbox Notifications features

6. The Dropbox service is primarily a file-sharing service designed to simplify the

distribution of large documents over the Internet between organizations and individuals. As such,

the service can be configured to notify outside third party users immediately of changes made to

folders such as the uploading of a new file. Notifications may be configured to appear in the

Dropbox desktop sync client, by email, or by push notification to mobile devices such as Android

or Apple phones. It is by this mechanism that a user may obtain immediate knowledge of the

presence of a new file on the Dropbox service.[https://help.dropbox.com/accounts-billing/settings-

sign-in/notified-changes]

000016

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



Post-June 6, 2019 Downloads

7. I understand Defendants have argued the City gave them express permission to

access and download ALL folders and documents contained within the City’s Dropbox account by

inadvertently producing a link and password to the City’s entire Dropbox account to Mr. Curlee on

June 6, 2019, 4:10:46 p.m. First, the email in which that link was produced to Mr. Curlee expressly

limited access to the Drobpox file name containing the documents responsive to his request: “PRR

Pro Card 5-29-19.” (See Klein Dec., Exh. E). Second, the only Dropbox folders containing PST

files that were downloaded after June 6, 2019, 4:10:46 p.m. were (1) “PRR_19-

[email protected]” and (2) “PRRS01152019_JF.zip,” but each of these

Dropbox folders had already been downloaded multiple times by Mr. Ferguson and his associates

before June 6, 2019. (See Supplemental Declaration of Mea Klein (“Supp. Klein Dec.”), ¶¶ 15, 18

& Exh. W thereto. See infra, ¶¶ 20, 23 & Exhs. 15, 17 for a history of the downloads of these two

folders). (True and correct excerpts from the City’s Dropbox activity log reflecting all downloads

dated after June 6, 2019, 4:10:46 p.m. are attached hereto as Exhibit “1”).

Defendants Routinely Downloaded Dropbox Folders Containing Privileged PST Files Before

the City’s Attorneys Had a Chance to Complete their Review and Before the City Provided

its Final Response to their PRRs

8. The Dropbox folder named “ACUSA_PRR.zip” was created by City IT for

attorney review on December 15, 2017. (Declaration of Ivy Tsai (“Tsai Dec.”), ¶ 3). It was

downloaded by the City Attorney’s office 4 days later. (See Tsai Dec., ¶ 6, identifying 76.79.196.58

as the IP address for Jones & Mayer). It was also downloaded by Joshua Ferguson, using his login

“[email protected]” and his work login “[email protected]”, through

Norway, using the PureVPN anonymizing service on December 28, 2017, December 29, 2017 and

December 30, 2017.1 (Strebe Dec., Exh. D). It was then downloaded by a TOR user on January 1,

2018. (True and correct excerpts from the City’s Dropbox activity log reflecting all downloads of

the Dropbox folder “ACUSA_PRR.zip,” and the IP address look-up for 185.38.14.215 are attached

1 Mr. Ferguson’s used PureVPN during his December 28 and December 30 downloads. (See Strebe Dec., Exh. F).

000017

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



hereto as Exhibit “2”). Based on my review of the City’s Dropbox activity log, Ms. Tsai’s

declaration and Ms. Klein’s supplemental declaration, and Mr. Ferguson’s logged-in activities, it

is clear that Mr. Ferguson downloaded this folder on December 29, 2017 and December 30, 2017.

It is also apparent that Mr. Ferguson and Mr. Curlee also downloaded this Dropbox folder on two

other occasions without being given a direct link to it, before the City produced non-privileged

documents in response to the corresponding PRR No. 17-458 on January 19, 2018. (See Supp.

Klein Dec., ¶ 5 & Exh. J; Strebe Dec., Exh. D; Tennyson Dec., Marni Rice Dec., Mike Rice Dec.).

9. The Dropbox folder named “CE_PRR_KC.zip” was created by City IT for

attorney review on April 10, 2018. (Tsai Dec., ¶ 4). It was downloaded through a former TOR exit

node in Germany on April 12, 2018, and by a TOR user through Norway, Netherlands and France

on April 13, 2018. It was then downloaded by the City Attorney’s office on April 24, 2018. (True

and correct excerpts from the City’s Dropbox activity log reflecting all downloads of the Dropbox

folder “CE_PRR_KC.zip,” and the IP address look-ups for 85.90.244.23, 128.31.0.13,

171.25.193.235, 185.50.191.250, and 2001:67c:289c::25 are attached hereto as Exhibit “3”). Based

on my review of the City’s Dropbox activity log, Ms. Tsai’s declaration and Ms. Klein’s

supplemental declaration, it is apparent that Mr. Ferguson and Mr. Curlee downloaded this Dropbox

folder on multiple occasions without being given a direct link to it, before the City produced non-

privileged documents in response to the corresponding PRR No. 18-72 on April 25, 2018. (See

Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 6 & Exh. K).

10. The Dropbox folder named “council_20180430.zip” was created by City IT for

attorney review on or about May 1, 2018. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 7). It contained 1 PST file named

“council_20180430,” which contained over 2,000 emails + attachments. The same day the folder

was created, it was downloaded by a TOR user through Switzerland. The folder was thereafter

downloaded by the City Attorney’s office on May 7, 2018 and a City of Fullerton employee on

May 8, 2018, May 9, 2018 and May 15, 2018. (True and correct excerpts from the City’s Dropbox

activity log reflecting all downloads of the Dropbox folder “council_20180430.zip” are attached

hereto as Exhibit “4A”). Based on my review of the City’s Dropbox activity log and Ms. Klein’s

supplemental declaration, it is apparent that Mr. Ferguson or Mr. Curlee downloaded this Dropbox

000018

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



folder without being given a direct link to it, before the City produced non-privileged documents

in response to the corresponding PRR No. 18-101 on June 27, 2018. Although the requestor was

inadvertently given a link to the City’s entire Dropbox account, he was directed to a specific folder

within it named “Moy responsive emails.” (See Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 7 & Exh. L). More importantly,

the Dropbox activity log shows that he only downloaded documents from the Dropbox folder the

City directed him to. (True and correct excerpts from the City’s Dropbox activity log reflecting all

downloads of the Dropbox folder “Moy responsive emails” and all activity within the City’s

Dropbox account performed by the user “[email protected]” are attached hereto as Exhibit

“4B”).

11. The Dropbox folder named “PRR_AIR20180604.zip” was created by City IT for

attorney review on June 4, 2018. It contained 4 PST files named “PRR_AIR_3,” “PRR_AIR_3-

1,” “PRR_AIR_3-3,” and “PRR_AIR_3-4,” which together contained over 1,700 emails +

attachments. It was downloaded by the City Attorney’s office that same day. (See Supp. Klein

Dec., ¶ 8). It was thereafter downloaded through a former TOR exit node in Liberia on June 6,

2018 before the City produced non-privileged documents in response to the corresponding PRR #

18-141 on January 8, 2019. (True and correct excerpts from the City’s Dropbox activity log

reflecting all downloads of the Dropbox folder “PRR_AIR20180604.zip,” and the IP address look-

up for 2c0f:f930:0:3::221 are attached hereto as Exhibit “5”). Based on my review of the City’s

Dropbox activity log and Ms. Klein’s supplemental declaration, it is apparent that Mr. Ferguson or

one of his associates downloaded this Dropbox folder without being given a direct link to it, before

the City produced non-privileged documents in response to the corresponding PRR No. 18-141 on

January 8, 2019. (See Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 8 & Exh. M).

12. The Dropbox folder named “HL_PRR” was created by City IT for attorney review

on July 25, 2018. It contained 2 PST files named “HL_PRR_1” and “HL_PRR_2,” which together

contained nearly 5,000 emails + attachments. It was downloaded by the City Attorney’s office the

same day it was created. (See Tsai Dec., ¶¶ 5-6). It was thereafter downloaded by a TOR user

through the Netherlands on July 26, 2018 and July 27, 2018 before the City produced non-

privileged documents in response to the corresponding PRR No. 18-190 on July 26, 2018. (True

000019

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



and correct excerpts from the City’s Dropbox activity log reflecting all downloads of the Dropbox

folder “HL_PRR,” and the IP address look-up for 89.31.57.5, are attached hereto as Exhibit “6”).

Based on my review of the City’s Dropbox activity log, Ms. Tsai’s declaration and Ms. Klein’s


folder without being given a direct link to it, before the City produced non-privileged documents

in response to the corresponding PRR No. 18-190. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 9 & Exh. N).

13. The Dropbox folder named “Tiger_Signal_PRR” was created by City IT for

attorney review on September 26, 2018. It contained 3 PST files named “AUTO_PST,”

“SIGNAL_PRR,” and “TigerText,” which together contained nearly 200 emails + attachments.

(Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 10). The same day it was created, it was downloaded by a TOR user through

Belgium and a PureVPN user through Los Angeles. It was then downloaded through Seychelles

and by the City Attorney’s office the next day, September 27, 2018, three days before the City

advised the requestor, Mr. Ferguson, that there were no documents responsive to his request, and

that two of his search terms were overburdensome because they yielded over 100,000 emails +

attachments. (Strebe Dec., ¶ J). Based on my review of the City’s Dropbox activity log and Ms.

Klein’s supplemental declaration, it is apparent that Mr. Ferguson and Mr. Curlee downloaded this

Dropbox folder multiple times without being given a direct link to it, before the City provided its

final response to the corresponding PRR No. 18-276. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 10 & Exh. O).

14. The Dropbox folder named “PRR_JF_20181002.zip” was created by City IT for

attorney review on October 2, 2018. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 11). It contained 13 PST files named

“JF_ANTEBELLUM,” “JF_CHIEF,” “JF_CONCERT,” “JF_CONCERTS,” “JF_DAVE,”

“JF_DAVID,” “JF_HAMEL,” “JF_HENDRICKS,” “JF_IRVINE,” “JF_OLI,” “JF_OLIVERAS,”

“JF_THOMAS,” and “JF_TOM,” which together contained over 2,000 emails + attachments. That

same day, it was downloaded by a PureVPN user through the Netherlands and Germany. The next

day, October 3, 2018, it was downloaded by the City Attorney’s office, 6 days before the City

produced records to the requestor (Mr. Ferguson) via PDFs attached to an email. (True and correct

excerpts from the City’s Dropbox activity log reflecting all downloads of the Dropbox folder

“PRR_JF_20181002.zip” are attached hereto as Exhibit “7”). Based on my review of the City’s

000020

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



Dropbox activity log and Ms. Klein’s supplemental declaration, it is apparent that Mr. Ferguson

downloaded this Dropbox folder without being given a direct link to it, before the City provided its

final response to his corresponding PRR No. 18-277. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 11 & Exh. P).

15. The Dropbox folder named “JF_PRR20181012.zip” was created by City IT for

attorney review on October 12, 2018. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 12). It contained 17 PST files named

“JF_BUSHALASIGN,” “JF_CARPETBAGGER,” “JF_DOUGSWIFE,” “JF_F.F.F.F.,”

“JF_FFFF,” “JF_FriendsforFullerton,” “JF_FULLERTONS_FUTURE,” “JF_Joshua,”

“JF_JoshuaFerguson,” “JOST_FERGUSON,” “JF_MARSHALLCHAFFEE,”

“JF_MAYORSSPOUSE,” JF_MAYORSWIFE,” “JF_PAULETTE,” “JF_SIGNTHEFT” and

“JF_SIGNTHIEF,” which together contained 13,420 emails + attachments. The same day it was

created, it was downloaded by the City Attorney’s office. The next day, on October 13, 2018, it

was downloaded by a PureVPN user through Liberia, Netherlands and Norway, and on October 14,

2018, it was downloaded by a TOR user through France and Switzerland, 50 days before the City

produced non-privileged documents to Mr. Ferguson in response to his corresponding PRR No. 18-

294. (True and correct excerpts from the City’s Dropbox activity log reflecting all downloads of

the Dropbox folder “JF_PRR20181012.zip,” and the IP address look-up for 2c0f:f930:0:3::221, are

attached hereto as Exhibit “8”). Based on my review of the City’s Dropbox activity log and Ms.

Klein’s supplemental declaration, it is apparent that Mr. Ferguson and Mr. Curlee downloaded this

Dropbox folder without being given a direct link to it, before the City provided its final response

to Mr. Ferguson’s corresponding PRR No. 18-294. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 12 & Exh. Q).

16. The Dropbox folder named “JF_PRR_2.zip” was created based on revised search

terms for PRR No. 18-294 by City IT for attorney review on October 30, 2018. (Supp. Klein Dec.,

¶ 12). It contained 7 PST files named “JF_F.F.F.F.,” “JF_FFFF,” “JF_Friends for Fullerton,”

“JF_Fullerton’s Future,” “JF_JOSH FERGUSON,” “JF_JOSHUA and

“JF_JOSHUA_FERGUSON,” which together contained 80 emails + attachments. It was

downloaded by the City Attorney’s office the same day it was created, followed by a TOR user

who also downloaded it the same day, through the Slovak Republic and Switzerland, about one

month before the City ultimately produced non-privileged documents to Mr. Ferguson in response

000021

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



to his corresponding PRR No. 18-294. (True and correct excerpts from the City’s Dropbox activity

log reflecting all downloads of the Dropbox folder “JF_PRR_2.zip,” and the IP address look-up for

2a00:1768:1001:21::32a3:201a, are attached hereto as Exhibit “9”). Based on my review of the

City’s Dropbox activity log and Ms. Klein’s supplemental declaration, it is apparent that Mr.

Ferguson and/or Mr. Curlee downloaded this Dropbox folder twice without being given a direct

link to it, before the City provided its final response to Mr. Ferguson’s corresponding PRR No. 18-

294. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 12 & Exh. Q).

17. The Dropbox folder named “PPR_Cox.zip” was created by City IT for attorney

review on November 6, 2018. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 13). It contained 1 PST file named “PPR_Cox,”

which contained nearly 2,000 emails + attachments. The same day it was created, it was

downloaded by a TOR user, followed by the City Attorney’s office, followed by Mr. Ferguson

(through a logged-in session attributed to his “[email protected]” email) about 21

days before the City produced its non-privileged documents in response to the corresponding PRR

No. 18-101, via a separate Dropbox folder named “PPR_18_326_Curlee.zip” on June 27, 2018.

(True and correct excerpts from the City’s Dropbox activity log reflecting all downloads of the

Dropbox folder “PPR_Cox.zip” are attached hereto as Exhibit “10”). Based on my review of the


Ferguson or Mr. Curlee downloaded this Dropbox folder without being given a direct link to it,

before the City provided its final response to Mr. Curlee’s corresponding PRR No. 18-326. (Supp.

Klein Dec., ¶ 13 & Exh. R).

18. The Dropbox folder named “PRRS01082019.zip” was created by City IT for

attorney review on January 9, 2019. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 14). It contained 1 PST file named

“PRRS01082019,” which contained over 5,200 emails + attachments. The same day it was created,

it was downloaded through a TOR exit node in Belgium and the Netherlands, and later by the City

Attorney’s office. The next day, on January 10, 2019, it was downloaded by (1) the City Attorney’s

office, (2) its IT contractor (logged in as “[email protected]”), and (3) a TOR user through

Austria, four days before the City produced non-privileged documents to Mr. Ferguson in response

to his corresponding PRR No. 19-16. (True and correct excerpts from the City’s Dropbox activity

000022

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



log reflecting all downloads of the Dropbox folder “PRRS01082019.zip,” and the IP address look-

up for 85.202.163.127 are attached hereto as Exhibit “11”). Based on my review of the City’s

Dropbox activity log, Ms. Tsai’s declaration and Ms. Klein’s supplemental declaration, it is

apparent that Mr. Ferguson and Mr. Curlee downloaded this Dropbox folder without being given a

direct link to it, before the City provided its final response to Mr. Ferguson’s corresponding PRR

No. 19-16. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 14 & Exh. S).

19. The Dropbox folder named “PRRS01092019.zip” was created based on revised

search terms for PRR No. 19-16 by City IT for attorney review on January 10, 2019. (Supp. Klein

Dec., ¶ 14). It contained 5 PST files named “PRRS01092019,” “PRRS01092019_2,”

“PRRS01092019_3,” “PRRS01092019_4” and “PRRS01092019_5,” which together contained

over 100 emails + attachments. The same day it was created, a TOR user, followed by the City

Attorney’s office, downloaded it. On January 15, 2019, a user downloaded it through a former

TOR exit node in the Netherlands, a day after the City produced non-privileged documents to Mr.

Ferguson in response to his corresponding PRR No. 19-16. (True and correct excerpts from the

City’s Dropbox activity log reflecting all downloads of the Dropbox folder “PRRS01092019.zip,”

and the IP address look-up for 2a00:1768:1001:21::32a3:201 are attached hereto as Exhibit “12”).

Based on my review of the City’s Dropbox activity log, Ms. Tsai’s declaration and Ms. Klein’s


folder without being given a direct link to it, before the City provided its final response to Mr.

Ferguson’s corresponding PRR No. 19-16. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 14 & Exh. S).

20. Interestingly, it appears that City IT created another Dropbox folder related to

“PRRS01092019.zip” in error. It was named “PRRS01092019_all.zip,” and created on January

10, 2019, less than 2 hours before “PRRS01092019.zip”. It was deleted within 2 hours of

uploading, but by then a user had already downloaded a copy of it 50 minutes after its creation,

through the Netherlands. The City Attorney’s office did not even download a copy of this folder,

and never even received a link to this folder. Deputy City Attorney Tsai did, however, receive a

link to the correct Dropbox folder named “PRRS01092019.zip” (Tsai Dec., ¶ 8). (True and correct


000023

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



“PRRS01092019_all.zip,” and the IP address look-up for 2a00:1768:1001:21::32a3:201a are

attached hereto as Exhibit “13”).

21. The Dropbox folder named “PRRS01152019_JF.zip” was created based on revised

search terms for PRR No. 19-16 by City IT for attorney review on January 15, 2019. (Supp. Klein

Dec., ¶ 15). It contained 22 PST files named “Deleted Records Any Name 2018,” “Limitations

Any Name 2018_1,” “Limitations Any Name 2018_2,” “Limitations Any Name 2018_3,”

“Limitations Any Name 2018_4,” “Limitations Any Name 2018_5,” “Limitations Any Name

2018_6,” “Oversight Any Name 2018_1,” “Oversight Any Name 2018_2,” “Oversight Any Name

2018_3,” “Oversight Any Name 2018_4,” “Oversight Any Name 2018_5,” “Personnel Files Any

Name 2018,” “Personnel Records Any Name 2018,” “Police Records Any Name 2018,” “Record

Retention Any Name 2018,” “Retention Any Name 2018_1,” “Retention Any Name 2018_2,”

“Retention Any Name 2018_3,” “Retention Any Name 2018_4,” “Retention Any Name 2018_5”

and “Retention Any Name 2018_6,” which together contained over 10,500 emails + attachments.

The folder was downloaded by: (1) a PureVPN user through the Netherlands and Los Angeles on

January 15, 2019; (2) the City Attorney’s office on January, 16, 2019; (3) a TOR user through

Switzerland and Canada on January 16, 2019; (4) a session attributed to Christopher Tennyson the

same day; and (5) a PureVPN user on June 7, 2019. (True and correct excerpts from the City’s

Dropbox activity log reflecting all downloads of the Dropbox folder “PRRS01152019_JF.zip,” and

the IP address look-ups for 95.174.67.59, 144.217.161.119, 185.220.101.33 and 185.230.126.243,

are attached hereto as Exhibit “14”).2 The download attributed to Mr. Tennyson was undoubtedly

performed by Mr. Ferguson, who worked with Mr. Tennyson and also had access to the Fullerton

Cameras computer, and as established in my prior declaration, the PureVPN and TOR downloads

can almost certainly be attributed to Mr. Ferguson and Mr. Curlee. (See Tennyson Dec.; Marni

Rice Dec.; Michael J. Rice Dec.). These downloads occurred even though the City never produced

documents in response to Mr. Ferguson’s PRR No. 19-19. (See Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 15).

2 The 95.174.67.59 IP address is registered to M247 Ltd Amsterdam, and 185.230.126.243 is registered to M247 Ltd LosAngeles. Both are associated with PureVPN. See https://whois.ipip net/AS9009. The IP address 185.220.101.33 is a TOR exitnode in the Netherlands. The IP address 144.217.161.119 is a former TOR exit node in Canada. The 141.101.146.87 IP addressis associated with PureVPN. (See Strebe Dec., Exh. E; See also Exh. 14 herein).

000024

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



22. The Dropbox folder named “PRRS02042019_VD_2” was created by City IT for

attorney review on February 4, 2019. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 16). It contained 1 PST file named

“PRRS02042019_VD_2,” which contained nearly 40 emails + attachments. The same day it was

created, a TOR user downloaded it through Germany.3 The City Attorney’s office downloaded the

folder on February 12, 2019 and February 13, 2019. (True and correct excerpts from the City’s

Dropbox activity log reflecting all downloads of the Dropbox folder “PRRS02042019_VD_2,” and

the IP address look-up for 87.118.92.43, are attached hereto as Exhibit “15”). The February 4,

2019 TOR download occurred even though the City never produced documents in response to the

corresponding PRR No. 19-48. Based on my review of the City’s Dropbox activity log and Ms.

Klein’s supplemental declaration, it is apparent that Mr. Curlee downloaded this Dropbox folder

without being given a direct link to it, before the City provided its final response to Ms. Duarte’s

corresponding PRR No. 19-48. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 16 & Exh. T).

23. The Dropbox folder named “PRRS02042019_VD” was created by City IT for

attorney review on February 4, 2019. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 17). It contained 1 PST file named

“PRRS02042019_VD,” which contained over 350 emails + attachments. The same day the folder

was created, it was downloaded by a TOR user through Germany.4 It was thereafter downloaded

by the City Attorney’s office on February 5, 2019 and February 13, 2019. (True and correct


“PRRS02042019_VD” are attached hereto as Exhibit “16”). The February 4, 2019 TOR download

occurred even though the City never produced documents in response to the corresponding PRR

No. 19-52. Based on my review of the City’s Dropbox activity log and Ms. Klein’s supplemental

declaration, it is apparent that Mr. Curlee downloaded this Dropbox folder without being given a

direct link to it, before the City provided its final response to Ms. Duarte’s corresponding PRR No.

19-52. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 17 & Exh. U).

24. The Dropbox folder named “[email protected]”

was created by City IT for attorney review on March 26, 2019. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 18). It

3 The IP address 87.118.92.43 is a TOR exit node in Germany. (See Exh. 15 herein).4 The IP address 87.118.92.43 is a TOR exit node in Germany. (See Exh. 15 herein).

000025

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



contained 1 PST file named “[email protected],” which contained over

500 emails + attachments. The day after it was created, the folder was downloaded by a PureVPN

user through Puerto Rico and a TOR user through North Carolina. On April 3, 2019, the folder

was downloaded by the City Attorney’s office. The TOR download occurred almost 1 month

before the City produced non-privileged documents to Mr. Ferguson in response to his

corresponding PRR No. 19-134. (True and correct excerpts from the City’s Dropbox activity log

reflecting all downloads of the Dropbox folder “[email protected]”

are attached hereto as Exhibit “17”). Based on my review of the City’s Dropbox activity log and

Ms. Klein’s supplemental declaration, it is apparent that Mr. Curlee downloaded this Dropbox

folder without being given a direct link to it, before the City provided its final response to Ms.

Duarte’s corresponding PRR No. 19-134. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 18 & Exh. V).

25. The Dropbox folder named “PR19-171VD_1_2.zip” was created by City IT for

attorney review on April 15, 2019. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 19). It contained 2 PST files named

“PR19-171VD_1” and “PR19-171VD_2,” which together contained nearly 500 emails +

attachments. The folder was downloaded by a TOR user and a PureVPN user the day after it was

created. It was thereafter downloaded by the City Attorney’s office and a City employee on April

23, 2019. The TOR and PureVPN downloads occurred 9 days before the City produced non-

privileged documents to Ms. Duarte in response to her corresponding PRR No. 19-171. (True and

correct excerpts from the City’s Dropbox activity log reflecting all downloads of the Dropbox

folder “PR19-171VD_1_2.zip” are attached hereto as Exhibit “18”). Based on my review of the


Ferguson and Mr. Curlee downloaded this Dropbox folder without being given a direct link to it,

and before the City provided its final response to Ms. Duarte’s corresponding PRR No. 19-171.

(Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 19 & Exh. W).

26. The Dropbox folder named “PR19-188VD.zip” was created by City IT for attorney

review on May 2, 2019, 6 days after the City had advised Ms. Duarte that the records she requested

were exempted from disclosure. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶ 20). The folder contained 2 PST files named

“PR19-188VD_1” and “PR19-188VD_2,” which together contained over 40 emails + attachments.

000026

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



Even though the City advised Ms. Duarte that the records were exempted from disclosure, a TOR

user downloaded the folder on May 3, 2019, a day after the folder was created. (True and correct


“PR19-188VD.zip,” and the IP address look-up for 5.196.66.162, are attached hereto as Exhibit

“19”). Based on my review of the City’s Dropbox activity log and Ms. Klein’s supplemental

declaration, it is apparent that Mr. Ferguson and Mr. Curlee downloaded this Dropbox folder

without being given a direct link to it, and before the City provided its final response to Ms. Duarte’s

corresponding PRR No. 19-188. (Supp. Klein Dec., ¶20 & Exh. 20).

27. My analysis may change before trial if additional information from any of the

parties-in-suit or their experts becomes available. I, therefore, reserve the right to supplement my

declaration accordingly.

I hereby declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the

foregoing is true and correct. Executed this 1st day of November, 2019, at Carlsbad, California.

Matthew Strebe

000027

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT 1

000028

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Drop

box Activ

ity Log

Excerpts re Po

st 6/6/201

9, 4:10:46

PM Dow

nloads

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2019

‐06‐07

T00:01

:13+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

141.10

1.14

6.87

NO

Oslo

Oslo

Cou

nty

PureVP

N

{"file_ob

j_id": "4cefSjLn5SUAA

AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame": "PR

R_19

‐13

4_data@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD

JjpIeQmcl3cRcT7ct9YvfCn

P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em

ail": "pctech@cityoffullerton

.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537

1, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

R_19

‐13

4_da

ta@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐06‐07

T00:07

:03+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

141.10

1.14

6.87

NO

Oslo

Oslo

Cou

nty

PureVP

N

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR

S011

5201

9_JF.zip", "link_ow

ner_name": "Fullerton

City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537


quests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01

1520

19_JF.zip",

"isdir": false}

2019

‐06‐10

T23:22

:47+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

95.174

.67.59

NL

Amsterdam

North Holland

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame": "19

‐135

Da

tatheh

ourly

struggle.com

", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537


quests/O

utbo

x/19

‐135

Datathe

hourlystruggle.com

", "is

dir": true}

2019

‐06‐13

T16:43

:52+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

216.14

.46.13

0US

Orange

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"Transpo

rtation Ce

nter Stairs", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537


quests/O

utbo

x/Tran

sportatio

n Ce

nter

Stairs", "is

dir": true}

2019

‐06‐14

T07:54

:47+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

65.19.16

7.13

2US

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"Com

mon

wealth

Ave.ra

r", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537


quests/O

utbo

x/Co

mmon

wealth

Ave.ra

r",

"is_dir": false}

000029

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Drop

box Activ

ity Log

Excerpts re Po

st 6/6/201

9, 4:10:46

PM Dow

nloads

2019

‐06‐14

T07:55

:22+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

65.19.16

7.13

2US

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame": "GO 201

8 ‐66

979 HITD

A 48

.pdf", "link_ow


City

Dropb

ox",

"link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537


quests/O

utbo

x/NAR

COTICS/G

O 201

8‐66

979 HITDA 48

.pd f", "is

dir": false}

2019

‐06‐14

T07:55

:55+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

65.19.16

7.13

2US

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"Transpo

rtation Ce

nter Stairs", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537


quests/O

utbo

x/Tran

sportatio

n Ce

nter

Stairs", "is_

dir": true}

2019

‐06‐14

T07:56

:16+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

65.19.16

7.13

2US

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame": "Airport

Database", "link_ow


City

Dropb

ox",

"link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537


quests/O

utbo

x/Airport D

atab

ase",

"is_dir": true}

2019

‐06‐14

T07:56

:32+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

65.19.16

7.13

2US

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"Dow

ntow

n Parking Managem

ent", "link_ow


City Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537


quests/O

utbo

x/Dow

ntow

n Pa

rking

Man

agem

ent", "is_

dir": true}

2019

‐06‐14

T07:57

:00+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

65.19.16

7.13

2US

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame": "Po

lice",

"link_ow


City

Dropb

ox",

"link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537


quests/O

utbo

x /Po

lice", "is

dir": true}

2019

‐06‐14

T07:57

:36+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

65.19.16

7.13

2US

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame": "19

‐135

Da

tatheh

ourly

struggle.com

", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537


quests/O

utbo

x/19

‐135

Datathe

hourlystruggle.com

", "is_

dir": true}

000030

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT 2

000031

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re: Dow

nloa

ds of "AC

USA

_PRR

.zip"

1 of 5

Time

Even

t catego

ryEven

t typ

eIP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2017

‐12‐15

T02:40

:01+00

:00

Files

Adde

d files

74.62.24

4.89

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Dropb

oxpctech@cityoffullerton

.co

m

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "is_

dir":

false

, "file_id": "4cefSjLn5SUAA

AAAA

AAIPQ", "ho

st_id":

4698

2204

38}

2017

‐12‐18

T17:12

:37+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

tester@traken

g.com

tester@traken

g.com

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

PRR.zip", "is

dir": false}

2017

‐12‐19

T22:29

:41+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/fol der from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.19

6.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

PRR.zip", "is

dir": false}

2017

‐12‐26

T03:45

:22+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2602

:306

:3b3

1:e290

:44

ee:412

9:9a87

:7d4

5US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

_PRR

.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2017

‐12‐26

T04:14

:42+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2602

:306

:3b3

1:e290

:44

ee:412

9:9a87

:7d4

5US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob

j_id": "4

cefSjLn5

SUAA

AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

_PRR

.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2017

‐12‐26

T04:16

:37+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2602

:306

:3b3

1:e290

:44

ee:412

9:9a87

:7d4

5US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

PRR.zip", "is

dir": false}

2017

‐12‐27

T23:44

:38+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2600

:170

0:d5

60:695

0:d

5cf:9

09f:ca04:a132

US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

PRR.zip", "is

dir": false}

000032

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re: Dow

nloa

ds of "AC

USA

_PRR

.zip"

2 of 5

Time

Even

t catego

ryEven

t typ

eIP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2017

‐12‐28

T01:23

:05+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2600

:170

0:d5

60:695

0:d

5cf:9

09f:ca04:a132

US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob

j_id": "4

cefSjLn5

SUAA

AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

PRR.zip", "is

dir": false}

2017

‐12‐28

T06:15

:17+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2605

:e00

0:87

d1:320

0:c

0d5:44

49:9dd

1:84

98US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

PRR.zip", "is

dir": false}

2017

‐12‐28

T19:26

:21+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2605

:e00

0:87

d1:320

0:8

dc9:e5b:b1

50:a82

bUS

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

PRR.zip", "is

dir": false}

2017

‐12‐28

T20:41

:00+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

172.94

.70.88

NO

Oslo

Oslo

Cou

nty

joshua@joshuaferguson

.com


.com

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fuller ton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

_PRR

.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2017

‐12‐29

T03:59

:45+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2605

:e00

0:87

d1:320

0:1

5c8:72

3:e88:9b

6eUS

Fullerton

California


.com


.com

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "is_

dir": false}

2017

‐12‐29

T04:19

:07+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2605

:e00

0:87

d1:320

0:1

5c8:72

3:e88:9b

6eUS

Fullerton

California


.com


.com

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

PRR.zip", "is

dir": false}

2017

‐12‐29

T18:40

:09+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2600

:170

0:d5

60:695

0:f4

66:178

7:68

73:dc69

US

Fullerton

California

info@fullerton

cameras

.com

info@fullerton

cameras

.com

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PR R

zip", "link_o w

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

PRR.zip", "is

dir": false}

000033

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re: Dow

nloa

ds of "AC

USA

_PRR

.zip"

3 of 5

Time

Even

t catego

ryEven

t typ

eIP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2017

‐12‐29

T18:58

:02+00

:00

Sharing

Adde

d a file/folder

to th

eir D

ropb

ox

from

a link

(non

‐team

mem

ber)

2600

:170

0:d5

60:695

0:f4

66:178

7:68

73:dc69

US

Fullerton

California

info@fullerton

cameras

.com

info@fullerton

cameras

.com

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

PRR.zip", "is

dir": false}

2017

‐12‐29

T19:17

:36+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2600

:170

0:d5

60:695

0:f4

66:178

7:68

73:dc69

US

Fullerton

California

info@fullerton

cameras

.com

info@fullerton

cameras

.com

{"file_ob

j_id": "4

cefSjLn5

SUAA

AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

PRR.zip", "is

dir": false}

2017

‐12‐30

T19:42

:24+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

172.94

.70.32

NO

Oslo

Oslo

Cou

nty


.com


.com

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

PRR.zip", "is

dir ": false}

2017

‐12‐30

T20:59

:24+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

141.10

1.14

6.24

3NO

Oslo

Oslo

Cou

nty


.com


.com

{file_ob

j_id

: 4cefSjLn5SUAA

AAAA

AAAC

Q,

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

PRR.zip", "is

dir": false}

2018

‐01‐01

T22:13

:00+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

65.19.16

7.13

1Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

_PRR

.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐01‐01

T22:13

:22+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

65.19.16

7.13

1Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

_PRR

.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐01‐01

T22:13

:47+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

65.19.16

7.13

1Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

PRR.zip", "is

dir": false}

000034

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re: Dow

nloa

ds of "AC

USA

_PRR

.zip"

4 of 5

Time

Even

t catego

ryEven

t typ

eIP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2018

‐01‐01

T22:13

:51+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

65.19.16

7.13

1Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

_PRR

.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐01‐01

T22:25

:34+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

185.38

.14.21

5NL

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_o w

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

PRR.zip", "is

dir": false}

2018

‐01‐01

T22:25

:49+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

185.38

.14.21

5NL

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

PRR.zip", "is

dir": false}

2018

‐01‐01

T22:30

:03+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

37.220

.35.20

2NL

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

_PRR

.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐01‐01

T22:42

:32+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

99.179

.28.16

4US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

_PRR

. zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐01‐02

T00:22

:41+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

99.179

.28.16

4US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

_PRR

.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐01‐04

T22:29

:37+00

:00

Sharing

Ope

ned a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

{file_ob

j_id

: 4cefSjLn5SUAA

AAAA

AAAC

Q,

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

PRR.zip", "is

dir": false}

000035

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re: Dow

nloa

ds of "AC

USA

_PRR

.zip"

5 of 5

Time

Even

t catego

ryEven

t typ

eIP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2018

‐01‐04

T22:29

:45+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "AC

USA

_PRR

zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/AC

USA

PRR.zip", "is

dir": false}

2018

‐03‐06

T22:45

:21+00

:00

Files

Deleted files

74.62.24

4.89

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Dropb


.co

m

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/AC

USA

_PRR

.zip", "is_

dir":

false


AAAA

AAIPQ", "ho

st_id":

4698

2204

38}

000036

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

9/20/2019 IP - 185.38.14.215 IP is in Netherlands | Myip.ms

https://myip.ms/info/whois/185.38.14.215 1/4

20 September 2019, 12:17:17Whois IP Live Results for 185.38.14.215 -

IP Address: 185.38.14.215

IP Location: Netherlands

IP Reverse DNS (Host): 185.38.14.215

IP Owner: Yisp B.v

Owner IP Range: 185.38.12.0 - 185.38.15.255 (1,024 ip)

Owner Address: Byronstraat 44, 3533 Vz, Utrecht, Netherlands

Owner Country: Netherlands

Owner Phone: +31852737135

Owner Website: www.serververhuur.com

Owner CIDR: 185.38.12.0/22

Whois Record Created: 03 Jun 2014

Reverse IP Lookup / Information on IP (185.38.14.215) -

IP Blacklist Check: Submit IPv4/v6 to Blacklist

Not Listed in Blacklist

Websites on this IP Now: No websites All websites in this IP Range »

Websites on this IP Before: No websites

Not Working Websites on IP: No websites

Nameservers on this IP: No nameservers

Web Browser/s on this IP:Android Android Webkit 4 BlackBerry 9860 BlackBerry 9900 Camino 0.7

Chrome 19 Chromium 55 Dillo 2 Firefox 10 Firefox 17 … … [see all]

OS on this IP:Android Android 2.3 Android 2.3.4 Android 5.0 Android 5.1 Android

6.0.1 Android 7.0 … … [see all]

Browser Agent/s on this IP:

Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.1; rv:38.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/38.0Opera/9.80 (Windows NT 6.2; Win64; x64) Presto/2.12 Version/12.16

... ... ... Found: 182 different web browsers ... ... more »

ASN: AS58073

Whois Original Data on IP 185.38.14.215 - [hide/show]

Information from whois://whois.ripe.net:43

000037

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.



% Information related to '185.38.12.0 - 185.38.15.255'

inetnum: 185.38.12.0 - 185.38.15.255

netname: NL-YISP-20131017

country: NL

org: ORG-RAta1-RIPE

admin-c: RA4892-RIPE

tech-c: RA4892-RIPE

status: ALLOCATED PA

mnt-by: RIPE-NCC-HM-MNT

mnt-by: RA92286-MNT

mnt-domains: RA92286-MNT

mnt-routes: RA92286-MNT

created: 2013-10-17T12:33:48Z

last-modified: 2019-05-14T15:21:51Z

source: RIPE # Filtered

organisation: ORG-RAta1-RIPE

org-name: YISP B.V

org-type: LIR

address: Byronstraat 44

address: 3533VZ

address: Utrecht

address: NETHERLANDS

mnt-ref: RA92286-MNT

mnt-ref: RIPE-NCC-HM-MNT


mnt-by: RA92286-MNT

abuse-c: AR13317-RIPE

created: 2010-11-23T10:22:22Z



phone: +31852737135

fax-no: +31852737135

person: Rens Ariens

address: Europalaan 20

address: 3526 KS Utrecht

phone: +31852737135

nic-hdl: RA4892-RIPE

mnt-by: RA92286-MNT

000038

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.



View All Records »Total: 357 records (show first 10 records only)

Total: 1 record

created: 2010-11-23T10:40:54Z



% Information related to '185.38.12.0/22AS58073'

route: 185.38.12.0/22

descr: YISP

origin: AS58073

mnt-by: RA92286-MNT

created: 2014-06-03T08:40:12Z


source: RIPE

Friday 20 September 2019, 12:17:17

Known User Web Browsers on IP - 185.38.14.215

No IP Address Country OS on this IP Web Browser on this IP CrawleBot Latest Site Visit Date

1 185.38.14.215 Netherlands Windows 7 x64 Edition Firefox 40.1 10 Apr 2018, 13:10

2 185.38.14.215 Netherlands Windows 7 Firefox 52 09 Apr 2018, 20:35

3 185.38.14.215 Netherlands HTC Desire Android Webkit 4 06 Apr 2018, 14:54

4 185.38.14.215 Netherlands LG Android Webkit 4 06 Apr 2018, 11:58

5 185.38.14.215 Netherlands HTC Pyramid Android Webkit 4 06 Apr 2018, 08:31

6 185.38.14.215 Netherlands Android 2.3 Android 06 Apr 2018, 04:58

7 185.38.14.215 Netherlands BlackBerry BlackBerry 9860 05 Apr 2018, 19:35

8 185.38.14.215 Netherlands BlackBerry BlackBerry 9900 05 Apr 2018, 17:31

9 185.38.14.215 Netherlands HTC Sensation Android Webkit 4 05 Apr 2018, 17:31

10 185.38.14.215 Netherlands HTC Desire Android Webkit 4 05 Apr 2018, 17:24

Websites IP Address Change History for IP - 185.38.14.215tor

No Website Old IP Address was Host was Date when site wasusing this IP

World SitePopular Rating

was

1 185.38.14.215 tor-exit.r1.apx.pubtor 19 Mar 2018 # 6,778,192

«« 185.38.11.240 - Prev IP Range « 185.38.14.214 185.38.14.215 185.38.14.216 » Next IP Range - 185.38.16.0 »»

Quick access to this page: https://myip.ms/185.38.14.215

000039

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000040

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT 3

000041

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Drop

box Activity

Log

Excerpts re: Dow

nloads of "CE

_PRR

_KC.zip

"1 of 3

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

Adde

d files

74.62.244.89

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box

pctech@cityoffullerton

.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/CE

_PRR

_KC.zip", "is_

dir":

false


AAAA

AAJnQ", "ho

st_id":

4698220438}

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

85.90.244.23

DEFrankfurt

am M

ain

Hesse

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"CE_PR

R_KC

.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/CE

_PRR

_KC.zip", "is_

dir": false}

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

85.90.244.23

DEFrankfurt

am M

ain

Hesse

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"CE_PR

R_KC

.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/CE

PRR

KC.zip", "is

dir": false}

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

85.90.244.23

DEFrankfurt

am M

ain

Hesse

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"CE_PR

R_KC

.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/CE

_PRR

_KC.zip", "is_

dir": false}

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

85.90.244.23

DEFrankfurt

am M

ain

Hesse

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"CE_PR

R_KC

.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/CE

_PRR

_KC.zip", "is_

dir": false}

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

85.90.244.23

DEFrankfurt

am M

ain

Hesse

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"CE_PR

R_KC

.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/CE

PRR

KC.zip", "is

dir": false}

000042

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Drop

box Activity

Log

Excerpts re: Dow

nloads of "CE

_PRR

_KC.zip

"2 of 3

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

85.90.244.23

DEFrankfurt

am M

ain

Hesse

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"CE_PR

R_KC

.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/CE

_PRR

_KC.zip", "is_

dir": false}

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

85.90.244.23

DEFrankfurt

am M

ain

Hesse

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"CE_PR

R_KC

.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/CE

_PRR

_KC.zip", "is_

dir": false}

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2001:67c:289c::25

SEUnkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"CE_PR

R_KC

.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/CE

_PRR

_KC.zip", "is_

dir": false}

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

51.15.86.162

NL

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"CE_PR

R_KC

.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/CE

_PRR

_KC.zip", "is_

dir": false}

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

163.172.67.180

FRUnkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"CE_PR

R_KC

.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/CE

_PRR

_KC.zip", "is_

dir": false}

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

171.25.193.235

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"CE_PR

R_KC

.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/CE

_PRR

_KC.zip", "is_

dir": false}

000043

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Drop

box Activity

Log

Excerpts re: Dow

nloads of "CE

_PRR

_KC.zip

"3 of 3

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

128.31.0.13

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"CE_PR

R_KC

.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/CE

_PRR

_KC.zip", "is_

dir": false}

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.196.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"CE_PR

R_KC

.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/CE

_PRR

_KC.zip", "is_

dir": false}

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

185.50.191.250

CHUnkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"CE_PR

R_KC

.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/CE

_PRR

_KC.zip", "is_

dir": false}

Deleted files

74.62.244.89

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/CE

_PRR

_KC.zip", "is_

dir":

false


AAAA

AAJnQ", "ho

st_id":

4698220438}

000044

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000045

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000046

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000047

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000048

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000049

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT 4A

000050

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re: Dow

nloa

ds of “coun

cil_20

1804

30.zip”

1 of 2

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2018

‐05‐01

T19:22:17+00:00

Files

Adde

d files

74.62.244.89

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/coun

cil_20180430.zip",

"is_dir": false, "file_id": "4cefSjLn5SUAA

AAAA

AAJ4w",

"host_id": 4698220438}

2018

‐05‐01

T21:58:03+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

185.50.191.250

CHUnkno

wn

Unkno

wn

TOR

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"cou

ncil_20180430.zip", "link_ow


City Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/coun

cil_20180430.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐05‐07

T23:30:39+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.196.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"cou



City Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/coun

cil_20180430.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐05‐08

T15:44:51+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"cou



City Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/coun

cil_20180430.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐05‐09

T16:32:22+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"cou



City Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/coun

cil_20180430.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐05‐09

T16:32:40+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"cou



City Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/coun

cil_20180430.zip", "is_

dir": false}

000051

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re: Dow

nloa

ds of “coun

cil_20

1804

30.zip”

2 of 2

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2018

‐05‐09

T18:09:43+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"cou



City Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/coun

cil_20180430.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐05‐09

T18:16:30+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"cou



City Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/coun

cil20180430.zip", "is

dir": false}

2018

‐05‐09

T18:17:38+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"cou



City Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/coun

cil20180430.zip", "is

dir": false}

2018

‐05‐15

T15:30:14+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"cou



City Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/coun

cil_20180430.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐07‐22

T21:42:35+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2605:e000:87ca:

6d00:2d2

0:8ad6

:2fca:f4

44US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"cou



City Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/coun

cil_20180430.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐08‐23

T18:05:20+00:00

Files

Deleted files

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/coun

cil_20180430.zip",


AAAA

AAJ4w",

"hostid": 42914893232}

000052

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT 4B

000053

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re Bryant M

oy Dow

nloa

ds Activity

1 of 1

Time

Even

t catego

ryEven

t typ

eIP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2018

‐06‐27

T17:43

:34+00

:00

Files

Adde

d files

74.62.24

4.89

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Dropb


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/Moy

respon

sive emails",

"is_dir": true, "file_id": "4cefSjLn5SUAA

AAAA

AALCA",

"host_id": 469

8220

438}

2018

‐06‐27

T18:30

:28+00

:00

Sharing

Ope

ned a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

24.207

.140

.97

US

St Lou

isMiss

ouri

bryant.m

oy@gm

ail.com

bryant.m

oy@gm

ail.com

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"Outbo

x", "link_ow


City

Dropb

ox",

"link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153


quests/O

utbo

x",

"is_dir": true}

2018

‐06‐27

T18:30

:35+00

:00

Sharing

Ope

ned a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

24.207

.140

.97

US

St Lou

isMiss

ouri

bryant.m

oy@gm

ail.com

bryant.m

oy@gm

ail.com

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"530

04 W

ater Quality", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/53

004 Water Qua

lity", "is

dir": true}

2018

‐06‐27

T18:31

:06+00

:00

Sharing

Ope

ned a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

24.207

.140

.97

US

St Lou

isMiss

ouri

bryant.m

oy@gm

ail.com

bryant.m

oy@gm

ail.com

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"Moy

respon

sive em

ails"

, "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/Moy

respon

sive emails", "is_

dir": true}

2018

‐06‐27

T18:31

:27+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

24.207

.140

.97

US

St Lou

isMiss

ouri

bryant.m

oy@gm

ail.com

bryant.m

oy@gm

ail.com

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"Moy

respon

sive em

ails"

, "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/Moy

respon

sive emails", "is_

dir": true}

2018

‐06‐27

T18:31

:34+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folde r from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

24.207

.140

.97

US

St Lou

isMiss

ouri

bryant.m

oy@gm

ail.com

bryant.m

oy@gm

ail.com

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"Moy

respon

sive em

ails"

, "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/Moy

respon

sive emails", "is

dir": true}

2018

‐07‐18

T23:04

:4Files

Deleted files

74.62.24

4.89

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Dropb


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/moy

respon

sive

emails/#W

eRise

Stronger, D

ocu‐Shred \u00

26 e‐W

aste

Even

t.pdf", "is_

dir": false, "file_id":

"4cefSjLn5

SUAA

AAAA

AALEA", "ho

stid": 469

8220

438}

000054

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT 5

000055

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re Dow

nloa

ds of "PR

R_AIR2

0180

604.zip"

1 of 1

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2018

‐06‐04

T21:48

:38+00

:00

Files

Adde

d files

74.62.24

4.89

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/PR

R_AIR2

0180

604.zip",


AAAA

AAKgg",

"host_id": 469

8220

438}

2018

‐06‐04

T21:55

:43+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.19

6.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PR

R_AIR2

0180

604.zip

",

"link_ow


City

Dropb

ox",

"link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

R_AIR2

0180

604.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐06‐06

T21:44

:24+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2c0f:f9

30:0:3::2

21LR

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PR

R_AIR2

0180

604.zip

",

"link_ow


City

Dropb

ox",

"link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

R_AIR2

0180

604.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐07‐16

T21:30

:39+00

:00

Files

Deleted files

74.62.24

4.89

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/PR

R_AIR2

0180

604.zip",


AAAA

AAKgg",

"host_id": 469

8220

438}

000056

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000057

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT 6

000058

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re Dow

nloa

ds of "HL_PR

R"1 of 1

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2018

‐07‐25

T20:24

:09+00

:00

Files

Adde

d files

74.62.24

4.89

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/HL_PR

R.zip", "is_

dir":

false


AAAA

AAT3A", "ho

st_id":

4698

2204

38}

2018

‐07‐25

T20:33

:24+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.19

6.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "HL

_PRR

.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/HLPR

R.zip", "is

dir": false}

2018

‐07‐26

T23:40

:53+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

89.31.57

.5Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "HL

_PRR

.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/HLPR

R.zip", "is

dir": false}

2018

‐07‐27

T06:44

:12+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

99.179

.28.16

4US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "HL

_PRR

.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/HLPR

R.zip", "is

dir": false}

2018

‐08‐23

T18:05

:20+00

:00

Files

Deleted files

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/HL_PR

R.zip", "is_

dir":

false


AAAA

AAT3A", "ho

st_id":

4291

4893

232}

000059

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000060

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000061

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT 7

000062

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re Dow

nloa

ds of “PR

R_JF_201

8100

2.zip”

1 of 1

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2018

‐10‐02

T17:27

:36+00

:00

Files

Adde

d files

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/PR

R_JF_201

8100

2.zip",


AAAA

AAUiw",

"host_id": 429

1489

3232}

2018

‐10‐02

T21:09

:59+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

185.2.29

.205

NL

Amsterdam

North

Holland

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PR

R_JF_201

8100

2.zip

",

"link_ow


City

Dropb

ox",

"link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

2018

‐10‐02

T21:19

:38+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

195.20

1.21

.137

DEBe

rlin

Land

Be

rlin

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PR

R_JF_201

8100

2.zip

",

"link_ow


City

Dropb

ox",

"link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x /PR

R_JF_201

8100

2.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐10‐03

T01:12

:30+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.19

6.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PR

R_JF_201

8100

2.zip

",

"link_ow


City

Dropb

ox",

"link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x /PR

R_JF_201

8100

2.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐01‐04

T00:52

:28+00

:00

Files

Deleted files

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/PR

R_JF_201

8100

2.zip",


AAAA

AAUiw",

"host_id": 472

0125

4512}

000063

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT 8

000064

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re Dow

nloa

ds of “JF_P

RR20

1810

12.zip”

1 of 2

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2018

‐10‐12

T19:00

:51+00

:00

Files

Adde

d files

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/JF_P

RR20

1810

12.zip",


AAAA

AAYYg",

"host_id": 429

1489

3232

}

2018

‐10‐12

T19:10

:39+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.19

6.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "JF_P

RR20

1810

12.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/JF_P

RR20

1810

12.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐10‐13

T02:22

:04+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

188.72

.80.10

3NL

Amsterdam

North

Holland

{ "file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "JF_P

RR20

1810

12.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/JF

PRR2

0181

012.zip", "is

dir": false}

2018

‐10‐13

T06:53

:36+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2c0f:f9

30:0:3::2

21LR

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "JF_P

RR20

1810

12.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/JF_P

RR20

1810

12.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐10‐13

T06:55

:42+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2c0f:f9

30:0:3::2

21LR

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "JF_P

RR20

1810

12.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/JF

PRR2

0181

012.zip", "is

dir": false}

2018

‐10‐13

T16:35

:49+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

162.24

7.74

.201

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "JF_P

RR20

1810

12.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/JF

PRR2

0181

012.zip", "is

dir": false}

000065

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re Dow

nloa

ds of “JF_P

RR20

1810

12.zip”

2 of 2

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2018

‐10‐13

T17:04

:19+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

206.12

3.14

7.12

NL

Amsterdam

North

Holland

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "JF_P

RR20

1810

12.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/JF_P

RR20

1810

12.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐10‐14

T02:11

:41+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

163.17

2.67

.180

FRUnkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "JF_P

RR20

1810

12.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/JF

PRR2

0181

012.zip", "is

dir": false}

2018

‐10‐14

T02:11

:50+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

163.17

2.67

.180

FRUnkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "JF_P

RR20

1810

12.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/JF

PRR2

0181

012.zip", "is

dir": false}

2018

‐10‐14

T02:13

:38+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

176.10

.99.20

0CH

Hune

nberg

Zug

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "JF_P

RR20

1810

12.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/JF_P

RR20

1810

12.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐01‐04

T00:52

:36+00

:00

Files

Deleted files

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/JF_P

RR20

1810

12.zip",


AAAA

AAYYg",

"host_id": 472

0125

4512

}

000066

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000067

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT 9

000068

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re Dow

nloa

ds of “JF_P

RR_2.zip”

1 of 1

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2018

‐10‐30

T20:18

:39+00

:00

Files

Adde

d files

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/JF_P

RR_2.zip", "is_

dir":

false


AAAA

AAbxg", "ho

st_id":

4291

4893

232 }

2018

‐10‐30

T20:33

:55+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.19

6.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "JF_P

RR_2.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x /JF_P

RR_2.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐10‐30

T21:32

:56+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2a00

:129

8:80

11:

212::165

SKUnkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "JF_P

RR_2.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x /JF_P

RR_2.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐10‐30

T21:36

:10+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

81.17.27

.138

CHUnkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "JF_P

RR_2.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x /JF_P

RR_2.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐01‐04

T00:52

:36+00

:00

Files

Deleted files

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/JF_P

RR_2.zip", "is_

dir":

false


AAAA

AAbxg", "ho

st_id":

4720

1254

512 }

000069

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000070

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT 10000071

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re Dow

nloa

ds of “PP

R_Co

x”

1 of 1

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2018

‐11‐06

T17:56:41+00:00

Files

Adde

d files

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box

pctech@cityoffullert

on.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/PP

R_Co

x.zip", "is_

dir":

false


AAAA

AAbzQ", "ho

st_id":

42914893232}

2018

‐11‐06

T19:07:01+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PP

R_Co

x.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PP

R_Co

x.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐11‐06

T 20:59:08+00:00

Sha ring

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

176.10.104.240

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PP

R_Co

x.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PP

RCo

x.zip", "is

dir": false}

2018

‐11‐06

T21:20:52+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.196.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PP

R_Co

x.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8 npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PP

R_Co

x.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2018

‐11‐06

T21:44:50+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

188.72.82.73

NL

Amsterdam

North

Holland

joshua@theh

ourly

struggle.com

joshua@theh

ourly

struggle.com

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PP

R_Co

x.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PP

R_Co

x.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐01‐04

T 00:52:36+00:00

Files

Deleted files

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box

pctech@cityoffullert

on.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/PP

R_Co

x.zip", "is_

dir":

false


AAAA

AAbzQ", "ho

st_id":

47201254512}

000072

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT 11000073

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re Dow

nloa

ds of "PR

RS01

0820

19.zip”

1 of 2

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2019

‐01‐09

T01:07:56+00:00

Files

Adde

d files

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/PR

RS01082019.zip",


AAAA

AAcyg",

"host_id": 47201254512}

2019

‐01‐09

T04:32:47+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

85.202.163.127

BEBruges

Flande

rs

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PR

RS01082019.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01082019.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐01‐09

T16:26:56+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

City of Fullerton

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PR


ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01082019.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐01‐09

T18:55:54+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

95.174.67.59

NL

Amsterdam

North

Holland

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PR


ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01082019.zip", "is

dir": false}

2019

‐01‐09

T22:13:30+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.196.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PR


ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01082019.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐01‐09

T22:24:37+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.196.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PR


ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01082019.zip", "is_

dir": false}

000074

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re Dow

nloa

ds of "PR

RS01

0820

19.zip”

2 of 2

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2019

‐01‐10

T06:18:02+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

99.40.197.210

US

Costa Mesa

California

mattdeitz@msn

.com

[email protected]

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PR


ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01082019.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐01‐10

T19:02:55+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2a03:e600:100::1

5AT

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PR


ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01082019.zip", "is

dir": false}

2019

‐01‐10

T20:58:24+00:00

Files

Deleted files

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/PR

RS01082019.zip",


AAAA

AAcyg",

"hostid": 47201254512}

2019

‐01‐10

T21:04:48+00:00

Files

Adde

d files

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/PR

RS01082019.zip",


AAAA

AAczw",

"host_id": 47201254512}

2019

‐01‐10

T23:00:32+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.196.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PR


ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01082019.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐01‐15

T01:39:46+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

95.174.67.59

NL

Amsterdam

North

Holland

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PR


ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152515371, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01082019.zip", "is

dir": false}

000075

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000076

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT 12000077

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re Dow

nloa

ds of "PR

RS01

0920

19.zip”

1 of 1

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2019

‐01‐10

T20:58

:41+00

:00

Files

Adde

d files

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/PR

RS01

0920

19.zip",


AAAA

AAczg",

"host_id": 472

0125

4512}

2019

‐01‐10

T21:20

:23+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2620

:7:600

1::ffff:

c759

:e65

7US

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PR

RS01

0920

19.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x /PR

RS01

0920

19.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐01‐10

T21:51

:36+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.19

6.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PR

RS01

0920

19.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x /PR

RS01

0920

19.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐01‐10

T21:52

:12+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.19

6.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PR

RS01

0920

19.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x /PR

RS01

0920

19.zip", "is

dir": false}

2019

‐01‐15

T01:39

:22+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

95.174

.67.59

NL

Amsterdam

North

Holland

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q",

"base_name": "PR

RS01

0920

19.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x /PR

RS01

0920

19.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐06‐10

T16:25

:42+00

:00

Files

Deleted files

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01

0920

19.zip",


AAAA

AAczg",

"hostid": 540

2143

1056}

000078

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT 13000079

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re Dow

nloa

ds of "PR

RS01

0920

19_all.zip”

1 of 1

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2019

‐01‐10

T19:08

:03+00

:00

Files

Adde

d files

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/PR

RS01

0920

19_all.zip", "is_

dir":

false


AAAA

AAczQ", "ho

st_id":

4720

1254

512}

2019

‐01‐10

T20:57

:55+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2a00

:176

8:10

01:

21::3

2a3:20

1aNL

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR

S010

9201

9_all.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x /PR

RS01

0920

19all.zip", "is

dir": false}

2019

‐01‐10

T20:58

:10+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a

link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2a00

:176

8:10

01:

21::3

2a3:20

1aNL

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR

S010

9201

9_all.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x /PR

RS01

0920

19_all.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐01‐10

T20:58

:28+00

:00

Files

Deleted files

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/PR

RS01

0920

19_all.zip", "is_

dir":

false


AAAA

AAczQ", "ho

st_id":

4720

1254

512}

000080

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000081

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT 14000082

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re: D

ownloa

ds of "PR

RS01

1520

19_JF.zip"

1 of 2

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2019

‐01‐15

T22:48:03+00:00

Files

Adde

d files

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/PR

RS01152019_JF.zip", "is_

dir": false,

"file_id": "4cefSjLn5SUAA

AAAA

AAc0g", "ho

st_id": 47201254512}

2019

‐01‐15

T22:56:48+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

95.174.67.59

NL

Amsterdam

North

Holland

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR

S01152019_JF.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/P R

RS01152019_JF.zip",

"isdir": false}

2019

‐01‐15

T22:56:51+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

95.174.67.59

NL

Amsterdam

North

Holland

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR



City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01152019_JF.zip",

"is_dir": false}

2019

‐01‐15

T23:04:34+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

95.174.67.59

NL

Amsterdam

North

Holland

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "bas e_n

ame":

"PRR



City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01152019_JF.zip",

"is_dir": false}

2019

‐01‐15

T23:04:47+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

95.174.67.59

NL

Amsterdam

North

Holland

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR



City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01152019_JF.zip",

"isdir": false}

2019

‐01‐15

T23:04:58+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

95.174.67.59

NL

Amsterdam

North

Holland

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR



City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01152019_JF.zip",

"isdir": false}

2019

‐01‐15

T23:05:02+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

95.174.67.59

NL

Amsterdam

North

Holland

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR


ner_name": "F ullerton

City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01152019_JF.zip",

"is_dir": false}

000083

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re: D

ownloa

ds of "PR

RS01

1520

19_JF.zip"

2 of 2

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2019

‐01‐15

T23:06:13+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

185.230.126.243

US

Los A

ngeles

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR



City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01152019_JF.zip",

"is_dir": false}

2019

‐01‐16

T02:12:39+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.196.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR



City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/P R

RS01152019_JF.zip",

"isdir": false}

2019

‐01‐16

T20:10:19+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

185.220.101.33

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR



City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01152019_JF.zip",

"is_dir": false}

2019

‐01‐16

T22:25:11+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

144.217.161.119

CABe

auharnois

Que

bec

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR



City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01152019_JF.zip",

"is_dir": false}

2019

‐01‐16

T23:34:23+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2600:1700:d5

60:

6950:ac52:35e9:

ad62:9ec3

US

Fullerton

California

christenn

yson

@gm

ail.com

christenn

yson

@gm

ail

.com

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR



City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/P R

RS01152019_JF.zip",

"isdir": false}

2019

‐06‐07

T00:07:03+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

141.101.146.87

NO

Oslo

Oslo

Cou

nty

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR



City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01152019_JF.zip",

"is_dir": false}

2019

‐06‐10

T16:25:42+00:00

Files

Deleted files

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS01152019_JF.zip", "is_

dir":

false


AAAA

AAc0g", "ho

st_id":

54021431056}

000084

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

10/31/2019 95.174.67.59, M247 Ltd Amsterdam Netherlands - Whois


31 October 2019, 20:43:39Whois IP Live Results for 95.174.67.59 -

IP Address: 95.174.67.59

IP Location: Netherlands, North Holland, Amsterdam


IP Owner: M247 Ltd Amsterdam

Owner IP Range: 95.174.67.0 - 95.174.67.255 (256 ip)

Owner Address: Street Kuiperbergweg 13, 1101, Amsterdam, Netherlands


Owner Website: ams01.bb.as205479.net

Owner CIDR: 95.174.67.0/24

Whois Record Created: 29 Jun 2018



Not Listed in Blacklist





Web Browser/s on this IP: Firefox 60 Google Chrome 71 Google Chrome 73 Safari 12

OS on this IP: Mac OS X 10.14.2 Windows 10 x64 Edition Windows 7


Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/71.0.Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_14_2) AppleWebKit/605.1.15 (KHTML, like Gecko) Vers


ASN: AS9009




inetnum: 95.174.67.0 - 95.174.67.255

000085

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

10/31/2019 95.174.67.59, M247 Ltd Amsterdam Netherlands - Whois


netname: M247-LTD-Amsterdam

descr: M247 LTD Amsterdam Infrastructure

org: ORG-MLA21-RIPE

country: NL

geoloc: 52.3740 4.8896

admin-c: GBXS13-RIPE

tech-c: GBXS13-RIPE

status: ASSIGNED PA

mnt-by: GLOBALAXS-MNT

remarks: ---- LEGAL CONCERNS ----

remarks: For any legal requests, please send an email to

remarks: [email protected] for a maximum 48hours response

remarks: ---- LEGAL CONCERNS----

created: 2018-06-29T15:20:03Z


source: RIPE

organisation: ORG-MLA21-RIPE

org-name: M247 Ltd Amsterdam

org-type: OTHER

address: Street Kuiperbergweg 13

address: 1101, Amsterdam, Netherlands

abuse-c: ME5262-RIPE

mnt-ref: GLOBALAXS-MNT


created: 2018-05-17T11:04:18Z



role: M247 NOC Amsterdam

address: Street Kuiperbergweg 13

address: 1101, Amsterdam, Netherlands

nic-hdl: GBXS13-RIPE


created: 2016-07-21T14:54:57Z




route: 95.174.67.0/24

origin: AS9009

000086

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000087

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000088

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

10/31/2019 185.220.101.33 - Markus Koch Markus Koch, Heinestrasse 37, 14621 Schoenwalde-Glien Siedlung, DE Netherlands



IP Address: 185.220.101.33

IP Location: Netherlands


IP Owner: Markus Koch

Owner IP Range: 185.220.101.0 - 185.220.101.127 (128 ip)

Owner Address: Markus Koch, Heinestrasse 37, 14621 Schoenwalde-Glien Siedlung, DE


Owner Phone: +49-176-56997504

Owner CIDR: 185.220.101.0/25

Whois Record Created: 27 Jan 2018



Listed in Blacklist





Web Browser/s on this IP:Android Webkit 4 BlackBerry 9800 BlackBerry 9900 Chromium 65 CoolNovo 2

Firefox 15.02 Firefox 3 Firefox 3.6 Firefox 31 Firefox 33 … … [see all]

OS on this IP:Android Android 2.3.4 Android 4.0 Android 6.0 Android 6.0.1 Android

7.0 Android 7.1.1 … … [see all]


Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.1; rv:52.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/52.0Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.1; WOW64; rv:40.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/40.1





inetnum: 185.220.101.0 - 185.220.101.127

000089

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.



netname: MK-TOR-EXITTOR

remarks: This network is used for Tor ExitsTor

remarks: We do not have any logs at all

remarks: For more information please visit:

remarks: https://www.torproject.orgtor

remarks: Dieses Netz hostet nur TorTor

remarks: Exists. Wir haben keinerlei Logs

remarks: Mehr Informationen unter:

remarks: https://www.torproject.orgtor

country: NL

admin-c: MK20944-RIPE

tech-c: MK20944-RIPE

status: ASSIGNED PA

mnt-by: ZWIEBELFREUNDE

mnt-by: de-zwf-1-mnt

created: 2018-01-27T18:07:57Z


source: RIPE

mnt-routes: FERAL-MNT

org: ORG-MK113-RIPE

organisation: ORG-MK113-RIPE

org-name: Markus Koch

org-type: OTHER

address: Markus Koch

address: Heinestrasse 37

address: 14621 Schoenwalde-Glien Siedlung

address: DE

abuse-c: ACRO11287-RIPE

mnt-ref: ZWIEBELFREUNDE

mnt-by: TNIEME

mnt-by: MKOCH

created: 2017-11-07T20:41:28Z



fax-no: +4933224324937

person: Markus Koch

address: Heinestrasse 37

address: 14621 Schoenwalde-Glien Siedlung

000090

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.




address: DE

phone: +49-176-56997504

nic-hdl: MK20944-RIPE

mnt-by: TNIEME

mnt-by: MKOCH

created: 2017-11-07T20:46:18Z


source: RIPE

fax-no: +4933224324937


route: 185.220.101.0/24

origin: AS200052

mnt-by: FERAL-MNT

created: 2017-11-17T14:33:49Z


source: RIPE

Thursday 31 October 2019, 20:56:46



1 185.220.101.33 USA Windows 7 Firefox 60 18 Oct 2019, 19:52

2 185.220.101.33 Netherlands Windows 10 x64Edition

Opera 63 06 Oct 2019, 09:29

3 185.220.101.33 Netherlands Windows Vista Internet Explorer 8 25 Sep 2019, 05:27

4 185.220.101.33 Netherlands Windows XP Internet Explorer 7 25 Sep 2019, 05:19

5 185.220.101.33 Netherlands Windows 7 x64 Edition Internet Explorer 11 12 Sep 2019, 09:15

6 185.220.101.33 Netherlands Windows 7 x64 Edition Google Chrome 22 09 Sep 2019, 05:46

7 185.220.101.33 Netherlands Windows 7 x64 Edition Google Chrome 21 08 Sep 2019, 06:04

8 185.220.101.33 Netherlands Windows 7 Google Chrome 20 08 Sep 2019, 05:09

9 185.220.101.33 Netherlands Windows 7 x64 Edition Internet Explorer 11 05 Sep 2019, 05:11

10 185.220.101.33 Netherlands Mac OS X 10.8.7 Google Chrome 33 02 Sep 2019, 05:07



000091

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT 15

000092

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re: D

ownloa

ds of "PR

RS02

0420

19_V

D_2"

1 of 1

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2019

‐02‐04

T19:03

:00+00

:00

Files

Adde

d files

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/PR

RS02

0420

19_V

D_2.zip", "is_

dir":

false


AAAA

AAdH

Q", "ho

st_id":

4967

4434

608 }

2019

‐02‐04

T19:25

:37+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2605

:e00

0:87

d1:

3200

:a87

8:6f53

:a750

:4e47

US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR

S020

4201

9_VD

_2.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537

1, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS02

0420

19_V

D_2.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐02‐04

T21:24

:10+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

87.118

.92.43

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR

S020

4201

9_VD

_2.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537

1, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS02

0420

19_V

D_2.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐02‐05

T01:59

:54+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.19

6.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR

S020

4201

9_VD

_2.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537

1, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS02

0420

19_V

D_2.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐02‐12

T01:10

:03+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.19

6.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR

S020

4201

9_VD

_2.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537

1, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS02

0420

19VD

2.zip", "is

dir": false}

2019

‐02‐13

T21:39

:53+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.19

6.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR

S020

4201

9_VD

_2.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537

1, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS02

0420

19_V

D_2.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐02‐13

T21:43

:00+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.19

6.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR

S020

4201

9_VD

_2.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537

1, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS02

0420

19_V

D_2.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐06‐10

T16:25

:36+00

:00

Files

Deleted files

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS02

0420

19_V

D_2.zip", "is_

dir":

false


AAAA

AAdH

Q", "ho

st_id":

5402

1431

056 }

000093

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

10/31/2019 87.118.92.43 - Neuwerkstr. 45/46, 99084 Erfurt, Germany



IP Address: 87.118.92.43

IP Location: Germany

IP Reverse DNS (Host): ns.tor-node.felix.io

IP Owner: Keyweb Ag

Owner IP Range: 87.118.64.0 - 87.118.127.255 (16,384 ip)

Owner Address: Neuwerkstr. 45/46, 99084 Erfurt, Germany

Owner Country: Germany

Owner Phone: +49 361658530

Owner Website: www.keyweb.de

Owner CIDR: 87.118.64.0/18

Whois Record Created: 12 Mar 2007



Listed in Blacklist





Web Browser/s on this IP:Android Webkit 4 Chromium 65 Chromium 8 Firefox 19 Firefox 21

Firefox 3.05 Firefox 30 Firefox 33 Firefox 35 Firefox 36 … … [see all]

OS on this IP:Android Android 2.2.2 Android 3.1 Android 4.2.1 Android 4.2.2

Android 4.4.2 Android 4.4.4 … … [see all]


Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.1; rv:38.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/38.0Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.1; rv:45.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/45.0


ASN: AS31103 , AS45031


000094

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.





inetnum: 87.118.64.0 - 87.118.127.255

netname: DE-KEYWEB-20051004

country: DE

org: ORG-KA2-RIPE

admin-c: KWAG-RIPE

tech-c: KWAG-RIPE



mnt-by: KEYWEB-MNT

mnt-lower: KEYWEB-MNT

mnt-routes: KEYWEB-MNT

created: 2005-10-04T13:32:36Z



organisation: ORG-KA2-RIPE

org-name: Keyweb AG

org-type: LIR

address: Neuwerkstr. 45/46

address: 99084

address: Erfurt

address: GERMANY

phone: +49361658530

fax-no: +493616585366

admin-c: KWAG-RIPE

admin-c: MERO-RIPE



mnt-ref: KEYWEB-MNT


mnt-by: KEYWEB-MNT

created: 2004-04-17T11:09:21Z



person: Hostmaster Day

address: Keyweb AG

address: Neuwerkstr. 45

000095

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.




address: 99084 Erfurt

address: Germany

phone: +49 361 658530

fax-no: +49 361 6585399

nic-hdl: KWAG-RIPE

mnt-by: KEYWEB-MNT

created: 2007-03-12T12:16:49Z




route: 87.118.64.0/18

descr: Keyweb AG IP Network

origin: AS31103

mnt-by: KEYWEB-MNT

created: 2005-10-04T17:39:03Z


source: RIPE




1 87.118.92.43 Germany Windows 7 Firefox 60 09 Oct 2019, 15:19

2 87.118.92.43 Germany Mac OS X 10.14 Firefox 69 28 Sep 2019, 06:03

3 87.118.92.43 Germany Windows 8 x64 Edition Google Chrome 31 04 Sep 2019, 06:16

4 87.118.92.43 Germany Windows 7 Google Chrome 14 03 Sep 2019, 05:55


6 87.118.92.43 Germany Mac OS X 10.8.7 Google Chrome 33 02 Sep 2019, 05:28

7 87.118.92.43 Germany Windows 7 Firefox 60 22 Aug 2019, 18:46

8 87.118.92.43 Germany Windows 7 x64 Edition Google Chrome 23 22 Aug 2019, 06:23

9 87.118.92.43 Germany Windows 8.1 x64Edition

Pale Moon 24.7 28 Jun 2019, 05:16

10 87.118.92.43 Germany Windows 10 x64Edition

Firefox 67 27 Jun 2019, 03:13



000096

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT 16

000097

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re: D

ownloa

ds of "PR

RS02

0420

19_V

D"

1 of 1

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2019

‐02‐04

T19:03

:39+00

:00

Files

Adde

d files

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/PR

RS02

0420

19_V

D.zip", "is_

dir":

false


AAAA

AAdH

g", "ho

st_id":

4967

4434

608 }

2019

‐02‐04

T19:25

:28+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

2605

:e00

0:87

d1:32

00:a87

8:6f53

:a75

0:4e47

US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR

S020

4201

9_VD

.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537


quests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS02

0420

19_V

D.zip",

"is_dir": false}

2019

‐02‐04

T21:23

:37+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

87.118

.92.43

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR

S020

4201

9_VD

.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537


quests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS02

0420

19_V

D.zip",

"is_dir": false}

2019

‐02‐05

T01:59

:41+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.19

6.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR

S020

4201

9_VD

.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537


quests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS02

0420

19_V

D.zip",

"isdir": false}

2019

‐02‐12

T01:10

:59+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.19

6.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PRR

S020

4201

9_VD

.zip", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

1525

1537


quests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS02

0420

19_V

D.zip",

"is_dir": false}

2019

‐06‐10

T16:25

:36+00

:00

Files

Deleted files

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

RS02

0420

19_V

D.zip", "is_

dir":

false


AAAA

AAdH

g", "ho

st_id":

5402

1431

056 }

000098

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT 17

000099

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re: Dow

nloa

ds of "PR

R_19

‐134

_data@

theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip"

1 of 3

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2019

‐03‐26

T22:05:57+00:00

Files

Adde

d files

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.co

m

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/PR

R_19

‐134_da

ta@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "is_


"4cefSjLn5

SUAA

AAAA

AAdyg", "ho

stid": 42914893232}

2019

‐03‐26

T22:05:57+00:00

Files

Adde

d files

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.co

m

{"path": "/file re

quests/outbo

x/PR

R_19

‐134_da

ta@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "is_


"4cefSjLn5

SUAA

AAAA

AAdyg", "ho

st_id": 42914893232}

2019

‐03‐26

T22:44:09+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame": "PR

R_19

‐134_data@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

R_19

‐134_da

ta@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐03‐27

T05:22:39+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

104.37.2.46

PRSan Juan

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame": "PR

R_19

‐134_data@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

R_19

‐134da

ta@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "is

dir": false}

2019

‐03‐27

T05:05:31+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

204.85.191.30

US

Burlington

North

Carolina

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame": "PR

R_19

‐134_data@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

R_19

‐134_da

ta@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐04‐03

T22:02:29+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.196.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame": "PR

R_19

‐134_data@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

R_19

‐134_da

ta@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "is_

dir": false}

000100

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re: Dow

nloa

ds of "PR

R_19

‐134

_data@

theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip"

2 of 3

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2019

‐05‐03

T00:08:28+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

5.196.66.162

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame": "PR

R_19

‐134_data@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

R_19

‐134da

ta@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "is

dir": false}

2019

‐05‐03

T00:08:38+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

5.196.66.162

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame": "PR

R_19

‐134_data@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

R_19

‐134_da

ta@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐05‐13

T23:11:07+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

95.174.67.59

NL

Amsterdam

North

Holland

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame": "PR

R_19

‐134_data@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

R_19

‐134_da

ta@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐05‐13

T23:36:58+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

95.174.67.59

NL

Amsterdam

North

Holland

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame": "PR

R_19

‐134_data@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

R_19

‐134da

ta@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "is

dir": false}

2019

‐06‐07

T00:01:13+00:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

141.101.146.87

NO

Oslo

Oslo

Cou

nty

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame": "PR

R_19

‐134_data@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "link_ow

ner_name":

"Fullerton

City

Dropb

ox", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

", "link_ow

ner_id":

152515371, "path": "/File re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

R_19

‐134_da

ta@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "is_

dir": false}

000101

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re: Dow

nloa

ds of "PR

R_19

‐134

_data@

theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip"

3 of 3

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2019

‐06‐10

T16:25:36+00:00

Files

Deleted files

74.62.244.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.co

m

{"path": "/file re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

R_19

‐134_da

ta@theh

ourly

struggle.com

.zip", "is_


"4cefSjLn5

SUAA

AAAA

AAdyg", "ho

st_id": 54021431056}

000102

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT 18

000103

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re: D

ownloa

ds of "PR

19‐171

VD_1_2.zip"

1 of 1

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2019

‐04‐18

T22:47

:15+00

:00

Files

Adde

d files

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

19‐171

VD_1_2.zip", "is_

dir":

false


AAAA

AAeH

Q", "ho

st_id":

4967

4434

608}

2019

‐04‐19

T00:18

:04+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

77.247

.181

.162

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PR1

9‐17

1VD_

1_2.zip

", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

19‐171

VD_1_2.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐04‐19

T00:49

:41+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

141.10

1.14

6.99

NO

Oslo

Oslo

Cou

nty

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PR1

9‐17

1VD_

1_2.zip

", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

19‐171

VD_1_2.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐04‐23

T00:05

:59+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PR1

9‐17

1VD_

1_2.zip

", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

19‐171

VD_1_2.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐04‐23

T00:20

:13+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.19

6.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PR1

9‐17

1VD_

1_2.zip

", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

19‐171

VD_1_2.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐04‐23

T16:52

:31+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PR1

9‐17

1VD_

1_2.zip

", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

19‐171

VD12.zip", "is

dir": false}

2019

‐04‐23

T23:29

:19+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

76.79.19

6.58

US

La M

irada

California

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PR1

9‐17

1VD_

1_2.zip

", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

19‐171

VD_1_2.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐06‐10

T16:25

:42+00

:00

Files

Deleted files

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.co

m

{"path": "/file re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

19‐171

VD_1_2.zip", "is_

dir":

false


AAAA

AAeH

Q", "ho

st_id":

5402

1431

056}

000104

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT 19

000105

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

Dropb

ox Activity

Log

Excerpts re: D

ownloa

ds of “PR

19‐188

VD.zip”

1 of 1

Time

Even

t category

Even

t type

IP add

ress

Coun

try

City

Region

Nam

eEm

ail

Info

2019

‐05‐02

T23:41

:10+00

:00

Files

Adde

d files

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

19‐188

VD.zip", "is_

dir":

false


AAAA

AAem

g", "ho

st_id":

4967

4434

608}

2019

‐05‐03

T00:10

:12+00

:00

Sharing

Downloade

d a

file/folder from

a link (non

‐team

mem

ber)

5.19

6.66

.162

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

Unkno

wn

{"file_ob


AAAA

AAAC

Q", "base_n

ame":

"PR1

9‐18

8VD.zip

", "link_ow


City

Drop

box", "link_ow

ner_mem

ber_id":

"dbm

id:AAA

8npD


P0oe

c",

"link_ow

ner_em


.com

",

"link_ow

ner_id": 152

5153

71, "path": "/File

requ

ests/O

utbo

x/PR

19‐188

VD.zip", "is_

dir": false}

2019

‐06‐10

T16:25

:42+00

:00

Files

Deleted files

74.62.24

4.66

US

Fullerton

California

Fullerton

City

Drop

box


.com

{"path": "/file re

quests/O

utbo

x/PR

19‐188

VD.zip", "is_

dir":

false


AAAA

AAem

g", "ho

st_id":

5402

1431

056}

000106

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.




IP Address: 87.118.92.43

IP Location: Germany

IP Reverse DNS (Host): ns.tor-node.felix.io

IP Owner: Keyweb Ag

Owner IP Range: 87.118.64.0 - 87.118.127.255 (16,384 ip)

Owner Address: Neuwerkstr. 45/46, 99084 Erfurt, Germany

Owner Country: Germany

Owner Phone: +49 361658530

Owner Website: www.keyweb.de

Owner CIDR: 87.118.64.0/18

Whois Record Created: 12 Mar 2007



Listed in Blacklist





Web Browser/s on this IP:Android Webkit 4 Chromium 65 Chromium 8 Firefox 19 Firefox 21

Firefox 3.05 Firefox 30 Firefox 33 Firefox 35 Firefox 36 … … [see all]

OS on this IP:Android Android 2.2.2 Android 3.1 Android 4.2.1 Android 4.2.2

Android 4.4.2 Android 4.4.4 … … [see all]


Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.1; rv:38.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/38.0Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.1; rv:45.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/45.0


ASN: AS31103 , AS45031


000107

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.





inetnum: 87.118.64.0 - 87.118.127.255

netname: DE-KEYWEB-20051004

country: DE

org: ORG-KA2-RIPE

admin-c: KWAG-RIPE

tech-c: KWAG-RIPE



mnt-by: KEYWEB-MNT

mnt-lower: KEYWEB-MNT

mnt-routes: KEYWEB-MNT

created: 2005-10-04T13:32:36Z



organisation: ORG-KA2-RIPE

org-name: Keyweb AG

org-type: LIR

address: Neuwerkstr. 45/46

address: 99084

address: Erfurt

address: GERMANY

phone: +49361658530

fax-no: +493616585366

admin-c: KWAG-RIPE

admin-c: MERO-RIPE



mnt-ref: KEYWEB-MNT


mnt-by: KEYWEB-MNT

created: 2004-04-17T11:09:21Z



person: Hostmaster Day

address: Keyweb AG

address: Neuwerkstr. 45

000108

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.




address: 99084 Erfurt

address: Germany

phone: +49 361 658530

fax-no: +49 361 6585399

nic-hdl: KWAG-RIPE

mnt-by: KEYWEB-MNT

created: 2007-03-12T12:16:49Z




route: 87.118.64.0/18

descr: Keyweb AG IP Network

origin: AS31103

mnt-by: KEYWEB-MNT

created: 2005-10-04T17:39:03Z


source: RIPE




1 87.118.92.43 Germany Windows 7 Firefox 60 09 Oct 2019, 15:19

2 87.118.92.43 Germany Mac OS X 10.14 Firefox 69 28 Sep 2019, 06:03


4 87.118.92.43 Germany Windows 7 Google Chrome 14 03 Sep 2019, 05:55


6 87.118.92.43 Germany Mac OS X 10.8.7 Google Chrome 33 02 Sep 2019, 05:28

7 87.118.92.43 Germany Windows 7 Firefox 60 22 Aug 2019, 18:46

8 87.118.92.43 Germany Windows 7 x64 Edition Google Chrome 23 22 Aug 2019, 06:23

9 87.118.92.43 Germany Windows 8.1 x64Edition

Pale Moon 24.7 28 Jun 2019, 05:16

10 87.118.92.43 Germany Windows 10 x64Edition

Firefox 67 27 Jun 2019, 03:13



000109

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EX

EM

PT

FR

OM

FIL

ING

FE

ES

PU

RS

UA

NT

TO

GO

VE

RN

ME

NT

CO

DE

SE

CT

ION

6103

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF MEA KLEIN IN SUPPORT OFCITY OF FULLERTON’S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION





CITY OF FULLERTON,

Plaintiff,

vs.


Defendants.

Case No. 30-2019-01107063-CU-NP-CJC


SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OFMEA KLEIN IN SUPPORT OF CITY OFFULLERTON’S MOTION FORPRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

[Filed Concurrently with Supp.Memorandum of Points and Authorities;Supp. Declaration of Matthew Strebe;Declaration of Ivy M. Tsai; Declaration ofMarni Rice; Declaration of Michael J. Rice;Declaration of Christopher Tennyson; and[Proposed] Order]




000110

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

- 1 -SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF MEA KLEIN IN SUPPORT OF


SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF MEA KLEIN

1. I, Mea Klein, state and declare:

2. I am an adult, over the age of eighteen years, and I can truthfully testify to the

following information of my own personal knowledge and belief.

3. I am the Assistant City Clerk for the City of Fullerton. I have held my position for

10 years. Prior to my current position, I was employed as the Deputy City Clerk at the City of

Fullerton for one year and as a Clerical with the department for two years prior to that. As part of

my duties as Assistant City Clerk, I maintain files on correspondence relating to Public Records

Act Requests (PRRs) received by the City, including the requests, internal correspondence relating

to those requests, and responses thereto.

4. I make this supplemental declaration in support of Plaintiff City of Fullerton’s (City)

Motion for Preliminary Junction.

5. On December 4, 2017, the City received PRR No. 17-458 from Michael Blackstone

of Air Combat USA, Inc., requesting certain emails, text messages and other documents. On

January 19, 2018, after attorney review of the potentially responsive emails was completed, I

produced the non-privileged responsive emails to Mr. Blackstone via an email that included a

Dropbox link to a separate folder named “Blackstone PRR Response Dec. 2017.zip.” (A true and

correct copy of my January 19, 2018 email to Mr. Blackstone is attached hereto as Exhibit “J”).

6. On March 12, 2018, the City received PRR No. 18-72 from Keith Cangiarella

requesting certain emails. On April 25, 2018, after attorney review of the potentially responsive

emails was completed, I produced the non-privileged responsive emails to Mr. Cangiarella via an

email that included a Dropbox link to a separate folder named “Keith Cangiarella PRR Responsive

E-mails.zip.” (A true and correct copy of my April 25, 2018 email to Mr. Cangiarella is attached

hereto as Exhibit “K”).

///

///

000111

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



7. On April 27, 2018, the City received PRR No. 18-101 from Bryant Moy, requesting

certain emails. On or about May 3, 2018, City IT created a Dropbox folder named

“council_20180430.zip” containing a PST file generated by the email search parameters requested,

and sent the link to that folder to me. I forwarded that link to Deputy City Attorney Ivy Tsai for

review on May 7, 2018. The only individuals who were given express authority to access the

Dropbox folder “council_20180430.zip” were Helen Hall (IT), Isaiah Suarez (IT), Ivy Tsai and me.

On June 27, 2018, after attorney review of the potentially responsive emails was completed, I

produced the non-privileged responsive emails to Mr. Moy via an email that included a Dropbox

link to the City’s Dropbox account, directing him to a folder named “Moy responsive emails.” (A

true and correct copy of my June 27, 2018 email to Mr. Moy is attached hereto as Exhibit “L”).

8. On May 24, 2018, the City received PRR No. 18-141 from Veronica Duarte of Air

Combat USA, Inc., requesting certain emails. On June 4, 2018, City IT created a Dropbox folder

named “PRR_AIR20180604.zip” containing 4 PST files generated by the email search parameters

requested, and sent the link to that folder to Deputy City Attorney Ivy Tsai for review. The only

individuals who were given express authority to access the Dropbox folder

“PRR_AIR20180604.zip” were Helen Hall (IT), Isaiah Suarez (IT), Ivy Tsai and me. On January

8, 2019, after attorney review of the potentially responsive emails was completed, I produced the

non-privileged responsive emails to Ms. Duarte via an email that included a Dropbox link to a

separate Dropbox folder named “Veronica Duarte.zip.” (A true and correct copy of my January 8,

2019 email to Ms. Duarte is attached hereto as Exhibit “M”).

9. On July 16, 2018, the City received PRR No. 18-190 from the Thomas Law Firm,

seeking certain emails. On July 26, 2018, after attorney review of the potentially responsive emails

was completed, I produced a PDF file to the Thomas Law Firm containing the non-privileged

responsive documents, via email. No Dropbox link was produced to the Thomas Law Firm

regarding PRR No. 19-52. (A true and correct copy of my July 26, 2018 email to the Thomas Law

Firm is attached hereto as Exhibit “N”).

///

///

000112

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



10. On September 20, 2018, the City received PRR No. 18-276 from Joshua Ferguson,

requesting certain emails. On September 26, 2018, City IT created a Dropbox folder named

“Tiger_Signal_PRR” containing PST file(s) generated by the email search parameters requested,

and sent the link to that folder to Deputy City Attorney Ivy Tsai for review. The only individuals

who were given express authority to access the Dropbox folder “Tiger_Signal_PRR” were Helen

Hall (IT), Isaiah Suarez (IT), Ivy Tsai, Lucinda Williams (City Clerk) and me. On October 1, 2018,

I responded to Mr. Ferguson that no responsive records existed as to all but two of his requested

email search terms, and informed him that the terms “Signal” and “Archive” were overly

burdensome because they yielded approximately 67,742 emails and 38,000 emails respectively, not

including attachments. (A true and correct copy of my October 1, 2018 email to Mr. Ferguson is

attached hereto as Exhibit “O”).

11. On September 20, 2018, the City received PRR No. 18-277 from Joshua Ferguson,

requesting certain emails. On October 2, 2018, City IT created a Dropbox folder named

“PRR_JF_20181002.zip” containing multiple PST files generated by the email search parameters

requested, and sent the link to that folder to Deputy City Attorney Ivy Tsai for review. The only


“PRR_JF_20181002.zip” were Helen Hall (IT), Isaiah Suarez (IT), Ivy Tsai, and me. On October

9, 2018, after attorney review of the potentially responsive emails was completed, I produced 6

PDF files containing the non-privileged responsive documents to Mr. Ferguson, via email. No

Dropbox link was produced to Mr. Ferguson in response to PRR No. 18-277. (True and correct

copies of my October 9, 2018 emails to Mr. Ferguson are attached hereto as Exhibit “P”).

12. On October 6, 2018, the City received PRR No. 18-294 from Joshua Ferguson,

seeking certain emails. On October 12, 2018, City IT created a Dropbox folder named

“JF_PRR20181012.zip” containing multiple PST files generated by the email search parameters

requested, and sent the link to that folder to Deputy City Attorney Ivy Tsai for review. On October

30, 2018, City IT re-ran a revised version of the email search terms and created another Dropbox

folder named “JF_PRR_2.zip” containing multiple PST files, and sent the link to Deputy City

Attorney Ivy Tsai for review. The only individuals who were given express authority to access the

000113

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



Dropbox folder “JF_PRR20181012.zip” and “JF_PRR_2.zip” were Helen Hall (IT), Isaiah Suarez

(IT), Ivy Tsai, and me. On December 3, 2018, after attorney review of the potentially responsive

emails was completed, I produced a link to a portfolio of multiple PDF files containing the non-

privileged responsive documents to Mr. Ferguson, via email. No Dropbox link was produced to

Mr. Ferguson in response to PRR No. 18-294. (A true and correct copy of my December 3, 2018

email to Mr. Ferguson is attached hereto as Exhibit “Q”).

13. On October 26, 2018, the City received PRR No. 18-326 from David Curlee,

requesting certain emails. On November 6, 2018, City IT created a folder named “PPR_Cox.zip”

containing PST file(s) generated by the email search parameters requested, and sent the link to me.

That same day, I forwarded the link to Deputy City Attorney Ivy Tsai for review. The only

individuals who were given express authority to access the Dropbox folder “PPR_Cox.zip” were

Helen Hall (IT), Joshua Martinez (IT), Ivy Tsai, and me. On November 27, 2018, after attorney

review of the potentially responsive emails was completed, I produced the non-privileged

responsive emails to Mr. Curlee via an email that included a link to a separate Dropbox folder

named “PPR_18_326_Curlee.zip.” On November 28, 2018, I produced a PDF file to Mr. Curlee

containing additional non-privileged responsive documents, via email. (True and correct copies of

my November 27, 2018 and November 28, 2018 emails to Mr. Curlee are attached hereto as Exhibit

“R”).

14. On January 2, 2019, the City received PRR No. 19-16 from Joshua Ferguson,

requesting certain emails. On January 9, 2019, City IT created a Dropbox folder named

“PRRS01082019.zip” containing PST file(s) generated by the email search parameters requested,

and sent the link to Deputy City Attorney Ivy Tsai for review. On January 10, 2019, City IT created

another Dropbox folder named “PRRS01092019.zip” containing PST file(s) generated by a revised

version of the email search parameters requested, and sent the link to Deputy City Attorney Ivy

Tsai for review. The only individuals who were given express authority to access the Dropbox

folder “PRRS01092019.zip” were Helen Hall (IT), Reza Shad (IT), Ivy Tsai, and me. On January

14, 2019, after attorney review of the potentially responsive emails was completed, I produced a

PDF file to Mr. Ferguson containing the non-privileged responsive documents, via email. No

000114

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



Dropbox link was produced to Mr. Ferguson in response to PRR No. 19-16. (A true and correct

copy of my January 14, 2019 email to Mr. Ferguson is attached hereto as Exhibit “S”).

15. On January 2, 2019, the City also received PRR No. 19-19 from Joshua Ferguson,

requesting certain email search terms. On January 15, 2019, City IT created a Dropbox folder

named “PRRS01152019_JF.zip” containing PST file(s) generated by the email search parameters

requested, and sent the link to Deputy City Attorney Ivy Tsai for review. The only individuals who

were given express authority to access the Dropbox folder “PRRS01152019_JF.zip” were Helen

Hall (IT), Reza Shad (IT), Ivy Tsai, and me. On May 7, 2019, City IT created another Dropbox

folder named “pr1919-Josh Ferguson” (the Subject File) housing multiple PST files generated by

a revised version of the email search parameters requested, and sent the link to Deputy City

Attorney Ivy Tsai for review. The only individuals who were given express authority to access the

Dropbox folder “pr1919-Josh Ferguson” were Helen Hall (IT), Reza Shad (IT), Ivy Tsai, and me.

No responsive records were produced in response to PRR No. 19-19, as Mr. Ferguson did not

respond to a request to further narrow his requested search terms, which the City advised him were

overbroad and unduly burdensome. As a result, no Dropbox link or PDF files were ever produced

to Mr. Ferguson regarding PRR No. 19-19. (See Declaration of Mea Klein (“Klein Dec.”),

previously submitted, ¶¶ 17-21 & Exh. F-I).

16. On January 21, 2019, the City received PRR No. 19-48 from Veronica Duarte of Air

Combat USA, Inc., requesting certain emails. On February 4, 2019, City IT created a Dropbox

folder named “PRRS02042019_VD_2” housing PST file(s) generated by the email search

parameters requested, and sent the link to Deputy City Attorney Ivy Tsai for review. The only


“PRRS02042019_VD_2” were Helen Hall (IT), Reza Shad (IT), Ivy Tsai, and me. On February

14, 2019, after attorney review had been completed, City Clerk Lucinda Williams responded to Ms.

Duarte’s request and (a) advised her that any emails between City personnel and the City Attorney’s

office were exempt from disclosure, and (b) requested that she further narrow her request,

suggesting that she limit the number of senders and recipients and further limit the scope of the

subject matter requested. (A true and correct copy of Ms. Williams’ February 14, 2019 email to

000115

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



Ms. Duarte is attached hereto as Exhibit “T.” I was a cc recipient of the email.). No responsive

documents were produced in response to PRR No. 19-48 because the request was not further

narrowed. In other words, no Dropbox link or PDF files were ever produced to Ms. Duarte

regarding PRR No. 19-48. The City did, however, produce responsive records to more targeted

similar requests in response to Ms. Duarte’s PRR Nos. 17-458, 18-001 and 19-86.

17. On January 23, 2019, the City received PRR No. 19-52 from Veronica Duarte of Air

Combat USA, Inc., requesting certain emails. On February 4, 2019, City IT created a Dropbox

folder named “PRRS02042019_VD” containing PST file(s) generated by the email search


individuals who were given express authority to access the Dropbox folder “PRRS02042019_VD”

were Helen Hall (IT), Reza Shad (IT), Ivy Tsai, and me. On February 7, 2019, after attorney review

was completed, I responded to Ms. Duarte and advised her that the emails she requested were

exempt from disclosure under the PRA. As a result, no Dropbox link or PDF files were ever

produced to Ms. Duarte regarding PRR No. 19-52. (A true and correct copy of my February 7,

2019 email to Ms. Duarte is attached hereto as Exhibit “U”).

18. On March 14, 2019, the City received PRR No. 19-134 from Joshua Ferguson,

requesting certain emails. On March 26, 2019, City IT created a Dropbox folder named “PRR_19-

[email protected]” containing PST files generated by the email search


individuals who were given express authority to access the Dropbox folder “PRR_19-

[email protected]” were Helen Hall (IT), Reza Shad (IT), Ivy Tsai, and me.

On April 30, 2019, after attorney review had been completed, I produced a PDF file containing

non-privileged responsive documents to Mr. Ferguson, via email. No Dropbox link was produced

to Mr. Ferguson in response to PRR No. 19-134. (A true and correct copy of my April 30, 2019

email to Mr. Ferguson is attached hereto as Exhibit “V”).

19. On April 15, 2019, the City received PRR No. 19-171 from Veronica Duarte of Air

Combat USA, Inc., requesting certain emails. On April 18, 2019, City IT created a Dropbox folder

named “PR19-171VD_1_2.zip” housing 2 PST files generated by the email search parameters

000116

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000117

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000118

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000119

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000120

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000121

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000122

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000123

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000124

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000125

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000126

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000127

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000128

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000129

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000130

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000131

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000132

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000133

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000134

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000135

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000136

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000137

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000138

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000139

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000140

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000141

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000142

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000143

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000144

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000145

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000146

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000147

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000148

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000149

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000150

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000151

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000152

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000153

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000154

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000155

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000156

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EX

EM

PT

FR

OM

FIL

ING

FE

ES

PU

RS

UA

NT

TO

GO

VE

RN

ME

NT

CO

DE

SE

CT

ION

6103

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

DECLARATION OF IVY M. TSAI IN SUPPORT OFCITY OF FULLERTON’S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION





CITY OF FULLERTON,

Plaintiff,

vs.


Defendants.

Case No. 30-2019-01107063-CU-NP-CJC


DECLARATION OF IVY M. TSAI INSUPPORT OF CITY OF FULLERTON’SMOTION FOR PRELIMINARYINJUNCTION

[Filed Concurrently with:Supp. Memorandum of Points and Authorities;Supp. Declaration of Matthew Strebe; Supp.Declaration of Mea Klein; Declaration of MarniRice; Declaration of Michael J. Rice;Declaration of Christopher Tennyson; and[Proposed] Order]




000157

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

- 1 -DECLARATION OF IVY M. TSAI IN SUPPORT OF


DECLARATION OF IVY M. TSAI

1. I, Ivy M. Tsai, state and declare:

2. I am an attorney at law authorized to practice law before all of the courts of the State

of California, and am an attorney with the law firm of Jones & Mayer, which serves as the City

Attorney’s Office for the City of Fullerton (the City) and is counsel of record for the City in the

above-captioned matter. I make this Declaration in support of Plaintiff’s Motion for Preliminary

Injunction. I am familiar with the files and records in this matter. If called as a witness, I could

and would competently testify thereto, as I have personal knowledge of the facts as set forth herein

below.

3. On December 4, 2017, the City received PRR No. 17-458 from Michael Blackstone

of Air Combat USA, Inc., requesting certain emails, text messages and other documents. A City

Information Technology (IT) employee created a Dropbox folder named “ACUSA_PRR.zip”

containing PST file(s) generated by the email search parameters requested, and sent the link to that

folder to my colleague Gary Kranker and me for review on December 19, 2017. The only

individuals who were given express authority to access the Dropbox folder “ACUSA_PRR.zip”

were City employees Helen Hall (IT) and Isaiah Suarez (IT), attorney Gary Kranker (from my law

firm), and me.

4. On March 12, 2018, the City received PRR No. 18-72 from Keith Cangiarella

requesting certain emails. City IT created a Dropbox folder named “CE_PRR_KC.zip” containing

a PST file generated by the email search parameters requested, and sent the link to that folder to

Code Enforcement Supervisor Guillermina Torrico, who forwarded it to me, for review on April

10, 2018. The only individuals who were given express authority to access the Dropbox folder

“CE_PRR_KC.zip” were Isaiah Suarez (IT), Guillermina Torrico and me.

5. On July 16, 2018, the City received PRR No. 18-190 from the Thomas Law Firm,

000158

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



seeking certain emails. City IT created a Dropbox folder named “HL_PRR” containing PST file(s)

generated by the email search parameters requested, and sent the link to that folder to my colleague

Gary Kranker and me for review on July 25, 2018. The only individuals who were given express

authority to access the Dropbox folder “HL_PRR” were Helen Hall (IT), Isaiah Suarez (IT), Gary

Kranker (Legal) and me.

6. The IP address registered to my law firm Jones & Mayer is 76.79.196.58. The ISP

associated with this IP address is listed as Spectrum Business, and the City, Region and Country

associated with this IP address is La Mirada, California, United States. (A true and correct copy of

the IP address registered to my computer at Jones & Mayer is attached hereto as Exhibit “A”).

7. The “Matt Deitz” referenced in the City’s Dropbox activity log is an Information

Technology contractor for Jones & Mayer. Mr. Deitz occasionally assisted me with downloading

folders and documents from the City’s Dropbox account. He identified his IP address as

99.40.197.210.

8. I searched my emails for the term “PRRS01092019_all.zip” but did not find any

emails with that search term. I do not recall deleting any emails from City personnel that would

have contained such a link. I also searched my emails for the term PRRS01092019.zip, and did

find an email from City IT with a link to the Dropbox folder named “PRRS01092019.zip.”

9. At no time did I share the City’s Dropbox link and password with any third parties,

including the Defendants in this matter, or authorize them to access the PST files forwarded to me

by the City of Fullerton for my review for privileged and confidential information and other records

exempt from disclosure under the California Public Records Act (Government Code §§ 6250 et

seq.).

10. From my review of the PST files that were created for my review, many of the PST

files contained privileged and confidential documents and/or documents otherwise exempted from

000159

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



disclosure under the Public Records Act, including attorney-client communications, attorney work

product (including attorney comments and revisions on draft documents), draft settlement and other

agreements, insurance-related documents, etc. Some of the PST files also included highly sensitive

information such as social security numbers, law enforcement investigative records, personnel

records and related information, and employee medical information.

I hereby declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the

foregoing is true and correct. Executed this 1st day of November 2019 at Fullerton, California.

Ivy M. Tsai

000160

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EXHIBIT A

000161

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000162

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EX

EM

PT

FR

OM

FIL

ING

FE

ES

PU

RS

UA

NT

TO

GO

VE

RN

ME

NT

CO

DE

SE

CT

ION

6103

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

DECLARATION OF MARNI RICE IN SUPPORT OFPLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION


Attorneys for PlaintiffCITY OF FULLERTON


COUNTY OF ORANGE

CITY OF FULLERTON,

Plaintiff,

vs.


Defendants.

Case No. 30-2019-01107063-CU-NP-CJC


DECLARATION OF MARNI RICE INSUPPORT OF PLAINTIFF’S MOTIONFOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

[Filed Concurrently with Supp. Memorandumof Points and Authorities; Supp. Declaration ofMatthew Strebe; Supp. Declaration of MeaKlein; Declaration of Ivy M. Tsai; Declarationof Michael J. Rice; Declaration of ChristopherTennyson; and [Proposed] Order]




000163

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000164

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000165

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EX

EM

PT

FR

OM

FIL

ING

FE

ES

PU

RS

UA

NT

TO

GO

VE

RN

ME

NT

CO

DE

SE

CT

ION

6103

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

DECLARATION OF MICHAEL J. RICE IN SUPPORT OFPLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION




COUNTY OF ORANGE

CITY OF FULLERTON,

Plaintiff,

vs.


Defendants.

Case No. 30-2019-01107063-CU-NP-CJC


DECLARATION OF MICHAEL J. RICEIN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFF’S MOTIONFOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

[Filed Concurrently with Supp. Memorandumof Points and Authorities; Supp. Declaration ofMatthew Strebe; Supp. Declaration of MeaKlein; Declaration of Ivy M. Tsai; Declarationof Marni Rice; Declaration of ChristopherTennyson; and [Proposed] Order]




000166

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000167

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000168

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EX

EM

PT

FR

OM

FIL

ING

FE

ES

PU

RS

UA

NT

TO

GO

VE

RN

ME

NT

CO

DE

SE

CT

ION

6103

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

DECLARATION OF CHRISTOPHER TENNYSON IN SUPPORT OFPLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION




COUNTY OF ORANGE

CITY OF FULLERTON,

Plaintiff,

vs.


Defendants.

Case No. 30-2019-01107063-CU-NP-CJC


DECLARATION OF CHRISTOPHERTENNYSON IN SUPPORT OFPLAINTIFF’S MOTION FORPRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

[Filed Concurrently with Supp. Memorandumof Points and Authorities; Supp. Declaration ofMatthew Strebe; Supp. Declaration of MeaKlein; Declaration of Ivy M. Tsai; Declarationof Marni Rice; Declaration of Michael J. Rice;and [Proposed] Order]




000169

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

DECLARATION OF CHRISTOPHER TENNYSON IN SUPPORT OFPLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

DECLARATION OF CHRISTOPHER TENNYSON

I, Christopher Tennyson, state and declare:

1. I am an adult, over the age of eighteen years, and I can truthfully testify to the

following information of my own personal knowledge and belief.

2. I worked as a Sales Associate at Fullerton Cameras from 1999 to September 28,

2019.

3. While I worked at Fullerton Cameras, I routinely used the computer there to access

my personal Dropbox account (registered to my email address [email protected]) to send

pictures to clients.

4. The computer at Fullerton Cameras was not accessible to clients or customers. It

was available for use only by the owners of the business Marni and Mike Rice and by employees.

5. I understand that the Fullerton Cameras computer and Dropbox account

([email protected]) was used to download folders from the City of Fullerton’s Dropbox

account on or about December 29, 2017, including the folders named “ACUSA_PRR.zip,” “51022

Malvern,” and “Pro-Card.” I did not personally download these folders from the City’s Dropbox

account on that date. Nor did I authorize or direct anyone else to do so.

6. I understand that my Dropbox account ([email protected]) was used to

download a folder named “PRRS01152019_JF.zip” from the City of Fullerton’s Dropbox account

on or about January 16, 2019. I did not personally download the folder “PRRS01152019_JF.zip”

from the City’s Dropbox account, nor did I authorize or direct anyone else to do so. I was not at

work at all on January 16, 2019. I must have been the last one to access Dropbox on the store’s

computer before the January 16, 2019 download.

7. Based upon the date, time and circumstances relating to the download of the folder

“PRRS01152019_JF.zip”, the download must have been made by my former co-worker Joshua

Ferguson. There were no other employees of Fullerton Camera on that date, and I have no reason

to believe the store owners Marni and Mike Rice would have downloaded any materials from the

City’s Dropbox account.

8. I have never accessed, downloaded or copied files from the City of Fullerton’s

000170

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

000171

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

EX

EM

PT

FR

OM

FIL

ING

FE

ES

PU

RS

UA

NT

TO

GO

VE

RN

ME

NT

CO

DE

SE

CT

ION

6103

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

[PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION



CITY OF FULLERTON,

Plaintiff,

vs.


Defendants.

Case No. 30-2019-01107063-CU-NP-CJC


[PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTINGPLAINTIFF’S MOTION FORPRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

[Filed Concurrently with:Supp. Memorandum of Points and Authorities;Supp. Declaration of Matthew Strebe; Supp.Declaration of Mea Klein; Declaration of IvyM. Tsai; Declaration of Marni Rice;Declaration of Michael J. Rice; andDeclaration of Christopher Tennyson]



000172

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

- 1 -[PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

[PROPOSED] ORDER

Plaintiff City of Fullerton’s (the “City”) Motion for Preliminary Injunction came on

regularly for hearing on November 21, 2019, at 8:30 a.m. in Department C-24 of this Court, before

the Honorable Thomas A. Delaney.

Having considered all papers submitted in support of and in opposition to the City’s Motion

for Preliminary Injunction, the briefs and admissible evidence submitted by the parties in

connection with the City’s Ex Parte Application, and the arguments made by counsel, and good

cause having been shown,

IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT the City’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction is

hereby GRANTED as follows:

(1) Defendants and their officers, agents, servants, employees, assigns, and all those

acting in active concert or participation with them are hereby temporarily restrained from doing

any of the following:

(a) Deleting, altering, destroying or removing any of the privileged and

confidential City Dropbox folders and files listed at Exhibit A, or the documents contained

therein, saved in any computers, servers, and storage media (e.g., hard drives, flash drives,

thumb drives, CD-ROMs, DVD-ROMs, etc.), or existing in hard copy form, under the

possession, custody or control of the Defendants and/or any third parties who may have

acted in concert with the Defendants or with whom the Defendants may have shared such

documents and data. Such documents and data shall be preserved until such time as they

may be examined as part of the litigation and the Court determines whether they should be

permanently destroyed under Court-appointed supervision. Defendants and all third

parties who may have acted in concert with them are under a mandatory preservation order

prohibiting them from destroying the records at issue in this litigation, as listed in Exhibit

A, pending hearing on the City’s Order to Show Cause;

(b) Deleting, altering, destroying or removing any written communications or

memorialization of communications concerning the documents and data described at

Paragraph (1)(a) above.

000173

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28


(c) Deleting, altering, destroying or removing any summaries of the documents

and data described at Paragraph (1)(a) above;

(d) Further accessing or attempting to access the City’s private computer

networks, private folders stored in any City File Sharing accounts, and/or City servers,

without the City’s authorization;

(e) Conspiring with any third parties to access or attempt to access the City’s

private computer networks, private folders stored in any City File Sharing accounts, and/or

City servers, without the City’s authorization;

(f) Removing, copying, extracting or downloading any information or data

from the City’s computer networks, private folders stored in any City File Sharing

accounts, and/or City servers, without the City’s authorization;

(g) Conspiring with any third parties to remove, copy, extract or download any

information or data from the City’s computer networks, private folders stored in any City

File Sharing accounts, and/or City servers, without the City’s authorization;

(h) Engaging in any activity that disrupts, diminishes the quality of, interferes

with the performance of, or impairs the functionality of the City’s computer networks, the

City’s File Sharing accounts, and/or City servers; and

(i) Conspiring with any third parties to engage in any activity that disrupts,

diminishes the quality of, interferes with the performance of, or impairs the functionality

of the City’s computer networks, the City’s File Sharing accounts, and/or City servers;

(j) Selling, publishing, distributing, disclosing or otherwise using any of the

information or documents obtained from the City Dropbox folders and files listed at

Exhibit A, without the City’s permission, or a valid court order; and

(k) Conspiring with third parties to sell, publish, distribute, disclose or

otherwise use any of the information or documents obtained from the City Dropbox folders

and files listed at Exhibit A, without the City’s permission, or a valid court order; and

This Order does not apply to the lawful access to the City’s public website

(https://www.cityoffullerton.com) or any of the public social media accounts of the City or any of

000174

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28


its Departments or to documents intentionally produced in response to a Public Records Act

request.

(2) The Court will appoint a third party forensic expert to examine the computers,

servers, and storage media (e.g., hard drives, flash drives, thumb drives, CD-ROMs, DVD-ROMs,

etc.) within Defendants’ possession, custody or control, or within the possession, custody or control

of any members, employees, writers, volunteers, agents, and any persons acting on their behalf or

in concert with them, for all copies of the PST files listed at Exhibit A, for segregation and to be

held in the Court’s custody until final resolution of this matter. Each side will be permitted to make

up to three (3) recommendations for a court-appointed third party forensic expert, to be submitted

on or before _____________, 2019; and

IT IS SO ORDERED.

Dated: , 2019Honorable Thomas A. DelaneyJUDGE OF THE SUPERIOR COURT

000175

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

- 1 -EXHIBIT A

EXHIBIT A

Dropbox Folders and Files at Issue

1. The Dropbox folder named “ACUSA_PRR.zip”;

2. The Dropbox folder named “CE_PRR_KC.zip”;

3. The Dropbox folder named “council_20180430.zip,” including the 1 PST file

contained therein: “council_20180430”;

4. The Dropbox folder named “PRR_AIR20180604.zip,” including the 4 PST files

contained therein: “PRR_AIR_3,” “PRR_AIR_3-1,” “PRR_AIR_3-3,” and “PRR_AIR_3-4”;

5. The Dropbox folder named “HL_PRR.zip,” including the 2 PST files contained

therein: “HL_PRR_1” and “HL_PRR_2”;

6. The Dropbox folder named “Tiger_Signal_PRR,” including the 3 PST files

contained therein: “AUTO_PST,” “SIGNAL_PRR,” and “TigerText”;

7. The Dropbox folder named “PRR_JF_20181002.zip,” including the 13 PST files

contained therein: “JF_ANTEBELLUM,” “JF_CHIEF,” “JF_CONCERT,” “JF_CONCERTS,”

“JF_DAVE,” “JF_DAVID,” “JF_HAMEL,” “JF_HENDRICKS,” “JF_IRVINE,” “JF_OLI,”

“JF_OLIVERAS,” “JF_THOMAS,” and “JF_TOM”;

8. The Dropbox folder named “JF_PRR20181012.zip,” including the 17 PST files

contained therein: “JF_BUSHALASIGN,” “JF_CARPETBAGGER,” “JF_DOUGSWIFE,”

“JF_F.F.F.F.,” “JF_FFFF,” “JF_FriendsforFullerton,” “JF_FULLERTONS_FUTURE,”

“JF_Joshua,” “JF_JoshuaFerguson,” “JOST_FERGUSON,” “JF_MARSHALLCHAFFEE,”

“JF_MAYORSSPOUSE,” JF_MAYORSWIFE,” “JF_PAULETTE,” “JF_SIGNTHEFT”;

9. The Dropbox folder named “JF_PRR_2.zip,” including the 7 PST files contained

therein: “JF_F.F.F.F.,” “JF_FFFF,” “JF_Friends for Fullerton,” “JF_Fullerton’s Future,”

“JF_JOSH FERGUSON,” “JF_JOSHUA and “JF_JOSHUA_FERGUSON”;

10. The Dropbox folder named “PPR_Cox.zip,” including the 1 PST file contained

therein: “PPR_Cox”;

11. The Dropbox folder named “PRRS01082019.zip,” including the 1 PST file

000176

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

- 2 -EXHIBIT A

contained therein: “PRRS01082019”;

12. Dropbox folder named “PRRS01092019.zip,” including the 5 PST files contained

therein: “PRRS01092019,” “PRRS01092019_2,” “PRRS01092019_3,” “PRRS01092019_4” and

“PRRS01092019_5”;

13. The Dropbox folder named “PRRS01152019_JF.zip,” including the 22 PST files

contained therein: “Deleted Records Any Name 2018,” “Limitations Any Name 2018_1,”

“Limitations Any Name 2018_2,” “Limitations Any Name 2018_3,” “Limitations Any Name

2018_4,” “Limitations Any Name 2018_5,” “Limitations Any Name 2018_6,” “Oversight Any

Name 2018_1,” “Oversight Any Name 2018_2,” “Oversight Any Name 2018_3,” “Oversight

Any Name 2018_4,” “Oversight Any Name 2018_5,” “Personnel Files Any Name 2018,”

“Personnel Records Any Name 2018,” “Police Records Any Name 2018,” “Record Retention

Any Name 2018,” “Retention Any Name 2018_1,” “Retention Any Name 2018_2,” “Retention

Any Name 2018_3,” “Retention Any Name 2018_4,” “Retention Any Name 2018_5” and

“Retention Any Name 2018_6”;

14. The Dropbox folder named “PRRS02042019_VD_2.zip,” including the 1 PST

file contained therein: “PRRS02042019_VD_2”;

15. The Dropbox folder named “PRRS02042019_VD.zip,” including the 1 PST file

contained therein: “PRRS02042019_VD”;

16. The Dropbox folder named “[email protected],”

including the 1 PST file contained therein: “[email protected]”;

17. The Dropbox folder named “PR19-171VD_1_2.zip,” including the 2 PST files

contained therein: “PR19-171VD_1” and “PR19-171VD_2”; and

18. The Dropbox folder named “PR19-188VD.zip,” including the 2 PST files

contained therein: “PR19-188VD_1” and “PR19-188VD_2.”

000177

Doc

umen

t rec

eive

d by

the

CA

4th

Dis

trict

Cou

rt of

App

eal D

ivis

ion

3.