x?????i-ieee-20110712 ?}???? ?l???? ?????? v1 20110810

1

IEEE P1609 WG Meeting 2011 #3

Annapolis

100 07 10

100 07 16

100 08 08

2

IEEE P1609 WG Meeting 2011 #3 Annapolis

07 12 07 14 20

ITRI 2

ITRI 2 ( 1 ) 1

2

IEEE Std 1609.3-2010IEEE Std 1609.4-2010 IEEE Std 1609.11-2010

2010/12/30 2011/02/07 2011/01/09 IEEE 1609.2

2011/06/02-07/04 initial sponsor ballot IEEE 1609.0 IEEE 1609.1 IEEE

1609.12 initial sponsor ballot

IEEE 1609.2 initial sponsor ballot comment resolution

IEEE 1609.0 IEEE 1609.1 IEEE 1609.12 2

ITRI IEEE 1609.1

� IEEE 1609.0 – Architecture

� IEEE 1609.1 – Remote Management Service

� IEEE 1609.5 – Communication Management

�

�

� IEEE 1609.2 – Security Services

� IEEE 1609.12 – Provider Service Identifier Allocations

�

�

3

................................................................................................…........2

.............................................................................................4

........................................................................4

.............................................................................................4

.............................................................................................4

( )......................................................5

......................................................................................14

...................................................................................................15

4

IEEE P1609 WG Meeting 2011 #3

IEEE 1609 IEEE Std

1609.3-2010 IEEE Std 1609.4-2010 IEEE Std 1609.11-2010

2010/12/30 2011/02/07 2011/01/09 IEEE 1609.2 2011/06/02-07/04

initial sponsor ballot IEEE 1609.0 IEEE 1609.1 IEEE 1609.12

initial sponsor ballot


IEEE 1609.0 IEEE 1609.1 IEEE 1609.12

IEEE 1609.3IEEE 1609.4 IEEE 1609.11

July 12 - 14, 2011

ARINC

2525 Admiral Cochrane Drive

Annapolis, MD

U.S.A.

5

( )

IEEE 1609.0 –

Architecture IEEE 1609.1 – Remote Management ServicesIEEE 1609.5 –

Communication Management IEEE 1609.2 – Security Services for Application

and Managements IEEE 1609.12 – Provider Service Identifier Allocations

1.0 INTRODUCTION (Tuesday) T. Kurihara

1.1 Introductions (name and company)

1.2 Local arrangements G. Pruitt

1.3 IEEE Patent Policy

1.4 WG Attendance and Attendance List

1.5 Identify Meeting Secretary

1.6 Modifications to draft agenda and approval of agenda

1.7 Review of draft minutes from February 2010 meeting

2.0 REVIEW OF ACTION ITEMS T. Kurihara

Action Item Review – Status of open action items from previous meetings.

N.B. Objective to identify OPEN items and placement into this meeting agenda or to indicate

completed action and, not to discuss the technical merits at this point in the agenda.

ACTION ITEM ACTION DISPOSITION

201008-11 J. Moring to create and maintain a file of P1609.0 topics In progress

201010-01 T. Kurihara to initiate communication with IEEE SA staff by

introducing the terms sheet and the nature of the agreement

desired between IEEE and SAE.

Initiated 10/14. In

progress

201101-05 R. Roy to provide to JM the list of international standards for

P1609.0.

Open. Before July

meeting

201101-06 R. Gerges to provide an overview of network management. Open. Before July

meeting

201104-01 T. Kurihara to include July RAC meeting agenda item

regarding IEEE P1609 WG position on PSID registration for

presentation to the RAC scheduled to meet during the IEEE 802

Plenary week in July 2011

6

ACTION ITEM ACTION DISPOSITION

201104-02 T. Kurihara to extend closing date for forming P1609.2 ballot

group to May 20, 2011

Done

201104-03 T. Kurihara to (1) inquire with G. Pruitt, ARINC, if conference

room space is available to host the IEEE 1609 WG meeting July

12-14 2011; (2) if unavailable, notify J. McNew for a venue in

San Diego area

Done. Space

available information

circulated

201104-04 J. Moring to change P1609.0 PAR title, scope, and purpose from

“trial-use standard” to a “guide”

Done. Comment

from NESCOM

resolved

201104-05 J. McNew to change P1609.12 title to be more generic to include

identifiers other then PSIDs

Done

201104-06 T. Kurihara to provide information to ETSI TC-ITS about

status of IEEE VTS P1609 activities with emphasis on the

development work on P1609.1

Done

201104-07 T. Kurihara inquire if NTCIP Joint Committee

(AASHTO/ITE/NEMA) there are standards coordination topics

for the Connected Car program that requires exploration.

Done Discussion in

progress. On agenda

for July meeting

3.0 PROGRAM OF WORK T. Kurihara

3.1 P1609.1 discussion threads and review of draft (by teleconference)

A. Malarky

Status of draft, review of comments, and plans for sponsor ballot

3.2 P1609.2 discussion threads and review of draft W. Whyte

Status of revised draft, review of comments, sponsor ballot status

3.3 P1609.0 discussion threads, review of drafts J. Moring

3.4 1609.3 Corrigenda J. Moring

Status of revised draft, review of comments, plans for sponsor ballot

3.5 Overview of P1609.2, PSID Allocation J. McNew

Status of expert discussions, review of comments, and other details

Additional identifiers essential to 1609 WAVE

3.5.1 ETSI/CEN/ISO Harmonization of Identifiers (102 860)

DR. H-J Fischer

3.5.2 ETSI and ISO ITS station facilities layer

3.5.3 ETSI and ISO IPv6 projects

7

3.6 SAE J2735, J2945.1 projects and status; ETSI TC-ITS WG1 coordination

J. Kenney

3.7 Safety Pilot Information and Connected Vehicle CONOPS Workshops (Thursday

morning) W. Fehr

4.0 OLD BUSINESS

4.1 Update of certification program; test methods, coordination R. Roebuck

ETSI Plugtest and test platform development

4.2 VSC3/CAMP update J. Kenney

5.0 NEW BUSINESS T. Kurihara

5.1 IEEE Standard 802.11-2007, amendment .11p and .11ai, FILS

5.2 Changes to PSID Information for the IEEE RAC (carry-over to July) T. Kurihara

5.3 Disposition of P1609.5 PAR (expires 12/2011) or change in title, scope

J. McNew

Requirements for change from communication manager to network manager or

other requirements for consideration

5.4 Overview of network management (carry-over from April) R. Gerges

5.5 NTCIP Joint Committee and wireless connectivity, C2C, C2Field (wed 1000),

AASHTO (W. Brownlow), ITE, and NEMA standardization activities

B. Schopp

6.0 FUTURE MEETINGS (Thursday am) T. Kurihara

6.1 Discuss and determine IEEE WG meetings after July 14, 2011 T. Kurihara

6.2 Known and To Be Determined Meeting Dates (any other group meeting?

DATE MEETING, VENUE, HOST

Jul 12-14 IEEE P1609 Working Group Meeting, ARINC, Annapolis, MD

Jul 17-22 IEEE 802.11 Meeting, San Francisco, CA

Jul 21 *IEEE RAC meeting, San Francisco, CA

Jul 29 NESCOM and REVCOM submission closing date for September 8-10 meeting

Aug 18-22 ISO TC204 WG16, CALM, Kyoto Research Park (KRP), Kyoto, Japan (ITU-T

invited)

Sep 8-10 IEEE NESCOM, REVCOM, and SASB Meetings

Sep 7-9 CEN TC278 WG16/ISO TC204 WG18, Brussels, BG

Sep 18-23 IEEE 802.11 Working Group Meeting, Okinawa, Japan

Sep 20-22 Review the Core System Requirements and Architecture Proposal, 2nd Workshop,

San Jose, CA

Oct 4-5 IEEE P1609 Working Group Meeting, host and venue, TBD

8

DATE MEETING, VENUE, HOST

Oct 18 Submission closes for REVCOM and NESCOM meetings in December 5-7

Oct 10-14 ISO TC204 Plenary, Hyatt downtown, Tampa, FL

Oct 16-20 ITS World Congress, Orlando, FL

Oct 24-28 ETSI TC-ITS plenary, Sophia Antipolis, FR

Nov 6-11 IEEE 802.11 Working Group Meeting, Atlanta, GA

Dec 5-7 REVCOM, NESCOM, IEEE SASB meetings

Dec 5-9 CEN TC278 WG16/ISO TC204 WG18 meeting, Kyoto, Japan (venue TBD)

* = indicates meetings for WG Chair not related to ITS and DSRC/WAVE (for 1609 meeting scheduling purposes)

7.0 ACTION ITEM REVIEW T. Kurihara

8.0 ADJOURNMENT T. Kurihara

2011/07/12 ( )

09:20 16 William Whyte (Security

Innovation) John Kenney (Toyota) Justin McNew (Kapsch) John Moring

(Kapsch) Richard Roy (ESF GmbH)Randy Roebuck (FST)Hans-Joachim Fischer

(ESF GmbH) Carl Kain (Noblis) Wayne Fisher (ARINC)Satish K. Putta (Harman

International) Gary Pruitt (ARINC) Ravi Puwala (Savari) Robert Rausch

(Transcore) (ITRI) (ITRI) Thomas M. Kurihara (TKstds

Management) Ramez Gerges (Caltrans)Gloria Gwynne (Caltrans) Jules

Madey (New Yourk State Thruway) Ron Hochnadel (INTRASS) 4

Tom voice conferencing

Tom action item

09:55 John Moring IEEE 1609.0 IEEE 1609.3 IEEE 1609.4 IEEE

1609.5 IEEE 1609.0 PAR (Project Authorization Request)

Guide Management ID IEEE 1609.12

John Kenney safety use case Dick

system WAVE device ITS station John

Moring Tom Dick contribution

John Moring John

Moring (expand networking discusssion electronic payment use case)Randy

(certification) Alastair (1609.1/remote management)William (security) Dick

9

(Reference/list of European standards)Randy certification

IEEE 1609.2 certification

UDSOT certification interoperability IEEE

1609.0 10 sponsor ballot comments

resolution 2012/02 2012/03 IEEE REVCOM

10:45 John Moring IEEE 1609.3 IEEE 1609.3

PAR 2011/05 4 IEEE 1609

Annex G-3D locationEDCA parameter set Gateway MAC address

John Moring IEEE 802.11 Reference Carl

IEEE 802.11 TGm IEEE 802.11-2012

IEEE 1609.3 ballot

11:00 John Moring IEEE 1609.4 IEEE

1609.5 Tom IEEE 1609.5 GeoNetworking

IEEE 1609.3 connection Dick Hans-Joachim

GeoNetworking WAVE Tom

GeoNetworking IEEE 1609

ETSI TC ITS GeoNetworking

11:25 John Kenney VSC3/CAMP CAMP USDOT

V2V Communication Security (V2VCS)V2V Interoperability

(V2VI) V2V Safety Pilot (V2VSP) Scability

channel congestion control

V2VSP Dick

congestion control

John Kenney CAMP congestion control prototype

IEEE 1609 congestion control

Stanley ETSI TC ITS

CAMP

12:06

13:25 William IEEE 1609.2 initial sponsor ballot

comment IEEE 1609.2 initial sponsor ballot

2011/06/02 07/04 60 (76%) 75%

48 8 4 William ballot

comment Dick comment resolution IEEE 1609

William comment

10

teleconference comment resolution comment

� IEEE 1609.2 scope purpose ( 1.1 1.2) Dick John

Kenney William

2011/07/29 PAR

� Definition ( 3.1) Dick high layer high layer

entity William security client security

consumer functional entity payload entity Dick

issuing certificate William PKI

Dick unit WAVE unit William

WAVE device

John Kenney PSID IEEE 1609.3

William IEEE 1609.3

� WAVE protocol stack Security SAP (Service Access Point) (

4.1) David Hunter

Dick MS-SAP Management/Security

SAP SAP William

John Moring Provider Services IEEE 1609.3

IEEE 1609.3

William Provider Service Entity Advertised Service

� Certificate Hierarchy ( 4.4) Dick end-entity

William /FAQ

� ToBeEncryptedCertificateResponse ( 5.3.35) Andre

Weimerskirch CRL cr_path<2^64-1> <var>

William 2^56

� WaveSecurityServices-SignedWsa ( 6.5.2) Dieter Smely John

Moring SignWithFastVerification EC Point Format IEEE

1609.3-2010 IEEE 1609.2

John Moring

WSA secured WSA explicit

certificate uncompressed pointsJustin William

secured WSA security profile

17:40

11

2011/07/13 ( )




(ESF GmbH) Carl Kain (Noblis) Wayne Fisher (ARINC) Satish K. Putta (Harman

International) Bob Robert Rausch (NTCIP) (ITRI) (ITRI)

Thomas M. Kurihara (TKstds Management) Gloria Gwynne (Caltrans) 1

09:20 William IEEE 1609.2 initial sponsor ballot

comment John Moring WSA Fast Verification Compressed

EC Point William option

WG member mailing list William

John Kenney WSA

Fast Verication Compressed EC Point IEEE 1609.2

security profile for WSA

implement overwrite security profile

10:10 John Moring “A CRL is processed by the CME. It shall

be encapsulated as a 1609Dot2Message. If it is transmitted as a WSM, the PSID shall

be 0x17.” “encapsulate” John Moring CRL

William 1609Dot2Message IEEE 1609.2

CRL John Moring William Carl William

IEEE 1609.2

10:25 John Moring IEEE 1609.2 mandatory

implementation IEEE 1609.2

William “A compliant unit may send secure messages,

receive secure messages, send secure WSAs, receive secured WSAs, or any

combination of the above.” William “A conformant unit

may send secure messages, receive secure messages, send secure WSAs, receive

secured WSAs, or one of the functions above.”

conformant to 1609.2 William

1609.2 component

“1609.2-conformant” 1609.2 checklist

vendor 1609.2

10:50 Bruce J. Schopp, Wiiliam (Bill) Brownlow, John R. Miller ATC

(Advanced Traffic Control), NTCIP (National Transportation Communications for

ITS Protocol) NEMA (National Electrical Manufacturers Association)

12

IEEE 1609 WG NTCIP SNMP

MIB

Ethernet 3G

MIB IEEE 1609 WG

(1) DSRC SPAT (2) DSRC

Carl Safety Pilot SPAT SAE

J2735 traffic controller J2735

loss NTCIP/NEMA

information loss legacy traffic controller

Dick DSRC 3G DSRC RSU

OBU

NTCIP Dick IEEE

funding Tom IEEE

Tom

IEEE 1609 CTS, VTS, ITS IEEE

CTS VTS ITS

12:09

13:10 Randy OmniAir

HIA “Here I Am (HIA) Device Certification Pilot” to OmniAir May 2

HIA

profiling IEEE 802.11p:2010, 1609.2 (D9),

1609.3 (2010), 1609.4 (2010) SAE J2735 (200911) standards GPS

2011/08 SwRI (San

Antonio) OmniAir Qualitative

13:40 William IEEE 1609.2 initial sponsor ballot comment

IEEE 1609.2 encryption description process John Moring Dick

function Service Access Point (SAP)

functions with normative processing

functional block William

13:50 William implicit certification chain

birthday paradox IEEE 1609.2 certification chain

certificate

William (1)

(2) 64-bit hash (hash value

implicit cert chain ) 256 bits (3) implicit cert chain

3

13

14:20 Justin IEEE 1609.12 PSID

Hans-Joachim ISO ISO

PSID ISO 15628 PSID

Hans-Joachim byte value ISO 15628

CEN/TC 178 2011/09

plenary meeting ID Justin John Moring Tom

sponsor ballot AID

(Application ID) IEEE 1609.12 sponsor ballot

comment IEEE 1609.12 IEEE

1609.12 4.1.3 “At the time of publication of

this standard, PSID values are allocated as specified in Table1 and harmonized with

the list of AIDs in ISP 15628:2007” “until such time

requests for future allocations should be made to the IEEE 1609 Working Group

Chair.” Management ID IEEE 1609.1 IEEE

1609.3 IEEE 1609.0 IEEE 1609.2 IEEE 1609.5 IEEE

1609.11 reserved

16:10 Hans-Joachim IEEE1609 harmonization

PSID IEEE 1609.12

17:05

2011/07/14 ( )




(ESF GmbH) Carl Kain (Noblis) Wayne Fisher (ARINC) Satish K. Putta (Harman

International) Robert Rausch (Transcore) (ITRI) (ITRI)

Thomas M. Kurihara (TKstds Management) Alastair Malarky (Kapsch)Ramez

Gerges (Caltrans) Gloria Gwynne (Caltrans) Jules Madey (New Yourk State

Thruway) Ron Hochnadel (INTRASS) 5

Tom Walton Fehr talk “Layered Communication

Enabling V-I Applications – Connected Vehicle Core System” Walton

US DOT Workshop

high-level CA RSE/OBU

John Kenney Walton HIA

? Walton congestion control

14

congestion control application

10:20 Alastair IEEE 1609.1

Alastair survey micro-controller vendor

SNMP/IP ASIC

10:50 Tom

2011/09/27-28 Annapolis

San Diego Tom editor

2011/11/29-30 17:00

IEEE 1609

IEEE 1609.0 Guide

2011/10 sponsor ballot comments resolution

2012/02 2012/03 IEEE REVCOM IEEE

1609.1 security SNMP survey

survey 2012 initial sponsor ballot IEEE 1609.2

2011/06/02-07/04 initial sponsor ballot comment resolution

teleconference sponsor ballot IEEE Std 1609.3-2010

IEEE Std 1609.4-2010 2010/12/30 2011/02/07

IEEE Std 1609.3-2010 ballot IEEE 1609.5

2012/12

IEEE Std 1609.11-20101 2011/01/09 IEEE 1609.12

ISO ETSI CEN

Initial Sponsor Ballot Tom

15

http://vii.path.berkeley.edu/1609_wave/

IEEE P1609 WG Meeting 2011 #3 ARINC, Annapolis, MD, USA.

IEEE P1609 WG Meeting 2011 #3 Thomas M.

Kurihara ( ) IEEE 1609 Chair

16


William Whyte ( ) Security Innovation IEEE 1609.2

William Whyte Attack on implicit cert chain IEEE

1609.2

17

IEEE 1609.12 Justin McNew (

) Kapsch IEEE 1609.12

C-ITS International Harmonization Hans-Joachim

Fischer ( ) ESF GmbH ETSI TC ITS WG2 Vice-chair

ISO TC204 SWG16.1 Convenor

x?????i-ieee-20110712 ?}???? ?l???? ?????? v1 20110810

Documents