year 2 service-learning/pbl follow-up session · year 2 service-learning/pbl follow-up session ......
TRANSCRIPT
Partnerships Make A Difference 1
"Progress and Possibilities"
TALLMADGE CITY SCHOOLSYear 2 Service-Learning/PBL Follow-Up Session
"Helping Young People Develop a Sense of Passion and Purpose for Their Learning and Lives"
October 8-9, 2018
Welcome and Re-Introductions
Goals for This Session Reinforce Understanding, Skills, and Commitment Identify Connections to Tallmadge Directional System Reflect on Progress to Date Explore Promising Possibilities Identify Needs, Resources, and Next Steps
Transition Activity Group Doodle: "Great Projects"
Reinforcement of Planning Model via Video Case Study
"Progress"—What Has Been Accomplished in Our School/District So Far? Projects, Strategies, and "Lessons Learned"
Guided Planning Time—"Promising Possibilities" Mind-Mapping Use of Planning and Reflection Resources Model Projects as Mentor Texts if Needed "Possibilities"—Project Topic/Focus, Curriculum Connections, Desired Outcomes, Potential Partners, Other Info of Your Choice Re: Elements of the Model
Video and Accompanying Reflection
Next Steps/Closing Reflections
2 Partnerships Make A Difference
Investigation“"Exploring Possibilities"
• LocalandGlobalNeeds• EmotionallyEngagingEntry Event(s)• ProjectIdea(s)• DrivingQuestion(s)• NeedtoKnow• InitialInquiry• Students’Strengthsand Interests
Action/Implementation"Becoming Changemakers"
• "DoingtheWorkofReal People"• AuthenticProduct(s)/ Service(s)forAuthentic Audience(s)/Client(s)• Categories: -- DirectService -- EducationandAwareness -- Advocacy -- Philanthropy/Fundraising
“Learning by Doing
AuthenticIssueorNeedCompellingTopicor
QuestionAcademicFocus
CurriculumIntegration/Standards
21stCenturySkillsMultipleIntelligencesStudentVoice,Choice,
andPassionCollaboration/Teamwork
CareerDevelopment
Preparation/Planning“"Becoming Experts"
• ContinuedInquiry/Research• NecessaryKnowledgeand SkillDevelopment• CommunityPartners/Mentors• Logistics
Reflection (ongoing)“"Attaching Meaning"
• What?SoWhat?NowWhat?• Revision/refinementof products/servicesasneeded• Truer,deeperlearning
Demonstration/Celebration"Making Learning Visible"
• ValidationofGainsand Impact• "CapturingtheMagic"• SharingNewKnowledgewith AuthenticAudiences• Assessment• Academic+Social+ EmotionalGrowth= "LearningthatLasts"
HIGH QUALITY SERVICE-LEARNING/PROJECT BASED LEARNING
A Planning Model for “Learning with Purpose . . . Serving with Passion”
This planning model, developed and utilized by Partnerships Make A Difference, blends widely endorsed definitions and key elements of Service-Learning and Project Based Learning. The model applies the "best of both worlds" in providing educators with an authentic instructional framework that effectively integrates rigor, relevance, and relationships.
Partnerships Make A Difference 3
Video Case Study Guide
SmallGroupAssignments:
(1) Investigation/Inquiry—"ExploringPossibilities": Why did students care about their inquiry? What did they become curious about? What “entry events” did the teacher use to “hook” the students’ interest and build emotional engagement/commitment? What other strategies can you envision in this regard?(2) Preparation/Planning—"BecomingExperts": What knowledge and skills did students need to acquire to successfully complete the project? What scaffolding/support did the teacher provide to ensure the necessary learning and skill development? What curriculum connections did you see or could you envision?(3) Action—"DoingtheWorkofRealPeople": What authentic products/services were students responsible for accomplishing/creating? Who benefited from their efforts? What additional products/services might have been a good fit?(4) Reflection—"AttachingMeaning":What types of reflection and revision do you think occurred? If this were your project, what other strategies might you use?(5) DemonstrationandCelebration—"MakingLearningVisible": How did the students demonstrate/celebrate their learning and impact? Who else was involved? What other culminating strategies could you envision if this were your project?(6) StudentVoiceandChoice—What evidence did you see of student ownership and initiative? What choices do you think students had throughout the project? What other possibilities can you envision?(7) Assessment—How do you think the teacher assessed student performance for the project? If this were your project, how might you define and measure "success"?
4 Partnerships Make A Difference
Ta
llmad
geK
-8Sch
ools
Visio
n:Lea
ding
the
Fut
ure
Mission
:Tal
lmad
geC
ity
Scho
ols,in
con
nect
ion
with
ourco
mm
unity,
will
prom
ote
the
21stcen
tury
ski
llso
f;cre
ativ
ity,
critica
lthi
nkin
g,p
robl
em-
solv
ing,
col
labo
ration
,and
com
mun
icat
ion,
toe
mpo
wer
eve
rystu
dent
to
bec
ome
aco
ntribu
ting
mem
berin
ag
loba
lcom
mun
ity.
Prin
cipl
es:
•
All
teac
hing
and
lear
ning
isg
roun
ded
ina
sen
seo
fcom
mun
itya
ndtr
ustw
hich
al
low
sus
tole
arn
from
our
mista
kesan
dde
velo
pne
ww
aysto
thin
kan
ddo
.
• Te
ache
rsa
reth
ede
sign
ersan
dfa
cilit
ator
sof
cre
ativ
ean
ddi
vers
eex
perien
ces
whi
chp
rom
ote
colla
bora
tion,
com
mun
icat
ion,
pro
blem
-sol
ving
,det
erm
inat
ion,
an
dcr
itica
lthi
nkin
g.
•
Criti
cala
ndcre
ativ
eth
inki
nga
rep
rom
oted
thr
ough
inqu
iry,
see
ing
conn
ectio
ns,
appl
ying
rea
lwor
ldp
ract
ices
,env
isio
ning
pos
sibi
litie
s,a
ndref
lect
ing
onid
eas,
actio
ns,a
ndo
utco
mes
.
• Pa
rticip
atin
gin
pro
blem
–ba
sed
and
serv
ice
lear
ning
ena
bles
stu
dent
s’p
erso
nal
grow
thw
hile
mas
tering
rig
orou
sac
adem
iccon
tent
sta
ndar
dsa
sth
eycon
trib
ute
toa
glo
balc
omm
unity
.
Inst
ruct
iona
lStr
ateg
ies:
• Pr
oble
mB
ased
Lea
rnin
gan
dSe
rvice
Lear
ning
• Co
llabo
rative
and
Inte
rdiscipl
inar
yTe
achi
ng
• Diff
eren
tiatio
n
• Te
chno
logy
Inte
grat
ion
• Gui
ded
Inst
ruct
ion/
Wor
ksho
pM
odel
Trai
ts:
• Em
pow
er-h
avin
gth
eco
nfid
ence
totr
yan
dth
efree
dom
tole
arn
from
failu
re.
• Em
path
y-un
ders
tand
ing
the
feel
ings
ofo
ther
san
dde
mon
stra
ting
com
pass
ion.
• Gro
wth
Min
dset
-per
seve
ring
thro
ugh
chal
leng
esd
espi
tea
dver
sity
.
• Re
spec
t-tr
eatin
got
hers
with
hon
ora
ndd
igni
ty.
• Ada
ptab
ility
-res
pond
ing
appr
opriat
ely
tocha
ngin
gcirc
umst
ance
san
dbe
ing
able
toth
ink
flexi
bly.
Be
liefs
Insp
ire
Visio
n:
We
belie
ve:
-col
labo
ration
and
com
mun
icat
ion
enab
lesus
tow
ork
toge
ther
tosha
re
idea
s,sup
port
diff
eren
ces,a
ndb
ech
alle
nged
. -in
cel
ebra
ting
and
supp
ortin
gst
uden
tsin
all
area
sin
clud
ing
acad
emica
ndsoc
ial-
emot
iona
lne
eds.
-ina
uthe
ntica
nde
ngag
ing
lear
ning
th
roug
hrigo
rous
aca
dem
ic
expe
rien
cesin
whi
chstu
dent
sta
ke
owne
rshi
pof
thei
rle
arni
nga
ndsee
re
alw
orld
con
nect
ions
. -in
bui
ldin
gpo
sitive
,tru
stin
gre
latio
nshi
psb
etw
een
stud
ents
,sta
ff,
adm
inistr
atio
nan
dco
mm
unity.
-in
cre
atin
ga
lear
ning
env
iron
men
tfo
ral
lstu
dent
sth
ate
ncou
rage
spr
oble
m-s
olvi
ng,
critical
thi
nkin
g,
crea
tivi
tya
ndrisk
taki
ng,
and
sees
fa
iling
asa
stud
ent’sat
tem
pto
fle
arni
ng.
Part
ners
inE
duca
tion
:St
uden
ts-a
recre
ator
sof
inno
vativ
ean
den
gagi
ngp
rodu
ctsth
atd
emon
stra
ted
epth
of
und
erst
andi
ng.
Pare
nts-
are
part
ners
with
the
scho
ola
nd
com
mun
ityto
sup
port
indi
vidu
alstu
dent
su
cces
s.
Staf
f-m
embe
rsa
red
esig
ners
ofp
ositi
vea
nd
supp
ortiv
een
viro
nmen
tsw
here
stu
dent
sar
em
otiv
ated
tob
ecom
elif
elon
gle
arne
rs.
Teac
hers
- are
des
igne
rso
fexc
iting
lear
ning
op
port
uniti
esw
here
stu
dent
sar
een
gage
dto
cre
ate
and
are
mot
ivat
edto
bec
ome
lifel
ong
lear
ners
. Pr
incipa
ls-a
recre
ator
sof
pos
itive
and
in
vitin
gclim
ates
whe
resta
ffta
kesrisk
sto
in
nova
testr
ateg
iesth
ate
ngag
est
uden
ts.
Supe
rint
ende
nt-is
the
mor
ala
nd
inte
llect
uall
eade
rof
lead
ersw
ho
esta
blishe
san
dm
aint
ains
uni
fied
dire
ctio
ns
forth
esc
hool
distr
ictf
ocus
edo
nst
affa
nd
stud
ente
ngag
emen
t.
Boar
dM
embe
rs-a
rea
dvoc
ates
forth
ein
tegr
ity,
abi
lity
and
char
acte
rof
the
lear
ning
org
anizat
ion.
Co
mm
unityM
embe
rs- a
rea
col
lect
ive
grou
pof
adv
ocat
esw
hocon
trib
ute
toth
eel
evat
ions
oft
helo
cals
ocie
tyb
ysu
ppor
ting
auth
entic
lear
ning
opp
ortu
nitie
sto
eng
age
alls
tude
nts.
Partnerships Make A Difference 5
Investigation“"Exploring Possibilities"
Action/Implementation"Becoming Changemakers"
“Learning by Doing
AuthenticIssueorNeedCompellingTopicor
QuestionAcademicFocus
CurriculumIntegration/Standards
21stCenturySkillsMultipleIntelligencesStudentVoice,Choice,
andPassionCollaboration/TeamworkCharacterDevelopmentCareerDevelopment
Preparation/Planning“"Becoming Experts"
Reflection (ongoing)“"Attaching Meaning"
Demonstration/Celebration"Making Learning Visible"
HIGH QUALITY SERVICE-LEARNING/PROJECT BASED LEARNING
A Planning Model for “Learning with Purpose . . . Serving with Passion”
This planning model, developed and utilized by Partnerships Make A Difference, blends widely endorsed definitions and key elements of Service-Learning and Project Based Learning. The model applies the "best of both worlds" in providing educators with an authentic instructional framework that effectively integrates rigor, relevance, and relationships.
6 Partnerships Make A Difference
"Enhancing the Design"
Investigation“"Exploring Possibilities"
• LocalandGlobalNeeds• EmotionallyEngagingEntry Event(s)• ProjectIdea(s)• DrivingQuestion(s)• NeedtoKnow• InitialInquiry• Students’Strengthsand Interests
Investigation/Inquiry—"ExploringPossibilities"—helps kids identify potential topics and become emotionally engaged
Possible topics and project ideas are explored during this phase, and initial inquiry is set in motion. If possible, the teacher may provide experiences/activities that encourage students to think about the “big picture” regarding local and/or global needs/issues. What problems/challenges can be addressed through skills and knowledge that students are acquiring in your class? How can your students also use their strengths and interests to maximize impact? Preliminary inquiry and analysis can be undertaken using a variety of methods that will allow students
to become emotionally engaged in the topic(s). Effective “entry events” are especially important.
Brainstormasmanyideasaspossibleonthispageandthenexttoenhance/enrich/addrigortothe"Investigation"partofyourproject.
Partnerships Make A Difference 7
Investigation“"Exploring Possibilities"
• LocalandGlobalNeeds• EmotionallyEngagingEntry Event(s)• ProjectIdea(s)• DrivingQuestion(s)• NeedtoKnow• InitialInquiry• Students’Strengthsand Interests
8 Partnerships Make A Difference
"Enhancing the Design"Preparation/Planning—"BecomingExperts"—includes further research, project schedule/logistics, and scaffolding (facilitated by the teacher as needed)
As your service-learning project plan takes shape, students will continue their inquiry/research to find answers to questions that begin to surface. Students prepare to “do the work of real people,” by acquiring necessary knowledge and skills,
developing more specific project plans, and attending to logistical details. Collaboration is an integral part of project planning, including students, teachers, and community partners/mentors.
Brainstormasmanyideasaspossibleonthispageandthenexttoenhance/enrich/addrigortothe"Preparation/Planning"partofyourproject.
Preparation/Planning“"Becoming Experts"
• ContinuedInquiry/Research• NecessaryKnowledgeand SkillDevelopment• CommunityPartners/Mentors• Logistics
Partnerships Make A Difference 9
Preparation/Planning“"Becoming Experts"
• ContinuedInquiry/Research• NecessaryKnowledgeand SkillDevelopment• CommunityPartners/Mentors• Logistics
10 Partnerships Make A Difference
"Enhancing the Design"Action—"DoingtheWorkofRealPeople"—includes Authentic Product(s)/Service(s) for Authentic Audience(s)/Client(s). The project design identifies "important stuff" that kids will create and/or accomplish and indicates who else will be part of/become aware of/benefit from the students’ efforts.
The key to high quality, curriculum-based service-learning is engaging students in authentic “professional” work that addresses significant issues/needs. Students become scientists, researchers, writers, filmmakers, historians, political scientists, website developers, statisticians, artists, etc. Their work products/services can take the form of direct service, education
and awareness, advocacy, and/or philanthropy/fundraising.
Brainstormasmanyideasaspossibleonthispageandthenexttoenhance/enrich/addrigortothe"Action/Implementation"partofyourproject.
Action/Implementation"Becoming Changemakers"
• "DoingtheWorkofReal People"• AuthenticProduct(s)/ Service(s)forAuthentic Audience(s)/Client(s)• Categories: -- DirectService -- EducationandAwareness -- Advocacy -- Philanthropy/Fundraising
Partnerships Make A Difference 11
Action/Implementation"Becoming Changemakers"
• "DoingtheWorkofReal People"• AuthenticProduct(s)/ Service(s)forAuthentic Audience(s)/Client(s)• Categories: -- DirectService -- EducationandAwareness -- Advocacy -- Philanthropy/Fundraising
12 Partnerships Make A Difference
"Enhancing the Design"Reflection—"AttachingMeaning"—extends the learning by helping students attach individual and collective meaning to their experiences. As we plan for reflection, it is important to address the following. What reflection questions/prompts should we consider? What reflection strategies/forms of student expression should we include?
Reflection is the connector between each stage of service and also summative. Through reflection students consider their thoughts and feelings (cognition and affect) regarding any overarching essential ques-tion or inquiry that is a driving force of the total experience. Reflection informs how the process develops, increases self- awareness, assists in developing future plans, and employs varied multiple intelligences. Cathryn Berger Kaye, M.A., CBK Associates © 2012
Brainstormasmanyideasaspossibleonthispageandthenexttoenhance/enrich/addrigortothe"Reflection"partofyourproject.
Reflection (ongoing)“"Attaching Meaning"
• What?SoWhat?NowWhat?• Revision/refinementof products/servicesasneeded• Truer,deeperlearning
Partnerships Make A Difference 13
Reflection (ongoing)“"Attaching Meaning"
• What?SoWhat?NowWhat?• Revision/refinementof products/servicesasneeded• Truer,deeperlearning
14 Partnerships Make A Difference
"Enhancing the Design"DemonstrationandCelebration—"MakingLearningVisible"—makes learning visible, reinforces relationships, and "captures the magic of the project" by documenting the process, its outcomes, and related next steps
Student demonstration captures or contains the totality of the experience, including what has been learned, the process of the learning, and the service or contribution accomplished. Beginning with investigation, students document all parts of the process, resulting in a complete and comprehensive ability to tell the story of what took place during each stage that includes key informative reflection. Students draw upon
their skills and talents in the manner of demonstration, often integrating technology. Cathryn Berger Kaye, M.A., CBK Associates © 2012
Brainstormasmanyideasaspossibleonthispageandthenexttoenhance/enrich/addrigortothe"Demonstration/Celebration"partofyourproject.
Demonstration/Celebration"Making Learning Visible"
• Assessment• ValidationofGainsand Impact• "CapturingtheMagic"• SharingNewKnowledgewith AuthenticAudiences• Academic+Social+ EmotionalGrowth= "LearningthatLasts"
Partnerships Make A Difference 15
Demonstration/Celebration"Making Learning Visible"
• Assessment• ValidationofGainsand Impact• "CapturingtheMagic"• SharingNewKnowledgewith AuthenticAudiences• Academic+Social+ EmotionalGrowth= "LearningthatLasts"
16 Partnerships Make A Difference
Partnerships Make A DifferenceService-Learning/PBL Planning Notes
Theme/Topic
Brainstorming Team Members
THE BIG IDEA
Issue/ServiceFocus: Who needs our help? What issue needs our attention?
Learning/AcademicFocus: What will we be learning about? What could our "Driving/Essential Question(s)" be? How will this service-learning/PBL project connect to your curriculum goals/content standards? What 21st Century Skills (e.g., collaboration, communication, critical thinking, creativity, etc.) might be addressed?
ProjectIdea: What can we do to address the identified need/issue? What community partner(s) might be involved?
Student“VoiceandChoice”: What strengths, interests, passions, and local/global awareness do students “bring to the table”? How can we build upon and utilize these assets?
Partnerships Make A Difference 17
POTENTIAL STRATEGIES/IDEAS FOR EACH STAGE OF YOUR SERVICE-LEARNING/PBL PROJECTEntryEvents—emotionally engaging “kick-off” activities that "set the stage" and serve as a “hook” for student interest and active learning
Investigation/Inquiry—"ExploringPossibilities"—helps kids identify potential topics/sub-topics, become emotionally engaged, and conduct initial inquiry/research
Preparation/Planning—"BecomingExperts"—includes further research/”expert groups,” project schedule/logistics, and scaffolding (facilitated by the teacher as needed)
Action—"DoingtheWorkofRealPeople"and“BecomingChangemakers”... AuthenticProduct(s)/Service(s)—identifies "important stuff" that kids will create and/or accomplish AuthenticAudience(s)/Client(s)—identifies who else will be part of/become aware of/benefit from the students’ efforts
18 Partnerships Make A Difference
Reflection—"AttachingMeaning"—extends the learning by helping students attach individual and collective meaning to their experiences. What reflection questions/prompts should we consider? What reflection strategies/forms of student expression should we consider?
DemonstrationandCelebration—"MakingLearningVisible"—makes learning visible, reinforces relationships, and “captures the magic of the project” by documenting the process, its outcomes, and related next steps
Partnerships Make A Difference 19
Partnerships Make A Difference: Consultant Bios
Ellen Erlanger was a teacher and administrator in Canton, Ohio and Upper Arlington, Ohio, for 30 years and was involved in service-learning, career development, character education, vocational education, guidance, staff development and community education throughout that time. In addition to fulfilling her local program responsibilities, she provided consultation, training and technical assistance to other public and private schools on a regional, statewide, and national basis. Ellen retired from the Upper Arlington City Schools in December 2002 and is now Vice President of Legacy Consulting Group and a consultant with Partnerships Make A Difference, a non-profit corporation providing training and educational materials development. Ellen has authored a variety of instructional materials and education-related articles as well as other books, works of poetry, and newspaper and magazine articles. During her leadership, the Upper Arlington City School District achieved the rare distinction of having all three of their secondary schools selected by the Corporation for National Service as “National Service-Learning Leader Schools.” Ellen holds a B.A. and M.A. from the University of Michigan.
Kathy Meyer, a teacher, guidance counselor, and administrator in Ohio for more than 30 years, served as an administrator for the Worthington City Schools from 1985 to 2000 and supervised service-learning, career development, character education, vocational education, guidance, science, and after-school and summer school programs. Under her leadership, Worthington was selected as a model school district by Learn and Serve Ohio. Kathy retired from the Worthington Schools in December 2000 and is currently President of Legacy Consulting Group. In addition, she is associated with Partnerships Make A Difference. In these roles, Kathy has authored and published a variety of instructional materials and provided related training programs in many public and private schools throughout Ohio and a number of other states. Over the years, she served in a number of leadership positions, including President of the Ohio Career Education Association. Kathy holds a B.A. from Wittenberg University and an M.A. from Wright State University.
As a part of their work with Partnerships Make A Difference, Ellen and Kathy have provided leadership for the “Growing Together” Service-Learning Network, which currently includes more than 45 central Ohio schools and 20-plus community agencies. In addition, they have provided in-depth professional development programs, curriculum development, and technical assistance in Project Based Learning, Service-Learning, and Career Development for a variety of school districts and organizations, including: Ridgemont Local Schools (OH), Zanesville City Schools (OH), Four-District Consortium (OH), Six-District Educational Compact (OH), Columbus (OH) Catholic Diocese, Fairborn City Schools (OH), Union Local Schools (OH), Northwest Ohio ESC (OH), Oakland County (MI) Schools, Birmingham (MI) Schools, Archdiocese of Los Angeles/Los Angeles Unified School District (CA), Loyola Marymount University (CA), University of New Mexico (NM), Gadsden Independent School District (NM), Albuquerque Public Schools (NM), Zuni Public Schools (NM), Learn and Serve Ohio (several regional and statewide training grants), and Ohio Department of Education (several regional and statewide training grants). Sponsors of their work have included American Electric Power Foundation (OH), ServeOhio, The Columbus Foundation (OH), Martha Holden Jennings Foundation (OH), Harry C. Moores Foundation (OH), Siemer Family Foundation (OH), Feinstein Foundation (national “Good Deeds” program based in Rhode Island), World of Children, Inc. (NY/NJ/MI/OH), New Mexico Commission For Community Vol-unteerism (NM), and Kellogg Foundation.
Partnerships Make A Difference is a nonprofit organization whose mission is to help young people develop a sense of passion and purpose for their own learning, and to enhance students’ belief that they can positively impact their own lives and the lives of others.
20 Partnerships Make A Difference
Partnerships Make A DifferenceContact Information
Ellen Erlanger, Consultant(C) [email protected]
Kathy Meyer, Consultant(C) [email protected]
Mailing Address:Partnerships Make A Difference1601 W. Fifth Ave., #106Columbus, Ohio 43212
Website: www.partnershipsmakeadifference.org
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Partnerships- Make-A-Difference-104692573211453/
Twitter: @partnershipsmak
Partnerships Make A Difference 21
ADDITIONAL RESOURCES
22 Partnerships Make A Difference
Partnerships Make A Difference 23
24 Partnerships Make A Difference
Partnerships Make A Difference 25
26 Partnerships Make A Difference
Partnerships Make A Difference 27
28 Partnerships Make A Difference
Partnerships Make A Difference 29
30 Partnerships Make A Difference
Partnerships Make A Difference 31
32 Partnerships Make A Difference
Partnerships Make A Difference 33
34 Partnerships Make A Difference
Dreaming + Doing = Aspirations
Educators know that something powerful happens when dreaming and doing
come together; students have aspirations. Students with strong aspirations show
that they have dreams for the future, and are inspired to do what it takes in the
present to work toward their fulfillment.
-- Russel J. Quaglia, President/Founder,
Quaglia Institute for Student Aspirations
A Student with Purpose is a Student with Unlimited Promise
The most successful students I know are clear about who they are and
what they believe in; they are not afraid to show it and are confident they
will make a difference in this world. That is called purpose.
Even though our ultimate goal in education is to ensure all students reach
their full academic potential, we do not want to graduate bright kids who
lack social and personal skills. We do not want to graduate students who
are devoid of curiosity and creativity, or who lack a spirit of adventure. We
want to graduate bright young people who have the confidence to take
action, are responsible leaders, and are genuine heroes to those whose
lives they touch.
-- Russel J. Quaglia, President/Founder,
Quaglia Institute for Student Aspirations