zara ali, cory carlson, daniella comito & emma hebblethwaite valuation
TRANSCRIPT
AGENDA
Company Overview Industry Overview
CompetitorsValue DriversRisk AnalysisRatio Analysis
Dividend Discount ModelFree Cash Flow Model
Valuation Using MultiplesRecommendation
COMPANY OVERVIEW
Founded in 1969Headquarters: Stamford Connecticut 1,162 Properties100 Different Countries171,000 Employees9 Brands
St. Regis, The Luxury Collection, W Hotels, Westing, Le Meridien, Sheraton, Four Points, Aloft & Element
SWOT ANALYSIS
Strengths
• Nine unique brands• Brand loyalty• World’s most award-winning
loyalty program
Weaknesses
• Not a strong global presence• Economy has customers
reducing their spending
Opportunities
• Digitalized media as a new source of revenue
• Economy has customers looking for packages
• Vacation ownership is a growing market
Threats
• Highly competitive industry• Is affected by many different
economies
INDUSTRY OVERVIEW
Lodging Industry Service Sector
Mature Industry
Delivers Specialized Services to Customers
8 Hotel Classifications Commercial, Airport, Conference, Economy, All-Suite,
Residential, Casino & Resort
INDUSTRY TRENDS
Booking Room Process Internet
Additional Luxury Furniture, Complimentary Breakfast, WIFI
Smoke-Free
“Destination” Theme Decor
TOP COMPETITOR
Marriot International
Net Income: $571 Billion
3,800 Properties
74 Countries
7 Brands
Other Top Competitor: Hyatt Hotels Corporation
VALUE DRIVERS
Award Winning Loyalty Program Increases Brand Loyalty Increases Customer Experience
Many Locations Wide Customer Base
Element Brand First LEED-certified Hotel Brand Environmentally Friendly is a Growing Trend
RISK ANALYSIS
Data Breach Identity Theft Loss of Credibility Costly Recover
Identify Areas of Exposure Risk Management Program
Industry High Competition
Geographical & Brand Diversification Loyalty Program
RISK ANALYSIS CONTINUED
Staff Poached by Competitors High Training Costs
Economy in Recovery
Tax & Law/Regulation Higher Tax & Higher Regulation Increase Costs
Currently No Government Talk
FINANCIAL RATIO ANALYSIS
Liquidity 2012 2011 2010 Industry
Current Ratio 0.95 1.27 1.21 1.16
Quick Ratio 0.27 0.26 0.25 1.05
Asset Management 2012 2011 2010 Industry
Inventory Turnover 6.52 2.42 2.24 14.78
Days sale outstanding 55.98 150.82 162.95 24.7
Total Asset Turnover 0.71 .59 0.52 0.24
• Reduced Ability to Pay Current Debt• Highly Dependent on their Inventory to cover
Debt
• High Volume of Sales• Reduced Time it takes to Receive Cash• Asset Efficiency has Increased
FINANCIAL RATIOS CONTINUED
Debt Management 2012 2011 2010 Industry
Total Debt Ratio 65% 69% 75% 46.6%
Times Interest Earned 5.24 3.15 2.39 11.79
Profitability Ratios 2012 2011 2010 Industry
Profit Margin 8.89% 8.69% 9.41% 6.6%
Return on Total Assets 6.34% 5.12% 4.88% 1.08%
Return on Equity 17.92% 16.55% 19.30% 2.53%
• Less Dependent on Creditors• Increased Ability to Pay Interest
• $0.09 of Net Income per Dollar of Sales• $0.06 of Net Income per Dollar of Assets• ROE Dominates the Industry
FINANCIAL RATIOS CONTINUED
Market Value Ratios 2012 2011 2010 Industry
Price/Earnings ratio 19.70 17.71 19.30 33.18
Market/Book Ratio 3.75 2.94 3.29 2.23
• Investors Willing to Pay $19.70 per Dollar of Profits• Industry is Higher
• $3.75 per Book Value of Shares• Higher than Industry
BETA
Regression: 2.33601704 Chose to Use this as our Beta
Yahoo! Finance: 1.91
Google Finance: 2.33
MSN Money:2.13
Conclusion: Twice as Risky as the Market
CAPITAL ASSET PRICING MODEL
Cost of Equity Capital = rf + (rm – rf) β
rf = 30 Year Treasury Bond Rate = 3.65% Use Treasury Bond because Firm may have Unlimited
LifeMarket Risk Premium = 2%
Low Risk/Mature Industry
Ri = 3.65% + (2%) * 2.33 = 8.31%
DDM Non-Constant Growth - Using 11.11%Horizon Year
r = 8.31%0 1 2 3 4 5 6
g= 11.11% g=11.11% g=11.11% g=11.11% g=11.11% g=11.11% g= 2.2%
D0 = $1.35D1 = D0 (1+g) = $1.35 (1.1111) = $1.50D2 = D1 (1+ g) = $1.50 (1.1111) = $1.67D3 = D2 (1+g) = $1.67 (1.1111) = $1.86D4 = D3 (1+g) = $1.86 (1.1111) = $2.07D5 = D4 (1+g) = $2.07 (1.1111) = $2.30D6 = D5 (1 + g) = $2.30 (1.022) = $2.35
P5 = D6r-g
P5 = 2.35/ 8.31% -2.2%P5 = $38.46
CF0 = 0CF1 = 1.50CF2 = 1.67CF3 = 1.86CF4 = 2.07CF5 = (2.30 + 38.46) = 40.76NPV = $33.12
• Uses Growth Percentage From Plow Back Equation
• Chose to Use this DDM
DDM Non-Constant Growth - Using 6.79%Horizon Year
r = 8.31%0 1 2 3 4 5 6
g= 6.79% g= 6.79% g= 6.79% g= 6.79% g= 6.79% g=11.11% g= 2.2%
D0 = $1.35D1 = D0 (1+g) = $1.35 (1.0679) = $1.44D2 = D1 (1+ g) = $1.44 (1.0679) = $1.54D3 = D2 (1+g) = $1.54 (1.0679) = $1.64D4 = D3 (1+g) = $1.64 (1.0679) = $1.75D5 = D4 (1+g) = $1.75 (1.0679) = $1.87D6 = D5 (1 + g) = $1.87 (1.022) = $1.91
P5 = D6r-g
P5 = 1.91/ 8.31% -2.2%P5 = $31.26
CF0 = 0CF1 = 1.44CF2 = 1.54CF3 = 1.64CF4 = 1.75CF5 = (1.87 + 31.26) = 33.13NPV = $27.43
• Uses Growth Estimated By Historical Dividend Growth
• This DDM shows Sensitivity
PROJECTED UNLEVERED FREE CASH FLOW
Fiscal Year 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
Net Income 2,294,462.80
2,356,458.39
2,646,526.78
2,970,388.13
3,331,979.33
3,735,695.90
Depreciation & Amortization 170,000
242,774.44
271,057.66
302,635.88
337,892.96
377,257.49
Total Other Non-Cash Adjustments
113,145.90
126,327.40
141,044.54
157,476.23
175,822.21
196,305.50
Net Operating Cash Flow 2,577,608.70
2,725,560.23
3,058,628.98
3,430,500.24
3,845,694.50
4,309,258.89
Capital Expenditures
$(1,034,136.61)
$(1,093,494.76)
$(1,227,121.95)
$(1,376,316.69)
$(1,542,892.63)
$(1,728,874.67)
Other Investments $ (809,626.89)
$ (856,098.47)
$ (960,715.36)
$(1,077,520.12)
$(1,207,932.64)
$(1,353,538.22)
Net Cash Flow from Operating Activities
$(1,843,763.50)
$(1,949,593.23)
$(2,187,837.31)
$(2,453,836.82)
$(2,750,825.27)
$(3,082,412.88)
Interest Expense 170,000 170,000 170,000 170,000 170,000 170,000
Levered Free Cash Flow 4,591,372.20
4,845,153.46
5,416,466.28
6,054,337.05
6,766,519.77
7,561,671.77
Tax Shield 36,601 36,601 36,601
36,601
36,601 36,601
Unlevered Free Cash Flow 4,554,771.20
4,808,552.46
5,379,865.28
6,017,736.05
6,729,918.77
7,525,070.77
WEIGHT AVERAGE COST OF CAPITAL
Cost of Equity
Cost of Debt
Debt to Value
Equity to Value
WACC Terminal WACC
8.31% 4.45% 50.15% 49.85% 5.59% 4.27%
Years 1 2 3 4 5 6
Unlevered Free Cash Flow
4,554,771
4,808,552
5,379,865
6,017,736
6,729,919 7,525,071
Terminal Value 363,530,000
• Cost of Debt=Treasury Yield (3.65%)+ BBB Credit Rating (0.80%)
• Equity to Value=Market Value of Equity ÷ Total Value of Debt & Equity
($14,146,843,700) ÷ ($28,376,843,700)
• Stabilize after 5 Years to Constant Growth of 2.2%
• Terminal Value = 7,525,071 ÷ (.047 - .022) = 363,530,000 Year 6 CF ÷ (Terminal WACC – Constant Growth Rate)
FREE CASH FLOW VALUATION
CF0=0
CF1=4,554,771
CF2=4,808,552
CF3=5,379,865
CF4=6,017,736
CF5=6,729,919+363,530,000
Terminal WACC=4.27
NPV=319,034,417
1. Value the Firm
Firm Value (+) Cash & Marketable Securities
(-) Long Term Debt
Equity Value
$319,034,417
$463,000 $3,695,000 $35,802,417
2. Find Value of Equity
3. Value Stock Price
Equity Value ($35,802,417) ÷ # of Diluted Outstanding Shares (194,000,000)
= $184.55
VALUATION USING MULTIPLES
EPS: 3.3
Industry P/E: 25.98 Found by Averaging 12 Competitors
Marriott P/E: 22 Very Close to Industry
Stock Price = $85.73 Market Price = $73.87 Undervalued by $11.86
CONCLUSION
Valuation Method Stock Price
P/E Ratio $85.73
DDM $33.12
FCF $184.55
Weighted Average $104.21
20% P/ELess Accurate
Simple
40% DDMCredible
40% FCFIn Depth Analysis
RECOMMENDATION
Current Trading Price = $73.87
Intrinsic Value = $104.21
Undervalued by $30.34
Recommendation = Buy!