(Triangulation)

()

(Triangulation) l(Triangulation)

(Triangulation)

(1) (2)(3)

i]21{-

4

[1][J] 2010(1)6465

[2][J] 2012(17)122123

[3][J]2011 (28)8081

( 105)

[1]PattonMQualitative Evaluation and Research MethodsNewbury

ParkCASage1990

[2] 2003102103

[3]CohenLManionL and MorfisonKResearch Methods in Educa tionLondonRoutledge2000

[4]participantasobserverwho isa part of the social life of partiei pantsLeCompteMand PreissleJEthnography and Qualitative Design in Educational Research(2 )LondonAcademic Press Ltd 1993

[5]ph ysjcalhumaninteraetional and programme settingMorrisonK RBPlanning and Accomplishing Schoolcentred EvaluationNor-

folkPeter Francis Pnblishers1993

[6]WilsonNand McleanSQuestionnaire Designa Practical Introduc tionNewton AbbeyCoAntfimUniversity of Ulster Press994

[7]comparisons to be made across groups in the sampleOppenheimA NQuestionnaire DesignInterviewing and Attitude Measurement LondonPinter Publishers Ltd1992

[8]BrymanASocial Research Methods(2 )OxfordOxford University Press2004

[9]RobsonCReal World ResearchOxfordBlackwell2005 [10]

2003144 [1 1]TuckmanBWConducting Educational ResearchNew YorkHar

court Brace Jocanovich1972

[12][] 1997235

[13]CohenLManionLand Mon'isonKResearch Methods in Educa tionLondonRoutledge2000

[14]BrymanASocial Research Methods(2 )OxfordOxford Univer- sity Press2004

[15]MilesMBand HubermanAMQualitative data analysis(2nd ed)Thousand OaksCASage1994

[15] () 1997316

[16] 200524(5)

072013 167