排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有 treatment of voiding dysfunction by urethral injection of...
TRANSCRIPT
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Treatment of Voiding Dysfunction by Urethral Injection of
Botulinum A toxin
Hann-Chorng KuoHann-Chorng Kuo
Department of UrologyDepartment of Urology
Buddhist Tzu Chi General HospitalBuddhist Tzu Chi General Hospital
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Voiding Dysfunction
Neurogenic detrusor external sphincter Neurogenic detrusor external sphincter dyssynergiadyssynergia
Dysfunctional voiding due to spastic Dysfunctional voiding due to spastic urethral sphincterurethral sphincter
Poor relaxation of sphincter & low detrusor Poor relaxation of sphincter & low detrusor contractilitycontractility
Detrusor underactivity or Detrusor failureDetrusor underactivity or Detrusor failure Detrusor areflexiaDetrusor areflexia
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Therapeutic modalities for voiding dysfunction Medication: alpha-blocker, skeletal muscle Medication: alpha-blocker, skeletal muscle
relaxants, nitric oxide donorsrelaxants, nitric oxide donors Behavioral therapy: biofeedback, electrical Behavioral therapy: biofeedback, electrical
stimulation, neuromodulationstimulation, neuromodulation Surgery: transurethral sphincterotomy, TUI-Surgery: transurethral sphincterotomy, TUI-
bladder neck, urethral stentbladder neck, urethral stent Clean intermittent catheterizationClean intermittent catheterization Indwelling Foley catheter or cystostomyIndwelling Foley catheter or cystostomy
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Background of Botulinum A toxin Botulinum A toxin is an inhibitor of acetylcBotulinum A toxin is an inhibitor of acetylc
holine release at the presynaptic neuromuscholine release at the presynaptic neuromuscular junctionular junction
Inhibition of acetylcholine release results in Inhibition of acetylcholine release results in regional decreased muscle contractility at thregional decreased muscle contractility at the injection sitee injection site
This chemical devervation is a reversible prThis chemical devervation is a reversible process, axons resprout in about 3-6 monthsocess, axons resprout in about 3-6 months
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Clinical usefulness of Botulinum A toxin Focal dystonia, blepharospasm (Scott et al 1Focal dystonia, blepharospasm (Scott et al 1
985)985) Dysphonia (Whurr et al 1993)Dysphonia (Whurr et al 1993) Limb spasticity ( Hesse et al 1994)Limb spasticity ( Hesse et al 1994) Dysphagia (Schneider, et al 1994)Dysphagia (Schneider, et al 1994) No severe adverse effects ever reported No severe adverse effects ever reported
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Clinical application of botulinum A toxin in voiding dysfunction Botulinum A toxin 20-80 U successfully treBotulinum A toxin 20-80 U successfully tre
ated 11 SCI & DESD (Dykstra et al 1988)ated 11 SCI & DESD (Dykstra et al 1988) In 21 of 24 SCI & DESD, BTX-A toxin 100 In 21 of 24 SCI & DESD, BTX-A toxin 100
U reduced residual urine and MUCP (SchurU reduced residual urine and MUCP (Schurch et al 1996)ch et al 1996)
Transperineal injection of BTX-A in 6 SCI iTransperineal injection of BTX-A in 6 SCI improved voiding function (Schurch et al 19mproved voiding function (Schurch et al 1997)97)
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Clinical application of botulinum A toxin in voiding dysfunction Relief of voiding dysfunction due to prostatitis in Relief of voiding dysfunction due to prostatitis in
4 men (Maria et al 1998)4 men (Maria et al 1998) Improved bladder capacity and decreased maximal Improved bladder capacity and decreased maximal
detrusor pressure after BTX-A in 5 SCI (Gallien et detrusor pressure after BTX-A in 5 SCI (Gallien et al 1998)al 1998)
Effective in treating DESD (12), pelvic floor spastEffective in treating DESD (12), pelvic floor spasticity (8), and acontractile detrusor (1) by BTX-A icity (8), and acontractile detrusor (1) by BTX-A 80-100 IU (Michael et al 2001)80-100 IU (Michael et al 2001)
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Improved Voiding Efficiency
Increased detrusor contractility in detrusor uIncreased detrusor contractility in detrusor underactivity – nerve stimulation, increased nderactivity – nerve stimulation, increased nerve densitynerve density
Reduced urethral resistance – urethral smooReduced urethral resistance – urethral smooth muscles and striated musclesth muscles and striated muscles
Recovery of detrusor contractility in idiopatRecovery of detrusor contractility in idiopathic detrusor acontractilityhic detrusor acontractility
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Patients suitable for Botulinum A toxin Treatment Patients with voiding dysfunction who were Patients with voiding dysfunction who were
refractory to medication or behavioral therapyrefractory to medication or behavioral therapy Chronic SCI & DESD with low empty efficiency Chronic SCI & DESD with low empty efficiency Cauda equina lesion and difficult urinationCauda equina lesion and difficult urination Peripheral neuropathy and difficult urinationPeripheral neuropathy and difficult urination Dysfunctional voiding Dysfunctional voiding Idiopathic detrusor underactivity Idiopathic detrusor underactivity Poor relaxation of urethral sphincterPoor relaxation of urethral sphincter
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Enrolled Patients Criteria
Patient is unable to void spontaneously, indwellinPatient is unable to void spontaneously, indwelling catheter, or on CISCg catheter, or on CISC
Difficult urination with low Qmax and large residDifficult urination with low Qmax and large residual urineual urine
Moderate to severe obstructive IPSS (>10 points)Moderate to severe obstructive IPSS (>10 points) High voiding pressure (>50 cm water) & low flow High voiding pressure (>50 cm water) & low flow
rate (Qmax <10ml/s) during urodynamic studyrate (Qmax <10ml/s) during urodynamic study Poor relaxation or hyperactivity of sphincter EMG Poor relaxation or hyperactivity of sphincter EMG
activity during pressure flow studyactivity during pressure flow study
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Pretreatment evaluation
Conventional treatment at least 3 monthsConventional treatment at least 3 months Cystoscopy to exclude anatomical BOOCystoscopy to exclude anatomical BOO Postvoid residual urine volumePostvoid residual urine volume Videourodynamic study: voiding pressure, aVideourodynamic study: voiding pressure, a
bdominal leak point pressure, Qmax, sphincbdominal leak point pressure, Qmax, sphincteric EMG activity, urethral patency in VCteric EMG activity, urethral patency in VCUGUG
Obstructive score in IPSSObstructive score in IPSS
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Obstructive symptom scoresand Quality of life index (IPSS) Residual urine sensation or retention 0-5Residual urine sensation or retention 0-5 Intermittency 0-5Intermittency 0-5 Small caliber of urine or retention 0-5Small caliber of urine or retention 0-5 Straining to void 0-5Straining to void 0-5
Quality of life index 0-6Quality of life index 0-6 Indwelling Foley catheter or on CISCIndwelling Foley catheter or on CISC
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Botulinum A toxin therapy
100 units (1vial) is diluted to 2ml100 units (1vial) is diluted to 2ml 50-100 units are used, 4 equivalent aliquot ar50-100 units are used, 4 equivalent aliquot ar
e injected via cystoscopy guide in men and are injected via cystoscopy guide in men and around the urethra in womenound the urethra in women
Complete cardiorespiratory monitoring in ORComplete cardiorespiratory monitoring in OR Foley catheter is indwelled for 1 dayFoley catheter is indwelled for 1 day Report adverse effect (AD, hematuria, UTI)Report adverse effect (AD, hematuria, UTI)
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Evaluation of Treatment Outcome Subjectively improved in voiding efficiencySubjectively improved in voiding efficiency Increase in voided volumeIncrease in voided volume Reduction of residual urine volumeReduction of residual urine volume Decrease of voiding pressure (detrusor or Decrease of voiding pressure (detrusor or
abdominal pressure)abdominal pressure) Decrease in frequency of catheterizationDecrease in frequency of catheterization Removal of indwelled Foley catheterRemoval of indwelled Foley catheter
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Clinical Results after Botulinum A toxin Urethral injection 50 –100 units of botulinum A toxin injected 50 –100 units of botulinum A toxin injected
to urethral striated musclesto urethral striated muscles Effect appears 2-3 days after injectionEffect appears 2-3 days after injection Detrusor pressure or abdominal leak point pDetrusor pressure or abdominal leak point p
ressure decreased and facilitate spontaneous ressure decreased and facilitate spontaneous voidingvoiding
Minimal adverse effect was notedMinimal adverse effect was noted
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Materials & Methods
A total of 103 patients received urethral BotA total of 103 patients received urethral Botox injectionox injection
48 men and 55 women48 men and 55 women Aged 16 to 94, mean 54 years oldAged 16 to 94, mean 54 years old 45 patients had urinary retention45 patients had urinary retention 48 patients received 50U, 55 patients receiv48 patients received 50U, 55 patients receiv
ed 100U ed 100U
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Diseases and Enrolled Patients
Dysfunctional voiding Dysfunctional voiding 2020
Detrusor hyperreflexia & external sphincter dyssynergiaDetrusor hyperreflexia & external sphincter dyssynergia 2929
Poor relaxation of urethral sphincterPoor relaxation of urethral sphincter 1919
Cauda equina lesion and detrusor areflexiaCauda equina lesion and detrusor areflexia 88
Detrusor underactivity or detrusor failureDetrusor underactivity or detrusor failure 1313
Detrusor areflexia due to peripheral neuropathyDetrusor areflexia due to peripheral neuropathy 1414
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Outcome assessment
Excellent: (1) spontaneous voiding by reflex or abExcellent: (1) spontaneous voiding by reflex or abdominal straining in urinary retention patients; (2) dominal straining in urinary retention patients; (2) improvement in voiding pressure (Pabd or Pdet), improvement in voiding pressure (Pabd or Pdet), Qmax, and residual urine by >25%Qmax, and residual urine by >25%
Improved: improvement in voiding pressure, QmaImproved: improvement in voiding pressure, Qmax, and residual urine but <25%, patient is satisfactx, and residual urine but <25%, patient is satisfactory to therapeutic effectory to therapeutic effect
Failed: subjectively no improvement, persistent urFailed: subjectively no improvement, persistent urinary retention, or persistent large residual urineinary retention, or persistent large residual urine
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Therapeutic Results of Urethral Botox for Voiding Dysfunction
ExcellentExcellent ImprovedImproved FailureFailure
DV (n=20)DV (n=20) 6 (30%)6 (30%) 14 (70%)14 (70%) 00
DESD (n=29)DESD (n=29) 8 (27.6%)8 (27.6%) 15 (51.7%)15 (51.7%) 6 (20.7%)6 (20.7%)
PRES (n=19)PRES (n=19) 8 (42.1%)8 (42.1%) 7 (36.8%)7 (36.8%) 4 (21.1%)4 (21.1%)
CE (n=8)CE (n=8) 5 (62.5%)5 (62.5%) 1 (12.5%)1 (12.5%) 2 (25%)2 (25%)
DF (n=13)DF (n=13) 8 (61.5%)8 (61.5%) 4 (30.8%)4 (30.8%) 1 (7.7%)1 (7.7%)
DA (n=14)DA (n=14) 5 (35.7%)5 (35.7%) 6 (42.9%)6 (42.9%) 3 (21.4%)3 (21.4%)
Total (n=103)Total (n=103) 40 (38.8%)40 (38.8%) 47 (45.6%)47 (45.6%) 16 (15.5%)16 (15.5%)
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Therapeutic Results of Urethral Botox for Voiding Dysfunction
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
DV DESD PRES CE DF DA
Excellent
Improved
Failure
-
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Changes in Urodynamic Parameters in All Patients with Successful Results
BaselineBaseline Post-BotoxPost-Botox P valueP value
CapacityCapacity 321.5±144.5321.5±144.5 317.5±147.5317.5±147.5 0.8180.818
Voiding Voiding pressurepressure
62.8±40.462.8±40.4 42.8±31.342.8±31.3 0.0000.000**
QmaxQmax 7.1±6.47.1±6.4 10.6±6.410.6±6.4 0.0000.000**
PVRPVR 226.4±164.8226.4±164.8 88.8±111.588.8±111.5 0.0000.000**
N= 66N= 66
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Urethral Botox in Treatment ofDysfunctional Voiding 20 patients with dysfunctional voiding20 patients with dysfunctional voiding 7 men and 13 women7 men and 13 women High voiding pressure & a hyperactive High voiding pressure & a hyperactive
urethral sphincter activityurethral sphincter activity 6 had excellent result, 14 had improved 6 had excellent result, 14 had improved
result, no failed caseresult, no failed case Success rate was 100%Success rate was 100%
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Changes in Urodynamic Parameters in Patients with Dysfunctional Voiding
BaselineBaseline Post-BotoxPost-Botox P valueP value
CapacityCapacity 233.8±110.9233.8±110.9 256.3±144.8256.3±144.8 0.4430.443
QmaxQmax 10.7±7.110.7±7.1 10.3±4.810.3±4.8 0.8030.803
Voiding Voiding pressurepressure
46.8±25.146.8±25.1 31.1±12.031.1±12.0 0.008 0.008 **
PVRPVR 141.7±135.9141.7±135.9 57.3±63.457.3±63.4 0.026 0.026 **
N= 16N= 16
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Urethral Botox in Treatment of Poor Relaxation of Sphincter 19 patients (12 men & 7 women) had a low 19 patients (12 men & 7 women) had a low
voiding pressure and intermittent sphincter voiding pressure and intermittent sphincter activity during voidingactivity during voiding
8 had excellent result, 7 had improved 8 had excellent result, 7 had improved result, 4 failed (all had psychological result, 4 failed (all had psychological disorder)disorder)
In 5 patients with retention, 3 had excellent In 5 patients with retention, 3 had excellent and 1 had improved resultand 1 had improved result
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Changes in Urodynamic Parameters in Patients with Poor Relaxation of Urethral Sphincter
BaselineBaseline Post-BotoxPost-Botox P valueP value
CapacityCapacity 403.0±148.4403.0±148.4 401.5±126.6401.5±126.6 0.9790.979
QmaxQmax 10.9±7.910.9±7.9 16.6±8.316.6±8.3 0.1760.176
Voiding Voiding pressurepressure
39.6±26.339.6±26.3 27.9±13.927.9±13.9 0.0910.091
PVRPVR 161.6±149.4161.6±149.4 24.3±25.124.3±25.1 0.034 0.034 **
N= 8N= 8
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Urethral Botox in Treatment of DESD 29 patients with DESD, 24 men & 5 women29 patients with DESD, 24 men & 5 women 27 had spinal cord lesion, 2 had multiple 27 had spinal cord lesion, 2 had multiple
sclerosissclerosis 8 had excellent result, 15 had improved 8 had excellent result, 15 had improved
result, 6 failedresult, 6 failed 4 patients with retention had excellent result4 patients with retention had excellent result High pressure or low pressure DESD had High pressure or low pressure DESD had
similar success rate (84.6% v 75%)similar success rate (84.6% v 75%)
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Changes in Urodynamic Parameters in Patients with DESD
BaselineBaseline Post-BotoxPost-Botox P valueP value
CapacityCapacity 243.3±106.3243.3±106.3 236.3±109.3236.3±109.3 0.8600.860
QmaxQmax 6.8±5.76.8±5.7 9.2±7.79.2±7.7 0.0770.077
Voiding Voiding pressurepressure
45.7±22.745.7±22.7 30.7±15.530.7±15.5 0.016 0.016 **
PVRPVR 160.2±124.0160.2±124.0 104.6±134.6104.6±134.6 0.2270.227
N= 18N= 18
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Urethral Botox in Treatment of Cauda Equina Lesion 8 patients with cauda equina lesion8 patients with cauda equina lesion 4 men and 4 women4 men and 4 women 5 had excellent, 1 had improved result5 had excellent, 1 had improved result In 6 patients with urinary retention, 4 had eIn 6 patients with urinary retention, 4 had e
xcellent result, 1 improvedxcellent result, 1 improved Repeat urethral Botox injection was necessaRepeat urethral Botox injection was necessa
ry in 1 with hypertonic sphincterry in 1 with hypertonic sphincter
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Changes in Urodynamic Parameters in Patients with Cauda Equina Lesion
BaselineBaseline Post-BotoxPost-Botox P valueP value
CapacityCapacity 454.7±86.4454.7±86.4 493.9±146.4493.9±146.4 0.4450.445
QmaxQmax 1.3±0.51.3±0.5 7.7±7.97.7±7.9 0.0650.065
Voiding Voiding pressurepressure
75.1±43.275.1±43.2 52.7±48.052.7±48.0 0.2070.207
PVRPVR 445.7±99.8445.7±99.8 200.0±214.1200.0±214.1 0.042 0.042 **
N=7N=7
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Urethral Botox in Treatment of Detrusor Failure 13 patients with detrusor failure or underact13 patients with detrusor failure or underact
ivity, 1 man & 12 womenivity, 1 man & 12 women 8 had excellent, 4 had improved result8 had excellent, 4 had improved result All 7 patients with retention could void afteAll 7 patients with retention could void afte
r urethral Botox treatmentr urethral Botox treatment Detrusor contractions reappeared in patients Detrusor contractions reappeared in patients
with detrusor failurewith detrusor failure
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Changes in Urodynamic Parameters in Patients with Detrusor Failure
BaselineBaseline Post-BotoxPost-Botox P valueP value
CapacityCapacity 360.5±153.1360.5±153.1 354.3±142.4354.3±142.4 0.8640.864
QmaxQmax 7.5±6.57.5±6.5 9.8±4.89.8±4.8 0.2910.291
Voiding Voiding pressurepressure
54.9±30.954.9±30.9 38.5±19.338.5±19.3 0.025 0.025 **
PVRPVR 242.1±180.4242.1±180.4 95.4±75.995.4±75.9 0.034 0.034 **
N= 12N= 12
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Urethral Botox in Treatment of Detrusor Areflexia 14 women had detrusor areflexia after 14 women had detrusor areflexia after
previous radical hysterectomyprevious radical hysterectomy Patients voided by abdominal strainingPatients voided by abdominal straining 5 had excellent, 6 had improved result5 had excellent, 6 had improved result 2 failed cases had bladder neck obstruction2 failed cases had bladder neck obstruction Improved voiding noted after TUI-BNImproved voiding noted after TUI-BN 1 patient received 21 patient received 2ndnd injection successfully injection successfully
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Reduction of Abdominal Voiding Pressure in Detrusor Areflexia after Radical Hysterectomy
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Changes in Urodynamic Parameters in Patients with Detrusor Areflexia
BaselineBaseline Post-BotoxPost-Botox P valueP value
CapacityCapacity 405.4±139.4405.4±139.4 404.8±181.0404.8±181.0 0.9920.992
QmaxQmax 4.5±4.64.5±4.6 8.3±4.68.3±4.6 0.1120.112
Voiding Voiding pressurepressure
118.1±65.6118.1±65.6 92.3±51.192.3±51.1 0.033 0.033 **
PVRPVR 329.3±130.4329.3±130.4 195.0±186.9195.0±186.9 0.025 0.025 **
N= 14N= 14
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
The Urethral Pressure Profile Parameters at Baseline and after Botulinum Toxin Injection
BaselineBaseline Post-BotoxPost-Botox Statistics*Statistics*
MUCP (cm water)MUCP (cm water) 97.1±31.797.1±31.7 51±23.2 51±23.2 0.027 0.027 **
FPL (cm)FPL (cm) 3.35±0.593.35±0.59 3.30±0.333.30±0.33 0.7730.773
MUCP=maximal urethral closure pressure, FPL=functional profile length,
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Factors for an Effective Urethral Botox Injection Adequate dose of Botulinum A ToxinAdequate dose of Botulinum A Toxin Exact injection into urethral sphincterExact injection into urethral sphincter Hyperactive urethral sphincter is less Hyperactive urethral sphincter is less
favorable than non-relaxing sphincterfavorable than non-relaxing sphincter Psychological inhibition of sphincter Psychological inhibition of sphincter
relaxation is less favorable than organic relaxation is less favorable than organic non-relaxing sphincternon-relaxing sphincter
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Relationship of Therapeutic Results and Botox Dose
ExcellentExcellent ImprovedImproved FailureFailure
50 Unit (n=48)50 Unit (n=48) 1919 2222 77
100 Unit (n=55)100 Unit (n=55) 2121 2525 99
Total (n=103)Total (n=103) 4040 4747 1616
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Relationship of Therapeutic Results and Botox Dose
19
2122
25
79
0
5
10
15
20
25
Excellent Improved Failure
50 Unit
100 Unit
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Relationship of Therapeutic Results and Voiding Pressure
ExcellentExcellent ImprovedImproved FailureFailure
High pressure High pressure voiding (n=33)voiding (n=33)
10 (30.3%)10 (30.3%) 21 (63.6%)21 (63.6%) 2 (6%)2 (6%)
Low pressure Low pressure voiding (n=70)voiding (n=70)
30 (42.9%)30 (42.9%) 26 (37.1%)26 (37.1%) 14 (20%)14 (20%)
Chi-square test, p= 0.063Chi-square test, p= 0.063
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Relationship of Therapeutic Results and Voiding Pressure
1921
2225
7
9
0
5
10
15
20
25
Excellent Improved Failure
High pressurevoiding
Low p r e s s u r evoid n g
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Changes in Urodynamic Parameters in Patients with High Voiding Pressure
BaselineBaseline Post-BotoxPost-Botox P valueP value
CapacityCapacity 221.3±107.7221.3±107.7 257.8±140.2257.8±140.2 0.2220.222
QmaxQmax 9.7±6.79.7±6.7 10.1±6.110.1±6.1 0.7450.745
Voiding Voiding pressurepressure
52.1±23.352.1±23.3 33.3±14.133.3±14.1 0.0000.000**
PVRPVR 141.9±133.2141.9±133.2 92.5±128.192.5±128.1 0.2030.203
N= 24N= 24
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Changes in Urodynamic Parameters in Patients with Low Voiding Pressure
BaselineBaseline Post-BotoxPost-Botox P valueP value
CapacityCapacity 377.2±136.8377.2±136.8 364.2±160.2364.2±160.2 0.5310.531
QmaxQmax 5.8±6.15.8±6.1 10.0±6.910.0±6.9 0.000 0.000 **
Voiding Voiding pressurepressure
69.2±53.869.2±53.8 50.5±41.750.5±41.7 0.0000.000**
PVRPVR 271.5±166.9271.5±166.9 116.8±141.7116.8±141.7 0.0000.000**
N= 50N= 50
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Relationship of Therapeutic Results and Sphincter Activity
ExcellentExcellent ImprovedImproved FailureFailure
Sphincter Sphincter Hyperactivity Hyperactivity (n=68)(n=68)
22 (32.4%)22 (32.4%) 36 (52.9%)36 (52.9%) 10 (14.7%)10 (14.7%)
Sphincter HypoaSphincter Hypoactivity (n=35)ctivity (n=35)
18 (51.4%)18 (51.4%) 11 (31.4%)11 (31.4%) 6 (17.1%)6 (17.1%)
Chi-square test, p= 0.103Chi-square test, p= 0.103
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Relationship of Therapeutic Results and Sphincter Activity
32.4%
51.4% 52.9%
31.4%
14.7%
17.1%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
Excellent Improved Failure
SphincterHyper a c t i v i t y
SphincterHypo a c t i v i t y
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Changes in Urodynamic Parameters in Patients with Sphincter Hyperactivity
BaselineBaseline Post-BotoxPost-Botox P valueP value
CapacityCapacity 268.7±130.0268.7±130.0 271.7±139.3271.7±139.3 0.8890.889
QmaxQmax 9.0±6.79.0±6.7 11.1±7.311.1±7.3 0.0700.070
Voiding Voiding pressurepressure
44.4±23.944.4±23.9 29.9±13.729.9±13.7 0.0000.000**
PVRPVR 154.6±128.4154.6±128.4 71.8±101.071.8±101.0 0.0020.002**
N= 43N= 43
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Changes in Urodynamic Parameters in Patients with Sphincter Hypoactivity
BaselineBaseline Post-BotoxPost-Botox P valueP value
CapacityCapacity 406.9±132.2406.9±132.2 410.1±156.5410.1±156.5 0.9080.908
QmaxQmax 4.5±5.34.5±5.3 8.7±5.48.7±5.4 0.0040.004**
Voiding Voiding pressurepressure
88.8±56.488.8±56.4 64.4±45.764.4±45.7 0.0000.000**
PVRPVR 329.9±162.2329.9±162.2 158.2±162.7158.2±162.7 0.0000.000**
N=31N=31
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Relationship of Therapeutic Results with Age and Sex
ExcellentExcellent ImprovedImproved FailureFailure
Male (n=48)Male (n=48) 1414 2424 1010
Female (n=55)Female (n=55) 2626 2222 77
P=0.153P=0.153
Age < 50 years (n=39)Age < 50 years (n=39) 1010 1818 1111
Age Age >> 50 years (n=64) 50 years (n=64) 3030 2828 66
P=0.018 P=0.018 **
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Relationship of Therapeutic Results with Age and Sex
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Male Female Age < 50years
Age >50years
Excellent
Improved
Failure
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Presumptive Causes for Patients Failed Urethral Botox Treatment NOCENOCE SexSex AgeAge DiseaseDisease DoseDose ReasonReason
11 MM 6262 PRESPRES 100100 PsychogenicPsychogenic
22 FF 3131 PRESPRES 100100 PsychogenicPsychogenic
33 MM 3030 PRESPRES 100100 PsychogenicPsychogenic
44 MM 5959 PRESPRES 5050 PsychogenicPsychogenic
55 MM 3131 DESDDESD 100100 Low detrusor contractilityLow detrusor contractility
66 MM 4343 DESDDESD 5050 Low detrusor contractilityLow detrusor contractility
77 MM 3939 DESDDESD 5050 Sphincter Hyperactivity Sphincter Hyperactivity
88 MM 3333 DESDDESD 100100 Bladder outlet obstructionBladder outlet obstruction**
99 MM 2626 DESDDESD 100100 Sphincter Hyperactivity Sphincter Hyperactivity
1010 MM 5353 DESDDESD 100100 Low detrusor contractilityLow detrusor contractility
1111 FF 1414 CECE 5050 Low detrusor contractilityLow detrusor contractility
1212 MM 3636 CECE 100100 Sphincter Hyperactivity Sphincter Hyperactivity
1313 FF 8080 DFDF 5050 Low detrusor contractilityLow detrusor contractility
1414 FF 6464 DADA 5050 Bladder neck obstructionBladder neck obstruction**
1515 FF 4848 DADA 100100 Bladder neck obstructionBladder neck obstruction
1616 FF 4848 DADA 100100 Sphincter Hypertonicity Sphincter Hypertonicity
* Voiding is smooth after transurethral incision of bladder neck
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Return of Detrusor Contractility after Botulinum A toxin injection In 7 patients, return of detrusor contractility In 7 patients, return of detrusor contractility
was noted at 1- 2 months after botulinum A was noted at 1- 2 months after botulinum A toxin injectiontoxin injection
Frequency, urgency or urge incontinence deFrequency, urgency or urge incontinence developed in 6 patients with detrusor underactveloped in 6 patients with detrusor underactivityivity
Rhythmic detrusor contractions developed iRhythmic detrusor contractions developed in one SCI patients with DESD and dysurian one SCI patients with DESD and dysuria
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Adverse Effects of Botulinum A Toxin No urinary tract infection developedNo urinary tract infection developed One 15 y/o girl had high fever lasting for 2 One 15 y/o girl had high fever lasting for 2
weeks after injection (failed case with weeks after injection (failed case with reduced MUCP & leak pressure)reduced MUCP & leak pressure)
Six women had mild incontinence during Six women had mild incontinence during sleep (2 DV, 4 DA)sleep (2 DV, 4 DA)
排尿障礙治療中心 版權所有
Conclusions
Botulinum A toxin in 50-100 units is effective in rBotulinum A toxin in 50-100 units is effective in reducing urethral resistance and facilitate voiding eeducing urethral resistance and facilitate voiding efficiency in 84.5% of patients with voiding dysfunfficiency in 84.5% of patients with voiding dysfunction and 82.9% of detrusor underactivity ction and 82.9% of detrusor underactivity
Patients with chronic retention may have a chance Patients with chronic retention may have a chance to urinate by abdominal straining after botulinum to urinate by abdominal straining after botulinum A toxin injectionA toxin injection
Good quality of life without catheter was achieved Good quality of life without catheter was achieved after botulinum A toxin therapyafter botulinum A toxin therapy