سنوات الخوف / years of fear

8/8/2019 Years of Fear /

1/118


2/118

Years of Fear

Truth and Justice for the enforceddisappearances in Syria


3/118

Transitional Justice in the Arab World Project


4/118

1970

198049


5/118


6/118


7/118


8/118

1

2

3

4

1

1821162000

19791999314513920084

20082008 2007

2003


9/118

20091979


10/118

1970


11/118

1970

3.5 4.4 6.4 4.6 3.1197051960 6

78

22919871 5

22

20056

55567

HannaPatatuSyria`sPeasantrytheDescendantsoItslesserRuralNotablesandtheirpoliticPrincetonNJPrincetonUniversitypress1999

19581946819491963819581949 19611958 19631958


12/118

1963

19701949

1973

91973

1031081111010795

2007

200009

20021973

10


13/118

11101100

197311

1987


14/118

12

652571531559.5%

13

1965 9000001419916850007000065000 1965 2004

1520047000005300001991

12

MiddleEastWatchCommitteeedSyriaUnmaskedthesuppressionohumanrightsbytheregime

NewHavenYaleuniversitypress1991

13

AlanGeorgeSyrianeitherbreadnorreedomLondon ;NewYorkzedBooks2003p2314VolkerPrethesTePoliticalEconomyoSyriaunderAsadLondonNewYorkIBauris1995

pp14114515


15/118

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1965 1991 2005

19634001665398197119923743321981

1.008.24317

16AlanGeorgeSyrianeitherbreadnorreedomLondon ;NewYorkzedBooks2003pp71Alan GeorgeSyrianeither bread nor reedompp101715.066199716.320200020 200413.782 19941960 6.30519709.046 1981

4.565


16/118

18

1984

8718


17/118

1980197919

19


18/118

201971

21

19631972 1971 19691973

22 19731138197419801976 280610252

23

5.419762000

12

241971

197331251950

12%20

21Hanna BatatuSyria`s peasantrythe Descendants o Its lesser Rural Notablesand their politics pp26026122VokerPerthesthepoliticalEconomyoSyriaunderAsadPP135140

23HannaBatutuSyria


19/118

26

27

28

1973

197312

197229

1962 30

200219732627PatrickSealeAsadoSyriaPP279

2792802829HannaBatutuSyria`sPeasantrypp26226530


20/118

31

19791973197819751980321975719761972 22

5519631976250019735 33

1977

8

171968931142004

1987 311995

32VolkerPerthesTePoliticalEconomyoSyriaunderAsadpp28

51733VolkerPerthesTePoliticalEconomyoSyriaunderAsadP109114


21/118

34

3519793616

1980

2737

381964 1975

16 342000

35VolkerPerthesTePoliticalEconomyoSyriaunderAsadP147153354442000

RegimethebyRightsHumanoSuppressionTeUnmaskedSyriaedCommitteeWatchEastMiddle

1991PressUniversityYaleHavenNew

Alasdair DrysdaleTe succession Question in SyriaMiddle East JournalVol39N2Spring 1985P93111omas kozynovskyRiaat AlassadOrientVol41984P465470shrcwww20021636org279120002

6831985Hanna Batatu Syrias Muslim Brothers MERIPReports Vol 12 November December 1982 No110P122037PatrickSealAsadandtheStruggleortheMiddleEastpp532533

200126wwwshrcorg 38ItzchakWeismannSa`idHawwaandIslamicRevivalisminBa`thistSyriaStudiaIslamicaNo851997pp;131154andItzchakWeismannSa`idHawwaTeMakingoaRadicalMuslimTinkerinModernSyriaMiddleEasternStudiesVol29No4October1993pp601623


22/118

197330 197519761976

1979

39 1979 4

1979

19807494041

39MiddleEastwatchCommitteeedSyriaUnmaskedP163185

2852001198217198074940

49153335063514441


23/118

22

1980

6

1979

4243 1978 30 99.61% 19788

1981

1982150005000 180044

53425198042

4501970 43

HannaBatatuSyriasPeasantrytheDescendantsoItsLesserRuralNotablesandtheirpoliticsNewJerseyPrincetonUniversityPress1999

53754044Nikolaos Van Dam Te Struggle For Power in Syria Sectarianism Regionalism and ribalism inpolitics19611978LondonGroomHelm1979TomasFriedmanFromBeiruttoJerusalemNewYorkFarrarStrausandGiroux1989p76105


24/118

45

46

1982 4748

49

DavidRobertsTeBathandtheCreationoModernSyriaLondon1987P128ReymondHinnebuschAuthoritarian Power and state ormation in Bathist Syria ArmyPartyandPeasantSanFrancisco1990P291300FredH LawsonSocialBasesortheHamahRevoltMeripReportsNovemberDecember1982P2428RobertFiskTeimesLondon19February198212000166167199311982

19871Michel SeuratLEtat de barbarie ParisEditions du Seuil1989

45HannaBatatuSyria


25/118

199050

19841984

51

1987

198049

19385019771975197719901979wwwaljazeeranet3122005511920

1920


26/118

52

53

1995

1995

198049

54

2000

5253

54RazanZeitounehandAbdulHaAlSayyedCanExtraordinaryCourtsEnsureJusticeSupremeStateSecurityCourtDamascusCenterorHumanRightsStudiesDCHRSMay2007


27/118

20062006

2005


28/118


29/118


30/118

2

3

4

558

59

58

2006200959


31/118

198260198027

61

62

198049

63

200150 64

65

1982 60

222006187199919802761

432006 6219801998200963

6465


32/118

2008

66

1973

251973

1

2

28

66SyriaDisclose Fate o DetaineesHuman Rights Watch July 32009

httpwwwhrworgennews20090703syriadiscloseatedetaineesSyriaLi Blackout on Prisoners FateHuman Rights WatchDecember 102009

httpwwwhrworgennews20091210syrialiblackoutprisonersate


33/118

6

69

5

1952

6

26

72

252242


34/118

1

2

43

104

1

2

105

385

359

2

367 1

237


35/118

1

1

2

3

4

1

2

2 1 3

2


36/118

3

14

1

2

3

4

5

6

7


37/118

14161969

1963


38/118

293 260

873369

459427

586573

117

8

9

11

14

1969

74


39/118

1969525549

200893069

47

1950

2

27

61

53

67

Nikolaos Van DamTe Struggle For Power in Syriapp567167


40/118

6819638

196382

196338

69 70737271 74

7568

69

41121110 702252531967

71319328451971

73619935821721996611097380581519754012111074

3101975


41/118

3

76

77

6

76

200777httptharwacommunitytypepadcomsyrianelector200707html


42/118

293260

873369

2459427

586573

1963 78196429

79

1982

1964

82842008119182000782008797275199132

26626922000


43/118

80 81

82

83

196576

3

39680

155157200710

15681 821162001

httpwwwaljazeeranetNRexeres2782922BCE354FEBB8299A20F7DD007Ahtm196583


44/118

19

19921992172984

1963 18

85196623

httpwwwshrcorgdataaspx004RESEARSHaspx84

85NikolaosVanDamTeStruggleForPowerinSyriapp8194


45/118

196717196625

1967

1967817 109 2

8619678141091966225

4

86


46/118

1966 8719648988

1982 1980713219678171092109

90

911985330

wwwmoustaatlassorg871888819672889

90httpwwwshrcorgdata 91

aspx005BOOKSaspx


47/118


48/118

199119841983

94

1967

196832847

6196517

httpwwwshrcorgdataaspx004RESEARSHaspx94


49/118

95

1965176 1973

9697

2831968479596

278

286

285

307Far rom Justice Syria`s Supreme State Security Court Human Rights Watch HRWFebruary 2497

2009 httpwwwhrworgenreports20090223arjustice0


50/118

98

99

100

29

196915 1416

19695409

3016101 74 1969 1 25 14 5 25 549

1969

1969125143016

1998252249105200699

httpwwwhrworgar 100news20090224


51/118

16

30

196952554910174

74

196911514101

2

367

247

1 391

2

247545 534 353 534

30


52/118


53/118

105

197119712400 106

1973

148 1071971

53 19798

198049

1980749

105Ibidpp27911106

20074774107


54/118

1979 53

49 530198078 108

109

151980110

19821710820099109

httpwwwthisissyrianet20090909writers05html2009110


55/118

30

1980 30 198077


56/118

1980 49

49

1980713219688171092109 111

1979616

54 32

111


57/118

11219801979 13

139147

httpwwwshrcorgdataaspx012BOOKSaspx112


58/118

113

1183813 1980627

114

10

115

1981

1982 25000 3500015000

1165000

httpbeirutindymediaorg 113200928ar200306301shtml

253262114

19801025019809 1161980 18 1980 25198011198011980 Middle East Watch, Syria Unmasked :The Suppression of Human Rights by the Asad Regime, Yale

Univ Press, 1991, for more about that see: Fisk, Robert, Pity the Nation, London, Touchstone, 1990

pp.87- 181,Time (Newspaper), Syria: Bloody Challenge to Assad, London, Monday, Mar. 08, 1982.

Time (Newspaper), Syria: Battle of Hama, London, Monday, Mar. 29, 1982. Read more: http://www.

time.com/

1983MDE 240483

1982


59/118

291976730236

117

11820001500

196198 65

httpwww200811 236117200915elaphcomElaphWebPolitics20082303313htm

15 httpwwwatehorumscomshowthreadphp?t109420 1182009


60/118


61/118


62/118

1980

1700020091980 % 4.3

120

2009 120


63/118


64/118


65/118

24

1

2

121

1988525

122

121Communication 5401993Celis Laureano vPeru views 25 March 1996 para8.5 Communication5421993Katombe Lshishimbi vZaireviews 26 March 1996para5.5 Communication 4401990Yousse ElMegreisi v the Libyan Arab Jamahiriya para 5.4 Communication 4491991 Mojica v

Dominican Republicpara5.7Te European Convention on Human RightsNo one shall be subjected to torturehttpwww122

facatorgenspipphp?article638


66/118

123

124

125

123A PsychoMoral Support to the amilies o victims o enorced disappearance By Khurram Parvez

Association o Parents o Disappeared Persons KashmirIndiahttpwwwediecorgareasdescriptionconsequences#c186124

2009125


67/118

1980126

127

2009126127

httpwwwictjnetarabicmemoralizationarhtm


68/118

128

129

2009128

httpwwwediecorgareasdescriptionconsequences#c186129


69/118

1301980

1614

1980

131

2009130

2009131


70/118

132

29

133

134

httpwwwicrcorgwebarasiteara0nshtmlallmissinginterview270807?opendocument13220091332009134


71/118

135

1980

136

20091352009136


72/118

1500751371981

2009137


73/118

6 24

138

202

203

204

2009138


74/118

139

24

140

2009139

2009140


75/118

1949812

141

ECN42006918 February 2006141


76/118

14230

21112005142


77/118


78/118

724

143

1980

144

143 2005

2000Human Rights Watch144Syria UnmaskedTe Suppression o Human Rights by the Asad Regime1990MED 240483 1983MDE 240495 1995MDE MDE 2400195 1999

240142001 2001


79/118

1453920041980

2004 4000

147

146

200314 7000

145

ECN420056523 December 2004198910146199010 1991 %99.981991219921991199272000

200720012003147


80/118

13347 199218

20031999148

200519901979 20062005

20061979

2007

149

1989

1979

150

200826

20031481492008 31

2007200615150


81/118

19891979

HRW

AMNESY 151

1980 152 153

1980

2006151152Middle East Watch Syria Unmasked Te Suppression o Human Rights by the AsadRegimepp60153Ibidpp60


82/118

1980154

1991

2005

198020052

17000

1995

200428

40155

200920082007

17000

154Ibidpp612009155


83/118

156

AHRC9NGO30

358

2003156


84/118


85/118

37 13

1632 161 1981 9

162

49 163

198026

1980132

164

1980 19821982

41469CNE161

1622001 4 253261

1980311631993164


86/118

500165

1661502005167

16826

1980

1979 Middle East WatchSyria UnmaskedTe Suppression o Human Rights by the Asad Regimepp16165

KoelblSusanneSYRIAA 101 Course in Mideast DictatorshipsDer SpiegelBrlin 02212005166

19791989

httpwwwspiegeldeinternationalspiegel0151834324200html167

1964

14 57 19791963Middle East Watch Syria UnmaskedTe Suppression o Human Rights by the Asad Regimepp130

198031168


87/118

1979 1982

169

1979

17060001982

19851984

291989

17000

1982 169 Middle East Watch Syria Unmasked Te Suppression o Human Rights by the AsadRegimepp130

Ibidpp6162170


88/118

141983ECN4

1980 1984

211984ECN4

198523151985ECN4198624 19858

E 181986CN4

1987429E 171988CN4

200321198032200219821994

2002

32


89/118

271413

702003ECN4

21 362004 2019941980242003

3611 13636

15

2005

562006ECN415

2007

25

2005131619801712006

20051994

4024

200623 171


90/118

A61289

1996

200829 AHRC9

NGO30


91/118

172

173ouvier

172GeorgeEmileIraniApologiesandReconciliationMiddleEastRitualsakingWrongsSeriouslyApologiesandReconciliationEditedbyElazarBarkanandAlexanderKarnStanordUniversitypress200520062005173

737


92/118

ANC

174

175

1990176199919971994199420042001

174

httpwwwarabtjorgnewsphp?idC15175Louis Bickord Te Encyclopedia o Genocide and Crimes Against HumanityMacmillan ReerenceUSA2004vol3pp10451047176Kritz Neil ed 1995 ransitional Justice How Emerging Democracies Reckon with FormerRegimesVolsIIIIWashingtonDCUSInstitute o Peace Press


93/118

177

178

179

180

181

177BoraineAlexJanet Levyand Ronel Scheereds1997Dealing with the PastCape ownSouthAricaInstitute or Democracy in South Arica and CrockerDA1999Reckoning with PastWrongsA Normative Framework Ethics &International Aairs 134361178HaynerPriscilla 2002Unspeakable ruths Facing the Challenge o ruth CommissionsNewYork Routledge and Zalaquett Jose 1993Introduction to the English Edition In ChileanNational Commission on ruth and ReconciliationReport o the Chilean National Commission onruth and Reconciliation transPhillip EBerrymanSouth BendIndUniversity o Notre DamePress

179BassiouniMCheried2000PostConictJusticeNew Yorkransnational Publishers180232004200420032004181


94/118

1

182

183

30182

200522004183


95/118

184

261974

185

4 184Hayner Priscilla 2002 Unspeakable ruths Facing the Challenge o ruth

Commissions

New York

Routledge

7 185aking Conict Intrstate and Commissions ruth Apology RotbergI Robert and Barkan Elazar by EditedReconciliation and Apologies Seriously Wrongs

3348P2006PressUniversityStanordKarnAlexander


96/118

2

3

186 187

wwwictjorg 186 187

2004


97/118

188

280

1894

wwwictjorg188

200420032004189


98/118

1

2

3190

191

wwwictjorg190wwwictjorg191


99/118


100/118


101/118

196

197198

199519871984

wwwictjorg19630197200520051982004

2005


102/118


103/118


104/118

1

2

3

4


105/118

5

49


106/118


107/118


108/118

30

199

70

200

httpwwwediecorg EDIEC199200200820025


109/118

13347

201199218

10

2006 17761 200620

202

2

httpwww1umneduhumanrtsarabb053html2012007202

200720072007


110/118

1948 10 3 217

194912

196616 21 2200 196949197623

663 1955

19771362207619573124

1985 29 34 40

19901411145

4639

198726198410127199628

203

53150RESA10March1999203


111/118

1 2

3

4

1962122251

1

2

3


112/118

4

5

6


113/118

293 260

8733692459427

5865737

8

9

102

11

12

195892716213

162


114/118

162

162

14

19678171091966225 2

19678141091

196765

2

3

4


115/118

5

6

7

8

9

1968817

196832847

1


116/118

2

3

4

5

6

196517

6

7


117/118

8

9

10

11

3016101741969125141969525549

196912514301616

30

19695255491017474

196911514101

19804949 198077


118/118

1

2

3

4

5

سنوات الخوف / years of fear

Documents