04-02-2005/amvdbint. ws saltdome shower array slac 3-4 feb. 20051 neutrino detection in salt domes...

25
04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb . 2005 1 Neutrino Detection Neutrino Detection in in Salt Domes under Salt Domes under LOFAR LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller Instituut (KVI), Groningen, NL Kernfysisch Versneller Instituut (KVI), Groningen, NL International Workshop on International Workshop on Saltdome Shower Array Saltdome Shower Array uclear physics research

Post on 23-Jan-2016

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 1

Neutrino Detection in Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFARSalt Domes under LOFAR

Ad M. van den BergAd M. van den BergKernfysisch Versneller Instituut (KVI), Groningen, NLKernfysisch Versneller Instituut (KVI), Groningen, NL

International Workshop onInternational Workshop on Saltdome Shower ArraySaltdome Shower Array

nuclear physics research

Page 2: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 2

OutlineOutline

High-Energy High-Energy Program Program

ZEchstein SAlt Neutrino Array (ZESANA)Directly linked to

– LOFAR and its CR program (KVI, Uni Nijmegen, ASTRON)– development of next generation of radio and signal-

processing techniques– cross calibration with other experiments (PAO ?)

Page 3: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 3

National APP topics in NL*National APP topics in NL*

Compact Objects (GRB’s, mergers, collapsers, magnetars, SNR’s)

Dark Matter & Exotic ParticlesFundamental Physics

*Preliminary streamlining by “Comité Astrodeeltjesfysica Nederland” CAN

Page 4: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 4

Messengers and DetectorsMessengers and Detectors

• Messengers– Cosmic Rays and ’s– Gravitational waves

• Detectors– LOFAR/PAO/Extensions– ANTARES/KM3NeT (deep-sea)– (mini-Grail, LISA-p)

& THEORY& THEORY

Page 5: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 5

New site in the NetherlandsNew site in the Netherlands

Page 6: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 6

LOFAR: Low Frequency ArrayLOFAR: Low Frequency Array• interferometer in frequency range of 10 - 200

MHz• array of 100 stations of 100 dipole antennas• baselines of 10 m to 400 km• fully digital: received waves are digitized and

sent to a central super computer (IBM Blue Gene @ university of Groningen)

• Science:– Cosmology: HI at z >10 (époque of re-

ionization)

– Surveys: >108 new sources

– All-Sky monitor: transient eventsSee http://www.lofar.org

Page 7: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 7

LOFAR: a digital telescopeLOFAR: a digital telescope

All-sky map from LOFARs Initial Test Station: 30 MHz (10-40), 60 antennas, 3o resolution.

Courtesy: Michiel Brentjes ASTRON/RUG

Page 8: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 8

LOFAR: a sensor networkLOFAR: a sensor network

Courtesy: KNMI NL

Page 9: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 9

LOFAR as CR or LOFAR as CR or detector detector

from: Heino FalckeUni Nijmegen, ASTRON

CRCR

Page 10: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 10

CR coherent synchrotron radiation CR coherent synchrotron radiation T. Huege and H. Falcke A&A 412 (2003) 19-34

Page 11: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 11

LOPES @ Kascade (FZK)LOPES @ Kascade (FZK)

• LOPESLOPES (LOLOFAR Prototypee SStation, Heino Falcke et al*)

• First CR events recently detected

*) H. Falcke and P. Gorham, Astropart. Phys., 19 (2002) 477-494

T. Huege, H. Falcke, A&A, 412 (2003) 19-34

Page 12: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 12

First ResultsFirst Results

From: Heino Falcke, 2nd Symposium “Astroparticle Physics in the Netherlands”

From: A. Bellétoile et al, SF2A 2004 CODALEMA @ Nançay France

Page 13: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 13

High-energy CR spectrumHigh-energy CR spectrum

Bram AchterbergColloquium Kapteyn 15 November 2004

Pierre AugerPierre AugerObservatory !Observatory !

Page 14: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 14

Marginal explanation by Marginal explanation by conventional models conventional models

Bra

m A

chte

rber

gC

ollo

quiu

m K

apte

yn

15 N

ovem

ber

2004

Page 15: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 15

Built a UHE Built a UHE detector detector

UHE ’s provide complementary informationsources are transparentUniverse is transparentno charge; no influence from EM fieldsvelocity is knowndirect link between and spectrum

Page 16: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 16

How (one option ...)How (one option ...)

• Detect UHE ’s using rock salt in Northern Europe (Groningen)

• Monitor UHE CR’s with LOFAR• Develop:

– radar techniques for salt domes– techniques to install antennas in salt domes– understanding of UHE CR and interactions with

matter– calibrate various detector systems (PAO LOFAR)

Page 17: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 17

Underground salt layers*Underground salt layers*

Zechstein salt

salt pillars

cavern

* © TNO-NITG

Page 18: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 18

Footprint of LOFARFootprint of LOFAR

salt domes

Page 19: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 19

Salt in GroningenSalt in Groningen

Veendam

Assen

Emmen

Stadskanaal

© TNO-NITG

Onstwedde

Zuidwending

Page 20: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 20

Zuidwending salt domeZuidwending salt dome

3D model of the Zuidwending salt dome: view from the East. The active horizon is the top of the salt.

Purple: Triassic; Dark green: Lower Cretaceous; Light green: Upper Cretaceous Orange: Lower Tertiary; Yellow: Miocene-Quaternary.

© TNO-NITG

2

,5 k

m

7,5 km

Page 21: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 21

Zuidwending Dome ?Zuidwending Dome ?

Aardgasbuffer Zuidwending: a fast Compressed Natural Gas storageGastransport Services, Akzo Nobel Salt, NUON (Energy Valley)

Page 22: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 22

LOFARLOFAR

Salt domes under LOFARSalt domes under LOFAR

CRCR

Page 23: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 23

i n s i t u m e a s u r e m e n t sP . G o r h a m e t a l

N a C l , D i e l e c t r i c M a t e r i a l s a n d A p p l i c a t i o n s ( A . R . v o n H i p p e l e d . ) , 1 9 5 4

t a n δ = 2 × 1 0 - 4

R o c k s a l t H o c k l e y m i n e , U S A

R o c k s a l t , H a l s t a d t m i n e , A u s t r i a

N a C l s y n t h e s i z e dL i m e s t o n e , K a m a i s h i , J a p a n

L i m e s t o n e , M t . J u r a , F r a n c e R o c k s a l t , A s s e m i n e , G e r m a n y

H i p p e l 2 5 G H z

1 G H z c a v i t y 5 . 5 G H z

8 . 2 G H z

1 1 G H z

N a c l p o w d e r

T e f l o n

D i e l e c t r i c r e s o n a t o r

tan

1

L

G r a n i t e , K a m a i s h i , J a p a n

First preliminary results (Chiba)First preliminary results (Chiba)

Page 24: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 24

R & D NeededR & D Needed

• Radio attenuation length measurement • Ultra-sensitive underground radar techniques

(receiver antennas)• Cross calibration with other experiments

(PAO, acoustic, WSRT, ...?)

Page 25: 04-02-2005/AMvdBInt. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 20051 Neutrino Detection in Salt Domes under LOFAR Ad M. van den Berg Kernfysisch Versneller

04-02-2005/AMvdB Int. WS Saltdome Shower Array SLAC 3-4 Feb. 2005 25

ConclusionConclusion• Radio techniques for detection of UHE are

very promising and provide an important step for the next generation of telescopes

• LOFAR, the largest radio telescope in the world, can be used for UHE CR and detection; it can be complemented with ZESANA using ‘standard’ techniques

LOFAR + PAO S/N ? & ZESANALOFAR + PAO S/N ? & ZESANA

PAO South & LOFARPAO South & LOFAR