8/11/2019 07 Uy Siu Pin vs Cantollas

1/2

FIRST DIVISION[G.R. No. 46850. June 20, 1940.]

UY SIU PIN and CHUA HUE,petitioners, vs. CASIMIRA CANTOLLAS, ETAL.,respondents.Trinidad & Enriquez andSumulong, Lavidez & Sumulong fo !e"#"#one$.Azada, Veluz & De Luna fo e$!onden"$.

SYLLABUS

1.%&R'()S* )ND S)+* N&++IT- )RTI'+* 1458 OF T(* 'IVI+ 'OD*. T/e $ae fo &. S. %."o /#$ #fe '. (. #$ nu and 3o#d no" on eau$e "/e foe /ad no #7/" "o d#$!o$e of "/e and #n

on"o3e$ #n 3#e of "/e e#$"ene of "/e on"a" */##" ), u" eau$e $u/ $ae oe$ #"/#n"/e !o/##"#on of a"#e 1458 of "/e '#3# 'ode.

D E C I S I O N

LAUREL,J !In "/e ea 1929 o "/eeaou" "/e $!ou$e$ %edo Vee7a:o and 'a$##a 'an"oa$ ee

#nde"ed "o * (o7a F##!#no #n "/e $u of %2,000 $eued a o"7a7e on e"a#n and o3eed o#7#na e"#;a"e of "#"e No. 101a$ oud e#n a !o$#"#on "o do $o, "/e /ad "/e #7/" "o edee $a#d and !a#n7 "o & S#u %#n o /#$$ue$$o$ #n #n"ee$" "/e $u of %1,a$, /a3#n7 fa#ed "o edee "/eand #"/#n "/e $"a"u"o !e#od, a ;na deed of $ae a$ #$$ued #n fa3o of El Hogar FilipinoonDeee 24, 19=4. On Deee 26, 19=4 "/e a""e $od "/e afoe$a#d and "o & S#u %#n fo%1,198.1a$ Vee7a:o ;ed #n "/e 'ou" of F#$"In$"ane of Taaa$ a o!a#n" a7a#n$" & S#u %#n and '/ua (ue #n /#/, a$ $u$eAuen"aended, #" a$ !aed "/a" "/e $ae #n fa3o of '/ua (ue and "an$fe e"#;a"e of "#"e No. 844a$. Ne#"/e oud "/e a""e e aed fo "/e# fa#ue "o edee "/e and fo El HogarFilipinoaf"e "/e foeo$ue $ae, fo "/e ea$on "/a" "/e /ad "/e !efe" #7/" "o e on "/e#on"a" #"/ & S#u %#n. In an e3en", /e"/e e on$#de & S#u %#n a$ /a3#n7 !u/a$ed "/e and

fo El Hogar Filipino#n /#$ on #7/", and no" on e/af of 'a$##a 'an"oa$ and >a$ Vee7a:o,/e #$ $"# ound, unde "/e #u$"ane$ of "/#$ a$e, "o eon3e "/e $ae "o 'a$##a and >a$af"e "/e e!#a"#on of "/e !e#od $"#!ua"ed #n "/e e#$"#n7 on"a" */##" ). I" #$ !e"ended,/oe3e, "/a" "/e o#7a"#on$ a$$ued & S#u %#n unde */##" ) /a3e een 3a#d e"#n7u#$/ed/en /e e"uned "/e !o$$e$$#on of "/e !o!e" #n Aue$"#on "o "/e de"o$ 'a$##a 'an"oa$ and>a$ Vee7a:o. )7a#n$" "/#$ !e"en$#on "/ee #$ "/e ;nd#n7 of fa" of "/e 'ou" of )!!ea$, no"a!ae of e3#e u$ #n "/e !e$en" !oeed#n7$, "/a" & S#u %#n /a$ ea#ned #n !o$$e$$#on of"/e and $#ne )!# 2, 19=2.

T/e $ae fo & S#u %#n "o /#$ #fe '/ua (ue #$ nu and 3o#d no" on eau$e "/e foe/ad no #7/" "o d#$!o$e of "/e and #n on"o3e$ #n 3#e of "/e e#$"ene of "/e on"a" */##" ),u" eau$e $u/ $ae oe #"/#n "/e !o/##"#on of a"#e 1458 of "/e '#3# 'ode. I" #$ no"nee$$a "o de u!on "/e $ae fo '/ua (ue "o "/e #n"e3eno Juan a7a?o$, a$ "/e a""e /a$no" a!!eaed fo "/e de#$#on o!a#ned of "/e !e"#"#one$.

T/e !e"#"#on fo e"#oa# # "/eefoe e d#$#$$ed and "/e a!!eaed de#$#on aCed,#"/ o$"$ a7a#n$" "/e !e"#"#one$. So odeed.

Avancea, !"J", #mperial, Diaz,and $oran,, JJ",onu.