1 case-mix and optimization of mortality prognostic scores in portuguese pediatric intensive care...

60
1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors: Rosa Oliveira 2 and Daniel Martins 3 1. [email protected]; 2. [email protected]; 3. [email protected];

Upload: marianna-paul

Post on 27-Dec-2015

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

1

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic

Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Introdução à Medicina II

2011/2012Class 121

Advisors: Rosa Oliveira2 and Daniel Martins3

1. [email protected];

2. [email protected]; 3. [email protected];

Page 2: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

Table of Contents

2Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

• Introduction

• Contextualization

• State of the Art

• Background

• Are scores discriminative? And calibrated?

• Differences in calibration… Why?

• Should scores be recalibrated?

• Problems…

• Research Questions

• Aims

• Methods

• Expected results

• Results

• References

• Acknowledgments

Page 3: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Introduction

3Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Introduction

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

State of the ArtState of the Art

Contextualization

• A Pediatric Intensive Care Unit (PICU) is an area within a hospital specialized in the care of critically ill infants, children, and teenagers.

• The type and number of patients and the provided health care differs according to its location.

Frankel, Lorry R; DiCarlo, Joseph V (2003). “Pediatric Intensive Care”. In Bernstein, Daniel; Shelov, Steven P. Pediatrics for Medical Students (2nd ed.).

MethodsMethods

ReferencesReferences

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

Introduction

MethodsMethods

Page 4: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

Introduction

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

State of the ArtState of the Art

MethodsMethods

Consume human and financial resources

Provide adequate treatment for severely ill children

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Introduction

4PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Portuguese PICUs

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

Introduction

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Page 5: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

Introduction

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

State of the ArtState of the Art

MethodsMethods

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Introduction

5PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Portuguese PICUs

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

Introduction

Provide adequate treatment for severely ill children

Major health quality resource Pacient stratification

Evaluation

Mortality rate Assistance quality

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Page 6: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

Introduction

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

State of the ArtState of the Art

MethodsMethods

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Introduction

6PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Portuguese PICUs

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

Introduction

Provide adequate treatment for severely ill children

Major health quality resource Pacient stratification

Evaluation

Mortality rate Assistance quality

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Page 7: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

Introduction

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

State of the ArtState of the Art

MethodsMethods

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Introduction

7PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Portuguese PICUs

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

Introduction

Provide adequate treatment for severely ill children

Major health quality resource Pacient stratification

Evaluation

Mortality rate Assistance quality

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Page 8: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

Introduction

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

State of the ArtState of the Art

MethodsMethods

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Introduction

8PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Portuguese PICUs

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

Introduction

Provide adequate treatment for severely ill children

Major health quality resource Pacient stratification

Evaluation

Mortality rate Assistance quality

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Page 9: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

Introduction

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

State of the ArtState of the Art

MethodsMethods

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Introduction

9PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Portuguese PICUs

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

Introduction

Provide adequate treatment for severely ill children

Major health quality resource Pacient stratification

Evaluation

Mortalit rate Assistance quality

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Page 10: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

Introduction

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

State of the ArtState of the Art

MethodsMethods

Consume human and financial resources

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Introduction

10PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Portuguese PICUs

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

Introduction

Provide adequate treatment for severely ill children

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Page 11: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

Mortality Prognostic Scores

PIM PRISM

Introduction

11PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

Introduction

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

PIM – Pediatric Index of Mortality; PRISM – Pediatric Risk of Mortality

Page 12: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

Mortality Prognostic Scores

PIM PRISM

Introduction

12PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

Introduction

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

PIM – Pediatric Index of Mortality; PRISM – Pediatric Risk of Mortality

Page 13: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

Introduction

13PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Expected resultsExpected results

MethodsMethods

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

Introduction

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

PIM – Pediatric Index of Mortality; PRISM – Pediatric Risk of Mortality

PIM PRISM

•Elective admission•Subjacent conditions•Pupil reaction to light•Mecânical ventilation

•Blood Pressure•Blood alcalemia•Oxigen in blood

•Sistolic blood presure•Diastolic blood presure

•Cardic and respiratory frequency•Partial pressure of oxygen in the blood (PaO2)•Partial pressure of carbon dioxide in the blood

(PaCO2)•Glasgow Coma scale

•Pupil reactionsTP/TTP•Total bilirubin

•Potassium and calcium concentrations•Glucose index•Bicarbonate

• Observation during 1h •Observation during 24h

• Parameters in admission and one hour after •The hightest parameter in the first 24 hours

• Amount of information;• Duration of the observation period;

• Moment in which the information is collected. 1

1. Slater, A.M.B., FRACP, FJFICM; Shann, Frank MB, BS, MD, FRACP, FJFICM; the ANZICS Paediatric Study Group, The suitability of the Pediatric Index of Mortality (PIM), PIM2, the Pediatric Risk of Mortality (PRISM), and PRISM III for monitoring the quality of pediatric intensive care in Australia and New Zealand. Pediatric Critical Care Medicine, 2004. 5(5): p. 447-453.

Logit = (-4.873) + (values * Beta) + (0.021 * (absolute(SBP-120))) + (0.071 * (absolute base excess)) + (0.415 * (FiO2/PaO2))

Mortality Prediction Value= eLogit/ (1+eLogit)

Page 14: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

State of the ArtState of the Art

Carmen Ferández, J.L.-H., Jose C. Flores, Dolores Galaviz, Marta Rupérez, Kay B. Brandstrup, Amaya Bustinza, Prognosis in critically ill children requiring continuous renal replacement therapy. IPNA, 2005.

State of the Art

14

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

MethodsMethods

Introduction

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

Introduction

Page 15: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

Are scores discriminative? And calibrated?

“Both PRISM and PIM scores have a good discriminatory performance. The

calibration with PRISM score is good but the PIM score displays poor

calibration.”

Taori RN, L. K., Tullu MS (2010). "Performance of PRISM (Pediatric Risk of Mortality) score and PIM (Pediatric Index of Mortality) score in a tertiary care pediatric ICU." Indian J Pediatr 77(3): 267-271.

Background

15

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

MethodsMethods

Introduction

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

Introduction

PIM – Pediatric Index of Mortality; PRISM – Pediatric Risk of Mortality

Page 16: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

Diferences in calibration... Why?

Background

16

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

MethodsMethods

Introduction

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

Introduction

Different regions

Missing values

Recalibrations

→ Population case-mix→ Type of PICU→ Admission policy→ …

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Page 17: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

Should scores be recalibrated?

“Subsequent validation of variables could improve the sensitivity and the

value of severity scoring in the future. Nevertheless, illness

severity scores will never be indicative of absolute irreversibility of disease or

impossibility of survival...” 2

“ In general, scoring systems should be used only in populations similar to

the reference population in which the prediction model was developed.” 1

Wells M, R.-F.J., Luyt DK, Dance M, Lipman J., Poor discriminatory performance of the Pediatric Risk of Mortality (PRISM) score in a South African intensive care unit. Crit Care Med., 1996. 24(9)

Unertl K, K.B., Prognostic scores in intensive care. Anaesthesist., 1997. 46(6): p. 471-80.

Background

17

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

MethodsMethods

Introduction

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

Introduction

Page 18: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

Problems...

Background

18

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

MethodsMethods

Introduction

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

Introduction

→ Inclusion and exclusion criteria of the data-base;

→ Time of collection;

→ Human resources;

→ Algorithm descalibration through time; → …

Page 19: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

Recalibration Background

19

PIM

PRISM

PIM-2

PRISM III

Assessment and Optimization of Mortality Pronostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care

“Are they doing a good job?”

MARTINS, D. A. A. 1; SANTOS, L. R.1; FIGUEIREDO, M. A. R. M.1; GUERRA, M. D. L.1; MAGALHÃES, R. S.1; FRANCISCO, R. M. H.1; REBELO, C. A. B. S. T.1; ABREU, C. A. M. L. M.1; LAIGINHAS, A. R. A.1; DIAS, M. O.1; CHAVES, J. G. A. C.1; OLIVEIRA, R. C. S.1,2;

Aim: To evaluate the Pediatric Risk of Mortality (…) and the Pediatric Index of Mortality (…) performance at Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units, where PIM2-R is the recalibrated PIM2 model using the Australia and New Zealand Pediatric Intensive Care 2008 coefficients (which is for the first time applied and analyzed in Portuguese context).

Lack of calibration and discrimination in Portuguese reality

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

MethodsMethods

Introduction

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

BackgroundBackground

Introduction

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

PIM-3

PIM – Pediatric Index of Mortality; PRISM – Pediatric Risk of Mortality

Page 20: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

20

ReferencesReferences

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

Expected results

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Carmen Ferández, J.L.-H., Jose C. Flores, Dolores Galaviz, Marta Rupérez, Kay B. Brandstrup, Amaya Bustinza, Prognosis in critically ill children requiring continuous renal replacement therapy. IPNA, 2005.

PIM AND PRISM underestimated the risk of death in other realities

Underestimated risk of death in Portugal

Optimize of the quality of the health care provided

We look forward to...

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

We expect...

PIM – Pediatric Index of Mortality; PRISM – Pediatric Risk of Mortality

ResultsResults

Page 21: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

• How do Pediatric Mortality Prognostic Scores (PIM-2) behave in Portuguese PICUs’ specific groups of diagnosis?

• Is it possible to enhance the performance of PIM-2 with a new recalibration?

• With what purpose are scores used in Portuguese PICUs’?

Research Questions

21

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

MethodsMethods

Introduction

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

BackgroundBackground

Introduction

State of the ArtState of the Art

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units; PIM – Pediatric Index of Mortality

Page 22: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

• To assess calibration and discrimination of Pediatric Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese PICUs and in the specific diagnosis groups.

• To recalibrate PIM-2, in the broad-spectrum patients and to specific diagnosis group.

• To evaluate the new model concerning calibration and discrimination

• To understand clinicians awareness of the purpose and use of prognostic mortality scores in Portuguese PICUs.

Specific aims

22

AimsAims

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

MethodsMethods

Introduction

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

Introduction

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units; PIM – Pediatric Index of Mortality

Page 23: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

23

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

MethodsMethods

Introduction

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

Target PopulationTarget Population

Methods

23Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

Introduction

The target population will be all children admitted in Portuguese PICUs.

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Page 24: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

MethodsMethods

Introduction

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

SampleSample

Methods

24Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

Introduction

Sources: PICUs from Hospital de Santa Maria, Hospital de D. Estefânia, Hospital Fernando da Fonseca, Hospital Geral de S. João, Hospital Pediátrico de Coimbra, Hospital Garcia de Orta, Hospital Geral de Santo António, Hospital da Misericórdia de Paredes and Hospital de Faro.

Children were included in different groups of diagnosis.

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Page 25: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

MethodsMethods

Introduction

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

SampleSample

Methods

25Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

Introduction

Age(mean) : 2005-2006: 6 y 1 m; 2007-2008: 6 y 1 m.

Lenght of stay(mean): 2005-2006: 182h; 2007-2008: 127h.

43%

57%

Admission Period2005/2006 2007/2008

Male Female

55.8 56.356.343.7

Gender

Planed Unplaned

36.5

63.5

39.6 60,4

Admission Type

Page 26: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

MethodsMethods

Introduction

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

SampleSample

Methods

26Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

Introduction

Accidents/

External C

auses

Cardiovascu

lar

Neurological

Respira

toryRenal

Gastrointesti

nal

Oncologica

l

Metabolic/E

ndocrinal/E

lectrolyti

c

Post-proce

dure

Post-operatory

Others

16

2.1

9.5

22.8

0.6 0.3 1.5 2.4 2.7

32.3

9.8

17.8

1.1

9.7

18

0.7 0.9 0.4 1.3 0.2

41.1

8.8

Groups Diagnosis

2005/20062007/2008

Page 27: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

MethodsMethods

Introduction

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

ValidationValidation

Calibration Discrimination

Methods

27

Standardized Mortality Ratio (SMR)

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

Introduction

Page 28: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

MethodsMethods

Introduction

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

ValidationValidation

Calibration Discrimination

Methods

28

Standardized Mortality Ratio (SMR)

Observed deaths / expected deaths

SMR<1.00 SMR=1 SMR>1.00

“we are doing better

than expected”

“we are doing as

expected”

“we are doing worse than expected”

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

Introduction

Page 29: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

MethodsMethods

Introduction

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

ValidationValidation

Calibration Discrimination

Methods

29Case-mix and Optimization in Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese PICUs

Standardized Mortality Ratio (SMR)

Hosmer-Lemeshow Test

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

Introduction

Page 30: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

MethodsMethods

Introduction

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

ValidationValidation

Calibration Discrimination

Methods

30

Standardized Mortality Ratio (SMR)

Relative Operating Characteristic (ROC)

Curves

Sensitivity vs. 1-Specificity for every

value of the score

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

Introduction

Page 31: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

MethodsMethods

Introduction

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

Methods

31Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

Introduction

ValidationValidation

Calibration DiscriminationStandardized Mortality Ratio

Sensitivity vs. 1-Specificity for every

value of the score

Area under the (AUC)ROC Curve

Relative Operating Characteristic (ROC)

Curves

Page 32: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

32

ReferencesReferences

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

Methods

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

Introduction

AUC – Area Under the ROC Curve

0,70≤AUC<0,80 0,80≤AUC<0,90 0,90≤AUC<1,00 AUC=1,00

Acceptable Good Execlent Perfect

Page 33: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

33

Methods

Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

Introduction

Main study

Surveys of use

Grounding of conclusions

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/viewform?pli=1&formkey=dHZpbU9hX1h6cFEyWExnTzNzRHplcnc6MQ#gid=0

Page 34: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

34

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

ResultsAgreement* (%)

Clinicians… 1 2 3 4 5 NAwereness of Mortality Prognostic Scores :- Concept 0 0 16,7 55,6 2,78 18

- Use in Portuguese PICUs 0 0 10,5 21,1 47,4 19

- Use in the their specific PICU 0 10,5 21,1 47,4 21,1 19

Access to the scores 0 26,3 10,5 47,4 15,8 19

Idea of scores Calibration to Portuguese reality 5,3 10,5 42,1 36,8 5,3 19

Idea of scores usefulness in Portuguese PICUs 0 0 5,3 89,5 5,3 19

*1 - Total disagreement, …, 5 - Total agreement

Page 35: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

35

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

ResultsAgreement* (%)

Clinicians… 1 2 3 4 5 NAwereness of Mortality Prognostic Scores :- Concept 0 0 16,7 55,6 2,78 18

- Use in Portuguese PICUs 0 0 10,5 21,1 47,4 19

- Use in the their specific PICU 0 10,5 21,1 47,4 21,1 19

Access to the scores 0 26,3 10,5 47,4 15,8 19

Idea of scores Calibration to Portuguese reality 5,3 10,5 42,1 36,8 5,3 19

Idea of scores usefulness in Portuguese PICUs 0 0 5,3 89,5 5,3 19

*1 - Total disagreement, …, 5 - Total agreement

Page 36: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

36

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

ResultsAgreement* (%)

Clinicians opinion … 1 2 3 4 5 NImpact of:the score use in the their specific PICU 0 0 15,8 78,9 5,3 19

recommended score (in their decision) 57,9 36,8 0 5,3 0 19

a recalibrated score (in their decision) 10,5 26,3 21,1 36,8 5,3 19

scores usefulness in clinical practice or PICU structure 5,6 38,9 44,4 11,2 0 18

Of scores abillity todiscriminate the quality of the health care 0 0 21,1 68,4 10,5 19

provide patient stratification 0 0 36,8 57,3 5,3 19

*1 - Total disagreement, …, 5 - Total agreement

Page 37: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

37

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

ResultsAgreement* (%)

Clinicians opinion … 1 2 3 4 5 NImpact of:the score use in the their specific PICU 0 0 15,8 78,9 5,3 19

recommended score (in their decision) 57,9 36,8 0 5,3 0 19

a recalibrated score (in their decision) 10,5 26,3 21,1 36,8 5,3 19

scores usefulness in clinical practice or PICU structure 5,6 38,9 44,4 11,2 0 18

Of scores abillity todiscriminate the quality of the health care 0 0 21,1 68,4 10,5 19

provide patient stratification 0 0 36,8 57,3 5,3 19

*1 - Total disagreement, …, 5 - Total agreement

Page 38: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

38

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

Results

Clinicians … Yes (%) No(%) NKnowledge of a model 94,7 5,3 19

Opinion on the necessity of recalibration in each country 57,9 42,1 19

Page 39: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

39

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

Results

Clinicians … Yes (%) No(%) NKnowledge of a model 94,7 5,3 19

Opinion on the necessity of recalibration in each country 57,9 42,1 19

Page 40: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

40

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

Results

ReferencesReferences

PIM-2 AUC

2002 0,639

2006 0,644

2008 0,647

2005/2006

AUC – Area Under the Curve; PIM – Pediatric Index of Mortality

1-Specificity

Sen

sitiv

ity

Page 41: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

41

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

Results

PIM-2 AUC

2002 0,633

2006 0,632

2008 0,645

2007/2008

AUC – Area Under the Curve; PIM – Pediatric Index of Mortality

1-Specificity

Sen

siti

vity

Page 42: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

42

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

Results

Page 43: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

43

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

Results

Page 44: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

44

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

Results

Page 45: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

45

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

Results

AUC

PIM2

2002 2006 2008

2005/2006

2007/2008

2005/2006

2007/2008

2005/2006

2007/2008

Accidents/External Causes

0,422 0,498 0,432 0,525 0,405 0,506

Cardiovascular 0,917 0,667 0,833 0,667 0,833 0,667

Neurologic 0,603 0,399 0,609 0,413 0,596 0,406

Respiratory 0,661 0,688 0,657 0,695 0,665 0,693

Postoperative 0,770 0,747 0,755 0,747 0,758 0,699

Others 0,657 0,745 0,674 0,725 0,661 0,716

AUC – Area Under the Curve; PIM – Pediatric Index of Mortality

Page 46: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

46

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

Results

AUC

PIM2

2002 2006 2008

2005/2006

2007/2008

2005/2006

2007/2008

2005/2006

2007/2008

Accidents/External Causes

0,422 0,498 0,432 0,525 0,405 0,506

Cardiovascular 0,917 0,667 0,833 0,667 0,833 0,667

Neurologic 0,603 0,399 0,609 0,413 0,596 0,406

Respiratory 0,661 0,688 0,657 0,695 0,665 0,693

Postoperative 0,770 0,747 0,755 0,747 0,758 0,699

Others 0,657 0,745 0,674 0,725 0,661 0,716

AUC – Area Under the Curve; PIM – Pediatric Index of Mortality

Page 47: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

47

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

Results

AUC

PIM2

2002 2006 2008

2005/2006

2007/2008

2005/2006

2007/2008

2005/2006

2007/2008

Accidents/External Causes

0,422 0,498 0,432 0,525 0,405 0,506

Cardiovascular 0,917 0,667 0,833 0,667 0,833 0,667

Neurologic 0,603 0,399 0,609 0,413 0,596 0,406

Respiratory 0,661 0,688 0,657 0,695 0,665 0,693

Postoperative 0,770 0,747 0,755 0,747 0,758 0,699

Others 0,657 0,745 0,674 0,725 0,661 0,716

AUC – Area Under the Curve; PIM – Pediatric Index of Mortality

Page 48: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

48

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

Results

• New Algorithm:

o PIM-2 IM=(-0.015 x SBP)+(4.270 x PUPIL REACTION)+ - 0.011 x mm)+(0.040 x BASE EXCESS)+(- 0.695 x VENTILATION)+(- 3.019 x PLANED ADMISSION)+(-1.099 x POST OPERATORY)+(19.805 x CARDIAC SURGERY)+(0.702 x RECOVERY)+(0.426 x DIGESTIVE) + 2.779

Page 49: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

49

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

Results

PIM-2 AUC

2002 0,633

2006 0,632

2008 0,645

2007/2008

AUC – Area Under the Curve; PIM – Pediatric Index of Mortality

1-Specificity

Sen

siti

vity

PIM-2 AUC

IM 0,875

Page 50: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

50

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

Results

Page 51: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

51

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

ResultsGroup AUC Chi-square p-value

Accidents/External Causes

0,848 19,336 0,013

Cardiovascular 0,500 5,000 0,172

Neurologic 0,865 7,326 0,502

Respiratory 0,674 10,329 0,243

Postoperative 0,731 7,816 0,452

Others 0,745 8,787 0,361

Group AUC Chi-square p-value

Accidents/External Causes

0,525 11,043 0,199

Cardiovascular 0,667 4,841 0,184

Neurologic 0,413 7,469 0,487

Respiratory 0,695 9,219 0,324

Postoperative 0,747 8,815 0,358

Others 0,725 12,430 0,133

PIM-2 IM

PIM-2 2006

Page 52: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

52

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

ResultsGroup AUC Chi-square p-value

Accidents/External Causes

0,848 19,336 0,013

Cardiovascular 0,500 5,000 0,172

Neurologic 0,865 7,326 0,502

Respiratory 0,674 10,329 0,243

Postoperative 0,731 7,816 0,452

Others 0,745 8,787 0,361

Group AUC Chi-square p-value

Accidents/External Causes

0,525 11,043 0,199

Cardiovascular 0,667 4,841 0,184

Neurologic 0,413 7,469 0,487

Respiratory 0,695 9,219 0,324

Postoperative 0,747 8,815 0,358

Others 0,725 12,430 0,133

PIM-2 IM

PIM-2 2006

Page 53: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

53

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

Conclusions and Discussion

PIM-2 showed acceptable discrimination but poor calibration in specific diagnosis groups and in general Portuguese PICUs.

Recalibrated version of PIM-2 showed better discrimination and calibration either in specific diagnosis groups either general Portuguese PICUs than the ones used nowadays.

Mortality Prognostic Scores’ importance is recognized in Portuguese PICUs, however:

Clinicians don’t feel the need of a recalibration Scores don’t frequently lead to a change in clinical practice.

Page 54: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

54

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

Conclusions and Discussion

PIM-2 showed acceptable discrimination but poor calibration in specific diagnosis groups and in general Portuguese PICUs.

Recalibrated version of PIM-2 showed better discrimination and calibration either in specific diagnosis groups either general Portuguese PICUs than the ones used nowadays.

Mortality Prognostic Scores’ importance is recognized in Portuguese PICUs, however:

Clinicians don’t feel the need of a recalibration Scores don’t frequently lead to a change in clinical

practice.

Page 55: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

55

ResultsResults

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

Conclusions and Discussion

PIM-2 showed acceptable discrimination but poor calibration in specific diagnosis groups, and in general Portuguese PICUs.

Recalibrated version of PIM-2 showed better discrimination and calibration either in specific diagnosis groups and general Portuguese PICUs than the ones used nowadays.

Mortality Prognostic Scores’ importance is recognized in Portuguese PICUs, however:

Clinicians don’t feel the need of a recalibration Scores don’t frequently lead to a change in clinical

practice.

Page 56: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

• Anthony R. Brady, D.H., Stephanie Black, Sam Jones, Kathy Rowan, Gale Pearson, Jane Ratcliffe and Gareth J. Parry, Assessment and Optimization of Mortality Prediction Tools for Admissions to Pediatric Intensive Care in the United Kingdom. Pediatrics, 2006. 117;

• Carmen Ferández, J.L.-H., Jose C. Flores, Dolores Galaviz, Marta Rupérez, Kay B. Brandstrup, Amaya Bustinza, Prognosis in critically ill children requiring continuous renal replacement therapy. IPNA, 2005;

• César Sánchez, J.L.-H., Santiago Mencía, Javier Urbano, Angel Carrillo and José María Bellón, Clinical severity scores do not predict tolerance to enteral nutrition in critically ill children. British Journal of Nutrition, 2009. 102: p. 191–194;

• Esra Arun Ozer, A.K., Berrak Sarioglu, Oya Halicioglu, Sumer Sutcuoglu, and Isin Yaprak, The Comparison of PRISM and PIM Scoring Systems for Mortality Risk in Infantile Intensive Care. Journal of Tropical Pediatrics, 2004. 50;

References

56Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

ResultsResults

Introduction

Page 57: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

• Ganapathy Balakrishnan, T.A., David Hallworth, Neil S Morton, Prospective evaluation of the Paediatric Risk of Mortality (PRISM) score. Archives ofDisease in Childhood, 1992. 67: p. 196-200.

• Okay, G.A.C.A.F.D.A.F.T.S., Application of the pediatric risk of mortality (PRISM) score and determination of mortality risk factors in a tertiary pediatric intensive care unit. Clinics, 2010. 65.

• Pollack MM, R.U., Getson PR, Pediatric risk of mortality (PRISM) score. Crit Care Med, 1998. 16(11): p. 1110-6.

• Slater, A.M.B., FRACP, FJFICM; Shann, Frank MB, BS, MD, FRACP, FJFICM; the ANZICS Paediatric Study Group, The suitability of the Pediatric Index of Mortality (PIM), PIM2, the Pediatric Risk of Mortality (PRISM), and PRISM III for monitoring the quality of pediatric intensive care in Australia and New Zealand. Pediatric Critical Care Medicine, 2004. 5(5): p. 447-453.

• S. Prieto Espuñes, J.L.-H.C., C. Rey Galán, A. Medina Villanueva, A. Concha Torre y P. Martínez Camblor, Índices pronósticos de mortalidad en cuidados intensivos pediátricos. An Pediatr (Barc), 2007. 66: p. 345-50.

References

57Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Expected resultsExpected results

Introduction

Page 58: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

• S M Tibby, D.T., M Festa, S Hanna, M Hatherill, G Jones, P Habibi, A Durward, I A Murdoch, A comparison of three scoring systems for mortality risk among retrieved intensive care patients. Arch Dis Child, 2002. 87: p. 421-425;

• Vanessa Feller Martha, P.C.R.G., Jefferson Pedro Piva, Paulo Roberto Einloft, Francisco Bruno, Viviane Rampon, Comparação entre dois escores de prognóstico (PRISM e PIM) em unidade de terapia intensiva pediátrica. Jornal de Pediatria, 2005. 81(3): p. 259-64.

References

58Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

ReferencesReferences

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Expected resultsExpected results

Introduction

Page 59: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

We gratefully acknowledge :

• Professor Altamiro Costa Pereira;

• Phd Armando Teixeira-Pinto;

• Msc Rosa Oliveira;

• Daniel Martins;

for their guidance and time

• And you;

For your attention.

PICUs – Pediatric Intensive Care Units

Acknowledgments

59Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units

MethodsMethods

State of the ArtState of the Art

BackgroundBackground

Research QuestionsResearch Questions

AimsAims

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Expected resultsExpected results

Introduction

ReferencesReferences

Page 60: 1 Case-mix and Optimization of Mortality Prognostic Scores in Portuguese Pediatric Intensive Care Units Introdução à Medicina II 2011/2012 Class 12 1 Advisors:

The End

60

Introdução à Medicina II

2011/2012Class 121

Advisors: Rosa Oliveira2 and Daniel Martins3

1. [email protected];

2. [email protected]; 3. [email protected];

Questions?