1/11/12 CCC-12-CD-01 & CCC-12-RO-01 1

Consent Cease and Desist Order CCC-12-CD-01

and Consent Restoration Order

CCC-12-RO-01

Goodell Family TrustUnincorporated Orange County

1/11/12 CCC-12-CD-01 & CCC-12-RO-01 2

Subject Property

Bolsa Chica ER

Huntington Beach

Huntington Harbor

1/11/12 CCC-12-CD-01 & CCC-12-RO-01 3

Brightwater Project

Parkside Estates Site

Subject Property

Bolsa Chica ER

California Coastal Records Project photograph Copyright © 2002-2010 Kenneth & Gabrielle Adelman - Adelman@Adelman.COM

2006

1/11/12 CCC-12-CD-01 & CCC-12-RO-01 4

Cogged stones uncovered at ORA-83

1/11/12 CCC-12-CD-01 & CCC-12-RO-01 5

Description of Unpermitted Development

• Excavation of 16 pits, and

• Deposition of excavated soil and material.

1/11/12 CCC-12-CD-01 & CCC-12-RO-01 6

Definition of “Development”

“Development” means, on land, in or under water, the placement or erection of any solid material or structures…grading, removing, dredging, mining or extraction of any materials...

1/11/12 CCC-12-CD-01 & CCC-12-RO-01 7

Development has occurred without a CDP

5-10-035-X issued

for surface study in

preparation for the

ARP

1/11/12 CCC-12-CD-01 & CCC-12-RO-01 8

Development has occurred without a CDP

1/11/12 CCC-12-CD-01 & CCC-12-RO-01 9

Basis for Issuance of Cease and Desist & Restoration Orders

Coastal Act Sections 30810 & 30811:• Development is unpermitted, • Development is inconsistent with the Coastal Act, and• Development is causing continuing resource damage.

• Section 30244 (Archaeological Resources)

1/11/12 CCC-12-CD-01 & CCC-12-RO-01 10

Development is inconsistent with the Coastal Act

“Where development would adversely impact archaeological or paleontological resources as identified by the State Historic Preservation Officer, reasonable mitigation measures shall be required”

• Section 30244 (Archaeological Resources)

1/11/12 CCC-12-CD-01 & CCC-12-RO-01 11

Development is inconsistent with the Coastal Act

• Eligible National Historic Place under Criteria A and D

• Criterion A: Is associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of history

• Criterion D: Has yielded, or may be likely to yield, information important in history or prehistory

• Sections 30230 and 30231 (Water Quality)• Section 30253 (Erosion)

1/11/12 CCC-12-CD-01 & CCC-12-RO-01 12

Development is inconsistent with the Coastal Act

1/11/12 CCC-12-CD-01 & CCC-12-RO-01 13

Development is causing

“continuing resource damage”

1/11/12 CCC-12-CD-01 & CCC-12-RO-01 14

Terms of the Proposed Consent Orders

• Arrange for Native American monitors,• Screen excavated soil for cultural materials,• Document and rebury cultural materials, • Restore topography of excavated areas,

and • Fund a mitigation project for archaeological

conservation.

1/11/12 CCC-12-CD-01 & CCC-12-RO-01 15

Subject Property