20130822+sciens+fund+of+funds+management+holdings+ltd

15
Fund & Asset Manager Rating Group www.fitchratings.com 22 August 2013 Fund of Hedge Fund Managers / Caymans Sciens Fund of Funds Management Holdings Ltd Full Rating Report Key Rating Drivers Solid Adaptability, Staff Turnover: Sciens Fund of Funds Management Holdings Ltd (Sciens) has continued to expand and diversify its managed accounts offering, which is at the centre of its growth strategy. Operating profitability has increased in 2012 from the 2011 low levels. Sciens demonstrates an overall solid organisational structure and governance mechanisms, with adequate separation of businesses and functions. The continued staffing turnover and attrition over the past 12 months has led to the current low levels of staff relative to business size. Hiring is in progress to support senior staff. Sound Control Environment: Control functions consist of a dedicated risk team within a separate affiliate and compliance officers. Solid investment risk management and compliance monitoring are supported by solid data management, risk analytics and reporting capabilities. Operational risk management is well embedded throughout the organisation and benefits from automated workflows, documented procedures and system-based controls. Disciplined Formalised Process: The investment process is well documented based on a robust blend of fundamental and quantitative analysis. The competitive advantage of the fund’s research and portfolio construction stems from deep access to underlying hedge fund data and risk analysis capabilities. Strong Administration Capabilities: Sciens's operations platform is robust, enabling a controlled, fully automated implementation of workflows with a variety of service providers. Funds of hedge funds (FoHF) investment administration is handled by Sigma Asset Management (Guernsey) Limited (Sigma), the manager of the funds. Leading IT Platform: A proprietary integrated technological platform, risk analytics and centralised in-house data management capabilities are the company’s key strengths. Sciens also makes available to investors an interactive look-through application that allows them to perform in-depth analysis of managed accounts. Category Scores Good Standards High Standards Highest Standards Company Controls Investments Operations Technology Source: Fitch Profile Alternative Asset Manager: Sciens Capital Management LLC (SCM) and its predecessor firms were founded in 1988 and began alternative asset management activities in 1994. Sciens is owned by John Rigas (71.5%). As of 30 June 2013, the group managed and advised on about USD5.6bn of assets. Assets under management (AUM) of FoHF and managed accounts were USD3.4bn (both in direct investments and advisory). Around forty of SCM’s 100-plus employees are dedicated to the FoHF and managed account platform (MAP). Asset Manager Rating Sciens Funds of Funds Management rating was converted to ―High Standards‖, Stable Outlook from M2- on 22 April 2013. The rating was affirmed on 24 June 2013. Outlook Stable Profile Asset under management (end 2012) USD5.2bn Operating EBITA 2012 Undisclosed Date of creation 1988 Domiciliation Cayman Islands (Sciens) UK (SCL) Ownership John Rigas (71.5%), other Sciens affiliates (28.5%) Total staff 100 (around 40 for Sciens FoF Management Ltd) Investment professionals 7 (for FoHF) Analysts Manuel Arrive, CFA +33 1 44 29 91 77 [email protected] Alastair Sewell +44 20 3530 1147 [email protected]

Upload: eimg20041333

Post on 25-Nov-2015

47 views

Category:

Documents


10 download

DESCRIPTION

hedge fund

TRANSCRIPT

  • Fund & Asset Manager Rating Group

    www.fitchratings.com 22 August 2013

    Fund of Hedge Fund Managers / Caymans

    Sciens Fund of Funds Management Holdings Ltd Full Rating Report

    Key Rating Drivers

    Solid Adaptability, Staff Turnover: Sciens Fund of Funds Management Holdings Ltd (Sciens)

    has continued to expand and diversify its managed accounts offering, which is at the centre of

    its growth strategy. Operating profitability has increased in 2012 from the 2011 low levels.

    Sciens demonstrates an overall solid organisational structure and governance mechanisms,

    with adequate separation of businesses and functions. The continued staffing turnover and

    attrition over the past 12 months has led to the current low levels of staff relative to business

    size. Hiring is in progress to support senior staff.

    Sound Control Environment: Control functions consist of a dedicated risk team within a

    separate affiliate and compliance officers. Solid investment risk management and compliance

    monitoring are supported by solid data management, risk analytics and reporting capabilities.

    Operational risk management is well embedded throughout the organisation and benefits from

    automated workflows, documented procedures and system-based controls.

    Disciplined Formalised Process: The investment process is well documented based on a

    robust blend of fundamental and quantitative analysis. The competitive advantage of the funds

    research and portfolio construction stems from deep access to underlying hedge fund data and

    risk analysis capabilities.

    Strong Administration Capabilities: Sciens's operations platform is robust, enabling a

    controlled, fully automated implementation of workflows with a variety of service providers.

    Funds of hedge funds (FoHF) investment administration is handled by Sigma Asset

    Management (Guernsey) Limited (Sigma), the manager of the funds.

    Leading IT Platform: A proprietary integrated technological platform, risk analytics and

    centralised in-house data management capabilities are the companys key strengths. Sciens

    also makes available to investors an interactive look-through application that allows them to

    perform in-depth analysis of managed accounts.

    Category Scores

    Good Standards High Standards Highest Standards

    Company

    Controls

    Investments

    Operations

    Technology

    Source: Fitch

    Profile

    Alternative Asset Manager: Sciens Capital Management LLC (SCM) and its predecessor

    firms were founded in 1988 and began alternative asset management activities in 1994. Sciens

    is owned by John Rigas (71.5%). As of 30 June 2013, the group managed and advised on

    about USD5.6bn of assets. Assets under management (AUM) of FoHF and managed accounts

    were USD3.4bn (both in direct investments and advisory). Around forty of SCMs 100-plus

    employees are dedicated to the FoHF and managed account platform (MAP).

    Asset Manager Rating

    Sciens Funds of Funds Management rating was converted to High Standards, Stable Outlook from M2- on 22 April 2013. The rating was affirmed on 24 June 2013.

    Outlook Stable

    Profile

    Asset under management (end 2012)

    USD5.2bn

    Operating EBITA 2012 Undisclosed Date of creation 1988 Domiciliation Cayman Islands

    (Sciens) UK (SCL)

    Ownership John Rigas (71.5%), other Sciens affiliates (28.5%)

    Total staff 100 (around 40 for Sciens FoF Management Ltd)

    Investment professionals 7 (for FoHF)

    Analysts

    Manuel Arrive, CFA +33 1 44 29 91 77 [email protected] Alastair Sewell +44 20 3530 1147 [email protected]

  • Fund & Asset Manager Rating Group

    Sciens Fund of Funds Management Holdings Ltd

    August 2013 2

    AUM Breakdowns

    0

    1,000

    2,000

    3,000

    4,000

    5,000

    6,000

    7,000

    2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

    FoHF Managed accounts FoHF advisory Private equity

    By Asset Type

    (USDm)

    Source: Sciens

    Asia & Middle

    East

    28.5%

    Americas

    0.2%

    Europe

    59.8%

    Other

    11.5%

    By Investor Location(% of total FoHF AUM (including Advisory)

    As at December 2012)

    Source: Sciens

    Opportunistic

    19.3%

    Global macro

    0.5%

    Managed

    futures

    0.7%

    Relative value

    19.3%

    Equity

    38.7%

    Fund of

    managed

    accounts

    10.7%

    Alternative beta

    10.7%

    By Strategy (Managed Accounts)(As at December 2012)

    Source: Sciens

    Thematic

    FofHF

    10%

    Multo-Strategy

    90%

    By Strategy (FoHF)(As at December 2012)

    Source: Sciens

    Company Structure

    Sciens Fund of Fund Management Holdings Group at 31 March 2013

    Source: Transaction documents

    Sciens Fund of Funds Management Holdings Ltd.

    Cayman

    Sciens Investment Management LLC

    Delaware

    Sciens Capital Limited England

    Sigma Asset Management (Guernsey)

    Limited Guernsey

    Sciens FOF Consulting Group

    Ltd. Cayman

    Sciens Offshore Management Ltd.

    Cayman

    Sciens CFO I Management Ltd.

    Cayman

    Sciens Fund of Funds

    Management Ltd. Cayman

    Sciens Group Fund Services

    Limited Guernsey

    Sciens Group Risk Services Limited

    England

    John Rigas

    Sciens FOF Offshore Holdings

    Ltd.Cayman

    71.5%28.5%

    Ownership 100% Unless Stated Dormant and Liquidating Companies Omitted

    Rating Scope

    Related Criteria

    Asset Manager Rating Criteria (April 2013)

  • Fund & Asset Manager Rating Group

    Sciens Fund of Funds Management Holdings Ltd

    August 2013 3

    Company High Standards

    Key Findings

    Well-established, specialist, privately owned, alternative asset manager, hedge fund investor since 1994.

    Consolidator of the industry between 2008 and 2010, now focusing on organic growth (through MAP).

    Low albeit improving profitability of FoHF and MAP business at current AUM levels (accelerating growth of MAP in 2013).

    Structural independence of firm and its affiliates (hosting separate businesses and functions), complemented by appropriate

    governance practices.

    Staff turnover and attrition since 2011 allowed a reduction of personnel costs but increased key person dependency and individual

    workload. Senior staff is in place with hiring being in progress to support them further.

    Sciens has a concentrated client base.

    Shareholding and Financial Standing

    Privately owned

    alternative asset manager

    SCM is an independent New York-based alternative asset manager established in 1994, originally

    focused on private equity. The predecessor firms of SCM, however, trace their roots back to 1988.

    The founder and ultimate owner of SCM is John Rigas. He is now chairman and chief executive officer

    of SCM. John Rigas has overall responsibility for the firm and its management.

    As at 30 June 2013, the group managed assets in private equity, venture capital, structured finance,

    real estate, aviation and FoHF for a total of USD5.6bn.

    Activities segregated in

    separate affiliates

    The FoHF business is hosted by the dedicated affiliate, Sciens, incorporated in the Cayman Islands.

    Sciens Group Fund Services Limited (SGFS) is a managed account services provider and the manager

    of Sciens Group Alternative Strategies PCC Limited, a Guernsey-based managed account platform.

    Both these entities were acquired from Partners Group AG (and rebranded) in April 2010.

    Sciens Capital Limited (SCL) serves as investment advisor to Sigma, its affiliated offshore fund of funds

    investment manager, incorporated in Guernsey. Sigma is dedicated to management, operations,

    compliance with the funds policies and legal due diligence on the underlying hedge funds for the FoHF

    business.

    Sciens Group Risk Services Limited (SGRS) provides risk management services.

    Sciens Management LLC is the dedicated private equity affiliate of the group.

    Low profitability, AUM

    growth in 2013

    Fitch has reviewed the consolidated audited financial statements of Sciens. Fitch did not review the

    financial statements of SCM and other affiliates. Based on the information provided, Fitch concluded

    that the financial condition of Sciens is adequate.

    The FoHF and MAP business show a low profitability and cash flow generation at current AUM levels.

    However, operational profitability has increased in 2012, largely due to lower costs. In 2013, AUM

    growth (driven by MAP AUM increasing from USD504m to over USD763m as at end of June), and

    performance fees increasing should contribute to higher revenues.

    Despite the positive momentum in AUM growth in the year to date, a major challenge for the company

    is to accelerate fund raising to increase the revenue base and profitability.

  • Fund & Asset Manager Rating Group

    Sciens Fund of Funds Management Holdings Ltd

    August 2013 4

    Company (continued) High Standards

    Experience

    FoHF manager since 1994,

    MAP since 2010

    FoHF activities started in 2003 at Sciens and in 1994 at Atlas, a London-based FoHF advisor, acquired

    by Sciens in September 2008. Through Atlas, Sciens has a 19-year track record.

    After 2008, Sciens has defined and executed in a timely and appropriate manner its external

    growth strategy to adapt to structural changes in the industry.

    One of the key drivers of the acquisition of Atlas in 2008 was the companys technological and

    operational platform. Subsequently, Sciens was appointed in April 2009 as sub-advisor of the residual

    FoHF activities of Fairfield Greenwich Group, which totalled USD2.4bn at the time. In April 2010, Sciens

    acquired the managed account platform of Partners Group AG.

    Sciens management swiftly restructured the firm around the core Atlas legacy platform and MAP. In

    Fitchs view, Sciens has demonstrated its ability to consolidate teams and platforms.

    Sciens has diversified the managed accounts it offers, which, along with a focused, rationalised range

    of liquid traditional FoHFs, is at the centre of its growth strategy.

    Diversification of investor

    base in progress

    Sciens investor base consists of around 120 clients (mostly global institutions), as at June 2013. It is

    diversified by region and by client type (see charts on page 2), but shows some concentration, as the

    five largest clients accounted for about 75% of AUM as of 30 June 2013.

    The largest FoHF client represents about 30% of FoHF AUM. The MAP has 38 institutional investors as

    at June 2013. The largest MAP investor represents 40% of AUM.

    Sciens has gained three and 26 new clients for FoHF (including advisory) and MAP, in the year to June

    2013.

    Governance and Independence

    Appropriate company

    supervision

    SGFS is regulated by the Guernsey Financial Service Commission (GFSC) in Guernsey and by the

    Commodities and Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) in the US. SCL is regulated by the Financial

    Conduct Authority (FCA), the Securities & Exchange Commission (SEC) and the CFTC. Sigma is

    regulated by the GFSC, the SEC and the CFTC.

    None of the FCA, the SEC or the CFTC has inspected the relevant FoHF companies of the group

    which fall under their jurisdiction. The GFSC visited the MAP while it was owned by Partners Group in

    2009. No major issues were raised.

    There is no independent board director on the board of Sciens, SCL or SGFS. Sigma has two

    independent directors. There are also two independent directors on the board of SGAS and on each of

    Sigmas ongoing funds.

    Deloitte (Cayman) is the auditor of Sciens. KPMG Channel Islands Ltd is the appointed auditor for the

    MAP. Deloitte LLP (Guernsey) is the auditor for Sigma and its funds.

    Well formalised intra-

    group relationships

    Intra-group service level agreements govern the relationship between the Sciens affiliates which have

    outsourced certain functions to other affiliates of the Sciens group. SCL provides management, legal,

    marketing and investor relations support to SGFS. SGRS provides risk management services to SGFS

    and Sigma. Most FoHF operations are delegated to Sigma.

    In general, the FoHF business and the MAP are segregated to prevent FoHF business from obtaining

    detailed information about the portfolio construction of the underlying managed accounts unless

    specific mandates allow this. A separate risk management affiliate SGRS is in charge of monitoring the

    FoHF and MAP investment activities, thereby reinforcing the independence of the risk management

    function.

  • Fund & Asset Manager Rating Group

    Sciens Fund of Funds Management Holdings Ltd

    August 2013 5

    Company (continued) High Standards

    Sound investment vehicle

    governance

    Funds are domiciled in the Cayman Islands or Guernsey. Some funds are listed on the Channel

    Islands and Irish stock exchanges. The majority of Sigma FoHF has two independent board

    members. Board meetings are generally held every six months at a minimum.

    The MAP consists of Guernsey-based protected cell company structures. MAP assets are held by

    the various custodian and sub-custodians. The MAP is separated from trading advisors for all

    governance and controls issues.

    Staffing

    Clear organisational

    structure, staff turnover

    Sciens has a good organisational structure, with an adequate separation of businesses and

    functions, often through separate companies.

    Sciens has experienced staffing turnover and attrition since 2011, which has led to the current low

    levels of staff relative to business size. In Fitchs view, this tends to increase key person dependency

    and individual workload, particularly for MAP personnel, legal and FoHF portfolio management.

    High calibre, renewed

    senior staff

    Stavros Siokos, who joined in 2011 is based in London and heads the FoHF and MAP business. He

    provides leadership for the whole platform, thereby reducing the historic reliance on John Rigas, who

    retains an overall responsibility for the firm and its management. Notable new hires are Alex Allen,

    who joined in 2011 as senior portfolio manager (PM), and in 2012, Tim Wilkinson who is responsible

    for global business development and distribution.

    In 2012-13, the head of MAP and the head of MAP operations left. The head of MAP operations was

    replaced by a former holder of that position who rejoined the company and Stavros Siokos has taken

    over as head of MAP. Sciens is in the process of adding junior to medium level staff to support the

    senior staff in place.

    Good alignment of

    interest

    Sciens employees have a market competitive base salary and a discretionary bonus, which is not

    directly linked to fund performance for PMs. A bonus is paid in three tranches per year. Employees

    may invest in the FoHF products, subject to the approval of the CEO and compliance officers. A long-

    term incentive plan for senior managers has recently been implemented.

    Funds typically have a 10% Performance fee, no hurdle rate with high water mark.

    Structure Diagram

    a Share their roles with other teams in the chart

    b Including 4 external third party marketers

    Source: Transaction documents

    John Rigas Chairman Group CEO

    Christopher Meyering General Counsel

    Legal, Compliance Support (3)

    a

    Dr. Stavros Siokos, Ph.DCEO

    Tim WilkinsonPresident

    Accounting, Treasury, Tax & IT

    (4)

    Sciens Group Risk Services (SGRS)

    (5)

    Sciens Managed Account Platform

    (Map) Dr. Stavros Siokos,

    Ph.D.

    Sciens Investment Services

    Tim Wilkinson (9)b

    Sciens Fund of Hedge Funds John

    Rigas - CIO

    Sciens Advisory Solutions

    Roberto Botero (2)

    Map Legal (3)Map

    Operations (4)

    Operations & Due Diligence

    (8)

    Investment Research, Data (8)

  • Fund & Asset Manager Rating Group

    Sciens Fund of Funds Management Holdings Ltd

    August 2013 6

    Controls High Standards

    Key Findings

    Risks are actively overseen by management, investment committee and risk committee.

    Control functions consist of a dedicated investment risk team within a separate affiliate, SGRS and compliance officers.

    Sciens has a demonstrated ability to oversee and control a large number of service providers.

    System-based controls and automated workflows contribute to embedding risk management in the processes.

    Underlying hedge fund and portfolio surveillance is well framed through numerous formal risk triggers.

    Risk and statistical analysis and reporting, supported by solid data management and risk analytics with central IT platform.

    High quality investment risk reporting packs.

    Overall Risk Control Framework

    Enterprise-wide risk

    oversight by management

    The investment committee (IC) reviews market and liquidity risks of the portfolios. A risk committee has

    been put in place to review the risk books and raise specific concerns to the IC on a monthly basis.

    Sigma, which is the entity in charge of FoHF investment administration, has an operational risk

    committee, with the minutes reviewed by the Sigma board. The MAP does not have a risk committee.

    SGRS, the dedicated risk management affiliate of five focuses on risk and statistical analysis. Its main

    duties are to screen and monitor hedge fund managers as well as to monitor, measure and report

    portfolio risks. This function is also responsible for data management, including the consolidation and

    clean-up of hedge fund and portfolio data, monitoring risk triggers and exposures and other quantitative

    modelling.

    Sciens has a chief compliance officer reporting to John Rigas. Sciens does not have an internal audit

    function, providing a third line of defence.

    Embedded, system-based

    operational risk control

    The good automated workflows and interfaces with third parties contribute to mitigating operational risk.

    FoHF order management is automated between SCL and Sigma. Instructions are then sent by Sigma

    using Scienss core system to the fund administrator and/or custodian as appropriate. The MAP

    benefits from direct feeds from prime brokers and counterparties, thereby avoiding reliance on trading

    advisors.

    Sciens has set up comprehensive risk controls parameters in its systems. For instance, the company

    tracks daily several thousand risk limits, soft limits and warning limits. Risk tools automatically write the

    error status into an SQL error log database.

    Procedures are documented, up to date and centralised. Escalation procedures are effective with a

    rapid notification to the Board facilitated by the small size of the company.

    Sciens encountered just one material error, which was almost fully compensated by the third parties

    involved. Sciens expects to recover the full amount shortly.

  • Fund & Asset Manager Rating Group

    Sciens Fund of Funds Management Holdings Ltd

    August 2013 7

    Controls (continued) High Standards

    Strong third party

    oversight

    FoHF administration is conducted independently by a number of administrators and custodians. The

    main administrators Kleinwort Benson Fund Services (since 1994). The main custodians have been

    ABN AMRO Guernsey since 2002 and UBP, Geneva since 2010. Service level agreements are in

    place with FoHF service providers and the performance of these is monitored by Sigma through key

    indicators and annual on-site reviews.

    SEI Investments Global Funds Services Limited and SS&C Technologies Inc provide sub-

    administrators services to SGFS (NAV determinations, trade reconciliations and reporting). All newly

    launched cells are now sub-administered by SEI.

    In July 2013, Sciens replaced HSBC Securities Services (Guernsey) Limited with ABN AMRO

    (Guernsey) Limited for the custody, transfer agency and registrar functions for the MAP, following

    HSBCs decision to discontinue these services in Guernsey.

    Sciens follows a rigorous on-boarding procedure to select trading advisors for the MAP and the

    relationship is formalised in an Service Level Agreement. Prime brokerage terms are agreed on cell

    by cell basis. MAP service providers produce a monthly report to SGFS, which has been tailored by

    SGFS. The reporting is then discussed during a bi-monthly oversight call with the service provider.

    Control Framework

    Source: Sciens, Fitch

    Board Meeting

    Sigma and SGFS - at least quarterly. SCL - as required SCL Board consists of J Rigas, C Meyering, S Siokos Sigma Board consists of J Rigas, C Meyering, J Sebire, M de Haaff and R Adair (last two independent) SGFS Board consists of S Siokos, S Bougourd and C Marley Oversight of reputation and business risks, assessment of control environment

    Sciens Risk Committee

    Meets as required Consists of A Allen, S Siokos, Risk Managers\ Review of investment risks at fund and manager level

    Sigma Operational Risk Committee

    Monthly Consists of relevant Sigma, SCL and SGRS staff Discusses all operational, legal and investment risk issues of Sigma's funds

    Investment Committee

    Weekly Consists of J Rigas, A Allen, S Siokos, F Mehregani and R Botero Review of portfolio investment and liquidity risk, approval of new funds (FoHF) and Trading Advisers (MAP)

    Fund Boards (Sigma and MAP)

    Sigma funds - at least six monthly; MAP at least quarterly Sigma funds generally have two independent directors; MAP has two independent directors

  • Fund & Asset Manager Rating Group

    Sciens Fund of Funds Management Holdings Ltd

    August 2013 8

    Controls (continued) High Standards

    Compliance and Controls

    Key controls well

    embedded

    FoHF pre- and post-trade compliance checks, including fair allocation rules, are automated in Scienss

    proprietary front office system where all limits are coded. Exposure versus regulatory, legal or internal

    limits are monitored as part of proprietary quantitative risk report on a monthly and quarterly basis for

    FoHF.

    The execution of the FoHF investment decisions is undertaken by Sigma, which has the latitude to veto

    any of SCLs recommendations. Sigma reviews recommendations for consistency with strategy, clarity,

    liquidity impact, holding restrictions, the funds prospectus and due diligence, independently of Sciens

    IC.

    Pre-trade compliance controls versus risk limits for the MAP are performed by the trading advisor. Post

    trade compliance is monitored by Scienss risk function as part of their daily processes. 500 metrics are

    calculated and monitored on a daily basis for the MAP.

    Investment Risk Management

    Advanced quantitative

    market risk management

    FoHF portfolio market risk is assessed quantitatively, based on the net asset value (NAV) of the

    underlying funds. Risk indicators, such as volatility, beta, risk contribution and value at risk (VAR), are

    calculated and monitored by the risk team using proprietary analytics. Sensitivity analysis and other

    quantitative analyses are carried out and reported periodically.

    Invested funds are closely monitored using formal risk triggers to identify material changes in AUM,

    style drift and abnormal fund performance, including performance against historical returns and versus

    peer funds, as represented by strategy indices. Alongside the return-based analysis, Scienss analysts

    also consolidate information gathered on the underlying funds via monthly risk reports adapted to each

    strategy.

    All risk indicators are summarised in a risk book. This document is produced by the data and risk team

    systematically for each portfolio on a monthly basis and is made available to relevant PMs. It is formally

    reviewed by the risk committee and the IC.

    Market risk management of MAP is based on position-based VAR, sensitivities market parameters.

    Stress test and scenario analysis are also conducted. Margin requirements, capital and risk

    concentrations, exposure by asset class and sectors are also closely monitored. In total, more than 500

    metrics are calculated and monitored on a daily basis.

    Good control of liquidity

    risk

    The liquidity of underlying hedge funds is monitored monthly and reported to the IC on an aggregated

    basis to ensure it is consistent with liquidity offered to investors, given redemption forecasts.

    Simulations are conducted to estimate the cost of a rapid liquidation and the fraction of the portfolio

    which could be liquidated within a certain timeframe.

    The proprietary MAP generally offers daily, weekly or monthly liquidity, depending on the manager, and

    daily NAV.

    Counterparty Risk Management

    Appropriate counterparty

    risk management

    Trading advisors of the MAP have to deal with counterparties that have been agreed by Sciens.

    Sciens monitors counterparties daily through rating changes, CDS spreads and equity returns (where

    possible). Counterparty exposure is monitored around agreed limits. Over-the-counter (OTC) credit

    exposure is calculated based on the current market value and risk-based add-on. Margin requirements

    and excess cash are monitored daily. Some of the MAP excess cash is unitised into a money market

    cell managed by JPMorgan.

  • Fund & Asset Manager Rating Group

    Sciens Fund of Funds Management Holdings Ltd

    August 2013 9

    Investments Highest Standards

    Key Findings

    Small team of seven investment professionals and two operational due diligence analysts.

    Deep access to underlying hedge fund data and risk analysis capabilities.

    Standard research process, based on a blend of quantitative and qualitative analysis, well formalised and effectively implemented.

    Well documented hedge fund operational due diligence is conducted in an independent manner by Sigma.

    Most decisions are taken at the five-person IC.

    Portfolio construction is a risk-based, research-driven process, aiming at building more concentrated portfolios (by source of

    uncorrelated alpha) but more diversified (by risk factors).

    Investment Resources

    Small investment team

    John Rigas is the chief investment officer and has 26 years experience in the finance industry.

    Alex Allen, with 15 years industry experience, is the head of research for Sciens FoHF. He is

    supported by two research analysts in London. A senior PM left and the former head of research

    retired in 2012. The small size of the investment team increases reliance on key persons such as

    John Rigas and Alex Allen, in Fitchs opinion.

    IC consists of the most senior investment professionals of the firm: J. Rigas, S. Siokos, A. Allen, F.

    Mehregani and R. Botero.

    The head of research is responsible for the execution of asset allocations and manager selection,

    while overseeing the risk management of portfolios. He has sufficient leeway in portfolio construction

    but investment decisions are made on the basis of allocation and selection decisions reached by the

    IC.

    Research analysts are responsible for manager due diligence and making recommendations to the

    IC. As head of research, the PM is well involved in the research process, beyond his typical role of

    sourcing and managing relationships with managers. Operational due diligence is the responsibility of

    two people one in Sigma and one in New York with support from the legal/risk teams and from

    third-parties where specific expertise is required.

    Very good access to

    information

    Superior access to quality fund data and markets feeds the proprietary research process and allows

    advanced quantitative risk analysis and reporting in FoHF.

    The MAP set up enables access to position-level information, provided from prime brokers and

    custodians in T+1.

  • Fund & Asset Manager Rating Group

    Sciens Fund of Funds Management Holdings Ltd

    August 2013 10

    Investments (continued) Highest Standards

    Investment Discipline

    Disciplined, flexible

    investment process

    Sciens implements a standard, iterative investment process, combining top-down tactical allocations

    with bottom-up manager selection, as described in the diagram below. The process emphasises the

    maximisation of manager selection alpha (through more concentrated portfolios by number of

    managers) and the maximisation of downside protection (through more diversified and uncorrelated

    sources of risks/returns).

    Decisions are taken at the weekly IC meetings. The responsibilities of the IC are to set guideline limits

    for strategic and tactical asset allocations, to provide final approval for manager-recommended lists

    and to continuously review portfolio risk exposures.

    Operational and legal due diligence, conducted both for the fund of funds and the MAP, covers all key

    risks and is documented in an appropriate manner. The process includes the review of a compulsory

    operational risk questionnaire, as well as a number of other requested documents and an on-site

    review.

    There are currently more than 100 funds approved for FoHF investments, including 34 funds from 31

    managers approved on the MAP.

    The trading advisors used on the MAP are subject to a comprehensive due diligence review conducted

    by Scienss risk, legal, operations and business development teams, prior to the appointment to the

    platform. The selection is documented in an on-boarding procedure report.

    Investment Process

    Source: Sciens, Fitch

    Asset Allocation

    Investment Committee Oversight

    Determine Strategic outlook

    Consider Managers for Final due Diligence or Approval

    Review Monthly Portfolio Allocation

    Analyze Monthly Risk Reports

    Review Recent

    Performance

    Fundamental Hedge Fund Monitoring

    Regular Manager Contact

    Formal Evaluation

    Watch List Procedure

    Annual operational Due Diligence

    Quantitative Portfolio Risk

    Monitoring

    Identification of Unexpected or Undesirations or Sensitivity to Risk Factors

    Stress Testing Marginal VAR

    of Each Manager

    Quantitative Risk Oversight Liquidity MonitoringManager Approval/ Selection

    Marco-Economic Outlook/Scenarios Strategy Review & Ranking Recommends

    Portfolio Construction

    Risk/Return Expectations Portfolio Construction

    Parameters

    Due Dilligen Preliminary Approval Separate Operational Due Dilligence Monitoring Initial review

  • Fund & Asset Manager Rating Group

    Sciens Fund of Funds Management Holdings Ltd

    August 2013 11

    Operations High Standards

    Key Findings

    Scalable, flexible, global operations platform both for the MAP and FoHF.

    Straight through processing and effective control points exist between Sciens and service providers for the MAP and FoHF.

    Recognised in-house risk reporting capabilities support investor communication and client services.

    High quality of administrative processes and connectivity with external service providers both for MAP and FoHF.

    Focused operations and legal team for the MAP.

    Operational Procedures

    Small operations teams

    Most FoHF operations are delegated to Sigma, including cash management, relationship management

    with underlying fund registrars, reconciliations and currency hedging. In this regard, Sigma appears

    well equipped, with four full time staff with access to SIMS and a cash management system, IT2.

    Three operations staff are in charge of MAP operations (relationship with trading advisors and sub-

    administrators, payment execution, distribution of documentation.) and three are in charge of legal

    (fund structuring, negotiation of legal documentation).

    Road tested FoHF

    administration capabilities

    A good level of STP between SCL and Sigma supports the fund administration workflows. SCL

    automatically submits recommendations to Sigma, which instructs administrators and/or custodians.

    Once due-diligence status, cash and overall consistency have been checked, an instruction is

    forwarded by Sigma using SIMS to the fund administrator and/or custodian as appropriate.

    All residual cash positions are either placed on deposit with the custodian or in money market funds by

    Sigma, which monitors and forecasts cash levels for up to three months, via the IT2 application.

    Currency management is the responsibility of Sigma, which prepares instructions on each valuation

    date. All active funds are systematically hedged against their base currency.

    Strong MAP operating

    workflows

    The MAP operating model is described in the diagram below. SGFS is the official manager and

    administrator for each cell, but most administration activities are outsourced to third parties through

    agreements.

    Trading advisors are responsible for trade confirmation. Sub-administrators are responsible for trade

    reconciliation and NAV calculation. The operations team and sub-administrators instruct cash

    movements using restricted templates and dual sign-off.

    Communication and Client Servicing

    Standard, transparent

    reporting

    Investor relations are managed by two dedicated client services staff located in New York and London.

    Monthly and quarterly investor reports are generated automatically from SIMS, which is also used as a

    customer relationship management (CRM) tool. Monthly factsheet reports are sent out to investors

    between the 15th and 20th day of the following month. Scienss investor website is available to FoHF

    and MAP clients.

    MAP investors have the ability to perform in-depth analysis of all cells, portfolio of client holdings in

    individual cells within MAP and portfolio simulation using SMART Sciens Managed Account Risk

    Technologies. Bespoke risk analysis is also available upon request.

  • Fund & Asset Manager Rating Group

    Sciens Fund of Funds Management Holdings Ltd

    August 2013 12

    Sciens MAP Operating Model

    Source: Fitch Sciens

    Investors

    Cell/Account

    ABN Amro (Custodian bank)

    Sciens (SGFS, MAP Operator)

    Trading Advisor(Underlying HF

    Investment Firm)

    Market Counterparties

    SEI, SS&C (Fund Sub-Administrator)

    Prime Broker (Cell-Specific)

    Client Invests in One or Several Funds/Accounts in the Platform

    Reporting (via SMART Portal)

    Fund Grants a Sub-Management Agreement to

    MAC Operator

    Fund Assets are Deposited at

    Custodian Bank

    Reconciliation and Controls Reports on

    Matching and Positions Updates

    MAP Grants a Trading Advisory Agreement (TAA)

    Execution on Behalf of Sciens

    HF Firm Sends Trade Details to

    Administrator

    Trade Reconciliation

    Reports on Positions

  • Fund & Asset Manager Rating Group

    Sciens Fund of Funds Management Holdings Ltd

    August 2013 13

    Technology High Standards

    Key Findings

    SIMS Scienss proprietary web-based tool integrates all critical fund research, portfolio risk management and front-office

    operations on the same platform.

    SMART is an interactive look-through engine allowing investors to perform in-depth portfolio analysis.

    Numerous automated interfaces exist between SCL, Sigma and its service providers.

    Centralised SQL database is fed by market data, hedge fund prices, portfolio valuations and cash flows.

    RiskMetrics is complemented by various add-ons and SIMS for MAP risk analysis.

    IT Resources

    In-house small IT team Scienss in-house team consists of two IT professionals in charge of system maintenance and

    development. Data management and data integrity is the responsibility of the risk team.

    Systems

    State of the art,

    proprietary IT platform

    SIMS is a proprietary integrated web-based application, customised to Scienss needs in the areas of

    research, portfolio management and front office operational management. Risk analytics and portfolio

    management tools are all centralised in SIMS.

    As an enterprise-wide solution, SIMS supports MAP risk analysis functionalities, workflow management,

    underlying fund monitoring, portfolio management, reporting and risk control. Sciens uses RiskMetrics as

    an enterprise-wide risk analytics. Salesforce is the main CRM system.

    SMART is an interactive look-through engine allowing investors to perform in-depth analysis of all cells on

    MAP, portfolio of client holdings in individual cells within MAP and portfolio simulation.

    Superior data

    centralisation and system

    interface

    Data is centralised on a SQL database, which is fed by market data (automatically for Bloomberg, HFR,

    Morningstar), hedge fund prices (semi-automatically), portfolio valuations and cash flows (through STP).

    It consolidates the groups portfolio positions, NAVs and other information (due-diligence questionnaires,

    call reports and e-mail copies, for example) on hedge funds. Data collection, analysis and reporting are

    therefore facilitated by the central database.

    RiskMetrics, which is complemented by various add-ons, is also linked with SIMS.

    Sciens benefits from a full integration, due to a centralised infrastructure and an enterprise-wide, front-

    to-back office system.

    IT Security

    Effective disaster

    recovery plan

    Sciens has comprehensive, tested disaster recovery and business continuity plans, with daily back-up

    procedures and alternative emergency sites.

  • Fund & Asset Manager Rating Group

    Sciens Fund of Funds Management Holdings Ltd

    August 2013 14

    IT Map

    Source: Sciens, Fitch

    Risk Metrics

    Risk Engine

    SIMS

    Core Front to Back System

    Central Database

    Bloomberg, HFR, Morningstar

    Market Data

    Administrator/ Prime Broker System

    Portfolio Data

    SMART

    Client Interface

    Proprietary System

    Vendor Solution

  • Fund & Asset Manager Rating Group

    Sciens Fund of Funds Management Holdings Ltd

    August 2013 15

    The ratings above were solicited by, or on behalf of, the issuer, and therefore, Fitch has been compensated for the provision of the ratings.

    ALL FITCH CREDIT RATINGS ARE SUBJECT TO CERTAIN LIMITATIONS AND DISCLAIMERS. PLEASE READ THESE LIMITATIONS AND DISCLAIMERS BY FOLLOWING THIS LINK: HTTP://FITCHRATINGS.COM/UNDERSTANDINGCREDITRATINGS. IN ADDITION, RATING DEFINITIONS AND THE TERMS OF USE OF SUCH RATINGS ARE AVAILABLE ON THE AGENCY'S PUBLIC WEB SITE AT WWW.FITCHRATINGS.COM. PUBLISHED RATINGS, CRITERIA, AND METHODOLOGIES ARE AVAILABLE FROM THIS SITE AT ALL TIMES. FITCH'S CODE OF CONDUCT, CONFIDENTIALITY, CONFLICTS OF INTEREST, AFFILIATE FIREWALL, COMPLIANCE, AND OTHER RELEVANT POLICIES AND PROCEDURES ARE ALSO AVAILABLE FROM THE CODE OF CONDUCT SECTION OF THIS SITE. FITCH MAY HAVE PROVIDED ANOTHER PERMISSIBLE SERVICE TO THE RATED ENTITY OR ITS RELATED THIRD PARTIES. DETAILS OF THIS SERVICE FOR RATINGS FOR WHICH THE LEAD ANALYST IS BASED IN AN EU-REGISTERED ENTITY CAN BE FOUND ON THE ENTITY SUMMARY PAGE FOR THIS ISSUER ON THE FITCH WEBSITE.

    Copyright 2013 by Fitch, Inc., Fitch Ratings Ltd. and its subsidiaries. One State Street Plaza, NY, NY 10004.Telephone: 1-800-753-4824, (212) 908-0500. Fax: (212) 480-4435. Reproduction or retransmission in whole or in part is prohibited except by permission. All rights reserved. In issuing and maintaining its ratings, Fitch relies on factual information it receives from issuers and underwriters and from other sources Fitch believes to be credible. Fitch conducts a reasonable investigation of the factual information relied upon by it in accordance with its ratings methodology, and obtains reasonable verification of that information from independent sources, to the extent such sources are available for a given security or in a given jurisdiction. The manner of Fitchs factual investigation and the scope of the third-party verification it obtains will vary depending on the nature of the rated security and its issuer, the requirements and practices in the jurisdiction in which the rated security is offered and sold and/or the issuer is located, the availability and nature of relevant public information, access to the management of the issuer and its advisers, the availability of pre-existing third-party verifications such as audit reports, agreed-upon procedures letters, appraisals, actuarial reports, engineering reports, legal opinions and other reports provided by third parties, the availability of independent and competent third-party verification sources with respect to the particular security or in the particular jurisdiction of the issuer, and a variety of other factors. Users of Fitchs ratings should understand that neither an enhanced factual investigation nor any third-party verification can ensure that all of the information Fitch relies on in connection with a rating will be accurate and complete. Ultimately, the issuer and its advisers are responsible for the accuracy of the information they provide to Fitch and to the market in offering documents and other reports. In issuing its ratings Fitch must rely on the work of experts, including independent auditors with respect to financial statements and attorneys with respect to legal and tax matters. Further, ratings are inherently forward-looking and embody assumptions and predictions about future events that by their nature cannot be verified as facts. As a result, despite any verification of current facts, ratings can be affected by future events or conditions that were not anticipated at the time a rating was issued or affirmed.

    The information in this report is provided as is without any representation or warranty of any kind. A Fitch rating is an opinion as to the creditworthiness of a security. This opinion is based on established criteria and methodologies that Fitch is continuously evaluating and updating. Therefore, ratings are the collective work product of Fitch and no individual, or group of individuals, is solely responsible for a rating. The rating does not address the risk of loss due to risks other than credit risk, unless such risk is specifically mentioned. Fitch is not engaged in the offer or sale of any security. All Fitch reports have shared authorship. Individuals identified in a Fitch report were involved in, but are not solely responsible for, the opinions stated therein. The individuals are named for contact purposes only. A report providing a Fitch rating is neither a prospectus nor a substitute for the information assembled, verified and presented to investors by the issuer and its agents in connection with the sale of the securities. Ratings may be changed or withdrawn at anytime for any reason in the sole discretion of Fitch. Fitch does not provide investment advice of any sort. Ratings are not a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any security. Ratings do not comment on the adequacy of market price, the suitability of any security for a particular investor, or the tax-exempt nature or taxability of payments made in respect to any security. Fitch receives fees from issuers, insurers, guarantors, other obligors, and underwriters for rating securities. Such fees generally vary from US$1,000 to US$750,000 (or the applicable currency equivalent) per issue. In certain cases, Fitch will rate all or a number of issues issued by a particular issuer, or insured or guaranteed by a particular insurer or guarantor, for a single annual fee. Such fees are expected to vary from US$10,000 to US$1,500,000 (or the applicable currency equivalent). The assignment, publication, or dissemination of a rating by Fitch shall not constitute a consent by Fitch to use its name as an expert in connection with any registration statement filed under the United States securities laws, the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 of the United Kingdom, or the securities laws of any particular jurisdiction. Due to the relative efficiency of electronic publishing and distribution, Fitch research may be available to electronic subscribers up to three days earlier than to print subscribers.