3. department of psychology, bangor university media ... · results 4 undergraduate/graduate...

1
Results Undergraduate/Graduate Category: Undergraduate Degree Level: Bachelor Abstract ID# 1345 Abstract Body image concerns have become excepEonally prevalent, impairing women’s ability to correctly idenEfy healthy body weights aJer media exposure. The purpose of this study was to analyze how women’s percepEons of healthy body types are influenced by the costs of being overweight, the posiEve valence of being thin, and the extent of internalizing media ideals. Eight computer- generated female body images were created with Body Mass Indices (BMI) ranging from 18 to 35. ParEcipants (16 women 18–22 years old) were asked to rate the images, presented randomly over a series of trials, before and aJer viewing a webpage of swimsuit adverEsements. ParEcipants rated how “typical” the images looked on a scale from 1 (thinnest) to 9 (heaviest). Higher perceived cost of being overweight was associated with raEng thinner bodies as more “typical” following the swimsuit adverEsements (r=-.635, p<.009). Higher perceived benefit of being thin was associated with more extreme dieEng behavior (r= .775, p<.001). These preliminary findings support the correlaEon between media exposure and skewed body image. Introduc1on The media is saturated with cultural ideals depicEng thinner women as more acracEve, more desirable and more successful, which adversely impacts women’s body percepEon. This phenomenon negaEvely affects women’s ability to correctly disEnguish healthy body weights. In previous studies, SEce et al. examined the effects of body dissaEsfacEon and how body image distorEons cause a person to view their body to be larger than it is in reality (SEce et al. 2002). This study acributed body dissaEsfacEon to have stemmed from sociocultural pressures like media, family, etc. (SEce et al.). Rhodes et al. took the SEce study further by invesEgaEng whether exposure to distorted bodies can change percepEons of acracEveness. In many Western cultures, acracEveness translates to being thin (Rhodes et al. 2005). The study concluded that the most acracEve body was thinner than the normal body aJer exposure (Rhodes et al.). In more recent studies, Glauert et al. examined how women from Western cultures cope with both body dissaEsfacEon and the effects of perceptual exposure to body ideals (Glauert et al. 2009). This study found that women’s body percepEons were impressionable to these body ideals because higher rates of body dissaEsfacEon were recorded aJer media exposure (Glauert et al.). With consideraEon to the previous studies on body dissaEsfacEon and perceptual exposure to body ideals, the purpose of our study was to analyze the extent to which media ideals can impact social norms related to body image, and to examine the influence it has on women’s percepEons of a healthy body weight. Our study also examined how much having this ideal body shown in media would affect their lives. We examined the perceived costs of being overweight and the perceived benefits of being thin. Methods Conclusion The results from this study lean towards the noEon that women’s percepEons of body image are influenced by the perceived costs of being overweight. If one believes that social status or approval may decrease if one’s weight increases, then a thinner body type is considered more typical aJer media exposure; media exposure thus skewing the percepEon of body images. The posiEve valence of being thin also influences percepEon because of the belief that being thin is more acracEve and more successful. If perceiving benefits of being thin is correlated with extreme dieEng behavior, women exposed to idealized bodies in media might be more likely to engage in unhealthy disordered eaEng behaviors. The internalizing of beauty and idealisEc norms has a negaEve influence on the way women perceive themselves and others, even computer generated sEmuli. These preliminary findings support the correlaEon between media exposure and skewed body image. BEACH SEXY ZIP-FRONT ONE- PIECE $54.50 NEW! BOMBSHELL SWIM TOPS THE BOMBSHELL ADD-2-CUPS PUSH-UP HALTER NEW! VERY SEXY FRINGE MACRAMÉ MONOKINI $108.50 NEW! VERY SEXY ONE- SHOULDER TRIANGLE TOP $46.50 Media exposure impairs percep1on of body image Olesnycky, Olenka 1 ; Asi, Suhair 2 ; Cutrim, Paula 1 ; Hartley, Ludger 3 ; McDonald, Daniel 4 ; Dubois, Russell Heyden 5 ; Rodgers, Rachel 5 ; Lynn, Spencer 4 Figure 1: Example sEmuli created according to the parEcipant’s self described personal characterisEcs. ParEcipants viewed these eight sEmuli 40 Emes, in random order, and categorized the sEmuli from a scale of 1 to 9, where 1 is thinnest and 9 is heaviest. ParEcipants completed three different runs or trials of the percepEon- based task. AJer run 1, parEcipants were primed with a visual search task. The visual search task was implemented to measure the influence of the idealized body type seen in media on the parEcipant’s overall body image percepEon. The task forced parEcipants to look carefully through a mock webpage of a Victoria’s Secret catalog with a few pages of swimsuits by asking detailed quesEons about the bathing suits. AJer the priming, the parEcipants completed the same percepEon-based task during run 2. The raEngs of run 1 and 2 were recorded and compared against each other to measure the effects of the priming. Figure 2: An example of the priming images the parEcipants were exposed to in the visual search task. -0.8 -0.6 -0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 Change in s1mulus number rated most “typical” Perceived cost of being overweight 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 Higher Die1ng Score on Survey Perceived Benefits of Being Thin The survey data was analyzed against the change in run 1 versus run 2 in what sEmulus was most “typical”. From the results obtained from run 1 and run 2 of the percepEon-based task, a change aJer the priming was noEced in which sEmuli were rated most “typical”. A correlaEon in the answers between two subscales of the survey was determined. References Glauert R, Rhodes G, Byrne S, Fink B, Grammer K. 2009. Body DissaEsfacEon and the Effects of Perceptual Exposure on Body Norms and Ideals. Interna1onal Journal of Ea1ng Disorders. Volume 42: 443-452. Rhodes G, Winkler C. 2005. Perceptual AdaptaEon Affects AcracEveness of Female Bodies. Bri1sh Journal of Psychology. Volume 96: 141-154. SEce E, Shaw HE. 2002. Role of Body DissaEsfacEon in the Onset and Maintenance of EaEng Pathology: A Synthesis of Research Findings. Journal of Psychosoma1c Research. Volume 53: 985-993. Figure 3: Example of the Swimsuit Priming Effect For this parEcipant, sEmulus 3 was rated as most “typical” during run 1. AJer priming, sEmulus 2 was rated as most “typical” in run 2. Thus, aJer the priming with the Victoria Secret bathing suit task, the most “typical” body type raEng decreased from sEmulus 3 to sEmulus 2, showing that a thinner sEmuli was perceived as more typical aJer being exposed to media images of ideal body types. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Mean "typical" ra1ng S1mulus number Run 1 Run 2 Figure 4: Higher perceived cost of being overweight was associated with raEng thinner bodies as more “typical” following the swimsuit adverEsements (r=-.635, p<.009). AJer the Victoria Secret Swimsuit priming, parEcipants who perceived high negaEve costs of being overweight on the survey rated a thinner sEmulus as most “typical”. A thinner sEmulus was perceived as more normal on average aJer the priming if the parEcipant believed that there are negaEve outcomes to being overweight, like “having less friends” or “less likely to get a job.” Figure 5: Higher perceived benefit of being thin was associated with more extreme dieEng behavior (r= .775, p<. 001). The parEcipants who marked that there are higher perceived benefits to being thin also recorded that they have dieted in the past 6 months to lose weight. For this subscale of the survey, the parEcipants rated on a 5-point scale their percepEon of the benefits of thinness across a number of areas, including social, professional, and relaEonship success. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Each parEcipant was administered a survey with quesEons falling into eighteen subscales. One subscale looked at the perceived benefits of being thin. This subscale asked the parEcipants to rate how strongly they agreed with phrases such as “If I were thinner I would be happier.” Another subscale looked at the perceived costs of being overweight, and incorporated phrases like “If I were facer I would have less friends”. Eight computer-generated female body images with Body Mass Indices (BMI) ranging from 18 to 35 were created using modelmydiet.com to match that parEcipant’s self-reported personal characterisEcs, such as hairstyle, color and skin tone. 1. Department of Behavioral Neuroscience 2. Department of Biology 3. Department of Psychology, Bangor University 4. Department of Psychology 5. Department of Applied Psychology

Upload: buianh

Post on 25-Sep-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 3. Department of Psychology, Bangor University Media ... · Results 4 Undergraduate/Graduate Category: Undergraduate Degree Level: Bachelor Abstract ID# 1345 Abstract Body image concerns

Results

Undergraduate/GraduateCategory:Undergraduate

DegreeLevel:Bachelor

AbstractID#1345

AbstractBody image concerns have become excepEonallyprevalent,impairingwomen’sabilitytocorrectlyidenEfyhealthybodyweightsaJermediaexposure.Thepurposeofthisstudywastoanalyzehowwomen’spercepEonsofhealthybody typesare influencedby thecostsofbeingoverweight, the posiEve valence of being thin, and theextent of internalizing media ideals. Eight computer-generated female body imageswere createdwithBodyMass Indices (BMI) ranging from 18 to 35. ParEcipants(16 women 18–22 years old) were asked to rate theimages, presented randomly over a series of trials,before and aJer viewing a webpage of swimsuitadverEsements. ParEcipants rated how “typical” theimages looked on a scale from 1 (thinnest) to 9(heaviest). Higher perceived cost of being overweightwas associated with raEng thinner bodies as more“typical”followingtheswimsuitadverEsements(r=-.635,p<.009). Higher perceived benefit of being thin wasassociatedwithmoreextremedieEngbehavior(r=.775,p<.001). These preliminary findings support thecorrelaEon between media exposure and skewed bodyimage.

Introduc1onThemedia issaturatedwithcultural idealsdepicEngthinnerwomenasmoreacracEve,moredesirableandmoresuccessful,whichadverselyimpactswomen’sbodypercepEon.ThisphenomenonnegaEvelyaffectswomen’sabilitytocorrectlydisEnguishhealthybodyweights.Inpreviousstudies,SEceetal.examinedtheeffectsofbodydissaEsfacEonandhowbody imagedistorEonscauseapersontoviewtheirbodytobe larger than it is inreality(SEceetal.2002).ThisstudyacributedbodydissaEsfacEontohavestemmedfromsocioculturalpressures likemedia, family,etc. (SEceetal.).Rhodesetal. tooktheSEcestudy further by invesEgaEng whether exposure to distorted bodies can changepercepEons of acracEveness. In many Western cultures, acracEveness translates tobeingthin(Rhodesetal.2005).ThestudyconcludedthatthemostacracEvebodywasthinner than the normal body aJer exposure (Rhodes et al.). Inmore recent studies,Glauert et al. examined how women from Western cultures cope with both bodydissaEsfacEonandtheeffectsofperceptualexposuretobodyideals(Glauertetal.2009).This study found that women’s body percepEons were impressionable to these bodyidealsbecausehigher ratesofbodydissaEsfacEonwererecordedaJermediaexposure(Glauert et al.).With consideraEon to the previous studies on body dissaEsfacEon andperceptualexposuretobodyideals,thepurposeofourstudywastoanalyzetheextenttowhichmedia idealscan impactsocialnormsrelatedtobody image,andtoexaminetheinfluence it has on women’s percepEons of a healthy body weight. Our study alsoexaminedhowmuchhavingthis idealbodyshowninmediawouldaffecttheirlives.Weexamined theperceived costsof beingoverweight and theperceivedbenefitsof beingthin.

Methods

ConclusionTheresults fromthisstudy leantowardsthenoEonthatwomen’spercepEonsofbody imageareinfluencedbytheperceivedcostsofbeingoverweight.Ifonebelievesthatsocialstatusorapprovalmaydecreaseifone’sweightincreases,thenathinnerbodytypeisconsideredmoretypicalaJermediaexposure;mediaexposurethusskewingthepercepEonofbodyimages.TheposiEvevalenceofbeingthinalsoinfluencespercepEonbecauseofthebeliefthatbeingthinismore acracEve and more successful. If perceiving benefits of being thin is correlated withextremedieEngbehavior,womenexposedtoidealizedbodiesinmediamightbemorelikelytoengage in unhealthy disordered eaEng behaviors. The internalizing of beauty and idealisEcnorms has a negaEve influence on the way women perceive themselves and others, evencomputergeneratedsEmuli.ThesepreliminaryfindingssupportthecorrelaEonbetweenmediaexposureandskewedbodyimage.

NEW! VERY SEXY&FRINGEMACRAMÉ BRALETTE

$58.50Matching)Bo,om)$48.50

5&Colors

PLUNGE-FRONT CAFTAN

$79.504&Colors

NEW! BEACH SEXY&MESH CROPTOP$34.50

Matching)Bo,om)$22.50

NEW! BEACH SEXY&THE FLIRTBANDEAU

$38.50Matching)Bo,om)$20.50

2&Colors

BEACH SEXY&ZIP-FRONT ONE-PIECE

$54.506&Colors

NEW! BOMBSHELL SWIM TOPSTHE BOMBSHELL ADD-2-CUPS

PUSH-UP HALTER

$64.50Matching)Bo,om)$34.509$38.50

3&Colors

NEW! VERY SEXY&FRINGEMACRAMÉ MONOKINI

$108.503&Colors

NEW! VERY SEXY&ONE-SHOULDER TRIANGLE TOP

$46.50Matching)Bo,om)$38.509$42.50

2&Colors

NEW! VERY SEXY&THE SEXIESTBANDEAU

$44.50Mix)&)Match)Bo,oms)24.509$46.50

5&Colors

FOREVER SEXY&THEUNFORGETTABLE DEMI TOP

$56.50Mix)&)Match)Bo,oms)$28.509$38.50

14&Colors

FOREVER SEXY&THE KNOCKOUTBANDEAU

$39.50Mix)&)Match)Bo,oms)$28.509$38.50

12&Colors

NEW! VERY SEXY&MESH-INSETTRIANGLE TOP

$42.50Matching)Bo,om)$38.509$42.50

2&Colors

Mediaexposureimpairspercep1onofbodyimageOlesnycky,Olenka1;Asi,Suhair2;Cutrim,Paula1;Hartley,Ludger3;McDonald,Daniel4;Dubois,RussellHeyden5;Rodgers,Rachel5;Lynn,Spencer4

Figure1:ExamplesEmulicreatedaccordingtotheparEcipant’sselfdescribedpersonalcharacterisEcs.

ParEcipants viewed these eight sEmuli 40 Emes, in random order, andcategorized the sEmuli from a scale of 1 to 9, where 1 is thinnest and 9 isheaviest.ParEcipantscompletedthreedifferentrunsortrialsofthepercepEon-basedtask.AJerrun1,parEcipantswereprimedwithavisualsearchtask.

The visual search task was implemented to measure the influence of theidealized body type seen in media on the parEcipant’s overall body imagepercepEon. The task forced parEcipants to look carefully through a mockwebpageofaVictoria’sSecretcatalogwithafewpagesofswimsuitsbyaskingdetailedquesEonsaboutthebathingsuits.

AJer thepriming, theparEcipants completed the samepercepEon-based taskduring run2.TheraEngsof run1and2were recordedandcomparedagainsteachothertomeasuretheeffectsofthepriming.

Figure2:AnexampleoftheprimingimagestheparEcipantswereexposedtointhevisualsearchtask.

-0.8

-0.6

-0.4

-0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80Chan

geins1

mulusnum

berrated

most“typical”

Perceivedcostofbeingoverweight

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70HigherDie1n

gScoreon

Survey

PerceivedBenefitsofBeingThin

Thesurveydatawasanalyzedagainstthechangeinrun1versusrun2inwhatsEmuluswasmost“typical”.

Fromtheresultsobtainedfromrun1andrun2ofthepercepEon-basedtask,achangeaJertheprimingwasnoEcedinwhichsEmuliwereratedmost“typical”.

AcorrelaEonintheanswersbetweentwosubscalesofthesurveywasdetermined.

ReferencesGlauertR,RhodesG,ByrneS,FinkB,GrammerK.2009.BodyDissaEsfacEonandtheEffectsofPerceptualExposureonBodyNormsandIdeals.Interna1onalJournalofEa1ngDisorders.Volume42:443-452.RhodesG,WinklerC.2005.PerceptualAdaptaEonAffectsAcracEvenessofFemaleBodies.Bri1shJournalofPsychology.Volume96:141-154.SEceE,ShawHE.2002.RoleofBodyDissaEsfacEonintheOnsetandMaintenanceofEaEngPathology:ASynthesisofResearchFindings.JournalofPsychosoma1cResearch.Volume53:985-993.

Figure3:ExampleoftheSwimsuitPrimingEffectFor this parEcipant, sEmulus 3was rated asmost “typical”during run 1. AJer priming, sEmulus 2 was rated as most“typical” in run 2. Thus, aJer the primingwith the VictoriaSecretbathingsuittask,themost“typical”bodytyperaEngdecreased from sEmulus 3 to sEmulus 2, showing that athinner sEmuli was perceived as more typical aJer beingexposedtomediaimagesofidealbodytypes.

123456789

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Mean"typical"ra

1ng

S1mulusnumber

Run1 Run2

Figure 4: Higher perceived cost of being overweight wasassociated with raEng thinner bodies as more “typical”following the swimsuit adverEsements (r=-.635, p<.009).AJer theVictoriaSecretSwimsuitpriming,parEcipantswhoperceived high negaEve costs of being overweight on thesurvey rateda thinner sEmulusasmost “typical”.A thinnersEmuluswasperceivedasmorenormalonaverageaJerthepriming if the parEcipant believed that there are negaEveoutcomes to being overweight, like “having less friends” or“lesslikelytogetajob.”

Figure 5: Higher perceived benefit of being thin wasassociatedwithmoreextremedieEngbehavior(r= .775,p<.001). The parEcipants who marked that there are higherperceivedbenefitstobeingthinalsorecordedthattheyhavedietedinthepast6monthstoloseweight.Forthissubscaleofthesurvey,theparEcipantsratedona5-pointscaletheirpercepEon of the benefits of thinness across a number ofareas,includingsocial,professional,andrelaEonshipsuccess.

12345678

Each parEcipant was administered a survey with quesEonsfalling into eighteen subscales. One subscale looked at theperceived benefits of being thin. This subscale asked theparEcipants to rate how strongly they agreed with phrasessuch as “If I were thinner I would be happier.” Anothersubscale looked at the perceived costs of being overweight,and incorporated phrases like “If Iwere facer Iwould havelessfriends”.

Eight computer-generated female body images with BodyMassIndices(BMI)rangingfrom18to35werecreatedusingmodelmydiet.com to match that parEcipant’s self-reportedpersonalcharacterisEcs,suchashairstyle,colorandskintone.

1.DepartmentofBehavioralNeuroscience2.DepartmentofBiology3.DepartmentofPsychology,BangorUniversity

4.DepartmentofPsychology5.DepartmentofAppliedPsychology