3j4e –jigsaw, jumpstart, juncture forexercises ... · play of basic adoption of prepared scenario...
TRANSCRIPT
3J4
E –
JIG
SA
W, J
UM
PS
TA
RT
, JU
NC
TU
RE
fo
rE
xer
cise
s
Th
ree
way
sto
enh
ance
yo
ur
cyb
erex
erci
seex
per
ien
ce
Ste
fan
Rit
ter
FIR
ST
Co
nfe
ren
ce B
erli
n /
20
15
/06
/15
20
15
/06/1
5N
atio
na
l IT-S
itua
tion
Ce
nte
r a
nd
CE
RT-B
un
d1
Na
tio
na
l IT
-Sit
ua
tio
n-C
ente
r
20
15
/06/1
5N
atio
na
l IT-S
itua
tion
Ce
nte
r a
nd
CE
RT-B
un
d2
Na
tio
na
l IT
-Cri
sis-
Rea
ctio
n-C
ente
r
20
15
/06/1
5N
atio
na
l IT-S
itua
tion
Ce
nte
r a
nd
CE
RT-B
un
d3
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
d C
ER
T-B
un
d4
3J4
E -
Mo
du
les
JIG
SA
W
JU
MP
STA
RT
JU
NC
-T
UR
E
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d5
3J4
E -
Mo
du
les
JIG
SA
W
JU
MP
STA
RT
JU
NC
-T
UR
E
Lar
ge
scal
e IT
-Cri
sis
Man
agem
ent
Exe
rcis
es
�LU
EK
EX
�7
0 B
SI-
pla
yers
(3
00
0,
5+
7
DE
sta
tes,
80
in
stitu
tio
ns)
�C
yber
Euro
pe
�2
0 B
SI-
pla
yers
(2
5 n
atio
ns)
�C
yber
Sto
rm I
V
�4
0 B
SI-
pla
yers
56
h
(14
na
tio
ns)
�N
AT
O C
C (
~2
9 n
atio
ns)
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d6
Preparation
Pa
rtic
ipa
tio
n M
atr
ix
Basic
Med
ium
Hig
h
Unid
irectional
Com
munic
ation
Multid
irectional
Com
munic
ation
Multid
imensio
nal
Com
munic
ation
1 P
ers
on
2 –
5 P
ers
ons
5 o
r m
ore
pers
ons
Poin
t of
Conta
ct
with
reply
Contr
ibute
to
pla
nnin
g
confe
rences
Hig
h c
ontr
ibution in
top level exerc
ise
pla
nnin
g
Basic
adoption o
f pre
pare
d s
cenario
ele
ments
Influence s
cenario
Advanced a
doption
of
pre
pare
d s
cenario
ele
ments
Ow
n local ele
ments
Make s
cenario
decis
ions
Develo
p c
om
ple
te
sto
rylin
eC
reate
ow
n
obje
ctives
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d7
Playing
Pa
rtic
ipa
tio
n M
atr
ix
Basic
Med
ium
Hig
h
Unid
irectional
Com
munic
ation
Multid
irectional
Com
munic
ation
Multid
imensio
nal
Com
munic
ation
1 P
ers
on
2 –
5 P
ers
ons
5 o
r m
ore
pers
ons
Take p
art
in
confc
alls
Contr
ibute
in
confc
alls
with o
wn
ideas
Pla
y w
ith n
ational
crisis
managem
ent
team
Pla
y of
basic
adoption o
f pre
pare
d
scenario e
lem
ents
Basic
incid
ent
handlin
gLeadin
g r
ole
in I
T
Crisis
-Managem
ent
Incid
ent
Facili
tato
r
Receiv
e info
rmation
Share
info
rmation
Deta
iled t
echnic
al
and s
ituational
report
s
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d8
Mu
ltil
evel
Jig
saw
Sce
nar
io
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d9
AN
D /
OR
Ke
y-an
d-L
ock
Sce
nar
io E
lem
en
ts
Sce
nar
io D
esig
n
Support
ing B
asic
Scenario
sto
rylin
es/t
racks
+ consolid
ation
=
solu
tion
?? ?? ?
?!!
!?
?
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d1
0
Sce
nar
io W
ork
flo
w(s
)
Obje
ctives
>E
xpecte
d P
laye
rA
ctions
>S
tory
line
>M
SE
L>
Pla
y
Sta
ndard
Work
flow
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d1
1
Sce
nar
io W
ork
flo
w(s
)
Obje
ctives
>E
xpecte
d P
laye
rA
ctions
>S
tory
line
>M
SE
L>
Pla
y
Obje
ctives
+P
art
icip
ati
on
C
om
mit
men
t
>C
luste
red
Expecte
d
Pla
yerA
ctions
>C
luste
red
Sto
rylin
e>
Jig
saw
MS
EL
>C
luste
red
Pla
y
Sta
ndard
Work
flow
Modifie
d c
luste
red W
ork
flow
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d1
2
Exe
rcis
ing
is s
tory
tel
lin
g...
�B
aselin
e
�D
ram
atu
rgy
�C
hara
cte
rs
�H
igh a
nd L
ow
Action
�T
urn
ing P
oin
ts
US
E I
T!
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d1
3
Co
sts
/ E
ffo
rts
Sta
ndard
-Exerc
ise
MC
EF
-Exerc
ise
0
0,2
0,4
0,6
0,81
1,2
Hig
h A
ctive
Pla
yer
Mediu
m P
layer
Basic
Part
icip
ant
→ C
osts
for
Hig
h A
ctive P
laye
rs d
on't
rise s
ignific
antly.
The o
thers
can p
art
icip
ate
fro
m them
.
Jig
sa
w
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d1
4
3J4
E -
Mo
du
les
JIG
SA
W
JU
MP
STA
RT
JU
NC
-T
UR
E
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d1
5
JUM
PS
TA
RT
: Ba
sics
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d1
6
Pre
-EX
PO
ST
-EX
(N
OT
PLA
YE
D!)
P
re-E
XE
X-P
lay
ST
AR
TE
XE
ND
EX
Crisi
s M
anagem
ent In
itC
risi
s M
anagem
ent
Wra
p U
pD
ete
ctio
nR
eport
ing / A
lert
ing
Wra
p U
pR
esp
onse
Pre
-Crisi
s
•O
bserv
e•
Orient
•D
ecid
e•
Act
JUM
PS
TA
RT
: As
Is
Pre
-EX
Crisis
Man
ag
em
ent
Wra
p U
p
Pre
-EX
EX
-Pla
yP
OS
T-E
X (
NO
T P
LA
YE
D!)
Dete
ction
Repo
rtin
g / A
lert
ing
Wra
p U
pR
esponse
Pre
-Crisis
EN
DE
XS
TA
RT
EX
Inte
rna
tiona
l P
lay
Nation
al P
lay
Crisis Management Intensity
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d1
7
JUM
PS
TA
RT
: En
ha
nce
men
t
Pre
-EX
EX
-Pla
yP
OS
T-E
X
De
tection
Wra
p U
pR
espon
se
Re
port
ing
/ A
lert
ing
JU
MP
ST
AR
TE
ND
EX
Pre
-Crisis
Inte
ratio
nal P
lay
Nationa
l P
lay
Crisis Management Intensity
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d1
8
JUM
PS
TA
RT
: Tim
elin
e C
om
pre
ssio
n
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d1
9
3J4
E -
Mo
du
les
JIG
SA
W
JU
MP
STA
RT
JU
NC
-T
UR
E
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d2
0
JUN
CT
UR
E: A
s Is
„Wh
ysh
ou
ldI
pa
rtic
ipa
te?
“
„Wh
atis
my
be
ne
fit?
“
„To
ote
ch
nic
al“
„My
focu
sis
po
litic
al“
„To
om
uch
de
tails
“
„No
t m
ym
an
ag
em
en
tle
ve
l“
„So
rry,
I d
on
‘tu
nd
ers
tan
d“
„I f
ee
lm
isu
nd
ers
too
d“
„Yo
ud
on
‘tu
nd
ers
tan
dm
y
str
ate
gy“
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d
JUN
CT
UR
E: E
nh
an
cem
ent
Fo
cu
s o
n:
�S
tra
teg
ic le
ve
l
info
rma
tio
nn
ee
ds
�D
ecis
ion
Su
pp
ort
�D
ecis
ion
Ma
kin
g
�A
gg
reg
ate
dE
ve
nts
�S
ing
ula
r E
ve
nts
�(p
hys
ica
l)
CO
NS
EQ
UE
NC
ES
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d2
2
JUN
CT
UR
E: H
ow
To
(Sin
gu
lari
ty)
Management Level
Hig
hly
div
ers
ed
sin
gle
eve
nt
info
rma
tio
n.
an
d info
rma
tio
n o
n S
ingu
larity
Eve
nt
Slig
htly m
od
ifie
d in
form
ation o
n
Sin
gula
rity
Even
t
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d2
3
JUN
CT
UR
E: H
ow
To
(Ag
gre
ga
tio
n)
Management Level
Hig
hly
div
ers
ed s
ingle
event
info
rmation.
Com
pre
ssed a
nd h
ighly
aggre
ga
ted
situational in
form
ation
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d2
4
3J4
E: C
on
clu
sio
n
�3J4E
is a
n inspiration
�expecta
tion m
anagem
ent
of
pla
yers
�jig
saw
sto
ry-t
elli
ng
�ke
y +
lo
ck s
ce
na
rio
�pla
y diffe
rent
part
s o
f in
cid
ent
tim
elin
e
�in
volv
e m
anagem
ent
adequate
ly
�firs
t experiences s
uccessfu
l
�d
o n
ot th
ink t
oo
co
mp
lica
ted
�tr
y it!
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d2
5
Ko
nta
kt
Bu
nd
esam
t fü
r S
ich
erh
eit
in d
er
Info
rmat
ion
stec
hn
ik (
BS
I)
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
entr
ean
dC
ER
T-
Bu
nd
Go
des
ber
ger
-All
ee 1
85
-1
89
53
17
5 B
on
n
Tel
: +
49
(0)2
28
99
-95
82
-51
10
Fax
: +4
9 (0
)22
89
9-1
0-9
58
2-5
11
0
lag
ezen
tru
m@
bsi
.bu
nd
.de
ww
w.b
si.b
un
d.d
ew
ww
.bsi
-fu
er-b
uer
ger
.de
20
15
/06
/15
Nat
ion
al I
T-S
itu
atio
n C
ente
r an
dC
ER
T-B
un
d2
6