3rd year project by james harper
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
1/38
1
Land use types in the Amazon basin, their connection to precipitation and the implications of
land use change in the basin system
Written by
James Harper
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
2/38
2
Abstract
This report looks at the rates of precipitation above different land use types in the Amazon basin
and shows that there is a significant relationship between the two variables. It is a small part of
the whole basin system but a very significant part none the less. Looking at pasture data sets and
data from the Tropical Rainfall Measurement Mission (TRMM) over the past 12 years from 1998
2009. Using each yearly average from different locations across the basin and statistical tests to
deem the significance of the rates of precipitation. There is a definite link between land use type
and the rates of precipitation, the possible implications these results have on the overall complex
basin system have been looked at and the impacts may be more far reaching that just the basin,
possibly the whole global circulation system.
Keywords
Amazon basin, Precipitation, Global circulation system, Land use change, Hydrological cycle
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
3/38
3
Contents
Page 4 Section 1Introduction
Page 6 Section 2Method
Page 9 Section 3Results
Page 9 3.1Pasture data set
Page 11 3.212 year averaged data
Page 14 3.3Yearly averages of precipitation
Page 21 3.4Statistical Analysis
Page 24 Section 4Discussion
Page 27 Section 5Conclusion
Page 28 Section 6Acknowledgements
Page 29 Section 7References
Page 31 Section 8Appendix 1Project Proposal
Page 35 Section 9Appendix 2Progress Report
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
4/38
4
Introduction (Section 1)
The Amazon basin is roughly located at latitude 5N15S and longitude 75W45W on the
South American continent. It contains the second largest river in the world with the largest
discharge of any river at over 200,000m-3
s-1
of water, due to a drainage basin of approximately
7,000,000km-2. It is the largest rainforest on our planet and one of the worlds major carbon
dioxide (CO2) reservoirs; this is not just looked at in terms of absorption by the trees but from all
the biomass and soil in the basin. It contains many valuable resources and has a large influence
on the global climate and is a dominant factor of the South American climate.
In this project I shall be looking at one aspect of the complex system that is the Amazon basin. I
want to concentrate on a small part of the whole, specifically the impact of the different types of
land use that occur within the Amazon basin. I want to see if there is a link between the rates of
precipitation over the different uses of land in the basin.
My hypothesis is this; there is a significant difference between the types of land use, and
precipitation rates above that land.
I decided to look at this aspect of the basin system because I will be able to justify my results
through quantitative and qualitative methods from the datasets that are available to me. There
have been many published articles on the Amazon Rainforest and the climates relationship to it,
and the link between the drier seasons and the increase in likelihood of forest fires (Arago et al,
2008). Also, how the different atmospheric phenomenon such as the El Nino Southern
Oscillation (ENSO) and the Atlantic Ocean Sea Surface Temperatures (SST) influence
precipitation and the climate across the Amazon basin (Nobre, 2009).
There are predictions about how the whole system may react to the changing global climate
through adaptation, for example by means of deep roots (Markewitz et al. 2010), or having more
negative effects on precipitation rates and the hydrological cycle where extreme events mayoccur for longer periods of time (Hiscock and Tanaka, 2006). There are also ideas on the further
deforestation of forest having an impact itself on the global climate (Bala et al, 2007).
The gap in the market that I am looking at specifically is land use linking to precipitation. I
want to place this work in the larger picture as a small part of the whole system, draw
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
5/38
5
conclusions, and discuss the consequences of the whole system changing. Land use change has
been linked to forest fires (Cochrane and Laurance, 2008), deforestation and loss of bio diversity,
but I believe has not been linked specifically to rates of precipitation with the data set for land
use that I have used in this report (Ramankutty et al, 2008). Also, the availability of new data
sets for land use and the ever increasing volume of data gathered from the Tropical Rainfall
Measurement Mission (TRMM), I have been able to look at longer timescales for precipitation
than was previously available.
The main reasons I am looking at precipitation and land use is because I am interested in how
potentially such a small part of the whole system can have such large implications and feedback,
into not just the regional system of the Amazon basin but potentially the whole global
atmospheric system.
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
6/38
6
Method (Section 2)
I first started by looking at where the precipitation data would come from. The best source for
this precipitation data in the tropics is from the TRMM satellite launched in 1997. Its purpose is
to observe and record precipitation rates and energy exchange in the tropics (Kummerow et al.
1998). I will be using the data collected from the TRMM Precipitation Radar (TPR) and the
TRMM Microwave Imager (TMI) from on board the satellite; these are combined into in large
tables of data. The data is in 3 hourly averaged 0.25x.025 grid boxes, ~25km, from 50N to
50S in a band across the whole planet, therefore the Amazon basin is well within the satellites
coverage and a reliable data set to use for my research.
The data is displayed in mm hr-1 and is taken over the whole year, so the numbers may seem
small but that is because they are averaged over a total of 8760 hours. I also needed to have a
data set that would help me look at land use across the Amazon basin, so I will be using a land
use dataset focusing on pastures, having a resolution of 0.1x0.1, ~10km (Ramankutty et al.
2008). The data is from the year 2000 so it coincides well with my precipitation data that runs
from 19982009. As it is almost from the start of the precipitation dataset then I will be able to
look at the impacts, for nearly a decade after the data was created and hopefully be able to see
what impacts if any have occurred as a result. They are both very high resolution sets of data
which will help me to see if there are any small scale changes in the region.
Both data sets needed to be manipulated into manageable formats for me to be able to use them
effectively. I was helped and taught to use Unix and Python script of which I had no previous
experience. The data was in netcdf form, being a standard format for climate based data sets, and
so could be utilised in the special linked computers, called the escluster, we have at the
University of East Anglia. The cluster consists of ~100 computers linked together generating
sufficient computing power able to process and work with the large datasets I am using. The site
is escluster.uea.ac.uk.
Within the cluster I was using a program called Climate Data Analysis Tools (CDAT) - this
program can easily read the netcdf file format that my data uses. I also used a basic text writing
program called Emacs, this let me type in a script to look at the specific data I wanted to look at,
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
7/38
7
it let me easily write what I needed and was able to be run as part of a longer script to let me see
my data in visual form.
Once my TRMM data had been sorted through for errors in the data and correctly sorted for use
in CDAT, I began to break it down into manageable sets, using Emacs, so I would be able to
look and compare the data. I decided to separate the data into yearly time intervals, as I deemed
it sensible to have an average for the whole year to start with, this would average out any
anomalies and help to highlight any annual patterns. My data ranged from 1998 2009, so I have
12 years of data and trends to look at. I also averaged the data over a 12 year period to see what a
complete average of the data would look like. After I had decided how to break the data down, I
wrote out the time scales, each being a year long, on Emacs and then ran it through scripts that I
had had help with creating (Section 6). Once the scripts had been run I had many individual data
sets for each year, and the multiple yearly averages that I wanted to use. If I needed other
averages or individual months I could still come back and write more into Emacs and run the
scripts I had again to produce what I needed.
The pasture data set was not as complex to work through as it was only from the year 2000. I
was not as confident using pure scripting code in CDAT so I using the Visual Climate Data
Analysis Tools (VCDAT) which was more interactive and easier for me to use, it had buttons
and sliders instead of having to write out the lines of code. I was able to zoom in on the Amazon
basin, by selecting specific latitude and longitude co-ordinates using the sliders on VCDAT, and
look at the areas in which there were the greatest concentrations of pasture. I deemed that
anything below 30% density of pasture was not of a significant impact on the landscape to
majorly alter the atmospheric system above. So I could look more closely at areas of higher
concentration that stood out and compare this to the TRMM data set to see if there were areas of
decreased precipitation that linked into areas of significant pasture outcrops in the basin that I
had found. I marked down those areas of the highest concentrations of pasture.
I began to look at areas of significantly high or low precipitation on the averages I had and mark
down those areas latitude and longitude as well. I created a new data set containing the wettest
season in the Amazon basin. This was December, January and February (DJF). As the wet
season overlaps into the next year I only had 11 data points for each grid box to compare. I did
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
8/38
8
this as I wanted to see what the rates of precipitation would be at the forests wettest point and
what impact this had in the areas of significant pasture.
Taking the rough latitude and longitudes I had, I made 1x1 squares from these areas of pasture,
I have taken the average precipitation for each year from 19982009 in the grid box that I
looked at. I have then taken another 1x1 square of complete rainforest at a sensible distance
from the pasture box, and taken the precipitation average as with the first box. After collecting
the data from different areas across the basin, I wanted to see if the pairs of data were
significantly independent from each other and not just random coincidence.
I wanted to show that the precipitation falling in these areas was significantly different, and
helped to prove my hypothesis about precipitation being linked to land use (Section 1). I used a
Students T Test to test if the groups of data were significantly independent from each other
above a 99% significance level.
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
9/38
9
Results (Section 3)
3.1- Pasture dataset
By looking at the data, I have been able to see some very interesting results relating to the land
use and precipitation in the Amazon basin and also some results I did not expect. The data below
is all that I deemed useful to my report as it shows the pasture data, wet season (DJF) data I was
using and the statistical analysis I conducted.
Figure 1 Pasture data from the year 2000 across the Amazon basin at < 30% density per 0.1 x 0.1 pixel
The pasture data (Figure 1) shows the spread of deforested areas that contain exposed pasture
used for grazing. The colour indicates the level of density of pasture in that area, red meaning the
highest concentrations at 100% coverage and blue meaning 30% coverage and white is the a
density lower than 30% per pixel. There are significant concentrations of pastures on the exterior
of the Amazon basin, but a lower concentration on the interior of the rainforest. The reason for
this is because there are fewer areas of concentrated population. The inhabitants will mostly only
live on the edge of the Amazon River, so any areas that have been deforested for pasture will be
Land use data over the Amazon
Pasture Density (%)
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
10/38
10
smaller than those more accessible areas on the edges of the forest. It is easier for people to fell
trees and use slash and burn techniques on the fringes of the forest and work inwards, this is
easier than trying to log from the interior of the forest and trying to transport the wood cut down
along the river where there is lower accessibility for a large scale operation.
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
11/38
11
3.212 year averaged data
Figure 2 12 year average (19982009) of precipitation (mm hr-1) over the whole Amazon basin
The precipitation data averaged over the 12 years (Figure 2) shows some results I was not
expecting to find, primarily that there are two main areas of more concentrated precipitation in
the Amazon basin.
One is in the West and I know that this is topographically related to the Andes mountain range.
The increasing height above sea level leading up to the mountain range forces the moisture to
ascend but this causes the clouds to form and cool and hold less moisture leading to forced
precipitation in the mountains. This is the reason for the higher levels of precipitation occurringon the western side of the Amazon basin. The rates of precipitation are also influenced in some
part by ENSO during its different phases.
In the area to the East of basin there is a dense concentration of pasture in the approximate area
2S by 49W (Figure 1) that correlates to an anomalously higher area of precipitation in the
19982009 averaged precipitation
Precipitation (mm hr-1)
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
12/38
12
similar location (Figure 2), however this may not be the only cause. As this is a coastal area there
would be the influence of warmer moist air coming off the South Atlantic Ocean due to varying
warmer SST. The ocean acts as a thermal reservoir and there may be increased moisture
available compared to that available on average further inland. Also this area has a high density
of population so the urbanized areas contribute to the modification of the local environment.
Figure 3 12 year average (1998 - 2009) precipitation (mm hr -1) with the Amazon river and its main arteries highlighted
The final interesting piece of information that I found was that purely from averaged
precipitation data the main arteries of the Amazon River itself can clearly be seen. This can be
shown as I have highlighted its outline (Figure 3). I did not expect to see the river as an area of
lower precipitation; I would have expected to see an area of increased precipitation as it is above
a large source of moisture, and would have caused increased rates provided by convective
precipitation in the afternoons in the Amazon. However, I can infer that it is the trees themselves
that provide a greater source from evapotranspiration than the moisture provided the river. Hence
it clearly being defined (Figure 2), approximately 34% of the precipitation in the basin is directly
Precipitation (mm hr-1)
Amazon River highlighted through precipitation
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
13/38
13
from recycled water from within the basin (Trenberth, 1999). As there is greater volume of trees
compared to area of river, the lower rate of precipitation of the river compared to that of the trees
makes it clearly defined on my graph (Figure 3) when the precipitation rates are averaged over
the 12 years of data I have.
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
14/38
14
3.3Yearly averages of precipitation
I have looked at each year of precipitation (Figure 415) to see if there are any significant
patterns in the precipitation across the basin. Looking at the yearly averaged data I can compare
this to global meteorological events that have occurred but I do not want to speculate in this
section, as I am leaving that for my discussion (Section 4).
From the graphs below (Figure 415) it can be seen that over the year the highest volume of
precipitation is consistently within the same two areas in the basin. On the Western side of the
basin at the base of the Andes and on the East coast, I have discussed these initial results already
(Section 3.2) but it is interesting to note that even in the years of severe drought (Figure 11) and
regardless of any other atmospheric influences they remain areas of higher intensity
precipitation, also in the North an area of consistently lower precipitation.
Figure 4 Average precipitation (mm hr-1) in 1998 over the Amazon basin
Precipitation (mm hr-1)
Rainfall in the Amazon basin in 1998
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
15/38
15
Figure 5 Average precipitation (mm hr-1) in 1999 over the Amazon basin
Figure 6 Average precipitation (mm hr-1) in 2000 over the Amazon basin
Precipitation (mm hr-1)
Precipitation (mm hr-1)
Rainfall in the Amazon basin in 1999
Rainfall in the Amazon basin in 2000
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
16/38
16
Figure 7 Average Precipitation (mm hr-1) in 2001 over the Amazon basin
Figure 8 Average precipitation (mm hr-1) in 2002 over the Amazon basin
Precipitation (mm hr-1)
Precipitation (mm hr-1)
Rainfall in the Amazon basin in 2001
Rainfall in the Amazon basin in 2002
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
17/38
17
Figure 9 Average precipitation (mm hr-1) in 2003 over the Amazon basin
Figure 10 Average precipitation (mm hr-1) in 2004 over the Amazon basin
Precipitation (mm hr-1)
Precipitation (mm hr-1)
Rainfall in the Amazon basin in 2003
Rainfall in the Amazon basin in 2004
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
18/38
18
Figure 11 Average precipitation (mm hr-1) in 2005 over the Amazon basin
Figure 12 Average precipitation (mm hr-1) in 2006 over the Amazon basin
Precipitation (mm hr-1)
Precipitation (mm hr-1)
Rainfall in the Amazon basin in 2005
Rainfall in the Amazon basin in 2006
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
19/38
19
Figure 13 Average precipitation (mm hr-1) in 2007 over the Amazon basin
Figure 14 Average precipitation (mm hr-1) in 2008 over the Amazon basin
Precipitation (mm hr-1)
Precipitation (mm hr-1)
Rainfall in the Amazon basin in 2007
Rainfall in the Amazon basin in 2008
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
20/38
20
Figure 15 Average precipitation (mm hr-1) in 2009 over the Amazon basin
Precipitation (mm hr-1)
Rainfall in the Amazon basin in 2009
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
21/38
21
3.4Statistical Analysis
Table 1 Statistical analysis of precipitation rates (mm hr-1) of different land use types in the Amazon basin over the wet season
(DJF) from each year of the dataset at each given latitude and longitude
Latitude/Longitude3.625N2.625N / 61.875W
60.875W1.625S2.625S / 61.875W
60.875W
Year Pasture Rainforest
98/99 0.1837 0.4217
99/00 0.1446 0.3431
00/01 0.0413 0.3094
01/02 0.0378 0.3662
02/03 0.0283 0.2831
03/04 0.0306 0.2222
04/05 0.1114 0.3371
05/06 0.1536 0.4022
06/07 0.0141 0.2098
07/08 0.0787 0.4303
08/09 0.2309 0.4745
Average 0.0959 0.3454
Std Deviation 0.074 0.085
T Test 0.000Table 1a.
Latitude/Longitude0.375S1.375S / 49.625W
48.625W0.125S1.125S / 50.375W
49.375W
Year Pasture Rainforest
98/99 0.4392 0.4616
99/00 0.5697 0.5223
00/01 0.5391 0.5626
01/02 0.3840 0.3815
02/03 0.3765 0.3931
03/04 0.5446 0.5263
04/05 0.3736 0.4260
05/06 0.4738 0.531706/07 0.3747 0.3895
07/08 0.5520 0.5978
08/09 0.5685 0.6315
Average 0.4723 0.4931
Std Deviation 0.085 0.088
T Test 0.071Table 1b.
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
22/38
22
Latitude/Longitude10.125S11.125S / 63.125W
62.125W7.125S8.125S / 63.125W
62.125W
Year Pasture Rainforest
98/99 0.3987 0.4926
99/00 0.3164 0.3938
00/01 0.4074 0.5923
01/02 0.4118 0.5919
02/03 0.3966 0.4598
03/04 0.3905 0.4095
04/05 0.3478 0.3794
05/06 0.4613 0.5466
06/07 0.3516 0.372607/08 0.3739 0.4016
08/09 0.3874 0.4732
Average 0.3858 0.4648
Std Deviation 0.038 0.082
T Test 0.000Table 1c.
Latitude/Longitude
1.125S2.125S / 53.875W
52.875W
1.125S2.125S / 51.875W
50.875W
Year Pasture Rainforest
98/99 0.2293 0.3354
99/00 0.4112 0.3705
00/01 0.2606 0.3873
01/02 0.2107 0.3388
02/03 0.2204 0.3008
03/04 0.2827 0.3674
04/05 0.2587 0.4612
05/06 0.3296 0.493006/07 0.1512 0.2858
07/08 0.2486 0.3893
08/09 0.3537 0.4909
Average 0.2688 0.3837
Std Deviation 0.073 0.071
T Test 0.000Table 1d.
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
23/38
23
Latitude/Longitude5.875S6.875S / 48.125W
47.125W1.875S2.875S / 48.125W
47.125W
Year Pasture Rainforest98/99 0.2327 0.4317
99/00 0.4118 0.5012
00/01 0.3638 0.524201/02 0.3847 0.3619
02/03 0.3825 0.4606
03/04 0.4650 0.5026
04/05 0.3008 0.365105/06 0.3234 0.4863
06/07 0.3475 0.4006
07/08 0.2517 0.5236
08/09 0.2787 0.4704
Average 0.3402 0.4571
Std Deviation 0.071 0.059
T Test 0.000Table 1e.
The pairs of data are made up of one complete area of pasture and one complete area of
rainforest. Four out of my five pairs of data (Table 1a, c, d, e), shown in blue are the results that
passed at a 99% significance level, to 3 decimal places. This proves that these locations are
independent and the data sets are from different locations. My statistical analysis (Table 1a-e)
has helped to show that there is a significant difference in the rates of precipitation, and proves
that my initial hypothesis (Section 1) that land use type affects the rate of precipitation above that
land use. It is the quantitative result I wanted to see and to show that there is a difference
between the types of land use and from this to discuss the implications of my findings. There was
one data pair that was not significant at either the 99% or 95% significance level (Table 1b),
which was the exception to the rest of my data. This pair was taken in the East of the basin in an
area of anomalously high average precipitation (Figure 2), which I have discussed previously in
my report. With further time and more detailed datasets on more land use types I believe I would
find results of a similar nature.
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
24/38
24
Discussion (Section 4)
From my results (Section 3) I have shown that there is a statistically significant difference
between the rates of precipitation above the different types of land use in the Amazon basin. I
have also found that the Amazon River itself is a land use type that influences the rates of
precipitation (Figure 23). The averaged data from each year (Figure 415) can be seen to
have been influenced from factors external to the basin. Although, it is hard to discern any real
seasonal pattern of rainfall from my graphs due to these external factors that vary from year to
year. It can still be seen throughout each graph that there are areas of consistently higher and
lower precipitation (Section 3.3). In 2001 (Figure 7) there is a higher precipitation rate further
into the Amazon basin than in the rest of my yearly averages. I believe this is due to a stronger
ENSO and a warmer set of SST in the South Atlantic which have both been seen to influence therates of precipitation in the basin (Liebmann, 2001).
Also, during 2005 (Figure 11) there was a major drought that plagued the Amazon basin (Zeng,
et al. 2008). It was very close to pushing the Amazon Rainforest past a tipping point, where it
would not have been able to fully recover from the damage caused. The reason that this was of
such concern was because, the longer the drought continued the lower the water table in the soil
became, this forced deep roots to seek out water further into the soil (Markewitz et al, 2010). If
the drought had continued any further without any significant period of precipitation the treeswould not have had enough water to survive till the next rainy season, even with the adaptations
of deep roots that draw water from deep sources (Zeng et al, 2009) throughout the dry season. So
with an increase in the change in land use across the basin, which we know has an influence on
the rates of precipitation (Table 1) Also from other papers, that show different land use types
have different varying on the atmosphere such as Pielke et al (2007). I can infer that there may
be more exposed soil, less land containing large tropical trees, which are able to contain
significant volumes of water, and more areas of pasture. Thus overall a decreased rate of
moisture entering the basin system through evapotranspiration in the long term would begin to
cause wide spread problems throughout the system.
It has been discussed byMalhi et al. (2009) that in the short term the Amazon may adapt its
overall system due to a change in land use and increased temperatures, but it would most likely
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
25/38
25
push the Amazon towards a seasonal forest instead of a rainforest. Even though land use change
is a small part of the whole it can have a large impact on the overall system. The lower
precipitation rates mean that there is more chance of prolonged large scale droughts throughout
the basin. If there were longer periods of drought there would be a higher chance of forest fires
occurring (Arago et al, 2008) due to the drying out of vegetation. The outside forcing of a
potential increase in global temperature, may also be another major factor that may influence the
length of the wet and dry seasons in the Amazon basin. With the chance of increased areas of
pasture it is much easier for this land use and similar types to dry out compared to tropical forest,
so more fires may occur and spread across the basin, making the rest of the basin vulnerable to a
much greater extent of damage. Also from the increased amount of fires occurring more burnt
carbon would be put into the atmosphere, leading to a higher proportion of cloud condensational
nuclei (CCN). In the short term this may be advantageous meaning there are more particles for
rain droplets to form around, but as the proportion increased then the spread of water droplets
would become thinned out across the area instead of more concentrated rainfall, and with less
moisture entering the system this would only help to further weaken the intensity of
precipitation. If this occurred or if there was less precipitation due to the changing land use in the
basin then the forest could be pushed past a tipping point (Nepstad et al, 2008) where it would be
almost impossible to restore the forest to its original state.
After the tipping point the forest will either readjust or collapse to become a seasonal forest
rather than a rainforest as mentioned above in the paper byMahli et al, (2009). If this were to
occur it would mean a massive loss in bio diversity in the basin. The forest would rapidly die
back to a much smaller size than it currently is and this has more implications. It would be a loss
of a large CO2
sink and storage area (Botta et al, 2002), although the scale of the sink is a subject
of discussion, as with all of the major carbon sinks and the volumes of CO2
they are able to hold.
But regardless of its scale the fact that we may lose large parts of the forest does not just mean a
loss of carbon sink it means more CO
2
would be released from the soil and biomass decay intothe atmosphere. The volume of carbon released may alter the atmospheric chemistry or increase
pressure on other carbon sinks, like the worlds oceans, which are undergoing acidification from
carbonic acid, which is causing a bleaching of coral reefs due to the oceans trying to process the
increased intake of CO2 from the atmospheric part of the system (Erez et al.2011).
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
26/38
26
With an increasing demand for renewable energies and cheaper sources of fuel I believe that
there is a danger posed by rapid land use change, for bio-fuels created from crops. As the
demand for them increases, more pressure will be put on creating space for these crops and for
more food. So the change in land use may occur more rapidly due to industrial pressure as they
want to press ahead and take advantage of a potentially lucrative opportunity, however this will
lead to the vulnerable systems such as the vast Amazon Rainforests, that will be exploited to the
point where in 50 years we may not have an Amazon Rainforest to protect.
The ramifications of the loss of the Amazon Rainforest through change in land use or forcing
from other factors are unknown, as we do not know what kinds of impact the loss of the forest
will have on the global atmospheric system. Also these are only some of my basic potential ideas
of branches of scenarios that have the potential for occurring, but it has been well documented by
recent journal articles such as the ones I have used in this discussion that there is a cause for
concern about the impact of a change in the volume of areas in the Amazon basin that are
undergoing land use change from humans.
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
27/38
27
Conclusion (Section 5)
Through the statistical analysis of the data that I have used (Section 3) to look at the relationship
between the type of land use and the precipitation rates above it, I have seen that there is a
statistically significant difference between the rates of precipitation in different areas across the
basin. Even though this is a small part of the Amazon basin system, from looking at the whole
system I can theorise that this small part has the potential to have large implications on the basin
system as I have discussed previously (Section 4). We cannot know the future implications as
trying to model all of the response of the basin system linking to the Global system is nearly
impossible to do. We have few long term averages or predictions for different parts of the
Amazon basin system, like the total impact of long term droughts or increases in local
temperature rise or the impact of more CCN being present in the atmosphere above the Amazon
due to increasing intensity of forest fires. We can only look to limit the potential anthropogenic
changes of land use in the basin, by trying to reduce the level of non-renewable logging and
illegal felling of trees in the basin and the clearing of large areas for use as pasture or cropland
for more food. As other climate forcing are out of our hands, we may already be at a point where
another long term drought in the Amazon basin may cause irreparable damage to the forest,
biodiversity and overall climate system. As this is yet to happen we may be able to limit these
manmade impacts.
The most important piece of information I have gained from doing this report is that the Amazon
basin is a dynamic system and even the smallest change, like a percentage increase in the area of
anthropogenically changed land use in the system, can have large knock on effect to the whole
system and potentially the whole global climate system.
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
28/38
28
Acknowledgements (Section 6)
I would like to thank Dr Adrian Matthews for all his help with the processing of the large
volumes of data I had to go through and helping to teach me the basics of python scripting, also
for helping to steer all my ideas into a cohesive project.
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
29/38
29
References (Section 7)
Arago, L.E.O.C., Mahli, Y., Barbier, N., Lima, A., Shimabukuro, Y., Anderson, L., Saatchi, S.,
2008, Interactions between rainfall, deforestation and fires during recent years in the Brazilian
Amazonia, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society Biological Sciences, 363, 1779
1785.
Balla, G., Caldeira, K., Wickett, M., Phillips, T.J., Lobell, D.B., Delire, C., Mirin, A., 2007
Combined climate and carbon-cycle effects of large-scale deforestation, PNAS, 104, No 16, 6550
6555.
Botta, A., Ramankutty, N., Foley, J.A., 2002, Long-term variations of climate and carbon fluxes
over the Amazon basin, Geophysical Research Letters, 29, No 9, 10.1029/2001GL013607.
Cochrane, M.A., Laurance, W.F., 2008, Synergisms among Fire, Land Use, and Climate Change
in the Amazon,Ambio: A Journal of the Human Environment, 37, No 78, 522527.
Erez, J., Reynaud, S., Silverman, J., Schneider, K., Allemand, D., 2011, Coral Calcification
Under Ocean Acidification and Global Change, Coral Reefs: An Ecosystem in Transition, Part
3, 151-176,DOI: 10.1007/978-94-007-0114-4_10.
Hiscock, K., Tanaka, Y., 2006, Potential impacts of Climate Change on Groundwater
Rescources: From the High Plains of the U.S. to the Flatlands of the U.K, National Hydrolody
Seminar 2006, 1926.
Kummerow, C., Barnes, W., Kozu, T., Shiue, J., Simpson, J., 1998, The Tropical Rainfall
Measuring Mission (TRMM) Sensor Package,Journal of Atmospheric and Oceanic Technology,
15,809817.
Liebmann, B., 2001, Interannual variability of the rainy season and rainfall in the
Brazilian Amazon basin,Journal of Climate, 14, 43084318.
Malhi, Y., Arago, L.E.O.C., Galbraith, D., Huntingford, C., Fisher, R., Zelazowski, P., Sitch, S.,
McSweeney, C., Meir, P., 2009, Exploring the likelihood and mechanism of a climate-change-
induced dieback of the Amazon rainforest, PNAS, 106, No. 49, 2061020615.
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
30/38
30
Markewitz, D., Devine, S., Davidson, E.A., Brando, P., Nepstad, D.C., 2010, Soil moisture
depletion under simulated drought in the Amazon: impacts on deep root uptake, New
Phytologist, 187, 592607.
Nepstad, D.C., Stickler, C.M., Soares-Filho, B., Merry, F., 2008, Interactions among Amazon
land use, forest and climate: prospects for a near-term forest tipping point, Philosophical
Transactions of the Royal Society Biological Sciences, 363, 1737-1746.
Nobre,P., Malagutti, M., Urbano, D.F., de Almeida, R.A.F., Giarolla, E., 2009, Amazon
Deforestation and Climate Change in a Coupled Model Simulation,Journal of Climate, 22, 5686
5697.
Pielke, R.A., Adegoke, J., Beltrn-Przekurat, A., Hiemstra, C.A., Lin, J., Nair, U.S., Niyogi, D.,
Nobis, T.E., 2007, An overview of regional land-use and land-cover impacts on rainfall, Tellus,
59B, 587601.
Ramankutty, N., T. Evan, A.T., Monfreda, C.,Foley, J.A., Farming the planet: 1. Geographic
distribution of global agricultural lands in the year 2000, Global Biogeochemical Cycles, 22,
GB1003.
Trenberth, K.E., 1999, Atmospheric moisture recycling: Role of advection and local evaporation,
Journal of Climate, 12, 13681381.
Zeng, N., Yoon, J., Marengo, J.A., Subramaniam, A., Nobre, C.A., Mariotti, A., Neelin, J.D.,
2008, Causes and impacts of the 2005 Amazon drought,Environmental Research Letters, 3,
014002.
http://www.geog.mcgill.ca/~nramankutty/Datasets/Datasets.html - pasture data set
http://trmm.gsfc.nasa.gov/data_dir/data.html - TRMM dataset
http://www.geog.mcgill.ca/~nramankutty/Datasets/Datasets.htmlhttp://www.geog.mcgill.ca/~nramankutty/Datasets/Datasets.htmlhttp://trmm.gsfc.nasa.gov/data_dir/data.htmlhttp://trmm.gsfc.nasa.gov/data_dir/data.htmlhttp://trmm.gsfc.nasa.gov/data_dir/data.htmlhttp://www.geog.mcgill.ca/~nramankutty/Datasets/Datasets.html -
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
31/38
31
Appendix 1 (Section 8)
Project Proposal
Background and Rationale
The use of satellites in observing the environment has revolutionized science in the last few
decades. They are used for a variety of measurements, the Tropical Rainfall Measuring
Mission (TRMM) measures precipitation rates over 3 hourly periods (Huffman et al. 2007)
across the planets tropical regions. Measuring changes in diurnal cycles, monthly averages and
yearly patterns can help us to better predict areas of intense rainfall and track small scale changes
across specific areas.
With advances in technology we are able to view and analyse parts of the environment that we
have never been able to or even thought of before. Deforestation is starting to become a major
factor influencing conditions in the rainforests of the world. The rates of precipitation across the
world can vary to the extremes; typical values in the tropical rainforests are from 2000
2500mm per year. However, with the large scale removal of forested areas is this having an
effect on the local climate (Nobre et al. 1991) and these rates may be changing. With the use of
the near real time data from TRMM there is data readily available to analyse these cycles (Negri.
2002) however, it is still not clear how data gathered by TRMM can be used to look at diurnal
cycles in the smallest spatial regions, so it is unknown if for example if the land use in an area
can effect rates of precipitation. Looking to find a gap in the science it seems that the data
gathered from TRMM has not been used when overlaid with the land use in specific areas, for
example the Amazon rainforest, where large swathes of trees are being cut down and used for
agriculture and seeing if rate of precipitation are affected by this.
Hypothesis
To explore whether changes in land use across the Amazon basin have an impact on precipitation
rates across different temporal periods.
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
32/38
32
The Study System
The reason that I will be using the Amazon basin is because over the past decades the area has
undergone significant changes in land use. Deforestation has destroyed large swathes of land in
the basin and much of this has been used for agriculture, other areas have just been left as empty
areas of loose soil and tree stumps. This change in land use and with large areas still as original
rainforest I will be able to compare the rates of precipitation, between these areas to see if there
is any significant difference spatially over the whole basin and over time as areas of
deforestation have increased over the decades has there been a more dramatic change in the rates
of precipitation in those areas. The TRMM data has been gathered for a long time so I will be
able to have accurate averaged measurements over the whole time period I will be looking at.
Design and Methodology
The test my hypothesis I will be using the data gathered from the TRMM satellites over the past
years and averaging it over different temporal periods to see if there is a change in the average
precipitation rates over the Amazon basin. I will be using analysing software such as CDAT to
gather the data into a manageable format so I will be able to over lay the data with a map of the
Amazon basins land use. I will be comparing the types of land use also to see if each type has a
different impact on precipitation rates, where in theory untouched rainforest should see the
highest amounts of rainfall and deforested areas the least.
Data Summaries and Analyses
I intend to display my data as a set of graphs with precipitation data, which will be coloured by
intensity so it is easily readable, overlaid by the Amazon basin and its land use types. I will be
showing numerous graphs that will display different temporal scales of averaged precipitation
and also possibly the Amazon at different times to show if there has been significant changes in
the land use across the basin.
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
33/38
33
Relevance
I will be helping to contribute to our understanding of the changes to micro scale and regional
scale climate, and how the intensity of meteorological events change as the land use changes
over time over an area of significant precipitation. I will be adding to our understand of the
impact humans are having as we change the environment around us and what far reaching
impacts that can have for the environmental norm as we disrupt the natural cycles that occur
within the rainforests.
Planning Schedule
References
Huffman, G. J., Adler, R.F., Bolvin, D.T., Gu, G., Nelkin, E.J., Bowman, K.P., Hong, Y.,
Stocker, E.F., Wolff, D.B., 2007, The TRMM Multisatellite Precipitation Analysis (TMPA):
Quasi-Global, Multiyear, Combined-Sensor Precipitation Estimates at Fine Scales.Journal of
Hydrometeorology, 8, 38-55
Negri, A.J., Bell, T.L., 2002, Sampling of the Diurnal Cycle of Precipitation Using TRMM.
Journal of Atmospheric and Oceanic Technology, 19, 1333-1344
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
34/38
34
Nobre, C.A., Sellers,P.J., Shukla, J., 1991, Amazonian Deforestation and Regional Climate
Change,Journal of Climate, 4, 957-988
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
35/38
35
Appendix 2 (Section 9)
Progress report
Work completed to date
At this current stage I have gathered and collected the data necessary to have started looking to
see if there was any link between the land use in the Amazon and precipitation rates across the
basin. I have processed and manipulated this data into graphical form and have been started to
prepare and make notes on how to write up my finding and researching the implications of a
change in precipitation rates and its effect on the Amazon as a whole
The methods used and further analyses to do
With the data I had gathered and sourced from many places I began by using the UEA cluster to
manipulate the data into manageable pieces that could be looked at and easily compare year by
year. After this I have began to use some land use data and overlain it on the precipitation data to
see if there are any changing trends.
However because I have been using a different type of computer code to deal with the vast
quantities of data I have been limited in the amounts of available land use data that I can find to
overlay on the precipitation data. So I have been thinking about finding other sources of land use
data and not overlaying it but comparing it side by side, I believe this is a viable way of
comparing the data I have and being able to see if there are changes throughout the basin over
different temporal periods. I have been using yearly averages so far but may try to use monthly
averages for each year to see if the seasonal variations affect the overall averages.
Results so far
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
36/38
36
Work remaining
Over the coming weeks is shall be continuing to improve on the graphs looking at more specific
areas within the Amazon and making them presentable and easy to understand
Dissertation structure
Title
Changes in land use across the Amazon basin and how precipitation rates vary across the basin
temporally and spatially
Abstract
A brief summary of my results and what the report is about
Keywords
A few words that can be looked at to get an idea of what the project relates to
Introduction
Outlining what my research is about, how and why I have investigated it and what relevance is has
to the broader area of climate change and land use impacts
Method
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
37/38
37
I will be detailing how I put the data into an easily understandable format, explaining how I edited
and manipulated the data, and the processes used to get the data into the correct format
Results
In this section I am going to be displaying all of my graphs from the average yearly rainfalls,
overlays of the land use data that was available to me and the zoomed areas of the Amazon that do
have significant changes in precipitation with regards the land use over time. I will attempt to
explain my findings from the data I have gathered and try to get across the significance of them if
there is any major revelation that I have found
Discussion
I believe this is going to be my largest section in my report as I will be discussing the implications
of my findings, if I do find significant evidence of decreasing precipitation with respect to change
of land use then I can go into detail about the impacts. For example, the implications on the
regional climatology, potentially global impacts to do with carbon sequestration and changing
climate for the whole of the South American continent. Changes in rainfall patterns in the area with
less precipitation and if these areas are now urbanised then the potential for more concentrated acid
rain and its impact on the forest. Also with the decrease in rain fall the more potential for forest
fires and talked about in other journal articles that I can cite. I believe there are other further areas I
can discuss if I find other evidence and significance to the changing patterns of rainfall linked to
land use
Conclusion
I will be summarising all that I have found while carrying out this scientific report and what it may
mean in the wider context of regional changes linked to changing land use over time and any other
significant findings that I have made over the due course of the time spent doing this report
Acknowledgements
I shall be thanking all those who have helped my with report and giving them fair credit where it is
due
-
7/31/2019 3rd Year Project by James Harper
38/38
References
This will be a comprehensive list of all the journals I have cited in my report and other sources of
data such as these sites I have found my land use data