7th circuit court of appeals ruling on rod blagojevich

8/20/2019 7th Circuit Court of Appeals ruling on Rod Blagojevich

1/23

In the

United States Court of AppealsFor the Seventh Circuit

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

#$% &&'()*(

+#,-./ 0-1-.0 23 14.5,61 7

!"#$%&$''()**+""++ 7

,-

52/ 891:2;.


2/23

P #$% &&'()*(

8A@S$T?MHKF U@J :$M?CG$C $B ,AAHG$HJZ EF? JE@E? A?SHJA@ELC?

HD>?@KF?I @GI C?D$M?I FHD BC$D $BBHK? EF? G?WE D$GEF%

-F? IHJECHKE K$LCE J?GE?GK?I 8A@S$T?MHKF E$ &[) D$GEFJ\ HD'

>CHJ$GD?GE $G EF? K$LGEJ EF@E @LEF$CH]? PN'V?@C D@WHDLD

E?CDJ7 @GI A?JJ?C E?CDJ $G @AA $EF?C K$LGEJ% 1AA J?GE?GK?J CLG

K$GKLCC?GEAV7 J$ EF? E$E@A HJ &[) D$GEFJ% 8?K@LJ? EF? KF@CS?J

@C? K$D>A?W7 EF? ECH@AJ A$GS7 @GI EF? HJJL?J GLD?C$LJ7 @G ?B'

B$CE E$ C?A@E? D@GV I?E@HAJ U$LAI >C$ILK? @ X$$^'A?GSEF

$>HGH$G% ,GJE?@I U? >C?J?GE $GAV EF? D$JE HD>$CE@GE B@KEJ

@GI IHJKLJJ $GAV EF? >@CEH?J\ >CHGKH>@A @CSLD?GEJ% 1AA ?AJ?

F@J X??G K$GJHI?C?I XLE I$?J G$E C?_LHC? IHJKLJJH$G%

-F? ?M?GEJ A?@IHGS E$ 8A@S$T?MHKF\J @CC?JE X?S@G UF?G

8@C@K^ 2X@D@7 EF?G @ 0?G@E$C BC$D ,AAHG$HJ7 U$G EF? ?A?KEH$G

B$C `C?JHI?GE HG #$M?DX?C PNN)% aF?G 2X@D@ E$$^ $BBHK? HG

;@GL@CV PNNb7 8A@S$T?MHKF U$LAI @>>$HGE FHJ C?>A@K?D?GE7 E$

J?CM? LGEHA EF? EHD? J?E XV @ UCHE $B ?A?KEH$G% 0?? 12/3+ ,-

82$%% 7 [&P 3%(I *(Y cYEF 6HC% PN&Nd% 8?B$C? EF? PNN) ?A?KEH$G7

B?I?C@A @S?GEJ F@I X??G HGM?JEHS@EHGS 8A@S$T?MHKF @GI FHJ

@JJ$KH@E?J% .MHI?GK? BC$D J$D? $B EF$J? @JJ$KH@E?J F@I A?I E$

U@CC@GEJ @LEF$CH]HGS EF? HGE?CK?>EH$G $B 8A@S$T?MHKF\J >F$G?K@AAJ% c-F? M@AHIHEV $B EF?J? U@CC@GEJ F@J G$E X??G K$GE?JE?I

$G EFHJ @>>?@A%d ,GE?CK?>EH$GJ C?M?@A?I EF@E 8A@S$T?MHKF

MH?U?I EF? $>>$CELGHEV E$ @>>$HGE @ G?U 0?G@E$C @J @ X$'

G@G]@%

-FC$LSF HGE?CD?IH@CH?J cFHJ $UG @GI EF? `C?JHI?GE'

?A?KE\Jd7 8A@S$T?MHKF J$LSFE @ B@M$C BC$D 0?G% 2X@D@ HG ?W'

KF@GS? B$C @>>$HGEHGS ?C'

K?HM?I @J EF? >?CJ$G 0?G% 2X@D@ U$LAI AH^? E$ F@M? JLKK??I

FHD% 8A@S$T?MHKF @J^?I B$C @G @>>$HGED?GE E$ EF? 6@XHG?E $CB$C EF? `C?JHI?GE'?A?KE E$ >?CJL@I? @ B$LGI@EH$G E$ FHC? FHD

@E @ JLXJE@GEH@A J@A@CV @BE?C FHJ E?CD @J :$M?CG$C ?GI?I7 $C


3/23

#$% &&'()*( (

BHGI J$D?$G? E$ I$G@E? e&N DHAAH$G @GI L> E$ @ G?U fJ$KH@A'

U?AB@C?g $CS@GH]@EH$G EF@E F? U$LAI K$GEC$A% -F? `C?JHI?GE'

?A?KE U@J G$E UHAAHGS E$ D@^? @ I?@A7 @GI 8A@S$T?MHKF U$LAI

G$E @>>$HGE ;@CC?EE UHEF$LE K$D>?GJ@EH$G7 J@VHGSh f-F?V\C?

G$E UHAAHGS E$ SHM? D? @GVEFHGS ?WK?>E @>>C?KH@EH$G% 3LK^

EF?D%g

8A@S$T?MHKF EF?G ELCG?I E$ JL>>$CE?CJ $B 5?>% ;?JJ? ;@K^'

J$G7 ;C%7 $BB?CHGS EF? @>>$HGED?GE HG ?WKF@GS? B$C @ e&%* DHA'

AH$G fK@D>@HSG K$GECHXLEH$G%g ca? >LE fK@D>@HSG K$GECHXL'

EH$Gg HG _L$E@EH$G D@C^J X?K@LJ? 8A@S$T?MHKF U@J J?CMHGS

FHJ J?K$GI E?CD @J :$M?CG$C @GI F@I I?KHI?I G$E E$ CLG B$C

@ EFHCI% 1 TLCV U@J ?GEHEA?I E$ K$GKALI? EF@E EF? D$G?V U@J

B$C FHJ >?CJ$G@A X?G?BHE C@EF?C EF@G @ K@D>@HSG%d 8A@S$T?MHKF

XC$^? $BB G?S$EH@EH$GJ @BE?C A?@CGHGS @X$LE EF? UHC?E@>J7 @GI

F? U@J @CC?JE?I X?B$C? F? K$LAI G?S$EH@E? UHEF @GV$G? ?AJ?%

-F? HGIHKED?GE KF@CS?I EF?J? G?S$EH@EH$GJ @J @EE?D>E?I

?WE$CEH$G7 HG MH$A@EH$G $B &) +%0%6% ii P @GI &b*&7 >ALJ K$C'

CL>E J$AHKHE@EH$G $B BLGIJ c&) +%0%6% ii (Y& @GI [[[c@dc&dc8dd

@GI UHC? BC@LI c&) +%0%6% ii &(j( @GI &(j[d% -F? HGIHKED?GE

@AJ$ KF@CS?I 8A@S$T?MHKF UHEF $EF?C @EE?D>EJ E$ C@HJ? D$G?VHG ?WKF@GS? B$C EF? >?CB$CD@GK? $B $BBHKH@A @KEJ7 ?M?G EF$LSF

B?I?C@A A@U B$CXHIJ @GV >@VD?GE c$C @SC??D?GE E$ >@Vd7 HG'

KALIHGS @ K@D>@HSG K$GECHXLEH$G7 HG ?WKF@GS? B$C EF? >?C'

B$CD@GK? $B @G $BBHKH@A @KE% 0?? 964:5;$6< ,- =%$&+/ >&+7 7

*NN +%0% P*Y c&bb&d% a? SHM? TLJE EU$ ?W@D>A?J%

3HCJE7 UF?G A$XXVHJEJ B$C 6FHAIC?G\J 4?D$CH@A =$J>HE@A

J$LSFE @G HGKC?@J? HG C?HDXLCJ?D?GE C@E?J B$C 4?IHK@HI >@'

EH?GEJ7 8A@S$T?MHKF cEFC$LSF HGE?CD?IH@CH?Jd C?>AH?I EF@E F?

U$LAI @>>C$M? @G ?WEC@ e) E$ e&N DHAAH$G $B C?HDXLCJ?D?GEHG ?WKF@GS? B$C @ fK@D>@HSG K$GECHXLEH$Gg $B e*N7NNN% 8A@S$'

T?MHKF HGHEH@AAV @>>C$M?I @ C@E? HGKC?@J? XLE I?A@V?I @GI


4/23

j #$% &&'()*(

EF?G C?JKHGI?I HE UF?G U@HEHGS B$C @ K$GECHXLEH$GZ F? U@J

@CC?JE?I X?B$C? @GV D$G?V KF@GS?I F@GIJ%

0?K$GI7 @BE?C EF? JE@E? A?SHJA@ELC? F@I @>>C$M?I @G ?WE?G'

JH$G $B @ >C$SC@D EF@E E@W?I K@JHG$J B$C EF? X?G?BHE $B C@K?'

EC@K^JOJ?? ?;*5+77 4#7$%: 1:"$+& 4:5*- ,- @#";:5#" A#6$%3

4"2BC D%6%7 [*& 3%(I YPP cYEF 6HC% PN&&d c?G X@GKdZ ?;*5+77 4#(

7$%: 1:"$+& 4:5*- ,- 1:E%7&:% 7 Y[( 3%(I YP( cYEF 6HC% PN&jdOXLE

X?B$C? 8A@S$T?MHKF JHSG?I EF? XHAA7 F? @EE?D>E?I E$ ?GJLC?

EF@E ;$FG ;$FGJE$G7 UF$ $UG?I HGE?C?JEJ HG EU$ $B EF? C@K?'

EC@K^J7 BLABHAA?I @ e&NN7NNN fK@D>@HSGg >A?IS?% 8A@S$T?MHKF

F@I HGE?CD?IH@CH?J HGB$CD ;$FGJE$G EF@E EF? XHAA U$LAI G$E

X? JHSG?I LGEHA EF? D$G?V @CCHM?I% 8A@S$T?MHKF U@J @CC?JE?I

X?B$C? F? JHSG?I EF? XHAA c@GI X?B$C? ;$FGJE$G JHSG?I @

KF?K^d%

-F?J? KF@CS?J A?I E$ SLHAEV M?CIHKEJ @E EF? J?K$GI ECH@A%

-F? KF@CS? EF@E >C$ILK?I @ SLHAEV M?CIHKE @E EF? BHCJE ECH@A

U@J EF@E 8A@S$T?MHKF F@I AH?I E$ EF? 38, HG PNN*7 MH$A@EHGS &)

+%0%6% i&NN&% ,GM?JEHS@EH$GJ $B 8A@S$T?MHKF\J @JJ$KH@E?J X?S@G

JF$CEAV @BE?C F? E$$^ $BBHK? @J :$M?CG$C HG PNN(7 @GI XV PNN*

EF? 38, U@GE?I E$ @J^ 8A@S$T?MHKF UF@E F? ^G?U @X$LE FHJ@JJ$KH@E?J\ K$GILKE% =? @SC??I E$ @G HGE?CMH?U HG FHJ A@U'

V?C\J $BBHK?% 1S?GEJ @J^?I UF?EF?C 8A@S$T?MHKF E$$^ K$GECH'

XLEH$GJ HGE$ @KK$LGE UF?G @>>C$MHGS JE@E? K$GEC@KEJ $C D@^'

HGS @>>$HGED?GEJ% =? C?>AH?I fEF@E F? I$?J G$E EC@K^ UF$

K$GECHXLE?J E$ FHD @GI I$?J G$E U@GE E$ ^G$U @GI I$?J G$E

^??> EC@K^ $B F$U DLKF EF?V K$GECHXLE? E$ FHD%g 0$ @G @S?GE

E?JEHBH?I7 C?AVHGS $G FHJ G$E?J% 1E 8A@S$T?MHKF\J HGJHJE?GK?7 EF?

HGE?CMH?U U@J G$E C?K$CI?I7 XLE @ TLCV K$LAI BHGI EF? @S?GE\J

E?JEHD$GV @KKLC@E?% -F? TLCV @AJ$ K$GKALI?I EF@E EFHJ @GJU?CU@J ^G$UHGSAV B@AJ?7 X?K@LJ? HG PNN* @GI ?@CAH?C 8A@S$T?MHKF

C?SLA@CAV B$LGI $LE UF$ K$GECHXLE?I F$U DLKF% c-F? TLCV


5/23

#$% &&'()*( *

U@J E$AI E$ @JJ?JJ EF? F$G?JEV $B EFHJ @GJU?C X@J?I J$A?AV $G

F$U 8A@S$T?MHKF F@I K$GILKE?I FHDJ?AB BC$D PNN( EFC$LSF

PNN*%d

8A@S$T?MHKF G$U @J^J LJ E$ F$AI EF@E EF? ?MHI?GK? HJ HG'

JLBBHKH?GE E$ K$GMHKE FHD $G @GV K$LGE% -F? @CSLD?GE HJ BCHM'

$A$LJ% -F? ?MHI?GK?7 DLKF $B HE BC$D 8A@S$T?MHKF\J $UG

D$LEF7 HJ $M?CUF?ADHGS% -$ EF? ?WE?GE EF?C? @C? B@KEL@A IHJ'

>LE?J7 EF? TLCV U@J ?GEHEA?I E$ KC?IHE EF? >C$J?KLEH$G\J ?MH'

I?GK? @GI E$ BHGI EF@E 8A@S$T?MHKF @KE?I UHEF EF? ^G$UA?IS?

C?_LHC?I B$C K$GMHKEH$G%

8LE @ >C$XA?D HG EF? U@V EF? HGJECLKEH$GJ E$AI EF? TLCV E$

K$GJHI?C EF? ?MHI?GK? C?_LHC?J LJ E$ M@K@E? EF? K$GMHKEH$GJ

$G K$LGEJ EF@E K$GK?CG 8A@S$T?MHKF\J >C$>$J@A E$ @>>$HGE CHM@E?'J?KE$C T$X7 $C B$C BLGIJ EF@E

F? K$LAI K$GEC$A7 XLE EF? HGJECLKEH$GJ >?CDHEE?I EF? TLCV E$

K$GMHKE ?M?G HB HE B$LGI EF@E FHJ $GAV C?_L?JE $B 0?G% 2X@D@

U@J B$C @ >$JHEH$G HG EF? 6@XHG?E% -F? HGJECLKEH$GJ EC?@E?I @AA

>C$>$J@AJ @AH^?% a? K$GKALI?7 F$U?M?C7 EF@E EF?V @C? A?S@AAVIHBB?C?GEh @ >C$>$J@A E$ EC@I? $G? >LXAHK @KE B$C @G$EF?C7 @

B$CD $B A$SC$AAHGS7 HJ BLGI@D?GE@AAV LGAH^? EF? JU@> $B @G

$BBHKH@A @KE B$C @ >CHM@E? >@VD?GE%

8?K@LJ? EF? HGJECLKEH$GJ I$ G$E ?G@XA? LJ E$ X? JLC? EF@E

EF? TLCV B$LGI EF@E 8A@S$T?MHKF $BB?C?I E$ EC@I? EF? @>'

>$HGED?GE B$C @ >CHM@E? J@A@CV @BE?C A?@MHGS EF? :$M?CG$C'

JFH>7 EF?J? K$GMHKEH$GJ K@GG$E JE@GI% 6$D>@C? F#&+7 ,- =%$&(

+/ >&+7 7 (*j +%0% Pb) c&b*Yd7 @GI =%$&+/ >&+7 ,- A$,+5# @:5(

5+5: 7 YY& 3%(I bY( cYEF 6HC% PN&jd7 UHEF G5$''$% ,- =%$&+/ >&+7 7*NP +%0% j[ c&bb&d% c`?CF@>J X?K@LJ? EF? TLCV I?@IA$K^?I @E

EF? BHCJE ECH@A7 EF? +GHE?I 0E@E?J I$?J G$E J?CH$LJAV K$GE?GI


6/23

[ #$% &&'()*(

EF@E @GV ?CC$C U@J F@CDA?JJZ @ $G?'AHG? JE@E?D?GE HG EF? XCH?B

IHBB?CJ BC$D @G @CSLD?GE% 6B% H+/3*+&E ,- !2"$/: 7 *** +%0% *Y7

[Nk[P cPNN)d c@G ?CC$C $B EFHJ ^HGI HJ G$E fJECLKELC@Agd%d

964:5;$6LXAHK

$BBHKH@A >?CB$CDJ @G $BBHKH@A @KE c$C >C$DHJ?J E$ I$ J$d HG ?W'

KF@GS? B$C @ >CHM@E? X?G?BHE7 JLKF @J D$G?V% 0?? @AJ$ =%$&+/

>&+7 ,- >2%(.$#;:%/ G5:J+57 :' 4#"$':5%$# 7 *P[ +%0% (b)7 jNjk

N* c&bbbdZ =%$&+/ >&+7 ,- 96.:%%+"" 7 PN&* +%0% 1>>% 9.l,0

&&))b cjEF 6HC% ;LAV &N7 PN&*d% 1 >$AHEHK@A A$SC$AA7 XV K$GEC@JE7

HJ EF? JU@> $B $G? $BBHKH@A @KE B$C @G$EF?C% 5?>C?J?GE@EHM? 1

@SC??J UHEF 5?>C?J?GE@EHM? 8 E$ M$E? B$C DHA^ >CHK? JL>>$CEJ7

HB 8 @SC??J E$ M$E? B$C EHSFE?C K$GEC$AJ $G @HC >$AALEH$G% 1

`C?JHI?GE @>>$HGEJ 6 @J @G @DX@JJ@I$C7 UFHKF 0?G@E$C /

@J^?I EF? `C?JHI?GE E$ I$7 HG ?WKF@GS? B$C /\J >C$DHJ? E$

M$E? E$ K$GBHCD . @J @ D?DX?C $B EF? #@EH$G@A 9@X$C 5?A@'

EH$GJ 8$@CI% :$M?CG@GK? U$LAI F@CIAV X? >$JJHXA? UHEF$LE

EF?J? @KK$DD$I@EH$GJ7 UFHKF @AA$U ?@KF >LXAHK $BBHKH@A E$

@KFH?M? D$C? $B FHJ >CHGKH>@A $XT?KEHM? UFHA? JLCC?GI?CHGS

J$D?EFHGS @X$LE UFHKF F? K@C?J A?JJ7 XLE EF? $EF?C >$AHEHKH@G

K@C?J D$C? JEC$GSAV%1 >C$>$J@A E$ @>>$HGE @ >@CEHKLA@C >?CJ$G E$ $G? $BBHK?

cJ@V7 EF? 6@XHG?Ed HG ?WKF@GS? B$C J$D?$G? ?AJ?\J >C$DHJ? E$

@>>$HGE @ IHBB?C?GE >?CJ$G E$ @ IHBB?C?GE $BBHK? cJ@V7 EF? 0?G'

@E?d7 HJ @ K$DD$G ?W?CKHJ? HG A$SC$AAHGS% a? @J^?I EF? >C$J?'

KLE$C @E $C@A @CSLD?GE HB7 X?B$C? EFHJ K@J?7 A$SC$AAHGS F@I

X??G EF? X@JHJ $B @ KCHDHG@A K$GMHKEH$G HG EF? FHJE$CV $B EF?

+GHE?I 0E@E?J% 6$LGJ?A U@J LG@U@C? $B @GV ?@CAH?C K$GMHK'

EH$G B$C @G ?WKF@GS? $B >$AHEHK@A B@M$CJ% 2LC $UG C?J?@CKF

IHI G$E ELCG $G? L>% ,E U$LAI X? D$C? EF@G @ AHEEA? JLC>CHJHGSE$ 4?DX?CJ $B 6$GSC?JJ HB EF? TLIHKH@CV B$LGI HG EF? =$XXJ


7/23

#$% &&'()*( Y

1KE7 $C EF? D@HA BC@LI JE@ELE?7 @ CLA? D@^HGS ?M?CVI@V >$AH'

EHKJ KCHDHG@A%

9?E\J U$C^ EFHJ EFC$LSF JE@ELE? XV JE@ELE?% 0?KEH$G &b*&7

EF? =$XXJ 1KE7 UFHKF LGI?CAH?J 6$LGEJ P& @GI PP7 B$CXHIJ

HGE?CB?C?GK? UHEF K$DD?CK? XV C$XX?CV $C ?WE$CEH$G% 8A@S$'

T?MHKF IHI G$E C$X @GV$G?7 @GI ?WE$CEH$G7 @ I?BHG?I E?CD7

fD?@GJ EF? $XE@HGHGS $B >C$>?CEV BC$D @G$EF?C7 UHEF FHJ

K$GJ?GE7 HGILK?I XV UC$GSBLA LJ? $B @KEL@A $C EFC?@E?G?I

B$CK?7 MH$A?GK?7 $C B?@C7 $C LGI?C K$A$C $B $BBHKH@A CHSFEg

ci&b*&cXdcPdd% -F? HGIHKED?GE KF@CS?I 8A@S$T?MHKF UHEF EF?

fK$A$C $B $BBHKH@A CHSFEg M?CJH$G $B ?WE$CEH$G7 XLE G$G? $B EF?

?MHI?GK? JLSS?JEJ EF@E 8A@S$T?MHKF KA@HD?I E$ F@M? @G f$BBH'

KH@A CHSFEg E$ @ T$X HG EF? 6@XHG?E% =? IHI F@M? @G f$BBHKH@A

CHSFEg E$ @>>$HGE @ G?U 0?G@E$C7 XLE LGA?JJ @ >$JHEH$G HG EF?

6@XHG?E HJ f>C$>?CEVg BC$D EF? `C?JHI?GE\J >?CJ>?KEHM?7 EF?G

J??^HGS HE I$?J G$E @D$LGE E$ ?WE$CEH$G% Q?E @ >$AHEHK@A $BBHK?

X?A$GSJ E$ EF? >?$>A?7 G$E E$ EF? HGKLDX?GE c$C E$ J$D?$G?

F@G^?CHGS @BE?C EF? >$JHEH$Gd% 4"+,+"#%/ ,- =%$&+/ >&+7 7 *(&

+%0% &P cPNNNd7 F$AIJ EF@E JE@E? @GI DLGHKH>@A AHK?GJ?J7 @GI

JHDHA@C I$KLD?GEJ7 @C? G$E f>C$>?CEVg HG EF? F@GIJ $B @ >LX'AHK @S?GKV% -F@E\J ?_L@AAV ECL? $B >LXAHK >$JHEH$GJ% -F? `C?JH'

I?GE'?A?KE IHI G$E F@M? @ >C$>?CEV HGE?C?JE HG @GV 6@XHG?E

T$X7 J$ @G @EE?D>E E$ S?E FHD E$ @>>$HGE @ >@CEHKLA@C >?CJ$G

E$ EF? 6@XHG?E HJ G$E @G @EE?D>E E$ J?KLC? f>C$>?CEVg BC$D

EF? `C?JHI?GE c$C EF? KHEH]?GCV @E A@CS?d%

>+&+7 7 &(( 0% 6E% PYPN cPN&(d7 JF$UJ EF@E

EF? >FC@J? f$XE@HGHGS $B >C$>?CEVg HG EF? =$XXJ 1KE DLJE

G$E X? ?WE?GI?I TLJE E$ >?G@AH]? JF@IV I?@AHGSJ% >+C$>?CEVgLGI?C i&b*&cXdcPd B$C EU$ >CHGKH>@A C?@J$GJh BHCJE7 HG EF? A$GS

FHJE$CV $B ?WE$CEH$G A@U HE F@I G?M?C X?B$C? X??G J$ LGI?C'


8/23

) #$% &&'()*(

JE$$I cJHDHA@CAV7 >$AHEHK@A A$SC$AAHGS F@J G?M?C X?B$C? X??G

K$GI?DG?I @J ?WE$CEH$GdZ J?K$GI7 EF? D@^HGS $B @ C?K$D'

D?GI@EH$G HJ G$E EC@GJB?CC@XA?% -F? 6$LCE C?JECHKE?I f>C$>?C'

EVg E$ UF@E $G? $UG?C K@G EC@GJB?C E$ @G$EF?C% 8V EF@E

JE@GI@CI @ T$X HG EF? 6@XHG?E c$C @GV $EF?C >LXAHK T$Xd HJ G$E

f>C$>?CEVg BC$D EF? ?D>A$V?C\J >?CJ>?KEHM?% ,E HJ G$E $UG?I

XV EF? >?CJ$G UHEF @>>$HGEHGS >$U?C7 @GI HE K@GG$E X?

I??I?I $M?C% -F? >$JHEH$G D@V X? '$""+/ XV IHBB?C?GE >?$>A?7

XLE EF? >$JHEH$G HEJ?AB HJ G$E @ EC@GJB?CC@XA? >C$>?CEV HGE?C?JE%

1 >$JHEH$G HJ fF?AIg $C f$KKL>H?Ig XLE G$E f$XE@HG?I7g @GI

LGI?C >+EAV m @GVEFHGS $B

M@AL?g HG K$GG?KEH$G UHEF @ EC@GJ@KEH$G U$CEF e*7NNN $C

D$C?% f6$CCL>EAVg C?B?CJ E$ EF? C?KH>H?GE\J JE@E? $B DHGI @GI

HGIHK@E?J EF@E F? LGI?CJE@GIJ EF? >@VD?GE @J @ XCHX? $C SC@'ELHEV% =%$&+/ >&+7 ,- H#JA@LJHXA? E$ I?JKCHX? @ >$AHEHK@A EC@I?

$B B@M$CJ @J @G $BB?C $C @EE?D>E E$ XCHX? EF? $EF?C JHI?% aF@E

HJ D$C?7 i[[[cKd >C$MHI?J EF@E EF? J?KEH$G @J @ UF$A? I$?J G$E

@>>AV fE$ X$G@ BHI? J@A@CV7 U@S?J7 B??J7 $C $EF?C K$D>?GJ@'

EH$G >@HI7 $C ?W>?GJ?J >@HI $C C?HDXLCJ?I7 HG EF? LJL@A

K$LCJ? $B XLJHG?JJ%g 6$D>?GJ@EH$G B$C @ T$X XV J$D?$G?

$EF?C EF@G @ SF$JE U$C^?C HJ @ fX$G@ BHI? J@A@CVgO@GI7 @J

U?\M? >$HGE?I $LE7 EF? fLJL@A K$LCJ? $B XLJHG?JJg HG >$AHEHKJ

HGKALI?J A$SC$AAHGS%


9/23

#$% &&'()*( b

-F? HGIHKED?GE @AJ$ KF@CS?I 8A@S$T?MHKF UHEF UHC? BC@LI7

HG MH$A@EH$G $B &) +%0%6% i&(j(% -F@E EF? G?S$EH@EH$GJ LJ?I

EF? >F$G? JVJE?D HJ HGIHJ>LE@XA?7 XLE UF?C?\J EF? BC@LIn

8A@S$T?MHKF IHI G$E ECV E$ I?K?HM? 0?G% 2X@D@% -F? >C$J?KL'

E$C K$GE?GI?I EF@E 8A@S$T?MHKF I?>CHM?I EF? >LXAHK $B HEJ HG'

E@GSHXA? CHSFE E$ FHJ F$G?JE J?CMHK?J7 UFHKF &) +%0%6% i&(j[

I?BHG?J @J @ B$CD $B BC@LI% -$ K@AA EFHJ @G F$G?JE'J?CMHK?J

BC@LI JL>>$J?J @G ?WEC?D? M?CJH$G $B ECLEF HG >$AHEHKJ7 HG

UFHKF @ >$AHEHKH@G K$DDHEJ @ B?A$GV LGA?JJ EF? $JE?GJHXA?

C?@J$G B$C @G $BBHKH@A @KE @AJ$ HJ EF? C?@A $G?% 0$ HB @ :$M?CG$C

@>>$HGEJ J$D?$G? E$ @ >LXAHK K$DDHJJH$G @GI >C$KA@HDJ EF?@>>$HGE?? fEF? X?JE >?CJ$G B$C EF? T$X7g UFHA? EF? C?@A C?@J$G

HJ EF@E J$D? JE@E? A?SHJA@E$C F@I @J^?I B$C @ BCH?GI\J @>'

>$HGED?GE @J @ B@M$C7 EF?G EF? :$M?CG$C F@J K$DDHEE?I UHC?

BC@LI X?K@LJ? EF? :$M?CG$C I$?J G$E @KEL@AAV X?AH?M? EF@E

EF? @>>$HGE?? HJ EF? X?JE >?CJ$G B$C EF? T$X% -F@E\J G$E @

>A@LJHXA? LGI?CJE@GIHGS $B i&(j[7 ?M?G HB c@J HJ LGAH^?AVd HE

U$LAI X? M@AHI LGI?C EF? 3HCJE 1D?GID?GE @J @ KCHDHG@A

>?G@AEV B$C DHJA?@IHGS >$AHEHK@A J>??KF% 1GI G$ D@EE?C UF@E

$G? D@^?J $B EF? JLXT?KE7 EF? F$AIHGS $B >&+7 7 *[& +%0% (*) cPN&Nd7 >C?M?GEJ C?J$CE E$ i&(j[ E$ >?G@A'

H]? >$AHEHK@A F$CJ?'EC@IHGS% >$AHEHK@A A$SC$AAHGS HJ

@ B$CD $B XCHX?CV7 UFHKF HE HJ G$E7 i&(j[ IC$>J $LE%

-F? >C$J?KLE$C HGJHJEJ7 F$U?M?C7 EF@E 8A@S$T?MHKF\J JHEL@'

EH$G HJ IHBB?C?GE @GI LGK$DD$G X?K@LJ? F? J$LSFE @ >$JE HG

EF? 6@XHG?E B$C FHDJ?AB% ,E HJG\E KA?@C E$ LJ EF@E EFHJ HJ LGLJL'

@A% -F? KLCC?GE 0?KC?E@CV $B 0E@E? U@J @>>$HGE?I E$ EF@E >$JH'

EH$G BC$D @ J?@E HG EF? 0?G@E?7 @GI HE U$LAIG\E JLC>CHJ? LJ HB

EFHJ F@>>?G?I @E A?@JE HG >@CE X?K@LJ? F? F@I >?CB$CD?I @

>$AHEHK@A J?CMHK? B$C EF? `C?JHI?GE% 1DX@JJ@I$CJ7 E$$7 K$D?


10/23

&N #$% &&'()*(

BC$D EF? =$LJ? $C 0?G@E? c$C BC$D JE@E? >$AHEHKJd @J >@CE $B

>$AHEHK@A I?@AJ%

0$D? FHJE$CH@GJ J@V EF@E EFHJ HJ F$U .@CA a@CC?G K@D? E$

X? 6FH?B ;LJEHK? $B EF? +GHE?I 0E@E?Jh F? I?AHM?C?I EF? 6@AH'

B$CGH@ I?A?S@EH$G @E EF? &b*P 5?>LXAHK@G K$GM?GEH$G E$ .H'

J?GF$U?C cC@EF?C EF@G 0?G@E$C -@BEd HG ?WKF@GS? B$C @ K$D'

DHED?GE E$ @>>$HGE FHD E$ EF? G?WE M@K@GKV $G EF? 0L>C?D?

6$LCE% 0??7 ?%S%7 4$CE$G ;% =$CUHE]7 KE+ L#55+% 4:25& #%/ &E+

!2572$& :' 127&$6+ Y c&bb)dZ 1CEFLC `@LAJ$G7 A+#"$3%;+%& #%/

!#5&M A+,$,#"N =%/+57%/$%3 );+5$6#% ?"+6&:5#" !:"$&$67 #& &E+

K25% :' &E+ KJ+%&M(O$57& 4+%&25M )[ cPNNNd% aF?EF?C EFHJ @K'

K$LGE HJ K$CC?KE HJ I?X@E@XA?7 J?? ;HD #?UE$G7 127&$6+ ':5 )""N

?#5" L#55+% #%/ &E+ P#&$:% H+ 9#/+ [k&& cPNN[d7 @GI 6FH?B

;LJEHK? a@CC?G FHDJ?AB I?GH?I EF@E @ I?@A F@I X??G D@I?

cEF$LSF >?CF@>J @ >$AHEHK@A I?XE F@I X??G HGKLCC?Id7 KE+

9+;:$57 :' ?#5" L#55+% P*Nk[& c&bYYd% ,B EF? >C$J?KLE$C HJ

CHSFE7 @GI @ JU@> $B >$AHEHK@A B@M$CJ HGM$AMHGS @ T$X B$C $G?

$B EF? >$AHEHKH@GJ HJ @ B?A$GV7 EF?G HB EF? JE@GI@CI @KK$LGE HJ

ECL? X$EF EF? `C?JHI?GE $B EF? +GHE?I 0E@E?J @GI EF? 6FH?B

;LJEHK? $B EF? +GHE?I 0E@E?J JF$LAI F@M? S$G? E$ >CHJ$G% Q?E@AEF$LSF FHJE$CH@GJ @GI >$AHEHK@A JKH?GEHJEJ F@M? I?X@E?I

UF?EF?C EFHJ I?@A U@J D@I?7 $C UF?EF?C HB D@I? U@J ?EFHK@A

c$C >$AHEHK@AAV LGUHJ?d7 G$ $G? E$ $LC ^G$UA?IS? F@J JLS'

S?JE?I EF@E HE MH$A@E?I EF? JE@ELE?J HGM$AM?I HG EFHJ K@J?%

caF?EF?C HE DHSFE F@M? MH$A@E?I &) +%0%6% i*bb7 @GI UF?EF?C

EF@E JE@ELE? HJ K$D>@EHXA? UHEF EF? 3HCJE 1D?GID?GE7 @C? HJ'

JL?J U? I$ G$E @IIC?JJ%d

9?E LJ S$ EFC$LSF EF? EFC?? JE@ELE?J @S@HG% 964:5;$6$AHEHKH@G\J $BB?C E$ >?CB$CD @ M@AL@XA? J?CMHK?K@G MH$A@E? i&b*& @J ?WE$CEH$G HB HE HGM$AM?J @ I2$/ *5: I2:h @

>LXAHK @KE HG ?WKF@GS? B$C @ M@AL@XA? C?ELCG >C$DHJ?% a?\M?


11/23

#$% &&'()*( &&

@AC?@IV ?W>A@HG?I7 F$U?M?C7 UFV A$SC$AAHGS I$?J G$E MH$A@E?

i&b*&% -F? ?WKALJH$G HG i[[[cKd B$C X$G@ BHI? ?D>A$VD?GE

@AJ$ @>>AH?J G$ D@EE?C UF$ S?EJ EF? T$X% aF$ U$LAI S?E EF?

>LXAHK T$X I$?J G$E D@EE?C E$ i&(j[ ?HEF?C% ,GI??I7 EF? @G@AV'

JHJ HG =%$&+/ >&+7 ,- KE:;*7:% 7 j)j 3%(I )YY cYEF 6HC% PNNYd7

@>>AH?J E$ 8A@S$T?MHKF E$$% KE:;*7:% C?M?CJ?I K$GMHKEH$GJ

LGI?C i[[[ @GI i&(j[ EF@E F@I X??G $XE@HG?I $G @ EF?$CV

EF@E @ >LXAHK ?D>A$V??\J HGE?C?JE HG ^??>HGS F?C T$X D?@GE

EF@E JF? MH$A@E?I B?I?C@A A@U HB JF? >?CB$CD?I @GV @J>?KE $B

F?C T$X HG U@VJ EF@E JF? ^G?U JF? JF$LAIG\E% c-F? @JJ?CE?I

?CC$C HG KE:;*7:% U@J @G HGK$CC?KE C@G^HGS $B XHII?CJ B$C @EC@M?A'J?CMHK?J K$GEC@KE%d KE:;*7:% F$AIJ7 @D$GS $EF?C

EFHGSJ7 EF@E EF? HGE?C?JE HG C?K?HMHGS @ J@A@CV BC$D @ >LXAHK

T$X HJ G$E @ B$CD $B >CHM@E? X?G?BHE B$C EF? >LC>$J? $B B?I?C@A

KCHDHG@A JE@ELE?J%

`LE E$ $G? JHI? B$C @ D$D?GE EF? B@KE EF@E @ >$JHEH$G HG

EF? 6@XHG?E K@CCH?J @ J@A@CV% 0L>>$J? EF@E 8A@S$T?MHKF F@I

@J^?I7 HGJE?@I7 EF@E 0?G% 2X@D@ K$DDHE FHDJ?AB E$ JL>>$CE'

HGS @ >C$SC@D E$ XLHAI G?U XCHIS?J @GI FHSFU@VJ HG ,AAHG$HJ

@J J$$G @J F? X?K@D? `C?JHI?GE% 4@GV >$AHEHKH@GJ X?AH?M?EF@E >LXAHK'U$C^J >C$T?KEJ >C$D$E? EF?HC C?'?A?KEH$G% ,B EF?

>C$J?KLE$C HJ CHSFE EF@E @ >LXAHK T$X K$LGEJ @J @ >CHM@E? X?G?'

BHE7 EF?G EF? X?G?BHE E$ @ >$AHEHKH@G BC$D HD>C$M?I KF@GK?J $B

?A?KEH$G E$ @ >@VHGS T$X JLKF @J :$M?CG$CO$C @ X?EE?C >C$'

J>?KE $B @ ALKC@EHM? K@C??C @J @ A$XXVHJE @BE?C A?@MHGS $BBHK?O

@AJ$ U$LAI X? @ >CHM@E? X?G?BHE7 @GI U? U$LAI X? X@K^ E$ EF?

>C$>$JHEH$G EF@E @AA A$SC$AAHGS HJ KCHDHG@A% .M?G @ >$AHEHKH@G

UF$ @J^J @G$EF?C >$AHEHKH@G B$C B@M$CJ $GAV X?K@LJ? F? JHG'

K?C?AV X?AH?M?J EF@E EF?J? B@M$CJ @JJHJE FHJ K$GJEHEL?GEJ K$LAI

X? K$GI?DG?I @J @ B?A$G7 X?K@LJ? SC@E?BLA K$GJEHEL?GEJ D@^?

EF?HC SC@EHELI? ^G$UG XV M$E?J $C >$JE'$BBHK? ?D>A$VD?GE%


12/23

&P #$% &&'()*(

aF@E U? F@M? J@HI J$ B@C C?_LHC?J EF? C?M?CJ@A $B EF?

K$GMHKEH$GJ $G 6$LGEJ *7 [7 P&7 PP7 @GI P(7 EF$LSF EF? >C$J?'

KLE$C HJ BC?? E$ ECV @S@HG UHEF$LE C?AH@GK? $G 8A@S$T?MHKF\J

_L?JE B$C @ >$JHEH$G HG EF? 6@XHG?E% c-F? ?MHI?GK? EF@E 8A@S$'

T?MHKF J$LSFE D$G?V HG ?WKF@GS? B$C @>>$HGEHGS @CE $B EFHJ

$>HGH$G IHJKLJJ?J J$D? $EF?C J?GE?GKHGS HJJL?J%d

aHEF EF? ?WK?>EH$G $B EF? >C$>$J?I 6@XHG?E I?@A7 EF? TLCV

HGJECLKEH$GJ @C? LG?WK?>EH$G@XA?% -F?V EC@K^ 964:5;$6>?AA@E? >C?J?GE@EH$G @JJLD?J EF@E

?WE$CEH$G K@G MH$A@E? EF? =$XXJ 1KE $GAV HB @ I2$/ *5: I2: HJ

I?D@GI?I ?W>AHKHEAV7 XLE EF? JE@ELE? I$?J G$E F@M? @ D@SHK'

U$CIJ C?_LHC?D?GE% 3?U >$AHEHKH@GJ J@V7 $G $C $BB EF? C?K$CI7f, UHAA ?WKF@GS? $BBHKH@A @KE l B$C >@VD?GE Q%g 0HDHA@CAV >?C'

J$GJ UF$ K$GJ>HC? E$ C$X X@G^J $C IHJECHXLE? ICLSJ I$ G$E

>C$>$J? $C JHSG K$GEC@KEJ HG EF? JE@ELE$CV A@GSL@S?% f#LIS?7

GLIS?7 UHG^7 UHG^7 V$L ^G$U UF@E , D?@Gg K@G @D$LGE E$

?WE$CEH$G LGI?C EF? =$XXJ 1KE7 TLJE @J HE K@G BLCGHJF EF? SHJE

$B @ 4$GEV `VEF$G J^?EKF%

8A@S$T?MHKF K$GE?GIJ EF@E F? U@J ?GEHEA?I E$ @G HGJECLK'

EH$G EF@E7 HB F? X?AH?M?I HG S$$I B@HEF EF@E FHJ K$GILKE U@J

A@UBLA7 EF?G F? DLJE X? @K_LHEE?I% -F@E HJ G$E J$Z @G $>?G'?GI?I fS$$I B@HEFg I?B?GJ? U$LAI X? ?HEF?C @ DHJE@^?'$B'

A@U I?B?GJ? HG IHJSLHJ? $C @G @IMHK?'$B'K$LGJ?A I?B?GJ?


13/23

#$% &&'()*( &(

UHEF$LE I?D$GJEC@EHGS @IMHK? $B K$LGJ?A% -FHJ KHCKLHE\J >@E'

E?CG TLCV HGJECLKEH$GJ K@AA B$C @ S$$I'B@HEF HGJECLKEH$G $GAV

UF?G EF? JE@ELE? K$GE@HGJ @ E?CD JLKF @J fUHAABLAg EF@E c@J

LGI?CJE$$I B$C EF@E >@CEHKLA@C JE@ELE?d D@^?J ^G$UA?IS? $B

EF? A@U ?JJ?GEH@A% !#&&+5% 45$;$%#" 125M D%7&526&$:%7 :' &E+ >+,(

+%&E 4$562$& i[%&N cPN&P C?MHJH$Gd%

0L>>$J? 8A@S$T?MHKF X?AH?M?I EF@E UHG^J @GI GLIS?J

@M$HI EF? 964:5;$6AV EF? G??I B$C @ J?>@'

C@E? HGJECLKEH$GZ @ TLCV\J E@J^ HJ F@CI ?G$LSF @J HE HJ UHEF$LE

LJHGS DLAEH>A? >FC@J?J E$ K$M?C EF? J@D? JLXT?KE% -F?J? HG'JECLKEH$GJ I?BHG?I EF? JE@ELE?J\ ;+%7 5+# ?A?D?GEJ K$CC?KEAVZ

G$ D$C? U@J C?_LHC?I%

-F? @CSLD?GE B$C @ S$$I'B@HEF HGJECLKEH$G C?AH?J >CHGKH'

>@AAV $G 4E++< ,- =%$&+/ >&+7 7 jb) +%0% &bP c&bb&d7 XLE EF@E\J

@ IHBB?C?GE ^?EEA? $B BHJF% -F? ;LJEHK?J C?@I EF? U$CI fUHAABLA'

AVg HG @ >@CEHKLA@C E@W A@U E$ C?_LHC? >C$$B EF@E EF? @KKLJ?I

^G?U EF? A@U7 UFHKF EF? ;LJEHK?J J@U @J E?KFGHK@A @GI X?'

V$GI EF? ^?G $B D@GV E@W>@V?CJ% -F? U$CI fUHAABLAAVg I$?J

G$E @>>?@C HG @GV $B EF? JE@ELE?J EF@E 8A@S$T?MHKF U@JKF@CS?I UHEF MH$A@EHGS% 1GVU@V7 F? I$?J G$E I?GV ^G$UHGS

EF? CLA? $B 964:5;$6


14/23

&j #$% &&'()*(

KH@A @KE B$C @ >CHM@E? X?G?BHE HJ HAA?S@A7 J$ 4E++ FHD ?M?G HB HE @>>AH?I% -F? fS$$I B@HEFg @CSLD?GE HJ

TLJE @ JE@A^HGS F$CJ? B$C EF? K$GE?GEH$G EF@E EF? I2$/ *5: I2:

DLJE X? JE@E?I ?W>AHKHEAV @GI K@GG$E X? HD>AH?I BC$D FHGEJ

@GI GLIS?JZ @J U? F@M? C?T?KE?I EF@E K$GE?GEH$G IHC?KEAV7 HE

K@GG$E X? C?JLJKHE@E?I HG EF? B$CD $B @ fS$$I B@HEFg HGJECLK'

EH$G LGE?EF?C?I BC$D JE@ELE$CV A@GSL@S?%

-F? IHJECHKE TLIS? /$/ SHM? @ S$$I'B@HEF HGJECLKEH$G AHD'

HE?I E$ EF? UHC?'BC@LI K$LGEJ7 UFHKF F@M? @G HGE?GE C?_LHC?'

D?GE UHEFHG EF? JK$>? $B i[%&N% -F? TLIS? LJ?I EF? A@GSL@S?

$B i[%&N7 @J D$IHBH?I E$ BHE EF? J>?KHBHK KF@CS?J7 @GI @II?I

$G? J?GE?GK? @E EF? ?GI% =?C?\J F$U EF? HGJECLKEH$G UC@>>?I

L>h

-F? XLCI?G HJ G$E $G EF? I?B?GI@GE E$ >C$M? FHJ S$$I B@HEFZ C@'

EF?C7 EF? S$M?CGD?GE DLJE >C$M? X?V$GI @ C?@J$G@XA? I$LXE

EF@E EF? I?B?GI@GE @KE?I UHEF EF? C?_LHJHE? HGE?GE% -F? S$M?CG'

D?GE HJ G$E C?_LHC?I E$ >C$M? EF@E EF? I?B?GI@GE ^G?U FHJ @KEJ

U?C? LGA@UBLA%

8A@S$T?MHKF K$GE?GIJ EF@E EFHJ HGJECLKEH$G\J BHG@A J?GE?GK? HJ

HD>C$>?C% -$ EF? K$GEC@CV7 EF? J?GE?GK? TLJE C?DHGIJ EF? TLCVEF@E DHJE@^? $B A@U HJ G$E @ I?B?GJ?% -F? UHC?'BC@LI JE@ELE?

C?_LHC?J @ J>?KHBHK HGE?GE E$ I?BC@LI XLE %:& UHABLAG?JJ $C @GV

$EF?C >C$WV B$C ^G$UA?IS? $B EF? A@U% -$ EF? ?WE?GE EF@E

8A@S$T?MHKF D@V EFHG^ EF@E @ G??I E$ JF$U HGE?GE E$ I?BC@LI

HJ EF? J@D? @J @ G??I E$ JF$U ^G$UA?IS? @X$LE UF@E EF? A@U

C?_LHC?J7 F? DHJC?@IJ =%$&+/ >&+7 ,- Q+.:%%+ 7 P& 3%(I &j&)7

&j(N cYEF 6HC% &bbjd% 0?? @#5":J ,- =%$&+/ >&+7 7 (P +%0% cY

`?E%d jNj7 j&Nk&& c&)((d cIHJEHGSLHJFHGS EF?J? EU$ JLXT?KEJd%

-F? IHJECHKE TLIS? U@J K$GK?CG?I EF@E 8A@S$T?MHKF F@I X??G

ECVHGS E$ @CSL? DHJE@^?'$B'A@U HGIHC?KEAV ?M?G EF$LSF G$G?

$B EF? JE@ELE?J C?_LHC?J A?S@A ^G$UA?IS?Z LGI?C EF? KHCKLD'

JE@GK?J7 HE U@J G$E @G @XLJ? $B IHJKC?EH$G E$ @II @ K@LEH$G E$


15/23

#$% &&'()*( &*

EF? HGJECLKEH$GJ% 6B% =%$&+/ >&+7 ,- 425&$7 7 Y)& 3%(I bNj7 bNY

cYEF 6HC% PN&*d c@G HGJECLKEH$G HJ >C$>?C LGA?JJ f@J @ UF$A?

oHEp DHJA?I EF? TLCV @J E$ EF? @>>AHK@XA? A@Ugd%

a? G$U E@^? L> KF@AA?GS?J E$ EF? @IDHJJH$G @GI ?WKAL'

JH$G $B ?MHI?GK?% .@KF ECH@A A@JE?I @X$LE @ D$GEF7 J$ EF?C?

U?C? >A?GEV $B ?MHI?GEH@CV CLAHGSJ% 2G EF? UF$A?7 EF? IHJECHKE

TLIS? @AA$U?I EF? I?B?GJ? K$GJHI?C@XA? A@EHELI?7 XLE 8A@S$'

T?MHKF K@G\E K$D>A@HG @X$LE EF? CLAHGSJ HG FHJ B@M$C% =? I$?J

K$D>A@HG @X$LE J?M?C@A EF@E U?GE EF? >C$J?KLEH$G\J U@V7 @GI

U? IHJKLJJ EFC?? $B EF?D%

-F? BHCJE K$GK?CGJ @ CLAHGS EF@E ?WKALI?I UHC?E@> EC@G'

JKCH>EJ JF$UHGS EF@E @E EF? J@D? EHD? 8A@S$T?MHKF U@J @J^HGS

EF? `C?JHI?GE'?A?KE B$C J$D?EFHGS HG ?WKF@GS? B$C @>>$HGEHGS

?@^?C $B EF? JE@E?\J =$LJ? $B 5?>C?J?GE@EHM?Jd E$ JL>>$CE

FHJ >$AHEHK@A >C$SC@D HG ?WKF@GS? B$C @>>$HGEHGS 9HJ@ 4@IH'

S@G7 4HKF@?A\J I@LSFE?C7 E$ EF? 0?G@E?% 8A@S$T?MHKF\J A@UV?CJ

K$GE?GI?I EF@E FHJ $XT?KEHM? @AA @A$GS U@J E$ @>>$HGE 9HJ@

4@IHS@G7 EF?G c@GI G$Ud EF? 1EE$CG?V :?G?C@A $B ,AAHG$HJ%

-F? IHJECHKE TLIS? IHI G$E @AA$U EFHJ UHC?E@> ?MHI?GK?7 CLAHGSEF@E HE U$LAI IHM?CE @EE?GEH$G BC$D EF? HGIHKED?GE\J KF@CS?J%

1 X@G^ C$XX?C K@GG$E JF$U EF@E $G D@GV $EF?C $KK@JH$GJ F?

?GE?C?I @ X@G^ UHEF$LE >LAAHGS @ SLG $G @ E?AA?C7 G$C K@G @

E?AA?C KF@CS?I UHEF ?DX?]]A?D?GE JF$U F$U $BE?G F? D@I?

K$CC?KE ?GECH?J HG EF? X$$^J%

1J U?\M? D?GEH$G?I7 EF? IHJECHKE K$LCE S@M? EF? I?B?GJ? @

A$GS A?@JF7 @GI EF? TLIS? U@J ?GEHEA?I E$ K$GKALI? EF@E ?MH'

I?GK? @X$LE G?S$EH@EH$GJ UHEF 0>?@^?C 4@IHS@G U$LAI JHI?'

EC@K^ EFHJ ECH@A% 0?? 3?I% 5% .MHI% jN(% -F? 4@IHS@G K$GM?CJ@'EH$GJ K$LAI F@M? JF$UG EF@E 8A@S$T?MHKF U@J G?S$EH@EHGS

UHEF D@GV >?$>A? B$C EF? X?JE I?@AZ EF?V U$LAI G$E F@M?


16/23

&[ #$% &&'()*(

JF$UG EF@E @GV $B FHJ C?_L?JEJ E$ EF? `C?JHI?GE'?A?KE $C 5?>%

;@K^J$G U@J A@UBLA% -F? TLIS? IHI >?CDHE 8A@S$T?MHKF E$ E?J'

EHBV EF@E F? F@I >A@GG?I E$ @>>$HGE 9HJ@ 4@IHS@G @AA @A$GS

@GI EF@E F? U@J I?K?HMHGS C@EF?C EF@G ?WE$CEHGS EF? `C?JH'

I?GE'?A?KE% c,G EF? ?GI7 F$U?M?C7 F? @>>$HGE?I 5$A@GI 8LC'

CHJ7 G$E 9HJ@ 4@IHS@G%d 0$D? EC@GJKCH>EJ @IDHEE?I B$C $EF?C

>LC>$J?J @AJ$ K$GE@HG?I 9HJ@ 4@IHS@G\J G@D?%

6$D? EF? KA$JHGS @CSLD?GE7 EF? >C$J?KLE$C LJ?I EF?

TLIS?\J CLAHGS E$ @IM@GE@S?7 JE@EHGSh

1GI EF? 9HJ@ 4@IHS@G I?@A7 V$L\AA F@M? EF? K@AAJ7 #$M?DX?C &JE

EFC$LSF #$M?DX?C &(EF% :$ X@K^ @GI A$$^ @E EF? K@AAJ @GI J??

F$U D@GV EHD?J 9HJ@ 4@IHS@G HJ @KEL@AAV D?GEH$G?I m % -F@E\J

$G?7 @GI EU$7 F$U $BE?G HJ JF? D?GEH$G?I HG @ U@V EF@E JF? HJ

G$E @ JE@A^HGS F$CJ?7 @GI V$L\C? G$E S$HGS E$ BHGI HE% 0F? U@J @

JE@A^HGS F$CJ?%

8A@S$T?MHKF K$GE?GIJ EF@E EFHJ @CSLD?GE MH$A@E?I EF? /L?

`C$K?JJ 6A@LJ? XV J$ DHJA?@IHGS EF? TLCV EF@E HE K$LAI G$

A$GS?C EFHG^ C@EH$G@AAV @X$LE FHJ SLHAE% 0?? .#5/+% ,- L#$%(

J5$3E& 7 jYY +%0% &[)7 &)& c&b)[d%

=@MHGS >?CJL@I?I EF? TLIS? E$ ^??> D$JE 4@IHS@G EC@G'JKCH>EJ $LE $B ?MHI?GK?7 EF? >C$J?KLE$C JF$LAI G$E F@M? @C'

SL?I EF@E EF? C?K$CI K$GE@HGJ M?CV B?U C?B?C?GK?J E$ F?C% -F?

>@LKHEV $B C?B?C?GK?J U@J @ C?JLAE $B EF? >C$J?KLE$C\J JEC@E?'

SV7 G$E EF? I?B?GJ?\J JEC@E?SV $C @ JF$CE@S? $B C?B?C?GK?J HG

EF? C?K$CIHGSJ% 8LE .#5/+% J?EJ @ M?CV FHSF X@C B$C @ IL?'

>C$K?JJ KF@AA?GS? E$ @ >C$J?KLE$C\J KA$JHGS @CSLD?GE% ,G EF?

D@HG7 EF? CHSFE C?J>$GJ? HJ @CSLD?GE BC$D EF? I?B?GJ? $C

K$CC?KEH$G BC$D EF? TLIS?7 G$E C?M?CJ@A $G @>>?@A% .J>?KH@AAV

G$E UF?G EF? ECH@A A@JE?I BHM? U??^J @GI EF? >C$J?KLE$CH@A

K$DD?GE A@JE?I @ B?U J?K$GIJ% ,E HJ ?WEC@$CIHG@CHAV LGAH^?AV

EF@E EFHJ K$DD?GE7 @X$LE UF@E HJ c@J U? F@M? D?GEH$G?Id @


17/23

#$% &&'()*( &Y

K$AA@E?C@A HB G$E @G HCC?A?M@GE D@EE?C7 K$LAI F@M? @BB?KE?I EF?

TLCV\J ?M@AL@EH$G $B EF? K$GE?GEH$G EF@E 8A@S$T?MHKF MH$A@E?I

EF? =$XXJ 1KE @GI i[[[ XV @J^HGS EF? `C?JHI?GE'?A?KE $C 5?>%

;@K^J$G B$C K@JF c$C @ ALKC@EHM? >CHM@E?'J?KE$C T$Xd HG ?W'

KF@GS? B$C 8A@S$T?MHKF\J @>>$HGED?GE $B EF? G?U 0?G@E$C%

-F? J?K$GI ?MHI?GEH@CV JLXT?KE K$GK?CGJ @ C?K$CIHGS $B @

K$GM?CJ@EH$G X?EU??G ;$FG =@CCHJ7 8A@S$T?MHKF\J KFH?B $B

JE@BB7 @GI aHAAH@D qLHGA@G7 FHJ S?G?C@A K$LGJ?A% =@CCHJ E?JEH'

BH?IZ qLHGA@G IHI G$E% /LCHGS EF? IHC?KE ?W@DHG@EH$G $B =@C'

CHJ7 EF? >C$J?KLE$C HGEC$ILK?I @ C?K$CIHGS $B @ K@AA X?EU??G

=@CCHJ @GI qLHGA@G7 ILCHGS UFHKF =@CCHJ @J^?I UFV 8A@S$'

T?MHKF F@I G$E V?E JHSG?I EF? XHAA ?WE?GIHGS EF? C@K?EC@K^

JLXJHIV7 @GI qLHGA@G C?>AH?Ih f1F7 A?E\J TLJE J@V7 HE HJ UF@E

V$L EFHG^%g -F? IHJECHKE TLIS? @IDHEE?I EF? JE@E?D?GE fG$E

B$C oHEJp ECLEF XLE B$C EF? ?BB?KE oHEp F@I $G m =@CCHJ @GI EF?

I?KHJH$GJ EF@E F? D@oI?p @J @ C?JLAE $B EFo?p K$GM?CJ@EH$G%g

-F? 3?I?C@A 5LA?J $B .MHI?GK? >C$FHXHE F?@CJ@V7 UFHKF HJ @G

$LE $B K$LCE JE@E?D?GE LJ?I E$ >C$M? EF? ECLEF $B EF? D@EE?C

JE@E?I7 J?? 3?I% 5% .MHI% )N&cKdcPd7 XLE UHEF EF? TLIS?\J AHDHE@'

EH$G qLHGA@G\J JE@E?D?GE U@J G$E F?@CJ@V% -F? >C$J?KLE$CEF?G @J^?I =@CCHJ UF@E F? LGI?CJE$$I cF? @GJU?C?I EF@E

8A@S$T?MHKF fU@J F$AIHGS EF? XHAA X?K@LJ? F? U@GE?I E$ E@A^

E$ o>?$>A?p @X$LE S?EEHGS K@D>@HSG K$GECHXLEH$GJ BC$D EF?

C@K?EC@K^ $UG?CJ X?B$C? F? JHSG?Igd @GI UF@E @KEH$GJ F?

E$$^ @J @ C?JLAE% #$ >C$XA?DJ J$ B@C%

2GK? @S@HG7 EF$LSF7 @ >C$XA?D KC$>>?I L> HG EF? KA$JHGS

@CSLD?GE% -F? >C$J?KLE$C J@HI EFHJh

;$FG =@CCHJ E@A^J E$ EF? I?B?GI@GE7 @GI V$L S$E EF@E K@AA @E -@X

*j7 @GI F? @J^J FHD UF@E E$ I$ @X$LE EF? C@KHGS XHAA X?K@LJ?UF@E F? ^G$UJ HJ F? F@J @>>C$M?I HE7 EF?C?\J @ SC??G AHSFE% -F?

I?B?GI@GE E?AAJ FHD HG EF@E K@AA f,\D JHEEHGS $G EF? XHAA%g =? @A'

C?@IV F@I @ F$AI $G EF@E XHAA @J $B G$$G $B #$M?DX?C EF? P[EF%


18/23

&) #$% &&'()*(

aF@E ;$FG =@CCHJ E$AI V$L HJ EF@E EF? ?WKLJ? EF@E F? S$E BC$D EF?

I?B?GI@GE $G EF@E K@AA D@I? G$ J?GJ? E$ FHD7 HE U@J @ C?I BA@S%=? J@HI J$D?EFHGS E$ FHD AH^? f, U@GE E$ J?? F$U HE @AA BHEJ E$'

S?EF?C%g aF@E =@CCHJ E$AI V$L EF?C? HJ EF?C? U@J G$EFHGS E$ J??

$G EFHJ XHAA @X$LE F$U HE BHE HG UHEF @GVEFHGS ?AJ? EF@E U@J >?GI'

HGS @E EF@E EHD?% 1GI J$ UF@E ;$FG =@CCHJ J@VJ7 f, X?E F?\J F$AI'

HGS EFHJ L> B$C @ K@D>@HSG K$GECHXLEH$G%g

;$FG =@CCHJ S$?J E$ 8HAA qLHGA@G7 F? E?AAJ FHD UF@E FHJ K$GK?CG HJ7

@GI F? @J^J FHD E$ E@A^ E$ EF? I?B?GI@GE @GI BHGI $LE HB EF@E\J

UF@E F?\J I$HGS% )%/ M:2 3:& &E+ 6#"" #& K#B RS JE+5+ @$"" 82$%"#%

6:%'$5;7 &E#&T7 +U#6&"M JE#& &E+ /+'+%/#%& $7 /:$%3- 1GI UF@E ;$FG

=@CCHJ E?JEHBH?I HJ $GK? F? ^G?U EF@E7 F? JE?>>?I $LE7 @GI F? A?BE

HE E$ EF? I?B?GI@GE @GI 9$G 4$G^ o@ A$XXVHJEZ B$CD?CAV 8A@S$' T?MHKF\J KFH?B $B JE@BBp E$ BHSLC? $LE% =? ^G?U F? U@JG\E S$HGS E$

X? @XA? E$ I$ @GVEFHGS $GK? F? F@I @ F$AI $G EF@E XHAA U@HEHGS B$C

@ K@D>@HSG K$GECHXLEH$G%

-F? A@GSL@S? U? F@M? HE@AHKH]?I HJ EF? >C$XA?D% ,E E@^?J

qLHGA@G\J JE@E?D?GE @J EF? >C$>$JHEH$G EF@E 8A@S$T?MHKF U@J

U@HEHGS B$C D$G?V% -F@E\J @ F?@CJ@V LJ?% -F? $GAV >C$>?C

LJ? $B EF? JE@E?D?GE U@J B$C EF? ?BB?KE HE F@I $G =@CCHJ%

`?CF@>J $G? K$LAI C?JKL? EF? @CSLD?GE XV J@VHGS EF@E

EF? HE@AHKH]?I J?GE?GK? HJ TLJE JF$CEF@GI B$C EF? >?CDHEE?I LJ?$B qLHGA@G\J C?K$CI?I U$CIJh =@CCHJ 2%/+57&::/ EF?D @J K$G'

BHCDHGS FHJ X?AH?B EF@E 8A@S$T?MHKF U@J F$AIHGS EF? XHAA HG $C'

I?C E$ ?WEC@KE D$G?V BC$D C@K?EC@K^ $UG?CJ% ;LC$CJ DHSFE

F@M? X??G F@CI >C?JJ?I E$ E?AA EF? IHBB?C?GK? X?EU??G fqLHG'

A@G K$GBHCD?I lg @GI f=@CCHJ LGI?CJE$$I qLHGA@G E$ K$G'

BHCD l%g -FHJ D@V C?BA?KE @IM?CJ?AV $G EF? F?@CJ@V I$KECHG?Z

TLC$CJ I$ G$E IC@U JLXEA? IHJEHGKEH$GJ TLJE X?K@LJ? EF?V F@M?

X??G >@CE $B EF? K$DD$G A@U JHGK? EF? ?HSFE??GEF K?GELCV%

1E @AA ?M?GEJ7 fJLXEA?g HJ EF? HD>$CE@GE U$CI% :HM?G EF? IL'

C@EH$G $B EFHJ ECH@A @GI EF? >$U?C $B EF? ?MHI?GK?7 EF? B@KE

EF@E @ >C$J?KLE$C J@VJ fqLHGA@G K$GBHCD?I lg UF?G F?

JF$LAI F@M? J@HI f=@CCHJ LGI?CJE$$I qLHGA@G E$ F@M? K$G'


19/23

#$% &&'()*( &b

BHCD?I lg K@GG$E F@M? @BB?KE?I EF? $LEK$D?% -F? TLIS? FHD'

J?AB J??DJ E$ F@M? DHJJ?I EF? IHJEHGKEH$G7 I?J>HE? FHJ ?@CAH?C

CLAHGS% -F? AH^?AHF$$I $B >C?TLIHK? BC$D EFHJ DHJJE@E?D?GE HJ

DHGLE?7 @GI UHEF$LE >C?TLIHK? EF?C?\J G$ X@JHJ B$C @ C?M?CJ@A%

0?? =%$&+/ >&+7 ,- A$6E#5/7 7 Y&b 3%(I Yj[7 Y[j cYEF 6HC% PN&(d%

#$U B$C EF? EFHCI ?MHI?GEH@CV HJJL?7 @GI EF? A@JE U? IHJ'

KLJJ% /LCHGS ECH@A7 EF? TLIS? @IDHEE?I ?MHI?GK? EF@E7 X?B$C?

FHJ @CC?JE7 8A@S$T?MHKF F@I C?E@HG?I EF? J?CMHK?J $B A@UV?CJ

UHEF ?W>?CH?GK? HG KCHDHG@A I?B?GJ?% 8A@S$T?MHKF\J @>>?AA@E?

XCH?B K$GE?GIJ EF@E EF? $GAV BLGKEH$G $B EFHJ ?MHI?GK? U@J E$

HD>AV K$GJKH$LJG?JJ $B SLHAE% -F? >C$J?KLE$C C?>AH?J7 F$U?M'

?C7 EF@E EFHJ ?MHI?GK? J?CM?I @ IHBB?C?GE BLGKEH$Gh E$ @IIC?JJ

UF@E J??D?I E$ X? @ I?M?A$>HGS @IMHK?'$B'K$LGJ?A I?B?GJ?%

-$ EFHJ 8A@S$T?MHKF C?T$HGJ EF@E F? G?M?C C@HJ?I JLKF @ I?'

B?GJ?7 J$ EF? ?MHI?GK? U@J X$EF HCC?A?M@GE @GI >C?TLIHKH@A%

f1IMHK? $B K$LGJ?A HJ G$E @ BC??'JE@GIHGS I?B?GJ?7 EF$LSF

@ A@UV?C\J BLAAV HGB$CD?I $>HGH$G EF@E K?CE@HG K$GILKE HJ

A@UBLA cB$AA$U?I XV K$GILKE JECHKEAV HG K$D>AH@GK? UHEF EF@E

$>HGH$Gd K@G G?S@E? EF? D?GE@A JE@E? C?_LHC?I B$C J$D?

KCHD?J7 HGKALIHGS BC@LI%g =%$&+/ >&+7 ,- A:&$ 7 j)j 3%(I b(j7b(* cYEF 6HC% PNNYd% 8A@S$T?MHKF IHI G$E D$LGE @G @IMHK?'$B'

K$LGJ?A I?B?GJ?% =? IHI G$E BLAAV C?M?@A FHJ @KEH$GJ E$ @GV

A@UV?C7 IHI G$E C?K?HM? @G $>HGH$G EF@E EF? @KEJ U?C? A@UBLA7

@GI IHI G$E K$D>$CE FHDJ?AB JECHKEAV HG K$D>AH@GK? UHEF @GV

JLKF $>HGH$G% 8LE F? FHGE?I HG EF@E IHC?KEH$G% =?C? HJ J$D? $B

FHJ E?JEHD$GVh

r f, HDD?IH@E?AV F@I 4@CV o0E?U@CEp BHGI 8HAA qLHG'

A@G B$C D? J$ EF@E , K$LAI E@A^ E$ 8HAA qLHGA@G DV

A@UV?C7 EF? S$M?CG$C\J A@UV?C7 @X$LE UF@E I$ , I$@X$LE EFHJ7 F$U I$ , F@GIA? EFHJ7 X?K@LJ? , U@GE?I

E$ X? M?CV K@C?BLA EF@E , I$G\E S?E K@LSFE L> HG J$D?'


20/23

PN #$% &&'()*(

EFHGS EF@E ,\D G$E @U@C? $B EF@E HJG\EOEF@E HJ >$E?G'

EH@AAV UC$GS @GI K$LAI M?CV U?AA X? UC$GS%g -C%

()Nb%

r f1GI EF?G , U@J C?K$GJECLKEHGS B$C 8HAA qLHGA@G7 DV

A@UV?C7 X@JHK@AAV7 V$L ^G$U7 J>HAAHGS UF@E?M?C ,

^G?U7 UF@E?M?C U@J K$DHGS HGE$ DV DHGI E$ FHD

@X$LE EF@E K@AA7 @X$LE EF@E K$GM?CJ@EH$G @X$LE EF?

BLGIC@HJHGS C?_L?JEJ BC$D `@ECHK^ 4@S$$G oEF?

`C?JHI?GE $B 6FHAIC?G\J 4?D$CH@A =$J>HE@Ap HG K$G'

G?KEH$G UHEF /LJEV 8@^?C o@ B$CD?C D@G@S?C $B EF?

6FHK@S$ 6LXJ UF$ U@J A$XXVHGS $G 4@S$$G\J X?'

F@ABp K@AAHGS D?% 1GI J$ , U@J C?A@EHGS EFHJ E$ 8HAA

qLHGA@G m X?K@LJ? , U@J X@JHK@AAV ECVHGS E$ BHGI $LE

BC$D qLHGA@G I$ V$L EFHG^ , J@HI J$D?EFHGS UC$GSn

6$LAI , F@M? I$G?OK$LAI , F@M? JELDXA?I HGE$

KC$JJHGS @ AHG? $B J$D? J$CEng -C% jNY)%

r fqh aFV U?C? V$L E?AAHGS 8HAA qLHGA@G EF@En 1h 8?'

K@LJ? 8HAA qLHGA@G\J DV S?G?C@A K$LGJ?A7 F?\J DV

A@UV?C @GI F? U@J HG D@GV U@VJ7 V$L ^G$U7 @OF?

U@J HG D@GV U@VJOV$L ^G$U7 F?O, E@A^?I E$ FHD@X$LE ?M?CVEFHGS EF@E U@J C?D$E?AV K$GG?KE?I E$

@GVEFHGS EF@E U@J $G A?S@A HJJL?J $C >?GIHGS HGM?J'

EHS@EH$G @GI @AA EF? C?JE X?K@LJ? , U@GE?I E$ X? K@C?'

BLA G$E E$ I$ @GVEFHGS UC$GS%g -C% jNYb%

r f8HAA qLHGA@G m U@J DV S?G?C@A K$LGJ?A7 @GI EF?C?

U@J G$EFHGS , U$LAI I$ $B @GV D@SGHELI? EF@E , B?AE

, G??I?I E$ IHJKLJJ UHEF DV S?G?C@A K$LGJ?A7 DV

A@UV?C 8HAA qLHGA@G%g -C% jNbP%

r fqh /HI V$L @AJ$ F@M? J?M?C@A K$GM?CJ@EH$GJ UHEF

8HAA qLHGA@G @X$LE EF? 0?G@E? J?@En 1h Q?J% , E@A^?I


21/23

#$% &&'()*( P&

E$ 8HAA qLHGA@G @X$LE HE K$GJE@GEAV7 K$GEHGL$LJAV7

@AD$JE ?M?CV I@V% 1AD$JE ?M?CV I@V% qh /HI V$L

F@M? K$GM?CJ@EH$GJ UHEF 8HAA qLHGA@G @X$LE o?JE@X'

AHJFHGSp @ *N&cKdcjd oJ$KH@A'U?AB@C? $CS@GH]@EH$Gp HG

C?A@EH$G E$ EF? 0?G@E? J?@En 1h , F@I J?M?C@A K$GM?C'

J@EH$GJ UHEF 8HAA qLHGA@G @X$LE @ *N&cKdcjd HG C?A@'

EH$G E$ EF? 0?G@E? J?@E%g -C% j&&P%

-F? >C$J?KLE$C $XT?KE?I E$ @AA $B EFHJ E?JEHD$GV7 $XJ?CMHGS

EF@E 8A@S$T?MHKF F@I G$E ECH?I E$ D??E EF? C?_LHC?D?GEJ $B @G

@IMHK?'$B'K$LGJ?A I?B?GJ?7 XLE EF? TLIS? @AA$U?I EF? E?JEH'

D$GV cEFHJ HJ $G? $B EF? D@GV ?W@D>A?J $B C?J$AMHGS I?X@E@'

XA? _L?JEH$GJ HG EF? I?B?GJ?\J B@M$Cd% =@MHGS @JJ?CE?I EF@E F?

K$GJLAE?I UHEF K$LGJ?A7 8A@S$T?MHKF $>?G?I EF? I$$C E$ ?MH'

I?GK? EF@E F? F@I $EF?C A@UV?CJ E$$ V?E U@J ^??>HGS DLD

@X$LE UF@E EF?V E$AI FHD% -F@E\J @G @>>C$>CH@E? E$>HK B$C

?MHI?GK? @GI B$C K$DD?GE ILCHGS KA$JHGS @CSLD?GE%

0?GE?GKHGS HJ EF? $GAV $EF?C JLXT?KE EF@E C?_LHC?J IHJKLJ'

JH$G% -F? IHJECHKE TLIS? K$GKALI?I EF@E EF? 0?GE?GKHGS

:LHI?AHG?J C?K$DD?GI @ C@GS? $B ([N D$GEFJ E$ AHB? HD>CHJ'

$GD?GE B$C 8A@S$T?MHKF\J $BB?GJ?J7 @GI EF? @KEL@A J?GE?GK? HJ&[) D$GEFJ% ,GJE?@I $B ?W>C?JJHGS C?AH?B7 8A@S$T?MHKF D@HG'

E@HGJ EF@E EF? J?GE?GK? HJ E$$ FHSF X?K@LJ? EF? C@GS? U@J E$$

FHSF% -F? TLIS? ?CC?I HG EU$ C?J>?KEJ7 8A@S$T?MHKF K$GE?GIJh

BHCJE7 EF? TLIS? HGKALI?I @J A$JJ EF? e&%* DHAAH$G EF@E7 F?

B$LGI7 8A@S$T?MHKF F@I @J^?I 5?>% ;@K^J$G\J JL>>$CE?CJ E$

JL>>AV% 0?? +%0%0%:% iP6&%&cXdcPd% =? K@AAJ EFHJ BHGIHGS

fJ>?KLA@EHM?%g -F? TLIS? @AJ$ @II?I B$LC A?M?AJ LGI?C

+%0%0%:% i(8&%&c@d @BE?C BHGIHGS EF@E 8A@S$T?MHKF U@J EF?

A?@I?C $C $CS@GH]?C $B KCHDHG@A @KEHMHEV EF@E HGKALI?I BHM? $CD$C? >@CEHKH>@GEJ $C U@J f$EF?CUHJ? ?WE?GJHM?g% 8A@S$T?MHKF


22/23

PP #$% &&'()*(

K$GE?GIJ EF@E EF? D@GV >?CJ$GJ F? K$GJLAE?I $C LJ?I @J HG'

E?CD?IH@CH?J JF$LAI G$E K$LGE%

-F? IHJECHKE TLIS? IHI G$E ?CC HG ?HEF?C C?J>?KE% -F? e&%*

DHAAH$G BHSLC? IHI G$E K$D? $LE $B @ F@EZ HE U@J @ GLDX?C

IHJKLJJ?I HG EF? C?K$CIHGSJ% -F@E G$EFHGS K@D? $B EF?J?

$M?CELC?J I$?J G$E @BB?KE EF? K@AKLA@EH$G $B A$JJ LGI?C

iP6&%&cXdcPd7 X?K@LJ? HE HJ @G @D$LGE 8A@S$T?MHKF HGE?GI?I E$

C?K?HM? BC$D KCHDHG@A K$GILKE ?M?G EF$LSF G$E @ JLD @GV'

$G? ?AJ? ELCG?I $LE E$ X? UHAAHGS c$C @XA?d E$ >@V% 1J B$C EF?

A?@I?CJFH> ?GF@GK?D?GE B$C @G f$EF?CUHJ? ?WE?GJHM?g $CS@G'

H]@EH$Gh -FHJ @>>AH?J UF?EF?C $C G$E EF? I?B?GI@GE\J JLX$C'

IHG@E?J @GI @JJ$KH@E?J @C? KCHDHG@AAV KLA>@XA?% +%0%0%:%

i(8&%& 1>>AHK@EH$G #$E? (% -F? GLDX?CJ HGM$AM?I F?C? JLX'

JE@GEH@AAV ?WK??I BHM? @GI _L@AHBV @J f$EF?CUHJ? ?WE?GJHM?%g

1GV ?CC$C HG EF? :LHI?AHG?J K@AKLA@EH$G U?GE HG 8A@S$'

T?MHKF\J B@M$C% 1BE?C K@AKLA@EHGS EF? ([N'E$'AHB? C@GS?7 EF?

TLIS? K$GKALI?I EF@E HE HJ E$$ FHSF @GI X?S@G D@^HGS C?ILK'

EH$GJ7 >C$ILKHGS @ C@GS? $B &*& E$ &)) D$GEFJ% 3$C ?W@D>A?7

EF? TLIS? S@M? 8A@S$T?MHKF @ EU$'A?M?A C?ILKEH$G B$C @KK?>E'

HGS C?J>$GJHXHAHEV7 J?? +%0%0%:% i(.&%&7 @GI E$$^ $BB EU$ D$C?B$C S$$I D?@JLC?7 ?M?G EF$LSF F? >A?@I?I G$E SLHAEV7 I?'

GH?I KLA>@XHAHEV @E EU$ A?GSEFV ECH@AJ7 @GI ?M?G G$U K$G'

E?GIJ EF@E EF? ?MHI?GK? HJ HGJLBBHKH?GE $G +,+5M K$LGE @GI EF@E

F? JF$LAI F@M? X??G @K_LHEE?I @KC$JJ EF? X$@CI% -F@E\J EF?

@GEHEF?JHJ $B @KK?>EHGS C?J>$GJHXHAHEV% -F? TLIS? C?ILK?I EF?

C@GS? BLCEF?C XV I?KHIHGS G$E E$ K$LGE @AA $B EF? e&%* DHAAH$G

@J A$JJ7 ?M?G EF$LSF F? F@I I?KHI?I ?@CAH?C EF@E HE HJ EF? CHSFE

BHSLC?% -F? >C$J?KLE$C F@J G$E BHA?I @ KC$JJ'@>>?@A HG _L?JE $B

@ FHSF?C J?GE?GK? XLE HJ ?GEHEA?I E$ I?B?GI EF? @KEL@A J?G'E?GK? $B &[) D$GEFJ c@GI E$ @J^ B$C HEJ C?'HD>$JHEH$G $G C?'

D@GId UHEF$LE G??IHGS E$ BHA? @G @>>?@A% 5?D$MHGS EF? K$G'


23/23

#$% &&'()*( P(

MHKEH$GJ $G EF? 6@XHG?E K$LGEJ I$?J G$E @BB?KE EF? C@GS? K@A'

KLA@E?I LGI?C EF? :LHI?AHG?J% ,E HJ G$E >$JJHXA? E$ K@AA &[)

D$GEFJ LGA@UBLAAV FHSF B$C 8A@S$T?MHKF\J KCHD?J7 XLE EF?

IHJECHKE TLIS? JF$LAI K$GJHI?C $G C?D@GI UF?EF?C HE HJ EF?

D$JE @>>C$>CH@E? J?GE?GK?%

-F? K$GMHKEH$GJ $G 6$LGEJ *7 [7 P&7 PP7 @GI P( @C? M@K@E'

?IZ EF? C?D@HGHGS K$GMHKEH$GJ @C? @BBHCD?I% -F? J?GE?GK? HJ

M@K@E?I7 @GI EF? K@J? HJ C?D@GI?I B$C C?ECH@A $G EF? M@K@E?I

K$LGEJ% 6HCKLHE 5LA? ([ UHAA G$E @>>AV% ,B EF? >C$J?KLE$C ?A?KEJ

E$ IC$> EF?J? KF@CS?J7 EF?G EF? IHJECHKE K$LCE JF$LAI >C$K??I

IHC?KEAV E$ C?J?GE?GKHGS% 8?K@LJ? U? F@M? @BBHCD?I EF? K$G'

MHKEH$GJ $G D$JE K$LGEJ @GI K$GKALI?I EF@E EF? @IMHJ$CV

J?GE?GKHGS C@GS? AH?J @X$M? &[) D$GEFJ7 8A@S$T?MHKF HJ G$E

?GEHEA?I E$ X? C?A?@J?I >?GIHGS EF?J? BLCEF?C >C$K??IHGSJ%

7th circuit court of appeals ruling on rod blagojevich

Documents