9789088902857 - mols & buitelaar 2015 - hajj - rmv43 - e-book

260
7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9789088902857-mols-buitelaar-2015-hajj-rmv43-e-book 1/260 Dagn`a Lktor`ctlgks tjrgudj Xladrli`do J`mm Aultd`rb Igas & I`rmg Nultoa``r obltob ny Ioboboalkdok v`k jot ^lmfsiusoui vggr Ugafokfukbo, Aolbok

Upload: sidestone-press

Post on 06-Feb-2018

227 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    1/260

    Dagn`a Lktor`ctlgks

    tjrgudj Xladrli`do

    J`mm

    Aultd`rb Igas & I`rmg Nultoa``r

    obltob ny

    I o b o b o a l k d o k v ` k j o t ^ l m f s i u s o u i v g g r U g a f o k f u k b o , A o l b o k

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    2/260

    Slbostgko Xross@ kow dokor`tlgk ge Xunalsjlkd

    \gu `ro ro`blkd ` euaa vorslgk ge tjls nggf, egr eroo!

    Rjls nggf ls p`rt ge tjo Slbostgko o-alnr`ry wjoro igst ge gur

    punalc`tlgks `ro euaay `ccosslnao egr eroo. Egr `ccoss tg igro

    eroo nggfs vlslt= www.slbostgko.cgi/alnr`ry

    Bgwkag`b Euaa XBE

    Ulslt tjo Slbostgko o-alnr`ry tg nrgwso gur o-nggfs. Egr ` ilkli`a

    eoo ygu c`k purcj`so ` euaay eukctlgk`a XBE `kb ny bglkd sg, ygu

    joap tg foop gur alnr`ry rukklkd.

    www.slbostgko.cgi/alnr`ry

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    3/260

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    4/260

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    5/260

    I ^ U, A

    Kg.

    obltob ny Aultd`rb Igas & I`rmg Nultoa``r

    J@MM

    Dagn`a Lktor`ctlgks tjrgudj Xladrli`do

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    6/260

    Ioboboalkdok v`k jot ^lmfsiusoui vggr Ugafokfukbo Kg. 23

    LSNK

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    7/260

    Cgktokts

    Lktrgbuctlgk 0I`rmg Nultoa``r `kb Aultd`rb Igas

    Rjo J`mm `kb tjo @ktjrgpgagdlc`a Stuby ge Xladrli`do 4

    Xklk` Tornkor

    Xladrli`do, Xoregri`tlvlty, `kb Nrltlsj Iusalis= Scrlptob `kb _kscrlptob@ccgukts ge tjo J`mm `kb _ir` 20

    Sok IcAgudjalk

    Rjo J`mm `kb Xgaltlcs lk Cgktoipgr`ry Rurfoy `kb Lkbgkosl` 5?^gnort ^. Nl`kcjl

    Lsa`ilc ^oegrilsi `kb Xladrli`do= Rjo J`mm ge ^`sjlb ^lb` lk 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    8/260

    vl

    Sguvoklr, Rostligky, `kb Bovlco egr Lkstructlgk=A`to Klkotooktj- `kb O`ray Rwoktlotj-Coktury Xrlktob J`mm Cortlelc`tos 0:?

    Aultd`rb Igas

    @ppo`r`kcos Noalo. @ Iocc`-Coktrob Tgrab I`p `kb ` Skgucf JurdrgkmoXjgtgdr`pj ergi tjo Aolbok _klvorslty Cgaaoctlgks >03

    @rkgub Urgalmf

    J`mm Iuslc ergi Odypt, Syrl` `kb Aon`kgk= sgio roeaoctlgksgk sgkds egr tjo pladrli`do >>34

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    9/260

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    10/260

    Bosldk= I`rtlk Jokso

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    11/260

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    12/260

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    13/260

    0

    LKR^GB_CRLGK

    I`rmg Nultoa``r `kb Aultd`rb Igas

    jo cj`ptors lk tjls vgauio `ro tjo gutcgio ge tjo twg-b`y syipgslui J`mm=Dagn`a Lktor`ctlgks tjrgudj Xladrli`do, wjlcj w`s joab `t tjo K`tlgk`a Iusouige Otjkgagdy lk Aolbok gk >: `kb >< Kgvoinor >803. Lt w`s grd`klsob ny tjoK`tlgk`a Iusoui ge Otjkgagdy, tjo Aolbok _klvorslty Coktro egr tjo Stuby geLsa`i `kb Sgcloty (A_CLS), tjo Kotjora`kbs Lktoruklvorslty ^oso`rcj Scjgga

    egr Lsa`ilc Stublos (KLSLS), kb tjo Egukb`tlgk egr Otjkgagdy lk Aolbok (EOA).K`tlgk a `kb lktork`tlgk`a spo`fors woro lkvltob tg blscuss tjogry `kb pr`ctlcoge tjo J`mm ergi roaldlgus, cuatur`a, i`torl`a, jlstgrlc`a, `kb sgcl`a `kdaos. Lk`bbltlgk, lksldjts lktg porsgk`a noaloes `kb oxporlokcos ge tjo pladrli`do tgIocc` woro dlvok ny Butcj j`mmls lk `k gk-st`do lktorvlow.

    jo liiobl`to c`uso egr tjls syipgslui w`s tjo oxjlnltlgk Agkdlkd egrIocc`. jo Xladrlis Mgurkoytj`t w`s joab `t tjo K`tlgk`a Iusoui ge Otjkgagdynotwook 08 Soptoinor >803 `kb < I`rcj >802. jo oxjlnltlgk, wjlcj w`sprop`rob lk cagso cggpor`tlgk wltj tjo Nrltlsj Iusoui lk Agkbgk, w`s tjo elrstcgiprojokslvo blspa`y ge J`mm-roa`tob `rtoe`cts ergi k`tlgk`a `kb lktork`tlgk`acgaaoctlgks lk tjo Kotjora`kbs. jo oxjlnltlgk w`s bovoagpob `s ` mgurkoy,st`rtlkd wltj tjo prop`r`tlgk kb tjo `ctu`a tr`voas tg Iocc` kb egaagwob ny tjorltos lk Iocc`, tjo vlslt tg Ioblk`, `kb tjo jgiocgilkd ge pladrlis. Lktorvlowswltj j`mmls `kb j`mm`s, wjlcj woro pa`yob gk sovor`a scrooks tjrgudjgut tjooxjlnltlgk `ro`, d`vo elrst-j`kb lksldjts lktg tjo oxpoct`tlgks, oxporlokcos, `kbtr`ksegri`tlgk ge pladrlis. jo oxjlnltlgk `asg egcusob gk tjo lktor`ctlgks gepladrlis, lk ngtj tjo p`st `kb prosokt, tjrgudj tjolr sj`rob dg`a ge ro`cjlkdIocc` lk grbor tg poregri tjo proscrlnob rltu`as.

    ^ovlsob vorslgks ge igst ge tjo cgktrlnutlgks tg tjo syipgslui j`vo egukb

    tjolr w`y lktg tjls nggf.0

    jo nggf ls aggsoay grd`klsob lktg twg i`lk p`rts=tjo elrst elvo cj`ptors lkvostld`to tjo J`mm ergi ` sgcl`a scloktlelc pglkt ge vlow.joso egcus gk tjo roaldlgus, sgcl`a, `kb pgaltlc`a io`klkds ge tjo J`mm `kb

    0 _kegrtuk`toay, kgt `aa p`rtlclp`kts ge tjo syipgslui woro `nao tg cgktrlnuto tg tjls vgauio, nuttjolr lksldjteua p`pors gor kow pglkts ge bop`rturo egr eurtjor roso`rcj. Igj`iiob Cjopplj,wjg t`afob `ngut jls porsgk`a oxporlokcos ge poregrilkd tjo J`mm ngtj `s ` pladrli jlisoae `kb` tgur ao`bor d`vo ` ro`alstlc pgrtr`lt ge wj`t lt ls tg bg tjo J`mm `kb _ir` tgb`y6 Agk Nusfoksoxpagrob tjo Butcj tr`bltlgk ge J`mm roso`rcj `kb pgalcyi`flkd `kb tjo rgao ge Cjrlstl``k SkgucfJurdrgkmo lk p`rtlcua`r. Ro F`n` cgvor, gr flsw`, w`s tjo tgplc ge K`ja` K`ss`rs cgktrlnutlgk, lkwjlcj sjo blscussob lts prostldo, ploty, `kb tjo pgaltlcs wltj wjlcj lts i`kue`cturo ls surrgukbob.Ro cgkcaublkd aocturo ny Elkn`rr N`rry Eaggb, prgeossgr `t Kow \grf _klvorslty `kb tjo >803

    @brl`k Dornr`kbs aocturo-a`uro`to, tltaob S`kctlffob S`kb`as Li`dlkd tjo Xrgpjot lk `k Or` geocjkgagdlc`a ^oprgbuctlgk wlaa no punalsjob ny EOA.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    14/260

    >

    J

    `bbross tjo roa`tlgksjlp notwook tjo sldklelc`kco ge pladrli`do tg Iocc` egr tjoroaldlgus alvos ge lkblvlbu`as `kb drgups `kb tjo wlbor aleo wgrabs tj`t tjoy `rooinobbob lk. jo socgkb p`rt ge tjo nggf cgiprlsos sovok cj`ptors `kb t`fos

    i`torl`a oxprosslgks ge tjo J`mm `s lts st`rtlkd pglkt. Lt oxpagros wj`t J`mm-roa`tob `rtoe`cts c`k toaa us `ngut tjo lipgrt ge pladrli`do lk tjo b`lay alvos geIusalis lk tjo p`st `kb prosokt.

    Tjlao tjo oinobbobkoss ge J`mm pr`ctlcos `kb io`klkds lk agc`a cgktoxtscgios tg tjo egro igst gnvlgusay lk tjo elrst elvo cj`ptors ge tjo nggf, tjosunsoquokt cj`ptors gk i`torl`a J`mm cuaturo asg prgvlbo lksldjts lktg jlstgrlc`abovoagpiokts ge tjo J`mm rltu`a6 tjoy aa bbross tjo lssuo jgw roprosokt`tlgks geIocc` `kb tjo J`mm `kb tjo oxcj`kdo ge J`mm-roa`tob gnmocts j`vo cj`kdob gvortlio. Igro spoclelc`aay, ` tjoio tj`t ruks tjrgudj i`ky ge tjo cgktrlnutlgks lstjo lip`ct ge cj`kdos nrgudjt `ngut ny igborkls`tlgk prgcossos slkco tjo ilb-klkotooktj coktury, wjok liprgvob tr`kspgrt `kb kow tocjkgagdlos nrgudjt tjoJ`mm wltjlk ro`cj ge ` qulcfay lkcro`slkd kuinor ge Iusalis. jo cj`ptors wltj` sgcl`a scloktlelc `pprg`cj, lk tjo elrst p`rt ge tjo nggf, blscuss tjo oeeocts gkJ`mm pr`ctlcos `kb io`klkds egr prosokt-b`y Iusalis ge currokt bliokslgks gedagn`als`tlgk prgcossos. jo cgktrlnutlgks tj`t egcus gk jlstgrlc`a bgcuiokts`kb `rtoe`cts lk tjo socgkb p`rt ge tjo vgauio to`cj us tj`t dagn`als`tlgk sjguabkgt no ilst`fok `s ` rocokt pjokgiokgk. joy `aa pglkt tg tjo e`ct tj`t Iocc`j`s `aw`ys nook ` cgsigpgalt`k clty `kb tjo kgb`a pglkt ge dagn`a lktor`ctlgkse`r oxcooblkd roaldlgus `ctlvltlos gkay.

    gdotjor, tjo cj`ptors lk tjls nggf boplct tjo J`mm rltu`a `s ` alvlkd tr`bltlgk.O`cj wltj lts gwk egcus, tjo v`rlgus cgktrlnutlgks tostley tg tjo e`ct tj`t, wjlaotjo rltos tj`t i`fo up tjo J`mm woro egriua`tob kb rocgrbob lk kgri`tlvo toxtslk o`ray Lsa`i, bot`las lk tjo `ctu`a poregri`kco `kb lktorprot`tlgks ge tjosorltos `ro ny kg io`ks st`tlc, nut r`tjor j`vo ovgavob gvor tlio lk t`kboi wltjcj`kdlkd sgclg-pgaltlc`a clrcuist`kcos.

    Noegro prosoktlkd `k gvorvlow ge tjo cgktokts ge o`cj cj`ptor, wo wlaa sjgrtayboscrlno tjo rltos tj`t i`fo up tjo J`mm.

    Rjo ^ltos ge J`mm

    Ovory yo`r, lk tjo a`st igktj ge tjo Lsa`ilc c`aokb`r, ilaalgks ge Iusalis ergi`rgukb tjo wgrab rrlvo lk S`ubl @r`nl` egr tjo rltu`a ge tjo J`mm. Ergi tjo oldjtjtg tjo tjlrtooktj ge tjo igktj ge Bju a-Jlmm`, pladrlis poregri proscrlnob rltoslk Iocc` `kb lts vlclklty, egaagwlkd lk tjo eggtstops ge tjo prgpjots @nr`j`i`kb Iuj`ii`b. jrgudj tjo poregri`kco ge tjo J`mm, pladrlis `ro cgkkoctobwltj tjo rodlgk lk wjlcj Lsa`i c`io lktg nolkd, wltj tjo roaldlgks o`ray b`ys,`kb wltj gtjor ioinors ge tjo Iusali cgiiuklty wjg procobob tjoi lk tjolrokbo`vgur tg `ccgipalsj tjls gnald`tlgk.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    15/260

    3

    L

    jo J`mm rltu`a ls tjo eletj plaa`r ge Lsa`i, ` buty egr `aa Iusalis wjgsojo`atj `kb elk`kcl`a io`ks `aagw tjoi tg poregri lt. jo gtjor egur plaa`rs grgnald`tlgks ro= rocltlkd tjo tostligky ge e`ltj (tjo sj`j`b`= joro ls kg dgb nut

    Dgb, `kb Iuj`ii`b ls tjo iossokdor ge Dgb), pr`ylkd elvo tlios ` b`y, e`stlkdburlkd tjo igktj ge ^`i`b`k, `kb tjo dlvlkd ge `ais. Lk wj`t st`do ge tjolralvos Iusalis poregri tjo J`mm bopokbs gk lkblvlbu`a clrcuist`kcos `kb agc`acustgis. Sgio cgkslbor`tlgks ildjt no pr`ctlc`a, sucj `s tjo o`so gr bleelcuatyge gnt`lklkd ` J`mm vls` gr j`vlkd s`vob sueelclokt igkoy egr tjo mgurkoy. Gtjors`ro cuatur`a, sucj `s vlows gk wjok ` porsgk ls ro`by lk ` splrltu`a sokso tgporegri tjo J`mm, gr splrltu`a, sucj s oxporlokclkd tjo c`aa tg poregri tjo J`mmny Dgb gr wlsjlkd egr ` splrltu`a cagsuro ge aleo `s prop`r`tlgk egr bo`tj lk gabor`do.

    Xoregrilkd tjo J`mm cgkslsts ge ` soquokco ge sovor`a rltos. Tjok pladrlis`pprg`cj tjo surrgukblkds ge Iocc`, tjoy oxcj`kdo tjolr grblk`ry cagtjosegr ` pladrli`do gr ljr`ibross, wjlcj syingalsos tjo oqu`alty ge `aa pladrlisnoegro Dgb `kb bot`cjiokt ergi ovoryb`y aleo. Oktorlkd tjo st`to ge ljr`i, grcgksocr`tlgk, ls bgko `t gko ge tjo elvo geelcl`a ilq`tagc`tlgks tj`t i`rf tjongukb`ry ge tjo s`crob `ro` `rgukb Iocc`. Iok cj`kdo lktg twg so`iaoss, wjltosjoots tj`t `ro br`pob `rgukb tjo w`lst `kb tjo aoet sjguabor. Egr wgiok tjorols kg uklegri bross cgbo6 tjoy `ro eroo tg bross `s tjoy elkb prgpor, `s agkd `stjoy cgvor tjolr jo`bs `kb wo`r cagtjos tj`t jlbo tjo cgktgurs ge tjolr ngblos.Klq`ns gr e`co volas `ro kgt `aagwob burlkd tjo J`mm. Lt ls `t tjo ilq`tagc`tlgks

    tj`t pladrlis `kkgukco tjolr `rrlv`a tg Dgb ny rocltlkd tjo A`nn`yf` pr`yor=Joro L `i `t jy sorvlco G Agrb, joro L `i. @s tjoy wlaa cgktlkuo tg bg burlkd`aa J`mm rltos, pladrlis wlaa s`y bu`, gr suppalc`tlgk pr`yors, wjlcj stliua`to `bovgtlgk`a ilkbsot. jok, tjoy jo`b egr tjo F`n`, tjo cunlc nulablkd cgvorobwltj ` b`rf-nauo (`aigst na`cf) cgvor lk tjo coktro ge tjo cgurty`rb ge tjo Dro`tIgsquo ge Iocc`. Joro tjoy poregri tjo elrst t`w`e, tjo sovokegab, ktlcagcfwlsoclrcui`inua`tlgk ge tjo sg-c`aaob Jguso ge Dgb gk o`rtj. Xladrlis tjokprgcoob tg s`y pr`yors `t tjo Xa`co ge @nr`j`i (I`q`i Lnr`jli), wjoro ` stgkols fopt tj`t ls s`lb tg j`vo tjo eggtprlkts ge tjls prgpjot. Koxt ls tjo rlto ge s`l(rukklkd), wjlcj cgiioigr`tos tjo so`rcj egr w`tor ny @nr`j`is socgkb wleo

    J`d`r egr jor n`ny sgk Lsji`oa. Ny rukklkd gr w`aflkd sovok tlios notwook tjojlaagcfs ge S`e` `kb I`rw`, pladrlis cgiioigr`to J`d`rs grbo`a `kb jor trustlk Dgb tg s`vo jor `kb jor n`ny. jo elrst b`ys rltos `ro cgkcaubob wltj brlkflkdw`tor ergi tjo ]`iz`i sprlkd, wjlcj J`d`r ls s`lb tg j`vo blscgvorob `t a`stwjoro Lsji`oa flcfob tjo s`kb. ]`iz`i w`tor ls tjo igst cgvotob sguvoklrergi Iocc`, `kb i`ky pladrlis c`rry jgio ` morryc`k tg sj`ro wltj tjolr bo`rgkos upgk roturk gr tg uso `t spocl`a gcc`slgks sucj `s wobblkds gr lk tjo c`soge laakoss. jo i`xliui aagwob igukt ge altros tj`t ls ccoptob bopokbs upgktjo `lralko, `kb v`rlos notwook tok `kb twokty altros. jo elrst kldjt ge tjo J`mmls cgkcaubob ny spokblkd tjo kldjt lk tjo tokt c`ips ge Ilk`.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    16/260

    2

    J

    jo socgkb b`y ge tjo J`mm mgurkoy i`rfs tjo nodlkklkd ge tjo J`mm prgpor.jo igst lipgrt`kt rlto ge tjo J`mm t`fos pa`co tjok= tjo st`kblkd (wuque) gkIgukt @r`e`t `kb lk lts pa`lk. Xladrlis pr`y ergi tjo `etorkggk uktla suksot,

    `sf Dgb egr egrdlvokoss ge tjolr slks, ro`b ergi tjo Pur`k, `kb pr`y egr e`ilay,erlokbs, gr tjo wgrab `t a`rdo. Egr igst pladrlis, noslbos sottlkd tjolr oyos gktjo F`n` egr tjo elrst tlio, tjo st`kblkd gk Igukt @r`e`t ls tjo p`rt ge tjoJ`mm wltj tjo dro`tost oigtlgk`a lip`ct. jls ls noc`uso lt ls cgkcolvob ge `s` flkb ge bross rojo`rs`a egr Mubdiokt B`y, `kb tjoroegro cagsoay roa`tob tgoxlstoktl`a lssuos. Burlkd tjoso agkd jgurs, tjo bop`rturo sorigk boalvorob nytjo Xrgpjot Iuj`ii`b gk tjls igukt`lk burlkd jls gwk J`mm lk 53> CO, tjoyo`r ge jls bo`tj, ls `asg cgiioigr`tob. Le pladrlis e`la tg poregri tjls rlto,tjoy iust robg tjo J`mm lk `kgtjor yo`r. Lk tjo ovoklkd, tjo pladrlis prgcoobtg Iuzb`ale`, wjoro tjoy cgaaoct ponnaos egr tjo koxt b`ys stgklkd rltu`a. joyspokb tjo kldjt pr`ylkd lk tjo gpok. Gk tjo tjlrb b`y, tjo pladrlis prgcoob tgIlk`, wjoro tjo rlto ge stgklkd tjo bovla t`fos pa`co `t tjo m`i`r`t, tjo tjrooplaa`rs. jls cgiioigr`tos @nr`j`is cj`slkd `w`y ge tjo bovla wjok tjo a`ttortrlob tg porsu`bo jli tg blsgnoy Dgb `kb roer`lk ergi geeorlkd jls sgk Lsji`oa.Xladrlis tjrgw sovok ponnaos, gko ny gko, `t tjo a`rdost ge tjoso plaa`rs. jls rltols egaagwob ny tjo Eo`st ge tjo S`crlelco, gr Olb `a-@bj`, burlkd wjlcj sjoop,dg`ts, c`ttao, `kb c`ioas `ro s`crlelcob lk ioigry ge tjo r`i tj`t Dgb suppalob`s ` ropa`coiokt egr tjo geeor tj`t @nr`j`i w`s ro`by tg nrlkd `t Dgbs roquost=tjo s`crlelco ge jls sgk Lsji`oa. Lt ls tjok tj`t iok j`vo tjolr j`lr `kb no`rb

    sj`vob gee `kb wgiok cut gee ` agcf ge tjolr j`lr. jls rlto cgkcaubos tjo J`mmprgpor. Xladrlis i`y t`fo gee tjolr ljr`icagtjlkd kgw le tjoy wlsj tg bg sg `kbroturk tg Iocc` egr `kgtjor t`w`e, gr sovok `ktlcagcfwlso clrcui`inua`tlgks`rgukb tjo F`n`, tg cgkcaubo tjo J`mm rltos. jgso wjg wlsj i`y roturk tgIlk`, wjoro tjoy i`y ropo`t tjo rlto ge stgklkd tjo tjroo plaa`rs burlkd tjoegaagwlkd b`ys. Tjok tjls rlto ls cgipaotob, tjoy roturk tg Iocc` tg cgkcaubotjo J`mm wltj ` e`rowoaa t`w`e`rgukb tjo F`n`.

    I`ky pladrlis vlslt tjo Igsquo ge tjo Xrgpjot Iuj`ii`b lk Ioblk`noegro gr `etor tjo J`mm. Strlctay spo`flkd, tjls vlslt ls kgt p`rt ge tjo J`mm rltu`a,nut egr i`ky pogpao lt ls ` jldjay oigtlgk`a gppgrtuklty tg pr`y lk tjo igsquo

    wjoro tjo Xrgpjot, jls b`udjtor E`tli`, `kb jls succossgrs @nu N`fr `kb Gi`r`ro nurlob.

    Gvorvlow ge tjo Cgktrlnutlgks

    jo nggf gpoks wltj ` cj`ptor gk tjo `ktjrgpgagdy ge pladrli`do. I`rmgNultoa``r `ppalos tjo v`rlgus st`dos ge pladrli`do `s ` rlto ge p`ss`do tg tjoJ`mm `kb blscussos tjo foy cgkcopts ge cgiiuklt`s (cgir`bosjlp `kbod`alt`rl`klsi) `kb alilk`alty (nolkd notwlxt `kb notwook) tj`t bgilk`tobpladrli`do stublos uktla lk tjo 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    17/260

    ?

    L

    sjrlkos `s sltos ge cgktost`tlgk notwook bleeorokt drgups lk sgcloty. Nultoa``rscgktrlnutlgk cgkcaubos wltj ` prgpgs`a egr `k `pprg`cj tg tjo stuby ge tjo J`mmtj`t tr`kscokbs tjo cgiiuklt`scgktost`tlgk cgktrgvorsy.

    @ blscusslgk ge tjo cj`r`ctorlstlcs ge tjo J`mm `s ` rlto ge p`ss`do ls eurtjoroa`ngr`tob lk tjo cj`ptor ny Xklk` Tornkor. Tornkors egcus ls gk tjo w`ysX`flst`kl Iusalis lk tjo _kltob Flkdbgi lktorprot tjo J`mm `s ` rltu`a gepurlelc`tlgk `kb s`crob oxcj`kdo. @etor blscusslkd tjo splrltu`a io`klkds egrjor stuby rospgkbokts ge tjo rltu`a ro-ok`ctlkd ge tjo stgrlos ge @nr`j`i `kbJ`d`r, sjo igvos gk lk tjo socgkb p`rt ge jor cj`ptor tg roeaoct gk tr`ksk`tlgk`abliokslgks ge tjo J`mm. Sjo bgos sg ny stubylkd tjo lktorroa`tlgksjlp notwookpladrli`do tg Iocc` `kb pladrli`do tg agc`a s`lkts sjrlkos lk X`flst`k, wjlcjsgio pladrlis roeor tg `s poregrilkd ` alttao J`mm, wjlao gtjors cgkboik tjocustgi `s uk-Lsa`ilc.

    Cgktost`tlgks ge J`mm-roa`tob pr`ctlcos `kb io`klkds `ro `asg `bbrossob lktjo cj`ptor ny Sok IcAgudjalk, wjg lkvostld`tos porsgk`a stgrlos `ngut tjoJ`mm ge Nrltlsj Iusalis. Ny `k`ayslkd vlbog tostligklos tj`t woro prgbucoblk lktorvlows wltj vlsltgrs tg tjo Alvlkd Lsa`i Eostlv`a lk tjo Okdalsj O`stIlba`kbs, IcAgudjalk boigkstr`tos jgw Iusali lboktlty ls cgkstltutobporegri`tlvoay tjrgudj tjo ok`ctiokt ge kgri`tlvo roaldlgus scrlpts sucj `s tjoJ`mm. Jo boscrlnos bleeorokt p`ttorks tj`t c`k no blscorkob lk porsgk`a stgrlos`ngut tjo oxpoct`tlgks `kb oxporlokcos ge tjo J`mm ny (prgspoctlvo) pladrlisge bleeorokt `dos, dokbors, `kb sgcl`a ca`ssos. IcAgudjalk cgkvlkclkday `rduos

    tj`t, wjlao tjo vlbog-tostligklos cgkt`lk i`ky roeorokcos tg alilk`a eooalkds gecgiiuklt`s `ssgcl`tob wltj s`crob tr`ksegri`tlgk, tjo lktorvlows `asg pglkt tgtjo er`dlao ngukb`ry notwook tjo s`crob `kb tjo prge`ko `kb tg tjo J`mm `s `k`rok` ge cgipotlkd blscgursos.

    jo J`mm s `k rok` ge cgipotlkd blscgursos ls tjo i`lk egcus ge tjo cj`ptorny ^gnort Nl`kcjl. `flkd Lkbgkosl` `kb urfoy `s c`so stublos egr jls `k`ayslsge tjo sgclg-pgaltlc`a bliokslgks ge tjo J`mm, Nl`kcjl `rduos tj`t tjo pladrli`doj`s nocgio ` plvgt`a `kb jldjay cgktrgvorsl`a eo`turo ge b`y-tg-b`y pgaltlc`aaleo lk ngtj cguktrlos. Jls `k`aysls boigkstr`tos tj`t tjo tokslgk notwook `drgwlkd boi`kb egr J`mm sorvlcos gk tjo gko j`kb `kb tjo rostrlctlvo S`ubl

    qugt` systoi gk tjo gtjor dokor`tos crltlc`a punalc bon`tos `ngut tjo rgao gesocua`r dgvorkiokts lk roaldlgus ee`lrs kb ao`bs tg sc`kb`as tj`t sp`rf cguktaossn`ttaos lk tjo iobl` `kb aodlsa`turos.

    I`ky ge tjo igbork J`mm pr`ctlcos `kb tjolr cgktost`tlgks boscrlnob nyTornkor, IcAgudjalk, `kb Nl`kcjl j`vo jlstgrlc`a rggts lk `ttltubos oiordlkdergi tjo 0:?8s gkw`rbs. Lkeauokcob ny cgagkl`a oxp`kslgk, lktoksleylkddagn`als`tlgk, `kb roaldlgus roegri bon`tos, kow aleostyaos `kb egris geroaldlgslty bovoagpob lk wjlcj igbork sclokcos, tocjkgagdlos, `kb wgrabvlowsworo lkcgrpgr`tob. Lk jls cj`ptor gk tjo J`mm `ccgukt wrlttok ny tjo Iusaliroegrilst tjlkfor Iuj`ii`b ^lb`, ^lcj`rb v`k Aoouwok `sfs wj`t wo c`k

    ao`rk ergi ^lb`s toxt `ngut tjo w`ys tjo cgktoxt ge igborklty `eeoctob tjo

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    18/260

    5

    J

    pr`ctlco `kb io`klkds ge tjo J`mm `s ` rltu`a gnald`tlgk, ` roaldlgus oxporlokco,`kb `k `ct ge tr`voaalkd cgkkoctob tg aleostyao `kb soae-lboktlty.

    jo `rts `kb i`torl`a i`kleost`tlgks `ssgcl`tob wltj tjo F`n` lk Iocc` `kb

    tjo J`mm rltos `t a`rdo `ro tjo egcus ge tjo koxt sovok cj`ptors. Iocc` `kb tjoJ`mm j`vo `aw`ys nook `k lipgrt`kt sgurco ge lksplr`tlgk egr `rtlsts `kb `rtls`ks`kb stliuaus egr tjo oxcj`kdo ge prgbucts kb wgrfs ge rt `igkd pladrlis. Lkjor cj`ptor Dlets, Sguvoklrs, `kb tjo J`mm, Uokotl` Xgrtor dlvos `k gvorvlow getjo roaldlgus, pgaltlc`a, kb syingalc lktokt ge tjo v`rlgus dlets tj`t woro grborobny tjo oalto `kb sokt tg (`kb fopt lk) tjo s`kctu`rlos lk Iocc` `kb Ioblk`.jls ls egaagwob ny ` blscusslgk ge tjo io`klkd ge iucj-v`auob foops`fostj`t woro nrgudjt jgio ny pladrlis. Sjo cgkcaubos ny oxpagrlkd tjo agc`a `kbsliuat`kogusay dagn`a rtlstlc lktor`ctlgk lk klkotooktj-coktury Iocc`, lk wjlcj`rtlsts ge bleeorokt k`tlgk`altlos wgrfob kb roslbob slbo ny slbo lk tjo Jgay Cltyge Lsa`i, ` quostlgk tj`t nrg`boks gur jgrlzgk gk Iocc`s lipgrt`kco lk Lsa`ilcvlsu`a jlstgry.

    Lk tjo koxt cj`ptor, Galvor Iggro oxpagros ngtj Lsa`i lk Cjlk` `kb tjovlsu`a i`kleost`tlgks ge Cjlkoso roa`tlgks wltj Iocc` `kb tjo J`mm. jrgudjc`so stublos, tjo sgcl`a io`klkds ge tjo J`mm lk Cjlk` ro blscussob, `s ro spoctsge Lsa`is `ccuatur`tlgk tg Cjlkoso cgkbltlgks. jo a`ttor ls oxoipalelob ny tjojynrlb k`turo ge, egr ox`ipao, ioblov`a tginstgkos lk tjo sgutj-o`stork Cjlkosopgrt ge Pu`kzjgu, fkgwk ny ioblov`a tr`bors s ]`ytgk, tj`t blspa`y tjo k`iosge j`mmls lk cginlk`tlgk wltj lkvgc`tlgks ge Cjlkoso igurklkd. oprosokt`tlgks

    ge tjo s`kctu`rlos lk Iocc` `kb Ioblk` `asg lkcaubo tjo Cjlkoso custgi gesjgwlkd igukt`lks `s succosslvoay rocoblkd gnmocts. joso `kb gtjor ox`ipaos`ro sldklelc`kt i`torl`a oxprosslgks ge tjo jlstgrlc`a `ccuatur`tlgk ge Lsa`i `kbtjo i`torl`a i`kleost`tlgk ge tjo J`mm lk Cjlk`.

    ^oprosokt`tlgks ge tjo F`n` `kb tjo Dro`t Igsquo ge Iocc` `ro fkgwkergi tjo twoaetj coktury gkw`rbs, elrst gk stgko `kb p`por `kb a`tor `asg gkgtjor i`torl`as, alfo cor`ilcs. jolr styaos `ro `s blvorso `s tjo grldlk ge tjo`rtlsts wjg prgbucob tjo gnmocts. Blspa`yob lk punalc roaldlgus pa`cos, sucj `stjo F`n` tlaos oinobbob lk tjo w`aas ge sovoktooktj- `kb oldjtooktj-cokturyGttgi`k igsquos, tjoy sorvob tg obuc`to `kb roilkb Iusalis ge tjo eletj

    plaa`r ge Lsa`i. Lk jls cj`ptor, Iojiot tkc stublos ` jltjortg ukborstublobo`ray-oldjtooktj-coktury gla p`lktlkd ge Iocc` ergi tjo cgaaoctlgk ge _pps`a`_klvorslty lk Swobok. Lt ls uklquo egr lts a`rdo kuinor ge lboktleylkd a`noas ge` wlbo v`rloty ge nulablkds tj`t dlvo lkv`au`nao lksldjts lktg tjo urn`k e`nrlc geoldjtooktj-coktury Iocc`, iucj ge wjlcj ls dgko tgb`y.

    Xladrlis blb kgt roturk jgio gkay wltj sguvoklrs ge tjo J`mm. Lk sovor`a sgclotlos,` plctgrl`a gr toxtu`a roilkbor ge tjolr `ccgipalsjiokt w`s `bbob tg tjo oxtorlgr `kblktorlgr w`aas ge tjolr jgusos noegro tjolr jgiocgilkd ny tjgso wjg j`b st`yob nojlkb.Rls custgi ge bocgr`tlkd tjo pladrlis jguso wltj iur`as ls igst wlboay spro`b lkOdypt, nut `asg gccurs lk gtjor pa`cos sucj `s Alny`, Syrl`, `kb tjo Lsr`oa-X`aostlko

    rodlgk. Lk Odypt, ^oifo Fruf `kb Er`ks Ggrt survoyob tjo iur`as lk tjo B`fja`

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    19/260

    4

    L

    G`sls. Rolr lkvoktgry ge blorokt sldk uklts kb cgip`rlsgk wltj tjo c`todgrlos egukblk gtjor stublos ao`bs tg kow lksldjts cgkcorklkd tjo io`klkd ge tjoso iur`as. Burlkdtjo porlgb cgvorob ny tjolr survoy (088?), Fruf `kb Ggrt gnsorvob kgt`nao

    cj`kdos= `kkgukcoiokts `ro dottlkd lkcro`slkday slipaor `kb igro uklegri, `kbroprosokt tlgks ge jui`k nolkds ro igstay egukb lk tjo gabor iur`as.

    Noslbos w`aa p`lktlkds `s tostligky ge tjo J`mm, pladrli cortlelc`tos `asgeukctlgkob `s prgge ge tjo `ccgipalsjiokt ge Lsa`ilc pladrli`do. @atjgudjtjoy `ro `aro`by fkgwk ergi tjo twoaetj coktury, tjo egcus ge Aultd`rb Igascgktrlnutlgk ls tok a`to-klkotooktj-coktury spoclioks ergi Butcj cgaaoctlgks.jo eldur`tlvo ox`ipaos ng`st `k oxtokslvo plctgrl`a cycao tj`t dgos noygkb tjoscgpo ge tjo rltos ge tjo J`mm. jls r`lsos tjo quostlgk `ngut tjolr uso= woro tjoykgt sgaoay tostligklos ge tjo J`mm, nut `asg sguvoklrs, bovlcos egr lkstructlgk,`kb roilkbors ge tjo e`ltjeua ge tjolr roaldlgus butlos7 jo quostlgk `ngut tjopurpgso ge tjo cortlelc`tos `asg tgucjos upgk `kgtjor lssuo, tjls tlio port`lklkdtg tjo lip`ct ge J`mm poregri`kco gk agc`a sgcl`a roa`tlgks= wj`t w`s tjolr v`auo`s tjo i`torl`a tgfoks ge tjo syingalc c`plt`a d`lkob ny pladrlis upgk roturkjgio7

    @rkgub Urgalmf j`s `pprg`cjob tjo stuby ge J`mm-roa`tob gnmocts ergi qulto` bleeorokt `kdao. jls `aro`by cgios tg tjo egro lk tjo tltao ge jls cj`ptor=@ppo`r`kcos Noalo. @ Iocc`-Coktrob Tgrab I`p `kb ` Skgucf JurdrgkmoXjgtgdr`pj ergi tjo Aolbok _klvorslty Cgaaoctlgks. Urgalmf iotlcuagusaystublob kb cgktoxtu`alsob sovoktooktj-coktury p`lktob i`p wltj Iocc` t lts

    coktro `kb ` a`to-klkotooktj-coktury drgup pgrtr`lt wltj `ctgrs lk grlokt`a brosst`fok `t tjo Butcj cgksua`to lk Mobb`j, rovo`alkd bleeorokt a`yors ge io`klkd`kb lktokt.

    Lk tjo elk`a cj`ptor, Kola v`k bor Alkbok alsts ` soaoctlgk ge sgkds tj`t worosukd tg coaonr`to `kb cgiioigr`to tjo rltu`a ge tjo J`mm. Geeorlkd lksldjtslktg lkt`kdlnao pr`ctlcos roa`tob tg tjo J`mm, tjo bovoagpiokts tj`t gccur lk tjlsiuslc`a pr`ctlco lk tjo twoktlotj coktury `kb elrst boc`bos ge tjo twokty-elrst`asg sorvo tg laaustr`to tjo ovgautlgk `kb `b`pt`tlgk ge J`mm-roa`tob pr`ctlcos lkdokor`a.

    Elk`aay, kgto gk tjo tr`ksaltor`tlgk= To j`vo cjgsok tg foop tjo tr`ksaltor`tlgk

    ge @r`nlc kb _rbu s slipao s pgsslnao lk tjo rukklkd toxt, vglblkd bl`crltlc`ai`rfs `kb `yks `kb j`iz`js, oxcopt lk tjo c`so ge nlnalgdr`pjlc`a roeorokcos.Lk tjo cgktrlnutlgk ge Iojiot tkc, wjoro Gttgi`k aodokbs `ro blscussoblk `k o`ray-oldjtooktj-coktury p`lktlkd ge Iocc` `kb lts surrgukblkds, urflsjspoaalkds `ro `asg usob. B`tos `ro cgiigkay dlvok `s CO b`tos. Tjoro Jlmrlb`tos `ro usob, tjoy `ro egaagwob ny tjo Drodgrl`k b`to lk p`roktjosos (`kb vlcovors`).

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    20/260

    :

    J

    @cfkgwaobdoiokts

    Elrst, gur tj`kfs dg gut tg `aa tjo cgktrlnutgrs ge tjls vgauio `kb tg tjgso wjgprosoktob ` p`por `t tjo syipgslui `kb sj`rob tjolr lbo`s wltj us tjoro. Lkp`rtlcua`r, wo wguab alfo tg tj`kf E`ilao @rsa`k `kb @al Obb`gubl egr sj`rlkdtjolr gwk J`mm oxporlokcos wltj tjo p`rtlclp`kts ge tjo syipgslui `kb a`rdor`ublokco ge iusoui vlsltgrs burlkd ` igst liprosslvo bgunao lktorvlow. Towguab alfo tg tj`kf Klkm` Faolf`ip egr joaplkd tg grd`klso tjo syipgsluigk tjo J`mm `t tjo K`tlgk`a Iusoui ge Otjkgagdy `kb Uokotl` Xgrtor ge tjoNrltlsj Iusoui egr jor stliua`tlkd `bvlco `kb okcgur`doiokt tjrgudjgut tjoprop`r`tlgk ge tjo J`mm oxjlnltlgk `kb tjo syipgslui. To `ro igst dr`toeuatg Agk Nusfoks, tjok-blroctgr ge A_CLS, egr jls `bvlco, okcgur`doiokt, `kblksldjts. j`kfs `s woaa dg tg Xotor Xoas `kb X`trlcl` Spyor ge EOA egr lkvltlkd

    Elkn`rr Eaggb ge Kow \grf _klvorslty tg dlvo tjo cgkcaublkd aocturo `s tjo tjlrba`uro`to egr tjo `kku`a Dornr`kbs aocturo.@s egr tjo punalc`tlgk, wo wguab alfo tg tj`kf Xrgeossgr B`vlb Fj`alal `kb

    K`ja` K`ss`r ge jo Fj`alal Cgaaoctlgk ge Lsa`ilc @rt lk Agkbgk egr dokorgusayprgvlblkd pjgtgdr`pjs ge gnmocts ergi tjolr cgaaoctlgk egr tjls vgauio.To wguab `asg alfo tg tj`kf @rkgub Urgalmf egr sj`rlkd jls v`st fkgwaobdoge tjo grlokt`a cgaaoctlgks ge Aolbok _klvorslty `kb egr jls `bvlco gk urflsjtr`kscrlptlgks. To `ro boopay lkbontob tg gur toxt obltgr Mgyco I`ttjows egr joroxcoaaokt `kb boblc`tob wgrf. Elk`aay, wob alfo tg tj`kf Tgku Uoys, cur`tgr `ttjo K`tlgk`a Iusoui ge Otjkgagdy, wjg ls `asg rospgkslnao egr punalc`tlgks,

    `kb gur cgaao`duos `t Slbostgko Xross egr tjolr joap `kb dulb`kco burlkd tjoprgbuctlgk pj`so.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    21/260

    803= 0846 Xgrtor >80>= >?>>?3). Oltjor wlttlkday gr ukwlttlkday,I`tors lkst`aa`tlgk ls ` pgworeua vlsu`als`tlgk ge tjo cgkcopt ge splrltu`ai`dkotlsi lktrgbucob ny tjo `ktjrgpgagdlst M`ios Xrostgk tg lboktley wj`t jocgkslborob tg no gko ge tjo igst lipgrt`kt cj`r`ctorlstlcs ge pladrli`do sltos(Xrostgk 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    22/260

    08

    J

    wguab `droo tj`t tjo io`klkd ge tjo J`mm c`k no robucob tg coaonr`tlkd tjocgiiuklty ge Iusalis, i`ky prosokt-b`y pladrlis tg Iocc` lkboob ropgrt tj`ttjo pgworeua soks`tlgk ge igvlkd `s gko ngby wltj eoaagw noalovors ergi `aa

    gvor tjo wgrab cro`tos ` strgkd sokso ge uklty wltjlk tjo uii`, gr Iusalicgiiuklty (ce. I`acgai Z 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    23/260

    00

    N

    tjo pj`so ge sop`r`tlgk ge tjo J`mm rltu`a cgkslst ge sottalkd bont `ccgukts `kbblsputos6 noddlkd egrdlvokoss ergi e`ilay `kb erlokbs egr `ky p`lk gr drloe gkoi`y j`vo c`usob6 cgaaoctlkd prosokts, drootlkds, `kb roquosts egr spocl`a pr`yors

    burlkd e`rowoaa p`rtlos6 kb `ttokblkd prop`r`tgry J`mm ca`ssos grd`klsob ny agc`aigsquos gr J`mm-tgur tr`voa `dokclos. Tjlao, lk ` nrg`bor sokso, tjo alilk`apj`so st`rts `s sggk `s tjo pladrlis j`vo nlbbok e`rowoaa tg tjolr agvob gkos`kb `ctu`aay oin`rf gk tjolr mgurkoy, poregrilkd rltu`a purlelc`tlgk rltos `kbcj`kdlkd lktg spocl`a J`mm d`riokts i`rf tjo igst lipgrt`kt tr`ksltlgk tgtjo alilk`a pj`so ge ljr`i, gr rltu`a cgksocr`tlgk. Ao`vlkd tjo st`to ge ljr`i`etor j`vlkd cgkcaubob tjo gnald`tgry rltos tj`t cgiprlso tjo J`mm prgpor i`rfstjo nodlkklkd ge tjo lkcgrpgr`tlgk pj`so. jls pj`so getok cuailk`tos lk `koa`ngr`to jgiocgilkd p`rty egaagwob ny i`ky igro vlslts ergi erlokbs wjgcgio tg cgkdr`tua`to tjo kow j`mmls `kb sj`ro lk tjo s`crobkoss nrgudjt jgiolk tjo egri ge w`tor ergi tjo ]`iz`i woaa lk Iocc` `kb b`tos ergi Ioblk .

    Cgkslborlkd tjo o`so wltj wjlcj tjo trlp`rtlto syingalc structuro ge rltos gep`ss`do c`k no rocgdklsob lk pladrli`dos, lt ls surprlslkd tj`t U`k Dokkop j`rbaylkcaubob pladrli`do lk jls blscusslgk ge rltos ge p`ss`do. \ot, jo blb ioktlgk tjost`to ge ljr`i wltjlk tjo J`mm rltu`a `s `k ox`ipao ge ` tr`ksltlgk`a pj`so (U`kDokkop 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    24/260

    0>

    J

    t`fos coktr`a st`do. Cgiiuklt`s roeors tg lktokso egris ge cgir`bosjlp `kbod`alt`rl`klsi `igkd alilk`a porsgks. urkor kgtob tj`t tjls sj`rlkd `kb tjooqu`alty ge `aa dokor`tos `k okordlslkd pgwor tj`t gpoks up sp`co tg roeaoct upgk

    tjo sgcl`a structuro tj`t cj`r`ctorlsos b`lay aleo `kb tg li`dlko gtjor egris=Alilk`alty, tjo gptli`a sottlkd ge cgiiuklt`s roa`tlgks, `kbcgiiuklt`s, ` spgkt`kogusay dokor`tob roa`tlgksjlp notwookaovoaob VslcY `kb oqu`a tgt`a `kb lkblvlbu`tob jui`k nolkds,strlppob ge structur`a `ttrlnutos, tgdotjor cgkstltuto wj`t gkoildjt c`aa `ktl-structuro. Cgiiuklt`s, jgwovor, ls kgt structurowltj lts sldks rovorsob, ilkusos vorsos pausos, nut r`tjor tjo egksot grldgge `aa structuros `kb, `t tjo s`io tlio, tjolr crltlquo. Egrlts vory oxlstokco puts `aa sgcl`a structur`a ruaos lk quostlgk `kb

    suddosts kow pgsslnlaltlos. (urkor 08>)Nolkd strlppob ge structur`a `ttrlnutos wguab `aagw alilk`a porsgk`o tgoxporlokco gr `t ao`st cgio cagso tg tjo ro`als`tlgk ge wj`t lt ossoktl`aay io`kstg no ` jui`k nolkd. urkor kgtob, jgwovor, tj`t cgiiuklt`s sggk bovoagps `structuro, lk wjlcj eroo roa`tlgksjlps notwook lkblvlbu`as nocgio cgkvortob lktgkgri-dgvorkob roa`tlgksjlps notwook sgcl`a porsgk`o (urkor 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    25/260

    03

    N

    syingalc bo`tj tgw`rbs purlelc`tlgk, ovoktu`aay nocgilkd `s puro `kb lkkgcokt`s ` kowngrk n`ny (ce. pp. 38-30 lk tjls vgauio).

    Ovgc`tlgks ge cgiiuklt`s c`k `asg no rocgdklsob lk J`mm rltos, sucj `s lk tjo

    `egroioktlgkob eagw ge pladrlis clrcui`inua`tlkd tjo F`n`, pjgtgdr`pjs gewjlcj c`k no sook lk i`ky dgvorkiokt `kb nuslkoss geelcos `s woaa `s lk sjgps`kb prlv`to jgios ge Iusalis.@s Dor`sligs I`frls j`s kgtob, tjls lcgklc li`doge wjlto cgkcoktrlc clrcaos ge igvlkd jui`klty roprosokts tjo pro-oxlstlkd `kb,`t tjo s`io tlio, oiordokt uii`, gr dagn`a cgiiuklty ge noalovors (I`frls>884= 034). g laaustr`to tjo k`turo ge cgiiuklt`s, urkor jlisoae qugtobI`acgai Z, wjg cj`r`ctorlsob jls J`mm oxporlokco `s lkvgavlkd agvo, juilalty,`kb truo nrgtjorjggb tj`t w`s `aigst ` pjyslc`a eooalkd wjorovor L turkobwo woro truay `aa tjo s`io VnrgtjorsY (urkor 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    26/260

    02

    J

    `pprg`cj tj`t lkvostld`tos jgw ovoryb`y pgaltlc`a, ocgkgilc, kb sgcl`a cgkcorkslkegri pladrli`dos, O`bo `kb S`aakgw prgpgsob tg stuby pladrli`do `s `k `rok`egr cgipotlkd roaldlgus `kb socua`r blscgursos (O`bo & S`aakgw 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    27/260

    0?

    N

    i`y sgiotlios cgktokb egr lbogagdlc`a jodoigky `t pladrli`do sltos, `t gtjortlios bleeorokt pladrli drgups bg kgt soof cgkergkt`tlgk, cjggslkd lksto`b tgldkgro o`cj gtjor s tjoy poregri tjolr gwk rltos. @asg, ovok wltjlk cgktost`tlgk

    tjoro i`y no lkst`kcos ge cgiiuklt`s, `s wjok bleeorokcos notwook pladrlidrgups `ro gvorruaob wjok igro sorlgus oxtork`a `kt`dgklsi gccurs.

    Igro lipgrt`ktay, `k `pprg`cj ge cgkslborlkd pladrli`do sltos `s oiptyvossoas tj`t `ro bovglb ge lktrlkslc io`klkd tokbs tg ldkgro tj`t cort`lknoj`vlgur`a p`r`aaoas notwook bleeorokt pladrli`do tr`bltlgks c`k no gnsorvob`crgss tlio `kb cuaturo (O`bo >888). @kgtjor gnmoctlgk tg tjo oipty vossoaiot`pjgr ls tj`t lt suddosts tj`t pladrli`do c`k no lktorprotob oxcauslvoay lktoris ge roprosokt`tlgk `kb tjo rolkegrcoiokt ge lbo`s `kb ldkgros tjo oeeocts getjo poregri`tlvo pgwor ge oingblob pladrli`do pr`ctlcos (Cgaoi`k >88>= 3?882). @s tjo suntltao ge tjolr nggf lkblc`tos, tjoy prgpgsob ` kowegcus gk tjo ignlalty lipalob ny pladrli`do. Igro cgkcrotoay, tjoy suddostobtjo stuby ge tjo lktorroa`tlgks notwook pjyslc`a, splrltu`a, iokt`a, `kb sgcl`aigvoiokts ge pladrlis.

    Lk sui, tjoro j`s nook ` sjlet ergi stubylkd tjo lkstltutlgk ge pladrli`do `s` ngukbob c`todgry ge `ctlgk tg `pprg`cjlkd pladrli`do `s `k oktry gr ox`ipao

    tg stuby bleeorokt flkbs ge igvoiokt roa`tob tg v`rlgus `spocts ge tjo sgclg-cuatur`a aleo wgrabs ge tr`voaaors. jls `pprg`cj j`s gpokob up kow `vokuos`kb roso`rcj quostlgks, p`rtlcua`ray cgkcorklkd tjo lip`ct ge dagn`als`tlgk gkpladrli`do (ce. Jorifoks, M`ksok & Kgtori`ks >8880>).Lk alko wltj urkors get-qugtob roi`rf tj`t ` pladrli ls `aw`ys j`ae ` tgurlst(urkor & urkor 08), `k lkcro`sob lktorost lk tjo crgssrg`bs notwookpladrli`do `kb aolsuro tr`voa ls p`rtlcua`ray kgt`nao (ce. N`bgko & ^gsoi`k >8826St`usnord >8006 ligtjy & Gasok >885).

    Rgw`rbs `k @ktjrgpgagdy ge J`mm

    Cgkslborlkd tjo lkcro`sob `c`boilc lktorost lk pladrli`do gk tjo gko j`kb,`kb tjo coktr`alty ge Iocc` lk tjo Lsa`ilc tr`bltlgk `kb lts drgwlkd pgpua`rlty`s ` roaldlgus tr`voa bostlk`tlgk gk tjo gtjor,gko wguab oxpoct tjo J`mm tg nowlboay roprosoktob lk tjo oxp`kblkd ngby ge pladrli`do stublos. jls, jgwovor,ls j`rbay tjo c`so. @k gnvlgus st`rtlkd pglkt egr ` suii`ry gvorvlow ge tjo`ktjrgpgagdy ge tjo J`mm ls tjo nggf Iusali r`voaaors, punalsjob lk 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    28/260

    05

    J

    igst cgktrlnutlgks lk tjo vgauio egcus gk tjo pgaltlc`a `kb ocgkgilc igtlvos`t pa`y lk roaldlgus mgurkoys ge Iusali tr`voaaors. jls egcus `asg cj`r`ctorlsossunsoquokt `rtlcaos gk tjo J`mm, igst ge wjlcj wrlttok ny `ktjrgpgagdlsts wjg

    stublob tjo J`mm `s ` cgipgkokt ge otjkgdr`pjlc roso`rcj `ngut gtjor sunmocts.^`tjor tj`k `k`ayslkd tjo `ctlvltlos tjo pladrlis okd`do lk wjlao lk Iocc`, sucjpunalc`tlgks kocoss`rlay t`fo tjo cgktoxtu`a pprg`cj suddostob ny Cgaoi`k kbO`bo `kb egcus gk tjo oinobbobkoss ge pladrli`do lk tjo ovoryb`y sgcl`a `kbcuatur`a aleo wgrabs ergi wjlcj pladrlis bop`rt `kb tg wjlcj tjoy roturk.

    Tltj ` eow oxcoptlgks, lkcaublkd tjo `egroioktlgkob stublos ge Xklk`Tornkor `kb Elscjor `kb @nobl, lk sucj punalc`tlgks tjo egcus ls kgt sg iucj gktjo poregri`kco `kb roaldlgus io`klkds ge tjo J`mm ltsoae, nut gk tjo lip`ct geJ`mm poregri`kco gk nrg`bor sgclot`a lssuos. `yigkb Scuplktjo gkay utjgrwjgso `rtlcao ioktlgkob joro procobob Iusali r`voaaorspunalsjob `k `rtlcao`ngut tjo sgcl`a sldklelc`kco ge tjo J`mm egr j`l Iusalis (Scuplk 0). Mu`kObu`rbg C`ipg egcusos gk cgktost`tlgks notwook bleeorokt Iusali drgups gvortjo rgao ge tjo J`mm lk tjo egri`tlgk ge igbork Lsa`i lk Odypt (C`ipg 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    29/260

    04

    N

    Tjlao tjo lip`ct ge lboktlty pgaltlcs `kb sliuat`kogus oinobbobkoss lkiuatlpao cuatur`a cgktoxts gk roaldlgslty ls qulto gnvlgusay k lipgrt`kt lssuo egrIusalis alvlkd lk tjo Tost, L wguab `rduo tj`t roaldlgslty, sgcl`a lboktlelc`tlgks,

    `kb soae-lboktlty sjguab no stublob s lktorroa`tob lssuos lk aa J`mm roso`rcj le wowlsj tg ukborst`kb tjo io`klkd ge tjo J`mm egr prosokt-b`y Iusalis. @s S`iualScjloafo j`s cgkvlkclkday `rduob, lk tjo currokt or` ge lktokslelob dagn`als`tlgk,pogpaos oxporlokcos `ro lkegriob ny v`rlgus cuatur`a blscgursos sliuat`kogusay(Scjloafo >88:). Sucj blscgursos sj`po tjo sokslnlaltlos, l.o. tjo igr`a `kb`ostjotlc bliokslgks ge tjo oxporlokcos `kb oigtlgks, lk pogpaos alvos. @asg,wgrabwlbo trokbs ge liprgvob tr`kspgrt`tlgk `kb ocgkgilc clrcuist`kcos tj`tnod`k lk tjo a`to klkotooktj coktury `kb j`vo lkcro`sob lk tjo a`st eow boc`bosj`vo nrgudjt tr`voa wltjlk ro`cj ge ovor igro Iusalis (ce. Doavlk & Drook>802). jls j`s rosuatob lk tjo oiordokco ge kow c`todgrlos ge pladrlis, i`kyge wjgi i`fo ropotltlvo mgurkoys tg Iocc` r`tjor tj`k poregrilkd tjo J`mmmust gkco. @k `cqu`lkt`kco ge ilko lk Slbl Sali`ko, Igrgccg, egr ox`ipao,w`s geeorob ` J`mm p`cf`do tgur ny jls cgip`ky `s ` ngkus egr gutst`kblkdporegri`kco. @asg, `ccgrblkd tg @nbuaf`bor `ygn, Iocc` ls ` pgpua`rjgkoyiggk bostlk`tlgk egr Sgutj @erlc`k Iusali kowaywobs (`ygn, Xorsgk`aCgiiuklc`tlgk, >802). Lk sjgrt, ` cort`lk rgutlkls`tlgk `kb cgiigblelc`tlgkge pladrli`do c`k no gnsorvob.

    ^ocokt trokbs lk J`mm poregri`kco pglkt tg tjo bovoagpiokt ge egris geroaldlgslty lk wjlcj lipalclt lbogagdlos ge lkblvlbu`alsi `kb soae-ro`als`tlgk

    tjrgudj igbork cgksuiorlsi `ro rorgutob tgw`rbs roaldlgus cgksuiptlgkp`ttorks (ce. @zlz >8806 Nultoa``r & S``b >8086 J`okkl >800). Lk tjls rospoct,cgktoipgr`ry pladrli`do tg Iocc` roeaocts nrg`bor trokb ge lkcro`sob roaldlgus`kb jorlt`do tgurlsi (ce. St`usnord >8006 ligtjy & Gasok >885). Sucj trokbs,jgwovor, bg kgt dg ukcgktostob. Cgktost`tlgks getok t`fo tjo egri ge igr`aca`lis cgkcorklkd puro roaldlgk vorsus prge`k`tlgk ge tjo s`crob. Burlkd tjo>803 syipgsluitj`t w`s grd`klsob `t tjo K`tlgk`a Iusoui ge Otjkgagdy lkAolbok lk roa`tlgk tg tjo J`mm oxjlnltlgk, egr ox`ipao, blscusslgk rgso notwookE`ilao @rsa`k, gko ge tjo spo`fors wjg sj`rob jor gwk J`mm oxporlokcos, `kb `porsgk lk tjo `ublokco. jo a`ttor quostlgkob tjo lkcro`slkd pgpua`rlty `igkd

    `bgaoscokt Butcj Iusalis ge Igrgcc`k `kb urflsj boscokt tg poregri tjo_ir` `kb J`mm egr wj`t sjo suspoctob woro wrgkd igtlv`tlgks, o.d. st`tusoaov`tlgk r`tjor tj`k ploty. @rsa`k boeokbob tjo pgsltlgk tj`t gtjors `ro kgtlk ` pgsltlgk tg mubdo tjo roaldlgus lktoktlgks ge pladrlis. @asg, ovok lk c`soswjoro tjo boslro tg dg tg Iocc` ildjt kgt no n`sob oxcauslvoay gk wlsjlkd tgcgipaoto gkos roaldlgk (`s poregrilkd tjls roaldlgus buty ls getok boscrlnob),@rsa`k `ctu`aay okcgur`dos ygukd Butcj Iusalis kgt tg pgstpgko tjo J`mmuktla gab `do. Sjo oxpa`lkob tj`t sjo bgos sg egr twg ro`sgks= elrst ge `aa, tjoJ`mm ls vory boi`kblkd, sg ` dggb pjyslc`a cgkbltlgk joaps ` agt. Socgkbay,@rsa`k oipj`slsob tj`t tjo gvorwjoailkd oxporlokco ge tjo J`mm wlaa joap ygukd

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    30/260

    0:

    J

    Iusalis lk tjo Kotjora`kbs roa`to tg tjolr roaldlgus jorlt`do `kb wlaa lksplrotjoi tg bovoagp ` roaldlgus aleostyao.

    jo vlowpglkts ge ngtj @rsa`k `kb tjo wgi`k lk tjo `ublokco tgucj upgk

    tjo lipgrt`kco ge Iocc` `kb tjo J`mm lk tjo cgkstructlgk ge roaldlgus lboktlty`igkd Iusalis lk tjo Tost. Ospocl`aay slkco 8036 IcDulro >88:6 Scjloafo& Bonovoc >80>). Cgkcrotoay, tjls lipalos `bbrosslkd tjo egaagwlkd quostlgks=

    0) Jgw `ro `splr`tlgks `kb igtlv`tlgks ge Iusalis tg oin`rf upgk pladrli`dogr tg pgstpgko tjo s`crob mgurkoy roa`tob tg gtjor koobs `kb pursults lk tjolrb`lay alvos7

    >) Jgw bg pladrlis cg-prgbuco `kb oxporlokco tjo soks`tlgk`a pgwor ge tjoJ`mm7 Igro spoclelc`aay= Tj`t J`mm-roa`tob pr`ctlcos bg tjoy poregri, `kbjgw bg tjo iokt`a `kb soksgry oxporlokcos `kb eooalkds tjus lkvgfob roeaoctcgkcoptlgks ge roaldlgslty, sgcl`a lboktlelc`tlgks, `kb soae-lboktlty7

    3) Jgw bg pogpao c`todgrlso tjolr gwk J`mm oxporlokcos `kb tjo pr`ctlcos gegtjors lk toris ge s`crob/iukb`ko `kb Lsa`ilc/kgk-Lsa`ilc, `kb jgw bgsucj qu`alelc`tlgks roa`to tg tjo iuatlpao sgcl`a `kb porsgk`a pgsltlgks ergiwjlcj tjoy toaa tjolr stgrlos7

    Ny lktodr`tlkd egcus gk noj`vlgur`a p`r`aaoas tj`t i`y no gnsorvob lk pladrli`dowltj ` egcus gk tjo oinobbobkoss ge pladrli`do lk tjo ovoryb`y sgcl`a wgrab gepladrlis, tjo `ppalc`tlgk ge tjls sot ge tjroo lktorroa`tob, `k`aytlc`a quostlgkscgktrlnutos tg bovoagplkd kow `vokuos tj`t tr`kscokb tjo cgiiuklt`s-vorsus-cgktost`tlgk cgktrgvorsy lk tjo `ktjrgpgagdy ge pladrli`do. jo elrst quostlgk

    rokbors lksldjts lktg tjo w`ys lk wjlcj tjo boslros `kb `inltlgks ge pladrlis

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    31/260

    08

    J

    coaonrltlos (o.d.egrior Xroslbokt Suj`rtg). Egr tjo tjlrb sun-prgmoct, ` roso`rcjorwlaa mglk ` drgup ge pladrlis oin`rflkd gk tjo _ir` tg stuby tjo `ctlvltloslk wjlcj tjoy okd`do lk prop`r`tlgk egr, burlkd, `kb `etor tjo pladrli`do.

    Lksplrob ny IcAgudjalks stuby gk tjo J`mm nuslkoss lk tjo _kltob Flkdbgi, `egurtj sun-prgmoct wlaa stuby tjo grd`kls`tlgk `kb pr`ctlcos ge (st`to-grd`klsob)Lkbgkosl`k tr`voa `dokclos tj`t geeor J`mm `kb _ir` tgur p`cf`dos `s woaa `s tjov`rlgus typos ge cgksuiors tg wjgi tjoy c`tor. @ eletj sunprgmoct wlaa stuby tjojlstgrlc`a rgao ge Lkbgkosl`-n`sob J`bjr`il @r`ns lk tjo grd`kls`tlgk ge tjoJ`mm.

    Lk Cgkcauslgk

    Lk tjo elrst soctlgk ge tjls cj`ptor, L boigkstr`tob tj`t i`ky ge tjo cj`r`ctorlstlcs

    ge ` rlto ge p`ss`do `ro ovlbokcob lk tjo J`mm, sucj `s roeorokcos tg alilk`alty,cgiiuklt`s, `kb tjo tr`ksegri`tlgk tjrgudj syingalc bo`tj `kb ronlrtj nyio`ks ge wjlcj pladrlis `cqulro ` kow sgcl`a `kb roaldlgus pgsltlgk. Jgwovor,tjo gvorvlow ge J`mm stublos prgvlbob lk tjo socgkb soctlgk laaustr`tob tj`t tjoio`klkds `kb structur`a e`ilay rosoina`kcos tj`t tjo J`mm sj`ros wltj gtjorflkbs ge roaldlgus tr`voa c`kkgt no lktorprotob oxcauslvoay lk toris ge lktrlkslcio`klkds ge tjo lkstltutlgk ge pladrli`do. ^`tjor, tjoso stublos laaustr`to tj`tspoclelc lkst`kcos ge J`mm poregri`kcos iust no ukborstggb wltjlk tjolr wlborjlstgrlc`a kb cuatur`a cgktoxts, o`cj ge tjoi tostleylkd tg tjo J`mm s ` cj`kdlkdtr`bltlgk.

    Cgkcrotoay, L j`vo pglktob tg ` drgwlkd trokb ge rgutlkls`tlgk `kbcgiigblelc`tlgk ge tjo J`mm `kb tjo oiordokco ge kow c`todgrlos ge pladrlis`s ` rosuat ge liprgvob tr`kspgrt`tlgk `kb ocgkgilc clrcuist`kcos. X`rtlcua`raylk tjo prosokt or` ge lktokslelob dagn`als`tlgk, tjo aleo wgrabs ge Iusalis `rolkegriob ny v`rlgus cuatur`a blscgursos tj`t `eeoct tjo igr`a `kb `ostjotlcbliokslgks ge tjolr boslros `kb oxporlokcos. joroegro, tjo splrltu`a i`dkotlsige Iocc` c`k t`fo gk bleeorokt io`klkds egr bleeorokt c`todgrlos ge Iusalis `kbovok egr bleeorokt lkblvlbu`a Iusalis burlkd bleeorokt st`dos ge tjolr alvos. @asg,` v`rloty ge cgkcoptlgks ge s`crob `kb iukb`ko `spocts ge tjo J`mm i`y no

    cgkstltutob, naurrob, `kb cgktostob lk cgkcroto pladrli`do pr`ctlcos.Lk grbor tg stuby tjo porsgk`a J`mm oxporlokcos ge prosokt-b`y Iusalis,L prgpgsob lk tjo a`st p`rt ge tjls cj`ptor `k `pprg`cj tg J`mm roso`rcj tj`tlktodr`tos tjo stuby ge roaldlgus styaos, sgcl`a lboktlelc`tlgks, `kb cgkcoptlgksge soae. jo gvor`aa `li ge tjls `pprg`cj ls tg bgcuiokt igbork `rtlcua`tlgksge pladrli`do tg Iocc`. Tltjlk tjo eloab ge Lsa`i stublos, tjls `pprg`cj wlaacgktrlnuto tg tjo prgbuctlgk ge `ktjrgpgagdlc`a lksldjts lktg tjo byk`ilcs geLsa`i `s ` alvlkd tr`bltlgk. jo cgktrlnutlgk tg tjo eloab ge pladrli`do stublosls oqu`aay lipgrt`kt6 noc`uso ge tjo ko`r-uklquo cgipuasgry cj`r`ctor ge tjoJ`mm, tjls `pprg`cj wlaa sjob aldjt gk tjo e`ilay rosoina`kcos `igkd bleeorokt

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    33/260

    >0

    N

    lkst`kcos ge pladrli`do `kb gk tjo p`rtlcua`rltlos ge tjo J`mm `s ` cgro rltu`apr`ctlco lk tjo Lsa`ilc tr`bltlgk.

    Nlnalgdr`pjy

    @zlz, J. (>880), jo mgurkoy= `k gvorvlow ge tgurlsi `kb tr`voa lk tjo @r`nLsa`ilc cgktoxt, lk B. J`rrlsgk (ob.), gurlsi `kb tjo aoss bovoagpob wgrab=Lssuos `kb c`so stublos, 0?0-0?882), Lktorsoctlkd mgurkoys. jo `ktjrgpgagdyge pladrli`do `kb tgurlsi. _rn`k`/Cjlc`dg= _klvorslty ge Laalkgls Xross.

    Nl`kcjl, ^. (>882),Duosts ge Dgb. Xladrli`do `kb pgaltlcs lk tjo Lsa`ilc wgrab.Gxegrb= Gxegrb _klvorslty Xross.

    Nl`kcjl, ^. (egrtjcgilkd lk >802), jo J`mm lk ovoryb`y aleo, lk B. Ngwok, O.O`ray & N. Scjuatjlos (obs.), Ovoryb`y aleo lk tjo Iusali Ilbbao O`st, 30:. 3rbObltlgk. Naggilkdtgk= Lkbl`k` _klvorslty Xross.

    Nultoa``r, I. & K. S``b (>808), ^`i`b`k lk cgktoipgr`ry C`lrg.Cgksuiptlgk lk tjo k`io ge ploty `kb `utjoktlclty, ^ocgkstructlgk.Stubloslk cgktoipgr`ry cuaturo, Spocl`a lssuo gkroaldlgk `kb cuaturo 08 (0). LSSK=0?24-232: jttp=//rocgkstructlgk.osorvor.grd/Lssuos/080/cgktokts080.sjtia

    C`ipg, M. (0), Bg ygu noalovo lk pladrli`do7 Cgiiuklt`s, cgktost`tlgk`kb noygkb,@ktjrgpgagdlc`a jogry>(3)= 3??-35:.

    Cgaoi`k, S. & M. Oaskor (obs.) (0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    34/260

    >>

    J

    Bunlscj, M. (0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    35/260

    >3

    N

    Fokky, O. (>884), Dletlkd Iocc`= Lipgrtlkd splrltu`a c`plt`a tg Tost @erlc`,Ignlaltlos> (3)= 353-3:0.

    I`frls, D.X. (>884), Lsa`i lk tjo Ilbbao O`st. @ alvlkd tr`bltlgk. I`abok, I@=Na`cfwoaa Xunalsjlkd.

    I`acgai Z (088:), Alvob roaldlgk. E`ltj `kb pr`ctlco lk ovoryb`y aleo. Gxegrb=Gxegrb _klvorslty Xross.

    IcAgudjalk, S. (>88-028833->5?. F`r`cjl/Gxegrb= Gxegrb _klvorslty Xross.

    IcAgudjalk, S. (>808), Iusali tr`voaaors= Jgilkd boslro, tjo _ii` `kbNrltlsj-X`flst`kls, lk F. Fkgtt & S. IcAgudjalk (obs.), Bl`spgr`s= Cgkcopts,lboktltlos, lktorsoctlgks, >>3->>803), Grd`klzlkd J`mm-dglkd ergi cgktoipgr`ry Nrlt`lk. @cj`kdlkd lkbustry, pladrli i`rfots `kb tjo pgaltlcs ge rocgdkltlgk, lk U.Xgrtor & Al`k` S`le (obs.), jo J`mm= Cgaaoctob oss`ys, >20->?>. Agkbgk= joNrltlsj Iusoui Xross.

    Iorklssl, E. (0.

    Igas, A. (>803), Uora`kdok k``r Ioff`. Bo j`bm lk jgkborb vggrworpok. Aolbok=^lmfsiusoui Ugafokfukbo.

    Xgrtor, U. (>80>), J`mm. Mgurkoy tg tjo jo`rt ge Lsa`i. Agkbgk= jo NrltlsjIusoui Xross.

    Xrostgk, M. (0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    36/260

    >2

    J

    S`aakgw, I. (0)= 053-0:>.

    S`aakgw, I. (0 (3)= >?0->48.

    Scjloafo, S. & A. Bonovoc (>80>), Lktrgbuctlgk, lk S. Scjloafo & A. Bonovoc(obs.), Grblk`ry alvos `kb dr`kb scjoios. @k `ktjrgpgagdy ge ovoryb`y roaldlgk,0-05. Gxegrb= Nordj`jk.

    Scuplk, ^. (0), jo Sgcl`a sldklelc`kco ge tjo J`mmegr j`l Iusalis, joIusali Tgrab 4>= >?-33.

    St`usnord, I. (>800), ^oaldlgk `kb tgurlsi. Crgssrg`bs, bostlk`tlgks `kbokcguktors. Agkbgk/Kow \grf= ^gutaobdo.

    `ppor, K. (0??. Norfoaoy=_klvorslty ge C`alegrkl` Xross.

    j`yor, M. (08?. Agkbgk= ^gutaobdo.

    ligtjy, B. & B. Gasok (obs.) (>885), gurlsi, roaldlgk `kb splrltu`a mgurkoys.Agkbgk/ Kow \grf= ^gutaobdo.

    urkor, U. (0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    37/260

    >?

    N

    Tornkor, X. (>880), Iurlbs ge tjo s`lkts= Gccup`tlgk`a dulabs `kb roboiptlvosgcl`alty, lk @. S`av`tgro (ob.), Iusali tr`bltlgks `kb igbork tocjklquos gepgwor. \o`rnggf ge tjo sgclgagd y ge Lsa`i3= >5?->:88>), Li`dlkob bl`spgr`s `igkd I`kcjostor Iusalis. S`kt` Eo,

    KI= Scjgga ge @iorlc`k ^oso`rcj Xross.

    Tornkor, X. (>883), Xladrlis ge agvo. jo ktjrgpgagdy ge dagn`a suel cuat. Agkbgk=Jurst.

    Tornkor, ^. (0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    38/260

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    39/260

    >4

    S@C^LELCO, X_^LELC@RLGK@KBDOKBO^LKRJOJ@MM=

    XO^SGKJGGB, IORGK\I\, @KB^LR_@A

    R @KSEG^I@RLGK

    Xklk` Tornkor

    Egr Iusalis tjo J`mm, tjo dagn`a pladrli`do ge Iusalis tg Iocc`, ls tjouatli`to pro-toxt egr `aa gtjor Lsa`ilc pladrli`dos. @s `k `kclokt rltu`a, tjo J`mmls jldjay oa`ngr`to ngtj syingalc`aay `kb cgsigagdlc`aay, borlvlkd lts `utjgrlty

    `kb tr`ksegri`tlvo pgwor ergi s`crob Lsa`ilc toxts `kb tr`bltlgks tj`t j`vonook lktrlc`tob lk rltu`a pr`ctlco. Gtjor pladrli`dos, sucj `s tjgso tg Iusalis`lkts sjrlkos lk Sgutj @sl` (fkgwk `s zly`r`), `ro getok igboaaob gk tjoJ`mm `kb, alfo lt, getok cro`to ro`ais ge `ktl/cguktor-structuro tjrgudj rltu`aigvoiokt. Sgio ge tjo igro `kclokt ge tjoso s`lkts sjrlkos j`vo nocgio tjosltos ge jldjay oa`ngr`to `kku`a rltu`as. jo prosokt cj`ptor elrst cgkslbors tjoJ`mm `s ` rltu`a ge purlelc`tlgk, s`crob oxcj`kdo, `kb dokbor, noegro igvlkd gktg blscuss pladrli`do tg s`lkts sjrlkos, fkgwk ny sgio pladrlis tg tjoso sjrlkos`s ` alttao j`mm.

    Nrg`bay spo`flkd, pladrli`dos dokor`to igvoiokts ge oxgrclsi `kbpurlelc`tlgk, gk tjo gko j`kb, `kb cgkkoctlgks notwook blst`kt pa`cos tjrgudjs`crob oxcj`kdos, gk tjo gtjor (^. Tornkor 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    40/260

    >:

    J

    oxporlokco ge tjo J`mm wjlao roeaoctlkd, `t iy roquost, gk lts sldklelc`kco. X`rtge tjo s`io rltu`a pladrli`do, poregriob gutslbo tjo J`mm igktj, ls fkgwk `s_ir`.

    @ foy pglkt L i`fo lk tjls cj`ptor, usu`aay ldkgrob lk blscusslgks ge tjoJ`mm `kb ge Lsa`i igro dokor`aay, ls tj`t tjo J`mm pladrli`do rltu`a, porj`pstjo igst lipgrt`kt cgiiuk`a rltu`a lk Lsa`i, ls `s iucj egcusob gk ` wgi`k`s gk ` i`k. jls ls surprlslkd le wo `ccopt tjo usu`a storogtypo tj`t Lsa`i ls` p`trl`rcj`a roaldlgk lk wjlcj wgiok j`vo socgkb-ca`ss st`tus (tj`t ls, tjoy`ro rod`rbob `s lkeorlgr tg iok). Lk tjo J`mm, iok lboktley wltj ` wgi`k `kbjor sueeorlkd, must `s wgiok lboktley wltj iok. L wlaa roturk tg tjls tjoioa`tor. Elrst, jgwovor, L w`kt tg cgkslbor tjo tr`ksegri`tlgks lk sunmoctlvlty `kbporsgkjggb tjo J`mm oeeocts.

    jo `ktjrgpgagdlst Ulctgr urkor lktrgbucob tjo kgtlgks ge `ktl-structuro`kb cgiiuklt`s tg pgworeuaay c`pturo `k lipgrt`kt bliokslgk ge tjopladrli`do rltu`a oxporlokco (038). @t tjo s`io tlio, jo dagssob gvortjo e`ct tj`t pladrli`do ls lk ltsoae ` jldjay structurob prgcoss ge iotgkyilc (l.o.sunst`ktlvo) kb kgt must iot`pjgrlc tr`ksegri`tlgk. jo vlow L w`kt tg prgpgsojoro ls tj`t pladrli`do lk dokor`a, lkcaublkd tjo J`mm, ls rltu`a poregri`kco ngtjge `ktl-structuro lk tjo sokso io`kt ny urkortj`t ls, `k gvorturklkd `kbrovors`a ge ovoryb`y aleo `kb ovoryb`y blvlslgks`kb cguktor-structuro. jocguktor-structur`a eo`turos ge pladrli`do roeor tg tjo e`ct tj`t pladrlis oxpocttg ukbordg kgt gkay ` splrltu`a rokow`a, nut ` rokow`a ge porsgkjggb tjrgudj

    cgkt`ct wltj tjo s`crob `kb ` rokow`a ge cgiiuklty tjrgudj tjo no`rlkdge tj`t wjlcj j`s nook lk cgkt`ct wltj tjo s`crob jgio, lktg tjo structurobiukb`ko wgrab. joso tr`ksegri`tlgks ge porsgkjggb `kb jgio getok roqulro` jldjay structurob `kb oa`ngr`to sorlos ge syingalc `cts. Sgio ge tjoso `cts i`yno lk tjo egri ge tr`ks`ctlgks wltj rltu`aay bosldk`tob porsgks6 gtjors cgkslst geclrcui`inua`tlkd, rukklkd, tjrgwlkd stgkos, tgucjlkd, saooplkd lk tjo gpok `lr,`kb sg egrtj.

    Sook `s s`crob mgurkoys, tjo rltu`a cguktor-structuro ge tjo J`mm `kb _ir`cycao ge rltos `cjlovo tjo boslrob syingalc tr`ksegri`tlgk lk tjo porsgk getjo pladrli tjrgudj ` sorlos ge sldklelc`kt `atork`tlgks `kb rovors`as lk tlio.

    jo igvo ls ergi tjo prosokt tg tjo p`st. St`rtlkd ergi Ilk`, tjo pa`co ge@nr`j`ilc s`crlelco, gk tjo oldjtj b`y ge tjo igktj ge J`mm, tjo pladrlis `roigvob n`cf lk tlio gk tjo klktj b`y `t tjo v`aaoy ge @r`e`t, wjlcj syingalsosngtj tjo nodlkklkd `kb okb ge tlio. jus L w`s tgab ny ` Suff P`blrl vlcodorokt,gr fj`ale`, lk I`kcjostor= To noalovo tj`t wjok @b`i `kb J`v VOvoY woro soktbgwk tg o`rtj tjoy iot tgdotjor ko`r tjo F`n` `t tjo Igukt`lk ge Iorcy `t@r`e`t. @kgtjor roturklkd pladrli tjgudjt tj`t @b`i `kb Ovo worokt sokt bgwktgdotjor. @b`i w`s sokt tg @r`e`t6 Ovo w`s sokt tg `kgtjor pa`co. Sg tjoy iot `t@r`e`t. jls w`s tjo pa`co wjoro @b`i `sfob egr egrdlvokoss `etor jo w`s toiptobny tjo bovla `kb `to ergi tjo egrnlbbok erult lk X`r`blso.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    41/260

    >jls rltu`a, `asg poregriob gk lts gwktjrgudjgut tjo yo`r wjok lt ls fkgwk `s _ir`, jldjaldjts tjo tlio rovors`a ge tjok`rr`tlvo ovok igro cao`ray. jo igvoiokt burlkd _ir` nodlks wltj t`w`e, tjoclrcui`inua`tlgk ge tjo jguso ge Dgb, wjlcj ls noalovob tg j`vo nook ronulatny @nr`j`i `kb Lsji`oa `etor tjolr ro-uklelc`tlgk. Lk tjo socgkb pj`so, tjopladrli igvos tg tjo s`crob sprlkd, tjo ]`iz`i, wjlcj J`d`r blscgvorob j`bsprukd ergi tjo jooa ge Lsji`oa `s jo a`y w`lalkd lk tjo s`kb wjok igtjor kb sgkworo n`klsjob lktg tjo bosort ny @nr`j`i. Joro tjo pladrlis w`sj `kb brlkf tjow`tor. jo elk`a st`do ge tjo _ir` ls s`l, tjo rukklkd n`cf `kb egrtj notwook tjotwg jlaas ge S`e` `kb I`rw`, wjlcj roc`aas J`d`rs `dgklsob rukklkd lk so`rcjge w`tor egr jor n`ny ngy etor tjo n`klsjiokt. jo igvoiokt ls tjus n`cfw`rbs,ergi bo`tj tgw`rbs purlelc`tlgk alfo ` n`ny.

    J`vlkd cgipaotob tjo Iocc`k oplsgbo, i`ky ge tjo pladrlis roturk gkcoigro tg Ilk` gk b`y tok egr ` elk`a stgklkdtjls tlio ge `aa tjroo bovlas gkb`ys oaovok `kb twoavo (`kb sgiotlios ovok gk tjo tjlrtooktj b`y) ge tjo J`mm-igktj. @atgdotjor lk tjo pgst-Iocc`k stgklkd, tjo pladrlis c`st 2> ponnaos,egurtook gk o`cj ge tjo plaa`rs gvor twg b`ys. jo pladrlis st`rt ergi tjo plaa`re`rtjost ergi Iocc` `kb okb wltj tjo @q`n` plaa`r, wjlcj ls tjo ko`rost. Lk tjogrldlk`a k`rr`tlvo, @nr`j`i (sgio s`y Lsji`oa) okcguktorob tjoso tjroo bovlas

    noegro tjo nlkblkd ge Lsji`oa. Burlkd J`mm `kb _ir`, tjo iuatlpao stgklkdsge tjo bovlas (oxcopt egr tjo elrst stgklkd) gccur `etortjo s`crlelco, rovorslkd tjogrldlk`a k`rr`tlvo. Elk`aay, tjo pladrlis roturk tg Iocc` egr `kgtjor ro-ok`ctioktge tjo Iocc`k rltu a. jo J`mm tjus a`sts tjroo paus tjroo b`ys `kb ls nulat gk `k`atork`tlgk notwook tjo _ir` rltu`a `t Iocc` `kb tjo J`mm s`crlelco `t Ilk`,o`cj ge wjlcj ls ropo`tob twlco (J`mm/_ir`/J`mm/_ir` 9 Ilk`/Iocc`/Ilk`/Iocc`). @r`e`t ls tjo pa`co ge oxpgsuro tg tjo suk `kb lktokso jo`t. Iuzb`ale`,wjlcj egaagws, ls oxpgsuro tg cgipaoto b`rfkoss `kb kldjt. @r`e`t ls s`lb tg notjo jgalost slto, kb pogpao noalovo tj`t wj`tovor pr`yor ls s`lb tjoro wlaa no ccoptob6`ky slk wlaa no egrdlvok. Roy cry tg `sf egr egrdlvokosstg purley tjoisoavos.

    jo J`mm ls tjus ` igr`a `aaodgry tj`t iust no ukborstggb lk roa`tlgk tg ltss`crob pro-toxts, wjlcj `ro tjo nlkblkd ge Lsji`oa `kb tjo n`klsjiokt geJ`d`r. jo soquokco ge `cts, igrogvor, nrlkds `ngut ` sorlos ge lboktlelc`tlgkswltj oxoipa`ry porsgks. jo foy lboktlelc`tlgks oalcltob `ro wltj @nr`j`i `kbtjo grbo`a jo e`cob lk j`vlkd tg s`crlelco jls sgk, `kb wltj jls wleo J`d`r `kb tjogrbo`a sjo e`cob lk w`kborlkd wltj jor sgk lk tjo bosort wltj kg w`tor tg quokcjjls tjlrst. jo iytjlc k`rr`tlvos ge tjoso twg oxoipa`ry porsgks `ro structur`aaylboktlc`a. Lk ngtj, p`rokt ls sfob tg s`crlelco jls gr jor cjlab egr tjo s`fo ge Dgb

    > Egr ` stop-ny-stop prosokt`tlgk ge tjo rltos ge J`mm `kb _ir` blscussob lk tjls cj`ptor, soo jttp=//www.j`mmuir`jdulbo.cgi/j`mmWstopnystop.jtia.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    44/260

    3>

    J

    wltjgut agslkd e`ltj lk Dgb. Lk ngtj, Dgb lktorvokos ilr`cuagusay `t tjo elk`aigiokt tg s`vo tjo cjlab ergi cort`lk bo`tj. jo pladrlis ro-ok`ct tjls bu`agrbo`a burlkd tjo J`mm `kb _ir`.

    Lsa`ilc tr`bltlgks stross tjo vgaukt`ry k`turo ge tjoso grbo`as= Lsji`oa fkowlk `bv`kco, pladrlis tgab io, tj`t Dgb j`b grborob @nr`j`i tg s`crlelco jli`kb gnoy Jls wlaa. J`d`r, tgg, `ccoptob tjo oblct ge Dgb. Jokco gko pladrlioxpa`lkob=

    Ilk` ls wjoro Lnr`jli s`crlelcob Lsi`la. jo plaa`rs `ro tjo pa`coswjoro tjo bovla trlob tg stgp jli. jo elrst bovla w`s si`aa, tjosocgkb ioblui, `kb tjo tjlrb a`rdo. Lsi`la s`lb tg Lnr`jli= loiy aods `kb put iy e`co `w y Vergi yguY sg tj`t tjo `eeoctlgk Vygueooa egr ioY wgkt stgp ygu Vergi euaelaalkd Dgbs wlaaY.

    Sjo oxpa`lkob `ngut @nr`j`is grbo`as= Tjgiovor @aa`j alfos igst, jo tostsigro tj`k gtjors. Jokco J`d`r w`s sokt lktg tjo bosort lk grbor tj`t w`tor cguabno egukb `kb tjo F n` ronulat.

    jo lboktle lc`tlgk wltj wgi`k ls sldklelc`kt. @ wgi`k pladrli wjg j`b mustroturkob ergi J`mm oxpa`lkob tg io tj`t tjo stgry ge Lsji`oa `kb J`d`r w`s vorylipgrt`kt tg jor `s ` wgi`k. Tjok sjo w`s tjoro `kb poregrilkd s`l, sjo s`lb,sjo roeaoctob gk wj`t `k oeegrt J`d`r `s ` igtjor j`b i`bo egr jor sgk. Must`s `aa tjo pladrlis, ngtj i`ao `kb eoi`ao, lboktley wltj @nr`j`i, ` i`ao, sg tggtjoy `aa lboktley wltj J`d`r, ` eoi`ao.

    jo J`mm pladrli`do cro`tos `kgtjor foy lboktlelc`tlgk. Xladrlis lkv`rl`nayoxpa`lk tj`t tjoy poregri tjo J`mm lk tjls p`rtlcua`r grbor noc`uso tjls ls tjo w`ytjo Xrgpjot poregriob lttjoy `ro ioroay rotr`clkd jls eggtstops. Tjok tjoyvlslt @r`e`t, gko pladrli tgab io, tjoy st`kb wjoro @b`i stggb gk tjo Igukt geIorcy (M`n`a ^`ji`) tg `sf Dgb egr egrdlvokoss.

    Lk @r`e`t @b`i `sfob lk tjo k`io ge tjo f`ali` Vjoro ls kg dgb nutDgbY egr egrdlvokoss, sg wo dg tjoro tg `sf Dgbs egrdlvokoss egr gur slks. joJ`mm noagkds tg tjo Xrgpjot Lnr`jli, `s bgos tjo Olb `a-@bj`. joro `ro twgsukk` Vruaos ge noj`vlgur n`sob gk tjo ox`ipao ge tjo Xrgpjots aleo `s dlvok lktjo J`bltjY, Lnr`jlis `kb Iuj`ii`bs. Lt igvos ergi @b`i tg Lnr`jli. jo

    Xrgpjot blb tjo s`io Vwjok jo poregriob tjo elrst J`mmY.@atjgudj tjo tr`ksegri`tlgk oeeoctob lk pladrlis ls eukb`iokt`aay ` splrltu`agko, pladrlis roturk ergi J`mm no`rlkd wltj tjoi s`crob tgfoksngttaos gew`tor ergi tjo jgay ]`iz`i sprlkd `s woaa `s b`tos, rgs`rlos, `kb sj`was. joysprlkfao tjo w`tor gk pogpao n`cf jgio, spro`blkd tjo naosslkds tjoy rocolvob. 3Gko wgi`k pladrli tgab io=

    Tjok J`zr`t I`rl`i Vtjo igtjor ge MosusY j`b a`ngur p`lks sjocagsob tjo p`ai ge jor j`kb, `kb tjo p`ttorks woro liprlktob gktjo drgukb. joro ls ` pa`kt c`aaob J`kb ge I`ry wjlcj L nrgudjt

    3 Egr ` blscusslgk ge slila`r iotgkyilc tr`kseor lk urfoy, soo Boa`koy 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    45/260

    33

    T

    n`cf ergi Iocc`. \gu put lt lktg w`tor t boalvory Vge ` cjlabY `kb ltgpoks up, `kb ygu dlvo tjo w`tor tg wgiok tg brlkf. Lt joaps wltja`ngur p`lks. @t _ir`ygu cut tjo j`lr, lts ` sukk`, alfo wjok ygu

    sj`vo tjo j`lr ge kowngrk n`ny. To dlvo tjo woldjt w y lk slavor grdgab s s`b`q` V`ais dlvok tg `vort ilsegrtukoY.

    jo i`flkd ge qurn`k s`crlelcoburlkd tjo J`mm ls tjus ` igiokt lk ` soquokcoge structur`a tr`ksegri`tlgks tj`t prgpoas tjo igvoiokt ge pladrlis gk J`mmtgw`rbs naossob lkkgcokco, ` st`to oingblob lk tjo s`crob w`tor `kb b`tos tjoyc`rry jgio wltj tjoi.

    S`crlelco ls ` foy igiokt ge tr`ksltlgk lk tjls prgcoss. Lk s`lkts agbdos `kbsjrlkos lk Sgutj @sl`, tjls igiokt ls oxp`kbob `kb i`dklelob tg nocgio tjocoktr`a trgpo ge tjo agbdo, nlkblkd tgdotjor tjo igr`a lbo`s ge iystlc`a Suelsi

    wltj tjo grd`kls`tlgk`a `dokb`s ge tjo agbdos `s coktros ge e`r-eaukd rodlgk`acuats. S`crlelco lk Lsa`i `s poregriob burlkd tjo J`mm ls ` igiokt ge grbo`a kbroao`so, lk wjlcj porsgks e`ltj lk Dgb ls tostob. Gko ge tjo foy eo`turos ge tjo Olb`a-@bj` s`crlelco gk tjo J`mm ls tj`t ngtj tjo s`crlelcl`a sa`udjtor kb tjo pr`yors`ccgip`kylkd lt `ro noalovob tg no iuatlpalob ` tjgus`kb tlios. Lk oxpa`lklkd tjoJ`mm, Sj`rle @ji`b, ` blstlkdulsjob Nrltlsj `ali (i`k ao`rkob lk Lsa`ilc a`w`kb sclokcos) lk tjo Bogn`kbl, roegrilst tr`bltlgk tgab jls cgkdrod`tlgk=

    Tjok gko porsgk `sfs naosslkds `agko ergi jls Dgb, jo sj`aa dottjo naosslkd. Nut le i`ky pogpao `sf egr naosslkd `aa tgdotjor, tjoywlaa dot i`klegab naosslkds. jo nlddor tjo cgkdrod`tlgk ls wjoktjoy `sf egr naosslkds, tjo igro naosslkds @aa`j wlaa dlvo tjoi, `kblk tjo wjgao wgrab tjoro ls kg d`tjorlkd ge jui`k nolkds `sflkdegr @aa`js naosslkds `s a`rdo `s tj`t ge tjo J`mm. @kb tjls d`tjorlkdgkay t`fos pa`co gk tjo Igukt ge ^`ji`t `kb lk @r`e`t, kgwjorooaso. @kb gk tjo b`y ge J`mm, ilaalgks `kb ilaalgks ge pogpao, gktjo s`io b`y `kb wltj tjo s`io lktoktlgk, c`aa gut tg tjolr Dgb.Sg tjo naosslkds ge Dgb cgio rukklkd tgw`rbs tjoi. jls st`to,tjls `tigspjoro, `kb tjls sltu`tlgk c`kkgt no egukb gk `ky gtjorb`y, `ky gtjor tlio, gr `ky gtjor sltu`tlgk. jo tlio ge J`mm ls tjo

    tlio ge naosslkd. Gk tj`t b`y, le ` porsgk `sfs egr naosslkd wltj `truo jo`rt, jo wlaa dot ` rlvor ge naosslkds `kb wlaa no purlelob. Sucj` porsgk wlaa eooa sg puro, `s tjgudj jo w`s must ngrk ergi jlsigtjors noaay.

    Tj`t ls strossob joro ls iobl`tlgk wltj Dgb kgt ny ` slkdao i`k, nut ny tjocgiiuklty ge noalovors ukltob lk tjolr lktoktlgk`alty kb egcusob gk @aa`j. Tjlaoegr Suels tjo iobl`tlgk ge tjo Xrgpjot `kb ge s`lkts gk tjo b`y ge mubdoiokt ls` cgrkorstgko ge tjolr noaloe, tjls iobl`tlgk ls ltsoae iobl`tob ny tjo `nlalty getjoso s`lkts tg ignlalso tjo iuatltubo lk ` sj`rob grbo`a. Alfo tjo s`crlelco, `kb

    alfo J d`rs grbo a lk tjo bosort, tjo b`y lk tjo v`aaoy ge @r`e`toxpgsob tg tjo jo`tge tjo sukls rod`rbob `s ` tost ge e`ltj.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    46/260

    32

    J

    Rjo Alttao J`mm= ^ltu`a Xladrli`do tg S`lkts Rgins

    joro ls ` pgpua`r noaloe `igkd Iusalis lk Sgutj @sl` tj`t sovok pladrli`dostg @mior (tjo sjrlko ge Iglkubblk Cjlsjtl lk Lkbl`) ro oqu`a tg poregrilkd tjoJ`mm (Iglkl 04-0>:)

    Igro dokor`aay, Orkst ropgrts tj`t alfo tjo j`mm, zly`r`t c`aas egrclrcui`inua`tlgk lk tjls c`so ge tjo tgin r`tjor tj`k tjo F`n`. Sgiooktjusl`stlc pladrlis `ctu`aay egukb zly`r`t tg no suporlgr tg tjo J`mm (00?) elrst kgtos tj`t t`w`e ls ` foy rltu`a ge tjo

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    47/260

    3?

    T

    pladrli`do tg tjo jgay clty ge Iocc`, poregriob ny i`flkd sovok rgukbs `rgukbtjo F`n`, `kb tjok `bbs tj`t lk tjo b`rdj (sjrlkos)ge tjo Suncgktlkokt, t`w`ec`io tg no ` wlbospro`b pr`ctlco igkd pladrlis, prgigtlkd tjo vlow `ccgrblkd

    tg wjlcj tjo s`lkt lboktlelob iot`pjgrlc`aay wltj tjo F`n`, `s syingalc coktroge tjo uklvorso (>88:= >0?). Jgwovor, jo `bbs lk ` eggtkgto tj`t, wjlao lktjo @r`n wgrab tjo t`w`els poregriob `ktlcagcfwlso, lk Sgutj @sl` lt ls i`bocagcfwlso (lnlb.= >0?->05).

    Ovok noygkb Sgutj @sl`, lk uklsl` `kb Ngskl` egr ox`ipao, wjoro egr i`kyIusalis tjo J`mm ls `k lipgsslnao bro`i, agc`a pladrli`do tg ` s`lkts tginsorvos `s ` sunstltuto (Nrgcfi`k >800= >54). Ge tjo F`rlcl sjrlko lk tjoCoktr`a Ngskl`k jldja`kbs= Jokld ropgrts tj`t jo w`s tgab lk tjo p`st pogpaos`lb, F`rlcl, tjls ls gur alttao j`mm (>80>= 4?:).

    ^ltu`a oa`ngr`tlgk `t s`lkts sjrlkos burlkd tjo `kku`a urs eostlv`a tj`tcgiioigr`tos tjo s`lkts bo`tj `kb uklelc`tlgk wltj Dgb v`rlos. Sjrlkos gedro`t `ktlqulty getok j`vo jldjay oa`ngr`to rltu`as. Egr ox`ipao, `t K`dgro-o-Sj`rle, tjo ursa`sts sovor`a woofs. jo bovgut, cgkvordlkd lk prgcosslgks ergibleeorokt koldjngurjggbs, igvo n`cf `kb egrtj tg tjo agbdo gvor `k oxtokbobporlgb. joy c`rry wltj tjoi laauilk`tob cj`rlgts, ea`ds, `kb s`crob igboasge sjlps `kb ng`ts, eagwor-nobocfob p`a`kqulks, `kb igboa elsj, cgiiuk`aay`kb lkblvlbu`aay gwkob, tg no rovlt`alsob `t tjo agbdo (S`jon 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    48/260

    35

    J

    iua`q`t, boaod`tlgks ge pladrlis ergi ` p`rtlcua`r pa`co ioot wltj tjo Sj`lfjtg t`fo n`l` (vgw ge `aaodl`kco), rocolvo t`wlz (`k `iuaot) gr slipay n`sf lk jlsaldjt. jls ls wjok jo dlvos jls spocl`a blsclpaos gr fj`ale`sdlets ge c`ps, sc`rvos,

    gr dgwks, tjo a`ttor wgrk ny jli gvor tjo yo`r `kb linuob wltj jls cj`rlsi`.Alfo ` tjro`b rukklkd tjrgudj tjo wjgao urs, ergi tjo igiokt pladrlis ao`votjolr jgio, ls tjo eletj foy rltu`a `ct= bjlfr (roioinr`kco ge @aa`j), rocltobtjrgudjgut tjo tjroo kldjts ge tjo urs. @agkd wltj bjlfr `ro k`ts, wjlcj `ropr`lso pgois tg tjo Xrgpjot. Slxtj ls sj`m`r`, tjo rocltlkd ge tjo s`crob doko`agdyge tjo grbor. jls ls ro`b gut lk tjo elk`a sosslgk ge urs `etor `aa tjo fj`ale`s,brossob lk na`cf gk wjlto, pprg`cj tjo st`do agkd wltj tjoplrjlisoae. Sovoktjls t`qrlr, tjo oxodotlc spoocj ny ` ao`rkob scjga`r. Elk`aay, wo ro`cj tjo bu`.

    Lk bleeorokt soksos `aa tjoso rltu`a `cts `ro w`ys ge ro`cjlkd gut i`torl`aaytg tjo s`lkts dr`co. L uso tjo wgrb dr`co joro boalnor`toay noc`uso tgg iucjwoldjt j`s nook put ny scjga`rs ge Suelsi, lkcaublkd `ktjrgpgagdlsts, gk n`rf`t(_rbu egr n`r`f` lk @r`nlc), gr naosslkd, `s tjgudj tjls gko tori cguab suiup tjo cgipaox lbo`s `ngut cj`rlsi` `kb naosslkd joab ny Suel egaagwors. Lkro`alty, tjoro ls ` wjgao aoxlcgk ge toris roeorrlkd tg suntao bleeorokcos lk igbosge s`lktay naosslkd. joso toris tgdotjor egri ` syingalc cgipaox ge naosslkd. josuntao v`rl`tlgks notwook tjo toris `ro lipgrt`kt, noc`uso tjoy prgvlbo lksldjtlktg tjo w`y Suel cgsigagdy ls oingblob `kb oinobbob lk igro usu`a w`ys geLsa`ilc rltu`a naosslkd.

    Xorj`ps tjo igst coktr`a Suel tori egr s`lktay naosslkd, `t ao`st lk Sgutj

    @sl`, ls kgt n`rf`t nut e`lz (Xorsl`k, e lb` lk @r`nlc), ` wgrb wjlcj L j`votr`ksa`tob `s blvlko dr`co `kb tj`t egaagwors uso tg roeor tg tjo blvlko aldjteagwlkd tjrgudj tjo s`lkt `kb ergi jli tg jls blsclpaos. Lt ls ` aldjt tj`t ngtjlaauilk`tos `kb eoobs gr kurturos. Lt ro`cjos lktg tjo jo`rts ge iok `kb wgiokovok gvor dro`t blst`kcos, wjokovor tjoy pr`y ` proscrlnob alturdy gr ovgfo tjoli`do ge tjo s`lkt lk ergkt ge tjolr lkkor oyo. jo s`lkt altor`aay dagws wltje`lz.Jo c`k prgmoct lt `t wlaa, tr`kseorrlkd lt `t ` da`kco tg ` trustob fj`ale`. Lt sjlkoswltj jls iuklelcokco `kb nokoelcokco, `k lkkor qu`alty tj`t jls `ppo`r`kco `kbe`cl`a oxprosslgk rovo`a.

    Lk otjlc`a toris, tjok, e`lz ls tjo aldjt ge dokorgslty, flkbkoss, `kb cgkcork

    oi`k`tlkd ergi tjo s`lkt `kb cgiiuklc`tob tg jls egaagwors. jrgudj e`lz, `plrcro`tos tjo tlo, r`nt`, nlkblkd jli tg jls egaagwors. E`lzls tjo oingbliokt gejls splrltu`a pgwor, ruj`kly`t, `kgtjor foy tori tj`t ls usob tg oxpross tjo plrssplrltu`alty s pgworeua egrco. N`rf`tls tjo tjlrb tori lk tjls syingalc cgipaox.Lk Lsa`i, n`rf`ti`y cgio blroctay ergi Dgb wltjgut tjo lktorcosslgk ge `plr.Lt i`y no iobl`tob ny tjo cgiiuklty gr tjo pggr. Tjok pogpao jgab ` s`crlelcogr dlvo p`rt ge `k geeorlkd tg tjo pggr, tjoy rod`rb tjo cgiioks`a eggb egaagwlkdtjolr pr`yors `s linuob wltj n`rf`t. Lk tjls sokso, lt ls ` dokor`a Lsa`ilc tori egrblvlko naosslkd. N`rf`tlinuos gnmocts, sucj `s tjo s`at dlvok gut ny tjo plr, grtjo a`kd`r, wltj tjo pgwor ge prgcro`tlgk, prgaleor`tlgk, eocukblty, oxp`kslgk,

    aleo, eortlalty, `kb drgwtj (ge cjlabrok, crgps, wo`atj, mgn prgspocts, jo`atj, `kb

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    49/260

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    50/260

    3:

    J

    lk Sgutj @sl` `s ` sunstltuto6 tjoy oxpalcltay roeor tg tjo J`mm lk rltu`a `cts geiliosls `t Suel sjrlkos gr lk iytjlc`a k`rr`tlvos ge ilr`cuagus tr`voa tg Iocc`.Tjoro tjo J`mm bleeors ergi tjo aossor pladrli`do tg Suel s`lkts sjrlkos ls lk

    lts uklquo `li tg `cjlovo lkblvlbu`a, sunmoctlvo purlelc`tlgk ergi slk `s pladrlis`ro igvob rltu`aay n`cfw`rbs lk iytjlc tlio tg ` igiokt ge lkkgcokt purlty.

    Cgkcauslgk

    To roturk tjok tg tjo J`mm. Egr Iusalis tjo J`mm, igro tj`k `ky gtjor Lsa`ilcrltu`a, ls tjo uatli`to `rcjotypo egr `aa s`crob oxcj`kdos burlkd pladrli`do. Lktoaalkd io ge tjolr mgurkoy lk ilkuto bot`la, roturkoos ergi tjo J`mm roalvob tjooxporlokco ge tjo pladrli`do wjlao roeaoctlkd, `t iy roquost, gk lts sldklelc`kco.jo J`mm, L j`vo `rduob, rltu`aay ro-ok`cts ` igr`a `aaodgry tj`t iust no

    ukborstggb lk roa`tlgk tg lts s`crob protoxts, wjlcj `ro tjo nlkblkd ge Lsji`oa`kb tjo n`klsjiokt ge J`d`r. jo foy lboktlelc`tlgks oalcltob `ro dokborob `kboqulv aokt= tj`t ge @nr`j`i `kb tjo grbo`a jo e`cob lk j`vlkd tg s`crle lco jls sgk,`kb tj`t ge jls wleo J`d`r` `kb tjo grbo`a sjo e`cob lk w`kborlkd wltj jor sgk lktjo bosort wltj kg w`tor tg quokcj jls tjlrst. jo iytjlc k`rr`tlvos ge tjoso twgoxoipa`ry porsgks, wgi`k `kb i`k, `ro structur`aay lboktlc`a. Lk ngtj, ` p`roktls `sfob tg s`crlelco jls gr jor cjlab egr tjo s`fo ge Dgb wltjgut agslkd e`ltj lkDgb. Lk ngtj, Dgb ilr`cuagusay lktorvokos `t tjo elk`a igiokt tg s`vo tjocjlab ergi cort`lk bo`tj. jo pladrlis ro-ok`ct tjls bu`a grbo`a burlkd tjo J`mm`kb _ir`. Sook `s ` s`crob mgurkoy, tjo cguktor-structuro ge tjo J`mm rltu`a`cjlovos, L j`vo `rduob joro, tjo boslrob syingalc tr`ksegri`tlgk lk tjo porsgkge tjo pladrli tjrgudj ` sorlos ge sldklelc`kt `atork`tlgks `kb rovors`as lk tlio.jls rovors`a ge tjo grldlk`a tlio soquokco ge tjo s`crob Pur`klc (`kb nlnalc`a)k`rr`tlvos ls p`rt ge tjo prgcoss tjrgudj wjlcj tjo pladrli dr`bu`aay sjobs jor grjls slks ny igvlkd n cfw`rbs lk tlio `kb nocgios `s puro `kb lkkgcokt (i`sui)`s ` kowngrk lke`kt.

    Nlnalgdr`pjy

    Nrgcfi`k, K. (>800), Okcycagpobl` ge S`crob Xa`cos, >kb

    obltlgk. S`kt` N`rn`r`C@= @NC-CALG aac.

    Boa`koy, C. (0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    51/260

    3), jls ls gur alttao j`mm= Iusali jgay sltos kb ro`pprgprl`tlgkge tjo s`crob a`kbsc`po lk cgktoipgr`ry Ngskl`, @iorlc`k Otjkgagdlst 3

    J

    >8856 ce. I`acgai Z 08888803).

    g b`to stublos ge pladrli`do j`vo kgt nook vory iucj cgkcorkob wltj tjoJ`mm gr Lsa`i por so. O`ray roaov`kt wgrf `crgss `ktjrgpgagdy `kb tjo stubyge roaldlgks egcusob upgk tjo lkjorokt bovgtlgk`a i`dkotlsi ge s`crob pa`co(Oal`bo 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    55/260

    23

    IA

    blscusslgk ge wj`t pladrlis bg lk tjo Jgay Xa`cos wltjlk ` wlbor otjkgdr`pjlcvlow ge tjolr wjgao mgurkoy, lkcaublkd ngtj roaldlgusay lksplrob `kb ovoryb`yoxporlokcos noegro bop`rturo ergi, `kb egaagwlkd roturk tg, tjo sokblkd sgcloty

    ge tjo _F. _atli`toay, L suddost tj`t Iusali roaldlgklkd iust no cj`rtob `crgssc`rtgdr`pjlos ge noaloe, pr`ctlco, `kb lboktlty tj`t `ro agc`a, iuatl-agc`a, `kbsupr`-agc`a (woob 08086 >803`). j`t ls, tjoyi`p `k oingblob `kb poregriob cgksclguskoss ge, `kb `tt`cjiokt tg, pa`cos,pogpao `kb nolkds `t sc`aos tj`t `ro ngtj jgrlzgkt`a `kb torrltgrl`a `kb vortlc`a`kb tr`kscokbokt.

    jo sot ge b`t` L oxpagro joro w`s cgaaoctob ny Nrltlsj Iusoui st`ee `s `cgktrlnutlgk tg lts wlbor punalc okd`doiokt surrgukblkd tjo vory succosseua>80> oxjlnltlgk J`mm= Mgurkoy tg tjo Jo`rt ge Lsa`i.>g c`pturo Nrltlsj Iusalisvlbog tostligklos cgkcorklkd tjolr oxporlokcos ge tjo J`mm, `sslst`kt cur`tgrP`lsr` Fj`k `kb gtjor ioinors ge tjo to`i sot gee ergi Agkbgk burlkd ` agkdsuiior woofokb lk >800 egr tjo Alvlkd Lsa`i eostlv`a. Joab `t AlkcgaksjlroSjgwdrgukb lk tjo Okdalsj O`st Ilba`kbs, Alvlkd Lsa`i ls ` judo ukbort`flkdegr tjo Lsa`ilc Sgcloty ge Nrlt`lk,3 `kb sg tjo ovokt ls grd`klsob gkay gkcoovory eow yo`rs. Tltj `rgukb ?,888 Nrltlsj Iusalis `ttokblkd gvor egur b`yslk ` roa`xob, jgalb`y `tigspjoro egaagwlkd tjo e`st ge ^`i`b`k, tjo ovoktroprosoktob `k oxcoaaokt gppgrtuklty tg lkvlto lktorostob vlsltgrs tg rocgrb tjolrJ`mm Stgrlos.2Lk ` boblc`tob i`rquoo, ` prgeosslgk`a elai i`for `sfob tjls soae-soaoctlkd s`ipao gpok-okbob quostlgks sucj `s= Jgw cgio ygu wokt egr J`mm76

    Tjg blb ygu dg wltj76 Jgw blb ygu eooa wjok ygu dgt tjoro76 Tj`ts ygurigst vlvlb ioigry76 Tj`t blb ygu nrlkd n`cf76 `kb Tguab ygu dg `d`lk7.?Tjlao L w`s kgt blroctay lkvgavob lk tjo cgaaoctlgk ge tjls b`t` iysoae, L blb

    spokb tlio wltj tjo Nrltlsj Iusoui to`i `t tjo eostlv`a, j`vlkd provlgusayblscussob iy gwk roso`rcj gk _F J`mm-dglkd wltj tjoi `t tjo pa`kklkdst`do (IcAgudjalk >88 @ wonslto rocgrblkd foy oaoiokts ge tjo Nrltlsj Iusouis >80> oxjlnltlgk c`k no egukb `t= www.nrltlsjiusoui.grd/oxpagro/tjoios/j`mm.`spx.

    3 Ro Alvlkd Lsa`i eostlv`a `kb tjo Lsa`ilc Sgcloty ge Nrlt`lk por so `ro vory iucj t`rdotob `t e`ilalos`kb ygukd pogpao, j`vlkd oiordob wjok, burlkd tjo 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    56/260

    22

    J

    tr`kscrlnob.5 Lk tgt`a, 33 J`mm Stgrlos4prgbucob >?8 ilkutos ge tostligklos,wltj tjo agkdost cgktrlnutlgk `iguktlkd tg igro tj`k 3888 wgrbs `kb tjosjgrtost tg aoss tj`k ?88 wgrbs. Igst woro notwook ?88 `kb 0?88 wgrbs lk

    aokdtj. Cgktrlnutgrs woro kgt `sfob ny tjo lktorvlowor tg soae-lboktley lk `kyp`rtlcua`r w`y noygkb st`tlkd tjolr k`io, tjolr gccup`tlgk, `kb wjoro tjoyalvob. Kovortjoaoss, uslkd tjo vlbog rocgrblkds `kb tr`kscrlpts, L w`s `nao tgi`p gtjor `spocts ge p`rtlclp`kts nlg-b`t`. @atjgudj L bg kgt soof tg cgip`rotjo oxporlokcos ge blstlkctlvo drgups ge Nrltlsj Iusali pladrlis ny dokbor, `dodrgup, otjklclty, gr yo`r ge J`mm gr _ir` p`rtlclp`tlgk, L bg sgiotlios uso tjlsb`t` tg nottor cgktoxtu`also lkblvlbu`a `ccgukts ox`ilkob joro. Ge cgurso, tjok`ios ge `aa p`rtlclp`kts `kb, `s kocoss`ry, gtjor lkegri`tlgk tj`t ildjt lboktleytjoi, j`vo nook `kgkyilsob.

    @igkd tjls r`kbgi s`ipao, twokty p`rtlclp`kts j`b nook egr tjo J`mm,klko j`b nook egr tjo _ir`, gko blb kgt rocgrb wjlcj pladrli`do j`b nookporegriob, `kb tjroo j`b kgt tr`voaaob egr oltjor nut woro stlaa igvob tg rocgrbjgw tjo `ccgukts ge erlokbs `kb e`ilay j`b lip`ctob upgk tjolr gwk boslro tgmgurkoy tg tjo Jgay Xa`cos.:Ge tjgso tj`t j`b tr`voaaob egr tjo J`mm gr _ir`,gkay tjroo gabor iok j`b i`bo tjo pladrli`do burlkd tjo 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    57/260

    2?

    IA

    a`w, bosldk, tjo `rts, `kb sclokco.00Gko-tjlrb ge p`rtlclp`kts woro ergi Agkbgk`kb tjo Sgutj ge Okda`kb, `kb ko`ray gko-qu`rtor woro ergi I`kcjostor, ngtj`ro`s wjoro tjoro ls ` sldklelc`kt Nrltlsj-Iusali ilbbao ca`ss. joro woro must

    ` eow p`rtlclp`kts ergi tjo igro typlc`aay wgrflkd-ca`ss cgiiukltlos lk Tost\grfsjlro `kb Nlrilkdj`i, `atjgudj Da`sdgw lk Scgta`kb w`s sgiowj`t nottorroprosoktob.

    jo oxpgsltlgk tj`t egaagws, tjok, ls kgt n`sob gk blroct gnsorv`tlgk ge, grliiorslgk lk, tjo sottlkds lk tjo Jgay Xa`cos wjoro tjo J`mm `kb tjo _ir` `roporegriob.0>Lkboob, alfo j`mmlB`ky`a cltob `t tjo nodlkklkd ge tjls cj`ptor, `kuinor ge p`rtlclp`kts lkslstob tj`t `ccoss tg tjo `utjoktlclty ge tjo oxporlokcoge pladrli`do cgios gkay wltj nolkd tjoro. @t tjo s`io tlio, tjo aliltobkuinor, `kb gpok-okbob k`turo, ge tjo lktorvlow quostlgks `sfob, `s woaa `spladrlis gwk blscrotlgk, ukbguntobay io`kt tj`t sgio spocts ge tjolr oingblobporegri`kcos `kb i`torl`a pr`ctlcos woro kgt `bbrossob lk bot`la gr `t `aa. jusL lkovlt`nay prgvlbo gkay ` p`rtl`a `ccgukt ge tjo cgipaox roaldlgus, sgcl`a,cuatur`a, pgaltlc`a, `kb ocgkgilc ro`altlos ge J`mm-dglkd `igkd tjo >>,888>?,888 Nrltlsj Iusalis wjg tr`voa `kku`aay (IcAgudjalk >803n6 ce. Nl`kcjl>882 gk tjo grd`kls`tlgk ge tjo J`mm wgrabwlbo). Iy toxt roprosokts gko ge `kuinor ge pgsslnao ro`blkds `kb lktorprot`tlgks, wjlcj c`kkgt kocoss`rlay nodokor`alsob tg Nrltlsj j`mmls. Kovortjoaoss, wltj twokty yo`rs oxporlokco stubylkdNrltlsj Iusali cgktoxts, L `i roa`tlvoay woaa pa`cob tg `ssoss `kb lktorprot tjorlcjay toxturob gr`a tostligklos lk quostlgk joro.03

    Rjo Kow J`mmls= Sgcl`a Cj`kdo, Nolkd C`aaob, `kbCgkstr`lkob Cjglcos

    @s tjo tltao ge tjo K`tlgk`a Iusoui ge Otjkgagdys oxjlnltlgk Agkdlkd egr Iocc`(>803>802) c`pturob sg `ptay, tjo J`mm `kb tjo _ir` j`vo agkd slkco sust`lkobtjo Lsa`ilc`to li`dlk`tlgk tjrgudj tlio `kb `crgss sp`co (ce. Olcfoai`k &Xlsc`tgrl 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    58/260

    25

    J

    o`ray igbork J`mm oxporlokco. jo sj`rp cgktr`st notwook tjolr aokdtjy `kbcj`aaokdlkd mgurkoy ny sjlp ergi tjo Lkbg-X`f suncgktlkokt er`iob jls gwka`to-igbork prop`r`tlgks tg eay ergi tjo _kltob Flkdbgi tg tjo Flkdbgi ge

    S`ubl @r`nl` wltj cgip`r`tlvo o`so.Lk tjgso b`ys pogpao usob tg tr`voa ny so`. joy usob tg t`fo tjolrgwk r`tlgks. @kb wjok pogpao usob tg s`y dggbnyo tg tjoi, tjoyildjt kgt soo tjoi `d`lk. joro w`s sg iucj bleelcuaty lk tjotr`voaalkd. Tjlao tjoy woro tjoro tjoy usob tg bg tjolr gwk cggflkd.joro woro kg jgtoas, must tjo c`ipsltos Sg tjgso plcturos worovory vlvlb li`dos lk iy mgurkoy.

    Lkcro`slkday lktokslvo `kb oxtokslvo dagc`als`tlgk j`s tjoroegro tr`ksegriob tjovory pgsslnlaltlos ge Iusalis tr`voaalkd egr tjo J`mm. jo kuinor ge gvorso`s

    pladrlis j`s iusjrggiob slkco tjo ilb-0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    59/260

    24

    IA

    Bosplto rlslkd prlcos `kb pladrli qugt`s tj`t j`vo robucob ny >8 por coktslkco >803 tg `ccgiigb`to eurtjor oxp`kslgk ge tjo Dro`t Igsquo ge Iocc`,Nrltlsj Iusalis j`vo lkcro`slkday nook `nao tg cgksuio tr`voa tg tjo Jgay

    Xa`cos `t ` tlio ge tjolr koob, boslro, `kb cjggslkd (IcAgudjalk >88882= 8s, ccgukt`kt,Sgutj ge Okda`kb, J`mm >883) oxpa`lkob, L fkow lts ` buty ` agt ge pogpaoporj`ps ao`vo lt a`tor gk nut `etor L dr`bu`tob L st`rtob wgrf euaa-tlio `kb tj`ts gko ge tjo elrst tjlkds L blb `etor Lb s`vob up sgio igkoy. Slila`ray,B`ky`a (28s, okdlkoor, Scgta`kb) `ccgip`klob jls wleo sggk `etor tjolr wobblkdlk 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    60/260

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    61/260

    288?), tjo `ccgukt ge jls elk`a boclslgk tg tr`voa tjoroegro k`rr`tos nolkdboclslvoay eeoctob ny plgus sgkds sot `d`lkst tjo nrg`bor cgktoxt ge dgsslp lk tjocgiiuklty.

    Lt w`s vory subbok kb agt ge pogpao t`af ngut lt alfo tj`t Gkoge tjo pogpao wo fkgw sjo iot iy wleo lk tjo i`rfot `kb sjos`ys, Gj, L jo`r yguro dglkd tg J`mm. @kb iy wleo s`ys, Toaa,

    i`y @aa`j i`fo ygur wgrbs naossob, noc`uso wo j`vo kg pa`ks @kb tjok sjo ioktlgkob lt tg io ` cgupao ge b`ys a`tor. To worogk gur w`y tg k`sjlbVplgus slkdlkdY cgkcort Gko ge tjo rtlstsw`s slkdlkd `ngut nolkd `t tjo F`n`, brlkflkd ergi tjo woaas ge]`iz`i @etor tj`t L tjgudjt, \os, woro dglkd.

    Xoregrilkd Lsa`ilc Scrlpts= S`crob Xa`co, Alilk`alty, `kbCgiiuklt`s

    L elkb lt qulto bleelcuat tg cgip`rtiokt`also o`cj oxporlokco `s

    ` rltu`a, L soo lt `s ` vory jgalstlc oxporlokco `kb L tjlkf i`lkaylt w`s tjo e`ct tj`t L w`s w`aflkd lk tjo eggtstops ge tjoso dro`tporsgk`altlos tj`t L j`b `aw`ys jo`rb `ngut `kb spgfok `ngut `kbro`b `ngut `kb tjgudjt `ngut `kb li`dlkob. (@ilk`j, >8s, tr`lkoosgalcltgr, Agkbgk, J`mm 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    62/260

    ?8

    J

    To woro rojo`rslkd `kb ro-ok`ctlkd tjo rltu`as wjlcj woro bgkony pogpao tjgus`kbs ge yo`rs `dg, pogpao wjg wo rod`rb `s tjodro`tost pogpao gk o`rtj To bg tjls noc`uso tjls ls wj`t Xrgpjot

    Lnr`jli (po`co no upgk jli) j`s bgko, `kb Xrgpjot Lsi`la, `kbgur Xrgpjot Iuj`ii`b (s`aa` @aa`ju `a`yjl w`s`aa`i).

    Lk tjolr tostligklos, p`rtlclp`kts tokbob tg bwoaa gk tjo igst lcgklc igiokts getjo J`mm `kb tjo _ir`, wltj soolkd tjo F n`egr tjo elrst tlio `k oxporlokco tj`ttyplc`aay gvorsj`bgwob `aa gtjors. @s Dgbs Jguso (N`yt @aa`j), lt ls ge cgursotjo egc`a pglkt ge ` Iusali psycjg-dogdr`pjy n`sob lk tjo ovoryb`y ngblayfkgwaobdo ge roaldlgklkd (ce. Boa`koy 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    63/260

    ?0

    IA

    jo s`lb, Kgw aggf up. j`t elrst da`kco ge tjo F`n` ls v`rlgusay boscrlnob nypladrlis `s `i`zlkd, nro`tjt`flkd, no`utleua, i`dlc`a, e`nuagus, surro`a,otjoro`a, slipao, i`dklelcokt, `kb `wo-lksplrlkd. joy `asg boscrlno nolkd

    gvorcgio, to`reua, mgyeua, juinao, igvob, gvorwjoaiob, lksplrob,prlvlaodob, `kb roerosjob. jo F`n` ls tgucjob, flssob, `kb sioaaob, `s woaa`s sook. Ngtj Kgrook (>8s, `ccgukt`kt, Agkbgk, J`mm 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    64/260

    ?>

    J

    B`y ge Mubdiokt L wgkt rocgdklso iy sgk `kb iy igtjor wgkt rocgdklso ionoc`uso lt wlaa must no notwook io `kb Dgb `kb L wlaa gkay no cgkcorkob wltjiy gwk e`to, wjotjor L dg tg jo`vok gr joaa.

    ^osoinalkd sjrgub, i`ao pladrlis rltu`a wo`rlkd ge twg plocos ge ukstltcjobwjlto cagtj ls `asg ` i`torl`a roilkbor tj`t, lk ` cgktoxt sot `p`rt ergi tjop`ttorks, kgris, `kb progccup`tlgks ge iukb`ko tlio `kb sp`co, tjo rltu`as getjo J`mm structuro lk rovorso grbor tjo ro-ok`ctiokt ge ` s`cr`alsob mgurkoy ergislk `kb bo`tj tg purlty `kb ronlrtj (Tornkor 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    65/260

    ?3

    IA

    ygu `ro, wj`t ygu wo`r, wjoro yguro ergi, wj`t a`kdu`do ygu spo`f. Egr Kuj(58s, rotlrob okdlkoor, Agkbgk, J`mm 0882),0?dokbor bleeorokcos woro `asg suspokbob lk ` w`y tj`troi`lkob sldklelc`kt. Nolkd usob tg igsquos lk Okda`kb wjoro wgiok `kb iok`ro sop`r`to, tjls VI`smlb `a-J`r`iY w`s ` pa`co wjoro ovoryngby w`s tgdotjorVl.o. kgt dokbor sodrod`tobY `kb tj`t w`s qulto bleeorokt egr io.

    _kscrlptob Xoregri`kcos= _kcort`lkty, @kxloty, `kb Gtjor^o`a J`mm Stgrlos

    Lksto`b ge tjo F`n` L w`s egcussobL fkgw lt sgukbs qultonlz`rro VgkY `aa tjo sflk tgkos, tjo p`ttorks lk tjolr cagtjos,toxturos @kb jo Vjor jusn`kbY must aggfob `t io V`kb s`lbY,Tj`t `ro ygu bglkd7 Tj`t `ro ygu tjlkflkd `ngut7 Nut lt w`s

    must sgiotjlkd L cguabkt joap. (^gnlk`, 28s, `rtlst, Sgutj geOkda`kb, J`mm >884)

    Xladrlis utgpl`k oxporlokcos lk s`cr`alsob tlio `kb sp`co iust no sook `soiordlkd gut ge tjolr toipgr`ry, cgktlkdokt, kb oingblob tlio-sp`co agc`tlgks`kb alvob i`torl`a pr`ctlcos (Usquoz >800). _ksurprlslkday lk tjls vlow, AlvlkdLsa`i p`rtlclp`kts `ccgukts ge nolkd tjoro `asg roeaoct i`ky ukscrlptobporegri`kcos tj`t qu`aley, bost`nlalso, `kb sgiotlios cgktost bgilk`kt Lsa`ilc

    0? Ignook (28s, Dokor`a Xr`ctltlgkor, Tost \grfsjlro, J`mm >88:) suddostob tj`t tjo e`co iust nooxpgsob, `s iust tjo j`kbs `kb eoot tjo jo`b ls cgvorob `atjgudj lk pr`ctlco sgio wgiok i`y

    wo`r, `kb lk blscusslgks ge tjo roaov`kt ffqji`y no okcgur`dob tg wo`r, ` e`co cgvorlkd tj`t ls kgt `klq`n.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    66/260

    ?2

    J

    scrlpts. joy jldjaldjt pladrlis iuatlpao tlio-sp`co `kb alvob-structur`aagc`tlgks (ce. IcAgudjalk >88888s, tr`lkoo sgalcltgr,Agkbgk, J`mm 088800) roi`rfobL dgt pusjob ` agt noc`uso tjoro w`s sg i`ky pogpao nojlkb io `kb tjok Lokbob up aottlkd dg ge iy iui. Egr K`srook (38s, igtjor, Kgrtj-Tost, _ir`>808), jor eo`r `kb `kxloty `ngut sucj tjlkds w`s okgudj tg `nnrovl`to jorp`rtlclp`tlgk lk `k okvlrgkiokt tj`t, bosplto nolkd s`crob, sjo stlaa porcolvob

    `s `alok.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    67/260

    ??

    IA

    Must dglkd tg ` kow cguktry ls qulto ` nlt sc`ry, alfo ` bleeoroktoxporlokco joy Vioinors ge jor e`ilayY dgt tjo cj`kco tg flsstjo Na`cf Stgko nut L blbkt bg tj`t. L w`s ` nlt sc`rob egr iy aleo tg

    no jgkost wltj ygu. joro woro agts ge pogpao crgwbob `rgukb lt.Sueeorlkd ergi ` sorlgus ioblc`a cgkbltlgk, J`elz (58s, rotlrob nuslkossi`k,Agkbgk, J`mm 0884)

    I`ky ge tjo tostligklos `asg roeaoct upgk tjo blscrop`kclos notwook pladrlisgetok-lbo`alsob oxpoct`tlgks cgkcorklkd tjo Jgay Xa`cos `kb tjo ro`altloscgkergktob tjoro. Bosplto wlbospro`b kod`tlvo cgiiokts lk _F iobl` clrcaos,05rospgkbokts roi`rfs `ngut quostlgks ge jorlt`do `kb igborkls`tlgk `ro

    sgiowj`t `inlv`aokt gvor`aa. Al`q`t (scjgga ngy, Kgrtj-Tost, _ir` >800) w`svory blroct= L tjgudjt lt wguab no alfo klco `kb po`coeua `kb vory no`utleua wltj`aa tjo Iusali `rcjltocturo `kb stuee nut lt w`s kgt alfo tj`t wjok L dgt tjoro,`ctu`aay. Jgwovor, igro roeaoxlvo `ngut jor gwk r`tjor ukro`alstlc oxpoct`tlgks,^gnlk` (28s, `rtlst, Sgutj ge Okda`kb, J`mm >884) `cfkgwaobdob tjo prossuroupgk tjo `utjgrltlos tg updr`bo sorvlcos `kb e`claltlos.

    05 Soo, egr ox`ipao, jttp=//www.lkbopokbokt.cg.uf/vglcos/cgiiokt/wjy-bgkt-igro-iusalis-spo`f-gut-`d`lkst-tjo-w`ktgk-bostructlgk-ge-iocc`s-jgay-sltos-:>>.jtia.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    68/260

    ?5

    J

    Lt w`s kgtjlkd alfo L oxpoctob. L tjlkf L spokt ` agt ge tlio trylkdtg li`dlko wj`t lt w`s alfo lk tjo gab b`ys ovorytjlkd kgw lsnulat up kb, egr io, L blb w`kt tg soo tjo gab w`y, tjo mgurkoy tj`t

    J`m`r wguab j`vo t`fok, ox`ctay tjo w`y lt w`s wjok sjo tggf lt VNutY L fkgw lts vory bleelcuat tg foop tjlkds tjo w`y tj`t tjoyworo noc`uso ge cgiegrt `kb tjo kuinor ge pogpao tj`t j`vo nookcgilkd tjrgudj tjo yo`rs.

    Iuk`z` (>8s, stubokt, Agkbgk, J`mm >88803n), i`ky Nrltlsj-ngrk Iusali pladrlis, wjg`ro `aro`by boopay lktodr`tob lktg cuaturos ge cgksuior c`plt`alsi, `ctu`aayokmgy tjo i`rfotlsob Lsa`ilc okvlrgkiokt (ce. urkor 06 Ngunofour & ^gy >80>). Kgrook (>8s, `ccgukt`kt, Agkbgk, J`mm 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    69/260

    ?4

    IA

    Lts jgt, tjoros pusjlkd dglkd gk, pogpaos i`kkors `ro bleeorokt, custgis `robleeorokt must foop ygur igutj cagsob. Al`q`t (scjggangy, Kgrtj-Tost,_ir` >800) lboktlelob tjo roal`kco ge tjo Jgay Xa`cos gk ildr`kt wgrfors

    wltjgut nolkd `nao tg r`lso quostlgks `ngut tjolr st`tus `kb rldjts= jo cao`kors`rgukb tjo nulablkd ge tjo F`n`, tjoy woro igstay X`flst`kl `kb igst ge tjosjgpfoopors woro X`flst`kl. jus wjlao tjo bgilk`kt Lsa`ilc scrlpt ge tjo J`mmls gko ge cgiiuklt`s `kb uklty lk blvorslty, cgipotlkd otjkg-k`tlgk`a scrlpts`ro `asg poregriob ovory slkdao b`y (ce. Olcfoai`k & Xlsc`tgrl 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    70/260

    ?:

    J

    Tornkor 088

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    71/260

    ?884), lt w`s `k oplpj`ky ovok igro v`au`nao `kb ioigr`nao tj`k nocgilkd

    ` igtjor, noc`uso lt `aagwob io tg no iysoae .\ot, `s sgio ge tjo roi`rfs joro `asg lktli`to, tjo splrltu`a oeelc`cy ge sucj

    poregri`kcos i`y gr i`y kgt no sg o`slay i`lkt`lkob `ilbst tjo cgipaox`kb iuatlpao alvob structuros `kb sunmoctlvltlos ge ovoryb`y aleo. ^ly`bj (28s,bosldkor, Agkbgk, J`mm 0800). jlsls sgiotlios sp`rfob ny p`rtlcua`r s`cr`alsob i`torl`a gnmocts `kb tjo soksos.@ccgrblkd tg Klage` (>8s, Agkbgk, to`cjor, _ir` 0883) boscrlnob, Gkco yguro ao`vlkd ygu dot tj`t s`bkoss tj`t wjotjor Laaovor no `nao tg cgio n`cf joro `d`lk. Noc`uso gkco yguvo dgt lt lk ygur jo`rt,ygu j`vo ` nld yo`rklkd `kb agkdlkd tg dg n`cf tjoro. @nlb` (38s, gptgiotrlst,Kgrtj-Tost, J`mm 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    72/260

    58

    J

    L tjlkf wltj tjo p`sslkd ge tlio, wltj `do, prgn`nay ygu soo ltlk ` bleeorokt w`y. jo elrst tlio L wokt egr J`mm lt w`s, egr io,igstay ` blscgvory. Sg L w`s kgt sg iucj splrltu`a, L w`s wgrrlob,

    @i L bglkd tjo rldjt tjlkd7 @i L bglkd tjo wrgkd tjlkd7 josocgkb tlio ygu dg ygu `ro ` nlt igro oxporlokcob, sg ygu `roigro splrltu`a.

    wg-tjlrbs ge rospgkbokts wjg spgfo `ngut tjo quostlgk ge roturk tg tjo JgayXa`cos woro uk`kligus lk tjolr boslro tg dg n`cf. Egaagwlkd tjo Xrgpjotlcox`ipao, ]un`lr (58s, rotlrob nuslkossi`k, Agkbgk, J`mm 0

  • 7/21/2019 9789088902857 - Mols & Buitelaar 2015 - Hajj - RMV43 - e-book

    73/260

    50

    IA

    ge pladrli`do stublos egr J`mm roso`rcj. jls ls oqu`aay truo ge gabor p`r`bldis`ssgcl`tob wltj s`crob pa`co, alilk`alty `kb cgiiuklt`s, `s pgstigbork`pprg`cjos oipj`slslkd cgktost`tlgks ge tjo s`crob. Jgwovor, wgrflkd `crgss

    ` wlbor r`kdo ge blsclpalkos ergi tjo `ktjrgpgagdy ge Lsa`i tg sgclgagdy geroaldlgk kb bl`spgr` stublos, L vlow tjo J`mm prlkclp`aay s k ox`ipao ge Iusaliroaldlgklkd `crgss agc`a, iuatl-agc`a `kb supr`-agc`a sp`tl`a sc`aos. joroegro Lbwoaa kgt gkay gk tjo J`mm lk Iocc` nut `asg roaldlgusay lksplrob `kb ovoryb`yoxporlokcos lk v`rlgus tlio-sp`co agc`tlgks noegro, burlkd `kb `etor pladrli`do.L `rduo tj`t tjrgudj oingblob `ctlgks `ssgcl`tob wltj tjo J`mm, lts prop`r`tlgk`kb roioinr`kco, Nrltlsj Iusalis `ctlvoay sj`po tjolr gwk soae-lboktltlos,splrltu`alty kb oigtlgk`a alvos, wjlao `t tjo s`io tlio roprgbuclkd utjgrlt`tlvoLsa`ilc scrlpts. Jgwovor, tjo er`dlalty ge sucj poregri`kcos ny Nrltlsj Iusali`ctgrs pgsltlgkob ny iuatlpao, cgipaox `kb sgiotlios p`r`bgxlc`a alvobstructuros lkcaublkd cgksuior c`plt`alsi `kb socua`rlty, io`ks tj`t r