a guide for using na-sul® - king industries · 2015. 5. 18. · na-sul® rust and corrosion...
TRANSCRIPT
NA-SUL®Rust Preventive Additives
SPECIALTY CHEMICALS®
A Guide for Using
NA-SUL® Rust and Corrosion Inhibitors have delivered superior rust and corrosion protection worldwide since 1952. The NA-SUL
trademark is short for naphthalene sulfonate. Dinonylnaphthalene sulfonates o�er uniquely e�ective chemistry
because of their polarity combined with excellent solubility in a wide range of carrier �uids. Combining this chemistry with
other synergistic polar compounds produces rust and corrosion preventive additives with unsurpassed e�ectiveness.
The additives described in this brochure can be used to solve most common rust and corrosion problems.
They are typically e�ective at a treat rate of 1/2 or less compared with competitive rust and corrosion preventive additives.
Classi�cation of Rust Preventive Additives
Oil-Based formulations consist of the rust preventive additive in oil alone. For this purpose oil includes mineral oil, vegetable oils, synthetic oils such as polyalphaole�n (PAO) and alkylated naphthalene, esters, polyalkylene glycols and many more. These formulations typically provide an oily coating with lubricity and low VOC content.
Oil-Solvent formulations consist of the rust preventive additive, oil and a volatile solvent. These less oily formulations are used to provide increased rust protection, improved penetration into crevices, or dewatering properties where the rust preventive displaces water from wet metal parts and leaves a protective coating. The amount of rust preventive additive left after the solvent evaporates in the coating is proportionally greater, thus improving protection.
10% Calcium Petroleum Sulfonate/carboxylate
10% Calcium Dinonylnaphthalene Sulfonate/carboxylate
Aqu
eous
Non
-Aqu
eous
Rust preventives may be classi�ed a number of ways based on their performance requirements. NA-SUL additives are available to meet a broad range of applications. This guide is to assist in the selection of the appropriate NA-SUL rust preventive additive.
NA-SUL rust and corrosion inhibitors exhibit superior salt fog performance compared to other sulfonate chemistries. Dinonylnaphthalene sulfonates are e�ective in a wide range of applications from general and indoor storage to harsh exterior applications. NA-SUL corrosion inhibitors are e�ective on steel, galvanized steel, aluminum and various other metals.
Polished
24 Hours Salt Fog Exposure Comparative Calcium Sulfonate Performance in 90% Group I, ISO VG 32 Para�nic Oil
MatteMatte Polished
Pg. 8
- 11
Pg. 2
- 7
1
NA-SUL Performance vs. Other Sulfonates
Water-Based formulations are either solutions or emulsions. Solutions rely on polar chemical activity alone for metal protection. Emulsions can add oil or waxes along with polar activity to give better rust prevention. In these systems, water is substituted for organic solvents resulting in greatly reduced VOC. This gives lower �ammability, lower worker exposure to solvents and easier regulatory compliance for VOC’s. The disadvantage of water-based formulations is slower drying time.
NA-SUL - Typical Performance
ApplicationsNA-SUL Description
CA-1259
CA-1089
CA/W1213
CA-1183
CA-1082
Most versatile general purpose rust preventive additive with excellent performance in high humidity and salt environments. Excellent for dewatering applications.
Excellent for dewatering and extended indoor storage of parts. Highly e�ective in preventing staining for coiled steel and stacked parts.
Excellent protection for steel, galvanized steel and aluminum. Excellent solubilityin a wide variety of carriers. Excellent dewatering performance.
Good salt fog and humidity performance. Performs well as a dispersant for wax containing formulations that allows for thixotropic �lms with longer protection.
Property/Use Not RecommendedGood
Oil Solubility
Dewatering /Water Tolerance
Room Temperature Mixing
Indoor Storage
Outdoor Storage(Sheltered)
Marine Environment
Acid Atmosphere
Tolerance for Strong Bases (Aqueous)
CA/W1213
CA-1089
CA-1089, CA-1082,CA-1183
CA-1082, CA/W1213
CA/W1213
CA-1082CA/W1213
CA-1183
CA-1089, CA-1082,CA-1183
CA-1082, CA-1183
CA-1259
CA-1259
Non
-Aqu
eous
NA-SUL for Non-Aqueous (oil and oil/solvent) Applications
Formulated for protection in harsh environments. Excellent salt fog and acid exposure performance. Recommended for long term indoor or sheltered outdoor storage.
NA-SUL Recommendations by Application
Oil & Oil-Solvent
2
Best
CA-1259, CA-1089,CA-1183, CA-1082
CA-1259, CA-1183, CA-1089
CA-1259, CA-1089, CA-1082
All
CA-1259, CA/W1213
CA-1259, CA/W1213
CA/W1213
CA-1183, CA-1089
All �lm thicknesses in the following test results are 3µm (0.12 mils) or less
NA-SUL CA-1259 is a high performance liquid rust preventive additive. It has excellent solubility in a wide range of mineral oils, esters and vegetable oils. NA-SUL CA-1259 is less viscous than many other additives of its type and can usually be cold blended into oils, resulting in lower energy cost and faster processing.
(P) = Polished Surface(M) = Matte Surface*ISOPAR® H and Exxsol® D-40 are registered trademarks of ExxonMobil
NA-SUL CA-1259
Highly versatile thin �lm rust preventive additive
Liquid, minimizing the need for heating prior to blending
Excellent water displacement, ideal for dewatering �uids
Resists gelling in the presence of bulk water
Excellent rust prevention allows high performance with low treat rates
Excellent low temperature stability
3
FORMULATIONS
TESTSSalt Fog (ASTM B 117)Average Hours to Failure
28 (P)18 (M)
30 (P)50 (M)
40 (P)32 (M)
72 (P)60 (M)
NA-SUL Performance - Oil-Based Formulations on Steel
5% CA-125995% Group IISO VG 32 Oil
10% CA-125990% Group IISO VG 32 Oil
10% CA-125990% Group IIISO VG 22 Oil
10% CA-125990% NaphthenicISO VG 46 Oil
FORMULATIONS
TESTSSalt Fog (ASTM B 117)Average Hours to Failure
85 (P)80 (M)
90 (P)110 (M)
105 (P)240 (M)
90 (P)95 (M)
NA-SUL Performance - Oil/Solvent Based Formulations on Steel
5% CA-125920% Group IISO VG 32 Oil75% Mineral Spirits
5% CA-125920% Group IISO VG 32 Oil75% ISOPAR® H*
20% CA-125930% Group IISO VG 32 Oil50% ISOPAR® H*
10% CA-125920% Group IISO VG 32 Oil70% Exxsol® D-40*
FORMULATIONS
TESTSSalt Fog (ASTM B 117)Average Hours to Failure
10 (P)8 (M)
14 (P)10 (M)
20 (P)14 (M)
22 (P)18 (M)
2% CA-125998% Soy Base Fluid
4% CA-125996% Soy Base Fluid
10% CA-125990% Canola Oil
15% CA-125930% Canola Oil55% Methyl Soyate
NA-SUL Performance - Vegetable Oil Based Formulations on Steel
5% NA-SUL CA-108995% ISO VG 46 Oil (220 SUS)
5% Competitive Rust Preventive95% ISO VG 46 Oil (220 SUS)
8% NA-SUL CA-10892% CA/W1177
90% ISO VG 32 Oil
2g Water in Steel Wool5% NA-SUL CA-1089
30 sec: 1.3ml :10 min: 1.5ml
NA-SUL CA-1089 is a versatile low odor (wax free) liquid rust preventive additive designed to provide excellent performance in high humidity. It has superior solubility in a wide range of oils and solvents including Group II oils and polyalphaole�ns, and has excellent water displacement characteristics that make NA-SUL CA-1089 especially recommended for dewatering �uid applications.
NA-SUL CA-1089 Performance - ISO VG 32 Group I
Excellent non-staining performance on steel
Outstanding solubility in highly para�nic oils
Exceptional dewatering with no gelling problems
Excellent general purpose rust preventive
Low odor
FORMULATIONS
TESTS
Average Film Thickness
Salt FogAverage Hours to Failure
Humidity CabinetAverage Hours to Failure
2% CA-108998% Oil
5% CA-108995% Oil
10% CA-108990% Oil
2.8 µm 2.8 µm 3.0 µm
3-5 5-10 15-20
150 250 450
3% CA-108920% Oil77% MS
5% CA-108920% Oil75% MS
10% CA-108920% Oil70% MS
1.8 µm 2.0 µm 2.4 µm
5 8-10 16-20
300 350-450 500-600
Para�nic Oil Formulations Oil / Mineral Spirits Formulations
NA-SUL CA/W1177 - Synergistic Performance Booster
NA-SUL CA/W1177 was designed speci�cally for use where water contact is likely. It combines excellent corrosion resistance with good water separation characteristics. The addition of CA/W1177 to a formula containing CA-1089 improves salt fog and humidity performance while maintaining the excellent dewatering and anti-staining properties of CA-1089.
4
NA-SUL CA-1089
Water Displacement Test
7 Day Stack Stain Test @ 77°C
Excellent salt fog and humidity protection
Thin protective �lm is e�ective in harsh environments and sheltered outdoor storage
NA-SUL CA/W1213 is an oil soluble rust preventive additive designed to provide superior salt fog performance in thin �lm coatings. It is very e�ective in harsh environments. It is also highly recommended for extended protection in high humidity or normal indoor storage. Extremely demanding applications will bene�t from the addition of K-CORR® 1227 as described below.
K-CORR 1227 is an oil soluble corrosion preventive additive designed to boost performance of certain NA-SUL corrosion inhibitors in di�cult applications. It improves performance in humidity and salt fog.
K-CORR 1227 - Synergistic Salt Fog Performance Booster
FORMULATIONS
TESTS
Average Film Thickness
Salt FogAverage Hours to Failure
10% CA/W121390% Oil #1
1.0 µm1.0 µm1.5 µm
50-6020-30
10% CA/W121390% Oil #2
10% CA/W121390% Oil #3
30-40
Salt Fog Performance
MS = 40°C (105°F) Flash Mineral Spirits
FORMULATIONS
TEST
7.5% CA/W12132.5% K-CORR 122790% Oil
60-70
6.0% CA/W12131.0% K-CORR 122720% Oil73% MS
80-85
Salt Fog Booster
Salt FogAverage Hours to Failure
Oil #1 = ISO VG 32 Group IOil #2 = ISO VG 22 Naphthenic
Oil #3 = ISO VG 32 Group III Para�nic
5
NA-SUL CA/W1213
NA-SUL CA-1183 is a liquid corrosion preventive additive designed for use where water contact is likely such as dewatering �uids. It provides excellent corrosion protection for steel, galvanized steel and aluminum. NA-SUL CA-1183 can be combined with waxes or polymers for specialty applications.
Excellent multi metal rust and corrosion inhibition
Outstanding water separation properties with no gelling tendency
Excellent solubility in a wide range of oils and esters
Compatible with alkaline contaminants and metalworking �uids
Highly e�ective performance when emulsi�ed for water based applications
NA-SUL Performance on Cold Rolled Steel
5% CA-118310% Oil #285% MS
FORMULATIONS
TESTS
Salt FogAverage Hours to Failure
Humidity CabinetAverage Hours to Failure
1% CA-118399% Oil #1
2% CA-118398% Oil #1
5% CA-118395% Oil #1
--8 (P)2 (M)
144 200 400
14 (P)6 (M)
3% CA-118310% Oil #187% MS
10% CA-118320% Oil #170% MS
6 18 26-32
300 500 700
Oil Formulations Oil / Mineral Spirits Formulations
Oil #1 = ISO VG 32 Group IOil #2 = ISO VG 22 Naphthenic
MS = 40°C (105°F) Flash Mineral Spirits6
NA-SUL CA-1183
FORMULATIONS
TESTS
Salt FogAverage Hours to Failure*
10% CA-118390% Oil #1
5% CA-118310% Oil #285% MS
10% CA-118320% Oil #270% MS
24 330
Galvanized Steel Aluminum
28 40+
5% CA-118310% Oil #285% MS
NA-SUL Performance on Galvanized Steel and Aluminum
*Until the appearance of white or brown corrosion
*One cycle is 8 hours at 50°C and 100% humidity followed by 16 hours at ambient temperature and humidity. Failure criteria: Rust extending more than 1.5 cm from the top edge or more than 0.5 cm from either side edge.
NA-SUL CA-1082 is a highly e�ective liquid rust and corrosion inhibitor. It outperforms most additive systems containing wax or polymers in salt fog testing. It has excellent solubility in base �uids such as highly processed para�nic oils and PAO, although rust prevention is best in naphthenic oils or less highly re�ned para�nic oils and solvents. NA-SUL CA-1082 also functions as a dispersant to keep waxes in suspension allowing stable thixotropic formulations for extended rust prevention.
It resists gelling when exposed to water and therefore can be used in high moisture applications such as rust preventives applied to wet parts. Contamination with alkaline metalworking �uids may cause gelling. Compatibility with other process chemicals should also be veri�ed prior to use.
Excellent rust inhibitor with good demulsibility
Liquid, no melting required
Low odor, petroleum oxidate-free
7
NA-SUL CA-1082
Excellent solubility
Good dispersant properties
Resists gelling
1% CA-108299% Group IISO VG 32 Oil
5% CA-108295% Group IISO VG 32 Oil
10% CA-108290% Group IISO VG 32 Oil
15% CA-108285% Group IISO VG 32 Oil
Salt FogAverage Hours to Failure
Humidity CabinetAverage Hours to Failure
FORMULATIONS
TESTS
<2 16-24 30-45 65-90
500+ 750-1000 1000+ 1000+
NA-SUL Performance - Para�nic Oil-Based Formulations on Steel
2% CA-10828% Group IISO VG 32 Oil90% MS
3% CA-10827% Group IISO VG 32 Oil90% MS
3% CA-108220% Group IISO VG 32 Oil77% MS
5% CA-108220% Group IISO VG 32 Oil75% MS
10% CA-108220% Group IISO VG 32 Oil70% MS
Salt Fog(ASTM B 117)Average Hours to Failure
FORMULATIONS
TESTS
5-10 35-40 80 100-1206-12
NA-SUL Performance - Oil/Solvent-Based Formulations on Steel
110 Cycles (P)110 Cycles (M)
FORMULATIONS
TESTSKesternich Cabinet(DIN 50 017)Cyclic Humidity*
2% CA-108298% Group I ISO VG 32 Oil
86 Cycles (P)65 Cycles (M)
5% CA-108220% Group I ISO VG 32 Oil75% MS
NA-SUL Performance - Kesternich Cabinet - Steel
NA-SUL Neutralization Description
450
1019A
1101
Calcium, Alkanolamine
Alkanolamine
Ammonia
Liquid emulsi�able rust preventive concentrate with excellent emulsion stability giving superior protection for steel, aluminum and galvanized steel.
Liquid rust and corrosion preventive additive that forms a clear solution providing good thin �lm protection of steel, aluminum and galvanized steel. Ideal for indoor storage.
Particularly e�ective on galvanized steel and aluminum. Can be used in oil or water.
Aqu
eous
NA-SUL for Aqueous Systems
ApplicationsWater Based
Property/Use Not RecommendedGoodBest
Oil Solubility
Dewatering
Ease of Use
Indoor Storage (Steel)
Indoor Storage(Galvanized, Aluminum)
Removability, Alkaline Cleaners
NA-SUL Recommendations for Waterborne Applications
1019A450, 1101
450, 1019A
1101450, 1019A
1101450, 1019A
450, 1101
450, 1019A,1101
1019A
8
1101
Excellent protection for steel, aluminum and galvanized steel during storage and transportation
Excellent rust and corrosion inhibitor
Excellent emulsion stability
Deposits extremely thin, removable hydrophobic �lms
Emulsions form easily with moderate stirring
No mineral oil, biodegradable ester carrier
Iron Chip Test (ASTM D 4627)NA-SUL 450 passes at 1%
NA-SUL 450 is an oil soluble, emulsi�able rust preventive additive based on calcium dinonylnaphthalene sulfonate. NA-SUL 450 provides remarkable protection in 100% humidity environments giving similar or better results than oil based additives at the same treat level. Emulsions at 5% or lower concentrations leave a dry to the touch protective �lm. It can be diluted in oil and then easily emulsi�ed providing signi�cant salt fog protection at reasonable treat rates.
NA-SUL 450 Performance on Cold Rolled Steel and Aluminum
FORMULATIONS
TESTS
HumidityAverage Hours to Failure
1% 45099% Water
3% 45097% Water
5% 45095% Water
10% 45090% Water
5% 45095% Water
500-750 900-1400 1500-2000
Cold Rolled Steel Aluminum
90 - 120 220 - 270
NA-SUL 450 Performance - Added Oil on Cold Rolled Steel
FORMULATIONS
TESTS
Salt FogAverage Hours to Failure
6.7% 45010.7% Napthenic Oil2% NA-SUL TEA/LB0.7% Emulsi�er79.9% Water
8.3% 45013.3% Napthenic Oil2.5% NA-SUL TEA/LB0.9% Emulsi�er75% Water
10% 45016% Napthenic Oil3% NA-SUL TEA/LB1% Emulsi�er70% Water
Cold Rolled Steel
18-24 20-308-12
9
NA-SUL 450
NA-SUL 1019A is a completely water soluble rust and corrosion inhibiting additive designed to protect steel, galvanized steel and aluminum during indoor storage. NA-SUL 1019A deposits an ultra-thin and dry hydrophobic �lm on metal surfaces providing storage protection in humid environments at treat levels down to 1%, while giving hundreds of hours of protection.
Water soluble, clear solutions
Fast drying
Ultra-thin dry �lm
Excellent hard water tolerance
Film can be removed easily with alkaline-type cleaners
NA-SUL 1019A Cold Rolled Steel Performance
FORMULATIONS
TESTS
Average Film Thickness
Humidity (ASTM D 1748)Average Hours to Failure
1% 1019A99% Water
5% 1019A95% Water
Humidity Performance
0.1 µm
300
Pass Pass
0.3 µm
500
Iron Chip(ASTM D 4627)
FORMULATIONS
TESTS
Average Film Thickness
Humidity (ASTM D 1748)Average Hours to Failure
6% 1019A94% Water
Humidity Performance
NA-SUL 1019A Performance on Aluminum
0.3 µm
450
10
NA-SUL 1019A
Emulsions of NA-SUL 1101 as Corrosion Inhibitor for Aluminum
Aluminum test pieces submerged for 16 hours at 85°C
NA-SUL 1101 is a high performance ashless corrosion inhibitor speci�cally designed for aluminum and zinc alloys. It is also easily emulsi�ed using alkanolamines. Stable emulsions of NA-SUL 1101 can be made at a pH of as low as 8. This is important to avoid blackening aluminum from high pH emulsions.
Can be used in oil or water
Excellent corrosion inhibitor for aluminum and zinc alloys
Liquid, no melting required
Excellent solubility in highly para�nic base oils and PAO
Easily removed with alkaline-type cleaners
FORMULATIONS
TESTS
Emulsion pH
Salt FogAverage Hours to Failure
Aqueous
NA-SUL 1101 Aluminum Performance
NA
120
8.1
400
10% 110190% Group I ISO VG 32 OIL
10% 11012% Diethylethanolamine88% Tap Water
10% 11012.5% Diethylethanolamine87.5% Tap Water
8.8
400
FORMULATIONS
TESTS
Film Thickness
Humidity CabinetAverage Hours to Failure
Humidity Performance
NA-SUL 1101 Galvanized Steel Performance
0.3 µm
450
10% 110190% Group I ISO VG 32 OIL
NA-SUL 1101
NA-SUL 1101 emulsionpH = 8.1
NA-SUL 1101 emulsionpH = 8.8
Commercial RustPreventive emulsion
pH = 9.9
Non-Aqueous
11
Salt Fog “hours to failure” is de�ned as rust extending more than 1.5 cm from the top edge or more than 0.5 cm from either side edge. This is used by King Industries and is not in the ASTM B 117 Practice.
P = polished test surface M = matte test surface
The solubility of additives in speci�c oils and solvents should always be con�rmed. Compatibility with likely contaminants of bulk rust preventives should be veri�ed prior to use.
There are Product Data Sheets and Technical Reports for these and other products with additional information and test results available on our website and through our technical service department.
12
Test MethodsTechnical Service
Salt Fog Cabinet(ASTM B 117)
Cyclic Humidity Cabinet (DIN 50 017)
Humidity Cabinet(ASTM D 1748)
Continuous salt spray exposure is widely speci�ed for testing components and coatings for corrosion resistance to severe environments.
The chamber is maintained at 35°C with a continuous fog of a 5% NaCl solution.
The humidity cabinet tests the ability of metal preservatives to prevent steel panels from rusting under conditions of high humidity.
Polished steel panels are immersed in the sample oil and then suspended in the humidity cabinet for a speci�ed test period.
The Kesternich test is a cyclic humidity test meant to simulate alternating condensation and drying found in sheltered outdoor storage.
One cycle is 8 hours at 50°C and 100% humidity followed by 16 hours at ambient temperature and humidity. Failure criteria: Rust extending more than 1.5 cm from the top edge or more than 0.5 cm from either side edge.
Our experienced Technical Service Department is there to help you develop the best formulations to meet the most demanding applications. King Industries has a wide variety of additives that can be used to meet common or unique application requirements.
These are coupled with a wide range of testing capabilities such as ASTM methods and practices, DIN test methods, Military Speci�cation tests, Industry Standard tests and other unique test methods. The combination of high performance additives, extensive test methods and our ongoing communication results in superior formulations that achieve your goals.
General Comments
King Industries has many other rust and corrosion preventive additives that can be used to solve your unique rust and
corrosion problems. We o�er individualized assistance in optimizing your formulation using our extensive experience
and wide range of testing capabilities. This is particularly valuable for our customers in light of changing base
�uids, worldwide regulations and increasingly stringent performance requirements.
The conditions of your use and application of our products, technical assistance and information (whether verbal, written or by way of product evaluations), including any suggested formulations and recommendations, are beyond our control. Therefore, it is imperative that you test our products, technical assistance and information to determine to your own satisfaction whether they are suitable for your intended uses and applications. Such testing has not necessarily been done by King Industries, Inc. ("King"). The facts, recommendations and suggestions herein stated are believed to be reliable; however, no guaranty or warranty of their accuracy is made. EXCEPT AS STATED, THERE ARE NO WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS OR OTHERWISE. KING SHALL NOT BE HELD LIABLE FOR SPECIAL, INCIDENTAL, CONSEQUENTIAL OR EXEMPLARY DAMAGES. Any statement inconsistent herewith is not authorized and shall not bind King. Nothing herein shall be construed as a recommendation to use any product(s) in con�ict with patents covering any material or its use. No license is implied or granted under the claims of any patent. Sales or use of all products are pursuant to Standard Terms and Conditions stated in King sales documents.
SPECIALTY CHEMICALS®
Global HeadquartersTech. Service, R&D, and SalesKing Industries, Inc.1 Science Rd.Norwalk, CT 06852Phone: 1-203-866-5551Email: [email protected]
European Tech. Sales O�ceKing Industries, InternationalNoordkade 642741 EZ WaddinxveenThe NetherlandsPhone: 31 182 631360Email: [email protected]
Asia-Paci�c Tech. Sales O�ceSynlico Tech Co., Ltd.42 Ju Lin Ya YuanRichMond Hill (Juhaoyuan)Zhongshan, ChinaPhone: 86 760 88229866Email: [email protected]
Contact Information www.kingindustries.com
Guide to NA-SUL® Rust Preventive Additives
Notes:
NA-SUL_rp_sjk_5/15
ISO 14001ISO 9001 OHSAS 18001