a modern approach to selecting capillary tubes andy · pdf filea modern approach to selecting...

54
1 1 A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy Schoen Manager, Technical Services Tecumseh Products Co.

Upload: buikhue

Post on 24-Mar-2018

255 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

1 1

A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes

Andy Schoen

Manager, Technical Services Tecumseh Products Co.

Page 2: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

2 2

Expansion Devices

Page 3: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

3 3

Hand Expansion Valve

Page 4: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

4 4

Short Tube Restrictor

Page 5: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

5 5

Automatic Expansion Valve

Page 6: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

6 6

Thermostatic Expansion Valve

Page 7: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

7 7

Electric Expansion Valve

Page 8: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

8 8

Capillary Tube

Page 9: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

9 9

Capillary Tube Flow

Bubble Point

Flow

Low ∆P High ∆P

High to Low Side ∆P

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Amount of flow determined by the tube length and ID. Is a capillary tube a regulating expansion device?
Page 10: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

10 10

Henry Ehrens

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Passed away about 8 years ago
Page 11: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

11 11

Lower Ambient Temperature

Bubble Point

Flow

Low ∆P High ∆P

High to Low Side ∆P

Presenter
Presentation Notes
If you buy in Henry Ehrens of Supco’s theory
Page 12: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

12 12

Higher Ambient Temperature

Bubble Point

Flow

Low ∆P High ∆P

High to Low Side ∆P

Page 13: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

13 13

Supco Cap Tube Chart

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Location: NJ. Founded 1945 Pioneered cap tube replacement charts
Page 14: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

14 14

J/B Cap Tube Chart

Presenter
Presentation Notes
This is the chart J/B Industries publishes Stan Jarrow, Greg Brinda founders. Location: Aurora, IL
Page 15: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

15 15

Cap Tube Sizing Problem

• Refrigerant R-134a • Medium Temp Cooler • 1/4 HP Compressor

Page 16: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

16 16

Supco Cap Tube Chart

Presenter
Presentation Notes
BC2 = 0.040” ID, 0.093” OD capillary
Page 17: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

17 17

Compressor HP vs Rating

Model Btu/h

TPA0421YXA 2050

TPA9421YXA 2075

TPA9423YXA 2320

AEA9423YXA 2390

TPB9423YAA 2675

1/4 HP R-134a Commercial Temp Compressors

Page 18: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

18 18

Supco Cap Tube Chart

Presenter
Presentation Notes
A chart like this can be reasonable accurate when we consider one refrigerant
Page 19: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

19 19

Wolf and Pate Correlations

1995

2002

Page 20: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

20 20

Characteristics Considered

• Capillary Tube Length and ID • Pressure (liquid and vapor) • Density (liquid and vapor) • Viscosity (liquid and vapor) • Specific Heat (liquid and vapor) • Surface Tension (liquid) • Amount of Subcooling • Latent Heat of Vaporization • Heat Exchange Length

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Test data using R-134a, R-22, R-410A, and isobutane
Page 21: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

21 21

Edgar Buckingham

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Harvard physicist. Worked for NBS in early 1900. Published Buckingham pi theorem in 1914
Page 22: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

22 22

Buckingham π Correlation

( )

( )

)1(23

121

321

21

...

, ... ,,

0, ... ,,

−−−

⋅⋅⋅=

=

=

mnamn

aa

mn

n

f

qqqf

ππππ

ππππ

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Form non-dimensional groups that Edgar called “pi groups”
Page 23: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

23 23

15 Different Parameters

Page 24: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

24 24

Wolf and Pate 2002 Correlation

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Test data using R-134a, R-22, R-410A, and isobutane
Page 25: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

25 25

Characteristics To Determine

• Capillary Tube Length and ID • Pressure (liquid and vapor) • Density (liquid and vapor) • Viscosity (liquid and vapor) • Specific Heat (liquid and vapor) • Amount of Subcooling • Latent Heat of Vaporization • Heat Exchange Length

Page 26: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

26 26

NIST Refprop

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Version 6 available in 1998. Result of the proliferation of refrigerants due to the Montreal Protocol NBS -> NIST
Page 27: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

27 27

Tecumseh Web App Site

Page 28: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

28 28

Capillary Tube Sizing Web App

Page 29: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

29 29

Capillary Tube Sizing Web App

Page 30: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

30 30

Capillary Tube Sizing Web App

Page 31: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

31 31

Capillary Tube Sizing Web App

Page 32: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

32 32

Capillary Tube Sizing Web App

Page 33: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

33 33

Adiabatic vs Non-adiabatic

Page 34: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

34 34

Heat Exchange Length

Page 35: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

35 35

Heat Exchange Length

Page 36: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

36 36

Why use heat exchange length?

Page 37: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

37 37

Web App Selection using HP

Page 38: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

38 38

Supco Cap Tube Chart

Presenter
Presentation Notes
BC2 = 0.040” ID, 0.093” OD capillary
Page 39: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

39 39

Web App Selection using HP

Page 40: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

40 40

R401A Selection using HP

Page 41: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

41 41

R401A Selection using HP

Page 42: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

42 42

R401A Selection using HP

Page 43: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

43 43

TPA9423YXA

Page 44: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

44 44

TPA9423YXA Selection at AHRI CBP

Page 45: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

45 45

TPA9423YXA

Page 46: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

46 46

TPA9423YXA Selection @ 25°F/110°F

Page 47: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

47 47

Cap Tube Selection using Comp Model

Page 48: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

48 48

Cap Tube Selection using Comp Model

Page 49: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

49 49

Cap Tube Selection using Comp Model

Page 50: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

50 50

Cap Tube Selection using Comp Model

Page 51: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

51 51

Supco Cap Tube Chart

Presenter
Presentation Notes
BC2 = 0.040” ID, 0.093” OD capillary
Page 52: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

52 52

Cap Tube Selection using Comp Model

Page 53: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

53 53

Cap Tube Chart using Btu/h

Page 54: A Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes Andy · PDF fileA Modern Approach to Selecting Capillary Tubes ... Capillary Tube Sizing Web App : 29 : ... Cap Tube Selection using

54 54

Questions?