a monumental glass wall presentation

97
JIM GOETTSCH STEVE NILLES LARRY WELDON JOACHIM SCHUESSLER ED ZIMMERMAN ERIK HARRIS VINCE RIGG JONATHAN REYNOLDS KEVIN MYERS DAVID HOOD VICTOR HERNANDEZ O’DONNELL INVESTMENT COMPANY 150 NORTH RIVERSIDE

Upload: the-architects-newspaper

Post on 02-Apr-2016

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation by Steve Nilles of Goettsch Partners and Chris Stutzki of Stutzki Engineering - Facades+ Chicago 2014

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

JIM GOETTSCH STEVE NILLES LARRY WELDON JOACHIM SCHUESSLER ED ZIMMERMAN ERIK HARRIS VINCE RIGG JONATHAN REYNOLDS KEVIN MYERS DAVID HOOD VICTOR HERNANDEZ

O’DONNELL INVESTMENT COMPANY

150 NORTH RIVERSIDE

Page 2: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

PROJECT+SITE HISTORY

OVERBUILD+LOBBY

LOBBY WALL

Page 3: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

•  Vacant for more than 50 years •  Only undeveloped site along the river in CBD •  Significant limitations due to adjacent railroad

lines

Page 4: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Existing Site - 1928

Page 5: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Existing Site - Today

Page 6: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

•  Office tower is situated as far east as possible from adjacent building

•  The Randolph Place building is 122’ away, which is approx. equal to Wacker Drive or Michigan Avenue at Oak St.

•  These are the two widest streets in the CBD

Page 7: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

RIVERWALK DISTRICT

RA

ND

OLP

H S

TREE

T

LAK

E ST

REE

T

WA

SHIN

GTO

N S

TREE

T

Page 8: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

PARCEL 01

PARCEL 02

PARCEL 03

Owned by Developer

City Right-of-Way - Amtrak granted permanent easements for active rail lines

Owned by Amtrak – Developer under contract with Amtrak for Air Rights

Site Survey – Property Ownership

Page 9: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 10: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

PROJECT+SITE HISTORY

OVERBUILD+LOBBY

LOBBY WALL

Page 11: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

January 2013 • 2-1/2 story parking structure • Parking reduced by 50 spaces • Plaza retail reduced 20% • Public ‘piazza’ • Landscape increased by 20%

Evolution of Plaza / Park Design

October 2011 •  3-story parking structure •  Public park 35’ above

plaza •  200 parking spaces •  ½ acre of hardscape

July 2013 •  1-story parking structure,

hidden underneath park •  Parking reduced to 75

spaces •  Landscaping constitutes

more than 75% of total site area

•  Continuous landscaping along Randolph St

•  The prior designs are but a representative sample of more than 10 iterations on design

•  20+ meetings with Alderman and DHED over 18+ months •  Current plan reflects continual refinement and improvement to quality of public

space

Page 12: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 13: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 14: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 15: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

PLAZA LEVEL PLAN TRACK LEVEL PLAN

Page 16: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

PLAZA LEVEL PLAN TRACK LEVEL PLAN

Page 17: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

PLAZA LEVEL PLAN PLAZA LEVEL PLAN

Page 18: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 19: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 20: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 21: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 22: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 23: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 24: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

PARK LEVEL PLAN

LAK

E ST

REE

T

RA

ND

OLP

H S

TREE

T

Page 25: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

VIEW OF MEZZANINE

Page 26: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

VIEW OF MEZZANINE

Page 27: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 28: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 29: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 30: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

PROJECT+SITE HISTORY

OVERBUILD+LOBBY

LOBBY WALL

Page 31: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 32: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 33: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

60,000 lbs

60,000 lbs

Page 34: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

16,000 lbs

Page 35: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

GLASS FINS HEAD DETAIL

Page 36: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

GLASS FINS TYPICAL PATCH FITTING

Page 37: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

GLASS FINS WIND PROP

Page 38: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

GLASS FINS SPLICE CONNECTION

Page 39: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

GLASS FINS CONNECTION AT FEATURE WALL

•  Force resisted by the topping slab of double-T over garage.

6,700 lbs

Page 40: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

TRUSS FIN

Page 41: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

A  Monumental  Glass  Wall  on  the  new  high-­‐rise  project  150  North  Riverside,  Chicago  

Page 42: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 43: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 44: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 45: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

•  Safety •  Economy •  Innovation

Page 46: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Safety  

Photo:  Claus  Bellers  

Page 47: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

The  5  R’s  of  Glass  Design    *)  -  Resistance  -  RetenLon  -  Redundancy  -  Residual  Capacity  -  RegulaLons  

                         *)  from:  Richard  Green:  An  ASTM  Guide  for  Structural  Glass;  Philadelphia,  2014    

Page 48: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

- Resistance  - RetenLon  - Redundancy  - Residual  Capacity  - RegulaLons    

Page 49: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

- Resistance  - RetenLon  - Redundancy  - Residual  Capacity  - RegulaLons    

Page 50: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

- Resistance  - RetenLon  - Redundancy  - Residual  Capacity  - RegulaLons    

Page 51: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Economy  

Page 52: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 53: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 54: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 55: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 56: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 57: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 58: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Result: a two-part glass fin, one splice, 3 layers of ½ “ glass= 1 ½ “ thick, 32” wide

Page 59: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

InnovaLon  

Photo:  Jason  Krugman  

Page 60: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Steel-­‐  reinforced  glass  beams  

Page 61: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Steel-­‐  reinforced  glass  beams  

Page 62: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Degree of Innovation

Time InnovaLon  in  our  Industry:  

 -­‐  List  of  ingredients  

Page 63: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Degree of Innovation

Time

Float Glass

InnovaLon  in  our  Industry:    -­‐  List  of  ingredients  

Page 64: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Degree of Innovation

Time

Float Glass

Laminated Glass

InnovaLon  in  our  Industry:    -­‐  List  of  ingredients  

Page 65: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Degree of Innovation

Time

Float Glass

Laminated Glass

Low Iron Glass

InnovaLon  in  our  Industry:    -­‐  List  of  ingredients  

Page 66: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Degree of Innovation

Time

Float Glass

Laminated Glass

Low Iron Glass

Structural Silicone

InnovaLon  in  our  Industry:    -­‐  List  of  ingredients  

Page 67: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Degree of Innovation

Time

Float Glass

Laminated Glass

Low Iron Glass

Structural Silicone

Structural Interlayers (e.g. Sentry Glass)

InnovaLon  in  our  Industry:    -­‐  List  of  ingredients  

Page 68: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Degree of Innovation

Time

Float Glass

Laminated Glass

Low Iron Glass

Structural Silicone

Structural Interlayers (e.g. Sentry Glass)

Large Glass

InnovaLon  in  our  Industry:    -­‐  List  of  ingredients  

Page 69: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Degree of Innovation

Time

Float Glass

Laminated Glass

Low Iron Glass

Structural Silicone

Structural Interlayers (e.g. Sentry Glass)

Large Glass

Engineered Structural Glass

InnovaLon  in  our  Industry:    -­‐  List  of  ingredients  

Page 70: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Solution effort

Time

Theoretical solution/ engineering

production

InnovaLon  in  our  Industry:    -­‐  List  of  ingredients    -­‐  Lmeline    

Page 71: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

InnovaLon  in  our  Industry:    -­‐  List  of  ingredients    -­‐  Lmeline      -­‐  the  kill  switch  (tradiLonal  esLmaLng)  

weight

Cost

Page 72: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

weight

Cost

Traditional estimating

InnovaLon  in  our  Industry:    -­‐  List  of  ingredients    -­‐  Lmeline      -­‐  the  kill  switch  (tradiLonal  esLmaLng)  

Page 73: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

weight

Cost

innovative Structures

Traditional estimating

Innovative approach

InnovaLon  in  our  Industry:    -­‐  List  of  ingredients    -­‐  Lmeline      -­‐  the  kill  switch  (tradiLonal  esLmaLng)  

Page 74: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

   

•  Pushing  for  innovaLon:  – Managing  conflict  energy  of  different  interests  – Managing  “crazy”  people  –  Taking  advantage  of  the  conflict  between  architects  and  engineers  

InnovaLon  in  our  Industry:    -­‐  List  of  ingredients    -­‐  Lmeline      -­‐  the  kill  switch  (tradiLonal  esLmaLng)    -­‐  managing  innovaLon  

Page 75: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Owner

General Contractor

Architect & Consultants

INNOVATION

pressure cooker of a building process:

Specialty Contractors

Specialty Contractor

Cost  Time  

Page 76: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Steps  to  the  new  soluLon  of    Steel-­‐  reinforced  glass  beams  

Page 77: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Glass  Sculpture:  Flight  of  the  Cranes,                                      year  1992    ArLst:  Renato  Santarossa          Engineer:  Professor  Sedlacek,            InsLtute  for  Steel  Structures,  Aachen  

Steps  to  the  new  soluLon  of    Steel-­‐  reinforced  glass  beams  

Page 78: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

78  Steps  to  the  new  soluLon  of    Steel-­‐  reinforced  glass  beams  

Glazed  Cable  Wall  with  exterior  glass  fins  

                           year  2002    ArLst:  James  Carpenter  Engineer:  Chris  Stutzki

     

Page 79: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Steps  to  the  new  soluLon  of    Steel-­‐  reinforced  glass  beams  

Glazed  Cable  Wall                year  2004    Architect:  Goecsch  Partners  (Steve  Nilles)      

Page 80: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Steps  to  the  new  soluLon  of    Steel-­‐  reinforced  glass  beams  

Page 81: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Glass  beam  to  resist  wind  

Wind  force  

Steps  to  the  new  soluLon  of    Steel-­‐  reinforced  glass  beams  

Page 82: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Wind  force  

Glass  beam  and  fin  to  resist  wind  

Page 83: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Glass  beams  to  resist  wind  

Page 84: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Glass  beam  and  fin  to  resist  wind  

Page 85: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Glass  beam  and  cable  to  resist  wind  

Page 86: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 87: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 88: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 89: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 90: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 91: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 92: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 93: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 94: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation
Page 95: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

These  were  the    

Page 96: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

InnovaLon  in  our  Industry:    -­‐  List  of  ingredients    -­‐  Lmeline      -­‐  the  kill  switch  (tradiLonal  esLmaLng)    -­‐  managing  innovaLon  

Do  enough  upfront  research    to  encourage  contractors  to  bid  this  for  a  reasonable  price,    and  to  convince  bidders    that  the  risk  is  under  control  

Page 97: A Monumental Glass Wall Presentation

Do  enough  upfront  research    to  encourage  contractors  to  bid  this  for  a  reasonable  price,    and  to  convince  bidders    that  the  risk  is  under  control  

Thank  you!