acc objection to garlock amended 2019 motion (p0197685)

8/3/2019 Acc Objection to Garlock Amended 2019 Motion (p0197685)

1/14

{D0197657.1 }

IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT

FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE

IN RE:

ACandS, Inc.Armstrong World Industries, Inc.Combustion Engineering, Inc.

The Flintkote CompanyKaiser Aluminum Corp.

Owens CorningUS Mineral Products Company

USG Corp.W.R. Grace & Co.

Debtors.

Case No.: 02-12687 (Rel. Dkt. Nos. 3650, 3660)Case No.: 00-4471 (Rel. Dkt. Nos. 10711, 10721)Case No.: 03-10495 (Rel. Dkt. Nos. 3391, 3400)

Case No.: 04-11300 (Rel. Dkt. Nos. 5668, 5693)Case No.: 02-10429 (Rel. Dkt. Nos. 10025, 10044)



IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURTFOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA

IN RE:

Mid-Valley, Inc.

North American Refractories Co.Pittsburgh Corning Corp.

Debtors.

Case No.: 03-35592 (Rel. Dkt. Nos. 2783, 2792)


Hearing Date: March 28, 2011 @ 9:00 a.m.

OBJECTION OF THE OFFICIAL COMMITTEES OF ASBESTOS CLAIMANTS INTHE FLINTKOTE, GRACE, NARCO AND PITTSBURGH CORNING

BANKRUPTCIES TO GARLOCKS AMENDED MOTION FOR ORDERS

AUTHORIZING ACCESS TO 2019 STATEMENTS AND RELATED RELIEF

The Official Committees of Asbestos Claimants in the Flintkote, Grace, NARCO and

Pittsburgh Corning bankruptcy cases (the ACCs) hereby object (the "Objection") to the

Amended Motion of Garlock Sealing Technologies LLC for Orders Authorizing Access to 2019

Statements Filed in This Court and For Related Relief (the Amended 2019 Motion). In

support of this Objection, the ACCs respectfully state as follows:

1. On January 10, 2011, Garlock Sealing Technologies (Garlock) filed theMotion for Order Authorizing Access to 2019 Statements filed in this Court(the "Original 2019


2/14

{D0197657.1 }

- 2 -

Motion").

2. On February 7, 2011, the ACC's filed the Joinder and Objection of the OfficialCommittees of Asbestos Claimants in the Flintkote, Grace, NARCO and Pittsburgh Corning

Bankruptcies to Garlock's Motion for Orders Authorizing Access to 2019 Statements and Related

Relief (the "ACC Joinder and Objection").

3. On February 14, 2011, a hearing was held on the Original 2019 Motion. At thehearing, counsel to the ACCs presented arguments in opposition to the Original 2019 Motion.

4. On February 18, 2011, Garlock filed the Amended 2019 Motion15.

The ACCs hereby incorporates by reference, as if fully set forth herein, the

arguments contained and the positions taken in the ACC Joinder and Objection. In addition, the

ACCs hereby incorporate by reference the arguments presented at the February 14, 2011 hearing

in opposition to the Original 2019 Motion.

For the foregoing reasons, the ACCs respectfully request that Garlocks Amended 2019

Motion be denied.

Dated: March 11, 2011 Respectfully submitted,

CAMPBELL & LEVINE, LLC

/s/ David B. Salzman

Douglas A. Campbell (PA ID No. 23143)

Philip E. Milch (PA I.D. No. 53519)David B. Salzman (PA I.D. No. 39360)

1700 Grant BuildingPittsburgh, PA 15219

Telephone: (412) 261-0310Facsimile: (412) 261-5066

[email protected]@camlev.com

[email protected]

CAMPBELL & LEVINE, LLC

/s/ Mark T. Hurford

Marla R. Eskin (DE Bar No. 2989)

Mark T. Hurford (DE Bar No. 3299)800 N. King Street, Suite 300

Wilmington, DE 19801Telephone: (302) 426-1900

Facsimile: (302) [email protected]

[email protected]

and

1At footnote one of the Amended 2019 Motion Garlock states that it "previously filed asubstantively identical motion in the above-captioned cases..."


3/14

{D0197657.1 }

- 3 -

and

CAPLIN & DRYSDALE, CHARTERED

Peter Van N. Lockwood

Trevor W. SwettKevin C. MaclayOne Thomas Circle, NW

Suite 1100Washington, DC 20005

Telephone: (202) 862-5000Facsimile: (202) 429-3301

E-mail: [email protected]; [email protected]@capdale.com

CAPLIN & DRYSDALE, CHARTERED

Elihu Inselbuch

375 Park Avenue, 35th FloorNew York, NY 10152-3500Telephone: (212) 319-7125

Facsimile: (212) 644-6755E-mail: [email protected]

Counsel for the Official Committees of Asbestos Claimants


4/14


FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE

In re:

ACandS, Inc.

Armstrong World Industries, Inc.Combustion Engineering, Inc.

The Flintkote Company

Kaiser Aluminum Corp.Owens Corning

US Mineral Products Company

USG Corp.

W.R. Grace & Co.

Debtors.









FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA

In re:

Mid-Valley, Inc.

North American Refractories Co.Pittsburgh Corning Corp.

Debtors.


Case No.:02-20198 (Rel. Dkt. Nos. 6984, 6998)Case No.:00-22876 (Rel. Dkt. Nos. 8139, 8162)

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

The undersigned hereby certifies that on March 11, 2011, I caused a copy of the Objection of TheOfficial Committees of Asbestos Claimants in the Flintkote, Grace, NARCO and Pittsburgh Corning

Bankruptcies to Garlocks Amended Motion for Orders Authorizing Access to 2019 Statements and

Related Reliefto be served upon the individuals on the attached service lists by electronic mail.

Respectfully submitted,

Dated: March 11, 2011 /s/ David B. Salzman

David B. Salzman

PA ID No. 39360

CAMPBELL & LEVINE, LLC1700 Grant Building

Pittsburgh, PA 15219T: 412-261-0310/ F: 412-261-5066

Email: [email protected]


5/14

Gregory W. Werkheiser, Esquire

Matthew B. Harvey, EsquireMorris, Nichols, Arsht & Tunnell LP

1201 North Market Street, 18th Floor

P.O. Box 1347Wilmington, DE 19899-1347Tel: 302-658-9200/ Fax: [email protected]@mnat.com

Arthur H. Stroyd, Jr. , Esquire

Richard A. Swanson, EsquireDel Sole Cavanaugh Stroyd LLC

The Waterfront Building

200 First Avenue, Suite 300Pittsburgh, PA 15222Tel: 412-261-2393/ Fax: 412-261-2110

[email protected]@dscslaw.com

Garland S. Cassada, Esquire

Richard C. Worf, Jr. , EsquireRobinson, Bradshaw & Hinson

101 North Tryon Street, Suite 1900Charlotte, NC 28246

Tel: 704-377-8317/ Fax: [email protected]

[email protected]

Daniel K. Hogan, Esquire

The Hogan Firm1311 Delaware Avenue

Wilmington, Delaware 19806Tel: 302-656-7540/ Fax: 302-656-7599

[email protected]

Peter J. Ashcroft, EsquireBernstein Law Firm, P.C.

Suite 2200 Gulf TowerPittsburgh, PA 15219

Tel: 412-456-8107/ Fax: 412-456-8255


Sander L. Esserman, EsquireDavid A. Klingler, Esquire

David J. Parsons, EsquireCliff I. Taylor, Esquire

Stutzman, Bromberg, Esserman & Plifka

2323 Bryan Street, Suite 2200Dallas, Texas 75201Tel: 214-969-4900/ Fax: 214-969-4999

[email protected]@sbep-law.com

[email protected]@sbep-law.com

Natalie D. Ramsey, Esquire

Laurie A. Krepto, EsquireMontgomery, Mccracken,

Walker & Rhoads, LLP123 S. Broad Street

Philadelphia, PA 19109Tel: 215-772-1500/ Fax: 215-772-7620

[email protected]@mmwr.com

Ellen C. Brotman, Esquire

Montgomery, McCracken,Walker & Rhoads, LLP

123 South Broad StreetAvenue of the Arts

Philadelphia, PA [email protected]


6/14

Joseph F. Rice, EsquireJohn Baden, Esquire

Motley Rice LLC28 Bridgeside Blvd.

Mt. Pleasant, SC 29464

Tel: 843-216-9000/ Fax: 843-216- [email protected]@motleyrice.com


7/14

IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURTFOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA

In re:

PITTSBURGH CORNING

CORPORATION,

Debtor.

Chapter 11

Case No. 00-22876-JKF

SERVICE LIST EFFECTIVE 9/8/2010

Counsel to Pittsburgh Corning Corporation

Rosalie J. Bell, EsquirePittsburgh Corning Corporation800 Presque Isle DrivePittsburgh, PA 15239-2779

Tel: 724-733-3838/ Fax: 724-387-3809Email: [email protected]

David Ziegler, Esquire

Reed Smith LLPReed Smith Center

225 Fifth Avenue, Suite 1200Pittsburgh, PA 15222


James J. Restivo, Jr., EsquireReed Smith LLPReed Smith Center225 Fifth Avenue

Pittsburgh, PA 15222Tel: 412-288-3122/ Fax: 412-288-3063


Douglas E. Cameron, EsquireReed Smith LLP

Reed Smith Center225 Fifth Avenue



Counsel to Official Committee of Asbestos Creditors

Elihu Inselbuch, EsquireCaplin & Drysdale, Chartered

375 Park Avenue, 35th

FloorNew York, NY 10152-3500

Tel: 212-319-7125/ Fax: 1-212-644-6755


Peter Van N. Lockwood, Esquire

Caplin & Drysdale, CharteredOne Thomas Circle N.W.

Washington, DC 20005Tel: 202-862-5000/ Fax: 1-202-429-3301


Douglas A. Campbell, EsquireEmail: [email protected]

Philip E. Milch, EsquireEmail: [email protected]

Campbell & Levine, LLC

1700 Grant BuildingPittsburgh, PA 15219Tel: 412-261-0310/ Fax: 412-261-5066


8/14

Counsel to Official Committee of Trade Creditors

David W. Lampl, EsquireLeech, Tishman, Fuscaldo & Lampl, LLC

Citizens Bank Building, 30th

Floor525 William Penn Place



Counsel to Shareholders

Counsel to PPG Industries, Inc.

Peter J. Kalis, EsquireEmail: [email protected]

David A. Murdoch, EsquireEmail: [email protected]

Neal R. Brendel, Esquire

Email: [email protected] F. McGonigle, EsquireEmail: [email protected]

K&L Gates, LLP210 Sixth Avenue


Counsel to Corning Incorporated

Kimberly Luff Wakim, EsquireThorp Reed & Armstrong

One Oxford Centre, 14

th

Floor301 Grant Street



Cheryl A. Heller, EsquireWard Greenberg Heller & Reidy LLP

300 State StreetRochester, NY 14614


Counsel to PNC Bank Office of the United States Trustee

Brad Erens, Esquire

Jones, Day, Reavis & Pogue77 West Wacker

Chicago, IL 60601

Tel: 312-269-4050/ Fax: 1-312-782-8585Email: [email protected]

Joseph M. Fornari, Jr., Esquire

970 Liberty Center1001 Liberty Avenue

Pittsburgh, PA 15222



9/14

Legal Representative for Counsel to Legal Representative

Future Claimants for Future Claimants

Mr. Lawrence Fitzpatrick

100 American Metro Blvd.Suite 108

Hamilton, NJ 08619Tel: 609-219-8862/ Fax: 609-620-1466


Joel M. Helmrich, Esquire

Dinsmore & Shohl, LLPOne Oxford Centre

301 Grant Street; Suite 2800Pittsburgh, PA 15219


James L. Patton Jr., EsquireEmail: [email protected]

Edwin J. Harron, EsquireEmail: [email protected]

Young Conaway Stargatt & Taylor, LLPThe Brandywine Building, 17

thFloor

1000 West Street

Wilmington, DE 19801Tel: 302-571-6600/ Fax: 302-571-1253

Others

C. Sanders McNew, Esquire

Weitz & Luxenberg, P.C.100 Maiden Lane

New York, NY 10038Tel: 212-558-5500/ Fax: 1-212-344-5461


Robert Knights, Esquire

Gertler, Gertler, Vincent & Plotkin127-128 Carondelet Street

New Orleans, LA 70130Tel: 504-581-6411/ Fax: 1-504-581-6568


R. Kenneth Willman, Esquire

Willman & ArnoldOne Corporate Center

5500 Corporate Drive, STE 150Pittsburgh, PA 15237

T: 412-366-3333/ F: 412-366-3462Email: [email protected]

Thomas M. Crawford, Esquire

Litchfield Cavo303 West Madison Street, Suite 200

Chicago, IL 60606T: 312-781-6677/ F: 1-312-781-6630


Jeffrey J. Leech, EsquireMichael Shiner, Esquire

Tucker Arensberg, P.C.1500 One PPG Place


T: 412-594-5524/ F: 412-594-5619Email: [email protected]: [email protected]

Robert A. Simon, EsquireBarlow Garsek & Simon, LLP

3815 Lisbon StreetFort Worth, TX 76107

Tel: 817-731-4500/ Fax: 817-731-6200

Counsel to the DurhamsEmail: [email protected]


10/14


FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA

In re:

NORTH AMERICAN REFRACTORIES

COMPANY, et al.,

Debtors.

Chapter 11

Case No. 02-20198-JKF

OFFICIAL SERVICE LIST EFFECTIVE 9/8/2010

Office of the U.S. Trustee

Attn: Kathy Robb, EsquireLiberty Center, Suite 970

1001 Liberty Avenue


T: 412-644-4752/ F: 412-644-4785

[email protected]

Robert P. Simons, Esquire

Reed Smith LLP225 Fifth Avenue, STE 2800


T: 412-288-7294/ F: 412-288-3063

Counsel to Debtors

[email protected]

Elihu Inselbuch, Esquire

Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered

375 Park Avenue, 35th Floor

New York, NY 10152-3500

T: 212-319-7125/ F: 212-644-6755Counsel to Official Committee of Asbestos

Creditors

[email protected]

Peter Van N. Lockwood, Esquire

Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered

One Thomas Circle, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20005-5802

T: 202-862-5000/ F: 202-429-3301Counsel to Official Committee of Asbestos

Creditors

[email protected]

Philip E. Milch, Esquire

Campbell & Levine, LLC

1700 Grant Building


T: 412-261-0310/ F: 412-261-5066

Counsel to Official Committee of Asbestos

Creditors

[email protected]

Robert G. Sable, Esquire

Sally Edison, Esquire

McGuire Woods, LLP

Dominion Tower, 23rd Floor

625 Liberty Avenue


T: 412-667-7936/ F: 412-667-6050

Counsel to Official Committee of UnsecuredTrade Creditors

[email protected]

[email protected]


11/14

Jon A. Allegretti, Esquire

North American Refractories Company

Cherrington Corporate Center

400 Fairway Drive

Moon Township, PA 15108

T: 412-375-6674F: 412-375-6957

[email protected]

Daniel M. Lewis, Esquire

Arnold & Porter

555 12th Street NW

Washington, DC 20004-1206

Tel. 202-942-5661

Fax. 202-942-5999Counsel to Honeywell [email protected]

Peter J. Sacripanti, EsquireStephen B. Selbst EsquireMcDermott, Will & Emery50 Rockefeller PlazaNew York NY 10020Tel: 212 547 5583Fax: 1-212-547-5444Counsel to Honeywell [email protected]

[email protected]

Mr. Lawrence Fitzpatrick100 American Metro Blvd.Suite 108Hamilton, NJ 08619Tel: 609-219-8862Fax: [email protected] Representative for Future Claimants

Joel M. Helmrich, Esquire

Dinsmore & Shohl, LLP

One Oxford Centre, Suite 2800

301 Grant StreetPittsburgh, PA 15219Tel: 412-288-5880Fax:412-281-5055Counsel to the Legal Representative for [email protected]

James L. Patton Jr., EsquireEdwin J. Harron, EsquireYoung Conaway Stargatt & Taylor, LLPThe Brandywine Building, 17

thFloor

1000 West StreetWilmington, DE 19801Tel: 302-571-6600Fax: 302-571-1253Counsel to the Legal Representative for [email protected]@ycst.com


12/14

In re:MID-VALLEY, INC., et ai.,

IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURTWESTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA

Jointly Administered atCase No. 03-35592 JKFChapter 11

Debtors.

))))))

OFFICIAL SERVICE LIST EFFECTIVE 01/06/05

Albert O. CornelisonExecutive Vice President &General CounselHalliburton Company1401 McKinney, Suite 2400Houston, TX 77010Ph: 713.759.2620Fax: 713.759.2622Email: [email protected]

Jeffrey N. Rich, EsquireK&L Gates LL P599 Lexington AvenueNew York, NY 10022-6030Ph: 212.536.4097Fax: 212.536.3901Email: [email protected]

Frank H. Griffm, ill, EsquireGollatz, Griffm & EwingFour Penn Center, Suite 2001600 John F. Kennedy BoulevardPhiladelphia, PA 19103-2803Ph: 215.563.9400Fax: 215.665.9988Email: fgriffin @ggelaw.com

Bruce StanskiSenior Vice President and CFOKellogg Brown & Root4100 Clinton DriveHouston, TX 77020Ph: 713.753.4908Fax: 713.753.2017Email: [email protected]

Counsel to Mid-Valley, Inc., et aleMichael G. Zanic, EsquireK&L Gates LLPHenry W. Oliver Building535 Smithfield StreetPittsburgh, PA 15222Ph: 412.355.6219Fax: 412.355.6501Email: [email protected]

Accountants & Financial Consultants to Mid-Valley, Inc . et aleThomas D. BibbyMesirow Financial Consulting, LLC717 North Harwood StreetSuite 3100Dallas, TX 75201Ph: 214.840.2479Fax: 214.840.2180Email: [email protected]

PI-I088388 vI

Dr. Francine K. RabinovitzHamilton, Rabinovitz & Alschuler, Inc.26384 Carmel Rancho Lane, Suite 202Carmel, CA 93923Ph: 831.626.1350Fax: 831.626.1351Email: [email protected]


13/14

Counsel to Committee of Asbestos CreditorsPeter Van N. Lockwood, EsquireCaplin & Drysdale, CharteredOne Thomas Circle N.W.Washington, DC 20005Ph: 202.862.5000Fax: 202.429.3301Email: [email protected] E. Milch, EsquireCampbell & Levine, LLC1700 Grant BuildingPittsburgh, PA 15219Ph: 412.261.0310Fax: 412.261.5066Email: [email protected]

Jack L. Kinzie, EsquireMichael C. Li, EsquireBaker Botts LLP2001 Ross AvenueDallas, TX 75201Ph: 214.953.6500Fax: 214.953.6503Email: [email protected]: [email protected]: [email protected]

Office of the U.S. Trustee

Joseph Sisca, EsquireOffice of the U.S. Trustee970 Liberty Center1001 Liberty AvenuePittsburgh, PA 15222Ph: 412.644.4756Fax: 412.644.4785Email: [email protected]

Elihu Inselbuch, EsquireCaplin & Drysdale, Chartered375 Park Avenue, 35th FloorNew York, NY 10152-3500Ph: 212.319.7125Fax: 212.644.6755Email: [email protected]

Counsel to Halliburton and RESITony M. Davis, EsquireBaker Botts LLPOne Shell Plaza910 LouisianaHouston, TX 77002-4995Ph: 713.229.1234Fax: 713.229.1522Email: [email protected]

Counsel to Legal Representativefor Future Claimants

James L. Patton Jr., EsquireEdwin J. Harron, EsquireYoung Conaway Stargatt & Taylor LLPThe Brandywine Building, 17 th Floor1000 West StreetWilmington, DE 19801Ph: 302.571.6600Fax: 302.571.1253Email: [email protected]: [email protected] M. Helmrich, EsquireDinsmore & Shohl LLPOne Oxford Centre301 Grant Street, Suite 2800Pittsburgh, PA 15219Tel: 412-288-5880Fax: 412-281-5055Email: [email protected]

2


14/14

John W. Burns. EsquireDickie, McCamey & Chilcote, P.C.Two PPG Place - Suite 400Pittsburgh, PA 15222Ph: 412.392.5413Fax: 412.392.5367Email: [email protected]

Steven P. Rice, EsquireCrowell & Moring LLP3 Park Plaza, 20th FloorIrvine, CA 92614-8505Ph: 949.263.8400Fax: 949.263.8414Email: [email protected]

Philip D. Anker. EsquireWilmer Cutler Pickering Hale & DOff LLP399 Park AvenueNew York, NY 10022Ph: 212.230.8800Fax: 212.230.8888Email: [email protected]

Katherine Worthman, EsquireJames A. Shepherd, EsquireWilmer Cutler Pickering Hale & DOff LLP2445 M. Street, N.W.Washington, DC 20037Ph: 202.663.6000Fax: 202.663.6363Email: [email protected]: [email protected] R. Very, EsquirePepper Hamilton LLP500 Grant Street, 50 th FloorPittsburgh, PA 15219-2502Ph: 412.454.5000Fax: 412.281.0717Email: [email protected]

Mark D. Plevin, EsquireClifton S. Elgarten, EsquireFrederick W. Claybrook, Jr., EsquireLeslie A. Epley, EsquireJames T. Hubler. EsquireCrowell & Moring LLP1001 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.Washington, DC 20004-2595Ph: 202.624.2500Fax: 202.628.5116Email: [email protected]: [email protected]: [email protected]: [email protected]: [email protected] R. Koepff, EsquireTancred V. Schiavoni, EsquireO'Melveny & Myers LLPTimes Square Tower7 Times SquareNew York, NY 10036Ph: 212.326.2000Fax: 212.326.2061Email: [email protected]: [email protected] Morse, EsquireNancy Manzer, EsquireLinda Chanow, EsquireWilmer Cutler Pickering Hale & DOff LLP1600 Tysons Boulevard10 th FloorTysons Comer, VA 22102Ph: 703.251.9700Fax: 703.251.9797Email: [email protected]: [email protected]: [email protected] K. Sinha, EsquireDKW Law Group LLC58th Floor, US Steel Tower600 Grant StreetPittsburgh, PA 15219Ph: 412.355.2600Fax: 412.355.2609Email: [email protected]

Thomas H. Grace, EsquireW. Steven Bryant, EsquireLocke Liddell & Sapp LLP3400 Chase Tower, 6600 Travis StreetHouston, TX 77002-3095Ph: 713.226.1200Fax: 713.223.3717Email: [email protected]: [email protected]

3

acc objection to garlock amended 2019 motion (p0197685)

Documents