aci financial analysis

11
Parvez M Chowdhury (880) 174 167 4023; [email protected] ACI Limited ACI Limited January 2010 January 2010 Rating: Rating: SECTOR PERFORM SECTOR PERFORM Target Price: BDT 675 Target Price: BDT 675 ACI Limited is one of the largest and most recognized pharmaceuticals manufacturing companies in Bangladesh. Maintaining the legacy of its predecessor company British ICI, ACI has good manufacturing practices and technical leadership in its flagship pharmaceuticals business. However, the company has expanded its business beyond pharmaceuticals encompassing agro-chemical, animal health, agro- machinery, consumer brands and retail chains. Since the company has been expanding its business horizon rather aggressively for the last few years, ACI has found itself in a cash crunch, which ultimately led the company to resort to a fair bit of leverage. Despite cash constraint, ACI is one of the more consistent dividend paying companies in the local market. We initiate our coverage of ACI Limited with a “Sector Perform” rating and a 12-month target price of BDT 675. Our recommendation considers the superior revenue generating ability of pharma business and the growth potential of ACI’s agro-chemical business whose merits are somewhat counteracted by the expansion into consumer brands and retail chain business. Our price target is based on a P/E ratio of 18x expected 2011 EPS of BDT 39.44 and 3.0x expected 2011 book value of BDT 222.03. We believe that despite its upside potential, significant risk remains because of ACI’s over-leverage and over-extension. Our target price is predicated upon ACI being able to improve its cash position by issuance of zero-coupon bonds, improvement of the retail business or outright divestment, and making sizable profit on its consumer item (salt, flour) businesses. Company Summary 52-week Price Range (BDT) 370 - 548.8 Current Price 509.7 12-month Target Price 675 Dividend Yield 2% Total Return 17% Number of Shares MM 19.4 Market Cap BDT MM 9,890.2 BDT MM 2008A 2009E 2010E Revenue 10,341.4 11,050.6 13,632.4 Ops Income 947.5 1,001.0 1,239.2 Net Income 932.9 784.7 465.4 Margins 2008A 2009E 2010E Gross Margin 30% 29% 29% Operating Margin 9% 9% 9% Net Margin 9% 7% 3% Growth 2008A 2009E 2010E Revenue Growth 80% 7% 23% Operating Income Growth 55% 6% 24% Net Income Growth 156% -16% -41% Per Share 2008A 2009E 2010E EPS 48.08 40.44 23.98 Dividend 10.00 10.00 10.00 Book Value/Share 144.92 175.36 189.34 Cashflow BDT MM 2008A 2009E 2010E Operating -1,514.2 578.4 1,114.9 Capex -1,212.1 -1,500.0 -679.5 Dividend -161.7 -194.0 -194.0 Valuation 2008A 2009E 2010E P/E 10.6x 12.6x 21.3x P/B 3.5x 2.9x 2.7x ROE 33% 23% 13% Miscellaneous BDT MM 2008A 2009E 2010E Total Debt 4,944.8 5,259.9 5,729.5 Cash 233.8 -566.8 144.3 Debt/Equity 176% 155% 156% Table 1: Performance Snapshot Source: Company Annual Reports 2006 2007 2008 2009E 2010E 2011E Sales MM BDT 4,237.9 5,756.8 10,341.4 11,050.6 13,632.4 16,139.4 YoY Growth 27% 36% 80% 7% 23% 18% Operating Income MM BDT 452.6 609.7 947.5 1,001.0 1,239.2 1,639.1 Operating Margin 33% 35% 55% 6% 24% 32% Net Income MM BDT 139.7 364.2 932.9 784.7 465.4 774.8 YoY Growth 3% 161% 156% -16% -41% 66% Net Margin 3% 6% 9% 7% 3% 5% Dividend/Share BDT 6.00 8.50 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 Total Debt MM BDT 1,776.0 3,024.0 4,944.8 5,259.9 5,729.5 5,029.5 Total Assets MM BDT 3,716.3 5,911.9 9,409.3 10,392.9 11,435.8 11,533.0 Debt/Asset 61% 64% 66% 63% 63% 56% Debt/Equity 146% 168% 176% 155% 156% 117% 0 200000 400000 600000 800000 1000000 1200000 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 12-month Price Performance Volume Close

Upload: mollah-md-naim

Post on 02-Dec-2014

206 views

Category:

Documents


5 download

DESCRIPTION

Parvez M Chowdhury(880) 174 167 4023; [email protected] LimitedJanuary 2010Company Summary 52-week Price Range (BDT) Current Price 12-month Target Price Dividend Yield Total Return Number of Shares MM Market Cap BDT MM BDT MM Revenue Ops Income Net Income Margins Gross Margin Operating Margin Net Margin Growth Revenue Growth Operating Income Growth Net Income Growth Per Share EPS Dividend Book Value/Share Cashflow BDT MM Operating Capex Dividend Valuation P/E P/B ROE Miscellaneous BDT M

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ACI Financial Analysis

Parvez M Chowdhury

(880) 174 167 4023; [email protected]

ACI LimitedACI Limited

January 2010January 2010

Rating: Rating: SECTOR PERFORMSECTOR PERFORM Target Price: BDT 675Target Price: BDT 675

ACI Limited is one of the largest and most recognized pharmaceuticals manufacturing companies in Bangladesh. Maintaining the legacy of its predecessor company British ICI, ACI has good manufacturing practices and technical leadership in its flagship pharmaceuticals business. However, the company has expanded its business beyond pharmaceuticals encompassing agro-chemical, animal health, agro-machinery, consumer brands and retail chains. Since the company has been expanding its business horizon rather aggressively for the last few years, ACI has found itself in a cash crunch, which ultimately led the company to resort to a fair bit of leverage. Despite cash constraint, ACI is one of the more consistent dividend paying companies in the local market.

We initiate our coverage of ACI Limited with a “Sector Perform” rating and a 12-month target price of BDT 675. Our recommendation considers the superior revenue generating ability of pharma business and the growth potential of ACI’s agro-chemical business whose merits are somewhat counteracted by the expansion into consumer brands and retail chain business. Our price target is based on a P/E ratio of 18x expected 2011 EPS of BDT 39.44 and 3.0x expected 2011 book value of BDT 222.03. We believe that despite its upside potential, significant risk remains because of ACI’s over-leverage and over-extension. Our target price is predicated upon ACI being able to improve its cash position by issuance of zero-coupon bonds, improvement of the retail business or outright divestment, and making sizable profit on its consumer item (salt, flour) businesses.

Company Summary

52-week Price Range (BDT) 370 - 548.8

Current Price 509.7

12-month Target Price 675

Dividend Yield 2%

Total Return 17%

Number of Shares MM 19.4

Market Cap BDT MM 9,890.2

BDT MM 2008A 2009E 2010E

Revenue 10,341.4 11,050.6 13,632.4

Ops Income 947.5 1,001.0 1,239.2

Net Income 932.9 784.7 465.4

Margins 2008A 2009E 2010E

Gross Margin 30% 29% 29%

Operating Margin 9% 9% 9%

Net Margin 9% 7% 3%

Growth 2008A 2009E 2010E

Revenue Growth 80% 7% 23%

Operating Income Growth 55% 6% 24%

Net Income Growth 156% -16% -41%

Per Share 2008A 2009E 2010E

EPS 48.08 40.44 23.98

Dividend 10.00 10.00 10.00

Book Value/Share 144.92 175.36 189.34

Cashflow BDT MM 2008A 2009E 2010E

Operating -1,514.2 578.4 1,114.9

Capex -1,212.1 -1,500.0 -679.5

Dividend -161.7 -194.0 -194.0

Valuation 2008A 2009E 2010E

P/E 10.6x 12.6x 21.3x

P/B 3.5x 2.9x 2.7x

ROE 33% 23% 13%

Miscellaneous BDT MM 2008A 2009E 2010E

Total Debt 4,944.8 5,259.9 5,729.5

Cash 233.8 -566.8 144.3

Debt/Equity 176% 155% 156%

Table 1: Performance Snapshot

Source: Company Annual Reports

2006 2007 2008 2009E 2010E 2011E

Sales MM BDT 4,237.9 5,756.8 10,341.4 11,050.6 13,632.4 16,139.4

YoY Growth 27% 36% 80% 7% 23% 18%

Operating Income MM BDT 452.6 609.7 947.5 1,001.0 1,239.2 1,639.1

Operating Margin 33% 35% 55% 6% 24% 32%

Net Income MM BDT 139.7 364.2 932.9 784.7 465.4 774.8

YoY Growth 3% 161% 156% -16% -41% 66%

Net Margin 3% 6% 9% 7% 3% 5%

Dividend/Share BDT 6.00 8.50 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00

Total Debt MM BDT 1,776.0 3,024.0 4,944.8 5,259.9 5,729.5 5,029.5

Total Assets MM BDT 3,716.3 5,911.9 9,409.3 10,392.9 11,435.8 11,533.0

Debt/Asset 61% 64% 66% 63% 63% 56%

Debt/Equity 146% 168% 176% 155% 156% 117% 0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

0

100

200

300

400

500

600 12-month Price Performance

Volume Close

Page 2: ACI Financial Analysis

ACI Limited (DSE, CSE: ACI)

Business

Advanced Chemical Industries Limited (ACI) is a leading and fast growing pharmaceutical industry in Bangladesh which was incorporated when ICI Plc of UK had sold their pharmaceutical business in 1992. At that time the name of the Company was changed to ACI Limited. ACI inherited the rich ICI culture of product quality, customer service and social responsibility and continues to nurture.

ACI is the first company in Bangladesh to obtain certification of ISO 9001 Quality Management System in 1995. ACI is also the first Company in Bangladesh to get certification of ISO 14001 Environmental Management System in 2000.

In what was primarily a Pharmaceutical business in 1992 with a turnover of Tk.80 million with stagnant growth, the new management brought about fundamental changes in policies and has in the year 2005 grown to over Tk. 3413.05 million in turnover through diversified business interest including personal care products, food products, animal health, agrochemicals and seeds in addition to gaining a strong position in Pharmaceuticals.

ACI represents principals like AstraZeneca, UCB, Searle and Fujisawa in Pharmaceuticals business; Colgate-Palmolive, Heinz & Dabur in Consumer Products sector; Syngenta in Agrochemicals; Ranbaxy, Dabur, Wockhardt, Sanofi and Invesa in Animal Health sector.

Industry

One of the fastest growing sectors with an annual average growth rate of 14-16%, Bangladesh’s pharmaceutical industry contributes to almost 1.3% of GDP. The market size was around BDT 39.0 billion in 2007. Local companies and MNCs together meet 95% of the country’s drug demand but the local manufacturers dominate the industry; they enjoy approximately 87% of market share, while multinationals hold a 13% share. Another notable feature of this sector is the concentration of sales among a very small number of top companies. The top 15 players or 6% of the manufacturers control around 73% of the market share.

Given the country's lack of spending power, the pharmaceutical market remains tiny in comparison with the population size. Pharmaceutical spending is amongst the lowest in the world in per capita terms. Healthcare expenditures consist of only 3.4% of GDP. However, the increased awareness of healthcare and the government’s increased expenditure in this sector is causing the demand to increase in this sector.

Growth and margins

ACI has been enjoying formidable growth in sales with a 4-year CAGR of 33%. Operating profit growth also remains respectable. Net profit growth, however, is not so impressive. ACI witnessed

a large jump in net profit growth in the last couple of years (161% in 2007 and 156% in 2008). These abnormal growths were a direct result of profit from sale of shares and investments. Since these extra-ordinary items are unlikely to be recurring in the future, we estimate the net profit growth will become negative for 2009 and 2010 which already look to be a testing period for the company. The profit growth rates took a hit as the company expanded aggressively to consumer brands and retail business. However, we expect the profit

2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

27% 36% 80% 7% 23% 18% Sales growth

33% 35% 55% 6% 24% 32% Operating profit growth

3% 161% 156% -16% -41% 66% Net profit growth

2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

35% 35% 30% 29% 29% 29% Gross Margin

11% 11% 9% 9% 9% 10% Operating Margin

3% 6% 9% 7% 3% 5% Net Margin

Source: Company Annual Reports and BRAC EPL Estimates

Table 2 and 3: Growth and Margin

Page 3: ACI Financial Analysis

ACI Limited (DSE, CSE: ACI)

growth to return to positive from 2011 when these segments start to produce profit themselves. ACI’s margins have been consistent and we expect them to remain similar for a while.

Outlook for 2009

From its recently published 3Q09 report, 2009 does not seem to be a very good year for ACI. Although consolidated revenue increased by 15% from BDT 7,378.9mn in 3Q08 to 8,466.4mn in 3Q09, gross profit increased by only 9% from BDT 2,261.7mn to 2,468.5mn. Net profit increased from BDT 256.0mn in 3Q08 to 437.4mn in 3Q09. However, if extraordinary income of BDT 512.8mn from sale of share is removed, profit before taxes becomes close to zero for the first three quarters of 2009. It appears that ACI is achieving its sales growth mostly from high volume low margin retail business lines. The company is rapidly growing its food, salt, flour and logistics business by committing management resources and large amount of capital. Although these are only the beginning years for these businesses with initial high capital outlays and operating expenses, the low gross margins do not foretell of very high profits in the future.

Higher leverage and worsening cash situation

ACI continued increasing its leverage through 2008 and the first nine months of 2009. Current total debt is over BDT 4.5 billion, which is about 50% higher than that in end-2007. Current debt to equity ratio is about 150%. Increase in debt, especially short-term debt occurred mainly because of higher working capital requirements. Since year-end 2007, ACI’s non-cash working capital increased by 80% by the end of 2008 and by 140% by the end of 3Q09. Most of this increase in working capital has been financed by short-term debt. Since the end of 2007, bank overdraft and short-term bank loan increased by 70%. ACI plans to increase the number of retail stores from 12 at the beginning of this year to 125 by 2010. This would require further increase in working capital. Higher short-term debt has significantly increased ACI’s financing costs. ACI paid BDT 220.5mn in financing cost for all of 2007. Financing costs during the nine months in 2009 is close to BDT 450.0mn. It appears as if ACI is borrowing short-term debt only to meet its interest expense. Currently ACI is in a negative cash position of BDT 3.5 billion (excluding long-term debt), compared to -4.0 billion in end 2008. A welcome respite in cash crunch came from the divestment of ACI Formulations shares. Since ACI separately listed ACI Formulations in 2008, it has sold 35% of the total shares for a total of BDT 1,350 million. It may prove desirable if not necessary for ACI to divest from some other businesses, especially unrelated retail businesses that need to be decoupled from the pharma and chemicals businesses.

A still attractive company, but needs clear direction

ACI’s Pharma business is still growing at a steady pace and is very profitable. Compared to an industry average of about 45%, ACI pharma achieved a gross margin of over 50% last year and 56% YTD 2009. It is investing heavily in novelty drugs such as anti-cancer, respiratory drugs and metered dose inhalers. In a market with strong pharmaceuticals manufacturers and almost no local producer of raw materials, ACI has a heads up through its investment in novel drug delivery systems (NDDS).

In the separate but related business of agrichemicals, ACI has correctly identified the need for producing and marketing high value-adding agro-supplies such as pesticides and nutrients. With a growing population, limited land and increasing demand for high-value food, demand for agro-input will continue to grow. The gross margins from this business segment is similar to pharmaceuticals.

ACI’s justification for expanding into the retail consumer market is not too convincing. Although it is a fact that huge inefficiency remains in this market, ACI is not the best placed company to take

Page 4: ACI Financial Analysis

ACI Limited (DSE, CSE: ACI)

advantage of this inefficiency. Already there are a number of contenders for the high-end and organized grocery market. It is a far-fetched plan that ACI would source the supplies for its chain-stores from the farmers that use its agro-nutrients. There is a likelihood that ACI would be able to get this business off the ground and break-even in the next couple of years, but it would not be as profitable as that of the core pharma and chemicals business. We believe that despite the challenges, ACI is a potentially good investment. In Bangladesh, there are not many professional management teams that investors can bet on. ACI has the legacy of a multinational management culture, a sound product line in pharma and chemicals, and a vision about improvement in demographics and in commercial farming. We believe with the offering of the zero-coupon bonds, ACI has taken the right step towards improving its business fundamentals. Before any new investment in ACI, it needs to be seen how well they execute the retail consumer item business.

Improving cash position - ACI 20% Convertible Zero Coupon Bonds

ACI has finalized the pricing of its convertible zero-coupon bonds. A total of 1.3 million of bonds would be offered (60% private placement, 40% public offer) at a face value of BDT 1,000 each, for a face value of BDT 1.34 billion and an issue value of BDT 1.0 billion. The bonds will mature in five years with an implied interest rate of 10.5%. Five bonds in a lot will have five different maturity dates at the end of each year and one bond from a lot will mature at the end of each year. At maturity of each respective bond, repayment will be made with 80% in cash and 20% in ordinary common shares. The conversion price at each maturity date would be 110% of the book value at the date of the last audited financial statement.

The zero-coupon bond goes a long way to finance fixed capital needs, repay some of the short-term debt and plug working capital needs. The implied interest rate (10.5%) is fairly low compared to what ACI has been paying (in excess of 14%). All these come at a price which is dilution of shares. However, Total dilution over a period of five years is less than 5%. This is a good deal for ACI.

With such cash constraints, ACI is better advised to stop cash dividend and retain cash instead. That does not seem likely because of a large family holding and for the likely effect on stock prices.

Outlook for various business segments

Pharmaceuticals:

Pharmaceuticals still constitutes the largest (24% of revenue) and most profitable business segment for ACI Limited. ACI achieved over 30% growth in the pharma segment in the last four years and lifted itself to 6th in ranking by revenue among pharma manufacturers in the country, compared to 9th position in 2007. During this time of growth, ACI maintained and improved its profitability. Compared to an average of 45% for the listed pharmaceutical companies, ACI managed over 48% gross margin in the last four years. ACI has a wide range of pharma products that includes legacy ACI brands as well as products from global manufacturers such as xx and xx. The company has a wide range of products in antibiotics, gastro-intestinal and cardiovascular classes as well as vitamin and mineral supplements and respiratory products. ACI has launched 43 new products and has been adding new respiratory and anesthetic products. The company plans to derive further growth from novelty products such as metered dose inhalers (MDI). The new MDI product line was launched in late 2009. The company also produces novel drug delivery systems (NDDS) which it uses for its own consumption as well as sells to other manufacturers. Although export sales increased over 70%, this is still a small source of sales and does not significantly impact total revenue. We expect the pharma division to continue its growth and profitability. Because of its expansion programs and introduction of new lines and products, we

Page 5: ACI Financial Analysis

ACI Limited (DSE, CSE: ACI)

estimate the pharma segment to grow at a rate of 25% over the near-term. We also expect this segment to maintain a high gross margin.

Consumer brands:

ACI’s consumer brand segment (18% of revenue) has performed as a high volume profitable business in the past. This was mainly because of its commanding market share and excellent name recognition in some of its household hygiene and cleaning products. ACI’s aerosol insect spray has remained a ubiquitous household product for the last 30 years without any competition. The Savlon brand is universally recognized as a potent antiseptic liquid. Savlon liquid and antiseptic crème do not face any material competition in the antiseptic product market. Both aerosol spray and Savlon command over 70% of the market share in their respective markets. ACI has complemented such brand names with other personal hygiene and household cleaning product. The consumer brand segment has achieved over 25% sales growth over the last four years, albeit with a thin gross margin of about 23%. We expect these levels to continue in growth and margin for the consumer brands.

Agribusiness and Animal health:

Animal health is a part of ACI’s agribusiness division, part of which has been divested with the listing of ACI Formulations. This segment constitutes about 20% of the total revenue. While the seeds, fertilizer and cropex are high-volume low-margin businesses, certain parts of the business such as animal health generate a healthy gross margin (about 40%). This segment gives the company an exposure to the ever-expanding and rapidly commercializing agriculture sector in Bangladesh, especially in dairy, poultry and aquaculture industries. As a low-income country, Bangladesh still has a low per capita protein intake. Traditionally, protein needs of the country have largely been met by homestead-based livestock farming and natural sources such as river-fish, as well as vegetable protein. However, with a growing middle class, demand for animal protein is growing rapidly. ACI produces feed for dairy, poultry and aqua farming as well as manufactures vaccines. The growth potential for this business is huge as commercial farmers get used to standard feed and vaccines. However, the industry itself is on weak grounds as farmers cope with a number of adverse business conditions such as the outbreak of the avian-flu. The seed and fertilizer businesses are also affected by the government’s agro-input distribution policies, which change based on macroeconomic conditions and election cycles. Consequently, we expect ACI’s agribusiness to continue to grow at an uneven pace.

ACI Food, ACI Salt and ACI Pure Flour:

These are ACI’s high volume low margin businesses that were launched in the last two years. They constitute about 20% of the revenue but less than 10% of the gross profit. Through these three segments, ACI serves the retail food market in spices, other food-ingredients, salt and flour. The retail food market in the country is highly fragmented where many different processors, especially no-name small companies operate. As there is no clear volume or quality leadership in this market, it is possible that one or more brands will eventually dominate this market. However, that is a long-time quest for somebody else and it is not clear why a specialist pharmaceuticals and chemical products company that is completely inexperienced in retail food products decided to pursue this market. While ACI boasts of high growth and brand name recognition, these businesses did little to the bottom line except padding up revenue and making an aggregate loss of about BDT 100Mn in 2008.

Page 6: ACI Financial Analysis

ACI Limited (DSE, CSE: ACI)

ACI Logistics:

ACI logistics is another of the company’s new and highly ambitious but unrelated businesses. ACI logistics is in the business of owning and operating neighborhood retail stores. It would be competing with two other successful local retail chains in the urban areas, namely Agora and Nandon, each with about 30 stores. These chains are targeted at affluent urban centers and are limited to the two major cities in the country. Although the concept is new in the country, these two and other smaller chains have gained a foothold as suppliers of standard, higher quality grocery and other food products at a clean environment and fixed price. However, the target market of high middle class consumers is small with a limited growth. ACI states that it has a separate clientele in mind for its chain “Swapno”, namely the middle class who aspires for the same services but are not willing to pay high prices. Consequently, Swapno has targeted less affluent neighborhoods with low-rent smaller stores. ACI management correctly points out that in the grocery market, there exists a huge supply chain inefficiency. There is a large gap between the price received by the grower and the price paid by the end-buyer. Also, significant improvements can be made by standardizing the farming, contracting, procurement and transportation practices. While that part is true, ACI’s plans to capture the retail grocery market is surprisingly unrealistic. It initially planned to open up to 125 stores by 2010 from a base of 12 in 2008. It lined up a syndicated loan of BDT 125.0mn to finance the fixed cost for the stores. However, the challenges of such rapid growth such as logistics, working capital financing and management of individual stores caught up and the company has trimmed its growth to a total of 60 stores in the first year. Initially, the toughest challenge appears to be financing the initial fixed cost of opening the stores as well as meeting the huge working capital requirement of stoking the stores.

ACI Motors and other segments:

ACI motors is in the business of sales and distribution of agro-machinery and light commercial vehicles, mostly Indian brands. This is another way for ACI to take an exposure in the commercial farming industry. With a very low capital intensity in the agricultural sector in Bangladesh and a demand to quickly increase productivity, this business is expected to grow in the future. However, until recently this segment has proved to be another high-volume low-margin business for ACI. Until the associated spare parts, service and other high value-added products are added, this business would continue to remain low-margin.

Page 7: ACI Financial Analysis

ACI Limited (DSE, CSE: ACI)

Valuation

We made several assumptions to determine a fair value for ACI

ACI completes the convertible zero-coupon bond transaction by early 2010

Gross margin for the pharma and agro-chemicals segment remain high and then levels off to the industry average in the longer terms

Gross margin for the consumer and retail segments stabilize at the 20% level

Selling, general and operating costs accelerates because of expansion of the consumer and retail items during the initial years; expense growth rate slows down in the later years when the retail businesses mature

ACI pays off its short term debts first and maintains a D/E ratio of about 30%.

We believe 2009 and 2010 will continue to be transition years for ACI and would not reflect its real earnings potential. Based on 2011 earnings and book value, and a 18x P/E and 3.0x P/B, we derive a target price of BDT 675 in 2011. With an average 2.0% dividend yield, this price target would provide a 17% total return in 12 months.

Other Pharmaceuticals Price 2008 EPS P/E BVPS P/B

Square Pharmaceuticals 2938.25 125.25 23.46 659.32 4.46

Beximco Pharmaceuticals 164.71 3.61 45.63 69.14 2.38

Renata 9970.25 303.37 32.86 438.37 22.74

Reckitt Benckiser 1252.31 35.05 35.73 92.46 13.54

GlaxoSmithKline 640.21 11.87 53.94 75.72 8.45

Average 38.32 10.32

ACI 428.81 18.16 23.62 144.92 2.96

ACI valuation EPS BVPS

2011 estimates 39.41 222.03

Multiple 18.0 3.0

Target price 709.40 666.08

Source: BRAC EPL Estimates

Table 4, 5 and 6: Valuation

Discounted FCF 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015

Operating Cash 578,368,698 1,114,949,068 1,231,726,511 1,410,844,831 1,690,114,889 1,788,059,630 1,967,010,983

Capital Expendture -1,500,000,000 -679,457,053 -467,678,231 -400,178,280 -424,931,576 -451,216,003 -479,126,271

Change in Debt 315,090,975 469,599,385 -700,000,000 -1,070,816,761 -1,200,000,000 -200,000,000 -200,000,000

-606,540,327 905,091,401 64,048,280 -60,150,210 65,183,313 1,136,843,627 1,287,884,712

Net Terminal Value 21,037,902,697

Terminal Value 23,396,572,260

Terminal Debt 2,358,669,563

Net free cash flow -606,540,327 905,091,401 64,048,280 -60,150,210 65,183,313 1,136,843,627 22,325,787,409

Discount Rate 15.0% NPV 11,050,450,933

Terminal Growth Rate 9.00% NPV/Share 569.49

Source: BRAC EPL Estimates

Page 8: ACI Financial Analysis

ACI Limited (DSE, CSE: ACI)

Table 7: Income Statement

Source: Company Annual Reports and BRAC EPL Estimates

Table 8: Cash Flow Statement

Source: Company Annual Reports and BRAC EPL Estimates

2006 2007 2008 2009E 2010E 2011E

Operating Activity

Net Income 784.7 465.4 774.8

Add back non cash expense 274.3 339.7 374.1

Change in working capital -480.6 309.8 82.7

Cash Flow from operations 76.4 -412.0 -1,514.2 578.4 1,114.9 1,231.7

Investing Activity

Capital Expenditure -1,500.0 -679.5 -467.7

Cash Flow from Investing -123.8 -709.0 -194.9 -1,500.0 -679.5 -467.7

Financing Acitivity

Change in Debt 315.1 469.6 -700.0

Newly issued shares 0.0 0.0 53.4

Dividend Paid -194.0 -194.0 -194.0

Cash flow from Financing 154.6 1,008.1 965.0 121.1 275.6 -840.6

Net cash 107.2 -112.9 -744.2 -800.6 711.1 -76.6

Beginning Balance 983.7 1,090.9 978.0 233.8 -566.8 144.3

Cash Balance 1,090.9 978.0 233.8 -566.8 144.3 67.7

Operating cash flow per share 3.94 -21.23 -78.04 29.81 57.46 63.48

2006 2007 2008 2009E 2010E 2011E

Revenue 4,237.9 5,756.8 10,341.4 11,050.6 13,632.4 16,139.4

Cost of sales 2,770.6 3,749.1 7,289.4 7,839.5 9,734.9 11,433.8

Gross profit 1,467.2 2,007.7 3,052.0 3,211.2 3,897.5 4,705.6

Admisnistrative expenses 119.0 171.1 321.8 331.5 409.0 484.2

Distribution expenses 193.3 252.4 277.1 331.5 409.0 484.2

Selling expenses 702.2 974.5 1,505.7 1,547.1 1,840.4 2,098.1

Operating profit 452.6 609.7 947.5 1,001.0 1,239.2 1,639.1

Other income 56.1 83.2 68.1 63.5 67.7 70.6

Result From opeating activities 508.7 692.9 1,015.6 1,064.5 1,306.9 1,709.7

Profit from sale of shares 0.0 86.2 639.3 512.8 0.0 0.0

Share of Profit equity accounted investees 37.0 3.8 0.9 0.0 0.0 0.0

EBIT 471.7 775.3 1,654.0 1,577.3 1,306.9 1,709.7

Financing cost 163.7 220.5 523.8 642.8 631.2 584.7

308.0 554.7 1,130.2 934.5 675.7 1,125.0

Provision for contribution to WPPF 17.7 28.6 35.5 46.7 33.8 56.3

Profit before tax 290.4 526.1 1,094.6 887.8 641.9 1,068.8

Income tax expenses:

Current tax expense 165.6 177.6 194.6 103.1 176.5 293.9

Deferred tax income 14.9 15.7 32.8 0.0 0.0 0.0

Profit after tax 139.7 364.2 932.9 784.7 465.4 774.8

Earning per share (adjusted for current number) 7.20 18.77 48.08 40.44 23.98 39.41

Page 9: ACI Financial Analysis

ACI Limited (DSE, CSE: ACI)

Table 9: Balance Sheet

Source: Company Annual Reports and BRAC EPL Estimates

2006 2007 2008 2009E 2010E 2011E

Inventory 1,239.2 1,583.0 3,144.3 2,850.7 3,245.0 3,277.4

Debtors 524.4 1,051.6 1,958.5 2,310.5 2,408.4 2,456.2

Advances 300.8 482.9 576.6 1,076.6 576.6 576.6

Inter-company receivable 28.9 27.6 13.0 13.0 13.0 13.0

Cash and bank balances 47.5 82.6 233.8 -566.8 144.3 67.7

Total current assets 2,140.8 3,227.7 5,926.1 5,684.0 6,387.2 6,390.9

PPE Net 1,393.4 1,949.9 2,975.5 4,201.2 4,540.9 4,634.4

Capital work-in-progress 39.4 567.5 265.0 265.0 265.0 265.0

Intangible assets 104.7 104.7 108.3 108.3 108.3 108.3

Investment 38.1 62.0 134.5 134.5 134.5 134.5

Total non-current assets 1,575.5 2,684.1 3,483.2 4,708.9 5,048.6 5,142.1

Total assets 3,716.3 5,911.9 9,409.3 10,392.9 11,435.8 11,533.0

Bank overdraft 166.1 314.2 1,209.6 1,200.0 1,000.0 500.0

Short term bank loan 1,178.7 1,915.0 2,870.8 3,200.0 2,870.8 2,870.8

Long term bank loan- Current portion 46.2 154.8 232.9 232.9 232.9 232.9

Creditors 505.4 759.4 1,313.4 1,391.3 1,693.2 1,856.2

Other current liabilities 237.4 338.5 344.8 340.3 339.1 339.1

Total current liabilities 2,133.8 3,481.9 5,971.6 6,364.5 6,136.1 5,799.1

Zero coupon bond 1,000.0 800.0

Long term bank loan 44.5 281.2 313.3 313.3 313.3 313.3

Other liabilities 325.6 348.6 312.4 312.4 312.4 312.4

Long term liabilities 370.1 629.8 625.7 625.7 1,625.7 1,425.7

Total liabilities 2,503.9 4,111.7 6,597.3 6,990.3 7,761.8 7,224.8

Share capital 161.7 161.7 161.7 194.0 194.0 247.5

Share premium 250.0 250.0 250.0 250.0 250.0 250.0

Reserves 309.5 602.0 598.9 598.9 598.9 598.9

Retained earnings 411.9 693.7 1,493.3 2,051.6 2,322.9 2,903.7

Total equity 1,133.1 1,707.4 2,504.0 3,094.6 3,365.9 4,000.2

Minority interest 79.3 92.8 308.0 308.0 308.0 308.0

Total equity and liabilities 3,716.3 5,911.9 9,409.3 10,392.9 11,435.8 11,533.0

Book value per share 62.48 92.77 144.92 175.36 189.34 222.03

Page 10: ACI Financial Analysis

ACI Limited (DSE, CSE: ACI)

Table 10: Indicators

Source: Company Annual Reports and BRAC EPL Estimates

2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Growth:

Sales growth 27% 36% 80% 7% 23% 18%

Operating profit growth 33% 35% 55% 6% 24% 32%

Net profit growth 3% 161% 156% -16% -41% 66%

Segment contribution to revenue:

Pharma and chemicals 34% 37% 28% 34% 36% 37%

Consumer and retail 66% 63% 72% 66% 64% 63%

Margins:

Gross margin 35% 35% 30% 29% 29% 29%

Operating margin 11% 11% 9% 9% 9% 10%

EBITDA Margin 14% 16% 18% 17% 12% 13%

Net margin 3% 6% 9% 7% 3% 5%

Ratios:

Depreciation/assets 0% 0% 6% 6% 6% 6%

Inventory turnover 224% 237% 232% 275% 300% 349%

Sales/assets 114% 97% 110% 106% 119% 140%

Working capital (MM BDT) 7.0 -254.2 -45.4 -680.5 251.1 591.8

Working capital ratio 100% 93% 99% 89% 104% 110%

Return on equity 12% 20% 33% 23% 13% 18%

Return on assets 4% 6% 10% 8% 4% 7%

Leverage:

Debt/equity 146% 168% 176% 155% 156% 117%

Debt/assets 61% 64% 66% 63% 63% 56%

Per share:

EPS 7.20 18.77 48.08 40.44 23.98 39.41

CFPS 3.94 -21.23 -78.04 29.81 57.46 63.48

BVPS 62.48 92.77 144.92 175.36 189.34 222.03

Multiples:

P/E 59.0x 22.6x 8.8x 12.6x 21.3x 12.9x

P/B 8.2x 5.5x 3.5x 2.9x 2.7x 2.3x

Page 11: ACI Financial Analysis

ACI Limited (DSE, CSE: ACI)

IMPORTANT DISCLOSURES

Analyst Certification: Each research analyst and research associate who authored this document and whose name appears herein certifies that the recommendations and opinions expressed in the research report accurately reflect their personal views about any and all of the securities or issuers discussed therein that are within the coverage universe. Disclaimer: Estimates and projections herein are our own and are based on assumptions that we believe to be reasonable. Information presented herein, while obtained from sources we believe to be reliable, is not guaranteed either as to accuracy or completeness. Neither the information nor any opinion expressed herein constitutes a solicitation of the purchase or sale of any security. As it acts for public companies from time to time, BRAC-EPL may have a relationship with the above mentioned company(s). This report is intended for distribution in only those jurisdictions in which BRAC-EPL is registered and any distribution outside those jurisdictions is strictly prohibited. Compensation of Analysts: The compensation of research analysts is intended to reflect the value of the services they provide to the clients of BRAC-EPL. As with most other employees, the compensation of research analysts is impacted by the overall profitability of the firm, which may include revenues from corporate finance activities of the firm's Corporate Finance department. However, Research analysts' compensation is not directly related to specific corporate finance transaction. General Risk Factors: BRAC-EPL will conduct a comprehensive risk assessment for each company under coverage at the time of initiating research coverage and also revisit this assessment when subsequent update reports are published or material company events occur. Following are some general risks that can impact future operational and financial performance: (1) Industry fundamentals with respect to customer demand or product / service pricing could change expected revenues and earnings; (2) Issues relating to major competitors or market shares or new product expectations could change investor attitudes; (3) Unforeseen developments with respect to the management, financial condition or accounting policies alter the prospective valuation; or (4) Interest rates, currency or major segments of the economy could alter investor confidence and investment prospects.