acquity in chromatography laboratory: analytical ... uplc... · analytical considerations ......

Download ACQUITY in Chromatography Laboratory: Analytical ... UPLC... · Analytical Considerations ... ACQUITY UPLC™ BEH Shield RP18 BEH (2.1 x 50 mm, ... Detection: UV 225 nm (Sample Rate:

If you can't read please download the document

Upload: dinhque

Post on 14-May-2018

222 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • Andrew Aubin

    Patricia McConville

    ACQUITY UPLC in the Chromatography Lab: Analytical Considerations

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLC

    ACQUITY UPLC in the Chromatography Lab: Analytical Considerations

    Ultra Performance LC delivers improved speed, sensitivity and resolution that can benefit many liquid chromatography applications in today's laboratory. We will discuss analytical performance along with considerations and recommendations for successful implementation of UPLC in the chromatography laboratory.

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Why Advance the Science and Technology of LC?

    Challenges in the LC Lab

    Chromatography Resolution Reproducibility Ruggedness Sensitivity Speed Detector optimization

    Business Complex samples Regulatory

    considerations Increased # samples Time pressures Cost savings

    Can you meet todays challenges?

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    HPLC: 7 Analgesics in 25 minutes

    AU

    0.00

    0.12

    0.24

    0.36

    0.48

    Minutes0.00 2.50 5.00 7.50 10.00 12.50 15.00 17.50 20.00 22.50 25.00

    Pea

    k1 -

    5.47

    0

    Pea

    k2 -

    8.42

    3

    Pea

    k3 -

    9.94

    9

    Pea

    k4 -

    11.7

    38

    Pea

    k5 -

    16.4

    10

    Pea

    k6 -

    17.4

    04

    Pea

    k7 -

    19.0

    37

    ComponentsPeak #1 Acetaminophen Peak #2 - 2-AcetomidophenolPeak #3 - CaffeinePeak #4 - AcetanilidePeak #5 - Acetylsalicylic AcidPeak #6 - Salicylic AcidPeak #7 Phenacetin

    Gradient Table

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    UPLC:7 analgesics in 25 seconds

    ComponentsPeak #1 Acetaminophen Peak #2 - 2-AcetomidophenolPeak #3 - CaffeinePeak #4 - AcetanilidePeak #5 - Acetylsalicylic AcidPeak #6 - Salicylic AcidPeak #7 Phenacetin

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Why Change from HPLC to UPLC?Time and solvent savings

    Column Volume

    (X5)

    System Volume

    (x3)

    Re-equilibration time (min.)

    Total cycle time

    (min.)

    # of injections in 24hours

    Solvent consumed per injection

    1.0 mL/min.

    41

    9931.3 mL/min

    35.2mL

    1.9mL

    10.2.HPLC

    4.6 x 100 525 min. run time

    1.04

    35.2

    1.45

    1.66mL

    (8.3mL)

    620uL

    (1.86mL)

    UPLC

    2.1 x 50 1.7

    0.41 min run time

    0.20mL

    (1.0mL)

    120uL

    (0.360mL)

    Total Liters of solvent for 1000 injections:HPLC: 35.2L Vs. UPLC: 1.9L

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Why Change from HPLC to UPLC?More information about your sample

    UPLC1.7 m

    Peaks = 168Pc = 360

    2.5X increase

    AU

    0.00

    0.02

    0.04

    0.06

    0.08

    AU

    0.00

    0.02

    0.04

    0.06

    0.08

    Minutes

    0.00 5.00 10.00 15.00 20.00 25.00 30.00 35.00 40.00 45.00 50.00 55.00 60.00

    HPLC4.8 m

    Peaks = 70Pc = 143

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Why Change from HPLC to UPLC?Improved sensitivity

    100 pg/mL

    Time1.00 2.00 3.00

    %

    3

    Mass1 > Mass2796

    1.722.08Rt = 2.08 min, Customer Compound A,

    100pg/mL, 10L injection. Phenomenex column 2.0x30mm, 4umPeak Width = 6 secs

    100 pg/mL

    Time0.30 0.60 1.00

    %

    0

    Mass1 > Mass21.15e4

    0.83

    0.54Rt = 0.83 min, Customer Compound A,100pg/mL, 10L injection. ACQUITY UPLC Column C18 2.1x50mm, 1.7umPeak Width = 1.8 secs

    HPLC

    UPLC

    Method Comparison 100pg/mL, 10L injectionNicholas Ellor

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Speed, Sensitivity, ResolutionAU

    0.00

    0.10

    0.20

    0.30

    0.40

    0.50

    0.60

    Minutes0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50

    HPLC

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    HPLC TodayThe state of the science

    The quality of the separation in HPLC is both driven and limited by column chemistry

    Optimized chemistry can bring speed, sensitivity and resolution benefits to the chromatographic process

    Particle size and selectivity are primary contributors to column performance

    Todays classical HPLC instruments cannot maximize the reality of state of art smaller particles

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Smaller ParticlesThe enabler of productivity

    Smaller particles provide: increased efficiency maintain efficiency over a

    wider linear velocity ability for both added

    resolution and increased speed of separation

    Particles are central to the quality of the separation

    van Deemter plot for classical HPLC

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Fundamental Resolution EquationAt constant column length

    NRs

    In UPLC systems, N (efficiency) is the primary driverAssuming the Selectivity and retentivity are the same as in HPLCThen, Resolution, Rs, is proportional to the square root of N

    Rs = N4 ( -1 ) kk+1( )

    System Selectivity RetentivityEfficiency

    And, Efficiency (N), is inversely proportional to Particle Size , dp

    dpN 1So:

    dp 3X,Therefore if: Rs 1.7X N 3X, Then:

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Smaller ParticlesThe enabler of productivityThe promise of the van Deemter plot

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Summary of Key System Attributes(at constant column length)

    Resolution Improvement

    Speed Improvement

    Sensitivity Improvement

    Back Pressure

    1.7 vs. 5 m particles 1.7X 3X 1.7X 27X1.7 vs. 3 m particles 1.3X 2X 1.3X 6X

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Influence of Particle Size on Chromatography

    AU

    0.000

    0.010

    0.020

    0.030

    0.040

    0.050

    Minutes

    0.00 2.00 4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 15.00

    4.8 m, 0.2 mL/min, 354 psi

    AU

    0.000

    0.010

    0.020

    0.030

    0.040

    0.050

    Minutes0.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00

    Theory1.7X Resolution3X Faster1.7X Sensitivity25X Pressure

    1.7 m, 0.6 mL/min, 7656 psi Actual1.5X Resolution2.6X Faster1.4X Sensitivity22X Pressure

    Isocratic methods with 2.1 x 50 mm columns

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Optimal Linear Velocity on ACQUITY UPLCTM:Isocratic Caffeine Metabolites Separation

    HPLCNon-Optimal Linear Velocity

    UPLCTMOptimal Linear Velocity

    AU

    0.00

    0.02

    0.04

    0.06

    0.08

    0.10

    0.12

    0.14

    0.16

    Minutes

    0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00

    ACQUITY UPLCTM BEH C182.1 x 50 mm, 1.7 m

    Alliance 2695F = 0.3 mL/minPSIMAX = 4,200

    T (4) = 1.63N (4) = 5,400

    Rs (2,3) = 0.97

    ACQUITY UPLCTM BEH C182.1 x 50 mm, 1.7 m

    ACQUITY UPLCTMF = 0.6 mL/minPSIMAX = 8,400

    T (4) = 1.02N (4) = 10,100Rs (2,3) = 2.25

    AU

    0.00

    0.02

    0.04

    0.06

    0.08

    0.10

    0.12

    0.14

    0.16

    Minutes0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00

    1

    2 3

    4

    Same ACQUITY UPLC Column on HPLC vs UPLC instruments

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTM TechnologyUltra performance by design

    Detectors:Optical and/or Mass SpecTunable UV or Photodiode ArrayOptimized flow cell for UPLCTMHigh speed data sampling for

    Column Manager:Innovative pivot designPositions column to detectorE-CordTM connection

    Sample Manager:Low dispersion XYZZ FormatFast cycle timesLow carryoverPlates and/or vialsOptional Sample Organizer

    Binary Solvent Manager:High pressure blendingBinary gradientsFour solvent choicesOn-line degassingLow dispersion designUPLC pressure capabilities

    Sample Organizer: (option)Expands capacity (22/15/8)Shuttles plate feedHeated/chilled

    System Considerations:Small FootprintRedesigned tubing and fittingsConsolidated waste managementIntegrated system diagnosticsConnections InsightTM remote diagnostics

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    UPLCUPLC Technology Challenges

    How do we take advantage of smaller particles?

    Pressure tolerant particle/column

    High pressure fluidic modules

    Holistic design, low system volume, optimized flow paths

    Reduced cycle time autosampler with minimum carryover

    High speed detectors; optical and mass

    Controlled and coordinated system interaction Software designed for system integration Comprehensive diagnostic suite

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMChemistry Proposition

    Advancing the Science

    Requires innovation in every aspect of column: New patented bridged hybrid particle required for pressure

    tolerance and outstanding chromatographic performanceSub 2m particlesPorous for optimum mass transfer

    Column hardwareNew patented frit technology to retain particles New end fittings for high pressure/low dispersion operation

    Packing technologyNew column packing processes to optimize stability

    eCordTMNew information chip to store column history

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Reversed-Phase Column Selectivity Chart

    SunFire C18

    YMC-Pack PolymerC18

    Hypersil CPS Cyano

    YMC-Pack CN

    Waters Spherisorb S5 P

    Hypersil BDS PhenylNova-Pak Phenyl

    YMC-Pack Phenyl

    Hypersil PhenylInertsil Ph-3

    YMC-Pack Pro C4

    YMCbasic

    Symmetry C8YMC-Pack Pro C8

    Nova-Pak C8

    XTerra MS C18 Symmetry C18

    YMC-Pack Pro C18

    Inertsil ODS-3

    YMC-Pack ODS-A

    Nova-PakC18

    YMC J'sphereODSL80 Nucleosil C18

    Waters Spherisorb ODS2

    Waters Spherisorb ODS1Resolve C18

    Bondapak C18

    YMC-Pack ODSAQ

    YMC J'sphere ODSH80YMC J'sphere ODSM80

    Inertsil CN-3

    Waters Spherisorb S5CN

    Nova-Pak CN HP

    SymmetryShield RP8

    SymmetryShield RP18

    XTerra RP8

    XTerra RP18

    -0.6

    -0.3

    0

    0.3

    0.6

    0.9

    1.2

    1.5

    1.8

    2.1

    2.4

    2.7

    3

    3.3

    3.6

    -1.5 -0.5 0.5 1.5 2.5 3.5

    (ln [

    ] am

    itrip

    tylin

    e/ac

    enap

    hthe

    ne)

    XTerra MS C8

    Luna C18 (2)

    ACQUITY UPLC BEH C18

    XTerra Phenyl Luna

    Phenyl Hexyl

    ChromolithTM RP-18

    Atlantis dC18

    Zorbax XDB C18ACT Ace C18

    Zorbax SB C18

    SunFire C8

    LunaC8 (2)

    ACQUITY UPLC BEH C8

    ACQUITY UPLC BEH Phenyl

    (ln [k] acenaphthene)012005 ACQUITY UPLC Shield RP18

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLC Column Selectivity Comparison for Analgesics

    C8

    C18

    RP18

    Phenyl

    1

    ACQUITY UPLC BEH C18 1.7m ACQUITY UPLC BEH RP18 1.7m ACQUITY UPLC BEH C8 1.7m ACQUITY UPLC BEH Phenyl 1.7m

    1. Acetaminophen2. 2-Acetomidophenol3. Caffeine4. Acetanilide5. Acetylsalicylic Acid6. Salicylic Acid7. Phenacetin

    23

    45 6

    7

    2

    6

    6

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Column Lifetime:>8,500 Injections

    ConditionsColumn: ACQUITY UPLC BEH

    C18 2.1 x 50 mmMobile Phase A: 0.1% HCOOHMobile Phase B: 0.1% HCOOH in ACNFlow Rate: 0.65 mL/minGradient: Time Profile

    (min) %A %B Curve0.0 95 5 Initial 0.1 95 5 60.4 5 95 30.5 95 5 110.8 95 5

    Injection Volume: 5 LTemperature: 40oCDetection: UV @ 254 nm

    Pmax: 6,650 psi

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Column LifetimeCustomer Example

    Isocratic aging experiment Cycle: low pressure runs/injections (data shown) 200/400/600 etc.

    high pressure runs/injections (13,000 psi) low pressure runs/injections

    This aging cycle was repeated

    Columns lasted over 4,000 high pressure injectionsConditions (Isocratic Slow Flow/Low Pressure)Column: ACQUITY UPLC BEH C18 (2.1 x 50 mm, 1.7 m)

    ACQUITY UPLC BEH Shield RP18 BEH (2.1 x 50 mm, 1.7 m) Part Number: 186002350Mobile Phase A: 0.1% HCOOH in WatersMobile Phase B: 0.1% HCOOH in ACNFlow Rate: 0.5 mL/min (~6,000 psi)Condition: 67% A / 33% BInjection Volume: 5.0 LSample Concentration: 208 g/mL ketorolac tromethamine and 13 g/mL naproxen in MeOHTemperature: 65oCDetection: UV 225 nm (Sample Rate: 10 Hz, Filter: Normal)

    Conditions (Isocratic Fast Flow/High Pressure)Columns: ACQUITY UPLC BEH C18 (2.1 x 50 mm, 1.7 m)

    ACQUITY UPLC BEH Shield RP18 (2.1 x 50 mm, 1.7 m) Mobile Phase A: 0.1% HCOOH in WaterMobile Phase B: 0.1% HCOOH in ACNFlow Rate: 1.250 mL/min (Pressure ~13,000 psi)Condition: 62% A / 38% BInjection Volume: 5.0 LSample Concentration: 208 g/mL ketorolac tromethamine and 13 g/mL naproxen in MeOHTemperature: 65oCDetection: UV 225 nm (Sample Rate: 10 Hz, Filter: Normal)

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Column LifetimeCustomer Example

    First Injection on Column No high pressure runsN = 3483 for Peak 1 N = 6352 for Peak 2

    Injection after4000 high pressure runs

    N = 3573 for Peak 1N = 6466 for Peak 2

    AU

    - 0 .4 0

    - 0 .2 0

    0 .0 0

    0 .2 0

    0 .4 0

    M in u te s0 .0 0 0 .2 0 0 .4 0 0 .6 0 0 .8 0 1 .0 0 1 .2 0 1 .4 0 1 . 6 0 1 .8 0 2 .0 0 2 .2 0 2 .4 0 2 .6 0 2 .8 0 3 .0 0

    1.16

    5

    1.97

    4

    AU

    -0.40

    -0.20

    0.00

    0.20

    0.40

    Minutes0.00 0.20 0.40 0.60 0.80 1.00 1.20 1.40 1.60 1.80 2.00 2.20 2.40 2.60 2.80 3.00

    1.16

    8

    1.97

    8

    AU

    -0.40

    -0.20

    0.00

    0.20

    0.40

    Minutes0.00 0.20 0.40 0.60 0.80 1.00 1.20 1.40 1.60 1.80 2.00 2.20 2.40 2.60 2.80 3.00

    1.17

    8

    2.00

    0

    Ketorolac Naproxen

    Chromatograms obtained under low (~6000 psi) isocratic conditions

    Injection after1600 high pressure runs

    N = 3659 for Peak 1N = 6489 for Peak 2

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    pH Stability At The Extremes

    What about chemical stability of the column at the extremes of pH, temperature and pressure?

    A 2 x 2 experimental design (at UPLC pressures, of course):

    30oC 60oCpH 2.0pH 11.3

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Column Stability at pH 2.0Direct Overlays

    Minutes0.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00

    Minutes0.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00

    2000

    1000

    1

    Injection

    60oC8,100 psi

    5.00

    ACQUITY UPLC BEH C18, 2.1 x 50 mm30% ACN (v/v) with 0.1% TFA (pH 2.0) at 0.9 mL/min

    Analytes: protriptyline, amitriptyline, butyrophenone

    30oC11,400 psi

    5.00

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Column Stability at pH=11.3

    Minutes1.50 3.00 4.50

    Inj. 1

    Inj. 500

    Inj. 1000

    Minutes1.50 3.00 4.50

    Acetonitrile-Pyrrolidine Buffer (pH=11.3) 45:55 (v/v) at 0.9 mL/min flow rateAnalytes: butyrophenone, protriptyline and amitriptyline

    Inj. 1

    Inj. 500

    Inj. 750

    60oC, 7,700 psi30oC, 11,500 psiOffset Overlays

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    UPLCUPLC Technology Challenges

    How do we take advantage of smaller particles?

    Pressure tolerant particle/column

    High pressure fluidic modules

    Holistic design, low system volume, optimized flow paths

    Reduced cycle time autosampler with minimum carryover

    High speed detectors; optical and mass

    Controlled and coordinated system interaction Software designed for system integration Comprehensive diagnostic suite

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTM TechnologyUltra performance by design

    Detectors:Optical and/or Mass SpecTunable UV or Photodiode ArrayOptimized flow cell for UPLCTMHigh speed data sampling for

    Column Manager:Innovative pivot designPositions column to detectorE-CordTM connection

    Sample Manager:Low dispersion XYZZ FormatFast cycle timesLow carryoverPlates and/or vialsOptional Sample Organizer

    Binary Solvent Manager:High pressure blendingBinary gradientsFour solvent choicesOn-line degassingLow dispersion designUPLC pressure capabilities

    Sample Organizer: (option)Expands capacity (22/15/8)Shuttles plate feedHeated/chilled

    System Considerations:Small FootprintRedesigned tubing and fittingsConsolidated waste managementIntegrated system diagnosticsConnections InsightTM remote diagnostics

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMBinary Solvent Manager

    Binary gradient Independent style piston drives Serial flow for each solvent, parallel

    gradient formation High Pressure Gradient

    Solvent select, 4 solvent choices On board solvent degasser 50l mixer, ~120L total system volume Ability to deliver non-linear gradients UPLC pressure capabilities

    0-1mL/min to 15K psi, 1 -2mL/min to 9K psi

    Dedicated transducer for each head. Enhances performance, provides diagnostic information

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    BSM Components

    Pump A Pump B

    SSV A SSV BDegasserTee

    FilterMixer

    Vent Valve

    PlungerWash

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    From Serial to Parallel Flow

    Two independently driven primary and accumulatorpiston drives Separate drive motors Two transducers Two inlet check valves

    Four Solvents Capability A1 or A2 and B1 or B2 Two solvents per gradient

    Six Channel Degasser 4 chromatographic eluents 2 solvents for Sample Manager

    Strong & weak wash

    B B A A

    B2B2B1B1

    A2A2

    Solvent A1Solvent A1

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Pressure Envelope Fluidic components optimized to support the pressure

    demands of UPLC separations Seals, head, bolts, check valves, fittings, tubing, mixer, pressure

    transducers

    UPLC compatible pressure with flow rate range

    1 2

    9000

    15000

    Pressure(psi)

    Flow Rate(mL/min)

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Tee/ Filter/ Mixer

    Glass Bead Mixing Technology Tortured Mixing Durable and will not disintegrate or affect delicate compounds Highly resistant to attack by most liquids and/or vapors.

    Glass Bead Mixer Standard 4 x 5, approximate volume 50 L (P/N 700002631) Optional Mixer 6 x 6, approximate volume 100 L (P/N 205000252)

    Filter Similar to Alliance, 2 micron filter (P/N 700002674)

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    New Tubing & Fittings

    HPLC Fittings Traditional drawn tubing

    Traditional Waters Fittings

    UPLCTM Fittings Center-less ground tubing

    Gold Compression Screw 2 Piece Swagelock Ferrules

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY 9/1000 SS316 Tubing

    @75 Times

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Standard 5/1000 inch 316 SS Tuning

    @75 Times @500 Times

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    New ACQUITY 2/1000 316 SS Tubing

    @75 Times @1000 Times

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMBinary Solvent Manager gradient steps

    N = 6

    1% Steps 0% B to 10% BFlow Rate=0.50 mL/minuteBackpressure ~9300 psi

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMBinary Solvent Manager Auto Blend

    Injections of Caffeine with Dial-a-Mix at 1.0mL/min4.0% to 5.0% ACN in 0.1% Increments

    4.0% ACN

    5.0% ACN

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Original Assay Method from the USP for: Benzocaine, Butamben, and Tetracaine Hydrochloride Topical Solution

    Mobile phase Prepare a mixture of methanol, water, and 0.25 M sodium 1-heptanesulfonate (500:500:20). Make adjustments if necessary (see System Suitability under Chromatography (621).

    Chromatographic system (see Chromatography [621])The liquid chromatograph is equipped with a 313-nm detector, and a 3.9-mm 30-cm column that contains packing L1. The flow rate is about 2 mL per minute.

    Standard preparation Transfer about 140 mg of USP Benzocaine RS, accurately weighed, to a 100-mL volumetric flask with the aid of 25 mL of methanol, and swirl. Transfer about 140 J mg of USP Butamben RS, accurately weighed, to the same volumetric flask with the aid of 25 mL of water, J being the ratio of the labeled amount, in percent, of butamben to the labeled amount, in percent, of benzocaine in the Topical Solution. Transfer about 140J mg of USP Tetracaine Hydrochloride RS, accurately weighed, to the same volumetric flask with the aid of 25 mL of water, J being the ratio of the labeled amount, in percent, of tetracaine hydrochloride to the labeled amount, in percent, of benzocaine in the Topical Solution. Sonicate for about 1 minute, dilute with Diluent to volume, and mix.

    Procedure Separately inject equal volumes (about 10 L) of the Standard preparation and the Assay preparationinto the chromatograph, record the chromatograms, and measure the peak areas for the major peaks.

    Chromatograph the Standard preparation, and record the peak responses as directed for Procedure: the relative retention times are about 0.3 for benzocaine, 0.8 for butamben, and 1.0 for tetracaine; the resolution, R, between the benzocaine peak and the butamben peak and between the butamben peak and the tetracaine peak is not less than 2; and the relative standard deviation for replicate injections is not more than 2.0% for each of the three analyte peaks.

    http://www.uspnf.com/uspnf/pub/data/v28230/usp28nf23s0_alpha-18-140.xml#usp28nf23s0_c11rs113http://www.uspnf.com/uspnf/pub/data/v28230/usp28nf23s0_alpha-18-140.xml#usp28nf23s0_c11rs157http://www.uspnf.com/uspnf/pub/data/v28230/usp28nf23s0_alpha-18-1412.xml#usp28nf23s0_c11rs1149

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMBSM Performance- RT Reproducibility

    Standard Deviations of 35, 94, 125 milliseconds

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Alliance HPLCAnalytical Performance with isocratic conditions

    AU

    0.00

    0.02

    0.04

    0.06

    0.08

    Minutes0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50

    Column XTerra RP C18, 5 um, 4.6 X 250 mm Solvent A 10 mMol Ammonium Bicarbonate pH=10Solvent B AcetonitrileFlow Rate - 2.0 mL/minColumn Temperature 45 CIsocratic 40% A + 60% BDetection - PDA in 2D mode, 301 nm at 4.8 nm bandwidthData rate: 5 pps filtering constant 0.5Injection Volume - 2 uL of 0.07 mg/mL (5/100 dilution of USP Standard)

    Average TR %RSD 0.133%Average Peak Area %RSD 0.467%Average Peak Width @ 4.4% 7.2 secAverage w Peak Width 3.2 sec.Minimum Resolution 2.9Total Cycle Time 351 secSolvent Used 11.7 mL

    Separation of Benzocaine, Butamben, and Tetracaine

  • 2005 Waters CorporationAU

    0.00

    0.10

    0.20

    0.30

    0.40

    0.50

    0.60

    Minutes0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 0.50 0.55

    Ben

    zoca

    ine

    - 0.2

    35

    But

    ambe

    n - 0

    .370

    Tetra

    cain

    e - 0

    .492

    Column ACQUITY UPLCTM BEH C18 2.1 X 50 mm, 1.7 m Solvent A 10 mMol Ammonium Bicarbonate pH=10Solvent B AcetonitrileFlow Rate - 1.0 mL/minColumn Temperature 45 CIsocratic 50% A + 50% BDetection - PDA in 2D mode, 301 nm at 4.8 nm bandwidthData rate: 20 pps Filter constant: 0.1Injection Volume 2 uL of 0.07 mg/mL (5/100 dilution of USP Standard)

    Average TR %RSD 0.370%

    Average Peak Area %RSD 0.467%

    Average 4 Sigma Peak Width 2.1 sec

    Average w Peak Width 0.93 sec.

    Minimum Resolution 4.2

    Total Cycle Time 65 sec

    Solvent Used 1.1 mL

    USP Separation of Benzocaine, Butamben, and Tetracaine

    ACQUITY UPLCTMAnalytical Performance with isocratic conditions

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Speed, Sensitivity, ResolutionAU

    0.00

    0.10

    0.20

    0.30

    0.40

    0.50

    0.60

    Minutes0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50

    HPLC

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Changes to Original Assay Method from the USP for: Benzocaine, Butamben, and Tetracaine Hydrochloride Topical Solution

    Mobile phase Prepare a mixture of acetonitrile, water containing 10 mMol ammonium bicarbonate at a pH of 10.0 (1:1) for UPLC, 4:6 for HPLC. Make adjustments if necessary (see System Suitability under Chromatography (621).

    Chromatographic system (see Chromatography [621])The liquid chromatograph is equipped with a 301-nm detector, and a 4.6-mm 25-cm column that contains packing L1 (XTerra RP18, 5 um) for HPLC and a 2.1 X 50 mm 1.7 um for UPLC. The flow rate is about 1 mL per minute for UPLC and 2 mL per minute for HPLC.

    Standard preparation Transfer about 140 mg of USP Benzocaine RS, accurately weighed, to a 100-mL volumetric flask with the aid of 25 mL of methanol, and swirl. Transfer about 140 J mg of USP Butamben RS, accurately weighed, to the same volumetric flask with the aid of 25 mL of water, J being the ratio of the labeled amount, in percent, of butamben to the labeled amount, in percent, of benzocaine in the Topical Solution. Transfer about 140J mg of USP Tetracaine Hydrochloride RS, accurately weighed, to the same volumetric flask with the aid of 25 mL of water, J being the ratio of the labeled amount, in percent, of tetracaine hydrochloride to the labeled amount, in percent, of benzocaine in the Topical Solution. Sonicate for about 1 minute, dilute with Diluent to volume, and mix. Further dilute this stock 5 in100 for UPLC use.

    Procedure Separately inject equal volumes (about 2 L) of the Standard preparation and the Assay preparationinto the chromatograph, record the chromatograms, and measure the peak areas for the major peaks.

    Chromatograph the Standard preparation, and record the peak responses as directed for Procedure: the relative retention times are about 0.3 for benzocaine, 0.8 for butamben, and 1.0 for tetracaine; the resolution, R, between the benzocaine peak and the butamben peak and between the butamben peak and the tetracaine peak is not less than 2; and the relative standard deviation for replicate injections is not more than 2.0% for each of the three analyte peaks.

    http://www.uspnf.com/uspnf/pub/data/v28230/usp28nf23s0_alpha-18-140.xml#usp28nf23s0_c11rs113http://www.uspnf.com/uspnf/pub/data/v28230/usp28nf23s0_alpha-18-140.xml#usp28nf23s0_c11rs157http://www.uspnf.com/uspnf/pub/data/v28230/usp28nf23s0_alpha-18-1412.xml#usp28nf23s0_c11rs1149

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMAnalytical Performance with Gradient conditions

    AU

    -0.10

    0.00

    0.10

    0.20

    0.30

    0.40

    0.50

    0.60

    0.70

    Minutes0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 0.50

    Ace

    tani

    lide

    - 0.

    176

    Ace

    toph

    enon

    e -

    0.23

    0

    Pro

    piop

    heno

    ne -

    0.27

    3

    But

    yrop

    heno

    ne -

    0.31

    0B

    enzo

    phen

    one

    - 0.3

    22

    Val

    erop

    heno

    ne -

    0.34

    6

    Hex

    anop

    heno

    ne -

    0.3

    83

    Hep

    tano

    phen

    one

    - 0.

    420

    Oct

    anop

    heno

    ne -

    0.4

    56

    Average TR %RSD 0.109%Average Peak Area %RSD 0.368%

    Average 4 Sigma Peak Width 0.369 secAverage w Peak Width 0.210 secMinimum Resolution 2.15Total Cycle Time 56 secMaximum Pressure 13,500 psi

    Column: 2.1 x 50 mm @ 65CMobile Phase A: 0.1% Formic Acid in WaterMobile Phase B: 0.1% Formic Acid in ACNFlow Rate: 1.3 mL/minGradient: 30% - 90% B over 0.5minutes, Curve 5Wash Solvents: Strong 50/50 Water/ACN (200L);

    Weak 95/5 Water/ACN 600L)Wavelength: 240nmData Rate: 40 pts/s, Filter Constant: 0.0

    6 injections9 phenones(3L, 0.1 mg/mL)30 sec. gradient

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMAnalytical Performance with Gradient conditions

    AU

    -0.10

    -0.05

    0.00

    0.05

    0.10

    0.15

    0.20

    0.25

    0.30

    0.35

    0.40

    Minutes0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 0.50

    Ace

    tam

    inop

    hen

    - 0.2

    08

    2-A

    ceto

    mid

    ophe

    nol -

    0.2

    25

    Caf

    fein

    e - 0

    .264

    Ace

    tani

    lide

    - 0.3

    06

    AS

    A -

    0.32

    3

    Phe

    nace

    tin -

    0.35

    8

    Sal

    icyl

    ic A

    cid

    - 0.3

    80

    10 Replicate Injections of a7 component Analgesic Mix

    (5L, 0.1 0.2 mg/mL in water)

    Column: 2.1x50mm @ 65CMobile Phase A: 0.1% Formic Acid in WaterMobile Phase B: 0.1% Formic Acid in ACNFlow Rate: 1.3 mL/minGradient: Time %A %B Curve

    Initial 93 7 -0.10 80 20 40.18 65 35 60.41 93 7 6

    Wash Solvents: Strong 50/50 Water/ACN, 100LWeak 98/2 Water/ACN, 500L

    Wavelength: 240nmData Rate: 40 pts/s, Filter Constant: 0.0

    Ave RT %RSD 0.115%Ave Area %RSD 0.133%Minimum Resolution 1.70Total Cycle Time 56 sec

    Maximum Pressure 11,000 psi

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCNon-Linear Gradient Capability

    Gradient Profiles on ACUITY UPLC

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Utility of Non-linear gradient capability

    Method Development Challenge:

    Gradient elution of 9 component mix To go as fast as possible

    To meet a minimum resolution requirement of 2.0

    Start with generic method 30s gradient with 15s hold at final conditions. (5% to 95% ACN)

    Run gradient using curves 3-9

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Chromatograms of Curves 3-9A

    U

    0.00

    0.50

    AU

    0.00

    0.50

    AU

    0.00

    0.50

    AU

    0.00

    0.50

    AU

    0.00

    0.50

    AU

    0.00

    0.50

    AU

    0.00

    0.50

    Minutes0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 0.50 0.55 0.60 0.65 0.70 0.75

    Curve 9

    Curve 8

    Curve 7

    Curve 6

    Curve 5

    Curve 4

    Curve 3

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Run Time Results and Minimum Resolution

    Curve 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

    Resolution 1.32 1.76 2.17 3.01 3.59 3.61 3.36

    Elution Time of Last Peak

    0.34 0.40 0.46 0.57 0.64 0.66 0.68

    Shortest Run Time with required resolution is using Curve 5

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMSample Manager

    Pressure tolerant, low volume flow-through isolation & injection valves

    Fast cycle times, low carry over

    2 Plate capacity, multiple formats Well plates, microtube plates, vials

    Thermal control (4 - 40C)

    Low dispersion column management

    Sample Organizer (optional)

    New Technologies - all-new injection process

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Pod Style Injector

    Modular design (removable Pod) permits easy access

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLC Loops available

    2 L5 L10 L20 L50 L

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMSample Manager Performance - Precision

    Component Summary Area RT ReportProject Name: PITTCON_2005Reported by User: Andrew Aubin (Aubin)

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    7

    8

    9

    10

    Mean

    Std. Dev.

    % RSD

    SampleName Date Acquired Inj Vol(ul) Inj Vial 3,4-MDA 2,3-MDA 3,4-MDMA 2,3-MDMA

    2,3+3,4 MDA MDMA

    2,3+3,4 MDA MDMA

    2,3+3,4 MDA MDMA

    2,3+3,4 MDA MDMA

    2,3+3,4 MDA MDMA

    2,3+3,4 MDA MDMA

    2,3+3,4 MDA MDMA

    2,3+3,4 MDA MDMA

    2,3+3,4 MDA MDMA

    2,3+3,4 MDA MDMA

    2/14/2005 10:28:57 AM

    2/14/2005 10:33:42 AM

    2/14/2005 10:36:38 AM

    2/14/2005 10:39:35 AM

    2/14/2005 10:42:31 AM

    2/14/2005 10:45:27 AM

    2/14/2005 10:48:24 AM

    2/14/2005 10:51:20 AM

    2/14/2005 10:54:14 AM

    2/14/2005 10:57:11 AM

    5.00

    5.00

    5.00

    5.00

    5.00

    5.00

    5.00

    5.00

    5.00

    5.00

    1

    1

    1

    1

    1

    1

    1

    1

    1

    1

    2:D,1

    2:D,1

    2:D,1

    2:D,1

    2:D,1

    2:D,1

    2:D,1

    2:D,1

    2:D,1

    2:D,1

    252746

    251676

    252557

    251382

    251354

    250666

    252694

    252331

    252360

    252659

    252043

    722

    0.29

    169926

    169802

    169395

    169090

    168659

    169286

    168439

    169251

    168626

    168037

    169051

    604

    0.36

    235323

    235335

    235366

    232696

    234721

    234564

    235468

    235365

    234133

    234904

    234787

    856

    0.36

    164552

    163520

    163371

    162642

    163114

    163830

    163120

    163195

    164507

    162978

    163483

    636

    0.39

    Component Summary For Area

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMSample Manager Performance - Linearity

    Are

    a

    -50000

    0

    50000

    100000

    150000

    200000

    250000

    Amount0.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 10.00

    R2 = 0.9998

    0.1 mg/mL Acetaminophen with 20L loop in Pressure-Assist Mode

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMSample Manager Performance -Carryover

    10 mg/mL Human Insulin

    Carryover 0.0036%

    Wash Conditions: 200L Strong (6:3:1 / 0.1% phosphoric in Water:ACN:IPA) 600L Weak (0.01M HCl)

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMSample Manager Performance -Carryover

    Carryover 0.0036%

    Wash Conditions: 200L Strong (6:3:1 / 0.1% phosphoric in Water:ACN:IPA) 600L Weak (0.01M HCl)

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLC Minimized CarryoverAlprazolam in Plasma

    Plasma Blank

    314.1>210.2

    260.2>116.0

    309.0>205.2

    1000 ng/mL

    Peak Area96015

    Peak Area747309

    Peak Area97963

    MRM transition

    Plumb

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Cycle Times?

    ACQUITY UPLC Injection-to-Injection Cycle TimesInjection-to-injection cycle times are calculated as the time it takes for the injector to perform all of the tasks during the injection cycle from the point of initiation by the data acquisition software until the valve turns and the injection is made. To determine this value a series of injections are monitored by a detector that is continually collecting data, even between the run times. The difference in time between corresponding peaks of each injection gives the total cycle time. Subtracting the run time from the total cycle time will yield the injection-to-injection cycle time.

    Injection Interval Total Cycle Time(sec)

    Run Time(sec)

    Injector Cycle Time(sec)

    1 64.9 36.0 28.9

    2 65.1 36.0 29.1

    3 65.0 36.0 29.0

    4 64.1 36.0 28.1

    5 63.0 36.0 27.0

    6 65.5 36.0 29.5

    7 67.0 36.0 31.0

    8 66.9 36.0 30.9

    9 65.2 36.0 29.2

    Average 65.2 36.0 29.2

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMColumn Manager

    Column Manager

    Symbiotic with Sample Manager Flow path distance optimized 65C upper limit Up to 150 mm column

    Pivot positioning Stacked mode

    w/ optical detector Swung out mode

    w/ MS detector only Column may be accessed from

    either side

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Attaching The Column to the System

    High Pressure Finger Tight FittingsHolds >15000 psi

    Patent Pending

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Column Outlet

    - One piece finger tight fittings work well- Cut 0.0025 Peek to length- Keep as short as possible to minimize dispersion

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Column Heating

    Column heating considerations Consistent temperature for RT stability Solvent viscosity is lower at higher temperatures Lower backpressures at higher temperatures

    AU

    0.00

    0.05

    0.10

    0.15

    0.20

    0.25

    0.30

    Minutes1.20 1.40 1.60 1.80 2.00 2.20 2.40 2.60 2.80 3.00 3.20 3.40 3.60 3.80

    60 C

    50 C55 C

    45 C40 C

    35 C

    30 C

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMColumn Manager with eCord

    eCordTM Technology

    eCordeCordreaderreader Column Information

    Certificate of Analysis

    Column Usage History Total number of samples Injections Pressure/Temperature history And much more

    eCordTM

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMeCordTM

    Columns

    eCordTM

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    eCordColumn QC

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMDetectors

    Faster eluting peaks require higher data rates High light throughput/transmission Faster digital filter time constants

    UPLC separations require low dispersion flow cells Maintain chromatographic fidelity

    Tunable UV, PDA and ELSD Options

    MS Options

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMFlow Cell Design

    Light Guided UPLCTM flow cells 10 mm pathlength, 500 nL volume Flow cell channel is the inside of a low-index Teflon AF tube Total internal reflection at walls, like optical fiber cladding

    Teflon AF

    water

    dTeflon AF

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMLow dispersion UPLC optics

    Time2.00 4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00 20.00 22.00 24.00 26.00 28.00 30.00

    %

    0

    100

    %

    0

    100 0.67

    22.92

    0.78

    2.09

    1.30

    11.208.62

    2.57

    3.55 4.205.615.15 7.336.49 7.93

    21.6621.10

    20.3117.13

    14.5112.71 16.32

    19.4318.26

    22.23

    26.01

    23.15

    24.40

    25.17

    26.51

    27.34

    28.7728.12

    0.69 23.050.81

    2.58

    1.37

    11.62

    9.11

    6.135.864.883.734.36

    7.06 7.678.38 9.99

    21.7321.1918.3817.3214.78

    13.6512.96 16.6015.39

    19.5020.40

    22.30

    23.30

    26.01

    23.5124.45

    25.8425.09

    26.61

    27.32

    27.5129.18

    UV cell in line75/500/75

    No UV cell

    Column2.1x100

    400L/min

    Effect of UV Cell on MS Data

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Low dispersion UPLCTM opticsExpanded Region

    Time10.80 11.00 11.20 11.40 11.60 11.80 12.00 12.20

    %

    0

    100

    %

    0

    100

    11.20

    11.62

    11.2810.93

    No UV cell

    UV cell in line

    0.43mins

    0.43mins

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Data Acquisition RatesImpact on UV chromatography data

    1 pt/s

    2 pt/s

    5 pt/s

    10 pt/s

    20 pt/s

    40 pt/s

    Minutes0.50 0.52 0.54 0.56 0.58 0.60 0.62 0.64 0.66 0.68 0.70 0.72 0.74

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Effect of Filtering Constant Effect of Filtering Constant on Chromatographyon Chromatography

    AU

    0.000

    0.010

    0.020

    0.030

    0.040

    0.050

    0.060

    0.070

    0.080

    Minutes0.50 0.52 0.54 0.56 0.58 0.60 0.62 0.64 0.66 0.68 0.70 0.72 0.74 0.76 0.78 0.80

    No Filtering0.1s0.3s0.5s1.0s

    5 component Analgesic Mix on 2.1x50mm ACQUITY UPLC Column, 30s gradient

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    UV Spectra on ACQUITY PDA

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Peak Purity and Library Match Capabilities

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMOptional Sample Organizer

    Supports high throughput/high capacity

    Expands capacity-mix or match 22 thin (microtitre) plates

    8,448 samples max 15 medium height plates 8 full height (vial) plates

    384 x 2mL vials

    Temperature controlled

    Programmable Access to any sample location

    Supports Walk-up Operation

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMOptional FlexCart

    Supports inlet mobility

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    UPLCUPLC Technology Challenges

    How do we take advantage of smaller particles?

    Pressure tolerant particle/column

    High pressure fluidic modules

    Holistic design, low system volume, optimized flow paths

    Reduced cycle time autosampler with minimum carryover

    High speed detectors; optical and mass

    Controlled and coordinated system interaction Software designed for system integration Comprehensive diagnostic suite

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    System Information

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Sample Syringe Diagnostic

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Needle Seal - Static vs Dynamic TEST

    Static Dynamic Static Dynamic

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    ACQUITY UPLCTMDesigned with Intent

    UPLCTM enabled, laboratory rugged

    Convenience AQT Qualification Small footprint Integrated waste management eCordTM Technology Intuitive Control Console Multiple plate formats High capacity sample organizer FlexCart

    Performance and Reliability UPLC pressure capabilities Low dispersion fluidics Rapid, clean injections Fast detection Rugged chemistry Analytical performance Extensive onboard diagnostics Connections InsightTM

    UPLCTM = a higher quality of (more) information faster

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    QUESTIONS?

  • 2005 Waters Corporation

    Acknowledgements

    John Morawski

    Tanya Jenkins

    Eric Grumbach

    Robert Plumb

    Jeffrey Mazzeo

    ACQUITY UPLC in the Chromatography Lab: Analytical ConsiderationsACQUITY UPLCWhy Advance the Science and Technology of LC?HPLC: 7 Analgesics in 25 minutesUPLC:7 analgesics in 25 secondsWhy Change from HPLC to UPLC?Time and solvent savingsWhy Change from HPLC to UPLC?More information about your sampleWhy Change from HPLC to UPLC?Improved sensitivityUPLC method verses customers HPLC methodSpeed, Sensitivity, ResolutionHPLC TodayThe state of the scienceSmaller ParticlesThe enabler of productivityFundamental Resolution Equation At constant column lengthSmaller ParticlesThe enabler of productivitySummary of Key System Attributes(at constant column length)Influence of Particle Size on ChromatographyOptimal Linear Velocity on ACQUITY UPLCTM:Isocratic Caffeine Metabolites SeparationACQUITY UPLCTM TechnologyUltra performance by designUPLC Technology ChallengesACQUITY UPLCTMChemistry PropositionReversed-Phase Column Selectivity ChartACQUITY UPLC Column Selectivity Comparison for AnalgesicsColumn Lifetime:>8,500 InjectionsColumn LifetimeCustomer ExampleColumn LifetimeCustomer ExamplepH Stability At The ExtremesColumn Stability at pH 2.0Column Stability at pH=11.3UPLC Technology ChallengesACQUITY UPLCTM TechnologyUltra performance by designACQUITY UPLCTMBinary Solvent ManagerBSM ComponentsFrom Serial to Parallel FlowPressure EnvelopeTee/ Filter/ MixerNew Tubing & FittingsACQUITY 9/1000 SS316 TubingStandard 5/1000 inch 316 SS TuningNew ACQUITY 2/1000 316 SS TubingACQUITY UPLCTMBinary Solvent Manager Auto BlendACQUITY UPLCTM BSM Performance- RT ReproducibilityAlliance HPLCAnalytical Performance with isocratic conditions Speed, Sensitivity, ResolutionACQUITY UPLCTMAnalytical Performance with Gradient conditionsACQUITY UPLCTMAnalytical Performance with Gradient conditionsACQUITY UPLC Non-Linear Gradient CapabilityUtility of Non-linear gradient capabilityChromatograms of Curves 3-9Run Time Results and Minimum ResolutionACQUITY UPLCTMSample ManagerPod Style InjectorACQUITY UPLC Loops availableACQUITY UPLCTM Sample Manager Performance - PrecisionACQUITY UPLCTM Sample Manager Performance - LinearityACQUITY UPLCTM Sample Manager Performance -CarryoverACQUITY UPLCTM Sample Manager Performance -CarryoverACQUITY UPLC Minimized CarryoverAlprazolam in PlasmaCycle Times?ACQUITY UPLCTMColumn ManagerAttaching The Column to the SystemColumn OutletColumn HeatingACQUITY UPLCTMColumn Manager with eCordACQUITY UPLCTMeCordTMeCordColumn QCACQUITY UPLCTM DetectorsACQUITY UPLCTMFlow Cell DesignACQUITY UPLCTMLow dispersion UPLC opticsLow dispersion UPLCTM opticsExpanded RegionData Acquisition Rates Impact on UV chromatography dataEffect of Filtering Constant on ChromatographyUV Spectra on ACQUITY PDAPeak Purity and Library Match CapabilitiesACQUITY UPLCTM Optional Sample OrganizerACQUITY UPLCTMOptional FlexCartUPLC Technology ChallengesSystem InformationSample Syringe DiagnosticACQUITY UPLCTMDesigned with IntentQUESTIONS?Acknowledgements