1REALLOCATIONOFLAI0tR:JPROCESSINNOVATIONSAND

R UNIONPROMOTESTHECASEINWHICHALABOt

AkaT

Ab

J

t tsrac

ir

re

hta

her

o

u

her

fferi

r

korer

rogrel iogcalecuc

l

e

iinhtc

d tnusry

-

i

d-an

fispec

hsearc

ci .Whns htmo lp ssoccusw et ea

ma gd nofw sd s&m t

meu

sitvaoroce

ic

f k hworerswe

i honwit

np ssi ninno

h decond ter hficons

dteid Wtnusry.nln

nt ec erll noio

itvao

toca

hi We

ea

fl nt sp nno no ei nalei ssi ni yo h e mi

h

roce

d terions

d tnusry.

her

paperw,

eac

hwe

in

is

ff teren

baour

h

i

I

d

o

toetprom

ionh ll tereaocatt taesiliac

lyias

sitvaorocehw ekorersfw np ssi ninno

nitvaorocehatsulinaysihTkorers. sa ss sttp ssi nigge nno

sl ilogcaprogreltecfopey mo ssi

d i S dtnusres prea,

fwer no

tecorssuc, teworiotfn

m b

ds ha oma ndn ki sesi na

ioll teaoca

i iunonze

nu

ht

less-

RODUCTIVITYTp

"daiIkiu'anlera dY 町as

af k h kipeoworerw oworsnil tcuarytapar

hgh f iepresenceoaunoni ton,tva mi

l ilogcaprogre

ioll teaoca

l ltgenera ec,

hd terions

d Itnusry n.eac

i Wspaper,

inff teren

h

i

I

d

nt ec er no

hi mo ssh innuenceT terenBidasa

ssiizeproce nnolif k teroworersu

i lcuatar

f lony

korer.

iitvh d teprouctproveim

Ap rt

yo

h tersecors.to

ioll teaocahitesClulr ,ter

ionsnhi fennuenceou

ion

nit

fitcaa

b fecauseo

LClssi Nu 2,21J,24J,6J;bm er

IJI.INTRODICTON

EJ

acnd tnusr

yto

ac

klei

i

l

ne hi yadone hw

forminssdloehesecausihT sisb et em sa

321

dloes.ataitcedpre dby sndrdm

tns.roveiitvd tprouc yi memp

駒揮大学経済学論集 第 41巻 第 4号

llntel u yi sa sw hh hp y Wigr ndw

h l lSecnooge.

iitv

ne

ns hc

ig

dnl

itkorer

toi

j tusdtoa

d itnusresw

d itnusre

h k idteseworersarerane

h i ktereexsworersan

lnon,onh d trouc

di 仇b hoda wtmn

I

i b tsurvveecause

h towever, ,

ucⅠ

h h tesorIty n.logwtmolechenetto

owever,d dHere.ionsnc

).h tape7C,9 r6

d luaiivdnfi

korerfow

dneritvaofproceittnaoleihed tericons mp me no ssi nunno

te

itrc

rols

asydner

9

he

har

luenc

tages,

a

fn

wt

eg,..

la

st np rl se cw re( Bl d1mi nc

iizn

i

Ho nt ni ya ne gw ymayaop molqua

fale

averll no ymayh easmir i eu mme

i

i fonone

lroe

cono

he

hi dt tenrouc

lonspa

f k Tworers.

owe

i tnnuence

ower

htauVe

io

iuno

lweverg,

toca

i lunonsaso

ea

hta

h

i

t

he

tew

h ipasze

ii honslteahlysea)

iona,

2loa

d i ite eunonza,

Acmo hi ndVi e( na er pb eenAg na nt 001 dto

dtmi ng ndi dtlhcaca

lgu,

lec

e

iaseb-lliks

lldeifks

ttueid i d bt tnusresproucesus

ivewbt texh d dtesanarTy. ookh lecnoog

bira

a

iliqu

nd

dleaOrSCteItwo mO nd

ion.d i it tes eunonza

tyilqua

peyfersoeachenu

toixs

iiitesav ,

r

t tnac

ee tb hs ge

ndt m b ht

rocessherb haourw e

vic

itooca

h

ea

icase

httaeiliac

nw hhoi

sterll nofl nt eisp

i ftsoenunemp metnloy

leveiitvd trouchbtoservma nma scmo etep y l soarnageri honw e,t

korers.

ifnor

w

inloointaepar gandp

mheT.itylnequa ye

ro

lpoye

iitrranniitvh d terproucit

da

yo gp mo

agtewii honslteahllayseJ9991 )a d te r p b een w e ine

?ncreaseyiiitvi d il d tonsoessocaproucitd h dtasesunerw acon,

gtobirrnlb Rfaour e.f

iitvd tproucheteror yo

e,

t

h feret,intepa

ioh ll tereaocattgessug

gtos ra ga ornd

no he

mheTences.idaged ieucn

ncreas

nr gw 飴r ye

ei

f i iounons

hdt nita nea

lroe

hsowe

nuhtefIrges. mb

inlooBts ofi mp

S tpresen.h lb itaaaourunot nl

hbiruiliqu ms

derW ispaper econs,

ioitdtacon

I

hd Wgoos.

n血i 血e

nf

lb iaourunonsoff fteecoheT

Ac u (mo

hnesw

k i tworersncreases,

dlte,

i tsnves

i

h

lr

Itn.

h fe

ic

lg

lpoy

e

nh heunem me smo

concem

dtee

ingt m' me

mi he

ee

biruiliqu m eme

fihsSncreases uc.

Wsepapers e,t

it

ftso

i lnequa

lresu

yi ha ts

he

itssumponheat

ioll teaocad tnusrynlnitovaoirm ni yo ?Rno ei ft txenohltoon

tnaloy

depen

foehssa'hid tenusrytonb ltuasoitrmovaon

nd sn yontee

re mp me ndt

nah f i Wepresenceoaunon.tsonyaswe,lgolechenef k h toworersw ouse

processi

wtmo lla h e

ionh tepropor

421

i

t

)da

hgninmioh fepresenceoaui ton,

ion.

R(T iIera,UOB

tzamo liteswageequaproh ieunont

NOFLAOIT

ssi tnnovaizeproce

f k hworersw en

lik torersub ferownum

OCALLAENSAND ROITOC SINOVANSERP

b feroum

tk dorerexpensoneu

･ktowor

♂E.ac

h terornoh htoosew e

hw ni

t.

fio

lrf

tropor

a

k teworersa

hT

l feveso

t

iitv

qua

lrm

-

d trouc

las

or

1is

ht,

pey

lrm

tra

kworer

kor

h l iltecnoogcaprogress

-a

hw

)

htce

t

t

a,

h tou

k equaworersa

korersa

少 1-

kworer

a

is

wi ep yl H-ndL

re l;A ndB oe ypll

ndw rema da nd nofH-yp mA

t nd( 4 soft Lw katf B. ep no

so ow atf (

mi

nIII, ed eb kc ndu odsst om a eormo es

iasesntt

t

lppdlea

us

ur

ase

V d lweeveo,

rlenc

iotec

h

Its.

hemo

idl ervsa me e

ndrd 飴c nS nI nda yine po mo oc

iscuw

iuno'

tte

dte

io

a

i

pro

S tec

tsa

l

'

dlIe n.hb ieascht moII ktwesec,iontec

henteelsd tnusry.hal ni ti rtftei Weaod etsp nap mihoareseniunobaourichw

V wep deirov

ikpewo ssrerty- 少

he

-

hau

l

A

fpe-

A,

ty

B.s smet tt

fB m Sis1

nlnfferilrkorerw sa mSd yindf so

ttoat

i fonotpropor

H,L;he ln

H

iontec

nSIs.fllasoowdze

l doyeneirektearbaousint rma ndh suhel mp

su rw hp yisi .InSdncrease

ng ma

iitvd troucich

ks.r

dne

re

ion

i

itdcon

ldconcu

=idnexe,

ta

lre

isir

wde

t-

ions

iotpropor

wec rt yp ffmS dbot so yi

nofA ef ta hyp ms ndt no

gP ssi

d terwo

ei htec yo

roce

ii dbconswe yp y -

fiitvd trouc

f k idesoworernexe,

hic

t

hnw ep

nno

ashd terC ions

fll loown

l･pei h tsoreryhftno

-k iorersspewty- 1

loyehtk itew mp me

htatAty.inoudt ssume

ioh teproport

hte

lrfence,i Hve.d trouc mS

ingsexpab isusne'kworerhek trers, ssi nd

pety-

ioh teproporT.om

iitcpae

l loyn

tar

eis

iesp

mp gWO

irm

.THEMODEL

1 Thwo dth fekrerane.

ⅠⅠ

II

rh lbeaour

irm

i tes

h

lp

e

kworersup

ntef

ma

i ltscreelnalbaoura,

nofL

fo ndcnO yd yc

airfpety- msre

ion.tva

no

ni

ioll treaoca

i ispapersorgahT

io

izelma

h teproporthat

k iworerssnor

dtan

acaitirhT

a

efm w hv nc

nda

hk Wworers.

fkorer)t-1♂a,)t nd( 少 w soBpetyf H

521

hfm a hresownirk iorerneacfeow

駒津大学経済学論集 第 41巻 第 4号

ype ka mB m b htyp

ABLE1T

fersoeachenuT.lrftor

T

Lw

el.lTba

t

in

ond depenh f tereore,

siitvtc yi

rocess

ll ioown

drprou

toesno

ighet,

i t tsconsana

lrfta

¢)

mA nhhe gp

ndd

F horeac

ks

hw,

tht

f ktaoworer

(.

H ow

Weassume a Y>y>1. at

)

h t teoupuor

lrmf

irm

り

jheachり f k ipeoworerneacb ferohenum

FirmA (t) Fim β (1-

wokrerH (4) f¢ (1

wokrerL(1-♂ ∫(1-♂) -i)♂(1

)ttiitv-drouc (1-yf

itouny.izel

f kworer

isnor

kor

iitv

nno Mo H w sf kworer

Ldhe tprouc yo

h f kt teoupuoworer

ireover,

L Tdtmyp mat,lrf

ion.

feo

dBt tgenerae ecause.

tva

hte

i

t

igi heveshac hpet yw Hkorerh ltaonposSup

inghtmacO f hl2eoeac.,iiTbavh d teprouc

Y;th

in

is,irfk torsaH hw, ow mAkorerfow

B Ly;ndt

i k d tngworerprouc, hssownt

korer

iiv

h ftaow

T

ais,

htcma yi

ABLE2T

Fim βFirmA

YwokrerH

h hrougievei hsac

i

korers

sawage

fwioll teaocahkt trerances,ircuSU dner

k l tworersvounar

血e eCwoms L er1 no〟1

dt

ndf

tyi isun

amkrerde.P iero

ha

Iitongwk

li

eriissoj

ycng

n dnmaa dmo lWo se

bos.jlng

ccLteuI.

I

2 Des o

i

ingi knueworoc tonf idoperohb i ieegnnngt

)daNOFLBOUR(T iIera,AOITAOCLLAERNSANDOIT

.山tup

OC SDNOVAJSERP

ma goinhtchierto

i tpencursacos.try

idpero,tfh b iie egtta m ngohe

fet eoyp

d tenoesi lveya,k trsrespec,korerw wo ndr

hel te,

o

cco gt

ittraege

At wo wo

ttesmef rtoq ttef ndmoeo Wo sp es st

uc

ursu

t

mi Awo mOma omo oa

b

ew oo omoea yt n fdandp

it :opons

krer

iescrwlge ssi sd es hawo

ln

n.

on

f

v

lr

xpre

k h trersave

i tscosca

tves

h

n

a

a

o

2,

irm

h

hiu

krerw

vttps

o,

ffshi .erpayo

irm

h

a

tze

korerw

t :msances

in

h

ix

dr

h

icrcu

a

a

T

skrer '

hshrougthi t teroupudteiivk doreraw hNa

Olrffptyttabo he eo m tj

)

)2(

(1

)3()LB,C-ALw,,( +wWL, +〟 x1A+ ma-

1 )4(i

heh teotf

)HB,C+W-HAw ,,(

1 )A,C+WH-HBw ,,(WHB+ ma+〟 1 x,-BH,V

htenob ituscrpeconi trsatge,'krerswa hef nds ds sd et

:fllsootteir na ws

LA,

lsvaue'krer

C+W

ewL Ca,kreriresichw, hh wo n b

)5(α-

B-,,L

We

Sliovng

lr.lricons

xlA.

d fer

5

tx,

b llarganng.

lebpro

Ne we Af ndmS m a

mf A

maWL

(

w+〟1 max(+BWL ,-

1 + max+〟1

hed t tenoes wo

h fen orexa,Traollgannbsar'korerhewd ttenoe gpwe Sa. m p

eors .T ollemo efhvesh

1w芸, AX(Y-wH,A)

heichirff minw ht

1

WHA,HA-,V

V

V B

LA,

L ,

hhichw

Vi t tsconex,

h te

h

h

i t tscounrae.

I

d tenoe

krera

h det

nt

stewo

wo ndt ypeo

imfor

W

ll iowngcわh fedtsilye) :ge 'skorerhew♭tri fonsitdon wa

721

駒揮大学経済学論集 第 41巻 第 4号

wH,A -aY )

)

6

7

(

(

)8(=a

isltt t toaoupu,lrff btersewik dworers eenfm S

kworersa

dTze.ixreiitvd taverageproucl dt t toaoupuan

re

ya mami he

)9(

verageffec

h

o

dne

oe

ze

kworer

ix

Jpe

-e

y

t

a

iitvd trouc

kworerswor

lrft

verag

or

-peyan

ence

korersw-pey

sd snta ta

.H ,a ep y ismamidu rtef

･a llt Hw ka mA;llt

dt L ka

A;yp L

inglloow

B;lmftak kworerswor

WI

W W BL,

/ll.

=AL,

l leves.hi t terouputtoi lonatagesareproporw'korersencew,H

tyiivd tyerageprouc3A.ⅠⅠ

=ay

-peyfak Iorers.-eftoionh ll teaoca yp Hw llt H

A;

1tanorkworersw ka yfm.

lmft

Y+(11¢)

L-enoftyp

irmft

d trouc

S丘 ma mo

-

ll :ows

eep yoyp Ht

)

f

he

isa

mariyd m i dbyt

iitv

t,mp at mA nt

ne

t tupu

ir

tee

f

u

ht

l

ixm

l doye

Because

ipr

lttoa

e

Qma 少r-

ioll tocahtt,tonra

tyiiv

lttnusoacos

B

d tprouc

yc s ea

mi t.

i :onsit tsua

-e･a llt Hyp

orkorersw-pey･a llt H w ka

ltt t tsoaoupuierof iareneaclehenwlb i t ttaoursconsan,f hp di

821

tiliitsuhdetfI yo

)daiINOFLAB R( ,T ieraUOOITAALOCLERSINOⅥt NSAmOIrNSECORP

NCHMARKCASES

rs.

ions

eed

it

exc

baou

ii dtcencon

nofl roccu

ht tages a

s

we,

e

i lcu

ar

tar

,

i Inon.

d tenoe

avirtoichas

i itzao

de

l-equaage

ions

hewd ter

Wtx,

icons

Ne ec hec nw hb hf eau np art ei msh r

nr nt

B( dby面) esta

korersfagesowhewi tscase,h

ehai tvetncen

k iorersrecevew

havea

a,llw

B n i ocng

hets

henboswje

tyiivhi d terprouc

ha

bb tosecauseje

B cng

eincashed terions

B

ydtseeiencCl: yi m血e db

irver

nr ec

iouninl ndt nw ha nl ne yfm .P S treen

ionw,

S

ttepresena

iunoichh ieoneP S treenaSo

ffurarenecell) yassa nds

lrmfta

irmfta

haoinc ocng

ty

i tveten

p.Wo ek frerso

haven

na mnyfiagesizewlqua

he yl leves.iitvi d trproucttoi lonatarepropor

eH

irmf

ioi fonsoumtgura五ouscon

Bone,heunbyt ni

ioll teaocahhet, nterfimr

.l ilogcaprogress

katworhw o

･onheutl foeo ni 2I

Ihint lscaseony,

f keorworerhaofrohepayotfiis,htaT ff mjbcng H

a(10)nd(

ntoe

ioitzalageequah b feasenceowInt

yptk forersow

he

ase

r

ou-

i ltonnun

noh f iereore,

cos

T

tofc gtOWOkatt

nt ni ,he nc

id:eifs

III.B

oc riderva

E

hn

ions

ic

T

hw

Wo y Lpetk frersobos.j

dze.ixbtageo eforaveragew mami

ioumh ieresnotenWh

ni tssaioitOdn

Ⅲ .1 No iumom

m ena

he gC

ni

ln

hesa

flloow

its

t

ltecft texeno

lrto

tossan

i ions.ⅡI

nc d也e mo

2 Un nb hrmS

ioil tsocad

-C+αy >αγ ⇔α(Y-y)>C

y丘rm

lrm

92

hos

1

a,d tenoe

:sllowわf

A( dbyw)ndt eatfltfrma

駒揮大学経済学論集

sosha,

tssaioit

ndtec ti

ni

s･ecause excLbosb t eedje

ld:eifsOdnhfll leoowntf面+ di gCh f lb i llC. tereoreaoursreaocae,T

dlesar

baou

tahreasonswhet

nofl

ysnd dmo

第 4巻 第 4号

Y+(1-♂))

1

wo satf A enoi etocng

ha

ha

atfmB egn&mjbcngoo

ivtncen

iaht,

hav

lr

lrmkrer

kworersFor

irideroI.l ilogcaprogresslecBotifene mtmo np 1,fmB

読-α(

面-α(Qy+(1-4))

¢

in

rin

korer

lloow

ilveyw,

h

t

T

eAirBrwage oighitabbtosje oo na he mfmA.ltma L

B. ef ougf

mtspresenoinoichashd terionsionw,tsecis ec ec nw ni dyin丘ei hau

ioll teaocanf herort

W-W>C

ioitdon

tns.provemiicenc

o

ffte

u-no

btonsosr

hempredwiht nit

ythani uc yI metu

a

lp

co

im

omaghitabboha

ierve

ca

ha

h

ic

I

hw

ca

fir

nt

hd

n cng

mA n cngej stoo n tew eB

fiissonhTase.nc eo

諭- -W-

t

hw ere

01 hec>¢> ,For

ZVI.PARTIALUNIONI

sasmallb

lrmkorerw,f iperob i iegnnnttAfageowoheuff toers nina 面. he go d2 nfHi

fm

;bosjhiertehcang

bbto u,jhanges〝C エd ;toesno

:d dereiconsmsre

bto

attpae

1. ndLhHa

2.

eisW

α¢(Y-y)

ATION

risstrong,

β,

B

面 .

;toesnobbto u,jhanges上C 〝d 3.

bos.jehcaLnorHhertine4. ng

031

)daNOFL OUR(Tihera,BAOITAOCLLAERNSANDOITOC SINNOVASERP

ber

n

n

In

krers

r

krer

np m 3 eu nw ecngsb etea nofw

h

korers

lqua

-

T

tor

io

y

ag

ll toca

pe

flm B,th o b yp L o

-

las

f

e

io

t,h

s

hht

hgeca

ltanum

k erer

1

面･-

ln

T

a

tropor

ag

(

h

ecaus

h♂(

t,

i

e

a

me

ha

♂(lt

)

korer

hepayo

w

t

ag

-

ino

-t e

1

ln

krer

tes

fero

ins

1

)

becaus,

,

oe

tem

kttae orers

L kitllo 訂wa yp wong ng w

te

H H siwo srma wo

mB Lndt ftstng ep no wo

L mB1np eo yw ew ee sa.t

Hayos

I

Thes e.

hca

s

I a

L mB ei oα.eo ywo ew ept

i

m 2becaus,

dcorresponngtowo nT

hca

lr

beco

tpae

f

ABLE3T Ho

llledf

)61()

H::上 α面,

h ltteoanumTs1-♂.

-peyep noftiotroporhT.♂)t

ws.lloわi fagesas

inghtacmheacf

b fo ehtani tonsitdcon eedt ul

rsinfm B iir

.I snt sebe ecau,iscah

iwu nwnoheneT.

lrfi tsa

l3e .ba

rke

at(1-

y･諾

irfi tsa

hsownittsraegesare'krers

♂)t-

α〔号諾

d terieconsbirumili Won,ieequt he

¢)+(11

♂-1

)+

wokrerH ss,ttraeg tyaflrm B D htonocan

ge, H :面一,L :-C+面一,

Change

H:--CC++aaYL..

H :-C+ Ya上: αe

wokrerL ttssraeg, tyaflrm Change

D htonocang

i bssuschtIn

hsV.I I Na

ft -ypeo

(11¢

'korershewtsrabirumiliquSheteitt traegesS ob Nahe

駒滞大学経済学論集 第 41巻 第 4号

iltoaes

e1(H:ng;L ng

3ses,

i

oll gc

hT

a

H: αY>面

t

L: a>a

ho

′

0>L Cfollmt gt wstec o sv.ait,

ssump ,hi nn

+

+

htoca

hca

C

C

(H: L:;ca ng on ng

-

:hca

-

scaseca

d

ehtoca

e

e

t

hca

h

hus

hca

d

Fro

i Ton.

Fro

lown

t

2se

3se

asc

f

a

ca (H:on ng;L:ng

mt ri

hetr,ooccui tscasehF tor.birumiliqu

htenr inlteaiotdoni

.birumiliqusNahehebteto

)12(

.birumiliqu

li rises.tnequanowigi ya

a(Yll-)C ¢< =Xlα(-)γ1

sheits)e Nahe

.birumiliqu

h fte, oll

Naheshe

llde.

its

if

)e

α+C Y>面

.ieslgtoLimp c>0

-H:

L:a> +C- a

eedtob ulfeionsnitdon

inlteaiotdconhe i nr

sheits)e Nahe

C-+αY

inlteaioti

Fro

h decon

mt

T nr

′

>′

C

面

-

H:

L: +面 >α

gtoH

nequanh flleoot, wigi lity

231

inlteaiotdconhe i nr gtoH

i)daR(T iIera,UOBNOFLAOITAALOCLERNSANDOITOC SDJNOV

mt

ASERP

Fro

)42(= x2

eitrsw,F

)52(

)82(

)92(

biruiliequheit tcerze m.

.birumiliqu

)y)t(-I-Yt

sheits)e Nahe

¢> =X3 ･

+(llt)tc )1-y(a

mt

mt

troper

htnocaca (H :on ng;L: ngdoehtoca

i feso

d

Fro

Fro

4se

.VI 2 P X

C-H :面> +αY

)1-Y(a-C

haic

i2x ,For

i fesotproper

l l fnavaueso

soi tneaeL dlteuse me x,wh hcra

xI ft

C-L:α> +面′

gtoH,

L,

¢> xl.

¢> a(-It+c

gto上,nr inlteaiotdconhe i

inlteaioth deconi nr

inglteaioth deconi nr to

¢<x 3･

:0-h iteemfid teni yt

331

駒津大学経済学論集 第 41巻 第 4号

α(x t=.

x2l=t1

4t-11･F rX3,f -

y

(( ) ) i 0: tsses o, ,

l2

Cro

C-)1-)03(X=

α(γ-1)

-1:fJ

,hus

I

T x2

)23(x 3 1=.1 -

α (γ-1)

las

:fJ-1

h Xus,

I

T 3 oc

)33(E11-x3l=

rosses(1,1)･

fi

n

d ten

s

ieS decon w, yc

ig

Forh l fesopesotionsonitdon x･ x2:

sgs-in (34)

)13(1-

((a(Y ･-1)-C)(Ca(y-Y)))

431

TIONSANDREAL OCATONOFLABOUR( ,T ieraILROCESSmlNOVAP

3:XFor

)daiI

sgsin-s(igna(y-1)-ci

at∈[ ,♂∈[01,]01, h fereor]T.we re

ma Sf

head ter

わa

icons

idrzebesum

f

iescan

a

h teseproper

he

te,

iidvdst ree a .I

s.llow

n1.iotP iropos

-1>C Y y ss) >a( - )if a(YI hen

･aa

ldeifsta ,t

re

x2

tssaa(yll>ci) d tesiivhenldte,ifs X3d he

lopeshes1i,ecause

he

)a,

ich

11,

ieasitexsar

( ndb Y>y> ft es

nw ht

Becausex2 a 3ndX Cross

herehei tve,tipos nt dsconbiruiliequ mi heseioneit dbyt

ines.

a

l

re

an)w,11,

0-.t

( ecr,ig

ioi tsques

c

h

W

ter

h ihi hesh x2

nbyi

ross

ihc

dtocae

ein

hnw

to

i

i

ha

i hons

ve

h lterea

0r

i itgantnves

X3?Ginttb hl sc

gt pi

s l

2.itonP iropos

wans

-1/ s s)2 iIf c>a(Y henideifsta , t x3 x2

)53(

fIbaove ･

531

駒揮大学経済学論集 第 41巻 第 4号

x3･baoveil dtsocae2xhenldte,ifsa(Yll)/2>ci tssa

ihch

nindepenesa eed goren dd

.htem

ashlndeions,we c ro y t e ie c n wlePXeam

i btpseweeni honsh ltereat

l(H :

2i 1gures,,

uc

iFnhesown

i tsnos

ionsarttua

om hl

feotrt

e

ine,ih

d htonoca

itsooh tecos

(a

B tecause.birumiliqu

H : ng;Lgh heyp

tnodo:

fno

kworer

,as¢

sbeco)ehtnocado

lrmkorerolbtalfro efrw nfH i

L: ng me

hantarger

ioh teproporW.birumiliqu h ent

lrmfro

However

kyworeritaneh beoneoto

B.

db H mf

bleoheareaT wX

lfebtalii ftssnopro or

･igurFinii hsssownhT･ el

iscase

h ieses

o dmo e u g a

Y 1 1>(Yll)/2>Y>y h- - - nty. ,

eedy. y.

I

T4

d3We

n

d toesnoexc

lsnttnsrae

.

In

T

an

ss w tts lg

nd

hrap

on

evera

l lf teveocosa,

hahoitoniropos

ireah teeni i iilTtscasesrva.h re

hilsowa,agew ndt

ashNetsme he

lai iagessil iaunonwthiieni tncreases, mirt

;htnocange

mo

3 N me mples

l ilogcaprogre

ilrcaexau

ltec

V.I

lblseow.hd iteeatliexpan

>a(yl1)

h ieunonk il tworerssow,

C>atshNe asme he

Y()h bcange eco

doH:baaovexl(

bos.jk hworercanges

beco)ehtoca

bu

d

lr

e

-e

hca

t

ng;L:on ng

yp H

Li mA,nf ti spti

ssa hendt

aeY,sischt

T-1).

ephesT

A:aseC

>

CaseB:

a(Y-1) C

Y

631

heate,h fere

S

T

het

A･ or re

Nahe .birumiliqu

i)daNOFL OUR(T iIera,BAOITA

･nd Where3x ,a?2xlx

ALOCLERNSAmOITNOVANISS

･T pb ween

-

teii honsh lterea1･igF

OCERP

e

hs

son

la

heuag

h

t,ino

i fscase ora,

eco

ihfr

hI.

e

tever,

hca

hk i toworerssa,

r

korer

e2 nt rg

;L: ng)b mesteNaH w

eumBnwniH ei

1.02.-C05.,

02.

1i0 古gu.2T0 4../)1- i6.0ii hsssownh nF

41 a., -15y,. -Y

Y(

ehaod(a,are¢a ma H ‥ ontcngndas llt

-petyf

Fo

ioteproporlaBecausea.birumiliequ

iism

rg no

A. rwirmkorertt tracagw ea sw Ltof

)1(y-aseCa C: >C>a

駒津大学経済学論集 第 41巻 第 4号

ndX3,Wherea,2･igF

fyoitlih bbeproattenoeD,

ndd

ium

a,

sp

ftilih bbeproattenoe yo

hayotxpece

e

h

xe

ha

iilt

o

bbroa

jf

fareao

4.0

hT

ttsraegin

-y),

mi de

gthe yo bcng a

oasq. ep y tatt

hee dp ffistes

ff fersromii dgureifsh3Tre.briliqu

1TherelationshipbetweenXl?x2

Y-1.5,y-1.4,a-0.5,C

18.i0guinF

8.01.=

6.ii h0sssownhT

h itereexssant

2.0

Caseα(D:1/ YY-)2>C>α(

hta

hc

igureF 2int

ooskworer

korerw

H

L

eam

ngs

h ttesraeg bhsencoy

dio

ht tw aever

)63(

)daiINOFL OUR( ,T ieraBAOITAOCLLAERNSANDOITSINNOVASEORP

αY一面 -C q= -l -

W -W

)73(

boveh

ugScaeing

Stea

･Almo h仇e ionsitdcon

hieriehhositcoexswbosj itht ew ormanint

olli fsas

hant ts

s.ow

leiBstaioitnaoht,

t tneres

mbec

iissanihT.birumiliqu

ywihr dtow Lkoreregartitlh bbeproaill tary,

面 P=

αTT''-

′ C-α-

nthea aofmi

血e Nahe

xe

S

mi

i ionss

re

is

I

tequa

de ubimriliqu

5y.forit toacunk dorers

mantesme

maye yma on mlnw nywhlixpa

ah

ish

i

b Tos.

re

j

ehaocnghkorersww,

931

C

駒津大学経済学論集 第 41巻 第 4号

･T pb eenXl

- . - .

tew

4a,1

ii hons

5y,1

h lterea

Y

3･igF ndX3,Wherea,x2

1.･0-05C.,

)

-

0.己

heecoehtocad

占;e.

korer

0hca

ilsoww,

4.0

h tecosB tecause.birumilh iasequ

Case

N

a a(H : ng

L:on ng)b mestH

(YE:- irtnhy)>C.Tee eare 1 _

ninwageflltasouoheu2t,

fttac,he

b H i idos encenpero. ,

ha

jhcanges

korworer

lfebta

kh woreus,

li ftsnopro

toss.

It.itny

nc T Ltocng

80

ioil tsocak i dworerncurs in;bosje

i)daR(TiIera,UOBNOFLAOITACOLLAENS DRNAOITAV

nttporaiismt

SNNOSEORP

ase.iuno- nc

e,h ferei idTnonze.ltpar

lbaour.fo

yu or

ionh ll tereaocatt taesiliac

i lonaith dtera

f

korer

nnuench

u

iresence

irv

ecaus

ls

flowerer

lias

iotnnova

d i S dtnusres prea,

i ht t tsonra unonsaveasron,

lyproce,

d itnusres

roce

e

tewor

her

h f i iereoreunons,

Btrsecors.

d i Ct tnusres onsequen.

ich

iot

t

ilTa.

k tesac

id tnusr

t tpoen

fnor

i iunons

a

s

har

yinw ht sp ssi nma od twei ya eo sw

nnwi mayl

si ma ndn ki se yb eo ei eona ft

nohe yc gp nt

mo ki ssi

dt

tk ies

hesa

he Si l ntor Hkworer

ites

f

4me me ng meterra

tporaiismhtaxts

-

lgure

i honw en,

fset

i ttasu

b taou

texre

l teraeaiot

r

fn

i

itr

ht.n

roce

syrr

prove

iase

owe

dne

ino

CONCLUDINGRE

hatgesug

ixercs

prea

liys

h

l iogca

hroug

V.

Ou

ltec

M

rb dp ssistturana ss

ht fu ciro me or nc cceeoee np ra ma n a

ls ndeda T simo me ccu noso

t

0,ろ>¢

ihchwienhera1t, ng

ionitzalqua

i donefhas-dl

hit

li Aa n.ttoen

o

-

h

4

haC .H erngee eedst tintenxcahtence,>)1-

wagitnnovaon, ee

htecorssuc,i iunonze- ds

hw ene,

hepara1t,

nc ･A tteo eetxremtiposphaseiuno-

nd tnusri ionnaitzab f lrsecauseowageequa ni yi

sd tnusrti si ntei yinC sg h

nf

hwetreaerrease

ioil i itaunonza

ltt toaoupu

tpar

d tnusryai hnsucitnnovaon ni ma

VIiontec

tk iorerswi trvesouwici honw,tva hd hp

iency.C

essiotnnovahtaprocettgessliysssug ssi ninl

ng

st

a(

eii)imo yi gin卓, hwenincreasnilltnoonca

Y

s

i

ha

iesifs

hca

tsa

Becaus

a

lweanayseihcb i haourunonsw, dinS

miencCl:B yI

･conomyheoveratniicencffieveaverageehaco yi lle

ionol terafpeoaitsy

t

h

hl

T

itsecorsw

cce ccu

h a

heb Itosn.

W

jng

ti henn t o

rocesnherichw ht ei ssiop nno

isahT na

0<♂<

RKS

141

C

1

駒津大学経済学論集 第 41巻 第 4号

hJeapanesetfgo

1)het

s

hen

toeno

-

2

to

t;()t mi rihed na

,i Y 1 c wsα(-)

keilourwtau

Japanese

h desecon

hohe Mift

T). ho dl

ilnng

ld hlfegeep

lleare,

w

hameet Of Ws maco

kcdl oano he

ing.

ktei

t

lrwou

SttaP tanICtparl

ul

ld tege

foitnsry

azawKofo ma

ioniti dsconhh ten

i dandbla

iib :ssecausehT (

'

ll tueueengff d iere varyn,agesff ierencesnwi

r

i lionsexpa

tngo

le

Vl taua

co

Mo mey(

nt o gq hu hehed dt

mpme

ir

ittsraegc

ff ierencesidlde, nfms

mmeet

We dl oanow

in

kckte

tauurr

ilwou.tyi invers

rogram

t dT y(MEXT

oano hP

h lecnoogSis cencean,Sture por,i Clon u,d tuca

kc

E

t

t

Ky oS tyi invers

8.00

Uyo

2y,

ang

U i invers

to

tyi inversUamazawoK

ies.titporunopbojsit tenerpreenb daca'irm f̀n t modlea,hisiis,lltaT

G) a.3002( ri

ity.d

1

iiagergfttconexow

)> C.

faoourconce

eno

a

)l-

htahesoL Wtaer. ,

t 0;u , hed minad ( t

t-1 wt x2 re mw

dahe2 6

yU

00tttaspresene

CitksaaOt

hef hoit trsaui ton,itdd

rciRc eseafi

† A r1 nohi

miss na

spaperwtf

ioitoca

i ierverso

fmNatensro

Ac

ea

Econo

comm

n

nthi Ina

he

eours.

t

spaperar

ftporoilasupC

ierrors

i lnuf Aidf Sitorcen-in-G tran

dtranlSe,bas

Vi ha yin仙e ttsraeg

fy orexa,sehamo gs yh eenu db mpttraeg

usesuc

in

)50

dlle

02(ltoane

suc

Y >1-

lS he rcReseaS ilpecatftporoupiaCi lnuhfeld tegew

-

nincreasnilltnooncar of x smo g i2 i y i

isI.birumiliequ nh mo

heniguouswsunatig hi yi mb a(Ylequaisnftonh iesT

heti dtnoyoanhSiko

ichicase

dxelluaysessuc)1991

nw h2y

hami

dteiivdd toesno he

iitsshi ton,l l ltecacua he

mitnao

hwen1

deno

α(y-)> O

ide.ifsi t tsnosa

ages.fowtyitnar

i4 Bysmp

5

2

3

241

i)daNOFLBO R(TiIera,UAOITAOCLLAERNSANDOITNOVANISSE

ERENCES

OCRP

itve

lca

lte

i lton ec,

t

nE cR ,8i

i iteunonza

conom

D'e ( mi).100

imerca

2

y:na maa

ievew p.9 p,

iclbu

2.381997p.p,

age

9.

idt ternusr

7-36

n

1p.6p,0i 1conomcs,

di yw

flCS ionerene ererC sonPR h tocese-C iarnege, '

RE

Ch nu mp m e nd liiagenequawtnaloyneianges').9991(.

F

l Dgu,

9,conomyitcailo lE ,1 pp.

Acmo

dsmee ,TeA

Acmo hi ntAg Vi

eadine

h

loa

Blnc

'

L.

2dG Vi e(

denceiv

ltoan

o

o

L.

n

P.,.

an

hcang

P.

l Dgu,

ibla ,d

e

e

a

G iar

llInc, .ice-P treni L d Ha:cs onon,

everancetnloyhT̀).50 eemp m ete飴 c sofs0

E iJ lconomcourna, ,'iesitd 115iiagerg

ni isperso

wime

E iqu

hw

). gbiruil' m waed na19

t

91(.

tnspay

JDry,.

hdlewit

Macroeconom).7991(.h d0ar,

i iarganni :nons

lourna o

ixpanso

Europea,'baor

eore nofu ab gmo

sl nJ fP

･lnaofoultuarerQ, yJ fE'

nandG

4.61922p.5p,i 5cy,Plo

tyilqua

in

Mo me

lechT' ed).3002

tngo

dJ(tran,.S

8.7-9521

yanheort

.

hteerogeneou

二1740一3

ilasf terentid

341