chapter 2 the nature of learner language presented by : aulya p. d. (2201410053)

CHAPTER 2

THE NATURE OF LEARNER LANGUAGE

Presented by :Aulya P. D. (2201410053)

ERRORS & ERROR ANALYSIS

Identifying errors

Describing erros

Explaining erros

Error evaluation

Identifying errors

To identify errors we have to compare the sentences learners produce with what seem to be the normal or ‘correct’ sentences in the target language which correspond with them.

For example, jean says:A man and a little boy was watching him.It is not difficult to see that the correct sentence should be:A man and a little boy were watching him.

Distinguishing errors and mistakes:

• Errors reflect gaps in a learner’s knowledge; they occur because the learner does not know what is correct.

• Mistakes reflect occasional lapses in performance; they occur because, in a particular instance, the learner is unable to perform what he or she knows.

There is an example of an apparent ‘mistake’ in Jean’s speech.Early in the narrative he says:The big of them contained a snake.Using the past tense of the verb ‘contain’ correctly. However, in the final sentence he says:The basket contain a snake.Making what seems to be a past tense error.

Describing errors

• Classifying errors into grammatical categories

We could gather all the errors relating to verbs and then identify the different kinds of verb errors in our samleFor example : errors in the past tense

• Trying to identify general ways in which the learners’ utterances differ from the reconstructed target-language utterances, including : Omission

Leaving out an item that is required for an utterance to be consider grammatical Misinformation

Using one grammatical form in place of another grammatical form Misordering

Putting the words in an utterance in the wrong order

Explaining errors• OmissionFor example : learners leave out the articles ‘a’ and ‘the’ and leave the –s off plural nouns

• OvergeneralizationFor example : the use of ‘eated’ in place of ‘ate’

• Transfer errorsReflect learners’ attempts to make use of their L1 knowledge

Error evaluation• Global errors : violate the the overall

structure of a sentence and for this reason may make it difficult process

• Local errors : affect only a single constituent in the sentence

DEVELOPMENTAL PATTERNS

The early stages of L2 acquisition

The order of acquisition

Sequence of acquisition

Some implications

The early stages of L2 acquisition

• Silent periodThe learners make no attempt to say anything to begin with.

• Propositional simplificationLearners find it difficult to speak in full sentences so they frequently leave words out.For example : Me no blue (I don’t have a blue crayon)

The order of acquisition

• To investigate the order of acquisition, researchers choose a number of grammatical structures to study. Then , they collect samples of learner language and identify how accurately each feature is used by different language. They rank the features according to how accurately each feature is used by the learners.

Sequence of acquisition

Stages in the acquisition of the past tense of ‘eat’Stage Description Example

1 Learners fail to mark the verb for past time.

‘eat’

2 Learners begin to produce irregular past tense forms.

‘ate’

3 Learners overgeneralize the regular past tense form.

‘eated’

4 Sometimes learners produce hybrid forms.

‘ated’

5 Learners produce correct irregular past tense forms.

‘ate’

Some implications

L2 acquisition is systematic and, to a large extent, universal, reflecting ways in which internal cognitive mechanisms control acquisition, irrespective of the personal background of learners or the setting in which they learn.

VARIABILITY IN LEARNER LANGUAGE

• Variability in learner language is systematic• Learners use the linguistic sources in predictable

ways• The use of specific grammatical forms has been

shown to vary according to the linguistic context, the situational context, and the psycholinguistic context

• Variability plays an integrative part in the overall pattern of development, with learners moving through a series of stages that reflect different kinds of variability.