appendix a - iow 15/16 lstf project plan...1c ev hire scheme 50 pp 1d 50drive les, see more dmo 1e...
TRANSCRIPT
Appendix A - IoW 15/16 LSTF Project Plan
14/15 15/16
Current LSTF New LSTF
Qtr 2 Qtr 3 Qtr 4 Qtr 1 Qtr 2 Qtr 3 Qtr 4
Scheme Jul Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr Resource (FTE days in 15/16)
Delivery Lead
Element 1: Access to Visitor Experiences 1A Bicycle Island Phase 2 50 DMO 1B Festival Economy 75 DMO 1C EV Hire Scheme 50 PP 1D Drive Les, See More 50 DMO 1E Travel Ambassadors 200 DMO 1F Grant fund 75 CAIW
Element 2: Access to Employment
2A Workplace engagement prog. 450 CC
2B Workplace bus enhancements 50 SV
2C Best practice partnership 60 CC
2D Hydrogen vehicles 150 PP
2E Share the Road campaign 100 CC
2F Grant fund 75 CAIW
Element 3: Access to Education
3A School engagement prog. 450 SPAA
3B Travel Safe campaign 40 CRP
3C Community activators 50 SPAA
3D Active journey grant 75 CAIW
3E Adult Bikeability 80 IF&R
Programme Management
4A Programme Manager 222 IoWC
Project Planning, Design and procurement DMO Destination Management Organisation
Delivery CAIW Community Action Isle of Wight
Evaluation and Legacy PP Supplier to be Procured
CRP Community Rail Partnership
SPAA Sport and Physical Activity Alliance
IoWC Isle of Wight Council
CC Isle of Wight Chamber of Commerce
IF&R Isle of Wight Fire & Rescue
Appendix B: Monitoring and Evaluation Framework
Code Package Measure Delivery/Output Outcome Monitoring Existing Data [Possible] Additional Data Impacts (Long Term)
Element 1: Access to Visitor Experiences
1A Bicycle Island media campaign
Multi-channel media campaign Increase awareness of travel choices/behavioural change
Modal shift
Increase in cycling
Increase in use of cycling parking
Cycling and walking festival attendances
Reduction in cycle/pedestrian related accidents
Reduction in car use
Increase in number of cycle hires
Increase rail/cycle/ferry tickets sold
Electric vehicle hires
Reduce local congestion
Meaningful engagements achieved by Travel Ambassadors
Media monitoring
Projects supported by the grant fund
Ferry customer numbers
Bus passenger journey numbers
Traffic volumes (permanent and ATCs)
Permanent cycle counts
Accident data
Length/location of public rights of way
Visitor surveys
Bus passenger data
Car park data
Tickets sold at visitor attractions
Local economy/ spend data
Pedestrian and cycle counts (MCC)
Station access surveys (before and after)
Visitor perception/ attitudinal surveys
Cycle parking audit
Number of cycles hired - rail ticket initiative
Number of cycles hired
Number of passengers using interchanges
Number of visitors taking bikes on ferries
Full value and volume data
Media reporting
Reduction in carbon emissions
Increase accessibility/social inclusion
Increase physical activity
Increase economic activity
1B Growing the festival economy
Larger walking and cycling festivals generating more benefit for the local economy
1C Electric Vehicle Hire Network of low carbon electric vehicles available for hire
1D Drive Less, See More toolkit
Marketing collaterals allowing Drive Less, See More messages to be used by all
1E Inspirational Travel Ambassadors
3 x FTE Travel Ambassadors providing sustainable transport advice to visitors and residents
Reduction in carbon emissions
Increase accessibility /social inclusion
Increase economic activity
1F Grant Fund Match funded sustainable transport projects delivered by businesses and communities
1G Travel Coordinator post
Project Management
Element 2: Access to Employment
2A Workplace Engagement Programme
Targeted delivery of proven interventions within the Islands 20 largest employers
Reduce car use
Reduce local congestion
Modal shift
Increase awareness of travel choices/behavioural change
Increase cycling/walking to workplaces
Increase cycling
Number of participants in Programme
Number of journey made by electric bus
Number of journey made by Hydrogen car club vehicles
Share the Road campaign awareness
Projects supported by the grant fund
Number of employees
Number of travel plans
Traffic volumes (permanent and ATCs)
Car park ticket sales/data
Visitor surveys
Bus passenger data
Permanent cycle counts
Accident data
Local vehicle (ATC)counts
Modal shift (before/after) surveys
Visitor perception/attitudinal surveys
Full travel plan monitoring
Manual cycle counts
Number of electric cycles hired
Number of participants - cycle training
Number of people engaged with best practice partnership
Reduction in carbon emissions
Increase accessibility /social inclusion
Increase economic activity 2B
Workplace bus enhancements
Leased electric bus linking large employers with transport hubs
2C Best practice partnership
Strategic alliance with European market leader Reduction in carbon emissions
Increase accessibility /social inclusion
Increase physical activity
Increase economic activity
2D Hydrogen vehicles Network of Hydrogen vehicles available for business journeys
2E Share the Road campaign
Positive campaign aimed at delivering a shared understanding of all road user needs
2F Grant Fund Match funded sustainable transport projects delivered by businesses and communities
Element 3: Access to Education
3A School engagement programme
Targeted delivery of proven interventions within the Islands 49 schools
Increase awareness of travel choices/behavioural change
Increase in cycling and walking
Modal shift
Reduce car use
Reduce local congestion
Increase in visitors arriving by public transport
Reduce carbon emissions
Increase in walking, cycling and public transport
School travel plans
Census
Bespoke school research
Sale of tickets at visitor attractions
Perception/attitudinal users surveys
Manual walking and cycling surveys
Travel plan questionnaires (before and after)
Obesity Index
Pedestrian and cycle counts
Car park surveys
Repeat cyclists
Reduction in carbon emissions
Increase accessibility/social inclusion
Increase physical activity
Improved health
3B Travel Safe campaign
Multi media campaign involving young people promoting sustainable modes
3C Community Activators
Cycle and walking experiences delivered to young people outside of school environment
3D Active Journey grant fund
Match funded sustainable transport projects delivered by education sector
3E Adult Bikeability 500 parents and teachers trained to Level 2 standard
Appendix C – Risk Register
Appendix D – Numerical Inputs and Outputs
HEAT Model Cycling
Measure Element Existing Projected Data Sources Risks and Uncertainties
Notes of Modelling
Annual estimate of existing and projected cycle trips
Education 64872 132120 Total 196992
School Census (2011)
2011 School Census was the last year which asked the question about home to school travel. No more recent data available.
Generates 203% growth and an increase of 2 percentage points in modal share (from 1% to 3%). Growth may appear ambitious but is conservative when compared to outputs from the Sustainable Travel Towns Programme, which achieved up to 540% growth.
Employment 144514 108226 Total 252740
Census (2011) No local data available, so projections are based on the 2011 census
Generates 74% growth, and an increase of 2 percentage points in modal share (from 3.03% to 5.03%)
Visitors 47670 95340 Isle of Wight Tourism Monitor (2012)
Assumes each cycling visitor will undertake 2 cycling trips per visit, on average. This is a combination of a larger proportion of day visitors undertaking 1 trip, and a smaller number of staying visitors undertaking 2+ trips.
Uses responses to the question ‘What mode of transport did you use to travel around the Island?’ Cycling represented 1% in 2012, the ambition is to increase to 2%.
Annual estimate of existing and projected cycling individuals
Education 166 339 additional individuals Total 505
School Census (2011) and school roll numbers (2013)
Mode split question is from 2011 school census. A number of respondents will no longer be in education.
Applies mode split from the 2011 school census to school roll numbers across the Islands 49 schools.
Employment 325 244 additional individuals
Census (2011) Applies mode split from the 2011 census to numbers of
Total 569 employees at the Islands 18 largest employers. Based on an increase of 2% points for cycling, from 3.03% to 5.03%.
Visitor Experiences 23835 23835 additional individuals Total 47670
Isle of Wight Tourism Monitor (2012)
Based on number of individual visitors which explore the Island by bicycle.
Average distance of cycling trip
Education
4.1km 4.1km National Travel Survey (2012)
No change forecast
Employment 14.4km 14.4km DfT Commuting and Business Travel Factsheet (2009)
No change forecast
Visitor 14.4km 14.4km No Isle of Wight data. Figure is based on New Forest data1.
The figure is based on another cycling destination with similar characteristics
No change forecast
Average number of trips per year
Education 390 390 195 school days x 2 trips each day
Assumes cycling will replace previous mode for all trips.
No change forecast, number of school days is fixed
Employment 444 444 222 working days x 2 trips each day
Modelling doesn’t account for part-time working.
No change forecast, number of working days is fixed
Visitor 2 2 Average staying which explores the Island by bike undertakes 2 cycling trips per stay
HEAT Model: Walking
Measure Element Existing Projected Data Sources Risks and Uncertainties
Notes of Modelling
Annual estimate of existing and projected walking trips
Education 3266032
194689 additional trips Total 3460721
School census (2011)
Currency of data Generates 5.9% growth, and an increase of 3 percentage points in modal share.
1 See http://www.newforestnpa.gov.uk/downloads/file/535/new_forest_national_park_application_appendix_1
Employment 758432
99771 additional trips Total 858024
Census (2011) Generates 13% growth, and an increase of 2% percentage points in modal share.
Annual estimate of existing and projected walking individuals
Education 8374
500 additional individuals Total 8874
School roll numbers (2013)
Mode split by school pupil
Employment 1708 224 additional individuals Total 1932
Dunn & Bradstreet listing (2012)
Mode split by employee
Average distance of walking trip
Education
1.6km 1.6km National Travel Survey (2012)
Employment 1.6km 1.6km National Travel Survey (2012)
Average number of trips per year
Education 390 390 195 school days each year x 2 journeys per day
Employment 444 444 222 working days each year x 2 journeys per day
Scheme Impact Pro-forma data
Mode Number of annual trips without scheme
Number of annual trips with scheme
Variance Notes and Reference to supporting information
Education Car Driver N/A N/A N/A Assumes no school children are car drivers
Car Passenger 1418484
1252063 -166421 (13% reduction)
Based on a reduction of 4% in trips made by car for primary school children, 5% for secondary school children, and 1% for SEN.
Bus Passenger 998661
998661
0 No change forecast. Home to school transport is operating effectively on the Island, with limited scope for efficiencies.
Rail Passenger 60200
60200
0 Rail network is limited to one corridor on the Island, limited scope to increase modal split in the education sector. Secondary schools are clustered around Newport, which isn’t served by the rail network.
Cyclists 64872
196992 +132120 (203% increase)
Ambitious growth is conservative when compared outcomes achieved through the Sustainable Travel Towns Programme2. Increase will be achieved through
2 [Darlington], Cycling increased by 425% and 540% respectively (in both cases, 5%-points) in these two groups of schools. See https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/4419/chap12.pdf
delivery of a full range of proven interventions to achieve modal shift.
Walking 3266032
3460721
+194689 (5.9% increase)
Walking is already the predominant mode for journeys to school on the Island, currently 54% for primary schools and 46% for secondary schools. Projected growth is consistent with results from the Sustainable Travel Towns programme.
Employment Car Driver 2601734
2363261
-238473 (10% reduction)
5 percentage point reduction in mode share, from 54.55% to 49.55%, or a 10% reduction in number of trips, comparable with outcomes achieved in the Sustainable Travel Demonstration Town programme in Peterborough3
Car Passenger 217010
264704
47694 (21% increase)
A 1 percentage point increase is forecast, based on an increase in mode share from 4.55% to 5.55%, representing an increase of 21%.This will be achieved through the business engagement programme.
Bus Passenger 200794
296183
95389 (47% increase)
A 2 percentage point increase is forecast, from 4.21% to 6.21%, representing a 47% increase during 15/16. The IoW has a comprehensive bus network yet commuting by bus falls well below the national average (7.1%). We will achieve this increase by promoting and incentivising use of existing services and enhancing bus route 39, which we predict will generate 35000 additional passenger journeys in year 1.
Rail Passenger 64388
64388
0 We do not forecast an increase in rail patronage as our target employers are mostly located away from the Islands rail network.
Cyclists 144514
252781
108267 (74% increase)
We forecast a 2 percentage point increase in cycle trips, delivering a 74% increase in trips. Again, this accords with outcomes achieved through the Sustainable Travel Towns programme, and will be realised through our business engagement programme.
Walking 758342
858024 99771 (13% increase)
13% growth will be achieved through an increase of 2 percentage points, from 15.99% to 17.99%. Capital improvements delivered through the current LSTF programme and the PFI agreement with Island Roads are improving the walking environment on the Island.
3 See https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/4418/chap11.pdf
Our targeted engagement programme will inspire greater usage.
Visitor Experiences Car Driver 2719500
2641600
77900 (2.9% reduction)
Current LSTF programme will reduce trip private car trips by 3% by March 2015. Therefore our base will be 70% modal share reduced from 73% in 2012. We forecast an additional 2 percentage point reduction through 2015/16, achieved through an increased marketing drive for car free breaks, and an improved sustainable transport offer e.g. electric vehicle hire, cycling etc.
Car Passenger 2719500
2641600
77900 (2.9% reduction
We forecast the same reduction as above, based on a 2 person per vehicle occupancy rate for tourism related car trips4
Bus Passenger 1087800
1243200
155400 (14% growth)
An increase of 14% is forecast, based on an increase of 1 percentage point from 7% to 8% of modal share. Growth will be achieved through marketing, joint ticketing and additional products, such as the Island Coaster service delivered through the current LSTF programme.
Rail Passenger 51800 52059
259 (0.5% growth) We forecast a modest 0.5% increase in rail journeys, based on the links with connections from the mainland at Ryde.
Cyclists 47669
95338 47669 (100% growth)
This is an increase of one percentage point, from 1% to 2% of visitor modal share. There is significant scope to grow cycling on the Island, particularly cycle tourism, and much of the focus of both our current and proposed LSTF programmes seeks to achieve this.
Walking 466200
466200
0 No significant increase in walking is proposed.
Carbon Saving data (DfT basic carbon tool)
Element Scenario Total emissions pre-intervention (tonnes of Co2)
Total emissions post intervention (tonnes of Co2)
Carbon saving at the end of 15/16 (tonnes of Co2)
Carbon cost saving5 at £29 per t/co2
Education Journeys between home and school currently undertaken by private car are replaced by cycling and walking journeys.
890 790 100 £2900
4 See p22 https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/243957/nts2012-01.pdf 5 See https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/48184/3136-guide-carbon-valuation-methodology.pdf
Employment Journeys between home and workplaces currently undertaken by private car are replaced by cycling, walking and bus journeys
6000 5460 540 £15660 Outputs based on applying scenario to DfT Carbon Tool. Carbon valuation based on 2013 non-traded values
Visitor experiences Visitors replacing private car journeys with cycling and bus journeys
8109 7877 232 £6728
Total 14999 14127 872 (6% reduction) £25288
Valuing Decongestion
Element Total car km’s pre intervention
Total car km’s post intervention
Km’s saved Value of car km’s removed6 (6p per km saved)
Education 5815784
5133458 682121 £40,927 Figure based on average home to school journey of 4.4km (NTS 2012)
Employment 37464969
34030958 3434011 £206,040 Figure based on average home to work journey of 14.4km (NTS 2012)
Visitor Experiences 57109500
55473600 1635900 £98,154 Figure based on average car journey distance for leisure trips on the Isle of Wight. This is an assumption based on input from industry expects, and a consideration of the Islands unique road network and geography.
Total 1189112 £345,121 6p per km saved is based on Sustainable Travel Town conclusions of 4p per km saved, increased to reflect inflation.
Valuing Health Benefits of increased cycling (from HEAT)
Element Number of new cyclists generated in 15/16
Cost saving per new cyclist
Saving
Education 339 £578 £195942 HEAT model output, based a value of £578 per additional cyclist. Model not appropriate for visiting cyclists.
Employment 244 £578 £141032
Total £336,974
Visitor Economy Contribution
Number of additional overnight staying visitors
Average spend per trip during 15/16
Current total visitor spend
Additional LSTF generated spend
% Visitor economy growth generated through this proposal
Visit Isle of Wight has ambitious plans for growth, and seeks to increase visitor numbers from 2.38M in 2012 to 2.59M by the end of 2015, an additional 210,000 visitors. LSTF will help to deliver this growth, with a focus on new car-free visitors, figures presented in this
6 See https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/4428/chap21.pdf
23834 £161.81 £264,132,000 £3,837,274 1.47% growth table are a conservative estimate, based on the number of additional cycling staying visitors to the Island in 15/16.
Number of new jobs
Element
Additional jobs created through LSTF interventions in 15/16
Methodology and assumptions
Education
8 Based on estimate of FTE’s created through new products introduced through the LSTF programme, noting that the outcomes for the education elements are focused on improving health and wellbeing of young people, and the target market is not in employment. - School Engagement Programme = +3 FTE - Community Activators = +1 FTE - Active Journey Grant = +3 FTE, cumulative growth generated across all projects - Adult Bikeability = +1 FTE
Employment
10 Based on estimate of FTE’s created through new products introduced through the LSTF programme and existing products which receive additional usage through mode shift. - Workplace Engagement Programme = +3 FTE - Workplace bus enhancements = +2 FTE - Hydrogen vehicles = +2 FTE - Grant fund = +3 FTE, cumulative growth generated across all project
Visitor experiences
184 Based on visitor spend by FTE calculation, 14/15 spend/FTE is £264M/14700FTE = £17968 spend per FTE. Total new visitor spend in 15/16 is estimated at £3.8M/£17968 = 184 additional new FTE (adjusted to account for 26% of tourism jobs being part-time7)
Total 202
Other output measures for the programme
New transport product or service
Description Number of users in 15/16
Evidence
Electric vehicle hire A fleet of five electric vehicles available for hire, predominantly by visitors
2338 (average occupancy of 2 persons)
Applies similar business model to existing projects in the Lake District, New Forest and London8
Assumes 80% hire rate between April and October, and 20% hire rate from November to March April to October hires = 4 hires per day for 217 days = 868 hires November to March hires = 2 hires per day for 148 days = 296 hires
7 http://www.ons.gov.uk/ons/rel/lms/labour-market-statistics/october-2013/single-month-labour-force-survey-estimates--october-2013--not-designated-as-national-statistics-.html 8 http://www.businessgreen.com/bg/news/2333928/electric-boris-cars-set-to-hit-london-in-2015
Total hires in 15/16 = 1164 @ £45 = £52380
Route 39 frequency enhancements
A project to improve transport links between workplaces and transport hubs
35000 passenger journeys
Programme predicts an additional 95389 employment related bus trips in 15/16. Demand from workplaces for better transport links
Assumes 157 passenger journeys on each of the 222 working days.
Hydrogen fuelled vehicle car club
A fleet of two hydrogen powered vehicles available for business to access via a car club
888 When employers provide alternatives to car ownership at the workplace, this has a transformative effect that reduces individuals’ propensity to drive for all trip purposes.
Assumes 4 trips per day for 222 working days.
Appendix E: Letters of Support
ECONOMY AND ENVIRONMENT County Hall High Street
Newport Isle of Wight PO30 1UD
Telephone 01983 821000
Lee Matthews Recreation and Open Spaces Manager
Email: [email protected]
22nd March 2014 Dear Wendy SPAA support – Local Sustainable Transport Fund (LSTF 2) On behalf of our local Sport and Physical Activity Alliance (SPAA) we fully support the Isle of Wight Council’s bid for LSTF 2 revenue funding. The proposal to deliver a programme that will inspire our visitors and residents to build active, sustainable modes of travel into everyday journeys fits perfectly with a number of strategic plans the group aligns itself too. The SPAA is multi agency partnership that helps coordinate and deliver a number of projects in partnership across the Island. We strongly support this innovative programme of education and school engagement, which will be both, be creative and ambitious. We will deliver through proven partnerships with the education, business and tourism sectors, delivering a series of shared outcomes and creating a legacy which is sustainable for the future. The Isle of Wight Council’s proposals will improve and promote the health of inactive people from wards across the Isle of Wight, therefore reducing inequalities. The benefits of physical activity are well known and this LSTF programme will benefit the health of Island residents. Isle of Wight SPAA is pleased to support and work in partnership with the Isle of Wight Council in order to help build and develop local opportunities to be more active. Yours sincerely Lee Matthews Recreation and Open Spaces
Elaine Cesar – Senior Events Officer
5th Floor County Hall Newport Isle of Wight PO30 1UD Tel (01983) 821000 Ext 6297 Email [email protected] Webwww.isleofwightwalkingfestival.co.k
Wendy Perera Deputy Head of Planning Services (Policy)| Planning Services Isle of Wight Council Seaclose Offices Fairlee Road, Newport Isle of Wight PO30 2QS
31 March 2014 Dear Wendy RE: Isle of Wight Walking & Cycling Festival Delivery of the Extended LSTF Project I would like to in brief write in support of the LSTF project. This funding has gone a long way in assisting the delivery and growth of both the Isle of Wight Walking Festival and Cycling Festival. It is essential in order to encourage additional participation of both locals, but primarily visitors to the Island, that we maintain and grow the transport infrastructure. The project also assists in improving healthy activity and encouraging people of all ages to participate in our outdoor activities and the drive less see more theme has had a very positive impact on peoples perception, and it has been extremely noticeable that many visitors to the Island are enquiring on how to get to the Island without their car, and the availability of local transport for both walkers and cyclists. The match funding for both Walking and Cycling at the moment stands at £60k, which potentially could increase with additional sponsorship. Yours sincerely
Elaine Cesar Senior Events Officer
From: ALEX LAWSON [[email protected]]
Sent: 26 March 2014 14:50
To: Perera, Wendy
Cc: TIM THORNE
Subject: IW Council LSTF Draft Bid for 15/16 : Response from Cyclewight
Wendy Perera | Deputy Head of Planning Services (Policy)| Planning Services
Dear Wendy,
Cyclewight are fully in support of the IW Council LSTF 2 bid.
We will continue to organise the Cycle Forum as liaison between the IW Council and bodies with
cycling interests on the Isle of Wight.
This includes cycling clubs, sale repair and hire businesses, as well as the police and emergency
services.
We note and support the objective to encourage visits to the island which are not car dependent.
A barrier to this is that mainland trains provide less space for luggage and in particular for bicycles
than they used to, in that the guards van has disappeared. There may be common ground with South
Hampshire Local Authorities in seeking to redress this problem.
However this barrier may provide business opportunities on the island to hire cycles or electric
vehicles to those keen to come to the island without a car. It is to be hoped that accommodation
providers will find ways to benefit from the situation.
regards,
Alexander Lawson
Secretary, Cyclewight
www.cyclewight.org.uk