appendix d: codebook

42
Appendix D: Codebook D.1 Overview This codebook refers to annual classifications of governmental institutions in the world along three dimensions: 1. Type of Electoral System: Majority-Plurality, Semi-proportional or Proportional Representa- tion. 2. Form of Executive: Presidential, Semi-presidential or Parliamentary. 3. Federalism of Political Authority: Unitary, Semi-federal or Federal. The data was created as part of the dissertation ’Institutional Variance of the Democratic Peace, 1816-2002: Electoral, Executive, and Federal Systems in Time and Space.’ 284

Upload: others

Post on 11-Feb-2022

30 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Appendix D: Codebook

Appendix D: Codebook

D.1 Overview

This codebook refers to annual classifications of governmental institutions in the world along threedimensions:

1. Type of Electoral System: Majority-Plurality, Semi-proportional or Proportional Representa-tion.

2. Form of Executive: Presidential, Semi-presidential or Parliamentary.

3. Federalism of Political Authority: Unitary, Semi-federal or Federal.

The data was created as part of the dissertation ’Institutional Variance of the DemocraticPeace, 1816-2002: Electoral, Executive, and Federal Systems in Time and Space.’

284

Page 2: Appendix D: Codebook

D.1.1 Variable Definitions

Column Variable Description

SSNO Country codes from Gleditsch and Ward (1999).Year Year in which country is observed.Name Country name.Primkey Primary key for the purpose of merging datasets,

(SSNO*10000)+year.Sysmember System membership as defined by Gleditsch and Ward (1999):

0=No, 1=Yes.Election dem Electoral system in democracies (dem-aut>=3), 1816-2002:

1=Majority-Plurality, 2=Semi-PR, 3=PR, 4=Autocracy.Parlpres Form of executive, 1816-2002: 1=Presidential, 2=Semi-

presidential, 3=Parliamentary, 4=Non-elective.Federal Degree of Federalism, 1816-2002: 1=Unitary, 2=Hybrid, 3=Fed-

eral.Electiondem dur Duration of electoral system in democracies, 1946-2002.Electionall dur Duration of electoral system in all states, 1816-2002.Parlpres dur Duration of presidential/parliamentary system in all states,

1816-2002.Federal dur Duration of federal system in all states, 1816-2002.Indexksg Authority index from the Polity4 dataset (democracy-

autocracy), ranging from -10 to +10, plus -66=Interruption,-77=Interregnum, -88=Transition.

D.1.2 Cases Included

The criteria for inclusion is based on the Gleditsch and Ward (1999) revision and update of theRussett, Singer and Small (1968) list of independent states from 1816 to present. According to thislist, an independent polity needs to meet the following criteria: a) it has a relatively autonomousadministration over some territory, b) is considered a distinct entity by local actors or the state itis dependent on, and c) has a population greater than 250,000 (Gleditsch and Ward, 1999:398).96

I base the identification of democracy on the Polity4, version 1.0 (Gleditsch, 2003). Thisversion of the Polity data has been modified and extended to fit the Gleditsch and Ward (1999)system membership definition. Scholars have used different thresholds on the democracy-autocracyindex to classify democratic states, with a score of 6 is considered a strict level and a score of 3 isseen as lenient. In order to leave the choice of strictness to each user of this data, electoral systemsare recorded in all countries that receive a score of democracy-autocracy >= 3 on the Polity4 index.

D.1.3 Classification of Electoral Systems

Electoral systems ’translate the votes cast in a general election into seats won by parties and candi-dates. The key variables are the electoral formula used’ (Reynolds and Reilly, 1997:7). Furthermore,an electoral system is ’a set of elements of the electoral regulations that have a direct influence onthe conversion of votes into seats by parties and candidates. It is the basic lines of mediation that allelectoral laws apply between votes and representation integrating, as such, the core decisions that all

96Countries that do not meet the criteria for system membership are American Samoa, Andorra, Antigua andBarbuda, Aruba, Bermuda, Cayman Islands, Cook Islands, Dominica, French Guiana, Grenada, Guadeloupe, Guam,Kiribati, Lichtenstein, Marshall Islands, Micronesia (Federated State of), Monaco, Nauru, Netherlands Antilles, NewCaledonia, Niue, Northern Marina Islands, Palau, Palestinian Territory (occupied), Reunion, Saint Kitts and Nevis,Saint Lucia, Saint Pierre and Miquelon, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, Samoa, San Marino, Sao Tome andPrincipe, Seychelles, Tonga, Turks and Caicos Islands, Vanuatu, Wallis and Futuna.

285

Page 3: Appendix D: Codebook

legislators must adopt when it comes to drafting an electoral laws, those that are able to bring aboutdifferent results in terms of representation with the same numbers of popular votes. It is a way toconstitute government bodies’ (ACE Project, 2003). The International Institute for Democracy andElectoral Assistance (International IDEA) (Reynolds and Reilly, 1997) and the ACE Project (2003)apply the same definitions of electoral systems.

The data here records legislative elections, including democracies only. The coding is straight-forward if the national assembly or parliament has a unicameral structure, but in the event of abi-cameral structure, the lower chamber is generally the most influential and therefore used as thebasis for the coding (Druckman and Thies, 2002:760). Electoral systems come in many forms, whichcan be classified within three main groups: plurality-majority, semi-proportional, and proportionalelections (Reynolds and Reilly, 1997:17-25).

1. Majority-Plurality Electoral Systems (Maj-Plur): Systems that use single-member districtsand favors allocating many seats to few parties or candidates. The winner is the one whoreceives the most votes or the majority of the votes.

2. Semi-Proportional Electoral Systems (Semi-PR) Systems which inherently translate votes intoseats won in a way that falls somewhere between the proportionality of proportional represen-tation systems and the majoritarianism of plurality-majority systems.

3. Proportional Representation Electoral Systems (PR): Representation proportionate to theoverall share of the national vote in order of the winning candidates’ position on the lists.

There are several difficulties involved in coding electoral systems. First, no sources system-atically record electoral systems annually for the entire 200-year period of interest. Most sourcesavailable classify electoral systems at the time of coding, which very often is not explicitly stated.Second, electoral systems exist in many different forms and discrepancies between different classifi-cations seem largely due to the application of unlike definitions and confusion of similar labels usedto classify different systems. A third problem refers to the failure of making the focus of attentionexplicit, for example whether referring to presidential or parliamentary elections, local or centralelections, or to the upper- or lower chamber of the parliament. All these problems are dealt with byconsulting different sources of information, among them are many excellent case studies and com-parative case studies. When sources are conflicting, the choice made is made explicit in footnotes(see below in coding scheme).

Another problem is that of classifying the years immediately following a period of authori-tarian rule or transition. Many of the newly independent countries are former colonies in which thefirst year of democratic rule is characterized by the former colonial power appointing a governmentor holding elections, whereas the first truly independent legislative election tends to follow withinthe next 5 years. In this situation, each country receives a code also for the first year upon inde-pendence because the governmental setup tends to be in the spirit of the electoral system, which isoften constitutionally accepted, although not always practically applied at that point.

Lastly, coding electoral systems rely on already made operational definitions of democracy.It is important to keep in mind the likely bias inherently present in classifying democracy andautocracy: the fewer democracies in a region, the laxer the region-specific criteria for classifying acountry as democratic (Geddes, 1999:13).

D.1.4 Classification of Executive

Executive systems define formal political authority between the head of state, the cabinet, and thelegislative. The two main forms of executive systems are presidentialism and parliamentarism.

The ’Executive Systems’ variable was generated through a three-stage process: It takes asits basis information from the variables ‘Type of Regime,’ ‘Head of State,’ ‘Effective Executive’

286

Page 4: Appendix D: Codebook

and ‘Legislative Selection’ from the Banks dataset (1986). These results were largely checked andcomplemented by consulting historical records. Lastly, the values have been extrapolated in order toavoid the problem of missing data. Specifically, this technique proved useful to overcome the problemof missing information during the two World Wars in the original data, and in order to extend theusage of the dataset from 1995 to 2002. If the code starting after the end of a World War differedfrom the code at the outset, the code during the war was assigned as a continuation of the code atthe war outset, because major regime changes generally took place in the aftermath of the WorldWars. In addition, the extrapolation technique was applied to avoid missing information created bydifferent criteria for inclusion in Banks (1986, 1996) and Gleditsch and Ward (1999). The generalcriteria for extrapolating being changes in the Polity4 index score of less than 3 during the relevanttime period. One example is Wurttemberg, which was included during 1816-1869 in Banks whereasGleditsch and Ward continue to regard it as an independent state until 1871. Consequently, theinformation for 1870-71 was coded based on the ending years in the Banks dataset. Another exampleis Hesse-Darmstadt in which the data for 1867-71 was based on previous Banks coding. Anothermodification of the original data was smoothening the data by recoding observations classified as‘other’ into one of the categories below. Typically, these are countries in which the head of state isclassified as ‘monarch’ for a single year within a longer period of a prime minister being regarded asthe effective executive.

1. Presidential (Pres): Systems in which the president exercises primary influence in the shapingof most major decisions affecting the state’s domestic and foreign policy. In this category fallregimes in which the effective executive was originally classified as ‘other’ or ‘military’ and thehead of state was president. The most important feature of presidential systems is that thegovernment is appointed by and contingent on presidential approval.

2. Semi-Presidential (Semi-Pres): Systems in which a prime minister works as the head of thegovernment (effective executive), whereas the head of state is a president. In some semi-presidential systems, the president possesses little effective power, at least in the democraticsemi-presidential states such as Finland and Iceland. However, in other semi-presidentialsystems, the president has some executive powers.

3. Parliamentary (Parl): Systems in which the executive is depending on legislative approval andin which the prime minister exercises primary influence in the shaping of most major decisionsaffecting the state’s domestic and foreign policy. This category also encompasses parliamentarymonarchies in which the head of state is a monarch, but the formal executive is the premier.An example of a parliamentary monarchy is contemporary Spain.

4. Military: Direct rule by the military, mostly following a coup d’etat, or an outwardly civiliangovernment that is effectively controlled by a military elite. Some of these observations areregimes in which the government achieved power through coup d’etat.

5. Non-elective: Systems in which selection of the effective executive is non-elective, such as 19thCentury European monarchies and theocracies in the Middle East.97 Franco Spain falls in thiscategory, as well as the nomenklatura systems in Eastern Europe.98 As there are examples ofin some nomenklatura systems, it is possible for a country to have an electoral system without

97Vanhanen (2000:254) interprets systems in which the governmental institution using the highest executive orlegislative power is not based on popular elections as power being concentrated in the hands of one group. Vanhanendescribes these regimes as being ’military, revolutionary, non-elective autocratic governments, and monarchies inwhich the ruler and the government responsible to the ruler dominate and exercise executive and often also legislativepower.’ Vanhanen’s description encompasses most of the regimes that I classify as non-elective.

98Nomenklatura is the communist party’s system of appointing key personnel in the government and other importantorganizations. Determining whether communist regimes were non-elective in this sense was difficult at times. The

287

Page 5: Appendix D: Codebook

actually performing elections. Other observations in this category are autocratic regimes inwhich there are no legislative or presidential elections under democratic or autocratic rule.These are Bhutan, Brunei, China, Eritrea, Quatar, Saudi Arabia, Somaliland and the UnitedArab Emirates.

D.1.5 Classification of Federalism

In most democratic states, the constitution determines the territorial distribution of powers (Hagueand Harrop, 1987:163), or in other words, the national and the sub-national concentration of politicalauthority. The two main forms are unitary states, in which sovereignity is placed at the centralgovernment, and federal states where there is a formal distribution of power between the central andthe sub-national government.

This variable was generated from a combination of sources. The starting point was the PolityIII dataset’s classification of ‘federalism of political authority’ (Gurr, Jaggers and Moore, 1989;Jaggers and Gurr, 1996) during 1816-1994. The variable was compared to other comprehensivedata sources and literature, such as Gerring and Thacker’s data on unitarism (2004), Lundell andKarvonen’s dataset on institutions (2003) and Lemco’s study of federal governments (1991). Whenthese sources differed, additional sources was consulted. The data was extended by following certainrules. First, assuming continuation backward and forward of code unless there was a transitioncode in-between. Secondly, assuming continuation backward and forward of code unless there wasa major change in the polity code.

Gurr, Jaggers and Moore (1989:21) political authority variable builds on structural patternslayed out by Eckstein and Gurr (1975). They refer to federalism of political authority as ‘an im-portant structural property of national political systems that is related to several dimensions ofauthority patterns [...]. In purely structural terms it is an aspect of Conformation: federal politieshave greater complexity of Conformation than do centralized polities. Opportunities for Partici-pation also tends to be higher in federal systems, and regional units of government potentially aremore responsive to local inputs than are centralized governments.’

Gerring and Thacker’s (2002, 2004) data and definition of federalism as ‘a highly institu-tionalized division or sharing of responsibilities between a national authority and semi-autonomousregional units.’ Gerring and Thacker’s data provide records of federalism during 1900-2001. SinceGurr, Jaggers and Moore’s and Gerring and Thacker’s universe did not always correspond to that ofmy own (as defined by Gleditsch and Ward (1999)), I altered and checked the applicability the datafor my purpose by consulting different sources on federalism. For example, I looked at Lundell andKarvonen’s (2003) comparative data set on political institutions during 1960-2002. Furthermore,Hicken and Kasuya (2003) provided an excellent source for Asia after 1945 and McHenry (1997)offered insightful discussions of federalism in post-independent African countries. Lemco (1991)provided historical information on federations.

Since the degree to which responsibilities are shared between central and local governmentalunits varies and this power-division is not always formally approved by the constitution, federalismcan sometimes be difficult to determine and operationalize. For example, the existence of territorial

1959 Constitution of North Korea was explicitly communist but established a symbolic president, an assembly and acouncil headed by the prime minister as the formally highest executive organ, when in reality all political power laidwithin the Political Bureau. Constitutional changes in 1980 replaced the North Korean president with the Council ofState in which all power was concentrated. North Korea was classified as non-elective therefore. The Socialist Republicof Vietnam (North) was similarly classified as non-elective during 1954-91: Until 1959, Ho Chi Minh’s presidentialgovernment dominated Vietnamese politics and from 1960 until 1991, parliamentary elections were held, but the realpower lied within the Communist Party. During 1960-1991 therefore, North Vietnam is classified as non-elective. Theconstitutional changes in 1992 reinstated the president as the head of state, established a national assembly, and aprime minister as the head of government, which qualified North Vietnam to be classified as semi-presidential.

288

Page 6: Appendix D: Codebook

sub-divisions in a country does not necessarily mean that these regions are guaranteed autonomy.Building on the sources layed out above, my own regime classification fall into three categories:

1. Unitary: Elective legislatures and constitutional sovereignty centered at the national govern-ment.

2. Semi-Federal: There are elective legislatures at the regional level, but constitutional sovereigntyis reserved to the national government.

3. Federal: Elective regional legislatures plus constitutional recognition of subnational authority.In this category fall countries in which the constitution formally divides legislative authoritybetween regional and central governmental units.

Classification of the above outlined categories was not always straightforward. For example dosome formally unitary regimes such as Japan assure substantial authority to regional governments,whereas power is very limited in some formally federal regimes, such as Malaysia (Hicken and Kasuya,2003:127-128). The Philippines is fairly unitary, but is classified as mixed since substantial power isgranted to governance regionally. Such aspects of the federal-unitary distinction are a reminder ofthe complexity hidden inside categories like federal and unitary, which is difficult to capture in theform used here.

289

Page 7: Appendix D: Codebook

D.2

Codin

gSch

em

e,G

overn

menta

lIn

stitutions,

1816-2

002

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

700

Afg

hanis

tan

1816-1

888

1919-2

002

1816-1

888:

Auto

cracy

1919-1

977:

Auto

cracy

1979-1

991:

Auto

cracy

1996-2

000:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

888:

Non-E

lect

ive

1919-1

972:

Non-E

lect

ive

1973-1

977:

Military

1979-1

979:

Military

1980-1

991:

Pre

s1996-2

000:

Non-E

lect

ive

1816-1

888:

Fed

eral

1919-1

924:

Fed

eral

1925-1

977:

Unitary

1979-1

991:

Unitary

1996-2

000:

Unitary

339

Alb

ania

1913-2

002

1913-1

914:

Auto

cracy

1925-1

938:

Auto

cracy

1946-1

991:

Auto

cracy

1992-1

995:

Sem

i-P

R1996-1

996:

Auto

cracy

1997-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R

1913-1

914:

Unitary

1925-1

938:

Unitary

1946-2

002:

Unitary

615

Alg

eria

1816-1

830

1962-2

002

1816-1

830:

Auto

cracy

1962-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

830:

Non-E

lect

ive

1962-1

964:

Pre

s1965-1

975:

Military

1976-2

002:

Pre

s

1816-1

830:

Mis

sing

1962-2

002:

Unitary

540

Angola

1975-2

002

1975-1

990:

Auto

cracy

1997-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1975-1

990:

Pre

s1997-2

002:

Pre

s1975-1

990:

Unitary

1997:

Mis

sing

1998-2

002:

Unitary

160

Arg

enti

na

1816-2

002

1816-1

828:

Auto

cracy

1835-1

851:

Auto

cracy

1853-1

936:

Auto

cracy

1937-1

942:

Maj-P

lur

1943-1

945:

Auto

cracy

1948-1

954:

Auto

cracy

1957-1

972:

Auto

cracy

1973-1

975:

PR

1976-1

982:

Auto

cracy

1983-2

002:

PR

1816-1

828:

Pre

s1835-1

851:

Pre

s1853-1

929:

Pre

s1930-1

930:

Military

1931-1

945:

Pre

s1948-1

954:

Pre

s1957-1

965:

Pre

s1966-1

972:

Military

1973-2

002:

Pre

s

1816-1

828:

Fed

eral

1835-1

851:

Fed

eral

1853-1

945:

Fed

eral

1948-1

954:

Fed

eral

1957-2

002:

Fed

eral

290

Page 8: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

371

Arm

enia

1991-2

002

1991-1

995:

Sem

i-P

R1996-1

997:

Auto

cracy

1998-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R

1991-2

002:

Pre

s1991-2

002:

Unitary

900

Aust

ralia

1901-2

002

1901-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1901-2

002:

Parl

1901-2

002:

Fed

eral

305

Aust

ria

1918-2

002

1920-1

932:

PR

1934-1

937:

Auto

cracy

1946-2

002:

PR

1920-1

932:

Sem

i-P

res

1934-1

937:

Sem

i-P

res

1946-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1920-1

932:

Sem

i-Fed

1934-1

937:

Sem

i-Fed

1946-2

002:

Sem

i-Fed

300

Aust

ria-H

ungary

1816-1

918

1816-1

917:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

917:

Non-E

lect

ive

1816-1

866:

Mis

sing

1867-1

917:

Sem

i-Fed

373

Aze

rbaijan

1991-2

002

1991-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1991-2

002:

Pre

s1991-2

002:

Unitary

267

Baden

1816-1

871

1816-1

871:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

871:

Non-E

lect

ive

1816-1

871:

Unitary

31

Baham

as

1973-2

002

1973-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1973-2

002:

Parl

1973-2

002:

Unitary

692

Bahra

in1971-2

002

1971-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1971-2

002:

Non-E

lect

ive

1971-2

002:

Unitary

771

Bangla

des

h1972-2

002

1972-1

973:

Maj-P

lur

1974-1

990:

Auto

cracy

1991-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1972-1

974:

Sem

i-P

res

1975-1

975:

Military

1976-1

981:

Sem

i-P

res

1982-1

985:

Military

1986-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1972-2

002:

Unitary

53

Barb

ados

1966-2

002

1966-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1966-2

002:

Parl

1966-2

002:

Unitary

245

Bavari

a1816-1

871

1816-1

871:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

871:

Non-E

lect

ive

1816-1

871:

Unitary

370

Bel

aru

s1991-2

002

1991-1

994:

Maj-P

lur

1995-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1991-2

002:

Pre

s1991-2

002:

Unitary

291

Page 9: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

211

Bel

giu

m1830-2

002

1830-1

852:

Auto

cracy

1853-1

898:

Maj-P

lur

1899-1

913:

PR

99

1915-1

938:

PR

1944-2

002:

PR

1830-1

913:

Parl

1915-1

938:

Parl

1944-2

002:

Parl

1830-1

913:

Unitary

1915-1

938:

Unitary

1944-1

969:

Unitary

1970-1

992:

Sem

i-Fed

1993-2

002:

Fed

eral

80

Bel

ize

1981-2

002

1981-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1981-2

002:

Parl

1981-2

002:

Unitary

434

Ben

in1960-2

002

1960-1

962:

Auto

cracy

1965-1

989:

Auto

cracy

1991-2

002:

PR

1960-1

962:

Pre

s1965-1

967:

Military

1968-1

968:

Pre

s1969-1

969:

Military

1970-1

989:

Pre

s1991-2

002:

Pre

s

1960-1

962:

Unitary

1965-1

989:

Unitary

1991-2

002:

Unitary

760

Bhuta

n1949-2

002

1949-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1949-2

002:

Non-E

lect

ive

1949-2

002:

Unitary

145

Bolivia

1825-2

002

1825-1

840:

Auto

cracy

1842-1

870:

Auto

cracy

1873-1

951:

Auto

cracy

1956-1

981:

Auto

cracy

1982-2

002:

PR

1825-1

840:

Pre

s1842-1

870:

Pre

s1873-1

929:

Pre

s1930-1

930:

Military

1931-1

951:

Pre

s1956-1

963:

Pre

s1964-1

965:

Military

1966-1

966:

Pre

s1967-1

978:

Military

1979-1

979:

Pre

s1980-1

981:

Military

1982-2

002:

Pre

s

1825-1

840:

Unitary

1842-1

870:

Unitary

1873-1

951:

Unitary

1956-2

002:

Unitary

346

Bosn

ia-

Her

zegovin

a+

1992-2

002

1992-2

002:

Mis

sing

1992-2

002:

Mis

sing

1992-2

002:

Mis

sing

571

Bots

wana

1966-2

002

1966-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1966-2

002:

Pre

s1966-2

002:

Unitary

99B

elgiu

mw

as

the

firs

tco

untr

yto

adopt

aP

Rsy

stem

in1899,fo

llow

edby

Fin

land

in1906,and

Sw

eden

in1907

(Farr

ell,

1997:6

1-6

2).

292

Page 10: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

140

Bra

zil

1822-2

002

1822-1

929:

Auto

cracy

1934-1

944:

Auto

cracy

1946-1

963:

PR

1965-1

984:

Auto

cracy

1985-2

002:

PR

1822-1

888:

Non-E

lect

ive

1889-1

929:

Pre

s1934-1

944:

Pre

s1946-1

963:

Pre

s1965-2

002:

Pre

s

1822-1

890:

Unitary

1891-1

929:

Fed

eral

1934-1

944:

Sem

i-Fed

1946-1

963:

Fed

eral

1965-2

002:

Fed

eral

835

Bru

nei

1984-2

002

1984-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1984-2

002:

Non-E

lect

ive

1984-2

002:

Mis

sing

355

Bulg

ari

a1878-2

002

1878-1

912:

Auto

cracy

1914-1

933:

Auto

cracy

1935-1

942:

Auto

cracy

1946-1

989:

Auto

cracy

1990-2

002:

PR

1878-1

883:

Non-E

lect

ive

1884-1

893:

Parl

1894-1

912:

Non-E

lect

ive

1914-1

918:

Non-E

lect

ive

1919-1

933:

Parl

1935-1

942:

Non-E

lect

ive

1946-1

971:

Sem

i-P

res

1972-1

990:

Pre

s1991-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1878-1

912:

Unitary

1914-1

933:

Unitary

1935-1

942:

Unitary

1946-2

002:

Unitary

439

Burk

ina

Faso

1960-2

002

1960-1

976:

Auto

cracy

1978-1

979:

PR

1980-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1960-1

965:

Pre

s1966-1

969:

Military

1970-1

976:

Pre

s1978-1

979:

Pre

s1980-1

982:

Military

1983-1

990:

Non-E

lect

ive

1991-2

002:

Pre

s

1960-1

976:

Unitary

1978-2

002:

Unitary

516

Buru

ndi

1961-2

002

1962-1

964:

Auto

cracy

1966-1

991:

Auto

cracy

1996-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1962-1

964:

Parl

1966-1

986:

Pre

s1987-1

987:

Military

1988-1

991:

Pre

s1996-2

002:

Pre

s

1962-1

964:

Unitary

1966-1

991:

Unitary

1996-2

002:

Unitary

811

Cam

bodia

1954-2

002

1955-1

969:

Auto

cracy

1972-1

974:

Auto

cracy

1976-1

978:

Auto

cracy

1993-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1955-1

969:

Parl

1972-1

974:

Pre

s1976-1

978:

Non-E

lect

ive

1993-2

002:

Parl

1955-1

969:

Unitary

1972-1

974:

Unitary

1976-1

978:

Unitary

1993-2

002:

Unitary

471

Cam

eroon

1960-2

002

1960-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1960-2

002:

Pre

s1960:

Unitary

1961-1

972:

Fed

eral

1973-2

002:

Unitary

293

Page 11: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

20

Canada

1867-2

002

1867-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1867-2

002:

Parl

1867-2

002:

Fed

eral

402

Cape

Ver

de

1975-2

002

1975-1

991:

Auto

cracy

1992-2

002:

PR

1975-2

002:

Pre

s1975-2

002:

Unitary

482

Cen

tral

Afr

ican

Rep

ublic

1960-2

002

1960-1

992:

Auto

cracy

1993-2

002:

Maj-P

lur1

00

1960-1

965:

Pre

s1966-1

978:

Military

1979-1

980:

Pre

s1981-1

985:

Military

1986-2

002:

Pre

s

1960-2

002:

Unitary

483

Chad

1960-2

002

1960-1

977:

Auto

cracy

1985-1

990:

Auto

cracy

1992-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1960-1

977:

Pre

s1985-1

989:

Pre

s1990-1

990:

Military

1992-2

002:

Pre

s

1960-1

977:

Unitary

1985-1

990:

Unitary

1992-2

002:

Unitary

155

Chile

1818-2

002

1818-1

873:

Auto

cracy

1874-1

923:

Maj-P

lur

1925-1

954:

Auto

cracy

1955-1

972:

PR

1973-1

988:

Auto

cracy

1989-1

989:

PR

1990-2

002:

PR

101

1818-1

825:

Military

1826-1

923:

Pre

s1925-1

972:

Pre

s1973-1

980:

Military

1981-2

002:

Pre

s

1818-1

825:

Unitary

1826-1

827:

Sem

i-Fed

1828-1

923:

Unitary

1925-2

002:

Unitary

100T

he

Nati

onalA

ssem

bly

was

susp

ended

follow

ing

aco

up

15

Marc

h2003

(IP

U,2003).

101B

oth

Colo

mer

(2004:9

7)

and

Rey

nold

sand

Rei

lly

(1997)

chara

cter

ize

the

Chilea

nel

ecto

ralsy

stem

as

pro

port

ionalre

pre

senta

tion.

How

ever

,R

eynold

sand

Rei

lly

(1997:9

3)

conce

de

that

this

elec

tora

lsy

stem

larg

ely

work

sas

two-p

art

ysy

stem

.A

ccord

ing

toB

lais

and

Mass

icott

e(1

997:1

11),

Chile

isth

eonly

dem

ocr

acy

that

does

not

fit

into

any

ofth

eth

ree

elec

tora

lsy

stem

cate

gori

es.

294

Page 12: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

710

Chin

a1816-2

002

1816-1

859:

Auto

cracy

1862-1

910:

Auto

cracy

1912-1

912:

Auto

cracy

1914-1

936:

Auto

cracy

1946-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

859:

Non-E

lect

ive

1862-1

910:

Non-E

lect

ive

1912-1

912:

Pre

s1914-1

923:

Pre

s1924-1

927:

Military

1928-1

936:

Pre

s1946-1

958:

Pre

s1959-1

982:

Non-E

lect

ive

1983-2

002:

Pre

s

1816-1

859:

Unitary

1862-1

910:

Unitary

1912:

Unitary

1914-1

936:

Unitary

1946-2

002:

Unitary

100

Colo

mbia

1831-2

002

1830-1

859:

Auto

cracy

1861-1

866:

Auto

cracy

1867-1

885:

Maj-P

lur

1886-1

929:

Auto

cracy

1930:

Maj-P

lur

1931-1

947:

PR

1948-1

956:

Auto

cracy

1957-2

002:

PR

1830-1

859:

Pre

s1861-1

952:

Pre

s1953-1

958:

Military

1959-2

002:

Pre

s

1830-1

852:

Unitary

1853-1

859:

Fed

eral

1861-1

885:

Fed

eral

1886-2

002:

Sem

i-Fed

581

Com

oro

s1975-2

002

1975-1

975:

Maj-P

lur

1976-1

989:

Auto

cracy

1990-1

994:

Maj-P

lur

1996-1

998:

Maj-P

lur

1999-2

001:

Auto

cracy

2002-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1975-1

994:

Pre

s1996-1

998:

Pre

s1999-1

999:

Military

2000-2

002:

Parl

1975-1

994:

Fed

eral

1996-2

002:

Fed

eral

484

Congo

1960-2

002

1960-1

962:

Maj-P

lur

1963-1

990:

Auto

cracy

1992-1

996:

Maj-P

lur

1997-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1960-1

990:

Pre

s1992-2

002:

Pre

s1960-1

990:

Unitary

1992-2

002:

Unitary

490

Congo,D

emocr

atic

Rep

ublic

of(Z

air

e)1960-2

002

1965-1

991:

Auto

cracy

1965-1

991:

Pre

s1965:

Fed

eral

1966-1

991:

Unitary

295

Page 13: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

94

Cost

aR

ica+

102

1840-2

002

1840-1

852:

Auto

cracy

1853-1

892:

Mis

sing

1893-1

952:

Sem

i-P

R1953-2

002:

PR

1840-2

002:

Pre

s1840-2

002:

Unitary

437

Cote

D’Ivoir

e1960-2

002

1960-1

998:

Auto

cracy

2000-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1960-1

998:

Pre

s2000-2

002:

Pre

s1960-1

998:

Unitary

2000-2

002:

Unitary

344

Cro

atia

1991-2

002

1991-1

998:

Auto

cracy

2000-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R1991-1

998:

Pre

s2000-2

002:

Pre

s1991-1

998:

Unitary

2000-2

002:

Unitary

40

Cuba

1902-2

002

1902-1

927:

PR

1928-1

932:

Auto

cracy

1933-1

947:

PR

1948-1

951:

PR

1955-1

958:

Auto

cracy

1961-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1902-1

951:

Pre

s1955-1

958:

Pre

s1961-1

975:

Sem

i-P

res

1976-2

002:

Pre

s

1902-1

951:

Unitary

1955-1

958:

Unitary

1961-2

002:

Unitary

352

Cypru

s1960-2

002

1960-1

962:

Maj-P

lur

1968-2

002:

PR

1960-1

962:

Pre

s1968-2

002:

Pre

s1960-1

962:

Fed

eral

1968-2

002:

Unitary

316

Cze

chR

epublic

1993-2

002

1993-2

002:

PR

1993-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1993-2

002:

Unitary

315

Cze

chosl

ovakia

1919-1

992

1919-1

938:

PR

1945-1

946:

PR

1948-1

967:

Auto

cracy

1969-1

989:

Auto

cracy

1990-1

992:

Sem

i-P

R

1919-1

938:

Sem

i-P

res

1945-1

946:

Sem

i-P

res

1948-1

967:

Non-E

lect

ive

1969-1

989:

Non-E

lect

ive

1990-1

992:

Sem

i-P

res

1919-1

938:

Unitary

1945-1

946:

Unit

ary

1948-1

967:

Unitary

1969-1

992:

Fed

eral

102A

ccord

ing

toLijphart

(1984:3

9),

the

long

Cost

aR

ican

dem

ocr

atic

rule

was

inte

rrupte

dby

civil

war

in1948.

This

inte

rrupti

on

isnot

reco

rded

inth

ePolity

4data

set.

296

Page 14: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

390

Den

mark

1816-2

002

1816-1

900:

Auto

cracy

1915-1

919:

Maj-P

lur

1920-1

939:

PR

1945-2

002:

PR

1816-1

848:

Non-E

lect

ive

1849-1

900:

Parl

1915-1

939:

Parl

1945-2

002:

Parl

1816-1

900:

Unitary

1915-1

939:

Unitary

1945-2

002:

Unitary

522

Djibouti

1977-2

002

1977-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1977-2

002:

Pre

s1977-2

002:

Unitary

42

Dom

inic

an

Rep

ub-

lic

1845-2

002

1845-1

860:

Auto

cracy

1865-1

913:

Auto

cracy

1925-1

929:

Auto

cracy

1932-1

960:

Auto

cracy

1963-1

963:

PR

1966-1

977:

Auto

cracy

1978-2

002:

PR

1845-1

860:

Pre

s1865-1

913:

Pre

s1925-1

929:

Pre

s1932-1

960:

Pre

s1963-1

963:

Pre

s1966-2

002:

Pre

s

1845-1

860:

Unitary

1865-1

913:

Unitary

1925-1

929:

Unitary

1932-1

960:

Unitary

1963:

Unitary

1966-2

002:

Unitary

860

East

Tim

or+

2002-2

002

2002-2

002:

PR

2002-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

2002:

Mis

sing

130

Ecu

ador

1830-2

002

1830-1

967:

Auto

cracy

1968-1

968:

Sem

i-P

R1969-1

969:

PR

1970-1

978:

Auto

cracy

1979-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R

1830-1

962:

Pre

s1963-1

965:

Military

1966-2

002:

Pre

s

1830-2

002:

Unitary

651

Egypt+

1827-1

855

1922-2

002

1827-1

855:

Auto

cracy

1922-1

927:

Mis

sing

1930-1

933:

Auto

cracy

1935-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1827-1

855:

Non-E

lect

ive

1922-1

927:

Non-E

lect

ive

1930-1

933:

Non-E

lect

ive

1935-1

951:

Non-E

lect

ive

1952-1

952:

Military

1953-1

956:

Non-E

lect

ive

1957-2

002:

Pre

s

1827-1

855:

Unitary

1922-1

927:

Unitary

1930-1

933:

Unitary

1935-1

957:

Unitary

1958-1

960:

Sem

i-Fed

1961-2

002:

Unitary

297

Page 15: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

92

ElSalv

ador

1840-2

002

1840-1

854:

Auto

cracy

1858-1

947:

Auto

cracy

1950-1

978:

Auto

cracy

1984-2

002:

PR

1840-1

854:

Pre

s1858-1

947:

Pre

s1950-1

959:

Pre

s1960-1

960:

Military

1961-1

978:

Pre

s1984-2

002:

Pre

s

1840-1

854:

Unitary

1858-1

947:

Unitary

1950-1

978:

Unitary

1984-2

002:

Unitary

411

Equato

rialG

uin

ea1960-2

002

1960-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1960-1

978:

Pre

s1979-1

981:

Military

1982-2

002:

Pre

s

1960-1

967:

Mis

sing

1968-2

002:

Unitary

531

Eri

trea

1993-2

002

1993-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1993-2

002:

Pre

s1993-2

002:

Unitary

366

Est

onia

1918-1

940

1991-2

002

1919-1

932:

PR

1936-1

940:

Auto

cracy

1991-2

002:

PR

1919-1

919:

Sem

i-P

res

1920-1

932:

Parl

1936-1

940:

Pre

s1991-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1919-1

932:

Unitary

1936-1

940:

Unitary

1991-2

002:

Unitary

530

Eth

iopia

+1855-2

002

1855-1

929:

Mis

sing

1930-1

935:

Auto

cracy

1942-1

973:

Auto

cracy

1975-1

990:

Auto

cracy

1995-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1855-1

935:

Non-E

lect

ive

1942-1

973:

Non-E

lect

ive

1975-1

986:

Military

1987-1

990:

Pre

s1995-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1855-1

935:

Unitary

1942-1

951:

Unitary

1952-1

962:

Fed

eral

1963-1

973:

Unitary

1975-1

990:

Unitary

1995-2

002:

Fed

eral

950

Fiji

1970-2

002

1970-1

986:

Maj-P

lur1

03

1987-1

989:

Auto

cracy

1990-1

999:

Maj-P

lur

2001-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1970-1

986:

Parl

1987-1

989:

Military

1990-1

999:

Sem

i-P

res

2001-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1970-1

999:

Unitary

375

Fin

land

1917-2

002

1917-1

929:

PR

1931-2

002:

PR

1917-1

929:

Sem

i-P

res

1931-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1917-1

929:

Unitary

1931-2

002:

Unitary

103U

pon

indep

enden

cefr

om

Bri

tain

,B

ritish

rule

sust

ain

eda

pow

erfu

lin

stitutionalfr

am

ework

for

the

Fijigover

nm

ent

(Nort

on,2002:1

37).

The

Leg

isla

tive

Counci

lin

stitute

din

1970

was

stro

ngly

dis

pro

port

ionate

toth

eet

hnic

com

posi

tion

ofth

est

ate

at

the

tim

e(N

ort

on,2002:1

51).

298

Page 16: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

220

Fra

nce

1816-2

002

1816-1

847:

Auto

cracy

1848-1

850:

Maj-P

lur

1852-1

859:

Auto

cracy

1863-1

869:

Auto

cracy

1877-1

939:

Maj-P

lur

1940-1

943:

Auto

cracy

1946-1

957:

PR

104

1958-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1816-1

847:

Non-E

lect

ive

1848-1

850:

Pre

s1852-1

859:

Non-E

lect

ive

1863-1

869:

Non-E

lect

ive

1877-1

878:

Pre

s1879-1

943:

Sem

i-P

res

1946-1

957:

Sem

i-P

res

1958-2

002:

Pre

s

1816-1

850:

Unitary

1852-1

857:

Unitary

1858:

Sem

i-Fed

1859:

Unitary

1863-1

869:

Unitary

1877-1

943:

Unitary

1946-2

002:

Unitary

481+

Gabon

1960-2

002

1960-1

989:

Auto

cracy

1991-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1960-1

989:

Pre

s1991-2

002:

Pre

s1960-2

002:

Mis

sing

420

Gam

bia

1965-2

002

1965-1

993:

Maj-P

lur1

05

1994-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1965-1

993:

Pre

s1994-1

995:

Military

1996-2

002:

Pre

s

1965-1

989:

Unitary

1991-2

002:

Unitary

372

Geo

rgia

1991-2

002

1991-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R1991-2

002:

Pre

s1991-2

002:

Sem

i-Fed

265

Ger

man

Dem

o-

cratic

Rep

ublic

1949-1

990

1949-1

988:

Auto

cracy

1949-1

988:

Non-E

lect

ive

1949-1

988:

Unitary

260

Ger

man

Fed

eral

Rep

ublic

1949-2

002

1949-2

002:

PR

1949-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1949-2

002:

Fed

eral

255

Ger

many

(Pru

ssia

)1816-1

945

1816-1

866:

Auto

cracy

1871-1

917:

Auto

cracy

1919-1

932:

PR

1933-1

944:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

866:

Non-E

lect

ive

1871-1

889:

Parl

1890-1

917:

Non-E

lect

ive

1919-1

944:

Sem

i-P

res

1816-1

866:

Unitary

1871-1

917:

Sem

i-Fed

1919-1

932:

Sem

i-Fed

1933-1

944:

Unitary

104A

ccord

ing

toLijphart

(1984:1

51-1

54)

the

Fre

nch

IVR

epublic

(1950-1

957)

exer

cise

da

PR

elec

tora

lsy

stem

wit

hm

ajo

rita

rian

elem

ents

,and

am

ajo

rity

-plu

rality

syst

emduri

ng

the

Fre

nch

VR

epublic

(1958-1

962).

Rei

lly

(2001:1

5,

fn.

10)

wri

tes

that

the

two-r

ound

run-o

ffm

ajo

rity

syst

emin

legis

lative

elec

tions

isty

pic

ally

ass

oci

ate

dw

ith

Fra

nce

.LeD

uc

etal.

(1996:5

4,

65-6

6)

class

ify

Fra

nce

as

aco

untr

yth

at

use

sdiff

eren

tel

ecto

ral

form

ula

s:it

use

sm

ajo

rity

-runoff

for

pre

siden

tial

elec

tions,

majo

rity

-plu

rality

insi

ngle

-mem

ber

dis

tric

tsfo

rle

gis

lative

and

dep

art

men

tal

elec

tions,

majo

rity

-plu

rality

inm

ulti-m

ember

dis

tric

tsfo

rse

nato

rial

and

smaller

munic

ipaliti

es.

105G

am

bia

gain

edin

dep

enden

cefr

om

Bri

tain

in1965.

Until1984,th

epre

siden

tof

Gam

bia

was

elec

ted

by

the

House

of

Rep

rese

nta

tives

,but

subse

quen

tly,

ther

ehas

bee

nse

para

teel

ecti

ons

toth

ele

gis

latu

reand

the

pre

siden

t(S

ain

e,2003:3

77).

299

Page 17: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

452

Ghana

1957-2

002

1957-1

968:

Auto

cracy

1970-1

971:

Maj-P

lur

1972-1

977:

Auto

cracy

1979-1

980:

Maj-P

lur

1981-1

990:

Auto

cracy

1992-2

000:

Auto

cracy

2001-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1957-1

959:

Parl

1960-1

965:

Pre

s1966-1

968:

Military

1970-1

971:

Pre

s1972-1

977:

Military

1979-1

980:

Pre

s1981-1

990:

Military

1992-2

002:

Pre

s

1957-1

968:

Unitary

1970-1

977:

Unitary

1979-1

990:

Unitary

1992-2

002:

Unitary

99

Gre

at

Colo

mbia

1821-1

830

1821-1

830:

Auto

cracy

1821-1

830:

Pre

s1821-1

830:

Fed

eral

350

Gre

ece

1827-2

002

1827-1

861:

Auto

cracy

1864-1

914:

Maj-P

lur

1915-1

915:

Auto

cracy

1920-1

921:

Auto

cracy

1924-1

925:

Auto

cracy

1926-1

927:

PR

1928-1

931:

Maj-P

lur

1932:

PR

1933-1

935:

Maj-P

lur

1936-1

940:

Auto

cracy

1944-1

951:

PR

1952-1

955:

Maj-P

lur

1956-1

957:

Sem

i-P

R1958-1

966:

PR

1967-1

973:

Auto

cracy

1975-2

002:

PR

1827-1

843:

Non-E

lect

ive

1844-1

861:

Parl

1864-1

915:

Parl

1920-1

921:

Parl

1924-1

924:

Parl

1925-1

925:

Military

1926-1

934:

Parl

1935-1

940:

Military

1944-1

966:

Parl

1967-1

973:

Military

1975-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1827-1

861:

Unitary

1864-1

915:

Unitary

1920-1

921:

Unitary

1924-1

940:

Unitary

1944-1

973:

Unitary

1975-2

002:

Unitary

90

Guate

mala

1840-2

002

1840-1

870:

Auto

cracy

1873-1

943:

Auto

cracy

1944-1

949:

Sem

i-P

R1950-1

965:

Auto

cracy

1966-1

969:

Sem

i-P

R1970-1

984:

Auto

cracy

1986-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R

1840-1

870:

Pre

s1873-1

981:

Pre

s1982-1

984:

Military

1986-2

002:

Pre

s

1840-1

870:

Unitary

1873-1

984:

Unitary

1986-2

002:

Unitary

438

Guin

ea1958-2

002

1958-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1958-2

002:

Pre

s1958-2

002:

Unitary

300

Page 18: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

404

Guin

ea-B

issa

u1974-2

002

1974-1

993:

Auto

cracy

1994-1

997:

PR

2000-2

002:

PR

1974-1

979:

Pre

s1980-1

983:

Military

1984-1

997:

Pre

s2000-2

002:

Pre

s

1974-1

997:

Unitary

2000-2

002:

Unitary

110

Guyana

1966-2

002

1966-1

991:

Auto

cracy

1992-2

002:

PR

1966-1

969:

Parl

1970-1

979:

Sem

i-P

res

1980-2

002:

Pre

s

1966-2

002:

Unitary

41

Haiti

1816-1

914

1934-2

002

1816-1

914:

Auto

cracy

1934-1

945:

Auto

cracy

1950-1

985:

Auto

cracy

1988-1

989:

Auto

cracy

1990-1

990:

Maj-P

lur

1991-1

993:

Auto

cracy

1994-1

998:

Maj-P

lur

2000-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

819:

Military

1820-1

914:

Pre

s1934-1

945:

Pre

s1950-1

950:

Military

1951-1

985:

Pre

s1988-1

989:

Military

1990-1

991:

Pre

s1992-1

993:

Military

1994-1

998:

Pre

s2000-2

002:

Pre

s

1816-1

914:

Unitary

1934-1

945:

Unitary

1950-1

985:

Unitary

1988-1

998:

Unitary

2000-2

002:

Unitary

240

Hanover

1816-1

871

1816-1

871:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

871:

Non-E

lect

ive

1816-1

871:

Mis

sing

275

Hes

se-D

arm

stadt

1816-1

871

1816-1

871:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

871:

Non-E

lect

ive

1816-1

871:

Mis

sing

273

Hes

se-K

ass

el+

1816-1

871

1816-1

871:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

871:

Non-E

lect

ive

1816-1

871:

Mis

sing

91

Hondura

s+1840-2

002

1840-1

851:

Auto

cracy

1854-1

893:

Auto

cracy

1894-1

903:

Mis

sing

1904-1

906:

Auto

cracy

1908-1

911:

Mis

sing

1913-1

918:

Mis

sing

1920-1

923:

Mis

sing

1925-1

929:

Mis

sing

1930-1

935:

Maj-P

lur

1936-1

979:

Auto

cracy

1982-2

002:

PR

1840-1

851:

Pre

s1854-1

906:

Pre

s1908-1

911:

Pre

s1913-1

918:

Pre

s1920-1

923:

Pre

s1925-1

955:

Pre

s1956-1

956:

Military

1957-1

962:

Pre

s1963-1

964:

Military

1965-1

971:

Pre

s1972-1

979:

Military

1982-2

002:

Pre

s

1840-1

851:

Unitary

1854-1

906:

Unitary

1908-1

911:

Unitary

1913-1

918:

Unitary

1920-1

923:

Unitary

1925-1

979:

Unitary

1982-2

002:

Unitary

301

Page 19: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

310

Hungary

1918-2

002

1919-1

943:

Auto

cracy

1948-1

955:

Auto

cracy

1957-1

988:

Auto

cracy

1990-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R106

1919-1

943:

Non-E

lect

ive

1948-1

955:

Non-E

lect

ive

1957-1

988:

Non-E

lect

ive

1990-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1919-1

943:

Unitary

1948-1

955:

Unitary

1957-1

988:

Unitary

1990-2

002:

Unitary

395

Icel

and

1944-2

002

1944-1

958:

Sem

i-P

R1959-2

002:

PR

1944-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1944-2

002:

Unitary

750

India

1947-2

002

1947-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1947-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1947-2

002:

Fed

eral

850

Indones

ia1945-2

002

1945-1

947:

Auto

cracy

1948-1

949:

PR

1950-1

998:

Auto

cracy

1999-2

002:

PR

107

1945-2

002:

Pre

s1945-1

948:

Unitary

1949-1

950:

Fed

eral

1951-2

002:

Unitary

630

Iran,

Isla

mic

Rep

ublic

of

(Per

sia)

1816-2

002

1816-1

905:

Auto

cracy

1925-1

952:

Auto

cracy

1955-1

978:

Auto

cracy

1982-1

996:

Auto

cracy

1997-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1816-1

905:

Non-E

lect

ive

1925-1

952:

Non-E

lect

ive

1955-1

959:

Parl

1960-1

962:

Non-E

lect

ive

1963-1

975:

Parl

1976-1

978:

Non-E

lect

ive

1982-2

002:

Pre

s

1816-1

905:

Unitary

1925-1

952:

Unitary

1955-1

978:

Unitary

1982-2

002:

Unitary

645

Iraq

1932-2

002

1932-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1932-1

957:

Non-E

lect

ive

1958-1

978:

Military

1979-1

994:

Non-E

lect

ive

1995-2

002:

Pre

s

1932-2

002:

Unitary

106T

his

code

issu

pport

edby

Bir

ch(2

001);

Bla

isand

Mass

icott

e(1

996:6

6);

Norr

is(2

003);

Shugart

and

Watt

enber

g(2

001:2

31-2

54).

How

ever

,R

eynold

sand

Rei

lly

(1997)

and

Inte

rnationalID

EA

(2003)

claim

that

Hungary

has

aP

Rsy

stem

.

107A

ccord

ing

toLip

set

(1995:8

6-9

1),

Indones

iaw

as

occ

upie

dby

the

Japanes

eduri

ng

1942-1

945,

follow

edby

adec

lara

tion

of

indep

enden

ceand

afo

ur-

yea

rre

vo-

luti

onary

stru

ggle

again

stth

eD

utc

hco

lonia

lpow

er(L

ijphart

,1977:1

83).

Indones

iaw

as

gra

nte

dfo

rmal

indep

enden

cein

1949

and

aco

nst

itutional

parl

iam

enta

rydem

ocr

acy

duri

ng

its

firs

tnin

eyea

rsas

aso

ver

eign

republic,

1950-1

959,

hold

ing

ale

gis

lative

elec

tion

in1955.

The

PR

elec

tora

lsy

stem

resu

lted

ina

wea

kand

div

ided

gover

nm

ent,

whic

hw

as

repla

ced

by

a‘g

uid

eddem

ocr

acy

’in

1959.

Acc

ord

ing

toth

eco

nst

itution,th

eH

ouse

ofR

epre

senta

tives

funct

ions

as

asi

ngle

-cham

ber

legis

latu

reand

have

400

dir

ectly

elec

ted

mem

ber

sand

100

pre

siden

tialappoin

tees

,th

ree

quart

erofw

hom

repre

sent

the

arm

edfo

rces

.E

lect

ions

are

hel

dev

ery

five

yea

rs(D

erbysh

ire

and

Der

bysh

ire,

1996:1

45).

302

Page 20: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

205

Irel

and

1921-2

002

1921-2

002:

PR

1921-1

936:

Parl

1937-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1921-2

002:

Unitary

666

Isra

el1948-2

002

1948-2

002:

PR

1948-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1948-2

002:

Unitary

325

Italy

/Sard

inia

1816-2

002

1816-1

921:

Auto

cracy

1928-1

942:

Auto

cracy

1948-1

992:

PR

1993-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R108

1816-1

860:

Non-E

lect

ive

1861-1

921:

Parl

1928-1

942:

Parl

1948-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1816-1

860:

Mis

sing

1861-1

921:

Unitary

1928-1

942:

Unitary

1948-2

002:

Unitary

51

Jam

aic

a1962-2

002

1962-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1962-2

002:

Parl

1962-2

002:

Unitary

740

Japan

1816-2

002

1816-1

857:

Auto

cracy

1868-1

944:

Auto

cracy

1952-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R

1816-1

857:

Military

1868-1

884:

Non-E

lect

ive

1885-1

894:

Parl

1895-1

909:

Non-E

lect

ive

1910-1

931:

Parl

1932-1

944:

Military

1952-2

002:

Parl

1816-1

857:

Unitary

1868-1

944:

Unitary

1952-2

002:

Unitary

663

Jord

an

1946-2

002

1946-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1946-2

002:

Non-E

lect

ive

1946-2

002:

Unitary

705

Kaza

kst

an

1991-2

002

1991-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1991-2

002:

Pre

s1991-2

002:

Unitary

501

Ken

ya

1963-2

002

1963-2

001:

Auto

cracy

2002:

Maj-P

lur

1963-2

002:

Pre

s1963-1

965:

Fed

eral

1966-2

002:

Unitary

730

Kore

a1816-1

910

1816-1

910:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

910:

Non-E

lect

ive

1816-1

910:

Unitary

731

Kore

a,

Dem

ocr

atic

Peo

ple

’sR

epublic

of(N

ort

h)

1948-2

002

1948-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1948-1

971:

Parl

1972-2

002:

Non-E

lect

ive

1948-2

002:

Unitary

108It

aly

wen

tth

rough

an

elec

tora

lre

form

in1993

that

abolish

edth

elist

PR

syst

emfo

rth

eSen

ate

and

toch

ange

the

elec

tora

lsy

stem

for

the

Cham

ber

ofD

eputies

(Farr

ell,

1997:8

0).

Inth

eC

ham

ber

of

Dep

uti

es’sy

stem

,th

evote

rshave

two

separa

tevote

s,one

for

const

ituen

cypolitici

ans

and

one

for

part

ylist

s.Farr

ellw

rite

sth

at

this

implies

that

the

Cham

ber

ofD

eputies

’sy

stem

share

featu

res

com

mon

with

the

two-v

ote

or

am

ixed

syst

em.

303

Page 21: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

732

Kore

a,

Rep

ublic

of

(South

)1948-2

002

1948-1

959:

Auto

cracy

1960-1

960:

Maj-P

lur

1961-1

962:

Auto

cracy

1963-1

971:

Sem

i-P

R109

1972-1

986:

Auto

cracy

1988-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R

1948-1

986:

Pre

s1988-2

002:

Pre

s1948-1

986:

Unitary

1988-2

002:

Unitary

690

Kuw

ait

1961-2

002

1961-1

989:

Auto

cracy

1991-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1961-1

989:

Non-E

lect

ive

1991-2

002:

Non-E

lect

ive

1961-1

989:

Unitary

1991-2

002:

Unitary

703

Kyrg

yz

Rep

ublic

1991-2

002

1991-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1991-2

002:

Pre

s1991-2

002:

Unitary

812

Laos

1954-2

002

1958-1

959:

Maj-P

lur

1960-1

960:

Auto

cracy

1975-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1958-1

959:

Parl

1960-1

960:

Military

1975-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1958-1

960:

Unitary

1975-2

002:

Unitary

367

Latv

ia+

1918-1

940

1991-2

002

1918-1

933:

Mis

sing110

1934-1

940:

Auto

cracy

1991-2

002:

PR

1918-1

940:

Sem

i-P

res

1991-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1918-1

940:

Unitary

1991-2

002:

Unitary

660

Leb

anon

1944-2

002

1944-1

969:

Auto

cracy

1970-1

974:

Maj-P

lur

1944-1

974:

Pre

s1944-1

974:

Unitary

570

Les

oth

o1966-2

002

1966-1

969:

Maj-P

lur1

11

1970-1

992:

Auto

cracy

1993-1

997:

Maj-P

lur

2002-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1966-1

969:

Parl

1970-1

985:

Non-E

lect

ive

1986-1

992:

Military

1993-1

997:

Parl

2002-2

002:

Parl

1966-1

997:

Unitary

2002:

Unitary

109South

Kore

ahas

applied

Sem

i-P

Rco

mbin

ing

elec

tora

lfo

rmula

sfr

om

1962

topre

sent

(Hic

ken

and

Kasu

ya,2003:1

33-1

36).

110T

he

multip

lici

tyofpart

iesin

the

parl

iam

ent(S

aei

ma)(2

2in

1922

and

24

in1931)m

ade

itim

poss

ible

tofo

rma

stable

gover

nm

entduri

ng

1920-1

934

(Ency

clopæ

dia

Bri

tannic

a,2003).

111R

eynold

sand

Rei

lly

(1997:1

7)

des

crib

eLes

oth

oas

acl

ass

ical

majo

rita

rian

FP

TP

syst

em,

and

the

web

site

list

sLes

oth

oas

havin

ga

plu

rality

syst

emin

1965,

1970,1993,and

2002.

IPU

(2003)

des

crib

esLes

oth

o’s

syst

emas

mix

edin

2002.

304

Page 22: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

450

Lib

eria

+1847-2

002

1847-1

883:

Mis

sing112

1884-1

989:

Auto

cracy

1997-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1847-1

979:

Pre

s1980-1

983:

Military

1984-1

989:

Pre

s1997-2

002:

Pre

s

1847-1

989:

Unitary

1997-2

002:

Unitary

620

Lib

ya

1816-1

835

1951-2

002

1816-1

834:

Auto

cracy

1951-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

834:

Non-E

lect

ive

1951-1

968:

Non-E

lect

ive

1969-2

002:

Military

1816-1

834:

Mis

sing

1951-1

963:

Fed

eral

1964-2

002:

Unitary

368

Lithuania

1918-1

940

1991-2

002

1918-1

925:

PR

1928-1

940:

Auto

cracy

1991-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R

1918-1

925:

Sem

i-P

res

1928-1

940:

Pre

s1991-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1918-1

925:

Unitary

1928-1

940:

Unitary

1991-2

002:

Unitary

212

Luxem

bourg

1867-2

002

1867-1

889:

Auto

cracy

1890-1

918:

Maj-P

lur

1919-1

939:

PR

1946-2

002:

PR

1867-1

939:

Parl

1946-2

002:

Parl

1867-1

939:

Unitary

1946-2

002:

Unitary

343

Mace

donia

1991-2

002

1991-1

997:

Maj-P

lur1

13

1998-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R1991-2

002:

Pre

s1991-2

002:

Unitary

112Lib

eria

was

founded

in1820

as

apla

ceof

refu

ge

for

free

dsl

aves

from

the

Unit

edSta

tes

and

the

Cari

bbea

n,w

hose

des

cendants

are

today’s

Am

eric

o-L

iber

ians.

The

are

aw

as

ade

fact

oA

mer

ican

colo

ny,

gover

ned

by

agen

tsofth

eA

mer

ican

Colo

niz

ati

on

Soci

ety,

until1847,w

hen

itm

ade

afo

rmaldec

lara

tion

ofin

dep

enden

ceas

the

Rep

ublic

ofLib

eria

.For

133

yea

rsaft

erin

dep

enden

ce,Lib

eria

was

apoor

but

pea

cefu

lone-

part

yst

ate

rule

dby

the

Am

eric

o-L

iber

ian-d

om

inate

dTru

eW

hig

Part

y(C

arr

,2003).

The

1847

const

itution

was

dra

wn

usi

ng

that

ofth

eU

nited

Sta

tes

as

am

odel

(Ency

clopæ

dia

Bri

tannic

a,2003).

113IP

U(2

003)

des

crib

esth

eM

ace

donia

nle

gis

lative

elec

tion

syst

emas

part

ylist

pro

port

ional

syst

em,

esta

blish

edby

the

elec

tora

lla

wfr

om

Sep

tem

ber

21,

1990.

Inte

rnati

onal

IDE

A(2

003)

des

crib

esM

ace

donia

as

havin

ga

para

llel

TR

Ssy

stem

inth

e1994,

1998,

2002

legis

lati

ve

elec

tions.

The

Carr

(2003)

elec

tion

arc

hiv

edes

crib

esM

ace

donia

as

havin

gP

Rle

gis

lati

ve

elec

tion

in1998.

305

Page 23: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

580

Madagasc

ar/

Malg

asy

1816-1

896

1960-2

002

1816-1

896:

Auto

cracy

1960-1

990:

Auto

cracy

1992-2

002:

PR

114

1816-1

896:

Non-E

lect

ive

1960-1

971:

Pre

s1972-1

975:

Military

1976-1

990:

Pre

s1992-2

002:

Pre

s

1816-1

896:

Mis

sing

1960-1

990:

Unitary

1992-2

002:

Unitary

553

Mala

wi

1964-2

002

1964-1

993:

Auto

cracy

1994-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1964-1

965:

Parl

1966-2

002:

Pre

s1964-2

002:

Unitary

820

Mala

ysi

a1957-2

002

1957-1

968:

Maj-P

lur

1969-1

970:

Auto

cracy

1971-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1957-2

002:

Parl

1957-2

002:

Fed

eral

781

Mald

ives

1965-2

002

1965-1

975:

Maj-P

lur

1976-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1965-1

967:

Non-E

lect

ive

1968-2

002:

Pre

s1965-2

002:

Unitary

432

Mali

1960-2

002

1960-1

990:

Auto

cracy

1992-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1960-1

967:

Pre

s1968-1

978:

Military

1979-1

990:

Pre

s1992-2

002:

Pre

s

1960-1

990:

Unitary

1992-2

002:

Unitary

338

Malt

a1964-2

002

1964-2

002:

PR

1964-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1964-2

002:

Unitary

435

Mauri

tania

1960-2

002

1960-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1960-2

002:

Pre

s1960-2

002:

Unitary

590

Mauri

tius

1968-2

002

1968-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1968-1

991:

Parl

1992-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1968-2

002:

Unitary

280

Mec

kle

mburg

-Sch

wer

in+

1816-1

871

1816-1

871:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

871:

Non-E

lect

ive

1816-1

871:

Mis

sing

114D

iffer

ent

sourc

esdis

agre

eon

how

tocl

ass

ify

the

elec

tion

syst

emin

Madagasc

ar.

Acc

ord

ing

toLib

rary

ofC

ongre

ss(2

003),

the

Madagasc

ar

legis

lative

elec

tion

isa

pro

port

ionalre

pre

senta

tion

list

-syst

em.

Inte

rnati

onalID

EA

(2003)

class

ifies

the

Madagasc

ar

legis

lati

ve

elec

tion

syst

emas

Para

llel

FP

TP,w

hic

hdiff

ers

from

the

Lis

tP

Rdes

crip

tion

from

the

Rey

nold

sand

Rei

lly

(1997).

IPU

(2003)

class

ify

Madagasc

ar

as

ase

mi-P

Rsy

stem

.

306

Page 24: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

70

Mex

ico

1821-2

002

1821-1

833:

Auto

cracy

1835-1

845:

Auto

cracy

1848-1

862:

Auto

cracy

1864-1

875:

Auto

cracy

1880-1

910:

Auto

cracy

1917-1

993:

Auto

cracy

1994-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R115

1821-1

833:

Pre

s1835-1

845:

Pre

s1848-1

862:

Pre

s1864-1

875:

Pre

s1880-1

910:

Pre

s1917-2

002:

Pre

s

1821-1

833:

Fed

eral

1835-1

845:

Unitary

1848-1

862:

Unitary

1864-1

875:

Unitary

1880-1

910:

Unitary

1917-2

002:

Fed

eral

332

Moden

a1816-1

861

1816-1

861:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

861:

Non-E

lect

ive

1816-1

861:

Unitary

359

Mold

ova

1991-2

002

1991-2

002:

PR

116

1991-2

002:

Pre

s1991-2

002:

Unitary

712

Mongolia

1921-2

002

1921-1

991:

Auto

cracy

1992-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1921-1

951:

Non-E

lect

ive

1952-1

991:

Parl

1992-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1921-1

928:

Sem

i-Fed

1929-2

002:

Unitary

341

Monte

neg

ro+

1868-1

915

1868-1

915:

Auto

cracy

1868-1

915:

Non-E

lect

ive

1868-1

915:

Mis

sing

600

Moro

cco

1816-1

904

1956-2

002

1816-1

904:

Auto

cracy

1956-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

904:

Non-E

lect

ive

1956-1

962:

Non-E

lect

ive

1963-1

964:

Parl

1965-1

969:

Non-E

lect

ive

1970-1

971:

Parl

1972-1

976:

Non-E

lect

ive

1977-2

002:

Parl

1816-1

904:

Mis

sing

1956-2

002:

Unitary

541

Moza

mbiq

ue

1975-2

002

1975-1

993:

Auto

cracy

1994-2

002:

PR

1975-2

002:

Pre

s1975-2

002:

Unitary

115R

eynold

sand

Rei

lly

(1997)

and

Inte

rnationalID

EA

(2003)

chara

cter

izes

Mex

ico

as

aM

MP

PR

syst

em.

Acc

ord

ing

toShugart

and

Watt

enber

g’s

case

study

of

the

Mex

ican

elec

tora

lre

form

s(2

001:2

09-2

30,598),

Mex

ico

switch

edfr

om

PR

toa

MM

Msy

stem

(Mix

edM

ember

Majo

rita

rian)

in1994.

116R

eynold

sand

Rei

lly

(1997)

class

ify

the

Mold

ova

elec

tora

lsy

stem

as

aT

RS

majo

rity

syst

emin

1997.

307

Page 25: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

775

Myanm

ar

(Burm

a)+

1816-1

885

1948-2

002117

1816-1

885:

Auto

cracy

1948-1

961:

Maj-P

lur

1962-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

885:

Non-E

lect

ive

1948-1

961:

Parl

1962-2

002:

Military

1816-1

885:

Mis

sing

1948-1

962:

Fed

eral

1963-2

002:

Unitary

565

Nam

ibia

1990-2

002

1990-2

002:

PR

1990-2

002:

Pre

s1990-2

002:

Unitary

790

Nep

al

1816-2

002

1816-1

956:

Auto

cracy

1959-1

989:

Auto

cracy

1990-2

001:

Maj-P

lur

2002-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

956:

Non-E

lect

ive

1959-1

989:

Non-E

lect

ive

1990-2

001:

Parl

2002-2

002:

Non-E

lect

ive

1816-1

956:

Unitary

1959-2

002:

Unitary

210

Net

her

lands

1816-2

002

1816-1

916:

Auto

cracy

1917-1

939:

PR

1945-2

002:

PR

1816-1

847:

Non-E

lect

ive

1848-1

939:

Parl

1945-2

002:

Parl

1816-1

939:

Unitary

1945-2

002:

Unitary

920

New

Zea

land

1907-2

002

1907-1

992:

Maj-P

lur

1993-2

002:

PR

118

1907-2

002:

Parl

1907-2

002:

Unitary

93

Nic

ara

gua

1840-2

002

1840-1

925:

Auto

cracy

1928-1

978:

Auto

cracy

1981-1

989:

Auto

cracy

1990-2

002:

PR

1840-1

925:

Pre

s1928-1

978:

Pre

s1981-1

984:

Military

1985-2

002:

Pre

s

1840-1

925:

Unitary

1928-1

978:

Unitary

1981-2

002:

Unitary

436

Nig

er1960-2

002

1960-1

990:

Auto

cracy

1992-1

995:

Sem

i-P

R1996-1

998:

Auto

cracy

1999-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R

1960-1

973:

Pre

s1974-1

986:

Military

1987-1

990:

Pre

s1992-2

002:

Pre

s

1960-1

990:

Unitary

1992-2

002:

Unitary

117A

ccord

ing

toLip

set

(1998:5

1),

the

Bri

tish

colo

nia

lru

leen

ded

in1948.

Upon

indep

enden

ce,

Burm

aadopte

da

multi-part

ydem

ocr

ati

csy

stem

dom

inate

dby

apoliti

cal

coalition,

whic

hgave

way

toa

military

regim

ein

1958.

Dem

ocr

ati

cru

lew

as

re-inst

itute

dth

rough

elec

tions

in1960

and

last

edunti

l1962.

Inte

rest

ingly

,B

urm

are

ceiv

esth

esc

ore

8on

the

Polity

4auth

ori

tyin

dex

thro

ughout

this

per

iod,in

cludin

gth

e1958

military

regim

e.

118T

he

new

PR

(MM

P)

syst

emin

New

Zea

land

was

inst

ituti

onalize

din

1993,but

the

firs

tel

ecti

on

apply

ing

the

new

syst

emdid

not

take

pla

ceuntil1996.

308

Page 26: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

475

Nig

eria

1960-2

002

1960-1

965:

Maj-P

lur

1966-1

977:

Auto

cracy

1979-1

983:

Maj-P

lur

1984-1

997:

Auto

cracy

1999-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1960-1

965:

Sem

i-P

res

1966-1

977:

Military

1979-1

983:

Pre

s1984-1

997:

Military

1999-2

002:

Pre

s

1960-1

977:

Fed

eral

1979-1

983:

Fed

eral

1984-1

997:

Unitary

1999-2

002:

Mis

sing

385

Norw

ay

1905-2

002

1905-1

919:

Maj-P

lur

1920-1

939:

PR

1945-2

002:

PR

1905-1

939:

Parl

1945-2

002:

Parl

1905-1

939:

Unitary

1945-2

002:

Unitary

698

Om

an

1816-2

002

1816-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1816-2

002:

Non-E

lect

ive

1816-1

919:

Unitary

1920-1

956:

Fed

eral

1957-2

002:

Unitary

564

Ora

nge

Fre

eSta

te+

1854-1

910

1854-1

910:

Mis

sing119

1854-1

910:

Pre

s1854-1

910:

Unitary

770

Pakis

tan

1947-2

002

1947-1

948:

Auto

cracy

1949-1

957:

Maj-P

lur

1958-1

968:

Auto

cracy

1973-1

976:

Maj-P

lur

1977-1

987:

Auto

cracy

1988-1

998:

Maj-P

lur

1999-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1947-1

955:

Parl

1956-1

968:

Pre

s1973-1

976:

Pre

s1977-1

985:

Military

1986-1

998:

Pre

s1999-2

002:

Military

1947-1

954:

Unitary

1955-1

968:

Fed

eral

1973-2

002:

Fed

eral

95

Panam

a1903-2

002

1903-1

954:

Auto

cracy

1955-1

955:

PR

1956-1

967:

Sem

i-P

R1968-1

988:

Auto

cracy

1989-1

989:

PR

1990-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R120

1903-1

967:

Pre

s1968-1

968:

Military

1969-2

002:

Pre

s

1903-2

002:

Unitary

119A

ccord

ing

toE

ncy

clopeæ

dia

Bri

tannic

a(2

003),

the

politica

lst

ruct

ure

of

the

form

erB

riti

shco

lony

com

bin

edtr

aditio

nal

Boer

inst

ituti

ons

with

Dutc

hand

Am

eric

an

const

ituti

onalth

eory

.T

he

mem

ber

softh

eunic

am

eralle

gis

lati

ve

ass

embly

,th

eVolk

sraad

wer

eel

ecte

dby

white

adult

male

sonly

.

120Panam

ahas

aunic

am

eral

legis

latu

re,

the

Leg

isla

tive

Ass

embly

(Asa

mble

aLeg

isla

tiva),

whic

hhas

71

mem

ber

sel

ecte

dfo

rfive-

yea

rte

rms

from

single

-mem

ber

and

mult

i-m

ember

const

ituen

cies

(Carr

,2003).

309

Page 27: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

327

PapalSta

tes

1816-1

870

1816-1

847:

Auto

cracy

1850-1

870:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

847:

Non-E

lect

ive

1850-1

870:

Non-E

lect

ive

1816-1

847:

Unitary

1850-1

870:

Unitary

910

Papua

New

Guin

ea1975-2

002

1975-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1975-2

002:

Parl

1975-2

002:

Sem

i-Fed

150

Para

guay

1816-2

002

1816-1

868:

Auto

cracy

1870-1

991:

Auto

cracy

1992-2

002:

PR

1816-1

839:

Pre

s1840-1

840:

Military

1841-1

868:

Pre

s1870-2

002:

Pre

s

1816-1

868:

Unitary

1870-2

002:

Unitary

335

Parm

a1816-1

860

1816-1

861:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

861:

Non-E

lect

ive

1816-1

861:

Unitary

135

Per

u1824-2

002

1828-1

834:

PR

1835-1

880:

Auto

cracy

1883-1

918:

Auto

cracy

1920-1

929:

Auto

cracy

1933-1

949:

Auto

cracy

1950-1

967:

PR

1968-1

977:

Auto

cracy

1980-1

991:

PR

1992-1

999:

Auto

cracy

2001-2

002:

PR

1828-1

880:

Pre

s1883-1

918:

Pre

s1920-1

929:

Pre

s1933-1

947:

Pre

s1948-1

949:

Military

1950-1

961:

Pre

s1962-1

962:

Military

1963-1

967:

Pre

s1968-1

977:

Military

1980-1

999:

Pre

s2001-2

002:

Pre

s

1828-1

836:

Unitary

1837-1

838:

Fed

eral

1839-1

880:

Unitary

1883-1

895:

Unitary

1896-1

918:

Fed

eral

1920-1

929:

Unitary

1933-1

977:

Unitary

1980-1

999:

Unitary

2001-2

002:

Unitary

840

Philip

pin

es1946-2

002

1946-1

949:

Auto

cracy

1950-1

968:

Maj-P

lur1

21

1969-1

985:

Auto

cracy

1987-1

994:

Maj-P

lur

1995-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R122

1946-1

985:

Pre

s1987-2

002:

Pre

s1946-1

971:

Unitary

1972-1

985:

Sem

i-Fed

1987-2

002:

Sem

i-Fed

121A

ccord

ing

toth

eE

ncy

clopeæ

dia

Bri

tannic

a(2

003),

the

Philip

pin

eshas

bee

ngover

ned

under

thre

eco

nst

itutions,

the

firs

tof

whic

hw

as

pro

mulg

ate

din

1935,

duri

ng

the

per

iod

of

U.S

.adm

inis

tration.

Itw

as

close

lym

odel

edon

the

U.S

.C

onst

ituti

on

and

incl

uded

pro

vis

ions

for

abic

am

eralle

gis

lative

bra

nch

,an

exec

uti

ve

bra

nch

hea

ded

by

apre

siden

t,and

an

indep

enden

tju

dic

iary

.D

uri

ng

the

per

iod

of

mart

ial

law

(1972-8

1)

under

Pre

siden

tFer

din

and

E.

Marc

os,

this

const

ituti

on

was

abolish

edand

repla

ced

by

anew

const

itution

(adopte

din

January

1973)

that

changed

the

Philip

pin

egover

nm

ent

from

aU

.S.-st

yle

pre

siden

tial

syst

emto

aparl

iam

enta

ryfo

rm.

122In

tern

ati

onalID

EA

(2003)cl

ass

ifies

the

Philip

pin

osy

stem

asPara

llel

FP

TP

and

plu

rality

,w

her

easD

erbysh

ire

and

Der

bysh

ire

(1996:5

45)and

Carr

(2003)cl

ass

ify

itas

am

ixed

syst

em.

Hic

ken

and

Kasu

ya

(2003:1

36-1

37)

defi

ne

the

Philip

pin

esas

havin

gan

elec

tora

lfo

rmula

with

both

Plu

rality

and

Mix

edP

Rfr

om

1995.

‘The

310

Page 28: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

290

Pola

nd

1918-2

002

1918-1

925:

PR

123

1926-1

938:

Auto

cracy

1947-1

988:

Auto

cracy

1989-2

002:

PR

1918-1

925:

Pre

s1926-1

938:

Military

1947-1

980:

Non-E

lect

ive

1981-1

981:

Military

1982-1

988:

Non-E

lect

ive

1989-1

996:

Pre

s1997-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1918-1

938:

Unitary

1947-2

002:

Unitary

235

Port

ugal

1816-2

002

1823-1

832:

Auto

cracy

1834-1

909:

Auto

cracy

1911-1

925:

PR

1930-1

973:

Auto

cracy

1976-2

002:

PR

1823-1

832:

Non-E

lect

ive

1834-1

909:

Non-E

lect

ive

1911-1

925:

Parl

1930-1

973:

Parl

1976-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1823-1

832:

Unitary

1834-1

909:

Unitary

1911-1

925:

Unitary

1930-1

973:

Unitary

1976-2

002:

Unitary

694

Qata

r1971-2

002

1971-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1971-2

002:

Non-E

lect

ive

1971-2

002:

Unitary

360

Rum

ania

1878-2

002

1878-1

915:

Auto

cracy

1917-1

939:

Auto

cracy

1941-1

943:

Auto

cracy

1948-1

988:

Auto

cracy

1990-2

002:

PR

1878-1

915:

Non-E

lect

ive

1917-1

937:

Parl

1938-1

939:

Non-E

lect

ive

1941-1

943:

Parl

1948-1

965:

Non-E

lect

ive

1966-1

988:

Pre

s1990-2

002:

Pre

s

1878-1

915:

Unitary

1917-1

939:

Unitary

1941-1

943:

Unitary

1948-1

988:

Unitary

1990-2

002:

Unitary

365

Russ

ia(S

ovie

tU

nio

n)

1816-2

002

1816-1

904:

Auto

cracy

1906-1

991:

Auto

cracy

1992-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R

1816-1

904:

Non-E

lect

ive

1906-1

990:

Non-E

lect

ive

1991-2

002:

Pre

s

1816-1

904:

Unitary

1906-1

921:

Unitary

1922-2

002:

Fed

eral

517

Rw

anda

1962-2

002

1962-1

992:

Auto

cracy

1994-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1962-1

972:

Pre

s1973-1

977:

Military

1978-1

992:

Pre

s1994-2

002:

Pre

s

1962-1

992:

Unitary

1994-1

995:

Mis

sing

1996-2

002:

Unitary

pro

vis

ion

for

am

ixed

-mem

ber

syst

emw

as

incl

uded

inth

e1987

Const

itution

but

ala

wfu

lly

imple

men

ting

the

mea

sure

was

not

pass

eduntil1995

and

not

use

din

an

elec

tion

until1998.

Inth

ein

teri

m,both

Pre

siden

tA

quin

oand

Pre

siden

tR

am

os

appoin

ted

som

ese

ctora

lre

pre

senta

tives

toth

elo

wer

cham

ber

’(I

bid

).

123A

ccord

ing

toE

ncy

clopæ

dia

Bri

tannic

a(2

003),

the

const

itution

of1921

made

the

parl

iam

entsu

pre

me

vis

-a-v

isth

eex

ecutive.

The

pro

port

ionalsy

stem

ofuniv

ersa

lsu

ffra

ge

(whic

hin

cluded

wom

en)

nec

essi

tate

dco

alition

cabin

ets,

and,ex

cept

at

tim

esofnati

onalcr

isis

,th

ele

ftand

the

right

hard

lyco

oper

ate

d.

311

Page 29: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

670

SaudiA

rabia

1932-2

002

1932-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1932-2

002:

Non-E

lect

ive

1932-2

002:

Unitary

269

Saxony

1816-1

871

1816-1

847:

Auto

cracy

1849-1

871:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

847:

Non-E

lect

ive

1849-1

871:

Non-E

lect

ive

1816-1

847:

Unitary

1849-1

871:

Unitary

433

Sen

egal

1960-2

002

1960-1

961:

Auto

cracy

1963-1

999:

Auto

cracy

2000-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R

1960-1

961:

Pre

s1963-2

002:

Pre

s1960-1

961:

Unitary

1963-2

002:

Unitary

340

Ser

bia

+1878-1

915

1878-1

902:

Auto

cracy

1903-1

914:

Mis

sing

1878-1

914:

Non-E

lect

ive

1878-1

914:

Mis

sing

451

Sie

rra

Leo

ne

1961-2

002

1961-1

966:

Maj-P

lur1

24

1967-1

995:

Auto

cracy

1996-1

996:

PR

2002-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R

1961-1

966:

Parl

1967-1

967:

Military

1968-1

970:

Parl

1971-1

991:

Pre

s1992-1

996:

Military

2002-2

002:

Pre

s

1961-1

969:

Fed

eral

1970-1

996:

Sem

i-Fed

2002:

Mis

sing

830

Sin

gapore

1965-2

002

1965-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1965-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1965-2

002:

Unitary

317

Slo

vakia

1993-2

002

1993-2

002:

PR

1993-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1993-2

002:

Unitary

349

Slo

ven

ia1991-2

002

1991-2

002:

PR

1991-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1991-2

002:

Unitary

940

Solo

mon

Isla

nds

1978-2

002

1978-2

000:

Maj-P

lur

2001-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1978-2

002:

Parl

1978-2

002:

Fed

eral

124A

ccord

ing

toE

ncy

clopæ

dia

Bri

tannic

a(2

003),

parl

iam

enta

ryin

stituti

ons

wer

ein

troduce

din

stages

duri

ng

the

1950s

on

the

Bri

tish

patt

ern.

The

last

stage

was

reach

edon

Apri

l27,1961,w

hen

Sie

rra

Leo

ne

bec

am

ean

indep

enden

tst

ate

wit

hin

the

Bri

tish

Com

monw

ealt

h.

Inte

rnationalID

EA

(2003)

list

sSie

rra

Leo

ne

as

havin

gan

FP

TP

elec

tora

lsy

stem

on

the

vote

rtu

rnout

UR

L,w

hic

hacc

ord

ing

tose

ver

also

urc

esse

ems

tobe

the

case

untilth

eco

nst

ituti

onalre

vis

ion

in1991

(Der

bysh

ire

and

Der

bysh

ire,

1996:3

96-3

97;H

irsc

h,2001:1

14-1

15).

note

sth

at

Sie

rra

Leo

ne

had

aP

Rsy

stem

in1997

(Rey

nold

sand

Rei

lly,

1997)

and

in2002,w

her

eas

Carr

(2003)

des

crib

esSie

rra

Leo

ne’

sle

gis

lati

ve

elec

tora

lsy

stem

as

PR

wit

hso

me

modifi

cations.

Acc

ord

ing

toH

irsc

h(2

001:1

14-1

15),

Sie

rra

Leo

nea

ns

vote

dover

whel

min

gly

infa

vor

ofin

troduci

ng

am

ult

i-part

ysy

stem

ina

1991

refe

rendum

.T

he

new

law

was

endors

edand

pass

edin

tola

wth

esa

me

yea

r.C

IA-

The

Worl

dFact

book

(2002)

list

sth

eper

centa

ges

of

vote

by

part

yin

the

2002

legis

lati

ve

elec

tions

as:

SLP

P70.0

6%

,A

PC

22.3

5%

,P

LP

3%

,oth

ers

4.5

9%

;and

the

seats

dis

trib

ute

dby

part

y:

SLP

P83,A

PC

27,P

LP

2,w

hic

hsu

pport

sth

ecl

aim

that

Sie

rra

Leo

ne

use

sa

sem

i-P

Rel

ecto

ralsy

stem

duri

ng

its

rece

nt

per

iod

ofdem

ocr

ati

cgover

nm

ent.

312

Page 30: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

520

Som

alia

1960-2

002125

1960-1

968:

Sem

i-P

R1969-1

990:

Auto

cracy

1960-1

968:

Pre

s1969-1

975:

Military

1976-1

990:

Pre

s

1960-1

968:

Fed

eral

1969-1

990:

Sem

i-Fed

560

South

Afr

ica

1910-2

002126

1910-1

991:

Maj-P

lur

1994-2

002:

PR

127

1910-1

960:

Parl

1961-1

983:

Sem

i-P

res

1984-1

991:

Pre

s1994-2

002:

Pre

s

1910-1

991:

Unitary

1994-2

002:

Sem

i-Fed

125A

ccord

ing

toth

eW

orl

dFact

book

(2002),

Som

alia

bec

am

ein

dep

enden

ton

1July

1960

(fro

ma

mer

ger

ofB

riti

shSom

alila

nd,w

hic

hbec

am

ein

dep

enden

tfr

om

the

UK

on

26

June

1960,and

Italian

Som

alila

nd,w

hic

hbec

am

ein

dep

enden

tfr

om

the

Italian-a

dm

inis

tere

dU

Ntr

ust

eesh

ipon

1July

1960,to

form

the

Som

ali

Rep

ublic)

.

126D

uri

ng

1910-1

991,South

Afr

ica

rece

ives

asc

ore

of4

on

the

Polity

IVdem

ocr

acy

-auto

cracy

index

,w

hic

hth

eore

tica

lly

mea

ns

the

countr

yis

adem

ocr

acy

duri

ng

the

apart

hei

dre

gim

e.South

Afr

ica

isa

spec

ialca

seand

not

repre

senta

tive

for

oth

erco

untr

ies

that

rece

ive

the

sam

esc

ore

on

the

auth

ori

tyin

dex

.Im

ake

an

exce

pti

on

toth

eobvio

us

auto

crati

cch

ara

cter

istics

inth

isca

se,and

trea

tSouth

Afr

ica

as

dem

ocr

atic.

127South

Afr

ica’s

firs

tdem

ocr

ati

cel

ection

wit

huniv

ersa

lsu

ffra

ge

took

pla

cein

1994.

313

Page 31: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

230

Spain

1816-2

002

1816-1

835:

Auto

cracy

1837-1

867:

Auto

cracy

1871-1

873:

Auto

cracy

1876-1

878:

Auto

cracy

1879-1

922:

Maj-P

lur1

28

1923-1

929:

Auto

cracy

1931-1

938:

Maj-P

lur

1939-1

974:

Auto

cracy

1978-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R129

1816-1

835:

Non-E

lect

ive

1837-1

839:

Non-E

lect

ive

1840-1

845:

Parl

1846-1

846:

Non-E

lect

ive

1847-1

867:

Parl

1871-1

872:

Parl

1873:

Pre

s130

1876-1

922:

Parl

1923-1

929:

Military

1931-1

936:

Sem

i-P

res

1937-1

974:

Non-E

lect

ive

1978-2

002:

Parl

1816-1

835:

Unitary

1837-1

867:

Unitary

1871-1

873:

Unitary

1876-1

929:

Unitary

1931-1

974:

Unitary

1978-1

979:

Unitary

1980-2

002:

Sem

i-Fed

780

Sri

Lanka

(Cey

lon)

1948-2

002

1948-1

978:

Maj-P

lur1

31

1979-2

002:

PR

1948-1

977:

Parl

1978-2

002:

Pre

s1948-2

002:

Unitary

128Lib

rary

of

Congre

ss(2

003)

des

crib

es1898

as

atu

rnin

gpoin

tin

the

Spanis

hdem

ocr

atic

gover

nm

ent.

The

Spanis

hdef

eat

by

the

United

Sta

tes

inth

ew

ar

over

Cuba,

pro

mpte

dpolitica

lre

evalu

ati

on

inSpain

.A

ple

thora

of

new

,oft

ensh

ort

-liv

ed,

per

sonalist

part

ies

and

regio

nalgro

ups

on

both

the

left

and

the

right

(that

bro

ke

the

heg

emony

ofth

etw

o-p

art

ysy

stem

and

ult

imate

lyle

ftth

eparl

iam

enta

ryst

ruct

ure

indis

arr

ay)

sought

solu

tions

toth

eco

untr

y’s

pro

ble

ms.

By

1915

itw

as

vir

tually

imposs

ible

tofo

rma

coaliti

on

gover

nm

ent

that

could

com

mand

the

support

ofa

parl

iam

enta

rym

ajo

rity

.T

he

Novem

ber

1932

elec

tion

com

bin

edel

ecto

ral

list

sand

enco

ura

ged

coaliti

ons,

whic

hin

tended

topre

ven

tparl

iam

enta

ryfr

agm

enta

tion

inth

em

ult

ipart

ysy

stem

.H

ow

ever

,Lip

set

(1998:1

60)

des

crib

esth

eel

ecto

ral

law

in1933

as

‘favori

ng

the

conse

rvative

coalition

again

sta

div

ided

left

.’

129Spain

has

ase

mi-P

Rsy

stem

acc

ord

ing

toIP

U(2

003),

whic

hco

rres

ponds

toB

lais

and

Mass

icott

e(1

996:6

7)

who

chara

cter

ize

Spain

as

havin

ga

PR

syst

emw

hic

hco

nta

ins

many

modifi

cations

whic

hm

ake

itst

rict

lydis

pro

port

ional.

Mack

ieand

Rose

(1991)

des

crib

ehow

the

dep

uti

esto

the

ass

embly

are

elec

ted

acc

ord

ing

todiff

eren

tru

les

dep

endin

gon

the

elec

ting

pro

vin

ce.

The

Nort

hA

fric

an

terr

itori

esofC

euta

and

Mel

illa

and

the

isla

nds

(Mallorc

a,G

ran

Canari

aand

Ten

erife)

all

elec

tth

eir

dep

uti

esby

aplu

rality

syst

emw

her

eas

the

gen

eralel

ecti

on

syst

emis

multi-m

ember

const

ituen

cies

by

d’H

ondt

elec

tora

lsy

stem

.

130T

he

Fir

stSpanis

hre

public

was

hea

ded

by

pre

siden

tE

milio

Cast

elar

yR

ipoll

and

last

edfr

om

Sep

tem

ber

1873

until

January

1874

(Ency

clopæ

dia

Bri

tannic

a,

2007).

131Sri

Lanka

has

one

of

the

longes

tex

per

ience

with

hold

ing

dem

ocr

atic

elec

tions

of

the

Asi

an

state

s(R

eilly,

2001:1

15).

Sri

Lanka

moved

from

aB

ritish

type

parl

iam

enta

rysy

stem

toa

mix

edpre

siden

tial-parl

iam

enta

rysy

stem

like

the

Fre

nch

inth

e1978

const

ituti

onal

changes

.A

PR

elec

tora

lsy

stem

was

intr

oduce

dto

parl

iam

enta

ryel

ections

in1978,but

was

not

applied

untilth

esu

bse

quen

tel

ection

adec

ade

late

r(H

icken

and

Kasu

ya

(2003:1

38,fn

.G

;R

eilly,

2001:1

17).

314

Page 32: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

625

Sudan

1956-2

002

1956-1

957:

Maj-P

lur

1958-1

963:

Auto

cracy

1965-1

968:

Maj-P

lur

1971-1

984:

Auto

cracy

1986-1

988:

Maj-P

lur

1989-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1956-1

957:

Parl

1958-1

963:

Military

1965-1

968:

Parl

1971-1

984:

Pre

s1986-1

988:

Pre

s1989-1

992:

Military

1993-2

002:

Pre

s

1956-1

963:

Unitary

1965-1

968:

Unitary

1971:

Unitary

1972-1

984:

Sem

i-Fed

1986-1

997:

Sem

i-Fed

1998-2

002:

Fed

eral

115

Suri

nam

1975-2

002

1975-1

980:

PR

1981-1

988:

Auto

cracy

1989-1

990:

PR

1991-1

992:

Auto

cracy

1993-2

002:

PR

1975-1

979:

Sem

i-P

res

1980-1

987:

Military

1988-2

002:

Pre

s

1975-2

002:

Unitary

572

Sw

azi

land

1968-2

002

1968-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1968-2

002:

Non-E

lect

ive

1968-2

002:

Unitary

380

Sw

eden

1816-2

002

1816-1

906:

Auto

cracy

1917-2

002:

PR

1816-1

882:

Non-E

lect

ive

1883-1

906:

Parl

1917-2

002:

Parl

1816-1

906:

Unitary

1917-2

002:

Unitary

225

Sw

itze

rland

1816-2

002

1816-1

917:

Maj-P

lur

1918-2

002:

PR

1816-1

847:

Mis

sing

1848-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1816-2

002:

Fed

eral

652

Syri

a+

1946-2

002

1946-1

948:

Mis

sing132

1949-1

953:

Auto

cracy

1954-1

957:

Mis

sing

1961-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1946-1

948:

Pre

s1949-1

953:

Military

1954-1

957:

Pre

s1961-2

002:

Pre

s

1946-1

957:

Unitary

1961-2

002:

Unitary

713

Taiw

an/

Rep

ublic

ofC

hin

a1949-2

002

1949-1

991:

Auto

cracy

1992-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R1949-1

974:

Military

1975-1

975:

Parl

1976-1

977:

Sem

i-P

res

1978-2

002:

Pre

s

1949-2

002:

Unitary

702

Tajikis

tan

1991-2

002

1991-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1991-2

002:

Pre

s1991-2

002:

Unitary

510

Tanza

nia

/Tanganyik

a1961-2

002

1961-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1961-2

002:

Pre

s1961-2

002:

Sem

i-Fed

132Syri

aw

as

adm

inis

tere

dby

the

Fre

nch

untilin

dep

enden

cein

1946,w

hic

hm

ight

have

affec

ted

thei

radapta

tion

ofdem

ocr

ati

csy

stem

.

315

Page 33: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

800

Thailand

1816-2

002

1816-1

931:

Auto

cracy

1935-1

940:

Auto

cracy

1942-1

967:

Auto

cracy

1969-1

972:

Auto

cracy

1974-1

975:

Maj-P

lur

1976-1

976:

Auto

cracy

1978-1

987:

Auto

cracy

1988-1

990:

Maj-P

lur

1991-1

991:

Auto

cracy

1992-1

996:

Maj-P

lur

1997-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R133

1816-1

931:

Non-E

lect

ive

1935-1

940:

Parl

1942-1

946:

Parl

1947-1

948:

Military

1949-1

950:

Parl

1951-1

951:

Military

1952-1

956:

Parl

1957-1

957:

Military

1958-1

958:

Parl

1959-1

959:

Military

1960-1

967:

Parl

1969-1

972:

Parl

1974-1

975:

Parl

1976-1

976:

Military

1978-1

987:

Military

1988-1

990:

Parl

1991-1

991:

Military

1992-2

002:

Parl

1816-1

867:

Sem

i-Fed

1868-1

931:

Unitary

1935-1

940:

Unitary

1942-1

967:

Unitary

1969-1

972:

Unitary

1974-1

976:

Unitary

1978-2

002:

Unitary

711

Tib

et1913-1

950

1913-1

950:

Auto

cracy

1913-1

950:

Non-E

lect

ive

1913-1

950:

Mis

sing

461

Togo

1960-2

002

1960-1

990:

Auto

cracy

1993-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1960-1

990:

Pre

s1993-2

002:

Pre

s1960-1

990:

Unitary

1993-2

002:

Unitary

563

Tra

nsv

aal+

1852-1

910

1852-1

910:

Auto

cracy

1852-1

910:

Pre

s1852-1

910:

Mis

sing

52

Tri

nid

ad

and

To-

bago

1962-2

002

1962-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1962-1

975:

Parl

1976-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1962-2

002:

Unitary

616

Tunis

ia1816-1

881

1956-2

002

1816-1

881:

Auto

cracy

1956-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

881:

Non-E

lect

ive

1956-2

002:

Pre

s1816-1

881:

Mis

sing

1956-2

002:

Unitary

133In

contr

ast

toIn

tern

ationalID

EA

(2003)

whic

hdefi

nes

Thailand

as

havin

ga

Maj-P

lur

syst

emduri

ng

all

yea

rsas

adem

ocr

acy

,H

icken

and

Kasu

ya

(2003:1

37)

class

ify

Thailand

as

aSem

i-P

Rsy

stem

from

1997

topre

sent,

com

bin

ing

Lis

tP

Rand

Plu

rality

elec

tora

lfo

rmula

s.

316

Page 34: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

640

Turk

ey/

Ott

om

an

Em

pir

e1816-2

002

1816-1

917:

Auto

cracy

1923-1

945:

Auto

cracy

1946-1

959:

PR

1961-1

970:

PR

1971-1

972:

Auto

cracy

1973-1

979:

PR

1980-1

982:

Auto

cracy

1983-2

002:

PR

1816-1

917:

Non-E

lect

ive

1923-1

959:

Pre

s1961-1

979:

Sem

i-P

res

1980-1

981:

Military

1982-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1816-1

917:

Fed

eral

1923-1

959:

Unitary

1961-2

002:

Unitary

701

Turk

men

ista

n1991-2

002

1991-2

000:

Auto

cracy

2001-2

002:

Mis

sing

1991-2

002:

Pre

s1991-2

002:

Unitary

337

Tusc

any

1816-1

861

1816-1

861:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

861:

Non-E

lect

ive

1816-1

861:

Unitary

329

Tw

oSic

ilie

s1816-1

861

1816-1

861:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

861:

Non-E

lect

ive

1816-1

861:

Unitary

500

Uganda

1962-2

002

1962-1

965:

Maj-P

lur

1967-1

978:

Auto

cracy

1980-1

984:

Maj-P

lur

1986-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1962-1

965:

Parl

1967-1

978:

Pre

s1980-1

984:

Pre

s1986-2

002:

Pre

s

1962-1

965:

Fed

eral

1967-1

978:

Unitary

1980-1

984:

Unitary

1986-2

002:

Unitary

369

Ukra

ine

1991-2

002

1991-1

997:

Maj-P

lur

1998-2

002:

Sem

i-P

R1991-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1991-2

002:

Sem

i-Fed

696

United

Ara

bE

mi-

rate

s1971-2

002

1971-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1971-2

002:

Pre

s1971-2

002:

Fed

eral

200

United

Kin

gdom

1816-2

002

1816-1

836:

Auto

cracy

1837-1

866:

Maj-P

lur

1867-1

883:

Sem

i-P

R1884-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1816-2

002:

Parl

1816-2

002:

Unitary

89

United

Pro

vin

ces

ofC

entr

alA

mer

ica

1823-1

839

1823-1

839:

Auto

cracy

1823-1

839:

Pre

s1823-1

839:

Fed

eral

2U

nited

Sta

tes

of

Am

eric

a1816-2

002134

1816-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1816-2

002:

Pre

s1816-2

002:

Fed

eral

134M

ost

Afr

ican-A

mer

icans

could

not

vote

inth

eSouth

until

1960

(Carr

,2003).

Nev

erth

eles

s,th

eU

nit

edSta

tes

has

score

dth

em

axim

um

of

10

on

the

Polity

4auth

ori

tyin

dex

since

1872.

317

Page 35: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

165

Uru

guay

1830-2

002

1830-1

918:

Auto

cracy

1919-1

933:

Maj-P

lur1

35

1934-1

951:

Auto

cracy

1952-1

970:

Maj-P

lur

1973-1

984:

Auto

cracy

1985-2

002:

Maj-P

lur

1830-1

970:

Pre

s1973-1

974:

Military

1975-2

002:

Pre

s

1830-1

970:

Unitary

1973-2

002:

Unitary

704

Uzb

ekis

tan

1991-2

002

1991-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1991-2

002:

Pre

s1991-2

002:

Unitary

101

Ven

ezuel

a1829-2

002

1829-1

934:

Auto

cracy

1936-1

957:

Auto

cracy

1958-2

002:

PR

1829-1

934:

Pre

s1936-1

947:

Pre

s1948-1

958:

Military

1959-2

002:

Pre

s

1829-1

863:

Unitary

1864-1

869:

Sem

i-Fed

1870-1

934:

Unitary

1936-2

002:

Fed

eral

815

Vie

tnam

1816-1

893

1816-1

893:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

893:

Non-E

lect

ive

1816-1

893:

Mis

sing

816

Vie

tnam

,D

emo-

cratic

Rep

ublic

of

1954-2

002

1954-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1954-1

959:

Pre

s1960-1

991:

Non-E

lect

ive

1992-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1954-2

002:

Unitary

817

Vie

tnam

,R

epublic

of

1975-2

002

1954-1

975:

Auto

cracy

1954-1

962:

Pre

s1963-1

963:

Military

1964-1

964:

Sem

i-P

res

1965-1

966:

Military

1967-1

975:

Sem

i-P

res

1954-1

975:

Unitary

271

Wurt

tem

ber

g1816-1

871

1816-1

871:

Auto

cracy

1816-1

871:

Non-E

lect

ive

1816-1

871:

Unitary

678

Yem

en(A

rab

Re-

public

of)

1918-2

002

1918-1

945:

Auto

cracy

1948-1

989:

Auto

cracy

1993-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1918-1

945:

Non-E

lect

ive

1948-1

961:

Non-E

lect

ive

1962-1

977:

Military

1978-1

989:

Pre

s1993-2

002:

Pre

s

1918-1

945:

Unitary

1948-1

989:

Unitary

1993-2

002:

Unitary

680

Yem

en,

Peo

ple

’sR

epublic

of

1990-2

002

1967-1

990:

Auto

cracy

1967-1

990:

Pre

s1967-1

990:

Unitary

135N

ationaloffi

cials

inU

ruguay

are

elec

ted

ever

yfive

yea

rs.

All

Uru

guayans

18

yea

rsofage

and

old

erare

requir

edto

vote

.E

lect

ions

have

bee

nse

cret

and

obligato

rysi

nce

1918,and

a1932

law

gra

nte

dw

om

enth

eri

ght

tovote

(Ency

clopæ

dia

Bri

tannic

a,2003).

318

Page 36: Appendix D: Codebook

(conti

nued

from

pre

vio

us

page)

Countr

yC

ode

Countr

ySyst

emM

ember

ship

Dem

ocr

atic

Ele

ctora

lSyst

em1816-2

002

Exec

utive

Syst

em1816-2

002

Fed

eralism

of

Politica

lA

uth

ori

ty1816-2

002

345+

Yugosl

avia

(Ser

-bia

)1918-2

002

2000-2

002:

PR

1921-1

936:

Non-E

lect

ive

1939-1

940:

Non-E

lect

ive

1945-1

951:

Sem

i-P

res

1953-1

962:

Sem

i-P

res

1963-1

979:

Pre

s1980-2

002:

Sem

i-P

res

1921-1

936:

Unitary

1939-1

940:

Unitary

1945-1

951:

Fed

eral

1953-2

002:

Fed

eral

551

Zam

bia

1964-2

002

1964-1

990:

Auto

cracy

1991-1

995:

Maj-P

lur

1996-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1964-2

002:

Pre

s1964-2

002:

Unitary

511

Zanzi

bar

1963-1

964

1963-1

964:

Auto

cracy

1963-1

964:

Parl

1963-1

964:

Mis

sing

552

Zim

babw

e1965-2

002

1965-1

978:

Maj-P

lur

1980-1

982:

PR

136

1983-2

002:

Auto

cracy

1965-1

969:

Parl

1970-1

978:

Sem

i-P

res

1980-1

986:

Sem

i-P

res

1987-2

002:

Pre

s

1965-1

978:

Unitary

1980-2

002:

Unitary

+In

form

atio

nm

issi

ng.

136A

ccord

ing

toR

eynold

s(1

999:6

4-6

7),

Zim

babw

esw

itch

edel

ecto

ral

syst

ems

from

plu

rality

toP

Rin

the

1980

parl

iam

enta

ryel

ection,

but

rever

ted

back

toa

plu

rality

syst

emin

1984.

319

Page 37: Appendix D: Codebook

D.3 Sources

Administration and Cost of Elections (ACE) Project, 2003. ACE Electronic Publication, Version1.0. The International Foundation for Election Systems (IFES), The UN’s Department of Economicand Social Affairs (UN-DESA), and the International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assis-tance (International IDEA). [Available athttp://www.aceproject.org].

Banks, Arthur, 1986. Cross-National Time-Series Data File, 1915-1973. Ann Arbor, MI: Inter-university Consortium for Political and Social Research, ICPR Study 7412.[Available athttp://ssdc.ucsd.edu/ssdc/icp07412.html.]

Banks, Arthur, 1996. Cross-National Time-Series Data File. Binghampton, NY: State Universityof New York.

Birch, Sarah, 2001. ‘Electoral Systems and Party Systems Stability in Post-Communist Europe.’Paper presented at the 97th Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, SanFrancisco, CA.

Blais, Andre and Louis Massicotte, 1996. ‘Electoral Systems,’ chapter 2 in Lawrence LeDuc, RichardG. Niemi and Pippa Norris, eds. Comparing Democracies: Elections and Voting in Global Perspec-tive. Thousand Oaks, CA and London: SAGE.

Blais, Andre and Louis Massicotte, 1997. ‘Electoral Formulas: A Macroscopic Perspective’ EuropeanJournal of Political Research 32:107-129.

Carr, Adam, 2003. ‘Psephos,’ Adam Carr’s Election Archive. [Available athttp://psephos.adam-carr.net/]

CIA - The World Factbook, 2002. Available at[http://www.faqs.org/docs/factbook/index.html]

Colomer, Josep M., ed., 2004. Handbook of Electoral System Choice. New York and London:Palgrave-Macmillan.

Courtney, John C. 1999. ‘Plurality-Majority Electoral Systems: A Review.’ Paper presented to theAdvisory Committee of Registered Political Parties Elections Canada. Elections Canada On-Line.[Available athttp://www.elections.ca/loi/sys/courtney e.pdf.]

Cyprus Election Connection, 1996. [Available athttp://kypros.org/Elections/.]

Derbyshire, J. Denis and Ian Derbyshire, 1996. Political Systems of the World. New York: St.Martin’s Press.

320

Page 38: Appendix D: Codebook

Druckman, James N. and Michael F. Thies, 2002. ’The Importance of Concurrence: The Impactof Bicameralism on Government Formation and Duration,’ American Journal of Political Science46(4):760-771.

Eckstein, Harry and Ted Robert Gurr, 1975. Patterns of Authority: A Structural Basis for PoliticalInquiry. New York: Wiley Interscience.

Elections Around the World, 2003. [Available athttp://www.electionworld.org/.]

Elklit, Jørgen, 1994. ‘Is the Degree of Electoral Democracy Measurable? Experiences From Bulgaria,Kenya, Latvia, Mongolia and Nepal.’ Chapter 5 in David Beetham, ed. Defining and MeasuringDemocracy. London: Sage, 89-111.

The Election Process Information Collection Project, 2003. The EPIC Project is a joint projectbetween of International IDEA, UNDP and IFES. [Available athttp://www.epicproject.org/.]

Encyclopædia Britannica, 2007. ‘Spain. The Revolution of 1868 and the Republic of 1873,’ fromEncyclopeædia Britannica Online. [Retrieved January 15, fromhttp://www.britannica.com/eb/article-70437/Spain.]

Encyclopædia Britannica, 2003. ‘Costa Rica,’ from Encyclopeædia Britannica Online. [RetrievedJuly 30, fromhttp://search.eb.com/eb/article?eu=118704.]

Encyclopædia Britannica, 2003. ‘Equatorial Guinea,’ from Encyclopeædia Britannica Online. [Re-trieved July 30, fromhttp://search.eb.com/eb/article?eu=120132.]

Encyclopædia Britannica, 2003. ‘Greece,’ from Encyclopeædia Britannica Online. [Retrieved July30, fromhttp://search.eb.com/eb/article?eu=109179.]

Encyclopædia Britannica, 2003. ‘Latvia,’ from Encyclopeædia Britannica Online. [Retrieved July30, fromhttp://search.eb.com/eb/article?eu=118238.]

Encyclopædia Britannica, 2003. ‘Liberia,’ from Encyclopeædia Britannica Online. [Retrieved July30, fromhttp://search.eb.com/eb/article?eu=120184.]

Encyclopædia Britannica, 2003. ‘Orange Free State,’ from Encyclopeædia Britannica Online. [Re-trieved July 28, fromhttp://search.eb.com/eb/article?eu=58698.]

321

Page 39: Appendix D: Codebook

Encyclopædia Britannica, 2003. ‘Philippines,’ from Encyclopeædia Britannica Online. [RetrievedJuly 25, fromhttp://search.eb.com/eb/article?eu=115084.]

Encyclopædia Britannica, 2003. ‘Poland,’ from Encyclopeædia Britannica Online. [Retrieved July28, fromhttp://search.eb.com/eb/article?eu=115136.]

Encyclopædia Britannica, 2003. ‘Sierra Leone,’ from Encyclopeædia Britannica Online. [RetrievedJuly 28, fromhttp://search.eb.com/eb/article?eu=120198.]

Encyclopædia Britannica, 2003. ‘Switzerland,’ from Encyclopeædia Britannica Online. [RetrievedJuly 28, fromhttp://search.eb.com/eb/article?eu=115268.]

Encyclopædia Britannica, 2003. ‘Uruguay,’ from Encyclopeædia Britannica Online. [Retrieved July28, fromhttp://search.eb.com/eb/article?eu=115672.]

Encyclopedia of World History, 2001. ‘Switzerland,’ 6th edition. [Available athttp://www.bartleby.com/67/1095.html.]

Farrell, David M., 1997. Comparing Electoral Systems. London and New York: Prentice Hall.

Geddes, Barbara, 1999. ‘Authoritarian Breakdown: Empirical Test of a Game Theoretic Argument.’Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, Atlanta,September. [Available athttp://www.uvm.edu/ cbeer/geddes/APSA99.htm.]

Gerring, John and Strom C. Thacker, 2002. ‘Political Institutions and Human Development.’ Paperpresented at the Northeast Universities Development Consortium Conference, Boston University,September 28-30. [Available athttp://www.bu.edu/sthacker/IMRinstits.pdf.]

Gerring, John and Strom C. Thacker, 2004. ‘Political Institutions and Corruption: The Role ofUnitarism and Parliamentarism,’ British Journal of Political Science, 34(2):295-330. [Available athttp://www.bu.edu/sthacker/corruptinstits.pdf.]

Gleditsch, Kristian Skrede. 2003. Modified Polity P4 and P4D Data, Version 1.0. [Available athttp://weber.ucsd.edu/ kgledits/Polity.html.]

Gleditsch, Kristian S. and Michael D. Ward, 1999. ‘A Revised List of Independent States Since theCongress of Vienna’ International Interactions 25(4):393-413. [An update until 2002 is available athttp://weber.ucsd.sdu/ kgledits/statelist.html.]

322

Page 40: Appendix D: Codebook

Global Beat, 1998. ‘1998 Elections in Macedonia,’ International Crisis Group Report, Resources forthe Global Journalist. [Available athttp://www.nyu.edu/globalbeat/balkan/ICG100998.html.]

Golder, Matt and Leonard Wantchekon, 2004. ’Africa: Dictatorial and Democratic Electoral Sys-tems Since 1946.’ Chapter 23 in Josep M. Colomer, ed. Handbook of Electoral Systems Choice.London: Palgrave Macmillan, 401-418.

Goodwin-Gill, Guy. S., 1994. Free and Fair Elections. Geneva: Inter-Parliamentary Union.

Grofman, Bernard and Arend Lijphart, eds., 2002. The Evolution of Electoral and Party Systemsin the Nordic Countries. New York: Agathon Press.

Gurr, Ted Robert, Keith Jaggers and Will H. Moore, 1989. Polity II Codebook. Boulder, CO: De-partment of Political Science, University of Colorado. [Available athttp://www.colorado.edu/IBS/GAD/spacetime/data/Polity.html.]

Hague, Rod and Marting Harrop, 1987. Comparative Government and Politics. An Introduction,2nd ed. Hong Kong: Macmillan.

Hicken, Allen and Yuko Kasuya, 2003. ‘A Guide to the Constitutional Structures and ElectoralSystems of East, South, and Southeast Asia’ Electoral Studies 22(1):121-151.

Hirsch, John L., 2001. Sierra Leone: Diamonds and the Struggle for Democracy. Boulder, CO, andLondon: Lynne Rienner.

International IDEA, 2003. International IDEA Electoral Systems Design. [Available athttp://www.idea.int/esd/data/world.cfm.]

IPU, 2003. The Inter-Parliamentary Union PARLINE Database. [Available athttp://www.ipu.org/english/home.htm.]

LeDuc, Lawrence, Richard G. Niemi and Pippa Norris, eds., 1996. Comparing Democracies: Elec-tions and Voting in Global Perspective. London and Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

LeDuc, Lawrence, Richard G. Niemi and Pippa Norris, eds., 2003. Comparing Democracies 2: NewChallenges in the Study of Elections and Voting. London and Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

Lemco, Jonathan, 1991. Political Stability in Federal Governments. New York:Praeger.

Library of Congress, 2003. Country Studies. [Available athttp://memory.loc.gov/frd/cs/cshome.html.]

Lijphart, Arend, 1977. Democracy in Plural Societies. A Comparative Exploration. New Haven,CT, and London: Yale University Press.

Lijphart, Arend, 1984. Democracies: Patterns of Majoritarian and Consensus Government inTwenty-one Countries. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

323

Page 41: Appendix D: Codebook

Lijphart Elections Archive, 2003. UCSD Social Sciences and Humanities Library. [Available athttp://dodgson.ucsd.edu/lij/.]

Lipset, Seymour M., ed., 1995. The Encyclopedia of Democracy, Vol. I-IV. London: Routledge.

Lundell, Krister and Lauri Karvonen, 2003. ‘A Comparative Data Set on Political Institutions,’Department of Political Science, Abo Akademi. [Available at

http://www.const.sns.se/rapporter/databank.pdf].

Mackie, Thomas T. and Richard Rose, 1991. The International Almanac of Electoral History. Wash-ington, DC: Congressional Quarterly.

Marshall, Monty G. and Keith Jaggers, 2000. ‘The Polity IV Project: Dataset Users Manual.’ Cen-ter for International Development and Conflict Management, University of Maryland, College Park,MD.http://www.bsos.umd.edu/cidcm/inscr/polity/

Marshall, Monty G., Keith Jaggers, and Ted Robert Gurr, 2002. ‘The Polity IV Project: PoliticalRegime Characteristics and Transitions, 1800-2000.’http://www.cidcm.umd.edu/inscr/polity/

McHenry, Jr., Dean E., 1997. ‘Federalism in Africa: Is it a Solution to, or a Cause of, EthnicProblems?’ Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the African Studies Association in Columbus,Ohio, November.

Norris, Pippa, 2004. Electoral Engineering: Voting Rules and Political Behavior. Cambridge: Cam-bridge University Press.

Norton, Robert, 2002. ‘Accommodating Indigenous Privilege: Britain’s Dilemma Decolonising Fiji,’The Journal of Pacific History 37(2):133-156.

Pareja Paz Soldan, Jose, 1984. ‘Derecho Constitucional Peruano y la Constitucion de 1979,’ Edi-ciones Valenzuela, 51-55. Translated by Alba Quionnes Hesselroth.

Project on Political Transformation and the Electoral Process in Post-Communist Europe, 2003.The University of Essex, UK. [Available athttp://www.essex.ac.uk/elections/.]

Reilly, Benjamin, 2001. Democracy in Divided Societies. Electoral Engineering for Conflict Man-agement. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Reynolds, Andrew, 1999. Electoral Systems and Democratization in Southern Africa. Oxford andNew York: Oxford University Press.

Reynolds, Andrew and Ben Reilly, 1997. The International IDEA Handbook of Electoral SystemDesign. Stockholm: International IDEA.

324

Page 42: Appendix D: Codebook

Russett, Bruce, J. David Singer and Melvin Small, 1968. ‘National Political Units in the TwentiethCentury: A Standardized List,’ American Political Science Review 62(3):932-951.

Saine, Abdoulaye, 2003. ‘The Presidential Elections in The Gambia, October 2001,’ Electoral Stud-ies 22(2):325-395.

Schjølset, Anita, 1996. ‘Are Some Democracies More Peaceful Than Others?’ Cand. Polit. Thesis,Department of Sociology and Political Science, Norwegian University of Science and Technology inTrondheim.

Shugart, Matthew Soberg and Martin P. Wattenberg, eds., 2001. Mixed-Member Electoral Systems:The Best of Both Worlds? Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Sveriges Riksdag, 2003. ‘Parliamentarism.’ [Available athttp://www.riksdagen.se/.]

Vanhanen, Tatu, 2004. Manuscripts for the Polyarchy Dataset. [Available athttp://www.sv.ntnu.no/iss/data/vanhanen/ and athttp://www.prio.no/page/Project detail//9244/42472.html.]

Williams, Donald C., 1992. ‘Accommodation in the Midst of Crisis? Assessing Governance in Nige-ria,’ chapter 5 in Goran Hayden and Michael Bratton, eds. Governance and Politics in Africa.Boulder, CO, and London: Lynne Rienner, 97-119.

325