archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the...

18
Archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the Chao Valley of Peru Jonathan D. Bethard, MA Department of Anthropology The University of Tennessee

Upload: abraham-norman

Post on 27-Dec-2015

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the Chao Valley of Peru Jonathan D. Bethard, MA Department

Archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the Chao Valley of Peru

Jonathan D. Bethard, MADepartment of AnthropologyThe University of Tennessee

Page 2: Archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the Chao Valley of Peru Jonathan D. Bethard, MA Department

“For in the seemingly little and insignificant things that accumulate to create a lifetime, the essence of our existence is captured.”

– James Deetz (1977)

Page 3: Archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the Chao Valley of Peru Jonathan D. Bethard, MA Department

Research Goals

1) Utilize established isotopic methods to investigate diet and residential mobility at Santa Rita B

2) Define previously unreported isotopic ranges for the Chao Valley

Page 4: Archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the Chao Valley of Peru Jonathan D. Bethard, MA Department

Location of Site

Santa Rita B

N

Page 5: Archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the Chao Valley of Peru Jonathan D. Bethard, MA Department

CA3

Page 6: Archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the Chao Valley of Peru Jonathan D. Bethard, MA Department

CA3

Page 7: Archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the Chao Valley of Peru Jonathan D. Bethard, MA Department

Demographics from CA3Entierro Sex Age

1 F 15 – 18

2 M 25 – 30

3 ? 10 – 12

4 ? 5 – 9

5 ? 10 –12

8 M 35 – 40

9 M? 12 – 16

10 ? 8 – 10

11 ? 9 – 11

TOTAL n = 9

* AMS Dates: cal. AD 1030 - 1240

Page 8: Archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the Chao Valley of Peru Jonathan D. Bethard, MA Department

Entierro 2 Entierro 3 Entierro 9

Page 9: Archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the Chao Valley of Peru Jonathan D. Bethard, MA Department

Stable Isotope Analyses

• Human bones/teeth reflect the isotopic composition of consumed foods

– Collagen and apatite

• Carbon isotopes: differentiate type of consumed plants

• Nitrogen isotopes: differentiate terrestrial from marine protein sources

• Strontium isotopes: reflect geological bedrock and differentiate locals from non-locals

Page 10: Archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the Chao Valley of Peru Jonathan D. Bethard, MA Department

Materials and Methods

• Samples obtained during 2006/2007 field seasons

• Collagen: Ambrose (1990)

• Apatite: Balasse et al. (2002)– Finnigan MAT 252 mass spectrometer interfaced with an

Elemental Analyzer and Kiel III Device

• Sr purified following Pin and Bassin (1992)– Nu Plasma Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass

Spectrometer

Page 11: Archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the Chao Valley of Peru Jonathan D. Bethard, MA Department
Page 12: Archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the Chao Valley of Peru Jonathan D. Bethard, MA Department
Page 13: Archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the Chao Valley of Peru Jonathan D. Bethard, MA Department

Chao Valley Strontium• Petford and colleagues (1996)

– 0.704108 to 0.705710

N

Local Range (Santa Rita B):0.7050 – 0.7056

Local Range (Moche):0.7069 – 0.7087

Page 14: Archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the Chao Valley of Peru Jonathan D. Bethard, MA Department
Page 15: Archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the Chao Valley of Peru Jonathan D. Bethard, MA Department

Discussion

• 1) C/N isotopes are effective for evaluating diet– Maize-based agriculture

– Coastal location not a definite indicator of marine consumption

• 2) Sr isotopes are effective for characterizing mobility– ‘Local’ signature must be established first

– Useful for determining if non-locals are present

Page 16: Archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the Chao Valley of Peru Jonathan D. Bethard, MA Department

Future Directions

• Continue using carbon isotopes to investigate introduction of maize

• Investigate geography and marine resource exploitation

• Characterize other north coast Sr local signatures

Page 17: Archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the Chao Valley of Peru Jonathan D. Bethard, MA Department

Acknowledgements

• Dr. Stanley Ambrose

• Dr. Kelly Knudson

• Dr. Lori Baker

• Justin Glessner, MS

• UIUC and ISGS laboratory personnel

• Dr. Dan Weinand

• Prof. Marty Salter

• Dr. Ann Kronk

• National Institute of Culture – (Peru)

• Profs. Victor Vasquez and Teresa Rosales

• Dr. Jonathan Kent

• Dr. Catherine Gaither

The William M. Bass Endowment funded this research.

Page 18: Archaeological applications of stable isotope analysis: subsistence and residential mobility in the Chao Valley of Peru Jonathan D. Bethard, MA Department