arrangement of urbancorp cumberland 2 gp (the … · 21/11/2018 · court file no.:...
TRANSCRIPT
Court File No.: CV-16-11541-00CL
ONTARIOSUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE
COMMERCIAL LIST
IN THE MATTER OF THE COMPANIES' CREDITORS
ARRANGEMENT ACT, R.S.C. 1985, c. C-36, AS AMENDED
AND IN THE MATTER OF A PLAN OF COMPROMISE OR
ARRANGEMENT OF URBANCORP CUMBERLAND 2 GP
INC., URBANCORP CUMBERLAND 2 L.P., BOSVEST INC.,
EDGE ON TRIANGLE PARK INC., AND EDGE
RESIDENTIAL INC.
(the "Applicants")
SUPPLEMENTAL BOOK OF AUTHORITIES OF TORO ALUMINUM (A
PARTNERSHIP), SPEEDY ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS LTD., & DOLVIN
MECHANICAL CONTRACTORS LTD.
November 21, 2018
TO: SERVICE LIST
LEVINE SHERKIN BOUSSIDANBarristers23 Lesmill Road., Suite 300Toronto ON M3B 3P6
KEVIN D. SHERKIN — LSUC#27099BEmail: [email protected] SACKS — LSUC#62361REmail: [email protected]: 416-224-2400Fax: 416-224-2408
Lawyers for Toro Aluminum (APartnership), Speedy Electrical ContractorsLtd., & Dolvin Mechanical Contractors Ltd.
URBANCORP TORONTO MANAGEMENT INC. ET AL.SERVICE LIST
(Updated October 23, 2018)
TO: DLA PIPER (CANADA) LLPSuite 6000, Box 3671 First Canadian PlaceToronto, ON M5X 1E2
Edmond F.B. Lamek / Danny M. NunesTel: 416.365.3444 / 416.365.3421Email: [email protected]/[email protected]
Lawyers for the Urbancorp CCAA Entities
AND TO: KSV KOFMAN INC.150 King Street West, Suite 2308Toronto, ON M5H 1J9
Bobby Kofman / Noah Goldstein / Robert HarlangTel: 416-932-6228 / 416-932-6027 / 416-932-6225Email: bkofman ksvadvisory.com / ngoldstein ksvadvisory.com /
rharlanci ksvadvisory.com
The Monitor
AND TO: DAVIES WARD PHILLIPS & VINEBERG LLP155 Wellington Street WestToronto, ON M5V 3J7
Robin B. Schwill / Jay SwartzTel: 416-863-5502 / 416-863-5520Email: rschwill dwpv.com / jswartz dwpv.com
Lawyers for KSV Kofman Inc., in its capacity as Monitor
AND TO: BENNETT JONES LLP3400 One First Canadian PlaceToronto, ON M5X 1A4
S. Richard Orzy / Raj S. SahniTel: 416-777-5737 / 416-777-4804Email: Orzyr bennettiones.com / SahniR bennettiones.com
Lawyers for Urbancorp Inc. and Alan Saskin
3514838
2
AND TO: DENTONS CANADA LLP400-77 King Street West, TD CentreToronto, ON M5K 0A1Neil Rabinovitch / Kenneth KraftTel: 416-863-4656 / 416-863-4374Email: neil.rabinovitch dentons.com / kenneth.kraft dentons.com
Lawyers for Adv. Gus Gissin, in his capacity as the Court-appointed IsraeliFunctionary of Urbancorp Inc.
AND TO: GOODMANS LLPBay Adelaide Centre333 Bay Street, Suite 3400Toronto, ON M5H 2S7
Brian EmpeyTel: 416-597-4194Email: bempev qoodmans.ca
Lawyers for Parc Downsview Park Inc.
AND TO: TORYS LLP79 Wellington Street West, 30th FloorBox 270, TD South TowerToronto, ON M5K 1N2
Scott A. BornhofTel: 416-865-7370Email: sbomhof torvs.com
Lawyers for First Capital Realty
AND TO: BLAKE, CASSELS & GRAYDON LLP199 Bay StreetSuite 4000, Commerce Court WestToronto, ON M5L 1A9
Silvana M. D'AlimonteTel: 416-863-3860Email: smda blakes.com
Lawyers for Laurentian Bank of Canada
AND TO: CASSELS BROCK & BLACKWELL LLPSuite 2100, Scotia Plaza40 King Street WestToronto, ON M5H 3C2
Jane Dietrich / Natalie E. LevineTel: 416-860-5223 / 416-860-6568Email: jdietrich casselsbrock.com / nlevine(a.casselsbrock.com
Lawyers for Mattamy Homes Limited
3514838
3
AND TO: ROBINS APPLEBY LLP120 Adelaide Street West, Suite 2600Toronto, ON M5H 1T1
Leor Margulies / Dominique MichaudTel: 416-360-3372 / 416-360-3795Email: Imarqulies robapp.com / dmichaud robapp.com
Co-Counsel for Terra Firma Capital Corporation
AND TO: THORNTON GROUT FINNIGAN LLP3200 — 100 Wellington Street WestTD Centre, Box 329Toronto, ON M5K 1K7
John T. PorterTel: 416-304-0778Email: jporter tgf.ca
Co-Counsel for Terra Firma Capital Corporation
AND TO:
AND TO:
AND TO:
TEPLITSKY, COLSON LLP70 Bond Street, Suite 200Toronto, ON M5B 1X3
James M. Wortzman / Catherine E. AllenTel: 416-865-5315 / 416-865-5326Email: jwortzman teplitskycolson.com / callen teplitskycolson.com
Lawyers for Atrium Mortgage Investment Corporation
FRIEDMAN LAW PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION150 Ferrand Drive, Suite 802Toronto, ON M3C 3E5
Judy HamiltonTel: (416) 496-3340 ext. 136Email: jh friedmans.ca
Lawyers for Felice Raso
AIRD & BERLIS LLPBrookfield Place, 181 Bay StreetSuite 1800, Box 754Toronto, ON M5J 2T
D. Robb EnglishTel: 416-865-4748Email: renglish airdberlis.com
Lawyers for The Toronto-Dominion Bank
3514838
4
AND TO: BANK OF MONTREALFirst Canadian Place,18th Floor, Toronto, ON M5X 1A1
Halim ChaccourTel: 416-867-4932Email: [email protected]
AND TO: CHAITONS LLP5000 Yonge Street,10th Floor, Toronto, ON M2N 7E9
Harvey ChaitonTel: 416-218-1129Email: harvey chaitons.com
Lawyers for Bank of Montreal
AND TO: GOWLING WLG1 First Canadian Place100 King Street West, Suite 1600,Toronto, ON M5X 1G5
Lilly A. Wong / Clifton P. Prophet / Frank LamieTel: 416-369-4630 / 416-862-3509 / 416.962.2609Email: lillv.woncOgowlingwIg.com / clifton.prophet owlingwIg.com /
frank.lamie ciowlingwld.com
Lawyers for Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce
AND TO: MCCARTHY TETRAULT LLPSuite 5300TD Bank TowerBox 48, 66 Wellington Street WestToronto ON M5K 1E6
Heather MeredithTel: 416-601-8342Email: hnneredith mccarthy.ca
Lawyer for the syndicate of lenders represented by The Bank of NovaScotia, as Administrative Agent
AND TO: WESTMOUNT GUARANTEE SERVICES INC.600 Cochrane Drive, Suite 205Markham, ON L3R 5K3
Jim EmanoilidisTel: 647-499-8249Email: i im westmountduarantee.com
3514838
AND TO: KAREG LEASING INC.31 Davisville AvenueToronto, ON M4S 1G3
Dino ChiesaTel: 416-520-3119Email: [email protected]
AND TO: MINISTRY OF FINANCE77 Bay Street, 11th FloorToronto, ON M5G 2C8
Kevin O'HaraTel: 416-327-8463Email: Kevin.Ohara ontario.ca
AND TO: TORYS LLP79 Wellington Street West, 30th FloorBox 270, TD South TowerToronto, ON M5K 1N2
Adam M. SlavensTel: 416-865-7333Email: aslavens torys.com
Lawyers for Tarion Warranty Corporation
AND TO:
AND TO:
AND TO:
CHAITONS LLP5000 Yonge Street,10th Floor, Toronto, ON M2N 7E9
Barry RotenbergTel: 416-218-1133Email: BRotenbercachaitons.com
HENDRICK AND MAIN DEVELOPMENTS INC.109 Atlantic Ave, Suite 302BToronto, ON M6K 1X4
Rick lafelice / Gemma FoxTel: 416-530-2438Email: rick(amainandmain.ca / gemma mainandmain.ca
FASKEN MARTINEAU DUMOULIN LLP333 Bay Street, Suite 2400Toronto, ON M5H 2T6
Aubrey E. KauffmanTel: 416-868-3538Email: [email protected]
Lawyers for Travelers Guarantee Company of Canada
3514838
6
AND TO: FOGLER, RUBINOFF LLP77 King Street WestTD Centre North TowerSuite 3000, P.O. Box 95Toronto, ON M5K 1G8
Vern W. DaReTel: 416-941-8842Email: vdare foglers.com
Lawyers for Adrian Serpa and Stefano Serpa
AND TO: CITY OF TORONTOLitigation Section, Legal Services Division26th Floor, Metro Hall, Stn. 1260, 55 John StreetToronto, ON M5V3C6
Christopher J. HendersonTel: 416-397-7106Email: [email protected] Counsel for the City of Toronto
Lawyers for the City of Toronto
AND TO: FARBER FINANCIAL GROUP150 York Street, Suite 1600Toronto, ON M5H 3S5
Hylton Levy / Rob StelzerTel: 416-496-3070 / 416-496-3500Email: hlevy farberfinancial.com / rstelzer farberfinancial.com
Financial Advisors for the Court-appointed Israeli Functionary ofUrbancorp Inc.
AND TO: DICKINSON WRIGHT LLP199 Bay Street, Suite 2200Commerce CourtToronto, ON M5L 1G4
Lisa S. Coyne / David P. PregerTel: 416- 646-4608 / 416-646-4606Email: Icorne dickinsonwright.com / dpreder dickinsonwright.com
Lawyers for certain purchasers of pre-construction units
AND TO: SALVATORE MANNELLA PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION3700 Steeles Ave W. Suite 600Woodbridge, Ontario L4L 8K8
Salvatore MannellaTel: 905.856.0773 ext.273Email: mannella westonlaw.ca
Lawyers for Pro-Green Demolition Ltd.
3514838
7
AND TO: TORKIN MANES LLP151 Yonge Street, Suite 1500,Toronto ON M5C 2W7
Kayla KwinterTel: 416 777 5420Email: kkwinter torkinmanes.com
Lawyers for MDF Mechanical Ltd.
AND TO: ALVAREZ & MARSAL CANADA INC.Royal Bank Plaza, South Tower200 Bay Street, Suite 2900P.O. Box 22, Toronto, ON M5J 2J1
Tony Zaspalis / Amanda FavotTel: (416) 847-5171 / (416) 847-5163Email: tzaspalis alvarezandmarsal.com / afavot alvarezandmarsal.com
Receiver of Urbancorp (Leslieville) Developments Inc., Urbancorp (TheBeach) Developments Inc., and Urbancorp (Riverdale) Developments Inc.
AND TO: BLAKE, CASSELS & GRAYDON LLP199 Bay StreetSuite 4000, Commerce Court WestToronto, ON M5L 1A9
Pamela L.J. Huff / Milly ChowTel: 416-863-2958 / 416-863-2594Email: [email protected] / milly.chow blakes.com
Lawyers for the Receiver and Construction Lien Trustee, Alvarez & MarsalCanada Inc.
AND TO: CASSELS BROCK & BLACKWELL LLPSuite 2100, Scotia Plaza40 King Street WestToronto, ON M5H 3C2
Mark St. CyrTel: (416) 869-5462Email: mstcyr casselsbrock.com
Lawyers for 1481614 Ontario Inc. formerly carrying on business as ColdwellBanker Case Realty
AND TO: GOLDMAN SLOAN NASH & HABER LLP480 University Ave Suite 1600Toronto, Ontario M5G 1V2
Mario Forte / Robert J. DrakeTel: 416 597 6477 / 416-597-5014Email: forte qsnh.com / drake(asisnh.com
Lawyers for Fuller Landau LLP, Proposal Trustee to Alan Saskin
3514838
-8
AND TO: FULLER LANDAU LLP151 Bloor Street WestToronto, ON M5S 1S4
Gary Abrahamson / Adam Erlich / Ken PearlTel: 416-645-6524 / 416-645-6560 / 416-645-6519Email: GAbrahamsona.FullerLLP.com / AErlicha,FullerLLP.com /
Proposal Trustee to Alan Saskin
AND TO: DELZOTTO ZORZI, LLP4810 Dufferin Street, Suite DToronto, ON M3H 5S8
Robert W. Calderwood / Sabrina AdamskiTel.: 416-665-5555E-mail: rcalderwood( dzlaw.com / [email protected]
Lawyers for Furkin Construction Inc. and GMF Consulting Inc.
AND TO: FINE & DEOBarristers & SolicitorsSuite 300, 3100 Steeles Avenue WestVaughan, ON L4K 3R1
Jonathan H. Fine / Maria DimakasTel: 905-760-1800, Ext. 226 / 905-760-1800, Ext. 247Email: [email protected] / mdimakasa,finedeo.com
Lawyers for Toronto Standard Condominium Corporation No. 2302, TorontoStandard Condominium Corporation No. 2348 and Toronto StandardCondominium Corporation No. 2448
AND TO: LEVINE SHERKIN BOUSSIDANBarristers & Solicitors23 Lesmill Road, Suite 300Toronto, ON M3B 3P6
Kevin Sherkin/Jeremy SacksTel: (416) 224-2400Email: [email protected] / [email protected]
Lawyers for Speedy Electrical Contractors Ltd.
3514838
URBANCORP TORONTO MANAGEMENT INC. ET AL.SERVICE LIST — EMAIL ADDRESSES(Updated October 23, 2018)
[email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected];[email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected];[email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected];[email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected];[email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected];[email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected],[email protected], [email protected]; [email protected];[email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected];[email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected];[email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected];[email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected];[email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected];[email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected];[email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected];[email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected];[email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected];[email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected];[email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected];[email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected];[email protected]; [email protected]
3514838
Court File No.: CV-16-11541-00CL
ONTARIOSUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE
COMMERCIAL LIST
IN THE MATTER OF THE COMPANIES' CREDITORSARRANGEMENT ACT, R.S.C. 1985, c. C-36, AS AMENDEDAND IN THE MATTER OF A PLAN OF COMPROMISE ORARRANGEMENT OF URBANCORP CUMBERLAND 2 GP INC.,URBANCORP CUMBERLAND 2 L.P., BOSVEST INC., EDGE ONTRIANGLE PARK INC., AND EDGE RESIDENTIAL INC.
INDEXTab Document
(the "Applicants")
1. Excerpt from the Report of the Attorney General's Advisory Committee on the DraftConstruction Lien Act. Citation: Ontario. 1982. Report of the Attorney General'sAdvisory Committee on the Draft Construction Lien Act. Toronto, Onatario: OntarioMinistry of the Attorney General.
1
,
)
4
••• • 14 •••• i• . 1 1 1,1 1 in fi 1 0
2
Awe,. ,*Ms.,
.0114_. •
•
kiRPCTION ZASIN.-.ACT
April
3
• • . • .• • .
.• .*,•,•• ••
••••••-• „ .. ....-: •-•... .... . . _: ,c•• ',,is;,... ' ,4,• - .
.. . . . ., . .. .
. . . ...',.'.: - :..:.,,,. ...:!... 4-....,:- . - •':.::;:,:-.,i..„..,*: ,
. • ... ' •
;.',. ; • .• • ••• .:. ..:. .•..., ... ,.. •.• &:',.'-'7=',"•'' 0 •-•. ...spo4. .. ...
1/1e
‘c-4:430r r a1 fot
18 sara..0.
W
Vie”flrt tLo 14.i
'404;:iWs ,'øu •tit 011 pioPs .:000 *OW ..-11i#*6'.i. . .
•
P a diverse groups•
cOripi40#0,of construction pve t
-441. ,..,p0.1.4*.ies, *C., 1.c;,,sg, ''4111c,) f aiic •=.0 •
from t. - 4•7f:j
pt.q4„tql..x)11of our e cra ons
,.60c4i0j4***4 coope
4 kCti174:,.•'. 11•:rtgkik_t#14t-.4:!
• "fl eaiL471 devise a ikimio-..-;the't stries a reasotb1e tjte,
•he often ccntpeing i.ntere$t of the '
str ioug as incwiduals e erc ot aiways i
t iq.tr each tb proposed ca ges, verthe1
rstoite.... aiaTi arid o support ths R4p:-0:' 'a-• • ' :":`,•••••.•••
• 4.f••:?',".,,
•
•
• 1.9, •• 7,•••••
4
A A IA A Al A
5
J
he Mnl-
a Di-ic uss ir,Pn Pa.Pet' titied- Dr4ft
:teint;atiiiit'-....
r4arni an 'serve- as
•
lens: It did,t,
5,1.1 m ssz,pns-, •
• -s- tra• . .. •
• :!*k,...#$"4.i.ft:-;. • • • • • .•
th ?0,r‘r
g:444‘Å Sh e d :14:4iS
t
i
irs or Y.' •
et-a the a 1 t irikit:
e it Gyt n p:tb_p0sa 1 s ..reter:11)
tla e;:•:4 ,e afik5 ej<per ti s t,116 .
the ."'
•
1 n • ," _ _ - 11 /^1 in n 1 o
6
1
1
J
1T 1 1 T 1 1 /11 hill
7
•
j
•
e - r of1.
ther:e• LLttle•-' did ftt,t- ,
.1.41 technical
:fc‘?tiriO, an0 the
hqge. #) a t'
th+e'Chi ttee pr aft. -1#ill be enaqte0 4tTs2.-sifx>in'a_ • -
We not,4:;.... t-b.-ct there-is -v4clespread support within• . ••
construct ion iimllii-tritt; r the. t of th •- aidiat
1so Trite. the wic3Es•
liOh• pf the pi.-e flt The 'Mini
:44•:eaSe
"•
• •• • •••,;••,,,,.• •
pre- Xik#,Olict:Or-._iA:. ,i0;tr-od4Ot4i,..„)::... •• • "Y. t-„:.
***1010Alt.
. . • • . . . • .. •
ItOg*, -*Kt trOgi..S.OW*0.01(:•:4
•
• • .4Eist -Of
1405 1:*OPI.q.Pt
u ,: a:s v.43i0aete: • ••4:
teq-- -6 tut •.. .. : •.• •
-1.!‘ft.S aSS,4101:ift':,1b0 4.0ret ;1144ikic. . . . • ,...• . „.**wafts! the'
1 4.44*louttg.,1•5eas:OrOw. O.P- •, , . .
•
. • •
: • : •. • _ • .
„ • .
8
4-tii-ooi10
e4t#li:11;
••••• 0.4134...i: •
T4. 1 /--- 1 1 PI 1 P1111 Q
9
J
J
10
rl
•
•
r.0•
ry
t.„ *.it, .:: . .. ,:',..
't €x-A-.Ø tbe ccri pli ca ted , ta ture--,-,ot contrgW4i1, •!?..e..thi..4.3;r1—",-
?Col-15 truction industry #-•.*n. . , -91ed5 -g.t.,4iY.t4. 4*-..,
' , an integral part . ' ''' nii‘i"."tz . • ,1.14::..y.;
•P - •
. ••... .
t-ti*-•::. ;PfirX'
9a. la:1‘̂
Eacb of th*e may
- §'.4.4(;¥.-4f-.;WPt*t
Ck-S' -15,c4tgg"-4. 44ø, t'Iqe
n air45, - hes e e net a 1,
• • .
p• r-nn rv-% -nli-n771-n=/1 7/item sim ag ... 11/21/2018
11
enxpioyed h .:fob
row. A t patyntrt- mist, --ccite f. o.
pyr-6,m de tec t7itre der a -m rac
• Y r4!Al IA, a
u;u: . cO. t" act n ie dory . - t411-1i92i,cet On d •04.4Wrid1.,'s in '
'the- 1? X23 a i44,
tfaik relati.onsbitzif-ituo.. er of - the k
, •L:.aemana pa roe at .•
• • .• ''OtIP
, . •
seelooka-
aUro
0.0.0,0*.ca 1 fi the 1104‘,n_.
• ski ti t ,c on t -r1.6 -or .6
01/ 3}e4-61t• •.• ...,.. • •
-- •a '
rs tiiv-mopi; he is
sap
.10* .„„;ti*..;t:oa•-it• :of ttit ~carid~i n.•44A!).? -.4Iva
r4fif.k** 4.$4611 joy.•
0.444'".. .5.toow
• *ktel,••
-**rotted% ' -•ti
• • :o•
• 4:#1*.:t--.):41-v.eii. • ....• .
'4.1f.r.(004;
• OS ••• A 0.% 1 • . _ tr% _ _ _ _ ... T) — 1 ..T1 ,= /1 / e imn CT 11 1')1 im R
12
-‘
J
J
J
1
•
*Pt- .00444,604hio
Olt..;i4iht*rf-41*. to:;- *it; iilittinVsof VI*
• • • I.. tr • 1 11 1 /1 1 T1 1 T_ - /1 n - 11 /11 11A1
13
property sold by making all payments teat he is obliged to make
under his contract in accordance with the proper payment
procedure set out in the Act. The trust rights isolate contract
monies, and require them to be used for paying suppliers who
have contributed towards the making of an improvement. By
making these funds a trust, the suppliers to a payer are given
protection in the event that the payer becomes insolvent, since
the monies will riot then form part of his estate. In addition,
the trust rights permit the tracing of contract funds that are
us ed for an in pr ope r pur pose.
By providing these rights, the lien legislation
facilitates the granting of credit within the construction
industry. The protections afforded by the Mechanics' Li en Act
h ave now beoonie an integral factor in the provision of credit in
that industry. Thus, the Act makes it easier for construction
to take place, since it assures that credit will be made
available, In addition, by providing a uniform regime of rights
to all suppliers in the industry, that. Act reduces both the
costs of negotiating both construction contracts and sub-
contracts, and also the uncertainties inherent in any complex
system of contractual relationships.
For these reasons, there is virtual unanimity within
the construction industry that the remedies provided by the Act
should continue to be made available. They are viewed to be
essential to the health of the industry. At the same time,
however r there is also a general consensus within the industry
that the present operation of the Mech anics' Lien Act is
unsatisfactory, and that this area of the law is ripe for
reform. It is widely believed that the present Act does not
provide the protection which it was intended to afford. In
addition, it is widely believed that the rights provided by the
Me ch an ics' Lien Act are vague and ill-defined, and subject to
14
• #Ocje
fQr. „
•
15
I
-GENZ.K.W,
e42at.4.-3.1
VAPort Pcz it Ike f
T - e &re :
,Tha:t
.0popt •
(a.) CO1Surnet a Ix( . ti:
• . ,•,;•
rr ,` rtue: to p
iiiiPP:410Stat
0 :case o• -- • • .. • ;-
r: • ,copsp
. .
d :ita Di s' I ien aC't.;07)s
i5-4614oiAtEl'.•'lie" 4 Aik i:t;i41.0 • - r enechfer* :ps:;'0v a. et
Af* .4.**1_!***/..*.i,̀ con effi:* el!).
OP* H Ao res-i.e10nc.eg,
;c rat to apply to S-uch CO fi$T4
• "Iiii40-045-: • %.*.•r••
_tr
-414 ****-trvzt.4.- 1.').§1/**k 4
r.goscirr; teet. 20**fitv..
.r.• • .
..t.to•ve0s04*--4040-;-:-o4ve„...444104..;:•*4 444:00.0.10o.*.*:01-# Of..-.**• -utiV.:t1•04!-.441g: 3*.
qa•
1 „ _ //11-‘1 Ar1 1_ • _ 1_T1 _ _ _1 _ _ _ 1 _ •rN _ _ _ _ _ _1_ " i "1 "Al 0
16
kV.
#A7
rb.imperits- invariably 1 rs,volves-•
ti- wheTi 4cittipat" et 't orris , of cons tructa• tl-- . . _
•• ga-e,. • • -,_sup4ejs ttf•:-5v0.7-iv,45 arid- inateidal's to the -KOrie- _icnproietmért
.,-iazikket are :..1424.Actail*-511.-$ v1netable1 : becaJ5e they - ;3_ . . . .
, •
Ties erves CPWRINT-04.•
p *aiy drà1v3yi4:15,L,Fatr'bli- • ATZT
•-kii*P146$‘, ;Or tbeIA**„Ina ter kals
• .
osTitTheflt cf P rt-t3na looaXyrMasters . • • • .
• • , '
•
• .
ibO the ::...JV ..41tY* • litint:•-• •tibia "-,
tt,;14ac.., ,:i: 5, -,.3t1'4-, 1: : ,tifg.t.• r ttiitk --,i4 -446.4An, v)4,,,.f. .7,:„.. -.....:,....... so te .411.1,dida, tut e, 41t,t,,.... "i' 2•6iti'
40-,.4(r. :the :.4:0itt4641A fc.W-',...:,• '.• .. .
• .... •449 4.,..s.• Pk' a -t,•42,P ,
::,.. irt1:,-. -2,rlais..,, _ is cjstomarzwithtn•-,.).4t44 ...103.0414,-,*•tf; I, ce • tir.• v., f.,,..,,,.•_$,. ... 7... - .
;On e - or ,st-').4•0 1.400..ir*.1*.li.#00***)); 414 p:t.S000Pes-, that:- .. . ,.... . • .s....-0'-:*000:41*40 the trial -6-k -thoi;k::
:;-:,,. Af.*#i•:aiida)p the is which:gOvevns• t tor and the ,a10. .•ett•
.
.,..- . • •
,j0-tk:-#21,, 11,1)i41:- --they Ocip•Cier,rt. *. *1), •10Ftit*i',tive:- :riat:'•--.•010;y elq.30065-*- . = -:: * (''------•.*: f,̀.•:. -, - • -• - -• •.* r 0
,...., : . • , ., ,.• , , 4444§0- 'cit.1FE t*;'• 04,*A71 .0U0;F`' #.' '0:#-,
....y ,i--- •:4-6fekt Second, -4.* -a coliateral 0. . t of 1--, -P -:
--:ju :ii(chptlori. , tis,
e* -le P; a :..
Tkird,.' 10-- 4*"'s•.•
. • ..: . • •...: .,„,.,..:„..-:::***-:
':.:10.1741004'.# -' ; .., - :.crerr4ai j. Oitit :*-04V7'!;- *0
tr iii 01-448#:'-.400ptis--1:t40 ??Ii0.ttivoi4 costilott.44 4.1124i*...k
..-.4,rv04y t 0,:' .'040.4.s
•
. rle- M t 4en• .•• a .of-
17
•
1e
titiotid
•-4• •4q1 of 004•40.-:
Of thti,opinion
-.6 IjQc 1 . P.,t04; )OW0*.
• . pprg
the one in r • ‘41ittitt- could ..... • . •. •
AO:
,inlVt0,irOe:4rawai,:f;rcktki44k*'t
pRpiaceati.eht .1,0 the .,Meralanags.-1 laen_ *It ly Tieuir tterj
Ger.erI64:16ti*V AviutOro..*IVSX.010,,4.4.4::•!-.-
• t
ktve:,me7aiati9-
:16fePciUt eoiti10:104-
0000#: ;,014u--tt'oti £n Lt rn:t!t ty wth--.. • - - • .
1e1 tOp 4tiU. jc tatute would
"
46044
•.,. ._. •. . ...tbe
ep
" • • • • :•--. . •
• •- • ••
•
18
ttf,
an 1.-cs n Att .•g
wås :tøp :cdlitt3.1
19
viciA*
,ctir#4. •
the Discla-esidelft
014- *4 tb# i4.".0:eAkt;
'cluittrxWktitir; 4day :petiod - Aiti4therqt. Afititt
vatrii-Aft
4,04;'11..0
stibti_tgaat-t.-401enti.. awan
-t-211- ,:lr+-opois-t-d 30 Atiticitinviti. _ .P,,I;mptect- :t1-1. 04- „ig44#.40
00#44:4 1.0k.471.441f.tt4de'd
the .14tV,Itiii::-'elit6hd‘,a-:,:tts, 40
se
f*k
23
1
•‘: • .aort- tit
•vis*001401107*Kt` 'from
piites.tit.. ;ties*, rtoolvioite.w:",iiii-ogett,:, an ou
•c44 -̀-e Xow: r: "spy ` .. r'! .tr.Lifen
ilearls'tfievti lOrtgaitteg0 to
44" if...h*:#404,0#910.- pr ov a
404•ikliti.if:t4P::i 511004 100:4‘.-9:titOtif:1). 0".p.1044./.4 0:4
the ;;;00, PP120144,06*-50......Itt nr*Ct- -
. • . . . • . . .• .•.• • .•it***t;;...:P.0040.400. w040*Sli, * ‘"*.‘•01***:04•4
10#0.6:**Figt:04.04* *fi40soiZ̀*014:'
10.414,;',14: t4), ,X".*ke;OiSt 'il-40:04010n44. •• • ..•
•:e• Vii;-2 K •• • ' :tfk, . • "Tr-7,f ..7r.•T4q,
."4:44:tf:** •114 !AtOf--.00:tei;4000,:5*7 1Te'
:004#1, .*IP*04 aavi'kP.-174tavAk.01.*,0•00;:r4VI T'•
. Ittg-tI—Ot
::0154:5* Hr ̀ #t 4;246:1.00 kik*aitordoca-t-:.---pin ticket-1'011s".
4466004:4
•
••• .:•fr.
•
.„.„ •ut-7,4
•
24
At the same time, there does not appear to be any
practical reason for permitting a supol ler to interrupt the flow
or contract monies by giving notice of a breach of trust. Any
supplier who wishes to protect himself may preserve a lien and
g ive wz tten notice of that 1 ien to the owner . in the event
that this is done, there are clear steps available to the owner
to protect himself and the supplier, and also to reopen the flow
of payment. There is no need for a second method of
interrupting pityment.
The Can eves at musk` pttiv lions
of the Act serve a useful purpose, they are in need of
clarification. These provisions prevent contract monies from
being misappropriated, and protect those monies Iran the claims
of other cc. ankruptcy. The Committee
believes thei't r. A.gtiiii-6a'a - st,t specifically the obligations
of a trustee and should outline how those obligations are to be
discharged. in the opinion of the Committee, the obligations
of a trustee under the Act are no more and no less than to use
the contract monies which are paid to him to pey those who
supply services or materials to hirn in respect to an improvement
for those services and nbterials. However, the Committee
ackncialedges that there may be occasions where a person may
believes that he has come into the possession of trust funds,
yet he is unsure of his precise obligations that result from
this. A typical situation, is where a private receiver
appointed under a debenture comes into possession of money that
he believes to be impressed with a trust. in such circum-
stances, it would be advantageous if the law permitted an
application to count for directions as to thg rights and
opbligations of all parties interested in the trust. Section 68
of the Committee Draft provides for such a right.
Page 1 of 1 25
A
A
•
in P III. . .
tto--:)4fttiati*e, Wows ed $4.4e egijgt raeth.!•:•:0410,18..."..., • e ,
- •••
139sse. ,
• er• --.4t t'e cake .0:t.- •-.460***(0—npre. 1ses that is owp.06.1 ii jøi.ct or, -Lenanc
alto the-riew . •
. •
tbe.;i ACW•143ri'tO
• •
*••• • 4.4•19l.t?).it,
Atturtilityther7}18151tar.
;04****-6-':W: -.. •
40ig.44t#00#0:
.rf*d**44 .11 cit-thi?s-Vrg.400244.•
•
• . t
• r .
t
•
.'01:,...i.,̀ ••• ' :.. ...'-'
.4 tt .i the :`- ...t
, ,..-•
: .:;Ji.. . 7'.: '• • --1:43.-,-...*
.).00400#01/114::::. pos ..f.'"7. .. .'r.
,:•-frit 0' #C' ts b.i .riv.,• 00400.0.4,ii *Iiiii'Prafi.6*44.004t4)---..PO PTY- f,* :1.:.0'.4. . o. or ©n -'i.i4i,- -c66 ,4.f.,,
4,03.11,0;141.i0.41,i 1;.* •k f.g*--. $*!!iikze,1,,.. ltk.,.sOOr .wo..4d: 11iii*'_-4in.
ttle*(400-jb .t."61.4..:::#0 •trie: 440.1..W..'*.....0. 4. .:.41.140 1::040-
*.;44:104: •Ae-:.40Vei. to .00:E;'alio: the ont trust--- iacF,...,:-.::: :,
ii ey '••would.have• •• • been -*it 091,,fLelk -the --,, an
0.:-... 3*.- *''''1P.ws While the
•
*Orra'441:4
26
a
fte
et
_ . .aofe never -f4
4:1 Ii:: 't.',:i:
61 ':11#y,-.•,.',/,,_ - , - - -•,:-:..-:-,:'.... ,....-t..?3, .2---. ?,-,•5
' ....for each t‘ . In the case ; 0,-. f . many''. -- -. -: .....,,,,,,,z:-..4•:,,,-..
'-'- :-'- • ' large'- ' 001..i.trA4,..--_' 1 0 ----. - -. ?,..7.;,.. '7 '. . co-tract
' . .- i,6 iiiiii:iii44i'..r0*:---,i'4-'##* 6..14,..'46:, 4,
every these. -,
-'s ve , ...
rlie y .,'yeo,r . The ' Cps t of open ing r . dO, : . ,
%4i64' C.-" a ' - - •
Lieen reel oil'ea
- hti61144-4.... ".40---' 1°° F'
q9,944g5 "-it#.4P.4?..',4• ::043/ :..sbeen _ v ery h i gh Lt,- 11).otifip404 , these are;-45,.44.:,,,,xv,\i,li,- ,,i.-....e... :-.:;i:..-.4:•.:::,i, .,-. ; , ;- .....14,--,--..'-' ,,,-,, - • ,L.i.a.,,,,..-.-̀f •-z.i. - . t er S ,,,,r_ho are ' th e -:)***t like:1.'y - to -4:1041-l1 •t.-4,0;
S,6k. a result the total cost of this
ikely have gret1,y e x?..1*Osig-Cj, the c' ost whiJt
he holiclb a -0,06to04; On :the ini:ItastrY-:,
aWit le 1 :14T:t Viii00. conmn forms off
:JAW C e
r:61-y res c the • **-:
...IN,* V • •
ot*:.,k.
h ai;re
g tior a3 •
VII. • 'WOW
4,4tt:respect to the ho the
s-- 5 ktua relay as
f the, the prem is es Az - r e0A-t
J. tQn..of arrears irk liKrgE*Srt =where .#4454n et de f 40.11:24f 'A r rtgage 51 the tei iVe. priorit
os0; :liens are tht....440,10' 0.
. . •
• .
nn nn1 /I• P 1 • 1 " • 4 Aft I• . a a Ia. a II.
27
9
• La
•
_
• • •,2e5."t Atal :.to'.1.-eitiaiit • • ko,b.i•eni ad 3 s t 0s e .
• .,pg.-.Loritti.$' $0 $:$.:.f !pb, It the 1.-i0i-••!3d- I:a iiftall t, s rqht
. = • - - - - • - - - -
proposeto 54'y
•_ i---3rtgage fOr- the purpose of
.. .. : -pv fpperit t'!bliii-liiii,1-9 Or:k9....- - . .. ..... _.,.. ,. ,. , ,.... _.
:••- -......',OY mottgagee i'<o y:xi fa : ;4,:i.,. 16 ttri.,,-,is:,
tiliiticluklit to the'....66tinecteht of the .:t. -,,,,:,,,,, • - :. -":',P ..' :::..,t,':;"•—• *.• :*: ., . • , .• :.: , At'? ; %. I 1.•.:r '',‘: ..' . . , .1 - . - ,...-• ':. -•'::..'1.,:: . • • ' • , . ';,' - - - • -',:-•:''.:)--,.. 0 Alt
trt ti .. feir41*. W.r4-0* .0. ‘: 44,sif.*e•-•-o that;
31,
1:040t*iail2e to ptead risks aneio
Ve:A.tama
47*. *-W- ',.-•-•—•u
;,*0411#0* Th r rsing streagth4 movtga. .
- t& in In al terhate sec
0 C:13#0:::140.::400,6:00:t* cjillt, 1 41s
'.P4*- 40 4c Tggcs4.1t A;it thei.,r e,. • Pr lor
kW' i0t44^.40b. titms.,Actadl,t1
but this • f4ii•-&1iiiW1,41 iipost7,1411. 1.1*-01-x reflect
e4Y the '"t, Pf r owner.:s
itiouioncys tc ,f the:ti -.41t4 Wke* the uilanca1: -stbil:it:-__Cem
04.**114';',±4;;;i.i - 011-t':'.*960:-.--4•
-tional.43pp;ef tir
:tegult 1.1-thl. isisteitive costV
4,S,*.:21A5v- -R it.** • *,'Whl- 4
—1."•••••••• :A.A. • . t314 • ''.0.4.4C.
•••;:.• •
• . .: .•
28
•
29
.J
J
• 1.41.•-
.01J •I:j 4 ,
tthg4i • •
hhts•
igt.*:$04, • 1M."'
• • craa. • .n.•
•
3.kitivsgibtir. •*.bt,:4:gait0.111% ;42t},'-•
444Piákï..:** 40„.isiogas.4 • • • • it fkkibi ,;f:itk.•;•ii;t114.1•SW
'71.4 ••,), ••
*1'142.`;:t'.0V4*.4.14g,f0:gr)::40~,:
,141-g .:,e:xpètsisg
• • . • • • ••
*1.4161..
log; • th 0,01)30:"*~::tiitoo2
c.tlettg nee,.
:In. tor:- .004.1.tii`• " • :•"tt•gt4Olitt-leif tfte
a.1~544.ke,
••-diigeá44.3b:~*átkit..4,1 4-i:édjitUr
• •. .• •• • • .
tránYtiliWav:k•xt . •: • • . .
RZS;te"..*4114
• 1.
•114
Arie -•
.t.6.- • vita. • y-p
•• •
117#0510V ï•;• •
A.:~ted . l'effiiiptitatját •
.n• •
relmetant-tti• ii4solone~ 114.:19tenti: eft .k..1;4;,,
jxmi4140
30
31
,
-4
J
r
J
-i
_J
Court File No.: CV-16-11541-00CL
IN THE MATTER OF THE COMPANIES' CREDITORS ARRANGEMENT ACT, R.S.C. 1985, c. C-36, AS AMENDEDAND IN THE MATTER OF A PLAN OF COMPROMISE OR ARRANGEMENT OF URBANCORP CUMBERLAND 2 GP INC., URBANCORPCUMBERLAND 2 L.P., BOSVEST INC., EDGE ON TRIANGLE PARK INC., AND EDGE RESIDENTIAL INC.
ONTARIOSUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE
(COMMERCIAL LIST)
PROCEEDING COMMENCED ATTORONTO
SUPPLEMENTAL BOOK OF AUTHORITIES OF TOROALUMINUM (A PARTNERSHIP), SPEEDY
ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS LTD., & DOLVINMECHANICAL CONTRACTORS LTD.
LEVINE SHERKIN BOUSSIDANBanisters23 Lesmill Road., Suite 300Toronto ON M3B 3P6
KEVIN D. SHERKIN — LSUC#27099BEmail: [email protected] SACKS — LSUC#62361REmail: [email protected]: 416-224-2400Fax: 416-224-2408
Lawyers for Toro Aluminum (A Partnership), SpeedyElectrical Contractors Ltd., & Dolvin Mechanical ContractorsLtd.