aspirations vs reality: analysis of built projects presentation

29
ASPIRATIONS VS. REALITY: FACADE CASE STUDIES IN TACOMA + FAIRBANKS

Upload: the-architects-newspaper

Post on 25-Jul-2016

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation by Devin Kleiner, Perkins+Will, Facades+AM conference Seattle 2015

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

ASPIRATIONS VS. REALITY: FACADE CASE STUDIES IN TACOMA + FAIRBANKS

Page 2: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

FACADESPLUS | 2

CASE STUDY 1CENTER FOR URBAN WATERSTACOMA

Page 3: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 1: CENTER FOR URBAN WATERS - TACOMA FACADES + 3

LOCATION

CENTER FOR URBAN WATERS

DOWNTOWN TACOMA

THEA FOSS W

ATERWAY

Page 4: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 1: CENTER FOR URBAN WATERS - TACOMA FACADES + 4

FACADE GOALS

• LEED PLATINUM

• 2030 CHALLENGE: 60% REDUCTION

• CLIMATE RESPONSIVE FACADE

• “SUSTAINABLE BILLBOARD”

• MAXIMIZE VIEWS TO SW + CONTROL HEAT GAIN / GLARE

Page 5: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 1: CENTER FOR URBAN WATERS - TACOMA FACADES + 5

SITE PLAN + CONSTRAINTS

Page 6: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 1: CENTER FOR URBAN WATERS - TACOMA FACADES + 6

SITE STRATEGY

Page 7: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 1: CENTER FOR URBAN WATERS - TACOMA FACADES + 7

SOUTHWEST FACADE

Page 8: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 1: CENTER FOR URBAN WATERS - TACOMA FACADES + 8

SOUTHWEST WALL SECTION

Page 9: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 1: CENTER FOR URBAN WATERS - TACOMA FACADES + 9

ENERGY USE: MODELED VS. ACTUALMODELED ENERGY USE: 82 kBtu/sf/yrACTUAL ENERGY USE: 86 kBtu/sf/yr

GAS: WATER HEATINGELECTRICITY: REMAINING ENERGY USES

Page 10: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 1: CENTER FOR URBAN WATERS - TACOMA FACADES + 10

ENERGY COMPARISONS: INTERIOR LIGHTING

Page 11: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 1: CENTER FOR URBAN WATERS - TACOMA FACADES + 11

ENERGY COMPARISONS: WATER HEATING

Page 12: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 1: CENTER FOR URBAN WATERS - TACOMA FACADES + 12

ENERGY COMPARISONS: PLUG LOADS

Page 13: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 1: CENTER FOR URBAN WATERS - TACOMA FACADES + 13

Lighting

How satisfied are you with the amount of light inyour workspace?

How satisfied are you with the visual comfort ofthe lighting (e.g., glare, reflections, contrast)?

POST OCCUPANCY EVALUATION: LIGHTING

Page 14: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 1: CENTER FOR URBAN WATERS - TACOMA FACADES + 14

Thermal Comfort

How satisfied are you with the temperature inyour workspace?

Thermal Comfort

Overall, does your thermal comfort in yourworkspace enhance or interfere with your abilityto get your job done?

POST OCCUPANCY EVALUATION: THERMAL COMFORT

Page 15: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 1: CENTER FOR URBAN WATERS - TACOMA FACADES + 15

POST OCCUPANCY EVALUATION: BUILDING FEATURESBuilding Features

Considering energy use, how efficiently is thisbuilding performing in your opinion?

Building Features

Exterior shades

Page 16: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 1: CENTER FOR URBAN WATERS - TACOMA FACADES + 16

POST OCCUPANCY FACADE CHANGES• UPPER OPERABLE WINDOWS: CHANGE ABRUPT TO GRADUAL BMS CONTROL

• LEVEL 1 WINDOWS:ADD INTERIOR BLINDS FOR GLARE CONTROL

Page 17: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

FACADESPLUS | 17

CASE STUDY 2STUDENT DINING EXPANSIONFAIRBANKS

Page 18: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 2: STUDENT DINING EXPANSION - FAIRBANKS FACADES + 18

LOCATION

Page 19: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 2: STUDENT DINING EXPANSION - FAIRBANKS FACADES + 19

FACADE GOALS• 2030 CHALLENGE: 60% REDUCTION

• AIR TIGHT ENVELOPE

• MEASURE PERFORMANCE: COLD CLIMATE RESEARCH CENTER

• HIGHEST PERFORMING CURTAIN WALL IN NORTH AMERICA

• COMFORT NEAR THE WINDOW IN SUB-ARCTIC CLIMATE

Page 20: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 2: STUDENT DINING EXPANSION - FAIRBANKS FACADES + 20

SUB-ARCTIC CLIMATE

Page 21: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 2: STUDENT DINING EXPANSION - FAIRBANKS FACADES + 21

SUB-ARCTIC CLIMATE: INSIDE-OUTSIDE CONNECTION

Page 22: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 2: STUDENT DINING EXPANSION - FAIRBANKS FACADES + 22

SUB-ARCTIC CLIMATE: LOW SUN ANGLE

SUMMER WINTER

Page 23: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 2: STUDENT DINING EXPANSION - FAIRBANKS FACADES + 23

CURTAIN WALL SECTION AND DETAIL

PATENT FOR CURTAIN WALL SYSTEMUS 8413403 B2

Page 24: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 2: STUDENT DINING EXPANSION - FAIRBANKS FACADES + 24

VACUUM INSULATED PANEL (VIP)

ALUMINIZED MULTILAYER BARRIER TO CONTAIN VACUUM AND PROVIDE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION

CORE BAGPRESSED FUMED SILICA CORE

Page 25: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 2: STUDENT DINING EXPANSION - FAIRBANKS FACADES + 25

VACUUM INSULATED PANEL (VIP): MODELEDR-

VALU

E

Vacuum Insulated Panel (VIP)

Aerogel Blanket

Polyisocyanurate

Extruded Polystyrene (XPS)

INSULATION LOCATION INBOARD VS. IN PLANE OF GLASS

INSULATION COMPARISON NOMINAL R-VALUE

Mineral Wool (MW)

Expanded Polystyrene (EPS)

Fiberglass Batts

Page 26: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 2: STUDENT DINING EXPANSION - FAIRBANKS FACADES + 26

VACUUM INSULATED PANEL (VIP): MOCK-UPVIEW FROM INSIDEVIEW FROM OUTSIDE

Page 27: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 2: STUDENT DINING EXPANSION - FAIRBANKS FACADES + 27

MEASURING FACADE PERFORMANCE: MULTIPLE DATA POINTS WITHIN ADJACENT FACADE ASSEMBLIES

Page 28: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 2: STUDENT DINING EXPANSION - FAIRBANKS FACADES + 28

MEASURING FACADE PERFORMANCE CLIENT SITTING AT THE WINDOW

Page 29: Aspirations vs Reality: Analysis of Built Projects presentation

CASE STUDY 2: STUDENT DINING EXPANSION - FAIRBANKS FACADES + 29