becoming rhizomatic?

171
Becoming Rhizomatic?

Upload: mark-ingham

Post on 30-Nov-2014

1.453 views

Category:

Education


0 download

DESCRIPTION

“A rhizome as subterranean stem is absolutely different from roots and radicles. Bulbs and tubers are rhizomes. Plants with roots or radicles may be rhizomorphic in other respects altogether: the question is whether plant life in its specificity is not entirely rhizomatic. Even some animals are, in their pack form. Rats are rhizomes.” (6)

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Becoming Rhizomatic?

Page 2: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Becoming Rhizomatic?

Mark Ingham

2012

Page 3: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Split

Page 4: Becoming Rhizomatic?

“A as subterranean stem is absolutely rhizome

different from roots and radicles.

Bulbs and tubers are rhizomes. Plants with roots or radicles may be

rhizomorphic in other respects

altogether: the question is whether plant life in its specificity is not

Page 5: Becoming Rhizomatic?

entirely . Even some rhizomatic

animals are, in their pack form. Rats are .” (6) rhizomes

Page 6: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 7: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Splitting in and Out

“Burrows are too, in all of their functions of shelter, supply, movement, evasion, and breakout.

The itself assumes rhizome

very diverse forms, from ramified surface extension in all directions to

Page 8: Becoming Rhizomatic?

concretion into bulbs and

tubers. When rats swarm over each other.

(7)

Page 9: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 10: Becoming Rhizomatic?

In and out through the roof.

“The includes the best and the rhizome

worst: potato and

couchgrass, or the weed. Animal and plant, couchgrass is crabgrass. We

get the distinct feeling that we will convince no one unless we

Page 11: Becoming Rhizomatic?

enumerate certain approximate

characteristics of the .“(7) rhizome

Page 12: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 13: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Through the roof

“Principles of connection and

heterogeneity: any point of a can be connected to rhizome

Page 14: Becoming Rhizomatic?

anything other, and must be. This

is very different from the tree or

root, which plots a point, fixes an order.” (7)

Page 15: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 16: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 17: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Opening to through the roof

“…not every trait in a

is necessarily linked to rhizome

a linguistic feature: semiotic chains of every nature are connected to

very diverse modes of coding

Page 18: Becoming Rhizomatic?

(biological, political, economic,

etc.) that bring into play not only different regimes of signs but

also states of things of differing status.” (7)

Page 19: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 20: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Escape Route

“A ceaselessly establishes rhizome

connections between semiotic

chains, organizations of power, and

Page 21: Becoming Rhizomatic?

circumstances relative to the arts, sciences, and social struggles.”

(7)

Page 22: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 23: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Escape Route too.

“A method of the type, on the rhizome

contrary, can analyze language

Page 24: Becoming Rhizomatic?

only by decentering it onto other

dimensions and other registers.” (8)

Page 25: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 26: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Looking up Concorde

“Multiplicities are , rhizomatic

and expose arborescent pseudomultiplicities

Page 27: Becoming Rhizomatic?

for what they are.” (8)

Page 28: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 29: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Rocket

“Puppet strings, as a

or multiplicity, are tied rhizome

not to the supposed will of an artist or puppeteer but to a multiplicity

of nerve fibers, which form another

Page 30: Becoming Rhizomatic?

puppet in other dimensions

connected to the first:” (8)

Page 31: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 32: Becoming Rhizomatic?

10, 9, 8, 7, 6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1. We have lift off.

“There are no points or positions in a

, such as those found in a rhizome

structure, tree, or root.

Page 33: Becoming Rhizomatic?

There are only lines.” (8)

Page 34: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 35: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 36: Becoming Rhizomatic?

One small step…

             

       

“The point is that a or multiplicity never rhizome

allows itself to be overcoded, never has available a supplementary dimension over

Page 37: Becoming Rhizomatic?

and above its number of lines, that is, over and above the multiplicity of numbers attached to those lines.” (9)

Page 38: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 39: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 40: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Shake Shake Shake Shaker it…

“Multiplicities are defined by the outside: by the abstract line, the line of flight or deterritorialisation

Page 41: Becoming Rhizomatic?

according to which they change in nature and connect with other multiplicities.” (9)

Page 42: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 43: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 44: Becoming Rhizomatic?

More Shaker it…

“A

may be broken, shattered at rhizome

a given spot, but it will start up

Page 45: Becoming Rhizomatic?

again on one of its old lines, or on new lines.” (9)

Page 46: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 47: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Sitting on the dock of the bay…

“Every rhizome contains

lines of segmentarity according to which it is stratified, territorialized, organized, signified, attributed, etc., as well as lines of deterritorialization down

Page 48: Becoming Rhizomatic?

which it constantly flees.” (6)

Page 49: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 50: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Dancing to Sitting on the Dock of the Bay…

“There is a rupture in the whenever rhizome

segmentary lines explode into a line of flight, but the line of flight is part of the rhizome. These lines always

Page 51: Becoming Rhizomatic?

tie back to one another.” (9)

Page 52: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 53: Becoming Rhizomatic?

A Paradise in Peckham…

“You may make a rupture, draw a line of flight, yet there is still a danger that you will reencounter organisations that restratify

Page 54: Becoming Rhizomatic?

everything, formations that restore power to a signifier, attributions that reconstitute a subject—anything you like, from Oedipal resurgences to fascist concretions.” (9)

Page 55: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 56: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 57: Becoming Rhizomatic?

A Paradise in Peckham…The Kings Fruit Basket…

“Groups and individuals contain microfascisms just waiting to crystallize. Yes,

Page 58: Becoming Rhizomatic?

couchgrass is also a

. Good rhizome

and bad are only the products of an active and temporary selection, which must be renewed.” (9-10)

Page 59: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 60: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 61: Becoming Rhizomatic?

A Paradise in Peckham…

“Wasp and orchid, as heterogeneous elements, form a

.” rhizome

(10)

Page 62: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 63: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 64: Becoming Rhizomatic?

A Paradise in Peckham…

“There is neither imitation nor

resemblance, only an exploding of two heterogeneous series on the

Page 65: Becoming Rhizomatic?

line of

flight composed by a common that rhizome

can

no longer be attrib

uted to or subjugated by anything signifying.” (10)

Page 66: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 67: Becoming Rhizomatic?

One of many

Page 68: Becoming Rhizomatic?

One of Many Follies…

“Evolutionary schemas would no longer follow models of

arborescent descent going from the least to

Page 69: Becoming Rhizomatic?

the most

differentiated, but

instead a rhizome

operating immediately in the heterogeneous and

ju

mping from one already differentiated

Page 70: Becoming Rhizomatic?

lin

e to another.” (10)

Page 71: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 72: Becoming Rhizomatic?

One More of many Follies…

“We form a rhizome

with our viruses, or rather our viruses cause us to form a

Page 73: Becoming Rhizomatic?

rhizome

with other animals.” (10)

Page 74: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 75: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 76: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Two of One of many Follies…

“We evolve

and die more from

our polymorphous and flus than from rhizomatic

Page 77: Becoming Rhizomatic?

hereditary

diseases, or diseases that have their own line of descent.

The rhizome

is an anti-genealogy.” (11)

Page 78: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 79: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 80: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Many Middens…

“…the book is not an image of the world. It forms a

rh

izome with the

world, the

re is an

Page 81: Becoming Rhizomatic?

aparallel evolution of the book

and

the world; the book assures the deterritorialization of the world,

but the world effects a reterritorialization

Page 82: Becoming Rhizomatic?

of

the book, which in turn

de

territorializes itself in the world (if it is capable, if it can). (11)

Page 83: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 84: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 85: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Inside one of the Many Middens…

“The wisdom of the

plants: even when they have roots, there is always an

Page 86: Becoming Rhizomatic?

outside where they

form a rhizome

with something else-with the

wind, an animal, human beings (and there is also an aspect under

which animals

Page 87: Becoming Rhizomatic?

themselves form

, as rhizomes

do people, etc.). (11)

Page 88: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 89: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 90: Becoming Rhizomatic?

More Many Midens…

"Drunkenness as a

triumphant irruption of the plant in us." (11)

Page 91: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 92: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 93: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Something Misunderstood…

“Always follow the rhizome

by rupture; lengthen, prolong, and relay the line of

Page 94: Becoming Rhizomatic?

flight; make it vary,

until you have produced the most abstract and

tortuous of lines of n dimensions and broken directions.” (11)

Page 95: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 96: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 97: Becoming Rhizomatic?

More of Something Misunderstood…

“Write, form a

, rhizome

increase

Page 98: Becoming Rhizomatic?

your territory by

deterritorialisation, extend the line of flight to the

point where it becomes an abstract machine covering the entire plane

Page 99: Becoming Rhizomatic?

of

consistency.” (11)

Page 100: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 101: Becoming Rhizomatic?

I gave you Too Many Pieces of Silver…

“Music has

always sent out lines of flight, like

so many "transformational multiplicities," even

Page 102: Becoming Rhizomatic?

overturning

the very codes that

structure or arborify it;

that is why musical form, right down to its ruptures and

Page 103: Becoming Rhizomatic?

proliferation,

is comparable to a weed, a

.” (11-rhizome

12)

Page 104: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 105: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Raymond Williams meets Rolf Harris…

“…a rhizome is

not amenable to any structural or generative model. It is a stranger to

Page 106: Becoming Rhizomatic?

any idea of genetic axis or deep structure.” (12)

Page 107: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 108: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Raymond Williams meets Rolf Harris…In a Rotten Garden…

“The is rhizome

altogether different, a map and not a tracing.

Page 109: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Make a map, not a tracing. The orchid does not reproduce the tracing

of the wasp; it forms a map with the wasp, in a

.rhizome

” (12)

Page 110: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 111: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 112: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Raymond Williams meets Rolf Harris…A they paper over the cracks….

“The map does not

reproduce an unconscious closed in upon itself; it constructs the

Page 113: Becoming Rhizomatic?

unconscious. It fosters connections between fields, the removal of

Page 114: Becoming Rhizomatic?

blockages on bodies without

organs, the maximum opening of bodies

without organs onto a plane of consistency. It is itself a part of the

.rhizome

” (12)

Page 115: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 116: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 117: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Raymond Williams meets Rolf Harris…

“Perhaps one of the most important characteri

Page 118: Becoming Rhizomatic?

stics of the

rhizome

is that it always has multiple entryways;” (13)

Page 119: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 120: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 121: Becoming Rhizomatic?

A Map Not a Tracing?

The t

racing has already translated the map into an image; it has already

transformed the rhizome

Page 122: Becoming Rhizomatic?

into roots and radicles.” (13)

Page 123: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 124: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 125: Becoming Rhizomatic?

A Map Not a Tracing?

“Look at what happened to Little Hans already, an example of child psychoanalysis at its purest: they kept on BREAKING HIS RHIZOME and BLOTCHING HIS MAP, setting it

straight for him,

Page 126: Becoming Rhizomatic?

blocking his every way out, until he began to desire his own shame and guilt, until they had rooted shame and guilt in him, PHOBIA (they barred him from the of the rhizome

building, then from the

Page 127: Becoming Rhizomatic?

of the street, they rooted him in his rhizome

parents' bed, they radicled him to his own body, they fixated him on Professor Freud).” (14)

Page 128: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 129: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Market Forces…

“Strike the

pose or follow the axis, genetic stage or structural destiny-one way or

the other, your will be rhizome

broken. You will be allowed to live and speak, but only after every

outlet has been obstructed. Once a has been obstructed, rhizome

arborified, it's all over, no desire stirs;

Page 130: Becoming Rhizomatic?

for it is always by that rhizome

desire moves and produces. Whenever desire climbs a tree,

internal repercussions trip it up and it falls to its

death; the , on rhizome

the other hand, acts on desire by external, productive

outgrowths.” (14)

Page 131: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 132: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 133: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Market Forces…

“That is why it is so important to try the

other, reverse but nonsymmetrical, operation. Plug the tracings back into the map,

Page 134: Becoming Rhizomatic?

connect the roots or trees back up with a

.” (14) rhizome

Page 135: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 136: Becoming Rhizomatic?

We become one

“The same applies to the group map: show at what point in the rhizome there

form phenomena of massification, bureaucracy, leadership, fascisation, etc., which lines nevertheless survive, if only underground, continuing to make

Page 137: Becoming Rhizomatic?

in the shadows.” (14) rhizome

Page 138: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 139: Becoming Rhizomatic?

We become one and Many

“There exist tree or root structures in ; conversely, a tree rhizomes

branch or root division may begin to

Page 140: Becoming Rhizomatic?

burgeon into a . The rhizome

coordinates are determined not by theoretical analyses implying universals but by a pragmatics composing multiplicities or aggregates of intensities.” (15)

Page 141: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 142: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 143: Becoming Rhizomatic?

We become one and Many

“A new rhizome

may form in the heart of a tree, the hollow of a root, the crook of a

Page 144: Becoming Rhizomatic?

branch. Or else it is a microscopic element of the root-tree, a radicle, that gets production rhizome

going.” (15)

Page 145: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 146: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 147: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Mapping not Tracing?

“Accounting and

bureaucracy proceed by

tracings: they can begin to burgeon nonetheless, throwing

Page 148: Becoming Rhizomatic?

out stems, as rhizome

in a Kafka novel.” (15)

Page 149: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 150: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 151: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Mapping not Tracing?

“To be

is to produce rhizomorphous

stems and

Page 152: Becoming Rhizomatic?

filamen

ts that seem to be roots, or better yet connect with them by

penetrating the trunk, but put them to strange new uses.” (15)

Page 153: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 154: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 155: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Mapping not Tracing?

“Nothing is beautiful or loving or political aside from underground stems and aerial roots, adventitious

Page 156: Becoming Rhizomatic?

growths and .” (15) rhizomes

Page 157: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 158: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Mapping not Tracing?

“Many people have a tree growing in their heads, but the brain itself is much more a grass than

a tree.” (15)

Page 159: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 160: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 161: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Mapping not Tracing?

“The same goes for

memory. Neurologists and psychophysiologists

distinguish between long-term memory and short-term memory

(on the order of a minute). The difference between them is not simply

Page 162: Becoming Rhizomatic?

quantitative: short-term memory is of

the or diagram type, rhizome

and long-term memory is arborescent and centralized (imprint,

engram, tracing, or photograph).” (15-16)

Page 163: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 164: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 165: Becoming Rhizomatic?

Mapping not Tracing?

“Short-term memory includes forgetting as a process; it merges not with the instant but instead with the nervous, temporal, and collective . Long-term memory rhizome

(family, race, society, or civilization) traces and translates, but what it translates continues to

Page 166: Becoming Rhizomatic?

act in it, from a distance, off beat, in an "untimely" way, not instantaneously.” (16)

Page 167: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 168: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 169: Becoming Rhizomatic?

A Boy A Pool A Freezing Lake

120 Days and Nights of Staggering and Stammering

Page 170: Becoming Rhizomatic?
Page 171: Becoming Rhizomatic?