before the public utilities commission state of south … · 2008. 12. 1. · before the public...

31
BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA KEYSTONE XL PROJECT DOCKET HP09·001 PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH ON BEHALF OF THE COMMISSION STAFF SEPTEMBER 2009

Upload: others

Post on 02-Sep-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

BEFORE THEPUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION

STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA

KEYSTONE XL PROJECTDOCKET HP09·001

PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSHON BEHALF OF THE COMMISSION STAFF

SEPTEMBER 2009

Page 2: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA

PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

Q. State your full name.

A. Kimberly Lorrene Mcintosh.

Q. State your employer.

A. South Dakota Department of Environment and Natural Resources.

Q. Explain the specific program for which you work.

A. Ground Water Quality Program - Spill Assessment and Cleanup Section. The

spill section is responsible for documenting all reported regulated substance

releases: petroleum, chemical, pesticide, fertilizer, metals, etc. The spill section

maintains the program files and the environmental events database which

contains information on each reported release. This section investigates

complaints and releases, obtains environmental samples, provides direction to

responsible parties, environmental consultants and local officials on state laws

and rules, and issues letters directing the assessment and cleanup of

contamination. This section is responsible for the SARA (Superfund Amendment

and Reauthorization Act) Title III Program which requires that chemicals stored in

certain quantities be reported to the state. The spill section also is responsible

for other projects such as emergency planning and response, methaphedimine

issues, low level radiation issues, and homeland security issues.

Q. State what you do for this program.

A. I direct and oversee the staff in the spill section. I evaluate information and data

to identify and name responsible parties. I direct environmental contractors and

responsible parties on emergency response activities, assessment and cleanup

activities associated with spills, releases and un-permitted discharges. I manage

the State Regulated Substance Response Fund and the Environmental Livestock

Page 3: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

Fund. I am responsible for the selection and hiring of contractors to be used in

the event that a responsible party is unable to perform a cleanup or refuses to

perform a cleanup and the Regulated Substance Response Funds are necessary

to remedy a situation. I am responsible for evaluation of spills and releases to

insure that the cleanup meets state requirements.

Q. Explain the range of activities and duties your program covers and what

you specifically do for the program.

A. I review consultant reports detailing sampling of soil and ground water

contamination associated with all types of spills and releases of regulated

substances. I review and approve cleanup plans and act as the team leader.

directing day to day work activity of the spill section. Activities included in the

spill section include the Superfund Amendment and Reauthorization Action

(SARA) Title III activities. department emergency response activities. homeland

security activities. and state emergency and disaster planning activities. I also

represent the state on the Regional Response Team acting as a state liaison with

EPA. and other federal agencies in the event of a multi-state disaster.

Q. On whose behalf was this testimony prepared?

A. This testimony was prepared on behalf of the Staff of the South Oakota Public

Utilities Commission (Staff).

Q. What federal and state standards exist for petroleum spills?

A. SOCL 34A-2. SOCL 34A-12. SOCL 34A-18 and ARSO Chapter 74:34:01. ARSO

Chapter 74:54:01, ARSO Chapter 74:56:03. ARSO Chapter 74:56:05 and ARSO

Chapter 74:10:05.

Q. Which of those standards do you personally work with?

A. All of the above.

Q. What level of cleanup is required in the case of a petroleum spill?

2

Page 4: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

A. All petroleum spills are evaluated to determine what damage has occurred and

what risk to human health and the environment exists based on the specifics of

each release: substance released, amount released, location of release, depth

to ground water, threat to surface water, threat to basements, water wells, or

utilities, etc. The department has established cleanup criteria and standards in

which each release is evaluated against to protect human health and the

environment, so not all petroleum releases are cleaned up to the same level of

contamination.

Q. Can there by hydrocarbon left in the soil after a cleanup?

A. Yes, petroleum contamination may be left in the soil after a cleanup if the

department determined that the remaining contamination does not pose a risk to

human health or further risk to the environment.

Q. What kind of remediation activities are conducted in response to a

hydrocarbon spill in soil?

A. Excavation and off site disposal/treatment of impacted soil, excavation and onsite

treatment of impacted soil and in-situ soil vapor extraction.

Q. What kind of remediation activities are conducted in response to a

hydrocarbon spill in groundwater?

A. Excavation of impacted soil and soil venting may be conducted in conjunction

with ground water sparging. Ground water monitoring is conducted to document ground

water conditions.

Q. Explain other activities you use for remediation.

A. Soil can be excavated and incinerated to destroy hydrocarbons.

Q. What are the leak size requirements for a reportable spill?

A. SDCL 34A-12: A release or spill of a regulated substance (petroleum) must be

reported to DENR immediately.if anyone of the follOWing conditions exists:

3

Page 5: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

1. The discharge threatens or is in a position to threaten the waters

of the state (surface water or ground water);

2. The discharge causes an immediate danger to human health or

safety;

3. The discharge exceeds 25 gallons; (For crude oil see bullet #8)

4. The discharge causes a sheen on surface water;

5. The discharge of any substance that exceeds the ground water

quality standards of ARSO chapter 74:54:01;

6. The discharge of any substance that exceeds the surface water

quality standards of ARSO chapter 74:54:01;

7. The discharge of any substance that harms or threatens to harm

wildlife or aquatic life;

8. The discharge of crude oil in field activities under SOCL chapter

45-9 is greater than 1 barrel (42 gallons).

Q. Has there been any permanent natural resource damage in South Dakota

as the result of a hydrocarbon pipeline leak?

A. I am not aware of any permanent natural resource damage from a petroleum

pipeline release.

Q. Are there spills that cannot be remediated?

A. I do not believe there are any petroleum spills that can not be remediated given

sufficient time and resources.

Q. Who is obligated to remediate a spill?

A. SOCL 34A-12 identifies that the person or persons who caused the release are

responsible to assess and cleanup the contamination. SDCL 34A-18-8 identifies

that each crude oil pipeline operator must implement their response plan

regardless of the cause of the party responsible for the release.

4

Page 6: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

Q. How do you remediate hydrocarbon contaminated wells?

A. It depends on the level of contamination pr~sent in the well and in the ground

water. The water from a contaminated well can be treated with a carbon filter

system that removes (strips) the hydrocarbons.

Q. What if you can't achieve remediation of a well?

A. The responsible party is required to supply the well owner/user with an alternate

source of drinking water. This may require drilling a new well in a different

location, drilling a deeper well in a deeper formation or hooking the well user up

to rural or city water supply.

Q. What is the extent of landowner involvement in remediation?

A. It depends on the situation. Some landowners want to be involved in the cleanup

but most allow the department to work with the responsible party to get the

cleanup work performed to state standards. The department copies the land

owner on all written correspondence with the responsible party and consultant. If

the land owner wishes to be involved with the cleanup, meetings may be held to

address the concerns of the landowner and other interested parties. Copies of

all documents can be provided if the land owner wishes to receive them.

Q. Does DENR have the resources to deal with a spill from a hydrocarbon

pipeline such as Keystone XL?

A. The DENR has the resources necessary to oversee the assessment and cleanup

of a crude oil release from existing crude oil pipelines and has the resources to

oversee a release from the Keystone XL pipeline, if one should occur. The

DENR manages a fund with sufficient resources to contain and initiate cleanup

actions, if a release should occur, and the pipeline company is unable or refuses

to perform the required response activities. Federal financial resources may also

5

Page 7: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

be available if the responsible party refuses or is unable to perform the cleanup

work.

Q. Does this pipeline place any additional burden on your program?

A. The Keystone XL pipeline does not place additional burden on the Ground Water

Quality Program.

Q. Please explain the Regulated Substance Release Fund, the Superfund

and/or any other program available to help fund a remediation project.

A. Please see Attachment 1. Attachment 1 is a copy of Appendix I from the

"Findings Report" dated December 1, 2008 from the South Dakota Underground

Pipeline Task Force report. This attachment is information on the South Dakota

Regulated Substance Response Fund. This information was previously compiled

and prOVided to the South Dakota Underground Pipeline Task Force.

Q. Is all of the information contained in Attachment 1 current?

A. No. The Department of Environment and Natural Resources currently has seven

environmental contractors under contract. Tetra Tech, Rapid City, South Dakota,

is also now under contract. Also, the balance of the Regulated Substance

Response Fund as of 06/30/09 was $2,782,073.

Please also see Attachment 2. Attachment 2 is a copy of Appendix N from the

"Findings Report" dated December 1, 2008 from the South Dakota Underground

Pipeline Task Force report. This attachment is information on the federal Oil Spill

Liability Trust Fund. This information was preViously compiled and provided to

the South Dakota Underground Pipeline Task Force.

Q. Any other information you believe the commission and the public will find

useful.

6

Page 8: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

A. The Ground Water Quality program has extensive staff experienced in

overseeing the assessment and cleanup of all types of petroleum releases both

in soils and ground water.

7

Page 9: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

Appendix I

South Dakota Regulated Substance ResponseFund.

Page 10: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

REGULATED SUBSTANCE RESPONSE FUND

DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES

CONTACTS:Steve Pimer, Secretary

Tim Tollefsrud, Director·

INTENT I USE I PURPOSE:The money in the Regulated Substance Response Fund is continuously appropriated to providefunding for the clean up ofregulated substance discharges. The SecretaI)' of the Department ofEnvironment and Natural Resources may expend funds from the response fund to provide for thecosts of investigations, emergency remedial efforts, corrective actions, and managerial oradministrative activities associated with such activities.

SUMMARY:In 1988 SDCL: 34A-12-3 created the Regulated Substance Response Fund. The fund was createdthrough an appropriation from general fund, a one-time contribution from the petroleum releasecompensation fund, and a temporary pesti~ide registration fee.

On going deposits into the fund come from; money from civil action ·oi administrative proceedingsfor violation of environmental statutes or upon damage to the environment, including actions foradministrative expense recoveries, civil penalties, compensatory damages, and money paid pursuantto any agreement, stipulation, or settlement in such actions or proceedings; and interest attributableto investment ofthe money in the response fund. Before the fund can be used, there must be adischarge of a regulated substance, but then the money is continuously appropriated to providefunds for the clean up of regulated substance discharges. The department may file civil actions orliens on property owned by the responsible person to cost recover.

REQUIREMENTS:The Secretary of the Department ofEnvironment and Natural Resources may expend funds fromthe response fund to provide for the costs of investigations, emergency remedial efforts, correctiveactions, and managerial or administrative activities associated with discharges of regulatedsubstances. For a substance to be classified as a regulated substance, it must be defined in eitherstatute or rule. SDCL 34A-12-1 exempts sewage and sewage sludge from being classified as aregulated substance.

The secretmy's use of the response fund shall be based upon the following:(1) In the case ofan investigation, when the secretary determines that a discharge requiringan emergency remedial effort may have occurred and that the general operating budget ofthe department for such purposes is not adequate to cover the costs of the necessaryinvestigatory activities;

Page 11: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

(2) In the case of an emergency remedial effort, when the secretary determines that adischarge has occurred and that corrective actions shall be immediately undertaken toprote~ an imminent threat to the public health or safety or to contain a discharge which, ifnot immediately contained, shall in time pose a significantly greater threat to public healthor safety or to the environment of this state than if such action is not immediately taken;

(3) In the case of a discharge not of an emergency nature when the secretary determines thata discharge has occurred, that a responsible party or liability fund capable ofperforming thecorrective actions either cannot be identified or refuses to undertake corrective actions, andthat corrective actions shall be undertaken to protect the public health, safety, welfare, orenvironment of the state.

SDCL 34A-12-12 makes the responsible person strictly liable for any corrective action costsexpended from the Regulated Substance Response Fund, and the department may file eithercivil actions or liens on property owned by responsible persons to cost recover.

STATUTES:

34A-12-3. Regulated substance response fund established - Purpose - Source of funds ­Continuous appropriation - Informational budget - Annualleeislative review - There is herebyestablished in the state treasury an operating fund to be known as the regulated substance responsefund for the purpose ofproviding funds for the clean up of regulated substance discharges. Inaddition to the money from the petroleum release cleanup fund as provided in § 34A-12-2 and thetemporary pesticide registration fee increase provided by § 38-20A-9, funds from the followingsources shall be deposited into the response fund:(1) Direct appropriations to the response fund from the general fund;(2) Money, other than criminal fines assessed in criminal actions, recovered by the state in any

action or administrative proceeding based upon violation ofthe state's environmental statutes orupon damage to the environment, including actions for administrative expense recoveries, civilpenalties, compensatory damages, and money paid pursuant to any agreement, stipulation, orsettlement in such actions or proceedings;(3) Interest attributable to investment ofthe money in the response fund;(4) Money received by the department in the form of gifts, grants, reimbursements, orappropriations from any source intended to be used for the purposes ofthe response fund.All money in the response fund is continuously appropriated for the purposes specified in § 34A-12­1:. All money received by the department for the response fund shall be set forth in an informationalbudget pursuant to § 4-7-7.2 and be annually reviewed by the Legislature.Source: SL 1988, ch 291, § 4.

34A-12-2. One-time contribution from petroleum release compensation fund to response fund- Annual contribution to groundwater protection fund -- The petroleum release compensationfund established pursuantto § 34A-13-18, shall make a one time contribution ofthree hundred fiftythousand dollars, to the response fund within one year after March I, 1988, and shall contribute onehundred thousand dollars annually for five years to the groundwater protection fund to fund thegroundwater research and education program established pursuant to § 46A-I-85. Source: SL1988, ch 291, § 3; 1989, ch 306, § 55.

Page 12: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

34A-12-4. Expenditure of funds by secretary - Grounds for expenditures -- When necessary inthe performance ofthe secretary's duties lUlder §§ 23A-27-25. 34A-I-39. 34A-2-75. 34A-6-1.4.34A-6-1.31, 34A-II-9, 34A-11-10. 34A-II-12, 34A-11-14, 34A-12-1 to 34A-12-15. inclusive, 45­6B-70, 45-6C-45, 45-6D-60. and 45-9-68 and Title 34A relative to discharges, the secretary mayexpend funds from the response fund to provide for the costs ofinvestigations, emergency remedialefforts, corrective actions, and managerial or administrative activities associated with suchactivities. The secretary's use of the response fund shall be based upon the following:

(1) In the case of an investigation, when the secretary determines that a discharge requiringan emergency remedial effort may have occurred and that the general operating budget ofthe department for such purposes is not adequate to cover the costs ofthe necessaryinvestigatory activities;(2) In the case of an emergency remedial effort, when the secretary determines that adischarge has occurred and that corrective actions shall be immediately lUldertaken toprotect an imminent threat to the public health or safety or to contain a discharge which, ifnot immediately contained, shall in time pose a significantly greater threat to public healthor safety or to the environment of this state than ifsuch action is not immediately taken;(3) In the case of a discharge not ofan emergency nature when the secretary determines thata discharge has occurred, that a responsible party or liability fund capable ofperforming thecorrective actions either cannot be identified or refuses to undertake corrective actions, andthat corrective actions shall be undertaken to protect the public health, safety, welfare, orenvironment ofthe state. Source: SL 1988, ch 291, § 5; 1992, ch 158, § 55A; 1999, ch 182,§ 3.

34A-12-12. Strict liability for costs of corrective action. Any person who has caused a dischargeof a regulated substance in violation of § 34A-12-8 is strictly liable for the corrective action costsexpended by the department pursuant to §§ 23A-27-25. 34A-1-39, 34A-12-1 to 34A-12-15,inclusive, 38-20A-9, 45-6B-70 i 45-6C-45. 45-6D-60, and 45-9-68. Source: SL 1988, ch 291, § 13.

CURRENT STATUS

The Department of Environment and Natural Resources currently has six (6) contracts in place withenvironmental consulting firms to provide response capabilities. These contracts are 4yearcontracts with extension provisions. Currently the department has contracts with the followingfirms: Geotek Engineering & Testing Services (Sioux Falls); Leggette, Brashears & Graham (SiouxFalls); Terracon Consultants (Rapid City and Omaha); West Central Environmental (Morris,Minnesota); BayWest (St. Paul, Minnesota); and American Engineering Testing Services (pierreand Rapid City).

The balance ofthe Regulated Substance Response Fund as of06/30/2008 was $ 2,575,500.00.

Page 13: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

AppendixN

Federal Oil Spill Liability Trust Fund

Page 14: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

The Oil Spill Liability Trust Fund.IntroductionThe Oil Spill Liability Trust Fund (fund) was created by Congress in 1986 and its use was authorized by the signingof the Oil Pollution Act in 1990. The fund, managed by the U.S. Coast Guard, is established as a funding source topay for cleanup costs and damages resulting from oil spills or threats ofoil spills to navigable waters ofthe UnitedStates. For the purposes ofthis fund "navigable waters" is defmed in § 300.5 ofthe National Contingency Plan.

The fund has two major components. First, the emergency fund. The emergency fund is available for Federal On­Scene Coordinators to respond to oil discharges and for Federal natural resource trustees to initiate natural resourcedamage assessments. This portion ofthe fund receives an annual $50 million apportionment. The Coast Guard hasthe authority to advance an additional $100 million into the emergency fund each year to supplement shortfalls.Second, the remaining Principal Fund balance is used to pay claims and to fund appropriations by Congress toFederal agencies to administer the provisions ofthe Oil Pollution Act and support research and development.

Who Can Access the Fund?• All Federal On-Scene Coordinators• Other Federal, State, Local, and Indian tribal government agencies that assist the Federal On-Scene

Coordinator can be reimbursed for their costs.• Natural Resource Trustees• Claimants - individuals, corporations, and governments can submit claims for uncompensated removal

costs and damages ifthe responsible party does not satisfy their claim.

Limitations to Accessing the Fund• The release or threat ofrelease must be into or on the navigable waters of the United States or adjoining

shorelines or the Exclusive Economic Zone• The discharge must be oil• In general, the maximum amount expendable from the fund per incident is $1 billion.

Responsibility of the Responsible party to a Spill• When an oil spill occurs, the responsible party is responsible for complete cleanup of the spill.• Ifthe responsible party does not fully remo-ve the spill and the Federal On-Scene Coordinator

responds to the spill the responsible party will be later billed for all Federal response costs.

Funding• The fund balance on April 27, 2006 was $662 million.• As ofMarch 18, 2008, the following is the projected end ofyear fund balance based on the barrel tax and

historical expenditures: .

2008 - $1,030,009,4552009 - $1,107,363,8312010 - $1,227,242,2562011 - $1,345,434,7822012 - $1,468,866,6742013 - $1,601,770,1892014 - $1,744,565,195

EPA's Use ofthe Fund in South DakotaIn the early 1990's EPA used monies from the fund to cleanup a coal tar spill in the Big Sioux River at Fawick Parkin Sioux Falls.

Page 15: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

-----_.._"---_.,,~-'----.,..----...,.-----------....,--------....,....,-----------

t,','

~..

~.

,.!,

!'

;.'! ...

....

".'"

'.~

.j:

t"'"

"

i.'

'.: ..

i!f...~~":"~

.:.'

~! \i

,." :li.I_~

~... '...!~;~.=_:~....;

"0;..

"

••... .....;.. -:.

~ .~

.'

".':"

::t

':""

.,:;

'..ow••,.,

~; .

.'.:~.

'·f

.~.

::1 ;'!

':

c·),

#~

",~!~i:

.' .•1''::

>,'

" ~.

"

'~~~'!._~,~

/{.';:

....

':~"

~.;~'.

.~

.';:" .::.~-.:

~ :.

..:

'=::~..

os·

0'"

.:."

f .

1;'

",.':.

.~;

'1:

;; !'

",

".

'".

"'.,

'"

;.:~ :':!'L

1,;

':",~

....•

.'

..~

...... ,,'~'

"

........ •. ;;.

Page 16: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

-"'~

'.'

.,'

'/

",

~:.

;.~ :t::... '5""~ ,';: ..;.. .'-'~;'.~.­,.

.~'~ .~ .

.~.

,..

.':

~:~."

.~.

.t.

'. ~

.';.

~.

.. ~

~::

.'

.',

',. ,.f

;:.,

;" .

.:

. 'I>

...

·.·:i

~.;. ,*'

.:~:.'.

Page 17: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

.•...,---_.._-_.__•....._---:------,--.,--.------------....-.----:'-

;,.'t -\

,1

"

,..;.

"': , .., ,

1·.· ......'I"

::'

'.. =.

'"

·1'"

..;~ ...

'.'

.:..

..;

. ... '"

...'

;:

:; :..~...

".

.'....~: .

Page 18: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

tifl

..

;:-

.i f.

'",.,

Page 19: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

.;.'

...

",

.;

. ~':-:";.

.:.

' ..--

:.i .

.: '-~..

:,!.

.':e0

~.' ;

:~.,_...~

".~

."." :,.

.-._.

-.:''.

; ~.

.',

"'. _~'i

. '."'-~

Page 20: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

...

~r,.·_

+.

~t~~· ~.~~:".:~';.:'~'::"':

...~

1:. ..,i ,,:•.

...... .;,...

,,,:'.

..

.~..

:-.,~

.;,{ ...

.~.1' ..

" .,,~

.~.

.,'."j

-'CII'

'r·.

".

i,i.; .: "·\~..:;;::v ~.~:':~ +.!".;.:.... '.~ ..

...".~.,"':....~; .

..j.

"

..'~.

~.

i'

;:·r "i.; '"

Page 21: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

~: . .l~'\ .., f .. .,. ...;.

"

.~ ..'

:"!'(I.",.~:';'

~,.

~:~

.:i\",

......:-'.-'

'.

:{ ''.1:R

..; ..~ :;' .' ~;..

iMi.~~fqif_.' ·()r~~9i~0it·y

,:;._~.:"_Ja.;.;'~~~';'·ti.· ~;., ;.\

;·~¥:Iii:~;.P~li~gt(~~~:~J.t~~_:Of..·DiBCh~:.:;.,;:f

~.tt~~~~~._t,:.,

.~.'

..•

...r

i' .

".'¥

......

..:~

~...~.,

:'.,~'f

~: .

. :-:..':.:.~~

',~.

;~'l

~.

..~

"l'

; ....

'. .,.,

Page 22: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

,J

, .

,.-.

.; :

:...~.

'.

: ~"....'

.", 'J .•

'.~

,....

. .. :.• -..j-

.~~':~f:~

. ... ~J

~,~....,:;

'::&~~!~~~:::;~"i~~~<"~",r~'.';., 1:',:.;.:·'_·~.:.1'~..·:.·"f.~~;P"7~~~.v .".

~\l~~~

W.:.'.

~.'.

.:r

,.-.

;;

c.

f o ':

.. "'

Page 23: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

~:

;...:"l •..

.'. ' ...-t· .. ,i~'

'*.:

'..;

......~"

<. .

;j:."·.1.

..~-: - ,'<

~,; '~~

-~.

J

-;,.. ~.,

.. ~.

~.9·.arl~.

~:

Page 24: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

~ .

....

"I':._~. ..;.

,:'..-;"" ~:, ~~j

';.:J::"$~' ~:..:' {.. ".

fit:,;"." '..>:tt:;~ •.

,~{:d(l.l:~t:-:~'

....

'~.

~~-~~~~

'~;~:' ;.l~~;."'i !:;;(~ {~:

.:;

. ~

." '-~;

....

..' .' .. ",.'.: ,:;.; ~" ~:, ,- .. "

'to"

~'.,

:.j.'

~ -'..:.,'

:'::

(I':1"

Page 25: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

..,

~.;'

;'.;.0

'<:

,~~~

.."~

:~~'

....~:'

.t:

,~r:~,:~

.:.;:

~;",

;.".

.~

Ii.'.

""

.>. ..~

''?;

:.;~

,,:11.

'?

~:"

~f

:j,~

:.:, :,~.

:c.H

,.,~

:;.

~~

:~;

ii~..

:

;':{ ''.!o'

~>i.

~".

..7,

;:~)

....

:".: ~~:£

:,,:~

".•....:.:..:

.~... <,'.

'.'t.

',\i

..'

't.

.1'

)•

il~

,;..:

.{~

,,~~

....-:t

':~

:~1;?,

':"y~,.

'.'.

'j.•;-

.'t,;,.:;

.-;;.\.

".:i:'

Y;:

.'"

" ,ii"'~

.~.,.

}~~

.'.".r,

:~~

:~;:l.

"::':!

:',

..,: !'~.

~:, ;L:

·...,1

.~;,

I:. ,:~.-

.:~.

'.:'1

:....~~ ~il

.'.:/::

::-.:

','::

;......

.,~

"

~;i:

i·,

,.,:

::.-i,

....,:

..••

...4

;.~.

:.:

--.....

·i.·

-,,

',

...•'.~.

...:....

..~

"'·~l;;§~.1

".'..,

.01"'·"

R,'

:.,'

.'~~

8.:'

"','

".:ft<

:.9E

t,/!,.

IF:f;;.

~..

".:,c

tjI

,!,&,~

.::·'~

:I~(::

~V"!

!.J,~{

;p,~"

":·'t i

l·~;i

';I;~·

:"~';

;J'~i

;~J.

'~oj~i

:f:",I;,:·

":',:~,'".'<G:

,'}B',":::

ui'r;

JP.'

':'.;..rE

i/'r:W

:t;;.:j':

j'.~'I

,;:i

:'~"'

·I""

,',:'.:~~:;.

1;1)

,"

'.':~."I.

~E.i.·

.,i;I'

i~~~:

~r!.i

f~;-·~

:.~",

y.·,::

~r:

';'~".

f',~.,

lllt

'f~J

""I'"

J!,·',

~l~:§~

':...

':~:)~

:r:~·

;:f~

!;'

,','

:~i::~

",;~::

~,:g'':i:'

)~'~

~'I',

~:

·w·:

,"'.

...;.:

8...'.';'

';':":

.'~I

~'"'.

..ilr.f

."j"

"..!

",I~~I

·,·'1'·

'l~;Ll~Ii

LJ

..,<

Ie;

J_~

',,~

.~

,,4'.~,

•....

•I

(,!

,.~.,

P,'

.'¥~

.:.~

t.:>

'~:,

".:'".

:~'.'

;:-,

,;.:~.

,~:.-:

.""

;,'.'

:7~~...,~.-

•.'"'

!

~..

"...

,...

4,l

.•",

~

Page 26: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

·.. ,....... ;

\.'i

,' .

'.,.

........ .,:

.";.~~~~ -~',-

. "; ,:::~.~'

,'~·4'2.',.

~.oft/;-·

"

..'

'..~~~~~., .;,.~'~~ . ..

l:'''f:~' . ..:~~-\

.~.:~

~ .-;,::t'~.~ N~

ir#:1~:,~~!h1t,~~. • : I '~!{~~k.,.

f.: ~~~~~;"~~i".," -t.:"

...

;.'.:

.,

C ,-I,.f i{.

i;'~~

I~

.~

[;i;" .

L ,~

F ~.t'~ .. ..~

I'

t: .~

t,';

.'

.i

... ,.".'".

..'

Page 27: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

"1l o lD <D

o o it

..... CO CO <.It ..... CO CO m ..... CO CO ..... .... <0

CO <» ..... <0

<0

<0

I\) o o o ~ o ..... I\,) o o N ~ C W N o ~ N o o <.It

I\) o ~ N o o ..... N o o Ol

~ ..... o o

~ ..... (:) g

t1

!1

11

11

1

~ ..... o b o o

II

II

:11

11

~ ..... o o (:) o c

Cos

t

~ .....

'0 o c '0 g ..I

II

I!1

11

1

~ .....

o g o b o o

II!I

III

~ ..... o o b o o '0 o o

I!

11

11

11

~ .....

(:) o o '0 g '0 o o

tI

Ililt

Page 28: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

q:

';~.,

OSLTF Funding: Coast Guard Projects(Removal Costs and Claims)

$1,000,000,000

$100,000,000

$10,000,000

$1,000,000

, • I .--iJ----1-- ..... -+-.---... -!'--i·--!.-,-;. ....... I --i~.----l·--..--l-_---J.-_--~L .--.:.------I•• -- .. £..-.~-~-:. , , . .. ..' I I..'. .r- - - - - • - - _ .. - - .. - .... ! - .. - .. -.! - -'. ., •• , .. "-. ~ - - - - -:- - - - - .. - - - - .====:l=="::.::t:=!=-:t==--~!."~~~ • ,. ,..,.. ~... ., ••o.' '. ·-:-----i-...--,--"-... +-----,-!.-~ ~ I::.:.=~~::.":::?:::=i=~il=:::=='=.:G;=I=!~§!:§=.!==t:=!===';=:;e!=!:=Ii::l.~!=.==~t:~-- ' ..... __ ,,_ .' ,...: # I • :,.-,.--

:::::.~ ;;.;':o.¢ ::~::i::-:"';!~:,!.: ;;c:::ig;!"';,~?;.~?,"; ~ cY'~if' i~t" ,~~" £, E i~~.,g '!;>;!;~pt,i ~"~"___;.,..__••_..- __t~.. -r-l.-1 )~1~ .. - t:e. - t -~.......... - .....- r }:.I;o:.::::-!~ r:i; "'-l..i: ~~::::.:!."~:".:;:--'-~=.;;:.:.=::::=: ~:.:. =:.,. !_. -1_,..'•••••,......,.. • ; ~ ..--.'l!::, ..\:-.-;~-4': -- -·-"'-i~_.. -- 1'-;"';- -(#- ~~a.--, -:J""\: jj~~...~-~- - ..p~::.. ..". ~""l.h(~'-"~.T-""~-~~ ..~. - ,.. .1'.. ...l" ... -,j.--........~."R- ~.. _.JI.: ~~ -... $ ..-· ..··r----.==&,.·~.~1:.'~~~ ~iii~':· ~ ·~:~~u:-i::- -.~. ~~-:;l~:·~..-r~·~l.OlO~.--~~~l.:.:.;~~~.":'I':::·f?..-·,~o.~~..---t r.:,t~•.d:" _ • ~ .. .. .,.t!.- -- --~ ·iii'I··...· .fl' I .......·...·t .~.: ..- ....,...---.::: . _.," - .., - !~ ~!.'"'!' • - .."'!!.. , •• : '-00: .-.__ .;b:f.:. ... ~ . e: ~ - - c.;::,. _~ ..~~!~~J'"'=~~~.~:!J~!?N·~- t··-=.__ ~'U-.. • tli ~~~~~ - ~ ~ ...~- ~..!o: _.. --___~~.~~fli" _.. :'II - :~. -~ ~~;. - ii\i!t::~~~L-,-:i .....j,:::.,.. . _ . _ . ~1!:'.~.-~~ .l. ....;~"t:--t•• --== "'!I~ ~~ • ''''~'''~ '~. t· 'e~~ It' 1I'::J"it ~;..••:.-i-;---::=~ 3~ _~~.:~ 1~f£VIi ..-1 ! _ ,••~ Ie ••~ ,-,$~ .... ;~·~.-r- .. -~..---

::::_. _...... ~~":: - _., ,~~_ ~_ - __ __ • •• --.,....... _._... ~.••; .:".... " I

:::~:ii;:::~:~?*;~;!;~~~;~~ii'i;"-'~~~~·~~~~~~l~~~~~~,:1"';h",..,.. , •.-.. --- -1.-...... ••. \...r.,.t.: II -- ~~ .._. .:.~ .. -..-- iiI- ~ • --,-----~____ ' ... ,__ ...~,l,p.- ..-.-~..~i!.. -,.--!.••• , •• -;,. - ;~t - _... _•• _.......-r. ~~.-:f~::;:,;;,---- "lt. ..--~-.-:.~.::!::I::+::::.. ::::

.1. • ,. ~. I•• T ---..... _ ... r--)--,-•••---' ._... .,_,.,. o--;- --.!.,-_ .. - .-._•• , ,-----. _. .., ,• '. •• F .., ,., ... •• .. t'. • 1- - • ., - (' - .. - - "l -~ - - .'- _ - -. I _ ..~--' .." ...~- - - - - .. - - - -, ,. ,•••, f ••••, .! -:! :. -: -'-;.---"'--. --,'--- -i-- --_.. ~ • i I I

8$100,000

$10,000

$1,000

$1001990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000

:;! Incident Date

2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Source: National Pollution Funds Center.;~."

Prepared by Greg Bule 07/13/2008 Page I

Page 29: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

Cos

t

(;,It

.".

....~

...."0

.".

.....0

0."

.....

00

0."

.....

·0'"0

'0'0

~....

00

00

0....

00

00

00

'0'0

b·0

·0b

"00

00

00

00

00

00

00

0

;uO

(J)<

n

3~

o <."

()Q

:o

::J~co

\1'1

..

Qm

::Ji)

0.» i

)()a Q

.(D

'3

0~vr

'11

01

1!!

11

!11

11

11

"Illtlit

11

11

11

11

11

'11

1:

11

11

11

IllIfll

,'1

11

1,

11

11

11

li!l1

11

I'

lJI!l1

I1

11

11

11

llIH

!1

II

I11

111

tI

II!

tII

II

II

II

rlll

II

til

IIII

I'1

II

!11

11I

1I

I1

11

11

II

,I

III

I1

11

11

11

!1

Il'~I.lll

~IIIIIIII·

11

11

11

11

11

11

.11

11

!1

11

11

11

11

1Itllll1

1--~

-J.

.J..

Ll.

1IJ.

--

1._"'-

.t..~I";'l.i.'"

--'

_.J.

!J..

J,1

1..:

U_

_.J

._

L.l

..~I

.J,U

'-_

_,-

.1-1

.JJ.

UU

__

.J._

L.1.

1.1.

.1u

L_

_'_

,j_1

-1.1

U1

11

11

11

11

:IlilH

II

11

1"itO

I1

11

11

11

1I

Illtllll

!1

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

1

::::;

::::·•

.r::I:::~"'~:':·::::::·:

::::::

:::i

ii::::

::i

ii::::

:::

:::::;

II

,It

1111

•I

I.

I.~

II!

~I

I1'.'"

•I

II

11

11

11

II

I'I

lltl

II

II

1111

1'1

'11

11

\I

It.III'1

11

11

14

11

1I.

l!ttl'l••

flllllll!

11

11

\11

11

I,1

11

1'!

,1

11

11

11

1

--;-

;:~;

::~_..

;-:-:-;~~~:-

-;:-~

.-;;:~~--

~-~

:-i:;

;;;--

..:-.:;

-:;~~

--;-

;;;~

r::--:

-;-:-;:~;

11

11

11

11

11

t.lllilll.1

11

11

11

11

ellll.I'1

"1

11

11

11

11

11

.1

11

11

Ill"II!

II

Illilll

1i

IIIIIII

.,

1·1

.1.1

11

"1

'.1

11

1..

,I'I

I!II

II

I11

11

IIII'

ljlll

•I

II

II

'1'1

Ilit

I1~~.

I1

II

,I

III

II

I:

I1

I1I

'I

It

I:

1'1

II

I1

III

II

I;

I,

III

I

-i-~

~~~

;~:,";

t-.r

~~:~~,

...:-t

i~~:-

:~--

~.-.~

~~:~

~:--

-;-~i

i~~~

--7-~

t~~~~

--:-

i-:i~~,

'II

I'

1111

1•

1-

I1

I.

lilt

".:

"I;

II

111

•I

IIt

I11

11I'

II

I11

11I

II

II

1111

'I

I"

iii

1.I~

JIII

I1('.

11

11

IH

•••

11

11

11

~1

1""1

11

11

"1

'11

'11

11

11

11

11

11

11

1"1

1I

1·1

'11

III'

1"1

IJ

II~I

'JI

."

11

lel'I4

1I

1.1

11

11

1'

!'I

I!,'llll

1Illtlll'

I'

t1

IIIl

-,-i

-t+~H:l..

-r-;-

~:-:+:

ilo-;

-;-i~

lT:1

o:-\--

;-H

~:iH:·

--...:.

..~;:-

HHH

---1

-Hr:in

:---:-+

:-:-H:

:••

,Jl

t111

~J1'

.'~.

lll

JIIIIIIII

...

'·1

11

11

10

.1

-'

!IIIII,

11

11

11

11

1'

11

11

11

11

elllll'IW

1·~.

I.ll

lt1

1.1

11'1

11

I1

tll1

11

1'1

1tlllll

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

1.1

·1

.1

'11

1'-

I1

11

11

11

.-·1

I~"I

"III

'•

Ile

tlll'

11

11

11

11

I1'1

11

11

1tl

'Illtill

1l·ll,lltl

Ii'

11

11

11

-1

.11

11

11

11

IIII

II~'

·11

11

11

11

1I

11

11

11

11

I1

IIIllt

~-

+4

4"'

1.l

t--

..-I

-~t-

I~~;

.--1

-~-t

4+1-

l~_.

-\"-~

"I-l

"I-I

t--

-1

-"-t

~..

....

..._

_•

_..

....~HH'"

_-1

--i

-I-t

~I-

!..;

I"lilT

".,.

11

1-':

1'1

.'

••'·

""1

1I

IIIW

ttl

I'.

11

11

11

1I

II

1ItII

II

11

11

11

1'.1

1.1

11

!1tI

1•

I1

'.1

11

"._

1-1

11

!IW

i.'

11

11

11

I!,

11

11

11

I1

11

11

11

1I

1\1

11

11

~t:

~:~:i;

:i~:

:::::.

:.r.~

::::l:.

:.:.:

~:::::

:::.::

::::::

::::::

:::

::::::

•--:..

t1it

~~--

;~-:-

~f:J.:

11"._!

.~_.J~~~~-i

-!tt

-:-tr

:~Hi··

•._;..~

-:-:4H

H--7

-rTr

HH~-

-:--:-

:-:~r:

:I

1·1

11

11

11

e1••

I\tI

II:1

t"'.

'·.1

11

11

'••

I1

IIII1

1,e

'e1

11

Il'l

11

1'1

11

11

Il"lil'

II·"

I;.~

".I

••

'••

"'1

Ii

'-"'I

HI

14I.

fl~I

W-I

.~ll

ltl'

11

11

11

11

1'I

Iflill

1"Ifllll

~._'

I.I"

'\.H

"".-

I~ll

tlll

lf"

·.II

IIII

I:=~

.1'L

11

..I1

l1...

le

,llllltl'

1IIIItll

'1

11

11

11

1I

._1;.

~I".

I1

11

11

11

1..

1'1

".1

'·_

····

1'.

.·1

'·111

1"11

""'I

~f

i'llIlI

11

11

11

11

.--1

-1""

'1""~

'1'-

{-'--

7J'..l

.f·.

.--

....

....

......

..HIr

--~

-,..~"

'1.H

"'·"

,-'"

-1..

.~H

H--

~-~

~~H

HI-

--,

.....

_,..

...H

.II

·1,

11

1111

.;,;tJ

!'I

I'te

-.1

-1

II

1·1

I1i

I.

II

1'r

ill

,1

,I

I11

i1I

II

tI

1111

IIII

III

I1

'11

11

11

1.

'a.l,

111

11

"'.1

11

"l_

UtI-••

Illltl~'

I1

11

11

1H

•1

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

1I

I1

I!.1

11

Ii"'''...'.rr

r•...

...I~

~'"~

11•

II!.IIli

t!I

-II

III

III

II

IIIIl

III

1I

IIII

II

11

11

11

11

.tt~~~II.~"""'ltII11

I~II!"III

I(*

11

11

11

1I

11

1'1

11

11

11

11

1\1

-_

I_!

-'~L

'JIl

__·l·

-to

.rIJ

.II~

J~~.

llt..

:1.

_L

LL

f.fU\!

!I_

J_

IJ1

SJU

__

.!_

L.lLU

fJL~

._

L_

l_i_

I.!U

!1

11

11

11

1••*

"1&,,-I.

T9

11

11

Ittl

11

11

11

•I

t1

11

11

1'

I1

11

11

11

1I

III1

III

II_

-Itllflf.,.

I1111··.f.litllll~

fIJ'I

*!1

11

11

II1

11

11

1I

IIIII1

II1

1IIIIIil

I'I

II.J!I.

11

•1

4j4

.~·

\t"I

"lll

l·I·II~IIIII

...

Itlllill

11

11

11

11

1'II!IIII

I1

1"1

1'1

11

·••

41J

11

f:'".~~I

11

¥1

1I

:1~1

.11.

11I!

11

11

11

(1

11

11

11

11

11

II

!It:

11

I1.11~1"

••."

I_1

··..·1

,fI.

11

11

-l

11

.1:1

11

I1

'11

11

11

r1

11

11

11

11

11

11

1!l

-"

....

.."

TI"

le'T

-"'

~rl-

Ili

f.tr

~,T

""-

-'''r

"r;,rl~n""

-!-...,

-I'''"

n--,.-i

TrM

nr

--1

-"-1

',n

.I

1••

11

11

1....1

;""••

~"I.

III.

1.'

11

,1'1

1"'-

.·i

I1

11

11

11

I'

IIIIH

I'1

11

11

11

·1

11

1..

..'4'-

•~_~t#il

••

I!id

lill

..1

11

11

.11

1'

I1

11

11

11

1I

1IIltin

II

!IIIII

1,II

~"I'

\·I

"-.

.....I

_.LII ,

""'''I

-I

'''-

II.

I,.

,('Ie

f'".'

II

1IIIIf

1I

IIII

I11

fI

Jtllll

I1

1!._

III'#

1T

".Iftl.

'"....

'.1

.J,l

11

11

.1

11

11

_:

••

11

.11

11

11

1i

I1

IIII1

11

11

11

11

1-

_1

_~J)

.L1§

'11'''~-~~~_.'-~~-'.-JJ..U\J

•.''.l

._L

L.L.I..lU~

__

1-.l

-lJ

.l\.

IU_

_.1

_L.

1L

.UU

L_

_1_

J_

IJ..

lU

l'IIIII~"'iI'f

~,_,I_#J'~ll'IIIlil

IIIIJIIIII

Itlllilli

I1

I1

IIII1

Illlllll

t11.1I1111:.~:

~.,I.l"J1!

"'l~

I'tt

"14!

~11

'11~

11I1

I1

11

11

11

11

11

1:llli

•I'.

t4~"

."~,

,;,••

f11••••

lltIn

l..

.I

1.1

'1_

_1

.II'

'11

11

1I

11

11

11

11

I1

IIIItI

1.1·

'.Ll

lh~

\1

·-

11~.!·~:l!".~

••.0

1.'.1

'"1"

"1

11

11

I1

11

'11

11

11

1'l1

11

II

ri'l

:WII

~•.,

II.,

.~~"

"'-I

.1."I_

••III'.!

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

1:1

1IIIIill

•-.~

...."

r,

-r;

-...

'~"1

'"•

-~i4l"".nt"--.-

..-..,

~n

o--~-r

rrn

nr

--,

-,-.

-.~n

-1

IIIII

,,!!..

..III·

1..~4

tII~

••

tl.,

.-I.

1I

IIIt

il'

•I

II

III'H

tI

11

11

Ift

III",lt

11

11

1'1

'__

,,.

-~.

"'•

•••.-t."1

11

I1

'11

11

1'

II

IIIIlit

I1

11

1I!

!·1

I1

t!".I"·

•I.

'~'.

1.1

.'.........

1.-

:1

""1

1'.

11

11

11

1I

11

11

t11

11

'1

il!!1

1·1

...lt.lllt.tlllt\

••

•....~I

I.,1

l1

1'"

11

11

Illlllllt

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

'11

_..

J_

.1-!

.Jl.

Ul.

l_

.-..ijL

!.J.

~-

oJ""

'..l

u...

.....

.L_

l-L

1.1~

'.II

_-.

-1_

",_I

-l~

I.IU

__

..L_~

.1.l.

1.J

Ul-

_.•

I_..

J_

'-'-

't.

llI

1.1

tllll

•I

:~:~11"_

I...

11

1"1

.1I

IItilll

II

II~

1111

I!

l!11

111

II

I1

11

1I

•.1

1.1

"'1

-.

,-!~

"'.1

11.·

I!L.

'.'~

I'ill

1'1

'''\

1.

_I

1·1

+1

11

11

,.

~111

1!1

I1

11

11

11

II

1'1

11

1L

.·1

'••

l..

IltI

l••I·

l-I~

IIII

L1

1.1

1'1

11

1I

"'1

11

11

!t1

1Illtlll

II'I'II!

II

11

11

11

1....

"I'rt'~HP.·~,....

'I1II

11

11

•1

'11

11

11

11

11

'11

1'

IIII1

11

I11

111.

lfl.

#I~p

.-':

!.It

!.I'

1.1

11

1··'1

1""1

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

--1

-T

'IIf'

l'1

-"';'

-1_

r*

1"-...

...,

I"~-

-.f.-.r

rrt

inl-

---I

-,-t

i1n

n-

-1'-

ri

illn

r--1

-i-i-Ii

ill

"I

I1

\1'1

';..

Wt.l

·'.I

;"l.

.Mf-

1.~1

1.-...

II."H

'I

III

liB

II

11

11

11

1•

IIIII!I

·lllll.l.r

·1""

~~~"

."""

'~""

"tll

l.l.

tI.!

!11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

Itlllill

.'.

\,III,.-:,

-.'.

tH

Alli"

,.,.

JU

..J.M

'.II

.~I

+11

11

11

•I

IIlIllll

'I

11

11

I1t

II

11

11

11

I1

11

11

11

.•

'I.III~

II':

1'T

iW·1

l~-I

11

11

11

.I

11

11

11

11

I1

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

1_

e-l

_,l

..J..

I~'t

.il\.

..."

"I-&

A.I~

,",.._

_..

:1'..

.-1-

1.1

.1-I

1.l..

--._~

4-J.,

.I-&~

I-_

_i_

-l_1

....

.""

'L&_

_.l

_~,L

L.I-

JW

I-_

_1

_'"

_I_

UU

•1

.ltlllll

••TJ

,lt~

'Wl.

...~.I.,..I

I1C'.!~ll.'.111

Illillill

!1

11

'11

11

11

11

111

1I

II"III'••~'"

It~"'~."I~~'

IlItlllt'lll

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

1IIIili

iI

It

IItil

lI

I.

llP

1.1

.•

If"i

,,~•~

iii'

ItIt

I.

I1

""1

1I

II

IItill

'JJ

I""

.1

!.I4

lIIl'f

I'·

.tC

t;!1

I.,~!

IJII

I1

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

III!

_1_l

.J!!

..11

Il'!

.._!

.~~/l.!.~~.

l~1J

__

.t!t

'!.

.lr.

IJ!.

..!L

__

'_J

_1

_I.

lU!.

!_

_l

_L

!L

IJU

L_

_I_

_l_

I_lj

Lit

'.

11

III1

11

.1

'-.'

i!W'.-••

J.ir

:I.1

1I·.tl

r!llt'

tI

Illillil

II

Itllill

I!

illlil

l.ill.IIII

.fe

ll"II",,-:

il

ttllll",1

1~fl

l1l1

IIjl!lI1

11

11

11

1ll.

Iltlllll

11

11

11

11

11.1:1.'lllt.I.I.~I..,I•••

11

11

11

11

1III1

11

1l

11

11

!1

1!!

tlllllil

II

fllltil

.11

'1:'

\11

II

1'1

11

1J1

I...

.I

III1

I1I

I1

11

11

11

I1

11

11

11

1'I

11

1"1

_ll!!tl

llll

tlllflll'.'4

i'I."'!!.It.1

11

11

11

1'.

11

1.1

1llllll!il

Illill!1

--!

.-t

-t-l

"'1-

1i-

-to

-1-'

"~'

tl-t

l-"

-I-l-

'tH

tT-

-+

~'.~

t-H

Ht-

_-1

--i

.•j4

-1t.

",~-

_-t

_}-

+rH

HI-

'~'

_I_'i

-l-t

~HI

II

III

II!!

'.1

I.'.

~II

i4"l

11

11

.·1

It'fJ

~:1I

~,,!

11

1!!

1I

11

11

11

f:",

'"il

:!.'

I1II

II~.

II!II

:1.'.1

:'.'.r:!~

n•

I"

I•

IIII

IiI

tI

I!

1111

II

II

III

Ii

II

II!

111

,.ItJllllil

•I

II

III!.,

.1\

..~.

I!

'1'1

.11

11

1!!llill

I1

ll,IIil

,I"!III

!1

11

11

11

11

111

111

_.1

·.

1·+

lfl

.11

_1

.11

11

11

.1

1illlltt

I:

11

11

11

11

I1

1I1

II

1I

I1

IfII

II

fI

i1

.tl"

'"

II

1·I

III.

Il

IIt!II

-it!

,i

III

II

II

IiI:

11I

II

II

IiI

--1

-'i

Ii

IlliT

--

•-1

-i·.

..11l

i.~-.-

•••

-U-,

iiii

--,

..,-

!~-l

ii....

·-_.

,-..j.',

-j'i;

,;-

-I

-,-

,i-"

iir

_...,-

,-,-

"i,

iI

11

11

11

11

:.

IS

II",••,

iIJ.1

~!.,

.1.1

.1.1

11

11

IIllillll

iI!

11

11

11

ItIlilll

II

II

I11

11I

I,

IIIII..!

1•

'--"""••lit

1I,"

I'

•I

,I

IIII

!I

II

IIII

I'I

II'I

II

i1

11

!lllli

IIIII!II,.

:f,tl!li

l1

·1

1;'!

!lll

:Illilll!

Il

ll

ll!1

11

1!ll'li

IIIIII:!!

!!li';I~·••1

'1;.

1.I

.li!

l!llIr

!i/lflln

Ilf/llllf

I"'!!lI

--1

-1

""""

,..1

11

,.--

T"-l

-~T

!H-

'-I

'f;t

....

,~-p

-.~

-r

M

r"rl'n

,.,-

..~_.

1-'.,.

,.M!"

I--'r

-r'·

1""'"

1.n

r"_

-I'·

'1-1

-'"

H.

i1

11

1'1

11

I!'

II!I

-i

"!'

.,....,~I.I,ltllll

.!t

11

11

1;1

1I

;lii!ll

1!I

;!\;

II

11!l

l~1

Il'I·li.

':t,

11

:.'1

·I

IIi

11

11

!!

I,Illil

II:

!llll

IIllili

II

I:

iilil

I!

t1

11

11

1I!

Ii

11

11

1I

IIl'

1111

:I

Illll!

I1

jIllll

II

iIIi

:I

IIII!!!!

II

Ifilii

!I

t1

11

!lt

II!

11

11

iI!

Iilill

11

:'1

11

Illiltl

~ .... 0 0.... lO lO 0 .... lO lO .... .... lO lO '" .... <

0lO (» .... lO <0

.jll. .... lO <0

U'I .... <0

<0

C» .... lO lO ......

:r....

0lO

0:<

0

mCD

::J....

....<

00

lOC

<0

.... m'"0 0 0 '"0 0 .... l\

)0 0 l\

)

l\)

0 0 Co

)

l\)

0 0 ~ l\.) 0 0 (It

l\.) 0 0 OJ

l\.) 0 0 .......

l\.) 0 0 CO

\J a (Q CD

Page 30: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

E:QU"0c0

0_

~o

"'~

o0

UC

l-

.t=~-

o=

>E~

CI>a=:u

..~o

illl!!1

11

11

11

11

1IIIIili

lIlIlill

lllilill

itlli

II

IIfillII,t

IIll/1

1J

tIf

If

II

1I

I1

!lIil!

II

0.,1

-1-0

-;.-·"--1

---'~"'H-t:""-'-+

-...-

--+

1.....

1-...+

-l--i--

__

,...;.-,...-

._.......

--i-

_.....

1-1.....

~••I-t--...

-_

_lllllli

I1

11

11

11

1i

tlllllll

IH

illill

Illillill

II

II

!I!Ii'

II

II

Ii

II

III

•I

tI

II

III

II

II

II

III

I1

II

II

,Trl-I-j-I-

-t-

---I'I

,'i1

-,-r

-,

--

-'i'1rr

rT

-1--r--

-'111-'-'-'-1'--,---

in,

rT

1-r-

r_

i!I

II

II

Ifll

iI

II

•i

illit

II

II

III

iI

tI

iI

11

11

1I

1:

I!J.i.'-'_

I_i....J

__

!--

__

ll.LIJ

.LJ_

1._

..i..L

1.J1

.LL

1.._1_

_L

IJL

i-J.J

_I_

.l_

_i

.lLIJ

1.1

J_

l._

J.._

11

11

11

1I

Ilililill

iiiII

II

II

Itlllill

Ililll'!l

I

~~~;-~~~--:---~~:~~~~-~-~---~:~~.~~~-;--~--

-:~~:~~-~~-~---~~~

~~~-~-~---

II

II

II

II

III

II

II

II

III

II

II

Ii

III

II

II

II

III

II

II

II

:+r:-:-~-:--:----:t:-:11-:-r-,---;:1trr+-:--r---:-ir:-:-:-:-~--:----ir:-t+t-t-~-t---

III1

11

11

11

1t1

11

II

HIIIII

II

11

11

'1\

II

11

11

11

1I

I.&

.L-.I_I_'"-1

--1

--

-":.1.1-1

""..I-1

_...._

~-

__

J.I.J

+.,-

~.L_

1-_

'-_

_-1.J,1-I~-i_I-'"

_~

__

-..

:..I""~~

4_~_.&.

_1

11

11

11

'"1

11

11

1I

I1

11

II1

1I

Ilillll'

I1

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

1I

1Il1

11

1l

I1

11

11

11

1I

11

II1

II1

I1

11

11

11

1I

1'''1

-'-r'-

-1---""1'

i'"-r-,

--

-T

I'lTrr,

-,--r

--

-1'7il"

-r'-,-

--,n

irr,-

1-

T_

11

1(1

11

I1

11

1'1

11

;rllll';r,

II!!III'

JIIIJIII'I

1'_

'_'_

LJ_

-'--

_JL

'J.1.1

J_

L_

.11

l.liI..I..1

_'_

_I..

_.;._'.1

LIJ-J_

'_.l

__

'.1U

.1L

il_

L_

i_

II

II

II

II

III

II

II

II

III

•I

II

II

III

II

Ii

II

III

II

II

II

tlllill

Iltlll'll

In

lllill

I1

11

11

1.1

I1

11

11

11

1I

+I-

I-I-

}-

-4-

-...

--

-IfoI-f

..of~

-..

-...

--

-+

H+-

1-1-..

-1--.-

-_

-lof

"'1-.

-t_1_

-+_

-1_

-_

-+1--1-+

......of

_...

_to

_1

11

11

11

I1

11

I1

11

1I

Iflllill

I1

11

11

11

1I

11

11

11

11

I1

11

11

!1

I1

11

11

11

1I

'11

11

11

1I

11

11

11

11

I1

11

11

11

1I

Trl-I-

r-.-

-,--

--lr

Ji1

1j-r

-7

---n

lrrrT

-1-

-1-

--

-11n

i'-I-'-j-

--,I"~

rT

l-r-

r_

illlill

I1

'11

11

11

I1

IIIIIti

I1

I1

l11

11

I1

11

11

11

1I

.l.L.I_

I_L

..J_

_1

--

_Jl.I

J.1

.1-'_

1.

_.J

.UJ

J..LL

.L_'-_L.

UL

I.J.J

_L

.J_

_1

.1U

.11

,L.J

_L

_1.

_1

11

11

11

II1

11

11

11

I0

11

11

11

I1

11

11

11

1I

1I1

11

!1

1I

III1

II

II

1'1

11

II

1I

11

11

1I

I'I

11

11

,1I

II

I1

II11

II

II

1'r-I-I-

(-'1

-'-

1-

--

"'11""1-1'1'"1~-1"-~

--

-1"1'1;-1""

t"l'-

r-

r---

-I"tl"'"1~~-r-;

--a-

--

'1H

"tf"1"oot-,..-

1"_

11

11

11

1I

11

11

11

11

I1

11

11

11

1I

1II1

III1

I1

11

11

11

1I

1III1

11

I1

11

11

11

1I

11

11

11

11

I1

11

11

1i.

I1

11

11

)1

11

Iiil··l-1

-1--.--

--IT

I-ll1

-I-r-1

--

-Til

Ti

iT-.--.-

--

-1

11

1-1

1-'-

1-

-1

--

-11

-11

rij-r-r---

III

II

II

I1

11

1I

II

II

III

I•

II

II

III

I1

II

II

III

II

II

II

.1.\.I_

I_L

...J_-I-

--

...J.LI-l

J..1

...J'_.L

_..1

J..I..J~L.L..

J._1_

_,-

IJL

..1-I..I._l-~

_..J

__-~UJ.!.J.-l_~

_.L

._

'I;Jlf

II

11

11

11

1f

I1

I1

11

rl

II

'H

'lli'

11

11

11

11

1I

1I1

11

11

I1

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

Illilllll

I1

11

11

11

1.

Trl-

I-r"-

-r--

"rl"

1'-r-,--

-T

nrrr

t-,-

-r--

-11rl'i-r,.-

-1

--

-'1

'n'l

TT'-r

-r

_

~l~:_:_~J..-~--Jl~_:~

~J_l_ll:~t~~l_:__

~~l~:JJ_~_

~._Jl~l

~11_~_~..__

II

II

II

II

III

I1

I1

II

III

II

II

II

III

II

II

II

II"

II

II

I1

11

11

11

I1

IIIIIIi

IIlllltll

II1

IIIIII

I1

11

11

11

1I

~"''''I_...

;'''-1

--1

--..;.

......I~....

-l_+

-_~

--

-...14

+-..."""+

-1_

_'"

I"............-1

-...

_-1

"\0.1104--"'~_;..._

...._

11

11

11

1I

Illlllli

I1

11

11

11

1I

11

1I1

II1

I1

11

11

11

1I

,I

I,

III,

IJ

II

II

II

IIII

II

II

II

III

I)

II

II

III

II

1I

II

Lrn

-l-r

-.--,--

-,rn

11j-r

-.,

--

-T

ilrr

rT

-1

--

r-

--(I

11

"-1

-'

--.-

--,n

lrr.,-r-r-

__

1II1

III

I1

11

11

11

1I

'11

11

11

1I

11

11

11

11

I1

11

11

11

1I

1.f.L

L.I_

I_L

..J_

_L

__

.J1

.IJ.1

.1J_

.L_

.1_

..._

.LI.1J...I...L

J._

I-_

L_

.._1.1

L.I.J.J_

'-~

_-1

J.U.l.L

J..1

_I..._

.L_

III

II

1I

I1

11

1I

II

II

11

1I

II

II

11

11

1I

I1

A-'

11

\I

II

II

I1

11

1·1

II

1I1

III

II

II

11

11

1I

II

I1

1III

II

II

11

1\1

II

II

tt+;"

I-I-

I--1

--1

---~"'H'i

'"t-t-

to-'i

--

-+

I-tto

l-l-T

-1--r---

-lot

t-I......-.-

'-t-

-1-

--'"t'H

ot

......;

_1

""'_t----II

II

II

II

fill

I)

II'

III

1I

II

II

IIII

I1

II

II

IiI

II

II

II

II

II

II

I1

11

1I

II

1I

III

II

I,

II

III'

II

I1

IIII

II

II

II

LT

n-l-

l-"1

--1

--

--1

11

'1'j1

-r-1

--

-JII

lir!

-1--r

---'f

1'-'

"i-

I-i-

-.-

--irll

rr

1-1

--r---

illlill

I1

III1

1l1

I1

11

11

11

1I

11

11

11

11

I1

11

11

11

1I

LiJ."-I_

I-L.~-

-1_--

-IJ.I..LL

..l~_

J._

.J-

--

J.U1.1...

L...L_1

__

l..1-1.~I-I..J_I-

~_~

.JU.L!.':'~

_L

.._1..

_1

11

1I

II

IIIII1

II

II

II11

II

II

I1

11

1i

II

II

IIII1

II

I1

~~~:-:-~~--:---

~~:~~~~-~_.;---~:~~~~~-:--:~---:~~:~~-:-~-~-

--~ri~~~~-~-~---1

11

.11

II

I1

11

11

II

II

'·.",1

11

11

·'t

-.I":~·I···~~~~·IIIII

I1

·1

11

11

1I

II

IIlL

I_I_

LJ

.•_

1.J!.U

.!J

J_.!.

_J

illL

I_L.!.

_1

_'_

1~il

LIJ..J_'L

J_

_1

J1

J1!.!..!_

L_

1._

11

11

11

1I

HIIIIII

I1

11

11

11

1I

11

11

11

11

I1

11

11

11

1I

~~~~L~J__

~_-J~~~JJ-~-1-_-1:~~~~1_L_~~~UJ_~1_~

1~~~1~_~_~_

11

11

Ile

iI

11

11

1I

I1

I1

11

11

)I

II

lilll

II

II

lilll

II

Ii

~~~:-~-~~--~---~~~~~

~~-}-~---~:~~~~~-:--~---:~~:-~,~~

~--:---~~~~

~~-~-~---II

II1

III

11

11

11

11

Itlllllll

t1

11

11

11

1'

Illlllir

I~J.

1..'_'_1..J_

-'-

'llJ.1l_

1-

L-~

.l1J

11

..11

_'_

_1..

Ul.I_

'.)_1

...1_

J..lL

lJI..J.

l_1

.._

1.._

11

11

11

11

'11

11

11

1I

11

11

11

11

II1

1II1

11

IIIIII

II

II

11

11

11

1I

11

11

11

11

In

lllill

I1

11

11

11

.I

'11

11

11

1I

~-r~I-I_'"-t-

-;-

--

....~I......

;-1-'"-.,---+

1-1

"'1-1

""'1"-:-

-t-

--

-1..-

...1-t....-1

--1

--1

--

-"-H

11

"to

'"t'-

"'-

",---

III1

I1

1I

11

11

11

11

I1

11

11

11

1I

11

11

11

11

I1

11

11

11

1I

I1

I1

1II

Ii1

11

11

11

I1

11

11

11

1I

11

11

11

11

ItiL

II

II

II

11

1'-

'-1

-1

--1

---

-11

1-1

11

-1-1

-1

---T

iiT

ll-T

-I--r--

'~Ilrl-I-i-I-l--I--

-In

,!i"i-r-

T---

11

11

11

1I

'11

11

11

1I

IIllllll

i1

I1

11

II1

I1

IIIlIIII

IJ1.1.i_L

..I...

..J_-1

--

-.J.L

U.1

.1..J

_.L

_..1

.1.1.1j.

L.L.

1_1_

_L

I.LL

.I.J.J

_I-

~_

..1.I

UJ.!.

L.J.

_I-

_L.

_••

_illlill

IIII1

1III

Itlllllll

I1

11

11

11

1~

11

11

11

11

II

I1

II

II

Ii

II

1I

1I

1I

III

II

II

II

11I

Ii

II

II

1II

II

II

II

Trl-

I-r-"--,-

--~~I""

'"t;-

.,.-.,

--

-T

'l'rr

r'"T

-1-

-r---

-1''1'rl"

;-r-

'"t-,---

"TM

"fTT

,-r--

T-

__

lJI

I.JI

I1

11

11

1I

II

I1

11

11

II

iI

I1

III

II

II

IIII1

II

II

i!.I_I_

l_L

_I_

_,

~L'..!11

_i_!._

J!.'l.!.L

L!.

_1__

LIJ

LI_

I...!_'-

J_

_1

.lUl!.

~l_

t._.!.._..o_

JI

II

II

II

1'1

II

II

11

11

1I

II

II

IIII

II

II

II

1IIlit

II

I;ill

tI

II

11I

II

I1

I1

Iii

II

II

I1

III

1I

II

II

III

1I

1I

II

·...~I-I-

...-I-

_I-

-_

-1

...1-1...

~-40_..

-..1---0

4--1

'"..~~

..-1

-_1

..1..

1-1

-J4_

1-"--1---~~4"'",

-I._I-

_....

_1

11

11

11

IlIllllf'l

11

11

11

11

'filII

11

1I

IIlIJII)

Illlilil

I1

11

11

11

1I

11

11

11

11

I1

11

11

11

1I

11

11

11

11

I1

il-I-r

-.--,--

'T1

'i1,-T-,

--

-T

I1rr

rT

-1-

-r

--

-Iir

n,-

r,-.,-

--.,

n1

Tr,

-j-r-

__

11

11

11

tI

IlIa

lll

II

11

11

11

1I

I1

11

11

11

11

IlIillll

I1

1L

I_'-L

_1_

_1

--_

JJ,.U

lJ

J_

l_

.1J.I.1

.LL

Ll

_1__

LIlL

IJJ_

I_J

_J

.IU

.1J.

LJ

_1

._.1

._

III

iI

II

f1

11

11

II

II

IIIIII

II

I1

11

11

II

II

11

1II

II

II

I1

I1

I1

1I

11

11

11

"I

1I1

11

1il

IIlIlIIII'

11

11

11

11

I..;-1

-1-)-

-t-

-1-

--

-i...l-t10

...~

--t.

--i

--

_.+1-+.......;-

.....\--

l--

--I-t

t-I-I-I-t-

.._

-1-

-_

..H

"i+I-

-t_

t-_

to_

11

11

11

1I

11

11

11

11

ItlI

11

11

1I

Iltllill

I1

I1

11

!1

1I

11

11

'1I,

11

11

1'

It

Illill

II

II

illl

II

II

I1

11

11

1'1

II

ITrl-I-r

-,--.-

-'1

""

i-,-

r-'

--

-Tn

rrr

T-1-

-r--

-I'1

1-1

-1

-'-

'--1

--

-1i,1r

T1-r

-T

_1

11

11

11

I1

11

11

11

1I

Itllill\

I1

11

11

11

1I

1IIIIIil

I

00

00

00

00

&8

&0

00

g~

80

;q."'"

-;q.

"'"c5

;q."'"

o0­

0-

Page 31: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH … · 2008. 12. 1. · BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA PREFILED TESTIMONY OF KIMBERLY LORRENE MCINTOSH

E'0G-go.:a",'"

Q)

8~

-a.

0._

~Q..

E~u..~eno

11

11

11

1I

1IIIItii

l1

11

11

!!1

I1

Ii1

11

11

1l1

11

!1

1I

~~~:-:-~~--:_--

~~p:~~~M~_1_

~---~:~~

~~.~._:_...~_.~-t:~:~..:-~-~

_~_'M_~~~

~~_~_~

__~

_

lili!

II!

illllllI!

lillill,e

lIIIII1

1I

I1

11

11

11

II

:~~:-:-~~--~---~~:1

~~-:-~-~---~:~r~.}-:--'----~~r:~-+-:-~--:--

-~r:~}~i

-~-}-__1

11

1ttl

ililll

III,

!llll;

II.

IIII!

II

tI

Ilill

II

II

loLL:"';_I.~

L..J

-._

i_-

-_11.1...1

J.1

J_

1.._

.J.1.1..1.

LL

L_

I-_

1l.l.

L..I_I

J_

,_,.I

__

I.~_

_..1

L.i.l

i..L.J

_L

_J..

••_

_

III

II

II

IIII

Iiii

II

III

II

II

II

I!II

III.

I1

11

1I

II

1I

~~~:-:-~~--:---~~;~~~~-~--~...--~:~~~,.~:-·-tt~-

-~~~:~~-:-~-~---~~~~~~_~_~

_ill

II

II

I1

11

1I

II

II

11

11

1I.

II

.11

11

II

Il

IIIII

II

II

:tr:-:-~~--:--...-:t:-:1~~-T-1---+:1rP:-+-:--_

"--1

7i-:-:-+-:--1--~--,H1tT-i-r-t---

II

1I

II

II

Iii

II

II

iiiI

III

II.

II

t1

11

_,

II

II

11

11

II

II

I~~l-I"-I.-L-

-1

--1

---

"'\4-I~-I.'"-1

-+-~~---.I.4""l-S-.I.

_......

_._

-'-I.~I-.4-1-I-'"_

-1_--..l~4

J.f..~_I-_.10-

__

:::::::::::::::::

:::::~:

~:•

+::::::::

:::::::::

f"tT'r"i-I-r

,--,--

--'r""'-

T-,-

--T

nr'''·T

"-r·-r--'-·~r!,,-r,-,---~",.,.

r-Y-r--

T---

1III

II

tI

11

11

11

_I

I1

11

11

'1

II.

til'

II

II

II!lll

II

II

~!'-'_'-L

J_

-'--

__

'L'J..!

JJ_

1.Jt.!

-_

_liJ

1L

L1

.'-_1...__

IJ1..'-'1-1-J

__

,l,.tJ

1!.L

L_

!_

11

11

11

1I

11

11

11

11

)1

IIIIe

ti

I1

11

11

Ie

,Itlillil

I1

11

11

1I

IIIII1

11

I.

I1

11

11

11

II.

1lII'

fI

III1

Ilf

1I

fH+

"'1- 1-1

--4-

-1----lr

Ho

of

...-t-r-

...--

-+

H+.~t-'"

-1-

-....

--""",-'-

4-1

-...

--1

---41

0-1

--++-+

-f-

...-i----1

11

11

11

Ii1

llllll

I1

11

11

11

1i-II_

IIII

I1

11

11

11

1I

11

11

11

11

itlllill

I1

11

11

11

1I

11

11

11

11

I1

I1

11

'll

In

TI-I-,-rj-

-,-

--

-ITtl

11

-I-r

--1-

--

TI1

Tr

IT

-1

-.1

---,~rt-I)-l-'--;---,

n1

ir.-r-

T_

till

II

II

IIII

II

II

II1

I1I

II

1.1

I"

II

I.

II

1I1

11

11

II

'j"L

..I_'-'-

J_

_1-

--

..J.1.l.JJ..l

J_

.1._

.1.1.1.11.

Ll..

J._

L_~

IJ.L

I_a

LI•

.i_-'!

__~J.1.1.

.1_

L_

1.

_

::::::::::::::.::

~::~:~::

~.:~~:::,:

:::;~:::::

:"1

1"I""'I-I-r-

-1

--1

---

··11-1....

.,-1;-.,.

-"1

---1

"I"1t"I"'I""'1

'-i-

-r--

--1

-t"r-'....;-I-"1

--.-

--:1

H-r"'1

"1

-r--

.,.••

__

IIII

II

II

11

11

II

II

I1

11

1I;

I1

Ie

lil

lI

I1

.1I

11

11

11

)I

I

;t~:-:-r-:--:-..--:+:-:il-:-t-i---f:ittr-f-:--i--.-:1i-:- I-

:-:-,-

-:-

--1H-fr

i-~-r-t---II

iI

II

II

11

'II'

II

II1

II1tIe

,I

11

11

-1I

II

11

11

1I

I,

I~.i.L.I_I_~

-J_

_i-

--

.J.LI.J..1

..l.J

_1

._.J

--

_.L

I.J....

I-L

_1_

_'-

_-_

I.1.l...l!.,J

_I_

.1_

-1..L

W..l

J........

-L.

_J.

_

::::::::

~::::::::

~::::::-i

:•

i~~~::

~i.

I:

::

:~:

::

Tn

-I-

r",-

-1-

--'r

a""T~-

r-,

--

-T

I'r

rr.

-t-

-,-

---.1.'1rl.,,-tett"I--

-~r-I"TTT

'-r

-T

_I1

1I1

1I

III1

III

II

III1

1II

II

I~"lill~l"

I1

11

11

1I

II

11

U_

I_!..

-'-

-1-

__

.JiI

J1..1

_1

_1

_.1

LI.lL

LL

!_1_

_~

_!'.l

L.IJ.J

••

..1_,...:_

~--l

UJ

LL

J_

L_

1_

1II1

tI

II

11

11

11

II

Iellll1

1I

I,

.11

11

11

1I

I.

~Ill'elI:

1I

II

Ii

II

II

II

II

II

II

III

I1

II

II

II~

I•

I1

.1

ej

II

Ij

Il

II

;~:-:-:-~~-

-:-

---:~:~-:~

~-~

-~

--

-:Ia

-:,~~~

-:-.~-

-i:~II-:t:-~

-~---~i:~

~~~-t-

~---1

11

11

1I

I1

11

11

11

II

IWlI1

..1".i-.1

1.a

;a

1I_

I!IIIIII

I1rr'-I-r

-1--,-

--

'T1

"1

1'j-

r-,

--

-T

ilT

rrj

-1-.·...

__

rl"""""--,-

.-,

'Wir

r'-r-T

_1

11

11

11

I1

11

11

1I

II

11

11

11

1II.

11

11

11

1..

;1

11

11

1II

I_

l;.LI..I_

I_L

J_

_1-

-_

Jl.l.J

.l.1-J

_.1

._

.J.._

_J..I..l.L

L~

.1_

1_

_L-

..._

_1.1

L.I

J._

I_

.r_-'

..l.U.1

.l..L.J

_L

_J..

_I

II

fI'I

1J

II

II

rtil

IJ

II

I,

iI

rJ1J.1

I'

I••

IIt

JI

,L..

II

III1

I1

II

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

.'••I"I~IJI.I

11

11

11

1"1

I+

t-I-I-,.......-

-1-

---t

...I""1~

-t-i-

t'-;--

-.,.1

;..

joo~

T-\-

-;.-

--;o'j~

!""I-l~-.......rle__

'&t"t-t'"

+;-J--'"

_illll''I

11

11

11

1I

I1

11

11

1i

II

.'.II.r.-I"

""1

11

1I

II

I11

1I

II

I1

11

11

II

II

11

11

11

II

11

11

11

.'

1"1

11

11

1'

II

I,T

I-I-I-r-I--1

--

--I1

11

'''-1-

r-,

--

-III

ir

rT

-,--

j"-

"-'Ii1

1-'-1

-1-1

--1

---liil

Ti1

-,-

T---

11

11

1t

II

II1

II

II

If

III11

II

II••

11..

11

II

I•

ill

1..1I

II

I'.1

.L-I_

'-1-

-1-

-1-

--~~u

J,J

.J_

J._

..l.-

_-

J.f..l.~L.L.J..

-1

"'_

"1

.l-'--I.J_1

-,_

-1..L

Ur...

.L.J_1-._'"

_:::::

:::

:::::::::

::::~::

::.

::::~::_

;I

::::::;::

rn

-j-

r'--1

--

-'1

1'l

''-

T--r

--

-T

I'.ir

T-r-

r--

-n.'I'''-''-d

.--.'

n"TTT.-

r-

r---

11

11

11

11

"JIIII.II

11

IllIllI

1-'

.1'llllf'~

tillill

II

.I!.L1,..1_~J

__

I1

1U

1J

-'_1

-.l----w.t.L~t.l._I_

_'_

1_

Ll.JJ

~_-4_..

-lLll!.L.!_~

__i

_

:::

:::::

:::

::

::::

III:

::

:::

::t:~::.:::::::::

:.....I_

I_l-o

-4-

-1-

-_-i~I-I

..of

-1_

4-._

o.t-

__

....I-/i..;-~

.......-J-_--I.~I-I"'_l-~

_-l-_.......q,....._~_..

_1

11

1I

II

Ile

iII

II

II

11

11

Ie,

II

I1

11

11

II

II

lilll

I1

.1I

~~~~-~-~~--~---~~:~~

~~-~-~---~:~~~~~-:--~

----:~~:~~-:-~-~---~~:~~~

~-~-~---IIII

II

1I

11

11

1I

II

I1

11

11

II'I

11

11

1I

II

I1

IIIIe

iI

II

.LL

I_I_

LJ

__

1-

-_

JL

I.JJ

.1J_

L_

.1.1.1J

1.L

L1

_1_

_L

IJ.L

1-'J

_I_

J_

_1

..L!..lJ.

1.1.

J_

L_

1._

I1I1

II

II

1II1

It

Ii

Iilill

II

II

IIIII1

II

Ifilii

II_

II

11

11

11

1I

11

11

11

11

IH

IIII\I

I1

1.1

11

1.1

11

11

11

11

I4T~I-t-1-

-t-

-1-

--

-i;..I....-t

-;-;-t"

-...

--

-+

Hi-

r-t-+-1

--r--

--1

.........-1-1

-;_

-t---*H

-t

Tt''''

_.-

_~

_

~::::::

::::::::::::~:~:::

:~::~:~:

~.~;~:~::

~:.

ITil-l-r

-I-·~I----ill-Ill-,-T

-1

---

"fllTrr-r

-1--r-

--1

11

1-,1

-.-1--1

-.-'t

llifi-r-

r---

11

11

'iI

I1

11

11

11

I·I

1III1

II

1I

1IIIII

II

I1

11

11

II

II

~.LL.'-I-L..J

__

'•..L

L.U

J..J.J

_.L

_e

UJj.Ll.l_.!_.~l..U~I~..J_.J

_-1

_--:.lU..1~.l_L._

1._

til

II

I'1

II

II

II

I;

III,

IIii

II

I1I1

II

II

IIII

II

II

II

illill

t1

lIIIl1

1I

I1

11

11

11

II

illlill

II

nlll.1

II

~Tr't-I-;-"'--~

--

-'r

l-''',,-or-.,--

-,..1.,

orr"r-,.

-1-

-r-----''1

rl-t;-I-'-e-c

---"1

M"T

rT

,-,.._r---

:1:_:_:_~-:-_:--__:~:~ll_:_~_.l

l:J~~~

~_~__~

:l~~_:_:_:_~__:_e__

!L~li.l~_~_l

_1

11

11

1I

III1

II1

II

Illliill

II

Ilflill

II

"/litl

iI

"i

II

II

I1

11

1I

•I

II

III

II

II

iI

III

II

II

1I

1II

I1

II

II

l-i...1-1_1_

..~-

-I--

__

1...1-1.1

-4....

_~

-.-I-

--

...14..

\-I..4-

-1

--I-

_-_

14"I-I~_I_"

__

141-1

.....J.

.I_lo

o_

..._

..._

11

11

11

11

lilllill

Ilillilll!

IIlillll

I1

IIII1

11

I1

IIIili

IIltllll

II

11

11

11

1I

I1

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

11

1IT

n-l-r

'""1--1---'i

l'i

,,-

j-,-

--j"

r"'"

T-)-

-r-

--Iir"'-I-'-j---"n

ir,

,_,._

j"_

'~~:_~-~~-_:_--

J~:Jl~~-~

_1_--~:~~~~~

_:..._~:l~:JJ_:_~

_J_--~~_:l~

~-~.-~__l_

11

11

11

II

11

11

11

1t

Itlllill

II

11

11

11

1I

I1

1(1

11

1I

Illlill

II

itllill

II

1I1

11

1!

II

41

11

11

1I,

11

11

11

1II

"'H-l-~r

-1

--1

,---

......H~-t

-t-;.-1

---to

l.........

I--t-t--I---

-11

-;-10

1-1

-1-

..._

....._--"h

oi-

+-

io"'!-

I--t---

11

11

11

1I

11

IItlii

I1

11

11

1/1

I1

11

11

11

'I

lIilllll

t1

11

11

11

I1

11

11

11

1I

II1

11

II1

I1

11

11

11

1I

lilllill

IIT

il-l-

j-1

--1

---iT

I"

'-1

-1

-'

--

-Tl'rrr

i-I-

-1

----IT

lli-I-I-I-,---

in1

rT

'-1

--T

---

III1

II

II

11

11

1I

II

I1

11

11

1_i

I1

11

11

11

II

II1I1

iI

II

00

08

08

8~

0g&

8c5

~~

-;A.

....c5

........

0-

00NOJ

~r-.00N-00~Ii)

8N"<t0~C

")

~N~~00~0-

0-

0-

OJ

0-

0-

r-.~

"""

0-

0-

-00-

0-

~0-

"<t0

-0

-

~0-

N0-

0-

0-

0-

~0-