behavioural materia medica: calcarea carb.appearance: •dr. margaret tyler remarks, “with the...

BEHAVIOURAL

MATERIA MEDICA:

CALCAREA CARB.

© Subrata

Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea, GOLD MEDALIST

B.H.M.S. (Honours In Nine Subjects Of Calcutta University)

Fellow: Society of Homoeopaths, U.K.

Fellow: Homoeopathic Medical Association of the United Kingdom

Fellow: Association of Natural Medicine, U.K

Fellow: Akademie Homoopathischer Deutscher Zentralverein (Germany)

Director: Bengal Allen Medical Institute

Principal: Allen College of Homoeopathy, Essex, England

“SAPIENS”, 382, BADDOW ROAD, GREAT BADDOW,

CHELMSFORD, ESSEX CM2 9RA, ENGLAND

Tel & Fax No. 44 (0) 1245 505859

E. Mail: [email protected] Web: www.homoeopathy-course.com

© Subrata

LOOK & DIAGNOSE: HANDSHAKES

• No firm

responding grip,

clammy hand.

• Flabby, Floppy.

• Boneless kind of

hand-grip.

• No bone, no firm

responding grip.

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

FACIAL EXPRESSION: LOOK & DIAGNOSE

• 4 Types: Anxious; Insecured;

Expression-less (as floppy);

Puffy.

• Pale, devoid of contour.

• Old looking expression.

• Swollen upper lip.

• Pale with deep seated eyes,

surrounded by dark rings.

Formication in face.

• Greasy. Hair. Whiskers,

falling out of hair.

• Facial Expression: Idiotic.

Sickly.

• Anxious, old looking

appearance.

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

VOICE

• Soft,

womanish.

• Can scream;

polarity (two

extremes) of

tubercular

miasm.

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

TONGUE • Dryness.

• Persistent sour

taste.

• Dryness of

tongue at night.

• Burning pain at

tip of the tongue;

worse, anything

warm taken into

stomach.

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

NAIL

• Glossy & spotted

(Tubercular).

• Hang nails.

• Brittle &

exfoliation of

nails.

• Sensation of

twitching.

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

SPPECH VARIATIONS

• Pif under pessure

Calcarea turns

peevish, grumpy,

querulous or childish,

but he is rarely nasty.

• Stubborn.

• Self-assertiveness.

• Non-aggressive but

determined obstinacy

(Tubercular miasm

characteristic).

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

GESTURE • Short -limbed.

• Fair, fat, flabby, freezing and pulp.

• Jiggles like jelly.

• Sit in a chair and slides down

because she is so flabby.

• Good planners and organisers.

• Late in attending social

gatherings.(lastminute.com)

• Tears drip down silently.

• Damp head may smell mildly of cottage

cheese.

• Trust-worthy, reliable, loyal, dedicated,

hard-working.

• Have damp hands and head.

• Flabby and have a boneless kind of

hand-grip.

• Clammy hand.

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

GESTURE (Contd. …) • No bone, no firm responding grip.

• Loose firmless grip socks, floppy shoes,

hats, no constriction around middle.

• Dislike tightness around the waist.

• Can be quiet stubborn resistance.

• Behave like a dunce, jaw hangs,

uncomprehending looks, pretends to be

slower. Defends himself by “switching off” in

various ways.

• Capricious appetite.

• Principle defensive action is to withdraw and

protect – close off the world and ignore it.

• Visibly upset by criticism an takes umbrage

at the least little comment.

• Strong willed, obstinate, toddler often difficult

to distract from his desires.

• Upset by horrible things, stories, events in

the news, by terrible tragedies happening to

others.

CALCAREA CARB

Gesture:

• Trust-worthy,

reliable, loyal,

dedicated,

hard-working.

• Visibly upset

by criticism

and takes

umbrage at the

least little

comment.

© Subrata

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

DRESS • Light colour.

• Loose, no

constriction

around midle.

• Floppy shoes.

• Don’t tie the

lace of the

shoes:

indolent,

sluggish.

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

SIT & BEHAVE

• Slide down.

• Anxious & scared.

• Insecured.

• Cold hands.

• During consultation:

switches off

withdraws does

not co-operate

obstinacy (+++).

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

HEAT AND COLD RELATIONSHIP

• Chilly patient,

disposed to catch

cold very easily.

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

DIATHESIS

• Scrofulous, rachitic

and tubercular

diathesis.

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

MAKING APPOINTMENT

• Anxious and

have cancelled

the appointment

twice before.

• They are

last minute.com;

will appear late in

a sloppy way!

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

BODY SHAPE

• 4F : Fair + Fat

+ Flabby &

Freezing.

• Fine hair.

• Puffy but

delicate face.

CALCAREA CARB

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

3F: Fair,

fat, flabby

Freezing Slow,

sluggish

movement

(compare:

oyster-

shell)

Look &

Diagnose

Appearance:

• Dr. Margaret Tyler remarks, “with

the chalky complexion goes;

fatness without fitness, sweating

without heat, bones without

strength, tissue of plus quantity

and minus quality, mere flabby,

bulky with weakness and

weariness”. Dr. Tyler remarks, it is

difficult to miss a Calcarea child.

• 4F = Constitution, F1 = Fair, F2 =

Fat, F3 = Flabby & F4 = Freezing

constitution.

• Dr. Blackie refers especially a

description of children who are

charming, smiling and who take

prize at the baby show. They sit

where they are put and do not

wriggle about like other children. © Subrata

CALCAREA CARB

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

• “Fatness

without

Fitness”

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

• Appearance:

Contrast: Tall

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

• Baby

Fat

Plumpy

© Subrata

FINGER

• The tips

of fingers

are

square.

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

APPEARANCE • Blond hair.

• Light complexion, blue eyes,

fair skin.

• Pale, weak.

• Children with red face, flabby

muscles, who sweat easily

and take cold readily in

consequence.

• Curvature of bones especially

spine & long bones.

• Children have no disposition

to walk and will not try.

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

APPEARANCE (Contd. …) • Tall & slender, who are pre-disposed to lung diseases (Ref.

Allen).

• Neck and body may be scraggy.

• She comes in puffily and presents you with a froggy hands

that makes you shrink an you can spot Calc. Carb by the

hands (Ref. Dr. Tyler). Some-times they are of large nose.

• Pale, chalky complexion.

• Can’t bear tight clothing around middle.

• Looks physically strong but lacks motivation.

• Round appearance.

• Look and Diagnose:

o 3F: Fair, fat, flabby.

o Freezing.

o Slow, sluggish movement (compare: oyster-shell).

• Strong bony framework.

• Forehead is wide.

• Upper lip protruding.

• Develop wrinkles.

• The tips of fingers are square.

• Short limbed.

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

IRRITABILITY, IMPATIENCE

• The “shadow side” of Calc

is the terribly difficult, badly

behaved child.

• Temper tantrums of

screaming, ungovernable,

disobedient, “self willed”.

• Uncontrollable natures.

• Tantrums are continuous

with little or no discernible

provocation.

• Stressed mostly from

overexertion of overwork

– mentally or physically.

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

LOOK & DIAGNOSE

• 3F: Fair, fat,

flabby.

• Freezing.

• Slow, sluggish

movement

(compare:

oyster-shell).

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

PERSONALITY

• Reliable, reserve.

• Dutiful,

compassionate.

• Sensitive.

• Shy.

• Anxious.

• Fearful.

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

BEHAVIOURAL • Anxiety.

• Worry.

• Fearful.

• Night terrors.

• Late.

• Good organizer.

• Stork – bite.

• Independent.

• Badly behaved child Temper

tantrum:

o Screaming & moaning (soft voice –

loud shrill voice, Chamomilla).

o Disobedient.

• Gets upset by criticism.

• Gets upset (+++) from hearing horrible

/ sad stories (e.g. accidents).

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

SLEEP

• Sleeps on

back.

• Starts at

every

noise.

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

REACTION TO EMOTIONS • Grieving or sad mood: Grief

from long past offences.

• Anxious mood: Fear of

death, disease, cancer,

contagious diseases,

infection, being observed.

• Aggressive mood: Irritability

after coitus.

• Personality: Fearful.

• Envious mood: Sensitive:

Sad stories affects

profoundly.

• Miserable nature: Aversion

to certain persons.

CALCAREA CARB

Fear (Loss of familiar ground)

Anticipation

Poverty

Reliable

Timid &

sluggish

MENTAL AETIOLOGIES PSYCHIC MANIFESTATIONS

Duty bond

Anxiety+++

Over

work

Events

&

stories

Mental

Aetiologies

Fears

Disease Others will

know her

confusion

Closed

Lack of ambition Lack of initiative

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

Anxiety

Overexertion News

Excite-

ment

Trage-

dies

(results

P.T.S.D.)

Over-

works to

maintain it

Respon

-sible Sincere

Reliable & responsible

Over-

respon-

sible

Over-

whelmed

Works

hard

Sincere

Overburdened

Reliable

& Simple

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

Duty-bound

Overworks

to keep it

Occupa-

tion >

Animals (including

dogs), insects & spiders

Claustro

-phobia

Poverty

Disease

(cancer)

High

places

(heights)

Others will know

her confusion

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

Fears

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

• Nervous

& scared

Closed

Sensitive

& senti-

mental

Timid

Shy &

slugg-

ish

Lack of

ambi-

tion and

initia-

tive

Homely

CALCAREA CARB

© Subrata

Protec-

tion &

Security

behavioural materia medica: calcarea carb.appearance: •dr. margaret tyler remarks, “with the...

Documents