belgian safety plan safety plan - sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #fmhjbo 4bgfuz 1mbo t 2012...

36
Federal Public Service Mobility and Transport Belgian Civil Aviation Authority BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN 2010-2014 2012 Update SAFETY PLAN

Upload: others

Post on 17-Apr-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

Federal Public Service

Mobility and TransportBelgian Civil Aviation Authority

B E L G I A N S A F E T Y P L A N

2 0 1 0 - 2 0 1 4

2 0 1 2 U p d a t e

S A F E T Y P L A N

Page 2: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety
Page 3: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

B E L G I A N S A F E T Y P L A N

2 0 1 0 - 2 0 1 4

2 0 1 2 U p d a t e

Federal Public Service

Mobility and TransportBelgian Civil Aviation Authority

Page 4: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

2 2012 Update

OUTLINE

The present document is the second update of the

2010-2014 Belgian Safety Plan and has been developed

according to the same methodology that was used to

develop the first edition.

The Belgian Safety Plan still encompasses two broad

areas:

General Actions (GA) designed to the further

development of the Belgian Safety Programme (BSP);

Operational Actions (OA) largely derived from

the risk management system for civil aviation

occurrences. A number of risk-mitigation actions

were developed in consultation with the Belgian

service providers and incorporated into this safety

plan.

The status of the standing actions has been revised.

An action is considered closed when the proposed

deliverable is achieved. Also new actions such as

the prevention of airspace infringements have been

incorporated in the second update of this Safety Plan.

These new actions have been placed within the existing

framework. They take into consideration new safety

initiatives aimed at mitigating risks.

It is recognised that an important part in the success of

the Safety Plan is played by a proper communication

of the intentions behind it. To that extend the BCAA

has already taken the lead by adequately informing

the Belgian service providers about the approach and

expectations. The BCAA is also committed to ensuring the

further involvement of aviation industry in the process

of developing safety plans. To this end, the BCAA is in

discussion with the various aviation industry committees

and teams for the discussion of safety concerns.

The primary focus of this Safety Plan is on commercial

air transport operations, especially those carried out

by aeroplanes. Additionally an effort has been made to

capture actions that also address general aviation. The

BCAA and other stakeholders have among others taken

measures to improve the general aviation safety level

through safety promotion such as the organization of

safety seminars.

We hope you get inspired by reading our safety plan. We

believe that this plan represents an opportunity to make

a difference in aviation safety.

Frank Durinckx,

The BCAA Director-General

Federal Public Service

Mobility and TransportBelgian Civil Aviation Authority

Page 5: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

3Contents

CONTENTS Outline

Link between the European Aviation Safety Plan (EASp) and the Belgian Safety Plan

General Actions (GA) to further develop the Belgian Safety Programme (BSP)

GA1: Establishing a National Safety Library

GA2: Developing Safety Performance Indicators (SPI’s)

GA3: Developing a strategy with respect to safety training and safety promotion

Operational Actions (OA) to improve civil aviation safety

OA1: Establishing a Belgian Aviation Wildlife Hazard Committee and drafting a national

action plan to prevent collisions with animals

OA2: Resolving problems related to ground handling in partnership with the market sector

OA3: Drafting regulations with respect to unruly passengers

OA4: Annual check of the reliability of flight controls for commercial aircraft in Belgium

OA5: Complete the regulation with respect to the “Targeting of Aircraft with Lasers”

OA6: Implementation of the European Action Plan for the Prevention of Runway Incursions (EAPPRI)

OA7: Implementation of the National Action Plan for Airspace Infringement Risk Reduction

Appendix 1: Outline of risks in the Belgian civil aviation sector

Appendix 2: Belgian Civil Aviation Safety Policy

Page 6: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

4 2012 Update

LINK BETWEEN THE EUROPEAN AVIATION SAFETY PLAN (EASP) AND THE BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN

In the European aviation system rulemaking, oversight

and safety promotion activities are shared between

the Member States and the European Institutions. The

European Aviation Safety Programme (EASP) describes

the roles and responsibilities that each of them have while

performing these functions. As certain competencies

have been transferred from the Member States to the

European Union, in order to obtain a complete picture

of safety in any single State, both the EASP and the BSP

needs to be considered.

EASA has published a second edition of the EASp. It

covers the period between 2012 and 2015 and has been

developed according to the same methodology that was

used to develop the first edition of the EASp. Therefore

the main risk areas have not been changed.

Through this Belgian Safety Plan, the BCAA aims to

contribute to the realisation of the first and second

edition of the EASp. The alignment between the EASp

and the Belgian Action Plan is shown for the relevant

safety actions.

Federal Public Service

Mobility and TransportBelgian Civil Aviation Authority

Page 7: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

5General Actions (GA) to further develop the Belgian Safety Programme (BSP)

GENERAL ACTIONS (GA) TO FURTHER DEVELOP THE BELGIAN SAFETY PROGRAMME (BSP)

The missing elements of the BSP were determined on

the basis of a gap analysis. This analysis was conducted

on the basis of the checklist included in ICAO Doc

9859 (Appendix 3 to Chapter 11: Guidance on the

development of a State Safety Programme).

GA1: Establishing a National

Safety Library

a. Description

The BCAA will create a central Safety Library.

Consequently, the BCAA will take the following actions:

Action GA1.1 (date: 2014): develop the legislative

framework for implementing and maintaining the

Belgian Safety Programme;

Action GA1.2 (date: 2010): develop the Belgian

Civil Aviation Safety Policy;

Action GA1.3 (date: 2010): develop the processes,

procedures, responsibilities and accountabilities for

the correct implementation of the BSP;

Action GA1.4 (date: recurring yearly): manage

data related to accidents, serious incidents and

reported occurrences;

Action GA1.5 (date: recurring yearly): perform the

annual risk analysis.

Expected Safety Benefit:

Improvement of the Belgian safety performance to

enable proportionate and timely corrective actions to be

taken, to continuously improve aviation safety

Safety Performance Indicators:

Dynamic Integrated Risk Management (DIRM) used by

BCAA

Safety Output Owner:

The BCAA Aviation Inspectorate;

The BCAA Legal Affairs Department;

The BCAA General Affairs Directorate.

Alignment with EASp:

Safety Actions SYS1.1, 1.7

b. Progress on Actions

Action GA1.1:

A Decision of the BCAA Director-General has been

elaborated and implemented in the course of

January 2010. The BCAA will also convert the ICAO

Annex 19 with regard to Safety Management into the

Belgian legislation. Publication of the new Annex 19

has been foreseen before the end of 2013.

Action GA1.2: CLOSED

The BCAA Safety Policy has been defined and

implemented in the course of January 2010. A first

revision of the BCAA Safety Policy has already been

performed in the course of January 2011.

Action GA1.3: CLOSED

Safety risk management processes and procedures

have been developed in the course of 2008-2010.

These processes and related procedures define the

responsibilities and accountabilities of all concerned

parties. The safety risk management system is based

on the Dynamic Integrated Risk Management

(DIRM) model. This model is fully described in the

procedures manual “Inspection Manual – Part II Risk

Management Procedures”.

Actions GA1.4 and GA1.5: CLOSED

The yearly risk analysis of civil aviation occurrences

for 2011 was performed and subsequently discussed

at the BCAA safety committee. Aviation risks to

be handled with priority were selected and risk-

mitigation actions were put in place.

Page 8: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

6 2012 Update

GA2: Developing Safety

Performance Indicators (SPI’s)

a. Description

The BCAA has a risk management system in place for

aviation occurrences in order to determine SPI’s for

Belgian civil aviation. The BCAA risk management system

represents a structured process to establish a treatment

priority for aviation risks. However, the BCAA has not yet

reached the SPI’s applicable to the safety management

systems (SMS) at the Belgian service providers.

Consequently, the BCAA will take the following actions:

Action GA2.1 (date: end 2014): systematically

implement SMS at the service providers in accordance

with the regulatory requirements;

Action GA2.2 (date: end 2014): determine SPI’s at a

national level in conjunction with the Belgian service

providers;

Action GA2.3 (date: end 2014): contribute to

the safety actions of the EASp with regard to the

development of SPI’s at the level of the European

Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) and EUROCONTROL.

Expected Safety Benefit:

Improvement of the monitoring of Belgian safety

performance to enable proportionate and timely

corrective actions to be taken, to continuously

improve aviation safety;

Increase the safety performance of service

providers leading to an increase of the overall safety

performance of the Belgian aviation system.

Safety Performance Indicators:

SPI’s established for all key safety issues of the Belgian

Safety Plan;

Number of service providers that have fully

implemented SMS before the final transitional dates

allowed by EASA regulations.

Safety Output Owner:

The BCAA Aviation Inspectorate;

The BCAA Company Approvals Directorate;

The BCAA Airspace and Airports Directorate;

The Belgian Supervising Authority for Air Navigation

Services;

The BCAA Licensing Directorate;

The BCAA General Affairs Directorate.

Alignment with EASp:

Safety Actions SYS2.7, 2.9, 2.10, 3.1, 3.4, 3.5, 3.6, 3.7

b. Progress on Actions

Action GA2.1: systematically implement SMS

at the service providers in accordance with the

regulatory requirements

Belgian service providers will be required to start SMS

implementation according to European standards

as of 2012. The initial requirements will cover the

domains of air operations and flight crew licensing.

The organization requirements for air crews have

already been published in the European Regulation

EC 290/2012. Implementation of SMS at the Approved

Training Organizations (ATO), Aero-medical Centres

and Operators of Flight Synthetic Training Devices

therefore becomes mandatory from April 2014.

The organization requirements for air operations will

most likely be published in the course of November

2012. These requirements will be further extended

to other domains of aviation (airworthiness, ATM/

ANS and aerodromes). In preparation for the

European rules, extensive guidance material has

already been developed by the different teams of

the European Strategic Safety Initiative (ESSI). This

guidance material addresses SMS principles and

implementation in commercial aviation, helicopters

and aerodromes. The BCAA continuously

encourages the implementation of this material

across their service providers.

Action GA2.2: develop SPI’s at a national level in

conjunction with the Belgian service providers

The BCAA has already developed a number of SPI’s

that are in use at national level. These indicators are

published in this safety plan. The BCAA organizes

periodic consultative meetings with representatives

of the Belgian aviation sector (Belgian Flight Safety

Committee, Local Runway Safety Teams, ANSP’s

etc.) to debate on SPI’s and safety levels in the

Belgian civil aviation sector and to communicate the

achievements related to the Belgian Safety Plan.

Action GA2.3: contribute to the safety actions

of the EASp with regard to the development

of SPI’s at the level of the European Aviation

Safety Agency (EASA) and Air Navigation Service

Providers (ANSP’s)

EASA

The BCAA is an active member of the Network of

Analysts (NoA). This voluntary partnership between

Federal Public Service

Mobility and TransportBelgian Civil Aviation Authority

Page 9: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

7General Actions (GA) to further develop the Belgian Safety Programme (BSP)

EASA and other aviation organizations has the

objective to enhance aviation safety in Europe by

providing a framework for the collaboration of safety

analysis activity throughout the European Aviation

Safety Community. The primary mission is to improve

aviation safety by identifying safety risks and bringing

such risks to the attention of the decision makers. The

BCAA participates in the NoA Framework Sub Group

1 “Risk Classification” and in the NoA Framework Sub

Group 2 “SPI’s”.

ANSP’s

On the 29th of July 2010, the Commission Regulation

(EU) No 691/2010 laid down a performance scheme

for air navigation services and network functions. This

regulation established three safety key performance

indicators (SKPI) for the first reference period (RP1)

covering 2012 till 2014. Those indicators were to be

developed jointly by the Commission, the Member

States, EASA and Eurocontrol and to be adopted by

the Commission prior to RP1.

This work was concluded by the publication of the

Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) No

1216/2011 of the 24th of November 2011, defining

the three SKPIs below.

The first national /Functional Airspace Blocks

(FAB) SKPI for RP1 is the effectiveness of safety

management as measured by a methodology

based on the ATM Safety Framework Maturity

Survey. With regard to Member States and their

national supervisory authorities and ANSP’s, certified

to provide air traffic services or communication,

navigation and surveillance services, this SKPI is

measured by the level of implementation of the

following management objectives:

Safety policy and objectives;

Safety risk management;

Safety assurance;

Safety promotion;

Safety Culture.

The second national/FAB SKPI for RP1 is the

application of the severity classification below,

based on the Risk Analysis Tool methodology to

the reporting of, as a minimum, three categories

of occurrences:

Separation Minima Infringements (SMI);

Runway Incursions (RI);

ATM-specific occurrences at all Air Traffic

Control Centers and at airports (ATM SO).

The third national/FAB SKPI for RP1 is the reporting

by the Member States and their ANSP’s through

a questionnaire which measures the level of

presence and corresponding level of absence of

Just Culture. The Just Culture means a culture

in which front line operators or others are not

punished for actions, omissions or decisions

taken by them that are commensurate with

their experience and training, but where gross

negligence, willful violations and destructive acts

are not tolerated.

For the implementation of the required SKPIs and

with the development of FAB’s, the decision was

taken to have a common performance plan for

the six states composing the FAB Central Europe

(FABEC): Belgium, France, Germany, Luxembourg, The

Netherlands and Switzerland. This performance

plan requires a safety performance monitoring and

reporting from States and ANSP’s.

To comply with all those requirements, Belgium

has two levels of monitoring and reporting, one at

national level and another at FABEC level.

At national level, the Belgian Supervising Authority

for Air Navigation Services (BSA-ANS) and the BCAA

are responsible to monitor and report on safety

performance.

For SKPI1, the effectiveness of safety management

will be measured as from September to December

2012. For the ANSP’s the scores based on the

ATM Safety Framework Maturity Survey will be

verified by the BSA-ANS prior to be provided to

the EASA and the Performance Review Body. For

the State, the scores will be verified through EASA

Standardization Inspections. The scores will be

published in 2013 following the EASA inspection

of September 2012.

For SKPI2, the three mandatory occurrences types

(SMI, RI, and ATM SO) are part of the occurrences

data that are collected and analyzed by the

BCAA. The ANSP has established processes for

safety performance reporting and those data are

monitored by the BSA-ANS. The Risk Analysis Tool

and methodology are already applied for SMI and

RI by the Belgian ANSP, the application for ATM SO

is still in trial but shall meet the objective of full

implementation in 2014.

For SKPI3, the Just Culture level will be measured

as from September to December 2012, following

the same method as for SKPI1 (effectiveness of

safety management). The scores will be published

in 2013.

Page 10: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

8 2012 Update

At FABEC level, Safety performance is monitored by

the FABEC NSA Committee in collaboration with

the FABEC Financial & Performance Committee. The

NSA Committee has therefore established a Safety

Performance Task Force to develop and maintain

safety performance monitoring at FABEC level. This task

force has membership of the Financial & Performance

Committee and deals with the safety elements of

the FABEC Performance Plan on behalf of the NSA

Committee. It will provide the Finance & Performance

Committee with the safety elements of the FABEC

performance plan as of 2012. The BSA-ANS is leading

this Safety Performance Task Force that includes Safety

Experts from all FABEC States and will analyze and

aggregate data from the 6 States and 7 ANSP’s that are

composing FABEC. The first reporting on FABEC safety

performance is foreseen for March 2013.

There will be no EU wide safety performance targets

during RP1. The BSA-ANS and the BCAA will monitor

and publish these SKPIs with regard to the following

objectives described in the performance plan:

Based on the FABEC ATM Safety Maturity Survey

scores from the seven ANSP’s, a baseline shall be

defined during 2012, and an objective shall be

set for the 2013-2014 period, on the level to be

achieved at the end of RP1.

Based on the FABEC ATM Safety Maturity Survey

scores from the six states, a baseline shall be

defined during 2012, and an objective shall be

set for the 2013-2014 period, on the level to be

achieved at the end of RP1.

To allow the harmonization of the reporting of

severity assessment, FABEC ANSP’s are committed

to implement the RAT7 (Risk Analysis Tool) before

the end of RP1.

FABEC’s are requested to perform a Cost Benefits

Analysis and an initial feasibility study for the

implementation of automated reporting systems,

at least for En-Route traffic. The added value

of those automated systems shall be assessed

and the objectives of those tools shall be clearly

identified and stated in Just Culture policies.

The feasibility study shall be completed prior

the end of RP1 and based on the results, the

implementation phase should be considered for

RP2.

Harmonization of a set of definitions, working

processes and historical data shall be completed

prior the end of RP1.

2012 is the first year of RP1 for the performance

scheme implementation. In 2013 the data will be

used to ensure compliance with all national and EU

wide requirements and FABEC objectives completion.

Federal Public Service

Mobility and TransportBelgian Civil Aviation Authority

Page 11: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

9General Actions (GA) to further develop the Belgian Safety Programme (BSP)

GA3: Developing a strategy with

respect to safety training and

safety promotion

a. Description

The BCAA has already taken a number of important steps

to improve the communication of information related to

safety.

The operational departments of the BCAA have access

to data related to aviation occurrences in the ECCAIRS

database and, based on this information they can launch

an investigation or gather additional data.

The BCAA and the Accidents and Incidents Investigation

Unit hold bimonthly meetings to discuss accidents,

incidents and occurrences. This process is in line with

the concept of accident prevention and helps establish

potential causes and formulate any measures to be taken

and safety recommendations to be made.

The reports of all accidents and serious incidents

occurring in Belgian airspace or involving Belgian aircraft

can be consulted on the website of the Federal Public

Service for Mobility and Transport.

The Belgian Safety Plan is communicated to both the

employees of the BCAA and the Belgian aviation sector.

The BCAA will further develop safety training and safety

promotion through the following actions:

Action GA 3.1 (date: recurring): provide initial and

recurrent training related to the BSP and SMS as part

of the BCAA employees training programmes;

Action GA3.2 (date: recurring yearly): organize or

participate in safety seminars in conjunction with the

Belgian commercial and general aviation sector in

association with the Belgian Accidents and Incidents

Investigation Unit.

Expected Safety Benefit:

Employees of the BCAA and the Accidents and

Incidents Investigation Unit are trained and

competent to perform their BSP duties;

Safety information is communicated and

disseminated to the Belgian aviation sector.

Safety Performance Indicators:

Proportion of relevant BCAA employees appropriately

trained against their competence requirements;

Belgian aviation sector timely informed of new

promotion material developed by the European

Commercial Aviation Safety Team (ECAST), the

European Helicopter Safety Team (EHEST) and the

European General Aviation Safety Team (EGAST).

Safety Output Owner:

The Belgian Accidents and Incidents Investigation

Unit;

The BCAA General Affairs Directorate;

The BCAA Operational Directorates.

Alignment with EASp:

Safety Actions SYS 2.7, HE1.3

b. Progress on Actions

Action GA3.1: CLOSED

The BCAA provides initial and recurrent training

related to BSP and SMS as part of the BCAA employees

training programmes. Upon request from the BCAA,

instructors from ICAO held a State Safety Programme

(SSP) implementation course in Brussels from 6 to

8 June 2012. This course was attended by 27 staff

members from the BCAA and the Belgian Air Accident

Investigation Unit. The topics covered included basic

Page 12: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

2012 Update10

safety concepts, fundamentals of safety management,

hazard identification and risk management, ICAO

safety management related provisions, and the

development and implementation of the SSP.

Action GA3.2: CLOSED

Representatives from EHEST, the Aviation Safety

Department of Defence (ASD), Belgocontrol, the

Belgian Air Accident Investigation Unit and the BCAA

organized a helicopter safety seminar for pilots and

industry representatives in Brussels the 27th June

2012. The topics covered included the presentation

of the EHEST safety leaflets, the analysis of helicopter

accidents and recommendations, the BCAA

occurrence reporting system, safety considerations

of a defaulting paperwork, the relationship between

accidents and human factors and finally the increasing

safety awareness by means of flight preparation.

The BCAA also supports the European Strategic Safety

Initiatives (ESSI), and specifically each of the three

pillars: European Commercial Aviation Safety Team

(ECAST), European Helicopter Safety Team (EHEST)

and European General Aviation Safety Team (EGAST).

The BCAA encourages the implementation of the

promotion material developed by ECAST, EHEST and

EGAST. The BCAA website continuously informs the

Belgian aviation industry of the availability of new

promotion material at the EASA website through a

direct link.

Federal Public Service

Mobility and TransportBelgian Civil Aviation Authority

Page 13: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

OPERATIONAL ACTIONS (OA) TO IMPROVE CIVIL AVIATION SAFETY

Operational issues are brought to light by the reporting

and analysis of occurrence data. The primary focus is on

commercial air transport operations, especially those

carried out by aeroplanes.

The operational actions are designed to reduce the risks

derived from the risk management system for aviation

occurrences. The risks to be handled were selected by

the BCAA Safety Committee and the related corrective

actions were further developed in conjunction with the

Belgian aviation sector.

OA1: Establishing a Belgian

Aviation Wildlife Hazard

Committee and drafting a

national action plan to prevent

collisions with animals

a. Description

The presence of wildlife (birds and other animals) on and

in the vicinity of an aerodrome poses a serious threat to

aircraft operational safety. The majority of collisions occur

at low heights, in the vicinity of an airport during takeoff

and landing. Annex 14-certified aerodrome operators

are required to take the necessary actions to identify,

manage and mitigate the risk to aircraft operations

posed by wildlife by adopting actions likely to minimise

the risk of collisions between wildlife and aircraft, to as

low as reasonably practicable.

The appropriate authorities are required to have in place

procedures for the identification and control of wildlife

hazards on and in the vicinity of an aerodrome, and to

ensure that competent personnel evaluates the wildlife

hazard on a continuing basis.

0 10 20 30 40 50

Dec

Nov

Oct

Sept

Aug

July

June

May

Apr

Mar

Feb

Jan

20072008200920102011

Monthly bird strike occurrences in Belgium

Operational Actions (OA) to improve civil aviation safety 11

Page 14: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

12 2012 Update

The BCAA will take the following actions:

Action OA1.1 (date: 2011): foundation of the Belgian

Aviation Wildlife Hazard Committee (BAWiHaC);

Action OA1.2 (date: 2011): preparation of a national

action plan in order to reduce risks related to collisions

with animals;

Action OA1.3 (date: end 2013): organization of

courses for Bird Control Unit (BCU) personnel;

Action OA1.4 (date: recurring yearly): exchange of

experience about specific technical issues in the field

of wildlife management;

Action OA1.5 (date: end 2013): improvement of

the reporting of wildlife occurrences;

Action OA1.6: development of regulatory actions:

Action OA1.6.1 (date: end 2013): development

of a Wildlife Management Manual;

Action OA1.6.2 (date: end 2013): development

of a regional hunting legislation;

Action OA1.6.3 (date: end 2014): development

of regional land use regulations.

Expected Safety Benefit:

Minimize the risk of collisions between wildlife (birds)

and aircraft, to as low as reasonably practicable

Safety Performance Indicators:

Wildlife Strikes at Belgian aerodromes;

Bird Strikes at Belgian aerodromes.

Safety Output Owner:

The BCAA Airspace and Airports Directorate

Alignment with EASp:

Safety Actions AER1.5, AER 4.5, 4.7

b. Progress on Actions

Action OA1.1: CLOSED

The BCAA established the BAWiHaC to exchange

information and expertise on the subject of wildlife

strikes. Based on the guidance in the ICAO Airport

Services Manual Part 3 (Doc 9137), the BCAA

documented the possible operation of the BAWiHaC,

among others by performing benchmark tests and

by determining the potential members. During a

preparatory meeting the BAWiHaC members (the

airport authorities of the certified aerodromes, the

Aviation Safety Department of Defence and the

BCAA established the committee’s objectives and

procedures (i.e. Terms of Reference). The BAWiHaC

meets at least once a year.

Action OA1.2: CLOSED

During the second meeting of the BAWiHaC, the

committee’s members defined, in addition to the

Terms of Reference, the top priorities to reduce the

wildlife risk in Belgium. This resulted in a national

action plan in order to reduce risks related to collisions

with animals. The BAWiHaC meetings follow the

introduction of the national action plan, assure the

possible amendment of the plan and guarantee the

exchange of information.

Action OA1.3:

All airports had different levels of training and finding

a good course for BCU personnel was not easy.

Moreover, the existing courses were focusing too

much on lethal methods and were not giving enough

attention to for example habitat management. The

ASD is still organizing courses for BCU personnel in

2012. Every module is organized two times in French

and two times in Dutch. Within the framework of the

BAWiHaC and the collaboration between ASD and

BCAA, personnel from all civil airports will participate

in this course.

Action OA1.4: CLOSED

Airport authorities need a discussion forum to

exchange ideas about specific technical issues

in the field of wildlife management. The aim of

exchanging experience is clearly mentioned In

the BAWiHaC Terms of Reference. Therefore regular

meetings were organized to achieve this goal.

Until now, specific topics were mentioned, like for

example grass management (especially the long

grass policy). The committee meetings are held

at different airports in order to combine them

with a visit of the local BCU service. The BAWiHaC

members invite from time to time other aviation

community players in order to widen the scope of

experience.

Action OA1.5:

The BCAA is keeping statistics on the wildlife

occurrences reported by the airports. It was however

difficult to draw clear conclusions from these

figures. The quality of the reports was rather low

and the reporting culture was company dependent.

The BAWiHaC members therefore decided to adopt

sections of the ICAO reporting template. Since

Federal Public Service

Mobility and TransportBelgian Civil Aviation Authority

Page 15: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

13Operational Actions (OA) to improve civil aviation safety

then the quality of the reported occurrences is

gradually improving. Until now, the BCAA receives

almost no reports from foreign aircraft operators.

The BAWiHaC members will therefore continue to

encourage the wildlife risk awareness within the

aviation community and the reporting of wildlife

occurrences to the BCAA and the concerned

airports. An instruction note concerning the

reporting practices will be distributed towards the

aircraft operators active on the Belgian airports.

Action OA1.6:

Action OA1.6.1: some European countries

already developed a wildlife management

manual. The BCAA is not providing such a manual

for the moment. The Belgian certified airports

request a manual that determines and explains

how to implement wildlife management. The

BCAA started with the development of the wildlife

management manual in the course of 2011.

Action OA1.6.2: restrictions in the regional

legislations for hunting can pose problems

for effective wildlife management. The BCAA

supported the quest for waivers on the (Flemish)

hunting decree and the species resolution by the

civil airports. In the meanwhile, Brussels Airport

obtained this kind of waiver and the Flemish

Region invited the other airports to introduce a

similar application.

Action OA1.6.3: the lack of land use regulations

for the surroundings of airports and the unclear

division of responsibilities in the wildlife risk issue

between the airport authorities, the BCAA and

the regions need further attention. The Secretary

of State for Mobility wrote a letter to the three

regional governments to draw attention to their

responsibilities and to offer the expertise of the

BAWiHaC in this matter.

Page 16: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

14 2012 Update

OA2: Resolving problems

related to ground handling in

partnership with the market

sector

a. Description

The risk analysis of the reported occurrences has

demonstrated that problems related to ground handling

are common. This represents a broad spectrum of

occurrences, e.g. incorrect loading procedures and

filling up fuel without the necessary authorizations,

near-collisions between aircraft and ground vehicles

or damage caused to an aircraft by one such ground

vehicle, etc.

The Belgian State currently does not have sufficiently

detailed national regulations in place with respect to

ground handling.

The BCAA will take the following actions:

Action OA2.1 (date: end 2012): investigation of the

handling companies in order to gather information on

their organizational structure, activities, equipment,

training courses completed, etc.;

Action OA2.2 (date: publication of a circular -

end 2013): approval of renewal and maintenance

programs for centralized infrastructure facilities;

Action OA2.3: completion of the national regulations

for ground handling:

Action OA2.3.1 (date: July 2014): publication of

a Ministerial Decree regarding the establishment

of conditions for survey, maintenance and

periodic inspection of rolling equipment used for

ground handling services;

Action OA2.3.2 (date: July 2014): publication

of a Ministerial Decree regarding the approval

of maintenance programmes for equipment

essential to the provision of ground handling

services;

Action OA2.3.3 (date: July 2014): publication

of a Ministerial Decree regarding the certification

of ground handling service providers and self-

handlers.

The implementation of the actions listed above should

result in lower risk levels as well as in a relative decline in

the number of occurrences related to ground handling.

Expected Safety Benefit:

Increased internal supervision and auditing to monitor

the handling companies.

Safety Performance Indicators:

Collisions, near-collisions and conflicts involving

vehicles and taxiing aircraft at Belgian aerodromes;

Collisions involving vehicles and parked aircraft at

Belgian aerodromes.

Safety Output Owner:

The BCAA Airspace and Airports Directorate

Alignment with EASp:

Safety Actions AER5.9 and 5.10

Event Type 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Ground Handling Services 131 115 73 69 65

Flight Preparation 49 37 31 36 23

Damage by vehicle/ equipment 33 31 25 32 60

Ground Handling - Total 213 183 129 137 148

Federal Public Service

Mobility and TransportBelgian Civil Aviation Authority

Page 17: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

15Operational Actions (OA) to improve civil aviation safety

b. Progress on Actions

Action OA2.1: CLOSED

The BCAA created a questionnaire for handling

companies active at Brussels National Airport. The

aim of this questionnaire was to obtain a clear view

of their organization. This document has been sent

to all dedicated companies beginning 2012. Focus

was in relation to the type of handling performed,

a request for detailed inventories of materials and

equipment used for their handling activities and a

review in relation to certain certifications, existing

criteria (standards, rules) etc. Meanwhile the BCAA

has received all necessary information.

Action OA2.2:

The BCAA is developing a circular which includes

among others the criteria for the approval

of maintenance and renewal programs of

centralized infrastructures. This circular will be

used as a template for BCAA audit and inspection

programmes after initial approval of the relevant

maintenance and renewal programs. The BCAA

has presented a review of these criteria, build-up

of the dedicated manual and illustrating particular

examples in relation to maintenance and renewal

programs, to The Brussels Airport Company (TBAC)

during several meetings.

Action OA2.3:

Action OA2.3.1: the BCAA will develop a

Ministerial Decree to list the conditions for survey,

maintenance and periodic inspection of rolling

equipment used for ground handling services.

A detailed list of rolling equipment has been

presented by the handling companies (ref. OA2.1)

and will be reviewed with dedicated specialists

to determine the conditions for survey for the

type of handling equipment. At a later stage,

the Ministerial Decree will be presented to the

handling companies.

Action OA2.3.2: the Ministerial Decree which

lists the conditions for survey, maintenance and

periodic inspection of the rolling equipment will

also determine the conditions of maintenance

requirements for the essential material used

by the ground handling companies. A review

of the Ministerial Decree will be done in close

consultation with all concerned partners at a later

stage.

Action OA2.3.3: the certification of the ground

handling service providers and self-handlers

will be based on the requirements as listed in

the dedicated Ministerial Decrees. The BCAA

will review the presented documentation and

will grant a certificate of recognition to ground

handling service providers and self-handlers

when all requirements are met. Corresponding

OA2.1, the BCAA will also create a questionnaire

for self-handlers to obtain a clear view on their

organizational structure, equipment, activities

etc.

Page 18: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

16 2012 Update

OA3: Drafting regulations with

respect to unruly passengers

a. Description

While security related acts like unruly passengers can

lead to accidents as defined as by ICAO Annex 13, they

are not considered accidents by some organizations.

Regardless, these events have similar consequences in

that they result in serious injury or death to person(s)

and/or substantial damage to the aircraft.

A certain number of occurrences are related to unruly

passengers. Two-thirds of these cases represented

occurrences related to smoking in the lavatories of the

aircraft, which is strictly prohibited due to fire hazard. In

addition, air rage incidents are prevalent as well.

The BCAA will take the following actions:

Action OA3.1 (date: end 2011): sensitize all airports

and aircraft operators to report occurrences related

to unruly passengers;

Action OA3.2 (date: recurring yearly):

systematically investigate the conclusions regarding

unruly passengers and prosecuting any violations

administratively or through the courts;

Action OA3.3 (date: end 2013): organize a meeting

with the aircraft operators in order to consider

stricter sanctions to be taken with regard to unruly

passengers.

Expected Safety Benefit:

Improved investigation and prosecution of unruly

passenger incidents

Safety Performance Indicators:

Unruly Passenger Occurrences;

Safety Output Owner:

The BCAA Aviation Inspectorate;

The BCAA Legal Affairs Department.

b. Progress on Actions

Action OA3.1: CLOSED

The airport police of Brussels National Airport and

the BCAA have sensitized the airports and aircraft

operators to report all incidents regarding unruly

passengers. Reporting such an incident however

cannot in itself lead to a prosecution. This requires a

more formal complaint to be filed.

Action OA3.2: CLOSED

In practice, cabin crew and passengers do not have

the time following a flight to lodge a complaint and

be interviewed. Therefore they often prefer to simply

mention the incident so that the airport police and

the BCAA do not dispose of an official complaint. In

order to improve willingness to lodge complaints,

the airport police at Brussels National Airport have

a form in use that victims of unruly passengers can

fill in. The airport police consider such a form as a

statement and this document forms together with

the interrogation from the unruly passenger, the

basis of the charge. On this basis the prosecutor may

proceed to a prosecution or the BCAA may impose

an administrative sanction. The airport police and the

BCAA Aviation Inspectorate investigate all findings in

connection with unruly passengers. Actual offences

are transferred to the competent Crown Prosecutor.

If the violation is dismissed for reasons unrelated to

the constituent elements of the violation, the BCAA

Aviation Inspectorate will impose an administrative

fine.

Action OA3.3:

The BCAA will organize a consultation with the

aircraft operators via the National Aviation Security

Committee in order to consider stricter sanctions

to be taken with regard to unruly passengers. In this

respect a system of administrative sanctions will be

considered, including direct recoverable fines.

Federal Public Service

Mobility and TransportBelgian Civil Aviation Authority

Page 19: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

17Operational Actions (OA) to improve civil aviation safety

OA4: Annual check of the

reliability of flight controls for

commercial aircraft in Belgium

a. Description

The annual risk analyses have demonstrated that there

have been technical problems related to flight controls.

These analyses take into account the number of flights

operated by Belgian aircraft operators, thereby creating

a similar frame of reference.

The BCAA will take the following actions:

Action OA4.1 (recurring yearly): perform a detailed

annual analysis of all occurrences related to flight

controls for commercial aircraft in Belgium and

determine annual SPIs for identifying trends;

Action OA4.2 (recurring yearly): determine items

to be addressed and taking targeted actions where

necessary (this includes analysing the reliability

programmes of the Belgian aircraft operators).

Expected Safety Benefit:

Improvement of the flight controls reliability

Safety Performance Indicators:

Flight Control Occurrences

Safety Output Owner:

The BCAA Company Approvals Directorate

Alignment with EASp:

Safety Actions AER4.6 and 4.7

b. Progress on Actions

Actions OA4.1 and OA4.2: CLOSED

The BCAA noticed an important increase in the

number of flight control occurrences in the course of

2011. This trend could be due either to a real increase

in the number of occurrences, to an improved

occurrence reporting culture, or to a combination

of both. However comparing the yearly evolution

of the SPI for “Flight Control Occurrences”, a general

0,E+00

5,E-05

1,E-04

2,E-04

2,E-04

3,E-04

3,E-04

4,E-04

4,E-04

5,E-04

2008 2009 2010 2011

Flight Control incidents per fl ight

Trend

SPI “Flight Control Occurrences”

decreasing trend can be observed. Reliability

meetings with the aircraft operators only seem to

confirm this trend.

Several actions were initiated by the Belgian aircraft

operators and the BCAA in order to increase the flight

controls reliability and the aircraft safety in general (like

improved de-icing and greasing instructions). The BCAA

will continue with the follow up of the effectiveness

of these preventive maintenance actions. It must

be reminded that the vast majority of flight control

occurrences (about 90%) are related to secondary flight

controls, mostly flaps, and therefore do not directly lead

to safety problems. In addition, the further renewal of

the Belgian registered fleet, as observed within several

Belgian aircraft operators, should also improve the

reliability of the aircraft operated.

Page 20: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

Within Belgium Outside Belgium

Year Number of Laser Events Year Number of Laser Events

2009 5 2009 8

2010 80 2010 27

2011 144 2011 27

0 10 20 30 40

Dec

Nov

Oct

Sept

Aug

July

June

May

Apr

Mar

Feb

Jan

200920102011

Monthly Interferences by laser in Belgium

OA5: Complete the regulation

with respect to the “Targeting of

Aircraft with Lasers”

a. Description

The last three years have seen a rapid growth in the

number of reports of Belgian aircraft being targeted by

hand held lasers. A number of reports were received

from Belgian aircraft when operating outside Belgium

so the table below has been broken down into events

within Belgium and events outside Belgium.

Laser emitters pose a significant threat to aviation safety

and security. The use of hand lasers could potentially

harm aircraft operations and asks for adequate

countermeasures to mitigate this threat.

18 2012 Update

Federal Public Service

Mobility and TransportBelgian Civil Aviation Authority

Page 21: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

The BCAA will take the following actions:

Action OA5.1 (date: end 2012): improve the

cooperation between the ANSP, the Federal Police

and BCAA by developing procedures to follow in the

case of laser interference;

Action OA5.2: (date: end 2013): complete the

Aviation Law of 27th June 1937 (if necessary) to make

the malicious use of lasers against aircraft and ATS

personnel an offence;

New Action OA5.3 (date: July 2013): improve

guidance for aircrew reporting of unauthorized laser

illumination.

Expected Safety Benefit:

Minimize the effects of laser attacks during the critical

phases of flight

Safety Performance Indicators:

Number of laser occurrences

Safety Output Owner:

The BCAA Aviation Inspectorate;

The BCAA Legal Affairs Department.

a. Progress on Actions

Actions OA5.1 and OA5.2:

The Belgian ANSP and the BCAA have organized

preparatory meetings in order to discuss the

reporting of targeting of aircraft with lasers and how

to improve the cooperation with the Federal Police.

The Belgian ANSP subsequently developed internal

procedures for information to Air Traffic Controllers

and Tower Supervisors how to establish contact

with the responsible police unit in case of laser

illumination. The Belgian ANSP has already started

with the publication of these procedures in the Local

Unit Operations Manuals of the Belgian international

airports. Several perpetrators were caught red-

handed after the application of the new procedures.

The completion of the Aviation Law of 27th June 1937

to make the malicious use of laser against aircraft

and ANS personnel a specific offence will depend

on the outcome of the perpetrators’ prosecution in

accordance with the current legislation.

Action OA5.3:

The BCAA has also started with the improvement of

guidance for aircrew reporting of unauthorized laser

illumination. All aircrew are requested to immediately

report these incidents by radio to the appropriate

ATC controlling facility. The future oral reporting

must contain all necessary information for ATC, law

enforcement and other governmental action taken

to safeguard the safety and efficiency of aviation

operation in the national airspace. The BCAA will

also develop a specific template for the reporting

of unauthorized laser illumination by aircrew upon

arrival of destination. All aircrew that have been

affected by a laser attack will be requested to complete

the specific template and to send the form to the

BCAA in accordance with the guidelines of Circular

CIR/INS-01.

19Operational Actions (OA) to improve civil aviation safety

Page 22: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

OA6: Implementation of the

European Action Plan for

the Prevention of Runway

Incursions

a. Description

The prevention of runway incursions is a key issue

for airport safety. The European Action Plan for the

Prevention of Runway Incursions (EAPPRI) is the result of

the combined efforts of multiple organizations dealing

with safety at airports, and its 2nd edition was published

in 2011. It contains recommendations to all airport

stakeholders (including regulators, airport operators,

ATC, aircraft operators…). When implemented, the

EAPPRI recommendations will enhance runway safety.

A major recommendation is the organization of Local

Runway Safety Teams.

The BCAA will take the following actions:

Action OA6.1 (date: end 2014): promote the

recommendations from the EAPPRI to the airport

stakeholders and verify the implementation by

all stakeholders (including aircraft operators, Air

Navigation Service Providers and airport operators);

Action OA6.2 (date: recurring yearly): ensure that

Local Runway Safety Teams are dealing with runway

safety and runway incursions based on local risks.

Expected Safety Benefit:

Enhanced runway safety

Safety Performance Indicators:

Runway Incursions by aircraft at Belgian aerodromes;

Runway Incursions by vehicles and persons at Belgian

aerodromes;

Proportion of EAPPRI recommendations

implemented.

Safety Output Owner:

The BCAA Company Approvals Directorate;

The BCAA Airspace and Airports Directorate;

The Belgian Supervising Authority for Air Navigation

Services.

Alignment with EASp:

Safety Actions AER5.1, 5.2, 5.4 and 5.5

b. Progress on Actions

Action OA6.1:

The BCAA has been promoting the EAPRRI

recommendations to all stakeholders (the aircraft

operators, the Belgian Air Navigation Service Provider

and the airport operators). The BCAA Operations

Department has among others developed a “Notice

to Aircraft Operators” with the request to implement

the EAPPRI recommendations.

2012 Update20

all stakehold

Navigation Se

Action OA6.

Local Runway

safety and ru

Exppected Safety

Enhhanced runwa

Saffety Performa

Runway Incu

Runway Incu

aerodromes;

Proportion

implemented

Saffety Output O

The BCAA Co

The BCAA Air

The Belgian S

Services.

Aliignment with

Saffety Actions AE

b. Progress o

Action OA6

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

Runway incursion by aircraftRunway incursion by vehicle/equipmentRunway incursion by person/animal/other/unknownGo-Around/Rejected Take-off

Runway incursion occurrences in Belgium

Federal Public Service

Mobility and TransportBelgian Civil Aviation Authority

Page 23: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

Operational Actions (OA) to improve civil aviation safety 21

The BCAA has already started verifying the

implementation of EAPPRI recommendations by

all stakeholders. The verification has been done by

sending questionnaires and organizing surveys.

In addition the BCAA Airports Department checks

the compliance with EAPPRI recommendations

through audits on the airport operators. By the

end of 2012 the BCAA will compile the first results

in an overview indicating the proportion of EAPPRI

recommendations already implemented. This

overview will show the result of the combined

efforts of the stakeholders to enhancing the safety of

runway operations.

Action OA6.2: CLOSED

At every Belgian airport Local Runway Safety

Teams have been established, which comprise

representatives from aircraft operators, Air Navigation

Service Providers, airport operators and the BCAA. The

BCAA is an active member of those teams. The SMS

audits performed by the BCAA verify their existence

and effectiveness.

Page 24: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

22 2012 Update

OA7: Implementation of

a National Action Plan for

Airspace Infringement Risk

Reduction

a. Description

Airspace infringement is also referred to as unauthorized

penetration of airspace and is generally defined as a flight

into notified airspace without previously requesting and

obtaining approval from the controlling authority of that

airspace in accordance with international and national

regulations.

The table below shows the number of reported

infringements for the period 2007-2011.

Since 2007 the overall number of reported incidents is

almost constantly increasing. The upward trend may also

be influenced by the increasing awareness of this type

of risk and other improvements in the general reporting

culture.

The analysis of the reported incidents clearly indicates

that the majority of infringements are committed by

General Aviation VFR flights.

The BCAA will take the following actions:

New Action OA7.1 (date: July 2013): establish a

national action plan for airspace infringement risk

reduction derived from the European Action Plan for

Airspace Infringement Risk Reduction;

New Action OA7.2 (date: end 2014): promote and

verify the implementation of the national action plan

for airspace infringement risk reduction.

2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Airspace infringements 30 43 41 62 130

0 20 40 60 80 100

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

Fixed wing

Helicopter

Other/Unknown

Airspace infringement occurrences: aircraft types involved

Federal Public Service

Mobility and TransportBelgian Civil Aviation Authority

Page 25: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

23Operational Actions (OA) to improve civil aviation safety

Expected Safety Benefit:

Reduced Risk of Collision

Safety Performance Indicators:

Belgian airspace infringements;

Proportion of the national action plan for airspace

infringement risk reduction implemented.

Safety Output Owner:

The BCAA Licensing Directorate;

The BCAA Airspace and Airports Directorate;

The Belgian Supervising Authority for Air Navigation

Services.

Alignment with EASp:

Safety Actions AER2.1, 2.8, 2.9 and GA1.5

b. Progress on Actions

New operational actions due to the results of the BCAA

risk analysis 2011 and the alignment with the European

Aviation Safety Plan (EASp).

Page 26: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

APPENDIX 1: OUTLINE OF RISKS IN THE BELGIAN CIVIL AVIATION SECTOR

The risk management performed by the Belgian State

relates to any occurrences occurring on Belgian territory

and in Belgian airspace. In addition, occurrences

occurring on foreign territory and foreign airspace

involving Belgian aircraft operators are also included.

The various aspects of aviation are considered, including

aircraft, companies operating in the aviation sector, air

traffic control services, airports, ground equipment, etc.

2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Number of received occurrences 1853 2209 2027 2270 2586

APPENDIX 1: OUTLINE OF RISKS IN

The risk management performed by the Belgian State

relates to any occurrences occurring on Belgian territory

2012 Update24

Any occurrences reported are entered in the ECCAIRS

database, which was created by the European Union

in 2003 for the implementation of the European

Directives related to reporting aviation occurrences.

The main safety risks can be deduced from the analysis

of these occurrences, and the priorities to be set by the

management in view of accident prevention can be

determined.

Federal Public Service

Mobility and TransportBelgian Civil Aviation Authority

Page 27: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

Appendix 1: Outline of risks in the Belgian civil aviation sector 25

The BCAA risk management system for aviation

occurrences is based on the Dynamic Integrated Risk

Management (DIRM) model. The BCAA risk management

system is described in the Risk Management Procedures

Manual with reference BCAA/PM/10/INS Part II. The risk

level of a specific type of occurrence is determined by

two factors: probability and impact.

Probability represents the likelihood that an incident will

occur. In order to determine probability, the number of

occurrences of a specific type is considered that occurred

within a one-year period. Depending on the number of

occurrences, the probability is then assigned a quote on

a scale from 0 to 5.

The impact of an occurrence takes into account the

possible impact on personnel, operations, equipment,

the environment and public confidence, along with

the media attention that an occurrence may attract.

Depending on the strength of the impact, it is assigned

a quote from 1 to 5. Class 1 means that there are no

noteworthy effects while class 5 indicates potentially

disastrous effects.

The risk level of a type of incident is established by

applying a combination of probability and impact based

on the formula displayed below.

RISK LEVEL = (PROBABILITY + IMPACT) / 2

Event type Risk Level R

Near collisions - loss of separation 4,5

ACAS/TCAS triggered 4,5

Ground proximity warning 4,5

Communications pilot/ANS 4,5

Other warning system triggered 4,5

Separation provision 4

Collision aircraft-object-ground 4

Windshear 4

Ground handling services 4

Aircraft flight control 4

Landing gear 4

Turbine engine 4

Systems/crew mismatch 4

Unstabilized approach 4

Airspace infringement 4

Event type Risk Level R

Deviation/ATC clearance 4

Medical emergency - passenger 4

Vehicle/equipment operations 4

Aircraft - bird strike 4

Turbine ingestion – bird 4

Communications 3,5

Weather encounters 3,5

Interference by LASER/Beamer 3,5

Explosions / fire/ fumes / smoke 3,5

Runway incursions 3,5

Difficult / unruly passenger 3,5

Aircraft return 3,5

Declared emergency 3,5

Rejected take-off 3,5

Missed approach 3,5

The Safety Committee has discussed these types of

occurrences and subsequently addressed the aviation

risks to be handled with priority, selected by taking into

account factors such as the level of the risk-mitigation

actions already in place.

The table below shows the types of occurrences with the

highest risk levels derived from the risk analysis 2011.

Page 28: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

APPENDIX 2: BELGIAN CIVIL AVIATION SAFETY POLICY

DECISION OF THE DIRECTOR-GENERAL

Our reference: Brussels,

LA/DG/2012-875 Rev.03 08/10/2012

1. Introduction

One of the duties of the Belgian State is to create an

environment in which the aviation sector can perform its

activities at the highest possible safety level. The Belgian

Civil Aviation Authority (BCAA) is responsible, on behalf

of the Belgian State, for developing and maintaining the

Belgian Safety Programme (BSP) in accordance with the

requirements of the United Nations International Civil

Aviation Organization (ICAO).

The BSP applies to the BCAA, the Belgian Accidents and

Incidents Investigation Unit and the Ministry of Defence.

The BSP is based to a large extent on the system of risk

management.

The purpose of risk management is to prevent accidents,

personal injury and material damage. An effective risk

management policy ensures that potential causes of

safety problems can be swiftly detected and resolved

through the optimization of regulatory and supervisory

actions.

In addition, the BCAA has begun implementing one of

the main elements of the Belgian Safety Programme:

the implementation of the Safety Management Systems

(SMS) at the Belgian service providers.

APPENDIX 2: 1. Introduction

2012 Update26

Federal Public Service

Mobility and TransportBelgian Civil Aviation Authority

Page 29: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

Appendix 2: Belgian Civil Aviation Safety Policy 27

2. General provisions

a. Definitions

Belgian Safety Programme (BSP): an integrated set of

regulations and activities established by the Belgian

State aimed at managing civil aviation safety;

Occurrences: any accidents and incidents arising in

the Belgian civil aviation sector;

Safety: the state in which risks associated with

aviation activities are reduced and controlled to an

acceptable level;

Safety Management System (SMS): a systematic

approach to managing safety including the necessary

organizational structures, accountabilities, policies

and procedures;

Safety Performance: the safety achievement of the

Belgian State or of the service provider as defined by

its safety performance targets and safety performance

indicators;

Safety Performance Indicator: a data-based safety

parameter used for monitoring and assessing

performance;

Safe Performance Target: the planned or intended

objective for safety performance indicator(s) over a

given period;

Service Providers: air traffic control and air navigation

services (ATC/ANS), airport operators, aircraft

operators, approved training organizations, aero-

medical centres, organizations for flight synthetic

training devices, production organizations,

maintenance organizations and maintenance

training organizations;

Safety Risk: the predicted likelihood and severity of

the consequences or outcomes of a hazard.

b. Purpose of this document

Inciting the Belgian aviation sector and the relevant

BCAA employees to develop and maintain a culture

of safety in civil aviation;

Providing the BSP with internal management

structures that ensure its implementation; identifying

risks and potential dangers; and drafting and

amending the Belgian Safety Plan. These structures

have been established through a series of processes

and procedures.

c. Objective of the BSP

The BSP is developed to improve aviation safety

by promoting close cooperation between the

Belgian aviation sector and the BCAA.

Page 30: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

3. Strategic orientation

a. BCAA Safety Culture

As safety is of primary importance at the BCAA, the latter

will never yield to economic, commercial and political

pressure. The BCAA is committed to integrating a safety

culture into all its activities in order to ensure that aviation

safety is managed as effectively as possible.

b. Regulatory and Supervisory Activities

The BCAA is dedicated to improving cooperation with

the Belgian aviation sector in order to identify key safety

issues and optimize its regulatory and supervisory

activities.

The BCAA undertakes to modify and optimize its

regulatory and supervisory activities following the

introduction of SMS at the Belgian service providers.

The BCAA undertakes to perform safety assessments on

foreign airlines in order to ensure a standardised safety

level within the context of European regulations.

c. Belgian Safety Plan

The implementation of the BSP has resulted in the

drafting of a Belgian Safety Plan. This plan forms part

of the safety policy of the Belgian State and seeks to

eliminate potential sources of safety problems through

the optimization of regulatory and supervisory activities.

The Safety Plan, which is valid for a period of five years, is

mainly based on the operational objectives derived from

the risk management system. Recommendations and

guidelines of the Accidents and Incidents Investigation

Unit are also incorporated into the Safety Plan. The

operational objectives contained in the Safety Plan

are developed in consultation with the Belgian service

providers.

The Safety Plan is approved by the BCAA Director-

General and annually assessed and published.

d. Means and Human Resources

The allocation of means is based on the operational

activities that contribute to increasing safety levels and,

by extension, to the realization of the Belgian Safety Plan.

As part of its training programmes, the BCAA offers

training related to BSP. This training helps foster a

culture of safety and clarifies the roles played by each

of the parties in implementing the plan.

e. Internal quality audits

The BCAA internal audits are conducted in accordance

with the processes and procedures contained in the

Quality Manual. These compliance audits serve to

establish whether the BCAA Departments respect

the regulations and correctly execute the applicable

processes, procedures and guidelines.

The internal audits are performed on the basis of an audit

programme approved annually by the BCAA Director-

General. The audits, which are based on the PDCA cycle

(‘Plan, Do, Check, Act’), contribute to the continuous

improvement of the operational activities.

2012 Update28

Federal Public Service

Mobility and TransportBelgian Civil Aviation Authority

Page 31: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

Appendix 2: Belgian Civil Aviation Safety Policy

4. Organization of the BSP

a. Scope of the risk management

The BCAA is responsible for collecting and managing

the aviation occurrences reported to the BCAA by the

service providers. Risk management relates both to

aviation occurrences occurring on Belgian territory

and those occurring in Belgian airspace. In addition,

occurrences occurring on foreign territory and foreign

airspace involving Belgian airlines are registered in the

risk management system as well.

b. Procedures and processes

The BCAA has a number of processes and procedures in

place designed to effectively implement the BSP. These

processes and procedures are approved by the Director-

General and subsequently managed by the relevant

BCAA departments. The processes and procedures of the

Accidents and Incidents Investigation Unit are approved

by the Chairman of the Federal Public Service for Mobility

and Transport in order to protect the independence of

this unit.

c. Safety Committee

The Safety Committee is comprised of the Director-

General, the directors of the operational departments,

the risk manager and the manager of the Accidents

and Incidents Investigation Unit. The Safety Committee,

which convenes three times per year, is responsible for:

discussing and selecting the aviation risks to be

handled with priority;

taking corrective actions where necessary;

assessing, approving, modifying and following up

these corrective actions;

validating and amending the Belgian Safety Plan.

d. Risk manager

The risk manager is responsible for:

collecting data on, and managing, aviation

occurrences;

participating in bimonthly meetings regarding

occurrences that require immediate action;

performing the risk analysis (i.e. preparing a list of

risks to be handled with priority);

drafting the Belgian Safety Plan, including annual

changes and updates.

e. Operational Departments

The operational departments are responsible for:

performing regulatory and supervisory activities;

proposing, implementing and realising corrective

actions in order to increase aviation safety;

participating in bimonthly meetings regarding

occurrences that require immediate action;

investigating these occurrences if necessary.

f. Involvement of external departments

The BCAA has signed a Service Level Agreement (SLA)

with the Accidents and Incidents Investigation Unit in

order to ensure smooth cooperation between these two

entities.

The BCAA has regular consultations with the Ministry of

Defence with regard to common interests in the domains

of ANS/ ATC, Search & Rescue and aerodromes.

29

Page 32: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

g. Coordination with international agencies

The BCAA supports the initiatives to develop and

implement the European Aviation Safety Programme

and Plan at the level of the European Aviation Safety

Agency (EASA).

The BCAA also supports the initiatives of the European

Regional Aviation Safety Group (RASG-EUR) at the level

of the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) to

implement the Global Aviation Safety Plan (GASP) and

the Global Aviation Safety Roadmap (GASR).

h. Consultation with the Belgian aviation sector

The BCAA organizes periodic consultative meetings

with representatives of the Belgian aviation sector

(e.g. representatives of Belgian service providers, pilots’

associations, aviation clubs, etc.).

These meetings have the following objectives:

conducting a debate on safety levels in the Belgian

civil aviation sector;

communicating achievements related to the BSP to

aviation sector representatives;

presenting the Belgian Safety Plan to aviation sector

representatives, including any modifications and

updates;

consulting on the policy objectives of the Belgian

Safety Plan (including on the relevance of the risks to

be handled with priority).

The Belgian Safety Plan is assessed and published

annually. The Belgian service providers and aviation

associations receive a copy of the Safety Plan each year.

2012 Update30

i. Internal communication

The employees of the BCAA and the Accidents and

Incidents Investigation Unit are annually informed about

the Belgian Safety Plan and any amendments to this plan.

The employees of the BCAA and the Accidents and

Incidents Investigation Unit are informed about the

Belgian Civil Aviation Safety Policy and any amendments

to this policy.

g y y y

to this policy.

Frank Durinckx

The BCAA Director-General

Federal Public Service

Mobility and TransportBelgian Civil Aviation Authority

Page 33: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

Belgian CAA Risk Management Process 31

BELGIAN CAA RISK MANAGEMENT PROCESS

Occurence Reports from

Aviation Industry

Process 3: Yearly Risk Analysis of

Occurrences by Risk

Manager

Process 1 (SPOC): Data Collection &

Storage in ECCAIRS

Process 2: Bimonthly BCAA

meetings concerning

analysis of individual

occurrences requiring

immediate action

BCAA Safety Committee

Prioritize Risk Domains

Evaluation

Risk Mitigation (Actions & Projects)

Process 4: Draw-up and realize

five-yearly Belgian Safety Plan

Aviation Industry &

BCAA Directorates

Project/Action closed Project/Action continues

Page 34: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

32 2012 Update

NOTES

Page 35: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

NOTES

Page 36: BELGIAN SAFETY PLAN SAFETY PLAN - Sprachauswahl · 2015-09-23 · 2 #FMHJBO 4BGFUZ 1MBO t 2012 Update OUTLINE The present document is the second update of the 2010-2014 Belgian Safety

Federal Public Service

Mobility and TransportBelgian Civil Aviation Authority

Federal Public Service

Mobility and TransportBelgian Civil Aviation Authority