building public infrastructure in a representative democracy

104
June 2009 Rationality, Behaviour and Experi ments Moscow 1 Building Public Infrastructure in a Representative Democracy Marco Battaglini Princeton University and CEPR Salvatore Nunnari Caltech Thomas Palfrey Caltech

Upload: mannix-duke

Post on 03-Jan-2016

55 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Building Public Infrastructure in a Representative Democracy. Marco Battaglini Princeton University and CEPR Salvatore Nunnari Caltech Thomas Palfrey Caltech. Public Infrastructure. New dynamic approach to the political economy of public investment - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

  • Building Public Infrastructure in a Representative Democracy Marco Battaglini Princeton University and CEPRSalvatore Nunnari CaltechThomas PalfreyCaltech

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Public Infrastructure

    New dynamic approach to the political economy of public investmentMany public goods are durable and cannot be produced overnight. Call this Public InfrastructureExamples:Transportation networksDefense infrastructureThree key features of public infrastructure:Public goodDurability current investment has lasting value Dynamics takes time to build

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Government and Public Infrastructure

    A major function of governments is the development and maintenance of lasting public goods.

    How do political institutions affect provision?Federalist systems: DecentralizedProvinces, States, Counties, etc.Centralized/Representative: Legislatures and Parliaments

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Theoretical Approach

    Simple infinite horizon model of building public infrastructure. Similar to capital accumulation modelsCharacterize the planners (optimal) solution as benchmarkCompare Institutions for making these decisionsTwo modelsCentralized (Representative Legislature):Legislative bargaining modelDecentralized (Autarky)Simultaneous independent decision making at district level

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Empirical Approach

    Laboratory ExperimentsControl the driving parameters (environment) of modelPreferences, Technology, EndowmentsMechanism: Rules of the gameIncentivize behavior with moneyTheory gives us predictionsEquilibrium behavior and Time paths of investmentDifferences across mechanisms and environmentsExperiments give us dataCompare theory and data

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • The Model

    n districts, i=1,,n each of equal sizeInfinite horizon. Discrete timeTwo goodsPrivate good xPublic good g (durable). Initial level g0Public policy in period t: zt=(xt,gt) where xt=(xt1,,xtn)Each district endowment in each period ti=W/nSocietal endowment WEndowment can be consumed (xt ) or invested (It)Public good technology. Depreciation rate d

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • The Model

    FeasibilityBudget balanceCan rewrite Budget balance as:Preferencesu () < 0u() > 0u(0) = u() = 0

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Planners Problem (optimum)Notice y0 constraint not binding because of Inada conditionsHence rewrite optimization problem as:Denote: value function vp(.) aggregate consumption X=xi

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Optimal Policy

    Denote optimal policy by y^(g). Optimal steady state yp*Three phases:Rapid growth It = WMaintenance of steady state 0 < It < WDecline It 0Depends on whether nonnegativity constraint on consumption is binding

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Optimal Path

    Case 1: Constraint binding Rapid growthI = Wyt = W + (1-d)gt-1Case 2: Constraint not binding. Steady state: y* = W + (1-d)gt-1Solves: nu(y*) + v(y*) = 1Corresponds to two phasesMaintenance of steady state 0 < It < WDecline It 0

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Optimal Path

    Switch from growth to maintenance phase at gp

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Optimal Path

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Optimal PathSummary of optimal policy:

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Planners solution 1y*pgpW1-dgp/(1-d)y(g)g

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Planners solution 2y*pgpWgp/(1-d)y(g)g

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Optimal Path: Exampleu(y) = y/

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • The Legislative MechanismLegislature decides policy in each periodNon-negative transfers, x1,,xnLevel of public good y= (1-d)g + W xiRandom recognition ruleProposer offers proposal (x,y)Committee votes using qualified majority rule (q)If proposal fails, then y = 0, xi = i = W/n for all i

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • The Legislative MechanismProposers Maximization Problem:Note: (1) Proposal is (x,s,y) (2) s is the private allocation offered to each of the (q-1) other members of the coalition. (3) x is the private allocation to the proposer (4) First constraint is IC: Other members of the coalition are willing to vote for the proposal. (5) v() is the value function for continuing next period at state y.

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • The Legislative MechanismProposers Maximization Problem:Several cases, depending on state, g=yt-1, and on whether IC is binding.

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • In the other case, we have W-y(g)+(1-d)g=0, i.e., x(g)=0.This occurs when g < g1(y1*)

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • IC Bindings > 0 CASE

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • IC Bindings = 0 CASE

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • LEGISLATIVE MECHANISM INVESTMENT FUNCTIONNote: Investment function is not monotonically decreasing!Investment is increasing in third region g2 < g < g3

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • y*1g11g3g2y*2y*2/(1-d)45oLegislative Mechanism 1

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • y*1g11g3g2y*2y*2/(1-d)q>qLegislative Mechanism 1

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • y*1g11g3g2y*2y*2/(1-d)45oLegislative Mechanism 2

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • y*1g11g3g2y*2y*2/(1-d)45oLegislative Mechanism 3

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • LEGISLATIVE MECHANISM VALUE FUNCTIONNote: Value function is monotonically increasing!Investment is increasing in third region g2 < g < g3

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • LEGISLATIVE MECHANISM VALUE FUNCTIONRelationship between v and (y1*,y2*)

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Illustration of Legislative Bargaining Equilibriumu=2y1/2n=3q=2W=15=.75d=0

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • COMPUTING THE EQUILIBRIUMExploit the relationship between v and (y1*,y2*)

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • The Autarky MechanismIn each period, each district simultaneously decides its own policy for how to divide i = W/n between private consumption and public good investment.District can disinvest up to 1/n share of gSymmetric Markov perfect equilibrium

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • The Autarky MechanismDistricts Maximization Problem:For each g, a district chooses the district-optimal feasible xi taking as given that other districts current decision is given by x(g), and assuming that all districts future decisions in the future are given by x(g)A symmetric equilibrium is a district-consumption function x(g)

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • The Autarky Mechanism

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • The Autarky Mechanism

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • The Autarky MechanismExample with power utility function u = By/:In planners solution, the denominator equals 1-(1-d)[Typo: Exponent Should be 1/(1-)]

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • y*vgV11-dAutarky Mechanism

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Summary of theory and possible extensions

    New Approach to the Political Economy of Public Investment.

    Applies equally as a model of capital accumulationCentralized representative system much better than decentralizedStill significant inefficiencies with majority ruleHigher q leads to greater efficiency theoreticallyWhy not q=n?Model can be extended to other political institutionsElectionsRegional aggregation (subnational)Different legislative institutions (parties, etc.)Model can be extended to allow for more complex economic institutionsDebt and taxation, Multiple projects, Heterogeneity

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Experimental Design

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Experimental Design

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Experiment ImplementationDiscount factor implemented by random stopping rule. (pr{continue}=.75)Game durations from 1 period to 13 periods in our dataMultiple committees simultaneously processed (5x3 and 3x4)Payoffs rescaled to allow fractional decisionsCaltech subjects. Experiments conducted at SSELMultistage game software package10 matches in each sessionSubjects paid the sum of earnings in all periods of all matchesTotal earnings ranged from $20 to $50Sessions lasted between 1 and 2 hours

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Sample Screens:Legislative Mechanism

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Sample Screens:Autarky Mechanism

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • RESULTS

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

  • L5 ALL COMMITTEE PATHS. PERIOD 1

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

    Chart11

    7.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    12.8333

    20.5

    29.8333

    29.8333

    29.8333

    L5

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.8333

    320.5

    429.8333

    529.8333

    629.8333

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    320.5

    429.8333

    529.8333

    629.8333

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    320.5353416.666666666740.333333333310.333333333340203543.33333333334036.6666666667221745404038.33333333336026.666666666729.3333333333454040354053.333333333347485020

    429.8333

    529.8333

    629.8333

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    320.5353416.666666666740.333333333310.333333333340203543.33333333334036.6666666667221745404038.33333333336026.666666666729.3333333333454040354053.333333333347485020

    429.833335341033.333333333346.6666666667404038.33333333338046.666666666733.66666666676551.66666666674546.66666666675263.33333333336

    529.8333

    629.8333

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    320.5353416.666666666740.333333333310.333333333340203543.33333333334036.6666666667221745404038.33333333336026.666666666729.3333333333454040354053.333333333347485020

    429.833335341033.333333333346.6666666667404038.33333333338046.666666666733.66666666676551.66666666674546.66666666675263.33333333336

    529.8333353413.333333333318.333333333358.333333333310066.666666666740.33333333338566.66666666674546.666666666725.333333333373.333333333326

    629.8333

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    320.5353416.666666666740.333333333310.333333333340203543.33333333334036.6666666667221745404038.33333333336026.666666666729.3333333333454040354053.333333333347485020

    429.833335341033.333333333346.6666666667404038.33333333338046.666666666733.66666666676551.66666666674546.66666666675263.33333333336

    529.8333353413.333333333318.333333333358.333333333310066.666666666740.33333333338566.66666666674546.666666666725.333333333373.333333333326

    629.8333353413.333333333338.333333333358.333333333312056.66666666674546.666666666725.333333333373.333333333326

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    L5

    L3

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    A5

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    A3

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    213

    316

    416

    516

    616

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    21322.5307.513.7527.5307.53030303022.53026.252423.753028.526.25303030151522.5303026.2526.2518.7526.253062.52011.2523.751522.518.751822.522.53.7518.75303029.2518.7518.75303030

    316

    416

    516

    616

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    21322.5307.513.7527.5307.53030303022.53026.252423.753028.526.25303030151522.5303026.2526.2518.7526.253062.52011.2523.751522.518.751822.522.53.7518.75303029.2518.7518.75303030

    3163041.251513.7541.25451541.25454533.7533.7533.754031.533.7541.2540.533.7532.2542.754515153027.7541.2528.56.75522.2522.532.518.7533.754537.53321.7515

    416

    516

    616

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    21322.5307.513.7527.5307.53030303022.53026.252423.753028.526.25303030151522.5303026.2526.2518.7526.253062.52011.2523.751522.518.751822.522.53.7518.75303029.2518.7518.75303030

    3163041.251513.7541.25451541.25454533.7533.7533.754031.533.7541.2540.533.7532.2542.754515153027.7541.2528.56.75522.2522.532.518.7533.754537.53321.7515

    4164045151604522.552.560037.541.2537.5553941.254551453650.2552.53022.597.52624.7541.2522.537.521.7530

    516

    616

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    21322.5307.513.7527.5307.53030303022.53026.252423.753028.526.25303030151522.5303026.2526.2518.7526.253062.52011.2523.751522.518.751822.522.53.7518.75303029.2518.7518.75303030

    3163041.251513.7541.25451541.25454533.7533.7533.754031.533.7541.2540.533.7532.2542.754515153027.7541.2528.56.75522.2522.532.518.7533.754537.53321.7515

    4164045151604522.552.560037.541.2537.5553941.254551453650.2552.53022.597.52624.7541.2522.537.521.7530

    5165056.251518.25048.753060452.531.543.550.256041.2522.510.516.2528.2528.55027.536.7521.7545

    616

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    21322.5307.513.7527.5307.53030303022.53026.252423.753028.526.25303030151522.5303026.2526.2518.7526.253062.52011.2523.751522.518.751822.522.53.7518.75303029.2518.7518.75303030

    3163041.251513.7541.25451541.25454533.7533.7533.754031.533.7541.2540.533.7532.2542.754515153027.7541.2528.56.75522.2522.532.518.7533.754537.53321.7515

    4164045151604522.552.560037.541.2537.5553941.254551453650.2552.53022.597.52624.7541.2522.537.521.7530

    5165056.251518.25048.753060452.531.543.550.256041.2522.510.516.2528.2528.55027.536.7521.7545

    6166556.252518.257.552.556045106.543.550.256052.522.511.2516.2543.2528.553.7542.5

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.38

    31.38

    41.38

    51.38

    61.38

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.3819.7513.252422.254015.7515.527.535159.538.5203825.252222.52813.25344029.524.755.7519.53718.75211016.7512.517713.255.53.56.754.7516.756.752.250.51.752.750.7516.252.2520.25

    31.38

    41.38

    51.38

    61.38

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.3819.7513.252422.254015.7515.527.535159.538.5203825.252222.52813.25344029.524.755.7519.53718.75211016.7512.517713.255.53.56.754.7516.756.752.250.51.752.750.7516.252.2520.25

    31.3816.58.53128.7548154134717.511.51484835.7537.255.7517.58.59.751.2534.250.753.25521.51.7521.25412.5

    41.38

    51.38

    61.38

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.3819.7513.252422.254015.7515.527.535159.538.5203825.252222.52813.25344029.524.755.7519.53718.75211016.7512.517713.255.53.56.754.7516.756.752.250.51.752.750.7516.252.2520.25

    31.3816.58.53128.7548154134717.511.51484835.7537.255.7517.58.59.751.2534.250.753.25521.51.7521.25412.5

    41.380.253.252915.255.53.55.25718.7554537.519.548.7510.758.252.250.52.55.7541955

    51.38

    61.38

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.3819.7513.252422.254015.7515.527.535159.538.5203825.252222.52813.25344029.524.755.7519.53718.75211016.7512.517713.255.53.56.754.7516.756.752.250.51.752.750.7516.252.2520.25

    31.3816.58.53128.7548154134717.511.51484835.7537.255.7517.58.59.751.2534.250.753.25521.51.7521.25412.5

    41.380.253.252915.255.53.55.25718.7554537.519.548.7510.758.252.250.52.55.7541955

    51.388.751.256.75123.7514.55.25318.52.2528.5018.558.2512.751.257.53.59.753.252.75

    61.38

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.3819.7513.252422.254015.7515.527.535159.538.5203825.252222.52813.25344029.524.755.7519.53718.75211016.7512.517713.255.53.56.754.7516.756.752.250.51.752.750.7516.252.2520.25

    31.3816.58.53128.7548154134717.511.51484835.7537.255.7517.58.59.751.2534.250.753.25521.51.7521.25412.5

    41.380.253.252915.255.53.55.25718.7554537.519.548.7510.758.252.250.52.55.7541955

    51.388.751.256.75123.7514.55.25318.52.2528.5018.558.2512.751.257.53.59.753.252.75

    61.3813.25724.253.51.2527.755.258.522.7514.2540.256.75483

    y*(g*)

    11.77117.259.256.257.759.7511.597.2511.57.58.2511.256.259.257.759.58.58.257.56.59610.258.256.759.757.567.259.57.759.254.2512.25413.755.258.55.58.57.2581144.54.510.56.257.2569.58.58.59.2564.512.255.7577.2511.257.253.58.53.5108.58.56

    21.77

    31.77

    41.77

    51.77

    61.77

    y*(g*)

    11.77117.259.256.257.759.7511.597.2511.57.58.2511.256.259.257.759.58.58.257.56.59610.258.256.759.757.567.259.57.759.254.2512.25413.755.258.55.58.57.2581144.54.510.56.257.2569.58.58.59.2564.512.255.7577.2511.257.253.58.53.5108.58.56

    21.77211018.54.7511.522.2510.7518.520.75518.7515.2516.7514.51211515.57.2516.5175.7515811.256.7515.756.519943.517.753.510.56.518.2511.757.259.7512.514.57.5177.55.5

    31.77

    41.77

    51.77

    61.77

    y*(g*)

    11.77117.259.256.257.759.7511.597.2511.57.58.2511.256.259.257.759.58.58.257.56.59610.258.256.759.757.567.259.57.759.254.2512.25413.755.258.55.58.57.2581144.54.510.56.257.2569.58.58.59.2564.512.255.7577.2511.257.253.58.53.5108.58.56

    21.77211018.54.7511.522.2510.7518.520.75518.7515.2516.7514.51211515.57.2516.5175.7515811.256.7515.756.519943.517.753.510.56.518.2511.757.259.7512.514.57.5177.55.5

    31.77418518.75112.2517.5114.750.54.7531.752.259.750.54.7521.751.513.552718.52.754.2511.52210.2525.2514.753.75

    41.77

    51.77

    61.77

    y*(g*)

    11.77117.259.256.257.759.7511.597.2511.57.58.2511.256.259.257.759.58.58.257.56.59610.258.256.759.757.567.259.57.759.254.2512.25413.755.258.55.58.57.2581144.54.510.56.257.2569.58.58.59.2564.512.255.7577.2511.257.253.58.53.5108.58.56

    21.77211018.54.7511.522.2510.7518.520.75518.7515.2516.7514.51211515.57.2516.5175.7515811.256.7515.756.519943.517.753.510.56.518.2511.757.259.7512.514.57.5177.55.5

    31.77418518.75112.2517.5114.750.54.7531.752.259.750.54.7521.751.513.552718.52.754.2511.52210.2525.2514.753.75

    41.7710.51110.57.753.258.554.54.50.753.25624.53.2511234.517.52.750.58.752914.75

    51.77

    61.77

    y*(g*)

    11.77117.259.256.257.759.7511.597.2511.57.58.2511.256.259.257.759.58.58.257.56.59610.258.256.759.757.567.259.57.759.254.2512.25413.755.258.55.58.57.2581144.54.510.56.257.2569.58.58.59.2564.512.255.7577.2511.257.253.58.53.5108.58.56

    21.77211018.54.7511.522.2510.7518.520.75518.7515.2516.7514.51211515.57.2516.5175.7515811.256.7515.756.519943.517.753.510.56.518.2511.757.259.7512.514.57.5177.55.5

    31.77418518.75112.2517.5114.750.54.7531.752.259.750.54.7521.751.513.552718.52.754.2511.52210.2525.2514.753.75

    41.7710.51110.57.753.258.554.54.50.753.25624.53.2511234.517.52.750.58.752914.75

    51.7721.56.5130.250.751252.59.52.7535.25272.251.7532.753.753612.5

    61.77

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

  • L5 ALL COMMITTEE PATHS. PERIOD 2

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

    Chart12

    7.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    12.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    20.5

    29.8333

    29.8333

    29.8333

    L5

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.8333

    320.5

    429.8333

    529.8333

    629.8333

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    320.5

    429.8333

    529.8333

    629.8333

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    320.5353416.666666666740.333333333310.333333333340203543.33333333334036.6666666667221745404038.33333333336026.666666666729.3333333333454040354053.333333333347485020

    429.8333

    529.8333

    629.8333

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    320.5353416.666666666740.333333333310.333333333340203543.33333333334036.6666666667221745404038.33333333336026.666666666729.3333333333454040354053.333333333347485020

    429.833335341033.333333333346.6666666667404038.33333333338046.666666666733.66666666676551.66666666674546.66666666675263.33333333336

    529.8333

    629.8333

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    320.5353416.666666666740.333333333310.333333333340203543.33333333334036.6666666667221745404038.33333333336026.666666666729.3333333333454040354053.333333333347485020

    429.833335341033.333333333346.6666666667404038.33333333338046.666666666733.66666666676551.66666666674546.66666666675263.33333333336

    529.8333353413.333333333318.333333333358.333333333310066.666666666740.33333333338566.66666666674546.666666666725.333333333373.333333333326

    629.8333

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    320.5353416.666666666740.333333333310.333333333340203543.33333333334036.6666666667221745404038.33333333336026.666666666729.3333333333454040354053.333333333347485020

    429.833335341033.333333333346.6666666667404038.33333333338046.666666666733.66666666676551.66666666674546.66666666675263.33333333336

    529.8333353413.333333333318.333333333358.333333333310066.666666666740.33333333338566.66666666674546.666666666725.333333333373.333333333326

    629.8333353413.333333333338.333333333358.333333333312056.66666666674546.666666666725.333333333373.333333333326

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    L5

    L3

    A5

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    A3

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    213

    316

    416

    516

    616

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    21322.5307.513.7527.5307.53030303022.53026.252423.753028.526.25303030151522.5303026.2526.2518.7526.253062.52011.2523.751522.518.751822.522.53.7518.75303029.2518.7518.75303030

    316

    416

    516

    616

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    21322.5307.513.7527.5307.53030303022.53026.252423.753028.526.25303030151522.5303026.2526.2518.7526.253062.52011.2523.751522.518.751822.522.53.7518.75303029.2518.7518.75303030

    3163041.251513.7541.25451541.25454533.7533.7533.754031.533.7541.2540.533.7532.2542.754515153027.7541.2528.56.75522.2522.532.518.7533.754537.53321.7515

    416

    516

    616

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    21322.5307.513.7527.5307.53030303022.53026.252423.753028.526.25303030151522.5303026.2526.2518.7526.253062.52011.2523.751522.518.751822.522.53.7518.75303029.2518.7518.75303030

    3163041.251513.7541.25451541.25454533.7533.7533.754031.533.7541.2540.533.7532.2542.754515153027.7541.2528.56.75522.2522.532.518.7533.754537.53321.7515

    4164045151604522.552.560037.541.2537.5553941.254551453650.2552.53022.597.52624.7541.2522.537.521.7530

    516

    616

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    21322.5307.513.7527.5307.53030303022.53026.252423.753028.526.25303030151522.5303026.2526.2518.7526.253062.52011.2523.751522.518.751822.522.53.7518.75303029.2518.7518.75303030

    3163041.251513.7541.25451541.25454533.7533.7533.754031.533.7541.2540.533.7532.2542.754515153027.7541.2528.56.75522.2522.532.518.7533.754537.53321.7515

    4164045151604522.552.560037.541.2537.5553941.254551453650.2552.53022.597.52624.7541.2522.537.521.7530

    5165056.251518.25048.753060452.531.543.550.256041.2522.510.516.2528.2528.55027.536.7521.7545

    616

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    21322.5307.513.7527.5307.53030303022.53026.252423.753028.526.25303030151522.5303026.2526.2518.7526.253062.52011.2523.751522.518.751822.522.53.7518.75303029.2518.7518.75303030

    3163041.251513.7541.25451541.25454533.7533.7533.754031.533.7541.2540.533.7532.2542.754515153027.7541.2528.56.75522.2522.532.518.7533.754537.53321.7515

    4164045151604522.552.560037.541.2537.5553941.254551453650.2552.53022.597.52624.7541.2522.537.521.7530

    5165056.251518.25048.753060452.531.543.550.256041.2522.510.516.2528.2528.55027.536.7521.7545

    6166556.252518.257.552.556045106.543.550.256052.522.511.2516.2543.2528.553.7542.5

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.38

    31.38

    41.38

    51.38

    61.38

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.3819.7513.252422.254015.7515.527.535159.538.5203825.252222.52813.25344029.524.755.7519.53718.75211016.7512.517713.255.53.56.754.7516.756.752.250.51.752.750.7516.252.2520.25

    31.38

    41.38

    51.38

    61.38

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.3819.7513.252422.254015.7515.527.535159.538.5203825.252222.52813.25344029.524.755.7519.53718.75211016.7512.517713.255.53.56.754.7516.756.752.250.51.752.750.7516.252.2520.25

    31.3816.58.53128.7548154134717.511.51484835.7537.255.7517.58.59.751.2534.250.753.25521.51.7521.25412.5

    41.38

    51.38

    61.38

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.3819.7513.252422.254015.7515.527.535159.538.5203825.252222.52813.25344029.524.755.7519.53718.75211016.7512.517713.255.53.56.754.7516.756.752.250.51.752.750.7516.252.2520.25

    31.3816.58.53128.7548154134717.511.51484835.7537.255.7517.58.59.751.2534.250.753.25521.51.7521.25412.5

    41.380.253.252915.255.53.55.25718.7554537.519.548.7510.758.252.250.52.55.7541955

    51.38

    61.38

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.3819.7513.252422.254015.7515.527.535159.538.5203825.252222.52813.25344029.524.755.7519.53718.75211016.7512.517713.255.53.56.754.7516.756.752.250.51.752.750.7516.252.2520.25

    31.3816.58.53128.7548154134717.511.51484835.7537.255.7517.58.59.751.2534.250.753.25521.51.7521.25412.5

    41.380.253.252915.255.53.55.25718.7554537.519.548.7510.758.252.250.52.55.7541955

    51.388.751.256.75123.7514.55.25318.52.2528.5018.558.2512.751.257.53.59.753.252.75

    61.38

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.3819.7513.252422.254015.7515.527.535159.538.5203825.252222.52813.25344029.524.755.7519.53718.75211016.7512.517713.255.53.56.754.7516.756.752.250.51.752.750.7516.252.2520.25

    31.3816.58.53128.7548154134717.511.51484835.7537.255.7517.58.59.751.2534.250.753.25521.51.7521.25412.5

    41.380.253.252915.255.53.55.25718.7554537.519.548.7510.758.252.250.52.55.7541955

    51.388.751.256.75123.7514.55.25318.52.2528.5018.558.2512.751.257.53.59.753.252.75

    61.3813.25724.253.51.2527.755.258.522.7514.2540.256.75483

    y*(g*)

    11.77117.259.256.257.759.7511.597.2511.57.58.2511.256.259.257.759.58.58.257.56.59610.258.256.759.757.567.259.57.759.254.2512.25413.755.258.55.58.57.2581144.54.510.56.257.2569.58.58.59.2564.512.255.7577.2511.257.253.58.53.5108.58.56

    21.77

    31.77

    41.77

    51.77

    61.77

    y*(g*)

    11.77117.259.256.257.759.7511.597.2511.57.58.2511.256.259.257.759.58.58.257.56.59610.258.256.759.757.567.259.57.759.254.2512.25413.755.258.55.58.57.2581144.54.510.56.257.2569.58.58.59.2564.512.255.7577.2511.257.253.58.53.5108.58.56

    21.77211018.54.7511.522.2510.7518.520.75518.7515.2516.7514.51211515.57.2516.5175.7515811.256.7515.756.519943.517.753.510.56.518.2511.757.259.7512.514.57.5177.55.5

    31.77

    41.77

    51.77

    61.77

    y*(g*)

    11.77117.259.256.257.759.7511.597.2511.57.58.2511.256.259.257.759.58.58.257.56.59610.258.256.759.757.567.259.57.759.254.2512.25413.755.258.55.58.57.2581144.54.510.56.257.2569.58.58.59.2564.512.255.7577.2511.257.253.58.53.5108.58.56

    21.77211018.54.7511.522.2510.7518.520.75518.7515.2516.7514.51211515.57.2516.5175.7515811.256.7515.756.519943.517.753.510.56.518.2511.757.259.7512.514.57.5177.55.5

    31.77418518.75112.2517.5114.750.54.7531.752.259.750.54.7521.751.513.552718.52.754.2511.52210.2525.2514.753.75

    41.77

    51.77

    61.77

    y*(g*)

    11.77117.259.256.257.759.7511.597.2511.57.58.2511.256.259.257.759.58.58.257.56.59610.258.256.759.757.567.259.57.759.254.2512.25413.755.258.55.58.57.2581144.54.510.56.257.2569.58.58.59.2564.512.255.7577.2511.257.253.58.53.5108.58.56

    21.77211018.54.7511.522.2510.7518.520.75518.7515.2516.7514.51211515.57.2516.5175.7515811.256.7515.756.519943.517.753.510.56.518.2511.757.259.7512.514.57.5177.55.5

    31.77418518.75112.2517.5114.750.54.7531.752.259.750.54.7521.751.513.552718.52.754.2511.52210.2525.2514.753.75

    41.7710.51110.57.753.258.554.54.50.753.25624.53.2511234.517.52.750.58.752914.75

    51.77

    61.77

    y*(g*)

    11.77117.259.256.257.759.7511.597.2511.57.58.2511.256.259.257.759.58.58.257.56.59610.258.256.759.757.567.259.57.759.254.2512.25413.755.258.55.58.57.2581144.54.510.56.257.2569.58.58.59.2564.512.255.7577.2511.257.253.58.53.5108.58.56

    21.77211018.54.7511.522.2510.7518.520.75518.7515.2516.7514.51211515.57.2516.5175.7515811.256.7515.756.519943.517.753.510.56.518.2511.757.259.7512.514.57.5177.55.5

    31.77418518.75112.2517.5114.750.54.7531.752.259.750.54.7521.751.513.552718.52.754.2511.52210.2525.2514.753.75

    41.7710.51110.57.753.258.554.54.50.753.25624.53.2511234.517.52.750.58.752914.75

    51.7721.56.5130.250.751252.59.52.7535.25272.251.7532.753.753612.5

    61.77

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

  • L5 ALL COMMITTEE PATHS. PERIOD 3

    Rationality, Behaviour and Experiments Moscow

    Chart13

    7.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    12.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    20.5353416.666666666740.333333333310.333333333340203543.33333333334036.6666666667221745404038.33333333336026.666666666729.3333333333454040354053.333333333347485020

    29.8333

    29.8333

    29.8333

    L5

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.8333

    320.5

    429.8333

    529.8333

    629.8333

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    320.5

    429.8333

    529.8333

    629.8333

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    320.5353416.666666666740.333333333310.333333333340203543.33333333334036.6666666667221745404038.33333333336026.666666666729.3333333333454040354053.333333333347485020

    429.8333

    529.8333

    629.8333

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    320.5353416.666666666740.333333333310.333333333340203543.33333333334036.6666666667221745404038.33333333336026.666666666729.3333333333454040354053.333333333347485020

    429.833335341033.333333333346.6666666667404038.33333333338046.666666666733.66666666676551.66666666674546.66666666675263.33333333336

    529.8333

    629.8333

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    320.5353416.666666666740.333333333310.333333333340203543.33333333334036.6666666667221745404038.33333333336026.666666666729.3333333333454040354053.333333333347485020

    429.833335341033.333333333346.6666666667404038.33333333338046.666666666733.66666666676551.66666666674546.66666666675263.33333333336

    529.8333353413.333333333318.333333333358.333333333310066.666666666740.33333333338566.66666666674546.666666666725.333333333373.333333333326

    629.8333

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    320.5353416.666666666740.333333333310.333333333340203543.33333333334036.6666666667221745404038.33333333336026.666666666729.3333333333454040354053.333333333347485020

    429.833335341033.333333333346.6666666667404038.33333333338046.666666666733.66666666676551.66666666674546.66666666675263.33333333336

    529.8333353413.333333333318.333333333358.333333333310066.666666666740.33333333338566.66666666674546.666666666725.333333333373.333333333326

    629.8333353413.333333333338.333333333358.333333333312056.66666666674546.666666666725.333333333373.333333333326

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    L5

    L3

    A5

    A3

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    213

    316

    416

    516

    616

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    21322.5307.513.7527.5307.53030303022.53026.252423.753028.526.25303030151522.5303026.2526.2518.7526.253062.52011.2523.751522.518.751822.522.53.7518.75303029.2518.7518.75303030

    316

    416

    516

    616

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    21322.5307.513.7527.5307.53030303022.53026.252423.753028.526.25303030151522.5303026.2526.2518.7526.253062.52011.2523.751522.518.751822.522.53.7518.75303029.2518.7518.75303030

    3163041.251513.7541.25451541.25454533.7533.7533.754031.533.7541.2540.533.7532.2542.754515153027.7541.2528.56.75522.2522.532.518.7533.754537.53321.7515

    416

    516

    616

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    21322.5307.513.7527.5307.53030303022.53026.252423.753028.526.25303030151522.5303026.2526.2518.7526.253062.52011.2523.751522.518.751822.522.53.7518.75303029.2518.7518.75303030

    3163041.251513.7541.25451541.25454533.7533.7533.754031.533.7541.2540.533.7532.2542.754515153027.7541.2528.56.75522.2522.532.518.7533.754537.53321.7515

    4164045151604522.552.560037.541.2537.5553941.254551453650.2552.53022.597.52624.7541.2522.537.521.7530

    516

    616

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    21322.5307.513.7527.5307.53030303022.53026.252423.753028.526.25303030151522.5303026.2526.2518.7526.253062.52011.2523.751522.518.751822.522.53.7518.75303029.2518.7518.75303030

    3163041.251513.7541.25451541.25454533.7533.7533.754031.533.7541.2540.533.7532.2542.754515153027.7541.2528.56.75522.2522.532.518.7533.754537.53321.7515

    4164045151604522.552.560037.541.2537.5553941.254551453650.2552.53022.597.52624.7541.2522.537.521.7530

    5165056.251518.25048.753060452.531.543.550.256041.2522.510.516.2528.2528.55027.536.7521.7545

    616

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    21322.5307.513.7527.5307.53030303022.53026.252423.753028.526.25303030151522.5303026.2526.2518.7526.253062.52011.2523.751522.518.751822.522.53.7518.75303029.2518.7518.75303030

    3163041.251513.7541.25451541.25454533.7533.7533.754031.533.7541.2540.533.7532.2542.754515153027.7541.2528.56.75522.2522.532.518.7533.754537.53321.7515

    4164045151604522.552.560037.541.2537.5553941.254551453650.2552.53022.597.52624.7541.2522.537.521.7530

    5165056.251518.25048.753060452.531.543.550.256041.2522.510.516.2528.2528.55027.536.7521.7545

    6166556.252518.257.552.556045106.543.550.256052.522.511.2516.2543.2528.553.7542.5

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.38

    31.38

    41.38

    51.38

    61.38

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.3819.7513.252422.254015.7515.527.535159.538.5203825.252222.52813.25344029.524.755.7519.53718.75211016.7512.517713.255.53.56.754.7516.756.752.250.51.752.750.7516.252.2520.25

    31.38

    41.38

    51.38

    61.38

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.3819.7513.252422.254015.7515.527.535159.538.5203825.252222.52813.25344029.524.755.7519.53718.75211016.7512.517713.255.53.56.754.7516.756.752.250.51.752.750.7516.252.2520.25

    31.3816.58.53128.7548154134717.511.51484835.7537.255.7517.58.59.751.2534.250.753.25521.51.7521.25412.5

    41.38

    51.38

    61.38

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.3819.7513.252422.254015.7515.527.535159.538.5203825.252222.52813.25344029.524.755.7519.53718.75211016.7512.517713.255.53.56.754.7516.756.752.250.51.752.750.7516.252.2520.25

    31.3816.58.53128.7548154134717.511.51484835.7537.255.7517.58.59.751.2534.250.753.25521.51.7521.25412.5

    41.380.253.252915.255.53.55.25718.7554537.519.548.7510.758.252.250.52.55.7541955

    51.38

    61.38

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.3819.7513.252422.254015.7515.527.535159.538.5203825.252222.52813.25344029.524.755.7519.53718.75211016.7512.517713.255.53.56.754.7516.756.752.250.51.752.750.7516.252.2520.25

    31.3816.58.53128.7548154134717.511.51484835.7537.255.7517.58.59.751.2534.250.753.25521.51.7521.25412.5

    41.380.253.252915.255.53.55.25718.7554537.519.548.7510.758.252.250.52.55.7541955

    51.388.751.256.75123.7514.55.25318.52.2528.5018.558.2512.751.257.53.59.753.252.75

    61.38

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.3819.7513.252422.254015.7515.527.535159.538.5203825.252222.52813.25344029.524.755.7519.53718.75211016.7512.517713.255.53.56.754.7516.756.752.250.51.752.750.7516.252.2520.25

    31.3816.58.53128.7548154134717.511.51484835.7537.255.7517.58.59.751.2534.250.753.25521.51.7521.25412.5

    41.380.253.252915.255.53.55.25718.7554537.519.548.7510.758.252.250.52.55.7541955

    51.388.751.256.75123.7514.55.25318.52.2528.5018.558.2512.751.257.53.59.753.252.75

    61.3813.25724.253.51.2527.755.258.522.7514.2540.256.75483

    y*(g*)

    11.77117.259.256.257.759.7511.597.2511.57.58.2511.256.259.257.759.58.58.257.56.59610.258.256.759.757.567.259.57.759.254.2512.25413.755.258.55.58.57.2581144.54.510.56.257.2569.58.58.59.2564.512.255.7577.2511.257.253.58.53.5108.58.56

    21.77

    31.77

    41.77

    51.77

    61.77

    y*(g*)

    11.77117.259.256.257.759.7511.597.2511.57.58.2511.256.259.257.759.58.58.257.56.59610.258.256.759.757.567.259.57.759.254.2512.25413.755.258.55.58.57.2581144.54.510.56.257.2569.58.58.59.2564.512.255.7577.2511.257.253.58.53.5108.58.56

    21.77211018.54.7511.522.2510.7518.520.75518.7515.2516.7514.51211515.57.2516.5175.7515811.256.7515.756.519943.517.753.510.56.518.2511.757.259.7512.514.57.5177.55.5

    31.77

    41.77

    51.77

    61.77

    y*(g*)

    11.77117.259.256.257.759.7511.597.2511.57.58.2511.256.259.257.759.58.58.257.56.59610.258.256.759.757.567.259.57.759.254.2512.25413.755.258.55.58.57.2581144.54.510.56.257.2569.58.58.59.2564.512.255.7577.2511.257.253.58.53.5108.58.56

    21.77211018.54.7511.522.2510.7518.520.75518.7515.2516.7514.51211515.57.2516.5175.7515811.256.7515.756.519943.517.753.510.56.518.2511.757.259.7512.514.57.5177.55.5

    31.77418518.75112.2517.5114.750.54.7531.752.259.750.54.7521.751.513.552718.52.754.2511.52210.2525.2514.753.75

    41.77

    51.77

    61.77

    y*(g*)

    11.77117.259.256.257.759.7511.597.2511.57.58.2511.256.259.257.759.58.58.257.56.59610.258.256.759.757.567.259.57.759.254.2512.25413.755.258.55.58.57.2581144.54.510.56.257.2569.58.58.59.2564.512.255.7577.2511.257.253.58.53.5108.58.56

    21.77211018.54.7511.522.2510.7518.520.75518.7515.2516.7514.51211515.57.2516.5175.7515811.256.7515.756.519943.517.753.510.56.518.2511.757.259.7512.514.57.5177.55.5

    31.77418518.75112.2517.5114.750.54.7531.752.259.750.54.7521.751.513.552718.52.754.2511.52210.2525.2514.753.75

    41.7710.51110.57.753.258.554.54.50.753.25624.53.2511234.517.52.750.58.752914.75

    51.77

    61.77

    y*(g*)

    11.77117.259.256.257.759.7511.597.2511.57.58.2511.256.259.257.759.58.58.257.56.59610.258.256.759.757.567.259.57.759.254.2512.25413.755.258.55.58.57.2581144.54.510.56.257.2569.58.58.59.2564.512.255.7577.2511.257.253.58.53.5108.58.56

    21.77211018.54.7511.522.2510.7518.520.75518.7515.2516.7514.51211515.57.2516.5175.7515811.256.7515.756.519943.517.753.510.56.518.2511.757.259.7512.514.57.5177.55.5

    31.77418518.75112.2517.5114.750.54.7531.752.259.750.54.7521.751.513.552718.52.754.2511.52210.2525.2514.753.75

    41.7710.51110.57.753.258.554.54.50.753.25624.53.2511234.517.52.750.58.752914.75

    51.7721.56.5130.250.751252.59.52.7535.25272.251.7532.753.753612.5

    61.77

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    MBD0004241B.xls

    Chart12

    7.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    12.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    20.5

    29.8333

    29.8333

    29.8333

    L5

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.8333

    320.5

    429.8333

    529.8333

    629.8333

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    320.5

    429.8333

    529.8333

    629.8333

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    320.5353416.666666666740.333333333310.333333333340203543.33333333334036.6666666667221745404038.33333333336026.666666666729.3333333333454040354053.333333333347485020

    429.8333

    529.8333

    629.8333

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    320.5353416.666666666740.333333333310.333333333340203543.33333333334036.6666666667221745404038.33333333336026.666666666729.3333333333454040354053.333333333347485020

    429.833335341033.333333333346.6666666667404038.33333333338046.666666666733.66666666676551.66666666674546.66666666675263.33333333336

    529.8333

    629.8333

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    320.5353416.666666666740.333333333310.333333333340203543.33333333334036.6666666667221745404038.33333333336026.666666666729.3333333333454040354053.333333333347485020

    429.833335341033.333333333346.6666666667404038.33333333338046.666666666733.66666666676551.66666666674546.66666666675263.33333333336

    529.8333353413.333333333318.333333333358.333333333310066.666666666740.33333333338566.66666666674546.666666666725.333333333373.333333333326

    629.8333

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    roundy*(g*)

    17.8333010.3333333333202010.333333333320201516.666666666716.3333333333202016.3333333333202016.666666666720202016.66666666672020208.33333333331720202013.3333333333206.66666666670510520202011.6666666667202002020202020202020202042042020202020

    212.833318.333333333320.666666666716.66666666672510.333333333340203536.66666666673025404036.666666666731.33333333332040153725402033.33333333334013.33333333339.333333333325302526.6666666667404015404074033.33333333332740404040425404020

    320.5353416.666666666740.333333333310.333333333340203543.33333333334036.6666666667221745404038.33333333336026.666666666729.3333333333454040354053.333333333347485020

    429.833335341033.333333333346.6666666667404038.33333333338046.666666666733.66666666676551.66666666674546.66666666675263.33333333336

    529.8333353413.333333333318.333333333358.333333333310066.666666666740.33333333338566.66666666674546.666666666725.333333333373.333333333326

    629.8333353413.333333333338.333333333358.333333333312056.66666666674546.666666666725.333333333373.333333333326

    729.8333

    829.8333

    929.8333

    1029.8333

    L5

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    L3

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    A5

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    A3

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    213

    316

    416

    516

    616

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    21322.5307.513.7527.5307.53030303022.53026.252423.753028.526.25303030151522.5303026.2526.2518.7526.253062.52011.2523.751522.518.751822.522.53.7518.75303029.2518.7518.75303030

    316

    416

    516

    616

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    21322.5307.513.7527.5307.53030303022.53026.252423.753028.526.25303030151522.5303026.2526.2518.7526.253062.52011.2523.751522.518.751822.522.53.7518.75303029.2518.7518.75303030

    3163041.251513.7541.25451541.25454533.7533.7533.754031.533.7541.2540.533.7532.2542.754515153027.7541.2528.56.75522.2522.532.518.7533.754537.53321.7515

    416

    516

    616

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    21322.5307.513.7527.5307.53030303022.53026.252423.753028.526.25303030151522.5303026.2526.2518.7526.253062.52011.2523.751522.518.751822.522.53.7518.75303029.2518.7518.75303030

    3163041.251513.7541.25451541.25454533.7533.7533.754031.533.7541.2540.533.7532.2542.754515153027.7541.2528.56.75522.2522.532.518.7533.754537.53321.7515

    4164045151604522.552.560037.541.2537.5553941.254551453650.2552.53022.597.52624.7541.2522.537.521.7530

    516

    616

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    21322.5307.513.7527.5307.53030303022.53026.252423.753028.526.25303030151522.5303026.2526.2518.7526.253062.52011.2523.751522.518.751822.522.53.7518.75303029.2518.7518.75303030

    3163041.251513.7541.25451541.25454533.7533.7533.754031.533.7541.2540.533.7532.2542.754515153027.7541.2528.56.75522.2522.532.518.7533.754537.53321.7515

    4164045151604522.552.560037.541.2537.5553941.254551453650.2552.53022.597.52624.7541.2522.537.521.7530

    5165056.251518.25048.753060452.531.543.550.256041.2522.510.516.2528.2528.55027.536.7521.7545

    616

    roundy*(g*)

    157.5153.7513.7513.7515015151515151515151515151512.515151515151515151515151515151515151515153.750157.5157.57.58.757.511.253.7514.251511.253.7511.25151511.253.7515151511.25151515151515

    21322.5307.513.7527.5307.53030303022.53026.252423.753028.526.25303030151522.5303026.2526.2518.7526.253062.52011.2523.751522.518.751822.522.53.7518.75303029.2518.7518.75303030

    3163041.251513.7541.25451541.25454533.7533.7533.754031.533.7541.2540.533.7532.2542.754515153027.7541.2528.56.75522.2522.532.518.7533.754537.53321.7515

    4164045151604522.552.560037.541.2537.5553941.254551453650.2552.53022.597.52624.7541.2522.537.521.7530

    5165056.251518.25048.753060452.531.543.550.256041.2522.510.516.2528.2528.55027.536.7521.7545

    6166556.252518.257.552.556045106.543.550.256052.522.511.2516.2543.2528.553.7542.5

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.38

    31.38

    41.38

    51.38

    61.38

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.3819.7513.252422.254015.7515.527.535159.538.5203825.252222.52813.25344029.524.755.7519.53718.75211016.7512.517713.255.53.56.754.7516.756.752.250.51.752.750.7516.252.2520.25

    31.38

    41.38

    51.38

    61.38

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.3819.7513.252422.254015.7515.527.535159.538.5203825.252222.52813.25344029.524.755.7519.53718.75211016.7512.517713.255.53.56.754.7516.756.752.250.51.752.750.7516.252.2520.25

    31.3816.58.53128.7548154134717.511.51484835.7537.255.7517.58.59.751.2534.250.753.25521.51.7521.25412.5

    41.38

    51.38

    61.38

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.3819.7513.252422.254015.7515.527.535159.538.5203825.252222.52813.25344029.524.755.7519.53718.75211016.7512.517713.255.53.56.754.7516.756.752.250.51.752.750.7516.252.2520.25

    31.3816.58.53128.7548154134717.511.51484835.7537.255.7517.58.59.751.2534.250.753.25521.51.7521.25412.5

    41.380.253.252915.255.53.55.25718.7554537.519.548.7510.758.252.250.52.55.7541955

    51.38

    61.38

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.3819.7513.252422.254015.7515.527.535159.538.5203825.252222.52813.25344029.524.755.7519.53718.75211016.7512.517713.255.53.56.754.7516.756.752.250.51.752.750.7516.252.2520.25

    31.3816.58.53128.7548154134717.511.51484835.7537.255.7517.58.59.751.2534.250.753.25521.51.7521.25412.5

    41.380.253.252915.255.53.55.25718.7554537.519.548.7510.758.252.250.52.55.7541955

    51.388.751.256.75123.7514.55.25318.52.2528.5018.558.2512.751.257.53.59.753.252.75

    61.38

    roundy*(g*)

    11.3812.759.251417.2513.751313.52010.5131617.512.2511.520162014.51614201218.5201613161419.51213.751011.511.512.513.7512.756.512.756.5813.7510.755.757.564.51010.752136.565.5610.7519.754.251.75

    21.3819.7513.252422.254015.7515.527.535159.538.5203825.252222.52813.25344029.524.755.7519.53718.75211016.7512.517713.255.53.56.754.7516.756.752.250.51.752.750.7516.252.2520.25

    31.3816.58.53128.7548154134717.511.51484835.7537.255.7517.58.59.751.2534.250.753.25521.51.7521.25412.5

    41.380.253.252915.255.53.55.25718.7554537.519.548.7510.758.252.250.52.55.7541955

    51.388.751.256.75123.7514.55.25318.52.2528.5018.558.2512.751.257.53.59.753.252.75

    61.3813.25724.253.51.2527.755.258.522.7514.2540.256.75483

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    y*(g*)

    11.77117.259.256.257.759.7511.597.2511.57.58.2511.256.259.257.759.58.58.257.56.59610.258.256.759.757.567.259.57.759.254.2512.25413.755.258.55.58.57.2581144.54.510.56.257.2569.58.58.59.2564.512.255.7577.2511.257.253.58.53.5108.58.56

    21.77

    31.77

    41.77

    51.77

    61.77

    y*(g*)

    11.77117.259.256.257.759.7511.597.2511.57.58.2511.256.259.257.759.58.58.257.56.59610.258.256.759.757.567.259.57.759.254.2512.25413.755.258.55.58.57.2581144.54.510.56.257.2569.58.58.59.2564.512.255.7577.2511.257.253.58.53.5108.58.56

    21.77211018.54.7511.522.2510.7518.520.75518.7515.2516.7514.51211515.57.2516.5175.7515811.256.7515.756.519943.517.753.510.56.518.2511.757.259.7512.514.57.5177.55.5

    31.77

    41.77

    51.77

    61.77

    y*(g*)

    11.77117.259.256.257.759.7511.597.2511.57.58.2511.256.259.257.759.58.58.257.56.59610.258.256.759.757.567.259.57.759.254.2512.25413.755.258.55.58.57.2581144.54.510.56.257.2569.58.58.59.2564.512.255.7577.2511.257.253.58.53.5108.58.56

    21.77211018.54.7511.522.2510.7518.520.75518.7515.2516.7514.51211515.57.2516.5175.7515811.256.7515.756.519943.517.753.510.56.518.2511.757.259.7512.514.57.5177.55.5

    31.77418518.75112.2517.5114.750.54.7531.752.259.750.54.7521.751.513.552718.52.754.2511.52210.2525.2514.753.75

    41.77

    51.77

    61.77

    y*(g*)

    11.77117.259.256.257.759.7511.597.2511.57.58.2511.256.259.257.759.58.58.257.56.59610.258.256.759.757.567.259.57.759.254.2512.25413.755.258.55.58.57.2581144.54.510.56.257.2569.58.58.59.2564.512.255.7577.2511.257.253.58.53.5108.58.56

    21.77211018.54.7511.522.2510.7518.520.75518.7515.2516.7514.51211515.57.2516.5175.7515811.256.7515.756.519943.517.753.510.56.518.2511.757.259.7512.514.57.5177.55.5

    31.77418518.75112.2517.5114.750.54.7531.752.259.750.54.7521.751.513.552718.52.754.2511.52210.2525.2514.753.75

    41.7710.51110.57.753.258.554.54.50.753.25624.53.2511234.517.52.750.58.752914.75

    51.77

    61.77

    y*(g*)

    11.77117.259.256.257.759.7511.597.2511.57.58.2511.256.259.257.759.58.58.257.56.59610.258.256.759.757.567.259.57.759.254.2512.25413.755.258.55.58.57.2581144.54.510.56.257.2569.58.58.59.2564.512.255.7577.2511.257.253.58.53.5108.58.56

    21.77211018.54.7511.522.2510.7518.520.75518.7515.2516.7514.51211515.57.2516.5175.7515811.256.7515.756.519943.517.753.510.56.518.2511.757.259.7512.514.57.5177.55.5

    31.77418518.75112.2517.5114.750.54.7531.752.259.750.54.7521.751.513.552718.52.754.2511.52210.2525.2514.753.75

    41.7710.51110.57.753.258.554.54.50.753.25624.53.2511234.517.52.750.58.752914.75

    51.7721.56.5130.250.751252.59.52.7535.25272.251.7532.753.753612.5

    61.77

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

    00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000