by mary l. mccain · 2018-04-26 · the power of technology to transform adult learning expanding...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Expanding Access to Adult Education& Workforce Skills Through
Distance Learning
by Mary L. McCain
Council for Advancement of Adult Literacy
1221 Avenue of the Americas - 46th FloorNew York, N.Y. 10020
http://www.caalusa.org
October 21, 2009
![Page 2: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
THEPOWEROFTECHNOLOGYTOTRANSFORMADULTLEARNING
ExpandingAccesstoAdultEducation
&WorkforceSkillsThroughDistanceLearning
byMaryL.McCain
October21,2009
Council for Advancement of Adult Literacy
1221AvenueoftheAmericas–46thFloorNewYork,NY10020www.caalusa.org
![Page 3: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
[Eds. Gail Spangenberg and Bess Heitner] Rev. links 10-23-09 © Council for Advancement of Adult Literacy
![Page 4: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
i
TABLEOFCONTENTSFOREWORD iiEXECUTIVESUMMARY iiiINTRODUCTION 1I.THECONTEXTFORTECHNOLOGYDEPLOYMENT 2A.WhatisICTLiteracy? 2B.TheToolsofTechnology 4C.ConfrontingForcesThatWorkAgainstProgress 6II.HELPINGADULTSACHIEVETHEIRGOALS 10A.DistanceEducationWorks 10
1.PositiveLearnerOutcomes 102.PersistenceandMotivation 123. Self‐Study 13
B.Access 131. AccessandConnectivity 142. ICTLiteracy 15
C.GoingtoScale 171. ChangingtheContext 172. SupportingtheLearnernottheSystem 18
III.RECENTRESEARCHFINDINGS 20A.CaliforniaDistanceLearningProject 21B.Portland’sLongitudinalStudyofAdultLearning 22C.ProjectIDEAL 23D.TheNationalResearchandDevelopmentCenterforAdultLiteracy(U.K.) 24E.TheLiteracyandBasicSkillsProgramsoftheOntarioMinistry 24 OfTraining,CollegesandUniversities(MTCU)F.InvestigatingtheLanguageandLiteracyRequirementsforIndependent 25Onlinelearning(NationalInstituteforLiteracy)G.EvaluationofEvidence‐BasedPracticesinOnlineLearning:AMeta‐Analysis 26andReviewofOnlineLearningStudies(U.S.DepartmentofEducation)IV.BUILDINGTHEFOUNDATION:Next‐StepRecommendations 28A.EstablishingANationalWebPortal 28B.EncouragingStateLeadership 33C.SupportingDistanceLearningPrograms 34D.MeetingTheResearchNeed 34E.FosteringStakeholderlnvolvement 35 V.CONCLUSION 37 AppendixA.AbouttheStudyDirector 38AppendixB.ProfessionalAdvisors 39AppendixC.Endnotes 41AppendixD.ToolsofTechnology 47 AppendixE.SelectedProgramsandStateModels 52AppendixF.Bibliography 59
![Page 5: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
ii
FOREWORDInearly2009,theCouncilforAdvancementofAdultLiteracy(CAAL)launchedaprojecttofurtherdevelopthetechnologyrecommendationsproposedbytheNationalCommissiononAdultLiteracyinReachHigher,America.THEPOWEROFTECHNOLOGYTOTRANSFORMADULTLEARNING:ExpandingAccesstoAdultEducation&WorkforceSkillsThroughDistanceLearningistheresultofthateffort.FederalandstategovernmentistheprimaryaudienceforTHEPOWEROFTECHNOLOGY,butCAALalsoaimstoguideprivatesectorengagementandassistprogramandcurriculumdevelopmentbyadulteducationandworkforceskillsprovidersatthenational,state,andlocallevels.Totheseends,THEPOWEROFTECHNOLOGYoffersaprimeronthetoolsoftechnology,reviewsthefindingsofrecentresearchondistancelearning,andpresentsawiderangeofotherinformationandanalysis.Italsorecommendsfederalandstateactioninfivemajorareas,alldirectedatscalinguptomoreeffectivelymeetnationalneed.Therecommendationsarerealisticandattainable.TheviewsinTHEPOWEROFTECHNOLOGYaresolelythoseofCAALandstudydirectorMaryMcCain(seeAppendixA).Dr.McCainisSeniorVicePresidentofTechVision21.Shebroughtextensiveknowledge,insight,andanopenmindtothetaskandCAALisdeeplygratefulforherenormouscontributiontoadvancingtheCommission’svision.Wearealsogratefultoouroutstandingteamofprofessionaladvisors,especiallythosewhogavetheirwisdomandexperienceasmembersofourcoreworkinggroup(seeAppendixB).WealsowanttorecognizethemanyotherresearchersandpractitionerswhohavecarriedoutimportantdevelopmentalandresearchworkintheareastreatedbyTHEPOWEROFTECHNOLOGYovertheyears.Iffundingsupportbecomesavailablealongthelinesrecommended,manyofthemarepoisedtodoevenmore.Theirworkisevidentthroughoutthispaper.Wealsowanttothankourorganizationalandindividualdonors,includingtheDollarGeneralCorporation(themajorfunderoftheNationalCommission),theJoyceFoundation,theWal‐MartFoundation,theCharlesStewartMottFoundation,andTheMcGraw‐HillCompanies.WeextendspecialthankstoHaroldW.McGraw,Jr.,whohaspersistedformorethan20yearsinhisfinancialandpersonalsupportofadulteducation.HehelpedfundtheNationalCommissionandremainsamajorsupporterofCAAL’swork.Thesteadfastcommitmentandgenerosityofalloftheseleadershasmadethisprojectpossible.
GailSpangenbergPresident,CAAL
![Page 6: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
iii
EXECUTIVESUMMARYThereisahighlycompellingcaseforusingtechnologyonalargescaletoincreaseaccesstoandimproveAmerica’sadulteducationandworkforceskillsenterprise.Manyofthereportsthathaveexaminedadultworkforcedevelopmentinthepastfewyearshavereachedthissameconclusion,includingReachHigher,America*(June2008)fromtheNationalCommissiononAdultLiteracy.BythereckoningoftheCommissionandothers,thenationmustreachmanymoremillionsofadultswitheffectivecollege‐andjob‐readinessskillsprogramsinthenextdecadeandbeyond.Werisklosingournation’seconomicviability,standardofliving,andcoredemocraticprinciplesifwedonot.Butwecannotbringaboutneededreformwithoutdeployingtechnologyonanunprecedentedscale.AsTHEPOWEROFTECHNOLOGYTOTRANSFORMADULTLEARNINGmakesclear,thismeanstheextensiveuseofdistancelearningandallofthetoolsinourdistancelearningarsenal.Fortunately,wedonotneedtostartfromscratchwithprogramsandmaterials.Allkindsofcontentisavailableasafoundationonwhichtobuildandawidevarietyofexistingandemergingtechnology(detailedinAppendicesDandE)canbepressedintoservice.Aswegetstarted,afewfundamentalfactsmustberecognized:• Somecollegeeducationorjobtrainingisrequiredforthemajorityofjobsnowandinthe
future.Yet,nearlyhalfofallAmericanadults,includingthoseintheworkplace,needsomelevelofskillsupgradingtogetintocollegeorjobtrainingortoadvanceinjobs(88millionto90millionindividualsaged16andolder).
• Informationandcommunicationstechnologyskills(ICTliteracy)areessential,bothonand
offthejobandthereisconsiderableworktobedoneonthisfront.Some70percentofalljobsintheU.S.willrequiresomelevelofICTskillsby2016).
• Manygoodtechnology‐basedprogramsexist–forskillsupgrading,professional
development,andprogrammanagementpurposes–butaccesstoinformationaboutthemislimited.Notenoughpeopleknowabouteitherthetoolsavailableortheprogramsandcontentdesignedforthem.
• Existingprogramsneedrigorousevaluationtoassurehighqualityandrelevancefordiverse
learnerneedsinself‐studyenvironments,and,additionally,newprogramsofconsistentlyhighqualityandrelevancyneedtobedeveloped.
• Planningfortechnologyuseneedstobesetintocomprehensivestatewideadulteducation
andworkforceskillsdevelopmentplans.
*Gotohttp://www.nationalcommissiononadultliteracy.org.
![Page 7: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
iv
• Learnersateventhelowestlevelsofliteracyandlanguageproficiencycanengagewith
onlinelearningcontent.Reportsindicatethattheyareeagertodosoandthattheybenefitinimportantways,e.g.,self‐confidence,self‐directedness,andindependence.Adultsacrosstheliteracyandlanguagespectrumshowstrongmotivationtogaincomputerliteracyskills,perceivedaskeytoworkadvancement.Infact,timespentinemploymentandexposuretoICTsubstantiallyenhanceliteracyproficiencygenerally.
• Technologyplaysaprominentandincreasingroleineverydaylifeandatwork.Accessto
itandconnectivitytotheInternetaregrowingrapidly,evenamonglow‐skilledadults.(Despitethehighercostsofbroadband,63percentofallAmericanshavebroadbandconnectivityathome,some77percentofadultshaveacomputer,and84percenthaveacellphone.)However,althoughaccessisgrowingamongallcategoriesofusers,thedigitaldivideremainsproblematicforcertaincategoriesofpotentiallearners,especiallythoseatthelowestskillslevelsandmostinneedofservices.
• WhetheranadulthasnoexperienceusingcomputersortheInternetoriswell‐versedinICT
skills,technologyoffersanentirelynewenvironmentandlearningexperiencethataddstoorcangobeyondthetraditionalclassroomexperienceofinstructor‐ledtext‐basedformats.Researchshowsthatself‐studythroughdistancelearning–wherematerialsaredeliveredthroughavarietyofmedia–holdshighpromiseintermsoflearninggains,andpersistenceandmotivationaremarkedlybetterthanintraditionalclassroom‐onlysettings,evenforlow‐skilledlearners.
FIVENEXT‐STEPRECOMMENDATIONSA. EstablishingaNationalWebPortal.Asatoppriority,thefederalgovernmentshould
establishanationalwebportal.Informationabouttechnology‐basedprogramoptionsmustbemadeavailablenationally,onacomprehensiveandcrediblebasistobothadultlearnersandprogramprofessionals,inordertosignificantlyexpandaccesstolearning.Theportalshouldbedesignedtoserveeffectivelytheuniquelydifferentlearningneedsandgoalsofthetwodifferentusergroups.Specialconsiderationsareneededtoensurenavigationeaseandappealtoadultlearners,includinglow‐literacyadultswithlimitedICTskills.Sustaineddisseminationandeffectivepromotionwillbenecessarytoensurethatinformationreachesthetargetaudienceseffectively.ThisportalshouldbetheresponsibilityofeithertheNationalInstituteforLiteracyorotherauthorizedfederalagency.ThespecifictechnicalrequirementsfortheportalshouldbedeterminedbyabroadlyrepresentativeAdvisoryBoard.
B. EncouragingStateLeadership.Thefederalgovernmentshouldlaunchagrantprogramto
helpstatesintegratetechnology‐assistedlearningsystemsand/orprogramsintotheiroveralladulteducationandworkforceskillsplanning.Self‐studyactivitiesmustbegroundedinparticularstateandregionalserviceprogramswherelearninggainscanbeformallyverified,andwherecommunitiesofneedcanbereachedthroughtargetedawarenessand
![Page 8: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
v
outreachcampaigns.Stateplanningandleadershipmustgohandinhandwithfederalleadership,althoughstatesmustseeadulteducationastheirownissue.
C. SupportingtheDevelopmentofDistanceLearningPrograms.Projectsshouldbe
undertakenbyfederalandstategovernmentthatfocusondistancelearningcertifications,performancemeasuresthatcertifyICTliteracy,onlineassessmentoflearning,testingandadaptationofnewformsoftechnology‐basedlearning,aligningunitsofsuccessfullearningwithcommunitycollegecredits,andotherareasofdevelopmentalneed.
D. MeetingtheResearchNeed.Thefederalgovernmentshouldsupportasustained,serious,
andwell‐fundedresearch,analysis,andevaluationeffort–tosupportandinformtheuseoftechnologyanddistancelearningforadulteducationandworkforceskillspurposes,andtoenrichthenationalwebportalonanongoingbasis.Forexample,weneedbetterbaselinedataonadultlearnersandcomputeruse,andweneedevaluationofself‐studylearningasitrelatestospecificeducationoutcomes(gettingaGED,gainingEnglishproficiency,demonstratingreadinessforjobsandcollege).Weneedtoknowaboutthekindsoftechnology‐assistedlearningadultsactuallyfindanduse,whyandhowtheyuseit,andwhetheritiseffectiveinachievingtheoutcomestheysought,andifso,why.WeneedtoknowmuchmoreabuttheconditionsunderwhichsuccessfulInternet‐basedinteractivelearningtakesplace.
E. FosteringStakeholderInvolvement.Federalandstategovernmentshouldprovide
incentivesforinvolvingafullrangeofnongovernmentalstakeholdergroups.Theyshouldundertakespecificprojectstoencouragecollaborationamongallsortsofgroupsatalllevels–includingadulteducatorsandworkforceskillsexperts,planningagencies,businesses,unions,youthpolicyorganizations,familyliteracygroups,correctionalinstitutions,schooldistricts,communitycolleges,healthcareentities,andothers.TheNationalInstituteforLiteracyorotherappropriateentityshouldestablishastateadvisorycommitteespecificallyrepresentingthesegroups.Corporateandphilanthropicsourceshaveaspecialroletoplayandarenaturalpartnersindevelopingtherecommendednationalwebportal.Theyshouldbecalledupontocontributeequipment,grants,employeetime,andtechnicalassistance.
CONCLUDINGNOTEItisnotpracticalordesirabletoabandonourcurrentservicesystem,norisitviabletosimplycontinuetweakingit.Wehavethemeansandknow‐howforasubstantialredirectionofthenationaladulteducationandworkforceskillseffortwithtechnologyasourally.Weneedwholesalechange;thewiderandwiseruseoftechnologycanhelpbringitabout.
![Page 9: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
1
THEPOWEROFTECHNOLOGYTOTRANSFORMADULTLEARNING
ExpandingAccesstoAdultEducation
&WorkforceSkillsThroughDistanceLearning
Thechallengeisclear;thecountrymustsuccessfullyreengageadultswhohavetoolittleeducation(knowledgeandskills)toholdlivingwagejobs.Failuretodosoputsthenationatcompetitiverisk.Risingtothechallengewillrequiredevelopingnewstrategiesandnewtools.Theoldoneshaveproventobeinsufficienttothetask.[NCHEMS]1
INTRODUCTIONnReachHigher,America(June2008),theNationalCommissiononAdultLiteracyfoundthatabouthalfallAmericanadultslackthebasicandsoft*skillsneededtogetandadvancein
21stcenturyjobsthatpayafamily‐sustainingwage.Itcalledfortransformingthecurrentfragmentedservicesofferedbyadultbasiceducationandworkforceskillsdevelopmentgroupsintoacoherentintegratedsystemwithoutcomestomeet21stcenturyneeds.Atstake,theCommissionemphasized,isnothinglessthanAmerica’sabilitytocompeteglobally,remainnationallysecure,andretainitscoredemocraticprinciples.TheCommissiontookasitsfocusthe88millionadults,aged16andabove,whohaveatleastonemajoreducationalbarriertoacquiringjobaccessandadmissiontopostsecondaryeducation2–highschooldropouts,adultswithhighschooldiplomaswhoarenotcollege‐orjob‐ready,andadultsinneedofEnglishlanguageservices.Thereportemphasizedthatabouthalfoftheworkforceisdeficientintheessentialbasicandsoftskills,andthatsometwo‐thirdsoftheworkforceisbeyondthereachofK‐12schools.Adultswhoneedbasicandworkplaceskills,includingEnglishlanguageservices,mustrelyontheexisting“system”thatprovidesthiseducation.Yetnotonlyisthissystemfragmentedandsiloed,butitisequippedtoserveonlyasmallpercentageofthoseinneed.3TheCommissioncalledonCongresstocreateanadulteducationandworkforceskillssystemwiththecapacitytoeffectivelyserveatleast20millionadultsannuallybytheyear2020,upfromthe3millioncurrentlybeingservedbythemajorfederalprograms.Itrecognizedthatthisgoalcouldnotbeaccomplishedwithoutheavyandinnovativeuseoftechnology–toexpandservicestoadultsthroughdistancelearningandself‐study,andtoprovidecostefficientapproachestoprogramanddatamanagement.4Indeed,oneoftheCommission’sninekeyrecommendationswastodeploytechnologyonanunprecedentedscale.*Thebasicskills,asdefinedbytheCommission,arereading,writing,math,andEnglishlanguageproficiency.Softskillsaretheabilitytocommunicate,acquireinformation,thinkcritically,solveproblems,usetechnology,andworkinteams.
I
![Page 10: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
2
TheCommissionstatedthat:“Technologyshouldbeusedinallitsformstomakelearningacontinuousprocessofinquiryandimprovementthatkeepspacewiththespeedofchangeinbusinessandsociety.”I.THECONTEXTFORTECHNOLOGYDEPLOYMENT
echnologyisnopanaceaforsolvingthenation’sadulteducationandworkforceskillsproblems,buttheCommission,someleadersinCongress,andmanyothershaverecently
recognizedthatitmustbeacentralcomponentofanyseriousnationalefforttoimproveandexpandserviceonthescaleneeded.Foronething,theadulteducationandworkforceskillssystemtheCommissioncallsforcannotaccommodatemorethanafractionofadultsinneedwithoutthehelpoftechnology.Foranother,wenowliveinaworldthatfunctionsincreasinglyinatechnology‐encompassedmode,andlearningandworkarelessandlessaccessibletothosewhocannotusetechnology.Strongtechnologyskillsareessentialforadultsseekingtoimprovetheirknowledge,skills,andEnglishability,andthisisthecasewhetherthegoalistoattainaGEDortoenrollinfurthereducationorjobtraining.Fortunately,wedonotneedtostartfromscratchinputtingtechnologytowideruse.ManygoodGED,postsecondary,andjob‐relatededucationprogramsarealreadyavailableviadistancelearningandtheyprovideafoundationonwhichtobuild.Furthermore,informationaboutprograms,courses,andcertificationisincreasinglyavailableonline,andindeedonline‐onlyapplicationsforeducationorjobsarebecomingmorecommon.Evaluating,adapting,anddevelopingthemodelswealreadyhave(seeAppendixE,p.52forsomeexamples)canprovidetheflexibilityandoptionsforself‐pacedlearningthatadultsfrequentlyrequireontheirpathstohighereducationandemployability.Moreover,theObamaAdministrationrecentlylaunchedthe“AmericanGraduationInitiative,”whichprovidesfordeveloping1,000freeonlinecourses,availablenationwidethroughcommunitycollegesandarticulatedtodegreerequirements.5ButtakingadvantageofcurrentanddevelopingopportunitiesinaninformationsocietyrequiresthatindividualsandprogrammanagershaveICTliteracy(informationandcommunicationstechnologyskills).Italsorequiresthatweallunderstandwhatthe“toolsoftechnology”areandwhattheyaregoodfor,andthatwelearnfromandbuildonwhatwealreadyknow.A.WhatIsICTLiteracy?ThebasicelementsofICTliteracy–sometimescalled“informationliteracy,”or“digitalliteracy”–aregenerallydefinedasfollows:• Access–Knowingaboutandknowinghowtocollectand/orretrieveinformation.Searching,
finding/locating,andretrievinginformationindigitalenvironments.
T
![Page 11: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
3
• Manage–Applyinganexistingorganizationalorclassificationscheme.Conductingarudimentaryandpreliminaryorganizationofaccessedinformationforretrievalandfutureapplication.
• Integrate–Interpretingandrepresentinginformation(summarizing,comparing,and
contrasting)materialfrommultiplesourcesbyusingICTtools.• Evaluate–Makingjudgmentsaboutthequality,relevance,usefulness,orefficiencyof
information.Judgingthecurrency,appropriateness,andadequacyofinformationandinformationsourcesforaspecificpurpose(includingdeterminingauthority,bias,andtimelinesofmaterials).
• Create–Generatinginformationbyadapting,applying,designing,inventing,orauthoring
informationinICTenvironmentstodescribeanevent,expressanopinion,orsupportabasicargument,viewpoint,orposition.
• Communicate–Communicatinginformationpersuasivelytomeetneedsofvarious
audiencesthroughuseofanappropriatemedium.Communicating,adapting,andpresentinginformationproperlyinitscontext(audience,media)inICTenvironmentsandforapeeraudience.
Jobsatalllevelsnowdemandthatemployeesnotonlyhaveahighschooldiplomabutalso,atleastminimally,theabilitytouseinformationandcommunicationstechnologies.Astechnologyhasbecomemorepervasiveineveryworkplace,workersmustbeabletocommunicateandcollaborateusingcomputers,mobiledevices,theInternet,andothertechnologytools,aswellasthepracticesassociatedwiththeiruse.Deliverydriversandservicetechniciansmustbeabletocommunicatewithsupervisorsorcolleaguesatadistance.Jobsinthehospitalityandretailindustriesrequiretheabilitytorecordandtrackinformationelectronically.Andemployeesincreasinglycanandmustaccesson‐the‐jobtrainingviacomputersandtheInternet.AccordingtoBureauofLaborStatisticsprojections,morethan70percentofalljobsintheUnitedStateswillrequiresomelevelofICTskillsby2016.6Numerousstudiesalsomakeitevidentthatmostjobsofthenearfutureandbeyondwillrequiresomeleveloffurthereducationineithercollegeorjob‐trainingprograms.Itisimportanttoacknowledgethatmanyassumptionsaboutthereluctanceofadultstousetechnologyinindependentlearningaremisinformed,basedlargelyondataandexperiencewithadultswhoparticipateintraditionalformalprograms.Arecentstudycomparingdataonlow‐skilledadultsinPortland,OregonandLondon,Englandfoundthattheexperiencesoflearningtousetechnologyinand/orforemploymentboostsliteracyproficiency.7Moreover,aNationalInstituteforLiteracyanalysis(2008)ofmultiplesurveysandresearchabouttheattitudesoftheseadultpopulationsindicatesthat“adultlearnersacrosstheliteracyandlanguagespectrumshowstrongmotivationtogaincomputerliteracyskills,perceivedaskeytoworkadvancement.”8
![Page 12: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
4
Significantly,“technology,”whichencompassesbothtoolsandcontent,isalsogrowingeasiertouse,becomingmoreportable,lessexpensive,andwidelyavailable.Inaddition,whileadultswithouthighschooldiplomas,theunemployedorthosewithlow‐wagejobs,andnon‐EnglishspeakersarelessconnectedtocomputersandtheInternetthanothersegmentsofthepopulation,thegrowthinconnectivityforthisgroupisexpandingrapidly.9B.TheToolsofTechnologyUsingtechnology–ormorespecificallythetoolsoftechnology–toexpandeducationisonlyasvaluableasthelearningorprogrammanagementitenables.Whatrepertoryoftoolsisavailableandwhatisthebestuseofvarioustoolstoenableaccess,learning,andprogramanddatamanagement?Apartialanswertothisquestionisthat“itdepends.”Fromthestandpointoflearning,itdependsontheindividuallearner;hisorherlearningstyle,experience,andknowledge;programcontent;whetheratutororothertypeofsupportisnecessary;andahostofotherissues.Itdependsonhowwellsuitedtheparticulartechnologyistothecontentandpurposeoflearning:Isthereanimmediateneedforapieceofinformation,foradvicefromafamilymemberorcolleague,forrealtimeguidancefordiagnosingamechanicalproblem,orforongoingcoursestudy?Aninteractiveonscreenprototype*canworkwellfortheoperationofamechanicaldevicebutitworkslesswellforunderstandingdialogueinaplay.Apartfromitsabilitytoextendlearning,technologyinvariousformscanhelpmanageprogramsandsystems,provideoptionstoteachersforprofessionaldevelopment,supportdevelopmentofnewlessonsorcurricula,andoffernewwaysofcommunicatingwithstudentsinandoutoftheclassroom.Toolssuchas“learningmanagementsystems”canenableprogrammanagerstotrackdataonstudents,costs,outcomes,andotherinformationrequiredforfinancial,regulatory,andperformancepurposes.Teacherscanaccessprofessionaldevelopment,eitherformallyinonlinecoursesorinformallybywatchingvideosofotherteachersteaching.Othertoolsenablecustomizedwebspacesforclasscollaborationandcommunication.Untilrecently,thecontentdesignedforparticulartechnologies–whetherforthelearnerortheprogrammanager–hasbeendevelopedtosupplement,notreplace,classroominstruction.Inmostcases,thecontenthasbeenderivedfromaspecificcurriculumanditsdesignatedlearninggoals.Themainattractionoftheseversionsoftechnologyhasbeentoenableadultswhowereunabletoattendregularon‐sitecoursestoparticipate,atadistance,inaformaleducationprogram.
*An“interactiveonscreenprototype”isaprogrammodelthatisinteractivelydisplayedonacomputerscreenorotherdevicewheretheinteractionisdriveneitherbythemouseorbytouchscreen.
![Page 13: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
5
Astechnologieshavegrownmoresophisticatedandcheaper,andbecomeapartofeverydaylife,someeducatorshavebegundevelopingapproachesthatenableanindividualtoaccessandmanagehis/herownlearning.Sometimescalled“self‐directed”or“independent”learning,theseapproachesincludepedagogicalstructuresandcontentthatenableanindividualtolearn,usuallyviatheInternet,withoutparticipatinginaformalprogramorbeingguidedbyaninstructor/mentor.(Thisisnotassimpleamatterasitmayseem.Intechnology‐basedinformallearning–whichissomewhatsimilartothekindofnontraditional“self‐study”thatindividualsusedbeforetheadventofuniversaleducation–therearechallengestoovercomeincontent,appropriateassessment,andcredentialing.)Radio,television,andvideo(nowCD‐ROMandDVD)havebeenusedthelongesttoenablelearning,andtheycontinuetobevaluablesupports.NoneofthesetechnologicaltoolsrequiresaccesstocomputersortheInternet,althoughtheyfrequentlysupplementlearningactivitiesthatarebestaccessedviacomputeroronlyavailableviatheInternet.Themostsignificantlimitationofthesetoolsisthattheyprovideonly“oneway”access,withnoopportunityforreal‐timeinteraction.Newertoolssuchasmobilephonesandpersonaldigitalassistants(PDAs)have,fromthebeginning,offeredportablelearningviacommunicationwithothers.ButitistheabilitytoconnecttotheInternetandtoaccesstheWorldWideWebthathasenabledthesedevicestoprovidereallysignificantlearningoptions.However,regardlessofthelevelorkindoftechnology,thesetoolsareonlyplatformsforthecontent(courseware),anditsform,thatisplacedonthem.Newoptionsforaccesstolearningmayarisefromnewversionsoftheexistingtechnologyorfromnewwaysofusingit,suchastheuseofmobilephonekeyboardsfor“texting.”Thevalueofthesekindsoftechnologiesforthosewhoneedadulteducationandwork/collegereadinessskillsisthattheyprovideoptionsforinstructorsandindividualsthatsuittheparticularneedsofthosewhoareunabletoenrollinand/orcompleteeducationinthetraditionalsystem.Theytypicallyofferoneormoreofthefollowingadvantages: Drillandpractice,interaction,and/oraudio/videothatextendsandenhancesthecapacity
ofteacherswithlargediverseclasses;
Enablinginstructorstocustomizelessonstosuitparticularneeds(authoringtools,Web‐basedresources);
Vibrant,relevant,andengagingcontentthatcanensureanadult’sinterestinremainingin
educationandinlifelonglearning; ViatheInternetandtheWeb,newwaysofcommunicating,ofrelatingtoinformationand
knowledge,andofgainingaccesstovisualandaudioexposurestootherplaces,people,andthings;
![Page 14: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
6
Fasterassessmentofanindividual’sliteracy,language,andskillsandwithadditionalqualitativemeasures;and
Accesstoinformationaboutthecommunityservicesthatareoftenessentialtoenable
peopletogettoworkorclasses(e.g.,childcare,transportation,healthcare,immigration,unemployment).
Theterm“learningenvironment”suggestsplaceandspace–aschool,aclassroom,alibrary.Butalearningenvironmentcanalsobevirtual,online,andremote.Learningenvironmentsarethestructures,tools,andcommunitiesthatinspirestudentsandeducatorstoattainknowledgeandskills.Expertssaythat21stcenturylearningmusttakeplaceincontextsthat“promoteinteractionandasenseofcommunity[that]enable[both]formalandinformallearning.”10(SeeAppendixD,p.47foranoutlineofthemostcommonand/orpromisingtoolsoftechnologyforadulteducationlearningandprogram/datamanagementpurposes.)C.ConfrontingForcesThatWorkAgainstProgressTheexistingsystemofadulteducationandworkforceskillsmustitselfchangeinmanywaysifitistobetransformedintoacoherentandeffectivesystemservingsubstantiallymoreadultseachyear.Twooverridingchallengesinthesystemgenerallyarelackofcapacitytoserveverymanyofthepeoplewhoneedsomelevelofbasic,ESL,andworkforceskillseducation,andlackofprogramsthatarerelevantandofconsistentlyhighquality.Whethertechnology‐assistedornot,programshavedevelopedoverthedecadesinahaphazardwayduetoinadequatefundingandinattention.Theyvarygreatlyinpurpose,size,availability,quality,andconnectiontomeaningfuleducationalachievementand/oremployment.Moreover,fewstatesrequiredemonstratedmasteryofthespecializedknowledgeandskillsneededtoteachadults–and,inanycase,themajorityofadulteducatorsnationwideworkpart‐time,oftenasasecondjob,11partlybecausesalariesarelowandtheprofessionisundervalued.Fromthelearner’sstandpoint,adultstoooftendonothavetheopportunityfortheeducationandlearningtheyneed.Somehavebeenforcedbyfamilyorothercircumstancestodropoutofaformalprogramandmaybeunabletore‐joinbecausethereisawaitinglistforstudents.Asnotedabove,otherswhomaywishtoimprovetheirknowledgeandskillsareoftenunabletolocateaprogramataconvenientplaceandtimeorthathasanopening,arealitythatcanquicklyundercutmotivation.Numerousotherproblemsmustalsobeaddressed.Mostarequitewellknown.Theyincludeinsufficientfunding,absenceofmanagementandfinancialinfrastructuretooverseetheapplicationandoutcomesoftechnology,regulatoryrequirementsthatinhibitchange,anddifficultypotentialstudentsandprofessionaleducatorshavefindinginformationaboutexistingtechnologyresourcesforbasiceducation,ESL,andworkreadiness.
![Page 15: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
7
Furthermore,accesstocomputersandtheInternetinclassroomsislimited.Andoften,evenwhenthatisnotthecase,neededsoftwareislackingorthelimitedspeedand/orbandwidthavailableresultsinineffectiveuseofthatsoftware.Moreover,publicspaceswithICTaccess,suchaslibraries,areoverwhelmedwiththenumberswhoseektousecomputersandwhosooftenneedassistancefromtheirsmallstaffs.12Wemustalsocountervariousadministrativechallenges.Oneislackofcomprehensiveplanningbylocal,state,andfederalagencies.Anotheristheabsenceofwell‐developedfinancialsystemsthatfullyreflectthetotaldirectandindirectcostsofoperation,andthatdealwithstudentaidissuesforonlinelearning.Athirdisthefailuretotakeadvantageofeconomiesofscaleinpurchasinglicensesforcontent.And,aboveall,theNationalReportingSystem(NRS)thatdrivesprogramfundingdoesnottakeaccountoflearninggainsvia“distanceeducation”orofadultswhomayusepartsofthesystem(suchasaGEDexam)butarenotenrolledorcountedinformalprograms.13Beyondtheseproblemsisthebarrieroftraditionandassumption–thatis,traditionallyheldandwidelysharedviewsbymanypolicymakers,educators,funders,andlearnersabouthowcontentandlearningmustbestructuredand“delivered.”Traditionaleducationhasbeenbuiltonthepremisethatinformationisscarceandthataccesstothatinformationshouldbeprovidedatparticularlocations(inclassrooms)–usingcontentand/orcurriculachosenbyandavailablefromothers,andwithoptionsforfurtherstudyorworkopenonlytothosewithcertaincredentials.“Teachers”inthistraditionalviewareregardedasthesourceoflearning.14Certainlythisapproachhasservedthenationwell.Butinatechnology‐drivensocietyofalmostlimitlessinformationandaccess,itcaninhibitlearningratherthanpromoteit.Officialsandeducatorshavecraftedastrategythatattachestechnologytotheadulteducationandworkforceskillssystemsthatalreadyexist–essentiallyusingcomputersandInternetaccesstodelivertraditionalcurriculumusingtraditionalmethods,ratherthanastransformativeagentsorvehiclesfornewopportunities.Thus,changedattitudesmustgohandinhandwitheffortstoovercometheotherbarrierscited.Otherwise,expectationsthattechnologycanenablesignificantexpansionofandaccesstoadulteducationandworkforceskillsserviceswillnotbemet.Ofcourse,technologycannotsolvealloftheseproblems.Butitcanhelpprogramsinmanyessentialandliberatingways.Itstoolsandmethodscanexpandaccessandquality,reducecostsbyimprovingmanagementefficiency,provideeducationatadistanceforadultswhoareunabletoattendaclassinperson,andofferservicesforinstructorswhowanttoimprovetheirskillsoracquirenewcertifications.Numerousoptionshavebeenavailableandprovensuccessfulforthesepurposesforsometimenowandatlowcost.However,therehasbeenlittleefforttotaketheseinitiativestoscalethroughdistanceeducation,wherethebulkofinstructionoccursindividuallyoutsideofaformalclassroom,atatimeandplaceconvenientforthelearner.Finally,simplelackofawarenessisaproblem.Althoughmanyrecentstudiescallforheavyuseoftechnologyineducation,awarenessaboutwhattechnologycanaccomplishislimited,asis
![Page 16: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
8
understandingabouthowtoincorporateitintoanadulteducationprogram.Thereisashortageofinformationabouttheresourcesavailablefordistanceeducation,whethertheseresourcesaredesignedtosupportaformalprogramorself‐study.Inaddition,despiterecentresearchevidencetothecontrary,manyeducatorsremaindoubtfulaboutadults’abilitytolearnontheirownsuccessfully,especiallythosewithverylowlevelsofreading,writing,math,andEnglishlanguage.Atthesametime,teachersandadministratorsthemselvesfrequentlyhavelittleornoexperienceinusingcomputersandtheInternet,eitherfortheirownneedsortosupportinstruction.Forthatreason,theymayfeelunqualifiedtoinitiatedistanceeducationoptions.Moreover,themeasuresthatguidefederalfundingforstateandlocalprogramsrequireinformationonadultswhoareformallyenrolledinaprogram,althoughrecentchangesinthereportingrequirementsaccommodate“proxyhours”ofdistanceeducation.15Clearly,theobstaclestochangearemanyandformidable.Itshouldbeagoalofallfederalandstateadulteducationprogramstomeetmanyofthemheadon.Butanessentialpartofanyserious,comprehensiveplanmustbeasignificantinvestmentindistancelearning.Thescopeofthenation’sneedmakesitimperative.And,asdiscussedinthefollowingsections,distanceeducationworks.AstheNationalCommissiononAdultLiteracyobserved,“itcanputthehighestqualityteachersintheworldateveryone’sdoorstep.”16
Ifthisnationistotakeadvantageofthepotentialroleoftechnologyinbringingtheadulteducationandworkforceskillssystemtoscale,itmustdoatleasttwothings:(a)offerresourcestoserviceproviderstoenablewider,moreeffectiveusesoftechnologyinthenewsystem(towardtheeducationalgoalsdesired)and(b)developandimplementnewpracticesandstructurestosupportthedifferentkindsoflearningthattechnologycanenable.Indoingthis,suchquestionsasthefollowingwillhavetobeaddressed: Howcantechnologybeintegratedintothecurrentsystemwithoutforestallingfurther
developmentoftechnology‐assistedlearningforadultsoutsideofformalprograms?
Whatstepscanbetakentoencourageandprovidetrainingtoteacherstohelpthemtransitionfrom“delivering”educationtoaroleasguideormentororcoach?
Howcannewoptionsforlearningbefundedinaneconomicenvironmentinwhichitishard
justtomaintainpresentfundingforthecurrentwayofdoingthings?
HowcanweensurethatmoreadultsachieveGEDs,postsecondaryeducation,andvocational/industrycertificationwhentheirlearningisdeterminedbyassessmentmeasuresdesignedforthetraditionalsystem,ratherthanbyassessmentsappropriatetotechnology‐basedlearning?
![Page 17: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
9
SectionIVofthisreport(BuildingtheFoundation,p.28)recommendsnextstepsforaddressingthiscomplexsetofissuesandquestions.
![Page 18: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
10
II.HELPINGADULTSACHIEVETHEIRGOALS
SOMESECTIONHIGHLIGHTSComparativestudiesofdistanceonly,classroomonly,and“blended”classroomanddistanceeducationhavefoundthatadulteducationstudentshavegreatersuccessinblendedlearningthanineitherdistanceorclassroomlearningalone.Adultswhostudyontheirown(self‐study)fortheGEDexamwithnoparticipationinaformalprogrampassatahigherpercentageratethanthosewhoparticipateonlyinaformalprogramwithnoself‐study.Adeterminingfactorinsuccessisregularconnectiontoateacherintheroleofguideandmentor.Whetherornotanadultcompletesclassesandcoursessequentiallyinaformalprogramislessimportantthanwhetheranadultcontinuestostudyandlearn,eitherwithself‐studyandperiodicprogramparticipationorthroughself‐studyalone.Accesscontinuestoexpand,particularlywiththeavailabilityofmobiledevicesthattendtobecheaperthancomputersandprovidemoreoptionsforcommunicatingwithothers.LiteracyproficiencyisenhancedsubstantiallybytimespentinemploymentandexposuretoICT.
A.DistanceEducationWorks1. POSITIVELEARNEROUTCOMES
esearchandpracticeinusingtechnologyforlearningamongadultswithlowlevelsofliteracyand/orEnglishlanguageabilityshowsthatadultscanbemeasurablysuccessfulin
increasingtheirknowledge,includingachievingtheGEDandenteringpostsecondaryeducation.“Distanceeducation”ordinarilyreferstothedeliveryofinstructiontostudentswhoareseparatedfromtheinstructor,usingsometypeoftechnologytosupportregularandsubstantiveinteractionbetweenthestudentsandinstructor,synchronouslyorasynchronously.17Astheprecedingsectionshows,distancelearningmaterialsaredeliveredthroughavarietyofmediaincluding,butnotlimitedto,print,audiorecording,videotape,broadcasts,computersoftware,web‐basedprograms,andotheronlinetechnology.Teacherscommunicatewithdistancelearnersviamail,telephone,e‐mail,oronlinetechnologiesandsoftware.Whencombinedwithclassroomattendance,distanceeducationisdescribedas“blended”learning.
R
![Page 19: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
11
Whateverthestructure,thedistanceeducation/blendedprocessisgenerallydesignedtoreplicatethetraditionaleducationalexperience–teacher‐ledinstruction,definedcurriculum,andspecifiedmilestonesrequiredforadvancement–albeitwiththesignificantadvantageofflexibilityfortheindividualwhoisunabletoattendaclassinaparticularlocationatsettimes.Itenablesthestudenttospendmoretimeontask.
AdulteducationdeliveredviadistancehasproventobesuccessfulforadultsstudyingforGED,advancingESLlevels,andimprovingliteracy,numeracy,andwork‐relatedskills.Manyresearchprojects,conductedinmanydifferentcontextsatbothstateandlocallevels,havefoundthatadultslearnatleastaswell,andoftenbetter,viadistanceeducationthaninclassroomsalone.ComparativestudiesofdistanceversusclassroomadulteducationintheU.S.,Canada,Australia,andtheU.K.havefoundthatthosetakingtheGEDoradvancinginreading,ESL,andotherknowledgeinblendedprograms,haveslightlyhigherresultsthanthosewitheitherclassroom‐onlyordistance‐onlystudy.18Strikingly,aten‐yearlongitudinalstudybyresearchersfromPortlandStateUniversity(fortheNationalCenterfortheStudyofAdultLiteracy)foundthatadultswhostudyontheirownfortheGEDexamwithnoformalprogramparticipationpassatahigherpercentageratethanthosewhoparticipateonlyinaformalprogramwithnoself‐study–24percentcomparedto17percent.ThehighestpercentageofGEDattainment–27percent–occurredamongthosewhousedblendedprocesses,althoughthiscombinedapproachwasonlyslightlyhigherthanforself‐studyalone.19Thesepositiveoutcomesresultinpartfromthelearner’sabilityto“self‐pace,”takingasmuchoraslittletimeasnecessarytoabsorbmaterial.Technologyisparticularlyeffectiveintheself‐pacedlearningendeavorbecause,initsmostbasicform(videooraudiotape),itallowsrepeatviewingand/orhearingofparticularcontent.Technologyalsocansupportindividuallearningbyprovidingaccesstomultipleprogramsbeyondtheadulteducationsystemitself.Accesstoonlinelearningoffersevenmoreeffectiveoptions–fromlinkstosimilarmaterialthatmaybepresentedindifferentcontexts,tointeractivecontentthatenablesthelearnertorespond,receivefeedback,repeat,ormoveon.20Inadditiontotheimportanceofself‐pacing,researchfromCanadaconcludesthatadeterminingfactorinsuccessisregularconnectiontoateacherintheroleofguideandmentor.Someevidencesuggeststhatratherthantheuseoftechnologyperse,itistheextratimeandindividualattentionthatateacherofferstothedistancelearnerthatgeneratesmorepositiveoutcomesthanresultsofformalclassroomlearning.21Theteacher’sroleisquitedifferentinatechnologyenvironmentthaninatypicalclassroom,wherematerialisdeliveredtostudentsofdifferingabilitiesandtime‐on‐taskneeds.Distanceeducationdesignedtotestdifferentapproachestolearningnormallyprovideatleastsomeprofessionaldevelopmentforthisnewrole.Insomecases,asinassisted‐technologyprogramsinOhio,teachersareassignedmentorsintheirfirstyearortwoofteaching,inaformof
![Page 20: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
12
professionaldevelopmentviadistancethatisbothvaluableandcost‐effective.Inadditiontothemanyonlineoptionsavailableforteacherlearningandsupport,anumberoffreeprogramsincorporatetechnologyintothelearningprocess,includingsometoolsthatenabletheteachertodevelophisorherownlessons.22However,thismethodiscurrentlylimitedinitsabilitytosignificantlyexpandaccessbeyondthestructuredsystemofadulteducation,becauseoftherequirementforinstructorsandtheshortageofteacherswithnecessaryadditionaltraining.Itwilltakeasubstantialinvestmentoffinancialandotherresourcestoenableprogramsandteacherstohandlelargenumbersofstudentsindistancelearningprograms.Itisworthrepeatingthatmoststudiesandresearch,andmostprogramsthathaveaddedtechnologytoformaladulteducationofferings,havefocusedonadultsenrolledinformalprograms–althoughlessthan10percentoftheadultlearnerpopulationattendsformal,classroom‐basedcourses.23Thefactisthatweknowverylittleaboutthosewhoarenotenrolled–thatis,aboutthevastmajorityofadultswhoneedsomeeducationtoattainGED,and/ortomoveontopostsecondaryeducationand/ortrainingforwork.2. PERSISTENCEANDMOTIVATIONAsolidbodyofresearchshowsthatacriticalcomponentofsuccessfullearninginadulteducationis“persistence,”intermsofbothintensityanddurationofstudy.24Persistenceisachallengetoadultlearnersbecausechangesinfinancial,employment,family,andothercircumstancescanforcethemtodropoutduringorbetweencoursesofstudy.Infact,programsthatrecognizethisproblemoftentryvariousstrategiestohelpadultscontinueorreturn.Aconcernfrequentlyexpressedabouttheuseofdistancelearningisthatstudentsdropoutinhighernumbersthanthoseinclassroom‐onlystudy.Indeed,California’s2007comparativestudyofclassroom‐only,distance‐only,andblendededucation,foundthatstudentpersistencewashighestintheblendedcategoryandlowestindistance‐only.25However,morerecentreviewsofhowmanyadultlearnerspersisthavedeterminedthatthey“persistinlearninginsideandoutsideofaprogramuntiltheyachievetheirgoals”.26Thus,whetherornotanadultcompletesclassesandcoursessequentiallyinaformalprogramislessimportantthanwhetherthatpersonalsostudiesonhisorherown,i.e.,through“self‐study”.Technologyinthesecircumstancescanenableprogrammanagers,teachers,andlearnerstotracktheirprogressviaonlineself‐assessments,regularreviewsofclasslessonsandassignments,learnerreports,andinotherwayssoastofacilitateasmoothre‐entryintoformalclasses,and/oreligibilityforassessmentsthatdemonstratemasteryofacertainlevelofmaterial.
![Page 21: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
13
3.SELF‐STUDYItiswidelythoughtthatadultlearnersneed,attheveryleast,guidanceandsupportfromaninstructorortutor,evenwhentheprimarymodeoflearningisself‐study.However,thepercentageofadultsenrolledinformalprograms(thebasefordatacollectionandeducatorexperience)representsasmallminorityofthetotalpopulationinneedofadulteducationservices–anduntilrecentlywehavehadlittleinformationaboutthemajority,whodonotparticipate.ThisinformationdeficitwasfilledinpartintheaforementionedPortlandstudy,whichwasbasedonlongitudinaltrackingovera10‐yearperiod.27Thestudyfocusedonadultswithouthighschooldiplomaswhodidanddidnotparticipateinformaleducationprograms.Somekeyfindingsarethese:OfthosewhowerestudyingfortheGEDwhohadneverparticipatedinanAdultBasicEducationprogram,oneinthree(34percent)hadengagedinself‐directedeffortstoimprovetheirbasicskills.Moreover,adultswithrelativelyweakbasicskillswerejustaslikelytoengageinself‐studyasthosewithhigherlevelsofproficiency.Thosewhoengagedinself‐studyusuallyusedworkbooksdesignedforGEDpreparation,butmorethanonethirdofthestudygroup(35percent)reportedusingcomputer‐basedmaterials.28Ofcourse,self‐studydoesnotrequiretheuseoftechnology.Itonlyrequiresaccesstomaterialsthatprovidetheinformationanadultlearnerneedstoachievehisorhergoals,whetherthatistopassaGEDtest,learnsufficientEnglishorbasicskillsforworkorfurthereducation,orfulfillotherneedsandinterests.Buttechnologydoesprovideaccesstoafarwiderrangeofmaterialthanisavailablefromabookstore,libraryorschool,andfrequentlyatlowornocosttotheindividual.AnumberofstateshavedevelopedtheirownonlineGEDpreparationoptions(forwhichtestsmustbetakenatamonitoredcenter)and/orofferauthorizedpublicprograms,andmanycredibleandacceptedoptionsforESLstudyareavailable.29Inaddition,onlineopportunitiesforlearningofallkinds–whetherornotrelatedtodefinedcurricula–areincreasinglyaccessibletolearnerswithacomputerormobiledevice.Technologyalsosimplifiescommunicationwithotherlearners,colleagues,family,ortutorsforquestionsandsupport.Again,thedefiningvariableforanyformofadultlearningatadistanceisaccesstothetechnologyandskillstouseittoachieveindividuals’needs.B.AccessToexpandtechnologyuseforadultswithlowbasicskillsandEnglishlevels,individuallearnersmustbegivenaccesstoinformationaboutavailableformalorinformaltechnology‐basedortechnology‐assistededucationprograms.Buttheymustalsoknowabouttheconditionsunderwhichtheycanlearneffectively,haveconnectivitytosuitabletechnology,andpossessbasicICTliteracy.Theseessentialsarediscussedbelow.
![Page 22: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
14
1. ACCESSANDCONNECTIVITYAlthoughcomputerandInternetaccesscontinuestoexpandsignificantlyamongalldemographicgroups,theleastamountofaccessisavailabletothosewithloweducationlevels,insufficientornoemploymentandlowincome,andblacksandHispanics–groupswiththegreatestneedforadulteducationservices.U.S.Censusdataindicatesnotonlythataccessisoftenlackingathome,butalsothatmostadulteducationclassroomsarenotequippedwithcomputers.Also,publiclyavailablecomputeraccessatlibrariesandcommunitycenterscanbeoverwhelmedwithdemand,insomecaseslimitingaccessto30minutesperperson.30Frequentlytheselocationshavecomputersandsoftwarethatarenotpowerfuloradvancedenoughtosupportmanyofthenewerlearningoptions.Andtheydonotalwayshaveconnection–especiallybroadband–totheInternet.Despitethesepersistentbarriers,accesscontinuestoexpand,particularlywiththeavailabilityofmobiledevicesthattendtobecheaperthancomputersandprovidemoreoptionsforcommunicatingwithothers.31Some84percentofalladultshaveacellphone.32Moreover,anApril2009PewResearchCentersurveyfoundthat77percentofalladultshaveacomputerinthehome,afigurethatrisesto95percentformarriedadultswithoneormorechildren.AcompanionsurveybyPewonInternetusefoundthat,ofthe79percentofalladultuserswhousedtheInternetatleastoccasionally,60percenthaveincomesbelow$30,000annually,50percenthavelessthanahighschooleducation,and67and84percentrespectivelyareblackandHispanic.Thehighestpercentageofactivityise‐mailuse(90percent),but88percentofthosesurveyeduseasearchenginetofindinformation.33Asthesophisticationoftechnologyandcontenthasgrown,broadbandconnectiontotheInternethasbecomemorenecessaryforaccesstonewereducationprogramsthatprovidegreaterchoiceofcontentandinteractivecapability.Despitethehighercostsofbroadbandandabsenceofitsavailabilityinsomelocations,63percentofAmericanshavebroadbandathome.Further,thegrowthratesinbroadbandconnectionaresignificantfromyeartoyear.AccordingtoPew’ssurvey,ofthoseinhouseholdswithincomesunder$20,000peryear,adoptionincreasedby10percentfrom2008to2009(from25to35percent).Inhouseholdswithannualincomesbetween$20,000‐$30,000,adoptionincreased11percent(from42to53percent).Amonghighschoolgraduates,therateofadoptiongrew12percent(from40to52percent),andamongruralAmericansitgrewby8percent(from38to46percent).Thedemographicgroupwhoseadoptionratesshowtheleastincreaseareblacks,whoseadoptionrateatonly3percent,increasedonlyslightly,from43percentin2008to46percentin2009.34Althoughthesetrendlinesareencouraging,thereremainsa“digitaldivide”formanymillionsofneedyadultswhocouldclearlybenefitfromaccesstolearningviacomputersandtheInternet.Nonetheless,aslowercostsandthehigherconnectivitycapacityofmobiledevicesandothertechnologytoolskeepsincreasing,greaternumbersofadultswillgainaccess.
![Page 23: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
15
2. ICTLITERACYAlongwithaccesstotechnologyandprograms,learnersmusthavereasonablysolidICTskillssothattheyknowhowtousecomputers,theInternet,andotherdevices.TheymustbeabletomanagetheoperationofcomputersandtheInternet,buttheyshouldalsobeabletosearch,evaluate,share,store,andconnectinformationandprocesses.Thetraditionalviewisthatsuchskillsmustbetaughtinclasses,likethosefrequentlyofferedincommunitytechnologycenters.ButrecentresearchandotherdataindicatethatadultstendtoprefertolearnICTskillslessformally,withthehelpoffriends,family,andcolleagues.Forexample,arecentU.K.surveyfoundthatasignificantgovernmentinitiativetoexpandthenumberofadultcomputerclassesandlocationshadlimitedornoimpactinitselfontheuseofsuchcenters.35Further,manyCD‐ROMandonlinesourcesprovideeitherstatictext‐basedtutorialsorinteractiveinstructioninhowtooperatecomputersandaccesstheInternet.Theyusevoice,text,pictures,andimagesthatenableindividualsatanylevelofliteracytofollowthesteps.(GoodexamplesareMicrosoft’sDigitalLiteracyprogramandTheLearningLadder.*)Clearlyweneedmore“user‐friendly”hardware.Itisencouragingthatsomehasbeguntopenetratetheadulteducationmarket,suchastouchscreensinsteadofkeyboards(originallydevelopedforpeoplewithdisabilities).Adultsgivemanyreasonsforwantingtolearnhowtousecomputers/mobiledevicesandtheInternet.ChiefamongthemisthegrowingimportanceofICTskillsinjobs.36ThecomparativelongitudinalstudyofadultsinPortland,OregonandLondon,England(2007)posedquestionsabouttherisingimportanceoftheuseofandaccesstocomputersaspartofcontemporaryemployability.Oneofthestudy’scentralconclusionsisthat“employmentandICTusesupportsthedevelopmentofliteracyproficiency.”Putanotherway,“enhancementofliteracyproficiencyisaidedsubstantiallybytimespentinemploymentandexposuretoICT.”37ThisapparentcorrelationbetweenICTuseandliteracyisreinforcedbydatafromthe2003NationalAssessmentofAdultLiteracy(NAAL).AnanalysisofresponsestoNAAL’ssurveyquestionsabouttechnologyuseandaccessfound,incomparingusersandnon‐usersontheDocumentliteracymeasure,thatabout10percentfewertechnologyusershadBelowBasicscorescomparedtonon‐technologyusers.Further,about10percentmoretechnologyusersscoredattheIntermediatelevelcomparedwithnon‐users.AsimilarpatternwasfoundfortheNAALProseandQuantitativeliteracyscores.Notsurprisingly,technologyuseisstronglyassociatedwithhigherliteracyscoresacrossdemographicvariablesofincome,education,andage.38Thereisevidencethatadultsfindtheuseoftechnologiesforlearningtobeamotivatingforce,bothbecauseoftherelationshipofICTskillstoemploymentandbecausetheyenablegreater
*http://www.microsoft.com/about/corporatecitizenship/citizenship/giving/programs/up/digitalliteracy/default.mspx,andhttp://learningladder.org.
![Page 24: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
16
flexibilityfortheteacherandthelearner.Inparticular,mobiletechnologies(e.g.,tabletsandPDAs)encouragestudentinterestandparticipation.39ThePortlandstudyindicatesthat“informallearningthroughcomputerusemayofferavenuesfordevelopmentofnewliteraciesnotavailableinformalprograms.”Forexample,“websitesaboutpopularculturecanpresentmorecomplexliteracydemandsthanthetextsencounteredinsomeliteracyprograms,computergamesdevelopakindofanalyticalexperienceorexpertisenotalwayscalledforintheclassroom,andadolescentsdevelopvoiceandidentitythroughwritingonline.”40Inshort,whetheranadulthasnoexperienceusingcomputersortheInternetoriswell‐versedinICTskills,technologyoffersanentirelynewenvironmentandlearningexperiencethataddstoorcangobeyondthetraditionalclassroomexperienceofinstructor‐ledtext‐basedformats.Thislearningenvironmentisasmuchaboutinformationandcommunicationasitisabouttechnology.Intheiruseoftechnologyforlearning,adultsatalllevelsofeducation,knowledge,andskillsrelyheavily,andincreasingly,oncommunitiesandnetworksofothers–colleagues,fellowstudents,instructors,experts,familyandfriends,strangerswithsimilarinterestsorinsimilarprofessions,andmanyothers–tosupportallkindsoflearning.InGivingLiteracyAway,Again:NewConceptsofPromisingPractice(presentedattheTwentiethAnnualRutgersInvitationSymposiumonEducation,2003),theauthorconcludesthatthereisamoreexpansiveconceptoftheadultliteracylearnerasonewho“choosesamongarangeofliteracydevelopmentstrategiesandresources….”Thereportstatesthat“differencesamonglearners’preferredmodesoflearning,theirlifecircumstances,andtheaccessibilityoflearningresourcessuchasclassesshapetheirchoicesabouthowtopursueliteracydevelopment.”Inconsideringsystemsthatcanoffertheseoptions,itisessentialthat“mappingofprograms,services,andmaterialsdoesnotretrofitthemtoanarrowlyprescribedframework.”41Ofcourse,datafromthesestudiesarelaggingindicatorsinanenvironmentthatisconstantlyshifting.Theyaresnapshotsatparticulartimesduringaperiodofrapidchangeindevelopment,use,access,acceptance,andunderstandingoftechnologyinallaspects.Nevertheless,theresultsareexcitingandthepotentialisevidentforusingtechnologytoexpandadults’accesstoprogramsthatwillqualifythemforcollegeandwork.What’sneededareeffectivepoliciesandsupportstodevelopICTskillsandmanagingtransitionsinanewadulteducationandworkforceskillssysteminawaythatmakesindependentdistancelearningfortheindividualvaluableandsuccessful.
![Page 25: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
17
C.GoingtoScale1.CHANGINGTHECONTEXTWhetherthegoalistoimprovethetraditionaladulteducationsystemorfosterdevelopmentofthenewsystemenvisagedbytheNationalCommission,itisoffirstorderimportancetoaggressivelyexpandawarenessofthetechnologyresourcesavailableforbasic,ESL,andworkforceskills.Takingstepstointegratetechnologyintoadministrationandmanagementisaclosesecond.ExpandingAwareness.Asdiscussedearlier,awidevarietyoftechnologyiscurrentlyavailable,alongwiththeapplicationsandpracticesassociatedwiththeiruse.Butfewpeople–includingteachers,students,andeventheexperts–knowofmorethanafewofthem,andknowledgeoftencomesduringrandomsearchesand/orbywordofmouth.Acentralsourceofinformationonthefullrangeofoptionsavailablewouldsignificantlyincreasethespeedofawarenessanduse.Withoutit,accesstotechnology‐basedlearningwillremainoutofreachformostadultlearners.Fortunately,theInternetandWorldWideWebareideallysuitedtohelpmeetthischallengebecausetheyenablethespreadofinformation“virally”byindividualsandsmallgroupswithoutreferencetoorganizationorgovernmentchoices.Equallyimportant,technologiessuchas“wikis”(“Wikipedia”beinganexample)makeitpossibletoprovidebothacentrallocationforinformationthatcanbeeasilyexpandedandchangedandameansthroughoversightbythewikihoststoensureitscredibility.ManagementToolsandPractices.Manytechnologytoolsandsystemsarealsoonthemarketforadulteducationadministrators,programmanagers,andinstructors.Theycanhelptheseprofessionalscollectandanalyzefinancialdata,trackstudentenrollment,determinepersistenceandoutcomes,assessperformanceonline,andmeasurethesedataaccordingtofederal,state,andprivateregulatoryandfundingrequirements.Someofthese“learningandcontentmanagementsystems”(LCMS)arelowcostandsomearefreelyavailableonline,suchasMoodleandHTTrack(seeAppendixDlisting,p.47).MosthavebeentestedandusedsuccessfullyinK‐12education,whichisanespeciallyappealingmarketforproductdevelopmentbyvirtueofitssizeandleveloffunding.Curricularcontentandlearning/instructionalapproachesaredifferentforadultsthanforchildrenandyouth,butK‐12systemsofdatacollectionandmanagementcanbeeasilyadaptedtoadulteducation.Similarly,technologyplatformsandcontentareavailableforteacherswhowanttodeveloptheirownlessonsorcoursesorprovideopportunitiesfortheirstudentstocreatetheirownwebsitesandwikis.Freeonlineoptions,suchasMoodle,areinwideusealreadyandoftenincludeonline“communities”ofteacherswithsimilaragegroups,subjectmatter,concerns,andquestions.(SeeAppendicesDandEformoreexamples.)
![Page 26: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
18
Professionalteacherdevelopmentandcertificationprogramsarealsoavailableonline.Theyincludebothinformalandformallystructuredcoursesandhavetheadvantageofbeingavailablearoundtheclockattimesconvenientfortheteachers.Butawarenessofthetoolsandaccessalonearejustfirststeps.Mostmanagersandinstructorsmustlearnhowtoworkwiththem,andhowtodevelopnewwaystosupporttheiruse.Toooften,individualprogramsoreducationdistrictsdecidetofindandpurchasetechnologiesfordistancelearningordatapurposeswithlittleefforttogetneededtrainingortoexchangeinformationandexperience.Yetsuchtechnicaldevelopmentisvitalifuseistoproducepositiveresultsandgenerateeconomiesofscale.Thebottomlineisthatadulteducationandworkforceskillsentitiesneedtoplancarefullyfortechnologyacquisitionandimplementation,andtheyneedtoalignthetechnologywithstrategiesforenrollingandeducatingstudents.Tothisend,partnershipsbetweenthepublicandprivatesectors–oneoftherecommendationsoftheNationalCommissiononAdultLiteracy–couldjump‐starttheprocess,byinitiatingandpromotingexpansionofbestpracticesandmodels.2. SUPPORTINGTHELEARNERNOTTHESYSTEMDistanceeducation,additionalprofessionaldevelopmentopportunitiesforteachers,betterprogramanddatamanagementtools,andincreasedfundingandmorevisibility–allwillhelpexpandaccessforadultsandimprovetheirlearningopportunities.Yetthesechangeswillservesignificantlylargernumbersofadultsonlyifflexibilityisbuiltintothesystemtoserveadultsinmanydifferentways.Forexample,credentialsandcertificationsshouldbedevelopedthatareappropriatetothevariousformsoftechnology‐basedlearningandreflectthattheindividualsholdingthempossesstherequiredskillsandknowledge–andtheyshouldbebasedonacceptedstandardsforcontent,assessment,andoutcomes.Adultswhoneedbasiceducation,ESL,andotherskillsandknowledgetoenterandsucceedincollegeorfindjobs,mustseek,engage,andmaintainconnectionstotheadulteducationandworkforceskillssystem.Technologyoffersthemeansformakingsuchconnectionspossibleonawidespreadbasis,whetherornotanadultchoosestoparticipateinall,some,ornoformalprograms.Varioustechnologicaloptions,ifproperlyorganizedandmarketed,willallowadultlearnerstopursuetheeducationtheyneedforGEDandcollege‐andjob‐readinesspurposes,andforformalassessmentsoftheirachievement.Theoptionsincludeonlinecoursesandcurriculum,sampleassessmentsforparticularlessonsormodules,periodiccommunicationswithaninstructororregularaccesstoanonlinetutor.Theseandothermeanswillallowadultlearnerstovalidatetheirlearningachievementsandmoveeffectivelytowardtheirgoals.Unfortunately,thecurrentadulteducationsystemislargelydisconnectedfromthetraditional“pipeline”ofpre‐Kthroughpostsecondaryeducation,whichineffectisolatesadultlearners.Yet,asadultlearnersinandoutoftheworkforcebecomemoremobileandfreertochoosewhere,how,and
![Page 27: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
19
whentheycanaccesseducationthroughtechnology,accumulatedexperienceindicatesthattheyarelikelytolooktoprogramsmoreinterconnectedwithmainstreameducationoptions.Intransforminglearningthroughtheuseoftechnology,oldwaysofdoingthingswillnotalwaysbeappropriate–e.g.,indetermininghowandinwhatformcontentshouldbeavailable,andindesigninglearningassessments.Newstructuresandprocessesmustbedevelopedtoaccommodatethenewreality:Individualsshouldbeabletoaccessknowledge,skills,andinformationnotonlybyusingmultiplemediaatanytimeorplace,butindifferentformats,structures,andquantities,andfordifferentpersonallydeterminedpurposes.English‐languageabilitymaybenecessaryforanimmediatepurpose,suchasajoborpromotionortomeetfinancialorfamilyresponsibilities.Ashort‐term,targetedlanguageoptionisnotsufficientforthelongtermbutservestheindividual’simmediateneed.Accesstoweb‐basedvocabularyandtranslationoffersamissingwordorphrase“justintime.”Thesekindsofoptionsareinplacealready,buttheyrepresentlittlemorethantransplantingthetraditionalandfamiliarprocessofeducationtoanonlineenvironment.Successfulprogramsthatleadtojobsandfurthereducationforlow‐skilledadults,whetherornottechnologyisinvolved,haveoftendesignedtheexperiencetosuittheneedsofthelearner,nottheneedsofthesystem.Asgovernments,educators,employers,andtechnologydevelopersconsiderhowtotakeadvantageoftechnologywithoutlosingthevalueofneededsupportsystems,theywillhavetodeterminewhatthenewenvironmentsshouldandcanbe,andwhichtechnologicaltoolsareappropriatetoenablemaximumlearning.Inshort,goodtechnologiesandgoodusesoftechnologyofferthepotentialtoprovideeducationthatiscustomizedtothelearner,whetherinaninstructor‐ledclassroomorinlearningatadistanceonone’sown.Self‐studyappearstobeeffectivewithadultlearnerswhentheyhaveidentifiedoneormoregoalsandareabletostructurethenecessarylearningtoreachtheirgoal(s).Evidenceaboundsthatdistanceeducationoffersincreasedflexibility,cost‐effectiveness,andsuccessfuloutcomes,butuntiltheclassroomisnolongerviewedasthefocalpointforalllearning,significantchange,alongthelinesdiscussed,willnotoccur.Traditionalassumptionsabouttheinterestandabilityoflow‐skilledadultsinusingtechnologyforlearningarenotvalidandneedtochangeaswell.SectionIIIpresentsadditionalfindingsfrommajorresearchonadultanddistancelearning.Thefindingssupporttheconclusionsdrawnabove.
![Page 28: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
20
III.RECENTRESEARCHFINDINGS
hissectionhighlightskeyfindingsfromseveralrecentlongitudinalstudiesthatrelatetotheuseoftechnologyforadulteducationlearning.Thestudiesshareallormostofthe
followingcharacteristics:
• Theywereinitiatedbyormanagedundertheauspicesofagovernmentagency.• Theyhavetrackeddataovertime.• Theyincludeinformationaboutparticipationbybothteachersandlearners.• Multiplereportsandanalysesaboutthemhavebeendevelopedandpublished.*
ThreeofthestudiessummarizedherearefromtheUnitedStates:theCaliforniaDistanceLearningProject(CDLP);thePortlandLongitudinalStudyofAdultLearning(LSAL),andProjectIDEAL(amulti‐stateconsortiumbasedinMichigan).TheothertwoareprojectsoftheUnitedKingdom’sNationalResearchandDevelopmentCentreforAdultLiteracy(NRDC)andofCanada’sOntarioLiteracyandBasicSkillsProgram.Twopreviouslycitedfederalreportsarealsoincludedherebecausetheyrelatecloselytotheabovework.TheyareacomprehensivereviewandanalysisofadultonlinelearningexperiencesfromtheNationalInstituteforLiteracyandanevaluationofevidence‐basedpracticesinonlinelearningfromtheU.S.DepartmentofEducation.Asnoted,muchoftheinitialresearchintotheuseoftechnologyinadultlearninghasfocusedoncomparingoutcomesamongadultlearnersinthreecategories:thosewhoparticipateonlyinclassroom‐basedprograms;thosewhoparticipateonlyindistancelearning;andthosewhoparticipateinblendedclassroomanddistanceactivities.• First,thesestudieshavefocusedprimarilyondistancelearningandcontentthat
supplementstraditionallystructuredclassroomcurricula,lessons,assessments,andothermeasuresdevelopedforformalprograms.Thosewholearnoutsideoftheseframeworkscannotbeevaluatedandtheirlearningoutcomesareunknown.
Second,muchofthelearningcontentusedisvideo/TV‐basedandoffersnoopportunityforthestudenttorespondandreceivefeedbackastheprogramprogresses,anoptionprovidedbymanyonlineprograms,suchasWorkplaceEssentialSkillsandEnglishforAll(seeAppendixD,p.47).
Limiteddataexistsabouttheexperienceandlearningoutcomesofadultsusingtechnologyforadulteducation.Thosewhoarenotenrolledobviouslycannotbeeasilyidentified,questioned,assessed,orotherwiseconsidered.Nonetheless,datathatisavailableprovidesvaluableinsightsintoadultsatdifferentlevelsofliteracyandskillwhousetechnology‐assistedlearning. *ThenumerouspublicationsthathaveresultedfromeachofthesestudiesarelistedneartheendoftheBibliographysectionofAppendixF,p.59.
T
![Page 29: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
21
A. CaliforniaDistanceLearningProject(CDLP):AdultLearningActivitiesTheAdultEducationOfficeoftheCaliforniaDepartmentofEducationsponsoredtheCDLPProject,from1995‐2007.TheCaliforniaStateUniversitySystemmanagedanddirectedit,andOTAN,theOutreachandTechnicalAssistanceNetworkoftheSacramentoCountyOfficeofEducation,wasthesubcontractorforallInternetandinformationdistributionactivitiesincludingwebsitemanagement.TheCDLPwebsiteispresentlyoperatedundertheauspicesofOTAN(www.otan.us).Becauseofitsscopeandlongevity,theCDLPisoneofthemostvaluableinitiativesinthisareaofresearch.From1995‐2007,thestudytrackedalmost60,000studentseachyear–usingconsistentmeasuresforpersistenceandoutcomesandcomparingparticipationindistance,classroom,andblendedcourses.StatelegislationpermitsCaliforniaadultschoolstospendupto5percent(15percentasofJanuary1,2009*)oftheirapportionmentonnontraditionaleducationapproaches.Mostofthesearecommonlycalled“innovationprograms.”TheymeettheCDLP’sdefinitionofdistancelearning,whichhasfourelements:separationofteacherandlearnerinspaceand/ortimeduringatleastamajorityoftheinstructionalprocess;two–waycommunicationbetweenteacher,tutor,oreducationalagencyandlearner;useofeducationalmediatouniteteacherandlearnerandcarrycoursecontent;andstudentcontroloflearningpaceandfrequencyratherthancontrolbythedistanceinstructor.42ESLprogramsrepresentabout90percentofthe59,000learnersenrolledinprogramyear2005–2006.CDLPevaluationsshowpositiveoutcomesforstudentsinclasseswheredistancelearningisasupplementoranoptionforself‐study,ifastudenthasto“stopout”ofregularclassattendance.Studentswhoparticipatedinblendedlearningin2004‐2005(regularclassattendanceplussupplementaldistancelearning)demonstratedgreatergainsonCalifornia’spost‐testthanstudentsintraditionalESLclasses,withlowerlevelsofproficiencyshowingthegreatestpercentagegains.Theinnovationprograms’levelofparticipantcompletionwasbetteroverallthanadultschoolclassroomprograms,withblendedlearningshowingthehighestcompletionrate.However,distancelearning‐onlyprogramsshowedthelowestlevelsofpersistence.43Morethan45percentofparticipantsintheinnovationprogramsreportedhavingnineorlessyearsofschooling.Abouthalf(nearly52percent)ofthe2005‐2006participantsreportedhavingnoearneddegrees.Morethanaquarter(about27percent)hadhighschooldiplomasor
*ItshouldbenotedthatCalifornia’s2010budgetincludessignificantcutstoalllevelsofeducation.Schooldistrictshavebeengiventheoptiontoignorefundingforadulteducationinnovationprograms.
![Page 30: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
22
GEDs.Morethan25percentoftheESLlearnerswereatbeginningliteracylevelsatthetimeofentryandsome5percentweredeterminedtobeattheintermediatelevels.44ForfurtherinformationabouttheCDLP,www.cdlponline.org.B. Portland’sLongitudinalStudyofAdultLearning(LSAL)PortlandStateUniversityconductedtheLongitudinalStudyofAdultLearning(LSAL)from1998‐2008.Thisstudycomparestheexperiencesoftwogroups:adultswhoparticipateinformalAdultBasicEducation(ABE)programsandthosewhodonot.Thepopulationwasastatisticallyrepresentativesampleof940adultsages18‐44livinginthePortlandmetropolitanarea.Atthetimeoftheirscreeningin1997,theywerenotinhighschool,werewithoutahighschooldiplomaorGED,andwereproficientspeakersofEnglish(notnecessarilynativespeakers).Thestudycollectedsixwavesofdataovernineyearswithrepeatedinterviewsandskillsassessments.EarlyLSALdataindicatethatofthoseinthestudywhoparticipatedinaformalABEclasspriorto1998,nearlyhalf(46percent)alsoengagedinself‐studytoimprovetheirreading,writing,ormathskillsortopreparefortheGED.AmongthoseinthepopulationwhohadneverparticipatedinanABEprogram,oneinthree(34percent)hadengagedinself‐directedeffortstoimprovetheirbasicskills.Adultswithrelativelyweakbasicskillswerefoundtobejustaslikelytoengageinself‐studyasthosewithhigherlevelsofproficiency.Infact,thehighertheliteracyproficiencylevel,thelesslikelyadultsintheLSALsampleweretoengageinself‐studytoimprovetheirbasicskills(althoughmorethan30percentofadultsatthehighestlevelsofproficiencyengagedinself‐studytoasignificantdegree).About17percentofthosewhoparticipatedinaformalbasicskillsprogrambutdidnotself‐studyreceivedtheirGED,comparedto24percentofthoseengagedinself‐studywhodidnotparticipateinaprogram.ThehighestpercentageofGEDattainment(27percent)wasobservedamongthosewhodidboth.45Ananalysisofthecomputer‐relateddatafromthesurveyprovidesadditionalfindings:46 Atbaseline,working,householdincome,andowningacomputerpredictcomputeruse.
Controllingforthesecharacteristics,literacyproficiencysignificantlypredictscomputerusestatus.
Peoplewithhigherliteracyproficiencyscoresareearlieradoptersofcomputeruse.Newadoptersateachtimeperiodsurveyedreachintoprogressivelylowerlevelsofliteracyproficiency.
Mostadultsbornbefore1968learncomputerskillsinformallyoratwork,whileyounger
usersaretaughtinschool.Participantsofadulteducationprogramswerenotmorelikelyto
![Page 31: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
23
becomputerusersthannon‐participants.Allusersprefertocontinuetolearnnewcomputerskillsthroughtrialanderrorandwithhelpfromfriendsandfamily.
Popularcultureandinformallearningthroughcomputerusemayofferavenuesfor
developmentofnewliteraciesnotavailableinformalprograms.47Formoreinformation,http://www.lsal.pdx.edu.C. ProjectIDEALProjectIDEALisaconsortiumofstatesthathavebeenworkingtogethersince2001todevelopeffectivedistanceeducationprogramsforadultlearners.Thefoundinggroupof15stateshasgrowntoinclude27currentandalumnimembers.*TheProjectIDEALSupportCenterattheUniversityofMichiganprovidesmemberstateswithtechnicalassistanceforprogramplanning,teachertraining,andprogramevaluation.Italsodevelopstrainingmaterials,onlinecourses,andWeb‐basedresearchtoolsthatmemberstatesusetomanageandimprovetheirprograms.Statesvarywidelyinthescopeandstructureoftheirdistancelearningprograms.In2004‐2005,Californiaservedsome51,000adults—mostlyESLlearners—outsideofclassroomprograms,primarilyusingavideocheckoutmodel.48Onasmallerscale,Pennsylvaniaoffersdistancelearningusingonline,video,andprintmaterialsthroughbothacentralizeddistanceagencyandlocaladulteducationproviders.49OhiooffersbothGEDandESLcoursesatadistance.50Eachofthesestateshastrackeddatafortheirprogramsnotonlyinrelationtostudentoutcomesbutalsotoprogramchallengesforteachers,validityofstructure(withinthestate’ssystemorindependently),supportneedsforstudentsandteachers,andotherissues.Stateswithongoingprojectsanddatatrackingshowevidenceofeducationalgainsonthesamestandardizedmeasuresusedtoassessclassroomlearners,allowingstateandnationalpolicymakerstoincludethemintheircountsofstudentsserved.51Inaddition,85percentofadultdistancelearnersreportthattheywouldtakeanotherdistancecourse.52Thememberstates’experiencesovertimedemonstratethatdesigning,developing,andimplementingsuccessfuldistancelearninghasasmuchifnotmoretodowiththesystemsandprocessesasitdoeswithwhichtechnologiesareused.Forexample,commitmentandsupportatthestatelevelishighlyimportant,includingastate‐levelpersonchargedwithoverseeingtheinitialefforts.Otherimportantvariablesarefunding,teachertrainingintheinitialstagesofimplementation,ongoingprofessionaldevelopmentfordistanceteachers,carefulplanningandevaluationofsmallscaleeffortstodeterminewhichdistancestrategiesworkwithinthestate,andsufficienttimefortheprogramtomature.53Initialcostsinthismodelfrequentlyexceedthoseforclassroom‐basedprograms.Butthecoststendtodropdramaticallyovertime,asteachersandadulteducationprogramsbecomemore
*Memberstatesinclude:WA,ID,MT,AZ,NM,TX,OK,MO,IL,IN,MI,OH,PA,NY,ME,MA,FI,MD,DC,WV,KY,AR,LA,GA,FL,SC,NC.
![Page 32: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
24
skilledatrecruitingandsupportingtheappropriatelearners.Additionally,sincedistancelearninghasthepotentialtoincreasethenumberofstudentsserved,itisnecessarytoallocatefundstocoverthegrowthinservicesthatmustbeprovided.
Formoreinformation,http://www.projectideal.org.D. NationalResearchandDevelopmentCentreforAdultLiteracy(NRDC)NRDCwasestablishedin2002bytheU.K.DepartmentforEducationandSkills,aspartofSkillsforLife,thenationalstrategyforimprovingadultliteracyandnumeracyskills.A2008reportoftheNRDCcomparedlongitudinaldatafromtheLSALstudyinPortlandwithacohortinLondon,takingasitscontexttherisingimportanceofusingandaccessingcomputersaspartofcontemporaryemployability.54Thecentralconclusionofthisstudyisthat“employmentandICTusesupportthedevelopmentofliteracyproficiency.”Inotherwords,“enhancementofliteracyproficiencyisaidedsubstantiallybytimespentinemploymentandexposuretoICT.”Thereislessevidenceofeffectsintheotherdirection,i.e.,ofimprovedliteracyproficiencyinfluencingthetake‐upofICTorthelikelihoodofgettingemployment.TheauthorspointoutthatICTskillscannotbeviewedinisolationfromotheraspectsofemployability,inwhichliteracyproficiencyhasacentralplace.55AsecondNRDCstudylookedatquantitativeandqualitativedatafromresearchbetween2003and2006ofapproximately500adultlearnersandtutors.Itfocusedonquestionsaboutimprovingteaching,learning,andassessingliteracy,numeracy,ESL,andICTwithattentiontofactorsthatcontributetosuccessfullearning.Thesetookplaceonlyinclassroom,instructor‐led,and/ormediatedenvironmentsandwerenotcomparedwithdistanceoptions.Evaluationtrialsshowedthatlearnersinvolvedinthisstudyimprovedinalmostallcasesinbothliteracy/ESLskillsandICTskillsandconfidence,oftentoastatisticallysignificantdegree.MostusersfoundtheuseofICTmotivating.Mobiletechnologies(tablets,PDAs,mobilephones)werefoundtobeparticularlymotivating,andenabledgreaterflexibilityinteaching.AswasfoundinthecomparativestudyofPortlandandLondon,therelationshipofICTtoemploymentisoneofgreatsignificanceformanyadults,anditisoftenpartofthereasontheyenrollinthesecourses.56Formoreinformation,http://www.nrdc.org.uk.E. TheLiteracyandBasicSkillsProgramoftheOntarioMinistryofTraining,
CollegesandUniversities(MTCU)
TheMTCU’sLiteracyandBasicSkillsPrograminitiatedaprojecttoexploredistancelearningforliteracyservicesamongfouragenciesfrom2003‐2005.Thedistancelearnersenrolledinthisprojectweremostlywomenaged27‐39whohadnotcompletedhighschoolandwhowere
![Page 33: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
25
enrolledprimarilytoallowthemtoworkattheirownpaceortoaccommodatefamilyorjobobligations.Mostofthelearnershadnotenrolledinanadulteducationclassforanumberofyearsandmosthadheldtheirpreviousenrollmentforlessthanayear.Amongthekeyfindings: Significantbarrierscanbeovercomebyfocusingontheneedsoflearnersand
theircommunities.
Distancelearningcanbeaneffectivetoolwithlow‐levelliteracylearners. Learnersappeartobeabletosustaintheireffortsintheprogramwitharelativelysmall
numberofhoursofdirectinstructionalcontact(anaverageoflessthan2hourspermonth). Instructorsfordistancelearningspentmoreoftheirtimeinpreparationandlearnersupport,
unliketraditionalinstructorswhospendmoretimeindirectinstructionaldelivery. Sitesreportedthatlearnersweremostsuccessfulinself‐managementwhen:
– Webportalsandcustomizedwebsitesprovidedaccessforpostingfrequentlyupdatedinformation;
– Computerskillsorientationenabledlearnerstonavigatewithself‐efficacyandthusminimizedtheneedfortroubleshootingsupport;and
– Frequentandregularcommunicationamonglearnersoccurred,facilitatingalearningcommunityandpeer‐supportedlearningenvironment.
Formoreinformation,http://www.edu.gov.on.ca/eng/training/literacy/index.html.F. InvestigatingtheLanguageandLiteracySkillsRequiredforIndependentOnline
Learning,(NationalInstituteforLiteracy)ThisreportbyHeidiSilver‐Pacuilla,publishedin2008,isincludedherebecauseitprovidesacomprehensivereviewandanalysisnotonlyofthesummarystudiesdescribedabove,butalsoofmanyotherstudies,research,andinterviewsthatpertaintoadultsanddistancelearning.Inaddition,itsauthorconductedasecondaryanalysisofthe2003NationalAssessmentofAdultLiteracy(NAAL)datasettoprovideamoredetailedprofileoftechnologyuseamongpopulationswithlowliteracyandlowEnglishlanguageproficiency.ThepurposeofthisreportwastoinvestigatethethresholdlevelsofliteracyandlanguageproficiencynecessaryforindependentstudyontheInternet.Amajorfindingoftheworkisthatthresholdsdonotexist.Thereportstatesthat:
“Learnersateventhelowestlevelsofliteracyandlanguageproficiencycanengagewithonlinelearningcontent.Moreover,allreportsindicatethattheyareeagertodosoandthattheybenefitinimportantways,suchasinself‐confidence,self‐directedness,andindependence.Adultlearnersacrosstheliteracyandlanguagespectrumshowstrong
![Page 34: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
26
motivationtogaincomputerliteracyskills,perceivedaskeytoworkadvancement.Ultimately,itbecameapparentthattheinteractionamongthelearners’skills,theopportunitiestheyencounter,andthesupportsavailabledeterminesthosethresholds.”57
Otherkeyfindingsarethat: Thecentralityofworkreadinesstothelearninglivesofadultsprovidesakeyleveragepoint
forprogrammingandcontentdesigntoaddressthisgoalmoredirectlyand,throughit,morebasicliteracyandlanguageskills.
Adults’existingfamilyandsocialnetworksthathaveprovencriticaltolearningpursuitswith
technologyprovideanotherleveragepointthatcouldbetappedwithcommunity‐based,authenticlearningenvironments,activities,andproducts.
Self‐directedskillsvaluedbylifelonglearnerscanbenurturedbyprovidingfacilitatedaccess
toonline,independentlearningenvironments.
TheresultsoftheNAALanalysisareespeciallynoteworthy.InacomparisonofDocumentliteracyscores,about10percentfewertechnologyusershadBelowBasicscorescomparedtonon‐technologyusers,andabout10percentmoretechnologyusersscoredintheIntermediatelevelcomparedwithnon‐technologyusers.AsimilarpatternwasfoundforProseandQuantitativeliteracyscores.58Further,technologyuseisstronglyassociatedwithhigherliteracyscoresacrossdemographicvariablesofincome,education,andage.59G. EvaluationofEvidence‐BasedPracticesinOnlineLearning:AMeta‐Analysis
andReviewofOnlineLearningStudies,(U.S.DepartmentofEducation)
Thisliteraturereviewandmeta‐analysis(2009)isrelevantherebecause44ofthe51studyeffectsexaminedweredrawnfromresearchonolderlearners.TheprojectwassponsoredbytheCenterforTechnologyinLearningoftheOfficeofPlanning,Evaluation,andPolicyDevelopmentoftheU.S.DepartmentofEducation.Theanalysiswaslimitedtoasearchofstudiesofweb‐basedinstruction.Itincludesonlythosewithrandom‐assignmentorcontrolledquasi‐experimentaldesigns,anditexamineseffectsonlyforobjectivemeasuresofstudentlearning.60Amongthefindingsare: Studentswhotookallorpartoftheirclassonlineperformedbetter,onaverage,thanthose
takingthesamecoursethroughtraditionalface‐to‐faceinstruction.
Inmanyofthestudiesshowinganadvantageforonlinelearning,theonlineandclassroomconditionsdifferedintermsoftimespent,curriculum,andpedagogy.Itwasthecombinationofelements(likelytohaveincludedadditionallearningtimeandmaterialsaswellas
![Page 35: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
27
additionalopportunitiesforcollaboration)thatproducedtheobservedlearningadvantages.Itshouldbenotedthatonlinelearningismuchmoreconducivetoexpandinglearningtimethanface‐to‐faceinstruction.
Givinglearnerscontroloftheirinteractionswithmediaandpromptinglearnerreflectioncan
enhanceonlinelearning.
![Page 36: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
28
IV.BUILDINGTHEFOUNDATION:NEXT‐STEPRECOMMENDATIONS
hecasefordeployingtechnologytoexpandandimproveAmerica’sadulteducationandworkforceskillsenterpriseisevident.Criticallearningandmanagementneeds,barriersto
overcome,andachievingeconomiesofscale–allareareaswheretechnologyisuniquelysuitedtohelpusget“fromheretothere.”Anumberofsuccessfulpoliciesandpracticesarealreadyinuseatthestateandlocallevels.Theyarevaluableguidinglightsandwecanbuildonthem.Yet,atthispointintime,thereislittleawarenessoracceptanceoftheseinitiativesandnoseriousmovestousetechnologyonthescaleneededeitherlocallyorbeyondthegovernmentalorgeographicboundariesofstatesandcommunities.TheNationalCommissiononAdultLiteracycallsforconnectingtheadulteducationsystemtoworkforceandeconomicdevelopmentactivities.ThepotentiallytransformingcapacityoftheAdultEducationandEconomicGrowthActof2009(AEEGA)recentlyintroducedinCongress*callsforthesamething.Thefollowingrecommendationsarelargelycommonsenseactions,andtheyareinterconnectedinmanyways.Itisagiventhatfortheirfull,effectiveimplementation,federalandstateleadersinboththepublicandprivatesectorsmusttakeanactiverole.AEstablishingaNationalWebPortalUntilinformationaboutprogramoptionsisavailablenationally,onacomprehensiveandcrediblebasistoadultlearnersandprogramprofessionalsalike,thenationwillnotbeabletoexpandaccesstolearningsignificantly.Werecommendanationalwebportal,withthespecificationsindicatedbelow–althoughweshouldnotethatbecauseofthescaleanddiversityoftheirneeds,anequallycompellingcasecanbemadefortwoportals,onedesignedforadultlearnersandanotherforprofessionaluse.Butwhetherthereisoneportalortwo,presentationofcontenthasparamountimportance.Users,especiallylow‐literacylearnerswithlimitedICTskills,mustbeabletomovequicklytothecontenttheywant(withaminimumnumberofclicks)soastoensuremaximumparticipation.Pageappearanceandnavigationmustbedesignedverydifferentlyforthetwodifferentusergroups,andtheessentialdifferencesshouldbeimmediatelyobviousonthewebsitehomepage.Moreover,toooften,valuableonlineinformationandmaterialsgounusedbecauseoflackofawareness.Thus,akeycomponentforthesuccessofanyportalissustained*TheAdultEducationandEconomicGrowthAct(AEEGA)wasintroducedinCongressinJuly2009asH.R.3238(Rep.PatrickKennedy)andS.1458(Sen.JimWebb).ToaccesstheAEEGA,searchforAdultEducationandEconomicGrowthActatwww.thomas.gov.
T
![Page 37: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
29
disseminationandpromotionofinformationonlearningoptionsavailable,inwaysthatmosteffectivelyreachthespecifictargetaudiencesforwhichitisdesigned,especiallyadultlearners.*1.ForProfessionalUseOnesectionofthePortalshouldbespecificallydesignedforprofessionaluse–forthosewhoplan,operate,teachin,evaluate,andfundtechnology‐assistedadulteducationandworkforceskillsprograms.Itwouldbeaccessibletoinstructorsoradvisorswithprofessionaldevelopmentneeds,officialsandadministratorswithmanagementandmeasurementneeds,employerswithspecificoccupationorprofessionalneeds,researchfundingagencies,andmanyothers.Atpresent,awarenessofandaccesstotheplethoraofinformationavailableforthesemultiplepurposestoooftendependsonaccidentaldiscovery,wordofmouth,orextensivehit‐and‐missInternetsearches.Forprofessionalandskilledusers,thePortalwillcollect,review,andprovide:• Linkstohighqualitytoolsandapplicationsthatmakeprogrammanagementmoreefficient
andeffective,includinginformationontechnologyplanningandaboutstateandlocalpoliciesandregulationsforstudentslearningonline.
• Platforms,tools,andcontent–reviewedforqualityandcredibility–thatenableclassroomteachersanddistanceguides/mentorstodevelopandmakeuseofcontentfortheirownandlearners’use.
• Linkstoonlineprofessionaldevelopmentoptions(suchaswebcasts,podcasts,streaming
videotutorials,andonlinecourses),practicesforteachingandguidinglearnersatadistance,andonline“communities”ofotherpractitioners.
• Linkstoevidence‐andoutcomes‐basedresearchontechnology‐based/distance
adultlearning.• Informationonexistingfinancialaidforstudentsindistancelearningprograms.• Linkstorelatedprograms,websites,resourcecollections,curricula,andotherdata.2.ForAdultLearnersTheotherPortalsection,clearlyandimmediatelydifferentiatedinappearanceonthehomepage,wouldbegearedtothevariedneedsandskilllevelsofadultlearners.
*TheAEEGAalsorecognizestheneedforanationalportalaspartofitscallfortheestablishmentofanewNationalAdultLearningandTechnologyResourceCenter.
![Page 38: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
30
Tomakeuseofalready‐existingtechnology‐basedlearningprograms,adultlearnersmusthaveeasyaccesstoasinglesourceofcredibleinformationaboutthem,aswellasguidanceonhowtoidentifyandnavigateprogramssuitedtotheirneeds,andhowtomovealongpathwaystolearningassessmentandcertification.Thispartofthewebsitemustbedesignedtobe“user‐friendly”forthemajorityofadultlearners,includingthosewithlowlevelsofliteracyand/orESLandthosewhohavelimitedInternetaccessorlittlebeginningknowledgeofcomputeruse.ItalsomustbeeasytonavigateonmobiledevicesforthosewithoutaccesstocomputersortheInternetathomeorwork.Evenwebsitesthatcurrentlypurporttoservetheseadultsrarelyprovidelinkstootherprogramoptionsandtheyarenotdesignedforeasyaccessandnavigation.ThePortalsectionforAdultLearnersshouldbethecentralrepositoryofalladultlearningprogramsandcontentavailable–inanonlineenvironmentwhereeveryone,includingyoungadults,canimprovetheirreading,writing,ESL,math,andbasicworkforce/workplaceskillsinaninteractivefashionattheirownconvenience.Forstudentlearners,thePortalshouldinclude,thoughnotnecessarilybelimitedto:
• Online“self‐study”optionsdesignedforformalcertifications,suchasGED,andoptionsthatofferinformallearningofallkinds.
• Linkstoappropriatelearningassessments.
• Easy‐to‐accessinformationonformalprograms,testingcenters,onlinetutorsandguides,studymaterials,andotherusefulcontent.
• Linkstoindividualplatforms,applications,andcurriculaforadultlearning,andto
teachersandlearningfacilitators.
• Informationaboutandlinkstorelevantworkforceandworkplaceprograms,includingthosethatprovideonlineskillsassessment,onlinetrainingforworkreadinessskills,informationaboutjobopenings,andotherpracticalassistance.
• Informationonnationallyavailableonlinecertificatesanddegreeprogramsthat
respondtoidentifiedhigh‐growthareasineachstate.TheNationalPortalshouldbeestablishedandrunbyanindependentinteragencyfederalbody.TheNationalInstituteforLiteracy(NIFL)wouldbeidealinthisroleaslongasitretainsanindependentstructure,adoptsafutures‐orientedagenda,andisadequatelyfunded.*ItissuggestedthatanAdvisoryBoard,perhapsbrokenintosubcommitteesthatfocusonthetwousergroups,beformedtohelptheresponsibleentitydevelopguidelinesforthecontentandoperationofeachPortalsection.
*AsurgedintheAEEGA,andproposedinanewCAALpaperRebuildingNIFLtoMeetFutureNeeds:ANewAgencywithaBroaderMission,October9,2009,availableasNC‐CAAL10fromwww.caalusa.org/publications.html.
![Page 39: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
31
ThisAdvisoryBoardshouldincludeadulteducators,potentialusers,technologylearningexperts,workforce/workplacedevelopmentinterests,leadersfrombusinessandlabor,curriculumdevelopmentspecialists,expertsintechnology‐assistedlearning,programplannersinadulteducationandworkforceskillsdevelopment(includingESL),assessmentexperts,andperhapsvendorsandothers,andsoftwareanddevice‐specificapplicationdevelopers.Thegoalshouldbetoestablishandeffectivelymarketdatabasesthatarecomprehensive,credible,andeasytokeepcurrent.Theyshouldprovidelinkstobestpractices,courses,andprograms,bothcommercialandnon‐commercial,frompublicandprivatesectorsourcesinboththeU.S.andabroad.3. EnsuringRelevantPortalProgramsandContent
Therelativelysmallvolumeandvarietyofcurrentlyavailableonlineprogrammingwillrequireongoingdevelopmentofnewprogramsandcontent.Thus–• ThePortalAdvisoryBoardshouldaggregateandassessexistingfreelyavailablecontentand
websitesineachareaofadulteducation(ABE,ASE/GED,ESL,work‐andcollege‐readiness)todetermineifthecontentisofsufficientqualityandrangefortheneedsofbothprofessionalandlow‐skilledadultlearners.
• TheNationalInstituteforLiteracy(NIFL)orequivalentfederalentity,incooperationwith
otherfederalagencies,shouldfunddevelopmentofnewandexistingprograms,content,andapplicationsforadulteducationviaanRFPprocess–witheligibleapplicantstoincludenonprofitandfor‐profitgroups,educationinstitutions,partnershipsofadulteducationandworkforceskills,andindividualswithprovencredentials.
• NIFLorotherappropriatefederalentity,withassistancefromitsAdvisoryBoard,should
maintainregularcommunicationswiththeICTindustry,technology‐assistedlearningresearchers,andvendors–toensurethatnewversionsofdevicesanddevice‐specificapplications(especiallyformobilelearning)andnewtechnologiesforaccessingcontentareincorporatedintoavailableinformationonbothsectionsofthePortal.
• NIFLorotherappropriatefederalentityshouldmaintainregularcommunicationswithnon‐
governmentalorganizationsandcommunity‐basedorganizationsandothers–toensureeffectiveoutreachtoadultswhodonotparticipateinformalprogramsandservices.
4. FactorsinDeterminingPortalCostsThecostsforestablishingandmaintainingtheNationalPortalcannotbedeterminedatthisstagebecausetheydependontheoutcomesofplanningandonchoicesmadeamongmanypossiblevariables.Moreover,eachofthreebasicwebportalcomponents–thedevelopmentof
![Page 40: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
32
thewebsiteitself,monitoringandupdatingcontent,anddevelopingnewcontent–requiresdifferentapproachestoestimatingcosts.EstablishingthePortal.Anessentialrequirementforanysite,regardlessofuseraudience,istheabilitytotrackandmeasureuseandvariationsinuseinordertodetermineifthewebsiteaccomplishesitsgoals.Suchevaluationcomponentshavedifferingcostimplicationsandrequireparticularspecificationsforthewebsite’sunderlying“architecture.”Othertechnicalrequirementsforwebsitesvarydependingontheneedsofthetargetaudience.Atypical“portal”siteprovideslittlemorethansubject/issue/usercategorieswithlinkstocontentlistedaccordingly.Thiskindofoption,whichislesscostlythanawebsite“customized”tothetargetusers,wouldbefeasibleforinitialestablishmentofthePortal’ssectionforprofessional/skilledusers.ThePortalsectionforadultlearnerswillcostconsiderablymoretodevelopbecauseitismorecomplex.Forexample,itwillneedauser‐friendlydesignthatreachesallskilllevels.Learningmustbestructuredtosuitspecificgoals,suchasacquiringaGED,reachingaparticularlevelofEnglishspeaking/understandingand/orwriting,andattainingavocationalcertification.[SeeLearnerWebmodel,AppendixE,p.52.]Inaddition,optionsmustbeprovidedforself‐study,aswellasforlearnerssupportedbyteachersortutors–contentshouldprovideforfeedbackfromandtoindividualusers,learningsequencescustomizedtotheindividuals’response,frequentandregularassessmentthatenableslearnerstoself‐assesswhethertheyhavelearnedthecontent,andotherfunctions.UpdatingthePortal.Themaincostsforupdatingtheportalsareassociatedwithidentifyingandevaluatingnewprogramsandcontent,addingnewmaterialtothesites,andupgradingthesitesasnewtechnologiesaredeveloped.Thecostofaddingnewmaterialdependsonwhetherthecontenthasbeendesignedforanonlineenvironmentthatusesthemostsophisticatedpedagogicalandtechnicaldesignsorwhetheritisaprogramwithsimplerfunctions.TheSCORMmodeldescribedinAppendixD(p.47)isonecost‐effectiveapproach.DevelopedinitiallybyaconsortiumoftheU.S.DepartmentofDefenseandotherfederalagencies,universitiesandotherresearchinstitutions,andtechnologycompanies,SCORM(ShareableContentObjectReferenceModel)makesitsimpletodevelop,useandre‐use,andmovefromonecurriculumorcoursetoanother.Moreover,SCORMincludessimpleandcost‐effectivemethodsforstorageandaccessofmaterial,and“opensource”websitesandcontentalsoenhanceoptionsforuserinputandfreeaccess.DevelopingNewContent.Thecostsofdevelopingnewcontent,althoughthesearenotnecessarilyannuallyrecurringcostsordependentonfederaloutlaysalone,willbehigherthanthecostsofbuildingandroutinelyupdatingthePortal,perhapsupwardsof$1millionforonenewmultimediaESLorbasicskillscourse.TheAEEGArecommendsnewfundingof$250millionforallpurposesinitsproposedTitleIIIcalled21stCenturyTechnologyandSkillsforAdultLearners.Theproposalincludes$7.5million
![Page 41: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
33
tosupportaNIFL‐managedNationalAdultLearningandTechnologyResourceCenterwhereanationalwebportalwouldbebased.Judgingfromourdiscussionswiththosewhooperateexistingportalsites,thislevelofproposedannualfundingshouldbeadequatetocoverbothinitialandrecurringcostsforPortaldevelopmentandmaintenance.BEncouragingStateLeadershipSelf‐studyactivitiesneedtobegroundedinparticularstateandregionalserviceprogramswherelearninggainscanbeformallyverified,andwherecommunitiesofneedcanbereachedthroughtargetedawarenessandoutreachcampaigns.Stateplanningandleadershipmustgohandinhandwithfederalleadership.Althoughstatesmustseeadulteducationastheirownandnotjustafederalissue,inthepresenteconomicclimateconcretefederalincentiveswillbeneeded.Itisrecommendedthatthefederalgovernmentlaunchagrantprogramdesignedtohelpstatesintegratetechnology‐assistedlearningsystemsand/orprogramsintotheiroveralladulteducationandworkforceskillsplanning.Eachstate–basedonplanningthatinvolvesallessentialstakeholders–shouldbechallengedto:
• Developastatewideplantointegratetechnologyintoitsadulteducationandworkforceskillssystem;
• Provideprofessionaldevelopmentforthosewhoteachinandmanageadulteducation,literacy,andworkforce/workplaceskillsservices;
• Giveadultlearnersandeligibleprovidersaccesstocurricula,instruction,
andassessment;
• Developinnovativepilotprojectsorimproveexistingprogramstoexpandtheuseoftechnologytoadultlearners;and
• Alignadulteducationservices(inABE,ASE/GED,ESL),postsecondaryeducation
(especiallycommunitycolleges),andoccupational/workforceskillsprogramssothatcomparablecoursecontentandcreditearnedinonepartofthesystemcantransferascredittoanother.
TheNationalInstituteforLiteracyorotherappropriatebodyshouldformanewAdvisoryCommitteeoftheStatestohelpdevelopthegrantprogram.ThisCommitteeshouldbesensitivetovariancesinstateneed,knowfirst‐handaboutwell‐runandsolidlydesignedsystemsandprograms,andvaluetheprovisionofinformationandaccessacrossstateboundaries.
![Page 42: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
34
CSupportingDistanceLearningProgramsFederalandstateleadersmustthinkoutsidetheboxastheyworktooffereffectivedistancelearningoptionsthatextendbeyondformalprogramsandastheyfacetheneedtovalidategainsthatoccurthroughindependentlearning.Thenationalwebportalconstitutesthecornerstoneofthisproposedplanofaction.Butaccessalonewillnotbeenough.Avarietyofsupportsmustbeidentifiedandofferedtoensureparticipationandsuccessfuloutcomes.Forexample,manylearnersneedtobemotivatedtojoin,re‐engage,and/orpersistinsuitableprograms.Newstrategiesareneededtoaccommodateadults’multiplelife,work,andfamilyresponsibilities.Learninggainswillhavetobemeasuredandvalidatedinnewandnontraditionalways.Andwemustknowifandwhenwereachdesirededucationaloutcomes.• Projectsshouldbeundertakentodevelopandimprove:
o Distancelearningcertificationsforonlineusethatcanbeusedforcollegecredit–incollaborationwithpostsecondaryinstitutionsandjobtrainingprograms–includingindustryand/orqualification‐specificcertificationssuchasinformationtechnology;
o PerformancemeasuresthatarelinkedtomultiplelevelsofcertificationforICTliteracy;
o Onlineassessmentsforlearning,includingnecessaryprovisionsforsecurityand
validation;and
o Theframeworkformaterialsdevelopmentfortechnology‐basedlearningandprofessionaldevelopmentforadulteducationandworkforceskills–i.e.,amapofthegreatestneedssoastoimprovethequalityandquantityofprogramsandservicesandhelpensurethemostcost‐effectiveuseoffundingresourcesandtime.
• Demonstrationprojectsshouldbefundedtotestandadaptnewformsof
technology‐basedlearning.
• Government,communitycolleges,andothersshouldseektoalignandarticulateunitsofsuccessfullearningonlinewithcommunitycollegecredits,inamannersimilartothatofPresidentObama’scommunitycollegeinitiative.Federalagencieswithmajorresponsibilityforadulteducationshouldtaketheleadinthisinitiative,especiallytheU.S.DepartmentsofLabor,HHS,Education,andDefense.
DMeetingTheResearchNeedThestudiesdiscussedinthispaperconstituteasolidbodyofresearch.Buttheyarearelativelysmalldatabaseandnotasufficientbasisonwhichtodevelopongoingpolicyorpractice.
![Page 43: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
35
• Thefederalgovernmentshouldsupportasustained,serious,andwell‐fundedresearch,analysis,andevaluationeffort–tosupportandinformtheuseoftechnologyanddistancelearningforadulteducationandworkforceskillspurposes,andtoenrichthenationalwebportalonanongoingbasis.
Followingareafewareasinneedofattention:
• Betterbaselinedataonadultlearnersandcomputeruse.
• Evaluationsofexistingprogramsandprogramuse.Thesuccessoftechnology‐basedself‐studylearningshouldbeevaluatedasitrelatestospecificeducationaloutcomes–gettingaGED,gainingEnglishlanguageproficiency,anddemonstratingreadinessforjobsandcollege.Wewillneedtoknowaboutthekindsoftechnology‐assistedlearningadultsfindanduse,whyandhowtheyuseit,whetheritiseffectiveinachievingtheoutcomestheysought,and,ifso,why.
• Analysisofsoftwareandlearningdevelopmentanddesignsforonlinelearning–sothatwecanknowmoreabouttheconditionsunderwhichsuccessfulInternet‐basedinteractivelearningtakesplace.
• Theconvergenceofmobileand“justintime”learning.
NationalAdultLearningTechnologyResourceCenter.Toprovideanoperationalbaseforthearrayofdistancelearningactivitiesrecommendedabove,anewNationalAdultLearningTechnologyResourceCentershouldbeestablished,underthejurisdictionoftheNationalInstituteforLiteracyoranotherappropriateinteragencybody.ThisCentershouldbethesourceofgrantstosupporttheaboveactivities.Itshouldoperateaclearinghouseforresearchabouttechnology‐assistedadultlearningthatisnotpartofformalprograminstruction.Anditshoulddevelopaninformeddataprofileofaccess,use,andconnectivityratesamongadults,possiblyincludingquestionsforthenextNationalAssessmentofAdultLearning.EFosteringStakeholderInvolvementIfthenationistotrulytransformadulteducationandworkforceskillsservicesfor21stcenturyneeds,andifitistofullytapthepotentialoftechnologytotakethatefforttoscale,federalandstategovernmentmustprovideincentivesfortheinvolvementofacompleterangeofnongovernmentalstakeholdergroups.Tothisend:• Collaborationshouldbeencouragedatthefederal,state,andlocallevelsamongsuch
stakeholdersasnonprofitadulteducationandworkforceskillsserviceproviders,stateandlocalplanningagencies,businesses,unions,youthpolicyorganizations,familyliteracygroups,correctionalinstitutions,schooldistricts,communitycolleges,healthcareentities,andothers.
![Page 44: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
36
• TheNationalInstituteforLiteracyorotherappropriateentityshouldestablishanadvisorycommitteerepresentingtheinterestsandneedsofthesegroupstoinformactionatthenationallevel,andstatesmightformsimilargroupstoinformtheirownplanning.Thegoalshouldbetodevelopandpromoteinnovativeplansandprogramsthatareresponsivetostateandlocalneed,and,whereappropriate,thatfittherealitiesoflocaleconomiesandbusinesspatterns,andthatincludeactiveinputbybusiness.
• Corporateandfundingpartnershaveaspecialimplementationroletoplay.Amongother
things,theyshouldbecalledupontodonateequipmentand/orprovidegrantssothatlow‐incomeadultscanacquirecomputerhardwareandInternetconnectivitytotakeadvantageofdistancelearningopportunities.Corporationscanalsocontributeemployeetimetohelpwithvariouskindsoftechnicalassistance.Andbecausetheystandtobenefitfromadulteducationforworkactivities,theyarenaturalpartnersindevelopingtherecommendednationalwebportal.
![Page 45: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
37
V.CONCLUSION
echnologyischangingthetime‐honoredbeliefthatadulteducation,asitexiststoday,iswhat“mustbe”toawiderunderstandingthatlearningiswhat“canbe.”Itisnotapractical
orevendesirableoptiontoabandonthecurrentsystem.Norisitaviableoptiontosimplycontinue“fixing”thissystem.Fortunately,wehavethemeansandknow‐howforasubstantialredirectionofthenationaladulteducationandworkforceskillseffortwithtechnologyasourally.Reportafterrecentreportmakesitclearthatweneedwholesalechangeandthatthewiderandwiseruseoftechnologycanhelpbringaboutthatchange.
T
![Page 46: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
38
AppendixA:AbouttheStudyDirector
MaryMcCain,SeniorVicePresidentofTechVision21,directedtheprojectthatresultedinthisCAALpublication,THEPOWEROFTECHNOLOGYTOTRANSFORMADULTLEARNING:ExpandingAccesstoAdultEducation&WorkforceSkillsThroughDistanceLearning.TechVision21isaWashington‐basedpublicpolicyconsultinggroupdedicatedtodevelopmentandapplicationoftechnologytoworkforcedevelopment,adulteducation,andotherissues.Dr.McCainearnedherPh.D.fromGeorgetownUniversity.HercurrentclientsincludetheMicrosoftCorporationandtheCenterforWomenandWorkatRutgersUniversity,wheresheisanAffiliateFellow.RecentclientsincludetheNationalCenteronEducationandtheEconomy,theU.S.ArmyEducationandOutreachProgram,andtheCenterforWorkforceSuccessoftheManufacturingInstituteoftheNationalAssociationofManufacturers.Shehasextensiveexperiencewithotherprivateandgovernmentalresearchandpolicyorganizations,suchastheAmericanSocietyforTrainingandDevelopmentandtheNationalGovernorsAssociation.HerlonglistofpublicationsinthefieldoftechnologyandlearningincludeLeapfroggingtheStatusQuo:E‐LearningandtheChallengeofAdultLiteracy(commissionedbyJobsfortheFuture),E‐Learning:AreWeinTransitionorAreWeStuck?(fortheNationalAssociationofManufacturersCenterforWorkforceSuccess),andAmerica’sWorkforceinCrisis:FacingtheChallengeforWorkforceDevelopmentintheGlobalEconomy(MicrosoftCommunityAffairs).
![Page 47: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
39
AppendixB:ProfessionalAdvisors(*WorkingGroup)
BruceN.ChalouxDirector,StudentAccessProgramsandServicesandtheElectronicCampusSouthernRegionalEducationBoard*ForrestP.ChismanSeniorVicePresidentCouncilforAdvancementofAdultLiteracy*JohnComingsPrincipalInternationalTechnicalAdvisorEducationDevelopmentCenterFormerDirector,NationalCenterontheStudyofAdultLearningandLiteracy(NCSALL) JoAnnCrandallProfessorofESOL/BilingualEducationDirector,Ph.D.PrograminLanguage,Literacy&CultureUniversityofMaryland,BaltimoreCounty(UMBC)*JohnFleischmanExecutiveDirectorOutreachandTechnicalAssistanceNetwork(OTAN) MykGarnDirector,EducationalTechnologySouthernRegionalEducationBoard*MaryGattaSeniorAdvisorSloanCenteronInnovativeTrainingandWorkforceDevelopmentDepartmentofLaborStudiesandEmploymentRelationsCenterforWomenandWork,RutgersUniversityJeromeJohnstonDirector,ProjectIDEALSupportCenterResearchProfessor,InstituteforSocialResearchUniversityofMichigan*CherylD.KingPresident,KentuckyWesleyanCollegeStudyDirector,NationalCommissiononAdultLiteracy*GeorgeKochDirector,GovernmentImplementationAdvancedDistributedLearningInitiative
![Page 48: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
40
*GarrettMurphyNationalABEPolicyAnalystAdvisortoCouncilforAdvancementofAdultLiteracy*MarkMusickQuillenChairofExcellenceinTeachingandLearning,ClaudiusG.ClemmerCollegeofEducationEastTennesseeStateUniversityMember,NationalCommissiononAdultLiteracy *JimParkerPolicyandResearchAssociateCouncilforAdvancementofAdultLiteracyFormerly,OfficeofVocationalandAdultEducationU.S.DepartmentofEducationLesliePettyAssociateDirector,ProjectIDEALSupportCenterUniversityofMichiganStephenRederUniversityProfessorandChairDepartmentofAppliedLinguisticsPortlandStateUniversityDavidRosenNewsomeAssociates*HeidiSilver‐PacuillaResearchAnalystAmericanInstitutesforResearch*MartinSimonDirectorSocial,Economic&WorkforceDevelopmentDivisionNationalGovernors’Association *GailSpangenbergPresidentCouncilforAdvancementofAdultLiteracyMember,NationalCommissiononAdultLiteracyClareStrawnAssistantProfessorPortlandStateUniversityLauraWestbergDirector,Research/SpecialProjectsNationalCenterforFamilyLiteracy
![Page 49: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
41
AppendixC:Endnotes(Note:Linkfunctionalitycanvarybybrowser,server,andPDFversion.)
1D.JonesandP.Kelly,MountingPressuresFacingtheU.S.WorkforceandtheIncreasedNeedforAdultEducationandLiteracy.PreparedfortheNationalCommissiononAdultLiteracy.Boulder,CO:NationalCenterforHigherEducationManagementSystems(NCHEMS),2007.[http://www.nationalcommissiononadultliteracy.org/pandp.html,Item2].2 U.S.CensusBureau,2006AmericanCommunitySurvey(PublicUseMicrodataSamples);analysisfortheNationalCommissiononAdultLiteracybytheNationalCenterforHigherEducationManagementSystems(NCHEMS),inReachHigher,America,finalreportoftheCommission,June2008,pp.2‐3. 3Federaladulteducation,training,andEnglishlanguageprogramsreachonlyabout3millionadultsayear,includingabout600,000intheadulteducationprogramsoftheWorkforceInvestmentActTitleI(DepartmentofLabor)adultprogram,dislocatedworkerprogram,TradeAdjustmentAssistance,andout‐of‐schoolyouth.Totalstatefundingforadulteducationandliteracyin2008isabout$1.6billion,approximatelythreetimesthefederallgrantamount;yetthatnumberisdeceptivebecausestateappropriationsvarywidely:justthreestates–California,Florida,andNewYork–provide65percentofallstatefunding.ReachHigherAmerica,p.11;Appendix6.[http://www.nationalcommissiononadultliteracy.org]4NationalCommissiononAdultLiteracy,op.cit.,pp.vi,24.[http://www.nationalcommissiononadultliteracy.org]5ExcerptsofthePresident’sremarksinWarren,Michigantoday[July14,2009]andafactsheetontheAmericanGraduationInitiative.OfficeofthePressSecretary,TheWhiteHouse.Availablefromhttp://www.whitehouse.gov/the_press_office/Excerpts‐of‐the‐Presidents‐remarks‐in‐Warren‐Michigan‐and‐fact‐sheet‐on‐the‐American‐Graduation‐Initiative/6USDepartmentofLaborBureauofLaborStatistics,Table1.Employmentbymajorindustrysector,1996,2006,and2016.Availableathttp://www.bls.gov/emp/empmajorindustry.pdf.7 JohnBynner,SteveReder,SamanthaParsonsandClareStrawn,ResearchSummary:TheDigitalDivide:ComputerUse,BasicSkillsandEmployment:AComparativeStudyinPortland[OR],USAandLondon,England.NationalResearchandDevelopmentCentre(NRDC),October2008.Availablefromhttp://www.nrdc.org.uk/publications_details.asp?ID=149. 8HeidiSilver‐Pacuilla,InvestigatingtheLanguageandLiteracySkillsRequiredforIndependentOnlineLearning.Washington,DC.NationalInstituteforLiteracy(10/08),p.1.Availablefromhttp://nifl.gov/publications/pdf/NIFLOnlineLearningReport.pdf.9Horrigan,John.HomeBroadbandAdoption,June2009.Washington,DC:PewInternetandAmericanLifeProject.Availablefromhttp://www.pewinternet.org/Reports/2009/10‐Home‐Broadband‐Adoption‐2009.aspx.TrendDataforDemographicsofInternetUsers,April2009Survey,PewInternetandAmericanLifeProject,availablefromhttp://www.pewinternet.org/Static‐Pages/Trend‐Data/Whos‐Online.aspx.
![Page 50: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
42
10 Partnershipfor21stCenturySkills,21stCenturyLearningEnvironments,2009,p.3.Availableathttp://www.21stcenturyskills.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=600<emid=185. 11NationalCommissiononAdultLiteracy,ReachHigherAmerica,pp.12‐13.[http://www.nationalcommissiononadultliteracy.org]12 Information Use Management Policy Institute, Public Libraries and the Internet 2008: Study Results and Findings, funded by the American Library Association and the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, pp. 1-3 and following. Available at http://www.ii.fsu.edu/content/view/full/15153. 13NRSmeasuresforintake/outcomes:(i)Reportingrequirementsincludeademographicprofileofeachindividualstudentwhoenrolls,alongwithcontacthoursandprogramenrollmenttype.Withoutastudentrecord,aprogramcannotreceivefundingforstudentswithno“intake”record.(ii)Studentsengagedinself‐studycannotmaintainalinktotheaccountabilitysystem,eveniftheycomeinandoutofit,becausetheyarenotformallyreported.14AnexcellentandextendeddiscussionofthisissueandrecommendationsmaybefoundinarecentreportbyTimMcDonaldandTedKolderie,TheRoleofInformationTechnologyinCreatingNewKindsofAmericanHighSchools.Washington,DC:InformationTechnologyandInnovationFoundation,July16,2009,pp.4‐6.Availableathttp://www.itif.org/index.php?id=263.15 U.S. Department of Education, Changes to NRS Guidelines for Distance Education Learners (2007). Available at http://www.nrsweb.org/docs/foundations/NRSGuidelinesSummaryofChangesJune2007.doc. 16NationalCommissiononAdultLiteracy,ReachHigherAmerica,p.24.[http://www.nationalcommissiononadultliteracy.org]17TheUSHigherEducationActof1998defines“distanceeducation”asfollows:(A)INGENERAL–Exceptasotherwiseprovided,theterm"distanceeducation"meanseducationthatusesoneormoreofthetechnologiesdescribedinsubparagraph(B)–(i)todeliverinstructiontostudentswhoareseparatedfromtheinstructor;and(ii)tosupportregularandsubstantiveinteractionbetweenthestudentsandinstructor,synchronouslyorasynchronously.(B)INCLUSIONS‐‐Forthepurposesofsubparagraph(A),thetechnologiesusedmayinclude‐‐(i)theInternet;(ii)one‐wayandtwo‐waytransmissionsthroughopenbroadcast,closedcircuit,cable,microwave,broadbandlines,fiberoptics,satellite,orwirelesscommunicationsdevices;(iii)audioconferencing;or(iv)videocassettes,DVDs,andCD‐ROMS,ifthecassettes,DVDs,orCD‐ROMSareusedinacourseinconjunctionwithanyofthetechnologieslistedinclauses(i)through(iii).18(1)SeeCaliforniaDistanceLearningProjectatwww.cdlponline.org;ProjectIDEALconsortiumofstatesatwww.projectideal.org;thePortland(OR)LongitudinalStudyofAdultLearningatwww.lsal.pdx.edu.(2)PaulPorterandMatthewSturm,CrossingtheGreatDivides:DistancelearningandflexibledeliveryinAdultBasicEducation.ResearchReportforOntario’sLiteracyandBasicSkillsProgram.Ontario:HumanResourcesandSocialDevelopmentCanada.AlphaPlusCentre.August2006.Availableathttp://www.distance.alphaplus.ca/pdfs/CrossingTheGreatDividesFullRpt.pdf.(3)HumanResourcesandSkillsDevelopmentCanada–GettingOnline:TheGOProject.Availableathttp://auspace.athabascau.ca:8080/dspace/handle/2149/2115.(4)RoslinBrennan,Onesizedoesn’tfitall:Pedagogyintheonlineenvironment–Volume1.NationalVocationalandEducationalTrainingSystem(NCVER),AustralianFlexibleLearningFramework,2003.Availableat
![Page 51: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
43
http://www.eric.ed.gov:80/ERICWebPortal/custom/portlets/recordDetails/detailmini.jsp?_nfpb=true&_&ERICExtSearch_SearchValue_0=ED476928&ERICExtSearch_SearchType_0=no&accno=ED476928.19StephenReder&ClareStrawn,Self‐Study:BroadeningtheConceptsofParticipationandProgramSupport,FocusonBasics,Vol.8,IssueC,11/06,pp.6‐10.NationalCenterfortheStudyofAdultLiteracy.Availableathttp://www.ncsall.net/?id=1152.20(1)RichardStilesandDennisPorter,TheCaliforniaAdultEducation2005‐2007InnovationandAlternativeInstructionalDeliveryProgram:AReview.CaliforniaStateUniversityDominguezHillsCollegeofExtendedandInternationalEducation,2007.http://www.cdlponline.org/pdf/InnovationProgramsReport2005‐2007.pdf;(2)StephenRederandClareStrawn,Self‐Study:BroadeningtheConceptsofParticipationandProgramSupport,FocusonBasics,Vol.8,IssueC,11/06,pp.6‐10.NationalCenterfortheStudyofAdultLiteracy.Foundatwww.ncsall.edu.(3)BarbaraMeans;YukieToyama;RobertMurphy;MarianneBakiaandKarlaJones,EvaluationofEvidence‐BasedPracticesinOnlineLearning:AMeta‐AnalysisandReviewofOnlineLearningStudies.U.S.DepartmentofEducation,OfficeofPlanning,Evaluation,andPolicyDevelopment,PolicyandProgramStudiesService,CenterforTechnologyinLearning,2009.Availableathttp://www.ed.gov/rschstat/eval/tech/evidence‐based‐practices/finalreport.pdf.21BarbaraMeans,et.al.,op.cit.;RichardStilesandDennisPorter,op.cit.,PaulPorterandMatthewSturm,CrossingtheGreatDivides:DistancelearningandflexibledeliveryinAdultBasicEducation.ResearchReportforOntario’sLiteracyandBasicSkillsProgram.Ontario:HumanResourcesandSocialDevelopmentCanada(2006).[http://distance.alphaplus.ca]22ASuccessStoryinOhio,DistanceinAction,ProjectIDEAL,2007.Availableathttp://www.projectideal.org/distance_in_action/action_1.html.Examplesincludeonlinevideosof“master”teachersusingtechnologyinadultlearningclassesinallsubjectsatalllevels(www.mlots.org);Moodlethatprovidesaplatformfordevelopingandtrackingstudentlearning(http://www.moodle.org);thePennsylvaniaonlineadulteducationwebsite(http://www.able.state.pa.us/able/cwp/view.asp?a=7&Q=42479&g=177&ableNav=|2842|3104|&ableNav=|3100|&ableNav=|2760|3100|;andwikisforonlineadulteducation,suchashttp://wiki.literacytent.org/index.php/Adult_Literacy_Professional_Developmentandhttp://aalpdresources.pbworks.com/. 23 Drawn from analysis done by the National Commission on Adult Literacy. 24 Significant work on persistence in community college ESL programs can be found at the website of the Council for Advancement of Adult Literacy, www.caalusa.org. 25RichardStilesandDennisPorter,TheCaliforniaAdultEducation2005‐2007InnovationandAlternativeInstructionalDeliveryProgram:AReview.CaliforniaStateUniversityDominguezHillsCollegeofExtendedandInternationalEducation,2007.http://www.cdlponline.org/pdf/InnovationProgramsReport2005‐2007.pdf 26JohnP.Comings,“StudentPersistenceinAdultLiteracyandNumeracyPrograms,p.173inStephenRederandJohnBynner,eds.,TrackingAdultLiteracyandNumeracySkills:FindingsfromLongitudinalResearch.NewYork:Routledge,2009.
![Page 52: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
44
27SeeSectionIIIforadescriptionofthisstudy. 28 RederandStrawn,op.cit.,pp.6‐8. 29SeedetailsofprogramsinOhio,Pennsylvania,NorthCarolina,andMissouriontheProjectIDEALwebsite:www.projectideal.org/distance_in_action/index.htmlandwww.projectideal.org/publications_resources/research_reports.html30InformationUseManagementandPolicyInstitute,op.cit.,pp.1‐3.TheUSCensusroutinely,butnotannually,asksaccessquestionsonitshouseholdsurveys.ItsmostrecentsurveydataforInternetaccessisfrom2007andfindsthat61.7percentofhouseholdsreportaccess.The2007surveydidnotaskaquestionaboutcomputeraccess,themostrecentyearforthatquestionbeing2003.U.S.CensusBureau,ComputerandInternetUseintheUnitedStates:October2007,Tables1‐5.Availableatwww.census.gov/population/www/socdemo/computer.html.31InformationUseManagementandPolicyInstitute,op.cit.,pp.1‐3. 32Kennedy,TracyL.M.;Smith,Aaron;Wells,AmyTracyandWellman,Barry,NetworkedFamilies,PewInternetandAmericanLifeProject,October19,2008.Availablefromhttp://www.pewinternet.org/Reports/2008/Networked‐Families.aspx.TheMaristInstituteforPublicOpinionPollconductedinMarchof2009foundaslightlyhigherpercentage‐87percent‐ofUSresidentswhohaveacellphone.Thosewithannualincomeslessthan$50,000/yeardroppedto82percent.Availableatwww.marketingcharts.com/interactive/employment‐age‐top‐factors‐in‐cell‐phone‐pda‐use‐9678/33TrendDataforDemographicsofInternetUsers,April2009Survey,PewInternetandAmericanLifeProject,availablefromhttp://www.pewinternet.org/Static‐Pages/Trend‐Data/Whos‐Online.aspx.34Horrigan,John.HomeBroadbandAdoption,June2009.Washington,DC:PewInternetandAmericanLifeProject.Availablefromhttp://www.pewinternet.org/Reports/2009/10‐Home‐Broadband‐Adoption‐2009.aspx.35Mostadultsbornbefore1968learncomputerskillsinformallyoratwork,whileyoungerusersaretaughtinschool.Participantsofadulteducationprogramswerenotmorelikelytobecomputerusersthannon‐participants.Allusersprefertocontinuetolearnnewcomputerskillsthroughtrialanderrorandwithhelpfromfriendsandfamily.ClareStrawn,TheRelationshipBetweenLiteracyProficiencyandtheDigitalDivideAmongAdultsWithLowEducationAttainment,2008.Availablefromhttp://www.lsal.pdx.edu/Documents/PDF/littech.pdf.Alsoseeanalysisofdatafrom2006UKsurvey,[email protected],S.Gorard,andJ.Furlong,AdultlearningintheDigitalAge,London,2006,citedinHeidiSilver‐Pacuilla,op.cit.,pp.9‐10.36Adultlearnersacrosstheliteracyandlanguagespectrumshowstrongmotivationtogaincomputerliteracyskills,perceivedaskeytoworkadvancement,Silver‐Pacuilla,op.cit.pp.3‐6;aswasfoundinthecomparativestudybetweenPortlandandLondon,describedpreviously,therelationshipofICTtoemploymentisoneofgreatsignificanceformanyadults,andisoftenpartofthereasontheyaredoingthesecourses.
![Page 53: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
45
37JohnBynner,SteveReder,SamanthaParsonsandClareStrawn,ResearchSummary:TheDigitalDivide:ComputerUse,BasicSkillsandEmployment:AComparativeStudyinPortland[OR],USAandLondon,England.October2008.http://www.nrdc.org.uk/publications_details.asp?ID=149,Ibid,pp.3‐6.38HeidiSilver‐Pacuilla,op.cit,pp.7‐8.39HarveyMellar,MariaKambouri,KitLogan,SallyBetts,BarbaraNanceandVivMoriarty,EffectiveTeachingandLearningUsingICT,SummaryReport,NRDC,February2007.Availablefromhttp://www.nrdc.org.uk/publications_details.asp?ID=87#.HeidiSilver‐Pacuilla,p.13. 40ClareStrawn,TheRelationshipBetweenLiteracyProficiencyandtheDigitalDivideAmongAdultsWithLowEducationAttainment:AtechnicalreportfromtheLongitudinalStudyofAdultLearning,PortlandStateUniversity,2008.Availablefromwww.lsal.pdx.edu/Documents/PDF/littech.pdf,p.i.41StephenReder,GivingLiteracyAway,Again:NewConceptsofPromisingPractice,inSummariesofPapersPresentedatTwentiethAnnualRutgersInvitationalSymposiumonEducation(RISE),co‐sponsoredbyNationalCenterfortheStudyofAdultLearningandLiteracy(NCSALL),InstitutefortheStudyofAdultLiteracyofPennStateUniversity,andRutgersGraduateSchoolofEducation(October23‐24,2003),pp.21‐22.Availableathttp://www.ncsall.net/fileadmin/resources/research/rise_summaries.pdf.42Stiles,Richard;Porter,Dennis.TheCaliforniaAdultEducation2005‐2007InnovationandAlternativeInstructionalDeliveryProgram:AReview.CaliforniaStateUniversityDominguezHillsCollegeofExtendedandInternationalEducation,2007,pp.1‐3.Availablefromhttp://www.cdlponline.org/pdf/InnovationProgramsReport2005‐2007.pdf.43Ibid44 Ibid 45StephenReder&ClareStrawn,Self‐Study:BroadeningtheConceptsofParticipationandProgramSupport,FocusonBasics,Vol.8,IssueC,11/06,pp.6‐10.NationalCenterfortheStudyofAdultLiteracy.Availableathttp://www.ncsall.net/?id=1152.46ClareStrawn,TheRelationshipBetweenLiteracyProficiencyandtheDigitalDivideAmongAdultsWithLowEducationAttainment:AtechnicalreportfromtheLongitudinalStudyofAdultLearning,PortlandStateUniversity,2008.Availableathttp://www.lsal.pdx.edu/reports.html.47Ibid,p.4.48Stiles,R.&Porter,D.(2006).TheCaliforniaAdultEducation2004‐2006InnovationandAlternativeInstructionalDeliveryProgram:Areview.Carson,CA:CaliforniaStateUniversityDominquezHillsCollegeofExtendedandInternationalEducation.http://www.cdlponline.org/pdf/InnovationProgramsReport2004‐2006.pdf.49Petty,L.,Shafer,D.,&Johnston,J.(2004).Beyondtheclassroom:Sixstatesdevelopdistanceprogramsforadultlearners.ProjectIDEALSupportCenter,InstituteforSocialResearch,Universityof
![Page 54: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
46
Michigan,AnnArbor,MI.http://www.projectideal.org/pdf/WorkingPapers/WP6StateDistancePrograms2004.pdf.50 A Success Story in Ohio, Distance in Action, Project IDEAL, 2007. Available at http://www.projectideal.org/distance_in_action/action_1.html. 51Johnston,J.&Petty,L.DistanceEducation–ExpandingOptionsinAdultEducation(underreview).ProjectIDEALSupportCenter,InstituteforSocialResearch,UniversityofMichigan,AnnArbor,MI,citedinJohnston,J.,ABetterEducatedCitizenry:IncreasingAdultLiteracythroughDistanceEducation.ProjectIDEALinternalpaperprovidedbyauthor.52 ProjectIDEALStudentSatisfactionSurvey,unpublisheddata,citedinJohnston,ABetterEducationCitizenry:IncreasingAdultLiteracythroughDistanceEducation,ProjectIDEALInternalpaperprovidedbyauthor. 53Petty,L.,Shafer,D.,&Johnston,J.,Beyondtheclassroom:Sixstatesdevelopdistanceprogramsforadultlearners.ProjectIDEALSupportCenter,InstituteforSocialResearch,UniversityofMichigan,AnnArbor,MI.54JohnBynner,SteveReder,SamanthaParsonsandClareStrawn,ResearchSummary:TheDigitalDivide:ComputerUse,BasicSkillsandEmployment:AComparativeStudyinPortland[OR],USAandLondon,England.October2008.http://www.nrdc.org.uk/publications_details.asp?ID=149.55Ibid,pp.3‐6.56HarveyMellar,MariaKambouri,KitLogan,SallyBetts,BarbaraNanceandVivMoriarty,EffectiveTeachingandLearningUsingICT,SummaryReport,NRDC,February2007,pp.6‐8.Availablefromhttp://www.nrdc.org.uk/publications_details.asp?ID=87.57HeidiSilver‐Pacuilla,InvestigatingtheLanguageandLiteracySkillsRequiredforIndependentOnlineLearning.Washington,DC.NationalInstituteforLiteracy(October,2008),p.1.http://www.nifl.gov/publications/pdf/NIFLOnlineLearningReport.pdf.58Ibid,p.8.59Ibid,p.7‐8.60Means,Barbara;Toyama,Yukie;Murphy,Robert;Bakia,Marianne;Jones,Karla.EvaluationofEvidence‐BasedPracticesinOnlineLearning:AMeta‐AnalysisandReviewofOnlineLearningStudies.U.S.DepartmentofEducation,OfficeofPlanning,Evaluation,andPolicyDevelopment,CenterforTechnologyinLearning,2009.Availableathttp://www.ed.gov/rschstat/eval/tech/evidence‐based‐practices/finalreport.pdf.
![Page 55: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
47
AppendixD:ToolsofTechnology(Note:Linkfunctionalitycanvarybybrowser,server,andPDFversion.)
TYPESOFTECHNOLOGIES/TOOLS EXAMPLES
THEFOLLOWINGDEVICESCANBEUSEDWITHOUTINTERNETACCESS
LEARNINGBYVIEWINGAND/ORLISTENING+SUPPLEMENTARYPRINTMATERIALS
TelevisionandVideo[earlyonesnotavailableonline]typicallyaresupportedbyprintmaterialsthataccompanythesegmentsand/orlessonsthatareviewed.Communication,ifappropriate,isbymailand/ortelephone.Thesemediaareusefulbecausetheycanpresentinformationincontextandwithapurpose,whetherlearninghowtolocateassistancewithinacommunityorperformtasksatwork.Videohasanadvantageinthatitmaybepausedandre‐played,enablingthelearnertotakenotes,reviewtheinformationandview/listentoasoftenasnecessary.Thedisadvantageisthatthesemediaare“one‐way”anddonotallowforinteraction.
IndianaGEDonTVSeriesof39half‐hourGEDConnectionTVprogramsonIndiana(PBS)channels&cable.Learnerscalltoll‐freetelephonenumbertoenroll;receivebooksbyUPS.• TV411‐http://www.tv411.orgTVseriesandVideos(DVD/VHS).Halfhourepisodesthatcorrelatewithacolorfulmagazine‐styleworkbook.Curriculumsupportforteachers.
RadioandMP3Players/iPodsBeingabletohearothersspeakisparticularlyusefultolanguagelearners,intermsofusingthecorrectaccentandunderstandinghowwordsareusedindifferentcontexts.MP3Players/iPodsincreasinglyareusedformobilelearning,withpurpose‐developedlessonsandwithinformationavailablefordownloadfrom“libraries”.
Podcasts(audioblogs)are“audiorecordings,usuallyinMP3format,oftalks,interviewsandlectures,whichcanbeplayedeitheronadesktopcomputeroronawiderangeofhandheldMP3devices[suchasiPODs].”
Landlineand/orMobilePhone:Callingconnectionenablescommunicationwithteacher/instructor/guideforlearningsupport.Mobilephonealsoenablescommunicationwithfriends,familyand/orcolleaguesforinformation,advice,instructions,otherinterests.
COMPUTER‐AIDEDINSTRUCTION(CAI) DVD/CD‐ROMs– Typicallydesignedforusewithteacher/instructor,eitherin
classroomoratadistance;althoughsomealsoareaccessibletoalearnerforindependentuse,withonlineteachersupport.Videosusuallyofferlearningwithinreal‐lifecontexts,withsupplementalmaterialsthatsupportthelessons.
– ForEnglishlanguagelearners,videohastheaddedbenefitofprovidingreallanguageandculturalinformation.Videocanbecontrolled(stopped,paused,repeated).Itallowslearnerstoseefacialexpressionsandbodylanguageatthesametimetheyhearthestress,intonation,andrhythmofthelanguage.
CrossroadsCafé–intermediateESLvideo‐
http://www.intelecom.org/course_info.asp?id=10
EnglishforAll–highbeginningESLvideo,DVD,Internet‐http://www.myefa.org
GEDConnectionvideoandDVDwithsupplementalprintmaterials‐http://litlink.ket.org)
AssistiveTechnologies:Initiallydevelopedtoenableindividualswithdisabilitiestoaccessandusetechnologies,anumberofthesetechnologiescanprovideusefuloptionsforuseoftechnologyinlearningforadultswhohavenotyetmasteredthefunctionsofacomputerand/orlanguageorreading.
Theuseoftouchscreeninsteadofakeyboardhasmigratedtothehigh‐endtechnologymarket.Otheroptionsinusearecomputersthatprovide“texttospeech”and“speechtotext”.
![Page 56: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
48
THEFOLLOWINGTOOLSANDPROGRAMSAREAVAILABLEVIAINTERNETCONNECTIONONLY
AdultLearning
LEARNINGBYVIEWING,LISTENINGAND/ORCOMMUNICATING
Videoonline:Hasthesamecapabilitiesanduseasstandalonevideo,withthevaluableoptionofenablingtheindividualtointeractinvariousways–Q/A,simultaneouspresentations/discussionwithothers–duringthevideo.DevelopingvideoforonlineaccessalsocanbesignificantlylessexpensivethandevelopingitforaCD‐ROM/DVD,withminimaltonocosttotheviewerandthepotentialforwideandimmediateaudiencereach.
EnglishforAll‐http://www.myefa.org
Internettelephony/VoiceOverInternetProtocol(VOIP)Potentialfor24/7/365worldwidevoiceand/orvideoofotherparties.Tutoringand/ortechnologysupportforlearning.
• Skype• Gizmoproject
SmartPhonesandPersonalDigitalAssistants(PDA):Wirelessphoneswithadvanceddatafeatures,includingemailand/oraccesstotheInternet.
• Blackberry• Palm
E–mail/ListServes;Real‐timeTexting/chat;Video–conferencing;Web–conferencing;Webinars(reusablelectures/fishbowlseminars)Providesreal‐timeopportunitiesforQ&Awithindividualsatadistance,eitherbypre‐arrangementoronthemoment.Mostofthesecommunicationsmaybesortedandarchivedbytheuser.
OfficeZilla GoogleGroups,YahooGroups
Twitterwww.twitter.com‐Hybridinstantmessaging/bloggingtoolthatenablesuserstobuildnetworksbyfollowingandbeingfollowedbyothersonTwitter.Messages(tweets)arelimitedto140charactersrequiringaconcisestructure.Twittercanbeusefulasacommunicationtoolbetweenteachers/tutorsandstudents,aswellasanoptiontoread“onthespot”informationaboutpeopleandactivitiesaspartofalearningprocess.
LEARNINGVIAUSER‐GENERATEDCONTENTANDCOMMUNICATION:WEB2.0
Blogs(shortforWeblogs)areWebpagesconsistingofregularentriesofcommentary,descriptionsofevents,orothermaterial,suchasgraphicsorvideothatfocusesonparticulartopics.
Wikisarecollectionsofwebpagesdesignedtoenableanyonewhoaccessesthemtocontributeormodifycontent,usingasimplifiedmarkuplanguage.Wikisareoftenusedtocreatecollaborativewebsitesandtopowercommunitywebsites.
http://wiki.literacytent.org/index.php/Adult_Literacy_Professional_Development;andhttp://aalpdresources.pbworks.com/
SocialNetworksandCommunitiesofPractice:Providesameansbywhichany/allindividualscandevelopand/orfindotherswhoarepartofthesameprofessional,personal,industry,neighborhood,certification,andanyotherlargeorsmalldefiningaspectfora“community”or“network.”Forlearning,whetheratwork,home,community,etc.suchnetworksprovideaccesstoknowledge,experience,advice,discussionandother.
![Page 57: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
49
Mashupsareapplicationsthatcombinedatafromtwoormoresourcestocreatesomethingmorevaluablethanthesumoftheirparts,suchasservicethatcombinesGooglemapswithrealestatelistings.
LEARNINGVIAWEBPORTALSWEBSITES/PORTALSLEARNINGVIAACCESSTOINFORMATION
Self‐ContainedLearningCenters:Provideacoherentexperiencetoanunassisteduser,typicallyofferingaplannedcurriculum,perhapsgatheringaninitialassessmentofuserskilllevel,andofferinglessonsdevelopedspecificallyforthegivensite.Aneffectiveself‐directedliteracywebsitecanassesstheuser’sabilitytooperateintheenvironment,andiftheuserisnotreadyyet,willprovidebasicinstructiononhowtoactuallyusethesite.
LearnerWeb‐www.learnerweb.orgFreeInternet“learningsupportsystem”thatconsistsofaWeb‐basedsoftwaresystemthatisimplementedregionally;organizedaroundLearningPlans‐stepsstructuredaroundachievinganidentifiedgoal.Learnercreatesapersonalprofile,choosesagoalfromtheavailablelistandfollowsthelearningplanindependentlyorwithatutororateacher.
WebApplicationsWebapplicationsaredifferentiatedfromwebsitesinthattheyaretask‐orientedandsupplytheuserwitharichsetofcontrolsandobjectstocreate,edit,andstoreinformation.Aliteracywebapplicationtranslatescurriculumtothemediumofthewebandprovidesweb‐based,on‐lineinstructionthatmakesfulluseoftext,audio,photoart,music,graphics,icons,videoclips,andanimation,toactivelyengagethemindandimaginationofadultlearnersandguidethemthroughaneffectivestudent‐centered,self‐study,instructionalexperience.IttakesadvantageoftheinteractivecapabilitiesoftechnologieslikeFlashthatallowuserstonavigatethroughvirtualspace,moveobjectsonthescreen,andenterdataoranswersandobtainimmediatefeedback.
USALearns‐www.usalearns.orgFreeWebportaldesignedforadultslearningEnglish.USALearnswasdesignedtoservelearnersatadistance,notforuseinschooloragencycomputerlabs.CurriculaforthreedifferentEnglishproficiencylevels;lessonsareintroducedwithbriefvideosfollowedbyalistofnewwords.Dependingonthelevel,wordsareintroducedwithpictures,audio,video,orwrittendefinitions,followedbyquizzes.Embeddedinthelessonsarerelevantlifeskills,suchasfindingajob,rentingaplacetolive.
ResourceCollections‐Sitesthatprimarilymaintainlinkstootherwebsitesthatoffersomeinstructionalcontentoractivities.Linksaregroupedbytopic(e.g.,“algebra,“readingcomprehension”).Thesitestowhichlinksaremaintainedareoftendiscipline‐specific‐e.g.,“math.com.”
LiteracyLinkOnline:Sitethatprovidesadultsoptionstodeveloptheirwork‐readinessskillsinunitsonemploymentstrategiesforfindingandkeepingagoodjob,communicating,reading,andmath;preparationandonlinepracticetestsfortheGEDexam,etc.‐http://www.ketadultlearning.org/litlink/online.htm
TheBeehive–http://www.thebeehive.org
VirtualReality(VR).Allowsausertointeractwithacomputer‐simulatedenvironment,whetherrealorimagined.Currentvirtualrealityenvironmentsareprimarilyvisualexperiencesdisplayedeitheronacomputerscreenorthroughspecialstereoscopicdisplays,butsomeincludesoundthroughspeakersorheadphones(e.g.,SecondLife).
![Page 58: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
50
MANAGEMENTTOOLS
Instructionallearningsystems(ILS);Learningmanagementsystems(LMS),Learningcontentmanagementsystems(LCMS),
Moodle isanOpenSourceCourseManagementSystem(CMS),alsoknownasaLearningManagementSystem(LMS)oraVirtualLearningEnvironment(VLE).Ithasbecomeverypopularamongeducatorsaroundtheworldasatoolforcreatingonlinedynamicwebsitesfortheirstudents.Moodlecanscaletoverylargedeploymentsandhundredsofthousandsofstudents,yetitcanalsobeusedforaprimaryschooloraneducationhobbyist.Manyinstitutionsuseitasplatformtoconductfullyonlinecoursesorsimplytoaugmentface‐to‐facecourses.
PIMS‐ThePennsylvaniaInformationManagementSystemisastatewidelongitudinaldatasystemtoefficientlyandaccuratelymanage,analyze,disaggregateanduseindividualstudentdataforeachstudentservedbyPennsylvania’sPreK‐12publiceducationsystem.
HTTrackisafreesoftwareandaneasy‐to‐useofflinebrowserutility.http://www.httrack.com/html/overview.html.ItallowsyoutodownloadaWorldWidewebsitefromtheInternettoalocaldirectory,buildingrecursivelyalldirectories,gettinghtml,images,andotherfilesfromtheservertoyourcomputer.
TOPSproisacomputerizeddatabasesystemdesignedforstudents,teachers,andprogramadministratorsinadulteducation.AutomatesCASASscoring,collectsstudentdemographicdata,tracksstudentprogress,generatesreportsandprofiles,andmanagesdataforstateandfederalaccountability.https://www.casas.org/home/index.cfm?fuseaction=home.showContent&MapID=125
AuthoringTools&ContentManagement
SCORM,theShareableContentObjectReferenceModel,showswhatkindsofserviceswillbeneededtosolveaparticularproblem,howtheycanbeputtogether,therelevantstandardsthatapply,andhowtheymightbeused.BenefitstoadoptingSCORMinclude‐‐Accessibility:Theabilitytolocateandaccessinstructionalcomponentsfrommultiplelocationsanddeliverythemtootherlocations.Interoperability:Theabilitytotakeinstructionalcomponentsdeliveredinonesystemandusetheminanothersystem.Durability:Theabilitytowithstandtechnologyevolutionand/orchangeswithoutcostlyredesign,reconfiguration,orrecoding.Reusability:Theflexibilitytoincorporateinstructionalcomponentsinmultipleapplicationsandcontexts.Forexample,e‐learningcontentdesignedforoneorganizationcanberedeployed,rearranged,repurposed,orrewrittenbyotherorganizationswithsimilarlearningneeds.http://www.adlnet.gov/Technologies/scorm/default.aspx
![Page 59: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
51
Theabilityofanetworktocoordinateandcommunicatewithothernetworks,suchastwosystemsbasedondifferentprotocolsortechnologies.
CNRIDigitalObjectRegistryCorporationforNationalResearchInitiatives–general‐purposedigitalobjectregistryfordownload,installation,andusebyanyorganizationorcommunity.Objectsareregisteredwiththeirmetadataandthatmetadataisindexedandmadesearchable.Makingeachsuchregistryaspecializedindexoveracollectionofdigitalmaterialinoneormorerepositories.‐http://www.doregistry.org
![Page 60: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
52
AppendixE:SelectedProgramsandStateModels[Summariesaretakenlargelyfromwebsitesandpublicreports.
MoreinformationisavailablefromtheURLsindicated.](Note:Linkfunctionalitycanvarybybrowser,server,andPDFversion.)
PROGRAMMODELSTheprogrammodelsthatfollowhavebeenchosentorepresentthevarietyofwaystechnologycansupportlearningandotheractivitiesforadultsandforpractitionersandprogrammanagers.Somearetypicalonlinecurriculumprograms;othersarenewlydevelopedprogramsstillbeingtested.Mostoftheprogramswerefundedbygovernmentandfoundations.Eachisbasedongenerallyacceptedprinciplesofeffectiveadultlearningandlearningusingtechnology.Afewaretechnology‐assistedprogramsdevelopedandmarketedbyfor‐profitcompanies,largelybecausethemarketisdiffuse,small(intermsoforganizationsthatbuyproducts),andlackingfinancialresourcestojustifyfor‐profitsales.Astechnologybecomesmorewidelyavailableandmoreindividualsarefamiliarwithitsuse,andasprogramsandlearningapplicationsexpand,currentdivisionsbetweeneducationlevels–K‐12,postsecondary,adulteducationandtraining–maybegintoblur,providingthenecessarymarketforproductsaimedatlow‐literacyandESLadultlearners.
InteractiveLearningUsingMultipleMedia• SeddeSaberTM(ThirstforKnowledge)
http://www.seddesaber.com
SeddeSaberisanelectronicEnglishlanguageprogramforHispanicadultswhohavelimitedEnglishproficiency.Itisaportable,interactive,self‐pacedprogramthatusesstorytelling,voicerecording,games,andreviewexercisestobuildandimproveEnglishlanguageskills.SeddeSabercombinesESLcurriculumwiththeLeapfrogQuantumPadPlusMicrophone™,whichallowsthelearnertorecord,playback,andcomparehis/hervoicetothewordorphrasebeinglearned,increasingconfidenceinpronunciationskills.MarriottInternationalhasusedSeddeSaberformanyofitsHispanicemployeesforwhomEnglishisasecondlanguagesince2006. OnlineWork‐RelatedTraining• WorkplaceEssentialSkills(WES)
http://litlink.ket.org/wesged.aspl
WESusesTV/videos,print,andtheInternettohelpindividualsimprovereading,writing,math,andjobskills.Thelessonsarewrittenatapre‐GEDlevel,designedtohelpbuildcriticalthinkingandproblemsolvingskillsthatcanhelpwithfindingajoband/orpreparingfortheGED.Thereare24half‐hourprograms(plusOrientation),fourworkbooks,and24freeonlinelessons.Theyaredesignedtoworktogethertomakelearningeasier.Anindividualcanregisterandsaveworkinanonlineportfolio,aswellaschoosetoworkonlinewithateacher.Theprogramsmaybeviewedonpublictelevisionstations,
![Page 61: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
53
online,orusingastandaloneCDROM.WorkplaceEssentialSkillsiscorrelatedtowidelyusednationalassessmenttoolsandtoeachother.WESwasdevelopedin1996throughapartnershipamongthePBSAdultLearningService,theNationalCenteronAdultLiteracyattheUniversityofPennsylvania,KentuckyEducationalTelevision,andtheKentuckyDepartmentofEducation. PennStateOnlinePostbaccalaureateCertificateinFamilyLiteracy
http://www.worldcampus.psu.edu/FamilyLiteracyCertificate.shtmlThe15‐creditfamilyliteracypost‐baccalaureatecertificatewasdevelopedtoprovideeducatorswithanopportunitytoenhancetheirskillsandcredentialsinthedisciplineofliteracyinstruction.Tomeetthewiderangeofneedsforliteraryprofessionals,theonlinecertificateprograminfamilyliteracyhastracksinchildren'seducation,adultliteracy,andparentalinvolvement.Studentstakingtheprogramatthepost‐baccalaureatelevelcanapplycourseworktoundergraduateandmaster’sdegreeprograms.EachcourseistaughtusingablendofWebande‐mailtomaximizeflexibility,whilemaintainingteacherandstudentinteraction.ThecertificatecurriculumwascreatedinpartnershipbetweentheGoodlingInstituteforResearchinFamilyLiteracyatPennStateandtheNationalCenterforFamilyLiteracy.
WebPortalandOnlineLearningEnvironmentforAdultLearnersinBasicEducation:• AlphaRoute[Canada]
http://www.alpharoute.orgAlphaRoute,developedbytheLiteracyandBasicSkills(LBS)programofOntario,Canada,isapassword‐protectedweb‐basedlearningenvironmentforadultswhowanttoimprovetheirreading,writing,math,andcomputerskillstoachievetheirgoals.Alpharoutetargetsadultliteracystudentswhowanttolearnonlineandoffers:ongoingmentorsupportfromtrainedLBSandABEprogrampractitioners,learningopportunitieswhichcomplementandreflectlearninggoalareasexpressedbyadultliteracystudents,andanonlinecommunityforadultliteracystudentstolearnonlinetogetherwithinapassword‐protectedlearningenvironment.Specificfeaturesinclude:interactivelearningactivitiesdevelopedspecificallyforadultlearners;learningmanagementtoolswithpersonalizedtrainingplans,activitylists,portfolios,andlearningtoolssuchaspersonalizednotepadsandwordlists;easy‐to‐usecommunicationtoolssuchasemail,discussiongroups,andchat;specialcontentareasforworkforceliteracy,numeracyandtechnology,self‐assessment,Internetsearchskills,andusefulweblinks.
• TheLearnerWeb
www.learnerweb.org
TheLearnerWeb(LW)isafreeWeb‐andtelephone‐accessedapplicationthatprovidescustomized,guidedinstructionalsupporttoadultsseekingtoimprovetheirbasicskills,preparefortheGED,orpursueotherlearninggoalssuchascitizenship,familyliteracy,orcollegeprep.TheLWmakesresourcesaccessibletolearnersontheirowntimeandintheirownenvironment.Alearner’sgoalsandskillneedsarematchedtosupportingresourcesavailableonlineorofflineinthelocalcommunity.Inadditiontoon‐lineresources,theLearnerWebintegratessupportservicesfromexistinglocaleducationprograms,communitybasedorganizations,tutors,andtelephonehelpers.TheLearnerWebconsistsofaWeb‐
![Page 62: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
54
basedsoftwaresystemthatisimplementedregionally.TheLearnerWebhasbegunthesecondyearofathree‐yeardemonstrationprojectinsevendemonstrationregionsacrossthecountry.
OnlineCommunities AdultLiteracyEducation(ALE)Wiki!
http://wiki.literacytent.org/index.php/Main_Page
TheALEWikiisafree,onlinecommunityofpracticeforteachers,tutors,administrators,practitioners,researchers,adultlearners,andotherswhoareinterestedintheconnectionsbetweenresearch,professionalknowledge,andpracticeinadultbasiceducation,adultsecondaryeducation,andEnglishlanguagelearning.Likeotherwikis,thisisatextenvironmentwhereonecanreadwhatothershavewrittenbutalsoeasilycontributeone'sownknowledge,opinions,findings,andobservations.TheALEWikiincludesdiscussionsandresourcesonanumberoftopicsrangingfromadultbasicliteracy,toassessment,workforceandworkplaceeducation,andpublicpolicy.Inthetopicalareasareselecteddiscussionsthathavetakenplaceonelectroniclists,summariesofthesediscussions,linkstorelevantresearch,researchcitations,bibliographies,glossariesofterms,andotherresources.ThiswikiwascreatedinNovember2004. TheOhioLiteracyNetwork(OLN)Website:
http://www.ohioliteracynetwork.org/about.html
TheOhioLiteracyNetwork(OLN)wasestablishedin1987topromoteawarenessofadultliteracyissuesandneeds;toserveasaclearinghousefortheexchangeofliteracyinformation;andtoencouragecollaborativeliteracyefforts.TheOLNisamembershiporganization,fundedbypublicandprivategovernmentgrants,donations,andmembershipdues.Itsservicesinclude:
•AstatewideLearnLinewhichprovidesaccesstofreelearningtoolsontelevision,throughtheInternet,athomeandinthelocalcommunity.•AstatewideGEDConnectionprojectwithhomeandInternetbasedaccesstoGEDpreparationtools.•TheLiteracyOhioOnlineLearningSitewithlearningtoolsandconnectionstolocaleducationprogramsandresources.•Astatewidenetworkofcollaborativeprojects.•Astatewidedirectoryofliteracyserviceproviders.•Publicawarenessandmarketinginitiativestorecruitpotentialstudentsandvolunteers.
TheOLNhaspartneredacrossOhiowithTimeWarnerCable,KentuckyEducationalTelevision,Ohio'seightPBSstationsandTheOhioCommunityComputerNetworktostream,broadcast,andprovideawidevarietyofDistanceLearningopportunities. AlpharouteCafé
http://resources.alpharoute.org/pdfs/ARCafe.pdf
OneofthegoalsoftheCaféistogivelearnersaplacewheretheydirecttheirownlearning.Theyarefreetoexplorediscussions,activities,andgamesthatinterestthemandthroughthesupportand
![Page 63: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
55
encouragementofmentors,facilitators,andotherlearnerstheycanfeelconnectedtoalargercommunitythroughtheuseofthesetools.TheCaféwaslaunchedinSeptember2003.TheCaféfeaturesanumberofinteractivetoolsthatlearnerscanchoose,includingachatroom,themeddiscussions,interactivegames,andamonthlyCyberSearchactivity.(Note:TheAlpharouteCaféispartofAlphaRouteoutlinedabove.) Web‐basedResourceCollections• PBSLiteracyLink
http://litlink.ket.org/LiteracyLink'sgoalistoprovidealinkforunderservedandhard‐to‐reachadultsandtheirteacherstoqualityadultbasiceducationandGEDpreparation.Combiningvideo,theInternet,andprintmaterials,LiteracyLinkprogramsarerelevanttotheneedsoftheindividuallearner,adultinstructionalprograms,andtheworkforce.AjointprojectofPBSAdultLearningService,theNationalCenteronAdultLiteracyoftheUniversityofPennsylvania,KentuckyEducationalTelevision,andtheKentuckyDepartmentofEducation,itbeganinJuly1996.Seriesarenowavailabletomorethan87%ofAmericanhouseholdsthroughpublictelevisionbroadcasts.Programsinclude:GEDConnection(LearnerspreparingfortheGEDexam),WorkplaceEssentialSkills(Adultslookingforjobsorlookingforbetterjobs),ProjectCONNECT(websitewhereadultsinadulteducationclassescanpracticeEnglishskillsandlearnaboutworking,studyingandlivingintheUS).• WorkforceOnlineLearningInformationPortal(WOLIP)
http://wolip.sreb.org/FromWOLIP,individualscansearchonlinetrainingopportunitiesinthepriorityareastargetedbytheirstate.Avarietyofotherlearningopportunitiesarealsoavailablefromthissite.EachofthefourWOLIPstates(Colorado,Maine,Mississippi,andPennsylvania)hasdefinedtheirpriorityworkforcetrainingneeds,selectedonlinecoursesandprogramstheywillmakeavailable,selectedandcertifiedtheinstitutions/providersofthecourses/programs,determinedstudenteligibilityandparticipationrequirements,andestablishedproceduresforenrollmentandfinancialassistance.
WOLIPissponsoredbytheAlfredP.SloanFoundationincooperationwiththeU.S.DepartmentofLabor,PennsylvaniaStateUniversity,andthefourpartnerstates,withassistancefromtheSouthernRegionalEducationBoard.
WebApplications• USALearns
www.usalearns.org
USALearnsisafreeESLinstructionalprogramdevelopedprimarilyforimmigrantadultswithlimitedEnglishlanguageskillswhocannotattendtraditionalclassroomprogramsbecauseofdifficultywithschedules,transportation,orotherbarriers.Thesiteofferspracticeactivitiesinlistening,reading,writing,andspeakingskillsaswellaslifeskillsnecessaryforsuccessatworkandinthecommunity.Allinstructionalmaterialsareonline;therearenovideos,workbooks,orothermaterialsforprinting.USA
![Page 64: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
56
Learnsisdesignedprimarilyforindividualdistancelearningoutsideofthetraditionalclassroom.TheUSALearnswebsiteconsistsofthreedistinctprograms,eachderivedfromEnglishForAll(www.myefa.org):
FirstEnglishCourse–20video‐based,beginner‐levelunits SecondEnglishCourse–17video‐based,intermediate‐levelunits PracticeEnglishandReading–42intermediate‐levelstoriesandactivities
LearnersdonotneedadvancedcomputerskillstouseUSALearns.Theprogramisdesignedprimarilyforindividualdistancelearningoutsideofthetraditionalclassroom.Butatutororteachercanusethewebsite’slearningmanagementsystemtocreateanonlineclassandsupportoneormorestudentsintheirstudies.Thelearningmanagementsystemenableseducatorstoviewstudents'workandprovidefeedbackonline.USALearnswasdevelopedbytheSacramentoCountyOfficeofEducation(SCOE)inconjunctionwiththeUniversityofMichiganandProjectIDEALaspartofalargerprojectontechnologyinnovationsanddistancelearningforadulteducation. BuildingSkills4Work
(seeemaillinksbelow)
BuildingSkills4Workaimstoequipout‐of‐schooladultsandyouthwiththeworkforceskillsthatwillpreparethemtoqualifyforandbesuccessfulinhigherpayingentry‐leveljobs.Thisfreeonlineprogramisdesignedtoengageadultlearnersandtobeusedsuccessfullybothinformalinstructionalsettingsandbylearnerswithouttheinterventionofateacherortutororenrollmentinaformalprogram.Itteachestheworkplaceskillsthatemployersseekinnewhires,includingbothacademicandinterpersonalskills.ThewebapplicationcanbetargetedontheneedsofindividualsatthelowtomiddleendoftheNAALBasicLiteracyskill(Level2)range,peoplewhosereadingandquantitativeskillsareoftennotsufficienttosuccessfullycompleteaGEDprogramorapprenticeship,tomatriculateincommunitycollegeoruniversitydegreeprograms,ortoqualifyforjobsthatpayself‐sufficiencywages.Threeorganizations–theCenterforWomenandWorkatRutgersUniversity(whichhasextensiveexperienceworkingwithstatestoimplementInternetlearningforlow‐skillworkers),theCenterforLiteracyStudiesattheUniversityofTennessee(whichmanagesEquippedfortheFuture),andR&DMediaSolutionsSF(aSanFranciscomediaandwebdevelopmentorganization)–havedevelopedthiswebapplicationtomeettheworkreadinessneedsoflow‐skilledadults.BuildingSkills4Workwillbeavailableatnocosttolearners,adulteducationteachers,workforceskillstrainers,andthegeneralliteracycommunity.ThewebsitewasdemonstratedinwebinarsinMayandJune2009andisbeingbeta‐testedaroundthecountry.Itwillbelaunchedlatein2009andaddadditionalcontentin2010.Forfurtherinformation,pleasecontactHeatherMcKayoftheCenterforWomenandWork([email protected]);DianeGardneroftheCenterforLiteracyStudies([email protected]);orRichardAppelbaumofR&DMediaSolutionsSF([email protected]).
STATEMODELSManystateshavedevelopedandimplementeddistanceeducationprogramsandpilotsforadulteducationandESL.Ingeneral,althoughtheseprogramshaveprovidedusefullessonsandexperienceandsignificantdegreesofsuccess,theyremainonthe“demonstration”level,servingrelativelyfewadults.Ifdistancelearningistogotoscale,statesandregionsmustaddressthepolicy,regulatory,
![Page 65: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
57
funding,andprogramstructureissuesthatinhibitexpansionofdistanceeducation.TwostatesthatbeganthisprocesssomeyearsagoareCaliforniaandPennsylvania.
CALIFORNIAhttp://www.cdlponline.org/index.cfm?fuseaction=whatis&pg=4
In1993theCalifornialegislaturepassedEC52522permittingtheSuperintendentofPublicInstructiontoapproveadultschoolplanstospenduptofivepercentoftheirblockentitlementoninnovationandalternativeinstructionaldelivery.ThisauthorizationandthesubsequentinitiativearecommonlyknownastheInnovationPrograminitiative.TheInnovationPrograminitiativewaslaunchedin1995,anduntilrecentbudgetcutsaffectedtheprogram,almostalltheapprovedinnovativeprogramshavefallenundertheCaliforniaDistanceLearningProject’sdefinitionofdistancelearning.AnyadultschoolwishingtorequestauthorizationfortheinnovativeprogrammingsubmittedanannualapplicationtotheCaliforniaDepartmentofEducation.Videoandaudiocheckoutprogramswerethemostcommondeliverymodalitiesfollowedbyonlineinstruction.Thestateprovidedadedicatedfundingstreamfordistanceeducationandthusenabledlongitudinalevaluations,experiencewithpractice,awarenessofthechallengesfacedbyeducators,managers,learnersandothers.Fundingwasprovidedforcollectingandassessingdataacrosstheseprograms,servingupto60,000adultsby2005,andoutcomesarethereforeavailablefor2005‐2008.Thestate’suseofacommonassessmentsystem–theComprehensiveAdultStudentAssessmentSystems,CASAS–enabledcomparisonsacrossthesystem.Findings,detailsofwhichareinSectionIII,includedthesuccessof“blendedlearning”bothforsuccessfulcompletionandpersistence.Unfortunately,theeconomicenvironmentinthestateofCaliforniain2009resultedincutsineducationacrosstheboardandmovedauthorityforadulteducationfundingfromtheCaliforniaDepartmentofEducationtoLocalEducationAgencies(LEA).LEAscanusethosepreviouslyrestrictedadulteducationfundsforwhateverpurposetheydeemappropriate.Thereisnomoreattendancereportingandnomoreprogrammonitoring.Somesmalleradulteducationagenciesareclosingshop,whileothersareradicallymodifyingtheirrangeandscopeofofferings. PENNSYLVANIA
http://www.able.state.pa.us/able/cwp/view.asp?a=7&q=117134Afterseveralyearsofexperimentingwithdeliveringdistanceeducationvialocalagencies,Pennsylvaniachosetopilotadifferentapproach.Agenciescouldcontinuetoofferdistanceeducationtotheirlearners,buttheywouldnotreceivespecialfundsfordoingso.Thestatewouldprovide,atnocosttotheagency,training,technicalassistance,andworkbooksforbothGEDCandWESdistancelearners.Alternatively,agenciescouldchoosetorefertheirstudentsinterestedindistancelearningtoacentralizedagency,theCentralizedDistanceTeachingServices(CDTS),coordinatedbytheTuscaroraIntermediateUnit(TIU).BoththereferringagencyandtheTIUwouldreceivecreditforservingthestudent.Pennsylvania’sinitiativeprovidedamodelforcentralizingadultdistanceeducationthatavoidedpenalizingindividualagenciesandthatprovidedteachersupportoutsideoftheexistingprogram
![Page 66: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
58
instructionpool.Pennsylvaniamaintainsasubstantialdatabaseofcurriculumandprofessionaldevelopmentresources.Forthe2004–2005academicyears,theCentralizedDistanceTeachingServicesemployed10distanceteachers.Distanceteachersarerequiredtoparticipateinbi‐monthlyconferencecallsandattendannualtraining.Thenumberofstudentsassignedtoateacherisbasedonthenumberofstudentsateacherfeelscomfortableserving,giventheirotherjobdemands;for2004–2005,teacherssupportedfromsevento23activestudents.
![Page 67: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
59
AppendixF:Bibliography(Note:LinkfunctionalityvariesbybrowserandPDFversion.)
Allen,Elaine,Seaman,JeffandGarrett,Richard.BlendingIn:TheExtentandPromiseofBlendedEducationintheUnitedStates.SloanConsortium(Sloan‐C).March2007.Availablefromhttp://www.sloan‐c.org/publications/survey/pdf/Blending_In.pdf.Askov,E.,Johnston,J.,Petty,L.I.,&Young,S.J.ExpandingAccesstoAdultLiteracywithOnlineDistanceEducation.Cambridge,MA:NationalCenterfortheStudyofAdultLiteracy.HarvardGraduateSchoolofEducation.2003.Atkinson,RobertD.andMcKay,AndrewS.DigitalProsperity:UnderstandingtheEconomicBenefitsoftheInformationTechnologyRevolution.Washington,DC:InformationTechnologyIndustryFoundation.March2007.Availableathttp://www.itif.org/index.php?id=34Bartlett,LynnParr,et.al.,DistanceLearningfortheAdultLearner:ImprovingPersistenceandEffectiveness‐AWorkingPaper(2006).Availableatwww.cdlponline.org/pdf/Distance%20Learning%20and%20Adult%20Learner%20Persistence.pdfBosworth,Brian.LifelongLearning:NewStrategiesforWorkingAdults.Washington,DC:CenterforAmericanProgress,December2007.Brennan,Roslin.Onesizedoesn’tfitall:Pedagogyintheonlineenvironment–Volume1.NationalVocationalandEducationalTrainingSystem(NCVER),AustralianFlexibleLearningFramework,2003.www.flexiblelearning.net.auBynner,JohnandReder,Stephen,eds.,TrackingAdultLiteracyandNumeracySkills.NewYork:Routledge.2009.Bynner,John;Reder,Steve;Parsons,Samantha;andStrawn,Clare.ResearchSummary:TheDigitalDivide:ComputerUse,BasicSkillsandEmployment:AComparativeStudyinPortland,OR,USAandLondon,England,October2008.Availablefromhttp://www.nrdc.org.uk/publications_details.asp?ID=149#Chambers,John.Commentary.Forbes,January23,2008,availableathttp://www.forbes.com/2008/01/23/solutions‐education‐chambers‐oped‐cx_sli_0123chambers.htmlComings,JohnandSoricone,Lisa.AdultLiteracyResearch:OpportunitiesandChallenges.Cambridge,MA:NationalCenterfortheStudyofAdultLearningandLiteracy.HarvardGraduateSchoolofEducation,2007.Availablefromhttp://www.ncsall.net/fileadmin/resources/research/op_opps_challenges.pdf Comings,JohnP.,“StudentPersistenceinAdultLiteracyandNumeracyPrograms,p.173inReder,StephenandBynner,John,Eds.,TrackingAdultLiteracyandNumeracySkills:FindingsfromLongitudinalResearch.NewYork:Routledge,2009.
![Page 68: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/68.jpg)
60
Creighton,S.,andHudson,L.ParticipationTrendsandPatternsinAdultEducation:1991to1999.Washington,DC:NationalCenteronEducationStatistics.2002.Eady,Michelle.LiteracyLearningataDistance–ANewApproach.AlphaPlusCentre,March2006Gatta,MaryL.NotJustGettingBy:TheNewEraofFlexibleWorkforceDevelopment.Lanham,MD:LexingtonBooks,2005.Gatta,MaryL.FindingsfromtheField:EarlyFindingsoftheNewJerseyOnlineLearningProjectforSingleWorking‐PoorMothers.AReportoftheRutgersUniversityCenterforWomenandWork.December2003.Availableathttp://www.itwd.rutgers.edu/PDF/FindingsfromField.pdf.GettingOnline/TheGOProject,AResearchReportonOnlineLearningforCanadianLiteracyPractitioners.Canada:October2008.Availablefromhttp://www.nald.ca/gettingonline.Horrigan,John.HomeBroadbandAdoption,June2009.Washington,DC:PewInternetandAmericanLifeProject.Availableathttp://www.pewinternet.org/Reports/2009/10‐Home‐Broadband‐Adoption‐2009.aspx.Horrigan,John.WirelessInternetUse,July2009.Washington,DC:PewInternetandAmericanLifeProject.Availablefromhttp://www.pewinternet.org/~/media//Files/Reports/2009/Wireless‐Internet‐Use.pdf.Hudson,LisaandShafer,Linda.ParticipationinTechnology‐BasedPostcompulsoryEducation.NationalCenteronEducationStatistics.December3,2003.Availableathttp://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2004020. Johnston,Jerome.,&TomsBarker,L.(Eds.).AssessingtheImpactofTechnologyinTeachingandLearning:ASourcebookforEvaluators.AnnArbor:InstituteforSocialResearch,TheUniversityofMichigan,2002.Availableathttp://www.projectideal.org.Johnston,Jerome.ThePotentialofTechnologyinAdultBasicEducation.AnnArbor:InstituteforSocialResearch,TheUniversityofMichigan.2001.Availablefromwww.projectideal.org/pdf/PrintResources/PotentialTechnologyinABE2001.pdf.Johnston,Jerome,Young,ShannonandPetty,LeslieI.NationalFieldTestofWorkplaceEssentialSkills.AnnArbor:InstituteforSocialResearch,TheUniversityofMichigan.2001.Availablefromhttp://litlink.ket.org/about/testrept.pdf.Johnston,Jerome.MeasuringContactHoursandEducationalProgressinDistanceEducationPrograms.ProjectIDEALSupportCenter,InstituteforSocialResearch,UniversityofMichigan.September2005.Availablefromhttp://www.projectideal.org.Kazis,Richard;Callahan,Abigail;Davidson,Chris;McLeod,Annie;Bosworth,Brian;Choitz,Vickie.AdultLearnersinHigherEducation:BarrierstoSuccessandStrategiestoImproveResults.Boston:JobsfortheFuture.2007.Availableathttp://www.jff.org/publications/education/adult‐learners‐higher‐education‐barriers/157.
![Page 69: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/69.jpg)
61
Kennedy,JohnHoops;TracyL.M.;Smith,Aaron;Wells,AmyTracyandWellman,Barry,NetworkedFamilies,PewInternetandAmericanLifeProject,October19,2008.Availableathttp://www.pewinternet.org/Reports/2008/Networked‐Families.aspx.Kutner,Mark,Greenberg,Elizabeth;Jin,Ying;Boyle,Bridget;Hsu,Yung‐chen,Dunleavy,Eric.LiteracyinEverydayLife:Resultsfromthe2003NationalAssessmentofAdultLiteracy.USDepartmentofEducation.InstituteofEducationSciences.NationalCenterforEducationStatistics.April,2007.Availableathttp://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2007480.Lenhart,Amanda.AdultsandSocialNetworkWebsites,January2009.PewInternetandAmericanLifeProject:Jan14,2009.Availableathttp://www.pewinternet.org/Reports/2009/Adults‐and‐Social‐Network‐Websites.aspx.McDonald,TimandKolderie,Ted.TheRoleofInformationTechnologyinCreatingNewKindsofAmericanHighSchools.InformationTechnologyandInnovationInstitute,July2009.Availableatwww.itif.orgMeans,Barbara;Toyama,Yukie;Murphy,Robert;Bakia,Marianne;Jones,Karla.EvaluationofEvidence‐BasedPracticesinOnlineLearning:AMeta‐AnalysisandReviewofOnlineLearningStudies.U.S.DepartmentofEducation,OfficeofPlanning,Evaluation,andPolicyDevelopment,PolicyandProgramStudiesService,CenterforTechnologyinLearning,2009.Availableathttp://www.ed.gov/rschstat/eval/tech/evidence‐based‐practices/finalreport.pdf.Moore,SarahCatherineK.UsesofTechnologyintheInstructionofAdultEnglishLanguageLearners.Washington,DC:CenterforAppliedLinguistics,February2009.Availableathttp://www.cal.org/caelanetwork/resources/usesoftechnology.html.Petty,LeslieI.andJohnston,Jerome.HandbookofDistanceEducationforAdultLearnersFourthEdition,ProjectIDEALSupportCenter,InstituteforSocialResearch,UniversityofMichigan.October,2008.Availableatwww.projectideal.org/pdf/Print%20Resources/DEHandbook4thEdition20081002sm.pdf.Petty,L.I.StatePolicyforDistanceEducationProgramsforAdultLearners(WorkingPaper7).ProjectIDEALSupportCenter,InstituteforSocialResearch,UniversityofMichigan,2005.Availablefromhttp://www.projectideal.org.Porter,PaulandSturm,Matthew.CrossingtheGreatDivides:DistancelearningandflexibledeliveryinAdultBasicEducation.ResearchReportforOntario’sLiteracyandBasicSkillsProgram.Ontario:HumanResourcesandSocialDevelopmentCanada.AlphaPlusCentre.August2006.Availableatwww.distance.alphaplus.ca/pdfs/CrossingTheGreatDividesFullRpt.pdf.Porter,Paul.CaliforniaDistanceProjectResearch:2004and2006‐07Studies,PPTPresentationtoCATechnologyDistanceLearningSymposium2007.Pusser,Brian;Breneman,DavidW.;Gansneder,BruceM.;Kohl,KayJ.;Levin,JohnS.;Milam,JohnH.andTurner,SarahE.ReturningtoLearning:Adults’SuccessinCollegeisKeytoAmerica’sFuture.LuminaFoundation,March2007.Availableathttp://luminafoundation.org/publications/ReturntolearningApril2007.pdf.
![Page 70: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/70.jpg)
62
Reder,Stephen.GivingLiteracyAway,Again:NewConceptsofPromisingPractice,SummariesofPapersPresentedatTwentiethAnnualRutgersInvitationalSymposiumonEducation(RISE).Co‐sponsoredbyNationalCenterfortheStudyofAdultLearningandLiteracy(NCSALL),InstitutefortheStudyofAdultLiteracy,RutgersGraduateSchoolofEducation.October23‐24,2003,pp.21‐22.Availableat:http://www.ncsall.net/fileadmin/resources/research/rise_summaries.pdf.Reder,StephenandStrawn,Clare.TheLongitudinalStudyofAdultLearning(LSAL):1998‐2008.PortlandStateUniversity.Availablefromwww.lsal.pdx.edu.Reder,StephenandStrawn,Clare.Self‐Study:BroadeningtheConceptsofParticipationandProgramSupport,FocusonBasics,Vol.8,IssueC,11/06,pp.6‐10.NationalCenterfortheStudyofAdultLiteracy.Availablefromhttp://www.ncsall.net/?id=1152.Silver‐Pacuilla,Heidi(author)andReder,Stephen(originalanalysis).InvestigatingtheLanguageandLiteracySkillsRequiredforIndependentOnlineLearning.Washington,DC.NationalInstituteforLiteracy.October,2008.http://www.nifl.gov/publications/pdf/NIFLOnlineLearningReport.pdfSitzmann,Traci;Bell,BradfordS.;Kraiger,Kurt;Kanar,AdamM.AMultilevelAnalysisoftheEffectofPromptingSelf‐RegulationinTechnology‐DeliveredInstruction.http://digitalcommons.ilr.cornell.edu/cahrswp/493.Soares,Louis.WorkingLearners:Educatingourentireworkforceforsuccessinthe21stcentury.Washington,DC:CenterforAmericanProgress,June2009.Availableathttp://www.americanprogress.org/issues/2009/06/working_learners.html.Stiles,Richard;Porter,Dennis.TheCaliforniaAdultEducation2005‐2007InnovationandAlternativeInstructionalDeliveryProgram:AReview.CaliforniaStateUniversityDominguezHillsCollegeofExtendedandInternationalEducation,2007.Availableathttp://www.cdlponline.org/pdf/InnovationProgramsReport2005‐2007.pdf.Strawn,Clare.TheRelationshipBetweenLiteracyProficiencyandtheDigitalDivideAmongAdultsWithLowEducationAttainment:AtechnicalreportfromtheLongitudinalStudyofAdultLearning,PortlandStateUniversity,2008.Availableathttp://www.lsal.pdx.edu/Documents/PDF/littech.pdf.Taylor,Jackie.TappingOnlineProfessionalDevelopmentThroughCommunitiesofPractice:ExamplesfromtheNIFLDiscussionLists,inAdultBasicEducationandLiteracyJournal(V2,#3,Fall08).Twigg,Carol.StateandSystemCourseRedesignProject.NationalCenteronAcademicTransformation(NCAT)–www.center.rpi.eduUSCensusBureau:ComputerandInternetUseintheUnitedStates:October2007
Table4. ReportedComputerandInternetAccessforIndividuals15YearsandOlder,bySelectedCharacteristics:2005
![Page 71: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/71.jpg)
63
Table5. ReportedInternetAccessandActivity,ForIndividuals15YearsandOlderWhoUsetheInternet,bySelectedCharacteristics:2005http://www.census.gov/population/www/socdemo/computer/2007.html
Waits,T.,andLewis,L.(2003).DistanceEducationatDegree‐GrantingPostsecondaryInstitutions:2000–2001(NCES2003–017).Wellman,Barry;Smith,Aaron;Wells,Amy;Kennedy,Tracy.NetworkedFamilies,October2008.PewInternetandAmericanLife:Oct19,2008.Availableathttp://www.pewinternet.org/Reports/2008/Networked‐Families.aspx.Young,S.J.,ExploringDistanceEducationCurriculaforAdultLearners(WorkingPaper8).ProjectIDEAL,2005.Availablefromhttp://www.projectideal.org/pdf/WorkingPapers/WP8ExploringDistanceCurricula2005.pdf.Wagner,DanielA.andKozma,RobertB.NewTechnologiesforLiteracyandAdultEducation.AGlobalPerspective.Paris,France:UNESCO,2005.ListofPublicationsAssociatedwithSectionIIIResearchSummariesCaliforniaDistanceLearningProject: Dr.RichardStiles&DennisPorter,TheCaliforniaAdultEducation2005‐2007Innovationand
AlternativeInstructionalDeliveryProgram:AReview(2007). LynnParrBartlett,KarenNorton,DennisPorter,et.al.,DistanceLearningfortheAdultLearner:
ImprovingPersistenceandEffectiveness(Fall2006) OutreachandTechnicalAssistanceNetwork(OTAN)TechnologySymposia,VariousPresentations
(2007&2009).
LongitudinalStudyofAdultLearning: StephenReder&ClareStrawn,Self‐Study:BroadeningtheConceptsofParticipationandProgram
Support,FocusonBasics,Vol.8,IssueC,11/06,pp.6‐10.NationalCenterfortheStudyofAdultLiteracy.Foundatwww.ncsall.edu.
ClareStrawn,TheRelationshipBetweenLiteracyProficiencyandtheDigitalDivideAmongAdultsWithLowEducationAttainment:AtechnicalreportfromtheLongitudinalStudyofAdultLearning,PortlandStateUniversity,2008.Availableathttp://www.lsal.pdx.edu/Documents/PDF/littech.pdf.
JohnBynner,SteveReder,SamanthaParsonsandClareStrawn,ResearchSummary:TheDigitalDivide:ComputerUse,BasicSkillsandEmployment:AComparativeStudyinPortland,OR,USAandLondon,England,October2008.Availableathttp://www.nrdc.org.uk/publications_details.asp?ID=149#.
StephenReder,GivingLiteracyAway,Again:NewConceptsofPromisingPractice,inSummariesofPapersPresentedatTwentiethAnnualRutgersInvitationalSymposiumonEducation(RISE),co‐sponsoredbyNationalCenterfortheStudyofAdultLearningandLiteracy(NSCSALL),InstitutefortheStudyofAdultLiteracyofPennStateUniversity,andRutgersGraduateSchoolofEducation(October23‐24,2003),pp.21‐22.Availableathttp://www.ncsall.net/fileadmin/resources/research/rise_summaries.pdf.
![Page 72: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/72.jpg)
64
ProjectIDEAL:NumerousarticlesandbookshavecomeoutoftheProjectIDEALwork,includingthecomprehensiveHandbookofdistanceEducationforAdultLearners(2004)andaseriesofworkingpapers: TheMissouriDistanceLearningMentoringProgram.AnEvaluationPreparedbyTheProjectIDEAL
SupportCenter(2005) ShannonYoung,ExploringDistanceEducationCurriculaforAdultLearners(2005) JeromeJohnston,MeasuringContactHoursandEducationalProgressinDistanceEducation(2005) LesliePetty,StatePolicyforDistanceEducationProgramsforAdultLearners(2005) JeromeJohnston,APilotTestofStudyGroups:ProfessionalDevelopmentforExperiencedDistance
Teachers(2004) LesliePetty,Pennsylvania'sDistanceLearningProject2004‐2005,July2005NationalResearchandDevelopmentCenter JohnBynner,SteveReder,SamanthaParsonsandClareStrawn,ResearchSummary:TheDigital
Divide:ComputerUse,BasicSkillsandEmployment:AComparativeStudyinPortland[OR],USAandLondon,England.October2008.Availablefromhttp://www.nrdc.org.uk/publications_details.asp?ID=149#.
HarveyMellar,MariaKambouri,KitLogan,SallyBetts,BarbaraNanceandVivMoriarty,EffectiveTeachingandLearningUsingICT,SummaryReport,NRDC,February2007.Availableathttp://www.nrdc.org.uk/publications_details.asp?ID=87#.
HumanResourcesandSkillsDevelopmentCanada‐OfficeofLiteracyandEssentialSkills GettingOnline/TheGOProject:AResearchReportonOnlineLearningforCanadianLiteracy
Practitioners.Canada:October2008.Availableatwww.nald.ca/gettingonline.
OntarioMinistryofTraining,CollegesandUniversities,LiteracyandBasicSkillsProgram: PaulPorterandMatthewSturm,CrossingtheGreatDivides:Distancelearningandflexibledelivery
inAdultBasicEducation.ResearchReportforOntario’sLiteracyandBasicSkillsProgram.Ontario:HumanResourcesandSocialDevelopmentCanada.August2006.www.distance.alphaplus.ca/pdfs/CrossingTheGreatDividesFullRpt.pdf
NationalInstituteforLiteracy: Silver‐Pacuilla,Heidi(author)andReder,Stephen(originalanalysis).InvestigatingtheLanguageand
LiteracySkillsRequiredforIndependentOnlineLearning.Washington,DC.NationalInstituteforLiteracy.October,2008.Availableathttp://www.nifl.gov/publications/pdf/NIFLOnlineLearningReport.pdf.
U.S.DepartmentofEducation,OfficeofPlanning,Evaluation,andPolicyDevelopment,PolicyandProgramStudiesService,CenterforTechnologyinLearning: Means,Barbara;Toyama,Yukie;Murphy,Robert;Bakia,Marianne;Jones,Karla.
EvaluationofEvidence‐BasedPracticesinOnlineLearning:AMeta‐AnalysisandReviewofOnlineLearningStudies.U.S.DepartmentofEducation,OfficeofPlanning,Evaluation,andPolicyDevelopment,PolicyandProgramStudiesService,CenterforTechnologyinLearning,2009.Availableathttp://www.ed.gov/rschstat/eval/tech/evidence‐based‐practices/finalreport.pdf.
![Page 73: by Mary L. McCain · 2018-04-26 · THE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSFORM ADULT LEARNING Expanding Access to Adult Education & Workforce Skills Through Distance Learning by Mary L](https://reader035.vdocuments.net/reader035/viewer/2022080718/5f788338a9923b7336073515/html5/thumbnails/73.jpg)
65
WebsiteResources AdultEdOnline‐www.adultedonline.org AssociationofPublicTelevisionStations‐WorkforceSkillsAdultLiteracy(WSAL)
http://www.apts.org/PTVissues/workforce/index.cfm CapturedWisdom‐www.ncrtec.org/pd/cw/adultlit.htm CenterforAppliedResearchinEducationTechnology(CARET)‐http://caret.iste.org NationalCenteronAdultLiteracy–UniversityofPennsylvania–http://www.literacy.org CaliforniaDistanceLearningProject(CDLP)‐www.cdlponline.org CommunityTechnologyCenters‐www.ed.gov/programs/comtechcenters DigitalEquityToolkit‐http://www.editlib.org/p/10041 DistanceEducationClearinghouse‐www.uwex.edu/disted EnglishForAll(EFA)‐www.myefa.org ESL/CivicsLink‐http://civicslink.ket.org ExpandingAccesstoAdultLiteracywithOnlineDistanceEducation–
http://www.ncsall.net/fileadmin/resources/research/op_askov.pdf HarnessingTechnologytoServeAdultLiteracy‐http://alri.org/harness.html InternationalCentreforDistanceLearning(ICDL)‐www‐icdl.open.ac.uk InternationalSocietyforTechnologyinEducation(ISTE)‐www.iste.org NIFLLINCSTechnologyTrainingSpecialCollection‐www.altn.org/techtraining Outreach&TechnicalAssistanceNetwork(OTAN)‐www.otan.us ProfessionalDevelopmentKit(PDK)‐http://www.editlib.org/p/10887 PBSLiteracyLink‐http://litlink.ket.org ProjectIDEAL‐http://projectideal.org TheUnitedStatesDistanceLearningAssociation(USDLA)–www.usdla.org USALearns‐www.usalearns.org “TheVerizonLiteracyNetwork”‐http://literacynetwork.verizon.org