carolandcarolineadaptationmodel
TRANSCRIPT
When I consider your heavens,The work of your fingers…What is man that you are mindful
of him,The son of man that you care for
him?You made him a little lower than
the heavenly beingsAnd crowned him with glory and
honorYou made him ruler over the
works of your hands Psalm 8: 3-6
When I consider your heavens,The work of your fingers…What is man that you are mindful
of him,The son of man that you care for
him?You made him a little lower than
the heavenly beingsAnd crowned him with glory and
honorYou made him ruler over the
works of your hands Psalm 8: 3-6
Sister Callista Roy’s
Adaptation Model and
Application
Person
-Person: adaptive system constantly interacting with external and internal environment
-Persons major task: Maintain personal integrity (wholeness) in face of environmental stimuli.
Environment4
Adaptation5
Integrated, Compensatory, or Compromised
Stimuli influence adaptation level
4
Roy’s Model Continued…
Coping mechanisms: Regulator and Cognator
Control Processes: Stabilizer and Innovator
ADAPTATION
Four Adaptive Modes
1. Physiological- oxygenation, nutrition, elimination, activity, rest, and protection
2. Self Concept- Psychological and spiritual elements
3. Role Function- primary,secondary, and tertiary roles the person performs in society
4. Interdependence- coping mechanisms arising from close relationships
Goal: Promote integrated adaptation in all four modes = HEALTH
Four Adaptation Modes
Apply the Nursing Process to Each of the Four Adaptive Modes
1. Assess Behavior
2. Assess Stimuli
3. Nursing Diagnosis
4. Goal Setting
5. Interventions
6. Evaluation
ULTIMATE GOAL: Promote integrated adaptation in each of the Four Adaptive Modes
Visual Aid
Roy’s Adaptation Model
Person-open system
Environmental Stimuli: Focal, Contextual, Residual
Adaptation level: integrated,
compensatory, or compromised.
Health
Nursing
Examples of Roy’s Model in Practice
Cancer patients -Cook(1999), Gerrish (1989) Amputations - Dawson (1998) Occupational Health -Doyle & Rejacich (1991) Pt’s with Anxiety- Fredrickson (1993) Hospitalized Children- Galligan (1979), Starn & Niederhauser
(1990) Coronary Care Unit- Hamner (1989) Adolescents with Asthma- Hennessy-Harstad (1999) Adult Hemodialysis patients- Keen et al. (1998) Home care- Lankester & Sheldon (1999), Schmitz (1980) Abused Women- Limandri (1986) Patients with Kawasaki disease- Nash (1987) Adolescents with bulimia nervosa- Pilote (1998a,1998b) Elderly in apartment complexes- Smith (1998) Patients with alzheimer’s disease- Thornbury & King (1992)
* List obtained from Fitzpatrick and Wall (2005)
More recently...Suggested use in Community Health Nursing
13
Physical-morbidity/mortality stats, medical facilities, funding
Group identity-culture,morale
Role function-effectiveness and accountability of institutions (fire, police, hospitals)
Interdependence-relationships of community with outside organizations, quality of relationships within the community
* Dixon, E.L. (1999). Community health nursing practice and the Roy adaptation model. Public Health Nursing 16(4), 290-300.
13
Use of Roy’s model to promote behavior change...
- Helped women have a more accurate understanding of smoking addiction
-Women were able to explain how stress affected their physical, mental, spiritual self and their relationships with others
In conclusion: More accurate understanding of their addiction and their perceptions of stimuli that produced the desire for them to continue smoking.
* Villareal, E. (2003). Using Roy’s adapation model when caring fpr a group of young women contemplating
quitting smoking. Public Health Nusing, 20(5), 377-384
Helping Women through Menopause15
Holistic approach to assessing and analyzing the menopausal transition
*Cunningham, D. A. (2003). Application of Roy’s adaptation model when caring for a group of women coping with menopause. Journal of Community Health Nursing, 19(1), 49-60.
Examples of Roy’s Adaptation Model in Research
16
Cross-cultural pain- Cavillo & Flaskerud (1993) Caesarean birth- Fawcett (1990) Child-bearing women- Fawcett & Tulman (1990), Tulman et al.
(1998) Cancer patients- Frederickson et al. (1991), Samarel et al. (1998) Spinal cord injury patients- Harding-Okimoto (1997) Abused women- Limandri (1986) Well adolescents- Modrcin et al. (1998) Breast-feeding women- Nyqvist & Sjoden (1993) Spouses of surgical patients- Silva (1987) Elderly persons- Smith (1988), Zhan (2000) Persons with Alzheimer’s disease- Thornbury and King (1992)
* List obtained from Fitzpatrick and Wall (2005)
16
More recently...
Brooke Army Medical Center and U.S. Army Institute of Surgical Research- Series of studies based on Roy’s Adaptation Model
1. Quality of life experienced by people with cancer. Findings: Military patients did not share with their healthcare provider about pain, sexual dysfunciton, ect. because they viewed these as expected.
2 Investigate feasibility of exercise program and examine the effects on physiological and psychological parameters of health in Cancer patients. Findings: Improved exercise tolerance, activity, sleep patterns, and quality of life.
Excellent guide for Quality of Life outcomes in patients with long term illness
• * Yoder, L. H. (2005). Using the Roy adaptation model: A program of research in a military research service. Nursing Science Quarterly 18(4), 321-323.
Adaptation in Children with Cancer
18
Used Roy’s model to guide in data collection in adaptation modes.
Different age groups will adapt differently
Age and physical maturity have significant impact on adaptation to cancer in pediatrics.
• *Yeh, C.H. (2001). Adaptation in children with cancer: Research with Roy’s model. Nursing Science Quarterly 14(2), 141-148.
Examples of Roy’s model in Education
19One of the most widely used models in the
U. S. for nursing education Geriatric Nurse-Practitioner Program University of Ottawa School of Nursing,
CanadaMount Saint Mary’s College, Los Angeles
Students deliver care based on Roy’s model http://www.msmc.la.edu/undergraduate-bachelor-programs/nursing/bachelor-of-science.asp
*Source: Fitzpatrick & Wall, 2005
Roy’s Model Applied to Administration
A research study explains how one hospital implemented Roy’s model to develop :
• A Nursing Philosophy
• Mission Statements
• Standards of Practice
• Job Descriptions
• Performance Planning and an Appraisal System
• A Quality Monitoring System
CONCLUSION: highly integrated system of nursing administration and practice
*Rogers et al.,1991
20
Caroline Gates RN
Evaluation of Model
AdequacyModel developed
from belief based mainly on pediatric clinical observations
Use of Harry Helson’s adaptation theory
(Patton, 2004)
Evaluation of Model
ClarityAdaptation
-How is it defined?-Who defines it?-How is it evaluated?
Health -Non-specific definition
(Lewis, 1988; Patton, 2004)
predictions
Evaluation of Model
ClarityAdaptive modes have unclear boundaries -Interrelated by perception
Some use of theoretical jargonGood assessment method (Lewis, 1988; Patton, 2004)
Evaluation of Model
Complexity
Abstract and difficult to understand
Concept of Person as an adaptive system
Cognator and regulator subsystems
Not easily operational for research -stimuli create an extensive list of potential variables
Tolson & McIntosh, 1996
Adaptation
Coping Control
Regulator Cognator Stabilizer Innovator
Cognitive Emotional
Output processes
Central processes
Input
Evaluation of Model
Completeness
Addresses all four concepts of a nursing model (metaparadigm)
Comprehensive and systematic assessment - Observed behavior is reflective of the parts
Focus on the individual -> More of a downstream approach
Smaller perspective
Person = adaptive system-> Little room for humanistic understanding
Clinical Use of the Model for FNPs in primary care setting
Develops systematic and comprehensive ways of knowing reality
Promotes critical thinking
Focused on the Person -rights, liberty, and
independent actions
Clinical Use of the Model for FNPs in primary care setting
Helps visualize the nursing process as a dynamic continuum -> the patient’s progress becomes the driving force within the process
Provides guidance for intervention that can enhance quality of life and enhance interaction of the person with the environment
Adaptation to chronic illness Family functioning
Clinical Use of the Model for FNPs in primary care setting
Limited by the perception of adaptation -> need to identify client’s
perception of the problem The meanings attached to
the experience Then assist the client in
forming realistic goals in coping with the problem
Clinical Use of the Model with a Geriatric Population
Assess circumstances that might contribute to a premature admission to a long term care facility.
Role reversal Powerlessness Difficulty coping with disability Adaptation of significant other
Farkas , 1981
Clinical Use of the Model for Cardiac Health
Chest pain, decreased levels of activity, fluid overload, sleep disturbance (physiologic mode)
Fear, anxiety, body image disturbance due to bypass surgery (self-concept mode)
Increased dependency on others (role function)
Relationship needs unmet (interdependence mode)
Self-esteem issues (interdependence mode)
Conclusion
Research supports Roy’s model as evidence based nursing process
Widely used in different settings and has enduring characteristics (based on system’s theory)(Alligood, 2010)
Updated as knowledge increases and trends change (Alligood, 2010)
In a world of globalization, the model is limited by an egocentric paradigm (Cody, 2006)
Limited by the view that the individual good is the highest good to be achieved (Cody, 2006)
References33
• Alligood, M. R. (2010). Nursing theory: Utilization and application. Maryland
Heights, MO: Mosby, Inc.• Cody, W. (2006). Philosophical and Theoretical Perspectives for Advanced
Nursing Practice. (4th Ed.). Sudbury, MA: Jones and Bartlett.• Cunningham, D. A. (2003). Application of Roy’s adaptation model when caring for a
group of women coping with menopause. Journal of Community Health
Nursing, 19(1), 49-60.• Dixon, E.L. (1999). Community health nursing practice and the Roy adaptation
model. Public Health Nursing 16(4), 290-300• Farkas, L. (1981). Adaptation problems with nursing home application for
elderly persons: an application of the Roy adaptation nursing model. Journal of Advanced Nursing (6), 363-368.
• Fitzpatrick, J.J., & Whall A.L. (2005). Conceptual models of nursing: Analysis andapplication. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education, Inc.
• Lewis, T. (1988). Leaping the chasm between nursing theory and practice. Journal of Advanced Nursing (13), 345-351.
20
References Continued
• Patton, D. (2004). An analysis of Roy’s Adaptation Model of nursing as used within acute psychiatric nursing. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing (11), 221-228.
• Roders, M., Paul, L. J., Clarke, J., Mackay, C., Potter, M., Ward, W. (1991). The use of the Roy Adaptation Model in nursing administration. Canadian Journal of
Nursing Administration 4 (2), 21-26.• Tolson, D, McIntosh, J. (1996). The Roy Adaptation Model: a consideration of its
properties as a conceptual framework for an intervention study. Journal of
Advanced Nursing (96), 981-987.• Villareal, E. (2003). Using Roy’s adapation model when caring fpr a group of young
women contemplating quitting smoking. Public Health Nusing, 20(5), 377-384
• Yeh, C.H. (2001). Adaptation in children with cancer: Research with Roy’s model. Nursing Science Quarterly 14(2), 141-148.
• Yoder, L. H. (2005). Using the Roy adaptation model: A program of research in a
military research service. Nursing Science Quarterly 18(4), 321-323.