7/21/2019 Case 15 People vs. Ulzoron(1998)

1/1

CASE NO. 15RULE 130: A | Section 1. Object [as] (REAL) Evidence

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES vs. SAMUEL ULZORONG.R. No. 121979 (286 SCRA 741); M !"# $2% 1998

FACTSAccused a!!e""ant Sa#ue" U"$o%on &as c'a% ed &it' %a!e &it' t'e use o a dead"* &ea!on. +o#!"ainin&itness &as E#i"* ,abo. On t'e st%en t' o t'e "atte%-s testi#on* t'e t%ia" cou%t convicted t'e accused. /t

ound ,abo-s testi#on* st%ai 't o%&a%d and c%edib"e. 'e ndin s o t'e e2a#inin !'*sician a"so "entc%edence to 'e% c"ai#.

au"tin t'e t%ia" cou%t o% convictin 'i# on 'is a""e ed"* &ea4 de ense accused a!!e""ant a% ues t'at t'eundis!uted acts and ci%cu#stances #ade it #o%e "i4e"* t'at co#!"ainin &itness ,abo &as invo"ved inan adu"te%ous %e"ations'i! &it' 'i#. 5e c"ai#s o% instance t'at t'e%e &as abso"ute"* not'in to su!!o%tt'e victi#-s c"ai# o st%u "e and t'at &'i"e 'e a""e ed"* d%a ed 'e% o%t* (60) #ete%s a&a* be o%eassau"tin 'e% se2ua""* t'e e2a#inin !'*sician cou"d not conc"ude t'at !'*sica" o%ce &as actua""*in7icted since s'e did not sustain an* !'*sica" inju%ies.

ISSUE8'et'e% it is necessa%* t'at co##ission o %a!e be acco#!anied b* #a%4s o !'*sica" vio"ence on t'evicti#-s bod* suc' t'at it s'ou"d 'ave %esu"ted in !'*sica" inju%ies on t'e victi#.

HEL&' NO.

A * ! +% , ,- o +"+-- !* o! #+ "o//,--,o o ! 0+ # #+!+ + / ! - o 0#*-," 3,o3+ "+ o #+ ," ,/ - o *. 8'i"e t'e victi# %e!eated"* #entioned 'e% st%u "es to be %e"eased %o#

'is %as! suc' e9o%ts need not a"&a*s %esu"t in !'*sica" inju%ies as suc' st%u "es %e e% to t'eci%cu#stances &'en s'e &as bein d%a ed b* t'e accused but to t'e ci%cu#stances &'en 'e initia""*

%abbed 'e% 'ands &'en 'e &as on to! o 'e% &'en 'e &as und%essin 'e% and &'en s'e &as e2e%tine9o%ts to disen a e 'e%se" %o# t'e se2ua" anc'o%a e. u%t'e% t'e%e &as su cient inti#idation &'ena!!e""ant !ointed 'is ; oot "on bo"o at E#i"*-s nec4 &'i"e t'e* &e%e nea% t'e &e"" unti" t'e* %eac'ed t'es!ot &'e%e s'e &as na""* abused.

T#+ ",!" /- "+- o o!"+ , ,/, ,o + , #+ , - " -+ +!+ / , +- +"3+ !3* o o 3* , #+ ," ,/ - +- ,/o * 3-o , #+ 0#*-," 3 + , + "+ 0!+-+ + !,

#+ !, 3 "o -,- , o #+! o! !+-- +! + ! - +33 - #+ /+ ,"o:3+ 3 !+0o! . Suc'!ieces o evidence indeed a%e #o%e e"o