complaint 11-28-12 6pm
TRANSCRIPT
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 1/27
1
STATE OF NEW YORK
SUPREME COURT - ALBANY COUNTY
___________________________________________
ROBERT L. SCHULZ, HENRY L. HAMILTON,
AL BELARDINELLI, ANDREA STUKAS,
JOHN I. MINERD, RITA EDWARDS, CARL EDWARDS,
EVELYN LONGLEY, DENNIS B. SWEENEY,
JAMES M. WALKER, ROBIN G. CARR, ROBERT E. RICE,
JOHN W. WALLACE, TIMOTHY A. CHICHESTER,
ZACHARIAH A. CHICHESTER, EMANUELE
MARINARO, PHILIP POLIZOTTO, KENNETH L.
HOLMES, JULIANNE M. THOMPSON, JOHN RUS VERIFIED COMPLAINT
THOMPSON, CAROL POLINER, JENNA POLINER,
ELEANOR CORCORAN, JAMES CORCORAN, INDEX NO. ___________
KENNETH C. SCHOLZ, VICTORIA POCZKALSKI,EDWARD L. MCCARTY, MICHAEL J. BRITT,
RICHARD C. BARRETT, SHELBY BARRETT, STEVEN
GLICK, CHRISTOPHER J. NICHOLS, LOUINE M. KOLB,
JOHN L. SHELTER, JOHN MARTIN, JOHN L.
BOSWORTH II, MICHAEL R. BELL, JOHN S. HUMPHREY,
JEFFREY L. STEVENS, JOHN C. DEWITT, KAY S.
HOFFMAN, BEVERLY J. HURLEY, BART S. BONNER,
DEBRA THOMPSON, ESTELLA A. HART, LAURA L.
STEVENS, RONALD G.MOORE, DAVID WILLIAM BOWER,
STEPHEN KRAEGER, JANE WOODWARD, SUSAN J.ENGLERT, JAMES P. DELANEY, EDWARD A. GARTZ,
RALPH ERIC SCHNACKENBERG, JULIA S. GAMBINO,
ANDREAS MILONIS, MARK AXINN, DONALD G. HOBEL,
EDWARD D. PETTITT, JANET MARTIN, MYRON D.
ANNIS, MARTHA A. FRANCIS, RITA D. LARSON,
THOMAS J. LARSON, ROBERT ELLISON, JOANNE
WILDER, MARY ANN BUERMAN, TANYA PARROW,
GEORGE G. RADFORD, PATRICIA M. RADFORD,
ANTOINETTE M. BLACK, HARVEY E. DAVIES, JAMES M.
DOOHER, KEVIN T. COTE, ROBERT SPENCER, MYRNA
A. THAYNE, PRISCILLA TAMARO, GEORGE TAMARO,
DAVE CRAWMER, EDWARD M. STEHLIN, MARY ANN
PENNELL, NANCY W. FOSTER, DALTON P. FOSTER,
DONALD R.WHITE, CHAD H. CURRIN, WILBUR W. CARD,
VANESSA PARSONS, HARVEY KASH, GARY L. PERRY,
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 2/27
2
DENVER L. JONES, KATHLEEN C. ELLIOTT, VIVIAN Y.
WADLIN, JUDITH M. WHITMORE, JOHN SALVADOR, JR.,
ANTHONY FUTIA, JR., and CHRISTOPHER J. ENGLERT
- Plaintiffs-Petitioners
-against
ANDREW M. CUOMO and all others similarly situated;
DEAN G. SKELOS and all others similarly situated;
JONATHAN LIPPMAN and all others similarly situated;
MICHAEL R. BLOOMBERG and all others similarly situated;
DANNY DONAHUE and all others similarly situated;
JOHN L. STIPO and all others similarly situated;
ED COX and all others similarly situated;
STEPHANIE MINER and all others similarly situated.- Defendants-Respondents
__________________________________________
PLAINTIFFS-PETITIONERS, each and every one listed in the caption above allege:
1. This is an action for declaratory and injunctive relief pursuant to CPLR 3001.
2. The relief requested herein is a judgment and order:
a) declaring it to be a conflict of interest for defendants to be delegates at any New York
State Constitutional Convention, and
b) permanently enjoining defendants and all similarly situated from becoming delegates
at any future New York State Convention, and
c) for such other and further relief as to the court may seem just and proper.
JURISDICTION
3. Section 3001 of the CPLR provides that a court "may render a declaratory judgment" to
resolve "the rights and other legal relations of the parties to a justiciable controversy."
“The supreme court may render a declaratory judgment having the effect of a final judgment as
to the rights and other legal relations of the parties to a justiciable controversy whether or not
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 3/27
3
further relief is or could be claimed. If the court declines to render such a judgment it shall state
its grounds.” CIVIL PRACTICE LAW AND RULES, SECTION 3001.
4. The statute is broad in scope. James v. Alderton Dock Yards, Ltd ., 256 N.Y. 298, 305(1931).
5. There is no inherent limitation on the type of declaratory relief available under the
Declaratory Judgment Act, CPLR 3001. Maguire v. Monaghan, 206 Misc. 550, 555, (Sup.
Ct. N.Y. County 1954), afl'd mem., 285 App. Div. 926 (1st Dep't 1955);
6. Plaintiffs have an individual, implied constitutional Right, a legally protected interest, to a
pathway to constitutional change that is not controlled by those who directly or indirectly
wield governmental power over them, i.e., their governmental “Agents.”
7. Plaintiffs have a substantial interest in the determination of this controversy.
8. This Right is in danger of infringement by the defendants.
9. This controversy is definite, substantial, and ripe for final determination. The parties have
adverse interests that collided in 1967, the last time the People voted for a Constitutional
Convention, and resulted in harm, and threaten to do so again as early as 2014.
10. However, neither an actual infringement of rights nor alternate coercive relief are necessary
in a declaratory judgment action. See, e.g., Town of Ramapo v. Village of Spring Valley,
40 Misc. 2d 589, 591 (Sup. Ct. Rockland County 1962) (declaratory relief available to test
validity of contract although it had not been breached), appeal dismissed, 13 N.Y.2d 918,
(1963).
11. A declaration of the Rights of the People and the Obligations of the Government under
Article XIX Section 2 of the New York Constitution in this case will serve a necessary and
useful purpose. Davis Constr. Corp. v. County of Suffolk , 112 Misc. 2d 652, 656, (Sup. Ct.
Suffolk County 1982), aff'd mem., 95 App. Div. 2d 819 (2d Dep't 1983).
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 4/27
4
PARTIES
12.
ROBERT L. SCHULZ is a citizen of New York State, residing in Washington County.
13. HENRY HAMILTON is a citizen of New York State, residing in Albany County.
14. AL BELARDINELLI is a citizen of New York State, residing in Broome County.
15. ANDREA STUKAS is a citizen of New York State, residing in Broome County.
16. JOHN I. MINERD is a citizen of New York State, residing in Cattaraugus County.
17. RITA EDWARDS is a citizen of New York State, residing in Cattaraugus County.
18. CARL EDWARDS is a citizen of New York State, residing in Cattaraugus County.
19. EVELYN L. LONGLEY is a citizen of New York State, residing in Cayuga County.
20. DENNIS B. SWEENEY is a citizen of New York State, residing in Chautauqua County.
21. JAMES M. WALKER is a citizen of New York State, residing in Chautauqua County.
22. ROBIN G. CARR is a citizen of New York State, residing in Chautauqua County.
23. ROBERT E. RICE is a citizen of New York State, residing in Chemung County.
24. JOHN W. WALLACE is a citizen of New York State, residing in Columbia County.
25. TIMOTHY A. CHICESTER is a citizen of New York State, residing in Columbia County.
26. ZACHARIAH A. CHICESTER is a citizen of New York State, residing in Columbia
County.
27. EMANUELE MARINARO is a citizen of New York State, residing in Dutchess County.
28. PHILLIP POLIZOTTO is a citizen of New York State, residing in Dutchess County.
29. KENNETH L. HOLMES is a citizen of New York State, residing in Erie County.
30. JULIANNE M. THOMPSON is a citizen of New York State, residing in Erie County.
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 5/27
5
31. JOHN RUS THOMPSON is a citizen of New York State, residing in Erie County.
32. CAROL POLINER is a citizen of New York State, residing in Erie County.
33. JENNA M. POLINER is a citizen of New York State, residing in Erie County.
34. ELEANOR CORCORAN is a citizen of New York State, residing in Erie County.
35. JAMES CORCORAN is a citizen of New York State, residing in Erie County.
36. KENNETH C. SCHOLZ is a citizen of New York State, residing in Erie County.
37. VICTORIA POCZKALSKI is a citizen of New York State, residing in Erie County.
38. EDWARD L. MCCARTY is a citizen of New York State, residing in Erie County.
39.
MICHAEL J. BRITT is a citizen of New York State, residing in Erie County.
40. RICHARD C. BARRETT is a citizen of New York State, residing in Herkimer County.
41. SHELBY BARRETT is a citizen in New York State, residing in Herkimer County.
42. STEVEN GLICK is a citizen of New York State, residing in Jefferson County.
43. CHRISTOPHER J. NICHOLS is a citizen of New York State, residing in Jefferson County.
44. LOUINE M. KOLB is a citizen of New York State, residing in Jefferson County.
45. JOHN L. SHELTER is a citizen of New York State, residing in Jefferson County.
46. JOHN MARTIN is a citizen of New York State, residing in Jefferson County.
47. JOHN L. BOSWORTH III is a citizen of New York State, residing in Jefferson County.
48. MICHAEL A. BELL is a citizen of New York State, residing in Jefferson County.
49. JOHN S. HUMPHREY is a citizen of New York State, residing in Jefferson County.
50. JEFFREY L. STEVENS is a citizen of New York State, residing in Jefferson County.
51. JOHN C. DEWITT is a citizen of New York State, residing in Jefferson County.
52. KAY S. HOFFMAN is a citizen of New York State, residing in Jefferson County.
53. BEVERLY J. HURLEY is a citizen of New York State, residing in Jefferson County.
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 6/27
6
54. BART S. BONNER is a citizen of New York State, residing in Jefferson County.
55. DEBRA THOMPSON is a citizen of New York State, residing in Jefferson County.
56. ESTELLA A HART is a citizen of New York State, residing in Jefferson County.
57. LAURA L. STEVENS is a citizen of New York State, residing in Jefferson County.
58. RONALD G. MOORE is a citizen of New York State, residing in Kings County.
59. DAVID WILLIAM BOWER is a citizen of New York State, residing in Lewis County.
60. STEPHEN KRAEGER is a citizen of New York State, residing in Lewis County.
61. JANE WOODWARD is a citizen of New York State, residing in Lewis County.
62.
SUSAN ENGLERT is a citizen of New York State, residing in Livingston County.
63. JAMES P. DELANEY is a citizen of New York State, residing in Monroe County.
64. EDWARD A. GARTZ is a citizen of New York State, residing in Monroe County.
65. RALPH ERIK SCHNACKENBERG is a citizen of New York State, residing in
Montgomery County.
66. JULIA S. GAMBINO is a citizen of New York State, residing in Nassau County.
67. ANDREAS MILONIS is a citizen of New York State, residing in Nassau County.
68. MARK AXINN is a citizen of New York State, residing in New York County.
69. DONALD G. HOBEL is a citizen of New York State, residing in Niagara County.
70. EDWARD D. PETTITT is a citizen of New York State, residing in Niagara County.
71. JANET M. MARTIN is a citizen of New York State, residing in Niagara County.
72. MYRON D. ANNIS is a citizen of New York State, residing in Niagara County.
73. MARTHA A. FRANCIS is a citizen of New York State, residing in Niagara County.
74. RITA D. LARSON is a citizen of New York State, residing in Niagara County.
75. THOMAS J. LARSON is a citizen of New York State, residing in Niagara County.
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 7/27
7
76. ROBERT ELLISON is a citizen of New York State, residing in Oneida County.
77. JOANN WILDER is a citizen of New York State, residing in Onondaga County.
78. MARY ANN BUERMAN is a citizen of New York State, residing in Onondaga County.
79. TANYA PARROW is a citizen of New York State, residing in Onondaga County.
80. GEORGE G. RADFORD is a citizen of New York State, residing in Onondaga County.
81. PATRICIA M. RADFORD is a citizen of New York State, residing in Onondaga County.
82. ANTOINETTE M. BLACK is a citizen of New York State, residing in Onondaga County.
83. HARVEY E. DAVIES is a citizen of New York State, residing in Onondaga County.
84.
JAMES D. DOOHER is a citizen of New York State, residing in Onondaga County.
85. KEVIN COTE is a citizen of New York State, residing in Orange County.
86. ROBERT SPENCER is a citizen of New York State, residing in Oswego County.
87. MYRNA A. THAYNE is a citizen of New York State, residing in Otsego County.
88. PRISCILLA TAMARO is a citizen of New York State, residing in Otsego County.
89. GEORGE TAMARO is a citizen of New York State, residing in Otsego County.
90. DAVID CRAWMER is a citizen of New York State, residing in Rensselaer County.
91. EDWARD M. STEHLIN is a citizen of New York State, residing in Richmond County.
92. MARY ANN PENNELL is a citizen of New York State, residing in Rockland County.
93. NANCY W. FOSTER is a citizen of New York State, residing in St. Lawrence County.
94. DALTON P. FOSTER is a citizen of New York State, residing in St. Lawrence County.
95. DONALD WHITE is a citizen of New York State, residing in Saratoga County.
96. CHAD H. CURRIN is a citizen of New York State, residing in Schenectady County.
97. WILBUR W. CARD is a citizen of New York State, residing in Steuben County.
98. VANESSA PARSONS is a citizen of New York State, residing in Suffolk County.
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 8/27
8
99. HARVEY KASH is a citizen of New York State, residing in Suffolk County.
100. GARY L. PERRY is a citizen of New York State, residing in Tioga County.
101. DENVER L. JONES is a citizen of New York State, residing in Tioga County.
102. KATHLEEN C. ELLIOTT is a citizen of New York State, residing in Tompkins County.
103. VIVIAN Y. WADLIN is a citizen of New York State, residing in Ulster County.
104. JUDITH M. WHITMORE is a citizen of New York State, residing in Warren County.
105. JOHN L. SALVADOR is a citizen of New York State, residing in Warren County.
106. ANTHONY FUTIA, JR is a citizen of New York State, residing in Westchester County.
107. CHRISTOPHER J. ENGLERT is a citizen of New York State, residing in Wyoming
County.
108. Under New York’s Constitutional Republic, and for purposes of this Declaratory Judgment
Action, the Parties listed in paragraphs 12 - 108 above are the “PRINCIPAL.”
109. ANDREW M. CUOMO, and all those similarly situated, are directly or indirectly
employed by the Executive Branch of the State of New York, and are thereby governed in
that capacity by the restrictions, prohibitions, mandates of and principles underlying the
New York State Constitution and its implementing statutes.1
110. DEAN G. SKELOS, and all those similarly situated, are directly or indirectly employed by
the Legislative Branch of the State of New York, and are thereby governed in that capacity
by the restrictions, prohibitions, mandates of and principles underlying the New York State
Constitution and its implementing statutes.2
1ANDREW M. CUOMO is the Governor of New York State, with principal offices located at New York State
Capitol Building, Albany, NY 12224.2DEAN G. SKELOS is the Senate Majority Leader, with principal offices located at Legislative Office Building,
Room 909, Albany NY 12207.
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 9/27
9
111. JONATHAN LIPPMAN, and all those similarly situated, are directly or indirectly
employed by the Unified Court System of the State of New York, and are thereby governed
in that capacity by the restrictions, prohibitions, mandates of and principles underlying the
New York State Constitution and its implementing statutes.3
112. MICHAEL R. BLOOMBERG, and all those similarly situated, are directly or indirectly
employed by a public corporation of the State of New York that has both the power to
contact indebtedness and power to collect rentals, charges, rates or fees, for the services or
facilities furnished or supplied by it, and are thereby governed in that capacity by the
restrictions, prohibitions, mandates of and principles underlying the New York State
Constitution and its implementing statutes.4
113. DANNY DONOHUE, and all those similarly situated, are directly or indirectly employed
by a lobbyist organization that is registered with the New York State Joint Commission on
Public Ethics and attempts to further its interests by influencing the governmental decision-
making process in New York State on the state and/or local level, and are thereby governed
in that capacity by the restrictions, prohibitions, mandates of and principles underlying the
New York State Constitution and its implementing statutes.5
114. JOHN STIPO, and all those similarly situated, receive a taxpayer supported pension from
the State of New York and/or one of its public corporations, and are thereby governed in
3 JONATHAN LIPPMAN is the Chief Judge of the State of New York and the Chief Judge of the Court of Appeals
with offices located at 25 Eagle Street, Albany, NY 12207.4MICHAEL R. BLOOMBERG is the Mayor of New York City with principal offices located at City Hall, New
York, NY 10007.5
Danny Donahue is the President of the Civil Service Employees Association, Local 1000, with principal offices
located at 143 Washington Ave., Albany N.Y., 12210.
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 10/27
10
that capacity by the restrictions, prohibitions, mandates of and principles underlying the
New York State Constitution and its implementing statutes.6
115. ED COX and STEPHANIE MINER, and all those similarly situated, are directly or
indirectly employed by a major Political Party, capable of designating and placing
candidates on the ballot for election, by the voters of New York State, to public official
positions and to political Party positions, and are thereby governed in that capacity by the
restrictions, prohibitions, mandates of and principles underlying the New York State
Constitution and its implementing statutes.7
116. Under New York’s Constitutional Republic, and for purposes of this Declaratory Judgment
Action, the Parties listed in paragraphs 109 – 115, and all those similarly situated are the
“AGENT” of the PRINCIPAL.
STATEMENT OF FACTS
117. Article XIX of the NY Constitution mandates the following question appear on the
statewide ballot on election day in November, 2017, “Shall there be a convention to revise
the Constitution and amend the same?”
“At the general election to be held in the year nineteen hundred fifty-seven, and every twentieth year
thereafter, and also at such times as the legislature may by law provide, the question “Shall there be
a convention to revise the constitution and amend the same?” shall be submitted to and decided by
the electors of the state;...” NY CONSTITUTION, ARTICLE XIX, SECTION 2
118. The New York State Constitution thus provides a pathway for the PRINCIPAL, the People
of New York State, to begin a process of peaceably putting their inherent, ultimate power
6 JOHN L. STIPO is a retired policeman from the Town of North Castle, County of Westchester.7 ED COX is the Chairman of the Republican Party of New York State, with offices located at 315 State Street,
Albany, NY 12210. STEPHANIE MINER is the Co-Chair of the New York State Democratic Committee with
principal offices located at 118a Fulton Street, Box #410 New York, NY 10038.
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 11/27
11
of self-government into their own hands every twenty years by calling a New York State
Constitutional Convention.
119. On information and belief, some legislators have suggested and bills have been introduced
to put the question on the ballot before 2017.
120. Should the People vote for a Constitutional Convention, Article XIX provides that three
delegates be elected from each State Senatorial District and fifteen delegates be elected at
large:
“and in case a majority of the electors voting thereon shall decide in favor of a convention
for such purpose, the electors of every senate district of the state, as then organized, shall elect
three delegates at the next ensuing general election, and the electors of the state voting at the sameelection shall elect fifteen delegates-at-large.” NY CONSTITUTION, ARTICLE XIX, SECTION 2
ARGUMENT
121. In 2017, or before, the free and sovereign People of New York State (the “PRINCIPAL”),
will have the opportunity to call a Constitutional Convention to evaluate the performance
of their “AGENT,” those who directly or indirectly wield governmental power over them,
and to restructure and redefine their relationship with the Agent based upon their
experience, and to do so by amending and revising the New York Constitution through the
Constitution’s constitutional convention process.
122. The PRINCIPAL must now prepare for the upcoming ballot question.
123. An immediate issue faces the PRINCIPAL: the all-important, influencing issue of who the
delegates to the convention should not be must be settled before the question appears on the
ballot.
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 12/27
12
124. It would be the ultimate conflict of interest for the AGENT to vote on issues at a
constitutional convention that was called by the PRINCIPAL, the purpose of which is to
revise and amend the Rule Book that is designed to restrict, prohibit and mandate the
activities of the AGENT, that is, the Rule Book that is designed to govern the government.
125. The AGENT is constitutionally restricted from serving as a Delegate at a constitutional
convention, not by a plain reading of the Constitution, but by essential principles
underlying America’s Charter, the Declaration of Independence, and Her State and Federal
Constitutions, including the essential principles of popular sovereignty, self-government
and separation of powers.
126. Should the AGENT sit as Delegates at a Constitutional Convention the AGENT would be
in control of both pathways to constitutional change provided by the Constitution: the
AGENT’S pathway and the PRINCIPAL’S pathway.
127. Besides providing the PRINCIPAL with the opportunity to revise and amend the
Constitution by a People’s Constitutional Convention at least once every twenty years, the
Constitution also provides the AGENT with the opportunity to revise and amend the
Constitution by placing specific amendments on the ballot at any time.
Any amendment or amendments to this constitution may be proposed in the senate andassembly whereupon such amendment or amendments shall be referred to the attorney-general
whose duty it shall be within twenty days thereafter to render an opinion in writing to the
senate and assembly as to the effect of such amendment or amendments upon other provisions
of the constitution. Upon receiving such opinion, if the amendment or amendments as proposed or
as amended shall be agreed to by a majority of the members elected to each of the two houses,
such proposed amendment or amendments shall be entered on their journals, and the ayes and
noes taken thereon, and referred to the next regular legislative session convening after the
succeeding general election of members of the assembly, and shall be published for three
months previous to the time of making such choice; and if in such legislative session, such
proposed amendment or amendments shall be agreed to by a majority of all the members elected
to each house, then it shall be the duty of the legislature to submit each proposed amendment or amendments to the people for approval in such manner and at such times as the legislature
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 13/27
13
shall prescribe; and if the people shall approve and ratify such amendment or amendments by a
majority of the electors voting thereon, such amendment or amendments shall become a
part of the constitution on the first day of January next after such approval. Neither the failure
of the attorney-general to render an opinion concerning such a proposed amendment nor his or
her failure to do so timely shall affect the validity of such proposed amendment or legislative
action thereon.” NY CONSTITUTION, ARTICLE XIX, SECTION 1.
128. This action goes to the very heart of the meaning of “self-government” and the phrase
found in the Declaration of Independence, which Declaration was incorporated in its
entirety in New York’s first Constitution (1777), to wit: “We hold these truths to be self-
evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain
unalienable rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness -- That
to secure these rights, governments are instituted among men, deriving their just powers
from the consent of the governed, that whenever any form of government becomes
destructive of these ends, it is the right of the people to alter or to abolish it, and to institute
new government, laying its powers in such form as to them shall seem most likely to effect
their safety and happiness.”
129. In October of 1932, former President Calvin Coolidge and Alfred E. Smith (Governor of
New York State and nominee for President in 1928) issued a joint statement of concern for
America. It said: “Unless the people, through a united action, arise and take charge of
their government, they will find that their government has taken charge of them.
Independence and liberty will be gone and the general public will find itself in a condition
of servitude to an aggregation of organized and selfish ambitions.” That was true then and
it is still true.
130. The constitutional will and intent of the sovereign people of New York State to have the
opportunity to take all of their power into their own hands at least once every twenty years,
in order to evaluate the performance of their (governmental) Agents and to restructure and
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 14/27
14
redefine their relationship with their government based upon that twenty-year experience,
and to do so by amending and revising the New York Constitution through the
constitutional convention process in accordance with Article XIX of the New York
Constitution, and Article IV, Section 4 of the United States Constitution would be violated
if delegates to the state constitutional convention were, in fact, representing the sovereign
people’s agent, i.e., the government, including defendants and all those similarly situated.
CONCLUSION
131. Plaintiffs respectfully request a final judgment and order:
a)
declaring it to be a conflict of interest for defendants and all those similarly situated
to be delegates at a New York State Constitutional Convention, and
b) permanently enjoining defendants and all similarly situated from becoming
delegates at any future New York State Convention, and
c) for such other and further relief as to the Court may seem just and proper.
DATED: November 17, 2012
ROBERT L. SCHULZ, pro se2458 Ridge Road
Queensbury, NY 12804(518) 656 3578
HENRY L. HAMILTON, pro se3108 East Lydius Street – P.O. Box 13321
Albany, NY 12212(518) 357-2018
AL BELARDINELLI, pro se2800 East Main Street
Endwell, NY 13760
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 15/27
15
(607) [email protected]
ANDREA STUKAS, pro se
2800 East Main StreetEndwell, NY 13760(607) 748-2228
JOHN J. MINERD, pro se
12271 Old Oleal Road(716) 560-6867
RITA EDWARDS, pro se1893 N. Main Street
Limestone, NY 14753(716) 925-7123
CARL EDWARDS, pro se1893 N. Main Street
Limestone, NY 14753(716) 925-7123
EVELYN L. LONGLEY, pro se17 Center Street
Auburn, NY 13021(315) 252-1629
DENNIS B. SWEENEY, pro se5939 Button Valley Road
Panama, NY 14767(716) 782-4021
JAMES M. WALKER, pro se3880 E. Ross Mills Rd
Falconer, NY [email protected]
(716) 985-4373
ROBIN G. CARR, pro se
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 16/27
16
33 Pullman StreetBrocton, NY 14716
(716) [email protected]
ROBERT E. RICE, pro se
160 Robinwood AvenueElmira Heights, NY 14903(607) 734-8024
JOHN W. WALLACE, pro se143 Longview Drive
Chatham, NY 12037(518) 392-7062
TIMOTHY A. CHICHESTER, pro se260 Spencer Road
Austerlitz, NY 12017
ZACHARIAH A. CHICHESTER, pro se260 Spencer Road
Austerlitz, NY 12017
EMANUELE MARINARO, pro se2779 Rt. 52
Hopewell Junction, NY 12533(845) 227-3717
PHILIP POLIZOTTO, pro se96 Gerald Drive
Poughkeepsie, NY 12601(914) 456-7581
KENNETH HOLMES, pro se6447 Armor Road
Orchard Park, NY 14127(716) 662-2476
JULIANNE M. THOMPSON, pro se
2394 Bedell RoadGrand Island, NY 14072
(716) 444-8908
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 17/27
17
JOHN RUS THOMPSON, pro se
2394 Bedell RoadGrand Island, NY 14072(716) 563-9901
CAROL POLINER, pro se4700 Schurr Road
Clarence, NY 14031(716) 544-4157
JENNA M. POLINER, pro se4700 Schurr Road
Clarence, NY 14031(716) 544-4157
ELEANOR CORCORAN, pro se5141 Willow Brook Rd
Clarence, NY 14031(716) 741-1076
JAMES CORCORAN, pro se5141 Willow Brook Drive
Clearance, NY 14031(716) 741-1076
KENNETH C. SCHOLZ, pro se18 Mill Valley Road
E. Amherst, NY(716) 688-5682
VICTORIA POCZKALSKI, pro se42 Layer Avenue
Buffalo, NY 14207(716) 874-4654
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 18/27
18
EDWARD L. MCCARTY, pro se
7246 S. Abbott RoadHamburg, NY 14075(716) 649-6745
MICHAEL J. BRITT, pro se34 Parkwood Road
Amherset, NY 14226(716) 364-9565
RICHARD C. BARRETT, pro se10243 Roberts Road
Sanquoit, NY 13456(315) 737-5644
SHELBY BARRETT, pro se10243 Roberts Road
Sanquoit, NY 13456(315) 737-5644
STEVEN GLICK, pro se34800 Elm Ridge Road
Philadelphia, NY 13673(315) 767-9414
CHRISTOPHER J. NICHOLS, pro se18591 County Rt. 66
Watertown, NY 13601(315) 767-2782
LOUINE M. KOLB, pro se
207 Ambrose StreetSackets Harbor, NY 13685
(315) [email protected]
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 19/27
19
JOHN L. SHETLER, pro se
32161 County Route 28Philadelphia, NY 13673(315) 286-2966
JOHN MARTIN, pro se31813 Town Line Road
Philadelphia, NY 13673(315) 767-3523
JOHN L. BOSWORTH II, pro se40390 Vrooman Hill Road
Theresa, NY 13691(315) 778-4190
MICHAEL R. BELL, pro se6417 Gosier Road
Cape Vincent, NY 13618(315) 654-3932
JOHN S. HUMPHREY, pro se
29079 NY State Route 12Watertown, NY 13601
(315) 222-5121 [email protected]
JEFFREY L. STEVENS, pro se
16983 CR 76Adams Center, NY 13606
(315) 767-5653 [email protected]
JOHN C. DEWITT, pro se
5571 Co Rt 120(315) 846-5787
KAY S. HOFFMAN, pro se
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 20/27
20
1230 Madison AvenueWatertown, NY 13601
(315) [email protected]
BEVERLY J. HURLEY, pro se
332 Arlington Street, Apt. DownWatertown, NY 13601(315) 782-0276
BART S. BONNER, pro se
23967 County Route 67Watertown, NY 13601
(315) 788-8208 [email protected]
DEBRA THOMPSON, pro se
225 Wyoming AvenueWatertown, NY 13601
(315) 782-8956
ESTELLA A. HART, pro se29122 Perch Lake Road
Watertown, NY 13601(315) 629-2601
LAURA L. STEVENS, pro se16983 County Route 76
Adams Center, NY 13606(315) 408-6310
RONALD G. MOORE303 Columbia Street – Apt 5F
(646) [email protected]
DAVID WILLIAM BOWER, pro se
7512 Railroad StreetLowville, NY 13367-1864
(515) [email protected]
STEPHEN KRAEGER, pro se
3922 High Street
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 21/27
21
Lyons Falls, NY 13368(315) 348-4296
JANE WOODWARD, pro se
7700 W. State StreetLowville, NY 13367(315) 376-6988
SUSAN ENGLERT, pro se
6706 Cleary RoadLivonia, NY 14487
(585) [email protected]
JAMES P. DELANEY, pro se
108 Image WayRochester, NY 14626
(585) 752-1434 [email protected]
EDWARD A. GARTZ, pro se
220 Orchard Creek Rochester, NY 14612
(585) [email protected]
RALPH ERIK SCHNACKENBERG, pro se
182 Logtown RoadFultonville, NY 12072
(518) [email protected]
JULIA S. GAMBINO, pro se
15 Dale RoadFarmingdale, NY 11735
(516) 694-9474
ANDREAS MILONIS, pro se101 Central Park Rd, Apt 9
Plainview, NY 11803(516) 286-9708
MARK N. AXINN
338 East 78th
Street
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 22/27
22
New York, New York 10075(212) 753-5599
DONALD G. HOBEL, pro se
3767 Moyer RoadWheatfield, NY 14120(716) 693-1823
EDWARD D. PETTITT, pro se3188 Coomer Road
Newfane, NY 14108(716) 471-6001
JANET M. MARTIN, pro se2163 Jagow Road #3
Niagara Falls, NY 14304(716) 731-8107
MYRON D. ANNIS, pro se
61 Gunson Street North Tonawanda, NY 14020
(716) [email protected]
MARTHA A. FRANCIS, pro se
41 Sweeney Court North Tonawanda, NY
(716) [email protected]
RITA D. LARSON, pro se
3700 Lockport RoadWheatfield, NY 14132
(716) [email protected]
THOMAS J. LARSON, pro se
3700 Lockport RoadWheatfield, NY 14132
(716) [email protected]
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 23/27
23
ROBERT ELLISON, pro se
109 AnnBoonville, NY(315) 778-3165
JOANNE WILDER, pro se8457 Chinkapin Circle
Cicero, NY 13039(315) 247-2256
MARY ANN BUERMAN, pro se5564 Kathan Road
Brewenton, NY 13029(315) 676-4518
TANYA PARROW, pro se4031 E. Lzngerwood Lane
Syracuse, NY 13215(315) 488-7821
GEORGE G. RADFORD, pro se19 The Orchard
Fayetteville, NY 13066(315) 632-4120
PATRICIA M. RADFORD, pro se19 The Orchard
Fayetteville, NY 13066(315) 632-4120
ANTOINETTE M. BLACK, pro se1320 Le Moyne Ave
Syracuse, NY 13208(315) 463-5998
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 24/27
24
HARVEY E. DAVIES, pro se
160 Manor DriveSyracuse, NY 13214(315) 446-8874
JAMES D. DOOHER, pro se1220 Vilton Drive
Dewitt, NY 12214(315) 446-6168
KEVIN T. COTE, pro se17 Little Brooklyn Rd.
Warwick, NY 10990(845) 987-0084
ROBERT SPENCER, pro se828 Holly Drive, #D45
Fulton, NY 13609(315) 887-5024
MYRNA A. THAYNE, pro se2389 State Highway 205
Mount Vision, NY(607) 432-4117
PRISCILLA TAMARO, pro seP.O. Box 62
Westford, NY 13488(607) 264-8454
GEORGE TAMARO, pro se
P.O. Box 62Westford, NY 13488
(607) 264-8454
DAVE CRAWMER, pro se
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 25/27
25
21 Indian Pipe DriveWynantskill, NY 12198
(518) [email protected]
EDWARD M. STEHLIN, pro se166 Wright StreetStaten Island, NY
(917) [email protected]
MARY ANN PENNELL, pro se
123 Call Hollow RoadPomona, NY 10970
(845) 354-0557
NANCY W. FOSTER, pro se4 Butternut Ridge
Massena, NY 13662(315) 764-1289
DALTON P. FOSTER, pro se4 Butternut Ridge
Massena, NY 13662(315) 764-1289
DONALD R. WHITE, pro se21 Garnsey Road
Rexford, NY 12148(518) 399-0684
CHAD H. CURRIN, pro se105 Hetcheltown Road
Glenville, NY 12302(518) 542-7959
WILBUR W. CARD, pro se4610 SR 414
Beaver Dams, NY 14812(607) 962-0308
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 26/27
26
VANESSA PARSONS, pro se
58 Old Country Road #21East Quogue, NY 11942(631) 338-5485
HARVEY KASH, pro se14 C. 2
NDStreet
Huntington Station, NY 11746(631) 470-9600
GARY L. PERRY, pro se
750 Walker Hill Road, pro seWaverly, NY
(607) [email protected]
DENVER L. JONES, pro se
1271 Owego RoadOwego, NY 13827
(607) [email protected]
KATHLEEN C. ELLIOTT, pro se
81 East Main StreetDryden, NY 13053
(607) [email protected]
VIVIAN Y. WADLIN, pro se
38 Bellevue RoadHighland, NY
(845) [email protected]
JUDITH M. WHITMORE, pro se
2458 Ridge RoadQueensbury, NY 12804
JOHN SALVADOR, JR, pro se
7/30/2019 Complaint 11-28-12 6pm
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/complaint-11-28-12-6pm 27/27
27
37 Alexy LaneLake George, NY 12845
(518) 656-3447 [email protected]
ANTHONY FUTIA, JR., pro se
34 Custis AvenueWhite Plains, NY 10603(914) 948-4368
CHRISTOPHER J. ENGLERT, pro se3647 Middle Reservation Rd
Perry, NY 14530(585) 237-6329