connective financing chinese infrastructure projects and...
TRANSCRIPT
Connective FinancingChinese Infrastructure Projects and the Diffusion of Economic
Activity in Developing Countries
Austin Strange (Harvard University)With Richard Bluhm, Axel Dreher, Andreas Fuchs,
Bradley Parks, and Michael Tierney
World Bank ABCDE
June 2019
Motivation
Source: mtega.com
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 2 / 27
Congestion, transport costs and dispersion
Many developing countries have high spatial concentration of activity:
Dar es Salaam home to 8% of the Tanzanian population and 53% ofmanufacturing value-added in 2002–Internal transport costs are veryhigh and isolate secondary cities (Storeygard 2016)
Many African cities congested, crowded and unproductive (WorldBank 2018)
Evidence suggests transport and other connective infrastructuredisperses economic activity in developing countries: e.g. see Straub(2015) on Brazil, Baum-Snow et al. (2017) on China, or Bayes(2017) on Bangladesh
However, infrastructure projects have been underfinanced in recentdecades . . .
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 3 / 27
Official development assistance in the transport sector
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 4 / 27
What’s new?
We investigate effect of Chinese development finance on spatialdistribution of economic activity
Georeferenced data on China’s development projects in the entiredeveloping world
Inequality in light intensity as proxy for distribution of economicactivity
Exploit domestic overcapacity in China as a global project inputsupply shock
Main finding: Chinese government-financed projects help diffuseeconomic activity in developing countries at all levels ofaggregation
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 5 / 27
Should “connective financing” lower spatial inequality?
Infrastructure investments
reduce trade costs and make migration easier (Krugman 1996)
lower inter-region price differences/volatility (Cirera and Arndt 2008)
lower cost of firm entry (Shiferaw et al. 2015, Ghani et al. 2016)
lower cost of inputs/consumption (Bayes 2007, Parada 2016)
raise land values (Donaldson and Hornbeck 2016)
Transport investments in one region can spill over into others and haveunintended consequences (e.g., more labor moving from poor region)
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 6 / 27
Spatial inequality and development finance
Western aid mostly unsuccessful in targeting inequality (Briggs 2017)
Mixed signals from Chinese-financed projects...
I Subject to regional and ethnic favoritism in Africa (Dreher et al. 2019)I Worsen perceptions of local corruption (Isaksson and Kotsadam 2018)I Promote short-to-medium run economic development (Dreher et al.
2017, 2019)
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 7 / 27
Chinese development finance polarizes observers
China as a pernicious partner
“rogue aid” (Naim 2009)
“debt trap diplomacy” (Chellaney 2017)
“white elephants” (Australian Dev. Minister 2018)
China as a promising alternative
“no strings attached” (State Council 2011)
“record time” (Senegalese President 2008)
“connectivity is the foundation of development” (Xi Jinping 2017)
China focuses on transport and economic infrastructure, replacingand surpassing investments of Western donors in this sector
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 8 / 27
Chinese financing in the 1970s: TAZARA railway
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 9 / 27
Chinese financing today: Addis Ababa light rail
AidData record.
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 10 / 27
AidData’s China data
AidData first released data on Chinese Official Finance in 2013 for Africaand in 2017 for the developing world
Tracking Underreported Financial Flows (TUFF) method based onpublicly available information (3.05 sources/project)
I documents from Chinese ministries and embassiesI aid and debt info management systems in recipient countriesI case study and field research by scholars and NGOsI English, Chinese and local-language news reports
Systematic, transparent and replicable
Categorization scheme for Chinese peculiarities
Projects tracked from pledge to completion
Accessible in China and for users worldwide
Flows Status Sectors
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 11 / 27
AidData’s China data
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 12 / 27
Addis Ababa light rail on china.aiddata.org
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 13 / 27
Project locations and values (2000–2014)
Geocoded all projects that reached the implementation stage
3,485 projects worth 2014 US$273.6b at 6,184 sites in 138 countries
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 14 / 27
Measuring spatial inequalities
Dispersion in nighttime light intensity (Henderson et al. 2018)
Divide the entire world into a grid of 6 arc minute cells and intersectthe grid with the global administrative boundaries
Compute the sum of light (si ), the land area in km2 (ai ), and thelight intensity in the cell (xi = si/ai )
Calculate the spatial Gini coefficient in region r as
Gr =
∑i w
ni
∑nj wj |xi − xj |
2∑n
i wi∑n
i wixi
where wi = ai/∑n
i ai is an area weight and n is the number of lit cells
The index captures the overall dispersion of economic activity, i.e. theproduct of the distributions of population and light per capita
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 15 / 27
Changes in spatial inequalities (2000–2013)
First-order regions (ADM1) Observations Mean St. dev. Min Max
Gini of light per km2, within 29881 0.51 0.18 0.00 0.85Gini of light per km2, between 23744 0.45 0.20 0.00 0.98
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 16 / 27
How to identify the effects of Chinese projects?
China needs lots of material to build all its homes, trains andtunnels. Even so, it produces more than it can use.(Economist, 09/09/17)
[Mr Xi] hopes to create new markets for Chinese companies, suchas high-speed rail firms, and to export some of his country’svast excess capacity in cement, steel and other metals.(Economist, 05/17/17)
Nearby, along a newly laid road, another Chinese factory wasproviding cement for tunnel construction. Nearly everything forthe Laos project is made in China. Almost all the labor force isChinese. (NY Times, 05/13/17)
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 17 / 27
Identification strategy I
Bartik-style supply-shock instrument (similar to Autor et al. 2013)
Variation across time: Proxy for potential development project inputsI China’s production of steel, cement, iron, timber, glass, and aluminum
Variation across regions: Exposure to Chinese development projectsI “Probability of receiving a development project”, i.e.
pir =∑2014
2000 I(ChnProjectirt > 0)/15
Similar to a differences-in-differences setting
Exploit differential effect of Chinese project inputs on aid toregions with high compared to low exposure to Chinesedevelopment projects
Works if differences in spatial inequality in high (low) exposureregions is not affected differently by China’s input production
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 18 / 27
Variation in overcapacity
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 19 / 27
Identification strategy II
Equation(s) of interest:Girt = βChnProjecti ,t−2 + x′irtγ + µir + λit + εirt (1)
ChnProjecti ,t−2 = δ(Ft−3 × ρir ) + x′irtπ + ωir + φi ,t−2 + υir ,t−2 (2)
ChnProjecti ,t−2 is a dummy for a Chinese project (one for 3 yrs afterassumed “completion”)
Ft−3 is the principal factor of the time series of six project inputs
ρir is the probability of receiving Chinese projects
xirt is a vector of controls (e.g., population density)
ωir and µir are region FEs (removing ρir )
φi ,t−2 and λit are country-year FEs (partialling out all commontrends)
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 20 / 27
OLS and reduced form (ADM1 and ADM2)
First-order admin Second-order adminAll Trans. All Trans.(1) (2) (3) (4)
Panel a) OLS estimates
ChnProjecti,t−2 -0.0004 -0.0080** -0.0031* -0.0030(0.0019) (0.0035) (0.0018) (0.0034)
Panel b) Reduced-form estimates
Ft−3 × ρir -0.0215*** -0.0646*** -0.0290*** -0.0584**(0.0066) (0.0176) (0.0062) (0.0249)
Observations 29,810 29,810 356,046 356,046Regions 2,668 2,668 32,603 32,603Countries 158 158 129 129
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 21 / 27
2SLS and first stages (ADM1 and ADM2)
First-order admin Second-order adminAll Trans. All Trans.(1) (2) (3) (4)
Panel a) IV estimates
ChnProjecti,t−2 -0.0541*** -0.0491*** -0.0436*** -0.0397**(0.0186) (0.0123) (0.0096) (0.0177)
Panel b) First-stage estimates
Ft−3 × ρir 0.3967*** 1.3143*** 0.6643*** 1.4710***(0.0801) (0.1519) (0.0762) (0.2438)
Kleibergen-Paap F-stat 24.51 74.87 75.92 36.40Observations 29,810 29,810 356,046 356,046Regions 2,668 2,668 32,603 32,603Countries 158 158 129 129
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 22 / 27
Unpacking concentration (2SLS at ADM1 and AMD2)
Non-zero Quintile sharesshare 0-20% 20-40% 40-60% 60-80% 80-100%(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)
Panel a) First-order admin
ChnProji,t−2 0.0390** 0.0086** 0.0093* 0.0156** 0.0134 -0.0469**(0.0185) (0.0042) (0.0053) (0.0068) (0.0117) (0.0201)
Kleibergen-Paap F-stat 30.05 20.68 20.68 20.68 20.68 20.68Regions 2760 2424 2424 2424 2424 2424Countries 159 146 146 146 146 146
Panel b) Second-order admin
ChnProji,t−2 0.0258** 0.0048 0.0074** 0.0057 0.0195** -0.0374***(0.0109) (0.0030) (0.0036) (0.0056) (0.0078) (0.0132)
Kleibergen-Paap F-stat 99.64 49.61 49.61 49.61 49.61 49.61Regions 35544 23720 23720 23720 23720 23720Countries 129 123 123 123 123 123
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 23 / 27
Extensions
Diffusion of activity or increasing inequality?
Small and mostly negative effects on (interpolated) population,opposite but unstable effect on light per capita Regressions
Similar effects for between regional inequalities Regressions
Does not unambiguously imply that inequality in wages andproductivity is rising, could be an artifact of the data
Comparison with geocoded World Bank development finance
Use IBRD’s equity-to-loans ratio as an IV for geocoded WB projectlocations
Find no comparable effects of WB projects (overall or transportsector) but instrument is weak and LATE differs Regressions
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 24 / 27
Robustness
Identification
Effects similar to main results with different IVs: detrended factors,just steel, detrended steel, iron, cement etc. Regressions
Parallel trends assumption is satisfied: instrument does not affectsome subgroups more than others Plots
Timing and world regions
Meaningful effects when using different dummies (1 to 5 yrs)Regressions
Regional decomposition: effects driven by Africa, Asia, and EuropeRegressions
Financial amounts
Qualitatively similar results where amounts are known Regressions
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 25 / 27
Conclusion
We find that Chinese state-financed projects abroad reducespatial inequalities in economic activity within and betweenregions
Effects are sizable: “connective infrastructure” produces significantpositive spillovers
Our LATE is driven by big infrastructure projects requiring largeamounts of physical inputs
Broader impact of Chinese projects on wages and social structure is amore complex question
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 26 / 27
Projects and values
Go back.
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 28 / 27
Project status
Go back.Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 29 / 27
Project sectors
Go back.Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 30 / 27
Alternate concentration measures (ADM1 and ADM2)
Unweighted WeightedGini Bias-corr. Gini Theil CV(1) (2) (3) (4)
Panel a) First-order admin
ChnProji,t−2 -0.0497*** -0.0478** -0.0753** -0.1164*(0.0166) (0.0204) (0.0370) (0.0598)
Kleibergen-Paap F-stat 24.51 17.19 24.51 24.51Regions 2668 2132 2668 2668Countries 158 130 158 158
Panel b) Second-order admin
ChnProji,t−2 -0.0513*** -0.0387*** -0.0335** -0.0719***(0.0108) (0.0124) (0.0145) (0.0218)
Kleibergen-Paap F-stat 75.92 57.86 75.92 75.93Regions 32603 12712 32603 32603Countries 129 105 129 129
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 31 / 27
Population and per capita Ginis (ADM1 and ADM2)
First-order admin Second-order adminAll Trans. All Trans.(1) (2) (3) (4)
Panel a) Population Gini
ChnProjecti,t−2 -0.0114* 0.0012 -0.0001 0.0054(0.0061) (0.0048) (0.0040) (0.0067)
Panel b) Per-capita Gini
ChnProjecti,t−2 0.0545** 0.0346 0.0343*** 0.0096(0.0248) (0.0217) (0.0101) (0.0139)
Kleibergen-Paap F-stat 23.82 73.90 73.81 35.37Observations 29,436 29,436 346,029 346,029Regions 2,636 2,636 31,720 31,720Countries 157 157 129 129
Go back.
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 32 / 27
Different instruments
Factors Det. Factors Steel Det. Steel(1) (2) (3) (4)
Panel a) IV estimates – first-order regions
ChnProjecti,t−2 -0.0541*** -0.1375* -0.0457*** -0.0295*(0.0186) (0.0769) (0.0165) (0.0175)
Kleibergen-Paap F-stat 24.51 4.35 27.86 23.17Observations 29,810 29,810 29,810 29,810
Panel b) IV estimates – second-order regions
ChnProjecti,t−2 -0.0436*** -0.0608*** -0.0372*** -0.0156(0.0096) (0.0183) (0.0091) (0.0111)
Kleibergen-Paap F-stat 75.92 25.86 83.58 58.68Observations 356,046 356,046 356,046 356,046
Go back.
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 33 / 27
Between regional inequalities (ADM1 and ADM2)
Between second-order Between first-orderAll Trans. All Trans.(1) (2) (3) (4)
Panel a) IV estimates – light Gini
ChnProjecti,t−2 -0.0589** -0.0472 -0.1264 -0.0517(0.0262) (0.0299) (0.1710) (0.0353)
Panel b) IV estimates – per capita Gini
ChnProjecti,t−2 0.0618** 0.0489** -0.5140 -0.0555(0.0273) (0.0229) (0.4426) (0.0464)
Kleibergen-Paap F-stat 17.18 63.57 1.54 21.75Observations 23,510 23,510 1,772 1,784Regions 2,129 2,129 – –Countries 126 126 157 158
Go back.
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 34 / 27
World Bank projects
First-order admin Second-order adminAll Trans. All Trans.(1) (2) (3) (4)
Panel a) IV estimates
WBProjecti,t−2 -0.0756 -0.0293 -0.0430 -0.0641(0.0566) (0.0192) (0.0313) (0.0658)
Panel b) First-stage estimates
IBRDt−3 × ρir 0.0278*** 0.0672*** 0.0166 0.0478(0.0087) (0.0190) (0.0154) (0.0428)
Kleibergen-Paap F-stat 3.09 12.58 3.66 1.25Observations 29,915 29,915 356,382 356,382
Go back.
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 35 / 27
Parallel trends
Go back.
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 36 / 27
Short and medium-term effects
Project dummy one for X years . . .One Two Three Four Five(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Panel a) IV estimates – first-order regions
ChnProjecti,t−2 -0.0802*** -0.0610*** -0.0541*** -0.0515*** -0.0503***(0.0263) (0.0202) (0.0186) (0.0181) (0.0182)
Observations 29,810 29,810 29,810 29,810 29,810Kleibergen-Paap F-stat 41.17 27.16 24.51 22.00 20.48
Panel b) IV estimates – second-order regions
ChnProjecti,t−2 -0.0892*** -0.0550*** -0.0436*** -0.0374*** -0.0337***(0.0207) (0.0123) (0.0096) (0.0082) (0.0075)
Kleibergen-Paap F-stat 45.39 65.55 75.92 82.76 83.75Observations 356,046 356,046 356,046 356,046 356,046
Go back.
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 37 / 27
Regional decomposition
ContinentAfrica Americas Asia Europe
(1) (2) (3) (4)
Panel a) IV estimates – first-order regions
ChnProjecti,t−2 -0.0924** -0.0069 -0.0442 -0.0607**(0.0348) (0.0083) (0.0439) (0.0260)
Kleibergen-Paap F-stat 8.78 38.02 6.21 20.31Observations 9,019 5,976 9,222 4,625
Panel b) IV estimates – second-order regions
ChnProjecti,t−2 -0.0479*** -0.0114 -0.0553** -0.0810***(0.0130) (0.0140) (0.0227) (0.0205)
Kleibergen-Paap F-stat 55.20 25.77 17.36 14.26Observations 55,811 135,804 84,137 79,005
Go back.
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 38 / 27
Amounts and completed projects
Log US$ amounts Completed dummyAll Trans. All Trans.(1) (2) (3) (4)
Panel a) IV estimates – first-order regions
ChnProjecti,t−2 -0.0085*** -0.0068*** -0.0542*** -0.0816***(0.0029) (0.0018) (0.0182) (0.0241)
Kleibergen-Paap F-stat 16.20 45.20 27.46 44.47Observations 29,810 29,810 29,810 29,810
Panel b) IV estimates – second-order regions
ChnProjecti,t−2 -0.0088*** -0.0056** -0.0548*** -0.0671**(0.0023) (0.0026) (0.0121) (0.0314)
Kleibergen-Paap F-stat 23.19 16.58 63.21 36.11Observations 356,046 356,046 356,046 356,046
Go back.
Austin Strange Connective Financing June 2019 39 / 27