costing for decision making_teupdate_final
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
1/102
ProfessionalDevelopment
Programme on
Enriching
KnowledgeoftheBusiness,AccountingandFinancialStudies
(BAFS)Curriculum
Course Title: Cost Accounting for Decision Making
1
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
2/102
LearningOutcomes
Uponcompletionofthiscourse,teacherparticipantsshould
beableto:
applycostvolumeprofitanalysistechniquestoascertaintheinterrelationshipsamongcosts,sellingprice,unitssold,
breakevenpoint,targetprofitandmarginofsafety;
statetheassumptionsandlimitationsofcostvolumeprofitanalysis;
identifyanddifferentiaterelevantcostsandirrelevantcostsindifferentbusinessscenarios;and
makerecommendationtoshorttermbusinessdecisions.
2
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
3/102
Syllabusin
HKDSE
Examination
Identify thenatureofvariouscostitemsandtheir
relevanceto
decision
making:
sunk
costs,
incremental
costsandopportunitycosts.
Apply costingconceptsandtechniquesinbusiness
decisions,e.g.
hire,
make
or
buy,
accept
or
reject
an
orderataspecialprice,retainorreplaceequipment,
sellorprocessfurther andeliminateorretainan
unprofitablesegment.
Conductcostvolumeprofitanalysistoassesstheeffectsofchangesincosts,sellingpriceandunitssoldonthe
breakevenpointandtargetprofit.
Identify thenatureofvariouscostitemsandtheir
relevanceto
decision
making:
sunk
costs,
incremental
costsandopportunitycosts.
Apply costingconceptsandtechniquesinbusiness
decisions,
e.g.
hire,
make
or
buy,
accept
or
reject
an
orderataspecialprice,retainorreplaceequipment,
sellorprocessfurther andeliminateorretainan
unprofitablesegment.
Conductcostvolumeprofitanalysistoassesstheeffectsofchangesincosts,sellingpriceandunitssoldonthe
breakevenpointandtargetprofit.
3
Whatifanalysis
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
4/102
Contents Breakevenpoint
Salelevelrequiredtoachievetargetprofit
Marginof
safety
Whatifanalysis(Illustrations1&2)
Salesmix(Illustration3&4)
Relevantcosts
vs.
irrelevant
costs
(Illustrations
5&
6)
Acceptorrejectanorder(Illustration7)
Hiredecision(Illustration8)
Make
or
buy
(illustration
9) Retainorreplaceequipment(Illustration10)
Sellorprocessfurther(Illustration11)
Eliminateorretainanunprofitablesegment(Illustration12)
4
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
5/102
PriorKnowledge
Required
5
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
6/102
CostVolume
Profit
Analysis
(CVPAnalysis)
(BreakevenAnalysis)
6
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
7/102
Whatis
it?
Breakeven=noprofit,orloss,thatis,
TotalSales
Revenue
=Total
Costs
(Variable
Costs
+
FixedCosts)
TotalContribution=FixedCosts
Itstudieshowcost,revenueandproduction/salesvolumeaffectprofit
Twoapproaches:
ByFormula
ByGraph7
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
8/102
BreakevenPoint
By
Formula
8
or
where
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
9/102
SalesLevel
Required
to
Achieve
TargetProfit
9
or
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
10/102
Marginof
Safety
By
Formula
10
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
11/102
Whatif
Analysis
Itstudieshowtheresultwillchangeifthe
originaldata
changes.
Itanswersquestionssuchas:
What
will
be
the
breakeven
point
if
variable
cost
perunitincreasedby5%?
What will be the profit if sales volume increases
by
5%?
11
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
12/102
Effectsof
Changes
in
Costs,
Selling
Price
ontheBreakevenPoint
12
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
13/102
Illustration1
EffectofChangesinCostsonBreakevenPoint
Amanufacturingcompanyproducesandsells
asingleproductasfollows:
Thefixedcostperannumisestimatedtobe
$600,000.
13
Sellingpriceperunit $250
Variablecosts
per
unit $150
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
14/102
Illustration
1EffectofChangesinCostsonBreakevenPoint
Thesalesmanagerwouldliketoproposea
changeto
pay
asalesman
on
commission
basisof$10perunitsoldratherthanonfixed
monthlysalariesof$8,000permonth.
Whatwouldbethebreakevenpointsinunitsforthesituationsbeforeandafterthe
change?
14
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
15/102
Illustration1
Effectof
Changes
in
Costs
on
Breakeven
Point
Breakevenpointbeforechange:
$600,000/($250$150)
=6,000units
Breakevenpointafterchange:
($600,000
$8,000
x
12)/[$250
($150+$10)]=5,600units
15
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
16/102
Illustration1
Effectof
Changes
in
Costs
on
Breakeven
Point
Itdoesnotmeanthattheproposedscenario
isbetter
than
the
original
scenario
because
of
lowerbreakevenpoint.
Italldependsontheactualsalesvolume.
Forexample,ifthesalesvolumeis10,000units,theprofitintheoriginalscenariowillbe
$400,000(10,000
x$100
$600,000)
while
thatinproposedscenarioitwillonlybe
$396,000(10,000x$90 $504,000).
16
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
17/102
Effectsof
Changes
in
Costs,
Selling
Price
andUnitsSoldontheProfit
17
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
18/102
Illustration2
Effectsof
Changes
in
Costs
and
Units
Sold
on
the
Profit
Acompanyproducesandsellsasingle
product.In
the
current
year,
20,000
units
will
besoldat$50each.Thefixedcostis$300,000
andtheprofitis$100,000.
Thecompanyisconsideringspending$30,000tolaunchapromotioncampaigninthenext
yearto
boost
the
sales
volume
by
5%.
Thesellingpriceandotherfixedoverheadwillkeepconstantoverthetwoyears.
18
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
19/102
Illustration2
Effectsof
Changes
in
Costs
and
Units
Sold
on
the
Profit
Required
1)Forthe
current
year,
calculate:
a) thebreakevenpoint inunits,and
b) themargin
of
safety
in
%
2)Preparetheincomestatementsforboth
currentyearandnextyear.
3)Explainwhetherthepromotioncampaign
shouldbelaunched.
19
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
20/102
Illustration2
Effectsof
Changes
in
Costs
and
Units
Sold
on
the
Profit
1) a) Totalcontribution
=$300,000
+$100,000
=$400,000
Contributionperunit=$400,000/20,000=$20
Breakevenpointinunits=$300,000/$20=15,000units
b) Marginof
safety
in
%
=(20,000
15,000)/20,000
x100%
=25%
20
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
21/102
Illustration2
Effectsof
Changes
in
Costs
and
Units
Sold
on
the
Profit
ContributionIncome
Statements
CurrentYear NextYear
$ $
Sales($50perunit) 1,000,000 1,050,000
Variablecost($30perunit) 600,000 630,000
Totalcontribution 400,000 420,000
Less:Fixedcost 300,000 330,000
Net
Profit 100,000 90,000
21
2)
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
22/102
Illustration
2EffectsofChangesinCostsandUnitsSoldontheProfit
3) Thepromotion
should
not
be
launched
as
itwouldlowerthenetprofit.
22
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
23/102
Activity1
IllustrativeIntegratedQuestion
CostProfit
Volume
Analysis
23
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
24/102
Question(1)
Amanufacturingcompanyproducesandsellsa
singleproduct.
The
accountant
has
just
prepared
the
companysbudgetforthecomingyear.The
budgeteddataisextractedasfollows:
24
Salesvolume 90,000
units
Fixedcosts $440,000
Variablecostsperunit $10
Loss $80,000
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
25/102
Question(2)
Thedirectorsaredissatisfiedwiththebudgetedlossandsuggestproposalsforimprovement.
DirectorAsuggestsspending$50,000onadvertisingtoincreasesales.Hewishestoachieveatargetprofit
of
$100,000. DirectorBsuggestsreducingsellingpriceby$1per
unittoincreasesales.Heexpectsthatthesales
volume
would
increase
by
80%. DirectorCsuggestsbuyingamoreefficientmachine
whichwouldreduceunitvariablecostsby50%.The
usefullife
of
the
machine
is
1year.25
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
26/102
Question(3)
Required
a) ForDirector
As
proposal,
what
is
the
percentage
increaseinsalesrequiredtoachievethetarget
profit?
b)ForDirector
Bs
proposal,
what
would
be
the
profit
orloss?
c) ForDirectorCsproposal,whatwouldbethe
maximumcost
of
the
machine
for
breakeven?
26
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
27/102
Answers
a) 50%b) Profit$46,000
c) $370,000
27
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
28/102
ByGraph
Breakeven
Chart
28
0
Activity (Sales units)
Sales revenue/Costs
Totalcos
tsVariablecosts
Fixedcosts
Profit
Loss
ProfitSales
Fixedcosts
Break-evenpoint
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
29/102
ByGroup
Contribution
Graph
29
0
Totalcos
ts
Profit
Loss
ProfitSal
es
Co
ntribution
Activity (Sales units)
Sales revenue/Costs
Break-even point
Fixedcosts
Variab
lecosts
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
30/102
ByGraph
Profit
Volume
Graph
30
0
Profit / Loss ($000)
Loss
Profit
Break-evenpoint
Fixed
costs
Profit
Contributio
n
Activity(Salesunits)
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
31/102
BreakevenPoint
for
Sales
Mix
Whenacompany
produces
multiple
products,
it
isassumedthattherelativecombinationofthe
productssold(salesunits)willbeconstant.
31
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
32/102
Illustration3
BreakevenPoint
for
Sales
Mix
Product XandProductYaresoldinsalesmixof3:1.
Details
about
the
two
products
are:
The fixedcostis$30,000.
Whatisthebreakevenpointinunitsanddollars?
32
ProductX ProductY
Sellingpriceperunit $5 $10
Variablecostperunit $4 $3
Unitcontribution $1 $7
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
33/102
Illustration3
BreakevenPoint
for
Sales
Mix
Since1standardbatchconsistsof3unitsofproductX
and1unit
of
product
Y,
the
breakeven
point
is
9,000
unitsofproductXand3,000unitsofproductY.
33
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
34/102
Breakevenpoint(in$)
34
Sales $
ProductX:9,000x$5 45,000
ProductY:
3,000
x$10 30,000
Breakevenpoint 75,000
Illustration3
BreakevenPoint
for
Sales
Mix
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
35/102
Alternatively,thebreakevenpointin$canbe
calculatedby
using
the
contribution
margin
ratio:
Contributioninstandardsalesmix
=$1x3+$7x1=$10
Sellingpriceinstandardsalesmix
=$5
x3=$10
x1=$25
35
Illustration3
BreakevenPoint
for
Sales
Mix
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
36/102
Hence,thecontributionmarginratiois
Thebreakeven
point
in
$is
36
Illustration3
BreakevenPoint
for
Sales
Mix
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
37/102
Continuewithillustration3.Asthemarketing
managerobserves
that
Product
Yis
more
profitable,heisconsideringspending
additional$5,000onmarketingcampaignto
boostthe
sales
of
Product
Y.
It
is
estimated
thatsalesvolumeofProductYcanbe
increasedby1/3.
HowmanyunitsofProductXshouldbesoldatleastinordertoachievebreakeven?
37
Illustration4
Effectof
Change
in
Expenses
on
Sales
Mix
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
38/102
$
Originalfixed
cost 30,000
Marketingexpenses 5,000
ContributionfromProductY($7x3,000x4/3) (28,000)
Uncoveredfixedcost 7,000
38
Illustration4
Effectof
Change
in
Expenses
on
Sales
Mix
Hence, number of units of Product X to be sold forachieving breakeven =
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
39/102
Assumptionsof
CV
PAnalysis
Sellingpriceperunitandvariablecostperunitare
constant.
Fixedcostperperiodisconstant.
Productionunits
equal
sales
units.
Asingleproductissoldorthesalesmix isconstant.
39
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
40/102
Limitationsof
CV
P
Analysis
Unitsellingpricemayvary,e.g.duetobulk
discountsoffered
to
customers.
Unitvariablecostsperunitmayvary,e.g.due
to
economies
of
scales
or
overtime
premium
etc.
Fixedcostsmaychangeatdifferentlevelsof
activity,e.g.
step
costs,
i.e.
in
different
relevantranges,thefixedcostwillvary.
40
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
41/102
CostClassification&Items
41
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
42/102
42
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
43/102
RelevantCost
vs.
Irrelevant
Cost
RelevantCostRelevantCost
Costthat
will
be
changedbya
decision
Costthat
will
be
changedbya
decision
IrrelevantCostIrrelevantCost
Costthat
will
not
be
changedbya
decision
Costthat
will
not
be
changedbya
decision
43
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
44/102
Relevant
CostsIncrementalCostIncrementalCost
Additionalcost
which
willbespecifically
incurredbecauseofa
decision
Additionalcost
which
willbespecifically
incurredbecauseofa
decision
OpportunityCostOpportunityCost
Benefitwhich
will
be
forgonewhenthe
choiceofonecourseof
actionrequires
an
alternativecourseof
action
be
given
up
Benefitwhich
will
be
forgonewhenthe
choiceofonecourseof
actionrequires
an
alternativecourseof
action
be
given
up
44
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
45/102
IrrelevantCost
SunkCostSunkCost
Costof
aresource
alreadyacquiredand
areunaffectedby
choicebetween
alternatives
Costof
aresource
alreadyacquiredand
areunaffectedby
choicebetween
alternatives
CommittedCostCommittedCost
Costwhich
has
been
committedalthoughit
hasnotbeenincurred
orpaid.
Costwhich
has
been
committedalthoughit
hasnotbeenincurred
orpaid.
45
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
46/102
MaterialCost:
HowRelevant?
46
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
47/102
Illustration5
MaterialCost:
How
Relevant?
Ajobrequires1,000unitsofmaterialXwhich
havealready
been
in
the
inventory.
Theywerepurchasedatacostof$8perunit.
Thematerialscanbesoldatanetrealizablevalueof$12perunit.
Itcanalsobeusedinanotherjobassubstitute
for1,500
units
of
material
Yof
which
the
currentpurchasingpriceis$10.
47
ll
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
48/102
Illustration5
RelevantCost
for
Material
X
48
Analysis:TheoriginalpurchasepriceofmaterialXis
irrelevantsinceitisa
sunkcost
Theopportunity
cost
wouldbethehigherof
NRVorCostingSavings,
i.e.$15,000
Therefore,the
relevant
costofmaterialXis
$15,000
Analysis:TheoriginalpurchasepriceofmaterialXis
irrelevantsinceitisa
sunkcost
Theopportunity
cost
wouldbethehigherof
NRVorCostingSavings,
i.e.$15,000
Therefore,the
relevant
costofmaterialXis
$15,000
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
49/102
Labour Cost:
HowRelevant?
49
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
50/102
Illustration6
Labour Cost:HowRelevant?
A company has been offered a special order
whichrequires1,000directskilled labour hoursat $400 per hour. Because of full capacity and
limited
supply,
the
direct
skilled
labour hourshavetobedivertedfromexistingproductionof
500unitsofProductXwhichgivescontribution
of$300
per
unit.
50
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
51/102
Illustration6
Labour Cost:HowRelevant?
Relevant
Costs
forDirect
Labour$
Incremental
Cost
($400
x
1,000) 400,000ContributionLost($300x500) 150,000
550,000
51
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
52/102
ShortTermBusinessDecisions
52
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
53/102
FactorstoConsiderinBusiness
DecisionMaking
Quantitativefactors:
cost
vs.
benefit
analysis
inmonetaryterms.
Qualitative
factors:
social
responsibility,
corporategoodwill,employeemoraleetc.
53
Concentratethisinthiscourse
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
54/102
54
Acceptor
Reject
anOrderata
SpecialPrice
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
55/102
55
Acceptor
Reject
anOrderata
SpecialPrice
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
56/102
56
AcceptorRejectanOrderata
SpecialPrice
Illustration7
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
57/102
Accept
or
Reject
an
Order
at
a
Special
PriceAfirmcurrentlymakes50,000unitsofproductper
annumandsellsat$30each.Theoperating
statementis
as
follows:
57
$
Sales(50,000x$30) 1,500,000
Less: Materials (500,000)
Labour (680,000)
Contribution 320,000Less:FixedCosts (200,000)
NetProfit 120,000
Illustration 7
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
58/102
Illustration7
Acceptor
Reject
an
Order
at
aSpecial
Price
Acustomeroffersanorderfor10,000unitsat
selling
price
of
$28
each.Iftheorderisaccepted:
Fixedcostwouldincreaseto$250,000.
Extralabour would
be
required
at
overtime
premiumof20%.
4%
discount
would
be
obtained
for
all
materials.
58
Illustration 7
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
59/102
Illustration7
Acceptor
Reject
an
Order
at
aSpecial
Price
CostBenefitAnalysisforAccepting $
IncrementalBenefits
Increasein
sales
revenue
(10,000
x$28) 280,000
Savingsinmaterialcostforexistingproduction(500,000x4%) 20,000
300,000
Incremental Costs
Materialcostforadditionalproduction($500,000/50,000x10,000x96%) 96,000
Labour costforadditionalproduction($680,000/50,000x10,000x120%) 163,200
Increasein
fixed
cost
($250,000
$200,000) 50,000
309,200
Decreaseinnetprofit 9,20059
Illustration 7
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
60/102
Illustration7
Acceptor
Reject
an
Oder
at
aSpecial
Price
Conclusion:
As
the
incremental
benefit
is
less
thantheincrementcost,theordershouldbe
rejected.
60
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
61/102
61
HireorNotHire
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
62/102
62
HireorNotHire
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
63/102
63
HireorNotHire
Illustration8
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
64/102
Hireor
Not
Hire
Acompanycurrentlyproduced1,000unitsof
product
X
per
month
at
unit
variable
costs
of
$50.
ProductXwassoldat$120perunit.
Thecompany
is
considering
hiring
an
additionalmachinewhichcanreducetheunit
variable
costs
to
$48
and
increase
production
by20%.
Themonthlyhirechargeis$200,000.64
Illustration8
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
65/102
Hireor
Not
Hire
CostBenefitAnalysisforHiring $
Savingsinvariablecostsforexistingproduction
[($50$48)
x1,000] 2,000
Increaseincontributionfromadditionalproduction
[($120$48)x(1,000x20%)] 14,400
Increasein
contribution 16,400
Less:Hirecharge 20,000
Decreaseinprofit 3,600
65
Illustration 8
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
66/102
Illustration8
Hireor
Not
Hire
Conclusion:
Since
hiring
would
lead
to
a
decreaseinprofit,itshouldnotbehired.
66
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
67/102
67
MakeorBuy
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
68/102
68
MakeorBuy
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
69/102
69
MakeorBuy
Illustration9
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
70/102
Makeor
Buy
Acompanyrequires800unitsofcomponentXspecificallyforasingleorderandisconsideringmakingthecomponents
itselfor
buying
them
from
outside
supplier.
Inmaking,itrequires$3,000materials,100labour hours athourlyrateof$28tobedivertedfromotherteamswhichare
idle
but
cannot
be
fired
because
of
the
employment
contract. Ifthecompanymakesthecomponentsitself,theexisting
productionofproductYwillfallby100units.ProductY
providesacontributionof$8perunit.
Thecomponentsaresoldatamultipleof1,000unitsat$4,500per1,000units.Anyexcessofthedemandcanbere
soldatapriceof$1perunit.
70
Illustration9
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
71/102
Makeor
Buy
RelevantCostforMaking $
Materials
3,000Contributionlost ($8x100) 800
TotalRelevant
Cost 3,800
71
Since the labour is idle, the cost is irrelevant.
Illustration9
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
72/102
Makeor
Buy
RelevantCostforBuying $
Purchasecost 4,500
Resaleofexcess[(1,000800)x$1] (200)
TotalNet
Relevant
Cost 4,300
72
Illustration9
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
73/102
Makeor
Buy
Conclusion:Since
the
relevant
cost
for
making
islowerthanthatofbuying,thecomponents
shouldbemade.
73
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
74/102
74
Retainor
Replace
Equipment
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
75/102
75
Retainor
Replace
Equipment
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
76/102
76
Retainor
Replace
Equipment
Illustration10
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
77/102
Retainor
Replace
Equipment
Acompanyisconsideringreplacinganoldmachine
withanewone.Detailsabouttheoldmachineandthe
newmachine
are
as
follows:
77
OldMachine
OriginalCost $1,000,000
Depreciatedamount $800,000
Remainingusefullife 3years
Currentdisposal
value $10,000
Disposalvalueafter3years Nil
Illustration10
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
78/102
Retainor
Replace
Equipment
NewMachine
Currentpurchase
cost $300,000
Usefullife 3years
Disposalvalue
after
3years $60,000
78
The new machine can reduce operating costs
by $80,000 per annum.
Illustration10
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
79/102
Retainor
Replace
Equipment
CostBenefitAnalysisforReplacement $
Incremental
Benefits
of
ReplacementTotal costssaving(3x$80,000) 240,000
Disposalvalueofnewmachineafter3years 60,000
Currentdisposal
value
of
old
machine 10,000
310,000
Less: Incremental Costs
Purchasecost
of
new
machine (300,000)
NetIncrementalBenefitsofReplacement 10,000
79
Note: Time value of money is ignored.
Illustration10
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
80/102
Retainor
Replace
Equipment
Conclusion:
Since
replacement
would
make
a
netincrementalbenefit,itshouldbereplaced.
80
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
81/102
81
SellorProcess
Further
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
82/102
82
SellorProcess
Further
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
83/102
83
SellorProcess
Further
Illustration11
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
84/102
Sellor
Process
Further
Acompanyisconsideringwhethertoprocessasemifinishedproductwhichhasbeenproducedattotal
variablecost
of
$60,000
and
can
be
sold
at
$100,000.
Ifthesemifinishedproductisfurtherprocessedtomakeitafinishedproduct,itcanbesoldat
$220,000.The
costs
involved
in
the
process
are
as
follows:
84
$
Directmaterials 150,000
Directlabour 10,000
Overheads 180,000
Illustration11
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
85/102
Sellor
Process
Further
Contracthasbeensignedforthepurchaseofthe$150,000materials.Thematerialsareforspecial
purposeand
cannot
be
used
in
another
alternative.
Ifitisnotused,itcanbesoldat$30,000.
Overheadsinclude$70,000specifictofurtherprocess
and
allocated
general
overheads
of
$110,000.
Thefinishedproductafterthefurtherprocesscanbesoldat$220,000.
85
Illustration11
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
86/102
Sellor
Process
Further
$
IncrementalBenefitsfromFurtherProcessing
Increasein
sales
revenue
($220,000
$100,000) 120,000
RelevantCoststoCompletion
Directmaterials 30,000
Directlabour 10,000
Overheads 70,000
110,000
NetIncrementalBenefits 10,000
86
Illustration11
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
87/102
Sellor
Process
Further
Conclusion:
Since
the
benefit
of
further
processingisgreaterthanthecosts,further
processingisrecommended.
87
Eli i t
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
88/102
88
Eliminate orRetain an
Unprofitable
Segment
Eli i t
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
89/102
89
Eliminate orRetain an
Unprofitable
Segment
Eli i t
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
90/102
90
Eliminate orRetain an
Unprofitable
Segment
Illustration12
Eli i t R t i U fit bl S t
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
91/102
Eliminateor
Retain
an
Unprofitable
Segment
ACompanyhastwodepartmentsproducingproductsX
andYrespectively.Thebudgetedoperatingstatement
forthe
coming
year
is
summarized
as
follows:
Ofthetotalcost70%isvariable,10%isspecificfixed
and20%isgeneralfixed.91
ProductX ProductY
$ $
Sales 60,000 100,000
Less:TotalCost 70,000 80,000
NetProfit
/(Loss) (10,000) 20,000
Illustration12
Eli i t R t i U fit bl S t
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
92/102
Eliminateor
Retain
an
Unprofitable
Segment
ContributionIncomeStatement ProductX ProductY Total
$ $ $
Sales 60,000 100,000 160,000
Less:Variablecost(70%oftotalcost) 49,000 56,000 105,000
Contribution 11,000 46,000 55,000
Less:Specific
fixed
cost
(10%
of
total
cost) 7,000 8,000 15,000
4,000 36,000 40,000
Less:Generalfixedcost(20%of$150,000) 30,000
Netprofit 10,000
92
Illustration12
Eliminate or Retain an Unprofitable Se ment
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
93/102
Eliminateor
Retain
an
Unprofitable
Segment
Conclusion:Sincethedepartmentproducing
productXmakes
contribution,
it
should
be
retained.Ifitiseliminated,theprofitwillbe
only$6,000insteadof$10,000.
93
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
94/102
Activity2
IntegratedIllustrativeQuestion
94
Q ti (1)
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
95/102
Question(1)
Amanufacturingcompanyhasbeenaskedtoquotefor
aoneoffjobwhichwouldrequirethefollowing
resources:
MaterialA
1,000kgwouldberequired.Thematerialisused
regularlyinotherjobs.Currentlythereare4,000kgin
theinventorywhichwaspurchasedat$8perkg.Itcan
besoldat$7ifnotused.Thecurrentreplacementcost
is$9
per
kg.
95
Question (2)
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
96/102
Question(2)
MaterialBorMaterialC
100kgwouldberequired.MaterialBisnotinthe
inventoryand
has
to
be
ordered
at
acurrent
price
of
$15perkg.However,materialCcanbeusedto
substitutematerialB.MaterialCisininventoryandhas
beenpurchased
at
acost
of
$20
per
kg.
It
was
specificallypurchasedforuseinaproductlinewhich
hasnowbeendiscontinued.Itcanbesoldatanet
realizablevalue
of
$8
per
kg.
If
it
is
used
to
substitute
materialB,additionalconversioncostof$6perkghas
tobeincurred.96
Question (3)
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
97/102
Question(3)
Skilledlabour
Directskilledlabour costforthejobwouldbe$40,000.
Skilledlabour is
in
short
supply.
If
the
workers
work
for
thisjob,theycannotworkforanotherjobwhichwould
makeatotalcontributionof$5,000.
97
Question (4)
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
98/102
Question(4)
Unskilledlabour
Unskilledlabour receivingpaytotaling$16,000willbe
transferredfrom
another
department
which
will
recruit
additionallabour atatotalcostof$17,000including
payandrecruitmentcosts.
98
Question (5)
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
99/102
Question(5)
Machinehours
50machinehourswouldberequired.Amachine
currentlylying
idle
will
be
used
in
the
job.
Details
about
themachineryareasfollows:
Ifthe
machine
is
not
used,
the
machine
hours
can
be
hiredfromaleasingcompanywhichcharges$1,000
perhour.
99
Depreciationduetouse $10,000
Currentnetrealizationvalue $240,000
Estimatednetrealizablevalueafteruse $200,000
Question (6)
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
100/102
Question(6)
Required
Calculate
the
minimum
price
that
should
be
quotedforthejob.
100
Answer
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
101/102
AnswerRelevantCosts $
MaterialA 9,000
MaterialC 1,400
Skilled
labour 45,000Unskilledlabour 17,000
Machine
hours 40,000112,400
101
Further Readings
-
7/29/2019 Costing for Decision Making_teupdate_final
102/102
FurtherReadings
Burgstahler,D.,Horngren,C.,Schatzberg,J.,Stratton,W.,&Sundem,
G.(2008).IntroductiontoManagementAccounting,14thed.UpperSaddleRiver:PrenticeHall.Chapters2&56.
Drury,C.(2008).ManagementandCostAccounting,7thed.London:SouthWesternCengage Learning.Chapters89&1112.
Horngren,C.T.,Datar,S.M.,Foster,G.,Raian,M.&Ittner,C.(2009).
CostAccounting:AManagerialEmphasis,13thed.UpperSaddleRiver:PrenticeHall.Chapters3&11.
Lucey,T.(2009).Costing,7thed.London:SouthWesternCengage
Learning.Chapters17&2021.102