crafted learning skills for life primary schools programme report 2014
DESCRIPTION
2014 evaluation report for the Design & Crafts Council of Ireland’s CRAFTed Learning Skills for Life primary schools programme. This report aims to inform all participants, and stakeholders involved in CRAFTed, about the process, development and strategic planning that took place in 2014, including the introduction of CPD workshops for teachers on the CRAFTed Plus programme. At the Design & Crafts Council of Ireland we evaluate all our education programmes, and this report outlines key recommendations for future action and strategic development of the DCCoI’s leading primary schools programme, CRAFTed. This 2014 Evaluation Report for CRAFTed serves to enhance DCCoI’s commitment to enhancing the mainstream education offering for craft and visual arts practice for primary school pupils and teachers.TRANSCRIPT
Primary Schools Programme Evaluation 2014
CRAFTed:Learning Skills For Life
The experience of making
Today the experience of making is more important than ever as we continue to move
in a fast-paced society, one largely dominated by digital and technological interface
experiences. Making takes time, while learning skills and applying skills to tasks involves
a dedication and devotion to materials and processes. The opportunity to discover the
power of making by hand in a school environment is vital to enable young children
flourish in their creativity.
Through exploring craft materials such as felt, clay, willow, wood and new mixed media,
these hands-on making experiences can open up worlds of possibilities for children.
Every child should have the chance to have access to and engage in creative projects
with professional makers. These creative interactions can enable young children to gain
confidence in their own ability to make and shape their environment. As Richard Sennett
writes in The Craftsman, ‘craftsmanship names an enduring, basic impulse, the desire to
do a job well for its own sake’.
The Design & Crafts Council of Ireland’s CRAFTed programme facilitates teachers and
children in exploring their creativity and it introduces the dynamic world of craft, design
and making techniques into the classroom. The class works together as a team on a
creative project while linking in with specific education curriculum strands. CRAFTed
also offers experience in 21st century skills like collaboration, problem solving, and
encourages children to fulfill their own potential as young individuals.
On behalf of the Design & Crafts Council of Ireland, I would like to sincerely thank
Polly Minett, Carrie Lynam and Amanda Walsh for all their work on compiling this report.
Working collaboratively as a team and sharing good practice is an intention of the
CRAFTed programme and of this report. We are delighted to share here the development
and delivery of CRAFTed: Learning Skills for Life in 2014.
Muireann Charleton
Education & Innovation ManagerDesign & Crafts Council of Ireland
Foreword
Two strong features strike me about the CRAFTed programme. Perhaps the most obvious
and striking manifestation of the experience has been the astonishing quality of the work
that the young people have made. I have had the pleasure of seeing at first hand much
of that wonderful work. Equally, I have also felt the excitement and joy both of the young
people and of the teachers and craftspeople involved.
The second feature is not as obvious, but is no less real. The strength of the CRAFTed
programme lies in its educational conception. This report is a documentation of the
implementation of that educational vision. The design of the programme is a highly
thoughtful and nuanced one. A professional partnership between educators and
craftspeople, the programme designers have sought to align the craftwork with various
strands and emphases of the primary school curriculum. This alignment was sensitively
handled; too crude a specification would have reduced the experience to a series of drills
or empty exercises. Instead, thanks to the well designed support service and through the
facilitation of the education centre network, the integrity of the craft-making process was
respected while the educational priorities of the teachers and learners were supported.
There is an authenticity about the work of the programme that lends huge quality
to the educational experience. The engagement of professional craft workers with
professional educators has allowed children and young people to engage in real
work – not simulated or diluted processes. This authenticity is an implicit component
of the very nature of craftwork. It is also – and this in my view is the long-term value of
the programme – the only way that the rhetoric of education policy can be realised.
That rhetoric promotes, for instance, the development of creativity, of enterprise, of
collaboration and similar generic skills, qualities and dispositions. But these cannot
be taught in artificial settings. They must be forged in the experience of the real world.
Nothing is more real than making. Working with artists and craftspeople in the CRAFTed
programme, young people were working as craftspeople themselves.
That authentic experience is a real confidence-builder. And confidence is perhaps the
most important quality that education can foster in young people. Through the process of
making, through the experience of the classroom studio, young people learn to fail, learn
to evaluate, learn to seek help, learn to support, learn to appreciate, learn to succeed.
The lessons of the CRAFTed in its design and implementation, its support programme
and in its focus on the real, the authentic, should serve as a model of good practice for
education planners and for initial and continuing teacher education.
Professor Gary Granville
Head of School of Education, NCAD
This report has been researched and written by Polly Minett,
National Coordinator of the Design & Crafts Council of Ireland’s
CRAFTed: Learning Skills for Life Primary School Programme
Cover Image — Bernie McCoy
Contents
1. Introduction P. 1
1.1 Overview of CRAFTed 2014 P. 3
Aims and objectives
Learning outcomes
1.2 CRAFTed 2014: Facts and Figures P. 4
CRAFTed: PLUS
CRAFTed: CORE
2. Changes and developments for CRAFTed 2014 P. 7
2.1 CRAFTed: PLUS and CRAFTed: CORE P. 7
2.2 Appointment of CRAFTed Assistant Coordinator P. 8
2.3 CRAFTed Training P. 9
2.4 Training in delivery of CPD for the Education Panel P. 10
2.5 CRAFTed Teachers’ Information Evenings P. 11
2.6 Changes to Collaborative Planning Sessions P. 11
2.7 Looking and Responding Sessions P. 12
3. CRAFTed: PLUS P. 15
3.1 The format and delivery of the CRAFTed CPD evenings P. 15
3.2 Feedback process P. 16
3.3 Outcome of CRAFTed: PLUS P. 16
4. CRAFTed CPD Summer Courses for Primary Teachers P. 21
4.1 Objectives P. 21
4.2 Training and planning P. 21
4.3 Participants P. 22
4.4 Feedback / testimonials P. 22
4.5 Plans for publishing a teaching resource P. 23
5. Analysis of Evaluation Surveys P. 26
5.1 The investment of DCCoI P. 26
5.2 The investment of the Association Teacher Education P. 28
Centres Ireland (ATECI)
5.3 Results of Survey Monkey Questionnaire P. 30
6. Key recommendations for CRAFTed 2015 P. 31
7. Appendix A, B, C P. 32-35
1
1. Introduction
The Design & Crafts Council of Ireland (DCCoI) recognise the critical role that education
plays in the future growth of craft and in the preservation of our cultural heritage.
This commitment to education and training is central to the Design & Crafts Council of
Ireland’s Strategic Plan 2013 - 2015.
The Design & Crafts Council of Ireland’s CRAFTed: Learning Skills for Life Primary
Schools Programme provides educational training opportunities to a range of
professional craftspeople, offers teachers training and support and opens a world of
creative possibilities to primary school children. It aims to develop good collaborative
practice between craftspeople and teachers and focuses on how craft and design skills
support integrated learning methodologies within the classroom, with an emphasis on
underpinning numeracy and literacy skills.
In response to the Department of Arts, Heritage and the Gaeltacht, and the Department
of Education and Skills, Art’s in Education Charter’s commitment in respect of schools
policies and plans for ‘enriching the curriculum and the wider life of the school’, the
Design & Crafts Council of Ireland and partnering body the Association of Teacher
Education Centres Ireland (ATECI), initiatied a number of changes and developments to
CRAFTed 2014 to reflect this position. A focus of this report is to outline the key changes,
evaluate the resulting outcomes and make recommendations for future action in respect
of the CRAFTed: Learning Skills for Life Primary Schools initiative.
32
CRAFTed 2014: Changes and strategic developments
• Introduction of Continuing Professional Development (CPD) – on
a CRAFTed PLUS programme
• Appointment of CRAFTed Assistant Coordinator
• Training in delivery of CPD for the Education Panel
• Introduction of Teacher Facilitators
• CRAFTed induction training for Teacher Facilitators
• CRAFTed Teachers’ Information Evenings
• Changes to Collaborative Planning Sessions
• Looking and Responding Sessions for teachers and craftspeople
The success and impact of these changes has been evaluated
throughout the programme using the following methods:
• Feedback meetings with participating teachers and craftspeople
• Evaluation reports complied by participating teachers and craftspeople
• Online questionaire surveys with participating teachers and craftspeople
• Consultation meetings with participating directors
1.1 Overview of CRAFTed 2014
Aims and Objectives
• Raise awareness of craft, design process and craft enterprise among primary
children, teachers, parents and the wider schools community
• Provide positive creative hands on making experience for primary school children
• Supports delivery of the Visual Arts Curriculum at primary level in Ireland
• Offer practical skills and lesson ideas to teachers and makers
• Facilitates opportunities for collaboration and ‘paired teaching’
• Promote integrated learning of multiple subject areas with a specific emphasis
on numeracy and literacy skills
• Use creative, child centred process led methodologies
• Provides 10 hours in the classroom with a professional craftsperson
• Provides training for craftspeople which includes: working in classroom contexts,
delivering a residency, contracts, agreements, planning, working collaboratively,
child protection, health and safety
• Create career pathways and offer employment opportunities in educational
contexts to craftspeople
Learning Outcomes
Students
• Enable the child to develop natural abilities, to acquire craft techniques
and to practice the skills necessary for creative expression and for joyful
participation in different art and craft forms
• Enable the child to acquire knowledge, skills and attitudes to develop an
informed and critical understanding of social, environmental and scientific issues
• Develop the child’s awareness of, sensitivity to and enjoyment of visual,
aural, tactile and spatial qualities in the environment
54
Teachers
• Develop an appreciation of the skills involved in craft based disciplines and an
awareness of the potential of the craft creative process as a learning tool
• Gain an awareness and understanding of the role of craftspeople and the
importance of craft to Irish culture, heritage and society
• Develop an understanding of the potential for integrated learning using process
based creative teaching methodologies through the Visual Arts, (VA) and Social,
Environmental and Scientific Education (SESE) curricula, while supporting and
underpinning numeracy and literacy skills
Craftspeople and Designers
• Develop project and classroom management skills to enable makers to direct
and deliver future crafts based programmes
• Develop a working knowledge of the Visual Arts and SESE curriculum at primary
level and facilitate the development of the creative process that will assist in the
delivery of the curriculum
• Develop an understanding of the potential for integrated learning using process
based creative teaching methodologies through the Visual Arts, (VA) and Social,
Environmental and Scientific Education (SESE) curricula
1.2 CRAFTed 2014:Facts and Figures
The total participants:
• 15 Education Centres (ATECI)
• 71 School projects
• 62 craftspeople
• 12 Teacher Facilitators
• 2,130 students (approximately)
CRAFTed: PLUS
• 12 Education Centres including: Dublin West, Wexford, Kildare, Kilkenny,
West Cork, Sligo, Carrick on Shannon, Clare, Mayo, Athlone, and Monaghan and
Education Centre Tralee
• 60 teachers attended the CRAFTed CPD evenings
• 48 craftspeople delivered skills based workshops
• 12 Teacher Facilitators facilitated
CRAFTed: CORE
• 3 Education Centres including: Blackrock, Laois and Waterford Teachers’ Centre
CRAFTed CPD Summer courses
• 6 Education Centres including: Kilkenny, Sligo, Athlone, Carrick on Shannon,
West Cork and Laois
• 8 craftspeople delivering the course: Aidan Power, Anna Faye, Sheila Jordan,
Sabrina Meynes, Maeve Sookram and Mary Sharkey, Liz Flatman and
Julie Forrester
• 115 teachers participating
CRAFTed 2014 Craftspeople involved:
Jane Seymour
Kathleen Moroney
Jodi Coyne
Lisa Fahy
Victoria Foutz
Lynsey de Burca
David Gorman
Francis Kilcommins
Emma Bourke
Fiona Smith Darragh
Vivienne Martin
Liz Flatman
Melissa MacGillycuddy
Michael Ray
Anke Eckardt
Brenda McGinn
Dorinda McCormack
Karen McArdle
76
2. Changes and developments forCRAFTed 2014
In order to facilitate the addition of the CRAFTed CPD evening workshops as part of the newly formed PLUS programme, the Design & Crafts Council of Ireland initiated a number of changes and developments to the existing CORE programme.
2.1 CRAFTed:PLUS and CRAFTed: CORE
In keeping with good collaborative practice DCCoI invited all participating Education
Centres directors to a CRAFTed ‘Think-in’ to discuss changes / developments to the
programme. The main outcome of the ‘Think in’ was to build a more structured CPD
element into the CRAFTed programme with the aim of incouraging skills and ideas
gained by particpating teachers to be utilised beyond the projects and be dissmeninated
into the wider school community.
The addition to the CRAFTed Programme of a skills based CPD for teachers at Primary
level had been mooted by some participating directors since 2011 as there was a growing
demand from teachers for skills based CPD to support the Visual Arts Curriculum. Based
on ideas put forward at the ‘Think-in’, CRAFTed developed and designed a structure that
included a suite of four CPD workshops to run concurrently with the main programme.
CRAFTed therefore offered two methodologies / approaches for CRAFTed 2014:
CRAFTed: PLUS – including CPD workshops for teachers
CRAFTed: CORE – not including CPD workshops for teachers
Mary Murphy
Deirdre Rogers
Elena Brennan
Anna Vahey Casey
Grainne
MacLoughlin
Henri Hedou
Kim Sharkey
Mary Markey
Christien Van Bussel
Patricia Howard
Ann Duggan
Maeve Hunter
Mairead Holohan
Collette Langan
Lynn Naughton
Emma Bourke
Gabriella McGrath
Jane Groves
Aideen Lynch
Emer O’Sullivan
Shona Flood
Sheila Jordan
Marika Miklosi
Manning
Caroline Schofield
Tunde Toth
Annabel König
Carrie Lynam
Una Ni She
Nora Finnegan
John Murphy
Theresa Murphy
Kate Ramsay
Aidan Power
Julie Forrester
Lian Callaghan
Anne McDonnell
Adele Stanley
Laura McNamara
Orla Kaminska
Niki Collier
Maeve Sookram
Liadain Butler
Camelia Shanahan
Laura Cripps
CRAFTed 2014 Craftspeople involved (Continued):
98
2.2 Appointment of a CRAFTedAssistant Coordinator
To support the additional administrational needs of CRAFTed, and to enable the National
Coodinator to focus on the CPD development side of the programme, an Assistant
Coordinator was appointed in January 2014.
The appointment of an Assistant Coordinator resulted in a smooth set up and roll-out
of the CPD element to 12 Education Centres who signed up for CRAFTed: PLUS. The
Assistant Coordinator assisted the clear communication between all stakeholders and
participants were well briefed on elements from expectations of roles to feedback /
evaluation procedures. The appointment also enabled support for strategically related
projects / events / exhibitions that further promoted the ethos of CRAFTed in 2014 such
as the CRAFTed exhibition, Make/Shape: Collaborations in Clay in partnerhship with The
Ark, Children’s Cultural Centre, Sept / Oct 2014. This CRAFTed exhibition presented by
DCCoI showcased the practice of eight ceramic makers and their collaborative ways of
working with children on CRAFTed craft educational projects. The exhibition was officially
launched by Dr. Judith Schwartz professor of Art and Art Professions at New York
University. (See Appendix B)
To assist the national dissemination of information across Ireland, a team of regional
coordinators were in place to deliver regional information evenings and facilitate the
Collaborative Planning Days. The regional facilitators are practising craftspeople
who are members of the DCCoI Education Panel: Aidan Power, Anna Vahey, Carrie
Lynam, Deirdre Rogers, Lindsey de Burca, Liz Flatman, Liadain Butler, Lorraine Bowen,
Maeve Sookram.
2.3 CRAFTed: Training
Induction for Teacher Facilitators
One of the aims of the CRAFTed: PLUS CPD workshops was to develop a discussion
forum for participating teachers. Each of the 12 participating Education Centres engaged
a Teacher Facilitator to work with the craftsperson when delivering these workshops.
The aim was to facilitate discussion around imaginative and useful ideas that would help
teachers transfer learned skills back into a classroom setting.
A one day induction for CRAFTed: PLUS and Teacher Facilitator role induction was held
at The National Museum, Collins Barracks at the end of January 2014. The induction
content was designed and delivered collabatively by Paul Fields (Kilkenny Education
Centre) Catherine Martin (Carrick on Shannon Education Centre) Mary O’Donavan (West
Cork Education Centre) and Polly Minett (National Coordinator of CRAFTed).
The role of Teacher Facilitators
Participating Education Centres selected a Teacher Facilitator and agreed to fund their
activity throughout the project. It was preferable that the Teacher Facilitator would be
a teacher who had engaged in the CRAFTed programme previously or had a strong
interest in arts and craft education in schools.
The role of the Teacher Facilitator included:
• Facilitating the sharing of skills and ideas arising from involvement
in CRAFTed
• Ensuring linkage with the primary curriculum
• Feeding back outcomes in a learning forum to Education Centre Directors
and DCCoI
The overall time commitment for the Teacher Facilitator in 2014
• 1 day: induction training in January
• 1 evening: January for CRAFTed introduction
• 1 evening: collaborative planning
• 3 CPD evenings
• 1 evening: looking and responding
1110
All 12 participants reported that they felt that the induction was worthwhile, although
there was a lot of information to take in on one day. They really enjoyed networking
and being with ‘like minded teachers’ who shared their belief in the importance of
supporting arts education. They all were enthusiastic about their involvement on
CRAFTed: PLUS in 2014.
2.4 Training in delivery of CPD forthe Education Panel
In order to facilitate the delivery of quality craft-skills based CPD workshops for primary
level teachers, a one day workshop designed by visual artist and arts educator Marie
Brett, co-facilitated with Polly Minett was offered to members of the DCCoI’s Education
Panel. The content was based on looking at teachers needs and expectations of the
CRAFTed CPD workshops, and informing participants of the roll out proceedure of
CRAFTed PLUS.
These workshops were delivered twice at the beginning of February 2014. Once at
The National Museum Collins Barracks, and once at The Model Arts Centre Sligo.
Attendance was voluntary, however anyone who wanted an opportunity to deliver the
CPD was strongly advised to attend. This workshop was mandatory for all new members
who wanted to be considered for CRAFTed. Attendance numbers for Dublin was 50,
whilst 15 attended in Sligo.
Evaluation sheets completed by participants on this training workshop indicated that
they felt the training was extremely informative and beneficial, and had given them more
confidence to apply for work in this area. They also enjoyed the opportunity to network
amongst each other and discuss and share their education facilitation experiences.
2.5 CRAFTed Teachers’Information Evenings
In keeping with previous CRAFTed programmes, it was felt that it was important to retain
the CRAFTed teachers’ information evenings in order that prospective participants have
clarity as the aims and objectives of the programme, and the collaborative nature of the
working methodology.
The rolling out of CRAFTed ‘nationwide’ meant that the number of funded projects is
now shared between the 15 education centres, each centre offers between four and six
projects to schools. (Previously DCCoI funded up to 18 schools in one region.) Therefore
some teachers in rural areas may have travelled long distances to attend the information
evening when funding for project participation was limited. To balance this situation,
DCCoI held a skills based sharing CRAFTed CPD workshop for interested teachers and
incorporated the CRAFTed information into these evenings. The intentional benefit of this
was to increase access to a skills based hands-on workshop for all teachers irrespective
of obtaining project funding.
Evaluations from participants who attended these evenings were extremely positive,
however in some regions they were poorly attended. Methods for promoting and
advertising of the CRAFTed Information and Skills Evening by Education Centres needs
to be reviewed for CRAFTed 2015.
2.6 Changes to collaborativeplanning sessions
The majority of craftspeople participating in the CRAFTed programme have been
collaborating with teachers on projects over the last three years, and therefore
have attended numerous collaborative planning days. Feedback from CRAFTed
2013 emphasised that many craftspeople felt that the content of the collaborative
planning days was repetitive and more for the teachers benefit as they were new
to the programme. These craftspeople now have confidence in their ability to work
collaboratively with their teachers and have clear understanding of their role within
the context of the programme. Based on this feedback it was decided to reduce the
1312
collaborative planning session to an evening and to run these sessions from the local
education centres. More emphasis on the methodology of CRAFTed was to be included
in the Teacher Information and Skills evening.
The Collaborative Planning evenings were designed to take place over two hours,
faciltitated by a CRAFTed regional coordinator and for CRAFTed PLUS in collaboration
with the CRAFTed Teacher Facilitator. The focus of the first hour was the main aims and
objectives of the programme - the CRAFTed video (available at learncraftdesign.ie) was
used to highlight the importance of a good working relationship between teachers and
craftspeople. During the second hour teachers and craftspeople had time to discuss
possible ideas around theme and methods of working.
The feedback on the shorter planning sessions was fairly positive as participants
appreciated that the sessions were held locally and didn’t require them to give up a
Saturday. However, the lack of time to explore possible topic areas was also reported.
Some craftspeople felt that more emphasis needed to be placed on relationship
building exercises, as it had taken longer to develop feeling of trust and a good working
relationship with their teacher than it had on previous years.
2.7 Looking and Responding
Feedback from the Education Centre Directors involved in CRAFTed 2013 emphasised
the importance of a CRAFTed Looking and Responding event for participating teachers
and craftspeople to share creative process, ideas and skills from their projects.
Based on this it was agreed by all participating directors that for CRAFTed 2014
Education Centres would hold a Looking and Responding evening event towards the
conclusion of the projects. The benefits of these sharing sessions would be transferred
back to participating school communities, thus ensuring that the programme became
more sustainable. It was decided to audio record these sessions to evaluate their
effectiveness.
The response from both craftspeople and teachers attending the Looking and
Responding sessions were positive. Participants enjoyed the opportunity to share
their craft making process and presentations given were well received with good,
lively discussion. The general consensus was that the sessions were beneficial as
participants felt stimulated with new ideas / topics to incorporate into their delivery
of the Visual Arts Curriculum.
1514
3. CRAFTed: PLUS
Aims and Objectives of the CPD Workshops
• Provide primary school teachers with ideas and skills, which support the Visual Arts Curriculum and includes approaches for integrated learning in the classroom • Provide a positive hands-on making experience and activities for teachers • Provide an ongoing discussion forum for sharing ideas and skills taken from participants’ experience of the CRAFTed Programme • Focus on building sustainability and self-sufficiency around future practice and support teachers with delivering the curriculum • Use the experience and methodology of CRAFTed as a spring board for future practice within the classroom • Build capacity and increase access to skills that support arts and craft education
3.1 The format and delivery of theCRAFTed CPD evenings
The CRAFTed CPD evenings were designed to incorporate the following:
• Participants for the CRAFTed CPD evenings were to be targeted by Education Centre Directors and include four CRAFTed teachers and other interested teachers who would benefit • Participants would form a learning community • Skills, ideas and experiences would be shared among the participating teachers and other teachers taking part in this CPD forum with the aim of increasing further access to the teaching community so that skills have a wider reach • A maximum of 15 participants • 2 hours per evening • Facilitated collaboratively by the teacher facilitator and one of the selected craftspeople (each craftsperson would take one evening to deliver a specific skill related to the curriculum)
1716
The aim was that potential outcomes of the CPD could include:
• The teacher facilitator could feedback on the CPD sessions to Education Centre Directors and the National Coordinator using a supplied feedback template • Selection of useful feedback to be shared on the www. learncraftdesign.ie website for digital dissemination
3.2 Feedback process
In order to evaluate the addition of the CRAFTed CPD evenings, the CRAFTed team engaged in additional feedback procedures.
• The National Coordinator and the Assistant Coordinator attended some of the CPD evenings • Close communication and monitoring was maintained with all the Teacher Facilitators and Regional Coordinators • The CRAFTed Looking and Responding evenings were audio recorded to evaluate the impact of the CPD evenings on the projects and record how often skills were being transfered into the classroom • A Survey Monkey questionaire was sent to all particpating teachers to evalute the format, delivery and effacacy of the CPD evenings • The Teacher Facilitators were invited to attend a feedback session at The Ark Cultural Centre for Children to share their thoughts on the CPD evenings
3.3 Outcome of CRAFTed: PLUS
The overall feedback from stakeholders’ evaluations, Survey Monkey questionaires and the audio recorded feedback sessions, was in general that the CRAFTed: PLUS model had been successful.
Content
Content and delivery of the skills workshop was considered to be useful and relevant to the curriculum. There was evidence of skills (in particular the clay strand) being transferred to the classroom and the CRAFTed projects.
65% of teachers who completed the questionnaire felt that the workshop skills were really useful. Some participants felt that they would have prefered to build their skills around one strand of the Visual Arts Curriculum rather that do shorter tasting sessions. Others prefered the wider approach and wanted practical skills to support all the strands.
Disscusion Groups / Learning Forums
Feedback suggested that the structured approach of having a one hour workshop followed by a one hour discussion on how skills could be implemented in a classroom session was limiting and perhaps too short. Many of the teachers did not have time to try out the new skills in the interum period in their classrooms, between workshops. They felt the more formal discussion session was too long and took away from their ‘hands on’ time. Both participating teachers and the CRAFTed teacher facilitators considered that a two hour workshop with a more organic informal approach to curriculum discussion would be more useful in the future.
Time Frame
All feedback emphasised that the CPD evening needed to take place earlier in the year and would be more effective if they took place before the CRAFTed projects rolled out in schools, as it would upskill the teachers before they began to work with the craftsperson.
When asked about the timing of the CRAFTed CPD evenings as part of Survey Monkey questionnaire 60% of the teachers said that they would prefer evening CPD over the 35% who opted for summer courses. 65% said that they would prefer the CPD to take place before the CRAFTed projects started in the classrooms.
1918
Advertising and enrollment in the CPD
The interest and attendence for the CPD evenings for teachers was lower than expected. The majority of participants attended as they were taking part in a CRAFTed project. In some Education Centres, numbers were low to begin with but increased over the weeks as interest grew and particpants encouraged their colleagues to attend. Low attendance was attributed to three main factors:
• The time of year. Teachers are tired by the summer term, and the summer term is extremely busy as they finish off the academic year • Advertising CPD. Advertising and targeting teachers to take part in CPD needs to be linked in to Education Centres calanders and be sent out to schools earlier in the year / at the start of the year • Communication by email advertising programmes often don’t reach the teachers they are targeting as the email may not leave the Principal’s administration office. The system of disseminating the information to schools through Education Centres needs to be reviewed as it is key to the success of attendance by teachers at CPD events
Summary of CRAFTed: PLUS
• CRAFTed demonstrates that creative ideas and themes can be successfully integrated into the broader curriculum. As a result, learning becomes a far more enjoyable and fun experience. The subjects now have a definite focus on topics that are relevant to the student and the specific locality. Extending the project time frame, increasing the number of contact hours with the craftsperson in the classroom, could enhance the student’s experience. The potential to increase teacher’s confidence for using craft techniques in cross-curricular ways in the classroom was explored throughout the CPD sessions
• The pilot CPD component was well received in 2014, however it could take a different approach if continued. For example, the craftsperson could run a skills day or a couple of evenings for all teachers at the particular school teaching all the staff rather than one teacher involved in the project. CRAFTed projects could run earlier in the year, allowing enough time for workshops to be carried out before the programme, and teachers to have time to fully benefit from the training
2120
4. CRAFTed CPD SummerCourses for Primary Teachers
Creative Craft Skills to enhance the delivery of the Visual Arts Curriculum at Primary level
• There has been a growing demand for good quality CPD summer courses
that support the Visual Arts Curriculum at primary level. In response
to this demand, in 2013 the Design & Crafts Council of Ireland designed
a core skills based CPD summer course and worked collaboratively with
four selected craftspeople to implement the courses with four
participating Education Centres in Ireland. A call-out for an expression of
interest was made to DCCoI’s Education Panel to select the tutors.
Selection was based on the quality of ideas that candidates submitted
4.1 Objective of the course
• To provide teachers with skills and ideas that will enhance their delivery
of the Visual Arts Curriculum at Primary level and provide linkage to other
areas of the primary curriculum
• The CRAFTed CPD Summer Courses were designed by DCCoI and
inspected and passed by the Department of Education and Skills. They
were run in partnership with six Education Centres and the Department of
Education. The title of this course is Creative Craft Skills to enhance the
delivery of the Visual Arts Curriculum at Primary level
4.2 Training and Planning
• The selected craftspeople spent a day preparing and planning and
presented a selection of skills based teaching materials and digital
presentation resources that could be used to deliver the courses
• The success of the courses led to two more Education Centres requesting
to run the CPD summer course for July 2014. An additional four
craftspeople were selected from the original applicants
2322
4.3 Participants
CPD teacher training courses took place from 1st July to 5th July in the following
Education Centres:
Sligo
Carrick on Shannon
Kilkenny
Athlone
Laois
West Cork
Number of craftspeople involved:
9 craftspeople nationwide
Number of teachers involved:
Sligo: 16
Carrick on Shannon: 18
Kilkenny: 16
Athlone: 20
Laois: 18
West Cork: 25
Total number of teachers who participated in the Creative Skills Summer Course: 115
4.4 Feed back / Testimonials
The evaluations for the courses were extremely positive with 110 of the teachers
describing the courses as excellent in all categories evaluated.
98% felt the courses met expectations
98% felt they would recommend the course to colleagues
Testimonies from the evaluations
“Excellent Course. Tutor was v. Good”
“Thanks for a very interesting non-boring course”
“Very well informative course on creating art”
“Excellent experience of visual arts and ideas for my classroom, thank you Aidan”
“Exceeds expectations”
4.5 Plans for Publishinga teaching resource
CRAFTed considers strongly that the area of developing good quality arts and craft
based CPD for teachers is a growth area in which members of the DCCoI’s Education
Panel are well placed to deliver. DCCoI are in the process of developing opportunities
in this area in 2015 including publishing a teaching resource book for primary level
teachers in partnership with the participating Education Centres.
2524Photographer — Johnny Savage
2726
5. Analysis of Evaluation Surveys
5.1. Investment of Design & CraftsCouncil of Ireland SWOT analysis
1. Nurturing future makers of design and craft
2. Nurturing future buyers of Irish design and craft
3. Raising the profile of Irish design and craft and its
makers nationwide
4. Provided training and employment opportunities for
DCCoI Education Panel members
1. Certain geographical regions have few craftspeople
registered on the Education Panel meaning some
craftspeople from other regions have to travel long
distances to facilitate projects
2. The cap of €150 to be paid to craftspeople for
travel and the extra time taken for journeys means
that craftspeople are reluctant to travel long
distances to facilitate projects
1. Further develop and strengthen partnerships to
support the CPD element of CRAFTed
2. Develop opportunities to profile and partner the
CRAFTed model internationally
1. Lack of long-term partnership agreement with
the ATECI due to budget constraints. A five year
partnership plan would allow the CPD element
of the programme to develop
2928
5.2 Investment of participatingEducation Centres (ATECI)SWOT analysis
1. CRAFTed is a developed model of a programme
with proven success
2. Education Centres can utilise the skills of the
DCCoI Education panel, to deliver other
creative programmes
3. CRAFTed provides support for integrated
learning, numeracy and literacy skills and CPD
in the Visual Arts Curriculum – key requirements
for Education Centres
1. Financial constraints on education budgets
2. Communication and the key advertising / awareness
building methods to schools is crucial
1. CRAFTed and partnership with DCCoI offers
Education Centres further opportunities to develop
the CPD training programmes for teachers
1. Budget cuts
2. Any potential changes in the requirements from
the Department of Education and Skills
3130
5.3 Results of SurveyMonkey questionnaires
As part of CRAFTed 2014 evaluation process two Survey Monkey questionnaires were conducted with participants. (For results of surveys see Appendix C)
DCCoI Education Panel
The aim of the survey for the DCCoI Education Panel was to assess how involvements in
the CRAFTed programme has impacted on their practice within an educational context.
The overall response showed that participants felt that their confidence around working
in this area has increased. Their work on CRAFTed has enabled them to successfully
apply for more arts education based opportunities with other organisations in Ireland.
CRAFTed: PLUS Teachers
The aim of the survey for the teachers who participated in CRAFTed: PLUS was to assess
the efficacy of the 2014 model, workshop content and timeframe work. The overall
response was positive, with the main changes focusing on the timeframe of the CPD
workshops. Most participants would have preferred the CPD workshops to take place
before the projects began so they could have utilised the skills better.
6. Key Recommendations forCRAFTed 2015
• Projects to take place earlier in the school term with all dates planned
and advertised well in advance
• Improve dissemination of CRAFTed information to schools. Increase
information links to key websites for promotion
• Update the DCCoI Educational Panel with targeted call-outs in specific
regional areas. This will provide new members with opportunities and
reduce travel time for craftspeople
• Develop opportunities for teachers’ craft-based CPD within 3rd
Level institutions
• Develop opportunities to share CRAFTed model internationally, working
with international agencies who are interested in developing a CRAFTed
model. The National Coordinator Polly Minett was invited to present the
CRAFTed Programme at the Innocrafts Conferences in Burgas, Bulgaria in
April 2014 and in Florence, Italy October 2014. The presentations
generated interest and discussion of the important role of education and
training in the support of maintaining and developing a strong craft
industry. Several of the Innocrafts partners are interested in working
with DCCoI to seek further funding to support educational programmes
based on the CRAFTed model
• A potential for interested teachers and craftspeople to link in thematically
with the National Museum of Ireland (NMI) to explore, and use historic
events in the Decade of Centenaries as a theme for CRAFTed projects
www.decadeofcentenaries.com
• The opportunity for schools to make an application to DCCoI for an
extension bursary to expand and lengthen their project. This will be
a joint application by the teacher and craftsperson for more time to
develop their project
3332
Appendix AStrategic Developments from CRAFTed 2013 and 2014
1. Touring Photographic Exhibition
Aims and objectives
• 12 photographic images and 4 banners
• Showcase CRAFTed projects, raise profile of programme
• Selected 12 images based on a cross section of disciplines, representing
the curriculum strands, process and completed work
• Presented in gallery spaces in Waterford Library, Tallaght Library,
Collins Barracks, Dublin
• Tallaght exhibition was contextualised for the local community by
showcasing a local CRAFTed project
1.2. Learn Craft Design Website and Lesson Plans
Call out to CRAFTed 2012 projects for Lesson Plan
• Primary curriculum
• Based on CRAFTed projects
• Used by teachers in the classroom
• Used at CPD workshops
1.3. CRAFTed film
• Highlighting and showcasing the collaborative element in the classroom,
planning process, stakeholders, cross-curricular ethos of CRAFTed
• Profile raising for programme
• Tool for CRAFTed teacher information evenings
• Online promotional tool
• Featured in exhibitions to contextualise CRAFTed for public audience
• http://www.learncraftdesign.com/crafted/crafted-film
1.4 Shaping Our World through Making Exhibition
• CRAFTed National Museum Collins Barracks Dublin
• 2 week exhibition in Riding School
• Opened by then Minister for Children & Youth Affairs
Ms. Frances Fitzgerald
• 19 projects exhibited, one from each Education Centre involved
in CRAFTed
• Featured in national press, Irish Independent
• Workshops
15 schools workshop 2 per day
1 Public workshop (38 members of the public attended)
8 craftspeople
450 students
30 teachers
1.5 The Ark –International Academy of Ceramics (IAC)
MAKE/SHAPE: collaborations in clay exhibition
• Capsule exhibition – process engaged by ceramicists working
collaboratively with students on CRAFTed projects
• CRAFTed craftspeople showcasing their practice
• National broadcast coverage on RTE Junior Radio and national and
regional press coverage
• 1,557 exhibition visitor numbers
• Schools / public workshops
8 schools workshops, 2 per day
275 Students
16 teachers
6 public workshops
1557 members of the public
9 craftspeople employed
3534
Appendix B
Make/Shape: Collaborations in Clay Report from The Ark
EXHIBITION DETAILS:
Duration: 9th Sept – 18th Oct 2014
Opening days: Tues 9th – Fri 12th Sept and every Saturday, plus Sunday 21st Sept
Open: 10.00am – 5.00pm (12.00 -5.00pm on Sunday)
Total attendance: 1557
PUBLIC WORKSHOP PROGRAMME:
Imagined Places
Clay workshop with ceramic artist, Adele Stanley
on Saturday 20th Sept @ 10.30, 12.00, 14.30
Max capacity: 20 Children per session
Total attendance: 55 children plus adults
Touch and Tactility
Clay workshop with ceramic artist, Maeve Sookram
on Saturday 11th Oct 10.30 & 12.30
Max capacity: 20 Children per session
Total attendance: 34 children plus adults
SCHOOLS WORKSHOP PROGRAMME:
Making Shapes
Ceramic Workshop for schools with Christien van Bussel from
Tues 14th – Fri 17th Oct: 2 sessions per day @ 10.15 & 12.15 for 1st – 6th Class
Total attendance: All 8 sessions booked – 195 children
FEEDBACK for Making Shapes Schools Workshops
“Staff were very helpful. We got lots of tips about clay”
“Great info on kilns and moulds”
“Inspiring, Imaginative”
“Excellent, educational, inspirational, great fun, creative, nourishing of
undiscovered talents”
“Awesome, interesting, fun, creative, arty”
Appendix C
Results from Survey Monkey Questionnaires
Data from the CRAFTed: PLUS Education Panel Craftspeople Questionnaire
The Design & Crafts Council’s
Education Panel Members CRAFTed Survey
3736
21
19
27
38
Increased confi dence facilitating arts education
engagements both formally and informally
Increased your opportunities in art education
based practice
Had a direct impact in developing your own arts practice
Please give examples
Q1. Has being involved in the CRAFTed Programme benefi ted
you in any of the following?
Answered: 45
Skipped: 1
Sample Comments
1. I am more confi dent in doing my own workshops and in applying for
other workshops. For example I am running an animation workshop in 15
schools for the Department of the Environment and I would not have felt
able to do this if it was not for doing the CRAFTed projects
2. The programme has greatly infl uenced my professional practice, as it’s
a constant learning curve. I have become more aware of what the needs
of the teacher and of the children are and I have more confi dence in
delivering arts engagements in general now
3. Every time I have worked with a school in the CRAFTed programme, I
have been challenged to think outside of the box and stretch my skills.
This has proven to be great for my own practice as I am no longer worried
about making mistakes
4. Being involved in the CRAFTed program has raised my profi le among lace
makers and artists/craftspeople who are very impressed by how a very
detailed craft can be simplifi ed and made more child friendly and relevant
to today’s world of design and craft
5. Since being involved in CRAFTed I have been in local schools both
Primary and Secondary level. At Primary level - extended schools projects
(construction club and STEM) At secondary level - S.T.E.M. projects and
master classes. Adult learning - Jewellery workshops. I completed a
FETAC train the trainer course level 6
6. CRAFTed provided opportunity to do well-defi ned projects with teacher in
school settings. This helps build up a solid record of valuable work. I can
promote myself better in schools knowing more of the curriculum and
what I can contribute to that
7. The work I do in CRAFTed always feeds back into my own work
and vice versa
3938
31
Child Protection Training
DCCoI Education Panel training on models of Creative
Engagement and Collaborative Practice
Training around the delivery of arts based CPD
for teachers
27 27
Q2. Please indicate the elements of CRAFTed training that
have been benefi cial to you?
Answered: 43
Skipped: 3
Sample Comments
1. It has made me more aware of all my interactions with children
2. This particular area was something I really lacked experience in and it
gave me more confi dence to work in this area
3. Preparing and delivering the CPD was really a great exercise in
communicating the fundamentals of my craft to teachers and it was
challenging but the delivery work I did stood me in good stead with the
school I went to and with other groups which I have been invited to speak
to about my work i.e. The local ICA Guild
4. All are useful but I fi nd getting together with other crafters for
collaboration planning is great for new ideas and sharing our experiences
5. The Child Protection Training gave me more confi dence working with
children as the CRAFTed project was my fi rst time working in schools, and
it covered any questions that I was concerned about
6. All of the training I have received through the CRAFTed programme has
been benefi cial and has lead to further work
7. All the above add to the overall experience and CV. Bi annual
retraining would perhaps be a good thing to keep on top of or perhaps an
open day of presentations too learn from other practitioners
4140
13
0
3
2
DCCoI Train the Trainer
A one year H.Dip in teaching
MA in and Arts / Design based area
PhD in an Arts / Design based area
Q3. Has being involved in CRAFTed encouraged you to seek out
further training in Arts Education in any of the following areas?
Answered: 18
Skipped: 28
Sample Comments
1. Being involved in CRAFTed has encouraged me to broaden my view of
lacemaking. I have begun to explore other means of expression through
lace. This has resulted in involving textile students in the art colleges in
our ‘Fashion-Able’ competition for our Kenmare Lace Festival
2. I am very interested in seeking out further training in this fi eld and I would
hope to begin a follow-on course next September
3. Craft based workshops to keep improving my own skill base
4. I am interested in taking the Train the Trainer course further to FETAC
7 level when it becomes available. I’m also planning to start studying for
MA in Arts Management next year
5. I am currently doing a degree in Animation. This has allowed me to use
my background in craft for the CRAFTed programme to enable children to
create work in mixed media and then see their creations come to life
on screen
6. I would like to do a H.Dip. in teaching
7. I already have training in working with children with special needs and am
also qualifi ed to teach adults in the area of my primary degree in Textiles
4342
11
5
17
16
9
Similar work in other schools
Further arts based work in your CRAFTed school
Similar work for Education Centres
Similar work for Arts Offi ces
Work with Museums and/or galleries, Community Arts organisations /
The Ark Children’s Culture Centre, The Butler Gallery etc.
Q4. Have you gained employment both part-time and / or
full time potentially resulting from your experience on the
CRAFTed programme?
Answered: 32
Skipped: 14
Sample Comments
1. I haven’t gained employment in any of these areas, but I have made
connections that may prove fruitful in the future. I have seen an increase
in my own private teaching practice though, and having the endorsement
of the Design & Crafts Council and being involved in CRAFTed has
played a role
2. Ardfert, Co. Kerry - Artist in Schools Programme, Arts and Craft CPD
Tralee Education Centre (summer 2015), Oaklands Second Level
Community College - Art and Resource
3. The National Craft Gallery, Guild of Irish Lacemakers and an upcoming
workshop to be held at The National Tailoring Academy
4. The programme led me to deliver a couple of lectures with the ICA
5. The Ark, Collins Barracks, The Hunt, National Craft Gallery, Waterford
Library Services, Kilkenny Arts Week
6. I have given private workshops since starting on the CRAFTed panel. My
ability and confi dence in presenting these workshops has been vastly
improved as a result of my experience on the CRAFTed panel
7. An Gailearaí Gweedore ran the animation from Donegal school CRAFTed
project in 2013. I am currently working for the local hospital producing
crafts with the longterm patients with dementia with the North West
Autism group running classes for the children and separate classes for
the parents. Last year I ran classes for the Irish wheel chair association
in this area. I have also ran one off workshops for other local toddler
groups and put a proposal together for the Laurete na nOg Eoin Colfer
to come to this area for his ‘Once Upon A Place’ project which has
been accepted
8. I will be working with the AMMA centre Armagh (Armagh Multi Media and
Arts centre)
9. Have had work with the National Craft Gallery, DLR, Education Centres
10. Douchas centre Mountjoy Prison, Western Care Western Region
11. Baboró Children’s Festival, Monageisha College Galway, The Ark,
National Museum, Arts Offi ces, Butler Gallery, Kilkenny Arts Offi ce,
Derry City of Culture
4544
9
10
911
DCCoI’s Train the Trainer
Introduction to Delivering CPD for teachers (Marie Brett)
Introduction to methods of Public Engagement (Marie Brett)
Child Protection Training
Q5. Which of the following DCCoI’s Education Panel training
workshops do you feel has potentially contributed towards
improving employment opportunities for you?
Answered: 39
Skipped: 7
Sample Comments
1. I found this the most relevant and useful training for pursuing
further employment
2. As the Child Protection Training is a nationally recognized programme,
having it is defi nitely a great credential in my portfolio
3. It has been useful knowledge for other workshops I do
4. Marie Brett`s presentations and workshops were benefi cial and inspiring
5. I have not done train the trainer I have though benefi ted from learning
with Marie Brett and completing the child protection training
6. All of the above have been benefi cial
4746
6
20
4
14
Encouraged me to seek out further training
Developed new techniques/methods of working
Experimented with other materials
Re-evaluated my process
Q6. In what way has being part of CRAFTed
infl uenced your own arts practice?
Answered: 44
Skipped: 2
Sample Comments
1. CRAFTed was my fi rst experience working in large group so it helped
me fi ne tune that process. It was also really interesting to see how other
makers worked with other groups
2. It has made me experiment with new materials and ways of working -
as each new project brings with it new challenges and opportunities,
and there is always lots of experimentation and research involved that
benefi ts and infl uences my own practice
3. I have been less afraid to make mistakes in my own practice after saying
the same to the students I have worked with
4. Adapting different techniques to suit the given age group
5. Development of new methods/techniques
6. Experimented with other materials
7. Work more with the Arts Curriculum
8. Given me the confi dence and experience to seek other related work
9. Learning a more time effective delivery for workshops
4948
Q7. How has having your profi le on the Learn Craft Design
Website infl uenced your arts education based opportunities?
Answered: 31
Skipped: 15
9
22
Promoted my practice to a wider audience
Allowed me to showcase my work
Q8. Finally, from your experience on CRAFTed, would you be able to
make a brief statement on how you think the children participating in
the programme benefi t from your input on CRAFTed? Is there
anything we could do to make the experience even better for them?
1. It gives them confi dence to try new things and realize that they can
achieve so much
2. We are a special visitor to the children and it gives the children that may
not be academic a chance at something different. They get to experiment
with materials that they may not have used before. They get to see the
processes involved in our practice
3. I think the biggest benefi t for the participating children is that we have
no pre-conceived ideas of how they will work within the project and gives
each child a chance to shine and to feel creative and have the
opportunity to work with a practicing artist
4. They get an insight into a practitioner’s work and potentially experience
crafts that they would not have access to otherwise
5. It is vital that children have enjoyable and creative learning experiences
in school that they will remember and benefi t from. By being involved in
CRAFTed, children are given the opportunity to not only learn new
craft skills but to have a holistic learning experience that covers many
other valuable curricular strands and units
6. The children that I have worked with have now gained an insight into
textiles and learned new techniques, which they may not have had the
opportunity to do otherwise
7. The shared activities seemed stimulating for the class. You can see
students who have a natural interest and ability
5150
8. The children benefit from the programme in a variety of ways: their
confidence in making is increased, they become as equally interested
in the process as well as the finished product, they are willing to
experiment and take chances, and their making skills improve. In some
cases, children that are excelling academically find their way back
into learning through the CRAFTed programme, as they start to engage
with the core curriculum in a creative way
9. I feel that I allowed students to experience an alternative approach to
learning about the curriculum. CRAFTed demonstrates that literally any
idea can be successfully integrated into the broader curriculum. As a
result learning becomes a far more enjoyable and fun experience. The
subjects now have a definite focus on topics that are relevant to the
student and the specific locality
10. To say we are exotic to them is not an overstatement, and as such we as
artists and craftswomen have a unique opportunity to show them the rich
possibilities of a hand made life
11. Children loved having an artist or craftsperson in school. They explored
and completed a project, which they would not have normally had the
chance to do
12. Children participating in the program have learned to appreciate a very
old Irish craft and have seen how it can change and develop to
incorporate new methods and techniques. They have seen how it can
come alive for them in the 21st century
13. CRAFTed is a brilliant way to introduce children to art, design and craft.
The collaboration between teacher and crafts person is paramount in this
project as both teacher and crafts people have a different job to do
14. To practice hand skills, creative problem solving, collaborative work,
dialogue and mutual appreciation of work, sense of achievement, to
own the creation of a visible product, self-advocacy, “quiet time”, focused
activity, reflection, trusting a process, openness to experimentation/risk
taking/allowing for failure, development of ideas
15. The children are given the opportunity to work directly with a practicing
craftsperson. They receive an insight into how a piece of craft/art is
produced and so gain an appreciation and understanding of the creative
process involved
16. The children I worked with enjoyed learning, discovering new ways and
methods of expressing their creativity
17. The students gain confidence in expressing their creative instincts and
abilities. They begin to see that working within a field of craft could be a
potential path for them for a future career
18. I think the programme would benefit from more contact hours and visits to
galleries, exhibitions and or operating craft studios
19. I think they see a role model in the craftsperson, somebody different, a
creator - a free flowing mind and that gives them opportunity to see that
there are other ways of living life
20. They benefit from the deep engagement I have with my medium. I open
windows connecting it with the wider environment and with future design
and craft career options
21. I think it would be beneficial if the children were encouraged to show new
skills to the rest of the school, and talk about the process
22. The participating children experienced a new way of approaching a visual
arts project and how their academic knowledge such as mathematics and
science can be applied in the visual arts
5352
Data from the CRAFTed: PLUSTeachers Questionnaire
Q1. In what way has being part of CRAFTed
infl uenced your own arts practice?
All questions answered by 35 teachers
Responses
1. My principal heard about it at a conference
2. Internet
3. A teacher friend who had taken part in a Local Education Centre initiative
4. I saw the advert on education website
4
12
8 13
Other
I was directly targeted by
my local Education Centre
I attended the
CRAFTed information
evening for schools
My school is taking part in
the CRAFTed programme
Q2. Are you or your school taking part in the
CRAFTed programme 2014?
Responses
If no, would you like to take part in future CRAFTed programmes?
Yes (8 responses)
8
1
323
If no, would you like
to take part in future
CRAFTed programmes?
No
Yes, another teacher
in our school
Yes, my class
5554
Q3. How many of the CRAFTed CPD evenings
were you able to attend?
Responses
1. Two as we were informed of a Whole School Evaluation – Management,
Leadership and Learning inspection
2. I attended all CPD workshops but there were only 3
2
7
9 17
Other (please specify)
Only one workshop
3 of the workshops
All 4 workshops
Q4. The CRAFTed CPD evening workshops were designed to take
place during term time to create a learning community of teachers
and crafts people. How useful did you fi nd the discussions on
adapting ideas to the classroom?
Responses
1. Very useful ideas
2. A great opportunity for sharing and learning from each other
3. We had no time to experiment with the ideas in our classrooms as the
artists were working with the class at the time of workshops. Perhaps
workshops held in term 1 would give teachers the chance to experiment
4
2
722
Please comment on
your choice
Not very useful, I would
have rather had a 2 hour
hands on workshop
Quite useful
Very useful I got lots
of ideas
5756
12
7
11
22
Please comment
Clay
Fabric and fi bre
Q5. Have you used any of the ideas or skills from the
workshops in your classroom?
Responses
1. I will be using most if not all of the skills learned through crafted in the
coming school year
2. As the workshops took place very close to the end of the school year, I
did not have the class time to try out the great ideas. I aim to use them in
my art lessons from September
3. No, as I had no time left
4. Very user-friendly ideas, well worth attending
5. Hope to use them next year as there hasn’t really been time to implement
them this year with completing the CRAFTed project
6. No, as they were held in third term - too late in the year to use them along
with ten hours of art which was happening due to crafted programme
7. Did not have the time yet but hope to use them next year
8. I did the hand knitting course taught it to my pupils the next art lesson and
its now a major craze
9. Aidan, the craftsperson was my assigned craftsperson so I had learned
the skills required from him before we taught the class. It was very useful
as I could be of help to Aidan
10. Not yet but will in future
5958
Q6. Which type of CPD course would you fi nd more useful for
supporting your teaching of the Visual Arts Curriculum?
2 0
21
12
Other (please specify)
A series of Saturday afternoons
A series of evening courses
A week long summer course
Q7. Do you think a CRAFTed CPD course would be more
useful if was held in a different format?
Responses
1. For the week during the summer would be preferable as it could be used
for Extra Personal Vacation days - otherwise in January. Under rule 58 of
the Rules for National Schools, teachers are entitled to Extra Personal
Vacation (EPV) on foot of attending approved summer courses
2. Defi nitely the earlier in the academic year the better as it gives us more
time to implement the ideas and structure the yearly plans around what
we would learn
5
2
523
Other (please specify)
For a week during
the summer holidays
For 4 evenings during
the CRAFTed projects in
March, April and May
For 4 evenings before
the CRAFTed projects
in January and February
For more information on CRAFTed visit www.learncraftdesign.com/crafted